You are on page 1of 9

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/362452353

Sustainable Management of Groundwater by Earth Observation Technologies

Conference Paper · June 2022


DOI: 10.3850/IAHR-39WC2521716X20221512

CITATIONS

24 authors, including:

Claudia Meisina Laura Pedretti


University of Pavia University of Pavia
184 PUBLICATIONS   2,094 CITATIONS    2 PUBLICATIONS   0 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Roberta Bonì Pietro Teatini


Università degli Studi di Urbino "Carlo Bo" University of Padova
51 PUBLICATIONS   393 CITATIONS    315 PUBLICATIONS   6,436 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

TIME DOMAIN REFLECTOMETRY View project

Virtual Element Method (VEM) View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Alper Elçi on 03 August 2022.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain
doi://10.3850/IAHR-39WC2521716X20221512

           



 


"48B8=0%43A4CC8!'H6DB">=P')40C8=8%.>220A0C>!8-D0A38>;0;14AC
I@D4AA>%AD)><LB'+0;34B14;;0=%;0#0E0AA>4A=L=34I";M8 0C:0=
 
J0H;0: KA4= (70C0=0F8 
8=3">70<<03
1D090A
!4CC4A8>) 4=>E4B8' 
A48B70 "8<8& 

% -)* +/&- - +#/
#, $ * %,% '- +#,)')++ ,% -)* + '-  +$ ##)/,*,% -)* + '-  +

% -)* +/&) %&4
)#& &5) %&+#/
)&)+&% ,% ,) +

% -)* +/&&-&-+#/
' +)&++ % ,% ' +#, 0&)+&,% ' +/,+ %# *+,%+ ,% ' +

%*+ +,+& &#2 &/ %)& *'1) ' %
,) &# $*'0(,))& $*), $*

% -)* +/&# %+# %+' %
)&)+&+&$*,*!- )-#*,*'#,*$ %%,*
 
 &",0 /#,#% -)* +/,)"/
#')# ,,+)/*,+"%$ #&$) */#"$ #&$# &)%,,+)


% -)* +/&&)%$$%&)%
"*+%. !,,!&!*$!,,!&,!)!,,!&
 

&%*&)0 &  &%   &%& )&') #
%# $ # %&&$%&#&+#/
#++) &&%*&)0 &) +%&-* &%*&)0 &) +
 
0)(+#%*)-&/#& +/&)+
&%*)-+ &%&+,)&)%
0$") *)*%&)!&($)#$ $ )*%&)!&


!*+) "+

)78B?0?4A?A4B4=CBC7458ABCA4BD;CB>5C74'('+$'?A>942C58=0=2431HC74%'">D=30C8>=)74?A>942C
08<B C> 34E4;>? 0= 8==>E0C8E4 <4C7>3>;>6H 5>A C74 7H3A>64>;>6820; 270A02C4A8I0C8>= >5 ;0A64B20;4 0@D854A
BHBC4<BDB8=6B0C4;;8C410B430AC7$1B4AE0C8>=$C427=8@D4BC>8=C46A0C403E0=243$C427=8@D4B8=C>
=D<4A820; 6A>D=3F0C4A 5;>F 0=3 64><4270=820; <>34;B C> 4=70=24 C74 :=>F;4364 >= C74 8<?02CB >5
06A82D;CDA0; 0=3 C>DA8BC 02C8E8C84B >= F0C4A A4B>DA24B 1H @D0=C85H8=6 ;0=3 38B?;024<4=C C> 4=6064 F0C4A
<0=064<4=C 0DC7>A8C84B 0=3 ?A>E834 <>34;B 5>A >?C8<0; <0=064<4=C >5 C74 0@D854A BHBC4<B >DA F0C4A
BCA4BB43"438C4AA0=40=0A40B84C742>0BC0;0@D854A>5><02278>8=C0;HC74;C>D030;4=CO=10B8=8=(?08=
C74 438I '8E4A 10B8= 8= )DA:4H 0=3 C74 IA0@ 10B8= 8= >A30= 0A4 B4;42C43 0B ?8;>C B8C4B = C74B4 B8C4B
06A82D;CDA48BCA038C8>=0;;HC74<>BC8<?>AC0=C42>=><8202C8E8CH1DC8=B><4>5C74<8C70B144=?A>6A4BB8E4;H
A4?;02431HDA10=8I0C8>=0=3C>DA8BC8202C8E8C84BF78270;B>70E40B86=85820=C8<?02C>=6A>D=3F0C4AA4B>DA24B
(C0:47>;34AB 8= 4027 ?8;>C B8C4 F4A4 4=60643 F8C7 C74 08< C> 38B2DBB C74 :=>F;4364 60?B 8= A4;0C8>= C>
BDBC08=01;46A>D=3F0C4A<0=064<4=C=6064<4=C2>=B8BC43>58=C4AE84FBF8C7;>20;0DC7>A8C84B50A<4AB0=3
C427=8280=B0=3C7458;;8=>5@D4BC8>==08A4BC>8=E4BC860C4DB4AA4@D8A4<4=CB!>F2>BC0=3=>=8=E0B8E4$
30C03E0=2438554A4=C80;('=C4A54A><4CAH=('0A4?A>24BB43C>>1C08=6A>D=338B?;024<4=C<0?B
>5C74?8;>CB8C4B)78B8=5>A<0C8>=F8;;14DB435>A0@D854A270A02C4A8I0C8>=0=3<>34;8=6

$.-()#* A>D=3F0C4A<0=064<4=C0AC7$1B4AE0C8>="438C4AA0=40=10B8=B,0C4ABCA4BB4310B8=


  

="438C4AA0=40=0A40B6A>D=3F0C4AA4B>DA24B0A40BBD<8=60=8=2A40B8=6;H?A><8=4=CA>;48=5A4B7F0C4A
BD??;H D=34A C74 2>=38C8>=B >5 2;8<0C4 270=64 *A10= 0=3 06A82D;CDA0; 6A>D=3F0C4A 34<0=3 8B A8B8=6 0B 0
2>=B4@D4=24 >5 ?>?D;0C8>= 6A>FC7 0=3 5>>3 34<0=3 A4B?42C8E4;H F74A40B 2;8<0C4 270=64 8B 05542C8=6 C74
C8<8=60=3C7438BCA81DC8>=>5?A428?8C0C8>=0=3740CF0E4B
)74 ;02: >5 A4;4E0=C 8=5>A<0C8>= >= 6A>D=3F0C4A A4B>DA24B 46 6A>D=3F0C4A ;4E4;B 0@D854A BC>A064
A4270A640=3?D<?8=6A0C4BA4?A4B4=CB02A8C820;3A0F102:5>A0=8=C46A0C430=3>?C8<8I43<0=064<4=C>5
F0C4AA4B>DA24B)78B:8=3>5:=>F;43648B5D=30<4=C0;C>0=8=34?C7D=34ABC0=38=6>5C742DAA4=CBC0CDB>5
0@D854ABHBC4<BC>834=C85HC748<?02CB>52;8<0C4270=64>=F0C4A0E08;018;8CH0=3C>B4CD?030?C0C8>=0=3
<8C860C8>=<40BDA4B2>?8=6F8C75DCDA4?>C4=C80;C7A40CB0AC7$1B4AE0C8>=$C427=>;>6H20=74;?C>58;;C78B

