You are on page 1of 9

Sensors & Actuators: B.

Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/snb

Dual-emission ratiometric probe combining carbon dots and CdTe quantum T


dots for fluorometric and visual determination of H2O2
⁎ ⁎
Rafael C. Castro, José X. Soares, David S.M. Ribeiro , João L.M. Santos
LAQV, REQUIMTE, Department of Chemical Sciences, Laboratory of Applied Chemistry, Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Porto, Rua de Jorge Viterbo Ferreira no 228,
4050-313 Porto, Portugal

A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T

Keywords: In this work, blue-emitting carbon quantum dots and distinctly sized CdTe semiconductor quantum dots were
Quantum dots combined to implement a ratiometric probe for the monitoring of H2O2. By implementing a sensing scheme that
Ratiometric assay combines multiple nanoprobes, excited at the same wavelength and emitting at different ones, which exhibit also
CdTe dissimilar reactivity, it was possible to minimize detrimental factors associated with the use of a single photo-
Carbon dots
luminescence wavelength such as fluctuations in excitation source or measured signal, fluorophore concentra-
Hydrogen peroxide
Visual assay
tion, matrix effects and background fluorescence. The developed ratiometric probe was applied on the im-
plementation of a conventional fluorometric assay and on a visual assay relying on the red, green and blue
(RGB)-based colour changes promoted by increasing H2O2 concentrations.
For the fluorometric determination assay, a good linear relationship between the fluorescence intensity ratio
(FICD434/FIMPA587) and H2O2 concentration within the range of 0.0100–0.2125% (w/w) was obtained
(R = 0.9994, n = 7). The detection limit was about 0.00793% (w/w). The obtained results in the determination
of H2O2 in contact lens solutions were in agreement with those provided by the reference procedure, with
relative deviations between −4.71 and 1.89%. Regarding the RGB-visual assay, a linear working range for
hydrogen peroxide concentrations up to 0.150% (w/w) was verified (n = 9) with a correlation coefficient of
0.9966, which confirms its potential as valuable analytical tool for on-the-spot semi-quantitative detection of
H2O2.

1. Introduction hydroxyphenylacetic acid [3], acetaminophen [4] homovanillic acid


[5] and 2′,7′-dichlorodihydrofluorescein [6] are examples of some non-
The capacity of hydrogen peroxide for triggering oxidative pro- fluorescent reagents, which can be found in the scientific literature, that
cesses has been widely explored as: i) food additive for controlling the were applied in H2O2 determination based on the formation of fluor-
growth of microorganisms; ii) hair bleaching or dyeing and fixing of escent compounds upon redox reaction with H2O2. These reactions
hair perm; iii) household cleaning agents, including contact lens dis- were usually catalysed by an enzyme, namely peroxidase or horseradish
infection; and iv) tooth bleaching [1]. Being a harmful chemical with peroxidase (HRP).
confirmed carcinogenicity and toxicity and considering the large An indirect fluorometric method involving the strong oxidizing
quantities as it is released into the environment, it has become im- ability of the Fenton reaction was also employed to oxidize non-fluor-
perative to monitor hydrogen peroxide effectiveness and safety in escent coumarin to fluorescent 7-hydroxycoumarin, being H2O2 quan-
several applications namely in industrial, environmental, biochemical tified as consequence of its concentration dependent fluorescence en-
and clinical fields. This has accentuated the need for rapid, simple, hancement [7]. The fluorometric scopoletin-horseradish peroxidase
selective and sensitive methodologies for H2O2 determination, relying method, relying on the quenching of scopoletin fluorescence upon re-
some of the most used procedures on fluorescence-based measure- action with H2O2, catalysed by HRP, has been also often used for H2O2
ments. Indeed, the oxidizing capacity of hydrogen peroxide was ex- determination [8–11]. A similar fluorescence quenching method was
plored to form either a fluorescent product from a non-fluorescent based on the reaction of H2O2 with 3,3′-diethyloxadicarbocyanine io-
compound or to quench the emission of native fluorescent probes. In dide to form a non-fluorescent compound in acidic medium [12]. A
this regard, 4-amino-1H-1,5-benzodiazepine-3-carbonitrile [2], p- significant drawback of the aforementioned methods is the use of HRP


Corresponding authors.
E-mail addresses: dsmribeiro@gmail.com (D.S.M. Ribeiro), joaolms@ff.up.pt (J.L.M. Santos).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2019.126665
Received 15 March 2019; Received in revised form 27 May 2019; Accepted 5 June 2019
Available online 15 June 2019
0925-4005/ © 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

