You are on page 1of 6

LEAVENING AGENTS 3485

cases of clinical lead poisoning continue to be below that associated with toxic symptoms, it should
reported from this source of contamination. Despite be remembered that dietary lead is a major source of
awareness of this potential problem improperly fired an individual’s total lead intake. Although it is not
pottery with lead-containing glazes continue to be clear at what level harmful effects first occur in
produced, predominantly in developing countries. humans, it is clear that lead is not an essential dietary
0016 Total food-related lead intake can be highly vari- component and it is prudent to avoid the addition of
able, depending on the dietary pattern. Estimates of lead to food during its processing or preparation. This
average daily lead ingestion from food in western begins with the obvious exclusion of food contact
cultures where studies have been performed have with any lead-containing alloy in food processing
typically ranged from 25 to 200 mg day1, although and preparation. It also means attention to more
intakes as high as 400 mg day1 have been reported subtle details, such as the exclusion of lead-based
for some populations. The current US recommended solder from the repair of food-handling equipment
daily intake from all sources is 75 mg day1 or less for and being aware of the potential risk of lead contam-
adults and 6 mg day1 or less for children under 6 ination from improperly glazed pottery containers.
years of age. These amounts are one-tenth the daily
intake estimate to produce blood lead levels of See also: Contamination of Food; Renal Function and
30 mg dl1 in an adult and 10 mg dl1 in a child. Disorders: Kidney: Structure and Function
0017 Dietary lead intake accounts for approximately
70% of the total daily lead absorption from all
sources in most studies. More recent studies, from Further Reading
the US Food and Drug Administration, have found Carrington CD and Bolger PM (1992) An assessment of the
significant reductions from these figures that are hazards of lead in food. Regulatory Toxicology and
attributed to almost complete elimination of lead- Pharmacology 16: 265–272.
soldered food cans and reduced airborne lead con- Ehle AL and McKee DC (1990) Neuropsychological effects
tamination from leaded petrol. In these studies, of lead in occupationally exposed workers: a critical
dietary lead was found to be less than half of the review. Critical Reviews in Toxicology 20: 237–255.
daily lead intake. Mahaffey KR (ed.) (1985) Dietary and Environment Lead:
Human Health Effects. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science.
Smith MD, Grant LD and Sors AI (eds) (1989) Lead Expos-
Monitoring and Surveillance ure and Child Development: An International Assess-
ment. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
0018 Monitoring of the lead content of foods is not rou- Tsuchiya K (1986) Lead. In: Friberg L, Nordberg GF and
tinely performed. Avoidance of lead contamination in Vouk VB (eds) Handbook of the Toxicology of Metals,
food preparation and food processing should be vol. II. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science.
sought as a part of an integrated public health pro- US EPA (1986) Air Quality Criteria for Lead. Research
gram to minimize lead exposure of the population. Triangle Park, North Carolina: US Environment Protec-
While lead exposure from the diet is normally far tion Agency.

LEAVENING AGENTS
J L Vetter, Technical Assistance Services, Leawood, available for less than 200 years. We have come to
KS, USA enjoy a wide variety of chemically leavened products
Copyright 2003, Elsevier Science Ltd. All Rights Reserved. as part of our daily menu. Some are sweet, e.g., cakes,
doughnuts, and biscuits, whereas others are more
bland, e.g., baking powder biscuits and many types
History of Chemical Leavening of crackers (see Figures 1 and 2).
0001 Bakery foods that depend on chemical leavening
Leavening with Yeast
systems for their appearance, texture, and taste
are relatively recent developments. Whereas yeast- The word ‘leaven’ comes from the Latin word ‘levare’ 0002

leavened products have nourished humans for over or ‘levo,’ which means ‘to raise’ or ‘to make light by
4000 years, chemically leavened products have been aeration.’ Leavened or aerated baked foods can be
3486 LEAVENING AGENTS

Sour milk, buttermilk, and cream of tartar all had 0005

one thing in common: they released the carbon


dioxide from baking soda very rapidly, and much of
the leavening gas was actually lost during the mixing
of a dough or batter, resulting in a baked product with
less volume than desired. There was a need for a
material that would not react so quickly and allow
sufficient time for mixing and forming products
before the leavening gas was released. This led to
the development in the mid-1800s of monocalcium
phosphate (MCP; also known as acid calcium phos-
phate, ACP) as an alternative to cream of tartar.
Although MCP is considered a ‘fast-acting’ leavening
fig0001 Figure 1 Leavening agents: machine-cut doughnut production.
(Courtesy of Rhone-Poulenc, New Jersey.)
acid, it is a little slower than cream of tartar. A patent
was issued in 1864 for such an acidic phosphate
leavening agent. However, better agents for control-
ling or delaying leavening activity were still required,
and this need led to the development of a number of
alternatives to cream of tartar and MCP for use with
baking soda. Sodium aluminum sulfate (SAS) was
developed in the early 1890s, sodium acid pyropho-
sphates (SAPPs) in the early 1900s, and sodium alu-
minum phosphates (SALPs) around 1960.