©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3170


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain

60?1H0BB4BB8=60=3<>=8C>A8=6E0A8>DB4=E8A>=<4=C0;540CDA4B0BB>280C43F8C7BD1BDA5024F0C4AA4B>DA24B
0C034@D0C4C4<?>A0;0=3B?0C80;B20;4BF8C7;>F2>BC0=3=>=8=E0B8E40??A>0274B
)74 '('+$' ?A>942C 58=0=243 1H C74 %'" >D=30C8>= 4BC01;8B743 D=34A C74 >A8I>= DA>?4
'4B40A27 %A>6A0<<4 >5 C74 DA>?40= *=8>= F8;; ?A>E834 =4F ?A>3D2CB 0=3 B4AE824B 5>A C74 4558284=C 0=3
BDBC08=01;4<0=064<4=C>56A>D=3F0C4ADB8=6$C427=>;>6H>DAF0C4ABCA4BB43"438C4AA0=40=0A40BC74
2>0BC0;0@D854A>5><02278>8=C0;HC74;C>D030;4=CO=10B8=8=(?08=C74438I'8E4A10B8=8=)DA:4H0=3
C74IA0@10B8=8=>A30=0A4B4;42C430B?8;>CB8C4B=C74B4B8C4B06A82D;CDA48BCA038C8>=0;;HC74<>BC8<?>AC0=C
42>=><82 02C8E8CH 1DC 8C 70B ?A>6A4BB8E4;H 148=6 A4?;02431H DA10=8I0C8>= 0=3 C>DA8BC82 02C8E8C84B F7827 0;B>
70E40B86=85820=C8<?02C>=6A>D=3F0C4AA4B>DA24B
)74>1942C8E4B>5'('+$'?A>942C0A4C745>;;>F8=6

 C>34E4;>?0=8==>E0C8E4<4C7>3>;>6H5>AC747H3A>64>;>6820;270A02C4A8I0C8>=>5;0A64B20;40@D854A
BHBC4<BDB8=6;>F2>BC0=3=>=8=CADB8E430C0BD270BB0C4;;8C410B43$C427=8@D4B
 C> 8=C46A0C4 03E0=243 $ C427=8@D4B 8=C> =D<4A820; 6A>D=3F0C4A 5;>F 0=3 64><4270=820; <>34;B
08<430C8<?A>E8=6C74:=>F;436401>DCC742DAA4=C20?018;8CH>50@D854ABC>BC>A4F0C4A0=3C745DCDA4
A4B?>=B4>50@D854ABHBC4<BC>=0CDA0;0=37D<0=8=3D243BCA4BB4B
 C> 4=70=24 C74 :=>F;4364 >= C74 8<?02CB >5 06A82D;CDA0; 0=3 C>DA8BC 02C8E8C84B >= F0C4A A4B>DA24B
C7A>D67C74@D0=C85820C8>=0=38=C4A?A4C0C8>=>5$;0=3BD1B834=24<40BDA4<4=CB
 C>4=6064F0C4A<0=064<4=C0DC7>A8C84B0=3?A>E834<>34;B5>A>?C8<0;<0=064<4=C>5C740@D854A
BHBC4<B
=C78BF>A:C74?A4;8<8=0AHA4BD;CB>5C74?A>942CF8;;14?A4B4=C438ABC;HBC0:47>;34AB8=4027?8;>CB8C4
F4A44=60643F8C7C7408<C>38B2DBBC74:=>F;436460?B8=A4;0C8>=C>BDBC08=01;46A>D=3F0C4A<0=064<4=C
=6064<4=C 2>=B8BC43 >5 8=C4AE84FB F8C7 ;>20; 0DC7>A8C84B 50A<4AB 0=3 C427=8280=B 0=3 C74 38BCA81DC8>= >5
@D4BC8>==08A4B C> 8=E4BC860C4 DB4A A4@D8A4<4=CB !>F2>BC 0=3 =>=8=E0B8E4 $ 30C0 3E0=243 8554A4=C80;
('=C4A54A><4CAH=('F4A4?A>24BB430=3E0;830C43C>>1C08=6A>D=338B?;024<4=C<0?B>5C74?8;>C
B8C4B)78B8=5>A<0C8>=F8;;14DB435>A0@D854A270A02C4A8I0C8>=0=3<>34;8=68=C74=4GC?70B4B>5C74?A>942C

   

'('+$'?A>942CB4;42C435>DA ?8;>C B8C4B 148=6 A4?A4B4=C0C8E4 >5 38554A4=C 0@D854A BHBC4<B 8= C74
"438C4AA0=40=0A4086DA4
)01;4


 )742>0BC0;0@D854A>5><02278>8=C0;H
 )74;C>D030;4=CO=0@D854A8=(?08=
 )740;;DE80;0@D854A>5C74438I'8E4A10B8=8=)DA:4H
 )74IA0@0@D854A8=>A30=
)74H70E4144=B4;42C43>=C7410B8B>5>=4>A<>A4>5C745>;;>F8=62A8C4A80
• 7867;H4G?;>8C435>A06A82D;CDA4>AC>DA8BC82?DA?>B4B
• ED;=4A01;4C>3A>D67C3DA8=63AH?4A8>3B
• ?A>E838=6:4HBCA0C4682F0C4AA4B>DA24BC>4=BDA4F0C4ABD??;HC>C74?>?D;0C8>=3DA8=63AH?4A8>3B
• ;>20C438=2>0BC0;0A40BBD554A8=65A><B0;8=8I0C8>=



&%,)$4>6A0?7820;;>20C8>=>5C74?8;>CB8C4B>5C74'('+$'?A>942C


©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3171


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain

 !'$70A02C4A8BC82B>5C74?8;>CB8C4B
  
  

 

 
 




 
 

 

  

 

 03003+/0 '&+.'/5#3:  33+)#5+0/ /#-:4+40(5*'&+(('3'/5130%'44'4

  0%%633+/)46%*#44#-+/'+/5364+0/#/&
  -#/&46$4+&'/%'&6'50/#563#-#/&

 #/5*3010)'/+%(#%5034
  0&+!0-#/0 '&+.'/5#3:   33+)#5+0/ /&'345#/&5*''(('%50(8#5'3-'#,#)'