enzymes, which are expensive, instable in solution and require reaction 2. Experimental
conditions that restrain their applicability [13].
An advantageous alternative to the referred methods could be the 2.1. Reagents and solutions
implementation of fluorescence-based sensing schemes relying on the
use of semiconductor quantum dots (QDs) as fluorophores. QDs exhibit All solutions and standards were prepared from chemicals of ana-
unique optical properties such as size-dependent and tunable photo- lytical reagent grade without any pre-treatment process and using
luminescence (PL), long-term photostability, high quantum yield (QY) water purified from a Milli-Q system (conductivity ≤ 0.1 μS cm−1).
and long excited-state decay lifetimes that assure simplicity, versatility All reagents used for the synthesis of semiconductor QDs were
and reliability in a variety of analytical applications. Additionally, their purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (St. Louis, MO, USA), namely, cadmium
broad excitation bands enable the simultaneous excitation of multi- chloride hemi(pentahydrate) (CdCl2·2.5H2O, 99%), sodium tellurite
colour QDs by using a unique light source [14–17]. In this regard, only (Na2TeO3, 100 mesh, 99%), sodium borohydride (NaBH4, 99%), so-
a few examples have been reported dealing with the direct interaction dium 2-mercaptoethanesulfonate (MES, C2H5NaO3S2, 98.0%), glu-
between QDs and H2O2 that typically result in a quenching of the tathione reduced (GSH, C10H17N3O6S, 99.0%), 3-mercaptopropionic
fluorescence of the PL probe in the presence of the oxidizing agent acid (MPA, C3H6O2S, 99%) and sodium citrate tribasic dehydrate
[18–20]. Others sensing strategies relying on indirect photo- (C6H5Na3O7·2H2O, 99%). Citric acid (C6H8O7, ≥99.5%) and ethyle-
luminescence detection of H2O2 were also proposed aiming to obtain an nediamine (N2C2H6, ≥99.5%), both acquired from Sigma-Aldrich (St.
improvement of sensitivity and selectivity of the QDs-based fluoro- Louis, MO, USA) were the reagents used for the synthesis of carbon-
metric methodology. Two illustrative examples are the use of H2O2 for based nanoparticles.
preventing the surface passivation of 3-mercaptopropionoic acid QDs and CDs intermediate solutions were prepared by direct dilu-
(MPA)–capped CdTe QDs [21] and thioglycolic acid (TGA)–capped tion, with deionized water, in a ratio of one to twenty (1:20) and one to
CdTe QDs [22] by reduced glutathione and hepatitis B core antibody fifty (1:50), respectively.
labelled with horseradish peroxidase, respectively. Hydrogen peroxide intermediate solution of 0.1% (w/w) was daily
All of the abovementioned QDs-based PL sensing strategies for H2O2 prepared by appropriate dilution of H2O2 stock solution acquired from
relied on the measurement of the fluorescence emission at a single Sigma-Aldrich (30% w/w, St. Louis, MO, USA) with deionized water.
wavelength which, although practical and easy to implement, could be The working standard solutions of H2O2 were prepared by proper di-
hindered by several factors, such as fluctuations in excitation source, lution of the above intermediate solution. Six different commercially
probe concentration, matrix effects in complex samples and background available lens care solutions were prepared by diluting with deionized
fluorescence [23–25]. These aspects can lead to inaccurate and irre- water an appropriate volume of the sample, in order to obtain a hy-
producible results impairing the detection and quantification of the drogen peroxide content included in the analytical range of the pro-
target analyte. The addition of a second fluorophore for the develop- posed methodology. All the samples were analysed without any pre-
ment of a ratiometric fluorescent method can be used to circumvent treatment process.
these adverse effects. Dual-emission ratiometric fluorescent probe sys-
tems consisting in a mixture of two distinct fluorophores, one as the 2.2. Equipment
analyte-dependent fluorophore and the other as an internal standard,
have been used for the determination of a myriad of analytes such as, The synthesis of CdTe QDs were carried out in a single mode CEM
metal ions [23–30], proteins [31], glucose [32,33], aspirin [34] and Discover SP® synthesizer operated through a computer using Synergy™
2,4,6-trinitrotoluene [35]. software (Matthews, NC, US). This equipment was equipped with an
Practical sensing devices, based on the change of materials macro- automated pressure control/sensing system (ActiVent™), an active
scopic properties [36] or naked eye colour visualization [37,38], is cooling system (PowerMAX™) and an integrated infrared (IR) sensor for
crucial for the development of in situ analytical methods. Considering the strict control of irradiation time, reaction temperature and pressure.
that on a dual-emission ratiometric fluorescent probe, one emission The emission spectra of the fluorometric probes were obtained with
intensity is constant and the other can be quenched in the presence of a Jasco FP-6500 spectrofluorometer (Easton, MD, USA) and a multi-
the analyte, the colour modifications endured by the probe can be ea- mode microplate reader (Cytation™ 3, BioTek™). All photographs were
sily and obviously perceived by naked eye under irradiation with UV acquired with a Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX10 V digital camera. The ra-
lamp. In fact, these kind of ratiometric probes can be applied as naked tiometric fluorescent probes were photographed in a CN-6 UV dark-
eye visual sensing platforms as is the example proposed by Xia et al in room with hand-held UV lamp 254 nm and 365 nm (6 W, model VL-
which they developed a red, green and blue (RGB)-based colour change 6.LC)
probe for the visual analysis of formaldehyde [39].
In the present work, two distinct photoluminescent nanoparticles 2.3. Procedure for the synthesis of MPA capped CdTe QDs and CDs
were exploited to implement a ratiometric assay for the determination
of H2O2 in real samples. This dual-emission nanosystem involved the The two different sized MPA capped CdTe QDs were synthesized
combination of a blue-emitting carbon dot, which due to their inertness according to the procedure proposed by Ribeiro et al [40]. This syn-
behaviour was used as internal standard, and an orange-emitting CdTe thetic methodology consisted in a one-step synthetic route assisted by
QDs capped with 3-mercaptopropionic acid (MPA) as analyte-depen- microwave irradiation. The experimental conditions for the synthesis of
dent fluorophore. The addition of H2O2 in the mixture induces the QDs, such as precursors concentration, pH, irradiation time were used
depassivation of the MPA-CdTe QDs, decreasing thus the orange-emis- exactly as recommended in the prior work [40].
sion PL while the photoluminescence of the blue-emitting CDs remained For the syntheses of the yellow and orange-emitting CdTe QDs the
constant. The exploitation of this effect was used to develop an analy- temperatures were 105 °C and 115 °C, respectively.
tical method for the determination of H2O2 using a conventional For the syntheses of CDs, our previously optimized conditions were
fluorometric assay. Additionally, a RGB-type sensing scheme based on used [unpublished results]. In short, citric acid (0.5 g) and ethylene-
the colour modulation of the two nanomaterials is also proposed. The diamine (0.3 mL) were mixed with water yielding a final concentration
PL variations and fluorescent colour changed from orange to blue were of citric acid of 10% (m/v). Then the pH of the reaction mixture was set
used for the detection and quantification of H2O2 in lens care solutions. to 3.8 by the addition of HCl (1 mol L−1). The reaction mixture was
transferred into a 40 mL Teflon-lined autoclave and heated at 260 °C for
5 h. After cooling to room temperature, the solution was extensively
dialyzed against Mili-Q water in a dialysis membrane (Spectra/Por 6 -

