Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Plantar fascia release is a surgical alternative for patients who suffer chronic heel pain due to plantar fasciitis and are unaffected
by conservative treatment. A computational (finite element) model for analysis of the structural behavior of the human foot during
standing was utilized to investigate the biomechanical effects of releasing the plantar fascia. The model integrates a system of five
planar structures in the directions of the foot rays. It was built according to accurate geometric data of MRI, and includes linear and
non-linear elements that represent bony, cartilaginous, ligamentous and fatty tissues. The model was successfully validated by
comparing its resultant ground reactions with foot-ground pressure measurements and its predicted displacements with those
observed in radiological tests. Simulation of plantar fascia release (partial or total) was accomplished by gradually removing parts of
the fascia in the model. The results showed that total fascia release causes extensive arch deformation during standing, which is
greater than normal deformation by more than 2.5 mm. Tension stresses carried by the long plantar ligaments increased
significantly, and may exceed the normal average stress by more than 200%. Since the contribution of the plantar fascia to the foot’s
load-bearing ability is of major importance, its release must be very carefully considered, and the present model may be used to help
surgeons decide upon the desired degree of release. r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Computational model; Numerical analysis; Finite element method; Plantar pressure
0021-9290/02/$ - see front matter r 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 2 1 - 9 2 9 0 ( 0 1 ) 0 0 2 4 2 - 1
630 A. Gefen / Journal of Biomechanics 35 (2002) 629–637
Fig. 2. The five selected planar cross-sections (marked as S1–S5) presented from (a) a plantar view, (b) an anterior view and (c) a posterior view.
A. Gefen / Journal of Biomechanics 35 (2002) 629–637 631
meaningful geometrical information (differences be- towards the forefoot could not be accounted for while
tween cross-sectional areas of bones in the original using the present planar modeling approach. It was
MRI and processed images did not exceed 1.5%). The further assumed that no space exists between the bones
geometric data of the bone’s contours were transferred and the attached plantar tissue pad, and, similarly, that
to a commercial finite element (FE) analysis software no space exists between the fascia and the soft tissue
package (ANSYS Co., Canonsburg, PA, USA) for above it.
construction of the five cross-sectional structures
(Fig. 3). 2.2. Material properties
Cartilage layers and ligaments forming the joints
between adjacent bones were introduced to conform to Bony elements and cartilage were idealized to linear,
the foot’s anatomy. The thickness of the ligaments and perfectly elastic and isotropic materials, while ligaments,
the locations of their insertions were based on anato- fascia and the soft tissue fat pad were considered as
mical descriptions (Gray, 1995). The cross-sectional being non-linear materials. The Young modulus and
shape of all the ligaments was assumed to be rectan- Poisson ratio for bone were taken from Nakamura et al.
gular, their thickness was determined as being 1.8 mm (1981) as being 7300 MPa (weighing cortical and
and the thickness of the plantar fascia was taken as trabecular elasticity values) and 0.3, respectively. For
being 2 mm, according to measurements of Simkin the cartilage, the Young modulus and Poisson ratio
(1982) on cadaveric normal feet. It should be noted were taken from Patil et al. (1996) as being 10 MPa and
that the 3D ‘‘fan-like’’ structure of the real fascia 0.4, respectively. The typical experimental non-linear
stress-deformation relation for the ligaments was
adapted from Race and Amis (1994) who used an
Instron system to test normal lower-limb ligaments
under tension. The mechanical behavior of the soft
tissue pad was taken from Nakamura et al. (1981) who
obtained the non-linear stress-deformation curve of a
specimen taken from the heel of a fresh cadaver. For the
computational procedures, the above experimental data
were fitted to polynomial expressions in the form of
s ¼ a1 l5 þ a2 l4 þ a3 l3 þ a4 l 2 þ a5 l þ a6 ð1Þ
Table 1
Material properties for the ligaments, plantar fascia and soft tissue fat pad of the model, specified as coefficients ai (in MPa) of a polynomial stress-
deformation relation, s ¼ a1 l5 þ a2 l4 þ a3 l3 þ a4 l2 þ a5 l þ a6 ; where s is the stress in MPa and l is the stretch ratio
Tissue a1 a2 a3 a4 a5 a6
regions of each of the foot joints, precisely as in the principal tension and compression stresses according to
living foot (Woo et al., 1987). the relation:
sv:M: ¼ ðs21 þ s22 s1 s2 Þ1=2 : ð2Þ
2.3. Loads and constraints
Automatic division was used to generate five optimal
The total load carried by the foot model was meshes containing 1100–2000 planar structural elements
determined to be 300 N. The external force system, for describing the curved geometry of bones, cartilages,
representing the body load on each of the five cross- ligaments, fascia and soft tissue (Fig. 4). The above
sections of the model in the standing posture, was meshes were determined by a converging process in
applied by weighing the loads to the five rays to be which the mesh density was gradually increased until the
distributed as 25%–19%–19%–19%–18% for the first deviation in the produced stress values did not exceed
through the fifth ray, respectively (Simkin, 1982). In 5%. The selected 8-node elements allowed for large
addition to the body-weight surface load, a concentrated deflections and large strains. Each node had two degrees
force was applied at the posterior aspect of the calcaneus of freedom, i.e., translation in both the x and y
to represent the effect of the Achilles tendon force due to directions, a state which is compatible with bending
contraction of the triceps surae muscle group (Fig. 3). stresses.