 (30.5*'+33+)#5+0//'5803,0/5*'
 5*+%,/'440(5*'46$463(#%'(3'4*8#5'3
-'/450#70+&4#-+/+;#5+0/0(5*'4*#--08
#26+('3
 -50 '53+5#-   33+)#5+0/ #/#)')306/&8#5'33'4063%'450
 
  6#&#-'/5</ '&+.'/5#3: 3+/,+/) #70+&)306/&8#5'307'3'91-0+5#5+0/
 #26+('3 8#5'3 #/&5*'46$4'26'/5-#/&46$4+&'/%'
  3+4,
#45 --67+#-   33+)#5+0/ #/#)')306/&8#5'33'4063%'450
#26+('3 '/463'4645#+/#$-'64'0()306/&8#5'3
6#5'3/#3:
#/&'0)'/'



4'&+.'/5#3:

-#:'34

"'45 --67+#-   6$-+% #/#)')306/&8#5'33'4063%'450


#26+('3 8#5'3 '/463'4645#+/#$-'64'0()306/&8#5'3


6#5'3/#3: 4611-:
#/&'0)'/'
4'&+.'/5#3:
-#:'34
 ;3#2 0.1-'9   33+)#5+0/ #/#)')306/&8#5'33'4063%'450

  #26+('3 #26+('3 3+/,+/) 13'4'37'5*')306/&8#5'3&'1'/&'/5



 4:45'.4 8#5'3 '%04:45'.
  3#/)+/)(30.
6#5'3/#3:
&'104+5450
&''1
4#/&450/'
#26+('3
%0.1-'9'4

)742>0BC0;0@D854A>5><02278>8B;>20C438=C742>0BC0;5;>>3?;08=>5C74%>'8E4A8==>AC74A=C0;H0=3
2>E4AB0=0A40>5
 :<C8B0A42;08<43;0=3F8C75;0CC>?>6A0?7HA0=68=65A><
C><0B;;0A64
?>AC8>=8B2><?>B43>5I>=4B14;>FC74B40;4E4;2A>BB431H034=B4<0=<034=4CF>A:>538C274B<0=0643
1H;>20;F0C4A0DC7>A8C84BF7827BD??;84BF0C4A5>A2A>?B<>=6C740AC858280;270==4;BC74<8;80=>'><06=>;>
70==4;8B>=4>5C74<>BC8<?>AC0=CC0;80=7H3A0D;82F>A:BA><40BCC>F4BCC74<09>A8CH>5C74B438<4=C0AH
D=8CB2>=B8BC>50F4364>5?4A<401;4B0=3HB438<4=CBF8C78=C4A20;0C8>=>5?40C0=3B8;CH;0H4AB(C450=80=3
+8=24=I8 C8B0=8=C4=B8E4;H50A<430A40F74A4C74?A8<0AH;0=3DB48B7>AC82D;CDA0;2A>?BC>DA8B<;0A64;H
8=2A40B4B F0C4A 34<0=3 0;>=6 C74 2>0BC;8=4 3DA8=6 BD<<4A C 8B 05542C43 1H B40F0C4A 8=CADB8>= )74
<D=828?0;8CH>5>A>F0BB4;42C430B0?8;>CB8C45>AC740=0;HB8B>5C7438554A4=C?A>24BB4B>22DAA8=6BD270B
B0;8=48=CADB8>=0=3;0=3BD1B834=243D4C>=0CDA0;0=30=C7A>?>64=82502C>AB)74%>38+>;0=>B8C4A4?A4B4=CB
C74?8;>CB8C4F74A4C7445542C>55A4B7F0C4A;40:0645A><C748AA860C8>==4CF>A:>=C74B70;;>F1A02:8B70@D854A
F8;;148=E4BC860C43
)74;C>D030;4=CO=10B8=8B;>20C438=C74"DA280'468>=B>DC740BC>5(?08=F8C70;C8CD34BE0AH8=65A><

 < C> 
 < 0B; D4 C> C74 3AH 2;8<0C4 0=3 E4AH ;>F ?A428?8C0C8>= C74 F0C4A2>DAB4B 8= C78B 10B8= 0A4
8=C4A<8CC4=C )74 ;C> D030;4=CO= 10B8= 8B 0 C42C>=82 34?A4BB8>= ;>20C43 8= C74 40BC4A= ?0AC >5 C74 4C82
>A38;;4A0N90A%8I0AA>4C0;
58;;431H%;8>&D0C4A=0AH0;;DE80;<0C4A80;B2><?>B43>5B0=30=36A0E4;
4<1433438=02;0H430=3B0=3H<0CA8G4AQ=0=3%D;83>>B27
)74B458;;8=6<0C4A80;B>E4A;0?F8C7
"8>24=434?>B8CB<08=;H2><?>B435A><1>CC><C>C>?>5<0A;BF8C72>=6;><4A0C4B0=3B0=3BC>=4B)F>
<D;C8;0H4A0@D854ABF78270A4;0C4A0;;H2>==42C43;C>0=309>D030;4=CO=0A4;>20C438=C740A40)74
8=C4=B8E4 DB4 >5 6A>D=3F0C4A 5>A 06A82D;CDA0; ?DA?>B4B B8=24
  ;43 C> C74 >E4A4G?;>8C0C8>= >5 C74 0@D854A
BHBC4<( C70CA468BC4A43C7478674BCBD1B834=24A0C4B<40BDA438=DA>?4
2<HA
)74438I'8E4A10B8=8B;>20C438=C744640=A468>=>5)DA:4H0=38C8B>=4>5C74;0A64BC>DC>5 <09>A
F0C4AB743B0=3<>BCF0C4ABCA4BB43A8E4A10B8=B8=C742>D=CAH)74438I'8E4A10B8=70B03A08=0640A40>5