2
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

1000 MWCO, Spectrum Labs™) for 5 days. photoluminescence of the QDs was gradually lessened with increasing
H2O2 concentrations until its complete disappearance. In effect, the
2.4. Conventional fluorometric assay procedure thiol groups of MPA attached on the QDs surface through CdeS
bonding can be oxidized to form an organic disulfide product (RS–SR)
Before the preparation of the ratiometric probe solution, the re- causing its detachment from the surface of the PL probe. As a con-
spective as-prepared nanoparticle solutions were diluted in deionized sequence of QDs depassivation, the surface traps increased which im-
water. Thus, QDs and CDs intermediate solutions were prepared by paired electron-hole recombination and therefore the QDs PL intensity
direct dilution of the crude solutions with deionized water in a ratio of is inhibited [42–44]. The observed blue shift can be ascribed to a
1:20 (1 mL in 20 mL) and 1:50 (0.5 mL in 25 mL), respectively. The two probable slight QDs size reduction caused by the irreversible oxidation
dual-emission ratiometric probes for the detection of H2O2 consisted in at the QDs surface [45,46]. This explanation was confirmed by per-
a mixture of CDs and QDs in a ratio of 1:5. In this sense, 3.2 mL and forming the measurement of the excitation spectra of the QDs in the
16 mL of CDs and QDs intermediate solutions, respectively, were mixed absence and presence of 0.050% H2O2. The results (Fig S4 – Supple-
into a 50 mL graduated tube. mentary material) demonstrated a decrease of the absorbance and a
Afterwards, 960 μL of the fluorescent probe solution and required slight blue shift (2 nm) of the absorption band for the first excitonic
amounts of deionized water and H2O2 were sequentially added com- transition with the addition of H2O2, which was accentuated (blue shift
pleting the final volume of 2 mL. Immediately after the addition of of 4 nm and 8 nm) by increasing the reaction time up to 2 and 5 min,
H2O2, the solution was shaken and transferred into a 1 cm quartz cell respectively. Moreover, the linear Stern-Volmer plots that describes the
and the emission spectra (λem, from 385 to 700 nm) were recorded with PL response of the two different sizes CdTe QDs upon interaction with
the excitation wavelength fixed at 360 nm. The slit widths of excitation H2O2 demonstrated a higher sensitivity of the 588 nm emitting QDs (O-
and emission were 5.0 and 10.0 nm, respectively. QDs) (F0/F = 57.4 × [H2O2] + 1.31) relatively to the 562 nm emitting
one (Y-QDs) (F0/F = 37.0 × [H2O2] + 0.89) (Figs. S2C) and S3C)).
2.5. RGB-visual assay procedure
3.2. Dual-emission CDs/CdTe-QDs combined probe for H2O2 detection
The ratiometric fluorescent probes prepared using the above-
mentioned conditions were photographed upon irradiation at 365 nm 3.2.1. Optimization of the CDs and CdTe-QDs mixture
with a digital camera. RGB-type images were cropped to 460 × 160 The blue emitting CDs (B-CDs) were mixed with each of the MPA-
pixel dimension image and aligned to the centre of the vial containing CdTe QDs (Y-QDs and O-QDs) in order to obtain two distinct dual-
the probe. The cropped RGB-images were imported to Matlab version emission ratiometric probes (B-CDs/Y-QDs and B-CDs/O-QDs) which
R2009b (MathWorks, Natick, MA, USA) and divided into three matrixes were evaluated for application in the fluorometric determination of
corresponding three channels (red, green and blue). Each matrix, with H2O2. In this sense, CDs and QDs were mixed in different proportions in
460 rows and 160 columns, contained at each entry the intensity value order to enhance the efficiency of the dual-emission ratiometric probe
(between 0–255) of the corresponding channel. Ratio between the pixel for the target analyte. Therefore, for both probes tested, the CDs and
intensity at blue and red channels were obtained by dividing at each QDs were mixed (for a final volume of 2000 μL) in a proportion of 1:1,
pixel the intensities on the blue and on the red channel. Average pixel 1:2.5, 1:4 and 1:5 (CDs:QDs), by fixing 160 μL of the diluted solution of
intensity were calculated by the mean of mean values on each column. CDs (50×) and by varying the amount of the semiconductor nano-
particle with the addition of 160, 400, 640, 800 μL of the diluted so-
2.6. Reference procedure lution of QDs (20×). The PL spectra of the blue emitting CDs, yellow
and orange emitting CdTe QDs and the corresponding ratiometric
To validate the results obtained by the conventional fluorometric probes are shown in Figs. 1 and 2.
and the image processing-based assays, the hydrogen peroxide de- Upon excitation at 360 nm, the blue emitting CDs and yellow and
termination were also performed by the reference methodology re- orange emitting CdTe QDs showed a maximum emission at 434, 560,
commended by the European Pharmacopoeia [41]. The reference pro- and 587 nm, respectively. This way, the corresponding combining
cedure involved a permanganometric titration of hydrogen peroxide in probes exhibited a dual emission PL band under a single-wavelength
acidic medium. The potassium permanganate solution was standar- excitation (360 nm) at, namely, 434/560 and 434/587 nm.
dized by titration with arsenic hexaoxide in acidic medium. The hy- The obtained results demonstrated that by increasing the amount of
drogen peroxide amount in the samples was calculated taking into ac- CdTe QDs, the PL intensity of the QDs gradually increased, as expected,
count that each mL of 0.02 mol L−1 KMnO4 solution was equivalent to while the PL intensity of the CDs was slightly inhibited (Figs. 1B) and 2
1.701 mg of H2O2. B)). In fact, the CdTe QDs can act as an inner filter by absorbing a
considerable portion of excitation photons and consequently the emis-
3. Results and discussion sion intensity of the CDs was quenched. In order to obtain an improved
reactivity and sensitivity of the dual-emission probe, the ratio CDs:QDs
3.1. Preliminary assays of 1:5 was selected for further assays.

