Method of assessment of compensation for injuries Need toavold ad hocism and arbitrariness im the matter of ‘compensation for njries Ie te noesary 16 ward off arteries and ad hac inthe mannar of assessment of compensaon for jute. the eae & made under Seb 2, ‘der scion 165 thre so maou, soe te varous hed im fare sabitrty proved and there i no scope for prewccaton Baan, the Injury rests in pivation of organs, the ele provided under the Workmen's Compensation At for asessment of pereentage of las of eaning powers « ‘004 guile for tha Trounal a folow. The conuson s wort confounded ony, ‘ahen the assessment fe mace by 9 doce, sy, esting shortening ft ‘fer an ny or sical vedio of race, when ther aun of trate and the datity asssied ia terms of percentage. Whan a doctor sseses dab, he nvarbly assesses functional sabi ofthe potuar forgn hate affected, Tie urderstaod on several acon 3k equaent to los of ening apacy ard the mutipir Is apie by work out the Decentage of dsbty onthe total nara hop tao the percentage of tors of earning power. Where mute 5 rot apple, some courts make 2 ‘eadynade applcnon off 1000 to 82000 for every percentage of isity surerea. sis wy an unssteer metnd of aeterminng compensation, Meads of lan injury cases nal cident clsimerlting to nuit, tere ae Bray te age eats oF clans ws, peanaey and nom pecaniry damages. The pecan dbmages are Invalyeeven thug docimertary even. tha tuna hal therfore ‘oi! arbitaness by merely conjctrng damages ad lok for evidence Pic bythe canon. The folowing re he pecan heeds of aims: ass ‘come anspor spt 8) Atensonteharges; fy) Diet nd nuttin nd Mesa oxpenses. The tuna shal eat athe tal athe above heeds Correct ra rear ae pose ard shall ot venture an sown esiration Without base, The rocioeof adding some amourts over and above the Inedcal bis on = wile staternant tht all bile coud not Rave Bean mode rail as juteaton for ming father eadions shall bet all mes elie Subjective componentin non-pecuniary heads, caus for arbitrariness The nonrpacaniary heads are) pai and stern (loss of amenities of te: (i ers ue to reduction in expectation af fe (i loss of eospects of maape nd (oso ein apa. Hee, whatever amunts are detemined they fe ad hoc ant sear grvate to cerita. For the same rarer the flainen’ssattacon quotient fs lw and there 5 ainays 2 clmour for Amounts sugested and the basis 2 Poin and suering1 Inthe matter of determination of pein ed sera. there shay any ulanc of how sabe determipad The Soh 2 caps thea oR. 500 for sevous ries ad 05.100 fo now-pevoUs ures Having reget the ‘oct that the Schaal os ean 2 decaes tock and there hasbeen 8 al salue of moray, woul ropes the amount to Be 7500 forever Eee Injury esting ie face of in, R700 fo oe of oath an 2500 for ‘very adtonal tot and 2500 for ranievous ir. For hed ny, resting in facture of cranium, the amount culd be 955,00. Suppose 3 pesan has facture ofthe upper fnb and anther acu of ower ib, the amages due to pan an suring may provide For RS15,00. Hf there sa fracture ofl andabasnsin the rest of the Body, damages othe tune of 510,000 could be proved fo. actu rece by sla inteseton, bn aditiona amon 8:00 forthe trauma for operon msy be proved for, Surg reduction % the medem substitute for connate ines! !maragement fo sorten the span of seg but it as other droubacs he espitaiatin, securing attendants, rik due