©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3172


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain


 :<0=38C8B=0<4305C4A8CB<08=A8E4AA4027C74438I'8E4AF78278B01>DC :<;>=6)7410B4<4=C
8B5>A<431H<4C0<>A?782A>2:B>5C74"4=34A4B"0BB85D;DC4C0; 2>E4A431H&D0C4A=0AH10B0;CB0=3
0;;DE8D<D=8CB)7410B8=4G7818CB0CH?820;"438C4AA0=40=2;8<0C4F8C77>C3AHBD<<4AB0=32>>;A08=HF8=C4AB
)74 06A82D;CDA4 B42C>A 8B C74 ;0A64BC 6A>D=3F0C4A DB4A B8=24 C74 10B8= 8B 06A82D;CDA43><8=0=C 7>F4E4A
B86=85820=C2><?4C8C8>=5>AF0C4A4G8BCB0<>=6E0A8>DBBC0:47>;34AB0=3>C74AB42C>AB
)74IA0@10B8=8BA42>6=8I430BC74;0A64BC6A>D=3F0C4AB>DA248==>AC7>A30=0=38C8B>=4>5C7414BC
@D0;8CHF0C4AB>DA24B8=C742>D=CAH)7410B8=8B;>20C438=C74=>AC740BC4A=?0AC>5>A30=F8C70=0A40>5
0A>D=3
 :<F8C7B<0;;4A?0ACB8=(HA800=3(0D38A0180)7410B8=8=2;D34B0A4B4AE4>58=C4A=0C8>=0;
8<?>AC0=24C70C2>=BC8CDC4B>=4>5C74<>BC?42D;80A42>BHBC4<B8=C74F>A;3840F4C;0=3A8278=18>38E4AB8CH
=0<43UIA0@,4C;0=3A4B4AE4V8=034B4AC)7410B8=2>=B8BCB>5C7A440@D854ABHBC4<BC74B70;;>F10B0;C
A>2:BF78272>=C08=05A4B7F0C4A0@D854A8B2DAA4=C;HC7A40C4=431HB0;8=8I0C8>=0=3>E4A4G?;>8C0C8>=C74<833;4
;8<4BC>=40@D854AF7827<08=;H2>=C08=B1A02:8B7F0C4A0=3C74344?B0=3BC>=40@D854AF782770B;>FH84;3B
1420DB4>5C74;0A6434?C71A078<
$E4AC74;0BC342034BC74IA0@10B8=5024303A0<0C828=2A40B4
8=F0C4A34<0=3F7827;43C>0=>E4A01BCA02C8>=5A><C740@D854A0=320DB430B86=85820=C34C4A8>A0C8>=>58CB
F0C4A @D0;8CH !>F4A8=6 >5 C74 6A>D=3F0C4A C01;4 F8C78= C74 10B8= 70B 8=2A40B43 C74 3A8;;8=6 >5 344?4A F4;;B
F7827A4BD;C438=5DAC74A;>F4A8=60=3346A030C8>=>5C74BD1BDA5024F0C4A;#0@04C0; 



)74 '('+$' ?A>942C <4C7>3>;>6H 8B BCAD2CDA43 8= 58E4 <08= ?70B4B %A4;8<8=0AH (2>?4 (C0C4<4=C
%70B4
0C02>;;42C8>=%70B4 '4B40A27%70B4 4<>=BCA0C8>=%70B4 0=3%8;>C8=6%70B4
%70B4B
0=3 0A4=>F2><?;4C43%70B4B 0=3 0A4>=6>8=6
%70B4
F0B08<43C>4=6064BC0:47>;34AB0=34=3DB4A6A>D?B8=>A34AC>
8 38B2DBB C74 A4B40A27 60?B F8C7 A460A3 C74 BDBC08=01;4 6A>D=3F0C4A <0=064<4=C C7A>D67
8=C4AE84FBF8C7C74;>20;0DC7>A8C84B50A<4AB0=3C427=8280=B0=3C>?4A5>A<DB4AA4@D8A4<4=CB
0=0;HB8BC7A>D6738A42C38BCA81DC8>=>5@D4BC8>==08A4B
88 2><<D=820C4C>C74<C74?A4;8<8=0AHA4@D8A4<4=CB834=C85843C7A>D67C74A4E84FD=34AC0:4=0=3
64CC748A5443102:
888 38BB4<8=0C4C74?A>942C>1942C8E4B1HBC0AC8=605A0<4F>A:5>A2><<D=820C8>=0=32>;;01>A0C8>=
3DA8=6C74;854C8<4>5C74?A>942C
)>02784E4C74B4>1942C8E4BF>A:B7>?B0=3F418=0AB70E4144=>A60=8I438=4027?8;>CB8C4 =>F;4364
60?BA4;0C43C>C74BDBC08=01;46A>D=3F0C4A<0=064<4=C70E4144=8=E4BC860C43C7A>D678=C4AE84FBF8C7C74
;>20; 0DC7>A8C84B 50A<4AB 0=3 C427=8280=B 0=3 4=3DB4A A4@D8A4<4=CB 70E4 144= 0=0;HI43  A4E84F >5 C74
102:6A>D=3>5C746A>D=3F0C4A6>E4A=0=2470B0;B>144=?4A5>A<43C>834=C85HC746A>D=3F0C4A?>;8284B0=3
A46D;0C8>=B5>A4027?8;>CB8C4
= %70B4  8=5>A<0C8>= 5>A 4027 ?8;>C B8C4 F0B 2>;;42C43 8=2;D38=6 64>;>6820; 64><>A?7>;>6820;
7H3A>64>;>6820;2;8<0C820=364>C427=820;30C08=>A34AC>34E4;>?064>;>6820;2>=24?CD0;<>34;>54027?8;>C
B8C4;;C74B430C0F4A4BC>A430=30=0;HI438=064>6A0?7828=5>A<0C8>=BHBC4<(
%70B4  8B 5>2DB43 >= A4B40A27 02C8E8C84B BD27 0B $ ?A>24BB8=6 8= >A34A C> @D0=C85H C74 B?0C80; 0=3
C4<?>A0;4E>;DC8>=>5;0=3BD1B834=24DB8=6('(H=C74C82?4ACDA4'030A02@D8B8C8>=B3E0=2438554A4=C80;
=C4A54A><4CA82 (H=C74C82 ?4ACDA4 '030A =(' C427=8@D4B F4A4 DB43 8= >A34A C> ?A>24BB (' 8<064B
02@D8A431HC74(4=C8=4;
(
A030AB0C4;;8C42>=BC4;;0C8>=8=A4?A4B4=C0C8E40A40B>54027?8;>CB8C4)74B4$
<4C7>3>;>684B ?A>E834 C8<4 B4A84B >5 BDA5024 38B?;024<4=C A4;0C43 C> =0CDA0; ?A>24BB4B 0=3 0=C7A>?>64=82
02C8E8C84B )74 ;0=3 <>E4<4=CB F8;; 14 DB43 8= C74 =4GC ?70B4B C> 8<?A>E4 C74 2>=24?CD0; 0=3 ?7HB820;
6A>D=3F0C4A5;>F<>34;B0=3C>20;81A0C4C7438B?;024<4=C<>34;5>A4027BCD38430@D854A
=0;;C74?8;>CB8C4B$0??;820C8>=8B20AA843>DC8=CF>BC4?B58ABC;H?A4;8<8=0AHBDA5024E4;>28CH<0?B8=
C74!8=4$5(867C!$(F78270A48=C4=343C>834=C85H?>C4=C80;345>A<0C8>=0A40B0A4?A>3D243DB8=6C74C>>;B
>5 4>70I0A3B G?;>8C0C8>= %;0C5>A< % 5D=343 1H C74 DA>?40= (?024 64=2H ( (42>=3;H 58=0;
A4BD;CB>5BDA5024!$(E4;>28CH0=338B?;024<4=CC8<4B4A84B0A4>1C08=43F8C7C08;>A43?A>24BB8=6DB8=6C74
>74A4=C %8G4;B )427=8@D4 %) 34E4;>?43 1H C74 '4<>C4 (4=B8=6 !01>A0C>AH '(!01 0C *=8E4AB8C0C
%>;8C42=820 34 0C0;D=H0 *% ;0=2>(0=274I 4C 0;  ">A0 4C 0;  )74 C>>;B DB43 5>A C74
?A4;8<8=0AH =(' E4;>28CH <0?B F4A4 C74 %0A0;;4; (<0;; B4;8=4 (D1B4C%(( 0BD 4C 0;