Design of Leavening Systems


There are three primary factors to consider in 0006

designing a chemical leavening system for a specific


fig0002 Figure 2 Examples of chemically leavened baked goods. product. These are:
1. How much leavening gas is needed to produce the 0007

traced as far back as 2000 bc, when Egyptians used desired finished product?
yeast to leaven bread. (See Bread: Breadmaking Pro- 2. What leavening acid is needed to achieve the 0008

cesses; Yeasts.) desired product characteristics?


3. What other effects might the leavening acid have 0009

Chemical Leavening on the dough, batter, or finished product?


0003 Yeast was the primary source of leavening gas to raise This article will discuss these three factors and
baked foods until late in the eighteenth century, when describe the characteristics of commercially available
it was discovered that sour milk or buttermilk would chemical leavening agents and their application in
release carbon dioxide gas from sodium bicarbonate specific bakery foods.
(baking soda) during baking of a dough or batter
to which these ingredients had been added. Carbon
dioxide from baking soda is the same gas as that
Mechanisms of Chemical Leavening
released by yeast during fermentation of a dough.
Air and Water as Leaveners
0004 Sour milk and buttermilk were replaced in many
recipes with cream of tartar after about 1835. Cream Although air and water are ‘chemicals’ in the truest 0010

of tartar (potassium bitartrate) was obtained as a sense of the word, they are generally not considered
byproduct from wine-making. There were early ‘chemical leavening agents.’ Nevertheless, air and
attempts to combine the baking soda and cream of water do provide leavening activity in a number
tartar into a more convenient blended product, and of bakery products. Air, which is incorporated
this led to the development of baking powders. A US into a dough or batter as small gas cells during
chemist by the name of Hoagland, living in Fort mixing, will expand during baking and cause some
Wayne, Indiana, originated the cream of tartar baking leavening of the product. In fact, air is the primary
powder in 1850 and founded the Royal Baking leavening agent in a fat-free sponge cake. During
Powder Company. baking, water contained in the dough or batter will
LEAVENING AGENTS 3487

be vaporized by the heat of the oven and cause a the soda reacts with the leavening acid, the finished
leavening – or raising – of the product. Water is the product should be close to neutral in pH, which is
primary leavening agent for saltine crackers, contrib- desired in most products. Higher (alkaline) or lower
uting to the tender, flaky texture of the product. The (acidic) pHs can be achieved, if desired, by adjusting
contributions of air and water to the leavening and the amount of leavening acid and/or soda from the
characteristics of baked products should not be over- amounts needed for complete reaction.
looked in designing a leavening system based on more The NV is defined as the weight of soda neutralized 0015

traditional ‘chemical’ leavening agents. by 100 parts of leavening acid. Since most formulae
for bakery products begin with a given weight of soda
Leavening by Decomposition (the weight needed to give the desired amount of
0011 There are two primary chemical leavening agents that leavening gas), the NV is most commonly used to
can release carbon dioxide gas by decomposition determine the amount of leavening acid required for
during baking. These are sodium bicarbonate (baking the amount of soda used according to the following
soda) and ammonium bicarbonate. Heat is required equation:
for these materials to decompose, and the tempera- % Soda  100
ture of baking is generally adequate for this purpose. % Leavening acid ¼ : ð4Þ
NV
Sodium bicarbonate decomposes when dissolved and
heated to release carbon dioxide according to eqn (1). The NVs for commonly used leavening acids are listed
in Table 1. It should be noted that larger amounts of
Heat leavening acids with low NVs are required for a given
2NaHCO3 H2O + CO2 + Na2CO3. (1)
amount of soda than for those leavening acids with
Ammonium bicarbonate decomposes when dissolved higher NVs. This could be a factor in the economics of
and heated according to eqn (2). developing a leavening system.
Heat
NH4HCO3 NH3 + H2O + CO2. (2) Rate of reaction The speed with which a leavening 0016

