365 Leader of AGRAHAYANA 26, IR91 (Sal-a) tlte OppOsition 366

~ ~ ~ (~) fo/&~ gesting tha1 Rhri RI~m Rl\hlmg Singh,

t.h'l leador of tile singl" llngost group
mor ~ ~ ~ fq~qf<CGI"'" ~ mt'!i'i 011 this side of 1he HOIIR'. having mol'(!
~~lIft~m.: ~~~~im tIlan [):I Mellllwrs. should he mnogllis,!<i
glIT 'IT m ~ ~m ~ qn:r;f ~ ii n~ tIm 1,,,:\.1,·,, of II,,· 0p]lfl ..;itilln. r

~ lift ~ mf'fi1> ~mH '1<: ~T W()IIIt) I ik" hi kllow wll('11rf'f "lllt !t,n'''
I'.'lk,'n all)' lI"l,i,joll III nil l\Iui. if Hilt.
~~~ ~~mlflf'r~lIft Imw ';(lOIl you will I," :11.1" to ,Ill it..
~~~~~~~fit;~
~ eft ;;rr<t' ffifit; ;;IT Mmc
mf'fi1> ~ UlI' m (~) : m:lf'el~. 1i
gm'IT~lIft~ ~om~? ~ m'f if.t ~ tm f<:rliT t1T fit; mR l1tt~ ~
1 7 (!nr:~ ~ fur ~ Jr <1~ ii ~1fC'\
fum ~ ;Of ~ ~ f<CQqfqCI.,,,,
opn;f lift omr lift ~ m;;.r ~ ~­ 'UI1' TT'1' f~ i <mf 5 0 ~ m!1'r. ~
W1"<'I'lf1 ii qr.rr fcmfcmT<'l'lf" i!il 1ft' wrfmr ;;.r if; 'fTl1 ~".T ~) ~ g~ 'Ii;Of ~ f.ri-
m lift ;m ~ ~', m m'limm ~. f.lr;rf;) ~ f.r.'lfT t1T t;!R 9;1'1'111 1ft' f.r.'lfT t1T fit; ~
~ ~ '1<: fum' ~ lift fuq;yfur
f.r<t'J1T if.t m ~ ~ 'UI1' ~ ~ 'tiT;;ft
~ ~ qr.rr f<CijllfqtJl.,,,, 1ft' ~
f~ ;r,t~ ~ f.l'inft ~ if; ~. t· ;;.JIfO)
fn.f<ctJl<'Ilf ~ ~ ~ ~ ?
~ Jf'J!T ii W'tlft ~ If,T ifffi l'fAT ;;rr<t' I
DR. V. K. R. V. RAO : To the h('"t
of my rellollootion I do not remt'mbor ~ ~ ii m'f ~ 'fit I ~rcr i~T
having received any IcttRr from t.he 'fit i ~o ~Tlf ~ ~ wmr ~ if; ;fffi
Bihar Government nfter tilllY cam.~ to
this agreement say ir g that t.hoy wanted ~. ifli11if; ;;.ri' ~ <tit '1'!ilfT 6 0 ~ ~ ~ I
the money for the implementation of 1i ~r f~ ~rcr ~~ Wof if 'it f.r<t'1I'i if.t
t.hat agreement. I alKO hnve no ro-
collection whatROevcr of allY requcHt ~ if><: ~ ~A If'~ f;l; Tfo 'UI1' l};1l1T ~
heing lJllldCl to us by tlw Bihar wW\' ~ >f; if;rr ~ I
Govemment for the oonversion of
Patna University into u. central univer- RHRI S. M. BANER.TF.F. (Kanpur) :
sity_ On thifl I wsnt ttl fll,cak.
MR. SPEAKER : Ploo~ Nit dowli.
~ IIliPI: ~: ~ ~ ~ I!i~
~) Ifln' III'Pf ~ ~ ? On t.hi~ JIl.H.tt(,r tIm RJI6I~ker h,,~ th...
di>lOretioll to go iu10 it. I am vcry
DR. V. K. R. V. RAO It is a ROrry I k(,pt. it pIlnding for HO I'mg
hypothetical question. hecau:<o I wsnted to go into it. I
made oertain <Jl\(\rio~ un<l Ci~rtlliJl
lotterll W6\'0 I\I~I writ.ten. I bIn-A 110
)J'18 lin. ohjootion if Dr. Ram SublJug SiIlgh iN
accepted,,~ tIl" I ..elldor of th" Oppolli-
LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION tion. (Interruptioll). But Illad 0110 111(11
of discussion.
SHRI RANGA (Srlkakulam): Sir.
I would like to requOKt you to let Mr. RanlAmurti. you fixed up time
mE' know your ans"'cr in rogprd to the with me this morning to cornu at 10·00
two Jettel'll that 11"6 had written 8Ug- O'dook. I WI~~ k"pt wait.ing, It is ..
367 Leader of DECEMBER 17, 1969 the Oppo8ition 368