"0=D=C0 4C 0;
 0=3 C74 ()+! 8=C4A54A><4CAH 2708=B 34E4;>?43 0=3 8<?;4<4=C43 8= % 1H C74
=BC8CDC45>A;42CA><06=4C82(4=B8=6>5C74=E8A>=<4=C>5C74#0C8>=0;'4B40A27>D=28;#''0=3
)';C0<8A0 A4B?42C8E4;H )74 8=74A4=C D=24AC08=C84B >5 C74 ?A>24BB43 $ 30C0 F4A4 033A4BB43 C7A>D67 0
?A>24BB>50BB4BB8=61H8=34?4=34=C<40=BC74@D0;8CH>5C7430C0?A>3D2CB34A8E435A><C74BHBC4<>DC?DCB
84E0;830C8>=)74$30C0B4CBF4A40=0;HI438=B?0240=3C8<4C>4GCA02CC74<>BC8<?>AC0=C8=5>A<0C8>=
0=3C>D=34ABC0=38=34C08;C74<4270=8B<BA4B?>=B81;45>AC74>1B4AE43;0=3<>E4<4=CB1HDB8=60=28;;0AH
30C0

©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3173


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain

= %70B4  A4B40A27 0=3 34<>=BCA0C8>= 02C8E8C84B BD27 0B C74 34E4;>?<4=C 20;81A0C8>= 0=3 DB4 >5
6A>D=3F0C4A 5;>F <>34;B C> 34C4A<8=4 C74 B?0C80; 38BCA81DC8>= 0=3 C4<?>A0; 270=64 >5 7H3A0D;82 7403 8= C74
0@D854AF8;;1420AA843>DC5>A0;;C74?8;>CB8C4B)745;>F<>34;BF8;;1458ABC20;81A0C43DB8=62>=E4=C8>=0;<4C7>3B
0=3 C74= 0??;843 C> B8<D;0C4 6A>D=3F0C4A 5;>F >E4A C74 $ 30C0 ?4A8>3 )74 8=5>A<0C8>= 5A>< =('
0=0;HB4BF8;;14DB41H0=8=E4AB4<>34;;8=6?A>243DA48=C>C746A>D=3F0C4A5;>F0=364><4270=820;<>34;B
C>@D0=C8C0C8E4;H270A02C4A8I4C74BC>A064540CDA4B>5C74BCD3H0@D854ABDAA4=C0=35DCDA445542CB>588=2A40B8=6
F0C4A34<0=3>=B40F0C4A8=CADB8>=0??;8201;4C>><02278>2>0BC0;0@D854A880@D854A>E4A4G?;>8C0C8>=>=
;0=3BD1B834=240=3BDBC08=018;8CH>56A>D=3F0C4AA4B>DA24B888<0=064<4=CB>;DC8>=B>=C746A>D=3F0C4A
34?4=34=CF4C;0=30??;8201;4C>IA0@F4C;0=3F8;;14B8<D;0C43
=%70B4C74A4BD;CB>5C74A4B40A270=334<>=BCA0C8>=?70B4BF8;;14DB43C>34E4;>?6D834;8=4B5>A
A>D=3F0C4A'4B>DA24"0=064<4=C5>A06A82D;CDA0;0=3C>DA8B<?DA?>B4B

 