For the development of the ratiometric fluorescence probe, CDs 3.2.2. Stability of the dual-emission ratiometric probe
were chosen as internal standard because they showed a remarkable The stability of the probe solutions is an important parameter that
chemical inertness upon interaction with H2O2. In fact, upon the pre- could affect the reproducibility and accuracy of successive fluorometric
sence of increasing concentrations of H2O2, up to 0.26% (w/w), the PL measurements performed during sample analysis. For this reason, the
emission intensity, as well as the observed colour under a UV lamp, stability in aqueous solution of the PL intensity of the 434/560 nm and
remains unchangeable (Fig. S1 – Supplementary material). On the other 434/587 nm arrangements was thoroughly studied. Thus, for both dual-
hand, two MPA-CdTe QDs of different size were tested to be used as the emission probes the fluorescence intensity ratios (FICD434/FIMPA560
analyte-dependent fluorophore. In both QDs the fluorescence intensity and FICD434/FIMPA587) were monitored throughout 360 min (Fig. 3
is gradually quenched in the presence of increasing H2O2 concentra- and 4). In the case of the 434/560 nm combination, the signal remained
tions (Figs. S2 and S3 – Supplementary material). Additionally, a constant up to 60 min (log (time) = 1.78) and thereafter decreased for
slightly blue shift of the maximum emission wavelength was observed longer period of time (Fig. 3B). Regarding the 434/587 nm probe, the
in both cases. The observed colour under a UV lamp corroborated the analytical signal persisted unchanged over 20 min (log (time) = 1.30)
abovementioned fluorometric results, in which the yellow and orange and then the stability decreased by prolonging the time (Fig. 4B). This

3
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

Fig. 1. PL spectra (A and B) and the corre-


sponding photographs taken under 365 nm UV
lamp (C and D) of blue emitting CDs (I), yellow
emitting QDs (II) and B-CDs/Y-QDs (434/
560 nm) ratiometric probe in the CDs:QDs
proportions of 1:1 (III), 1:2.5 (IV), 1:4 (V) and
1:5 (VI). (For interpretation of the references to
colour in this figure legend, the reader is re-
ferred to the web version of this article.)

results revealed a good stability of the optical properties of both probes being MPA-CdTe QDs used as the recognition element and the CDs
considering the kinetics of the reaction with the target analyte. employed as reference fluorophore.
Additionally, the analytical response (FI ratio) of ratiometric probe The obtained results revealed a linear relationship between the
solution was monitored upon the addition of 0.0500% (w/w) H2O2 fluorescence intensity ratios (FICD434/FIMPA560 and FICD434/
solution. The obtained results revealed that the reaction between the FIMPA587) and the concentration of H2O2 in the range up to 0.1000%
dual-emission probe and hydrogen peroxide occurred promptly. (w/w) and 0.2125% (w/w), when using B-CDs/Y-QDs and B-CDs/O-
Prolonging the reaction time up to 25 min, FICD/FIMPA increased gra- QDs, respectively.
dually due to the PL quenching of the MPA-CdTe QDs which is caused The regression equations obtained from the interaction of H2O2 and
by the oxidation of capping thiol groups attached to the QDs surface B-CDs/Y-QDs and B-CDs/O-QDs probes can be expressed as FICD/
(Fig. 5). Consequently, the surface depassivation promoted the occur- FIMPA = 10.0 ( ± 0.2) × [H2O2] + 0.37 ( ± 0.01) (R = 0.9972) and
rence of dangling bonds (mid-gap energy states) that act as surface FICD/FIMPA = 20.6 ( ± 0.4) × [H2O2] + 0.73 ( ± 0.04) (R = 0.9972),
traps and prevent radiative electron-hole recombination. Consequently, respectively. From the obtained results it was observed that the linear
in order to guarantee a good compromise between stability and re- regression sensitivity obtained for B-CDs/O-QDs probe was twice as
activity the fluorescence response was measured immediately after the high as for the B-CDs/Y-QDs one.
addition of H2O2. In addition, both ratiometric probes also allowed the visual detec-
tion of H2O2. In fact, the changes in fluorescence intensity ratios
(FICD434/FIMPA560 and FICD434/FIMPA587) with the increasing of
3.2.3. Fluorometric determination of H2O2
H2O2 concentration can also be observed through the continuous var-
The PL properties of the 434/560 nm and 434/587 nm probes were
iation of the colour of the fluorescence emission from yellow to blue
assessed upon interaction with H2O2 at a concentration range of
(Fig. 7 (A)) and from orange to blue (Fig. 7(B)) in the case of the B-CDs/
0–0.26% (w/w) (Fig. 6). As expected, the two characteristic emission
Y-QDs and B-CDs/O-QDs probes, respectively.
bands showed different responses. In both cases, the PL intensity cor-
Indeed, the combination of both Y-QDs and O-QDs, as sensing
responding to the CdTe QDs band at 560 and/or 587 nm were effec-
probes, and B-CDs, as reference, allowed the obtaining of a wide range
tively inhibited by the addition of increasing concentrations of H2O2,
of colour variations which can be clearly detected by the naked eye.
while the 434 nm emission band of CDs was unaffected in the presence
This can be used to demonstrate the advantage of the ratiometric
of H2O2. Hence, the combination of both nanomaterials demonstrated
probes relatively to the single fluorescence quenching of the respective
to be a valuable approach for the ratiometric determination of H2O2,

Fig. 2. PL spectra (A and B) and the corre-


sponding photographs taken under 365 nm UV
lamp (C and D) of blue emitting CDs (I), orange
emitting QDs (II) and B-CDs/O-QDs (434/
587 nm) ratiometric probe in the CDs:QDs
proportions of 1:1 (III), 1:2.5 (IV), 1:4 (V) and
1:5 (VI). (For interpretation of the references to
colour in this figure legend, the reader is re-
ferred to the web version of this article.)

4
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

Fig. 3. (A) PL spectra of the dual-emission B-CDs/Y-QDs (434/560 nm) ratiometric probe during 360 min. (B) Fluorescence intensity ratio of the (434/560 nm)
ratiometric probe as a function of time (on logarithmic scale).

