11/09/2019 Why Professors Are Writing Crap That Nobody Reads | Intellectual Takeout

   

Search 

Culture Economics Education Family History Literature Philosophy Politics Religion Science

Why Professors Are Writing Crap That Nobody Reads

Daniel La ier | October 26, 2016

     

Professors usually spend about 3-6 months (sometimes longer) researching and writing a 25-page article to submit an
article to an academic journal. And most experience a twinge of excitement when, months later, they open a letter
informing them that their article has been accepted for publication, and will therefore be read by…

… an average of ten people.

Yes, you read that correctly. The numbers reported by recent studies are pretty bleak:

82 percent of articles published in the humanities are not even cited once.
Of those articles that are cited, only 20 percent have actually been read.
Half of academic papers are never read by anyone other than their authors, peer reviewers, and journal editors.

So what’s the reason for this madness? Why does the world continue to be subjected to just under 2 million academic
journal articles each year?

Well, the main reason is money and job-security. The goal of all professors is to get tenure, and right now, tenure
continues to be awarded based in part on how many peer-reviewed publications they have. Tenure committees treat
these publications as evidence that the professor is able to conduct mature research.

Sadly, however, many academic articles today are merely exercises in what one professor I knew called “creative
plagiarism”: rearrangements of previous research with a new thesis appended on to them.
https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/why-professors-are-writing-crap-nobody-reads 1/6
11/09/2019 Why Professors Are Writing Crap That Nobody Reads | Intellectual Takeout

Another reason is increased specialization in the modern era, which is in part due to the splitting up of universities into
various disciplines and departments that each pursue their own logic.

One unfortunate effect of this specialization is that the subject matter of most articles make them inaccessible to the
public, and even to the overwhelming majority of professors. (Trust me: most academics don’t even want to read their
peers’ papers.) Some of the titles in the most recent issues of the Journal of the American Academy of Religion—which
proclaims itself as “the top academic journal in the field of religious studies”—serve as evidence:

“Dona Benta’s Rosary: Managing Ambiguity in a Brazilian Women’s Prayer Group”

“Death and Demonization of a Bodhisa va: Guanyin’s Reformulation within Chinese Religion”
“Brides and Blemishes: Queering Women’s Disability in Rabbinic Marriage Law”

Thus, increased specialization has led to increased alienation between not only professors and the general public, but
also between the professors themselves.

All of this is very unfortunate. Ideally, the great academic minds of a society should be put to work for the sake of building
up that society and addressing its problems. Instead, most Western academics today are using their intellectual capital to
answer questions that nobody’s asking on pages that nobody’s reading.

What a waste.

Dan is a former Senior Fellow at Intellectual Takeout. He received his B.A. in Philosophy and
Catholic Studies from the University of St. Thomas (MN), and his M.A. and Ph.D. in Systematic
Theology from Duquesne University in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. You can find his academic work
at Academia.edu.

E-mail Dan

COMMENTS

More From Intellectual Takeout

9th Grade Reading Lists: 1922 Camus’ Touching Le er to Bernie Sanders’ Education
vs. Today Teacher After Receiving Nobel Plan: Rife With Deceit?
Education, History Prize Culture, Education
Education, History

https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/why-professors-are-writing-crap-nobody-reads 2/6
11/09/2019 Why Professors Are Writing Crap That Nobody Reads | Intellectual Takeout

Get thought-provoking
content delivered to your
inbox every day!
Subscribe to IT's newsle er.

Enter your email address 

G R E AT E S T H I T S

The Arrogant Ignorance of the 'Well-Educated'

 4 ½ mins  186,009

Why We Need Alpha Males

 3 ¾ mins  108,084

Good Grammar in Text Messages Might Make You Look Like a Jerk
 6 mins  162,041

https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/why-professors-are-writing-crap-nobody-reads 3/6
11/09/2019 Why Professors Are Writing Crap That Nobody Reads | Intellectual Takeout

Why Are So Many Female Teachers Sleeping With Students?

 3 ¼ mins  199,194

Can’t stand Hillary or Trump? Here’s what you must do.

 2 mins  161,264

TRENDING

Physician: American Children ‘Immersed in a Culture of Disrespect’

 2 ½ mins 

Dilbert Cartoon on Climate Change Prompts Rebu al from Yale

https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/why-professors-are-writing-crap-nobody-reads 4/6
11/09/2019 Why Professors Are Writing Crap That Nobody Reads | Intellectual Takeout

 8 ¾ mins 

Why We Are a Republic, Not a Democracy

 3 ¼ mins 

John Cleese Has a Theory on Why Political Correctness Is Rampant in Our Culture
 ¾ mins 

I Was America’s First ‘Nonbinary’ Person. It Was All a Sham.

 11 ¼ mins 

SUBSCRIBE TO THE IT NEWSLETTER

Get thought-provoking content delivered to your inbox every day.

enter your email 

https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/why-professors-are-writing-crap-nobody-reads 5/6
11/09/2019 Why Professors Are Writing Crap That Nobody Reads | Intellectual Takeout

   

ABOUT

ARTICLES

MEDIA

DONATE

SUBMISSIONS

Copyright © 2017 Intellectual Takeout. All rights reserved. | 8011 34th Avenue South, Suite C-11 - Bloomington, MN 55425 | (952)-388-0840 | Privacy
policy | Terms

https://www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/why-professors-are-writing-crap-nobody-reads 6/6