You are on page 1of 86

THE CHINESE UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG

FACULTY OF LAW

Research Paper No. 2022-20

The Global Red Scare and the Anti-Worker


Repressive Model, 1913-1927

Christopher Roberts

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

*"%"()($*$*-%(!(
(&()),#%"  Q  

",#-.)*",),.-
*   
   
  
  " 
 )87<G<BA"4JF 
 A4E6;<F@4A7)LA7<64?<F@"4JF 
 FFB6<4G<BA4A7)GE<>8"4JF 
 #<:E4G<BA"4JF 
 8AFBEF;<C"4JF 
   

  
 AG8??<:8A68:8A6<8F 
 &EBC4:4A74:8A6<8F
 "8:<F?4G<I8AI8FG<:4G<I8B@@<GG88F
,  (
&
  %  

  



#
 (4<7FEE8FGF4A7&EBF86HG<BAF
 #4FF*E<4?F
 8AFBEF;<C 
 8CBEG4G<BAF
 %G;8E#84FHE8F
,  )
,   
  
  
, & %

 

,   
 










 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     


"#-,.#&)(-#,-."2.(-#0,*,--#0'-/,-(.
,)/( ." 1),& /,#(! ( #( ." 1% )  ." #,-. ),& ,
"#&,*,--#00&)*'(.-#(."),&,(*)-.1,*,#
)-"0*,0#)/-&3(2'#(#(# ,(.(.#)(&)(.2.-&#..&
-")&,-"#*"-)*.'),!&)&&(-)..,),!(#4(
)(-#,.",&0(.0&)*'(.-."#-,.#&0&)*-.3*)&)!3) 
-#2# ,(..!),#-) */&#),,!)0,((#(.)1"#"."'
$),#.3) .",*,--#0'-/,-) ."*,#)'3&--# #."
*--!) (1&1-."0&)*'(.) (1#(-.#./.#)(-,#-,
,-.- *,)-/.#)(- ( ).", $/##& ( '#(#-.,.#0 '-/,-
.%(!#(-.-/-*.#--#(.-#,.-/**,--#)(0#."*&)3
'(.) -.. ),."0&)*'(.) (1#)&)!#& ),'.#)(-
(.",.#)((-.,(!."(#(!) *,-..&),!(#4.#)(- )(
-#,#(!0&)*'(.-,)/(."1),&/,#(!(#(." .,'."
) ),&,1#.".""&*) ."#-.3*)&)!3"&*-.)'%&,")1
2.(-#0#()."%#((-)*."#(()0.#)(-(2.(-#)(-) ,
*,--#0*/&#),,!)0,((#(."*,#)1, &)&-./3) 
-/"0&)*'(.-"&*-.),0&'),)0,")1&#..&-/"'-/,-
1,-)&&3),0(*,#',#&3)(,(1#."1,.#'2#!(#-(
")1'/"#()(.,-.."31,)(,(1#."&'*#(!)1()(
&),/(,-.-)#&#-.!#..#)(((.#)&)(#&,-#-.("
0&)*'(.-) ."*,#),().)(&3"#-.),#&/,#)-#.3,.",
."3)(.#(/.)#( ),'%3)'*)((.-) ,*,--#0!)0,((#(
(/',)/- -..- .)3 - -/" '), #,.&3 )( ,)(.#(! ( 
,--#(!.""#-.),3) -/"&1-#---(.#&.)"#0#(!!,.,,
-*. ),"/'(,#!".-#(.")(.'*),,31),&
 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




  
 
AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FG;8L84EF49G8E-BE?7-4EF4JG;89BE689H?
E8CE8FF<BAB9?89G<FG4A7?45BEBE:4A<M4G<BAF4J4I8B9E8CE8FF<BAG;4G
64@8GB58>ABJA4FG;8S(87)64E8T8FC<G8G;878C?BL@8AGB9G;8
G;<FG8E@GB78F6E<58G;8CBFGJ4EL84EF;BJ8I8E@4ALB9G;846G<BAF
HA78EG4>8A<A  4A7 
6BAG<AH87CB?<6<8F4A74CCEB46;8F78
I8?BC877HE<A:G;8J4E4A7589BE8<GF6B@@8A68@8AGA477<G<BA
G;8E8CE8FF<BAB9JBE>8EF4A7FB6<4?<FGF<AG;8C8E<B7J4FABG?<@<G87
GBG;8+A<G87)G4G8FRE4G;8E<GJ4F4:?B54?C;8AB@8ABA8A6B@C4FF
<A:ABGBA?LG;8+A<G87)G4G8F5HG4?FBG;8+A<G87!<A:7B@BG;8EA
:?BF8GG?8EFG4G8FFH6;4FHFGE4?<44A4744A7)BHG;9E<64G;8E<G
<F; 6B?BA<4? JBE?7 ;<A4 4A7 @4AL B9 G;8 FG4G8F B9 6BAG<A8AG4?
HEBC8J;8E88I8AGFFH6;4FG;8$BI8@58E(8IB?HG<BA<A8E@4AL
G;8<8AA<B(BFFB<AG4?LG;8B?F;8I<>*E<8AA<H@<A)C4<A4A7G;8
786?4E4G<BAB9G;8HA:4E<4A)BI<8G(8CH5?<6J8E8@8G5L4J4I8B9
I<B?8AG E846G<BA4EL 546>?4F; A 6BAGE4FG GB CE8I<BHF @BE8 A4G<BA
4??L9B6HF87FGH7<8FG;<F4EG<6?87E4JFG;8F8;<FGBE<8FGB:8G;8E8KC?BE
<A:G;8GE4AFA4G<BA4?8KG8AGB9G;8J4EG<@84A7CBFGJ4E(87)64E8



.?<I<J<8I:?LE;<ICP@E>K?@J8IK@:C<N8JG8IK@8CCP=LE;<;9P8@I<:K!I8EK=FI,<

J<8I:?*IFA<:K#  I<:<@M<;=IFDK?< 8:LCKPF=&8N8KK?<?@E<J</E@

M<IJ@KPF="FE>%FE> .?<8LK?FI8CJFK?8EBJK?<<;@K@E>JK8==F=K?<8I;FQF#EK<I

E8K@FE8CFDG8I8K@M<&8N,<M@<N 
  #E8;;@K@FE K?<[,<;-:8I<\F=K?< J@J9<KK<IJ<<EEFK8JK?<=@IJK9LKI8K?<I
8JK?<J<:FE;>CF98CI<;J:8I< K?<=@IJKG<I@F;D<I@K@E>K?8KC89<C?8M@E>K8B<EGC8:<
@EI<JGFEJ<KFK?<JKI@B<J8E;GIFK<JKJF=K?< J8E; J $--IE<JKF-:I<G8EK@ 
76/+76751+A+4-;)6,#-+=::16/":74-<):1)66;=:/-6+1-; ,!   
       Y   )E K?< GI<
N8I IFFKJ F= E<N I<GI<JJ@M<
D<8JLI<J@EK?</E@K<;%@E>;FD@EK?<<8ICPKN<EK@<K?:<EKLIP J<<?I@JKFG?<I' 
,F9<IKJ  7:/16/ <0- )<176)4 $-+=:1<A $<)<- "=*41+ !:,-: -/)41<A 16 :1<)16
C /  " ! $ & &=FIK?:FD@E>  
  $--.  1 1  ) .   1   ! 
1  Y . ,     *          Y
#MF8E8:<; SC8F;U "):)5141<):A'174-6+-16=6/):A.<-:<0-
1:;< (7:4, ():        +     '  +  *) *+ $
*   $ 0  
-  "  $  Y   
SC8F;U %0-(01<-%-::7:16=6/):AC %0-$7+1)4(7:4,7.<0-"):
)5141<):A :7=8;      "  3      1   * 
*   $0 ! 1 ,F9<IK!<IN8IK?
$F?E"FIE<<;J  -! * . !  ,!   "$ 
#   Y 8KY CC8E8D<IFEKI8EJ )O=FI;
/E@M *I<JJ  '  $    1  0 
!  ,!   Y   ,  !"   .
0   1$   1 1      Y  
$F?E(<ND8E #->74=<176)6,7=6<-::->74=<17616=:78-C
16.
  "$ -@CM@F*FEJ<;   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

4A7 G;8 89986GF B9 G;8 9<8E68 4AG<JBE>8E 4A7 4AG<FB6<4?<FG 46G<BAF
47BCG87<A=HE<F7<6G<BA49G8E=HE<F7<6G<BA4EBHA7G;8:?B58<AG;8C8E<B7
,<8J<A:G;8 
F4A7 
F9EB@4:?B54?C8EFC86G<I8;8?CFGB
E8A78E 4CC4E8AG F8I8E4? 946GF G;4G @<:;G BG;8EJ<F8 58 F;<8?7879EB@
I<8J<EFG47BCG<A:4:?B54??8AF;8?CFGB@4>86?84E;BJJ<78FCE847
G;8E8CE8FF<I8CE46G<68FB9G;8C8E<B7J8E8RABG6;4E46G8E<FG<6FB9BA8
FLFG8@ BE 4ABG;8E 4?BA8 G;BH:; ?B64? C4EG<6H?4E<G<8F <@C46G87 G;8
F;4C8G;4G78I8?BC@8AGFGBB><A7<998E8AG?B64G<BAF5HGE4G;8E:?B54?
GE8A7F<A:BI8EA@8AG4?<GLCEBIB>875L4A7<AE846G<BAGBG;8FGE8A:G;
4A7FH668FF8FB9JBE>8E4A7FB6<4?<FGCB?<G<6F<A6?H7<A:G;8B?F;8I<>
(8IB?HG<BA
)86BA78K4@<A<A:G;8(87)64E8B9G;8C8E<B7<A78G4<?;8?CFGB
HA78EF6BE8G;8CB<AG8@C;4F<M875L(8:4A)6;@<7G<A;<F@4:<FG8E<4?
466BHAGB9G;884E?L78I8?BC@8AGB9G;8HE84HB9AI8FG<:4G<BAG;4G
<A<@C?8@8AG<A:ABI8?E8CE8FF<I8@84FHE8FG;84HG;BE<G<8FJ8E8ABG
E8FCBA7<A:GB@4FFCBCH?4E;LFG8E<4BEC4E4AB<44FG;8(87S)64E8T
?458?FH::8FGF5HGJ8E8E4G;8E9<E@?L<AG;87E<I<A:F84G)6;@<7GVF
4E:H@8AG<F?8AGJ8<:;GABGBA?L5LG;8946GG;4G78I8?BC@8AGF<ABG;8E
=HE<F7<6G<BAFG8A7GB6BA9<E@G;8466BHAG;8CE8F8AGFB978I8?BC@8AGF
<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F5HG4?FB5LG;8I8EL8KG8AF<I8A8FFB9G;878I8?
BC@8AGF <A DH8FG<BARFH::8FG<A: GBC7BJA C?4AA87 78F<:A E4G;8E
G;4ACBCH?4E?L7E<I8AE846G<BA
*;<E7 6BAF<78E<A: G;8 CBFG-- (87 )64E8 <A :?B54? 6BAG8KG
;8?CFGB@4>84CC4E8AGG;86?BF86BAA86G<BA58GJ88A?45BEBE:4A<M4
G<BA 4A7 4AG<6B?BA<4? @BI8@8AGF A HEBC8 4A7 G;8 F8GG?8E 6B?BA<4?
FG4G8F G;8 CE<@4EL 8A8@L 9BH:;G J4F G;8 7B@8FG<6 JBE><A: 6?4FF
*;EBH:;BHGG;8<@C8E<4?6B?BA<4?JBE?7;BJ8I8EJBE><A:6?4FFE8
F<FG4A68J4FB9G8A<A8KGE<645?L<AG8EJBI8AJ<G;A4G<BA4?<FGFGEH::?8
EB@G<@8GBG<@84A7C?468GBC?4686BAA86G<BAFJ8E89BE@87<A6?H7
<A:9BE8K4@C?85LG;8GE4AFA4G<BA4?E8IB?HG<BA4EL;474E<G8FJ;B
9BE:87 6BAA86G<BAF J<G; @8@58EF B9 G;8 A7HFGE<4? -BE>8EF B9 G;8
-BE?7S--T)HA/4GF8A4A7BG;8E;<A8F8E8CH5?<64AA4G<BA4?
<FGF 4A7 :LCG<4A E8IB?HG<BA4E<8F 4@BA: BG;8EF I8A J;8A G;8

  FIDFI<FE@EK<IE8K@FE8CI<8:K@FEJKFK?<FCJ?<M@B,<MFCLK@FE J<<.,
 !  #  #"  #   ) 08C

<EK@E<&FD<CC@E@<;    
  $--,- ,-  # ) 
/-  Y  
  FI DFI<  J<< '   ,    "   /  ""  !  
'! ! ,   )!"
 Y  #E8;;@K@FE $L8E<D8I:?@ 8D<D9<IF=K?<#E

;LJKI@8C1FIB<IJF=K?<1FIC;[#11\ N8JI<JGFEJ@9C<=FI?<CG@E>KFI8;@:8C@Q<8

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

FGEH::?8F<ADH8FG<BAJ8E8ABGG;8@F8?I8F?<A>87G;8?8:4?4A7<AFG<
GHG<BA4? GBB?F 78I8?BC87 5L G;8 4HG;BE<G<8F GB 9<:;G FH6; @BI8@8AGF
J8E8F<@<?4E4A7G;8E8CE8FF<I8CBJ8EFB9G;8FG4G84H:@8AG87<AE8
FCBAF8GB5BG;
<A4??L@BFGF<@C?L5HG4?FBC8E;4CF@BFG<@CBEG4AG?LE86B:
A<M<A:G;8:?B54?A4GHE8B9G;8E846G<BA4EL7LA4@<6G;4GGBB>C?468<A
G;8L84EF9B??BJ<A:-BE?7-4E;8?CFGBE8I84?G;88KG8AGGBJ;<6;
6BAG8@CBE4EL E846G<BA4EL ?4JF 4A7 <AFG<GHG<BAF J8E8 :8A8E4G87
G;EBH:;G;8:?B54?FGEH::?84:4<AFGBE:4A<M87?45BE*;8<EFG-BE?7
-4E?<>8G;8)86BA7-BE?7-4E49G8E<G4A7C8E;4CFJ4EG<@88KC8E<
8A68<A:8A8E4?<FB9G8ACE8F8AG874F4A<A78C8A78AG64HF8B9G;878
I8?BC@8AGB9@BE8CBJ8E9H?4A7E8CE8FF<I8FG4G8FA4EEBJ9B6HFBA
G;8J4E;BJ8I8E@<FF8FG;88KG8AGGBJ;<6;G;8E8CE8FF<BAG;4GGBB>
C?4687HE<A:G;8J4EJ4F<ACE46G<68CE<@4E<?LBE<8AG87GBJ4E77B
@8FG<67<FF<78AGF<A6?H7<A:JBE>8EF4A7FB6<4?<FGFE4G;8EG;4A4G;BF
G<?89BE8<:A58??<:8E8AGF *;8CE8F8EI4G<BA4A7BA:B<A:78I8?BC@8AG
B9FB@8B9G;8@BE8E8FGE<6G<I8@84FHE8FCHG<AC?4687HE<A:G;8J4E
@BE8BI8E<A6?H7<A:G;BF8BE<8AG87GBJ4E7G;8?<@<G4G<BAB99E887B@
B9 @BI8@8AG 4FFB6<4G<BA 8KCE8FF<BA 4A7 4FF8@5?L 4F 8KCE8FF87
G;EBH:;G;89BE@4G<BAB9GE478HA<BAF4A7FGE<>846G<BA<AC4EG<6H?4E
J4FABG4A4GHE4?6BAF8DH8A68B9G;8J4E5HGE4G;8E4@84AFB9E8
FCBA7<A:GBG;8:EBJG;B9G;8BE:4A<M87CB?<G<64?CBJ8EB9?45BE<A
G;8C8E<B7
BAF<78E<A: 78I8?BC@8AGF <A CH5?<6 BE78E :BI8EA4A68 <A G;8

F4A7 
F9EB@4:?B54?C8EFC86G<I8<F;8A68I4?H45?8<AG8E@F
B9G;86BEE86G<I8F<GB998EFE8?4G<I8GBF8I8E4?;8:8@BA<6;<FGBE<64?A4E
E4G<I8F5BI84A758LBA7<GF5EB478EA4EE4G<I8<@C?<64G<BAFG;8FGH7L
B978I8?BC@8AGF<A:BI8EA4A68<AG;8C8E<B7<FI4?H45?85864HF8B9
J;4G <G 64A G846; HF 45BHG G;8 A4GHE8 B9 G;BF8 78I8?BC@8AGF G;8@
F8?I8FEB@BA8C8EFC86G<I8G;8FGH7L8A:4:87<A;8E8@4L58HA
78EFGBB74F9BE@<A:C4EGB9G;8?8:46LB9FGH7<8F47I4A6875L(HF6;8


PFLE> -8CM8;FI CC<E;< @E ?@C< @E K?<  J  $--      '  
#!      "   ' #  '  &  
5,  "$ ' # &   6 - ! 
&     <CKI@E<CC@  
  $-- -/  '  &   /  ! &  
.  1   $       .   " 
,!  $1  !1  11 # 11 ##  
*  1    ,   -    ,  "   
&!      !"   !!;
<;   
  $--,F9<IKJ ;=8:)EFK< 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

4A7!<E6;;8<@8EVF/(#-"'(.()#&.,/./,
*;8E8(HF6;8
4A7!<E6;;8<@8E47I4A687G;8G;8BELG;4G6E<@<A4??4J4A7CHA<F;
@8AG ?4E:8?L 8IB?I87 4F 4 @84AF B9 8A9BE6<A: BE78E BI8E FB6<8GLVF
?BJ8E6?4FF8F*;<FG;8BEL5EB47?LHA78EFGBB7;4F588AG4>8AHC5L
4:E84G784?B9?<G8E4GHE8F<A68J;<6;;4F8@C;4F<M875BG;G;87<E86G
EB?8B9G;86E<@<A4??4J<A7<F6<C?<A:G;8JBE><A:6?4FF8F4A7<GF@BE8
<A7<E86G @84AF B9 E88A9BE6<A: G;8 7B@<A4AG FB6<4? BE78E <A6?H7<A:
G;EBH:;G;88@C;4F<FC?4687BAG;8I<EGH8FB9?45BE<AG;86BAG8KGB9
CHA<F;@8AG 4A7 5L G;8 @4AA8E <A J;<6; G;8 CHA<F;@8AG B9 FB@8
F8EI8F 4F 4 G;E84G F;BJ<A: G;8 E8FG B9 G;8 ?BJ8E BE JBE><A: 6?4FF8F
;BJ@H6;JBEF8G;8L6BH?7;4I8<G 
@BA:G;8G;8BE<FGF<A9?H8A6875LFH6;JBE>J4F#<6;48?BH
64H?G J;BF8
#-#*&#( ( /(#-" 8KC?BE87 G;8 GE4AF<G<BA 9EB@ 4
@BE8 8KGE8@8 CHA<G<I8 4A7 8K8@C?4EL @B78 B9 CHA<F;@8AG GB G;8
@BE8?<@<G875HGF<@H?G4A8BHF?L@BE88KG8AF<I84A7<AGEHF<I87<F6<
C?<A4ELFLFG8@FB9G;8A<A8G88AG;68AGHEL-;<?8BH64H?GJ4FE8
F<FG4AGGB8KC?4A4GBEL6?4<@F<G<FABA8G;8?8FF=HFG4F6?84E<A;<FG;8BEL
4F<AG;8@BE88KC?<6<G?L#4EK<FG4CCEB46;8FG;4GS7<F6<C?<A84A7CHA
<F;@8AGT4E88A46G87<AG;8<AG8E8FGFB9G;8CBJ8E9H?<AFB6<8GL"4G8E
<A;<F?<98BH64H?G6BAG<AH87GB5EB478A;<F<AG8E8FG<A@BE8<@@87<
4G8?LBE7<E86G?LCB?<G<64?DH8FG<BAF5L78I8?BC<A:4G;8BELB9S:BI8EA
@8AG4?<GLT J;<6; FBH:;G GB 8KC?BE8 G;8 8KC4AF<BA BI8E G<@8 B9 G;8
@B74?<G<8F4A7G86;A<DH8FG;EBH:;J;<6;FB6<8GL<F:BI8EA874A7G;8
;8:8@BALB9S:BI8EA@8AG4?<GLTBI8EBG;8E9BE@FB9FGEH6GHE<A:FB6<4?
4A7CB?<G<64??<98
*;8FGH7L8A:4:87;8E8<F6?BF8?LE8?4G87GBFH6;49<8?7B9FGH7
<8F6BAFG<GHG<A:4F<G7B8F4FGH7LB968EG4<AG86;A<DH8FB9:BI8EA4A68
5EB47?L HA78EFGBB7 G G;8 F4@8 G<@8 @4AL B9 G;BF8 J;B ;4I8


 ! ,   ) %  *   - 
-  ,FLKC<;><  
  $---/   " $ *&  $! ,   * .
   1"   ^   .   -$  

 $      '  '  * !   . *
  $ )   * $ -$  ' 
#    $  '    *  . * $   #  
,!    Y   8I@F '<CFJJ@  )B-<<- 7. 7:)41<A )6, $7+1)4
(018"=61;05-6<-/-576A)6,<0-);-7.<0-&$ - & 
-  &FT:18:HL8EK %0-"-6)41;)<1767."7>-:<A)6,<0-#1;-7. -7
1*-:)41;5   $  *^$,    
  '     - !  *  (      
5 * .*6 
  $--'    (      *
   Y5.&  *
  Y6  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

78I8?BC87JBE><AG;8(HF6;84A7!<E6;;8<@8EGE47<G<BA4FJ8??4F
BH64H?G4A7I4E<BHFFH5F8DH8AGBH64H?G<4AF;4I8G8A787GB9B6HF
BA@BE8<784G<BA4?4A7BE:4A<M4G<BA4?6B@CBA8AGFB9FB6<4?6BAGEB?
A6BAGE4FGG;<FFGH7L6B@5<A8F4A8@C;4F<FBA<78B?B:<64?@4A<CH
?4G<BAJ<G;46BA68EAJ<G;G;8@BE87<E86G@84AFB98A9BE6<A:G;8<A
G8E8FGFB9G;87B@<A4AG6?4FF8F4A868FF4ELCB<AGB98@C;4F<F:<I8A
G;88KG8AGGBJ;<6;FH6;@BE87<E86G@84AFB96BAGEB?J8E845HA74AG?L
4CC4E8AG4A7E8?<87HCBA46EBFF=HE<F7<6G<BAF<AG;8C8E<B76BAF<78E87
-;4G9BE@7<7G;878I8?BC@8AGF<ACH5?<6BE78E:BI8EA4A68G;4G
GBB> C?468 <A G;8 
F 4A7 
F G4>8 *;8E8 <F AB F<A:?8 J4L B9
G;<A><A:45BHGG;BF878I8?BC@8AGFJ;<6;@4L586BAG8@C?4G879EB@
F8I8E4?C8EFC86G<I8FBJ5EB47?LBA864FGFBA8VFA8GE8@4<AF4ABC8A
DH8FG<BA4FG;8G86;A<DH8F<ADH8FG<BA6BH?74?BA:G;8?<A8FBH64H?G
FH::8FGF 58 GE4687 <AGB F8I8E4? 7<998E8AG 4FC86GF B9 FB6<4? BE78E<A:
*;<F4EG<6?878IBG8F<GF4GG8AG<BABA?LGBFB@8B9G;85EB478FG4A7@BFG
9HA74@8AG4?G86;A<DH8FB9:BI8EA4A6878I8?BC87;BJ8I8E6BA68EA
<A:J;<6;G;8E8<F@BE8G;4A8ABH:;@4G8E<4?GB9?8F;BHG4?8A:G;L
4A4?LF<F4FG;89B??BJ<A:466BHAG@4>8F6?84EBEGLCB?B:<64?CHE
CBF8FG;BF878I8?BC@8AGF@4L58HA78EFGBB74F6BAF<FG<A:B9F<K7<9
98E8AG6B@CBA8AGF
<EFG G;8 C8E<B7 F4J G;8 C4FF4:8 B9 4 E49G B9 A8J E8CE8FF<I8
?4JF&4EG<6H?4E?LCEB@<A8AG<AG;<F6BAG8KGJ8E8?4JFC8A4?<M<A:8F
C<BA4:8F87<G<BA4A4E6;<F@4A7FLA7<64?<F@4FJ8??4FE8FGE<6G<I8
4FFB6<4G<BA4A7@<:E4G<BA?4JF4A7?4JF8A45?<A:A8J9BE@FB968A
FBEF;<C B??86G<I8?L G;8F8 ?4JF :4I8 G;8 4HG;BE<G<8F G;8 CBJ8E GB
C8A4?<M8<A7<I<7H4?FB9J;B@G;8L7<F4CCEBI87GB64E89H??L6BAGEB?
4FFB6<4G<BA4?46G<I<G<8F4A7F;HG7BJA4FFB6<4G<BAFJ;8E8788@87A86
8FF4EL4A7GB?<@<G9E887B@B9@BI8@8AG9E887B@B98KCE8FF<BA4A7
4668FFGB<A9BE@4G<BAA477<G<BAFH6;?4JFC?4L874>8LEB?8<AF8G
G<A:G;8G8E@FB9FB6<4?<AG8E46G<BA;8?C<A:GB789<A8G;85BHA74E<8FB9
?8:<G<@4G8FB6<4?4A7CB?<G<64?C4EG<6<C4G<BA4A77<F6BHEF84A74<7<A:
<AG;86BAFGEH6G<BAB95EB478E<78B?B:<64?4A7E;8GBE<64?9E4@8JBE>F
4F7<F6HFF879HEG;8E58?BJ


  FIDFI<FEK?<I<GI<JJ@M<C<>@JC8K@M<;<M<CFGD<EKJF=K?<G<I@F; J<<%  
"  ! $ .- !& *  
, & "  Y ?I@JKFG?<I' ,F9<IKJ %0-
/-7.5-:/-6+A 1  / ! -  & ,!   
  $---/ -<;@K@FE:KF= *L9 & Y  -K8K / - E8I:?@:8C
8E;,<MFCLK@FE8IPI@D<J:K #E;@8&64)?.=4;;7+1)<176;+< K?
LJKC I@D@E8CF;< -  V8E #DD@>I8K@FE:KF= *L9 & 

  -K8K / -  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

)86BA7G;8C8E<B7F4JG;878I8?BC@8AGB9A8J9BE@FB9E8CE8F
F<I8<AFG<GHG<BAFEBAG4A768AG8EJ4FG;878I8?BC@8AGB9@B78EA<A
G8??<:8A684:8A6<8F9B6HF87BA5BG;G;87B@8FG<64A79BE8<:AE84?@F
*;BH:;B9G8A6E84G87<AG;8<@@87<4G8CE8J4EC8E<B7G;8F8BE:4A<
M4G<BAF8KC4A7877E4@4G<64??LBI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8<EFG-BE?7-4E
4A75864@88AGE8A6;8749G8EG;8J4EVF8A77HE<A:J;<6;C8E<B7<A
G;8<EE<G<F;<A64EA4G<BAF4G?84FGG;8L78IBG878KG8AF<I84GG8AG<BAGB
G;8 GJ<A 6;4??8A:8F B9 E47<64?<F@ 4A7 6B?BA<4? <A78C8A78A68 @BI8
@8AGF?BF8?L?<A>87GBG;878I8?BC@8AGB9G;8F84:8A6<8FJ4FG;8
78I8?BC@8AGB9CEBC4:4A745HE84HFBE<8AG87ABGGBB5G4<A<A:<A9BE
@4G<BA 5HG E4G;8E GB G;8 CEB7H6G<BA B9 A4EE4G<I8F <AG8A787 9BE @4FF
7<FF8@<A4G<BAJ<G;G;84<@B9FG88E<A:G;8CBCH?4G<BA<AG;87<E86G<BAF
G;84HG;BE<G<8F78F<E87<A4??LG;8C8E<B74?FBF4J<AABI4G<BAF<A
G8E@FB9G;8HG<?<M4G<BAB9?8:<F?4G<I86B@@<FF<BAFB9<ADH<ELGB6BA
7H6G CH5?<6 ;84E<A:F <AGB FB6<4?<FG G;E84GFR<AFG<GHG<BAF 78F<:A87 GB
9H8?CBCH?4EC4E4AB<44A74AG4:BA<F@RE4G;8EG;4AGB8A:4:8<ABC8A
8A787946G9<A7<A:
*;<E7G;8C8E<B7F4J8KG8AF<I8E4<7F4EE8FGF4A7CEBF86HG<BAF
6BA7H6G87 HA78E 5BG; E868AG?L C4FF87 ?4JF 4A7 HA78E E8CE8FF<I8
@84FHE8F C8EF<FG<A: 9EB@ G;8 CE8I<BHF C8E<B7 @BA: G;8 @BFG
CEB@<A8AG CEBF86HG<BAF J8E8 @4FF GE<4?F B9 -- @8@58EF J;<6;
GBB>C?468<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F4A4744A7HFGE4?<4GE<4?FB94AG<
6B?BA<4? E47<64?F FH6; 4F G;8 @4FF GE<4? B9 ;474E @8@58EF <A G;8
+A<G87)G4G8F<A  4A7  4A7GE<4?FB96B@@HA<FGF6BA7H6G87
<AA:?4A7A7<44A78?F8J;8E8*;8F8GE<4?FF;4E87AH@8EBHF6;4E
46G8E<FG<6F <A6?H7<A: 4 G8A78A6L GBJ4E7 6B??86G<I8 CEBF86HG<BA

  FIDFI< J<<.     ' $ #  Y
 . !   ' # ) %  
$$ ,    $  - #   ."
 $   '   '      
1 1      '  .     #
- $-!    
  )EK?<<8ICP;<M<CFGD<EKF=I@K@J?8E;D<I@:8EGIFG8>8E;89LI<8LJ J<<
- 0   "  # &  $  (   
    *  #   $  & . 
*   *   *    & (  ! 
1  Y 
(@:B @J:?<I %0-7551<<--76"=*41+6.7:5)<176)6,<0-1:<07.&$$<)<-":78
)/)6,)       $    -     $ ' #" "  
'     '  1" 1      
*     
  $-- -/  -  ;=8:) EFK<        * 
,    *    "$      - 
   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

BAFC<E46L6;4E:8FJ8E8B9G8AE8?<87HCBA 4??BJ<A:G;84HG;BE<G<8F
GBC4<AGG;8C<6GHE8B9G;86E<@8FB9G;8466HF87J<G;45EB475EHF;G
G;8F4@8G<@8FH6;GE<4?F499BE787466HF87<A7<I<7H4?F4ABCCBEGHA<GL
GB4GG8@CGGB47I4A68G;8<ECB?<G<64?CEB=86GF5LHG<?<M<A:G;8C?4G9BE@
B9G;8GE<4?GB6;4??8A:85BG;G;8A4GHE8B9G;8CEB68FF4A7G;88K<FG<A:
CB?<G<64?FLFG8@F@BE85EB47?L
*;84HG;BE<G<8FHG<?<M874AH@58EB9
BG;8E@84FHE8FGB4GG8@CGGBE8FGE<6GG;8FC4689BEJBE>8EF4A7FB6<4?
<FGF4FJ8??<A6?H7<A:68AFBEF;<CB9FC886;CH5?<64G<BAF4A76B@@H
A<64G<BAF78CBEG4G<BAFG4E:8G87<A=HA6G<BAFBAFGE<>846G<BAF4A754AF
BA4FFB6<4G<BAF 
BHEG;J;8E8BG;8E@84FHE8FCEBI87<A478DH4G8G;84HG;BE<G<8F
E8FBEG87GB78C?BL@8AGB9G;8HA@87<4G87CBJ8EB9G;8FG4G8GLC<64??L
<AG;89BE@B9@4FF><??<A:F6BA7H6G875LCB?<68BE@<?<G4EL4HG;BE<
G<8F<A6?H7<A:4GG<@8F5L@84AFB9G;8A8JGBB?B9S4E<4?CB?<6<A:T
*;<FJ4FABG494IBE87FGE4G8:LRE86BHEF8GB?8G;4?9BE68B9G8ACEB
IB>874GG8AG<BABHGE4:84A7CHF;546>E8A78E<A:<GFH5BCG<@4?<AG;8
8L8FB94HG;BE<G<8F<AG8E8FG87<AF86HE<A:BE78EI<4G;8@BFG89986G<I8
@84AFCBFF<5?8$BA8G;8?8FF<A6EH6<4?@B@8AGF4A7C8E;4CF4GG<@8F
F<@C?L4F4E8@<A78EB9G;8HA78E?L<A:7<FGE<5HG<BAB9CBJ8E<AFB6<
8GL4HG;BE<G<8FBA5BG;G;8?B64?4A7A4G<BA4??8I8?FJ8E8ABG47I8EF8
GBG;8HA@87<4G8778C?BL@8AGB9FG4G8CBJ8E<A6?H7<A:G;8HF8B9?8
G;4? 9BE68 GB 7<FC8EF8 4FF8@5?<8F 4A7 G;8 FH@@4EL 8K86HG<BA B9


   $---/ * ' $ .'  - 
1 ,Y*<K<I&<;<ID8E $-,1<17616(16
618-/6@)516)<1767.<0-%:1)4;.7:$-,1<17=;76;81:)+A:1;16/.:75<0--6
-:)4$<:13-7. + & $ $8:B18CB<I %0-:-)<)6),1)6$-
,1<176%:1)4;$-+76,,1<176 '  & $  Y  
 
 FIDFI<FEK?<D8JJKI@8CJF=K?<G<I@F; J<<# .  -$$^ 
,   ;=8:)EFK<&   1  . .   -
 ^!&  !8A<E;I8-@E>? 7,0$16/0%0-
!?8;8I7>-5-6<)6,<0-6<174761)4->1)6<16<0-6/475-:1+)65)/16)
<176   *   *      -   %  1 
) ^' .  ,$   
 #11  
   FI DFI<  J<< *  ' $  1 1  #   )  !
& /- "! $ ;=8:)EFK<,
- ;=8:)EFK<,F9<IKJ ;=8:)EFK< 
  )E K?< C8KK<I 8GGIF8:?  J<< *I@P8 -8K@8  :76-;  1;<7:A .:75 <0- :1<1;0
1,,4-);< "        [<I@8CGFC@:@E>N8J@EM<EK<;@EI@K@J?#I8H
8=K<I1FIC;18I#    ,8K?<IK?8EI<CPFE<OG<EJ@M<8E;LEGFGLC8IKIFFG;<GCFP

D<EKJ K?<I@K@J?<DGCFP<;K?<=C<;>C@E>, KFG8KIFCK?<:FLEKIP :FFI;@E8K@E>


@E=FID8K@FE=IFD@EK<CC@><E:<8><EKJFEK?<>IFLE;KF9FD98I;JL9M<IJ@M<M@CC8><J
8E;KI@9<J \ 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

7<FF<78AGF4F@BFG<A94@BHF?LB66HEE87<AG;8C8E<B7G;EBH:;G;88K
GE4=H7<6<4?8K86HG<BAFB9!4E?"<85>A86;G4A7(BF4"HK8@5HE:
<9G; 46EBFF G;8 CB?<G<8F 6BAF<78E87 G;8 4HG;BE<G<8F 78C?BL87 4
E4A:8B9FGE4G8:<8FBE<8AG87GBJ4E76BAFGEH6G<A:A8J<78B?B:<64?9BE
@4G<BAF 78F<:A87 GB ?8:<G<@<M8 G;8<E BJA CBF<G<BA B9 CBJ8E 4A7 GB
78?8:<G<@<M8G;BF8:EBHCFG;8LF4J4F<AA887B9FHCCE8FF<BA4A76BA
GEB?%9G;8@4ALG86;A<DH8FG;4G@<:;G586BAF<78E87<AFH6;E8:4E7
G;<F4EG<6?89B6HF8FBABA8G;84GG8@CGGB7E4J6BAA86G<BAF58GJ88A
I4E<BHF9BE68F4A746GBEF6BAF<78E87;BFG<?8SBG;8EFTL6BAA86G<A:
FH6;:EBHCFGB:8G;8EG;84HG;BE<G<8FJ8E845?8GBGE4AF98EG;8;BFG<?<GL
7<E86G87GBJ4E7BA8:EBHCGB4ABG;8E4A7GB@4:A<9LG;8?8I8?B9G;8
C8E68<I87G;E84G94687<A:8A8E4?*;86BAFGEH6G<BAB9FH6;4A<AG8E
?<A>4:8 J4F @BFG 4E6;8GLC4??L HA78EG4>8A <A G;8 A:?B 6BAG8KG
G;EBH:;E898E8A68FGBS8E@4AB?F;8I<>T6BAFC<E46L5HGJ4FABG
?<@<G87 GB G;4G 6BAG8KG J<G; G;BF8 47IB64G<A: 9BE :E84G8E JBE>8EFV
E<:;GF4GG<@8F6BAA86G87GB8I8ELBG;8E64G8:BELB98A8@LB9G;8FG4G8
BEBG;8EJ<F8HA78F<E45?8C8EFBAG;84HG;BE<G<8F6BH?78AI<F<BAA47
7<G<BAGBFG4G8@8AGF9EB@CEB@<A8AGCB?<G<6<4AF4A7:BI8EA@8AGB99<
6<4?FF<:A<9<64AGJBE>J4F7BA85L?8:<F?4G<BA<A6?H7<A:<@@<:E4G<BA
?8:<F?4G<BA<AC4EG<6H?4EJ;<6;B9G8ACEBI<7876?84E6BA6E8G8?<FGFB9
G;864G8:BE<8FB9C8EFBA788@87HA78F<E45?84A7 BEG;E84G8A<A:
)<KG;4??B9G;845BI878I8?BC@8AGFJ8E86B@C?8@8AG875LG;8
:EBJG; B9 J;4G @<:;G 58 G8E@87 SC4GE<BG<6T BE SI<:<?4A68T 4FFB6<4
G<BAFRE<:;G J<A: S6<G<M8AFVV :EBHCF G;4G BJ87 @BE8 GB :BI8EA@8AG
4A75HF<A8FF6B@@HA<GLFHCCBEGG;4AG;8L7<7GB:E4FFEBBGFBE:4A<M4
G<BA *;8F8 BE:4A<M4G<BAF GBB> AH@8EBHF 7<998E8AG 9BE@F 4G G<@8F
8A:4:87<ABHGE<:;GE46<FGI<:<?4AG<F@4GBG;8EG<@8FG4><A:G;89BE@
B9 5HF<A8FF 4A7 8@C?BL8E 4FFB6<4G<BAF -;4G8I8E G;8<E 9BE@ FH6;

  )E K?<@I ;<8K?J  J<< '  $    1  0  
! ,! Y 8KY  
  .?<K@KC<F=8GIFG8>8E;8GL9C@:8K@FEGIF;L:<;8E;;@JJ<D@E8K<;9PK?<FD

D@KK<<FE*L9C@:#E=FID8K@FE $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 


  $--#DD@>I8K@FE:KF= *L9 & 
  -K8K / -  
  FI DFI<  J<< ' "   -  1  .  &  
   Y *   #$      
  %%  / -  1  3  1 1  #  
'    '   %   ' " "$ 
) % *        1  *   #   
  Y  
  $--;N@E&8PKFE %0--<<-:5-:1+)-,-:)<176);-$<=,A7.$=8-:8)
<:17<1;5  *  " ,! - ;=8:)EFK< 8KY Y 
' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY Y Y %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K
 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

:EBHCFC?4L874A<@CBEG4AGEB?85BG;<A8A;4A6<A:G;8CBJ8EB98FG45
?<F;87<AG8E8FGFGBCE8FF546>4:4<AFGG;8CEB:E8FF<I878I8?BC@8AGB9
JBE>8EFVE<:;GF4A7<A8KG8A7<A:G;8CBJ8EB9G;8FG4G8GBFHCCE8FF
JBE>8EFV@BI8@8AGF5L8A:4:<A:<A9BE@FB96B@@HA4?;4E4FF@8AG
4A778G8EE8A6858LBA7G;8@84FHE8FG;8FG4G8JBH?7;4I8588A45?8GB
HA78EG4>8<A4AB99<6<4?64C46<GL
&4EG<6H?4EJ8<:;G<F:<I8AGBG;8+A<G87)G4G8F<AG;86BAG8KGB9
G;88K4@C?8FG;4G9B??BJEB@G;8E8FGB9G;8JBE?7C4EG<6H?4E4GG8A
G<BA <F C4<7 GB 78I8?BC@8AGF J<G;<A E<G4<A 4A7 G;8 E<G<F; <@C8E<4?
JBE?7G;BH:;F<@<?4E4CCEB46;8F47BCG878?F8J;8E8<A6?H7<A:9BE<A
FG4A68<AF8I8E4?6BAG<A8AG4?HEBC84ACB?<G<8F4E84?FB6BAF<78E874G
G<@8FF<F<A8I<G45?8J<G;4FGH7LB9FH6;F6BC878I8?BC@8AGF8I8
ELJ;8E864AABG58GE84G87J<G;G;8F4@878:E88B94GG8AG<BA8FC<G8
FH6;?<@<G4G<BAFG;8G8KGG;4G9B??BJFCEBI<78F<AAH@8E45?88K4@C?8F
B9G;8G86;A<DH8FB9:BI8EA4A686BAF<78E879EB@46EBFF4E4A:8B9=H
E<F7<6G<BAF<AG;8C8E<B75BG;S9E88T4A76B?BA<M87@4><A:6?84E5BG;
G;8:?B54?8KG8AGB9G;878I8?BC@8AGFFH::8FG874A7;BJ<A9?H8AG<4?
4A79BE689H?G;BF878I8?BC@8AGFJ8E8
8I8?BC@8AGF<A846;B9G;8F<K4E84F6BAF<78E874?BA86BAFG<
GHG874:E4I8A8J6;4??8A:89BEJBE>8E4A7FB6<4?<FG@BI8@8AGF4A7
4A8J6B@CBA8AGJ<G;<AG;85EB478E4EF8A4?B9G86;A<DH8FG;8FG4G8
@<:;G HF8 GB FHCCE8FF 7<FF8AG *4>8A GB:8G;8E G;8F8 78I8?BC@8AGF
;8?C87 9BE@ 4 6B;8F<I8 A8J @B78? B9 E8CE8FF<BA (86B:A<M<A: G;8
E4C<7:?B54?78I8?BC@8AG4A7 BE7<99HF<BAB9G;<F@B78?<F<@CBEG4AG
<AG8E@FB9G;8?<:;G<G64FGFBAG;8J4LE846G<BA4ELE8CE8FF<I8CB?<6<8F
78I8?BC:8A8E4??L4A7BAG;87LA4@<6FG;4G;8?C78G8E@<A8;BJ89
986G<I8 FH6; E8CE8FF<BA @4L 58 *;8 <AI8FG<:4G<BA 6BA7H6G87 <A G;<F
4EG<6?8<FABG@8E8?LBA8B9;<FGBE<64?6HE<BF<GL;BJ8I8EE4G;8E<G4?FB
F;87F?<:;GBA6BAG8@CBE4ELE84?<G<8F:<I8AG;88KG8AGGBJ;<6;@4AL
B9G;8G86;A<DH8F78I8?BC87<AG;8C8E<B7E8@4<A8FF8AG<4?GBCH5?<6
BE78E:BI8EA4A684EBHA7G;8JBE?7GB74L

 "
*;8 
F4A7 
FF4JG;8C4FF4:8B9AH@8EBHFA8J?4JF78
F<:A87GB6BHAG8EG;8G;E84GCBF875LG;8:EBJ<A:FGE8A:G;B9?89G<FG
BE:4A<M4G<BAF JBE?7J<78 *;8F8 ?4JF GBB> AH@8EBHF 9BE@F J<G;
@4ALCHECBF8FB9G8A9H?9<??874GBA68EB47?LFC84><A:4A79BECE8
F8AGCHECBF8FG;8F8?4JF64A586?4FF<9<87<AGB9BHE64G8:BE<8FF87<
G<BA?4JFJ;<6;7E8JBA4?BA:GE47<G<BAB9C8A4?<M<A:4AG<:BI8EA
@8AG FC886; 4A7 46G<I<GL 4A4E6;<F@ 4A7 FLA7<64?<F@ ?4JF 4 @BE8
E868AG9B6HFB9?8:4?4GG8AG<BA4AG<4FFB6<4G<BA?4JFJ;<6;4GG8@CG87

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

GB?<@<GG;8FC4689BE4FFB6<4G<BAFB9I4E<BHFFBEGFGB586E84G874A7GB
BC8E4G84A7@<:E4G<BA?4JFJ;<6;FBH:;GGB?<@<GG;8@BI8@8AGB9
C8EFBAF4A7GB:<I8G;84HG;BE<G<8F8KC4A787CBJ8EFGB78CBEG<A7<I<7
H4?F 788@87 GEBH5?8FB@8 A 477<G<BA GB ?8:<F?4G<BA G;8 C8E<B7 F4J
=H7<6<4?<AG8ECE8G4G<BAFG;4G9HEG;8EE8FGE<6G879E887B@F<AG;8F84E84F
89986G<I8?L4H:@8AG<A:?8:<F?4G<I8@84FHE8FE8?8I4AG<AG8ECE8G<I8=H
7<6<4?46G<BA<F;8A686BAF<78E8758?BJ4FJ8??