Simkin (1982) calculated that this force should be
approximately 50% of the body load during standing. 2.5. Model validation
Assuming that the load at the Achilles tendon divides
equally between the five cross-sections, a vertical force The FGP during standing, a fundamental character-
of 30 N was applied at the tendon’s insertion point in istic of this posture, was selected as a basic validation
each of the cross-sectional structures. criterion for the computational predictions. Accord-
Supports constraining the model’s vertical displace- ingly, the percentage of weight carried by each foot
ments (Fig. 3) were positioned under the calcaneal base, segment was experimentally measured from 20 feet of 10
under each of the five metatarsal heads and under the normal, healthy subjects (age range: 21–30 years) during
lateral metatarsal and cuboid bodies (Saltzman and standing, using the optical CPD method. The model’s
Nawoczenski, 1995). The maximal distance between predictions of percentage of weight carried by the foot
adjacent constraints was determined to be 12 mm, segments were compared with the experimentally
identically to the distance between sensors of the contact measured ones (by employing a statistical t-test with a
pressure display (CPD) method for foot-ground pres- significance level of 5%), and no statistically significant
sure (FGP) measurements (Arcan, 1990; Brosh and differences were evident (Table 2).
Arcan, 1994; Gefen et al., 2000, 2001), to enable The lateral X-rays of the weight-bearing and non-
validation of model predictions according to experimen- weight-bearing foot of the subject used for model
tally obtained FGP patterns. Sliding of the structures in geometry reconstruction were digitized, and the posi-
the horizontal direction was prevented by constraining a tions of the talus and metatarsal heads were detected on
point under the center of the calcaneal base in each each radiograph. Distances between the talus apex and
cross-sectional structure against translation displace- the calcaneus plantar aspect as well as those between the
ment in that direction. Consequently, this point was also talus apex and the metatarsal heads were measured on
used as a reference for movements of all other nodal both the weight-bearing and non-weight bearing X-rays
points. using image-processing software. The obtained lengths
were used to calculate the deflection of the talus and the
2.4. Numerical method lengthening of the foot for comparison to the computa-
tional predictions. Weight-bearing feet of healthy,
The FE analysis resulted in a quantitative structural normal subjects generally show very small displacements
stress distribution in terms of the principal tension s1 ; during standing, i.e., mean talus depression of 0.15 mm
the principal compression s2 ; and the von Mises and even smaller elongation of the foot’s rays
equivalent stress (sv:M: ), which weighs the effects of (Carlsoo, 1964). The model simulations of displacement
A. Gefen / Journal of Biomechanics 35 (2002) 629–637 633
Fig. 6. The model-produced isostatics (vector representation of the stress flow) in the second ray of the normal foot (second cross-sectional structure,
marked as S2 in Fig. 3). The arrows represent the transfer of tension (2 bright) and compression ( dark) stresses. The regions marked 1–4 on
the top image are magnified for clarification.
simulation of a total surgical release of the fascia Sharkey et al. (1998), who demonstrated that complete
demonstrated significant rise in stresses carried by the fascia release in cadaveric feet caused a 2.5 mm decrease
LPLs. Extensive deformation of the arch (2.85 mm), i.e., in the mean arch height under loading conditions which
to more than 10 times the predicted normal arch simulated the push-off stage of gait. Kitaoka et al.
deformation, was observed as well. These computational (1997) measured larger decreases in arch height of
results are in good agreement with the measurements of cadaveric feet, ranging between 3.3 and 11.5 mm, and
636 A. Gefen / Journal of Biomechanics 35 (2002) 629–637
Table 3
10
Predicted deformation of the foot’s arch and long plantar ligament
Displacement [mm]
(LPL) averaged stresses for different simulated plantar fascia degrees 8
Cartilage
of release (PFDR)
6
PFDR Arch Deep LPL Superficial
(percentage) deformation stress (kPa) LPL stress 4
(mm) (kPa)
2
0 (normal 0.28 35 25
foot) 0
25 0.48 39 30 -50 -25 0 25 50
Displacement [mm]
50 0.99 47 42 8
Ligaments
75 1.73 60 57
100 (total 2.85 78 76 6
release)
4
0
-50 -25 0 25 50
Displacement [mm]
Plantar Tissue
8
0
-5 0 -25 0 25 50
Neutral
Decreased Stiffness [%] Increased Stiffness [%]
(Fig. 6). Removal of the fascia elevated the bending Duvries, H., 1978. Surgery of the Foot. Mosby, St. Louis.
loads on these bones, and, thereby, increased the dorsal Gefen, A., Megido-Ravid, M., Itzchak, Y., Arcan, M., 2000.