acid reacts with baking soda to release carbon dioxide


Both ammonia and carbon dioxide are gases and
leavening gas is very important in controlling the
contribute to the leavening of the baked product.
characteristics of the finished baked product. If
Leavening by Chemical Reaction the acid reacts too rapidly with the soda, all of the
leavening gas could be released during mixing and,
0012 The vast majority of chemical leavening systems are therefore, would not be available to raise the product
based on the reaction of an acid with sodium bicar- during baking. In this case, the finished product
bonate to release chemically the carbon dioxide from would be low in volume and dense in texture. How-
the soda, and it is with these systems that the majority ever, if the acid reacts with the soda too late in the
of this article is concerned. A general equation for the baking process, the structure of the product will be
reaction is shown in eqn (3). ‘set’ by the heat of baking, and the leavening gas
Moisture cannot raise the product without causing cracks or
HX + NaHCO3 NaX + H2O + CO2. (3) splits.
Heat
(Neutral sodium salt) The release of some leavening gas, or incorporation 0017

In addition to the carbon dioxide leavening gas, water of some air, during mixing is desirable for the forma-
is released, and a sodium salt of the leavening acid tion of small air or gas cells in the dough or batter.
is formed. The nature of the neutral sodium salt This process, called ‘nucleation,’ is responsible for the
depends on the leavening acid being used. development of a fine and uniform grain in the final
0013 There are a number of leavening acids from which
to choose in formulating a chemical leavening system. Table 1 NVs of commonly used leavening acids tbl0001

They differ in the amount required to release com- Leavening acid NV


pletely all of the carbon dioxide in the soda, the speed
with which they release this leavening gas, and their Monocalcium phosphate monohydrate 80
Anhydrous monocalcium phosphate 83
effects on doughs, batters, and finished product
Sodium acid pyrophosphate 74
characteristics. Sodium aluminum phosphate 100
Dicalcium phosphate dihydrate 33
0014 Neutralizing value The neutralizing value (NV) is a Dimagnesium phosphate 40
term used to describe the amount of leavening acid Sodium aluminum sulfate 104
Cream of tartar 45
needed to react completely with the amount of baking
Glucono-d-lactone 45
soda used in formulating a bakery product. If all of
3488 LEAVENING AGENTS

product. However, most of the leavening gas should Table 2 Rates of reaction with baking soda for commonly used tbl0002

leavening acids
be reserved for release at the proper time during
baking in order to achieve the total volume desired. Leavening acid Rate of reaction
0018 A number of factors affect the proper time for
Cream of tartar Rapid
release of gas during baking. Product size is certainly Monocalcium phosphate monohydrate Intermediate
important. A small product will heat, and the struc- Anhydrous monocalcium phosphate Intermediate (slower)
ture will set, faster than a larger product. Oven Sodium acid pyrophosphates Slow
temperature obviously affects the rate at which a Sodium aluminum phosphate Very slow
Sodium aluminum sulphate Very slow
product’s temperature rises to the point of setting
Dicalcium phosphate dihydrate Very slow
the structure. Other ingredients in the formula can Dimagnesium phosphate Slow
affect the temperature at which a product sets. The Glucono-d-lactone Slow
amount of time to mix fully a dough or batter and the
time required to form or deposit the product to be
baked will influence the time at which the leavening
acid should react with the baking soda. Glucono-d-lactone (GDL) does not fit any of the 0024

0019 The manufacturers of leavening acids have at- above categories of no delay, time delay, and tempera-
tempted to meet all the diverse needs of the house- ture triggered. GDL reacts continuously, but slowly,
hold, institutional and large-scale wholesale baker by with baking soda. The speed of reaction, of course,
developing and marketing products with a wide range increases with temperature and becomes quite rapid
of ‘reaction rates.’ during baking. The steady release of carbon dioxide
0020 Some materials have essentially no delay in their in a dough containing GDL is very similar to the
reaction with baking soda. They react as soon as they release of carbon dioxide by yeast in a fermenting
dissolve in the water present in the formula; the soda dough. Therefore, GDL has been popular in the
has probably already dissolved. These materials development of chemically leavened bread.
include the lactic acid in sour milk or buttermilk, The rates of reaction of commonly used leavening 0025

cream of tartar, and MCP monohydrate. acids are listed in Table 2.