 #.#)(1-
AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FJ4EG<@8F87<G<BAJ4F94@BHF?LCHA<F;875L
G;8FC<BA4:84A7)87<G<BA6GF*;8<A<G<4?46GJ4F9BE@4??LG<G?87A
6GGB&HA<F;6GFB9AG8E98E8A68J<G;G;8BE8<:A(8?4G<BAF4A7G;8
BE8<:A B@@8E68 B9 G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F GB &HA<F;FC<BA4:8 4A7
8GG8E GB A9BE68 G;8 E<@<A4? "4JF B9 G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F 4A7 9BE
%G;8E&HECBF8F<GJ4F>ABJA4FG;8FC<BA4:86G*;8?4G8E)87<
G<BA6GJ4F4A4@8A7@8AGGBG;4G?4J *;8F8?4JF;47GJB9HA6
G<BAF%AG;8BA8;4A7G;8LC4EGBB>B9G;8S8FC<BA4:8?4JTGE47<G<BA
*;4GGE47<G<BA58:4A<AE<G4<A<AG;8?4G8A<A8G88AG;68AGHEL<AG;8
9BE@B9G;8 %99<6<4?)86E8GF6G
-;<?89E4@874A7FB?74F4
@84AFB96B@54GG<A:9BE8<:AFC<8F<ACE46G<68G;8?4JJ4F@BG<I4G87
ABG 5L 4AL 8KG8EA4? CBJ8E 5HG E4G;8E 5L G;8 ?84> B9 F8AF<G<I8 7B6H
@8AGF 5L 4 :BI8EA@8AG B99<6<4? GB G;8 CE8FF  )87<G<BA ?4JF ;4I8 4
?BA:8E;<FGBEL*;8L64AC8E;4CF58FG58HA78EFGBB74F46B@C?8@8AG
GB4A74ABHG:EBJG;B9GE84FBA?4JF4A<A;8E8AG?L5EB474A7I4:H8
@84AF B9 C8A4?<M<A: G;BF8 4EG<6H?4G<A: BCCBF<G<BA GB G;8 8FG45?<F;87
FLFG8@B9CBJ8E
-;<?8G;8  FC<BA4:86G8A6B@C4FF878?8@8AGF9EB@5BG;
B9G;8F8GE47<G<BAFG;8?4GG8E9HA6G<BACE87B@<A4G87A<G<4?7E49GFB9
G;8 FC<BA4:8 6G J8E8 CE8C4E87 5L FF<FG4AG GGBEA8L 8A8E4?
;4E?8F-4EE8A4A7CE8F8AG87GBBA:E8FF<A@<7  -;<?8FB@8
B9G;85<??VF@BE8E8CE8FF<I86B@CBA8AGFJ8E8E8@BI87<AFH5F8DH8AG


  *L9 & 
  -K8K  
   *L9 & 
  -K8K  
 
 )==@:@8C-<:I<KJ:K 0@:K : E>  
   $-- *<K<I 1?@K<  !..1+1)4 $-+:-<; )6, 7>-:65-6< !8-66-;; 16 :1<)16  
   &  $      ! " )  - . / 
 Y 
  FIDFI<FEK?<?@JKFIPF=J<;@K@FEC8NJ J<<?I@JKFG?<I' ,F9<IKJ @8-:1
5-6<;?1<0$=88:-;;176%0->74=<1767.#-8:-;;1>--/)41<A16:1<)1616<0-#->
74=<176):A"-:17, &$ &  #^ & ,!    
  $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




;84E<A:F G;8 9<A4? FC<BA4:8 6G G;4G C4FF87 <A HA8 B9   E8
@4<A874FHCCE8FF<I8GBB?A466BE74A68J<G;G;8GE47<G<BAB94AG<
8FC<BA4:8?4JFG;86GC8A4?<M87I4E<BHF9BE@FB9G;86B??86G<BA4A7
6B@@HA<64G<BAB9B99<6<4?FG4G8BEA4G<BA4?F86HE<GL<A9BE@4G<BAA
477<G<BA<A466BE74A68J<G;G;8GE47<G<BAB9F87<G<BA?4JFG;86GC8
A4?<M87G;8J<??9H?@4><A:BE6BAI8L<A:B9S94?F8E8CBEGFBE94?F8FG4G8
@8AGFTJ<G;S<AG8AGGB<AG8E98E8TJ<G;G;8BC8E4G<BAFB9G;8@<?<G4EL4F
J8??4FJ<??9H??L64HF<A:BE4GG8@CG<A:GB64HF8S<AFH5BE7<A4G<BA7<F
?BL4?GL@HG<ALBEE89HF4?B97HGLT
-;<?8G;<F?4GG8E?4A:H4:8J4FHF87GB4HG;BE<M8AH@8EBHFCEBF
86HG<BAF<GCEBI87@BE86;4??8A:<A:GB6BAI<6GHA78EG;8G8E@FB9G;8
FC<BA4:86GG;4AG;84HG;BE<G<8F?<>87G;4A>F<AC4EGGBE8F<FG4A68
9EB@A8J6<I<??<58EG<8FBE:4A<M4G<BAFFH6;4FG;8$4G<BA4?<I<?"<5
8EG<8FHE84HS$"TFB6<4?<FGBE:4A<M4G<BAF4A7G;8$4G<BA4?F
FB6<4G<BA9BEG;87I4A68@8AGB9B?BE87&8BC?8S$&TA
FC<E4G<BA J4F G4>8A 9EB@ G;8 FG4G8 ?8I8? ;BJ8I8E 4A7 G;8 FG4G8 B9
#BAG4A4<AC4EG<6H?4E4F<G8B99<8E686?4F;8F58GJ88A8@C?BL8EF4A7
G;84HG;BE<G<8FBABA8F<784A7BE:4A<M87?45BEBAG;8BG;8EA 4AH4EL
 ,8F4??4#BAG4A4E4A6;8EJ4F6;4E:87HA78EG;8FC<BA4:8
6G49G8E;8E898EE87GB-BB7EBJ-<?FBA4F4SGBB?4F8EI4AGB9-4??
)GE88G @<??<BA4<E8F 4A7 G;8 E<6;8FG 4A7 6EBB>878FG 333 8I8E &E8F<
78AGT  A BCCBF<G<BA GB G;8 FHCCE8FF<I8 G8A78A6<8F B9 G;8 C8E<B7
4??VF6BAI<6G<BAJ4FBI8EGHEA875LG;8?B64?9878E4?=H7:8
*;8F8G
546>9BEG;84HG;BE<G<8FJ4F5E<89;BJ8I8E4FG;8#BAG4A4?8:<F?4GHE8
DH<6>?LC4FF874A8J@BE8FGE<A:8AGFG4G8F87<G<BA?4J 
#BAG4A4VFA8J?4J<@@87<4G8?L64@8GBA4G<BA4?4GG8AG<BA<A
FC<E<A:G;8C4FF4:8B94A4@8A7@8AGGBG;8FC<BA4:86GBA#4L 


  :KF=$LE<  *L9 & (F 
  -K8K  
  FIDFI<FEK?<GIF:<JJ J<<' $;=8:)EFK< 8KY Y"8IFC;
;>8I<EEF-:?D@;K$I %0-;8176)/-$<)<=<-;)6,<0-"=*41+)<1767.-.-6;-
6.7:5)<176      &  ,!     ! ,   . 
  #  3  Y  !<F==I<P -KFE<  =,/-
-):6-,)6,)6,<0-;8176)/-+<7.A;<-:A&6:)>-4-,  /  & 
,!  Y Y  
  *L9 & 
 VV8
< 8  -K8K  Y 
  ,V .?<G<E8CKPN8J8 =@E<8E; FILGKFKN<EKPP<8IJ^@DGI@JFE

D<EK $--1,
  $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   ,8K 
 
 $--/E@K<;-K8K<JM "8CC    'FEK  
   $--,  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

 J;<6;64@8GB58>ABJA4FG;8)87<G<BA6G-;<?8G;8E8J4F
CHF;546>9EB@FB@8F8A4GBEFG;8)87<G<BA6GJ4FFGEBA:?LFHCCBEG87
5L BG;8EF <A6?H7<A: G;8 GGBEA8L 8A8E4? 4F J8?? 4F )8A4GBE "88
%I8E@4A B9 $BEG; 4EB?<A4 J;B <AF<FG87 G;4G S8I8EL )8A4GBE J;B
IBG8F4:4<AFGG;<F6BA98E8A68E8CBEG64A;4I8G;8F4G<F946G<BAB9>ABJ
<A:G;4G;8;4FIBG879BE4A4@8A7@8AGG;4GJ<??G;EBJ46?B4>B9CEB
G86G<BA4EBHA78I8ELFCL<AG;<F6BHAGEL4A78I8ELGE4<GBE4A78I8EL
B?F;8I<>4A78I8EL--G;4G<F78A<87GB4?BL4?@8E<64A6<G<
M8AT)HCCBEG875LFH6;9<8ELE;8GBE<6G;85<??C4FF87
*;8)87<G<BA6G8KC4A787G;8G8E@FB9)86G<BA*;E88B9G;8F
C<BA4:86G@BA:<GF@BE88:E8:<BHFG8E@FJ8E8C8A4?<M4G<BAFB9
S7<F?BL4?CEB94A8F6HEE<?BHFBE45HF<I8?4A:H4:8T<AG8A787GB5E<A:
G;8 :BI8EA@8AG G;8 BAFG<GHG<BA BE G;8 ?<>8 S<AGB 6BAG8@CG F6BEA
6BAGH@8?L BE 7<FE8CHG8T B9 S4AL ?4A:H4:8 <AG8A787 GB <A6<G8 CEB
IB>8BE8A6BHE4:8E8F<FG4A68GBG;8+A<G87)G4G8FBEGBCEB@BG8G;8
64HF8B9<GF8A8@<8FTB964??<A:9BES4AL6HEG4<?@8AGB9CEB7H6G<BAT
G;4G@<:;G<A4ALJ4L<@C46GG;8J4E899BEG4A7B9FHCCBEG<A:BE94
IBE<A:5L4ALSJBE7BE46GT4A8A8@LB9G;8+A<G87)G4G8FBEBCCBF
<A:G;8+A<G87)G4G8FV64HF8
*;8+A<G87)G4G8FJ4FABGG;8BA?L6BHAGELG;4GFGE8A:G;8A87<GF
45<?<GLGBCEBF86HG87<FF<78AGF<AG;<FC8E<B7AE<G4<AG;8898A68B9
G;8(84?@6GS%(T7E4@4G<64??L8KC4A787G;8CBJ8EB9G;8
8K86HG<I85E4A6;4A7J4FHF874FG;84HG;BE<GL9BEAH@8EBHF8@8E
:8A6L E8:H?4G<BAF <A6?H7<A: (8:H?4G<BA  J;<6; C8A4?<M87 G;8
FCE847<A:B9S94?F8E8CBEGFBE94?F8FG4G8@8AGFBEE8CBEGFBEFG4G8
@8AGF?<>8?LGB64HF87<F49986G<BAGB<F#4=8FGLBEGB<AG8E98E8J<G;
G;8FH668FFB9<F#4=8FGLVF9BE68F5L?4A7BEF84BEGBCE8=H7<68;<F
#4=8FGLVF E8?4G<BAF J<G; 9BE8<:A CBJ8EF T (8:H?4G<BA   J;<6;
C8A4?<M87S4GG8@CGFGB64HF8@HG<ALF87<G<BABE7<F49986G<BA4@BA:


  *L9 & 
  -K8K  "8IJ?8J@KN8J K?<-<;@K@FE:KJKFGG<;
J?FIKF=K?<;<:C8I8K@FEF=D8IK@8CC8NJFD<N<I<:8CC@E>=FI N?@:?=8@C<;KFG8JJ
K?<-<E8K< $-- ,  
GI  ' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K
Y 
   ,    
  *L9 & 
 V  -K8K  Y .?<GLE@J?D<EK=FI<8:?F=K?<J<
8:KJN8J8 =@E<8E; FILGKFKN<EKPP<8IJ^@DGI@JFED<EK $--1,.?<:K
8CJF8CCFN<;8EP>FM<IED<EK<DGCFP<<J=FLE;KF?8M<LJ<;[;@JCFP8C\C8E>L8><KF
9<;@JD@JJ<; $--1,
  .?<:K?8;K?I<<@K<I8K@FEJ!<F : L>  !<F 
: L>  !<F : (FM    FIDFI<FEK?<:K @KJ98:B

>IFLE; 8E;@KJ>CF98C@E=CL<E:< J<<,F9<IKJ ;=8:)EFK<,F9<IKJ ;=8:)EFK< 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

4ALB9<F#4=8FGLVF9BE68FBE4@BA:G;86<I<?<4ACBCH?4G<BAT4A7
(8:H?4G<BA   J;<6; C8A4?<M87 <A7H6<A: @8@58EF B9 G;8 4E@87
9BE68FSGB46G<A4@4AA8EJ;<6;FH6;C8EFBA>ABJFGB58<A6BAGE4
I8AG<BAB9TBE78EFBEE8:H?4G<BAF-;<?8%(?4CF87<A  G;8
:BI8EA@8AGHF87G;8B664F<BAB946B4?@<A8EFVFGE<>8<A 
GBE4@
G;EBH:;4A8J@8E:8A6L&BJ8EF6GS&TJ;<6;J4FHF874F
4HG;BE<GLGB<FFH84E49GB9A8J8@8E:8A6LE8:H?4G<BAF<A  <AE8
FCBAF8GB64??F5LG;8S*E<C?8??<4A68TB9@<A8EFE4<?J4L@8A4A7
GE4AFCBEGJBE>8EFG;4G;4764??879BE4A4G<BA4?FGE<>8 
AHFGE4?<4G;8 
-4E*<@8&E864HG<BAF(8C84?6GC4FF87
J<G; G;8 -- <A @<A7 47787 A8J 6E<@8F GB G;8   E<@8F 6G
<A6?H7<A:)86G<BA J;<6;@478<G4AB998AF8GB8A:4:8<ABE6BHAF8?
4F87<G<BHF8AG8ECE<F8BEGBJE<G8HGG8EBECH5?<F;F87<G<BHFJBE7F
G
4?FB8AH@8E4G874A8KG8AF<I8?<FGB9F87<G<BHF<AG8AG<BAF<A6?H7<A:4G
G8@CG<A: SGB 8K6<G8 7<F49986G<BAT GB CEB7H68 4?G8E4G<BAF <A G;8 ?4J
SBG;8EJ<F8G;4A5L?4J9H?@84AFTBESGBCEB@BG8988?<A:FB9<??J<??
4A7;BFG<?<GL58GJ88A7<998E8AG6?4FF8FB9<F#4=8FGLVFFH5=86GFT A
4A474G;8-4E#84FHE8F6G8KC4A787CBJ8EFGB78G4<A4A7CEBF8
6HG8 G;BF8 6BAF<78E87 :H<?GL B9 F87<G<BA 5EB47?L 789<A87 )<@<?4E
@84FHE8FJ8E88AGE8A6;87<AG;8?4J9B??BJ<A:G;8J4E4FJ8??HE<A:
G;8 -<AA<C8: :8A8E4? FGE<>8 4A474VF )B?<6<GBE 8A8E4? )<E H:;
HG;E<878?<I8E87G;8E8CBEGB9G;8B@@<GG88BA)87<G<BA4A7)87<
G<BHF&EBC4:4A74J;<6;;47588A6BAI8A87<AE8FCBAF8GB?45BEHA
E8FG GB G;8 BHF8 B9 B@@BAF *;8 (8CBEG 4E:H87 G;4G FGEBA:
@84FHE8FJ8E8A868FF4ELGBCE8I8AGG;8F<GH4G<BA<A4A4749EB@4C
CEBK<@4G<A:G;4G<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F*;8BHF8J4FFJ4L874A7<G
<AGEB7H6874@8A7@8AGFGB4A474VFE<@<A4?B78J;<6;C8A4?<M87
G;87<FGE<5HG<BAB9F87<G<BHF@4G8E<4?F8KG8A787G;8F6BC8B9F87<G<BA
6;4E:8F4A77E4@4G<64??L<A6E84F87G;8C8A4?GL9BEF87<G<BA

    & ! %   (FM      & ! %
  <:   
   &! % -<GK   
  .?<D<I><E:P*FN<IJ:K  !<F : E>  
   $--     1   %  *  * - 
   Y 8K Y 
 
 ,
   ():%15-":-+)=<176;#-8-)4+< K?JLJKC  .?<E<N:I@D<J
N<I<8CI<8;PC8I><CP:I@D@E8C@Q<;LE;<IJK8K<C8N $--,F><IFL>C8J $)>16/=;
<:)41).:75$-,1<176=;<75;<0-<<7:6-A-6-:)4G;-8):<5-6<)6,<0-,516
1;<:)<1767."-)+-<15-"741<1+)4-6;7:;018    & ,!    
  18I'<8JLI<J:K !<F : E> 8E  
  $--"<9 $LE<GG 
8E  
  $--I@D@E8CF;< -  V8E 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

?F8J;8E8 4EBHA7 G;8 E<G<F; @C<E8 F<@<?4E ?4JF J8E8 CHG <A
C?468AJ4EG<@8A7<4FHCCE8FF<BAB9F87<G<BAJ4F8A45?875LG;8
898A68B9A7<46GS%TJ;<6;:E4AG87G;84HG;BE<G<8F8K
G8A787CBJ8EFB978G8AG<BAJ<G;BHGGE<4?E87H6877898A74AGFVCEB68
7HE4? E<:;GF 4??BJ87 9BE G;8 HF8 B9 FC86<4? GE<5HA4?F <A 68EG4<A <A
FG4A68F4A7<@CBF87E8FGE<6G<BAFBA9E887B@B98KCE8FF<BA<A6?H7<A:
C8A4?G<8F9BEFCE847<A:94?F8A8JF4A79BE8A:4:<A:<A4AL46G<I<G<8F
G;8 :BI8EA@8AG 788@87 CE8=H7<6<4? GB G;8 J4E 899BEG A E<G4<AVF
4FG F<4A 6B?BA<8F G;8 BHG5E84> B9 -BE?7 -4E  J4F 9B??BJ87 5L
C4FF4:8B94E4A:8B9FHCCE8FF<I8@84FHE8F4<@874GF87<G<BHFJE<G
<A:F*;8F8<A6?H787G;8  )87<G<BHF&H5?<64G<BAF%E7<A4A68G;8
 )87<G<BHF&H5?<64G<BAF&BFF8FF<BA%E7<A4A684A74  %E
78E<ABHA6<?<ABA:!BA: 4FJ8??4FG;8  )87<G<BHF&H5?<64
G<BAF&EB;<5<G<BA%E7<A4A68
<AG;8)GE4<GF)8GG?8@8AGF4A7G;8  
&E<AG<A:4A7BB>FA46G@8AG <AG;8878E4G87#4?4L)G4G8F-;<?8
G;8J4ECEBI<787=HFG<9<64G<BA9BEFH6;@84FHE8FG;8CE<@4ELG4E:8GF
<A 5BG; )BHG; 4A7 4FG F<4 J8E8 4AG<6B?BA<4? A4G<BA4?<FGF 4@BA:
J;B@JBE>8EFVBE:4A<M4G<BAF4A7FB6<4?<FGFJ8E8CEB@<A8AG
)<@<?4E@84FHE8F6BAG<AH87<AC?4684A76BAG<AH87GB58CHG<A
C?468<AG;8L84EF9B??BJ<A:G;8J4EAE8FCBAF8GBG;8:EBJG;B9CEB
G8FGF<AG;84E<5584A<AG;8CBFGJ4EL84EFFC4E>875L7<F6BAG8AG

  <=<E:<F=#E;@8:K  
  $--1, FIDFI< J<< '   . # $ -  *   
' # *"#  Y  
  -<;@K@FLJ *L9C@:8K@FEJ )I;@E8E:<  (F     " %   .?< FI;@E8E:< N8J
GIF:<<;<;9P8J@D@C8ID<8JLI<@E  N?@:??8;K8I><K<;K?<I<MFCLK@FE8IP?@

E<J<C8E>L8><GI<JJ  FIDFI< J<<'@:?8<C(> (0-6$14-6+-$8-)3;":-;;-6


;7:;018)6,#=4-7.)?16:1<1;076/76/ ;C ; & &  
  Y  
  -<;@K@FLJ*L9C@:8K@FEJ*FJJ<JJ@FE)I;@E8E:< (F  " %  
   $-- " % ! % Y '8P     +1<-, 16 (  ' 
"%/# ,  Y 8K Y $--)4;7(> ;=
8:)EFK< 8KY 
 
 -<;@K@FLJ*L9C@:8K@FEJ*IF?@9@K@FE)I;@E8E:< (F   
   $-- 3FE>,  ':%<EE8 %0-=7516<)6/7>-5-6<16)4)A))6,
$16/)87:- C $ -  -     FCCFN@E>K?<N8I 
K?<J< D<8JLI<J N<I< <E?8E:<; 9P K?< *I@EK@E> *I<JJ<J )I;@E8E:<  (F      
N?@:?@DGFJ<;:I@D@E8CG<E8CK@<J=FIK?<@CC<>8CGI@EK@E>F=[GFC@K@:8C\D8K<I@8C $--
1,
  $--) 1 *?<CGJ #1;-7.<0-)*7=:7>-5-6<16)5)1+) -    
-        $L8E@K8 < 8IIFJ  &:*)6 :1<1;0 =1)6) 
C 
(0):. #)<; -6<18-,-; )6, "7:3 67+3-:;  16 '   -!   
'          Y  8K  FL>C8J "8P 
*8LCI8M<E<;J  "FN8I;$F?EJFE %0-:1<1;0):1**-)6.:75-57*141B)
<176<776;<1<=<176)4-+74761B)<176 16. )# "$ 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

G;4G 78I8?BC87 BHG B9 G;8 C4EG<6<C4G<BA B9 4E<5584A FB?7<8EF <A G;8
<EFG-BE?7-4E4A7G;8899BEGFB9#4E6HF4EI8LVF+A<I8EF4?$8:EB
@CEBI8@8AGFFB6<4G<BAG;8E<G<F;8A46G87F87<G<BA?4JF4EBHA7
G;8E8:<BA-;<?8:LCGJ4F786?4E87<A78C8A78AG5LG;8E<G<F;BA
85EH4EL    F;BEG?L 49G8E G;8 J4E :LCGVF A8J9BHA7 FBI8E
8<:AGLJ4FF;4EC?L?<@<G87-;<?84A8J6BAFG<GHG<BAJ4FCEB@H?
:4G87BACE<?   4A7)44704:;?BH?5864@8:LCGVF9<EFGCBC
H?4E?L8?86G87&E<@8#<A<FG8E<A  G;8A8J?8:4?BE78E<A6?H787
4??G;8E8CE8FF<I8?4JFG;8E<G<F;;47CHG<AC?468BI8EG;8CE8687<A:
786478F <A6?H7<A: 4 ?4J 4??BJ<A: 9<I8L84E CE<FBA G8E@F GB 58 <@
CBF87BA4ALC8EFBABEC4C8ES9B@8AG1<A:2;4GE87BE6BAG8@CG4:4<AFG
G;8 :BI8EA@8AG CEBC4:4G1<A:2 FH5I8EF<I8 <784F 6BAGE4EL GB G;8A8J
6BAFG<GHG<BABE47IB64G1<A:2G;84?G8E4G<BAB99HA74@8AG4?<AFG<GHG<BAF
5L<??8:4?@84AFTB??BJ<A:4@4FF<I8:8A8E4?FGE<>8<ABA:!BA:
G;4G?4FG879EB@  GB  G;8:BI8EA@8AG<FFH874E8:H?4G<BA54A
A<A:S4ALBE:4A<M4G<BAJ;4G8I8EJ;<6;<AG;8BC<A<BAB9G;8BI8EABE

 . ."  $ Y  $L;@K? '  IFNE  1 '  ,F><I
&FL@J<;J  .?<J<JKI@B<JN<I<EFKN@K?FLKJL::<JJ C<8;@E> =FI@EJK8E:< KF
K?<<JK89C@J?D<EKF=J<M<I8CE<NLE@FEJ @E:CL;@E>K?<$8D8@:8E <;<I8K@FEF=&8

9FLI 8E; K?< I@K@J? !L@8E8 &89FLI /E@FE  K?< I<M@M8C F= K?< .I@E@;8; 1FIB@E>

D<E^JJJF:@8K@FE 8E;K?<G8JJ8><F=8E<N.I8;</E@FE)I;@E8E:<@E$8D8@:8 
$--1, 
  $--$F?EJFE ;=8:)EFK< 
  .?<D<I@:8EFEJLC@E.I@E@;8; =FI@EJK8E:< ;<<D<;K?<8JJF:@8K@FEJ^G8

G<I  -/:7(7:4, [I<JGFEJ@9C<=FIK?<I8G@;>IFNK?F=:C8JJ8E;I8:<=<<C@E> 8E;F=


8E8I:?@JK@: 8E; FCJ?<M@JK @;<8J 8DFE> K?< @>EFI8EK GFGLC8K@FE ?<I< \ $-- .FEP
'8IK@E  ):+=; ):>-A )6, %:161,),  C   16 ! !$      
 ,LG<IK&<N@J'8LI<<E18IE<I
&<N@J<;J .?<G8G<I
N8J98EE<;@EI@K@J?"FE;LI8J I@K@J?!L@8E8 -K 0@E:<EK 8E;.I@E@;8;FM<IK?<
:FLIJ<F=8E; $--$F?EJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  .?<J<8:KJ@E:CL;<;K?<-<;@K@FLJ*L9C@:8K@FEJ*IF?@9@K@FE:K@EK?<8?8D8J
:K(F F= -<;@K@FLJ*L9C@:8K@FEJ)I;@E8E:<J@E!I8E8;8)I;@E8E:<(F 
F=  -8@EK&L:@8)I;@E8E:<(F F= 8E;-8@EK0@E:<EK)I;@E8E:<
(F F=  K?<-<;@K@FLJ*L9C@:8K@FEJ*IF?@9@K@FE:K@EK?<&<<N8I;#JC8E;J
:K(F F=  K?<-<;@K@FLJ:KJ8E;*L9C@:8K@FEJ)I;@E8E:<@E$8D8@:8)I

;@E8E:<(F  F=  8E;K?<-<;@K@FE:K@E.I@E@;8;8E;.F98>F)I;@E8E:<


(F  F=  $--"<9(FM  :FCJ Y1 ?KKGJ 8G@ G8I

C@8D<EK LB ?@JKFI@:
?8EJ8I; NI@KK<E
8EJN<IJ  EFM  :IFNE
:FCFE@<J
G<8:<

I<>LC8K@FEJ 
  $-- <:C8I8K@FE KF >PGK 9P "@J I@K8EE@: '8A<JKP^J !FM<IED<EK  <9   
 ' 1  8CP  %0- :1<1;0 !++=8)<176  C  16 .   
"$$' 1 8CP<; 
  $-- -<CD8 FKD8E  %0- 1*-:)4 /- 
C  16  .   
"$$' 1 8CP<; 
  $-- $   4  $ &   1   (
(       #     $  1    Y
 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

<ABHA6<?<FHF87GBCEB@BG84:8A8E4?FGE<>8BE7<FBE78EB94AL><A7
BEG;8FCE847B9F87<G<BAT4A7@4><A:<G4AB998A68GBSF4L4ALG;<A:
J;<6;<9E87H687GBJE<G<A:JBH?758F87<G<BHFT 4FJ8??4FE8:H?4
G<BAF4??BJ<A:9BE<@CE<FBA@8AGB97<FF8AG8EFHCBAFH@@4EL6BAI<6
G<BA
A)BHG;9E<64J;8E8G;8)BHG;9E<64AA7HFGE<4?4A7B@
@8E6<4? -BE>8EF +A<BA J4F :EBJ<A: <A FGE8A:G;  G;8 4HG;BE<G<8F
4H:@8AG87G;88KG8AF<I8J85B9E8CE8FF<I8?8:4?<GL4?E847L<AC?468
J<G; G;8   $4G<I8 7@<A<FGE4G<BA 6G J;<6; C8A4?<M87 4@BA:
BG;8EG;<A:FS4ALC8EFBAJ;BHGG8EF4ALJBE7FBE7B8F4ALBG;8E46G
BEG;<A:J;4G8I8EJ<G;<AG8AGGBCEB@BG84AL988?<A:B9;BFG<?<GL58
GJ88A$4G<I8F4A7HEBC84AFT 
F@H6;4F5L4ALBG;8EFBEGB9?8:4?CEBI<F<BAG;8AG;8 
F
4A7 
FJ8E8@4E>875L49?BHE<F;<A:B9F87<G<BA?4J*;8F8J8E8
ABGC4C8EG;E84GF@BE8BI8EFJ<??58F;BJA58?BJG;8F8?4JFJ8E8
9E8DH8AG?LHG<?<M87<ACE46G<68)87<G<BA6;4E:8FJ8E8I4?H45?8ABGBA?L
<A G;4G G;8<E 5EB47 G8E@F @478 G;8@ 4CC?<645?8 GB 4 J<78 E4A:8 B9
FC886;788@87BCCBF<G<BA4?G;8LJ8E8I4?H45?8GBB<AG;4GG;86;4E:8
B9F87<G<BA64EE<87J<G;<G4CHA6;FH::8FG<A:GBG;8J<78E6B@@HA<GL
G;4GG;BF86;4E:87J8E8ABG@8E8?L<A7<I<7H4?FJ;B;8?768EG4<A58
?<89FR9BE<AFG4A68G;4GABAJ;<G8F<A)BHG;9E<64F;BH?7588AG<G?87
GB54F<69E887B@B9@BI8@8AGR5HGG;4GG;8LJ8E8<A946G9HA74@8A
G4?G;E84GFGBG;8CB?<G<64?6B@@HA<GL

 (,"#-'(3(#&#-'1-
*;8 
F4A7 
F4?FBF4JG;8C4FF4:8B9?4JFG4E:8G<A:S4A
4E6;<F@T4A7SFLA7<64?<F@T74;BC4FF8746E<@<A4?FLA7<64?<F@?4J
BA#4E6;   G;4G789<A876E<@<A4?FLA7<64?<F@4FG;8S7B6GE<A8
J;<6; 47IB64G8F 6E<@8 F45BG4:8 I<B?8A68 B9 HA?4J9H? @8G;B7F B9


   ,<>LC8K@FEF=$8EL8IP" %  +1<-,16(FID8E'@E<IJ %0-&;-)6,
*=;-7.5-:/-6+A"7?-:;*A<0-76/76/7>-:65-6<"FE>%FE>& $  
 
 
 $--' ;=8:)EFK< 8K'@:?8<C(> -?<E>PL<4?8E>'8O1FE> 
D(07=<<0-7>-:67:16@-+=<1>-7=6+141;<0-=,/-EC1;<7:1+)4&;-7.<0-
5-:/-6+A#-/=4)<176;!:,16)6+-  " % & $    
   $--8M@;$F?EJFE 4-5-6<;),)41-<0-&)6,<0-)6/=)/-7.:--,75 
     #E8;;@K@FEKFK?<#/ GIF>I<JJ@M<8;MF:8:PN8J:FE

;L:K<;9PK?<-FLK?=I@:8E.I8;<8E;&89FLIFLE:@C =FID<;@E N?@:?8;

MF:8K<;=FIK?<FG<ED<D9<IJ?@GF=8CCKI8;<LE@FEJ8JN<CC8JK?<<JK89C@J?D<EKF=
G8I8CC<C 9C8:B LE@FEJ N?<I< FG<E D<D9<IJ?@G N8J EFK GFJJ@9C<  $-- 'G=8I@J<E@
L;<C@ %:),-&61761;5)6,"741<1+;16.:1+)%0-$7=<0.:1+)6@8-:1-6+- 
  #^& $ -     
  (8K@M<;D@E@JKI8K@FE:KF=V- =I  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

G8EEBE<F@4F4@84AFB9466B@C?<F;<A:<A7HFGE<4?BECB?<G<64?E89BE@T 
74;BVF?4JJ4FDH<6>?L8@H?4G87<A#<AA8FBG4 4A7<AG;89B??BJ<A:
G;E88L84EF<A4ABG;8EGJ8AGLBA8FG4G8F4A7GJBG8EE<GBE<8F4FJ8?? 
$H@8EBHFFG4G8F4?FBC4FF87A8J?4JFC8A4?<M<A:4A4E6;<F@GB:8G;8E
J<G;?4JFCEB;<5<G<A:G;87<FC?4LB94E879?4:<ACH5?<64FF8@5?<8F 
AA7<4@84AJ;<?89B??BJ<A:G;8J4E4S)87<G<BAB@@<GG88T
J4F8FG45?<F;87HA78EG;86;4<E@4AF;<CB9)<7A8L(BJ?4GGJ<G;4@4A
74G8GB4FF8FFS6E<@<A4?6BAFC<E46<8F6BAA86G87J<G;G;8E8IB?HG<BA4EL
@BI8@8AG<AA7<4T4A7GBS47I<F84FGBG;8?8:<F?4G<BA<94ALA868F
F4ELGB8A45?8BI8EA@8AGGB784?89986G<I8?LJ<G;G;8@T *;8B@
@<GG88VFE8CBEG9BHA7G;4G<AFHEE86G<BAE898EE87GB4F4SCB<FBAT4A74
SI<EHFT G;4G FCE847 G;EBH:; S6BAG4:<BAT J4F :EBJ<A: 4A7 E86B@
@8A787G;847BCG<BAB94A8J?4J8KG8A7<A:@4ALB9%VFCEBI<
F<BAF *;8B@@<GG88VFE86B@@8A74G<BAJ4F9B??BJ87G;EBH:;C4F
F4:8 B9 G;8 A4E6;<64? 4A7 (8IB?HG<BA4EL E<@8F 6G  @BE8
6B@@BA?L>ABJA4FG;8(BJ?4GG6GJ;<6;:4I8G;8BI8EABE8A
8E4?<ABHA6<?CBJ8EGB4HG;BE<M8FC86<4?GE<5HA4?F4A78KG8A787CBJ
8EFB9F84E6;4EE8FG4A778G8AG<BAJ<G;BHGGE<4?J;8E8;86BAF<78E87
G;4GG;8E8J8E8F8E<BHFG;E84GFGBCH5?<6F498GL

A4E6;<F@FLA7<64?<F@4A7E879?4:?4JF?46>87G;85E847G;B9
G;8 @BE8 :8A8E4? F87<G<BA ?4JF G;8L 466B@C4A<87 L 6E<@<A4?<M<A:
C4EG<6H?4E 9BE@F B9 ?89G<FG <78B?B:L 4A7 46G<I<GL ;BJ8I8E G;8 ?4JF
@47846?84EFG4G8@8AGE8?4G<I8GBG;BF8J;B@<:;G<78AG<9LJ<G;FH6;

  :KF='8I:?  :?  #;8?F-<JJ &8NJ 
  :KF=GI@C  :?  '@EE &8NJ 
  $--?D<;1?@K< %0-:15-7.+76751+#),1+)41;5:1516)4$A6,1+)41;5
)?;)6,<0-6,=;<:1)4(7:3-:;7.<0-(7:4,C  ) & ,!  
  $--)4;74<:?8I@8??8=<<$I -/1;4)<176/)16;<6):+0A (", 
$LCP     "   "$    -$ 
&  / - 0@E:<EKC8J@ %0-1:;<5-6,5-6<
)6,<0-,-)47.1>1+7=:)/-%0-:)6,-1;!816176161?@KE<PM 8C@=FIE@8 
1 ' $& ,!   
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K.?<G8JJ8><F=JL:?C8NJN8J?<8M@CPJLG

GFIK<;9PK?<LI<8LF=#EM<JK@>8K@FE[F#\ $--1,8KY 
  -  , @@@ 8C:LKK8 -LG<I@EK<E;<EK !FM<IED<EK
*I@EK@E>  +1<-,16% 1         
 '   '    $--)4;7*<K<I,F99 . !!
#   , * ."  *     Y
 8K  Y$FJ<G?':+L8;< .<IIFI@JD &8N 8E;-FM<I<@>EKP@E
#E;@8 8E; K?< &<8>L< F= (8K@FEJ  Y  8K Y   F:KFI8C .?<J@J 
.I@E@KP"8CC 
  $-- ."  ^!1   $
." $1  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  E8I:?@:8C8E;,<MFCLK@FE8IPI@D<J:K #E;@8 

 $--1,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

:EBHCF BE 6BAF<78E HA78EG4><A: @BE8 BI8EG 9BE@F B9 FB6<4?<FG 47IB
646L*;8LC?4L874I4?H45?8EB?8<AG;4G6BAG8KGB96B@C?8@8AG<A:
G;8F8AF8B94AG<FG4G8G;E84G6BAI8L875LF87<G<BA?4JFJ<G;G;8@BE8
:8A8E4?<M8778?8:<G<@<M4G<BAG;4G64@8J<G;FH::8FG<A:?89G<FGCB?<G<64?
46G<I<GLJ4F6E<@<A4?

 --)#.#)((.,#%1-
-BE>8EFV47IB646L<AG;8C8E<B7J4F4?FB@8G5L?8:4?@84FHE8F
E8FGE<6G<A:9E887B@B94FFB6<4G<BA4A74FF8@5?LAG;8+A<G87)G4G8F
G;8)HCE8@8BHEGC?4L874>8LEB?8<AG;<F6BAG8KGG;EBH:;4F8E<8F
B9 E8FGE<6G<I8 786<F<BAF <A   4A7   A
/*&2 ,#(.#(! ,--
)0
,#(! G;8BHEGE8499<E@87<GF84E?<8EEH?<A:<A)10
1&),
9<A7<A:G;4GF86BA74EL5BL6BGGFJ8E8HA?4J9H?78FC<G8G8E@F
<AG;8  ?4LGBAAG<GEHFG6G8KCE8FF?LFH::8FG<A:G;8BCCBF<G8

A,/20 ),,#!(
G;8BHEG9BHA7E<MBA4VF4AG<<A=HA6G<BA?4J
HA6BAFG<GHG<BA4?A',#(.& )/(,#-0,# #.3, )/(
#&
G;8BHEG8FF8AG<4??LBHG?4J87C<6>8G<A:A(#.#(),%
,-0 ),)() )& )
G;8BHEG4??BJ87?4E:874@4:8FGB58
?8I8?874:4<AFGHA<BAF8A:4:<A:<A<A7HFGE<4?46G<BA78F<:A87GBCE8
I8AG8@C?BL8EF9EB@F;<9G<A:GB4ABC8AF;BC4CCEB46;*;<F9?HEELB9
=H7<6<4? 46G<I<GL F;4EC?L 6BAFGE4<A87 HA<BAFV CBJ8E 4H:@8AG<A: G;8
89986GFB9G;8I4E<BHF6E<@<A4??4JF7<F6HFF8745BI8
$BI8??8:4?E8FGE<6G<BAFBAHA<BAF4A7FGE<>8FJ8E86B@@BA8?F8
J;8E8<AG;8C8E<B74FJ8??AE<G4<A<A477<G<BAGBG;8CE8I<BHF?L
@8AG<BA87E8:H?4G<BAF%(J4FHF87GB<FFH8E8:H?4G<BAFG4E:8G<A:
4FF8@5?<8F<A6?H7<A:(8:H?4G<BA<FFH87<AE8FCBAF8GB4C?4AA87
C46<9<FG78@BAFGE4G<BAJ;<6;4??BJ87G;84HG;BE<G<8F
J;8E8G;8E8<FE84FBAGB4CCE8;8A7G;4GG;8;B?7<A:B94@88G<A:
<A 4 CH5?<6 C?468 J<?? :<I8 E<F8 GB :E4I8 7<FBE78E  12 GB @4>8 4A
BE78ECEB;<5<G<A:G;8;B?7<A:B9G;8@88G<A:4A7<94@88G<A:<F;8?7
BE4GG8@CG87GB58;8?7<A6BAGE4I8AG<BAB94ALFH6;CEB;<5<G<BA
GBG4>8FH6;FG8CF4F@4L58A868FF4ELGB7<FC8EF8G;8@88G<A:



  LGC<O*I@EK *I<JJF M <<I@E> / -  

 &F<N<M &8NCFI  / -   

 =84-@":16<":-;;7 / - 8K 

 .IL8OM FII@>8E / -  

 D -K<<C FLE;I@<JM .I@
@KP<EK .I8;<JFLE:@C / -  

 /E@K<;'@E<1FIB<IJM FIFE8;FF8CF / -  

  & ! %   GI      & ! %
GI   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

4A7 (8:H?4G<BA   J;<6; 4??BJ87 F86HE<GL B99<6<4?F GB 4GG8A7


S@88G<A:1F2 BE 4FF8@5?1<8F2  B9 FH6; 4 6;4E46G8E G;4G 4A B998A68
4:4<AFGG;8F8E8:H?4G<BAF@4L586B@@<GG87G;8E84GT
B??BJ<A:G;8
@4FF<I8 :8A8E4? FGE<>8 <A   G;8   *E478 <FCHG8F 4A7 *E478
+A<BAF6GBHG?4J87FGE<>8F4<@874GS6B8E6<A:TG;8:BI8EA@8AG4A7
F86BA74ELFGE<>8FCEBI<7874@H6;5EB478E4A7I4:H8E789<A<G<BAB9
<AG<@<74G<BAG;4AG;4GJ;<6;;47CE8I<BHF?L588A<A89986G4A7CEB
;<5<G87@4FFC<6>8G<A:4A7C<6>8G<A:4GJBE>8EFV;B@8F

?F8J;8E8E8FGE<6G<I8?4JFJ8E8B9G8ADH<G8FC86<9<64??LG4E:8G87
<A6?H7<A:4:4<AFGG;8--AHFGE4?<4<A  984E9H?B94:8A8E4?
FGE<>8 G;8 :BI8EA@8AG <AGEB7H687 G;8 +A?4J9H? FFB6<4G<BAF <??
J;<6;786?4E875BG;G;8--4A74ALBG;8ES4FFB6<4G<BAJ;<6;<A
6<G87@8AGBG;8G4><A:B9?<98BEG;878FGEH6G<BAB9CEBC8EGLTHA?4J9H?
4A7 S@478 <G 4 FH@@4EL B998A68  GB 58?BA: GB FH6; 4A 4FFB6<4
G<BAT

*;85<??C4FF87<A9<I874LF
*;8+A?4J9H?FFB6<4G<BAF6G
J4F 4@8A787 <A   :E4AG<A: G;8 :BI8EA@8AG 8A;4A687 45<?<GL GB
786?4E84FFB6<4G<BAF<??8:4?4A7C8A4?<M<A:FHCCBEG9BEFH6;BE:4A<M4
G<BAF *;8F8CEBI<F<BAFJ8E84H:@8AG875L  4@8A7@8AGFGBG;8
E<@8F 6G  J;<6; 8KG8A787 G;8 :EBHA7F BA J;<6; 4FFB6<4G<BAF
6BH?758788@87HA?4J9H? *;84@8A7@8AGF4?FB:4I8G;8BI8E
ABE8A8E4?CBJ8EGB<FFH84S&EB6?4@4G<BATJ;8E8<A;<FBC<A<BA
G;8E8J4FS4F8E<BHF<A7HFGE<4?7<FGHE54A68CE8=H7<6<A:BEG;E84G8A<A:
GE478BE6B@@8E68T ALBA86BAG<AH<A:GBG4>8C4EG<A4S?B6>BHG
BE FGE<>8T 9B??BJ<A: FH6; 4 CEB6?4@4G<BA JBH?7 58 :H<?GL B9 4A B9
98AF8 BL6BGGFBEG;E84GFB95BL6BGGFC8EG4<A<A:GBG;8CEBI<F<BAB9
CH5?<6F8EI<68FBESG;8GE4AFCBEGB9:BB7FBEG;86BAI8L4A68B9C4F
F8A:8EF<AGE478BE6B@@8E68TJ8E8F<@<?4E?LCHA<F;45?8 