compression stresses by as much as 65%. This suggests Biomechanical analysis of the three-dimensional foot structure
during gaitFa basic tool for clinical applications. Journal of
that release of the fascia will accelerate fatigue damage Biomechanical Engineering 122, 630–639.
to these bones during intensive activity such as marching Gefen, A., Megido-Ravid, M., Itzchak, Y., 2001. In vivo biomecha-
and hence, when surgical removal or significant release nical behavior of the human heel pad during the stance phase of
of the fascia is considered, a decrease in the foot’s gait. Journal of Biomechanics 34, 1661–1665.
abilities of load-bearing and shock-attenuation should Gormely, J., Kuwada, G.T., 1992. Retrospective analysis of calcaneal
spur removal and complete fascial release to the treatment of
be taken into account. chronic heel pain. Journal of Foot Surgery 1, 166–169.
The model presented in this work may be further Gray, H., 1995. Gray’s Anatomy. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh.
applied to investigate numerous acquired foot deformi- Ker, R.F., Bennet, M.B., Bibby, S.R., Kester, R.C., Alexander, R.M.,
ties or traumatic injuries, and the mechanisms acting in 1987. The spring in the arch of the human foot. Nature 325,
147–149.
such conditions could be studied by altering its
Kim, W., Voloshin, A.S., 1995. Role of the plantar fascia in the load
geometrical or material properties. Moreover, various bearing capacity of the human foot. Journal of Biomechanics 28,
new or conservative surgical interventions could be 1025–1033.
evaluated by removing or adding elements to the Kitaoka, H.B., Luo, Z.P., Growney, E.S., Berglund, L.J., An, K.N.,
computational simulation. Orthotics and supportive 1994. Material properties of the plantar aponeurosis. Foot & Ankle
devices may also be assessed, and their effect on the International 15, 557–560.
Kitaoka, H.B., Luo, Z.P., An, K.N., 1997. Mechanical behavior of the
internal and foot-ground contact stress distributions can foot and ankle after plantar fascia release in the unstable foot. Foot
be studied. When used together with FGP experimental & Ankle International 18, 8–15.
measurements, the present computational foot model Lutter, L.D., 1986. Surgical decisions in athlete’s subcalcaneal pain.
can be a highly effective biomechanical tool with clinical American Journal of Sport Medicine 14, 481–485.
applications in pre- and post-treatment evaluations. Nakamura, S., Crowninshield, R.D., Cooper, R.R., 1981. An analysis
of soft tissue loading in the foot: a preliminary report. Bulletin of
Prosthetic Research 18, 27–34.
Patil, K.M., Braak, L.H., Huson, A., 1996. Analysis of stresses in two-
Acknowledgements dimensional models of normal and neuropathic feet. Medical and
Biological Engineering and Computing 34, 280–284.
With this paper, I wish to honor the memory of the Race, A., Amis, A., 1994. The mechanical properties of the two
bundles of the human posterior cruciate ligament. Journal of
late Prof. Mircea Arcan (deceased June, 2000), my Biomechanics 27, 13–24.
academic supervisor, who motivated and guided my Saltzman, C.L., Nawoczenski, D.A., 1995. Complexities of the foot
work in the field of musculoskeletal biomechanics. architecture as a base of support. Foot/Ankle Therapy & Research
21, 354–360.
Sharkey, N.A., Ferris, L., Donahue, S.W., 1998. Biomechanical
consequences of plantar fascial release or rupture during gait: part
References IFdisruptions in longitudinal arch conformation. Foot & Ankle
International 19, 812–820.
Arcan, M., 1990. Non invasive and sensor techniques in contact Simkin, A., 1982. Structural analysis of the human foot in standing
mechanics: a revolution in progress (invited paper). Proceedings of posture. Ph.D. Thesis, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
the Ninth International Conference on Exp. Mech., Copenhagen, Simkin, A., Liechter, I., 1990. Role of the calcaneal inclination
pp. 122–131. in the energy storage capacity of the human foot: a biomechanical
Brosh, T., Arcan, M., 1994. Toward early detection of the tendency to model. Medical and Biological Engineering and Computing 28,
stress fractures. Clinical Biomechanics 9, 111–116. 149–152.
Carlsoo, S., 1964. Influence of frontal and dorsal loads on muscle White, D.L., 1994. Plantar fascia release. Journal of the American
activity and on the weight distribution in the feet. Acta Podiatric Medical Association 84, 607–613.
Orthopaedica Scandinavia 34, 299–309. Woo, S.L-Y., Mow, V.C., Lai, W.M., 1987. Biomechanical properties
Chu, T.M., Reddy, N.P., Padovan, J., 1995. Three dimensional finite of articular cartilage. In: Skalak, R., Chien, S. (Eds.), Handbook of
element stress analysis of the polypropylene ankle-foot orthosis: Bioengineering. McGraw-Hill, New York.
static analysis. Medical Engineering & Physics 17, 372–379.