fMr. Speaker] : RHlU p, RAMAMURTllI Silloo

gwat di1>L'ouJ'te~y to the Speak"f t,hat. you rofftrred the matter in the public,
YOIl did not. haYi~ tlul cou!1'"w ,:'ynn to I owo an explanat.ion. Mter alL (Inter-
iufol'lll HlH. (111/"fl'llpl;OIl), . 1·lIpt'iol1.• ). It. iH n mat.ter oj' perllOm~1
oxplanat.ioll-- not Oil thiN. I \\'allt, to
HHRll'. RA~IAM,(JRTI (Madurai) : lIIake a llOrsonal explanation.
I want4,d to' muke it olear, Sir, •
that u" far as tll" l ...~.,lo\' of Oppo"it ion l\1R. SPEAKER : Primll Mini~t(lr
is (lmlem"lwd, Ito 1'I\ILIlot talk oil Iwllulf want. to HllOOk.
nf t,he ,mt.iro oppositioll, what"n\' lila),
ho tl\l' (,oll\'llltion ill Britl,ill, (ll1/I'r· TH"E PRIME MINISTER, MINIS-
rIl7'/;01l), TER 0Ii' FINANVE, MINISTER OJ<'
ATOMlV ENERGY ANI) MINISTER
SHRI BABI RAY: \r,· aI'" 1."1'" OF PI. . ANNING (SHRDIATI INDIRA
to t ,.11. 011 OUI' holm If, GANDHI): I only wUlltl~l t.o (1011-
grat.ullLto Dr. R,.m SuhlJllog Singh, Sir.
~ ~ : iIl'f ~m ~T flfi <iFtl
I look forwnrd to co-operation from
;nlI' ~ it t ~ qq;:rr;nll' mir~ Iliru and from the le...~clers of all other
partir·s.
~I .q~~l'I"Pr~~~fif;1:rr~T I
~Wfift~~lf,~1ft~g I SHRI HEM BARUA (Mangaldai:
May I draw yourIIott~lItioll to n
"fIf;;f .q ~ fiI;~ ~ ~ ~ ~ very rele"mt matter, Sh·. We haYe
f1r. ~ ~ ~ 'liT fum:!' ~ ffi Imbmitted all ad.joumment motion 011
the reported ()ollapse of tho ROlIoffolding'
1 will t!\k,. t.hclIl ,\" Oppo"it inn Or· ill t.he Soviot ()ultural Centre huilding
g.mizntion, at Trivandrum, whioh ill being con~­
tructecl without t.he kIl<Iwledge of thi!!
I IlIU~t. h" fmnk to YOII. You "ay Government. This ill a very important
t hnt. all t.hose rtay" thl'y Illwo heen suhject.
pro""ing thiR. I would not al,'J'(1I1 to it.
Thl'1l tll!'y ng"'~111 that dilly slll\ll be SHRI 1'. RAMAMURTI: I did ask
Opposit iOl1, ThOll I have givell
kJ\o\\,llll~ for a meeting with you and that was
thi", othol'\\'i"" HOt. (ll1/I'/,Tllp/;OIlS), fixbd at 10 ·15 this mOnling, But,
ullfortUIU\tcly, inspite of my best
11ft m ~: I1!r ~ Rmft om'!' efi'ol'ts. certain things rlid ha.ppen anti
~ I ITo WI' ~ ~ ifi1 ~ om'!' I was h"ld UJI in the hospita.l. 1 did not
~);f .q ;r.Tf ~~ ~ ~ I expoot tha.t you would make so muoh
(If it in the House. I certainly expected
SHUI SURENDRANATH mH- that. you would give mo au opportunity.
Vlmy (~endrapara): W" a .... happy, I did rot miNi! it in tILe HouRO. I r.ame
SII', that. III our !'arlianlellt \\'<1 hl\\"o lien, at. 11 O'clock. I w&ntul to lIlect
II"~\' .. mcoglliY.tlct 1..e••,l.-r of' 0llllo- you,
Sit lUll
The other day you referred in this
S~RI HAL RAJ MADHOK (South Houso about my lL~illg pan ill your
Deihl): All theso y'~lr< \1'" ,lirl 1101. pn....llIle. When Mr. Sa.njh·& Reddy
lun·,· .. r.tl"'{('r (If 0p1'0"it iun. Now \\"(' WI\< tItc Speaker, h., u81ld to oft'er
111.\'(\ 011•• , Thi, is ,~ IU1lll'Y rlay fUI' this "i~rettos a.nd nobody objeoted to that.
l'.. rlinlll"'lt, If you aN opposud. to t~t. a.fter all
 369 Questions of Privilege AGRAHAYANA 26, 1891 (saka) Questions oJ Privilege 370