 $--&! % <9   

 .I8;<@JGLK<J8E;.I8;</E@FEJ:K !<F : E>  


 .  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 



 &64)?.=4;;7+1)<176;+< K?(F LJKC  $--.  ;=8:)EFK<
 8K (<N-FLK?18C<J8L>D<EK<;K?@JJK<G9PG8JJ@E>K?<I@D<J*I<M<EK@FE
:K =8:@C@K8K@E>GIFJ<:LK@FE=FI@E:@K<D<EK 
  $--1,8K 
  $--6+<<75-6,<0-:15-+< C  K?(F LJKC  
  $--1,V  -FC@:@K@E>JLGGFIKFIGL9C@J?@E>8EP;F:LD<EK=FIJL:?8E
FI>8E@Q8K@FEN8J8CJFG<E8C@Q<; K?<GL9C@:8K@FEJF=JL:?FI>8E@Q8K@FEJN<I<98EE<;
=IFD K?< GFJK  8E; 8EP >FF;J K?<P GFJJ<JJ<; N<I< :FEJ@;<I<; [=FI=<@K5<;6 KF K?<
%@E> \$--1,V 
! 
  ,V $ 
  ,V $ 
  ,V % 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

A 4A474 GBJ4E7 G;8 J4EVF 8A7 %E78EF <A BHA6<? BHG?4J87
FGE<>8F4A7?B6>BHGF 4A7786?4E87F8I8E4?CEBJBE>8EBE:4A<M4G<BAF
<??8:4?<A6?H7<A:G;8--4A74ALBG;8E4FFB6<4G<BA4<@874G5E<A:<A:
45BHG S4AL :BI8EA@8AG CB?<G<64? FB6<4? <A7HFGE<4? BE 86BAB@<6
6;4A:8J<G;<A4A474T A477<G<BAGB8KC4A7<A:G;8C8A4?G<8F9BE
F87<G<BAG;8  4@8A7@8AGFGB4A474VF&8A4?B786E<@<A4?<M87
4FFB6<4G<BAFJ;<6;;47G;8SCEB98FF87CHECBF8TBEJ;<6;G4H:;G47
IB64G87BE7898A787BES5L4AL@84AFC8EF86HG8172BECHEFH8172TG;8
4<@FB9S:BI8EA@8AG4?<A7HFGE<4?BE86BAB@<66;4A:8J<G;<A4A474
5LHF8B99BE68I<B?8A68BEC;LF<64?<A=HELGBC8EFBABECEBC8EGLBE
5LG;E84GFB9FH6;<A=HELT

?F8J;8E84EBHA7G;8E<G<F;@C<E84E4A:8B9@84FHE8FJ8E8
CHG<AC?468?<@<G<A:G;89E887B@FB94FFB6<4G<BA4A74FF8@5?L4FJ8??
AG;84FG9E<64&EBG86GBE4G84F8E<8FB94@8A7@8AGFGB?45BE?4J
J8E8C4FF877HE<A:G;8J4E4??BJ<A:9BE9BE687?45BEG<:;G8A<A:G;8
6BAFGE4<AGFBA8@C?BL88FHA78EG;8#4FG8E4A7)8EI4AG?4J4A78A
;4A6<A: CHA<F;@8AGF 9BE 5E84><A: 6BAGE46GF  A 477<G<BA G;8  
(8:<FGE4G<BAB9$4G<I8F%E7<A4A68<@CBF874FLFG8@B9<78AG<GL68E
G<9<64G8F>ABJA4F%#*(J;<6;J8E8HF87GB6BAGEB?G;8?45BE4A7
@BI8@8AGB99E<64AJBE>8EFA:LCGG;8?8:4?FLFG8@<A;8E<G87
5L G;8 -497 49G8E 9BE@4? <A78C8A78A68 <A6?H787 ?4JF E8DH<E<A: G;8
CB?<68GB58ABG<9<87<ABE78E9BE4CH5?<64FF8@5?LGB58;8?74A7:<I
<A:G;8@G;8CBJ8EGB7<FFB?I8G;4G4FF8@5?L<9G;8LF4J9<GGB7BFB
4A7CEB;<5<G<A:FGE<>8F5LJBE>8EF<AGE4AFCBEG4G<BABE4GCH5?<6HG<?<
G<8FRG;8 GJB F86GBEF J<G; G;8 @BFG BE:4A<M87 JBE>8EF <A :LCGR


  (F
-KI@B<)I;<I
@E
FLE:@C -# 8E  
  )I;<I
@E
FLE:@C   -#   8E   FI DFI<  J<< I8; -K  IF@O 
)*7=: 7>-5-6<; %:),- &6176; )6, $<:13-; )6),)  16 Y )
#  $  11   ?KKGJ <E:P:CF

G<;@8 

FEC@E< E<K 8IK@:C< C89FLI7DFM<D<EKJ7KI8;<7LE

@FEJ78E;7JKI@B<J7:8E8;8 

 $--E:KKFD<E;K?<I@D@E8CF;< -   V 
  $--8M@;E;<IJFE -6A) C
#-/1;<:)<176)6,#7=/0=;<1+- 16
'  -!   '     Y 
;=8:)EFK< 8K  
  $--8M@;E;<IJFE );<-:)6,$-:>)6<1674761)4-6A) C
 
$    "        P   FM<I 8 D@CC@FE G8JJ<J ?8; 9<<E @JJL<; @E
%<EP8 $--E;<IJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 J@D@C8IJPJK<DN8J@DGC<D<EK<;
@E @E.8E>8EP@B8 $--' % 8EKFE %0-74761)4!..1+- C 76
;<)6<4A<0-$=*2-+<7.$5)44$<:=//4-; 16'  -!   '  
   Y ;=8:)EFK< #E9PK?<'8JK<I8E;
(8K@M<-<IM8EKJ)I;@E8E:<8E;K?<<JK@KLK<*<IJFEJ)I;@E8E:< #E 8E<NG<

E8C:F;<N8J@EKIF;L:<; N?@:?98EE<;8JJF:@8K@FEJ8E;8JJ<D9C@<J $--1,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




HA?8FFG;8LCEBI<7879<9G88A74LFVCE<BEABG<68A)BHG;9E<64G;8
 +E54AE84F6GFGE8A:G;8A87G;8:BI8EA@8AGVF6BAGEB?BI8E9
E<64A@8AVF45<?<GLGBE8F<78<ABEGE4I8?GBBEG;EBH:;HE54A4E84F
$8J?45BE?8:<F?4G<BA<A  @84AJ;<?8?<@<G87G;845<?<GLB9J;<G8
JBE>8EFGBFGE<>84A78K6?H787@8@58EFB9G;8A4G<I8CBCH?4G<BA9EB@
=B<A<A:HA<BAF4A74668FF<A:A8J?L8FG45?<F;87J4:87<FCHG8@87<4
G<BA<AFG<GHG<BAFABA:!BA:9B??BJ<A:G;8  Q  :8A8E4?
FGE<>8G;8:BI8EA@8AG<FFH87E8:H?4G<BAF4HG;BE<M<A:G;8CB?<68GB7<F
C8EF8CEB68FF<BAFCEB;<5<G@88G<A:FCEBF6E<58?45BEHA<BAF4A7F8<M8
4A76BA9<F64G8CE<AG<A:@46;<A8EL
ABG;8ECB?<G<8F?4JFJ8E8C4FF87B99<6<4??LE86B:A<M<A:468EG4<A
FC4689BEHA<BAFBEFGE<>8FJ;<?8F;4EC?LE8FGE<6G<A:JBE>8EFV45<?<GLGB
89986G<I8?LHG<?<M8G;8<EE<:;GF<ACE46G<68AA7<4G;8 
FF4JAH
@8EBHF@4=BEFGE<>8F<A6?H7<A:;HA7E87FB9FGE<>8F<A;@874547VF
G8KG<?8@<??F4A78A:4?VF=HG8@<??F?4E:8FGE<>8F<AB@54LVF6BGGBA
@<??F <A   FGE<>8F BA G;8 $BEG; -8FG8EA (4<?J4L <A   4A7
FGE<>8F<A!;4E4:CHE<A  *;8:BI8EA@8AGE8FCBA787J<G;G;8
 *E478+A<BAF6G-;<?8G;86G4??BJ87GE478HA<BAFGB58
?8:4??LE8:<FG8E87<G4?FBE8FGE<6G87G;846G<I<G<8FHA<BAF6BH?78A:4:8
<A4A7G;8HF8FGBJ;<6;HA<BAF6BH?7CHGG;8<E9HA7FF;4EC?L7<FG<A
:H<F;87E8:<FG8E879EB@HAE8:<FG8E87HA<BAF4A7E89E4<A879EB@<@
CBF<A:?<@<G4G<BAFBAJBE>8EFV6<I<?4A76E<@<A4??<45<?<GL9BEGE478HA
<BA46G<I<G<8F A&4?8FG<A8@84AJ;<?84A8J?45BEBE7<A4A68G;8
&E8I8AG<BAB9AG<@<74G<BA%E7<A4A68GBB>89986G<A  *;8A8J


  $--&  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--'8IK@E?8EF:B $7=<0.:1+) C #)+-76<:)+<)6,7-:+176 
16 '   -!    '          Y
 ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  #E;LJKI@8CFE:@C@8K@FE:KF=- =I -?LC8'8IBJ $7=<0-:6.:1+) 16
. )# "$     $L;@K?' IFNE1 ' 
,F><I&FL@J<;J  
  $--(> 4?8E>1FE> ;=8:)EFK< 
  $--98E@'LB?<IA@ 6,1)6)*7=:7>-5-6<#->1-?7.<0-$1<=)<176 
  ,! -   -  1   #  "$
$ '!
 8KY!<FI><J&@<K<E $<:13
-:; )6, $<:13-:-)3-:; 75*)A %-@<14- 144; $<:13-       *^$
1$  
  .I8;</E@FE:K #E;@8 
   $--- ;=8:)EFK<  8KY J-<EEFK<J -<:K@FE F=K?<#E;@8E
*<E8CF;<8CCFN<;=FI:I@D@E8CG<E8CK@<JKF9<@DGFJ<;FEK?FJ<G8IK@:@G8K@E>@E
LEI<>@JK<I<;LE@FE8:K@M@K@<J $--1,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

BE7<A4A68B99<6<4??L4??BJ87C<6>8GF5HG9BE5478FGE<>8EF9EB@<A9?H
8A6<A:BG;8EF4A7@478<AG<@<74G<BAFH5=86GGB;84ILC8A4?GL

AG<4FFB6<4G<BA4A7FGE<>8?4JFGBB>@4AL9BE@F<A6?H7<A:5BG;
G;8G4E:8G<A:B9C4EG<6H?4E4FFB6<4G<BAF4FJ8??4F@BE8:8A8E4?54AF
4A7J8E84GG<@8F@<K87J<G;@BE8C8E@<FF<I8CEBI<F<BAFG8FG<9L<A:
GBG;8946GG;4G?45BECBJ8E6BH?7ABG4?J4LF586B@C?8G8?L78A<87
-;<?8?8:4??<@<G4G<BAFBA4FFB6<4G<BA4A74FF8@5?LJ8E89EB@BA8
CB<AG B9 I<8J ?8FF 7E46BA<4A G;4A C8A4?<M4G<BAF B9 F87<G<BA 4A7 G;8
?<>8J;<6;GLC<64??L64EE<87?8A:G;LF8AG8A68F<ACE46G<68G;8LJ8E8
CBG8AG<4??L8I8A@BE889986G<I8G4E:8G<A:4A7?<@<G<A:CE86<F8?LG;BF8
9BE@FB96B??86G<I88A784IBEA868FF4ELGB8A45?8G;878I8?BC@8AGB9
@BE88:4?<G4E<4ACB?<6<8F


 #!,.#)(1-
*;8 
F4A7 
F4?FBF4JG;8C4FF4:8B9F8I8E4?E8FGE<6G<I8
@<:E4G<BA?4JF4EBHA7G;8JBE?7-;<?8FH6;?4JF;47@H?G<C?8CHE
CBF8FBA86BAF<FG8AG@BG<I4G<A:946GBEJ4FG;878F<E8GB?<@<GG;8@B
5<?<GL B9 ?45BE 4:<G4GBEF  A8J @@<:E4G<BA 6G J4F C4FF87 <A G;8
+A<G87)G4G8FBA85EH4EL   *;86G;47588A7854G87F<A68
 4F4@84AFB9E8FCBA7<A:GBG;84:<G4G<BA64EE<87BHG5LG;8--
J;<6;J4FG;BH:;GGB;4I8@4AL9BE8<:A@8@58EFG@4784AL4?
<8A78CBEG45?8BAG;8:EBHA7FB9G;8<E;4I<A:S47IB64G1872BEG14H:;G2
G;8HA?4J9H?78FGEH6G<BAB9CEBC8EGLBE4A4E6;LBEG;8BI8EG;EBJ
5L9BE68BEI<B?8A68B9G;8BI8EA@8AGB9G;8+A<G87)G4G8FBEB94??
9BE@FB9?4JBEG;84FF4FF<A4G<BAB9CH5?<6B99<6<4?FT*;8?4J
4?FBE8DH<E87G;4G<@@<:E4AGFC4FF4?<G8E46LG8FG<A6E84F87G;847@<F
F<BAG4K4A78K6?H7874A8KG8AF<I8F8GB9<A7<I<7H4?F54EE879EB@47
@<FF<BA7<F6HFF87<AG;8F86G<BABA<78B?B:<64?9BE@4G<BAF58?BJ
$BG ?BA: 589BE8 G;8 8A7 B9 G;8 J4E G;8 @@<:E4G<BA 6G B9
  4?FB >ABJA 4F G;8 ?<8A A4E6;<FGF K6?HF<BA 6G J4F
C4FF87*;86G4??BJ87G;89878E4?:BI8EA@8AGGB8K6?H784A778CBEG
4AL4?<8AFJ;BJ8E8S4A4E6;<FGFTJ;BS58?<8I8172<ABE47IB64G8172
G;8 BI8EG;EBJ 5L 9BE68 BE I<B?8A68 B9 G;8 BI8EA@8AG  BE B9 4??
9BE@F B9 ?4JT J;B S7<F58?<8I8172 <A BE 1J8E82 BCCBF87 GB 4??

 
 $-- !0 - (  & /
*  #  Y 8K  
   #DD@>I8K@FE:KF= *L9 & (F 
  -K8K  
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  #DD@>I8K@FE:KF=VV  -K8K 8K  
  $--1,
  #DD@>I8K@FE:KF= *L9 & (F 
  -K8K   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

BE:4A<M87:BI8EA@8AGTJ;BS47IB64G8172BEG14H:;G2G;84FF4FF<A4
G<BA B9 CH5?<6 B99<6<4?FT J;B S47IB64G8172 BE G14H:;G2 G;8 HA?4J9H?
78FGEH6G<BAB9CEBC8EGLTBEJ;BJ8E8S@8@58EFB9BE499<?<4G87J<G;
4AL BE:4A<M4G<BA G;4G 8AG8EG4<A1872 4 58?<89 <A G14H:;G2 BE 47IB
64G8172TBA8B9G;845BI88A7F
*;8CBFGJ4EL84EFF4JF8I8E4?@84FHE8F9B??BJ<A:HCBAG;8?
<8AA4E6;<FGFK6?HF<BA6G*;8@@<:E4G<BA6GB9  4?FB
>ABJA4FG;8@8E:8A6L'HBG46G<@CBF87DHBG4FBA<@@<:E4AGF
BAG;854F<FB9C?468B9BE<:<AA  G;88C4EG@8AGB9 HFG<686B@
@8A687 78A4GHE4?<M4G<BA CEB6887<A:F 4:4<AFG 4?? A7<4AF HA78E G;8
6G@BG<I4G875LG;8E868AGE47<64?46G<I<GLB9G;8;474E<G8F*;8
9B??BJ<A:L84EG;8  @@<:E4G<BA6G 4?FB>ABJA4FG;8$4
G<BA4?%E<:<AF6G8FF8AG<4??L54AA87F<4A<@@<:E4G<BAFGGBEA8L
8A8E4? B;A&E8FGBACHG<GS1G2;<F6BHAGEL<FABJ?84EA<A:G;4GJ8
@HFG G846; G;8 ABA4FF<@<?45?8 C4E4F<G<6 BE:4A<M4G<BAF <A BHE @<7FG
G;4GG;<F<F4?4A7B9?<58EGLABG46BHAGELB9@8E8?<68AF8T

#<:E4G<BA?4JF@BG<I4G875LG;878F<E8GB?<@<GG;8@BI8@8AGB9
E47<64?FJ8E88A46G87<ABG;8ECB?<G<8FGBBAE<G4<A%(4HG;BE
<M878@8E:8A6L(8:H?4G<BA J;<6;4??BJ879BEC8EFBAFSFHFC86G87
B946G<A:BEB9;4I<A:46G87BEB958<A:45BHGGB46G<A4@4AA8ECE8=
H7<6<4?GBG;8CH5?<6F498GLBEG;87898A68B9G;8(84?@TGB58E8@BI87
9EB@ C4EG<6H?4E C4EGF B9 G;8 6BHAGEL 4A7 (8:H?4G<BA  J;<6; 4?
?BJ87 9BE C8EFBAF B9 S;BFG<?8 BE<:<A BE 4FFB6<4G<BAFT GB ;4I8 G;8<E
@BI8@8AGFE8FGE<6G87GB58E8DH<E87GBE8?B64G8BEGB58<AG8EA87 
AHFGE4?<4<A477<G<BAGB<GFBG;8ECEBI<F<BAFG;8  +A?4J9H?
FFB6<4G<BAF6G4??BJ879BEG;878CBEG4G<BAB9ABAHFGE4?<4A5BEA
@8@58EFB9FH6;4FFB6<4G<BAFA 
G;8HFGE4?<4A:BI8EA@8AG
4@8A787G;8@@<:E4G<BA6GB9 
GB4??BJ9BEG;878CBEG4G<BAB9
4?<8AF9BHA7GB;4I847IB64G87G;8I<B?8AGBI8EG;EBJBE45B?<G<BAB9
G;8:BI8EA@8AGBEJ;BJ8E8@8@58EFB9BE:4A<M4G<BAF6BAF<78E87GB
;4I88AG8EG4<A87FH6;<784FB??BJ<A:4@4=BEF84@8AVFFGE<>8<A

  ,VVY 
  #DD@>I8K@FE:KF= *L9 &(F 
 -K8K  
  $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   #DD@>I8K@FE:KF= *L9 &(F 
 -K8K '8P  
 
 $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
    &! % (FM  ;--&! %
 <:  "! $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  &64)?.=4;;7+1)<176;+< K?(F LJKC  $--)4;7.  ;=8:)
EFK< 8KY 
  $--,F><IFL>C8J --816/<0-#->74=<176)<)A%0-&64)?.=4;;7+1)<176;
":7>1;176;7.<0-75576?-)4<0:15-;+<  & ,!     

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

 G;8:BI8EA@8AG<AGEB7H687A8J4@8A7@8AGFGBG;8@@<:E4G<BA
6G :E4AG<A: G;8 @<A<FG8E CBJ8E GB 78CBEG 4AL C8EFBA SABG 5BEA <A
HFGE4?<4T J;8E8 G;8 @<A<FG8E J4F F4G<F9<87 G;4G G;4G C8EFBA J4F <A
IB?I87<A;<A78E<A:G;8GE4AFCBEG4G<BAGE4786B@@8E68BECEBI<F<BA
B9CH5?<6F8EI<68FA<AGEB7H6<A:G;86G&E<@8#<A<FG8EEH688@
C;4F<M87G;4GG;<FCBJ8EJ4FA88787BAG;8:EBHA7G;4G<A7HFGE<4?7<F
GHE54A68F<AHFGE4?<4<AE868AGL84EF;47SABG1588A264HF875LG;8
HFGE4?<4A5BEA5HG1E4G;8E2J8E87H8GBG;87B6GE<A8F4A74G@BFC;8E8
<AGEB7H6875L4?<8AFT
A4A474G;8-4E#84FHE8F6G:E4AG878KC4A787CBJ8EFB9
8K6?HF<BA4A778CBEG4G<BA%A HA8  7HE<A:4A7<AE846G<BA
GBG;8-<AA<C8::8A8E4?FGE<>84A47<4A<@@<:E4G<BACB?<6<8FJ8E8
4@8A787GB4??BJ9BEG;878CBEG4G<BAB94ALC8EFBABG;8EG;4A4A4
7<4A 6<G<M8AF 5BEA <A 4A474 6BAI<6G87 B9 68EG4<A B998AF8F B9 F87<
G<BAB??BJ<A:G;8FGE<>8G;8:BI8EA@8AG<AGEB7H687A8J4@8A7
@8AGFGBG;8?4J4??BJ<A:9BEG;878CBEG4G<BAB9G;BF8J;B7898A787
G;8HA?4J9H?78FGEH6G<BAB9CEBC8EGLBEJ;B4FFH@87J<G;BHG?4J9H?
4HG;BE<GLCBJ8EFB9G;8:BI8EA@8AG<A4A474BE4ALC4EGG;8E8B9
"45BE4:<G4GBE<AFC<E87@<:E4G<BAE8FGE<6G<A:@84FHE8FJ8E8CHG
<AC?4688?F8J;8E84EBHA7G;8E<G<F;@C<E84FJ8??B??BJ<A:G;8
6B@@8A68@8AGB9G;8<EFG-BE?7-4EF8I8E4?G;BHF4A7;474E<G8F
58:4AE8GHEA<A:GBA7<4 J4E8B9G;8@BI8@8AGVFE8IB?HG<BA4EL
4<@FG;8E<G<F;58:4AGBI<8JS8I8ELA7<4AE8GHEA<A:9EB@@8E<64
BE4A474J;8G;8E?45BHE8E4EG<F4ABEFGH78AGJ<G;G;8:E84G8FG
FHFC<6<BA4F4CEB545?846G<I8E8IB?HG<BA4ELBE4G4ALE4G84FL@C4
G;<M8EJ<G;G;8E8IB?HG<BA4ELC4EGLT
66BE7<A:?LG;8:BI8EA@8AG
C4FF87G;8A:E8FF<AGBA7<4%E7<A4A68 J;<6;<A6?H787G;8<AFGEH6
G<BAG;4G8I8ELE8GHEA<A:A7<4ASJ4FGB58E8:4E787J<G;G;8:E84G8FG
FHFC<6<BA4A78I8A4F4CBG8AG<4?E8IB?HG<BA4ELTJ<G;G;BF8J;BJ8E8
SE84FBA45?L FHFC86G87 GB 58 B9 E8IB?HG<BA4EL 499<?<4G<BAFT GB 58

  $--- ,@:B<KJFE 1*-:)4)?16)#-8:-;;1>-/-755=61;5)6,<0-)?
 C  ' / & ,!    Y  
  $--1,8K :@K@E> 75576?-)4<0"):41)5-6<):A-*)<-; Y$LE<
  
  .?<18I'<8JLI<J:K  !<F :/ %  
  $--18CB<I ;=8:)EFK< 8K&<JC@<%8KQ $75--/)476;-9=-6+-;7.
<0-(16618-/-6-:)4$<:13-7. '  & $   &<;<ID8E ;=8:)
EFK< 8KY 
  $--%8KQ ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8K
 ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
 
   #  $  - $    !   $ 
Y 8K:@K<;@E,   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   #E>I<JJ@EKF#E;@8)I;@E8E:< 0@:K : E>  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

78G4<A87HE<A:G;8J4E%J4FHF874F4HG;BE<GL9BE4#4E6;
 ABG<9<64G<BAE8DH<E<A:4C4FFCBEG9BE8AGELBE8K<G9EB@A7<45L
F84B??BJ<A:G;8J4EG;84HG;BE<G<8FE8A78E87G;8A8JC4FFCBEG
E8:<@8 C8E@4A8AG G;EBH:; G;8 
 A7<4A &4FFCBEG 6G ?F8
J;8E8@BE8?<@<G87@84FHE8FJ8E8CHG<AGB89986G4?58<GJ<G;<AG;8
F4@85EB478E6BAFG8??4G<BAB96BA68EAFABA:!BA:G;8  %E78E
<ABHA6<?7<F6HFF8745BI88KC4A787G;8:BI8EA@8AGVFCBJ8EFE8?4
G<I8GB8K6?HF<BA4A778CBEG4G<BAA:LCGG;8?8:4?FLFG8@<A;8E
<G875LG;8-497<A6?H7874?4JC8E@<GG<A:G;88KCH?F<BAB9SI4:E4AGFT
9EB@6<G<8F
#<:E4G<BA ?4JF 4E8 B9G8A 6BAG8@C?4G87 <A 4 I46HH@ F8C4E4G8
9EB@G;8;<FGBELB96BE86<I<?4A7CB?<G<64?E<:;GF?84E?L;BJ8I8E
<A6E84F<A:?LFGE<6G@<:E4G<BAE8:H?4G<BAF<AG;8 
F4A7 
FJ8E8
<A9?H8A687<AFH5FG4AG<4?C4EG5LG;8GE4AFA4G<BA4?E47<64?<F@B9G;8C8
E<B74F78@BAFGE4G875LG;89E8DH8AG4GG8AG<BAGB4A4E6;<FGFG;8--
4A7G;8?<>8J<G;<A@<:E4G<BA?4JF*;8F8?4JF6BAFG<GHG874ABG;8E>8L
6B@CBA8AGB9G;85EB478E4E6;<G86GHE8B9FHCCE8FF<BAG;4G78I8?BC87
<AG;8C8E<B7

 (-),-"#*1-
*;8 
F4A7 
FF4J4AH@58EB9?4JF4HG;BE<M<A:68AFBE
F;<C 4F J8?? 8AFBEF;<C 4HG;BE<M4G<BAF J8E8 B9G8A 4GG46;87 GB G;8
@84FHE8F7<F6HFF8745BI8C4EG<6H?4E?LF87<G<BA?4JFA477<G<BAGB<GF
BG;8ECEBI<F<BAF9BE<AFG4A68G;8FC<BA4:86GE8DH<E87G;4G4AL@4
G8E<4?<AI<B?4G<BAB9G;86GGB:8G;8EJ<G;4??@4G8E<4?FS47IB64G<A:
BEHE:<A:GE84FBA<AFHEE86G<BABE9BE6<5?8E8F<FG4A68TF;BH?75878
6?4E87SABA@4<?45?8T@4GG8E4A7E8@BI879EB@G;8CBFG*;8F868A
FBEF;<CCBJ8EFJ8E89HEG;8E8KC4A7875LG;8*E47<A:J<G;G;8A8@L
6GC4FF87BA%6GB58E  A477<G<BAGB:E4AG<A:G;8&E8F<78AG

  $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--,8;?@B8-@E>?8 %0-:-)<():)6,)F":78-:G");;87:<.7:<0-7476A
7:,-::7;;16/ 16 :1<1;0 6,1) +  C    #     -  " 
,!    
  .?<*8JJGFIKEKIP@EKF#E;@8:K  :K(F F= #E;  
  $--"%! %
'8P :@K<;@E' ;=8:)EFK< 
8K Y 
  $--&  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   -K8K V #E>I8EK@E>K?@JGFN<I K?<:K9L@CKFE8E;<OG8E;<;
K?<GFN<IJ>@M<EKFK?</E@K<;-K8K<J*FJK)==@:<9PK?<FDJKF:B:K 
-K8K  N?@:?8CCFN<;K?<*FJK)==@:<KF:<EJFI[F9J:<E<\8E;[@E;<:<EK\D8K<

I@8CJ $--,  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 


  .I8;@E>N@K?K?<E<DP:K *L9 & 
  -K8K  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

G;8CBJ8EGBE8FGE<6GGE47858GJ88AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F4A7<GF8A8@<8F
G;86G:4I8G;8&BFG@4FG8E8A8E4?5EB47CBJ8EFGB68AFBEG;89BE
8<:A?4A:H4:8 CE8FF  *;8 CBJ8EF :E4AG87 5L G;8 FC<BA4:8 6G
J8E8<A6E84F875LG;8)87<G<BA6GJ;<6;:4I8G;8&BFG@4FG8E8A
8E4?G;8CBJ8EGBE8GHEA@4<?6BAF<78E87GB58<AI<B?4G<BAB9G;86G

A E<G4<A %( J4F 4?FB HF87 4F 4HG;BE<GL 9BE J;4G @4L 58
HA78EFGBB7 4F 68AFBEF;<C CEBI<F<BAF <A6?H7<A: (8:H?4G<BA 
J;<6;C8A4?<M87F;4E<A:<A9BE@4G<BAC8EG4<A<A:GBF86E8GF8FF<BAFB9
&4E?<4@8AG  4A7 (8:H?4G<BA  J;<6; E8DH<E87 G;4G ?849?8GF 4A7
C4@C;?8GF584EG;8A4@8F4A7477E8FF8FB9G;8<E4HG;BEF4A7CE<AG8EF
4A7 G;4G CE<BE 4CCEBI4? 58 B5G4<A87 589BE8 G;8<E CH5?<64G<BA A
BA:!BA:G;8  %E78E<ABHA6<?CE8I<BHF?L@8AG<BA879HEG;8E
8KC4A787G;8:BI8EA@8AGVFCBJ8EFE8?4G<I8GB68AFBEF;<C4A7<GF6BA
GEB?BI8E6B@@HA<64G<BAF

  

 
(8FGE<6G<I8A8J?4JF9BE@8749<EFG6B@CBA8AGB9G;8CH5?<6BE78E
E8:<@88FG45?<F;87<AE8FCBAF8GBG;8E<F<A:CBJ8EB9?45BE4:<G4GBEF
ABG;8E>8LC<868B9G;8E8FCBAF8G;4G78I8?BC87<AG;8C8E<B7J4FG;8
6BAFGEH6G<BA B9 A8J <AFG<GHG<BAF BE CE8F8AG CHECBF8F G;8F8 64A 58
7<I<787<AGB<AFG<GHG<BAFB9G;E889BE@F<EFG4A7@BFGF<:A<9<64AG?L
G;8 84E?L GJ8AG<8G; 68AGHEL J4F G;8 C8E<B7 <A J;<6; @B78EA <AG8??<
:8A684:8A6<8FJ8E85BEA-;<?8G;8F84:8A6<8F;474E4A:8B9E8FCBA
F<5<?<G<8F<A6?H7<A:E8FCBAF<5<?<GL9BE5BG;7B@8FG<64A79BE8<:A<AG8?
?<:8A68BA8>8L6B@CBA8AGB9G;8<EJBE>JBH?76B@8GB589B6HF87
BAG;8FHEI8<??4A684A7;4E4FF@8AGB9:EBHCF6BAF<78E877B@8FG<6CB
?<G<64?7<FF<78AGFA477<G<BAGB<AG8??<:8A684:8A6<8F4FFH6;G;8C8
E<B74?FBF4JG;8E<F8B9CEBC4:4A744:8A6<8FBE<8AG87ABG4GFHEI8<?
?4A684A77<FEHCG<BA5HGE4G;8E4GG;8:8A8E4G<BA4A77<FF8@<A4G<BAB9
A4EE4G<I8FHA78EFGBB7GB466BE7J<G;G;8:BI8EA@8AGVF5EB478E<AG8E
8FGF<A4??LJ;<?8G;8C8E<B7J4FABGG;8BE<:<AB9?8:<F?4G<I8<AI8FG<
:4G<I8 6B@@<GG88F <G F4J G;8 C<BA88E<A: HF8 B9 FH6; 6B@@<GG88F GB
CH5?<6?L<AI8FG<:4G8SE87T4A7BG;8E7<FF<78AG46G<I<GL


   $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K Y 
 
  -K8K V'8P  
   $--&! %GI  &! %
GI   
  $--"! $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--"%! %
'8P :@K<;@E' ;=8:)EFK< 
8K Y 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

 (.&&#!(!(#-
AG;8A<A8G88AG;68AGHELG;8CE<@4EL9878E4?CB?<G<64?CB?<68F8E
I<68<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FJ4FG;8*E84FHEL8C4EG@8AGA 
G;8
CB?<G<64?CB?<6<A:EB?8J4FG4>8ABI8E5LG;8HE84HB9AI8FG<:4G<BA
SBT A8J?L 8FG45?<F;87 J<G;<A G;8 HFG<68 8C4EG@8AG HA78E G;8
?8478EF;<CB9;4E?8FBA4C4EG8%I8EG;8FH5F8DH8AG786478G;8B
6BAG<AHBHF?L 8KC4A787 <A F<M8 FBBA 586B@<A: G;8 9878E4? :BI8EA
@8AGVFCE<A6<C4??4J8A9BE68@8AG4:8A6LACE<?#4L4A7 HA8
B9  ?8GG8E5B@5F466B@C4A<875L4A4E6;<FG9?<8EF786?4E<A:J4E
BA64C<G4?J8E8F8AGGBG;8;B@8FB9F8I8E4?CEB@<A8AG:BI8EA@8AG
B99<6<4?F<A6?H7<A:G;8GGBEA8L8A8E4?#<G6;8??&4?@8EAE8
FCBAF8&4?@8E4CCB<AG87 7:4EBBI8EGB;847G;8A8J8A8E4?
AG8??<:8A68<I<F<BA4?FB>ABJA4FG;8(47<64?<I<F<BAJ<G;<AG;8
BJ;<6;J4F8FG45?<F;87<AH:HFG*;BH:;F@4??G;8(47<64?
<I<F<BAJ4F7LA4@<64FF8@5?<A:;HA7E87FB9G;BHF4A7FB99<?8FBA
@8E<64AF 788@87 FHFC<6<BHF BI8E G;8 A8KG F8I8E4? @BAG;F *;8
CE<A6<C4?CE8B66HC4G<BAFB9G;8B4F4J;B?8@84AJ;<?84E8<A7<
64G875L4E8CBEG<GCEB7H687<A H?LB9  G<G?87S(47<64?<F@4A7
)87<G<BA @BA: G;8 $8:EB8F 4F (89?86G87 <A *;8<E &H5?<64G<BAFT
J;<6;B5F8EI87G;8S74A:8EBHF<A9?H8A68FT4A7G;8S6BA68EG87899BEG
458GG875L68EG4<ACEB@<A8AGJ;<G8CH5?<6<FGFGB4EBHF8<AG;8A8:EB4
J8??789<A876?4FF6BAF6<BHFA8FFFL@C4G;8G<6BA?LJ<G;G;8@BFG@4
?<:AE47<64?@BI8@8AGFT %I8EG;89B??BJ<A:9<I8L84EFG;8 HFG<68
8C4EG@8AGSE8C84G87?L6?4<@87GB;4I8HA6BI8E878I<78A68B9B@
@HA<FGBEE47<64?<A9?H8A6858;<A75?46>CB?<G<64?46G<I<G<8FT

AE<G4<AGJBBE:4A<M4G<BAFC?4L874EB?8F<@<?4EGBG;8BG;8
)C86<4?E4A6;4CB?<G<64?CB?<6<A:BE:4A<M4G<BA6E84G87<AG;8 
F
GB6B@54GE<F;A4G<BA4?<FGFJ;<6;J4FFBBA:<I8AE8FCBAF<5<?<GL9BE
G;8CB?<6<A:B9A7<4A4A7:LCG<4A4AG<6B?BA<4?<AFHE:8AGFGB:8G;8E
J<G;4A4E6;<FGFFB6<4?<FGF4A7FH99E4:8GG8F 4A7G;8)86E8G)8EI<68

  ' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K $--)4;7- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  --- !* %  .3 -#*  
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K  )E
"FFM<I J<<,  ! *" -$  *" . & $   
"!    .   $ #  .  $    "!
!  #  
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   $--1,8K  
 
 ,8K 
   $--% - . $  1    * .
)0 -  * * *   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

HE84H6E84G87<A 
4FH56B@CBA8AGB9J;<6;<AG<@85864@8G;8
E<G<F;<AG8??<:8A684:8A6L>ABJA4F#-;<?85BG;G;8)C86<4?
E4A6; 4A7 G;8 CEBGB# CE868787 G;8 <EFG -BE?7 -4E 5BG; 8K
C4A7877E4@4G<64??LBI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8J4E4A7E8@4<A8746G<I8<A
<GF49G8E@4G;<AJ;<6;6BAG8KGG;8L78IBG87FH5FG4AG<4?4GG8AG<BAGBG;8
FHEI8<??4A68B9HA<BABE:4A<M8EF
?F8J;8E8 4EBHA7 G;8 E<G<F; @C<E8 GBB <A6E84F<A: 8@C;4F<F
J4FC?4687BAG;878I8?BC@8AGB9<AG8??<:8A684:8A6<8F7HE<A:4A7<A
G;8J4>8B9G;8J4EAA7<4<A6E84F<A:4GG8AG<BAGB<AG8??<:8A68J4F
@BG<I4G87<AF<:A<9<64AGC4EG5LG;8E<F8B9G;8;474E<G8@BI8@8AG
FG;8E<G<F;<E86GBEB9E<@<A4?AG8??<:8A68<AA7<47HE<A:G;8J4E
CHG<GSG;86B@5<A4G<BAB9CB?<G<6B6E<@<A4?C?BGFJ<G;8A8@L<AGE<:H8
4A74<@F8A45?87G;8CB?<684A78K86HG<I84HG;BE<G<8FGBHF8G;8FC86<4?
J4ECBJ8EFJ<G;G;8@BFGG8??<A:89986G4:4<AFGC?BGG8EF4A7BHEFLF
G8@ B9 <AG8??<:8A68 CE8I8AG<BA 4A7 CHA<F;@8AG <@CEBI87 GE8@8A
7BHF?LTABA:!BA:9B??BJ<A:4  F84@8AVFFGE<>8G;8E<G
<F; <A6E84F87 @<?<G4EL CE8F8A68 4A7 <AG8??<:8A68 BC8E4G<BAF <A G;8
6B?BALAE8FCBAF8GB4@4FF<I8:8A8E4?FGE<>8<A  G;84HG;BE
<G<8F9HEG;8EFGE8A:G;8A87BA:!BA:VF<AG8??<:8A68F8EI<68F<A6?H7
<A:5L4H:@8AG<A:@4<?4A7G8?8C;BA8FHEI8<??4A68G84@F<AC4EG<6H
?4E A )BHG; 9E<64 4 A8J <AG8??<:8A68 BE:4A<M4G<BA 9B6HF87 BA
6B@@HA<FGFGE478HA<BA<FGF4A7SBG;8E4:<G4GBEFT78I8?BC87BI8EG;8
?4G8 
FA:LCG9B??BJ<A:4F8E<8FB94GG46>FBAE<G<F;FH5=86GF
<AG;8CBFGJ4EL84EFG;84HG;BE<G<8F6E84G874A8JS6B@CE8;8AF<I8
<AG8??<:8A68BE:4A<M4G<BATJ<G;4@4A74G8SGB6B??86G<A9BE@4G<BABA
G;8 CB?<G<64? F<GH4G<BA GB <AI8FG<:4G8 64F8F B9 CB?<G<64? 6E<@8 4A7 GB
7<F6BI8EG;8<A7<I<7H4?FBEFB6<8G<8FE8FCBAF<5?89BEG;8F86E<@8FBE

 "$  *        Y  "  
- $
' !  .    ! * -  
"   0    
  $-- " - -! . '  
#  $ Y  $$ ,    $ 
-#." $ Y 
  $-- % $$  * "$  -   $ 
!! -   8K1  ;=8:)
EFK< 8K DFE>FK?<IK<:?E@HL<J -G<:@8CI8E:?J<EKF==@:<IJKFD<<K@E>J 
G8@;@E=FID8EKJ K8GG<;K<C<G?FE<C@E<J GC8EK<;9L>J@E?FD<J8E;F==@:<J 8E;@E

K<I:<GK<;:FII<JGFE;<E:< $--"! $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 


  $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 
  $--1,8K 
  $--' ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--,@:?8I;%C<@E %0-581:-$<:13-;)+3:1<)16G;&;-7.<0-)?<7$=8
8:-;;"741<1+)41;;-6<1676/76/  / #^& $  Y 
  $"    *-   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

9BE G;8 7<FGHE54A68 B9 CH5?<6 BE78E <A G;8 6BHAGELT  AG8??<:8A68
4:8A6<8FJ8E84?FB<AG8:E4?GBE<G<F;4A7E8A6;6B?BA<M4G<BAB99BE
@8E %GGB@4A G8EE<GBE<8F 46EBFF G;8 #<77?8 4FG 4F *;B@4F ;4F
F;BJA


 ,)*!(!(#-
*;884E?LGJ8AG<8G;68AGHEL4?FBF4JG;89BE@4G<BAB9CEBC4:4A74
5HE84HFAG;8+A<G87)G4G8FG;868AGE4?8AG<GLJ4FG;8B@@<GG88BA
&H5?<6A9BE@4G<BAS&T6E84G87BACE<?   5L8K86HG<I8
BE78E  )HCCBEG8EF B9 G;8 :8A6L 4E:H87 G;4G <G JBH?7 4??BJ 9BE
S1628AFBEF;<C 4A7 CH5?<6<GL 1GB2 58 =B<A87 <A ;BA8FGL 4A7 J<G;
CEB9<GT*;8:8A6L5864@8SG;8B99<6<4?@<A<FGELB9CEBC4:4A74
9BEG;8+A<G87)G4G8FT4A75LG;8J4EVF8A7<G;477<FGE<5HG87


CE8FFE8?84F8F

C4@C;?8GF4A7 

CBFG8EFJ;<?86BBE
7<A4G<A:

CH5?<6FC84>8EF4A78@C?BL<A: 

;<FGBE<4AFS4F
JE<G8EF4A7946G6;86>8EFT%A88K4@C?8B9G;8&VFJBE>J4FG;8
, 3&)*#J;<6;:4I8B99<6<4??LF4A6G<BA87789<A<G<BAFGB@4G
G8EFFH6;4F9E887B@B98KCE8FF<BA8FC<BA4:84A7F87<G<BAJ;<?8:<I
<A:G;8S6?84E<@CE8FF<BAG;4GG;BF8J;B7<F4:E887J<G;FH6;<AG8ECE8
G4G<BAFJ8E88<G;8EHAE84FBA45?8BE7<F?BL4?T
AG;8+A<G87!<A:7B@G;84CCEB46;GBCEBC4:4A748IB?I87F<:
A<9<64AG?LBI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8J4E4FG;8&EBC4:4A74HE84HJ;<6;
J4F6BAF<78E87SGBB?<G8E4EL4A7E4G<BA4?TJ4FE8C?4687<A  5L
G;88C4EG@8AGB9A9BE@4G<BAFBBAE8A4@87G;8#<A<FGELB9A9BE
@4G<BAJ;<6;J4F8A6BHE4:87GBCEB7H68S4@BE8I<:BEBHF4A7FGE<
78AGCEBC4:4A744<@874GG;8@4FF8FT4A7ABGGB5849E4<7B9SBHGE<:;G


   '     "  *  0  $  Y -
- *    Y :@K@E>! C8PKFE ;M@J<I
=FIK?<#EK<I@FI -<:I<K8E;FE=@;<EK@8C'<DFI8E;LDFEJK89C@J?D<EK@E>PGKF=
8 FDGI<?<EJ@M< #EK<CC@><E:< )I>8E@Q8K@FE  )        <9   
  
 
 $--   ;=8:)EFK< 
   $--#-+7:,;7.<0-7551<<--76"=*41+6.7:5)<176#
 (8K^CI:?@M<J 
?KKGJ NNN 8I:?@M<J >FM I<J<8I:? =FI<@>E
GFC@:P I<C8K<;
I<:FI;J I>

RK<OK.?< FDD@KK<< FE *L9C@: #E=FI

D8K@FE *# N8J <JK89C@J?<; 9P O<:LK@M< (8MP 8J <O


 F==@:@F D<D9<IJ5?KKGJ G<ID8 :: .
".6-<GK    
  $--, $  1"1& &  
  FE8C; @J?D8E -7:/-:--4:--,757.$8--+0<0-1456,=;<:A)6,
-6;7:;018=:16/(7:4,():  -3     
  ' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

