Quality of Piece was written Piece was written Piece had little Piece had no style Writing in an extraordinary in an interesting style or voice or voice style and voice style and voice Gives no new Somewhat Gives some new Very informative information and informative and information but and well-organized very poorly organized poorly organized organized Grammar, So many spelling, Usage & Virtually no Few spelling and A number of punctuation and Mechanics spelling, punctuation spelling, grammatical punctuation or errors, minor punctuation or errors that it grammatical errors grammatical errors grammatical errors interferes with the meaning Ideas Presents ideas in Presents ideas in a Ideas are too Ideas are vague or an original manner consistent manner general unclear Sentence Sentence structure Sentence structure Sentence structure Structure enhances No sense of is evident; is limited; meaning; flows sentence sentences mostly sentences need to throughout the structure or flow flow flow piece Sources are cited Sources & Some sources are Sources are not and are used Did not include citation missing cited critically