Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A. Muthuraja, S. Kalainathan
www.elsevier.com/locate/jcrysgro
PII: S0022-0248(16)30758-8
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2016.11.070
Reference: CRYS23798
To appear in: Journal of Crystal Growth
Received date: 21 July 2016
Revised date: 3 November 2016
Accepted date: 15 November 2016
Cite this article as: A. Muthuraja and S. Kalainathan, Study on growth, structural,
optical, thermal and mechanical properties of organic single crystal Ethyl p-
amino benzoate (EPAB) grown using vertical Bridgman technique, Journal of
Crystal Growth, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2016.11.070
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for
publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of
the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting galley proof before it is published in its final citable form.
Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which
could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Study on growth, structural, optical, thermal and mechanical
properties of organic single crystal Ethyl p-amino benzoate
(EPAB) grown using vertical Bridgman technique.
A. Muthuraja, S. Kalainathan*
Centre for Crystal Growth, School of Advanced Sciences, VIT University,
Vellore-632 014, Tamilnadu, India
Abstract
Ethyl p-aminobenzoate (EPAB) single crystal was grown using vertical Bridgman
technique (VBT). The crystal system of grown crystal was identified, and lattice parameters
have been measured from the powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD). The optical transparency of
EPAB single crystal was 55%, and the cut-off wavelength was found to be 337 nm. The
thermal stability of EPAB single crystal was analyzed by thermogravimetric analysis. Etching
studie were carried out for the grown crystal using different solvents, and etch pit density
(EPD) was calculated and compared. Vickers microhardness (Hv) measurements revealed
that EPAB belongs to the category of soft material. The dielectric studies reveal that the
dielectric constant and dielectric loss of grown crystal decreases with increasing frequency
for various temperatures. The third-order nonlinear optical property of EPAB was
investigated and compared with other organic crystals. The evaluation of third-order optical
properties such as nonlinear refractive index (n2), nonlinear absorption (β) and third-order
nonlinear susceptibility (χ3) have found to be in the range of 10-11 m2/W, 10-4 m/W and 10-
5
esu respectively. The Laser damage threshold energy of EPAB was measured using Nd:
YAG laser. The blue emission of the grown crystal was identified by photoluminescence (PL)
spectra measurements. The second harmonic generation (SHG) for the grown EPAB crystal
In recent technologies, researchers are much interested in paying more attention to the
field of organic materials. Organic materials possess high nonlinearities, ultra-fast response,
and high damage threshold [1, 2]. Due to its hydrogen bonds and weak Vander Waal’s force,
organic materials are optically more non-linear than inorganic materials, and it also possesses
a higher degree of delocalization [3]. The third-order nonlinear optical (NLO) crystals
possess weak nonlinear absorption (NLA), but still it attracts more researchers because of its
strong nonlinear refraction (NLR) which can be used in applications like photonic switching
devices [4]. The search for efficient third-order NLO material has become even more crucial
than second order materials. Research on third order nonlinear optical materials from the
limiters, optical switching and devices [5]. Organic Pi-conjugated materials possess high
optical nonlinearity, and molecular design can quickly tune it. An organic Pi-conjugated
material shows adequate performance in all optical devices [6]. The NLO crystals possess
the formation of a molecule with an electron donating (D) and accepting groups (A)
connected via a π-conjugated system. When compared to inorganic materials, this feature is
enormously observed in organic molecules [7, 8]. Most of the organic materials reported so
far possess D– π–A-type structure. The large molecular hyperpolarizability and the nonlinear
susceptibility in the organic molecule happens due to the strong delocalization of π-electron
which further causes the significant enhancement of the third-order nonlinear optical
measure the third-order optical nonlinearities of the materials. EPAB (C9H11N2) is a non-
hygroscopic organic crystal which possesses good NLO properties [9]. EPAB possesses a D–
π–A-type structure where charge transfer is from the donor to acceptor group. Sinha and
Pattabhi determined the structure of the EPAB materials [10]. Previously, the EPAB single
crystal was grown from the microtube – Czocharlski method and solution growth method by