945E<64G<BAT"BE784I8E5EBB>J4FCHG<A6;4E:8B9G;8#<A<FGEL<A
 BI8EF88<A:478C4EG@8AG<AJ;<6;S1F2B?7<8EF4A76<I<?<4AFJ8E8
BE:4A<M87<AGB4CH5?<6<GL@46;<A89BEG;8:BI8EA@8AGVFJ4ECB?<
6<8FT
-;<?8 G;8 CEBC4:4A74 5HE84HF <A G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F 4A7 +A<G87
!<A:7B@7<7ABG?BA:BHG?<I8G;8J4EG;84CCEB46;8FG;8LC<BA88E87
;474A8A7HE<A:<A9?H8A68*;<F<A9?H8A6864A58F88A<AG;8HF8B9
CEBC4:4A74G86;A<DH8F<AG;89B??BJ<A:786478<A6?H7<A:9BE8K4@
C?849G8EG;8BHG5E84>B9G;8  FGE<>8<ABA:!BA:<AE846G<BAGB
J;<6;G;8:BI8EA@8AG8FG45?<F;874A8J6BHAG8ECEBC4:4A745HE84H
J;<6;7<FGE<5HG874AG<FGE<>8CBFG8EF4A7?849?8GFCHGBHG474<?LA8JF
C4C8EE86EH<G87@8@58EFGBG;8SG;H:?<>8"45BHE&EBG86G<BAHE84H
4F86E8G5HE84H8FG45?<F;87GBCEBG86G?45BHE8EF9EB@CEBFGE<>8<A
G<@<74GBEF4A7GB?4HA6;46BHAG8E4GG46>4:4<AFGG;8F8<AG<@<74GBEFT
4A76E84G874A<@4:<A4ELS&84684A7%E78E&E8F8EI4G<BA)B6<8GLTGB
:<I8G;8<@CE8FF<BAB9:E84G8ECBCH?4EFHCCBEG9BEG;8:BI8EA@8AG
B??BJ<A: G;8 FGE<>8 G;8 :BI8EA@8AG FCBAFBE87 4 A8J 4AG<FGE<>8
A8JFC4C8EG;8 )(!-"(!#) 

 !#-&.#0(0-.#!.#0 )''#..-
A477<G<BAGBG;8F8@BE8ABI8?<AFG<GHG<BAFG;8C8E<B7F4JG;8
HG<?<M4G<BAB94AB?7<AFG<GHG<BAG;8?8:<F?4G<I86B@@<FF<BAB9<ADH<EL
9BE4A8JCHECBF8RCH5?<6<AI8FG<:4G<BAB9?89G<FGBE:4A<M4G<BAF4A7
47IB646L*;<F4CCEB46;J4FC<BA88E875LG;8%I8E@4AB@@<GG88
4 FH56B@@<GG88 B9 G;8 +) )8A4G8 H7<6<4EL B@@<GG88 ;84787 5L
"88)?4G8E%I8E@4A8FG45?<F;87<A)8CG8@58EB9  J<G;4@4A74G8
GB<AI8FG<:4G8CEB8E@4AF8AG<@8AG<AG;8?<DHBE<A7HFGEL
B??BJ
<A: G;8 J4EVF 8A7 G;8 B@@<GG88VF 4GG8AG<BA GHEA87 GB B?F;8I<F@

  ! ,         1 1   ; <; 
  
  <@8E"FGB@E 75-;<1+-6;7:;01816<0-1:;<(7:4,(): $   
"    $--)4;7. JLGI8EFK< 8K  
  $---   . / *" *  , Y
"$ & $ .$ .   - "   $
$  &^  *  ,      "$  * 
*    ."  $  #I8 8J<E  (7:4, ():  )6, <0-
1:<07."=*41+#-4)<176; $ * ^  
  $F?E 8IIFCC  74761)41;5 )<176)41;5 )6, 7=:/-71; ,-6<1<A 16 74761)4
76/76/ $ ) -     $--)4;7%C<@E ;=8:)EFK< 
8K 
   $-- -! .    ' "$  " % Y  8K 
  
 
 - , ( 
 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




4A7<A85EH4ELB9  G;8B@@<GG88VF@4A74G8J4F5EB478A87GB
4??BJ <G GB <AI8FG<:4G8 S4AL 899BEGF 58<A: @478 GB CEBC4:4G8 <A G;<F
6BHAGELG;8CE<A6<C?8FB94ALC4EGL8K8E6<F<A:BE6?4<@<A:GB8K8E6<F8
4HG;BE<GL<A(HFF<4T4A7S4AL899BEGGB<A6<G8G;8BI8EG;EBJB9G;8BI
8EA@8AGB9G;<F6BHAGELBE4??:BI8EA@8AG5L9BE68BE5LG;878FGEH6
G<BAB9?<98BECEBC8EGLBEG;8:8A8E4?68FF4G<BAB9<A7HFGELT *;8
G8ABEB9G;8%I8E@4AB@@<GG88;84E<A:F<F7<F6HFF879HEG;8E58?BJ
;8E8<G<FBA?LA868FF4ELGBB5F8EI8G;4G6B@@<GG88;84E<A:FF8EI87GB
7EH@HCCBCH?4E4AG<C4G;LGBJ4E7B?F;8I<>(HFF<44A7?89G<FG46G<I
<F@ 4<@F 78@BAFGE4G87 5L G;8 B@@<GG88VF 9<A4? E8CBEG J;<6; 78
F6E<587B?F;8I<>47I4A68F<A(HFF<44F;4I<A:<A4H:HE4G87S4E8<:A
B9 G8EEBE HAC4E4??8?87 <A G;8 ;<FGBEL B9 @B78EA 6<I<?<M4G<BAT  *;8
B@@<GG884?FB6BA78@A87G;8E47<64?@BI8@8AG<A@8E<649BE4C
C84?<A: GB SG;8 ;4GE87 4A7 G;8 ?BJ8FG <AFG<A6GF B9 G;8 @BE8 <:ABE4AG
8?8@8AGFB9G;8CBCH?4G<BAE8<A9BE6875LG;86E<@<A4??L<A6?<A87T4A7
9BE4<@<A:4GSG;8BI8EG;EBJB98K<FG<A::BI8EA@8AG4?<AFG<GHG<BAF4A7
G;86B@C?8G878@BE4?<M4G<BAB9@B78EAFB6<8GLT 
*;8%I8E@4AB@@<GG88;474FG4G84A4?B:H8<AG;89BE@B9G;8
B<AG"8:<F?4G<I8B@@<GG88GBAI8FG<:4G8)87<G<BHF6G<I<G<8F4?FB
>ABJA 4F G;8 "HF> B@@<GG88 9BE <GF ?8478E )8A4GBE ?4LGBA "HF>
J;<6;J4F8FG45?<F;875LG;8$8J/BE>)G4G8"8:<F?4GHE8BA#4E6;
  J<G;4@4A74G8GBS<AI8FG<:4G8<A7<I<7H4?F4A7BE:4A<M4G<BAF
<A G;8 )G4G8 J;B J8E8 FHFC86G87 B9 CEB@BG<A: G;8 BI8EG;EBJ B9 G;8
@8E<64A:BI8EA@8AG<AI<B?4G<BAB9G;86E<@<A4?4A4E6;L4EG<6?8FB9
G;8)G4G8VF&8A4?B78T %I8EG;89B??BJ<A:L84EG;8B@@<GG88
FHCCBEG875LCE<I4G878G86G<I8FFG4G8CB?<684A7G;8BE4<787B9
9<68F<A9<?GE4G87@88G<A:F6B??86G877B6H@8AGF4A7FH5CB8A487J<G
A8FF8F :4G;8E<A: <A9BE@4G<BA BA AH@8EBHF BE:4A<M4G<BAF <A6?H7<A:
G;8 (HFF<4A )BI<8G HE84H G;8 (4A7 )6;BB? B9 )B6<4? )6<8A68 G;8
)B6<4?<FG&4EGLG;8B@@HA<FG&4EGLG;8--4A7G;8$" *;8

   - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   - , ( 
 8K 
   ,8KY 
   ( 3 - ! .& !  ,
 $ & !   #!  -  ! 
  ?KKG NNN 8I:?@M<J EPJ<; >FM :FDDFE 8I:?@M<J =@C<J I<J7KFG

@:J79LJ7CLJB G;= .?FJ<8IK@:C<JN<I<G8JJ<;=FCCFN@E>K?<8JJ8JJ@E8K@FEF=*I<J@

;<EK':%@EC<P@EL==8CF $--1,
   $--1,8KY- ;=8:)EFK< 8KY .?<(&N8J@EM<JK@>8K<;
FEK?<>IFLE;JK?8K@K?8;LE;<ID@E<;K?<E8K@FE^J<==FIKJ;LI@E>K?<N8I 8E;@KN8J
8::LJ<; 16<-:)41) F=[@JJL@E>GIFG8>8E;8=FII8;@:8CFI>8E@Q8K@FEJ\8E;F=[=LI

E@J?@E>8KKFIE<PJ=FIK?FJ<F9A<:K@E>KFD@C@K8IPJ<IM@:<8E;=FIK?FJ<9<@E>GIFJ<

:LK<;=FIM@FC8K@E>K?< <;<I8CJG@FE8><:K \( 3  -  ! ;=8:)EFK<

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

"HF> B@@<GG88 FH5@<GG87 <GF E8CBEG 8AG<G?87 S(8IB?HG<BA4EL (47<


64?<F@GF<FGBEL&HECBF84A7*46G<6FTGBG;8$8J/BE>)G4G8)8A
4G8 BA CE<?  
  B??BJ<A: G;8 B@@<GG88VF 78AHA6<4G<BA
9<I8FB6<4?<FGFJ8E88KC8??879EB@G;8)G4G8FF8@5?L *;BHF4A7F
J8E84EE8FG87G;BH:;BA?L498JJ8E86;4E:874A78I8A98J8E6BA
I<6G87BE78CBEG87G8FG<9L<A:GBG;8F64E6<GLB96BA6E8G88I<78A68HA
6BI8E875LG;8B@@<GG88 

, (
&
  %  

  



#
A 477<G<BA GB G;8 ?8:4? 4A7 <AFG<GHG<BA4? @84FHE8F 7<F6HFF87
45BI8G;8FHCCE8FF<BAB9E47<64?46G<I<GL<AG;8 
F4A7 
FJ4F
HA78EG4>8AG;EBH:;4E4A:8B98K86HG<I84A7=H7<6<4?@84FHE8F<A6?H7
<A:AH@8EBHFE4<7F4EE8FGFCEBF86HG<BAFGE<4?F<@CBF<G<BAFB968A
FBEF;<C78CBEG4G<BAF<A=HA6G<BAF54AF4A7BG;8E@84FHE8FA477<
G<BAGBG;86BFGF<@CBF87BAG;BF8G4E:8G878I8EL@84FHE8G4>8A<A
FH6;E8:4E7F64FG46;<??<A:F;47BJ78@BAFGE4G<A:G;86BAF8DH8A68F
<A7<I<7H4?F4A7BE:4A<M4G<BAF@<:;G9468<9G;8L6;BF8GB6BA9EBAGG;8
8FG45?<F;87BE78E

 #-,,-.-(,)-/.#)(-
&EBF86HG<BAB9?45BE46G<I<FGFJ4F4?E847LHA78EJ4L<AG;8+A<G87
)G4G8F 589BE8 G;8 <EFG -BE?7 -4E A   4 7<FBE78E?L 6BA7H6G
6;4E:8J4F?8I<874:4<AFGG;8--?8478E<??4LJBB7G;BH:;<G
J4FF8G4F<785LG;8)HCE8@8BHEGB9$8J 8EF8L *;89B??BJ<A:
L84E?8K4A78E)6BGG87<GBEB94FB6<4?<FGA8JFC4C8EJ4F6BAI<6G87
B9S47IB64G1<A:2G;8FH5I8EF<BA4A778FGEH6G<BA5L9BE68B94AL4A7
4??:BI8EA@8AGTHA78E4$8J 8EF8LFG4GHG87H8GB4A4EG<6?8;8;47
JE<GG8A 6BA78@A<A: CB?<68 I<B?8A68 4:4<AFG C84689H? CEBG8FG8EF



 8K #EK?<:FLIJ<F=@EM<JK@>8K@E>K?<(& K?<FDD@KK<<<O8D@E<;@E
;<K8@C:FII<JGFE;<E:<9<KN<<EK?<FI>8E@Q8K@FE^J?<8;HL8IK<IJ8E;8JJF:@8K<;8KKFI

E<PJ 8JN<CC8J:FII<JGFE;<E:<N@K?M8I@FLJ:C@<EKJ8E;GFK<EK@8C:C@<EKJ $--( 3 


- ! ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   $--( 3 - ! ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--1,8K 
   $--1,
   $--,  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY"8PNFF;M ,P8E   ( $ 
 
 
 $--,  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

)6BGGJ4FH?G<@4G8?LE8?84F87;BJ8I8E49G8E;<F6BAI<6G<BAJ4FBI8E
GHEA87BA4CC84? 
%G;8E7898A74AGFJ8E8ABGFB?H6>L?@BFG9<I8G;BHF4A7FGE<>
8EFJ8E84EE8FG87<AG;8&4G8EFBAF<?>JBE>8EFVFGE<>8B9J;B@4CCEBK
<@4G8?L 

J8E8F8AGGBCE<FBA
A4?<9BEA<4+CGBA)<A6?4<EJ4F
4EE8FG874A76;4E:879BE?847<A:4CEBG8FG<A9EBAGB9G;8)G4A74E7%<?
B@C4AL5H<?7<A:4A76BAI<6G87HA78E4FG4G8FG4GHG8CEB;<5<G<A:7<F
BE78E?L6BA7H6G
)<A6?4<EVF6BAI<6G<BAJ4FHC;8?7BA4CC84?BAG;8
:EBHA7 G;4G J;<?8 G;8 CEBG8FG ;47 588A C84689H? )<A6?4<EVF JBE7F
'#!". ;4I8 CEBIB>87 4 5E846; B9 G;8 C8468
 )<@<?4E 6BAI<6G<BAF
J8E86B@@BA4EBHA7G;86BHAGEL8FC86<4??L4:4<AFG?45BE4:<G4GBEF
J;B9BE@8746BAF<FG8AGG4E:8GB9S1C2EBF86HGBEF4G8I8EL?8I8?TJ;B
SCEB6887874:4<AFG1G;8@2HA78EJ;4G8I8EG;8BE<8FG;8L6BH?7@HFG8E
E8:H?4E?L<AIB><A:6E<@<A4??<58?F87<G<BHF?<58?4A7B5F68A<GL?4JF
4@BA:BG;8EFG4GHGBEL4A76B@@BA?4JCEBI<F<BAFT

&EBF86HG<BAF6BAG<AH87BI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8J4E?847<A:GBG;8
<@CE<FBA@8AGB9G;887<GBEB9G;8((.)(#)(+/#,,
G;84EE8FG
B9 G;8 87<GBEF B9 G;8 --(!,  &;<?<C (4A7B?C; 4A7 ;4A7?8E
%J8A
4 HA8  E4<7BAG;8B99<68FB9).", ,."J;<6;?87
GB 6;4E:8F 58<A: 5EBH:;G 4:4<AFG @@4 B?7@4A 4A7 ?8K4A78E
8E>@4A?847<A:4A4E6;<FGFHA78E5BG;<I<?-4E8E4FG4GHG8F4A7G;8
#4L  E49G6GBAG;8:EBHA7FG;4GG;8L;479BE@8746BAFC<E46L
GB<A7H68C8EFBAFABGGBE8:<FG8E
4A7G;8CEBF86HG<BAB94FG@4A
4A7 BG;8E 87<GBEF B9 " --- BA G;8 :EBHA7F G;4G G;8L ;47 B5
FGEH6G87G;87E49G
A477<G<BAGBCEBF86HG<BAFSE47<64?FT<A6?H7<A:
9E<64A@8E<64ABE:4A<M8EF<AC4EG<6H?4EJ8E8;4E4FF875LG;8B
9G8EG;8J4EFG4EG87EH@BEF58:4A6<E6H?4G<A:G;4G8E@4AFJ8E84G
G8@CG<A:GBE86EH<G?46>F<AG;8)BHG;GB9<:;G4:4<AFGG;8J;<G8CBC
H?4G<BA

AE8FCBAF8G;8BC<6>87HC<GFFHEI8<??4A68B99E<64A

   $--1,8KY -K8K<M -:FKK   ( $  
 
 $-- ,     -$    .  
 #    ! $Y  
 
 $--,  ;=8:)EFK<  8KY *<FGC<M -@E:C8@I '@J:  
K !<E -<JJ  )..G, ( 3 -  
 
 $--,  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY  
 
 1 ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 $--FLC;@EM /E@K<;-K8K<J  JK@I  
 
 $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
 
 ' $  ;=8:) EFK<   8K Y  .?< :8J< N8J 8GG<8C<; KF K?< -LGI<D<
FLIK  N?@:? LE8E@DFLJCP LG?<C; !FC;D8E^J 8E; <IBD8E^J :FEM@:K@FEJ  $--
!FC;D8EM /E@K<;-K8K<J / -  
 
 $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 

 $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

@8E<64ABE:4A<M4G<BAF4A7<A7<I<7H4?FG;BH:;<GJ4FHA45?8GBFH5
FG4AG<4G8G;8466BHAGFB948E@4A6BAA86G<BA
9E<64A@8E<64A
FB6<4?<FG4A7?45BEBE:4A<M8EFJ8E84?FBFH5=86G87GBC4EG<6H?4E?L<A
G8AF8 FHEI8<??4A68 <A6?H7<A: <AI8FG<:4G<BAF <AGB ?89G<FG C8E<B7<64?F
FH6;4F ,#-#-4A7G;8 "#!)
 (, %AG;8FG4G8?8I8?46B@
5<A4G<BA B9 ?4JF <A6?H7<A: SI4:E4A6L FG4GHG8F 7<FBE78E?L 6BA7H6G
6;4E:8F4A7AH<F4A68?4JFT4FJ8??4F?4JFG4E:8G<A:SF87<G<BHFE8
@4E>FTJ8E8HF875L?B64?4HG;BE<G<8FGBC8A4?<M84A7F<?8A684??9BE@F
B9BCCBF<G<BA4?FC84>8EF 
878E4?CEBF86HG<BAFC<6>87HCC4689B??BJ<A:C4FF4:8B9G;8)8
7<G<BA6G<A946GG;86GJ4FFBFH668FF9H?4G946<?<G4G<A:CEBF86H
G<BAFG;4G<A%6GB58EB9  G;8 HFG<688C4EG@8AG;47GBBE78E+)
4GGBEA8LFGB;B?7B99BA9HEG;8E<A7<6G@8AGF %I8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8
J4EG;8FC<BA4:86GJ4F<AIB>87GBCEBF86HG8@BE8G;4AGJBG;BH
F4A7 <A7<I<7H4?F 9BE BA8 9BE@ B9 SF87<G<BHFT FC886; BE 4ABG;8E B9
J;B@45BHGBA8G;BHF4A7J8E86BAI<6G87 @BA:G;BF86BAI<6G87
J8E8,<6GBE8E:8E4A79BHEBG;8E)B6<4?<FGC4EGL?8478EFJ;BJ8E8
<A7<6G87<A85EH4ELB9  4A7F8AG8A687GBGJ8AGLL84EF<ACE<FBA
F;BEG?L49G8EG;8J4EVF8A7 898A74AGF6BAI<6G87<A6?H7874)B6<4?
<FG ?86GHE8E J;B FH::8FG87 G;4G 8A?<FG87 FB?7<8EF JBH?7 58 SHF87 9BE
98EG<?<M8ET CH5?<6FC84>8EFJ;BFH::8FG87G;4GG;8:BI8EA@8AGJ4F
6BEEHCG 4A7 G;8 )8?86G )8EI<68 6G J4F HA6BAFG<GHG<BA4?  4A7 G;4G
7E49G7B7:8EFJ8E8SI<6G<@FB9474@A45?8FLFG8@B9:BI8EA@8AGT 
(BF8&4FGBE)GB>8F4(HFF<4A<@@<:E4AGJ;BJ4FF8AG8A687GBG8A
L84EF<@CE<FBA@8AG9BEF4L<A:S4@9BEG;8C8BC?84A7G;8:BI8EA
@8AG <F 9BE G;8 CEB9<G88EFT GB G;8 !4AF4F <GL -B@8AVF <A<A:


 
 $--1,
   $--1,8KY 
   $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--1,8K 
   $--,  ;=8:)EFK< 8K' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $-- $  '"   '1+<7:  -:/-:   
?KKGJ <DB< LND <;L <EKIP M@:KFI
C
9<I><I  .?< ;<=<E;8EKJ 8GG<8C<; K?< AL;>

D<EKJ  /E (FM<D9<I F=   N?@C< FLK FE 98@C  <I><I  N?F ?8; NFE 8 J<8K @E
FE>I<JJ KI8M<CC<;KF18J?@E>KFEKFK8B<@K 9LKN8J;<E@<;K?<89@C@KPKF;FJF 
JG<:@8C<C<:K@FE=FCCFN<; N?@:?<I><I8>8@ENFEFE:<8>8@E ?FN<M<I FE>I<JJ
I<=LJ<;KFJ<8K?@D $--1,.?<:FEM@:K@FEN8JLCK@D8K<CPFM<IKLIE<;9PK?<-L

GI<D<FLIK $--<I><IM /E@K<;-K8K<J / -  


   )^"8I<M /E@K<;-K8K<J   K?@I  
   $--%@I:?E<IM /E@K<;-K8K<J   K?@I  
   FC;N<CCM /E@K<;-K8K<J     JK@I  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

?H5
4A7*?B7:8GGJ;BJ4FF8AG8A687GBGJ8AGLL84EF<@
CE<FBA@8AG9BE6<E6H?4G<A:4?849?8G4E:H<A:G;4GG;8J4EF8EI87G;8<A
G8E8FGFB964C<G4? A477<G<BAFC<BA4:86G6;4E:8FJ8E8?8I<87
4:4<AFGF8I8E4?;474E<G8?8478EF<A6?H7<A:BAG;854F<FG;4GG;8L;47
588ACE8C4E<A:GBF8A74?8GG8EGBG;8(HFF<4A:BI8EA@8AGHE:<A:)B
I<8GFHCCBEGB9G;8<E64HF8
)G4G8?4JFJ8E84?FBHF87GB6BA7H6GCB?<G<64?CEBF86HG<BAFBI8E
G;86BHEF8B9G;8J4EE4A>"BJ8EL9BE<AFG4A68J4F6BAI<6G87HA78E
6E<@<A4?4A4E6;L?4JF<A-4F;<A:GBA)G4G8BAG;854F<FB9;<F@8@
58EF;<C<AG;8---;<?8"BJ8EL4E:H87;8J4FABGC8EFBA4??L
E8FCBAF<5?89BEG;8BC<A<BAF6BAG4<A87<AAH@8EBHF--C4@C;?8GF
FH5@<GG87 4F 8I<78A68 4:4<AFG ;<@ G;8 -4F;<A:GBA )HCE8@8 BHEG
E89HF87 GB 4668CG FH6; 4 7<FG<A6G<BA E84FBA<A: G;4G SG;8 7898A74AG
@478G;8F87B6GE<A8F;<FBJA5L4668CG<A:@8@58EF;<C<AG;8BE:4A
<M4G<BA5LJ;<6;G;8LJ8E8CEB@H?:4G874A74A8KCBF<G<BAB9J;BF8
CE<A6<C?8FG;8LE8CE8F8AGTHA7E87FB9BG;8EFJ8E8CEBF86HG87BA
G;8FG4G8?8I8?HA78EFG4G8F87<G<BA4A4E6;<F@4A76E<@<A4?FLA7<64?
<F@<AG;8C8E<B74FJ8??
)HEI8<??4A68;4E4FF@8AGE4<7F4EE8FGF4A7CEBF86HG<BAF6BAG<A
H8749G8EG;8J4E%A 4AH4EL   58GJ88A 

4A7



F;<CL4E7JBE>8EFJ8AGBAFGE<>8<A)84GG?8A85EH4ELG;8F;<CL4E7
FGE<>85864@84:8A8E4?FGE<>8AE8FCBAF8G;8BBC8A879<?8FBA
G;8CE8FH@87FGE<>8?8478EF4A74EE8FG87AH@8EBHF--@8@58EFG;8
A4G<BA4?F4@BA:J;B@<GGHEA87BI8EGBFG4G84HG;BE<G<8F9BECEBF86H
G<BAHA78E-4F;<A:GBAVF4A4E6;<F@?4J$H@8EBHF9HEG;8ECEBF8
6HG<BAFB9JBE>8EF64@8<AG;89B??BJ<A:@BAG;F4F  J4F4L84E
@4E>875LF8E<BHF?45BEHAE8FG<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FJ<G;@BE8G;4A

 
 $--/E@K<;-K8K<JM -KFB<J LEI<GFIK<;1  'F  .?<;<:@J@FEN8J
I<M<IJ<; 9P -KFB<J M  /E@K<; -K8K<J     K? @I     FI DFI<  J<<
4    $  -/- Y 
   $-- -KFE<  ;=8:) EFK<   8K   Y  :@K@E> /E@K<; -K8K<J  M  CF;><KK 
LEI<GFIK<;-  #FN8 
  $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  .?FJ<:I@D@E8C8E8I:?PC8NJG<E8C@Q<; 16<-:)41) 8EPFE<[8;MF:8K5@E>6 8;

M@J5@E>6FIK<8:?5@E>6K?<;LKP E<:<JJ@KPFIGIFGI@<KPF=FM<IK?IFN@E>FIFM<IKLIE@E>
FI>8E@Q<;>FM<IED<EK9P=FI:<FIM@FC<E:< FI9P8JJ8JJ@E8K@FEF=K?<<O<:LK@M<?<8;
FIF=8EPF=K?<<O<:LK@M<F==@:@8CJF=>FM<IED<EK FI9P8EPLEC8N=LCD<8EJ\8E;
[FI>8E@Q5@E>6 FI ?<CG5@E>6 KF FI>8E@Q< FI 9<:FD5@E>6 8 D<D9<I F= FI MFCLEK8I@CP
8JJ<D9C5@E>6N@K?8EPJF:@<KP >IFLGFI8JJ<D9CPF=G<IJFEJ=FID<;KFK<8:?FI8;

MF:8K<JL:?;F:KI@E< \-K8K<M &FN<IP  18J?   


  ,8K 
  $--1?@K< ;=8:)EFK< 8K Y- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     



 FGE<>8F 46EBFF G;8 6BHAGEL C4EG<6<C4G87 <A 5L BI8E 


JBE>8EF4?@BFG4DH4EG8EB9G;8GBG4?JBE>9BE68%A)8CG8@58E 
4A4G<BAJ<78FG88?FGE<>8<AIB?I<A:4CCEBK<@4G8?L 

JBE>8EF58
:4A A84E?L%6GB58E4HG;BE<G<8FE8FCBA787GBG;8?B64?@4A<98FG4
G<BAB9G;<FFGE<>8<A4ELA7<4A4G;EBH:;786?4E4G<BAB9@4EG<4??4J
4A7 G;8 4EE8FG B9 45BHG
 FHFC86G87 E8IB?HG<BA4E<8F
 *;8 F4@8
@BAG;6?BF8GBBA8;HA7E879E<64A@8E<64AF94687GE<4?9B??BJ<A:
I<B?8AG4GG46>FBAG;89E<64A@8E<64A6B@@HA<GL<AE>4AF4F*;8
7898A74AGF J8E8 9BE5<778A 6BHAF8? 78A<87 G;8 45<?<GL GB 64?? J<G
A8FF8F 4A7 ;47 G;8<E 64F8F ;84E7 5L 4??J;<G8 =HE<8F J;B E8GHEA87
:H<?GLI8E7<6GF4:4<AFG4??B9G;87898A74AGF?847<A:GB784G;F8AG8A68F
9BEGJ8?I84A7?BA:CE<FBAG8E@F9BEG;8E8FG 
);BEG?LG;8E849G8EG;84HG;BE<G<8F6BA7H6G87G;89<EFGEBHA7B9G;8
<A94@BHF&4?@8E(4<7F*;8E4<7F58:4ABA$BI8@58E  RG;8
F86BA74AA<I8EF4ELB9G;8B?F;8I<>(8IB?HG<BARJ<G;4E4<7BAG;8
;847DH4EG8EFB9G;8+A<BAB9(HFF<4A-BE>8EF<A$8J/BE>%I8EG;8
6BHEF8B9G;8$BI8@58EE4<7F4EBHA7BA8G;BHF4A7C8EFBAFJ8E84F
F4H?G87 4A7 4EE8FG87 <A 4 7BM8A BE @BE8 6<G<8F F8I8E4? ;HA7E87 B9
J;B@J8E878G4<A879BE?BA:8EFC8??FBAG;8:EBHA7FG;4GG;8L6BAFG<
GHG8774A:8EBHF4?<8AF-;<?8G;8E4<7FCEB7H6876BA98FF<BAFG;8L
J8E8?4E:8?L@4AH946GHE874F)6;@<7GB5F8EI8FSG;8B99<6<4?E86BE7
<F9<??87J<G;499<74I<GF5L4?<8AFE8?4G<A:;BJG;8LJ8E8@<FGE84G87
7HE<A: G;8 E4<7F 4A7 <AG8EEB:4G<BAF 4A7 9BE687 GB 6BA98FF GB G;8<E


  $--1,8K .?<<OK<EKF=K?<JKI@B<JN8J<E89C<;9PK?<=8:KK?8KKI8;<LE@FE
D<D9<IJ?@G?8;;FL9C<;9<KN<<E8E; @E:CL;@E>K?IFL>?K?<8;;@K@FEF=
LEJB@CC<;8E;@DD@>I8EKNFIB<IJ K?8EBJKFK?<NFIBF=FI>8E@Q8K@FEJC@B<K?<#11 
$--8M@;'FEK>FD<IP  -?%-6,-6+1-;16&6176$<:=//4-;)6,$<:)<-/1-;16=
:78-)6,<0-&61<-,$<)<-; C 161   $  *" .
#&     Y 8K$8D<JIFE@E
8ID<E-@I@8EE@<;J  
   CC<E*LJ<P $-8< %0-:-)<$<--4$<:13-7. $ -<GK  
   ?KKGJ NNN 898AFLIE8C :FD D8>8Q@E< 8IK@

:C< J<GK 777K?<7>I<8K7JK<<C7JKI@B<7F=7 


 
 $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   )EK?<KI@8CGIF:<JJ J<<!-$ .$. 
, '   8K Y  .?<:FEM@:K@FEJN<I<LCK@D8K<CPFM<I

KLIE<; FE 8GG<8C  9LK FECP 8=K<I K?< ;<=<E;8EKJ JG<EK D8EP P<8IJ @E A8@C  $--
 %% ;=8:)EFK< 8KY #E8
ILC@E>@E K?<-LGI<D<FLIK
=FLE; K?< ;L< GIF:<JJ M@FC8K@FEJ @EMFCM<; NFLC; ?8M< M@FC8K<; K?< FLIK<<EK?
D<E;D<EK @=K?<P?8;@E=8:KF::LII<; 8E;J<EKK?<:8J<98:BKFK?<=<;<I8C;@JKI@:K
:FLIKKF;<K<ID@E<@=K?<P?8; $--'FFI<M <DGJ<P / -   FIDFI<
FEK?<9IF8;<I@DGC@:8K@FEJF=K?<:8J< J<< '  '    ! ,
' ' -   
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

E47<64?46G<I<G<8FT*BG;88KG8AGG;8<AG8AGB9E4<7FJ4FGBFCE847
984EG;8LJ8E889986G<I8<AG;8JBE7FB9BA8<A9BE@8E9B??BJ<A:G;8
E4<7F @8@58EF B9 G;8 +A<BA B9 (HFF<4A -BE>8EF S4CC84E1872 GB 58
49E4<7B98I8ELG;<A:*;8<E:8A8E4?I<8J<FG;4GG;8L@HFG58CE8
C4E879BEHA8KC86G87E4<7F4A74FF4H?GF5864HF8G;8BI8EA@8AG;4F
786<787GBC8EF86HG8J<G;BHGE8FG4??E47<64?F<A:8A8E4?TJ;<?84A
BG;8E<A9BE@8E4CC4E8AG?LE8CBEG87G;4G@8@58EFB9G;8+A<BAJ8E8
78FGEBL<A: G;8<E E8@4<A<A: ?<G8E4GHE8 <A BE78E ABG GB 58 64H:;G J<G;
<G
HEG;8E G;8 &4?@8E (4<7F 6B@@8A687 BA 4AH4EL  
 <A
J;<6;58GJ88A

4A7


C8BC?8J8E84EE8FG87<AG;<EGLG;E88
6<G<8F46EBFFG;8+A<G87)G4G8FB9G8AI<B?8AG?L4A7J<G;BHGJ4EE4AGF
*;<FG<@8G;8B@@HA<FG&4EGL4A7B@@HA<FG"45BE&4EGLJ8E8G;8
CE<@4EL G4E:8GF %A68 4:4<A G;BF8 78G4<A87 J8E8 :<I8A ?<GG?8 7H8
CEB68FF J<G; G;8 B 8@C?BL<A: SG;E88 @8G;B7FT GB B5G4<A 6BA98F
F<BAFSG;8CE8?<@<A4EL8K4@<A4G<BAG;878A<4?B96BHAF8?124A7<A
789<A<G86BA9<A8@8AGTAG;<F6BAG8KGG;84:8AGFJ8E8<AFGEH6G87GB
@4>8SU8I8EL899BEGVGBCEBI8G;84?<8AFV@8@58EF;<C4A71GB2
U8A784IBEGBB5G4<A9EB@G;8@<9CBFF<5?847@<FF<BAFG;4GG;8L4E8
@8@58EF B9 8<G;8E 1B@@HA<FG C4EGL2 GB:8G;8E J<G; 4AL FG4G8@8AG
6BA68EA<A:G;8<E6<G<M8AF;<CFG4GHFVTAG;8J4>8B9G;8E4<7FG;8
HFG<688C4EG@8AG7<78I8ELG;<A:<G6BH?7GB9HEG;8EG;8<ECEBC4:4A74
I4?H8 <A6?H7<A: 6BA7H6G<A: <AAH@8E45?8 C8EC J4?>F ?84><A: <A9BE
@4G<BA4A7C?4AG<A:FGBE<8F<AG;8CE8FFJE<G<A:GBS@4:4M<A887<GBEF
6BAF8EI4G<I8:EBHCF124A7BG;8EU?8478EFB9G;8G;BH:;GB9G;<F6BHA
GELV45BHGG;8A4GHE8B9G;8E47<64?@8A4684A71G;8 HFG<6828C4EG
@8AGVF6BHAG8E@84FHE8FT4A7CHGG<A:BHG<GFBJACH5?<64G<BAF6BA
68EA<A:G;8E47<64?G;E84G4A7G;8@84FHE8F<G;47G4>8A4:4<AFG<G 
FG;8 
FJ8AGBAG;84HG;BE<G<8F6BAG<AH87GB78IBG84GG8A
G<BA GB ?89G<FG 47IB64G8F <A6?H7<A: FGE<><A: JBE>8EF :8A8E4??L G;8
--4A76B@@HA<FGF%AH:HFG   G;8BE4<787G;8F86E8G
A4G<BA4?6BAI8AG<BAB9G;8B@@HA<FG&4EGL;8?7<AE<7:@4A#<6;
<:4A
)<KG88AC4EGL?8478EFJ8E8G4>8A<AGB6HFGB7L4A7GHEA87BI8E
GB ?B64? 4HG;BE<G<8F 9BE CEBF86HG<BA HA78E #<6;<:4AVF 6E<@<A4?

  - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,8K 
  $--1,8K  Y %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  ,8K 
  ,
   ,8K 
 
 ,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

 
     

FLA7<64?<F@?4J ACE<?B9  G;8CB?<68E8FCBA787GB4?BA:


F;BE8@8AVFFGE<>8J<G;9BE6854AA<A:CH5?<6@88G<A:F5LG;8--
E4<7<A:--@88G<A:C?468F4A7F8<M<A:?<G8E4GHE84A74EE8FG<A:4A7
78G4<A<A:;HA7E87FB9--@8@58EFBA6;4E:8FB9I4:E4A6LGE499<6
I<B?4G<BAF 4A7 6E<@<A4? FLA7<64?<F@ +CGBA )<A6?4<E BE:4A<M87 4
F@4??CEBG8FGB9G;8F8@84FHE8F<AE8FCBAF8G;8CB?<6878G4<A87)<A
6?4<E 4A7 F8I8E4? BG;8EF ;B?7<A: G;8@ <A6B@@HA<647B 9BE G;8 9<EFG
8<:;G88ABEFB;BHEFACE<?4A7#4LB9  G;8B6BA7H6G87
4F8E<8FB9E4<7FB9G;8CE8@<F8FB9G;8-BE>8EFV&4EGL<A&<GGF5HE:;
<AJ;<6;GJ8AGLF8I8AC8BC?8J8E84EE8FG874A7GHEA87BI8EGBFG4G8
4HG;BE<G<8F9BECEBF86HG<BAHA78E&8AAFL?I4A<4VFFLA7<64?<F@?4J
A  F<?>JBE>8EF<A&4G8EFBA$8J 8EF8LJ8AGBHGBAFGE<>8J<G;
G;8FHCCBEGB9G;8"+AE8FCBAF86BHEGF<FFH874F8E<8FB9<A
=HA6G<BAF4:4<AFGG;8<E45<?<GLGBC<6>8GBE4FF8@5?8J;<?8G;8CB?<68
4EE8FG87CEBG8FG8EF('--BAG;854F<FB9AH<F4A684A7HA?4J9H?4F
F8@5?L6;4E:8F
(47<64?FJ8E8FH5=86GGBFHEI8<??4A68;4E4FF@8AG4A7CEBF86H
G<BA8?F8J;8E84EBHA7G;8JBE?74FJ8??AE<G4<AC46<9<FGFHA<BA
BE:4A<M8EF 4A7 FB6<4?<FGF J8E8 FHEI8<??87 4EE8FG87 <@CE<FBA87 4A7
54AA879EB@68EG4<A4E84FBI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8J4EACE<?B9
 4FGE<>8<AIB?I<A:

JBE>8EFGBB>C?46849G8EG;8:BI8EA
@8AG4GG8@CG87GBE8IB>8HA<BA8K8@CG<BAF9EB@G;8@<?<G4EL7E49G
AE8FCBAF8G;8:BI8EA@8AGGBB>GJ8AGLGJBF;BCFG8J4E7F<AGB6HF
GB7L4@BI8J;<6;CEB@CG?L5EBH:;GG;8FGE<>8GB4A8A7 9G8EG;8
J4EVF8A7<AE8FCBAF8GB  64??F9BE4A4G<BA4?FGE<>8G;8:BI8EA
@8AG4EE8FG874A76;4E:87JBE>8EFJ<G;F87<G<BA4FJ8??4FJ<G;I4E<
BHF I<B?4G<BAF B9 5BG; %( 4A7 G;8 &
 *;8 4HG;BE<G<8F 4?FB
HF87G;8B664F<BAGBE4<7G;8B@@HA<FG&4EGLVFB99<68F4A74EE8FG4A7
6;4E:8?58EGA>C<AG;8&4EGLVF:8A8E4?F86E8G4EL AG;89B??BJ<A:

   $--1,8K  
  $--   ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  $--1,8K Y 
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  1 ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,8KY 
  $--(@:?FC8J"@C<P 7=6<-:;8176)/-)6,$-+=:1<A16:-)<:1<)16=:16/
<0-1:;<(7:4,():    "  ,!   "  ! $ 
;=8:)EFK< 8K Y'  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY , ;=8:)
EFK< 8K 
  '  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--1,
 
 $--"! $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K Y  
   ,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

L84EF G;8 4HG;BE<G<8F 6BAG<AH87 GB FHEI8<??8 E4<7 68AFBE 4A7 5E<A:
6;4E:8F 4:4<AFG B@@HA<FG &4EGL @8@58EF *;<F FHCCE8FF<BA
E846;87<GF;8<:;G<A  J;8AG;8:BI8EA@8AG4EE8FG87GJ8?I8?847
8EF B9 G;8 B@@HA<FG &4EGL HA78E I4E<BHF 6;4E:8F 4A7 786?4E87 G;8
B@@HA<FG&4EGL<??8:4?%A#4L   9B??BJ<A:@4AL@BAG;F
B97<FCHG84:8A8E4?FGE<>84:E887GB5L6?BF8GBBA8G;BHF4A778?8
:4G8F B9  HA<BAF E8CE8F8AG<A: 

 C8EFBAF 58:4A *;8


:BI8EA@8AGE8FCBA7875L<AIB><A:G;8&78C?BL<A:G;8@<?<G4EL
4A7 4 ;H:8 A8J 9BE68 B9 FC86<4? 6BAFG45?8F G;8 <I<? BAFG45H?4EL
(8F8EI84EBHA7G;86BHAGEL9BE689H??L7<FC8EF<A:FGE<>8F4A7CEBG8FGF
4A7CHGG<A:BHGCEBC4:4A74GBFHCCBEGG;8B99<6<4?64HF8L#4L
 G;8 :8A8E4? FGE<>8 J4F 78984G87 *;8 :BI8EA@8AG 7<7 ABG E8?8AG
;BJ8I8E<G@4<AG4<A87G;8FG4G8B98@8E:8A6L54AA87@BE8G;4ABA8
;HA7E874FF8@5?<8F4A76;4E:87FB@88<:;GG;BHF4A7I<B?4G<BAFB9
G;8&4A76B@@BA?4JBI8EG;89B??BJ<A:@BAG;F589BE8C4EG<F4A
@4:<FGE4G8F4A7HG<?<M<A:FH@@4ELCEB687HE8F
AHFGE4?<4G;8--J4F49E8DH8AGG4E:8GB9CEBF86HG<BAFBI8E
G;8C8E<B7<ADH8FG<BAA  *B@4E>8E)86E8G4ELB9G;8)L7A8L
-- CE8C4E87 4 CBFG8E FH::8FG<A: G;4G 64C<G4?<FGF CB?<G<6<4AF 4A7
BG;8E@8@58EFB9G;88?<G8J8E8;LCB6E<G8F9BE64??<A:9BEJBE>8EFGB
8AG8E G;8 J4E J;<?8 FG4L<A: ;B@8 G;8@F8?I8F );BEG?L G;8E849G8E
4E>8E J4F 4EE8FG87 6;4E:87 4A7 6BAI<6G87 HA78E G;8 $8J )BHG;
-4?8F-4E&E864HG<BAF(8:H?4G<BAFBAG;854F<FG;4G;8;47CH5?<F;87
4CBFG8ECE8=H7<6<4?GBE86EH<G<A: L84E?4G8E4E>8EE868<I874A
BG;8E F8AG8A68 B9 BA8 L84EVF <@CE<FBA@8AG 7H8 GB ;<F CBF<G<BA 4F
CE<AG8E4A7CH5?<F;8EB9
#,..#)(G;8--CH5?<64G<BA
*;8
4HG;BE<G<8FE4<787G;8--VF;847DH4EG8EF<A H?LB9  F;BEG?L49
G8EJ;<6;G;8L786?4E87G;8-BE>8EFV898A684A7(8?84F8B@@<G
G88RG;8A4@8G;8--;474FFH@8749G8EG;8  +A?4J9H?FFB
6<4G<BAF 6G 786?4E87 G;8 -- <??8:4?R4A <??8:4? 4FFB6<4G<BA 49G8E

  $--1,8K Y 
  $--1,8KY 
  $--1  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY"! $ ;=8:)EFK< 
8KY 
  .?<D@E<IJ?<C;FLKLEK@C(FM<D9<I9<=FI<:8CC@E>F==K?<@IJKI@B< 


$--1  ;=8:)EFK< 8K  $--)4;7"! $ ;=8:)EFK<
 8KY 
  $--1  ;=8:)EFK< 8K  $--)4;7"  ! $ ;=8:)
EFK< 8KY 
  $--.  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--1,8KY 
 
 $--1,8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

J;<6;G;8CB?<684:4<AE4<787G;8--;4??4A7;4FG<?L6;4E:876BA
I<6G874A7<@CE<FBA87F8I8E4?--@8@58EF 
A4A474AH@8EBHFF87<G<BACEBF86HG<BAFJ8E85EBH:;G4:4<AFG
<A7<I<7H4?F788@87GB;4I86E<G<6<M87G;8J4E899BEGBI8EG;86BHEF8B9
G;8<EFG-BE?7-4E8FC<G8FH6;E8FGE<6G<I8@84FHE8FGE478HA<BA
@8@58EF;<C:E8J<A4A474BI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8J4EE<F<A:9EB@
4CCEBK<@4G8?L 