to anoesthes, adtonat dug intakes, ture hosianon and atonal erences: and hence the provon foc tlatvelys higher sum fr pin rl seri to surgical ntervention. ‘must be remenered thatthe Wormers Compensation et proves 2 hed sur onthe bass of fearing capac anda mulpeton tough a acor ‘roid under the Sele tthe At secre sn thet sly ger ten the ranciequvalent othe actual os sine the Act makes prowson for Separately foros of come and medal agenses howe ofamenition of te 1+ Los of amentis of fe another smite ead thai subjective and our tempt must terafoe Beto prove for some amount whieh deprives 3 person of Ns fee movement and foe. A human being ino machine. Fmwsament nd entertainment 246 necessary spice to lie. A peson hanaeapped to alto un o gallop at hs wi 9 person ciple Js tn body but in ind a spt wel. A pertan that cannot ide on ato wheter or dive Ne vehie fetes ht mbilty and becomes dependent on eters for fis fee ambustion. A prion tat conto to Bed draws sympthy fom ‘thes ad becomes 2 burden on other Depending onthe preity ofthe nary ‘nd what preonconnot or hr person Recomes dependant on others oF ‘ny form of epriation of mater pesures sal become relevant. To a il ‘hat is young and ano geeon, the yard arma be he same. The sale has tobe ona descending erent and oul ange betwoen 100000 to 25,000, Agi he quant aso be diferent for prvation of nd ha eee, perceptions may change. AT to judge what causes greater sbi. lose a awar in affects mobity ane ence my view, a greater mount Asnthunion a race shorten fin by afew ems, orinches have but cosmetic value and te compensation fas to be modest end raazorable, Te cattty may elter be permanent or temporary. For ‘permanent cet, whch capabie of ascertainment in ems of percentage ff funcional csbity ofthe para organ ofthe boy that feted, the mount cout be Re3000 for every % of permanent aby ar 250 for very of trgorry bly ‘+ Disability assessment. as por government guidelines 2‘+ Imacases esting ingrivous nies that include fractures that futher et In dsslement, temporary or parmanent there f3 pret to simply exept whtover the doctorates. Thee early ever any ere exarinatin the tsb assessment tome doctor, except a suggestion that is eseesment high er important to know how the assessment Is made end what the perentage of dabty signer In order to review the gels for aluavon of various asabines and procedure for eetifeaion and to recommend approptte mocfieton/sarztons, commie was setup in 1985 by the Government of nda, Ministry of Soc sie & Epowsrment under the Chaiemastip, OGHS, GO with subcormitce, one each in the ae ‘of Kemal Retardation, Loconeto/Onhopoed,Visil and Speech & Hearing dusty, Mer eoveidring the reports of commie, heeping In view the ovisns of Persons with Dsailtes (ql oppornts, Protection of ts and Full paication) Act 1995, guldles for evaketon of folowing ‘dzoies ondprocedare for certiston war notified vide, The Gate ot ni era erie Pat Section 3, sted 13, une 200 for 2. Visual parent 2 Locomotor / Orthoped Diaby 5 Speech na eng Dsty antl Retréton| 5. mutt Osis ‘+ tn the gues the functional (peamanent psa inpatrent or FP eto angel, pst daree of trauma hove been evshated. Tis i commony Interpreted 0 say woh not, nse tens. ease of leo motor orator, troy, Ue Uouy han hee hed pe oe frank In perl, the funeion of one part cannot be repleed by other, ‘hoefre