I want to make it el"IU tlult, t.ho ~~:~~<tT~

Speaker's Chamber Hhould not be taken
~ WIT ~ fi!; ~ ;f ~ ~ffi~ f.r.lJT
t.o bo tho HOUSJ and wllat is 110t allow". I
in th;, House, sllOui<lnot, Ill, t,III"'1I tllH)'O. ~ i(s~ fi!;ln I <mit ~ 'If~
I J~Vl'r oxpooterl th'lt you w(lul,l tako ft;r1;rr ~ I ~ ~ zrn " f1:nrr ~ t
such IlIfltt.ers M<)riousl\· alii I I1l1lk" II
public exhibit,iolt or" th,,,,, things. -it m ~ ('i~) : m'WoT '1ft' ~tT<'I'T
(Interruptitm8). ;r{t flr<;iT ~ ~ffift <tT I ~ firflf<hr
MR. SPEAKER: I alii sorry if Mr. W-T Ii ;;rm ~ I
Ramamurti tllkos it lik" thllt,. Wllllt
hap}ltlll,q som~timo.q is this-it, is Hot, ~~: ~~Tf':"tq~
only ltis case. I alii surry if ho t'lkns it ~ 'WI' ~ fw ~ ....
like t.hat -tlmt in tIL" la"t houl' til" tilllJ
i~ so little aJl(I the motion am ,,0 ~ ~Ift'q' ~ : q'Tq' flff.R;;r WT
IlIflny. But a l\f,Hllhnr com",. si!,s, lights
~thr~1
}Iis cigarott.o and loovl~' his cigal'lltto
piecoo on lily ttl],le all,l allot.II"I· 111'111 -., SI1mr m
m:IIiI' (~) : Ii ~
com~. I just mad" a mep""t, You ~ f~ of; f';rIl ~ .....
are wt'leom" t.o do it. aliI' time, but, it
is fl roquest and I mado ,~ roquest to ,Ill SHm ROK AY.\.NE (Panclharpur) :
thll lIIembers tltat. during tit., IHost. ludf This sholll.l 1m huarel first, Ril',
an hour if you at iIoll ha.vo to eOIlUI, ple.lso
rnko lis littl" I illlil as possi blo hecauso MR. SPEAKER : I 111"'" told him.
so JUlmy moti0I1S aro pondillg befuro I IUI\'" hOllt. it, 1" 1 ho HOlllo l\:Iini"t4lT
me. Tu-day I specially tllimil ollrly alHI As ;,OOlllls t.h" ropl)' C:UIllO:;, I shall plae~lI
I cancelled somo programm" bllCau~ it iwfom tho Hou,,*,.
Mr. Ramamurti is coming hut I was
kept waiting. Evon I (,xpecte,l that he -it SI1mr m mm: q'Tq' ;1. ~ ITo
would just soud 1110 a. word "I am sol'ry ~ ~~mlTit~ 'tiT;r.".~
I could not come". (Interruptions).
f.r.lJT ~ ~ 'f f;ruh:r of; f';rIl ;;rr.r q. ~
SHRI P. &AMAMURTI : I I~vnr flX- ~; IfmfT ~ ~h: wR ~ if." ¢;:;r.
peotocl it. I came from tho hospiuli.
~4'f m: ~ 'tiT ~ '" ~
MR. SPEAKER : BufuTo hi~ going m ~ ~ mtf ~ ~ of; ~11fTTlf If,\" 1ft
to tho hospital, ho cuuld havo told m".
(Interruptions). Ordor ploa.:;e. ~ IfmfT ~ Ii mr mntt
~ ;f; ~
!fi~ Ii~~ 1IT¢i;r ~~
~ ~r ~ 'Itt fif;ln t ~ Tfo
QUESTIONS OF PRIVIJ.EGE
UIf ~ ~ of; f;;rir "h: ~ 'l'11fTT1f
(i) AGAINST SOB-INSPECTOR OF
POLICE, MAHESHI (BmAR) FOR ILL-
11>1 ;mr t
I
TI~EATMENT OF AN l\:I. P. ; AND
-'" IIIIIIl'" "'" ~ (~): iro'r
(ii) AGAINBTMunl!TEB OF EDUCATION ~~ QfT1'~ qyq; II'ri~ t I q'Tq'~ ;iT ~
AND YOUTJl SERVICEH.
~ ~, ~ If7 ~ I ~ ifIlf m~
'" l! lI1f (II'Ufw) : q'f:!ru Ifit~. ~a'f wir.ftrr;r ~ ~ I ~ ~
~. ~ 'fr'l'~ 'fm fm<hr ;ft~oT ~JI'f ~ ~ fit;Irr t T'f~r 'f(lf mil" lfln' ~
q II'I\rit f.f~ ~f ~ ~... ~ ?