0021 Anhydrous monocalcium phosphate (AMCP) has a
time delay, which, although relatively short, does Ionic effects of leaveners Although the primary 0026

allow time for preparing doughs and batters for function of chemical leavening systems is to leaven,
baking. A major use for AMCP has been self-raising or raise, a product, leavening agents can also affect
flour, which is often used to prepare baking powder- characteristics of doughs, batters, and the finished
type biscuits. The time delay of AMCP allows suffi- baked product. These effects are due to reactions
cient time for mixing, rolling, and cutting the dough between the leavening agents and components (par-
prior to baking. ticularly starch and protein) of the dough or batter.
0022 Manufacturers of SAPPs have been able to vary the These are called ‘ionic’ effects, since the leavening
amount of time delay of these leavening acids from a agents dissolve in the water of the dough or batter
few minutes to as much as an hour or more. This is and dissociate into positive cations and negative
done by controlling the conditions under which the anions. In some cases, it is the cation (such as calcium
SAPP is manufactured. ions) that is responsible for the observed effect. In
0023 SAS, SALP, and dicalcium phosphate dihydrate other cases, it is the anion (such as pyrophosphate)
(DCP) are basically heat-triggered leavening acids. that causes a change in the dough, batter, or finished
They have essentially no reaction with soda until the product.
temperature of the product is raised by the heat of The calcium and aluminum cations in phosphate- 0027

baking. In some baked products, this delay may be based leavening acids provide more resiliency to cake
too long, and SAS, SALP, and DCP perform better products than the sodium cation in other phosphate-
when used in combination with a faster-acting based leavening agents. Therefore, if resiliency is a
leavening agent such as MCP or AMCP. Of course, property desired in a cake product, the formulator
all leavening agents are essentially ‘heat triggered,’ may choose a leavening system containing calcium
since they dissolve and react with soda faster as the and/or aluminum ions. Calcium ions tend to stiffen
temperature of the dough or batter increases. Never- doughs and thicken batters; they also tend to dry out
theless, the term ‘heat triggered’ is usually reserved moist or slightly sticky doughs. These properties of
for those materials that have an almost indefinite time doughs and batters are important considerations in
delay until the temperature rises to a certain point, in handling and processing, particularly in high-speed,
contrast to those leavening agents that are both time automated commercial bakeries. (See Bread: Dough
and temperature triggered. Mixing and Testing Operations.)
LEAVENING AGENTS 3489

0028 The pyrophosphate anion in SAPP leavener inter- bonate leaves no residue when it decomposes by heat.
acts with proteins from other ingredients in the for- It, therefore, has no effect on the pH of the baked
mula. This tends to result in a moister texture, which product. If there is more than about 5% moisture in
is usually desirable. Unfortunately, the pyrophos- the baked product, however, the ammonia gas will
phate ion also imparts a slightly bitter aftertaste dissolve in this water and impart an ammoniacal
when used at higher levels. Therefore, the product flavor to the product. For this reason, ammonium
formulator must try to balance such desirable and bicarbonate is used only in low-moisture products
undesirable effects in developing a leavening system such as crackers.
for a specific product.
0029 Final product pH can affect the color of a baked Cream of Tartar
product, and the pH can be controlled by the Cream of tartar (potassium acid tartrate) reacts very 0033

leavening system. In white products such as white rapidly with soda in a dough or batter, releasing
layer cakes, a pH that is slightly below neutral accen- 70–80% of the leavening gas within 2 min of comple-
tuates whiteness. This lower pH can be achieved by tion of mixing. For this reason, it has little application
adjusting the balance between leavening acid and in commercial production of bakery foods, since
baking soda (more acid, less soda) or by selection of there is insufficient time to process the dough prior
leavening acid. Pyrophosphate leavening acids tend to to baking.
buffer pH in the range 7.3–7.5 and it is somewhat
difficult to lower the pH by adjusting the pyro- Sodium Aluminum Sulfate
phosphate and soda balance. Calcium phosphates, SAS is a very slow-reacting leavening agent and does 0034
however, do not have the pH buffering capacity of not release leavening gas until the product is in the
the pyrophosphates, and pH can be manipulated oven, and its temperature rises. SAS is most often
more easily by adjusting the acid/soda balance. The used in combination with a faster-acting leavening
color and flavor of chocolate products are enhanced acid such as MCP. This combination (SAS and
by higher pH. Again, this can be achieved by selection MCP) is the most popular composition of household
of leavening acid and/or adjustment of the acid/soda baking powders. SAS is not used extensively in com-
balance (less acid, more soda). mercial baking.
0030 The development of a suitable leavening system is a
highly complex activity. The formulator has a number Monocalcium Phosphates
of objectives to meet, and fortunately, there is
Monocalcium phosphate leavening acids are avail- 0035
available a number of leavening agents with varying
able in two forms: the monohydrate (MCP) and the
properties to help meet these objectives.
anhydrous product (AMCP). The monohydrate is
fast-acting, although slightly slower than cream of
Characteristics of Leavening Agents tartar. It is usually used in combination with slower-
acting leavening agents. MCP will release leavening
Sodium Bicarbonate (Baking Soda) gas from baking soda during mixing, which is desir-
able in achieving a fine, uniform grain in the baked
0031 As mentioned previously, the heat of baking can cause
product as long as a slower-acting leavener is present
baking soda to decompose, giving off carbon dioxide
to provide leavening gas during baking. AMCP is
leavening gas without reacting with a leavening acid.
coated with a slowly dissolving phosphate material
The sodium carbonate formed by the decomposition
that delays its reaction with baking soda. This delay is
of baking soda is very alkaline and will tend to give
relatively short, but sufficient for some products that
the baked product a high pH. This is desirable in
are baked in the home. These products include
some applications, because the high pH enhances
certain flavors, such as chocolate. Many recipes for biscuits, pancakes, and waffles.
chocolate chip cookies call for leavening only with Sodium Acid Pyrophosphates
baking soda.
SAPPs are available with a range of reaction rates 0036