<A  GB 


<A84E?L  A#4E6;
B9   FB6<4?<FGF E47<64?F 4A7 GE478 HA<BA<FGF <A -8FG8EA 4A474
BE:4A<M874@88G<A:<A4?:4ELJ;8E8G;8L78ABHA687)4@H8?B@
C8EF4A7SG;8GE47<G<BAB9@B78E4G<BA1;82E8CE8F8AG87T4A7C4FF874
E8FB?HG<BA4CCEBI<A:SG;89BE@4G<BAB9G;8%A8<:+A<BA%+4A7
<GF J84CBA B9 6;B<68 Q G;8 A4G<BA4? :8A8E4? FGE<>8T %A #4L 
 G;8-<AA<C8::8A8E4?FGE<>858:4A9G8EF8I8E4?J88>FG;8
4HG;BE<G<8F58:4AGB<@C?8@8AG4@BE89BE689H?E8FCBAF8@BA:BG;8E
@84FHE8FG;84HG;BE<G<8F4EE8FG87GJ8?I8C8BC?8<A6?H7<A:8<:;GFGE<>8
?8478EFJ;BG;8LFH5F8DH8AG?L6;4E:87J<G;F87<G<BHF6BAFC<E46LHA
78E)86G<BA B9G;8E<@<A4?B78
B??BJ<A:G;88A7B9G;8FGE<>8BA8FGE<>8?8478E((HFF8??
J4FGE<87F8C4E4G8?L9EB@G;8E8FG(HFF8??J4F6;4E:874A76BAI<6G87
BAF<K6BHAGFB9F87<G<BHF6BAFC<E46L<A6?H7<A:6BAFC<E46LGB5E<A:BA
SHA?4J9H?:8A8E4?FGE<>8FTGB64HF8SJBE>8EFGB5E84>1G;8<E26BAGE46GF
4A7 78F8EG 9EB@ G;8<E F8EI<68 4A7 7HG<8FT 4A7 BA G;8 54F<F G;4G G;8
FGE<>8J4F<AG8A787SGB584FG8C<A4E8IB?HG<BA4:4<AFGG;86BAFG<GHG87
9BE@B9:BI8EA@8AG<A4A474T<FGE<4?J4F<AG;8JBE7FB9BA8
?4G8E6B@@8AG4GBES4?BA:4A7:EH8?<A:6BAG8FG@4E>875L@4AL
46E<@BA<BHF 8K6;4A:8F T AL ;BC8 (HFF8?? ;47 B9 E868<I<A:
E8?<8949G8E;<F6BAI<6G<BAJ4F74F;875LG;8#4A<GB54BHEGB9C
C84? J;<6; HA4A<@BHF?L E89HF87 (HFF8??VF 4CC84? 4:4<AFG ;<F F8A
G8A68  ?BA: G;8 J4L G;8 6BHEG @478 6?84E <GF 4AG<C4G;L GB G;8

   ,8KY 
  $--&<;<ID8E ;=8:)EFK< 8KY :@K@E>, M  <CKFE    
 CK8 -  8E  , M F?<E     8E  , M '8EJ?I@:B
    8E  8E;, M 8IIFE  & , 8E  
  $--%8KQ ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  18CB<I ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  $--%0-(16618-/-6-:)4$<:13-   '   "   ,  ?KKGJ ?LD8E

I@>?KJ :8 JKFIP K?<


N@EE@G<>
><E<I8C
JKI@B<C8JKM@J@K<;):K    
  18CB<I ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  <JDFE;IFNE %0-:).<;5)6;0187.1);$-,1<176)6,<0-(16618-/$<:13-
%:1)4 '  & $  :@K@E>#E;@:KD<EK8K:FLEKJY , M ,LJJ<CC 
56-  ,  8E )EK  
  ,
   $--, M ,LJJ<CC 5 6 & , 8E  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




:8A8E4? FGE<>8 G;4G ;47 G4>8A C?468 4G -<AA<C8: BC<A<A: G;4G G;8
SU(87FV4<@874GG;8BI8EG;EBJB9G;88K<FG<A:9BE@B9:BI8EA@8AG
<A4A4744A7G;8<AGEB7H6G<BAB949BE@B9)B6<4?<FGBE)BI<8GEH?8<A
<GF C?468T 4A 4<@ G;8L <AG8A787 GB 466B@C?<F; G;EBH:; S:8A8E4?
FGE<>8F9BE6812G8EEBE124A7<9A868FF4EL5L5?BB7F;87T
4A7
E898EE<A:GBG;8:8A8E4?FGE<>84FS4A<AFHEE86G<BA4EL4GG8@CGGBFH5I8EG
G;84HG;BE<GLB9BHEBI8EA@8AGFT4A7S45B?74GG8@CGGBHFHECG;8
CBJ8EFB9G;87H?L6BAFG<GHG874HG;BE<G<8F4A7GB9BE68G;8CH5?<6<AGB
FH5@<FF<BA G;EBH:; 9<A4A6<4? ?BFF FG4EI4G<BA J4AG12 4A7 5L 8I8EL
CBFF<5?8@84AFG;4G4A4HGB6E4G<6=HAG4788@8747I<F45?8T 
)<@<?4E4CCEB46;8FJ8E88@C?BL874EBHA7G;8E<G<F;@C<E8A
A7<4;HA7E87FB94??8:87;474E<G8FJ8E8GE<87HA78E%BI8EG;8
6BHEF8B9G;8J4EB??BJ<A:G;8J4EF8I8E4?GE<4?FB9A7<4AB@
@HA<FG &4EGL @8@58EF J8E8 6BA7H6G87 <A6?H7<A: <A &8F;4J4E 4A7
!4ACHE A )BHG; 9E<64 - A7E8JF 4 @8@58E B9 G;8 B@
@HA<FG &4EGL B9 )BHG; 9E<64 S&)T 4A7 87<GBE B9 " (.,(
.#)(& J4F 4EE8FG87 4A7 6;4E:87 J<G; <A6<G8@8AG GB I<B?8A68 BA G;8
54F<FB94EG<6?8F<AG;8C4C8EHE:<A:4A8KC4AF<BAB9G;8FGE<>8F*;8
:BI8EA@8AG4?FBE4<787G;8&)VFB99<68F78FGEBL87G;8<ECE8FF6BA
9<F64G87 FH6; ?<G8E4GHE8 4F G;8L 9BHA7 4A7 FHCCE8FF87 " (.,(
.#)(&9BEG8AJ88>FA!8AL44EEL*;H>H49BHA78E4A7?8478E
B9 G;8 4FG 9E<64A FFB6<4G<BA J;<6; 64@C4<:A87 4:4<AFG G;8
%#*(FLFG8@4A79BE687?45BEJ4F4EE8FG879BE;<FCEBJBE>8E47
IB646LA:LCGF;BEG?L49G8E04:;?BH?5864@8&E<@8#<A<FG8E<A
4AH4ELB9  #H;4@@47!4@<?HF4LA4A4G<BA4?<FG?4JL8E4A7
?8478EB9G;84<EB*E4@J4L-BE>8EFV+A<BA4GG8@CG87GBBE:4A<M8
4FGE<>8HF4LA4A7BG;8E@8@58EFB9G;8HA<BAJ8E84EE8FG874A7
6;4E:87 J<G; I<B?4G<A: CH5?<6 BE78E 4A7 <AFH?G<A: G;8 &E<@8


 
 ,8K 
   ,8KY 
  $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  $-- -L:?<K8E8 ?8KKFG8;?P8P  %7?):,; 755=61;5   -  -  
Y  
  $--1<JJ<C* 0@JJ<I D%71/0<<0-)<<4-;7.<0-(7:3-:;E%0-5-:/-6+-
7.":7;<:13-"=*41+)<176;16):4A%?-6<1-<0-6<=:A$7=<0.:1+) #^,! 
- "   Y   
  $--1,8K 
  $--" $ .   " $ .       $ % $ %@E> 
%0- )<176)41;57.)::A%0=3=$<=,A16<0--/16616/;7..:1+)6"741<1+;16
-6A) .   $ " E;<IJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--&  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

#<A<FG8E);BEG?LG;8E849G8EG;86B@@HA<FG?87BA9N7NE4G<BAN
ANE4?87H*E4I4<??874F8E<8FB9FGE<>8F<A?8K4A7E<4 AE8FCBAF8
G;8-4976E46>877BJA;4EF;?L5E84><A:G;8FGE<>8F4A7=4<?<A:B@
@HA<FG &4EGL @8@58EF
 ?8I8A 78G4<A87 6B@@HA<FG ?8478EF J8E8
GE<87<A)8CG8@58EB9  6;4E:87J<G;S6BAFC<E46LGBBI8EG;EBJG;8
:BI8EA@8AG4A78FG45?<F;46B@@HA<FGE8:<@8TF8AG8A687GBCE<FBA
G8E@FB9F<KGBG;<EGLF<K@BAG;F4A7G;8ABA:LCG<4AF4@BA:G;8<E
E4A>F J8E8 78CBEG87  GG8@CGF GB E8I<I8 G;8 B@@HA<FG &4EGL <A
:LCG<AG;89B??BJ<A:L84EFJ8E8DH<6>?LFHCCE8FF87G;EBH:;F<@<?4E
@84AF
?F8J;8E8GBBFGE<>8BE:4A<M8EF4A7B@@HA<FG&4EGL@8@58EF
94687GE<4?A#4LB9 
G;8E8A6;:BI8EA@8AG5EB>84?4E:8F64?8
FGE<>8B9E4<?J4LJBE>8EF@8G4?JBE>8EF4A7BG;8EF5L4EE8FG<A:FGE<>8
?8478EFA;<A4@84AJ;<?849G8E58<A:9BE@87<A  G;8B@
@HA<FG&4EGL:E47H4??L:E8JG;BH:;<GF45<?<GLGB4GGE46GJBE>8EFJ4F
<A<G<4??L?<@<G87BG;B@@HA<FG&4EGL4A7BG;8EJBE>8EBE:4A<M
8EFV899BEGF<A);4A:;4<J8E8FHEI8<??874A7G4E:8G875LG;8AG8EA4
G<BA4?)8GG?8@8AGCB?<68J;B4EE8FG87"<'<;4A4?847<A:@8@58EB9
G;8B@@HA<FG&4EGL<A HA8B9  BA6;4E:8FB9;4I<A:S<A6<G1872
FGE<>8FT4A7B9;4I<A:CH5?<F;874EG<6?8FS?<>8?LGB64HF845E846;B9
G;8C8468T%A868@58E  );4A:;4<+A<I8EF<GLJ;<6;;47
586B@8SG;86;<8968AGE8B9E8IB?HG<BA4EL46G<I<GL<AG;86<GL58GJ88A
FCE<A:  4A7G;8#4L*;<EG<8G;#BI8@8AGTJ4FE4<7875LG;BF8
F4@8CB?<68J;BF8<M87;HA7E87FB95BB>F4A7G8@CBE4E<?L4EE8FG87
G;8 46G<A: CE8F<78AG B9 G;8 HA<I8EF<GL %A G;8 E<G<F; 4HG;BE<G<8FV
BJA4FF8FF@8AG4G?84FGFH6;@84FHE8FJ8E889986G<I8J<G;G;8E<G<F;

  E@E;@:8K@FE 8J<@E@EGLKJ@K K?8K[-8^;48>?CLCN8JLEN@CC@E>KF:FLEK<

E8E:<8EPK?@E>K?8KD@>?K;@J:I<;@KK?<18=;>FM<IED<EKFI?@J:C8@DKFC<8;K?<
E8K@FE \$F<C<@E@E /A8<$7+1-<A)6,+7675A
C 16.  
"$$' 1 8CP<;  
   &  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 $--<@E@E ;=8:)EFK< 8K&  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   &  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,8K 
  $--.?FD8J<8LDFEK  ". ! . /
 #   ,     , " $  Y  8K Y
  
  $-- $ $  0  #    ,   
- ) 1  -! - , #'  
-   Y 8KY  
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K =K<IK?I<<DFEK?J@DGI@JFED<EK &@N8J
?8E;<;FM<IKFK?<?@E<J<!8II@JFEFDD@JJ@FE<I LE;<IN?FJ<GFN<I?<N8J;<

K8@E<;=FI8=LIK?<IKN<EKP
<@>?KDFEK?J $--1,
  ,8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

#HA<6<C4?BHA6<?B5F8EI<A:G;4GGB:8G;8EJ<G;@BE89BE689H?E8CE8F
F<I8 @84FHE8F 7<F6HFF87 58?BJ CEBF86HG<BAF 9BE SE<BG<A: <AG<@<74
G<BA7<FGE<5HG<BAB9?<G8E4GHE84A7><A7E87B998A68FT;47;8?C876BA
GE<5HG8GBG;8FHCCE8FF<BAB9G;8JBE>8EFV@BI8@8AGBI8EG;86BHEF8
B9G;8786478

 --,#&-
-<G;<AG;85EB478E4@5<GB9CEBF86HG<BAF<G<FJBEG;F<A:?<A:BHG
BA8 C4EG<6H?4E FBEG B9 CEBF86HG<BA 9E8DH8AG?L 78C?BL87 <A G;8 C8E<B7
4:4<AFG?45BE46G<I<FGFRG;8S@4FFGE<4?T*;8F8GE<4?FJ8E86;4E46G8E
<M875LG;8946GG;8LJ8E847I4A6874:4<AFGF8I8E4?<A7<I<7H4?F6B??86
G<I8?L8A45?<A:G;8@BE88KG8AF<I8FH5@<FF<BAB98I<78A68G;8:8A
8E4G<BA B9 4 7<99HF8 F8AF8 B9 :H<?G 5L 4FFB6<4G<BA 4 @BE8 CBJ8E9H?
CH5?<6FC86G46?8B9CHA<F;@8AG4A7:E84G8E<@C46GBAG;8BE:4A<M4
G<BAF<ADH8FG<BA7H8GBG;8:E84G8EAH@58EFB9<A7<I<7H4?F78G4<A87
*;8 -- J4F 4 9E8DH8AG FH5=86G B9 @4FF GE<4?F A G;8 +A<G87
)G4G8FGGBEA8L8A8E4?*;B@4FE8:BELJ<G;G;8FHCCBEGB98<:;G
J8FG8EA:BI8EABEF786<787GBG4>846G<BA4:4<AFGG;8--84E?L<A
 A H?LE8:BELJEBG8GB-4EE8AG;4GG;8--6BAFG<GHG87
S4:E4I8@8A468GBG;8A4G<BAT4@8A4689<A4A6875LSFB@8;BFG<?8
BE:4A<M4G<BAT  F -8<AE<5 CHGF <G S?8FF G;4A ;4?9 4 L84E 49G8E <GF
786?4E4G<BA B9 J4E BA 8E@4AL G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F :BI8EA@8AG
?4HA6;874?8FF68?85E4G87<AG8EA4?4GG46>1BA2G;8--4?45BE
BE:4A<M4G<BAG;4GB99<6<4?F788@87=HFG4FG;E84G8A<A:GB@8E<64A78
@B6E46L4F4AL<AG8EA4G<BA4?CBJ8ET
 *;4GG;8CHECBF8B9FH6;89
9BEGFJ4FGB78FGEBLG;8--J4FBC8A?L46>ABJ?87:875LG;8 HFG<68
8C4EG@8AG  A84E?L)8CG8@58EG;8BE4<787--B99<68F4A7
;B@8F46EBFFG;8A4G<BA%A)8CG8@58E    --?8478EF
J8E86;4E:87J<G;;4I<A:I<B?4G87G;8FC<BA4:86GBAG;854F<FG;4G

  $--1,8K Y 
  $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K  .?<1<JK<IE>FM<IEFIJN<I<@E=8:K:8CC

@E>=FI<M<E?8IJ?<ID<8JLI<J @E:CL;@E>K?<@EK<IED<EKF=8CCJLJG<:K<;D<D9<IJ
F=K?<#118E;898EFEK?<I<GFIK@E>F=K?8K@EK<IED<EK $--- ;=8:)EFK<
 8K 
   ' $  ;=8:) EFK<   8K   :@K@E> &<KK<I =IFD .?FD8J !I<>FIP  KK^P
!<E KF?8IC<J18II<E JJ@JK8EKKK^P!<E $LCP / - <G^KF=$LJK 
@C<(F   -?FIKCPK?<I<8=K<I 8E@EM<JK@>8K@FEN8J:FDD<E:<;KF;<K<I

D@E<N?<K?<IK?<#11N8J=@E8E:<;9PK?<!<ID8EJ $--- ;=8:)EFK< 


8K 
 
 1 ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   *?@C@G FE<I  /E@K<; -K8K<J F= D<I@:8 MJ  1D    "8PNFF;  <K 8C  %0-
((6,1+<5-6< & "     

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

G;8L;47@47894?F8FG4G8@8AGFJ<G;G;84<@B97<FEHCG<A:G;8J4E89
9BEG4A7G;8LJ8E8GE<87<AI4E<BHF6B??86G<I8GE<4?F4EBHA7G;86BHA
GEL *;8;<64:BFH56B@CBA8AGB9G;8GE<4?J;<6;<A6?H7874L
JBB74@BA:<GF7898A74AGF?4FG87A84E?LA<A8@BAG;F4A7CEB7H6874
E86BE7G;BH:;GGB;4I8588AG;8?4E:8FG8I8E9<?874GG;8G<@8 @BA:
BG;8E 984GHE8F G;8 GE<4? <AIB?I87 ;HA7E87F B9 7898A74AGF 58<A:
@4E6;879EB@G;8=4<?GBG;86BHEG;BHF88I8EL74LS8A7HE<A:I8E54?
45HF84A7C;LF<64?I<B?8A684?BA:G;8J4LT 
*;84HG;BE<G<8F6;4E:87G;8--@8@58EFJ<G;;4I<A:HA78E
@<A87G;8J4E899BEGAE8FCBAF8G;8--@8@58EFHF87G;8GE<4?GB
4GG8@CGGB47I4A68G;8<EBJA47IB646L:B4?F5L9BE<AFG4A68
1E286BHAG1<A:2G;8?<I<A:6BA7<G<BAF<AG;8@<A8F4A7G;8?H@
58E64@CFG;8<A478DH4G89BB74A7J4G8EG;8?46>B94668FF
GB54G;<A:946<?<G<8FG;8;4E7FGE4J6BI8E875HA>FBAJ;<6;
G;8LF?8CG14A72G;8@8G;B7FHF87GBFHCCE8FF?45BEBE
:4A<M<A: 9EB@ 5?46>?<FG<A: GB ?LA6;<A: *;8 FG4G87 :B4? B9
G;8 --VF 7898AF8 J4F GB CHG G;8 <A7HFGE<4? FLFG8@ BA
GE<4? 
*;8:BI8EA@8AGJ4F78G8E@<A87GB8AFHE8G;<FFGE4G8:LJBH?7ABGFH6
6887;BJ8I8E4A7466BE7<A:?L<@C?8@8AG874E4A:8B9@84FHE8F78
F<:A87GB@4K<@<M8G;8<E6;4A68FB9FH668FF4A7G;8CEBC4:4A74I4?H8
B9G;8GE<4?<A6?H7<A:CE8I8AG<A:@BA8G4ELFHCCBEG9BEG;8--VF?8
:4? 7898AF8 FHCCE8FF<A: CH5?<64G<BA B9 4 C4@C;?8G CHG BHG <A G;8
--VF7898AF85LG;8$"4A7CE8FFHE<A:A8JFC4C8EFABGGB46
68CG -- 47I8EG<F8@8AGF  $84E?L

 C8BC?8 J8E8 ;4FG<?L


   $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--1 ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   ,
   ,8K 
   $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K .?<KI@8C?8;<==<:KJN@K?@EK?<;<M<CFG@E>
NFIC;F=:@M@CC@9<IK@<J8JJF:@8K@FEJ8JN<CC 8JJLGGFIK=FIK?<#11LCK@D8K<CPC<;
KFK?<J<G8I8K@FEF=8C;N@E8E;K?<(&=IFDK?<D<I@:8E/E@FE>8@EJK'@C

@K8I@JD8E;K?<=FID8K@FEF=K?<&/ $--,  ;=8:)EFK< 8K  8C;N@E


?8; BEFNE K?8K ;<=<E;@E> K?< #11 NFLC; 9< :FEKIFM<IJ@8CZ@E;<<;  @E ?@J FNE
NFI;J K?<GF@EKF=;F@E>JF?8;9<<EKF[GLKK?<N?FC<@E;LJKI@8CJPJK<DFEKI@8C \
KF 8J'LIG?PGLKJ@K [GF@EK56FLKK?<N8PK?8KGI@M8K<:8G@K8CN8J<OGCF@K@E>NFIB<IJ
8E; LJ@E> K?< =<;<I8C >FM<IED<EK 8J 8 N@CC@E> 8><EK @E K?8K GIF:<JJ \  
$ .   11 # ,
   ! &  /' $ ;=8:)EFK<  8K
  8C;N@E^J ;<=<EJ< F= K?< #11 C<; KF 8 F# I8@; FE K?< (&^J F==@:<J  @E
N?@:?K?<8><EKJN<I<[LE;<IFI;<IJKF=@E;8EPK?@E>K?8K]<@K?<I;@I<:KCPFI@E;@

I<:KCP :FEJ:@FLJCPFILE:FEJ:@FLJCP D@>?KK<E;KF?@E;<IN@EE@E>K?<N8I <JG<

:@8CCPC<KK<IJKFFI=IFD8E8I:?@JKJ JF:@8C@JKJ #11^JFI8EPFK?<I!F;


;8DE=FFCJ ^\
  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

6BAI<6G87B9

6BHAGF6BA68EA<A:@BE8G;4A


<A7<I<7H4?6E<@
<A4?46GFJ;8AG;8;<64:BGE<4?6BA6?H787<ACE<?G;89B??BJ<A:L84E
4A7G;8LJ8E8F8AG8A687GB?8A:G;L=4<?F8AG8A68F 
AHFGE4?<4GBB@8@58EFB9G;8--94687@4FFGE<4?F4?58<GB9
4F@4??8EBE78EB9@4:A<GH78*;8--8FG45?<F;87<GF9<EFGB99<6<4?
CE8F8A68<AHFGE4?<4<A%6GB58EB9 
J;8A46?H5J4FBC8A87<A
)L7A8L <A 6BBC8E4G<BA J<G; G;8 )B6<4?<FG "45BHE &4EGL  A  
GJ8?I8 -- 7898A74AGF J8E8 4EE8FG87 BA 466HF4G<BAF B9 ;4I<A: F8G
F8I8E4?9<E8F<A)L7A8LG;8LJ8E8=B<AG?L6BAI<6G87B9F87<G<BHF6BA
FC<E46LFB@8BABG;8E6BHAGF4FJ8??78FC<G8G;<A8I<78A68 A
BG;8E GJ8?I8 @8@58EF B9 G;8 -- J8E8 4EE8FG87 4A7 6;4E:87 J<G;
F87<G<BHF6BAFC<E46L<A-8FG8EAHFGE4?<44EBHA7G;8F4@8G<@8BA
G;8:EBHA7FG;4GG;8L;47FBH:;GSGB64EEL<AGB8K86HG<BA4A8AG8ECE<F8
;4I<A:9BE<GFB5=86GGBE4<F87<F6BAG8AG4A77<F49986G<BA14A72GB
CEB@BG8 988?<A:F B9 <??J<?? 4A7 8A@<GL 58GJ88A 7<998E8AG 6?4FF8F B9
FH5=86GFT7H8GBG;8<E@8@58EF;<C<AG;8--J;<6;J4F
788@874ABE:4A<M4G<BAG;4GS47IB64G87F87<G<BAF45BG4:84A7BG;8E
U?4J?8FF46GFVT
AG;4G64F84F*HEA8ECHGF<GS<GJ4FG;8BE:4A<F4
G<BAE4G;8EG;4AG;8<A7<I<7H4?J;<6;J4FBAGE<4?TJ<G;F64E68?L4AL
S8I<78A68B998E87B9C4EG<6H?4E46GFT (8?4G<I8GBG;864F8G;8
=H7:8B5F8EI87
*;8CEBC4:4A74B9G;8--4CC84E87GB584A8KBG<6B9
9BE8<:A:EBJG;GBG4??L<A4CC?<645?8GBG;86BA7<G<BAFB9HF
GE4?<4GBJ;<6;<GE4G;8E5BE8G;8E8?4G<BAB94ABK<BHFJ887
<AGEB7H687 4@BA: G;8 J;84G9<8?7F  BH?7 4ALBA8 F4L
G;4G G;8 JBE><A: 6?4FF <A HFGE4?<4 J4F ABG 9E88  $B
JBE>8EF88<A:G;4GG;8?4JFB9G;8?4A7CEBI<787G;8@46;<A
8EL9BE<@CEBI<A:;<F<A7HFGE<4?6BA7<G<BA;47G;8E<:;G5L4
FH5G8E9H:8GBCE8G8A7GB7BG;4GJ;<6;;8J4FABG<AE84?<GL
7B<A:

$<A87898A74AGFJ8E86BAI<6G87

A4A474G;8-<AA<C8::8A8E4?FGE<>8J4F9B??BJ875LG;8GE<4?
B9F8I8E4?BG;8EFGE<>8?8478EF<A477<G<BAGB(HFF8??%99<6<4?F8AG<@8AG

   $-- *?@C@G .8=K  %0- -,-:)4 %:1)4; 7. <0- ((  &  "   
1 ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   $-- %0- (7**41-; -$$ &! '    ?KKGJ JP;E<PC@M@E>DLJ<

LDJ :FD 8L NN NF99C@<JC8JKM@J@K<;):K    


   $--.  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
 
 ,8K 
   ,8K 
 
 ,8KY 
 
 $--1,8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

J4F9EB@G;858:<AA<A:F8G4:4<AFGG;878G4<A88F
AG;8GE<4?G;8
:BI8EA@8AG4E:H87G;4GG;8-<AA<C8::8A8E4?FGE<>8J4FABGCEBG86G87
5LG;8CEBI<F<BAFB9?4J4HG;BE<M<A:FGE<>8FBAG;8:EBHA7FG;4GG;8
FGE<>8;47ABG4<@874GG;8JBE>8EFVSE84FBA45?8CEBG86G<BAT5HGE4
G;8E4GG;8B998A68FB96E<@<A4?5E846;B96BAGE46G6B@@<GG875L6HG
G<A:B99I<G4?CH5?<6F8EI<68F4A7G;8E85L6E84G<A:4F<GH4G<BA74A:8EBHF
GB;H@4A?<984A7CEBC8EGL4A7B9<AG<@<74G<BA<AG;89BE@B9C<6>8G
<A:BE<AG;8JBE7FB9G;8?4JS58F8GG<A:BEJ4G6;<A:T
)<K78
98A74AGFJ8E8H?G<@4G8?L6BAI<6G87

ABG;8E@4FFGE<4?<AG;8C8E<B7J4F5EBH:;G4:4<AFG;474E<G8
E8IB?HG<BA4E<8F 4A7 GBB> C?468 <A )4A E4A6<F6B 58GJ88A   4A7
 *;8GE<4?<AIB?I87
<A7<6G@8AGF?4FG879BEF<K@BAG;F4A7
6BFG6?BF8GB @<??<BAG;8@4=BE<GLC4<75LG;8E<G<F;@4><A:<GG;8
?BA:8FG4A7@BFG8KC8AF<I8GE<4?;8?7<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FHCGBG;4G
G<@8
%I8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8GE<4?F<KG88A7898A74AGF4668CG87784?F
GB CEBI<78 8I<78A68 9BE G;8 :BI8EA@8AG 4A7 G;8 BE7<A4EL EH?8F BA
;84EF4LJ8E8E8?4K87GB8A45?8G;8CEB7H6G<BAB94@BE878G4<?87E86
BE7
 *;8 GE<4? J4F 8KG8AF<I8?L 4A7 F8AF4G<BA4??L E8CBEG87 <A G;8
CE8FF J;8E8 <G J4F E898EE87 GB 4F G;8 S<A7H8E@4A BAFC<E46L
*E<4?T4A74F<AIB?I<A:S142JBE?7J<786BAFC<E46LJ;<6;<AIB?I87
;HA7E87F<A6?H7<A:G;894@BHFCB8G*4:BE8 4C4A8F8FG4G8F@8A4A7
;<A8F8@4A74E<AF(HFF<4A12B?F;8I<>F4A7@8E<64AE87F<AC?4AF
9BE4AHCE<F<A:<A*<58G5B@58KC?BF<BAF<A$8J/BE>4A74?<9BEA<4
4A74A4E@878KC87<G<BAGBA7<49EB@BHE&46<9<66B4FGT


 (-),-"#*
*;84HG;BE<G<8F4?FBE8FCBA787GBG;8E<F<A:FGE8A:G;B9JBE>8EF
4A7FB6<4?<FGFJ<G;68AFBEF;<C8AFBEF;<CGBB>I4E<BHF9BE@F<A7<9
98E8AG G<@8F 4A7 C?468F <A6?H7<A: CE<BE 54AF BA G;8 CH5?<64G<BA B9


 
 $--18CB<I ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 $--&<;<ID8E ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
 
 $--1,8K 
 
 $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8KY-@E>? ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 $--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 $---@E>? ;=8:)EFK< 8K #EI<JGFEJ<KFK?<8LK?FI@K@<J^GC8EKF;<GFIK
J<M<I8C!?8;8ID<D9<IJ=FCCFN@E>K?<KI@8C K?< I@<E;JF= I<<;FD=FI#E;@8 N?@:?
@E:CL;<;FE@KJ<O<:LK@M<:FDD@KK<<8E;9F8I;F=;@I<:KFIJ=@>LI<JJL:?8J,F><I
8C;N@E '8I>8I<K-8E><I 1   LF@J 8E;/GKFE-@E:C8@I N8J=FID<;KF=@>?K
98:B @EN?@:?:8LJ<K?<;<K8@E<<J8CJF?8;K?<JLGGFIKF=K?<(7:4, 8E)8BC8E;

98J<;JF:@8C@JKG8G<I K?<D<I@:8E <;<I8K@FEF=&89FI 8E;J<M<I8CCF:8CLE@FEJ 


$--,   ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

68EG4<A @4G8E<4?F CBFGCH5?<64G<BA 6E<@<A4? 4A7 @BA8G4EL C8A4?G<8F


4A7G;8CE8I8AG<BAB968EG4<A@4G8E<4?F9EB@6<E6H?4G<BA<AG;8CBFG
AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FG;8A8J68AFBEF;<CCBJ8E:E4AG87GBG;8&BFG
%99<685LG;8FC<BA4:86GJ4F<@@87<4G8?LCHG<AGB89986G4FG;8
&BFG@4FG8E8A8E4??58EGHE?8FBAF8AGBHG4F86E8G@8@BE4A7H@
BE78E<A:CBFG@4FG8EFGB>88CS6?BF8J4G6;BA@4GG8E1F264?6H
?4G87GB<AG8E98E8J<G;G;8FH668FFB9G;8BI8EA@8AG<A6BA7H6G<A:
G;8J4ET

ACE46G<68?B64?CBFG@4FG8EF;474:E84G784?B97<F6E8G<BA
G;4GG;8L6BH?7HF8GB;4E4FF:EBHCFG;8L788@877<F?BL4?BEBCCBF<
G<BA4?BEF<@C?LGBCHEFH8C8EFBA4?I8A78GG4F
*;8--J4FC4E
G<6H?4E?L;84I<?LG4E:8G87 *;8HA98GG8E874CCEB46;47BCG875LG;8
&BFG%99<68J4F:<I8AIB<685L-<??<4@"4@4EG;8&BFG%99<68VFFB
?<6<GBEJ;BB5F8EI87G;4G<GJBH?7;4I8588AS6E<@<A4?T9BEG;8B99<
6<4?FB9G;8&BFG%99<68SGBC8E@<G4A8K4::8E4G87F8AG<@8AG4?<F@4
@<F4CC?<87 E8I8E8A68 9BE ?8:4? 4K<B@F J;<6; BHE 6BHEGF ;4I8 ;8?7
;4I8ABGEH84CC?<64G<BAGBG;8DH8FG<BAF<AIB?I87GBE8FGE4<AHFT 
-<G;<A4@BAG;B9G;8+A<G87)G4G8FV8AGEL<AGBG;8J4E9<9G88ACH5?<
64G<BAF ;47 588A 8K6?H787 9EB@ G;8 @4<?  B??BJ<A: 9HEG;8E 8A
;4A68@8AGB9G;8&BFG%99<68VF68AFBEF;<CCBJ8EF5LG;8*E47<A:J<G;
G;8A8@L6GHE?8FBA58:4AGB?4LBHGCE8F6E<CG<BAF4FJ8??<A7<
64G87G;4G4@4<?54AJBH?758<@CBF87BA4ALC4C8EF4L<A:SG;4GG;8
BI8EA@8AG<F6BAGEB??875L-4??)GE88GBE@HA<G<BAF@4AH946GHE8EF
BE 4AL BG;8E FC86<4? <AG8E8FGFT 4GG46><A: S6BAF6E<CG<BA 8A?<FG@8AGF
F4?8B9F86HE<G<8F1"<58EGLBA7F2BEE8I8AH86B??86G<BAFTBE<A4AL
BG;8EJ4LS;4@C8E<A:G;8J4EVFCEBF86HG<BABE4GG46><A:<@CEBC8E?L
BHE4??<8FT 
 5E<89 6;4??8A:8 GB J4EG<@8 68AFBEF;<C 64@8 I<4 G;8 64F8 B9
---/&#-"#(! )0..( J;<6;6BA68EA87$8J/BE>&BFG
@4FG8E*;B@4F&4GG8AVF H?L   78G8E@<A4G<BAG;4G"---
4 CBCH?4E ?89G<FG C8E<B7<64? J4F <A I<B?4G<BA B9 G;8 FC<BA4:8 6G

 

 $-- FE8C; $F?EJFE  (14;76 =:4-;76 )6, -6;7:;018 16 <0- 1:;< (7:4,
():$ - "  #E8;;@K@FEKF?@J8>>I<JJ@M<8GGIF8:?KF:<EJFIJ?@G 
LIC<JFEN8J8EFM<IKI8:@JKN?F@EJK@KLK<;I8:@8CJ<>I<>8K@FE@EK?<GFJKF==@:< $--
$F?ECLD 4*-:<$1,6-A=:4-;76 16 $  $Y
 
 
 $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
   $--1,
   $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K DFE>K?<G8G<IJ98EE<;N8JK?<-;;-6
/-: $--1,8KY 
   $--   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   '8JJ<J*L9 F M *8KK<E  -  ( 3 :->G,  ;
@I  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

CE8I8AG<A: <GF 7<FGE<5HG<BA G;EBH:; G;8 @4<? A E8FCBAF8 #4K4FG


@4A G;8 =BHEA4?VF CE<A6<C4? 87<GBE 6BAI8A87 4 SE88 &E8FF BA98E
8A68TJ<G;G;8FHCCBEGB9G;8@8E<64A+A<BA:4<AFG#<?<G4E<F@VF
<I<?"<58EG<8FHE84H 4A7F;BEG?LG;8E849G8E6;4??8A:87G;854A<A
6BHEGA;<F=H7:@8AG"84EA874A7B5F8EI87G;4GJ;<?8G;8G8KG<A
DH8FG<BA7<76BAFG<GHG8S4I<EH?8AG4GG46>HCBAG;8J4E4A7G;BF8?4JF
J;<6;;4I8588A8A46G87GB4FF<FG<GFCEBF86HG<BA1G;4G@<:;G2<AG8E
98E8J<G;G;8FH668FFB9G;8@<?<G4EL9BE68FB9G;8+A<G87)G4G8FT 
G;<F7<7ABG5E<A:G;4GG8KGJ<G;<AG;8G8E@FB9G;8?4J4??BJ<A:9BEG;8
68AFBEF;<CB9SJ<??9H??L94?F8FG4G8@8AG1F2T (4G;8E<A4A7VFI<8J
G;8E8CE8F8AG4G<BAF@478F;BH?758788@87GBS94??J<G;<AG;8F6BC8
B9G;4GE<:;GGB6E<G<6<F88<G;8E5LG8@C8E4G8E84FBA<A:BE5L<@@B78E
4G84A7<A7868AG<AI86G<I8J;<6;<FABE@4??LG;8CE<I<?8:8B9G;8<A
7<I<7H4?<A6BHAGE<8F78C8A78AGHCBAG;89E888KCE8FF<BAB9BC<A<BA4F
G;8 H?G<@4G8 FBHE68 B9 4HG;BE<GLT
 *;8 I<6GBEL 9BE 9E887B@ B9 8K
CE8FF<BA 78?<I8E87 5L 4A7VF 786<F<BA J4F F;BEG?<I87 ;BJ8I8E 4F
G;8786<F<BAJ4FCEB@CG?LE8I8EF875LG;8)86BA7<E6H<G 
8AFBEF;<C J4F 9E8DH8AG?L E8?<87 HCBA 8?F8J;8E8 4EBHA7 G;8
JBE?74FJ8??AE<G4<AAH@8EBHF7<FF8AG<A:CH5?<64G<BAF4A74FFB
6<4G<BAF;47G;8<EB99<68FE4<7874A7J8E8FHCCE8FF87BI8EG;86BHEF8
B9G;8J4E<A6?H7<A:G;8$4G<BA4?"45BHE&E8FFG;8$BBAF6E<CG<BA
8??BJF;<C4A7G;8$4G<BA4?BHA6<?:4<AFGBAF6E<CG<BAA47
7<G<BA GB G;8 @84FHE8F @8AG<BA87 45BI8 @BE8BI8E G;8 :BI8EA@8AG
E8FCBA787GBG;8  :8A8E4?FGE<>85LE4<7<A:A8JFC4C8ECE8@<F8F
4A75E<A:<A:6;4E:8F4:4<AFG87<GBEFCH5?<F;8EF4A77<FGE<5HGBEF
AHFGE4?<4G;8$8J)BHG;-4?8F:BI8EA@8AG54AA87G;8F4?8
B9G;8--C4C8E<A HA8B9  -;8A--@8@58EFE8F<FG87
G;854AG;8LJ8E878G4<A87A  @BG<I4G875L984EB94:8A8E4?
FGE<>8G;8?B64?CB?<68FBH:;GGB?<@<GG;8--VF45<?<GLGB7<FGE<5HG8

   $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   );;-;"=*7  8K 
   ,
 
 ,
   $--);;-;"=*7  -  ( 3  :->G, ;@I 
 
  $--"FGB@E ;=8:)EFK< 8K YFC@E&FM<C8:< :1<1;0":-;;-6;7:
;018=:16/<0-1:;<(7:4,(): 16(" "$-!
 $* $!<FI><FP:< $8D<JLII8E*8LC@E<1@E

>8K<<;J "@C<P ;=8:)EFK< 8K"! $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K


Y Y'  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--"! $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY  
  .  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

?849?8GFA  G;84HG;BE<G<8FCEB;<5<G87G;87<FGE<5HG<BAB9
#,.
.#)(5LCBFG4A7E4<787G;8--;4??<AG;86BHEF8B9J;<6;G;8L
F8<M87 6BC<8F B9
#,. .#)( GB:8G;8E J<G; G;8 --VF CE<AG<A:
CE8FFA  G;8:BI8EA@8AG54AA87G;8<@CBEG4G<BAB9F87<G<BHF
?<G8E4GHE8
A4A474G;8-4E#84FHE8F6G:E4AG878KG8AF<I868AFBEF;<C
CBJ8EF F8?F8J;8E8?45BE46G<I<FGF9BHA7G;8@F8?I8F9E8DH8AGG4E
:8GF 4F BI8E G;8 6BHEF8 B9 G;8 J4E C4C8EF FHCCBEG<I8 B9 FGE<>8F 4A7
?B6>BHGFJ8E8FH5=86G87GBF8<MHE84A754AA87
HE<A:G;8-<AA<
C8::8A8E4?FGE<>8G;8.,#%/&&.#(J4F6?BF877BJABAG;854F<FB9
<GF E8CBEG<A: B9 FG4G8 FHCCE8FF<BA 4A7 GJB @8A J8E8 FH5F8DH8AG?L
6E<@<A4??L6;4E:87BAG;854F<FB94EG<6?8FG;8LCH5?<F;87<AG;8-.
,( ), 1- G;4G J8E8 6E<G<64? B9 G;8 FHCCE8FF<BA  4A474VF
6BHEGF4?FB<@CBF8768AFBEF;<CJ;8AI8AF478G4<A87FGE<>8?8478E
6E<G<6<M87 (HFF8??VF 6BAI<6G<BA 5L 4FF8EG<A: G;4G (HFF8?? ;47 588A
SGE<875L4CB<FBA87=HEL5L4CB<FBA87 H7:84A7;8<F<A=4<?GBA<:;G
5864HF8B94CB<FBA87F8AG8A68T4A7B5F8EI87G;4G;<FBJAGE<4?J4F
68EG4<AGB58HA94<E4FJ8??;8J4F6BAI<6G87B96BAG8@CG
)<@<?4E 4CCEB46;8F J8E8 47BCG87 8?F8J;8E8 4EBHA7 G;8 E<G<F;
@C<E84FJ8??B??BJ<A:C4FF4:8B9G;8(BJ?4GG6GG;8A7<4A:BI
8EA@8AG<@CBF876BAGEB?FBAAH@8EBHFCH5?<64G<BAF<A6?H7<A:4A
7;<VF#(1,$9G8EG;8BHG5E84>B9G;8@4FF<I8FGE<>8<ABA:
!BA:<A  @84AJ;<?8G;84HG;BE<G<8F68AFBE87AH@8EBHFCH5?<64
G<BAFAF;BEGJ;<?868AFBEF;<CA8I8ECEBI<787G;8FB?84I8AH8B9
B99<6<4?46G<BA4:4<AFG7<FF<78AGF<G<A8I<G45?L6BAFG<GHG87BA8<AFGEH
@8AGJ<G;<AG;85EB478EGBB?5BK



*),..#)(-
&BJ8EF B9 CEBF86HG<BA 4A7 68AFBEF;<C J8E8 6B@C?8@8AG87
J;8E8CBFF<5?85L78CBEG4G<BAFAG;8+A<G87)G4G8F9B??BJ<A:G;8
4EE8FGB9--@8@58EF<AIB?I87<AG;8)84GG?8:8A8E4?FGE<>8<A  

  $--1,8K 
  ,8KY 
  $--FL>C8J ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   18I'<8JLI<J:K , -   : 8E  
 
 $---K IF@O ;=8:)EFK< 
   $--18CB<I ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  %8KQ ;=8:)EFK< 8K:@K@E>, M #M<EJ 5 6 & ,   Y 
  $-- .     '   !  #  !
   