)74 4=60643 BC0:47>;34AB 38554A 8= C74 E0A8>DB ?8;>C B8C4B = ?0AC82D;0A C74 BC0:47>;34AB >5 C74 2>0BC0;
0@D854A >5 ><02278> 0A4 ;>20; 0DC7>A8C84B A468>=0; 4=E8A>=<4=C0; 064=284B 0=3 50A<4AB >A C74 ;C>
D030;4=CO=0@D854AC74BC0:47>;34AB0A4C740DC7>A8CHA4B?>=B81;45>AF0C4A<0=064<4=C=0C8>=0;A468>=0;
8AA860C>AB0BB>280C8>=;>20;F0C4ABD??;H2><?0=84B;>20;4=E8A>=<4=C0;4=68=44A8=62>=BD;C8=62><?0=84B
0=3=>=?A>58C4=E8A>=<4=C0;>A60=8I0C8>==C74438I'8E4A10B8=C74BC0:47>;34AB0A46>E4A=<4=C0;0CC74
2>D=CAH 0=3 A468>=0; ;4E4; C74 ;>20; 0DC7>A8C84B A4B?>=B81;4 5>A F0C4A <0=064<4=C 0=3 BD??;H 8=3DBCA80;
2>=BD<4ABA4B40A27>A60=8I0C8>=B#$B<D=828?0;8CH0=3?A8E0C42><?0=84B=C74IA0@F4C;0=3A4B4AE4
C74BC0:47>;34AB0A40DC7>A8C84B?>;82H<0:4ABF0C4ABD??;H2><?0=84B28E8;B>284CH>A60=8I0C8>=BA4B40A27
0=302034<82>A60=8I0C8>=B
)740=0;HB8B>5C74BC0:47>;34A4=6064<4=C02C8E8C84B?4A5>A<431HC74'('+$'?A>942C68E4B8=B867C
01>DCC7438554A4=C8BBD4B3D4C>C746A>D=3F0C4A<0=064<4=C5>AC745>DA?8;>CB8C4B=?0AC82D;0AC74<08=
8BBD4 8= 0;; C74 ?8;>C B8C4B 8B C74 0@D854A >E4A4G?;>8C0C8>= 4G24?C 5>A C74 2>0BC0; 0@D854A >5 ><02278>
DAC74A<>A4 >C74A 8BBD4B 0A4 C74 6A>D=3F0C4A ?>;;DC8>= 3D4 C> C74 06A82D;CDA0; 02C8E8C84B 0=3 C74 7867
6A>D=3F0C4A34<0=3C>BDBC08=C74<>BC8<?>AC0=C42>=><820;F40;C75>AC74438I'8E4A10B8=0=3C74IA0@
10B8= A4B?42C8E4;H =BC403 C74 <08= 8BBD4B 5>A C74 ><02278> 2>0BC0; 0@D854A 0A4 C74 =0CDA0; 0=3
0=C7A>?>64=82;0=3BD1B834=240=3C74B0;CF0C4A8=CADB8>=8=C74?7A40C820@D854A
DAC74A<>A40BD558284=C;H4GC4=B8E4<>=8C>A8=6=4CF>A:>5C746A>D=3F0C4A@D0;8CH;02:B8=0;;C74?8;>C
B8C4B)740=0;HB8B>5C74034@D0C4<>=8C>A8=6BHBC4<B44<BC>14>5385582D;C8=C4A?A4C0C8>=5>AC74BC0:47>;34AB
)74A4BD;CB7867;867CC74=424BB8CHC>8=CA>3D240=33458=40??A>?A80C4?0A0<4C4ABC>4E0;D0C4C74034@D02H>5
C744BC01;8B743<>=8C>A8=6=4CF>A:2>=B834A8=61>C7C74B?0C80;0=3C4<?>A0;B0<?;8=6>5C74<40BDA4<4=CB
)74A45>A48=C745A0<4F>A:>5C74'('+$'?A>942C0=455>ACF8;;14<034C>033A4BBC78B8BBD4$E4A0;;
C74<08=?A>1;4<8BC74034@D0C4B?0C80;38BCA81DC8>=>5<>=8C>A8=6>5C746A>D=3F0C4A;4E4;E0A80C8>=B
)74 BC0:47>;34AB 0A4 0F0A4 C70C =D<4A820; <>34;;8=6 20= 14 0= 45542C8E4 C>>; 5>A 6A>D=3F0C4A
<0=064<4=CB?4285820;;H5>A;>=6C4A<?;0==8=60=3F0C4A1D364C0=0;HB4BC8BF>AC7=>C8=6C70C<>34;BF4A4
=>C ?A4E8>DB;H 34E4;>?43 5>A ;0=3 BD1B834=24 ?A4382C8>= 8= C74 438I '8E4A 10B8= 0=3 C74 IA0@ 10B8= )74
'('+$'A4BD;CBF8;;?A>E834=4F?A>3D2CB08<43C>033A4BBC78B8BBD4)74<08=270;;4=645>AC74;C>
D030;4=CO=0@D854A8BC>9>8=0BD1B834=24<>3D;4C>C745;>F<>34;>AC74><02278>?8;>CB8C4C74A48BC74
=424BB8CHC>344?;HD=34ABC0=3C748=C4A02C8>=14CF44=5A4B7F0C4A0=3B0;CF0C4A0=3C>38BC8=6D8B7C7438554A4=C
2><?>=4=CB>5;0=3BD1B834=24

 

)74?A4;8<8=0AH0BB4BB<4=C>56A>D=3<>E4<4=C0CC745>DABCD3HB8C4B70B144=3>=4DB8=6(
('
8<064B?A>24BB43F8C7C74()+!0=3%((C>>;B8=%>C70;6>A8C7<BAD=0DC><0C820;;H8=%F41
F8C7E4AH;8CC;4DB4A8=C4A02C8>=)74HDB40B<0;;10B4;8=42>=586DA0C8>=0=302>74A4=2410B43?D=2CD0;C0A64C
B4;42C8>= ()+! ?A>E834B <40= !$( E4;>28C84B <0?B >=;H <40=F78;4 %(( 0;B> ?A>E834B !$(
38B?;024<4=CC8<4B4A84B5>A4027?D=2CD0;<40BDA4<4=C>A?8G4;34C42C43>F4E4A0BC74B4C>>;B70E4144=
DB43>=;H0B4G?;>A0C>AH?A>243DA4BF470E4144=8=C4A4BC438=!$(38B?;024<4=CA0C4B>=;H$C74A8<?>AC0=C
38BC8=2C8>=B14CF44=C74C>>;B0A4C74?8G4;B8I4>5C74>DC?DC?A>3D2C G <5>A()+!0=3 G <5>A
%((C744GC4=CC70=20=14?A>24BB43<D27;0A64A5>A%((0=3C74=D<14A>5?0A0<4C4ABC70C20=
14CD=43AD4C0;

)74BCD3H?4A8>3B0A4B8<8;0A5>A0;;C740A40BA0=68=65A><4=3
C>1468==8=6
>C70B24=38=6
0=3 34B24=38=6 >A18CB F4A4 ?A>24BB43 )01;4  )74 ><02278> 0=3 ;C> D030;4=CO= BCD3H 0A40B 0A4
2><?;4C4;H8=2;D3438=1>C7()+!0=3%((0=0;HB4B)74438I'8E4A10B8=0=0;HB8B8B38E83438=CF>
0A40B,4BC0=30BC)74IA0@F4C;0=3A4B4AE48B2><?;4C4;H8=2;D3438=C74()+!0=0;HB8B0;C7>D67
C744=C8A410B8=F0B>=;H2>E4A43F8C7%((=64=4A0;C74A4BD;CB>1C08=43F8C7()+!0A4=>8B84A0=3

©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3174


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain

;4BB A4;801;4 C70= F8C7 %(( ">E8=6 0A40B 2;40A;H A4;0C43 C> 0=C7A>?>64=82 ;0=3 BD1B834=24 70E4 144=
834=C858438=;C>D030;4=CO=438I'8E4A10B8=0=3IA0@F4C;0=3A4B4AE4?8;>CB8C4B>=E4AB4;H02;40A;0=3
BD1B834=24?0CC4A=70B=>C144=A4CA84E438=C74><02278>0@D854A0A4086DA4 

 !'$"08=270A02C4A8BC82B>5C74?A4;8<8=0AH0=358=0;=('?A>24BB8=6(0=3(BC0=35>A
0B24=38=60=334B24=38=6>A18CB>5C74B0C4;;8C4A4B?42C8E4;H0=3#C>C74=D<14A>5(
('8<064B
4<?;>H435>AC740=0;HB8B

 
 
 
    
 

  

    
    

        
       
    
!
          

  
     
 
      



     
 
  
 
!        
  
     
      
          



         

!           
        

          
 



!     
       
      
    
  
    


 
 
     

  !
      