QDs Figs. S2(A) and S3(A) – Supplementary material). For each in- (FICD 434)
= 24.9 (± 0.4) × C + 0.94 (± 0.04)
dividual QDs the small slight colour changes associated with the in- (FIMPA 587)
crease of H2O2 concentration was much more difficult to perceive by
naked eye when they were assayed alone than when they were com- Where in (FICD434/FIMPA587) was the ratio between the fluorescence
bined with the CDs. In fact, the combination with the blue-emitting intensity obtained by CDs and CdTe QDs and C was the H2O2 con-
CDs, which exhibits a bright emission band at 434 nm, affords a re- centration. The obtained correlation coefficient was 0.9994 (n = 7)
ference colour that facilitates visual readout. Thus, the large separation which indicates good linearity. The detection limit calculated from the
between 434 and 560 nm and/or 434 nm and 587 nm emission peaks equation of the calibration curve according to Miller and Miller [47]
enables that colour changes caused by the addition of a small con- was about 0.00793% (w/w), far below the declared content of H2O2 in
centration of H2O2 could be easily discerned by the naked eye (Fig. 7). lens care solutions (3% (w/w)).
Moreover, the larger separation of the emission peaks of the B-CDs/
O-QDs combination probe (434/587 nm) relatively to the B-CDs/Y-QDs 3.3.2. Applicability in real samples
one (434/560 nm) makes it easier to detect a distinguishable colour Prior to the application with real samples, the selectivity of the
change from the background. Therefore, the B-CDs/O-QDs combined developed ratiometric fluorescent assay for the H2O2 determination in
system demonstrated to be a more efficient ratiometric probe for H2O2 lens care solutions was evaluated in the presence of excipients, such as,
because showed a more sensitive RGB-type visual read out as well as a sodium dihydrogen phosphate, sodium chloride and edetate disodium.
higher sensitivity in the PL detection of H2O2. For that reason, it was No influence on the analytical signal (FICD434/FIMPA587 variation
chosen for the further assays. ≤4%) was verified by the aforementioned compounds, which was ex-
pected considering the pronounced real sample dilution that had to be
performed before the analysis.
3.3. Analytical features and application
The applicability of the proposed ratiometric fluorescent assay was
assessed by applying it in the determination of H2O2 in commercially
Under the optimum conditions, the analytical performance of the
available lens care solutions and the obtained results were compared
ratiometric fluorescent assay for H2O2 detection was demonstrated
with those provided by the reference procedure recommended by the
through the evaluation of the linear working range, limit of detection,
European Pharmacopoeia [41].
precision and accuracy. Moreover, the influence of some possible in-
The results compiled in Table 1 show the good agreement between
terfering species was tested before application in real samples.
both procedures as the relative deviations were between –4.71 and
1.89%. The variance ratio F-test and a paired Student’s t-test was used
3.3.1. combination of both Y-QDs and O-QDs to evaluate precision and accuracy, respectively [47]. Regarding the
By conducting the analysis according to the optimized conditions, accuracy, the paired Student’s t-test confirmed no significant differ-
the fluorescence intensity ratio (FICD434/FIMPA587) showed a good ences between the proposed fluorometric assay and the reference pro-
linear relationship with the concentration of H2O2 in the range of cedure since the calculated value (t = 1.51) was lower than the critical
0.0100–0.2125% (w/w). The corresponding regression equation can be tabulated value (t = 2.57), for a confidence level of 95% (n = 6). In
expressed as: terms of precision, the variance ratio F-test also showed no significant

Fig. 4. (A) PL spectra of the dual-emission B-CDs/O-QDs (434/587 nm) ratiometric probe during 360 min. (B) Fluorescence intensity ratio of the (434/587 nm)
ratiometric probe as a function of time (on logarithmic scale).

5
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

Fig. 5. PL spectra (A) and the effect of the re-


action time on fluorescence intensity ratio
(FICD/FIMPA) (B) of the dual-emission B-CDs/O-
QDs (434/587 nm) ratiometric probe solution
upon the addition of a 0.0500% (w/w) H2O2.
Dashed line and solid line corresponds to the
fluorescence signal of the ratiometric probe in
the absence and presence of 0.0500% (w/w)
H2O2, respectively.

differences between the results obtained by both procedures


(Fcalculated = 1.28 and Ftabulated = 5.05, for a confidence level of 95%).
The assessment of the intramethod precision, through the repeated
analysis of each commercial lens care solutions, shown good repeat-
ability considering the calculated concentration ranges for a confidence
level of 95%.

3.3.3. RGB-visual determination of H2O2


As abovementioned, a B-CDs/O-QDs combined system provided a
more sensitive RGB-type visual read out for the quantification of H2O2.
Making use of a conventional UV lamp and a digital camera, images of
the standard solutions with a known concentration of H2O2 and real
sample were acquired without any special treatment for removing the
Fig. 7. Fluorescence images of B-CDs/Y-QDs (A) and B-CDs/O-QDs (B) ratio-
shade of the incident light (Fig. 8(A)). By decomposing the image on its
metric probes upon interaction with H2O2 at different concentrations levels. All
corresponding RGB channels, the intensity (between 0 and 255) at each photographs were taken under 365 nm UV lamp. (For interpretation of the re-
pixel of blue and red channels were extracted (Fig. S5 – Supplementary ferences to colour in this figure text, the reader is referred to the web version of
material). The ratio between the pixel intensity at blue and red channels this article.)
(Blue:Red channels), obtained by dividing at each pixel the intensities
on the blue and on the red channel, was suitable for the quantification.
precision, when compared with the same ratiometric probe quantified
In fact, a linear response was obtained between the average of the in-
by a conventional fluorometer (error between 0.09-0.44 vs. 0.04-0.09
tensity ratios and the concentration of H2O2 (Fig. 8(B)), which can be
for image-based and fluorometer-based detection, respectively).
expressed as Iblue/Ired = 13.26 ( ± 0.98) × [H2O2] + 0.27 ( ± 0.07)
Moreover, the accuracy of the RGB-visual detection was also worst as
(R = 0.9966, n = 9).
this method provided systematically lower values than those found with
The RGB-visual detection method shown worst intramethod

Fig. 6. PL spectra of B-CDs/Y-QDs (A) and B-CDs/O-QDs (B) combined probes upon the interaction with H2O2 at different concentrations. Linear relationship
between the fluorescence intensity ratios (FICD/FIMPA) and H2O2 concentration using B-CDs/Y-QDs (C) and B-CDs/O-QDs (D) ratiometric probes.