  $--%C<@E ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

G;8BGHEA87G;8ABAA4G<BA4?F4@BA:G;878G4<A87BI8EGBG;8<@
@<:E4G<BA4HG;BE<G<8FFBG;4GG;8L6BH?75878CBEG87<9CBFF<5?89
G8E G;8 9<EFG &4?@8E (4<7F  <@@<:E4AGF <A6?H7<A: ?847<A: 4A4E
6;<FGF@@4B?7@4A4A7?8K4A78E8E>@4AJ8E878CBEG87BAG;8
+)) H9BE7 BA 868@58E  49G8E FH@@4EL CEB6887<A:FRBA
)6;@<7GVF466BHAGSG;8BA?L@4FF78CBEG4G<BAB9CB?<G<64?7<FF<78AGF
<A+);<FGBELTAE<G4<AG;8:BI8EA@8AGE8:<FG8E87FHEI8<??87<A
G8EA874A74GG<@8F78CBEG878A8@L9BE8<:A8EFBI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8
J4EA477<G<BA49G8EG;8  :8A8E4?FGE<>8G;8:BI8EA@8AG78
CBEG87F8I8E4?B9G;89BE8<:A8EFJ;B;47588A78G4<A87A4A474
9B??BJ<A:G;8-<AA<C8::8A8E4?FGE<>89<I8CEB@<A8AGFGE<>8?8478EF
J8E878CBEG87GBG;8+A<G87!<A:7B@ A!8AL44EEL*;H>HJ4F
8K<?8749G8E;<F4EE8FGCEBF86HG<BA4A778G8AG<BA

)B@8G<@8F78CBEG4G<BAFJ8E8@BE8?B64?<M87<AIB?I<A:ABGA4
G<BA4?5HGE4G;8EHE54A5BHA74E<8FA:LCG49G8EG;8E8@BI4?B9G;8
-4979EB@CBJ8E4A7G;87<FFB?HG<BAB9C4E?<4@8AG<A  G;84H
G;BE<G<8F78CBEG87F8I8E4?HA<BA?8478EF546>GBG;8<E;B@8I<??4:8F<A
BE78EGBJ84>8AHA<BAE8F<FG4A68 B??BJ<A:G;8  Q  :8A8E4?
FGE<>8<ABA:!BA:G;84HG;BE<G<8F78CBEG87SFGE<>8EF4A7<7?8EFT
-;<?8G;8A4GHE8B9846;B9G;8F878CBEG4G<BAFJ4FF?<:;G?L7<998E8AG
6B??86G<I8?L G;8L G8FG<9L GB 4 E86B:A<G<BA G;4G F8C4E4G<A: @BI8@8AG
?8478EF9EB@G;8@BI8@8AGFG;8L?876BAFG<GHG874CBJ8E9H?@84AFB9
J84>8A<A:?45BEVFCBJ8E

 .",-/,-
*;84HG;BE<G<8F78C?BL874E4A:8B9BG;8E@84FHE8FGB?<@<GHA<BA
BE:4A<M<A:4A7FGE<>846G<BA4FJ8??8AGE4?<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FJ8E8

  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  ,8K 
  $--*  *  *   ;=8:)EFK< 8K*8E@BFJ*8E8P@ 
%0--;<:=+<1767.<0--:5)6755=61<1-;16:1<)16=:16/<0-1:;<(7:4,():
16!    *8E@BFJ*8E8P@<; ,8:?<C0FIJG8E 
)?)6,():6,1>1,=)4#1/0<;@-+=<1>-=<07:1<A)6,=,1+1)4"7?-:166/
4)6,=:16/(7:4,(): 0  $ .  ^&   
  $--* ;=8:)EFK<8KY  .?<<OGLCJ@FEJN<I<:FE;L:K<;LE

;<IK?<8LK?FI@KPF=K?< C@<EJ)I;<I 8E8D<E;D<EKKFK?<C@<EJ,<

JKI@:K@FED<E;D<EK:K  !<F : !I I@K  N?@:?D8;<8EP8:K9P


8E8C@<E:8LJ@E>J<;@K@FEFI;@J8==<:K@FE8DFE>K?<8ID<;=FI:<JFIK?<:@M@C@8EGFG

LC8K@FE8EF==<E:< 
   $--18CB<I ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 $--E;<IJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--&  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--%C<@E ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




<A=HA6G<BAF4<@874GCE8I8AG<A:JBE>8EF9EB@8A:4:<A:<AC<6>8GF4A7
BG;8E<A7HFGE<4?46G<BAF4CB<AGE86B:A<M874GG;8G<@85L*;8B7BE8
)6;EB878EG;8;847B9G;8E88)C886;"84:H8<A;<FG8FG<@BAL58
9BE8G;8B@@<FF<BABAA7HFGE<4?(8?4G<BAF<A  *;<F4CCEB46;
J4F78C?BL879BE8K4@C?8<A$BI8@58EB9  J;8AG;89878E4?
:BI8EA@8AG E8FCBA787 GB 4 A4G<BAJ<78 6B4? FGE<>8 5L <FFH<A: 4A<A
=HA6G<BA9BE5<77<A:G;8?8478EFB9G;8+A<G87#<A8-BE>8EF9EB@:<I
<A: FGE<>8 BE78EF G4><A: C4EG <A G;8 FGE<>8 CH5?<6?L FHCCBEG<A: <G BE
7<FGE<5HG<A:FGE<>8C4L)<@<?4E?L<A H?LB9  G;8GGBEA8L8A
8E4?E8FCBA787GB4FGE<>85L

E4<?J4L8@C?BL88F5LB5G4<A<A:
4A <A=HA6G<BA CEB;<5<G<A: G;8 JBE>8EF 9EB@ <AG8E98E<A: J<G; E4<?EB47
BC8E4G<BAF 9EB@ C<6>8G<A: 9EB@ C8EFH47<A: BG;8E JBE>8EF GB ?84I8
G;8<E=B5F9EB@8A:4:<A:<A4ALFGE<>846G<I<GLS5L?8GG8EFG8?8:E4@F
G8?8C;BA8F1BE2JBE7B9@BHG;T4A79EB@SU8A6BHE4:1<A:2V4ALC8E
FBAGBU454A7BAVBEUE89E4<A9EB@8AG8E<A:VG;88@C?BL@8AGB94E4<?
EB475LC<6>8G<A:<AG;8CE8FFBE<ACE<I4G86B@@HA<64G<BAFR<A7887
U<A 4AL @4AA8E J;4GFB8I8EVRG;EBH:; UFH::8FG<BAV BE UC8EFH4
F<BAVT-<G;G;8FHCCBEGB9G;8F85?4A>8G<A=HA6G<BAFG;8BGBB>


 FGE<><A: JBE>8EF <AGB 6HFGB7L  6BHC?8 B9 =BHEA4?<FGF J;B


E8CBEG87 BA G;8 FGE<>8F J8E8 4?FB 6;4E:87 G;8 9<EFG 9BE 78ABHA6<A:
FGE<>85E84>8EF G;8 F86BA7 9BE FHCCBEG<A: G;8 9<EFGVF E<:;G GB 9E88
FC886;8GJ88A 
4A7 
?45BE<A=HA6G<BAFJ8E8<FFH87BA
@BE8 G;4A 

 B664F<BAF %A BG;8E B664F<BAF 8K86HG<I8 BE78EF


J8E8HF87<AFG847AE8FCBAF8GB@<A8EFVFGE<>8F<A-8FG,<E:<A<4<A
 9BE<AFG4A68G;8:BI8EABECEB;<5<G87HA<BA@88G<A:F4A7CH5?<
64G<BAFG;8E849G8E4EE8FG<A:HA<BA?8478EFJ;B6BAI8A8778@BAFGE4
G<BAFBA6;4E:8FB9HA?4J9H?4FF8@5?L 
?F8J;8E84EBHA7G;8JBE?754AFBAC4EG<6H?4EHA<BAF4FFB6<4
G<BAF4A7@88G<A:FJ8E89E8DH8AG?L78C?BL87HE<A:G;8<EFG-BE?7
-4E 4A47<4A <AA<F; +>E4<A<4A 4A7 (HFF<4A @88G<A:FR6BAF<7
8E87 C4EG<6H?4E?L ?<>8?L GB <AIB?I8 <A7<I<7H4?F J<G; FB6<4?<FG

  $--/ -  #   ,  ^  #   ,    , 
.$ -  ( 
 8K Y 
  $---;=8:)EFK< 8KY Y 
  1 ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K .?<?<8;F=K?<F#8KK?<K@D<N8J1@CC@8D
LIEJ N?FD8@EK8@E<;?@JGI<M@FLJIFC<8J?<8;F=K?<GI@M8K<@EM<JK@>8KFI:FDG8EP
LIEJ(8K@FE8C<K<:K@M<><E:PN?@C<;@I<:KFIF=K?<F# $--1,8K 
  $--   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $-- 1@CC@8D FI98K?  %0- $0)816/ 7. <0- 5-:1+)6 )*7: 7>-5-6<   
" ! & ,!   1    7>-:65-6<*A62=6+<176 
16& " -  & '! 
   %0-$0)816/7.<0-5-:1+)6)*7:7>-5-6< ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

FL@C4G;<8FRJ8E854AA87
B??BJ<A:G;8?4E:8F84@4AVFFGE<>8<A
  G;8BA:!BA::BI8EA@8AG<FFH874A8J@8E:8A6L(8:H
?4G<BAF%E7<A4A68HA78EJ;<6;<GBHG?4J87G;8)84@8AVF+A<BA4A7
6?BF877BJA<GF;847DH4EG8EFB??BJ<A:G;84EE8FGB94EEL*;H>H
<A!8AL4<A  G;84FG9E<64AFFB6<4G<BAJ4F54AA87B?
?BJ<A: FGE<>8F 4G G;8 4C4A8F8 946GBE<8F <A );4A:;4< <A 85EH4EL B9
 G;8 4C4A8F8#<??BJA8EFVFFB6<4G<BA<@CBF87454ABAGE478
HA<BA@8@58EF;<C<A<GF@<??F4A7CH5?<F;874?<FGB9SF87<G<BHFHA
<BAFTB??BJ<A:?4E:8F64?84AG<E<G<F;CEBG8FGF46EBFFG;8;<A8F8
JBE?7<A  4HG;BE<G<8F<AG;8)GE4<GF)8GG?8@8AGF4A7G;8878E4G87
)G4G8F B9 #4?4L 54AA87 G;8 !HB@<AG4A: -;<?8 <A=HA6G<BAF 4A7
54AFJ8E8?<>868AFBEF;<C4A778CBEG4G<BAFABG4F68AGE4?BE89986G<I8
4F CEBF86HG<BAF <A 78G8EE<A: JBE>8E 4A7 FB6<4?<FG BE:4A<M<A: G;8L
ABA8G;8?8FF;8?C87946<?<G4G8G;84HG;BE<G<8FV5EB478E4<@F<AFH6;E8
:4E7FJ;<?84?FB<@CBF<A:477<G<BA4?B5FG46?8F4A7C8A4?G<8FBAG;8
<A7<I<7H4?F4A74FFB6<4G<BAFG4E:8G87

, )
*;8 CE8687<A: F86G<BAF 7<F6HFF87 F8I8E4? @BE8 FBC;<FG<64G87
@84AFG;EBH:;J;<6;FG4G8E8CE8FF<BAJ4F47I4A687<AG;8C8E<B76BA
F<78E87 *;8 78I8?BC@8AG B9 FH6; 4CCEB46;8F 7<7 ABG CE86?H78 E8
6BHEF8 GB F<@C?8E GE47<G<BA4? @8G;B7F ;BJ8I8E (4G;8E G;8 HF8 B9
FG4G89BE68GBI<B?8AG?LE8CE8FF7<FF8AGFE8@4<A874AHA78E?L<A:BCG<BA
64??87 HCBA J;8A BG;8E @84AF 94<?87 BE J;8A G;8 G4E:8G CBCH?4G<BA


 
 $---K IF@O ;=8:)EFK< 
   $--.  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  D<I><E:P,<>LC8K@FEJ)I;@E8E:< (F  8G " %  
  $--%C<@E ;=8:)EFK< 8K .?<-<8D<E^J/E@FE <JK89C@J?<;@E  N8J
FE<F=K?<DFJK<JK89C@J?<;8E;I8;@:8C@EK?<I<>@FE 
  $--E;<IJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--3FE>':%<EE8 ;=8:)EFK< 8K .?<FCFE@8C)==@:<N8J@E=CL

<E:<;9P@EK<CC@><E:<I<GFIKJJL>><JK@E>K?8K-LE38K
J<E K?<,LJJ@8EJ 8E;FK?<I
8EK@
:FCFE@8C =FI:<J N<I< NFIB@E> @E C<8>L< KF LE;<ID@E< K?< I@K@J? DG@I<  J
&8LI<E:<!L@CC<D8I; !FM<IEFIF=K?<-KI8@KJ-<KKC<D<EKJ8E;"@>?FDD@JJ@FE<I
=FIK?< <;<I8K<;'8C8P-K8K<J GLK@K 
#:8EEFK;<EPK?<=FI:<F=K?<8I>LD<EKN?@:?K<E;JKFJ?FNK?8K9<?@E;8CCK?@J
:FE:<EKI8K<;8KK8:BFEK?<I@K@J?GFJ@K@FE@EJ@8C@<J8M8JK-FM@<KFI>8E@J8K@FE
N@K?8;@JKI@9LK@E>:<EKI<@E<IC@EK?8KK?@JFI>8E@J8K@FE@J@EK?<:CFJ<JKKFL:?N@K?
]' (  ,FP^  N@K? $8M8E<J< FDDLE@JKJ  -E<<MC@<K  N@K? ?@E<J< @E $8M8  N@K?
-?8E>?8@8E;-LE38K
J<EK?8K@J N@K?%LF'@E.8E> 
$--1,

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

J4F788@87<AFH99<6<8AG?LCB?<G<64??LF<:A<9<64AGBECBJ8E9H?GBCE8
I8AG<GF4CC?<64G<BA
*;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F F4J F8I8E4? FH6; 4CC?<64G<BAF B9 7<E86G FG4G8
9BE684:4<AFGJBE>8EFBI8EG;8C8E<B76BAF<78E87%ACE<?
  
9BEGL9<I8FGE<><A:@8AJB@8A4A76;<?7E8AJ8E8><??875LFG4G8@<
?<G<4<A"H7?BJB?BE47BA  49G8E;<FGE<4?4A76BAI<6G<BA9BE
@HE78EBAG;854F<FB98KGE8@8?LG;<A8I<78A68--FBA:JE<G8E B8
<??J4F8K86HG875L9<E<A:FDH47AI8E8GG-4F;<A:GBA<A  
9<I8BE@BE8@8@58EFB9G;8--J8E8F;BG4A7><??875L78CHG<M87
5HF<A8FF@8A  A G;8 FH@@8E B9   <A E<MBA4 4 ?B64? F;8E<99
546>87 HC 5L @BE8 G;4A 

 78CHG<M87 @8@58EF B9 G;8 <G<M8AVF


&EBG86G<I8"84:H84A7G;8-BE>@8AVF"BL4?GL"84:H8;HA7E87FB9
;<E8778G86G<I8F4A7G;8CE8F<78AGB9G;8&;8?CFB7:8BECBE4G<BA
<A7<F6E<@<A4G8?L78G4<A87@8AJB@8A4A76;<?7E8AHA78EFGBB7GB58
C4EGB94?B64?JBE>8EFVFGE<>8HA78E4E@87:H4E7589BE89BE6<A:45BHG


B9G;8@BAGBGE4<AFJ;<6;78CBF<G87G;8@<AG;878F8EGGBJAB9
8E@4A4F $8J #8K<6B
 A G;8 FCE<A: B9   G;8 :BI8EABE B9
-8FG,<E:<A<4786?4E87@4EG<4??4J<AE8FCBAF8GBI<B?8A6858GJ88A
@<A8JBE>8EF4A7@<A86B@C4A<8FV@<?<G<4F AH:HFGG;89878E4?
:BI8EA@8AGF8AG<AGEBBCFGBFHCCE8FFG;8JBE>8EF?BA:F<78FH6;
@84FHE8F 4F -;<G8 CHGF <G SG;8 @<?<G4EL 58:4A 4 CE46G<68 B9 G4><A:
6BAGEB?B9J8FG8EAE4<?EB47FHG<?<G<8F4A7BG;8ECEB7H6G<BA946<?<G<8F
HA78EG;8:H<F8B99BE8FG4??<A:8A8@LF45BG4:84A78FC<BA4:8T?847
<A:GBS4FG4G8B9?B64?<M87@4EG<4??4JT
*;8+A<G87)G4G8FJ4FABGG;8BA?LC?468J;8E87<E86GFHCCE8F
F<BAJ4F<@C?8@8AG87A4A4747HE<A:G;8-<AA<C8::8A8E4?FGE<>8
G;8 CB?<68 9BE68 J4F E8C?4687 5L 4 9BE68 B9 FC86<4? 6BAFG45?8F 8@
C?BL87ABG9BEG;8<EG86;A<64?GE4<A<A:4A764C46<GL5HGE4G;8E9BEG;8<E
:E84G8E?BL4?GLJ;<?8@BHAG87CB?<684A7@<?<G4ELHA<GFJ8E8C?4687


  $-- ' $  ;=8:) EFK<   8K  -:FKK '8IK<CC<   *  .
& " '      1      1   . 
" %  ^ & 1    
  $--  ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   $--FE8C;8IE<J %0->-:-<<);;)+:-%=:616/"716<16((1;<7:A 
) '!$ $ 1- "$
#  11Y  
 
 $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   $--& - !  .  '   . 1 0  '
1  Y  !  ! .  ,  ,  
  $"$10 '1   
  $--   ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  1?@K< ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   


 
     

BAFG4A75L%A HA8   4?4E:84FF8@5?LJ4F9BE689H??LFHC


CE8FF875LG;8FC86<4?6BAFG45?8FGB:8G;8EJ<G;@8@58EFB9G;8@<?<
G4EL?F8J;8E84EBHA7G;8E<G<F;@C<E8F<@<?4E4CCEB46;8FJ8E8
78C?BL87*;8CBFGJ4EL84EFF4J?4E:8F64?8FGE<>8F46EBFFA7<4R
<A6?H7<A: <A FF4@ 8A:4? B@54L 8?;< 4@F;87CHE #47E4F
4A7 &HA=45RJ;<6; J8E8 6BAF<FG8AG?L @8G J<G; 9BE689H? FHCCE8F
F<BAA4FG9E<64@84AJ;<?8J;8A?4E:878@BAFGE4G<BAFJ8E8
6BAI8A879B??BJ<A:G;84EE8FGB94EEL*;H>HG;8CB?<68E8FCBA787
J<G;?<I89<E8><??<A:4EBHA7GJ8AGL<A7<I<7H4?FA:LCG9B??BJ<A:
G;88A7B9G;8<EFG-BE?7-4E)4V4704:;?BH?4A7G;8-497&4EGL
58:4A464@C4<:A<A94IBEB99H??<A78C8A78A68AE8FCBAF8G;8
E<G<F; 4EE8FG87 04:;?BH? 4A7 BG;8E C4EGL ?8478EF 4A7 8K<?87 ;<@ GB
#4?G4 *;84EE8FG?87GB@4FFCEBG8FGF4A7FGE<>8F5LG;84<EBGE4@
J4LJBE>8EFA4G<BA4?E4<?J4LJBE>8EFHG<?<GL<A7HFGELJBE>8EF4A7
I4E<BHF:BI8EA@8AG8@C?BL88F9BE@<A:S4J4I8B9FGE<>8F4A7<A7HF
GE<4?HAE8FGHACE86878AG87<A:LCG<4A;<FGBELT
*;8E<G<F;E8
FCBA7875L4EE8FG<A:#H;4@@47!4@<?HF4LA4A4G<BA4?<FG?4JL8E
4A7?8478EB9G;84<EB*E4@J4L-BE>8EFV+A<BA786?4E<A:@4EG<4?
?4J4A74GG8@CG<A:GBFG4@CBHGE8F<FG4A68<A6?H7<A:G;EBH:;G;8HF8
B9?8G;4?9BE684A76B??86G<I8CHA<F;@8AG 
*;8@BFG8KGE8@84CCEB46;8FJ8E878C?BL878?F8J;8E8<A6?H7
<A: <A CBFGJ4E 68AGE4? HEBC8 4A7 ;<A4 A 8E?<A F<KG88A C8BC?8
J8E8><??87J;8AFB?7<8EFBC8A879<E8BACEBG8FG<A:)C4EG46<FGFBA8
68@58E  %A 4AH4EL   9B??BJ<A:4@BAG;B96?4F;8F
CEB:BI8EA@8AGFB?7<8EFHF874EG<??8EL4A7@46;<A8:HAFGBF8<M8G;8

  $--&<;<ID8E ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,8K 
  $-- 'LB?<IA@  ;=8:) EFK<   -  ;=8:) EFK<    8K Y % 
0   ,$  1     -  '  
*$  Y -LJ8E1FC:FKK $<:13-;1674761)46,1) C

#&, ,!      EBLI-?LBC8 5847A5-6<$=884A7.)*7=:)6,
6,=;<:1)4#-4)<176;16-401 * # "     
  $--E;<IJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--/A8<1)6;)58)1/6.7:6,-8-6,-6+- Y !CF9 (FEM@FC<EK:

K@FE 8K898J< ):K       ?KKGJ EM;8K898J< JN8IK?DFI< <;L :FEK<EK <>PG

K@8EJ
:8DG8@>E
@E;<G<E;<E:<

5?KKGJ G<ID8 :: +$
.,+6 
   $--&  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 ,8K 
   $--1,8K-@D<FE-?FLC -FC;@<IJ ,@FKJ 8E;@;KFK?<@M@C*FN<I @E
#E;@8 >PGK8E;*8C<JK@E< Y *?  .?<J@J /E@M<IJ@KPFCC<><
&FE;FE$8D<J%@K:?<E '174-6+-16-.-6+-7.581:- $ '   "  
Y  
  $-- '  $    1  0   ! 
,! Y 8K Y   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




E8IB?HG<BA4EL;8?7 ),15,.- A8JFC4C8E 5H<?7<A: 5E<A:<A: 8E?<AVF


4AH4ELHCE<F<A:GB4A8A7AG;86BHEF8B9G;84FF4H?GF8I8A)C4E
G46<FGCE<FBA8EFJ;B;47GE<87GBA8:BG<4G8G;8FHEE8A78EB9G;85H<?7<A:
J8E88K86HG87%AG;8A<:;GB9 4AH4EL   !4E?"<85>A86;G
4A7(BF4"HK8@5HE:J8E88KGE4=H7<6<4??L8K86HG874FJ8??LG;8
G<@8 :BI8EA@8AG 9BE68F ;47 9<A<F;87 

 C8BC?8 J8E8 7847


BE689H? E8B66HC4G<BAF B9 AH@8EBHF BG;8E 6<G<8F 4A7 GBJAF 9B?
?BJ87:8A8E4?FGE<>84A7466B@C4AL<A:46GFB9I<B?8A68<A8E?<A
<A#4E6;B9  J8E8@8GJ<G;G;8786?4E4G<BAB94FG4G8B9F<8:84A7
G;8 4CC?<64G<BA B9 8KGE8@8 9BE68 <A6?H7<A: G;8 HF8 B9 4EG<??8EL @4
6;<A8:HAF4A74<EC?4A84GG46>F?847<A:GBBI8E 

784G;F<A6?H7
<A:BI8E

8K86HG8749G8E64CGHE8HA78E4A8K86HG<BABE78E*;8
:BI8EA@8AG 4?FB E8FCBA787 GB G;8 4I4E<4A )BI<8G (8CH5?<6 J<G;
9BE68?847<A:GBF8I8E4?;HA7E87784G;F<A6?H7<A:BI8E

FH@@4EL
8K86HG<BAF 
KGE8@89BE68J4F4?FBHG<?<M87<A;<A4*;8$BEG;8EA;<A8F8
J4E?BE7-H&8<9H9BE<AFG4A68@B5<?<M87G8AFB9G;BHF4A7FB9FB?
7<8EF 4A7 CB?<68 GB 9BE689H??L 5E84> 4 @4FF FGE<>8 5L G;8 8<=<A:
4A>BH?45BEHA<BABA85EH4EL   
A85EH4ELB9  G;BH
F4A7F B9 JBE>8EF 4G G;8 4C4A8F8 #<??F <A );4A:;4< J8AG BA FGE<>8
64??<A:9BE4A8A7GB584G<A:F4J4:8E<F8CEB@CGC4L@8AGB9J4:8F
4A8A7GB7<F@<FF4?J<G;BHG64HF8E8<AFG4G8@8AGB97<F@<FF87JBE>8EF
4 E8?84F8 B9 G;BF8 <A 78G8AG<BA 4A7 C4L@8AG 9BE G;8 C8E<B7 B9 G;8
FGE<>8 AE8FCBAF8G;8AG8EA4G<BA4?)8GG?8@8AG4HG;BE<G<8F786?4E87
@4EG<4??4J4A7F8AG8A6879<9GLF<KC8BC?8GBCE<FBAG8E@F9BE5E846;
B9G;8C8468)H5F8DH8AG6BA9EBAG4G<BAF58GJ88A@<??@4A4:8EF4A7
JBE>8EF?87GBBA8JBE>8EH0;8A:;BA:58<A:F;BG4A7><??87
%A #4L  4A7    F<K FGH78AGF J8E8 4EE8FG87 <A );4A:;4<VF
AG8EA4G<BA4?)8GG?8@8AGJ;<?86B??86G<A:9HA7F9BEH0;8A:;BA:VF


  ,8K 
  $--1,8KY 
  $--1,8KY 
  $--1,8K 
  $--1,8KY 
  $--1,8KY 
   $--1,8KY 
 
 $---;=8:)EFK< 8K  
   $--1,8KY  
  $--1,8K Y .?<CF:8C:FKKFENFIB<IJ^LE@FEK<C<>I8G?<;K?<I@K@J?&8

9FLI*8IKP 8JB@E>@KKFGIFK<JKK?<;<K<EK@FEJK?<&89FLI*8IKP;@;EFKI<JGFE; $--


1,8K Y 
  $--1,8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   


 
     

94@<?L4A7G;8LJ8E86;4E:87J<G;7<FGHE5<A:G;8C8468AG;89468
B94B@@HA<FG&4EGLFHCCBEG87@4FFCEBG8FGFC4E>875LG;878G8A
G<BAFG;8AG8EA4G<BA4?)8GG?8@8AG4HG;BE<G<8FBC8A879<E8J<G;?<I84@
@HA<G<BA?847<A:GBGJ8?I8784G;F$8JFB9G;8E<G<F;><??<A:B9
CEBG8FGBEF <A );4A:;4< FCE847 DH<6>?L 4EBHA7 4FG F<4 CEB@CG<A:
AH@8EBHF78@BAFGE4G<BAFAG;89468B94?4E:8CEBG8FG<A4AGBABA
HA8   G;8E<G<F;BA684:4<AE8FCBA787J<G;?8G;4?9BE68><??
<A:@BE8G;4A9<9GLC8EFBAF
A );4A:;4< G;8 B@@HA<FG &4EGL 64??87 4 :8A8E4? FGE<>8 4A7
?4HA6;8748A8E4?"45BHE+A<BA4A7<GFHCCBEG87G;85EB478E#4L
*;<EG<8G; #BI8@8AG G;4G 78I8?BC87 J;<6; 47I4A687 I4E<BHF 78
@4A7F<A6?H7<A:G;864A68??4G<BAB9G;8FG4G8B98@8E:8A6L466BHAG
45<?<GL9BEG;8><??<A:FE8FC86G9BEG;8E<:;GFGB9E887B@B98KCE8FF<BA
4A74FFB6<4G<BAE8FC86G9BEJBE>8EFVE<:;GFGBFGE<>84A79BE@HA<BAF
G;845B?<G<BAB98KGE4G8EE<GBE<4?<GL4A79H??;<A8F8E8CE8F8AG4G<BABA
G;8#HA<6<C4?BHA6<?*;8FGE<>8J4F5EB>8A5L8A8E4?.<A:G;8
J4E?BE7<A6BAGEB?B9G;8;<A8F8CBEG<BAB9G;8<GLJ;B7<FFB?I87
4?? HAE8:<FG8E87 ?45BE HA<BAF 4A7 54AA87 78@BAFGE4G<BAF );BEG?L
G;8E849G8E.<A:J4F7<FC?46875L)HA;H4A94A:
*;8A8J@<?<G4ELE8:<@8J4F8I8A@BE85EHG4?;BJ8I8EFH@
@4E<?L8K86HG<A:;HA7E87FB946G<I<FGF *;<FJ4FBA?L4CE8?H78GB
J;4GJ4FGB6B@8AG;8J4>8B9G;8FH668FF9H?47I4A68B9!HB@<A
G4A:S!#*T9BE68FABEG;<A  HAE8FG<A);4A:;4<:E8J?847<A:
GB GJB 45BEG<I8 SHCE<F<A:FT <A %6GB58E B9   4A7 85EH4EL B9
 
BG;J8E89BE689H??LFHCCE8FF87G;8F86BA7J<G;8KGE8@8I<
B?8A68 A#4E6;B9  4G;<E7HCE<F<A:J4F?4HA6;87J;<6;FH6
68FF9H??L78984G87)HA;H4A94A:VF9BE68F4A7GBB>6BAGEB?B9);4A:
;4< );BEG?LG;8E849G8EG;8$4G<BA4?(8IB?HG<BA4ELE@L4EE<I87 
<A7<A:GBB@H6;CBJ8E<A?89G<FG;4A7F9BE<GF?<><A:G;8!#*78
6?4E87 @4EG<4? ?4J 49G8E J;<6; BA CE<?    G;8 );4A:;4<


  $--1,8K 
  $--1,8KY 
  ,8K 
  $--1,8KY 
  $--1,8KY 
   $--1,8KY  
 
 $--1,8KY 
   $--1,8KY  
   $--1,8KY 
   $--   $   . ( #  ^ (  
,! Y 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




#4FF46E8GBB>C?468<AJ;<6;G;BHF4A7FB9JBE>8EF4A7@8@58EFB9
G;8;<A8F8B@@HA<FG&4EGLJ8E8><??875L!#*9BE68F 

,  
  
 
*;845BI8F86G<BAF;4I86BAF<78E87I4E<BHF@BE8@4G8E<4?6B@
CBA8AGFB9G;8E8CE8FF<I8FLFG8@CHG<AC?4684EBHA7G;8JBE?7<AG;8

F4A7 
F<AE8FCBAF8GBG;8E<F<A:CBJ8EB9JBE>8EF4A7FB
6<4?<FGF 9986G<I8 E8CE8FF<BA A8I8E E8FGF BA <AFG<GHG<BA4? ?8:4? 4A7
CE46G<64?CBJ8EF4?BA8(4G;8EFH6;@84FHE8F4E8<A8I<G45?L6B@C?8
@8AG875LG;8:8A8E4G<BAB95EB478E<78B?B:<64?9E4@8F78F<:A87GB
FHCCBEG4A7ABE@4?<M8G;88FG45?<F;87FLFG8@B9CBJ8E4A7GB78?8:<G
<@<M87<FF8AG8EF
BAFGE4<AGFB9FC468J<??ABG4??BJG;89H??6BAGBHEFB9FH6;8A
784IBEFGB588KC?BE87;8E8$BA8G;8?8FF<G<FJBEG;;<:;?<:;G<A:4G
?84FGBA8>8L9468GB9G;<F<78B?B:<64?JBE>G;86BAFG4AG8A784IBE5L
G;84HG;BE<G<8F46EBFFCB?<G<8FGBJ84I8GB:8G;8EI4E<BHF64G8:BE<8FB9
S8A8@LT*;<FJ4F946<?<G4G87<A@4AL6BAG8KGF5L-BE?7-4EJ;<6;
CEBI<787 G;8 G4<?BE@478 <@4:8 B9 G;8 8E@4A 4F G;8 FG8E8BGLC<64?
;BFG<?846GBE4G?84FG9BEG;BF8FG4G8FBCCBF87GB8E@4AL*;84HG;BE
<G<8FV4<@G;8E89BE8J4FGB6BAA86G<AG8EA4?7<FF8AG8EFB9J;4G8I8E
FBEGGBG;88E@4AFRGB6BAFGEH6G<AF;BEGG;864G8:BELB9G;88A8@L
J<G;<A5BI84A758LBA74GG8@CGFGB?<A>CEB:E8FF<I89BE68FGB;BF
G<?89BE8<:ACBJ8EFG;84HG;BE<G<8F4?FBB9G8A4GG8@CG87GB6B@5<A84F
@4ALGEBH5?<A:64G8:BE<8F4FG;8L6BH?7J<G;G;84CC4E8AG4<@B98A
FHE<A:G;4GG;87<FG4<AG;8L<@4:<A87JBH?7584GG46;87E8?4G<I8GB4AL
C4EG<6H?4E64G8:BELB9BG;8E@<:;G58F;4E874EBHA74A74H:@8AG875L
G;8CBCH?4E4A<@HFGBJ4E7G;8BG;8E78?<@<G8764G8:BE<8F4FJ8??
AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F<@CBEG4AG:EBHA7JBE>J4F?4<75L&E8F<78AG
-<?FBAA?4G8  -<?FBA:4I84A477E8FFGBG;84H:;G8EFB9G;8
@8E<64A(8IB?HG<BA<AJ;<6;;8FH::8FG87S4@<A4;HEEL9BE4A
BCCBEGHA<GLGB;4I84?<A8HC4A7?8GG;8@8AJ;B4E8G;<A><A:9<EFGB9
BG;8E6BHAGE<8FFG4A7BABA8F<784A74??G;BF8G;4G4E89BE@8E<64
9<EFG?4FG4A74??G;8G<@8BAG;8BG;8EF<78T A;<F  )G4G8B9G;8
+A<BA77E8FF-<?FBAB5F8EI87G;4GSG;8:E4I8FGG;E84GF4:4<AFGBHE
A4G<BA4?C84684A7F498GL;4I8588AHGG8E87J<G;<ABHEBJA5BE78EFT
FH::8FG87G;4GS6<G<M8AFB9G;8+A<G87)G4G8F5BEAHA78EBG;8E9?4:F

   $---;=8:)EFK< 8KY  
   1FF;IFN1@CJFE K?*I<J@;<EKF=K?</E@K<;-K8K<J ;;I<JJKFK?<8L>?

K<IJ F= K?< D<I@:8E ,<MFCLK@FE    *$ * ):K     


?KKGJ NNN GI<J@;<E:P L:J9 <;L ;F:LD<EKJ 8;;I<JJ
K?<
;8L>?K<IJ
K?<
8D<I@:8E

I<MFCLK@FE
5?KKGJ G<ID8 :: "
.(36C8JKM@J@K<;$8E    

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   


 
     

5HGJ8?6B@87HA78EBHE:8A8EBHFA4GHE4?<M4G<BA?4JFGBG;89H??9E88
7B@4A7BCCBEGHA<GLB9@8E<64;4I8CBHE87G;8CB<FBAB97<F
?BL4?GL<AGBG;8I8EL4EG8E<8FB9BHEA4G<BA4??<98T4A764??879BE@8E
<64GB58SCHE:87B91FH6;26BEEHCG7<FG8@C8EFT -<?FBA6BAG<AH87
*;8L4E8ABG@4AL5HGG;8L4E8<A9<A<G8?L@4?<:A4AG4A7G;8
;4A7B9BHECBJ8EF;BH?76?BF8BI8EG;8@4GBA68*;8L;4I8
9BE@87C?BGFGB78FGEBLCEBC8EGLG;8L;4I88AG8E87<AGB6BA
FC<E46<8F4:4<AFGG;8A8HGE4?<GLB9G;8BI8EA@8AGG;8L;4I8
FBH:;GGBCEL<AGB8I8EL6BA9<78AG<4?GE4AF46G<BAB9G;8BI
8EA@8AG<ABE78EGBF8EI8<AG8E8FGF4?<8AGBBHEBJAG<FCBF
F<5?8 GB 784? J<G; G;8F8 G;<A:F I8EL 89986GH4??L  A887 ABG
FH::8FGG;8G8E@F<AJ;<6;G;8L@4L58784?GJ<G; 
*;8 CE<?    &EB6?4@4G<BA B9 -4E 78I8?BC87 F<@<?4E
G;8@8F*;8786?4E4G<BA<AIB>87G;8 ?<8AA8@L6GVFCEBI<
F<BAFFG<CH?4G<A:G;4G<AG;86BAG8KGB9J4ES4??A4G<I8F6<G<M8AF78A
<M8AFBEFH5=86GFB94;BFG<?8A4G<BABE:BI8EA@8AG58<A:@4?8FB9G;8
4:8 B9 9BHEG88A L84EF 4A7 HCJ4E7F J;B F;4?? 58 J<G;<A G;8 +A<G87
)G4G8F4A7ABG46GH4??LA4GHE4?<M87F;4??58?<45?8GB584CCE8;8A787
E8FGE4<A87F86HE874A7E8@BI874F4?<8A8A8@<8FT4A7<A7<64G87G;4G
G;8&E8F<78AG@<:;G<AFH6;46BAG8KG
7<E86GG;86BA7H6GGB58B5F8EI87GBJ4E7G;84?<8AFJ;B
586B@8FB?<45?8G;8@4AA8E4A778:E88B9G;8E8FGE4<AGGB
J;<6;G;8LF;4??58FH5=86G4A7<AJ;4G64F8F4A7HCBAJ;4G
F86HE<GLG;8<EE8F<78A68F;4??58C8E@<GG874A7GBCEBI<789BE
G;8 E8@BI4? B9 G;BF8 J;B ABG 58<A: C8E@<GG87 GB E8F<78
J<G;<A G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F E89HF8 BE A8:?86G GB 78C4EG G;8E8
9EB@4A7GB8FG45?<F;4ALFH6;E8:H?4G<BAFJ;<6;4E89BHA7
A868FF4EL<AG;8CE8@<F8F4A79BEG;8CH5?<6F498GL 
&HEFH4AGGBG;<FCBJ8E-<?FBABE78E87
142??4?<8A8A8@<8FGBCE8F8EI8G;8C8468P4A7GBE89E4<A
9EB@6E<@84:4<AFGG;8CH5?<6F498GL4A79EB@I<B?4G<A:G;8

   1FF;IFN1@CJFE K?*I<J@;<EKF=K?</E@K<;-K8K<J .?@I;EEL8C'<JJ8><
<:   .?@JN8JEFKFECP8><E<I8C:8CC=FIM@>@C8E:<9LK8CJF8E8KK<DGKKF
J<:LI<K?<G8JJ8><F=DFI<=FI:<=LCC<>@JC8K@FE 8J1@CJFE8CJFLJ<;K?<FGGFIKLE@KP
KFLI><FE>I<JJKF[<E8:K   C8NJ8KK?<<8IC@<JKGFJJ@9C<DFD<EK\@EFI;<IKF8;

;I<JJK?<[:I<8KLI<JF=G8JJ@FE ;@JCFP8CKP 8E;8E8I:?P\K?8KN<I<FEK?<CFFJ<8E;


KF[:ILJ5?6\K?<D $--1,<?@E;K?<J:<E<J 8;D@E@JKI8K@FEF==@:@8CJ@E:I<8J@E>CP
<OGI<JJ<;:FE:<IEK?8KK?<PC8:B<;[C8NJ8;<HL8K<KF;<8CN@K?K?<@EJ@;@FLJD<K?

F;JF=@EK<IE8C?FJK@C<8:K@M@K@<J \$F?E&FI;)^I@8E  -?6+:7)+05-6<;766,1


>1,=)4:--,75 " ! & ,!   $--)4;7,  ;=8:)EFK< 8K
Y 
   1@CJFE ;=8:)EFK< 
   *IF:C8D8K@FE(F GI   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




?4JF4A79EB@46GH4?;BFG<?<GLBE:<I<A:<A9BE@4G<BA
4<7 BE 6B@9BEG GB G;8 8A8@<8F B9 G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F 4A7 GB
6B@C?LFGE<6G?LJ<G;1B99<6<4?2E8:H?4G<BAF 
);BH?7G;8L7BFBG;8LJBH?7G;8CEB6?4@4G<BA4FFHE87S58HA7<F
GHE587 <A G;8 C84689H? CHEFH<G B9 G;8<E ?<I8F 4A7 B66HC4G<BAF 4A7 58
466BE787 G;8 6BAF<78E4G<BA 7H8 GB 4?? C84689H? 4A7 ?4J45<7<A:C8E
FBAFTR8K68CGG;4G<FSFB94E4FE8FGE<6G<BAF@4L58A868FF4EL9BEG;8<E
BJACEBG86G<BA4A79BEG;8F498GLB9G;8+A<G87)G4G8FT
8FC<G8<GF
G;<A 4FFHE4A68F BG;8EJ<F8 G;8 CE<@4EL <AG8AG B9 G;8 &EB6?4@4G<BAVF
?4A:H4:8BA4?<8AFJ4F6?84EGBE8I8EF8G;85HE78AB9CEBB9E8?4G<I8GB
8A8@L4?<8AFBAJ;B@4A4HE4B9FHFC<6<BAJBH?794??9BEG;87HE4
G<BAB9;BFG<?<G<8F
%A68G;8J4E;4758:HA<78B?B:<64?JBE>J4F64EE<87BA5BG;5L
G;8&4A75LI4E<BHFCEB@<A8AGCB?<G<6<4AF4A76<G<M8AF@BA:G;8
&VFCEB7H6GFJ4FG;8(87-;<G84A7?H8)8E<8F4F8GB9C4@C;?8GF
<FFH87GBF6;BB?FGB8KC?4<AGB6;<?7E8AJ;LG;8+A<G87)G4G8FJ4F4G
J4E @BA:BG;8EG;<A:FG;8C4@C;?8GF8@C;4F<M87G;4GG;8E8J4F
8KG8AF<I8 7<F?BL4?GL <A G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F G;4G G;8 :BI8EA@8AGVF E8
FGE<6G<BAFBA8KCE8FF<BAJ8E8CEBC8E4A7A868FF4EL4A7G;4G8E@4AF
J8E858;<A7?45BE7<FF8AG<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F
@BA:G;8@BFGI<E
H?8AGFC84>8EF;84E75LG;8:8A8E4??L4AG<E87%I8EGBAB@@<GG88J4F
E6;<54?7)G8I8AFBA4FG4HA6;4AG<B@@HA<FG$8J/BE>?4JL8E
J<G; 6BAA86G<BAF GB F8I8E4? 9878E4? 4A7 FG4G8 <AG8??<:8A68 4:8A6<8F
J;B6BAG8A787G;8E8J4F46?BF88E@4AB?F;8I<>6BAA86G<BA4A7
4E:H87 G;4G B?F;8I<F@ J4F SG;8 :E4I8FG @8A468 GB G;8 6BHAGEL GB
74LT4A764??87<A)6;@<7GVFE86BHAG<A:9BESG;878CBEG4G<BAB94??
4?<8A4:<G4GBEFG;88K6?HF<BAB9F87<G<BHF?<G8E4GHE8G;88A46G@8AG
B94C8468G<@8F87<G<BA?4JGBCHA<F;E47<64?6<G<M8AFG;8<AGEB7H6G<BA
B946B@CE8;8AF<I864@C4<:AB96BHAG8ECEBC4:4A7458:<AA<A:<AG;8
F6;BB?F 4A7 +) <AG8EI8AG<BA <A (HFF<4 GB GBCC?8 "8A<AVF :BI8EA
@8AGT
A<GFFH5F8DH8AG;84E<A:F4F)6;@<7GCHGF<GG;8B@@<G
G88
1:24I84FL@C4G;8G<6?<FG8A<A:GB4A74668CG874G9468I4?H8
G;8B9G8AHA7B6H@8AG87EH@BEF4A74??8:4G<BAF@4785L4
?BA:?<A8B9J<GA8FF8F@BFGB9J;B@;47I<F<G87)BI<8G(HF
F<47HE<A:BE49G8EG;8E8IB?HG<BA4A74?@BFG4??B9J;B@

   ,
 
 ,
   $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
 
 $--1,
 
 - ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   


 
     

J8E8BC8A?L;BFG<?8GBG;8B?F;8I<>FGJ4FG4>8A9BE
:E4AG87G;4GG;8B?F;8I<>FJ8E86BAGEB??875LG;88E
@4AFABG;8E6B@@BAG;8@8J4FG;4G(HFF<4AB?F;8I<F@
J4F;84I<?L<A9?H8A6875L 8JFFB@8B9J;B@64@89EB@
$8J/BE>VF"BJ8E4FG)<7866BHAGFB9G;84??8:87
FB6<4?<M4G<BAB9JB@8AG;8CE46G<68B99E88?BI8G;8A4G<BA
4?<M4G<BAB96;<?7E8A4A7G;8?HKHE<BHF?<I<A:B9G;8B?F;8
I<>?8478EFJ8AGHABCCBF87<AGBG;8CH5?<6E86BE7

%A BG;8E B664F<BAF SCEB8E@4AT 466HF4G<BAF J8E8 ?8I<87
4:4<AFGS4?@BFG4ALBA8J;BF846G<BAFBEFG4G8@8AGF;<A78E87G;8J4E
899BEGT<A6?H7<A:S1F2GE<><A:JBE>8EFE47<64?FH99E4:<FGF4A79E<64A
@8E<64A@<:E4AGFT

-;<?86;4E:8FB9CEB8E@4AF8AG<@8AGGBB>CE86878A687HE<A:
G;8J4E<GF8?9J<G;G;88A7B9G;8J4E4A8J8A8@L;47GB589BHA7
*;<FA8J8A8@LCE8F8AG87<GF8?9<AG;89BE@B9G;8B?F;8I<>F*E4A
F<G<BA9EB@BA88A8@LGBG;8BG;8EJ4F946<?<G4G875L7<FF8@<A4G<BAB9
G;8<784SG;4G8E@4AL;4778?<58E4G8?L9B@8AG87G;8B?F;8I<>(8I
B?HG<BAGBHA78E@<A8G;8(HFF<4AJ4E899BEGT
7E4J<A:4G<:;G6BA
A86G<BA58GJ88AG;88E@4AF4A7G;8B?F;8I<>F4A<78447I4A687
5L4CH5?<64G<BAG<G?87" ,'()&-"0#% )(-*#,3CHGBHG5L
E88?VF&<A%6GB58EB9  J;<6;CHECBEG87GBCEBI8G;4G"8A<A
4A7*EBGF>LJ8E88E@4A4:8AGF
*;8B?F;8I<>G;E84GJ4F;8A68
45?8GBE8C?468G;88E@4AG;E84G4FG;8=HFG<9<64G<BA9BEG;8BA:B<A:
9BE689H?FHCCE8FF<BAB9JBE>8EF
*;84AG<6B@@HA<FGF8AG<@8AG:8A8E4G875LG;84HG;BE<G<8FCEB
I<787G;8=HFG<9<64G<BA9BEG;8@8E<64A(87)64E84F@BFG<A94@BHF?L
<??HFGE4G875LG;8&4?@8E(4<7F7<F6HFF8745BI8)8AG<@8AGJ4FFBBA
E4??<874:4<AFG&4?@8EVF@BE87E46BA<4A4CCEB46;%CCBF<G<BA@8@
58EF<A6?H787"BH<F&BFG;847B9G;8"45BE8C4EG@8AG
4A7G;8
@8E<64A<I<?"<58EG<8F+A<BAS"+TE868AG?L6E84G87<AF<:A<9
<64AGC4EG<AE8FCBAF8GBG;8E4<7F
*;<FBCCBF<G<BA?87GBBA:E8F
F<BA4? ;84E<A:F <A 4AH4EL B9  