Arivanandhan et al. [11]. The self seeding vertical bridgman technique were analyzed by
Anandha babu et al. The self seeding vertical bridgamn technique EPAB crystal posses SHG
efficiency 28 times than that of standard KDP[12]. However, no systematic studies of its
optical, third order non-linear, mechanical, surface analysis and laser damage threshold were
made. In the current investigation, the EPAB single crystal was grown using vertical
Bridgman technique. We have reported the powder XRD, UV–Vis, TG-DTA, Etching,
2. Experiments
The two-zone vertical Bridgman furnace was used to grow the EPAB single crystal. In the
Bridgman technique, the temperature distribution and magnitude of temperature gradient are
the relevant parameters. Depending on the geometry of the furnace, dimension and nature of
the crucible, these two parameters are highly differed. Hence, it is necessary to concentrate
more on these parameters while using Bridgman technique [13]. The furnace was made of
alumina muffle with wall thickness (2 mm), diameter (60 mm) and length (600 mm). The
alumina muffle was entirely covered with nichrome wire with the thickness of 0.5 mm. The
temperature controller with an accuracy of ±0.01oC was used in the growth run. The
ampoule design is another vital factor in the crystal growth. Researchers developed many
ampoules with different shapes to grow crystal using Bridgman technique [14]. The conical
tip of the ampoule is the point of initiation for solidification hence the conical shaped
ampoule is mostly preferred to grow crystal in the Bridgman technique which also controls
the further growth of the crystal [15]. In the present experiment, conical shaped borosil glass
ampoule (Fig. 1.) was used to grow the single crystal. The height and inner diameter of the
C/cm. The axial temperature profile of the furnace is determined, and it is shown in Fig.2.
The EPAB organic material was purchased from Aldrich [number A88409 and CAS
Number119-52-8]. The material was filled in conical shape borosil glass ampoule which was
evacuated up to 10-6 torr and then sealed. The two-zone furnace temperature was maintained
at 110o C. (approximately 20o C more than the melting point of the material). The sealed
ampoule was hanged inside the furnace at the hot region. The material melts completely, and
it was kept inside the furnace for 4 hrs to attain the thermal equilibrium. Due to the slow
growth rate (0.5 mm/hr) organic single crystals grown using Bridgman technique need very
less translation rate (less than 0.5 - 1 mm/h) [16]. Two different translation rates were
maintained in this experiment. From the hot region to cold region the ampoule was slowly
moved at a translation rate of 1 mm/h to the crystallizing temperature point and after that
translation rate of 0.5 mm/h was employed. After growth, the furnace was cooled slowly and
brought back to room temperature. There are more possibilities for the occurrence of cracks
due to the difference in the thermal expansion coefficient of the glass and the crystal, hence
slow cooling rate was preferred to prevent the grown crystal from cracks. The grown crystal
was safely removed from the ampoule using the standard diamond wheel cutter. The grown
The TG-DTA was used to afford the information about the melting and
decomposition point of the materials. EPAB was subjected to TG–DTA to analyze the
thermal behaviour of the grown crystal. NETZSCH Sta-449F3 analyzer was used to analyse
TG-DTA in the nitrogen atmosphere at a heating rate of 10˚C min-1. The thermal property of
the EPAB grown crystal is shown in Fig. 4. The DTA curve reveals a sharp peak at 91˚C,
which indicates the melting point of the crystal. The material remains stable up to 125 ˚C in
TG curve, and the single sharp weight loss curve occurs. No phase transition or
decomposition is observed before the melting point of EPAB. EPAB starts to decompose
after 125oC. The EPAB material 100 % weight loss occurs between 125o C and
206 oC. The crystalline nature of the sample was revealed from the sharp curve in the
differential thermal analysis. Hence, it is clear that the grown EPAB crystal is thermally
constant up to 125˚C.
Powder X-ray diffraction studies have been carried out to calculate the lattice
parameters of the grown EPAB crystal. The X-ray powder data were collected using Bruker
X-ray diffractometer with CuKa radiation (k = 1.5418 Å). The powder X-ray diffraction
pattern of the grown crystal is shown in Fig.5. The observed 2θ values and lattice parameters
are calculated using powder X software [17]. EPAB belongs to the orthorhombic crystal
system with space group P212121, and calculated lattice parameters are a = 8.05 Å, b = 20.69
Å, c = 5.10 Å. These values are in good agreement with standard JCPDS File [94097].