6
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

Table 1
Comparison of the analytical results obtained in the determination of H2O2 in commercial lens care solutions.
Sample Batch Declared amount (%, w/w) Amount found (%, w/w)a

Reference procedure Fluorometric assay R.D %b RGB-visual assay R.D %b

1 A 3 3.35 ± 0.02 3.26 ± 0.04 −2.85 3.08 ± 0.09 −8.12


B 3.34 ± 0.05 3.18 ± 0.08 −4.71 2.92 ± 0.44 −12.68
C 3.32 ± 0.02 3.33 ± 0.09 0.25 3.23 ± 0.32 −2.69
2 D 3 2.94 ± 0.04 2.92 ± 0.06 −0.78 2.80 ± 0.14 −4.87
E 2.92 ± 0.05 2.85 ± 0.04 −2.46 2.76 ± 0.24 −5.42
F 2.95 ± 0.02 3.01 ± 0.06 1.89 2.85 ± 0.29 −3.43

a
Mean ± t(0.05) (Student’s t-test)×(S/√n).
b
Relative deviation of the proposed ratiometric assay regarding the reference procedure.

the reference procedure. The modest precision and accuracy were at- as an alternative analytical tool for monitoring hydrogen peroxide in
tributed to the shadows resultant from the incident UV light (darker household cleaning samples. In comparison with the reference method,
areas on the RGB-type image, Fig. 8A). Nevertheless, the image pro- the H2O2 titrimetric method preconized by European Pharmacopoeia,
cessing-based method do not require special equipment and provided the proposed ratiometric assays allowed to circumvent the operational
an expeditious procedure suitable for a semi-quantitative detection of errors associated with the visual detection of the titration end-point. In
H2O2. comparison with the other QD-based fluorometric methods, the
straightforward nature of our method provides a simpler method when
compared with indirect sensing schemes [21,22], and the ratiometric
4. Conclusions nature of the present method provides a more robust method when
compared with direct sensing schemes based on a single fluorophore
A dual-emission CDs/QDs combined system was successfully de- [18–20], due to the minimization of the variations in excitation source,
veloped for the ratiometric detection of hydrogen peroxide. The addi- in the probe concentration, and in the emission readout. As the emis-
tion of H2O2 to the combined probe solution induced the depassivation sion readout is not focused into a single fluorophore, the analytical
of the MPA-CdTe QDs, decreasing its PL emission (587 nm) while the PL figures of merits of this method, namely LOD and linearity range, were
of the blue-emitting CDs (434 nm) remained constant (reference) due to not as great as other reported methods. Nevertheless, the limitations did
its chemical inertness towards the analyte. This ratiometric probe was not hamper the application of our method as the LOD (0.00793% (w/
successfully applied in the development of ratiometric fluorescent assay w)) was far below the declared content of the real sample (3% (w/w)).
for H2O2 determination in lens care solutions since sensitive, selective, Together with the use of the combined probe for the quantification of
accurate and precise results were obtained which could be considered

Fig. 8. A) RGB-type image and Blue:Red-type image of standards with known concentration of H2O2 and samples. B) Calibration curve for the RGB-visual assay. (For
interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)