 A 9EBAG B9 G;<F ?8FF G;4A



 
 , 8K 
 
  %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
 
 ,8K  
 
 - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 $--1,8K  
 
 & 1;<7:A  &/ ?KKGJ NNN 8:CL FI> 89FLK 8:CL
?@JKFIP
5?KKGJ G<ID8 :: /
0"-%6C8JKM@J@K<;$8E    
 

 $-- ")45-: -<; ) )44 7?6 *A *4- )?A-:;  &   $   <9     
?KKGJ :?IFE@:C@E>8D<I@:8 CF: >FM C::E JE  

 <;
 J<H

 NFI;J*&',*8CD<II8@;JI8@;@E> 5?KKGJ G<ID8 :: +


1246
 %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   

FL@C4G;8G<64H7<8A68&4?@8E@4786?84EG;88KG8AGGBJ;<6;;8;47
<AG8EA4?<M87G;8<@4:8B9G;88A8@LG;4G;84A7BG;8EGBC:BI8EA@8AG
B99<6<4?F ;47 588A <AIB?I87 <A CEBC4:4G<A: FH::8FG<A: G;4G ;8 ;47
588A9<:;G<A:4:4<AFGSCB<FBABHFG;8BE<8FT4A7S4?<8A9<?G;TJ;<6;;47
S<A986G871G;825B7LB9?45BE1?<>82G;8CE8F8A68B97<F84F87
G<FFH8<AG;8;H@4A5B7LT
&4?@8E8KCE8FF87;<F984EG;4GSG;86BA
G<AH4?<AB6H?4G<BAB9CB<FBAI<EHFB9FB6<4?F87<G<BACB<FBABHFGB8I8EL
9<58E4A7EBBGGB8I8EL5BA84A7F<A8JGBG;8I8EL;84EG4A7FBH?T
JBH?7?847GBSG;8E8IB?HG<BA4EL7<F84F8T4A7BC<A87G;4GG;8EB?8B9
G;8BJ4FSFB6<4?F4A<G4G<BAT 878F6E<587G;8E47<64?F4:4<AFG
J;<6;G;8B46G874F6BAF<FG<A:B9S<784?<FGFJ<G;7<FGBEG87@<A7FT
F4L<A:S@4AL14E828I8A<AF4A8T 84?FB6E<G<6<M87G;8B4FSCEB
98FF<BA4?4:<G4GBEFJ;B4E8C?4<A?LF8?9F88>8EFT4A7SCBG8AG<4?BE46
GH4?6E<@<A4?FJ;BF854F8A8FFB96;4E46G8E?847FG;8@GB8FCBHF8G;8
HAE8FGE4<A874A7:EBFFG;8BE<8F4A7G46G<6FB9G;8F8BE:4A<M4G<BAFT 
<F6E<G<DH8F?87GB;<@<AI<G<A:BA:E8FFGB<AI8FG<:4G8G;8C;BGBFB9
G;8 E8IB?HG<BA4E<8F B5F8EI<A: S1B2HG B9 G;8 F?L 4A7 6E49GL 8L8F B9
@4ALB9G;8@?84C6HC<7<GL6EH8?GL<AF4A<GL4A76E<@89EB@G;8<E
?BCF<7879468FF?BC<A:5EBJF4A7@<FF;4C8A984GHE8F@4L58E86B:
A<M87G;8HA@<FG4>45?86E<@<A4?GLC8T &4?@8E7898A787;<F4:8AGF
5LB5F8EI<A:G;4G4AL8K68FFI<B?8A684:4<AFGG;BF878G4<A87J4F7H8
GB G;8 946G G;8L J8E8 SBI8EM84?BHF BE C8E;4CF BHGE4:87 4F C4GE<BG<6
@8E<64A6<G<M8AF5LG;86BA7H6GB9G;8F84?<8AFT4A7F;BH?758
8K6HF87466BE7<A:?L 


 
 $-- -  ;=8:) EFK<   8K Y  :@K@E> <<7:6-A -6-:)4  1<+0-44
")45-:)3-;D%0-);-/)16;<<0-#-,;E " '   ?KKG ?@JKFIP

D8KK<IJ >DL <;L ;   5?KKGJ G<ID8 :: 2


/6 C8JK M@J@K<; $8E   
  
   ,
   ,
   ,8K 
   $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8KY :@K@E>0):/-;/)16;<<0--8):<5-6<
7.=;<1+--):16/;-.7:-<0-75576#=4-; K?FE> Y JK8K<

D<EKF= '@K:?<CC*8CD<I KK^P!<E F=K?</E@K<;-K8K<J .?<K<IDJN<I<I<D@

E@J:<EK F= &FD9IFJF^J G?I<EFCF>@:8C K?<FIP  I<:<EKCP GFGLC8I@Q<; @E K?< /E@K<;
-K8K<J  FIDFI<FEK?8KK?<FIP8E;@KJ@DG8:KFEK?<;<M<CFG@E>=@<C;F=:I@D@EFCF>P
@EK?<G<I@F; J<<?8IC<JCCNFF; 75*:7;7G;%0-7:A7.:15- $    &  
$8M@;!8IC8E; *  1 "$
* -   -."$
$#  *!*<K<I<:B<I,@:?8I;1<KQ<C
<;J   . "   "$  *$ $
,LK?EE.I@GC<KK<;   
    %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   


 
     

*;8 JBE?7 I<8J 58?<87 5L &4?@8EVF FG4G8@8AGF 64A 58 78G86G87
8?F8J;8E84FJ8??89BE8G;8+A<G87)G4G8F8AG8E87G;8J4E4E8CBEG
BAG;8--CE8C4E874GG;8<AF<FG8A68B9F8I8E4?J8FG8EA:BI8EABEF
B5F8EI87 G;4G G;8 -- J4F @478 HC B9 S4:<G4GBEF @8A J<G;BHG
;B@8F@BFG?L9BE8<:A8EF4A7G;87<F6BAG8AG874A7HA8@C?BL87J;B
4E8ABG4AK<BHFGBJBE>4A7@8AB94I8EL?BJBE78EB9<AG8??<:8A68
4A7@BE4?FT C4EG<6H?4E?L6?84E<??HFGE4G<BAB9G;8<AG8E?<A>4:8B9
?89G<FG CB?<G<64? 46G<I<FGF 9BE8<:A8EF G;8 @<:E4GBEL G;8 HA8@C?BL87
G;8<@@BE4?4A7G;86E<@<A4?J4FCEBI<7875LG;8  @@<:E4G<BA
6G *;8 6G FC86<9<64??L 8K6?H787 4@BA: BG;8EF 4?6B;B?<6F 4A4E
6;<FGF6E<@<A4?F8C<?8CG<6F9885?8@<A787C8EFBAF<7<BGF<??<G8E4G8F
<@586<?8F<AF4A8C8EFBAFC4HC8EFC8EFBAFJ<G;6BAG4:<BHF7<F84F8F
@8AG4??LBEC;LF<64??L78986G<I8C8EFBAFC8EFBAFJ<G;6BAFG<GHG<BA4?
CFL6;BC4G;<6 <A98E<BE<GL CB?<G<64? E47<64?F CB?L:4@<FGF CEBFG<GHG8F
I4:E4AGF4A7C8EFBAF9EB@@BFGF<4A6BHAGE<8F 
)<@<?4E<78B?B:<64?899BEGFJ8E8HA78EJ4L8?F8J;8E84FJ8??A
E<G4<A BA8 # B99<6<4? B5F8EI87 G;4G G;8 CEB98FF87 I4?H8F B9 J4E
F>8CG<6F4A7C46<9<FGF6BAFG<GHG87S474A:8EBHFJ84CBAJ;8E85LG;8
?BL4?GLB9G;8C8BC?8<F58<A:CEBFG<GHG874A7G;87<F6<C?<A8B9G;84E@L
<AG8E98E87J<G;T589BE86BA6?H7<A:S1<29G;8L4E8ABG9BEG;8FH668FF
B9BHE6BHAGEL<G<FABGHAE84FBA45?8<9G;8L4E86?4FF874FCEB8E
@4AT *;8)C86<4?E4A6;@84AJ;<?8J4FHE:87GB9<A7S48E
@4A6BAA86G<BA58;<A77<FF<78AGCEBC4:4A74BEFGE<>846G<BAFT<ABE
78E GB CEBI<78 :EBHA7F BA J;<6; SGB 6?4@C 7BJA BA 4AG<J4E
4:<G4G<BAFT
 BI8EA@8AG C?4AA8EF @84AJ;<?8 HA78E G;8 :H<F8 B9
CE8C4E<A: 9BE 8I8AGH4?<G<8F FH6; 4F 4 8E@4A B66HC4G<BA CE8C4E87
6BAG<A:8A6LC?4AFG;4GF88@8794E@BE8:84E87GBG;86BAG8KGB9S4
FB6<4? E8IB?HG<BA BE :8A8E4? FGE<>8T HA78E J;<6; SFH5I8EF<I8FTR
@84A<A:?89G<FGFB9I4E<BHFFBEGFRJ8E8GB5878G4<A874A7G;86B@
@HA<64G<BA A8GJBE> @<?<G4E<M87  B??BJ<A: G;8 J4E F8A<BE @8@
58EFB9:BI8EA@8AG8KCE8FF87G;8<E:E4I86BA68EAF45BHGG;8CBG8AG<4?
9BE<@@<A8AGE8IB?HG<BABEG;8CBFF<5?88FG45?<F;@8AGB94)BI<8G(8
CH5?<6<AE<G4<A


   - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   $--#DD@>I8K@FE:KF= *L9 & Y  -K8K  
   "@C<P ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
 
 1  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   '  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--IK?LI':#MFI F:=;),-.7:)81<)41;5G%0-+76751+-)/=-C

 $  "   

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




A HFGE4?<4 AH@8EBHF B99<6<4?F <A CBF<G<BAF B9 4HG;BE<GL 4G


G8@CG87GBC4<AGG;8--<AG;8JBEFGCBFF<5?8?<:;G#4=BEFGE<>8F
GBB><A 4AH4ELB9  64HF<A:HFGE4?<4A&E<@8#<A<FG8E-<??<4@
H:;8F GB 5?4@8 G;8 -- J;B@ ;8 78ABHA687 4F S9BH? C4E4F<G8F
J;B ;4I8 4GG46;87 G;8@F8?I8F GB G;8 I<G4?F B9 "45BHET 4A7 4:4<AFG
J;B@ ;8 HE:87 4A S4GG461>2 J<G; G;8 98EB6<GL B9 4 8A:4? G<:8ET
B??BJ<A:G;86BAI<6G<BAB9GJ8?I8--@8@58EF<A)L7A8L<A  
G;8=H7:8E898EE87GBG;8--4FS4A4FFB6<4G<BAB96E<@<A4?FB9G;8
I8ELJBEFGGLC84A74;BG587B96E<@8T4A764??879BESI8ELFGEBA:
4A77E4FG<6FG8CF1GB258G4>8AGBHCEBBGG;4G4FFB6<4G<BATA=HFG<
9L<A: C4FF4:8 B9 HFGE4?<4VF   +A?4J9H? FFB6<4G<BAF 6G G;8
&E<@8#<A<FG8E8@C;4F<M87G;4GS4?4E:8AH@58EB9G;8@8@58EFB9
G;<F4FFB6<4G<BA4E89BE8<:A8EF4A7494<EAH@58EB9A4@8F<A
G;8?<FGB9@8@58EF;<C4E88E@4AT4A7FH::8FG87G;4GG;8E89BE8G;8
--J4FS58<A:HF879BE4CHECBF84:4<AFGG;8??<8F<AG;<FJ4ET4A7
G;4G<G6BAFG<GHG87S474::8ET4<@87S4GG;8;84EGB9FB6<8GLTGBJ;<6;
G;8BA?LE84FBA45?8E8FCBAF8J4FGBS<AF8?97898A6878FGEBL<GTA
<AGEB7H6<A: G;8   @@<:E4G<BA 6G @84AJ;<?8 &E<@8 #<A<FG8E
)G4A?8LEH688@C;4F<M87G;4GG;8CBJ8EJ4FA88787BAG;8:EBHA7
G;4G<A7HFGE<4?7<FGHE54A68F<AHFGE4?<4;47SABG1588A264HF875LG;8
HFGE4?<4A5BEA5HG1E4G;8E2J8E87H8GBG;87B6GE<A8F4A74G@BFC;8E8
<AGEB7H6875L4?<8AFT
?F8J;8E84EBHA7G;8E<G<F;@C<E8F<@<?4E4GG<GH78F6BH?758
78G86G87AA7<4G;8C4FF4:8B9G;8 
&4FFCBEG6GJ4F=HFG<9<87
<AF<@<?4EG8E@F
ABA:!BA:<AE846G<BAGBG;8  Q  :8A8E4?FGE<>8BI
8EABE(8:<A4?7)GH55FB5F8EI87
1G2;8 CE8F8AG @BI8@8AG 64AABG 58 64??87 4 U)GE<>8V  G;8
@BI8@8AG <F ABG;<A: 8?F8 G;4A 4A 4GG46>  BA 8K<FG<A:
FG4A74E7F B9 6<I<?<M4G<BA 4F E8CE8F8AG87 5L BA:>BA: 
1J28;4I8GBE84?<M8G;4GJ84E894687J<G;478?<58E4G84G
G8@CGGB78FGEBL<AG;8<AG8E8FGFB94A4E6;LG;8CEBFC8E<GL
4A7G;8I8EL8K<FG8A68B91G;826B@@HA<GL


  $--.  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1, 8K 
  $--1,8K 
    75576?-)4<0 "):41)5-6<):A -*)<-;  "FLJ< F= ,<GI<J<EK8K@M<J  
$LE<  YLJKC :@K<;@E,@:B<KJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
  $---@E>?8 ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
  ,<GFIKJF=K?<'<<K@E>JF=K?<&<>@JC8K@M<FLE:@CF="FE>%FE> " % & 
  $LCP     8K Y 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

6EBFFCB?<G<8F<AF;BEGG;8E8J4F4A4GG8@CGGB?<A>4A4E6;<FGF
FLA7<64?<FGFB6<4?<FGF6B@@HA<FGF4A7BG;8EE47<64??45BEBE:4A<M8EF
J<G;;BFG<?8J4EG<@8CBJ8EF6E<@<A4?<GL4?<8AF<A:8A8E4?4AG<6B?B
A<4?9E887B@9<:;G8EF4A7:8A8E4?7<FF8AG8EFGB6E84G8<AI4:H8BHG?<A8
4G?84FG4FBEGB99HF87;B?<FG<6<@4:8B9G;8S8A8@LBG;8ETGG<@8F
@BE8C4EG<6H?4ESBG;8EFTJ8E847787GBG;8@<K4FJ8??<A6?H7<A:S4?
6B;B?<6FTSC4HC8EFTSCEBFG<GHG8FT4A7SI4:E4AGFT -;<?8?<>84??
<78B?B:<64? JBE> G;8F8 6BAA86G<BAF J8E8 9BE:87 <A ?BBF8 4A7 9?H<7
J4LFG;8LJ8E8ABA8G;8?8FFCBJ8E9H?;8?C<A:GBE8<A9BE68G;8F8?9
<@4:8B9G;BF8<A8FG45?<F;87CBF<G<BAFB9CBJ8E4A74HG;BE<GLJ<G;<A
FB6<8GL4FG;8E<:;G8BHFBCCBA8AGFB94??FH6;9BE68FJ;<?8JBE><A:GB
78?8:<G<@<M8G;8:EBHCF<ADH8FG<BA<AG;88L8FB9G;85EB478ECBCH?4
G<BA5L64FG<A:G;8@<A4FHAF4IBEL4?<:;G4FCBFF<5?8

, & %



 
*;8CE8687<A:F86G<BAF;4I84A4?LM87F8I8E4?6B@CBA8AGFB9G;8
E8CE8FF<I84E6;<G86GHE8G;4G:E8JHCBI8EG;8 
F4A7 
F<AE8
FCBAF8GBG;8E<F<A:FGE8A:G;B9JBE>8EF4A7FB6<4?<FGBE:4A<M4G<BAF
9<A4?6B@CBA8AGJ<G;<AG;<F4E6;<G86GHE8@HFG58FGE8FF874FJ8??<A
477<G<BAGB@BE87<E86GFG4G846G<BAG;8C8E<B7F4JG;8J<78FCE8479BE
@4G<BAB9J;4G@<:;G58E898EE87GB4FS6<G<M8AFTSC4GE<BG<6TBESI<:
<?4A68T4FFB6<4G<BAF
&EB@<A8AG6<G<M8AFVI<:<?4A684FFB6<4G<BAF<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F<A
6?H787G;8$4G<BA4?)86HE<GL"84:H8S$)"TG;8$4G<BA4?<I<687
8E4G<BAS$TG;8@8E<64A898AF8)B6<8GLS)TG;8@8E<
64A &EBG86G<I8 "84:H8 S&"T G;8 B@@<GG88 9BE @@<:E4AGF <A
@8E<64G;8B@8898AF8"84:H8G;8"<58EGL"84:H8G;8@8E<
64A(<:;GF"84:H8G;8)87<G<BA)?4@@8EFG;8*8EE<5?8*;E84G8A8EF
4A7G;8BL)C<8FB9@8E<64
A@4AL<AFG4A68FG;8F8:EBHCFJ8E8
?<GG?8@BE8G;4ASUG;8@BHG;C<868FB9F<A:?8?8478EFBEF@4??6454?FV
J;<6;J8E8FH5F<7<M875L6BECBE4G<BAF4A75HF<A8FF@8AGBCEBC4:4A
7<M84:4<AFGBE:4A<M87?45BET *;8$)"4A7G;8$9BE<AFG4A68
SJ8E85BG;9<A4A6875L?847<A:5HF<A8FF@8A4A76BECBE4G<BAFFH6;4F

?KKGJ JLEQ@ C@9 ?BL ?B ?B>IF M@<N ?  G;=:@K<;@E%C<@E ;=8:)EFK< 
8K 
   #DD@>I8K@FE:K *L9 &(F 
  -K8K  <9   
 
 $--"   *  !     ) 1   Y  8K
 &   &$ $Y' $ ;=
8:)EFK< 8KY %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K[.?<NFIBF=K?<J<M@>@

C8EK:@K@Q<EJLE:FM<I<;EFK8J@E>C<!<ID8EJGP 8E;DL:?F=N?8KK?<P;@;N8J
@E<==<:KL8CFI<M<E89JLI; \ 
   - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

&#BE:4A B;A(B6>898??8E*B?8@4AH&BAG-<??<4@!
,4A78E5<?G+))G88?4EA8:<8)G88?B@C4AL4A7)G4A74E7%<?T
)H6; 4FFB6<4G<BAFV 46G<BAF J8E8 I4E<BHF?L 7<E86G87 4:4<AFG ?45BE
:EBHCFG;BF8HA78EFGBB74FCEB8E@4A4A7BG;8EFC8E68<I874FBHG
F<78EFBEBCCBF87GBG;8FG4GHFDHBA<E@<A:;4@?454@49BE<A
FG4A6846<G<M8AFV:EBHC9BE6<5?L5EB>8HC@88G<A:FB9E4<?J4LJBE>
8EF4GG8@CG<A:GBBE:4A<M84HA<BA786?4E<A:
-8G;8&4GE<BG<64?B@@<GG88HA78EFG4A7G;4GLBH;4I84?
?BJ87 G;8 -- BE 8E@4A 4:<G4GBEF GB ;B?7 @88G<A:F <A
LBHE;4??-8988?G;4GLBH7<7ABG>ABJFB@8G;<A:F
G;4GJ87<74A7<9LBH4??BJG;8F8@88G<A:FGB6BAG<AH8
LBH@4L?BBF81-#2LBHE;4??FB@8;BJBEFB@8G;<A:@4L
;4CC8A-864AVGG8??LBH8K68CG58?BL4?GBLBHE6BHAGEL
)G4G8
A#4LB9  8EL?8?I8E4ABE:4A<M8E9BEG;8$BAC4EG<F4A
"84:H8R4A BE:4A<M4G<BA $85E4F>4 BI8EABE !8<G; $8I<??8 ;47 E8
98EE87GB4F4S6<E6H?4G1BE2B9F87<G<BHF?<G8E4GHE864?6H?4G87GB4EBHF8
4AG<@8E<64A F8AG<@8AG 6?4FF ;4GE87 4A7 <A :8A8E4? <AG8E98E8 J<G;
G;8FH668FF9H?CEBF86HG<BAB9G;8J4ETRJ4F4?@BFG?LA6;87<A#8E
E<6>BHAGL$85E4F>4AH:HFGE4A>"<GG?84?847<A:--BE
:4A<M8EJ4F;HA:<AHGG8#BAG4A4A%6GB58E<A<A6<AA4G<8E
58EG <:8?BJ 4 CEB:E8FF<I8 @<A<FG8E J4F ><7A4CC87 J;<CC87 4A7
GB?7GB?84I8GBJAA%>?4;B@4G;8!A<:;GFB9"<58EGLGBB>I4E<
BHF 46G<BAF 4:4<AFG ?45BE :EBHCF 4A7 G;8 ?B64? 8E@4A?4A:H4:8
CE8FF%ACE<?  4:EBHCB9@8A?LA6;87(B58EG&E4:8E4
8E@4A@8E<64A 6B4? @<A8E <A ??<AB<F *;8F8 46G<BAF J8E8
J<78?LE8CBEG87<AG;8CE8FF9EB@G;8J4EVF58:<AA<A:GB<GF8A7A8JF
C4C8EC4:8FJ8E89<??87J<G;466BHAGFB9G;8;4E4FF@8AGB94A7E8CBEG
<A:BA@8E<64AF788@87<AFH99<6<8AG?LC4GE<BG<6 *;8A8JFC4C8EF


  ,J-:?D@;K=LIK?<IF9J<IM<J [)K?<IFI>8E@Q8K@FEJN<I<<JK89C@J?<;9PCF

:8C8E;F=K<ELCKI8:FEJ<IM8K@M<<:FEFD@:@EK<I<JKJ .?<D<I@:8EFEJK@KLK@FE8CJ

JF:@8K@FEN8JFG<I8K<;9PK?<C8I><JK:F8C8E;LK@C@KP:FDG8E@<J@E1<JK0@I>@E@8 
N?@C<K?<<KK<ID<I@:8 <;<I8K@FE@E8C@=FIE@8N8JILE9P8JD8CC>IFLGF=<O

KI<D<I@>?K
N@E>9LJ@E<JJD<E@E&FJE><C<J \,
   %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,8K 
  $--IEFE!LI=<C; %0-=:,-:7.:)631<<4-#),1+)4)*7:/1<)<17616
=<<-76<)6)  & "  
  $--   ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8KY
  $--1,8K 
   $--1,8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

4?FBCEBI<78747I<68GB@8E<64AF4FGB;BJGB6BA7H6GG;8@F8?I8F
FBA8A8JFC4C8ECHG<G
9LBH8I8EBAG;8FGE88GBE<A4GEB??8L64EF;BH?7;84EFB@8
FB9GF;8??C46<9<FGBE;4E75B<?875HGCBBE?L64@BH9?4:87CEB
8E@4A @4>8 F87<G<BHF BE HAC4GE<BG<6 E8@4E>F 45BHG LBHE
+A6?8 )4@ LBH ;4I8 G;8 E<:;G 4A7 CE<I<?8:8 B9 G4><A: G;4G
C8EFBA5LG;86B??4E;4A7;<@BI8EGBG;8A84E8FGCB?<68@4A
BE8?F8G4>8;<@LBHEF8?9589BE8G;8@4:<FGE4G8
/BH7BABGE8DH<E84ALB99<6<4?4HG;BE<GLGB7BG;<F4A7G;8
BA?L547:8A88787<FLBHEC4GE<BG<698EIBE*;8F4@8G;<A:
4CC?<8FGBJB@8AI8EL@8E<64AHA78ECEBI<F<BAFB9G;8
6B78B96<I<?CEB687HE8;4FG;84HG;BE<GLGB4EE8FG4ALC8EFBA
@4><A: 4 E8@4E> BE HGG8E4A68 J;<6; SBHGE4:8F CH5?<6 78
68A6LT

A477<G<BAGB8A6BHE4:8@8AG9EB@-<?FBAVFFG4G8@8AGF78G4<?87
<AG;8CE8I<BHFF86G<BAG;8F8:EBHCFE868<I87BG;8E9BE@FB9@BE8B9
9<6<4?FG4G8FHCCBEGB??BJ<A:G;8+A<G87)G4G8FV8AGEL<AGBG;8J4E
GGBEA8L8A8E4?E8:BEL4F>87?BL4?@8E<64AFGB46G4FSIB?HAG88E
78G86G<I81F2THE:87G;8@GBS5E<A:G;8<EFHFC<6<BAF4A7<A9BE@4G<BAGB
G;88C4EG@8AGB9 HFG<68T 4A78@C;4F<M87G;4G4F94E4F6B@
C?4<AGFJ8E86BA68EA87@4GG8EFSB98I8AG;8@BFG<A9BE@4?BE6BA9<
78AG<4?A4GHE81J8E824?J4LFJ8?6B@8T*;4A>FGBG;8FHCCBEGB9
47I8EG<F8@8AGF<AG;8./,3 0(#(!)-.G;8 HFG<688C4EG@8AG
J4FFBBAE868<I<A:BA8G;BHF4A7?8GG8EF474L)G4G8:BI8EA@8AGF
@84AJ;<?88FG45?<F;876B@@<GG88F4A76BHA6<?FB97898AF8G;4G6B@
C?8@8AG87G;8JBE>B96<G<M8AFVI<:<?4A684FFB6<4G<BAF5LF8A7<A:BHG
G;E84G8A<A: @8FF4:8F GB G;BF8 FHFC86G87 B9 ;4E5BE<A: 4AG<J4E F8AG<
@8AGFBEJ;BE89HF87GB5HL?<58EGL5BA7F<AFH99<6<8AGDH4AG<G<8F
*;86BAA86G<BA58GJ88AG;84HG;BE<G<8F4A7FB@8B9G;8I<:<?4A68
4FFB6<4G<BAFJ4F8I8A6?BF8E*;8&"J4F6E84G87BAG;8<A<G<4G<I8B9
?58EGE<::F4;<64:B5HF<A8FF@4A4A7;474@8@58EF;<C7E4JA
9EB@G;85HF<A8FF8?<G8GFCHECBF89EB@G;858:<AA<A:J4FGB4<7
G;8BFFH6;G;8&"J4FABGFB@H6;S4A8KCE8FF<BAB94:E4FF
EBBGF;LFG8E<4T4FS4A<AFGEH@8AGHF875LG;85HF<A8FF8?<G8GB<@CBF8
6BA9BE@<GL4A7FHCCE8FFE47<64?HA<BAF4A7BG;8EBCCBA8AGFT

 
 ,8K 
   ' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
   %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--1,
  $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  ,$--)4;7$ $ .*0 Y  Y 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

EH68<8?4F><G;8;847B9G;8B6BAI<A687E8:BELG;4G6?BF86B
BE7<A4G<BAJ<G;G;8&"JBH?7586BAFGEH6G<I89BEG;8:BI8EA@8AG
?847<A:E8:BELGB4HG;BE<M8G;8BE:4A<M4G<BAGBFG4G8BA<GF?8GG8E;847
G;4G <G J4F S%E:4A<M87 J<G; G;8 CCEBI4? 4A7 %C8E4G<A: HA78E G;8
<E86G<BAB9G;8+A<G87)G4G8F8C4EG@8AGB9 HFG<681B2T#8@
58EFJ8E845?8GB46DH<E84547:8FG4G<A:S)86E8G)8EI<68<I<F<BAT
?4G8E 6;4A:87 9B??BJ<A: CEBG8FGF 9EB@ G;8 *E84FHEL 8C4EG@8AG GB
SHK<?<4ELGBG;8+)8C4EG@8AGB9 HFG<68T4A7;474668FFGB HF
G<68 8C4EG@8AG FG4G<BA4EL F #HEC;L B5F8EI8F 78FC<G8 G;8 946G
G;4GG;8L?46>87FG4GHGBEL4HG;BE<GLGB@4>84EE8FGF
BC8E4G<I8F B9 G;8 ?84:H8 8A:4:87 <A 4 I4E<8GL B9 <AI8FG<:4
G<BAFCEB5<A:G;8?BL4?GLB96<G<M8AFG;846G<BAFB9G;87E49G
8K8@CG<BA5B4E7G;846GH4?FG4GHFB96BAF6<8AG<BHFB5=86GBEF
4A7G;8@BA<GBE<A:<AG;BHF4A7FB964F8FB9FHFC<6<BHF46
G<I<G<8FE8CBEG875LC8BC?8G;EBH:;BHGG;86BHAGEL<AE8FCBAF8
GB4CC84?F9BEI<:<?4A68 
*;BF8@BA<GBE87<A6?H787FHFC86G87@8@58EFB9G;8--S8A
8@L4?<8AFT4A7C46<9<FGF
AGBG4?FB@88<:;GLC8E68AGB9G;8BVF
JBE>J4F6BA7H6G875LG;8&"?847<A:G;8 HFG<688C4EG@8AGGB
4CCEBI<A:?LE8@4E>S1<2G<FF498GBF4LG;4GA8I8E<A<GF;<FGBEL;4FG;<F
6BHAGEL588AFBG;BEBH:;?LCB?<6874F4GG;8CE8F8AGG<@8T 8:<A
A<A:<A#4E6;4A7C84><A:<A)8CG8@58EB9  @8@58EFB9G;8&"
58:4A6BA7H6G<A:SF?46>8EE4<7FT<AJ;<6;GB:8G;8EJ<G;4F@4??6BA
G<A:8AGB9B4:8AGF4A7?4E:8E6BAG<A:8AGFB9FB?7<8EF4A7CB?<68@8A
G;8L EBHA787 HC @8A FHFC86G87 B9 4IB<7<A: G;8 7E49G 4A7 78G4<A87
G;8@<A?B64?=4<?F4A46G<BA7898A787<A6BHEG5L+)4GGBEA8LF
<G<M8AFVI<:<?4A68:EBHCFJ8E8C4EG<6H?4E?L46G<I84:4<AFG9E<
64A@8E<64AF6BAG<AH<A:4GE47<G<BAB9SCE<I4G8TFHCCE8FF<BAFG8@
@<A:546>GBG;89<EFGA:?<F;F8GG?8@8AGF<AG;8@8E<64F,<B?8A68
4:4<AFG9E<64A@8E<64AFJ4FC4EG<6H?4E?L<AG8AF8<AG;8FH@@8EB9
 A;<64:B4GG46>FBAG;8?46>CBCH?4G<BA?87GB6?4F;8FG;4G
?89GFB@8G;<EGL8<:;GC8EFBAF7847AE8FCBAF8G;8 HFG<688C4EG
@8AG4A7G;8"HF>B@@<GG88<AI8FG<:4G87J;8G;8EBEABGG;8--
J<G;)BI<8G(HFF<4A9<A4A6<A:;47588A58;<A7G;86?4F;8FH?G<@4G8?L

  ' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  $--1,8K 
   ,
 
 $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
   ,
  $--' $ ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

6BA6?H7<A: G;4G E47<64? CEBC4:4A74 J4F 4G ?84FG <A C4EG E8FCBAF<5?8
78FC<G86?84E8I<78A68G;4GG;84GG46>F;47588A7E<I8A5LG;8J;<G8
CBCH?4G<BA4A7;47588AE46<4??L@BG<I4G87A-4F;<A:GBA
4GG46>FBA9E<64A@8E<64AF?87GB74LFB96BA9?<6GFJ;<6;?89GF<K
78474A7BA8;HA7E87<A=HE8749G8EJ;<6;G;8BBA684:4<AGHEA87
<GF4GG8AG<BAGBG;8I<6G<@FE4G;8EG;4AG;84::E8FFBEF?4HA6;<A:4A<A
DH<EL<AGB?46>E47<64?<F@A%@4;4$85E4F>4-<??EBJA4A
9E<64A@8E<64AJ4F?LA6;874A7;<F5B7L5HEA874A7G;8@4LBE
J4F 4?@BFG ?LA6;87 J;8A ;8 4GG8@CG87 GB <AG8EI8A8 *;<F HAE8FG
J4FBA?LDH8??875LG;84EE<I4?B9G;84E@L?GB:8G;8EF8I8AGLF<K
9E<64A@8E<64AFJ8E8?LA6;87<AG;8L84E9B??BJ<A:G;8J4E A
%6GB58EB9  J;<G8I<:<?4A68:EBHCF4A79878E4?GEBBCF4GG46>87
9E<64A @8E<64AF <A6?H7<A: @8@58EF B9 G;8 &EB:E8FF<I8 4E@8EF
4A7BHF8;B?7+A<BAB9@8E<64<AE>4AF4F?847<A:GBF6BE8FB9
8KGE4=H7<6<4?><??<A:FGBEGHE84A7CEBC8EGL78FGEH6G<BA

*;8 @BE8 8KGE8@8 JBE> B9 I<:<?4A68 4FFB6<4G<BAF J4F 6B@C?8
@8AG875LBG;8E9BE@FB94AG<JBE>8ES6<I<?FB6<8GLT4FJ8??AG;8
?4G8 
F8@C?BL8EF4A7499<?<4G87:EBHCFRFH6;4FG;8+);4@
58E B9 B@@8E68 G;8 $4G<BA4? BHA78EF FFB6<4G<BA G;8 $4G<BA4?
#8G4?*E478FFFB6<4G<BAG;8$4G<BA4?FFB6<4G<BAB9#4AH946GHE8EF
4A7BG;8EFR78I8?BC874ASBC8AF;BCT64@C4<:A4?FBE898EE87GB4F
G;8 S@8E<64A &?4AT J;<6; J4F 46G<I8 <A 
 6<G<8F 5L 
 4A7
J;<6;4<@87GBSHA78E@<A8G;8CBF<G<BAB9G;8HA<BAF5L4CB?<6LB9
ABAE86B:A<G<BA4A7G;878A<4?B98@C?BL@8AGGB4A7G;87<F6;4E:8B9
HA<BA@8@58EFT *;EBH:;G;8<ECH5?<64G<BAG;8*(")*0#1
G;8@8@58EFB9G;8@8E<64A&?4AE898EE87GBHA<BAF4FSG;8:E84G8FG
6E<@8?89G<AG;8JBE?7TBECBE4G<BAF8@C?BL87F8I8E4?BG;8EFGE4G
8:<8F 78F<:A87 GB HA78E@<A8 G;8 CBJ8E B9 ?45BE 4F J8?? <A6?H7<A:
S5?46>?<FGFB9HA<BA@8@58EF4A7U4:<G4GBEFVJ;BJ8E89<E87BEE89HF87
8@C?BL@8AGTSUL8??BJ7B:V6BAGE46G1F2<AJ;<6;1JBE>8EF2C?87:87
ABGGB=B<A4HA<BATS4CC84?1F2GBG;86BHEGFGB<FFH8?45BE<A=HA6G<BAF

  $--1,8KY 
  ,8KY 
  ,
  $-- %% ;=8:)EFK< 8K
   $--1,
 
 $---$ ;=8:)EFK<  
   - ;=8:)EFK< 8K $--)4;7CC<E' 18BJK<@E %0-!:1/16;7.<0-
!8-6$0787>-5-6<C  $  " #! .
&  3   "$     1   Y  8K Y
  
  - ;=8:)EFK< 8K 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

GB5E84>FGE<>8FTS1C2E<I4G878G86G<I8F8@C?BL87GB<A9<?GE4G8FCL
BA4A76E84G8<AG8EA4?7<FF8AF<BAJ<G;<AHA<BAFQ4A7<AFB@864F8FGB
46G4F4:8AGFCEBIB64G8HE4A7CEBIB>8?45BEHAE8FGTS1F2GE<>85E84>
8EF12  B9G8A J<G; 4E@87 :H4E7FT SCE<I4G8 CB?<68 FLFG8@1F2 
J;<6;J18E82HF874F4CE<I4G84E@L4:4<AFGFGE<>8EFT4A7S6B@C?8G8
6BAGEB? B9 G;8 ?45BE 9BE68  1<A2 6B@C4AL GBJAF J;<6; <FB?4G87
JBE>8EF 9EB@ G;8 BHGF<78 4A7 FH5=86G87 G;8@ GB 6BAFG4AG FHEI8<?
?4A68T L G;8 ?4G8 
F G;8E8 J8E8 4A 8FG<@4G87

 ?45BE
FC<8F4GJBE>@4ALB9J;B@GHEA87BHGGB584@BA:G;8@BFG8KGE8@8
4:<G4GBEF
*;8C4GE<BG<64FFB6<4G<BAFG;4GJ8E86E84G87BEEBF8GBCEB@<A8A68
7HE<A:G;8J4E6BAG<AH87GBC?4L4FHCCBEG<A:EB?8<AG;8E8CE8FF<BAB9
9E<64A@8E<64AFJBE>8EF4A7FB6<4?<FGF9B??BJ<A:G;8J4EVF8A7
@BA:BG;8EG;<A:FFH6;4FFB6<4G<BAFSJ4EA87G;4G4:<:4AG<66BA
FC<E46LG;E84G8A87G;8+)4A7G;4G4E8IB?HG<BA4ELHCE<F<A:J4F<@@<
A8AGT4A7S78@4A787G;4GG;887H64G<BA4?FLFG8@4A7:BI8EA@8AG58
CHE:87B9E47<64?F4A7G;4G4?<8AF58@8E<64A<M87T)B@8FH6;4F
G;88GG8E@8E<64A878E4G<BA9BHA787<A"BFA:8?8F<A#4LB9

 5L E4<?J4L 78I8?BC8E ?< ?4E> 4A7 BG;8E 5HF<A8FF@8A J8AG
8I8A9HEG;8ES4GG46>1<A:24??9BE@FB9:BI8EA@8AGE8:H?4G<BAFB6<4?
?8:<F?4G<BA4A7CH5?<6BJA8EF;<C9BE58<A:F87<G<BHF4A7HA@8E<64A
4A778@4A71<A:2G;4G9E88FC886;4A7G;8E<:;GGBIBG858E8
FGE<6G87T%G;8EBE:4A<M4G<BAF6BAG<AH87GB4FF<FG:BI8EA@8AGCEBF
86HG<BAF 4A7 64@C4<:AF B9 78@BA<M4G<BA 4A7 78?8:<G<@<M4G<BA B?
?BJ<A:G;8E4<7BAG;8B@@HA<FG&4EGL6BAI8AG<BA<A  G;8B
CEBI<787G;8)4668FFGB6BC<8FB9F8<M877B6H@8AGFGB:8G;8EJ<G;
78F>FC468J<G;<AG;88C4EG@8AGB9 HFG<68E8FH?G<A:<AG;8CH5?<64
G<BAB94F8E<8FB94EG<6?8F78F6E<5<A:G;8SE87TG;E84GJ;<?8G;8$
;8?C87GBF86HE89HA7<A:9BEG;8CEBF86HG<BA*;8$)"8A:4:87<A
4A4AG<HA<BA64@C4<:AG;4GJ4F5EB47?L89986G<I8E8FH?G<A:<A478
6?<A8<AHA<BA@8@58EF;<C9EB@BI8E@<??<BA<A 
GB @<??<BA
5L   


  ,8K 
  $--1,
  ,8K 
  ,;--)4;7&8PKFE ;=8:)EFK< 
  $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
  $--1,8K  
   $-- 744-+<1>- ):/)1616/ )6, 1>14 1*-:<1-;  &/ 
?KKGJ NNN 8:CL FI> FK?<I :FCC<:K@M<
98I>8@E@E>
8E;
:@M@C
C@9<IK@<J
5?KKGJ G<ID8 :: 0''
$$/6C8JKM@J@K<;$8E    

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

?F8J;8E84EBHA7G;8JBE?7F<@<?4E78I8?BC@8AGFJ8E8HA78E
J4L4GG<@8F<A8I8A74E>8E9BE@FAE<G4<AG;8:BI8EA@8AGGB:8G;8E
J<G;5HF<A8FF<AG8E8FGF8A6BHE4:87G;89BE@4G<BAB9C4GE<BG<66<G<M8AFV
:EBHCFBCCBF87GBG;8<AG8E8FGFB9?45BE<A6?H7<A:9BE<AFG4A68G;8
E<G<F;@C<E8+A<BA4A7G;8E<G<F;B@@BAJ84?G;+A<BA4A78A
6BHE4:87G;8@GB4GG46>7<FF<78AGFV@88G<A:F
B??BJ<A:G;8J4E
A8J 8@C?BL8EFV BE:4A<M4G<BAF FH6; 4F G;8 #<77?8 ?4FF +A<BA G;8
"<58EGL"84:H84A7G;86BAB@<6"84:H8J8E89BE@87GBCHF;546>
4:4<AFGG;8:EBJ<A:CB?<G<64?CBJ8EB9BE:4A<M87?45BE B??BJ<A:
G;8  F84@8AVFFGE<>8<ABA:!BA:G;8E<G<F;FHCCBEG87G;86E8
4G<BA B9 4A 8@C?BL8EFV 9878E4G<BA B??BJ<A: G;8 @4FF<I8  
FGE<>8G;8:BI8EA@8AG8A6BHE4:87CE<I4G86BBC8E4G<BAJ<G;FG4G8F8
6HE<GL 4HG;BE<G<8F 5L <FFH<A: E8J4E7F 9BE 4AL <A9BE@4G<BA BA S4:<G4
GBEFT4A7S8I<?7<FCBF87C8EFBAFTI8A49G8EG;8FGE<>88A787G;8
:BI8EA@8AG6BAG<AH87GB8@C?BL4A8GJBE>B9<A9BE@4?6BHAG8EFGE<>
8EF
GJ4F<A68AGE4?4A7FBHG;8EAHEBC8G;4GG;8@BFGI<B?8AG4A7
89986G<I8C4E4FG4G4?:EBHCF8@8E:87;BJ8I8EAG4?LG;8GHE5H?8AG
CEBG8FGF B9 G;8 <8AA<B (BFFB J8E8 9B??BJ87 5L G;8 8@8E:8A68 4A7
E4C<7:EBJG;B9G;84F6<FG&4EGLBI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;884E?L 
F
HA7E87F B9 FB6<4?<FGF 4A7 ?45BE BE:4A<M8EF J8E8 @HE78E87 589BE8
#HFFB?<A<GBB>CBJ8E<A  4GJ;<6;CB<AGG;894F6<FG@<?<G<4F58
64@84F8@<B99<6<4?<M874E@B9G;8FG4G8A8E@4ALFG4G8FHC
CE8FF<BAB9E8IB?HG<BA4ELHCE<F<A:F49G8EG;8J4EJ4F4FF<FG875LI8G
8E4AF :EBHCF >ABJA 4F E8<>BECF A HA:4EL N?4 !HAVF 5E<89
C8E<B7<ACBJ8EJ4F9B??BJ875LG;8J;<G8G8EEBE<AJ;<6;E<:;GJ<A:

 
 $-- "FGB@E  ;=8:) EFK<   8K  *  *  *    ;=8:)
EFK< 8KY"! $ ;=8:)EFK< 8K '  ;=8:)EFK<
  8K   Y  Y  Y &   ;=8:) EFK<   8K   FI DFI<  J<<
"  ;=8:)EFK< "L>?<JF9J<IM<JK?8KK?<I@K@J?DG@I</E@FE[N8J8JJF

:@8K<; EFK FECP N@K? ><E<I8C 8EK@


!<ID8E 8>@K8K@FE 9LK JG<:@=@:8CCP N@K?    8EK@

-<D@K@:8>@K8K@FE8E;:FEJG@I8:PK?<FI@<J   \K?8K@K=I<HL<EKCP<E>8><;@EM@FC<E:< 
8E;K?8K@K?<CG<;@EJK@>8K<8EK@
$<N@J?I@FKJ@E&<<;J@E ,8K 
   $---K<G?<E1?@K< ,-747/1+)4-/-576A)6,"741<1+)476<:74%0-$7+174
7/A 7. 6<174;0->1;5 16 :1<)16 C    -  &  "  -   
':#MFI ;=8:)EFK< 8KY"  ;=8:)EFK< 
  $--' ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--%C<@E ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  $--.  ;=8:)EFK< 8K 
  $--D@C@F!<EK@C< "):)5141<):A'174-6+-16<)4A%0-#)<176)4-7.);+1;5
)6,<0-!:1/16;7.%7<)41<):1)61;5 16. 0   1$  1
1  
  