3.3 UV–visible analysis
The Perkin Elmer spectrometer was used to analyze the transmission spectrum of the
EPAB crystal for the wavelength range of 200-1100 nm, and it shown in Fig. 6. The
transparent crystal with 1.5 mm thickness was used for the analysis. The cut-off wavelength
was observed at 337 nm. The EPAB single crystal possesses low cut-off wavelength and
greater transparency properties in the visible region. The grown EPAB crystal reveals 55%
According to Tauc’s relation, the absorption coefficient (α) of material is related to optical
Where A is a constant, Eg is the optical band gap, h is the Planck’s constant and v, the
frequency of the incident photons. The optical band gap of the EPAB crystal was found to be
The chemical etching process is a vital criterion to analyze the defects and growth
features of a grown single crystal. The surface features were analyzed and examined under
Carl Zeiss metallurgical microscope was used to view the etched patterns in EPAB crystals in
the reflected mode. In this present analysis, the EPAB single crystal with the smooth surface
without cracks was subjected to etching analysis by using acetone and methanol as an
etchant. Fig. 8 shows the flat and crack-free surface of the grown EPAB crystal. At room
temperature, the etching analysis was carried out at an etching period of 60 s and 90 s. Fig 8
(b-e) shows the rectangular shaped growth pattern observed during the etching process using
both the etchants. The etch pits increases when the etching time increases (90 s), and the
observed etch pits is shown in Fig. 8 (d, e). It has noted that there is no new pits have formed,
and the pits formation occurs at dislocation sites due to an increase in their size. From the
obtained result of an etching process, it was identified that the etch pits formed due to the
dislocations present in the grown EPAB crystal. The EPAB crystals quantitatively determined
from the dislocation density of grown crystal which measured from the etch pit counts per
unit area (cm-2). When a real crystal grows in an uncontrolled system, it will usually have a
dislocation density of the order of 108-10 lines cm-2 [20]. The low value of dislocation
density makes the crystal to be used for device fabrication. The etch pit density (EPD) of
EPAB crystal with acetone and methanol were calculated and tabulated in Table 1. The
acetone etch bit density was less compared to methanol etch bit density, and low etch bit
density value shows the crystal contains less number of dislocations. From this analysis the
grown EPAB single crystal having systematic packing of atoms/molecules and greater
crystalline perfections.
Single crystals with good mechanical strength are very necessary for the device
fabrication. At room temperature, the Vickers microhardness measurement was carried out
for grown EPAB single crystals using an MH-112 Vicker's hardness tester fitted with a
pyramid indenter. By applying load, the indentation marks were made on the polished crack
free surface of the grown crystal. By keeping the indentation time of 10s, the loads were
applied on the sample crystal ranging from 10, 15, 25 and 100 g. Fig. 9. Shows the plot of
Load P vs. hardness number (Hv) for the EPAB crystal. From that graph, it is noticed that the
hardness number increases when load increases. It is termed as reverse indentation size
effect (RISE). The hardness value was calculated using the formula:
diagonal length in micrometer. 1.854 is a constant geometrical factor for the diamond
pyramid. The cracks occur on the surface of the crystal generated during indentation and the
The plot of log P vs. log d least square fitting gives straight line which is in good agreement
with Meyer’s law. According to onitsch [21], the work hardening coefficient ‘n’ of the grown
EPAB single crystal was derived from the graph plotted between log P vs. log d which is
shown in Fig. 10. The value of n should lie between 1 and 1.6 for harder materials and above
1.6 for softer materials. The value of n for EPAB is 2.1 and which means it belongs to the
P = W + A1d2
Where W is the minimum load to initiate plastic deformation in grams and A1 is a load-
independent constant. These two values estimated from the plots drawn between P vs. d2 for
entire load range 10 - 100 g which is shown in Fig. 11, where W is the intercept along the
load axis and A1 is the slope. The grown crystals exhibit the reverse ISE behaviour, which
revealed from the estimated negative value of W [23]. The corrected hardness Ho for the
crystals was calculated using the following relation and the values are given in Table 2.