7
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

H2O2 by measuring the ratiometric fluorescence intensity, the visual J.A.V. Prior, et al., Application of quantum dots as analytical tools in automated
detection of the analyte was also accomplished. In fact, the interaction chemical analysis: a review, Anal. Chim. Acta 735 (2012) 9–22.
[16] S.S.M. Rodrigues, D.R. Prieto, D.S.M. Ribeiro, E. Barrado, J.A.V. Prior,
between H2O2 and the dual-emission CDs/QDs probe can be surveyed J.L.M. Santos, Competitive metal–ligand binding between CdTe quantum dots and
by means of the significant colour variation of the emitted photo- EDTA for free Ca2+ determination, Talanta 134 (2015) 173–182.
luminescence. Despite not having such good results in terms of accuracy [17] S.S.M. Rodrigues, Z. Oleksiak, D.S.M. Ribeiro, E. Poboży, M. Trojanowicz,
J.A.V. Prior, et al., Selective determination of sulphide based on photoluminescence
and precision as in the fluorometric assay, it was demonstrated that the quenching of MPA-capped CdTe nanocrystals by exploiting a gas-diffusion multi-
proposed RGB-visual methodology can be used efficiently for semi- pumping flow method, Anal. Methods 6 (2014) 7956–7966.
quantitative detection of H2O2. In fact, the combination of the mini- [18] H. Lim, D. Kim Hai, J. Kim, Fluorescence quenching of dendrimer‐encapsulated CdS
quantum dots for the detection of H2O2, Bull. Korean Chem. Soc. 37 (2016)
mization of the detrimental factors associated with the use of a single 254–257.
fluorophore with the RGB-visual detection enables the development of [19] Y.L. Zeng, Y.J. Wang, Z.H. Su, C.R. Tang, Determination of hydrogen peroxide re-
spot test analysis which provides the additional advantages of minimize sidue in food using CdS quantum dots as fluorescence probes, Adv. Mat. Res. 455-
456 (2012) 1189–1194.
the reagents consumption, reduce the waste generation, and increase
[20] Y. Gao, G. Wang, H. Huang, J. Hu, S.M. Shah, X. Su, Fluorometric method for the
the sample throughput. determination of hydrogen peroxide and glucose with Fe3O4 as catalyst, Talanta 85
(2011) 1075–1080.
Acknowledgments [21] S.S.M. Rodrigues, D.S.M. Ribeiro, L. Molina-Garcia, A. Ruiz Medina, J.A.V. Prior,
J.L.M. Santos, Fluorescence enhancement of CdTe MPA-capped quantum dots by
glutathione for hydrogen peroxide determination, Talanta 122 (2014) 157–165.
David S.M. Ribeiro thanks FCT (Fundação para a Ciência e [22] T. Gong, J. Liu, Y. Wu, Y. Xiao, X. Wang, S. Yuan, Fluorescence enhancement of
Tecnologia) and POPH (Programa Operacional Potencial Humano) for CdTe quantum dots by HBcAb-HRP for sensitive detection of H2O2 in human
serum, Biosens. Bioelectron. 92 (2017) 16–20.
his Post-Doc grant ref. SFRH/BPD/104638/2014. José X. Soares thanks [23] H. Xie, J. Dong, J. Duan, G.I.N. Waterhouse, J. Hou, S. Ai, Visual and ratiometric
FCT (Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia) and POPH (Programa fluorescence detection of Hg2+ based on a dual-emission carbon dots-gold na-
Operacional Potencial Humano) for his Ph.D. grant Ref. SFRH/BD/ noclusters nanohybrid, Sens. Actuators B Chem. 259 (2018) 1082–1089.
[24] Y. Ma, Y. Chen, J. Liu, Y. Han, S. Ma, X. Chen, Ratiometric fluorescent detection of
98105/2013, and also the Biotech Health Programme (Doctoral chromium(VI) in real samples based on dual emissive carbon dots, Talanta 185
Programme on Cellular and Molecular Biotechnology Applied to Health (2018) 249–257.
Sciences), Reference PD/00016/2012. Authors are grateful for the re- [25] F. Ghasemi, M.R. Hormozi-Nezhad, M. Mahmoudi, A new strategy to design colorful
ratiometric probes and its application to fluorescent detection of Hg(II), Sens.
search grant supported by European Union (FEDER funds POCI/01/ Actuators B Chem. 259 (2018) 894–899.
0145/ FEDER/007265) and financing from National Funds (FCT/MEC, [26] Q. Song, Y. Ma, X. Wang, T. Tang, Y. Song, Y. Ma, et al., “On-off-on” fluorescent
Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia and Ministério da Educação e system for detection of Zn2+ in biological samples using quantum dots-carbon dots
ratiometric nanosensor, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 516 (2018) 522–528.
Ciência) under the Partnership Agreement PT2020UID/QUI/50006/
[27] Y. Wang, C. Zhang, X. Chen, B. Yang, L. Yang, C. Jiang, et al., Ratiometric fluor-
2013. Financing from Programa INTERREG V A Espanha Portugal escent paper sensor utilizing hybrid carbon dots-quantum dots for the visual de-
(POCTEP) under the project FOODSENS is greatly appreciated. termination of copper ions, Nanoscale 8 (2016) 5977–5984.
[28] Q. Mu, Y. Li, H. Xu, Y. Ma, W. Zhu, X. Zhong, Quantum dots-based ratiometric
fluorescence probe for mercuric ions in biological fluids, Talanta 119 (2014)
Appendix A. Supplementary data 564–571.
[29] J. Yao, K. Zhang, H. Zhu, F. Ma, M. Sun, H. Yu, et al., Efficient ratiometric fluor-
Supplementary material related to this article can be found, in the escence probe based on dual-emission quantum dots hybrid for on-site determina-
tion of copper ions, Anal. Chem. 85 (2013) 6461–6468.
online version, at doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.snb.2019.126665. [30] Z. Houjuan, Z. Wen, Z. Kui, W. Suhua, Dual-emission of a fluorescent graphene
oxide–quantum dot nanohybrid for sensitive and selective visual sensor applica-
References tions based on ratiometric fluorescence, Nanotechnology 23 (2012) 315502.
[31] N. Chang, Y. Lu, J. Mao, J. Yang, M. Li, S. Zhang, et al., Ratiometric fluorescence
sensor arrays based on quantum dots for detection of proteins, Analyst 141 (2016)
[1] J.M. Sharon, R. Allanou, K. Ascheberger, F. Berthault, J.D. Bruijn, C. Musset, et al., 2046–2052.
European Union Risk Assessment Report. Hydrogen Peroxide, (2003), pp. 1–258. [32] H. Zhai, T. Feng, L. Dong, L. Wang, X. Wang, H. Liu, et al., Development of dual-
[2] Y. Okamoto, S. Inamasu, T. Kinoshita, Fluorometric determination of hydrogen emission ratiometric probe-based on fluorescent silica nanoparticle and CdTe
peroxide with 4-amino-1H-1, 5-benzodiazepine-3-carbonitrile hydrochloride, quantum dots for determination of glucose in beverages and human body fluids,
Chem. Pharm. Bull. 28 (1980) 2325–2328. Food Chem. 204 (2016) 444–452.
[3] H. Hwang, P.K. Dasgupta, Fluorimetric determination of trace hydrogen peroxide in [33] T. Hao, X. Wei, Y. Nie, Y. Xu, K. Lu, Y. Yan, et al., Surface modification and ra-
water with a flow injection system, Anal. Chim. Acta 170 (1985) 347–352. tiometric fluorescence dual function enhancement for visual and fluorescent de-
[4] N. Jie, J. Yang, X. Huang, R. Zhang, Z. Song, Fluorimetric determination of hy- tection of glucose based on dual-emission quantum dots hybrid, Sens. Actuators B
drogen peroxide in water using acetaminophen, Talanta 42 (1995) 1575–1579. Chem. 230 (2016) 70–76.
[5] B. Paital, A modified fluorimetric method for determination of hydrogen peroxide [34] L. Chen, L. Sun, J. Zheng, J. Dai, Y. Wu, X. Dai, et al., Dual-emission ratiometric
using homovanillic acid oxidation principle, Biomed Res. Int. 2014 (2014) 8. fluorescence detection of aspirin in human saliva: onsite naked-eye detection and
[6] C. Scaramboni, C.P. Crispim, J.C. Toledo, M.L.A.M. Campos, Investigating hydrogen high stability, New J. Chem. 41 (2017) 14551–14556.
peroxide in rainwater of a typical midsized city in tropical Brazil using a novel [35] J. Qian, M. Hua, C. Wang, K. Wang, Q. Liu, N. Hao, et al., Fabrication of l-cysteine-
application of a fluorometric method, Atmos. Environ. 176 (2018) 201–208. capped CdTe quantum dots based ratiometric fluorescence nanosensor for onsite
[7] M.E. Abbas, W. Luo, L. Zhu, J. Zou, H. Tang, Fluorometric determination of hy- visual determination of trace TNT explosive, Anal. Chim. Acta 946 (2016) 80–87.
drogen peroxide in milk by using a Fenton reaction system, Food Chem. 120 (2010) [36] Y. Sun, X. Mao, L. Luo, D. Tian, H. Li, Calix[4]arene triazole-linked pyrene: click
327–331. synthesis, assembly on graphene oxide, and highly sensitive carbaryl sensing in
[8] T.R. Holm, G.K. George, M.J. Barcelona, Fluorometric determination of hydrogen serum, Org. Biomol. Chem. 13 (2015) 9294–9299.
peroxide in groundwater, Anal. Chem. 59 (1987) 582–586. [37] G. Nsengiyuma, R. Hu, J. Li, H. Li, D. Tian, Self-assembly of 1,3-alternate calix[4]
[9] M. Wu, T.G. Wong, Y.-C. Wu, The Scopoletin-HRP fluorimetric determination of arene carboxyl acids-modified silver nanoparticles for colorimetric Cu2+ sensing,
H2O2 in seawaters—a plea for the two-stage protocol, Methods Protoc. 1 (2017). Sens. Actuators B Chem. 236 (2016) 675–681.
[10] L.-S. Zhang, G.T.F. Wong, Optimal conditions and sample storage for the determi- [38] Z. Chen, Y. Lin, X. Ma, L. Guo, B. Qiu, G. Chen, et al., Multicolor biosensor for fish
nation of H2O2 in marine waters by the scopoletin–horseradish peroxidase freshness assessment with the naked eye, Sens. Actuators B Chem. 252 (2017)
fluorometric method, Talanta 48 (1999) 1031–1038. 201–208.
[11] W. Donahue, Interference in fluorometric hydrogen peroxide determination using [39] H. Xia, J. Hu, J. Tang, K. Xu, X. Hou, P. Wu, A RGB-type quantum dot-based sensor
scopoletin–horseradish peroxidase, Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 17 (1998) 783–787. array for sensitive visual detection of trace formaldehyde in air, Sci. Rep. 6 (2016)
[12] H. Chen, H. Yu, Y. Zhou, L. Wang, Fluorescent quenching method for determination 36794.
of trace hydrogen peroxide in rain water, Spectrochim. Acta A. 67 (2007) 683–686. [40] D.S.M. Ribeiro, G.C.S. de Souza, A. Melo, J.X. Soares, S.S.M. Rodrigues,
[13] M. Onoda, T. Uchiyama, K.-i. Mawatari, K. Kaneko, K. Nakagomi, Simple and rapid A.N. Araújo, et al., Synthesis of distinctly thiol-capped CdTe quantum dots under
determination of hydrogen peroxide using phosphine-based fluorescent reagents microwave heating: multivariate optimization and characterization, J. Mater. Sci.
with sodium tungstate dihydrate, Anal. Sci. 22 (2006) 815–817. 52 (2017) 3208–3224.
[14] S.S.M. Rodrigues, D.S.M. Ribeiro, J.X. Soares, M.L.C. Passos, M.L.M.F.S. Saraiva, [41] E. Council of, C. European Pharmacopoeia, M. European Directorate for the Quality
J.L.M. Santos, Application of nanocrystalline CdTe quantum dots in chemical of, Healthcare, European pharmacopoeia, European Directorate for the Quality of
analysis: Implementation of chemo-sensing schemes based on analyte-triggered Medicines and Healthcare, Council Of Europe, Strasbourg, 2010.
photoluminescence modulation, Coord. Chem. Rev. 330 (2017) 127–143. [42] N.E. Azmi, N.I. Ramli, J. Abdullah, M.A. Abdul Hamid, H. Sidek, S. Abd Rahman,
[15] C. Frigerio, D.S.M. Ribeiro, S.S.M. Rodrigues, V.L.R.G. Abreu, J.A.C. Barbosa, et al., A simple and sensitive fluorescence based biosensor for the determination of