 
          

)7458=0;A4BD;CB8=C4A<B>5!$(<40=E4;>28CH0=3!$(38B?;024<4=CC8<4B4A84B70E4144=>1C08=43F8C7
C74 %) C427=8@D4 F7827 0;B> DB4B 0 B<0;; 10B4;8=4 2>=586DA0C8>= 0=3 0 2>74A4=2410B43 ?D=2CD0; C0A64C
B4;42C8>=)74>DC?DC?8G4;B8I4A0=64B5A>< G C> G <B8=6;4>A18C70B144=0=0;HI435>A4027BCD3H
0A40)01;4 0=3C74?A>24BB434GC4=C70B144=A4BCA82C43C>C7438B?;024<4=C0A40B>58=C4A4BC34;8<8C431H
C74?A4;8<8=0AH0=0;HB8B=C7420B4>5C74438I'8E4A10B8=C74%)0=0;HB8B70B144=?4A5>A<43>=;H8=C74
40BC4A=?0AC0=35>AC74IA0@0@D854A>=;H>E4AC74IA0@F4C;0=3A4B4AE4
)74%)?A>24BB8=63>4B=>C34C42C02;40A38B?;024<4=CCA4=3>E4AC74><02278>0@D854ABCD3H0A40
8= 06A44<4=C F8C7 C74 ?A4;8<8=0AH =(' 0=0;HB8B )74 (' 8<064B 5>A C74 BD<<4A ?4A8>3B ?A8; C>
(4?C4<14A70E4144=38B20A3433D4C>C74B86=85820=C8=2A40B48==>8B42><?0A43C>C74A4BC>5C7430C4B=
C74;C>D030;4=CO=0@D854AC74<0G8<D<345>A<0C8>=0A408B;>20C438=C74=>AC74A=B42C>A>5C7410B8=0=3
C74<0G8<D<345>A<0C8>=A0C434C42C438=!$(8B2<H40A)74A48B0;>20;<0G8<D<;>20C430CC74(,>5
C7410B8=C>F0A3B%D4AC>!D<1A4A0B28CH)8<4B4A84BB7>F0;8=40A38B?;024<4=CCA4=3=C7440BC4A=?0AC>5
C74438I'8E4A10B8=C74<0G8<D<38B?;024<4=CB0F0H5A><C74B0C4;;8C4D?C>
2<H40A0A434C42C43
8=C7424=C4A>5C74E0;;4H)74345>A<0C8>=B7>FBE4AHB70A?4364B0=3C74C8<4B4A84BB7>F0B40B>=0;CA4=3
=C74IA0@0A40C7410A4;0=32>E4ABDA5024B7>FB;>FC4<?>A0;342>AA4;0C8>=F7827A4BD;CB8=C7434C42C8>=
>50E4AH786734=B8CH>5<40BDA4<4=C?>8=CBF8C70E4AH6>>3B?0C80;2>E4A064#><40BDA4<4=C?>8=CB70E4
144=34C42C43>E4AC74B40B>=0;8=D=30C8>=0A40>5C74F4C;0=30;C7>D678=2>=CA0BCF8C7C74?A4;8<8=0AHA4BD;CB
B><4?8G4;B70E4144=A4CA84E43>=C741>A34AB">E4<4=C70B144=34C42C438=1>C738A42C8>=B0F0H0=3
C>F0A3BC74!$(>5C74B0C4;;8C4F8C7345>A<0C8>=A0C4BA0=68=65A>< 2<H40AC> 2<H40AA4B?42C8E4;H
)7438B?;024<4=CC8<4B4A84BB7>FB40B>=0;5;D2CD0C8>=B


©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3175


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain


&%,)$%A4;8<8=0AH(
<40=!$(E4;>28CH<0?B>5C74?8;>CB8C4B>1C08=43F8C7C74%((C>>;0
><02278>A4BD;CB>1C08=43F8C7(>A18C('8<064B)74CF>0A40B>58=C4A4BC>A>>A8=>0=3%>38
+>;0=>0A434;8<8C438=1;02:1;C>D030;4=CO=A4BD;CB>1C08=43F8C7(>A18C('8<064B)74;8<8CB>5
C740@D854A0A434?82C438=1;02:2IA0@F4C;0=3A4B4AE4A4BD;CB>1C08=43F8C7(>A18C)74F4C;0=3
A4B4AE48B34;8<8C438=1;02:0=3C7410B8=F8C7030B7431;02:;8=43"40=!$(E4;>28CH<0?>5C744=C8A4
438I10B8=>5CF>38BC8=2C%((?A>24BB4B>5CF>38554A4=C(CA02:B 0=3


  

)740=0;HB8B>5C74BC0:47>;34A0=BF4ABC>C74?A>?>B43@D4BC8>==08A468E4B8=B867C8=C>38554A4=C0B?42CB
A4;0C43C>6A>D=3F0C4A<0=064<4=C)74<08=?A>1;4<8=0;;C74?8;>CB8C4B8B0@D854A>E4A4G?;>8C0C8>=F8C7C74
4G24?C8>=>5C74C0;80=2>0BC0;0@D854A8=><02278>$C74A8<?>AC0=C8BBD4B0A4C746A>D=3F0C4A?>;;DC8>=3D4
C>C7406A82D;CDA0;02C8E8C84B0=3C7478676A>D=3F0C4A34<0=3C>BDBC08=C74<>BC8<?>AC0=C42>=><8202C8E8C84B
8= C74 438I '8E4A 10B8= 0=3 C74 IA0@ 10B8= >A C74 ><02278> 2>0BC0; 0@D854A C74 <08= 4=E8A>=<4=C0;
?A>1;4<B0A4C74B0;CF0C4A8=CADB8>=8=C74?7A40C820@D854A0=3C74=0CDA0;0=30=C7A>?>64=82;0=3BD1B834=24
A><C74BC0:47>;34A?4AB?42C8E4C746A>D=3F0C4A<>=8C>A8=6BHBC4<B8=C74BCD3H0A40B0A48=034@D0C4
)74 A4BD;CB 7867;867C C74 =443 C> 8=CA>3D24 0=3 3458=4 ?0A0<4C4AB C> 4E0;D0C4 C74 0??A>?A80C4=4BB >5 C74
6A>D=3F0C4A<>=8C>A8=6=4CF>A:2>=B834A8=61>C7C74B?0C80;0=3C4<?>A0;B0<?;8=6>5C74<40BDA4<4=CB0=3
6A>D=3F0C4AF8C73A0F0;B)74A45>A48=C745A0<4F>A:>5C74'('+$'?A>942C455>ACBF8;;0;B>14<034C>
033A4BBC78B8BBD4
)74?A4;8<8=0AHA4BD;CB>1C08=43F8C7C74=('C>>;B8=C74%F41C>>;B0A4E4AHDB45D;C>834=C85H
C740A40B<>BC;H05542C431H;0=3BD1B834=248=C74?8;>CB8C4B48=6%0=>=34<0=32;>D3B4AE8240;;C74
C427=820;A4B>DA24B0A44GC4A=0;0=3C74?A>24BB4B0A4<D2750BC4AC70=C08;>A43=('0=0;HB4B)74;0A64
4GC4=CB0=0;HB431HC74%((C>>;70E40;;>F43DBC>A4CA84E40DB45D;345>A<0C8>=?82CDA4>5C744=C8A4438I
10B8=8=)DA:4H0=3C>34C42CD=:=>F=7>CB?>CB>DCB834C740A40B>58=C4A4BC)7458=0;A4BD;CB>1C08=43F8C7
%)C427=8@D4B7>F<>E4<4=CB2><?0C81;4F8C7;0=3BD1B834=248=;C>D030;4=CO=0=3C7440BC4A=?0AC>5