Ho =1854.4 X A1
The value of W and Ho was calculated and is found to be -3.01004 g and 99.1362 kg mm2
respectively.
3.6 Dielectric constant and dielectric loss measurements
The information about structural changes, defect behaviour and transport phenomena
of the material can be revealed by the dielectric studies [24]. The dielectric measurement is
essential for non- linear optical materials to find how the non-linear optical materials are
easily polarized in an electric field [25]. Measurements were carried out at the temperature
range of 50, 55, 60, 65 and 70 K with the frequency range of 50Hz – 5MHz. EPAB crystal
with high transparency and defect-free was used in this measurement. The silver paste
applied on both flat sides of the sample crystal to act as an electrode. The dielectric constant
ε'=Cd/εA
Where C is the capacitance, d is the thickness of the crystal, εo is the permittivity of the free
space, and A is the area of the crystal. The dielectric loss was derived using the following
relation,
ε′′ = ε′ x D
Where D is the dissipation factor. The variation of dielectric constant with the frequency
at different temperature range is shown in Fig. 12. From the curve, it was apparently noticed
that the dielectric constant and dielectric loss values were high at low frequencies, and the
values gradually decrease when frequency increases. Due to the space charge polarization,
the dielectric constant and loss were very low at low frequency. The low dielectric constant at
high frequency was observed due to space charge polarization and it is an important criterion
for the construction of photonic and NLO devices [26]. Fig. 13 shows the variation of
dielectric loss for various frequencies at different temperatures. It indicates that the dielectric
loss decreases with the increase of temperature. The low dielectric constant and dielectric loss
values at higher frequencies support the enhanced optical quality of the crystal with less
defects [27].
The Z-scan technique was used to carry out the third-order NLO measurement for the
grown sample. When compared to other techniques, the Z-scan technique is the perfect
method to determine the non-linear index of refraction (n2), nonlinear susceptibility (χ3) and
nonlinear absorption coefficient (β) of samples. In this present investigation, the third-order
NLO properties of the sample crystal was examined using He-Ne laser as a source (5 mW)
with the wavelength and beam diameter of 632.8 nm and 0.5 mm respectively. The third-
order nonlinear absorption coefficient and nonlinear optical refraction were measured using
The sample was transformed from + Z to - Z axial direction using the stepper motor. The
digital power meter (Field Master GS- Coherent) was used to quantify the transmittance
intensity variations through the closed aperture. The input laser beam was modified into
Gaussian form by using Gaussian filter. The perfect single Gaussian beam was suitably
endorsed to scan the sample along the z-axis. The path length detached into positive Z-axis
and negative Z-axis by using the convex lens with 30 mm focal length.
The input intensity increases with the decrease in the transmission which is clearly well-
known from the open aperture Z-scan curve which is shown in Fig. 14. The present curve
indicates a reverse saturable absorption (RSA) (excited state absorption) with a positive
nonlinear absorption coefficient. The reveres saturation absorption means the molecule
title crystal possesses a positive sign of third-order non-linear refractive index which is
clearly evident from the valley and peak configurations and also reveals the self-focusing
effect. The calculated value of the non-linear refractive indexes (n2), non-linear absorption
(β), third-order nonlinear susceptibility (χ3) of EPAB crystal is. The experimental and
The third-order nonlinear optical susceptibility value (χ3) of EPAB was compared with
some other well-known organic NLO crystals in Table 4. From that above analysis, it was
concluded that the EPAB crystal reveals high value when compared to the other crystals. It is
due to the movement of π electron cloud from the donor to accept, which may induce the
The laser damage threshold study was carried out using Q-switched Nd-YAG laser
with the wavelength range of 1064nm and pulse duration of 30ns. The convex lens with the
focal length of 300 mm has used for LDT measurement. The diameter of Nd-YAG laser
beam is 1 mm at the focal length. The energy density of the input laser beam at which the
crystal got damaged was measured using power meter during laser radiation. The laser
damage threshold value of EPAB crystal was measured and recorded as 4.40 GW/cm2. The
laser damage threshold value of organic crystal was comparatively high than other crystals.