each anton partie Kelis 100s and this los ont PP of {tat pate akon ae TOON. On te other han, the whole Body wala cannot ‘xed 10%. Thus in caste imalmentIssaenn more than one function or boo part the mathemteal sum may exces 100 bu tal of bedndiuat ‘hrnoteceed 100% Ths etal one oral segment of bod canna enced 00% in any station. +The gdsines sal be spl for determing the of danlity.fadocr or {nec ard makes an aero there sl be no mst Seeing the same, prima fe. Howser the asassent Is doubted ls neces) to troseveriy withthe mode ef assessment prescribed unr tho gules. Brody necasory to brow thatthe inary 2 upper ib assessed us + Upper nb assessment Upper Lis i I 1 em Component and component I Monit (cane ocd (hheton Gsanaton | + omen ep suTay horgopsor + costae © secatonn 1 {) The vale of maximum range of matin (RON nthe ar components 0% Eich ofthe three Jos of the am (Shuler, elbow and ws) weighed quay, Le, 30% oF 03D. Ts col be undestod trouph an isration. A {recreate it shoulder may affect ROM so that active abduction about, ‘Sto ew eway trom te medline of the body rede to say, 9 is Dost to take ths arm teow dour rom alone the ie to touch ‘he ear by abducting It 20" The relative Iss fs SOM ofits ea, at terms ofthe aun component, the 5 of los shall be SOX 030 » 28% toss oF ‘motion forthe stm cmpatent more than ane lt Iwate same ‘ethos ppd andthe tse in ach the feta jot are a6. ho lar of abueton of the soe 6D, ss af extension of wrt as opposed to bending, tending mens sraghieig. Mealy, dey afe sefered ‘espace psimgefesion and dor eso) 0, tan the ss fang of ‘motion for the ar (680.0) + (43030) = 30%. (i) the strengt of muscles cou be teste by manual esting ee 0 rag. = 2 coal pars) $5 sow eer of contratn ont) 1 = Gan ipower detected wnen gry Is exceed, Ke, when the am ‘mover aweys end nol upars agaist gravy) + ox movement agains force of wavy but not aaast examiner's ‘esiaea) = zok nial weakness) 2 Getseratevereh) “Te mean percentage af mus strength loss multiple by 030. ter has beens os ot mute teh ote Ut ue J he voles or ade as as been dered foros of RON. {ai Pencles of evslutlon ofc ordinate ates shal be 1 The toa val forco-ornate ates SOR cach acy has value of 9% {Combing the valves forthe arm component: ‘Ie aie of ae of fneon af am eamponentsobtaned by combining the vss of ROM, muse strength ond co-ordinated actos sng the °0 + Thetotaaiue of and eomgonent is 0%. 2 Tae pungples of evr tan of prebersion nse: 2 Qpoeaian (ER) texted asin Ingen ger (2), mide Hnger (2h, ig re) an le ger 28, ‘+ Lateral ch 8) etd by aking the patient to oll ey. 1 yk araup (Os) ested for (are jets (38) ab smaty oe sage sie (8) "sphere ra (6) testa for ole objet sw (and sat bet se 3) Hook sp (8 teste by asking te patent to Bo. + rns ofeainton of seston: "Trl value of sensation 30% indo 1. Ral side of tam (9% tt i the outer i), 2, Una side of hum (1.2% thats the Inner te), 3 ral ie of ach res.) and ar ie of each finger (1.36) Tle valve of srngth is 30% 1 nce, 3. ip $tength (20%, 2 Pen stent 0S). 