8
R.C. Castro, et al. Sensors & Actuators: B. Chemical 296 (2019) 126665

uric acid using H2O2-sensitive quantum dots/dual enzymes, Biosens. Bioelectron. David S. M. Ribeiro is a Researcher at REQUIMTE (LAVQ) Associate Laboratory, Faculty
67 (2015) 129–133. of Pharmacy, University of Porto. He obtained his PhD degree in Pharmaceutical Sciences,
[43] D. Jin, M.-H. Seo, B.T. Huy, Q.-T. Pham, M.L. Conte, D. Thangadurai, et al., speciality in Analytical Chemistry (2012) and MSc degree in Analytical Chemistry –
Quantitative determination of uric acid using CdTe nanoparticles as fluorescence Quality Control (2007) from Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Porto. He is carrying out
probes, Biosens. Bioelectron. 77 (2016) 359–365. research on the development of new analytical methodologies combining the sensitivity
[44] Y. Li, B. Li, J. Zhang, H2O2‐ and pH‐sensitive CdTe quantum dots as fluorescence offered by nanomaterials, as quantum dots, and the versatility, low cost and portability of
probes for the detection of glucose, Luminescence 28 (2012) 667–672. flow-based analytical techniques for chemical analysis.
[45] L. Jing, S.V. Kershaw, Y. Li, X. Huang, Y. Li, A.L. Rogach, et al., Aqueous based
semiconductor nanocrystals, Chem. Rev. 116 (2016) 10623–10730. José X. Soares is a PhD student at REQUIMTE (LAVQ) Associate Laboratory, Faculty of
[46] Y. Zhang, J. He, P.-N. Wang, J.-Y. Chen, Z.-J. Lu, D.-R. Lu, et al., Time-dependent Pharmacy, University of Porto. He obtained his MSc degree Pharmaceutical Sciences from
photoluminescence blue shift of the quantum dots in living cells: effect of oxidation Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Porto in 2011. He is carrying out research on the
by singlet oxygen, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128 (2006) 13396–13401. synthesis of carbon based nanoparticles and semiconductors quantum dots.
[47] J.N. Miller, J.C. Miller, Statistics and Chemometrics for Analytical Chemistry, 6th
ed., Prentice Hall/Pearson, England, 2010. João L.M. Santos is Auxiliary Professor at the Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Porto,
and research scientist at REQUIMTE Associate Laboratory. He received his PhD in
Rafael C. Castro is currently a junior researcher and student in Faculty of Pharmacy of Analytical Chemistry in 2000. His research activities have been focused in the develop-
the University of Porto. His research interest is focused on the synthesis of nanomaterials ment of automated flow-based methodologies, mainly multicommutation, multipumping
and its application on chemical analysis. and single reaction interface flow systems. His current interests include nanotechnology
and nanomaterials, namely quantum dots and metallic nanoparticles for photo-
luminescent detection and nanodiagnostics.

You might also like