©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3176


Proceedings of the 39th IAHR World Congress
19–24 June 2022, Granada, Spain

C74438I10B8=F8C7A4;0C8E4;H7867E4;>28CHA0C4B=C7420B4>5><02278>0A40C74%)A4BD;CB3>=>CA4E40;
2;40A;0=3BD1B834=241470E8>DAB=C74IA0@F4C;0=3A4B4AE4C7434C42C43D?;85C0=3B4CC;4<4=C<>E4<4=CB
F8;;=4435DAC74A8=E4BC860C8>=BC>4BC01;8B7C748A>A868=

 

)78BBCD3H70BA4248E435D=38=68=C745A0<4F>A:>5C74'('+$'?A>942C(DBC08=01;46A>D=3F0C4A
'(>DA24B <0=06<4=C 1H 8=C46A0C8=6 40'C7 >1B4AE0C8>= 34A8+43 <>=8C>A8=6 0=3 5;$F <>34;=6 '4BD;CB
5D=3431HC74%0AC=4AB78?5>A'4B40A270=3==>E0C8>=8=C74"438C4AA0=40=A40%'"BD??>AC431HC74
DA>?40=*=8>=A0=C6A44<4=C
 7CC?BA4B4AE>8A?A8<0>A6


  

N90A%8I0AA>"D0A38>;0;14AC0A2O0LA34=0B'%4AA4A00AA0!Q?4I">;8=0
)4BB8C>A4((C0;;4A$AC460424AA8;0A2O00A2O0'%
=C4A?>;0C8>=>5%(0=3
4>;>6820;0C0DB8=6=('345>A<0C8>=<0?B"4C7>30=30??;820C8>=C>;0=3BD1B834=248=C74;C>
D030;4=CO=0@D854A((?08='-/3'2'.2+.) 
;0=2>(0=274I%"0;;>A@DOD@D4(0=3">=4;;B )742>74A4=C?8G4;BC427=8@D4%)
=03E0=243=('C427=8@D45>A=>=;8=40A345>A<0C8>=<>=8C>A8=6%DA40=3??;8434>?7HB82B5
 ./ 0 

ADI@D4AA>%D0A38>;0;14ACN90A%8I0AA>"4AA4A0)><LB'#0E0AA>4A=L=34I"
!Q?4I(0=274I"0:0=J0H;0:;M84(70C0=0F8 8=31D>=P'"48B8=0

!0=3BD1B834=240=0;HB8B20DB431H0@D854A>E4A4G?;>8C0C8>=DB8=6%C>>;B=('>=C74
2;>D3.1/%''&+.)2
1&/.)1'22+.'/-#3+%2.)+.''1+.)00 
&+3/1+#, .+5'12+3#3
/,+38%.+%#&'!#,8.%+#
D;DC$DADJ0:<0:KR=70=K8;4:-4C8B* 4C4A<8=0C8>=>56A>D=3F0C4AC7A4B7>;3
E0;D4B<4C7>3>;>6820;0??A>027/41.#,/(,'#.'11/&4%3+/.5
0 
0BD;450=C4(<?4A0C>A4%.8==>"0=D=C0"4!D200=3!0=0A8'
((
=('?0A0;;4;?A>24BB8=65>A345>A<0C8>=C8<4B4A84B2><?DC0C8>=/41.#,/(','%3'&/0+%2+.
00,+'&#13*$2'15#3+/.2#.&'-/3''.2+.)5./0
 
 
4AQ=%D;83>>B27
A>D=3F0C4A?A>1;4<BA4BD;C8=65A><$ ?>;;DC8>=0=3
>E4A4G?;>8C0C8>=8=;C>D030;4=CO=0@D854A"DA280(?08=.5+1/.-'.3#,'/,/)6  
 
( %;0=4B?4280;0=C4B8CD028>=4B340;4AC0H4E4=CD0;B4@DO04=;02D4=2034;(46DA0
/.('&'1#%+9.*+&1/)17(+%#&',')41#
;#0@0;"><0=8" 8;0=8(0<<>DA8# A>D=3F0C4A4C4A8>A0C8>=>5(70;;>FA>D=3F0C4A
@D854ABD4C>$E4A4G?;>8C0C8>=8=#>AC740BC>A30=,'#.
   
1A078< 
)74'468>=0;4>;>6H>5;IA0@A40"0?(744C#> 
#341#,'2/41%'2
43*/1+364,,'3+.
 0
"0=D=C0"4!D20.8==>0BD"0=I>">=0=>"DB2>%4?4$=>A0C>0=3
4A0A38=>%
)74?0A0;;4;((0??A>0275>A(4=C8=4;
8=C4A54A><4CA82F834BF0C7345>A<0C8>=
C8<4B4A84B64=4A0C8>=0;6>A8C7<34B2A8?C8>=0=3?A>3D2CB@D0;8CH0BB4BB<4=C1#.2#%3+/.2/.
'/2%+'.%'#.&'-/3''.2+.)5 ./0  
">A0$"0;;>A@D80=3A>@D4C0B !8=40A0=3=>=;8=40AC4AA08=345>A<0C8>=<0?B5A><0
A43D243B4C>58=C4A54A><4CA82('8<064B1#.2#%3+/.2/.'/2%+'.%'#.&'-/3''.2+.)5 
./0


(C450=8"+8=24=I8( )748=C4A?;0H>54DBC0BH2;8<0C40=37D<0=02C8E8CH8=C74;0C4&D0C4A=0AH
34?>B8C8>=0;4E>;DC8>=0=3B438<4=C0AH0A278C42CDA4>5C74%>4;C0BHBC4<#1+.''/,/)6  

©2022 IAHR. Used with permission / ISSN-L 2521-7119 3177

View publication stats

You might also like