1% atonal weghag to 4be sven to the fllowing factors vie, 1 nfestion; 2. Deformity, 3 Ma linet; 4. Contracture: 5. Abonermal maby (hen person hs “vod hang, fr vamp 6 Dominant extremity (en depending ‘nth kf stent + Combi aie of se Rand component shal mean the fal vale or loss ‘ot futon of hand comporent stained by summing up o lose of Prcherslo,snston and tena, + ning the formula mentoned In the preceding eaagraph, the % of ‘Geabty fr the combined ann aa band components coud be ‘aleultes. the inparet ofthe arm iso 27% an impamen of {he hand 0 th come vale "2719058, 64a = 7. wher 4 ste higher vac and 27 the so + Lower tind assessment ‘+ The lower exremity 5 died ino mobity component and. stably ‘omponent. Moblty component ius rang of movement and muscle Seng To put Rarely, = ssbity i 1 forge of movement Muscle strerath {Te value of maximum ROM nthe dit component 0%. Each ‘ofthe 3 ons, Le, hip, kee, footne welghes equal a 30% oF (020: foremmple sacs of the ight hip lets rane of melon, s0 that acveabsuclon 27" agai the abduton of 5° fund or the Tet tip. Thre 85 reltve los of abducton. The 6 of ass of ray components SOX 30-15%. more than ene ort sated, the sae method 3 app above ape and the loses each of ‘the affected nt re added, For examps the loss of aon of thehipis 6% anes of tension 4 the ato 20M For maby ‘eomponent (De 30) |60%0.20)-30% (Prine of evalatin of muscle strength consists of. Taking the ‘alue for muscle stengh ithe eto be 90% and 2, Tare the ‘rong of muscle tested by mana esting ke O10 redng ated. 100% ‘rile 80% Gade? Grades 408 Grades 208 “The mean of mas stength 5st mutpie by 0.0. there ar been» os of marc svengt of more than one Ji he valoes te edded ws deserved for OM. (i combining vie of matey component. Suppose an nua has Stace ofthe rt fp oi and hs oon to. 16% loss of frat, e% lee of strength muss, combining the valle, the 90-15) en (in Pipe ot euluing the etait component consists of aing the 5totalvalue as 50m and testes on snl method nl fn mathos + Trowmauc and non-traumatilesions Ccervlspnetacures are sested on th bas of eatin of verabat omprestion, again Inolemnent of poser eran nave root ‘ovohement of posterior elemants and moderate neck ry. Thay a sessed by Xray examina and Wend surly. Caria intervertebral (sc doco thrad ad dors umbar spine acttesresutign acute pan, arpleg,vertebral eompresion surg in severe ain, neurogenic ow back {ie injrisresling in lovers pain ae aiesed on sale f to 100% ‘without the accompaniment of ay compression, fractures oF fons, hee auld be perstent muscle spa stiess of spine wth mid, moderate 0 ‘Severe odo changer fe sesedintherange a 010308. tiney of sal iy ofassessment + Assessment of compensation for pan In he manner of zation of pana slferg, the sbi assessed wi ‘be a god guide to know bow the pata injury tects perfomance Inthe ‘workplace and sewer Head inhry or spol injry are sometines, ‘pressive ap lend ofthe complains te paps, numbess, acute pal apd spams. There i 4 ned to know the ral steer from 2 malngeret Epes evince though a doctor wl lp the tbunl i determining the approprateresgonse to rayerfor compensation. 1+ Tronsloing sail int lss of earning power _Alinjutis ad assessment of isbity donot impact the een caps; nor {a ina way. The asaity hs tobe sean Inthe corer ofthe pstaar ‘ezupaton er cag hat te ver engaged. For sane, a aon oF ‘roctreinthelouer mba siless othe ne for profesional ever of ‘motor vei may complly nk uit ob ede, dort of ond eo afc» carpet ferent han now maybe revo fr, {telephone operator. The ater a the whl sa aways be toa how the futur perantgs of dsb hat atc the job thatthe person was og and Int sabe forthe Some jp, to what