The surface damage threshold value of the EPAB crystal was computed using the equation P
= (E/τπr2) Where E is the energy (mJ), t the pulse width (ns) and r the radius of the spot
(mm). The obtained laser damage threshold value of EPAB crystal compared with other
wavelength, the high intensity of fluorescence spectrum is 136,179 a.u and exhibits blue light
emission at the same wavelength. The excitation wavelength of EPAB grown crystal
occurred at 337 nm which was clearly identified from the UV–Visible studies. The PL
emission of the title material possesses many applications especially based on the blue
organic light emitting diodes [31]. At the highest peak intensity, the band gap energy of the
title material was calculated using the following relation Eg = hc/λe Where h, c, e are
constants and λ is the wavelength of fluorescence. The calculated energy band gap of EPAB
The non-linear optical susceptibility of grown EPAB crystals were précised through
second harmonic generation by using standard Kurtz and Perry method [32]. The Q -
Switched High Energy Nd:YAG Laser ( QUANTA RAY Model LAB – 170 - 10 ) with the
fundamental wavelength of 1064 nm was used as a light source. The grown crystals were
ground and tightly packed in a capillary tube. In the SHG measurement, the potassium di-
hydrogen orthophosphate (KDP) crystal was powdered and used as reference material. The
input energy of KDP and EPAB were obtained and the value is 0.68 J. The output signal
voltages of KDP and EPAB SHG were obtained and it was found to be 7.80 and 7.96 m/J.
The SHG efficiency of EPAB was found to be 1.02 times greater than the KDP.
4. Conclusions
Single crystals of EPAB were grown using vertical Bridgman technique using single wall
ampoule. The lattice parameters of the grown crystal were identified from powder XRD
technique. EPAB crystal exhibits good transparency in the entire visible region. The cut-off
wavelength and band gap energy were found to be 337 nm and 3.5eV respectively. The TG-
DTA measurement confirmed the thermal stability of the EPAB crystal. The mechanical
stability of the crystal was found for various loads, and it belongs to soft materials category.
The low value of dielectric constant and dielectric loss at higher frequencies indicates the
suitability of the material for NLO applications. The third-order nonlinear refractive index (n2
= 1.91 X 10-11 m2/W), nonlinear absorption coefficient (1.59 X 10-4 m/W) and third order
optical susceptibility (1.3827 X 10-5esu) was estimated using Z-scan technique. The laser
damage threshold of EPAB was found to be (4.4GW/cm2). Blue emission was observed in
the PL spectrum of the EPAB crystal. The EPAB SHG efficiency was found to be 1.02 times
References
[1] R.L. Sutherland, Hand Book of Nonlinear Optics, Dekker, New York, 1996.
[2] D.S. Chemla, J. Zyss (Eds.), Nonlinear Optical Properties of Organic Molecules
and Crystals, vols. 1 and 2, Academic Press, New York, 1997.
[3] R. Santhakumari, K. Ramamurthi, G. Vasuki, B.M. Yamin, G. Bhagavannarayana,
Spectrochim. Acta Part A 76 (2010) 369.
[4] T. Thilak, M. Basheer Ahamed , G. Vinitha Third order nonlinear optical properties of
[6] J.M. Hales, J. Matichak, S. Barlow, S. Ohira, K. Yesudas, J.L. Bredas, J.W. Perry,S.R.
[19] J. Tauc, in: J. Tauc (Ed.), Amorphous and Liquid Semiconductors, Plenum, New
York, 1974
[20] M. Senthilpandian, P. Ramasamy, Binay Kumar, Mater. Res. Bull. 47 (2012) 1587–
1597.
[24] H.M. Lin, Y.F. Chen, J.L. Shen, W.C. Chou, Journal of Applied Crystallography 89
(2001) 4476
Fig.8. (a) Without Etching (b) 60 s Etching in methanol (c) 60 s Etching in Acetone
(d) 90 s Etching in methnaol (d) 90 s Etcing in Acetone
S. Etchants Etching time Etching behaviour Figure number Etch pit density
No (EPD)
Table-5 Comparison of Laser damage threshold with well know NLO crystals.
2 DAST 2.8 29
3 Benzimidazole 2.9 30
4 MMST 3.98 29