Ammonium Bicarbonate from slow to very slow. SAPPs are used almost exclu-
sively in some applications such as cake doughnuts
0032 Ammonium bicarbonate will also decompose during
and canned, refrigerated biscuit doughs. They are
baking and release ammonia and carbon dioxide
one of several options available to the formulator of
leavening gases without reacting with a leavening
cakes, biscuits, pancakes, etc. The aftertaste, to which
acid. Unlike sodium bicarbonate, which leaves a resi-
due of alkaline sodium carbonate, ammonium bicar- many people are sensitive, somewhat limits the use of
3490 LEAVENING AGENTS

SAPPs, particularly since the development of SALP Glucono-d-lactone


leavening agents.
GDL is an organic compound that forms gluconic acid 0040

Sodium Aluminum Phosphates when dissolved in water. It reacts slowly, but steadily
with baking soda. The rate of reaction, of course, in-
0037 SALPs are the most recently developed chemical creases as the temperature of the dough or batter in-
leavening agents. They are very slow-reacting with creases during baking. GDL has a low NV of about 45,
baking soda and are often marketed as blends with a requiring about two parts of GDL for every one part of
faster-acting leavener such as MCP or AMCP. SALPs soda. It is, therefore, relatively expensive to use and
have become quite popular with product formulators, finds limited application in specialized products.
because of their high NV, relatively low cost, lack of
undesirable flavors, and ability to be blended with
other leaveners to achieve optimized properties for Summary
specific applications. The technology of chemical leavening is quite com- 0041

plex, because of the varying requirements of different


Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrate
products and processes. It is made even more complex
0038 DCP is not technically a leavening ‘acid,’ because it is by the availability of a variety of chemical leavening
an alkaline phosphate salt. However, when incorpor- agents, each with its own set of properties, advan-
ated into a dough or batter and subjected to the heat tages and disadvantages.
of baking, DCP decomposes to MCP and tricalcium An understanding of the technology of chemical 0042

phosphate (TCP). The TCP is insoluble, precipitates leavening should lead to the production of even better,
out of the system, and leaves MCP – a fast-acting cost-effective, and consumer-satisfying bakery foods.
leavening agent – to react with baking soda. The
temperature at which DCP decomposes is relatively See also: Bread: Dough Mixing and Testing Operations;
high (55–60  C), so that decomposition occurs rather Breadmaking Processes; Yeasts
late in the baking process. For this reason, DCP is
classified as a very slow-acting leavening agent and is
Further Reading
commonly used in combination with a fast-acting
leavener. Dubios DK (1981) Chemical leavening. Technical Bulletin,
vol. 3, No. 9. Manhattan: American Institute of Baking.
Kichline TP and Conn JF (1970) Some fundamental aspects
Dimagnesium phosphate of leavening agents. The Bakers Digest August: 36–40.
LaBaw GD (1982) Chemical leavening agents and their use
0039 Magnesium phosphate is a new leavening acid that is
in bakery products. The Bakers Digest February: 16–21.
slow-acting and is activated by heat (40  C). It has a Reiman HM (1977) Chemical leavening systems. The
clean flavor profile, provides a uniform cell structure, Bakers Digest August: 33–36, 42.
and imparts moistness to baked product crumbs. It is
particularly useful in frozen and fresh baked cakes,
muffins, biscuits, and pizza crusts.

Lecithin See Phospholipids: Properties and Occurrence; Determination; Physiology

Leeks See Onions and Related Crops

You might also like