other typeof employment ‘al or she Is for, nth hanged cemstnces and what al 0 be the los of income. th the pang of Persons th Disbies (ual ‘Operate, Potton of Rghe end Ful Pareto) Se, 195, a eran ‘may conten sh sre eleven, natthstanng such Bsbity ut the {tartan of los of enrang capt wil st be rlevant to Know the “mplyabity of the parson open mare with the pater dab mist be ated oth tha Workers Compensation Act andthe MMV Act ws the ‘Shoes le fearing capac dare fom db pe ean without ‘hokng ference tothe sean sesdene athe exper option ofa Jor, {Ril be ary to singly to the of cby 9 af ss of earning ‘apnety. 8 Tribal assesses compensation at 2 fed sum for every of ‘Sealy, wil rutin overaping fans if sessment of ss of eating ‘apy ie ndependelysuesnd. Tere ae certain feent decison ofthe Supreme Court ta, whee the of abi assessed has been taken a: syonymeds th oss fearing power, butt mest be assumed tat he ‘hurt took the wae of fay fo Be the sme as of eating pow, faving end to te spac facts ni creumtancs When the Is fete power ond crmpesation are determines, fr notrecssry to make 3 eduction for personal eapeses, ar we 0, fr determing Gependeney fo Clans rfl accidents. The reason bows Oe camart save tO Fectv the whole os fine in ur cae ad this pina has ao Been ‘ecognted in ret srnce Co Ram Prasad (20082 SEC 7,tare medical expenses The question of proving for future mudeal expense was spect deat with by the Supreme Court Nogappe v Gurutoel Singh when observed thatthe MV Act doesnot provide for further award ater afl award ie ase Therefore ina ese wher injury toa vet requires parcel mea ‘rps, rch award cannot psec previous award cannot be reviewed, when mea! exons are nued after alton of he avers Hence, te iy alternative that atthe time of psig offal ard th buat souls ons such event and determine cmpersation szordney. tf moet sesabie tat the Tul els fem the doctor ims i fate medial tweaonant shal be necessary andthe hey expenses. Preperation ofa template Ie wi be worth w prepare a template to answer every head of cin specticaly, while tering compassion for inure. shal be necessary for the Trbina to el evidence on eath oF the heads ad not nde In “onacures for pecuniary damages: an for non-pecuniary damages, take & ‘orm aprouch oe apple or every cse del th by. woul propose | rough estimate in each ease, sro Els theorem to remain nmutabe for al times to come, The Tsuna may examine lol enon an pevosealy Update them to conform to what ae opropit. Aga, the fs given sais each head are Imag and spe evdenee shal be secured foreach ‘ofthe pecuniary head of, Pecuon domo 7 ose ofincome 2 ‘Tensport te espa 3 Ascendo (8 750/menth 4 Dit natton 200 5 Medial exgenses otal charges 200 sugery soo Medines 0 Fuuremedicalepenses = an &Siferng Fer ractre 7900 7 Per surgery 15,000 7 Los ofamenises ite case ofamputatin ‘ona tee 140000 ord 75,000, eat up 75000 ane So,000 Sensor eizon oe/ Hand 25,000, 5 tos of prospects of arg 25000 {Oisaty ha eases os Ferrin, tforesnpe, ma-union of ctr at [empath normal funciona the ° (raids organ 7Fuca sity Percent 1000 (sbi tar coucestssot eaming power ‘Metlorrf income Matiser Lost ening compensation for loss of aman provided for amputation, comapenstion for isaby fe uncon os nw not be separately ried, oe of meni need rot be restrtd only to amputees. The sad hed ofc could be awarded aan ‘eases