  $--1,
  $--  $   .!  Y  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




C4E4@<?<G4E<8FGBEGHE87FH@@4E<?L8K86HG874A74E5<GE4E<?L78G4<A87
G;BHF4A7F B9 FHFC86G87 FB6<4?<FGF 8JF 4A7 BG;8E 8A8@<8F B9 G;8
E<:;G
&4E4FG4G4?C4GE<BG<64A7I<:<?4A684FFB6<4G<BAF9BE@874>8LC4EG
B9G;84AG<JBE>8EE8CE8FF<I8@B78?G;4G78I8?BC877HE<A:G;8 
F
4A7 
F*;8F8BE:4A<M4G<BAFGBB>I4E<BHF9BE@FFB@8@BE8;84I
<?LFHCCBEG875L@8@58EFBG;8EF8FF8AG<4??L8@CGLF;8??FFB@8@BE8
7<FG4AG 9EB@ G;8 FG4G8 BG;8EF 6?BF8?L <AG8EJBI8A J<G; FG4G8 CBJ8E
FB@8 @BE8 BE:4A<64??L 6B@CBF87 BG;8EF BE:4A<M87 9<A4A687 4A7
@4<AG4<A87 5L 5HF<A8FF <AG8E8FGF F I<B?8AG 4F FH6; BE:4A<M4G<BAF
6BH?758G;8LJ8E8<EBA<64??LC8E;4CF6;86>87GBG;88KG8AGG;4GG;8
BG;8E @B74?<G<8F B9 FHCCE8FF<BA 78G4<?87 45BI8 J8E8 @BFG 89986G<I8
-;8E8BG;8E@84AFB9FHCCE8FF<BAJ8E8?8FF4I4<?45?8;BJ8I8E4F<A
F8I8E4? HEBC84A FG4G8F G;8F8 BE:4A<M4G<BAF GBB> BA 4A 8I8A @BE8
GEBH5?<A:4FC86G6B@<A:<AG4?L9BE8K4@C?8GBFH5FH@8G;8FG4G8
<GF8?9CE89<:HE<A:G;8E<F<A:FGE8A:G;B994F6<F@<AG;8L84EFGB6B@8

,   
 
*;8C8E<B7589BE87HE<A:4A749G8EG;8<EFG-BE?7-4E5EBH:;G
45BHG9HA74@8AG4?6;4A:8F<AG;8FGEH6GHE8B9CH5?<6BE78E:BI8EA4A68
:?B54??L*;8F86;4A:8FJ8E8ABGFB@H6;7H8GBG;8J4E<GF8?9F<:
A<9<64AGG;BH:;<GJ4F4F4A8A45?<A:946GBE4FGBHA78E?L<A:FB6<4?
7LA4@<6F *;<F J4F C4EG<6H?4E?L GEH8 9BE G;8 6BA9?<6G 58GJ88A G;8
9BE68FB9?45BE4A764C<G4?G;4GC?4L87BHG<ACB?<G<8F4EBHA7G;8JBE?7
BI8EG;8C8E<B7*;4G6BA9?<6GGBB>I4E<BHF9BE@F4A7J4F@4E>875L
7<998E8AGC?4L8EFC4EG<8F4A7C8EFC86G<I8F<A<GF7<998E8AG<A64EA4G<BAF
%AG;8JBE>8EFVF<78G;8C8E<B7F4J?4E:8F64?8?45BEBE:4A<M4
G<BA4A7FGE<>846G<BA<AAH@8EBHFCB?<G<8F#4=BE?45BE46G<BAFB9G;8
C8E<B7<A6?H787:8A8E4?FGE<>8F<A-<AA<C8:4A7<A*E<A<7474A7*B
54:BFG88?4A76B4?@<A8EFVFGE<>8F<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F4A74?4E:8
6BGGBA@<??JBE>8EFGE<>8<AB@54L<A   6B4?@<A8EFVFGE<>8F

  $--F;U "):)5141<):A'174-6+- ;=8:)EFK<+ ;=8:)EFK<F;U 
(01<-%-::7: ;=8:)EFK<,F9<IK!<N8IK? 1/0<16/<0-#-,-);<7=6<-:#->
74=<176):A '174-6+- 16 <0- -.-)<-, $<)<-; 7. -6<:)4 =:78-  16 1   * 
*   $0 ! 1 ,F9<IK!<IN8IK?
$F?E"FIE<<;J   
   $--%8KQ ;=8:)EFK<I@EJC<P-8D8IFF %0-%:161,),(7:316/5-6G;;
;7+1)<176)6,<0-!:1/16;7."78=4):":7<-;<16):7?67476A -  
-   .FEP'8IK@E #->74=<176):A&80-)>)416%:161,),'1-?;
.:75:1<1;0)6,5-:1+)6$7=:+-;  $      " &<;<I

D8E ;=8:)EFK<$F?EJFE ;=8:)EFK< 8K Y 18CB<I ;=8:)EFK<


,8M@E;<I%LD8I %0-75*)A%-@<14-$<:13- #     -  " 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

<A-8FG,<E:<A<44A7<AG;8+A<G87!<A:7B@<A  
E4<?J4L4A7
6B4?@<A8EFVFGE<>8F<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F4A74?4E:8F84@8AVFFGE<>8<A
BA:!BA:<A   4?4E:86BGGBA@<??JBE>8EFGE<>8<AB@54L<A
  4 F84@8AVF FGE<>8 <A HFGE4?<4 G;8 $BEG; -8FG8EA (4<?J4L
FGE<>8<AA7<44A7:8A8E4?FGE<>8F<A);4A:;4<4A7<ABA:!BA:<A
 4A74:8A8E4?FGE<>8<AG;8+A<G87!<A:7B@<A  *;8
CE8FFHE89BE@BE88:4?<G4E<4ACB?<G<64?BE78EF4A78A;4A6876<I<?CB
?<G<64?4A7JBE>8EFVE<:;GF8K8EG875LG;8F8FGE<>8FJ4F@8G5L4E4A:8
B9A8JE8CE8FF<I8@84FHE8F<A6?H7<A:G;8C4FF4:8B9A8J?4JFG;8
78I8?BC@8AGB9A8J<AFG<GHG<BAFFHEI8<??4A68;4E4FF@8AGE4<7F4E
E8FGFCEBF86HG<BAF4A7BG;8E=H7<6<4?4A747@<A<FGE4G<I8@84FHE8F7<
E86GFG4G89BE68G;878I8?BC@8AGB9A8J<78B?B:<64?9BE@4G<BAF4A7
G;8 :EBJG; B9 C4E4FG4G4? BE:4A<M4G<BAF 8E8 <A 6BA6?HF<BA FB@8
5EB478E?8FFBAFG;4G@4L588KGE46G879EB@78I8?BC@8AGF<A846;4E84
J<??586BAF<78E87
%A G;8 ?8:4? ?8I8? 9<I8 GLC8F B9 ?4JF 78I8?BC87 <A G;8 C8E<B7
?4JFG4E:8G<A:F87<G<BA?4JFC8A4?<M<A:4A4E6;L4A7FLA7<64?<F@?4JF
E8FGE<6G<A: 4FFB6<4G<BA 4A7 4FF8@5?L ?4JF :BI8EA<A: @<:E4G<BA 4A7
?4JF<@CBF<A:68AFBEF;<C$8JF87<G<BA?4JF47BCG87<AG;8C8E<B7
<A6?H787G;8+A<G87)G4G8FVJ8??>ABJA)87<G<BA6G4FJ8??4FG;8
4AG<F87<G<BA@84FHE8F<@C?8@8AG874EBHA7G;84E<5584A$H@8E
BHFS4A4E6;<FGT4A7SFLA7<64?<FGT?4JFJ8E84?FB8A46G875BG;<AG;8
+A<G87 )G4G8F 4A7 8?F8J;8E8 <A6?H7<A: 9BE <AFG4A68 <A G;8 9BE@ B9


,!    '<CMPE L9F=JBP  FJK<I ,?<8 LCC<J &     
"$K?<; - ;=8:)EFK< 8KY1FC:FKK ;=8:)EFK<
 
 
 $--!  "  &   
'# $Y
- !  ;=8:)EFK<  ;=8:)EFK<1  ;=8:)EFK< 8K
 Y 
   $-- ' $  ;=8:) EFK<   8K   '  ;=8:) EFK<   8K  .  
;=8:)EFK< 8KY 
  $--@:B%FF@D8E 75*)A755=61;<;)6,<0- %-@<14-$<:13-  
*^$1$  ;--/-6-:)44A-LJ8E1FC:FKK $<:13-;1674761)46
,1) C
 #  & , ,!    
  $-- ,@:B<KJFE  ;=8:) EFK<   8K  Y  '  ;=8:) EFK<   8K 
.  ;=8:)EFK< 8K(> 4?8E>1FE> ;=8:)EFK<'LB?<IA@ ;=8:)
EFK< - ;=8:)EFK< 8KY3FE>':%<EE8 ;=8:)EFK< 8K
- ;=8:)EFK<  8KY 
  $-- % &$    . !  -     
   '( 1! -&   
   *  
  -<;@K@FE:K *L9 & 
  -K8K  
  $--"<9(FM  :FCJ 
1 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

A7<4VF A4E6;<64? 4A7 (8IB?HG<BA4EL E<@8F 6G $8J ?4JF E8


FGE<6G<A: 4FFB6<4G<BAF <A6?H787 HFGE4?<4VF   +A?4J9H? FFB6<4
G<BAF 6G 4A7 4@8A7@8AGF GB G;8 E<@8F 6G <A    4A7 G;8
  4@8A7@8AGF GB G;8 4A47<4A E<@<A4? B78
 *;8  
4@8A7@8AGFGBHFGE4?<4VFE<@8F6G4?FB?<@<G87G;8E<:;GGBFGE<>8
4F7<7G;8+A<G87!<A:7B@VF*E478<FCHG8F4A7*E478+A<BAF6GB9
  ABG;8E6B@CBA8AGB9G;<FE8CE8FF<I8?8:4?4E6;<G86GHE864@8
<AG;89BE@B9A8J@<:E4G<BA?4JFG;4GE8FGE<6G87<@@<:E4G<BA4A78K
C4A787CBJ8EFB978CBEG4G<BA<A6?H7<A:G;8         
4A7    @@<:E4G<BA 6GF <A G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F 4@8A7@8AGF GB
<@@<:E4G<BA?4J47BCG87<AHFGE4?<44A74A474<AE8FCBAF8GB--
46G<I<G<8F 4A7G;8 
A7<4A&4FFCBEG6G 8AFBEF;<CCEBI<
F<BAF<A6?H787<A?4JFFH6;4FG;8FC<BA4:84A7)87<G<BA6GF9HEG;8E
?<@<G87CH5?<69E887B@<A6?H7<A:5L:E4AG<A:A8JCBJ8EFB96BAGEB?
BI8E6B@@HA<64G<BAFGBCBFG4?4HG;BE<G<8F
%AG;8<AFG<GHG<BA4??8I8?G;8C8E<B7J4F6EH6<4?GBG;89BE@4G<BA
B9GJBA8JFBEGFB9<AFG<GHG<BAF@B78EA<AG8??<:8A684:8A6<8FFH6;4F
G;8)C86<4?E4A6;4A7#4A7I4E<BHF?B64?<AG8??<:8A68;H5F
4GG;86B?BA<4??8I8?9BE<AFG4A68<AA7<4BA:!BA:4A7:LCG4A7
CEBC4:4A745HE84HFFH6;4FG;8(4A7G;8#<A<FGELB9A9BE@4G<BA
-;<?8@B78EA<AG8??<:8A684:8A6<8F58:4AGB78I8?BC589BE8G;8J4E
G;8L:E8J5L?84CF4A75BHA7FBI8EG;86BHEF8B9G;8J4E4A7FH5F8
DH8AGL84EFA477<G<BAG;8C8E<B7F4JG;8ABI8?HF8B9G;8?8:<F?4G<I8
6B@@<FF<BAB9<ADH<EL4F4@84AFB94GG8@CG<A:GB:8A8E4G8A8:4G<I8
CH5?<6F8AG<@8AGE8?4G<I8GBE47<64?4A7?89G<FG@BI8@8AGF4HF88K8@
C?<9<875LG;8%I8E@4A4A7"HF>6B@@<GG88F


  :K(F  #E;@8 
  &64)?.=4;;7+1)<176;+< K?(F LJKC  
   6+<<75-6,<0-:15-+< C  K?(F LJKC  
 
 E:KKFD<E;K?<I@D@E8CF;< K?<3FLK?I@D@E8C$LJK@:<:K8E;)K?<I
:KJ8E;KF'8B<FEJ<HL<EK@8CD<E;D<EKJKF)K?<I:KJ -   : V
8E  
   !<F : !I I@K  
   #DD@>I8K@FE:K *L9 & (F 
  -K8K  <9   
   E:KKFO:CL;<8E;OG<C=IFDK?</E@K<;-K8K<JC@<EJ1?F8I<'<D9<IJ
F=K?<E8I:?@JK@:8E;-@D@C8IC8JJ<J *L9 & 
  -K8K   
   E:KKF&@D@KK?<#DD@>I8K@FEF=C@<EJ@EKFK?</E@K<;-K8K<J *L9 & 

 -K8K  
   E:KKF&@D@KK?<#DD@>I8K@FEF=C@<EJ@EKFK?</E@K<;-K8K<J 8E;=FI)K?<I
*LIGFJ<J *L9 & 
 -K8K  
   $--%8KQ ;=8:)EFK<FL>C8J ;=8:)EFK< 
   :K(F   #E;@8 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

A 477<G<BA GB ?8:4? 4A7 <AFG<GHG<BA4? 78I8?BC@8AGF JBE>8EFV


@BI8@8AGFJ8E8@8G5LFHEI8<??4A68;4E4FF@8AGE4<7F4EE8FGFCEBF
86HG<BAF 4A7 BG;8E =H7<6<4? 4A7 47@<A<FGE4G<I8 @84FHE8F $H@8EBHF
<A7<I<7H4?FJ8E8CEBF86HG874EBHA7G;8JBE?7HA78EG;8A8J?4JF4F
J8??4FHA78EE8CE8FF<I8?4JF4?E847LBAG;85BB>FB9G8A9BEAB@BE8
G;4A G;8 6E<@8 B9 C84689H? 4FF8@5?L BE 74E<A: GB 78@4A7 :E84G8E
E<:;GFGG<@8FG;8F8CEBF86HG<BAFGBB>G;89BE@B9@4FFGE<4?F<A
6?H7<A:G;8@4FFGE<4?FB9--@8@58EF<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FHF
GE4?<44A74A4744FJ8??4FG;8+A<G87)G4G8F54F87@4FFGE<4?FB9
;474EC4EGL@8@58EF%A68G;86B@@HA<FGG;E84G4EE<I87 9H??LBA
G;8F68A86B@@HA<FGFGBBJ8E8CEBF86HG87<A6?H7<A:<AG;8+A<G87
)G4G8FG;8+A<G87!<A:7B@A7<44A7:LCG%A<AAH@8E45?8BG;8E
B664F<BAF 6B@@HA<FGF FLA7<64?<FGF 4A7 BG;8EF J8E8 GE<87 I<4 BA8
9BE@B9FH@@4ELCEB687HE8BE4ABG;8EJ<G;G;8BHG6B@8B9G;BF8GE<
4?F :8A8E4??L 4 9BE8:BA8 6BA6?HF<BA A 477<G<BA GB G;8F8 @84FHE8F
68AFBEF;<C?<@<G87G;87<FF8@<A4G<BAB9FB6<4?<FGFV4A7JBE>8EFVC8E
FC86G<I8F 4A7 BC<A<BAF 78CBEG4G<BAF F8C4E4G87 @BI8@8AG ?8478EF
9EB@G;8@4FF54F8FG;8LJBE>87GB5H<?74A7<A=HA6G<BAF4A754AFB9
C4EG<6H?4EBE:4A<M4G<BAFG;E8J4JE8A6;<AGBFB@8B9G;8@BFGFH668FF
9H?64@C4<:AFJ;<?88KC4A7<A:G;8F6BC8B9?45BEHA<BA46G<I<GLG;4G
6BH?7586E<@<A4??LCHA<F;87
)H6; ?8:4? <AFG<GHG<BA4? 4A7 47@<A<FGE4G<I8 78I8?BC@8AGF CEB
I<787G;8546>5BA8B9G;8FLFG8@B9:BI8EA4A6878I8?BC87<AG;8C8
E<B7-;8E8CBFF<5?86BAGEB?B9JBE>8EF5LG;8F8@84AFJ4FCE898E4
5?8CE8I8AG<A:G;8A8879BE@BE8BI8EG5HGCBG8AG<4??L78FG45<?<M<A:
G86;A<DH8F -;8E8 ?8:4? EH?8F FHEI8<??4A68 68AFBEF;<C 4EE8FGF 4A7
CEBF86HG<BAF94<?87GB8K8EG4FH99<6<8AG?L6;<??<A:4HE4G;84HG;BE<G<8F
;47BA8@BE8GBB?G;8L6BH?7HG<?<M84FJ8??G;8GE<874A7G8FG874C
CEB46;B9BHGE<:;G9BE689H?FHCCE8FF<BA58<G<AG;89BE@B9G;87<F
C8EF4?B9CEBG8FGBEFG;EBH:;G;8HF8B9?<I84@@HA<G<BABE<A@BE8
8KGE8@864F8F8KGE4=H7<6<4?8K86HG<BAAFB@8C4EGFB9G;8JBE?7G;8
I<B?8A68 78C?BL87 GBB> BA C4EG<6H?4E?L F8I8E8 9BE@F <A6?H7<A: <A
;<A44A78E@4AL9BE8F;47BJ<A:9HEG;8EI<B?8A68GB6B@8
??FH6;G86;A<DH8FB9:BI8EA4A68J8E8FHCC?8@8AG875L899BEGF
BAG;8<78B?B:<64??8I8?%A8B9G;8CE<@4EL4CCEB46;8FCHEFH875L
G;84HG;BE<G<8FJ4FGB4GG8@CGGB7E4J46BAA86G<BA58GJ88AI4E<BHF
7<998E8AG:EBHCF4A7<A7<I<7H4?FG;8LC8E68<I874F8A8@<8FB9G;8FG4G8
4A7B9E8FC86G45?8FB6<8GL*;89<:HE8FB9G;8;BFG<?8J4EG<@8BCCB
A8AG G;8 ?89G<FG 4:<G4GBE G;8 9BE8<:A8E G;8 6B?BA<4? <A78C8A78A68
9<:;G8E4A7G;86E<@<A4?6BAFG<GHG87G;864G8:BE<8FG;4GE868<I87G;8
@BFGE8:H?4E4GG8AG<BA)G<??4?G8EA4G<I8SBG;8EFTJ8E84GG<@8FG;EBJA
<AGBG;8@<K4FJ8??4F<??HFGE4G875LG;8  @@<:E4G<BA6G<AG;8

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

+A<G87)G4G8FJ<G;<GF8KG8AF<I8?<FGB9HA78F<E45?8FG;4G<A6?H7874A
4E6;<FGF4A7E47<64?FC4HC8EFI4:E4AGF4A76BAGE46G?45BE8EFCEBFG<
GHG8F4A7CB?L:4@<FGF6E<@<A4?F4?6B;B?<6F<7<BGF<@586<?8F4A7G;8
<AF4A8 *;8FG4G8@8AG5L4@8@58EB9G;8A7<4A:BI8EA@8AGG;4G
G;8 
 &4FFCBEG 6G J4F 78F<:A87 GB CE8I8AGF 6E<@<A4?F C<@CF
CEBFG<GHG8F4A7G;BF8B94E47<64?CB?<G<64?C8EFH4F<BA9EB@8AG8E<A:
G;86BHAGEL 4A7G;8CEB6887<A:FB9G;8%I8E@4AB@@<GG88J;<6;
C4<AG87 8E@4AF B?F;8I<>F 4A7 CBBE 8J<F; @<:E4AGF <A $8J
/BE>VF"BJ8E4FG)<78<AG;8F4@8;BFG<?86B?BEF
4E84?FB<??HFGE4
G<I8
<A4??LBAG;8C4E4FG4G4??8I8?G;8C8E<B7J4F@4E>875LG;89BE
@4G<BA 4A7 <A6E84F<A: FGE8A:G; B9 AH@8EBHF 6<G<M8AFV I<:<?4A68 4A7
C4GE<BG<64FFB6<4G<BAF)H6;:EBHCF<A6?H787G;8$)"G;8)4A7
G;8&"<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FG;8E<G<F;@C<E8+A<BAG;8E<G<F;
B@@BAJ84?G;+A<BA4A7G;86BAB@<6"84:H8<AG;8+A<G87!<A:
7B@8@C?BL8EF<AC?468F?<>8B@54L4?6HGG4);4A:;4<4A7BA:
!BA:4FJ8??4FG;894F6<FGBE:4A<M4G<BAFG;4G78I8?BC87@BFGDH<6>?L
4A78KG8AF<I8?L<A6BAG<A8AG4?HEBC8*;8F<:A<9<64A68B9G;8F8BE
:4A<M4G<BAF<A@B5<?<M<A:4:4<AFGCEB:E8FF<I89BE68FI4E<8778C8A7<A:
BA G;8 8AG<GL <A DH8FG<BA G G<@8F G;8L J8E8 ?<GG?8 @BE8 G;4A G4?>
F;BCFBE8I8A?4E:8?L<@4:<A4EL8AG<G<8F4F<AG;864F8B9G;8&8468
4A7 %E78E &E8F8EI4G<BA )B6<8GL <A BA: !BA: %A BG;8E B664F<BAF
G;8L6BAFG<GHG874>8LC4EGB9G;8BI8E4??4E6;<G86GHE8B9FHCCE8FF<BA
4FF88A<AG;88KG8AF<I84A789986G<I8E8CE8FF<BAHA78EG4>8A5LFH6;
:EBHCF<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8F4A7G;8+A<G87!<A:7B@7HE<A:G;8J4E
4A7<AG;8CBFGJ4EL84EF%AL8G9HEG;8EB664F<BAFG;8L@8G4FG4F<M87
FBE4C<7?L4A789986G<I8?LG;4GG;8LFJ4??BJ87G;8FG4G8<GF8?94FJ<G;
G;8E4C<778F68AGB9G4?L<AGB94F6<FGEH?8
AF;BEG4A7<AFH@G;8 
F4A7 
FF4J8KG8AF<I878I8?BC
@8AGF<AE8CE8FF<I8:BI8EA4A68:?B54??L-;<?8G;8<EFG-BE?7-4E
4668?8E4G87F8I8E4?B9G;8F878I8?BC@8AGFG;8<EBA:B<A:@BG<I4G<BA
J4FCEBI<787ABG5LG;8J4E<GF8?95HGE4G;8E5L4HG;BE<G<8FVC8E68<I87
A887GBE8FCBA7GB4A7FHCCE8FFG;8:EBJ<A:FGE8A:G;B9?89G<FG?45BE
4A7FB6<4?<FGBE:4A<M<A:4A747IB646L4FJ8??4F46EBFFG;8<@C8E<4?
JBE?7G;87<FG<A6G5HGB9G8A<AG8E?<A>87:EBJG;B94AG<6B?BA<4?@BI8
@8AGF+A78EFG4A7<A:G;8F878I8?BC@8AGF<FB95EB478EFB6<B;<FGBE<
64?<AG8E8FG<AFB94E4F<GG8FG<9<8FGBG;8@4AA8E<AJ;<6;G86;A<DH8FB9

   :KKF,<>LC8K<K?<#DD@>I8K@FEF=C@<EJKF 8E;K?<,<J@;<E:<F=C@<EJ@E 
K?</E@K<;-K8K<J *L9 & 
  -K8K  
   $---@E>?8 ;=8:)EFK< 8K  
 
 $--- ;=8:)EFK< 8KY 

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

:BI8EA4A688IB?I8<AE8FCBAF8GB6;4A:<A:FB6<4?6<E6H@FG4A68F4F
J8??4FGBG;88KG8AGGBJ;<6;5LG;8 
F4G?84FGA8JG86;A<DH8FB9
:BI8EA4A68J8E8DH<6>GBFCE84746EBFF5BE78EF+A78EFG4A7<A:G;8F8
78I8?BC@8AGF<F4?FB6EH6<4?9BEG;8F<@C?8E84FBAG;4GG;89BE@FB9
:BI8EA4A68 G;4G 8IB?I87 <A G;8 C8E<B7 E8@4<A 788C?L 8AGE8A6;87
J<G;<A6BAG8@CBE4ELBE78EF*;8<AG8??<:8A684A7CEBC4:4A744:8A
6<8F78I8?BC87<AG;8C8E<B74E88I8A@BE8ABE@4?<M874A7CBJ8E9H?
GB74L*;8F4@8@<:;G58F4<7<AG8E@FB9G;8FBEGFB9C4E4FG4G4?BE
:4A<M4G<BAFG;4G78I8?BC875L?84CF4A75BHA7<AG;8C8E<B7*;89?H
<7<GLJ<G;J;<6;BA8S8A8@LBG;8ETJ4F?<A>87GB4ABG;8E<AG;8C8E<B7
4?FBE8@4<AF4>8LC4EGB9FG4G84A7E846G<BA4ELFGE4G8:L46EBFFCB?<G<8F
BA8G;4G<FFB788C?L8FG45?<F;875LABJG;4G<GB9G8A4CC84EFGBG4>8
C?468J<G;?<GG?86BAF6<BHF899BEG
%AG;8?8:4?C?4A8FB@8?4JF9EB@G;8C8E<B7E8@4<A<A89986G
4A76BAG<AH8GB58CHGGBG;8FBEGB9FHCCE8FF<I8HF89BEJ;<6;G;8L
J8E8<A<G<4??L<AG8A7874F9BE<AFG4A68<AG;864F8B9G;8FC<BA4:86G
<AG;8+A<G87)G4G8FABG;8E<AFG4A68FJ;<?8A8J@84FHE8F;4I8588A
47BCG87G;8L6?84E?LC4EG4>8B9G;8F4@8?4A:H4:84A7<AG8AG4FG;8
@84FHE8FG;8L;4I87E4JA9EB@<A6?H7<A:9BE8K4@C?8G;864F8B9
BA: !BA:VF

 $4G<BA4? )86HE<GL "4J EB@ G;8 @B@8AG G;8L
J8E89<EFG8A46G87HAG<?G;8CE8F8AGFH6;@84FHE8F;4I86BAGE<5HG87GB
G;87<@<A<F;<A:FGE8A:G;B9G;8E47<64?I<F<BAFB9E<:;GF4A78DH4?<GL
8@C?BL87 5L G;8 FB6<4? @BI8@8AGF B9 G;8 84E?L GJ8AG<8G; 68AGHEL
-;8E8I8EBA8?BB>F46EBFFG;8G8EE4<AB96BAG8@CBE4ELCH5?<6BE78E
:BI8EA4A68<AF;BEGG;8(87)64E8?8:46L6BAG<AH8FGB6BA7<G<BAG;8
CBFF<5<?<G<8F9BECEB:E8FF<I86;4A:8

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

  !()"%
 %
 

 ( 
   Q  

*;89B??BJ<A:G45?8FH@@4E<M8F>8L?8:<F?4G<I846GFBE7<A4A68FBE
78EF <A 6BHA6<? 4A7 E8:H?4G<BAF 7<F6HFF87 <A G;8 CE8I<BHF G8KG *;8
FH@@4E<8FCEBI<7874E85E<89F<@C?<9<874A7BA?L477E8FF68EG4<A4F
C86GF B9 G;8 ?4JF <A DH8FG<BA &?84F8 E8?L BA G;8 G8KG 45BI8 4A7 B9
6BHEF8G;8?4JFG;8@F8?I8F9BE9HEG;8E78G4<?F

6G &B?<GL )H@@4EL

 
%( +A<G87 &8A4?<M87 G;8 FCE847<A: B9 S94?F8
(8:H?4G<BA  !<A:7B@ E8CBEGFT T94?F8
FG4G8@8AGFT TE8CBEGFBEFG4G8@8AGF
?<>8?LGB64HF87<F49986G<BAT
%( +A<G87 &8A4?<M87 S4GG8@CGF GB 64HF8
(8:H?4G<BA  !<A:7B@ @HG<ALF87<G<BABE7<F49986G<BAT
%( +A<G87 &8A4?<M87 <A7H6<A: @8@58EF B9
(8:H?4G<BA !<A:7B@ G;8 4E@87 9BE68F GB 46G
  6BAGE4I8AG<BA B9 BE78EF BE
E8:H?4G<BAF
-4E #84FHE8F 4A474 KC4A787 CBJ8EF GB 78G4<A 4A7
6G   CEBF86HG8G;BF86BAF<78E87:H<?GL
B9F87<G<BA
)87<G<BHF BA:!BA: &8A4?<M87F87<G<BHFCH5?<64G<BAF
&H5?<64G<BAF
%E7<A4A68
 
898A68 B9 A7<4 E4AG87 G;8 4HG;BE<G<8F 8KG8A787
A7<46G   CBJ8EFB978G8AG<BAJ<G;BHGGE<4?
E87H687 7898A74AGFV CEB687HE4?
E<:;GF 4??BJ87 9BE G;8 HF8 B9
FC86<4? GE<5HA4?F <@CBF87
E8FGE<6G<BAF BA 9E887B@ B9
8KCE8FF<BA<A6?H7<A:C8A4?G<8F9BE
FCE847<A: 94?F8 A8JF 4A7 9BE
8A:4:<A: <A 46G<I<G<8F CE8=H7<6<4?
GBG;8J4E899BEG
)87<G<BHF BA:!BA: &8A4?<M87 G;8 CBFF8FF<BA B9
&H5?<64G<BAF F87<G<BHFCH5?<64G<BAF
&BFF8FF<BA
%E7<A4A68

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

 
)87<G<BHF )GE4<GF &8A4?<M87 G;8 CBFF8FF<BA B9
&H5?<64G<BAF )8GG?8@8AGF F87<G<BHFCH5?<64G<BAF
&BFF8FF<BA
%E7<A4A68
 
&E<AG<A: 4A7 878E4G87 @CBF87G<:;G6BAGEB?FBACE<AG8EF
BB>F #4?4L)G4G8F
A46G@8AG
 
%E78E <A BA:!BA:
KC4A787 G;8 :BI8EA@8AGVF
BHA6<?   CBJ8EF GB 4EE8FG 4A7 78G4<A
7<FF<78AGF
FC<BA4:8 6G +A<G87)G4G8F &8A4?<M87 94?F8 E8CBEGF 4A7
  FG4G8@8AGF 4A7 4GG8@CGF GB
7<F?BL4?GL @HG<AL BE E89HF4? B9
7HGL
)87<G<BA 6G #BAG4A4 &8A4?<M87 7<F?BL4? 4A7 45HF<I8
  +A<G87)G4G8F ?4A:H4:8 6E<G<64? B9 G;8
:BI8EA@8AG G;8 BAFG<GHG<BA BE
G;8?<>8
)87<G<BA 6G +A<G87)G4G8F &8A4?<M87 7<F?BL4? 4A7 45HF<I8
  ?4A:H4:8 6E<G<64? B9 G;8
:BI8EA@8AG G;8 BAFG<GHG<BA BE
G;8?<>88A6BHE4:<A:E8F<FG4A68GB
G;8 +A<G87 )G4G8F BE
8A6BHE4:8@8AG B9 <GF 8A8@<8F
4A7 64??<A: 9BE 4 6HEG4<?@8AG B9
CEB7H6G<BA
6G GB @8A7 4A474 &8A4?<M87 G;8 7<FGE<5HG<BA B9
G;8 E<@<A4? F87<G<BHF @4G8E<4?F 8KG8A787 G;8
B78   F6BC8 B9 F87<G<BA 6;4E:8F
<A6E84F87G;8C8A4?GL9BEF87<G<BA
)87<G<BHF 4;4@4F &8A4?<M87F87<G<BHFCH5?<64G<BAF
&H5?<64G<BAF
&EB;<5<G<BA
6G  
-4E *<@8 HFGE4?<4 #478<G4AB998A68GB8A:4:8<ABE
&E864HG<BAF 6BHAF8?4F87<G<BHF8AG8ECE<F8BEGB
(8C84? 6G JE<G8 BE GB HGG8E BE CH5?<F;

 F87<G<BHFJBE7F
)87<G<BHF E4A474 &8A4?<M87F87<G<BHFCH5?<64G<BAF
&H5?<64G<BAF )4<AG "H6<4

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

%E7<A4A68F  )4<AG

 ,<A68AG
)87<G<BHF "88J4E7 &8A4?<M87F87<G<BHFCH5?<64G<BAF
&H5?<64G<BAF F?4A7F
&EB;<5<G<BA
6G 

)87<G<BHF 6GF 4@4<64 &8A4?<M87 F87<G<BHF 46GF 4A7
4A7 CH5?<64G<BAF
&H5?<64G<BAF
%E7<A4A68


)87<G<BA 6G *E<A<747 4A7 &8A4?<M87 F87<G<BHF 46GF 4A7

 *B54:B FG4G8@8AGF
@8E:8A6L +A<G87 HG;BE<M87G;8HF8B98@8E:8A6L
&BJ8EF 6G !<A:7B@ CBJ8EF<AC8468G<@8


@8E:8A6L BA:!BA:
4AA<A:BE:4A<M4G<BAFCEB@BG<A:
(8:H?4G<BAF 4 :8A8E4? FGE<>8 BE 7<FBE78E B9
  F87<G<BA C8A4?<M87 F87<G<BHF
FG4G8@8AGF 4??BJ87 9BE G;8
FH@@4EL6BAI<6G<BAB97<FF8AG8EF
$4G<I8 )BHG;9E<64 &8A4?<M87 4AL 46G<BA 788@87 GB
7@<A<FGE4G<BA CEB@BG8 988?<A:F B9 ;BFG<?<GL
6G   58GJ88A$4G<I8F4A7HEBC84AF
    
E<@<A4? $H@8EBHF &8A4?<M87 G;8 47IB646L B9
FLA7<64?<F@ FG4G8F <A G;8 HA?4J9H? 46GF BE<8AG87 GBJ4E7F
?4JF6   +A<G87)G4G8F <A7HFGE<4?BECB?<G<64?8A7F
(87 9?4: ?4JF $H@8EBHF &8A4?<M87G;87<FC?4LB94E879?4:
6   FG4G8F <A G;8
+A<G87)G4G8F
A4E6;<64?4A7 A7<4 E4AG87G;8BI8EABE8A8E4?<A
(8IB?HG<BA4EL BHA6<? CBJ8E GB 4HG;BE<M8
E<@8F 6G FC86<4? GE<5HA4?F 4A7 8KG8A787
  CBJ8EF B9 F84E6; 4EE8FG 4A7
78G8AG<BA J<G;BHG GE<4? J;8E8 ;8
6BAF<78E87 G;8E8 J8E8 F8E<BHF
G;E84GFGBCH5?<6F498GL
    

%( +A<G87 ??BJ87G;84HG;BE<G<8FGBCEB;<5<G
(8:H?4G<BA !<A:7B@ 4A77<FC8EF84FF8@5?<8F
%( +A<G87 ??BJ87 F86HE<GL B99<6<4?F GB
(8:H?4G<BA !<A:7B@ 4GG8A7FHFC86G4FF8@5?<8F

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

 
(8:<FGE4G<BA B9 4FG 9E<64 @CBF876BAGEB?FBAG;8?45BE4A7
$4G<I8F &EBG86GBE4G8 @BI8@8AGB99E<64AJBE>8EF
%E7<A4A68
 
+A?4J9H? HFGE4?<4 %HG?4J87 G;8 -- 4A7 BG;8E
FFB6<4G<BAF 4FFB6<4G<BAF BE<8AG87 GBJ4E7 G;8
6G   78FGEH6G<BAB9CEBC8EGL
@8A7@8AGF HFGE4?<4 KG8A787 G;8 :BI8EA@8AGVF
GB G;8 45<?<GL GB 786?4E8 4FFB6<4G<BAF
+A?4J9H? <??8:4? C8A4?<M87 CEBI<7<A:
FFB6<4G<BAF FHCCBEGGBFH6;BE:4A<M4G<BAF
6G  
%E78E <A 4A474 %HG?4J87FGE<>8F4A7?B6>BHGF
BHA6<?  
 
%E78E <A 4A474 86?4E87 G;8 -- 4A7 BG;8E
BHA6<?  JBE>8EFVBE:4A<M4G<BAF<??8:4?
 
6G GB @8A7 4A474 E<@<A4?<M87 4FFB6<4G<BAF J;<6;
G;8 E<@<A4? 47IB64G87 :BI8EA@8AG4?
B78   <A7HFGE<4?BE86BAB@<66;4A:85L
9BE684??BJ87G;8CB?<68GBF8<M8
@4G8E<4?F9EB@C8EFBAFFHFC86G87
B9 58?BA:<A: GB <??8:4?
BE:4A<M4G<BAF
+E54A E84F )BHG;9E<64 )GE8A:G;8A87 G;8 :BI8EA@8AGVF
6G   6BAGEB? BI8E 9E<64A @4?8FV
45<?<GL GB E8F<78 <A BE @BI8
G;EBH:;HE54A4E84F
A7HFGE<4? )BHG;9E<64 "<@<G87J;<G8JBE>8EFV45<?<GLGB
BA6<?<4G<BA FGE<>8 CEB;<5<G87 9E<64AFV
6G   C4EG<6<C4G<BA<AHA<BAF
@8A7@8AGF HFGE4?<4 KG8A787 G;8 :EBHA7F BA J;<6;
GB G;8 E<@8F 4FFB6<4G<BA 6BH?7 58 9BHA7
6G   HA?4J9H? 4??BJ87 9BE
SCEB6?4@4G<BAFT GB 58 <FFH87
E8?4G<I8 GB F8E<BHF <A7HFGE<4?
7<FGHE54A68F E8A78E<A: G;BF8
C4EG<6<C4G<A: <A ?B6>BHGF BE
FGE<>8F :H<?GL B9 4A B998A68
C8A4?<M87 5BL6BGGF B9 CH5?<6
F8EI<68F 4A7 G;8 6BAI8L4A68 B9

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

   




:BB7FBEC4FF8A:8EF
*E478 +A<BAF A7<4 ??BJ87GE478HA<BAFGB58?8:4??L
6G   E8:<FG8E87E8FGE<6G87G;846G<I<G<8F
HA<BAF 6BH?7 8A:4:8 <A
7<FG<A:H<F;87 E8:<FG8E87 9EB@
HAE8:<FG8E87 HA<BAF 4??BJ87
?<45<?<GL 9BE JBE>8EFV GE478 HA<BA
46G<I<G<8F
*E478<FCHG8F +A<G87 %HG?4J87 FGE<>8F 4<@87 4G
4A7 *E478 !<A:7B@ S6B8E6<A:T G;8 :BI8EA@8AG
+A<BAF 6G BHG?4J87 F86BA74EL FGE<>8F
  CEBI<787 4 5EB47 4A7 I4:H8
789<A<G<BA B9 <AG<@<74G<BA
CEB;<5<G87 @4FF C<6>8G<A: 4A7
C<6>8G<A:4GJBE>8EFV;B@8F
,4E<BHF BA:!BA: HG;BE<M87G;8CB?<68GB7<FC8EF8
8@8E:8A6L CEB68FF<BAF CEB;<5<G @88G<A:F
E8:H?4G<BAF CEBF6E<58 ?45BE HA<BAF 4A7
  6BA9<F64G8CE<AG<A:@46;<A8EL
&E8I8AG<BA B9 &4?8FG<A8 ??BJ87 C<6>8GF 5HG 9BE5478
AG<@<74G<BA FGE<>8EF 9EB@ <A9?H8A6<A: BG;8EF
%E7<A4A68 4A7 @478 <AG<@<74G<BA FH5=86G GB
  ;84ILC8A4?GL
  
%( +A<G87 ??BJ87 9BE C8EFBAF GB 58
(8:H?4G<BA  !<A:7B@ E8@BI87 9EB@ C4EG<6H?4E C4EGF B9
G;86BHAGEL
%( +A<G87 ??BJ87 G;8 :BI8EA@8AG GB
(8:H?4G<BA !<A:7B@ E8FGE<6G G;8 @BI8@8AGF B9
 E8?B64G8 4A7 <AG8EA C8EFBAF B9
;BFG<?8BE<:<ABE4FFB6<4G<BAF
-4E #84FHE8F 4A474 E4AG87 8KG8A787 CBJ8EF B9
6G   8K6?HF<BA4A778CBEG4G<BA
A:E8FF <AGB A7<4 A7<64G87 G;4G E8GHEA<A: A7<4AF
A7<4 FHFC86G87 GB 58 E8IB?HG<BA4E<8F
%E7<A4A68 F;BH?75878G4<A87
 
+A?4J9H? HFGE4?<4 ??BJ87 9BE G;8 78CBEG4G<BA B9
FFB6<4G<BAF 9BE8<:A5BEA @8@58EF B9
6G   HA?4J9H?4FFB6<4G<BAF
%E78E <A BA:!BA: KC4A787 G;8 :BI8EA@8AGVF
BHA6<?   CBJ8EF E8?4G<I8 GB 8K6?HF<BA 4A7
78CBEG4G<BA

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

  
     

@@<:E4G<BA +A<G87)G4G8F (8FGE<6G87 8AGEL B9 4 ?4E:8 :EBHC


6G   B9 HA78F<E45?8F 4??BJ87 9BE G;8
78CBEG4G<BA B9 G;BF8 <AIB?I87 <A
G;8 HA?4J9H? 78FGEH6G<BA B9
CEBC8EGL
@@<:E4G<BA +A<G87)G4G8F ??BJ87 9BE G;8 78CBEG4G<BA 4A7
6G   8K6?HF<BAB94A4E6;<FGF
@@<:E4G<BA 4A474 ??BJ87 9BE G;8 78CBEG4G<BA B9
(8:H?4G<BAF 9BE8<:A8EF 6BAI<6G87 B9 F87<G<BA
  4??BJ87 9BE G;8 78CBEG4G<BA B9
G;BF8J;B7898A787G;8HA?4J9H?
78FGEH6G<BA B9 CEBC8EGL BE J;B
4FFH@87J<G;BHG?4J9H?4HG;BE<GL
CBJ8EF B9 G;8 :BI8EA@8AG <A
4A474BE4ALC4EGG;8E8B9
@8A7@8AGF HFGE4?<4 ??BJ87 9BE G;8 78CBEG4G<BA B9
GB G;8 4?<8AF9BHA7GB;4I847IB64G87G;8
@@<:E4G<BA I<B?8AG BI8EG;EBJ BE 45B?<G<BA B9
6G 
 G;8:BI8EA@8AG
A7<4A A7<4 (8DH<E87 C4FFCBEGF 9BE 8AGEL <AGB
&4FFCBEG 6G 4A78K<G9EB@A7<4


@@<:E4G<BA +A<G87)G4G8F @CBF87 DHBG4F BA <@@<:E4G<BA
6G   54F87BAC?468B9BE<:<A
@@<:E4G<BA +A<G87)G4G8F 4AA87F<4A<@@<:E4G<BA
6G  
@8A7@8AGF HFGE4?<4 E4AG87 G;8 @<A<FG8E CBJ8E GB
GB G;8 78CBEG 9BE8<:A8E5BEA C8EFBAF
@@<:E4G<BA J;8E8 G;8 @<A<FG8E J4F F4G<F9<87
6G   G;4G G;4G C8EFBA J4F <AIB?I87 <A
;<A78E<A: GE4AFCBEG4G<BA GE478
6B@@8E68 BE G;8 CEBI<F<BA B9
CH5?<6F8EI<68F

 
%( +A<G87 &8A4?<M87G;8F;4E<A:<A9BE@4G<BA
(8:H?4G<BA !<A:7B@ C8EG4<A<A: GB F86E8G F8FF<BAF B9
 &4E?<4@8AG
%( +A<G87 (8DH<E87 G;4G ?849?8GF 584E G;8
(8:H?4G<BA !<A:7B@ A4@8F 4A7 477E8FF8F B9 G;8<E
 4HG;BEF4A7CE<AG8EF4A7G;4GCE<BE
4CCEBI4? 58 B5G4<A87 9BE
CH5?<64G<BA
%E78E <A BA:!BA: KC4A787 G;8 :BI8EA@8AGVF

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676


! 
  "!!   

    

BHA6<?   CBJ8EF B9 68AFBEF;<C 4A7 GB


6BAGEB?6B@@HA<64G<BAF
FC<BA4:8 6G +A<G87)G4G8F HG;BE<M87G;8E8@BI4?B968EG4<A
  @4G8E<4?F9EB@G;8@4<?
*E47<A: J<G; +A<G87)G4G8F 4I8 G;8 &BFG@4FG8E 8A8E4?
G;8A8@L6G CBJ8E GB 68AFBE G;8 9BE8<:A
  ?4A:H4:8CE8FF
)87<G<BA 6G +A<G87)G4G8F ??BJ87 G;8 &BFG@4FG8E 8A8E4?
  GB E8GHEA @4<? 6BAF<78E87 <A
I<B?4G<BAB9G;846G



Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4132676

You might also like