of funtion daily of agi, depending on how they may affect the ualty of lle The templates oni tow attention othe partes te tat theese be ‘idence gist each ead before anyane can exec stable ral fr nes.ua TN RO NUON RE UT RT OA P| TS A, CERT DORON ara aN AT Sos a a wor “io MoH NWS USN HoaepIN2H) TSS STS TT TTTeran oman ahs ple ues 2 jo spodsaen an, Buu JC “iio pO RTA WHS Tea (0252 sp sz pale voRS 0 oP) ERIE eaEINW oy As EN eueAS|_eLSe ISTO UH Tanda napomy 98395 str] few SRS aN WOT ADIA|_OGEIEE (eT ERG 35GB x SUBTEST 65 Se SOREN NOS MOTE TID, BELTS TH TEC)) —S 15 ae ate ae BET sR 1 SPE {Gia wa i amo sass aie 06v See ap, oa a oolTFS VERO TORT] TALI TEE] Fp sie “sian ee poo ecg ats eset pa aN Sag pe wns barnses| tet osin iia) 6 ‘ampere = Pee eT ETD = ry e802 J ueSupe UD APsBU 3q OU Fe UORESUSCIEDo wranesy| Buea ayaa M URITONABORD weaieee iewsaaae a SaEUEp ‘BY oj 955 Us Aue aj Uno BBeLIESpOaT a aa a CORES ennui deni ator ain — rapa arcs ve teee| aint Wamtaea”in| — eeL SDs eTROOE, FE iacecoppeo| 9305 (e00u| oF Brongn] — 9305 Luo02l 6 awous ain] — 665305 Seat] Tedjoveysiog ain} st 205 cla] L fanaa in| sep2086 029 ~ HUAN, S030 ¢ (62S ‘aura MAIS Nev DOSTIB|— oyeisy nn —eza a6 TTeOSE ‘us ou Ain| ewe owsoae HEHE nora EN, Ty SSSTTETCD, ag ouaTTBuopeR| —TeLIET (ete ~ 35 Bassaispuo Bu) | yeah waning waning SELES LT | aio spear wonders ued ewe ‘sayuBaUIOy souorTFU] JO S95URTIO‘ang SINS — BT 3558 TOE ixAavopunog| —B6etGa6t WY bus wens EIA Fa poe a an Pin 63 sass oa fain) ar iis opowia nn] eve'aa80 uae = as woven | ~TSEDISE i |ea ac pa ee aD Eas Tu iE 3 Baa ATA “uy a aE 0 aves | ‘ous mpaaty | may Toa Bed 33S LE) Sap Tees MOK Napa] — aTVR TITS ‘iapoo fy vanaa 410) ETE DSE TE TTC ee e002 as owuien | eesbettecet| jana eR ove 355 eG ~~ inj voataeG sows us vos pan mu, von, ~ SSATP pe S59pO URED EUIUHD FO HENTORE RSS EROT TPTEENATT] aS SR EDR TAY WA PO UTE REY aaa oT aD eH PEED aeegnToMBI'ST| Toa A RPE BE FEA aA OT a A A aE ee Sea eS ES aE TET TTR | eT SS as TENA UT AT “aig sn gn vUOUES 4 “Buns oonon aus move Way] [Ear POH ABH BOE] SEEDS DD] a SRA PRAY ATBaIsoN nwowouns| —TeLETDW eae] ——_E UR SOS ie SDT ws AT ‘SRS ESET Tall ——T Spar ooo ur eho]ig eas GH A PaeaTpOH FR BES TTA HOT TPT) ‘WE BOBBY agar Ua DIA AT CHLOE TTT] ial Ha Guay wa a|—ETSTRETTGEY TR or we Wee TBSET TST} RT9229 2 aun au re auoan rene yep uno> cea lawow cone E30 turuuejooo'o'e waren anu roca vow oe6e aoa tepa089 soap 20 py 9 0 sumaroy3eSisy ——YUOREN A ag ¢ veo e500) soyeuno ep Povian-tee dnp surah 9 sas yo pio spavaie sy suse 107 006550 «15 sg Reus ‘AspueinsyeuoneN Tloops wpyep sles Bus afew: sexaoseoest) suas eeern9 Te reronotcon) unsmaps see ypa'AH0w MIEN BES OF tasers) eons 308 lmsuapii> ROVER AER HUH § aur ene re ne ruounecap sos ve foroz) Pinel areonur jeden sj won 301) 0 90/2986) “nea fan Quow-fooor wnulesus-vedyo matbonesen saw aioyn —galo}ueurlez ———AUIMSN AINSQNEES Binjury Case frog otros Jocsston a nome June ot rcs: race / Operation /Amputzton Tick an neo are spa) esd of im loa anon tom sont fori fos fearing captey © Bf oy Ramalnconar maaRey (iaiaionm Wega os of prospect fa ose duete dsfguenentSie ve apt Toma iMighe Tikal — Th aay — fact’ nchate [Jedi fear —fovioas eNGEGEGESES:[Fatal Accidents lose ofscaden| (ena ca [saat — pour a [wan fafa e [tira SORTS, Peducten 7218. Us Imurptena anus) edslopenes [Mate as ofl nd acon Si [funsl peer