Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BRUNA BORGES WAGECK, PT1 • MARCOS AMARAL DE NORONHA, PT, PhD1,2 • ALEXANDRE DIAS LOPES, PT, PhD3
RONALDO ALVES DA CUNHA, PT4 • RICARDO HISAYOSHI TAKAHASHI, PT5 • LEONARDO OLIVEIRA PENA COSTA, PT, PhD3
Cross-cultural Adaptation
and Measurement Properties
of the Brazilian Portuguese Version
of the Victorian Institute of Sport
Assessment-Patella (VISA-P) Scale
P
atellar tendinopathy is an injury related to structural damage acceleration and deceleration, and in ath-
in the distal and proximal regions of the patellar tendon.22 letes who perform repetitive movements
This injury generally occurs in individuals who engage such as jumping, climbing, and kicking.
These activities are known to have the po-
in sports and recreational activities that require sudden
tential to overload the extensor apparatus
of the knee.7,22
Lian et al,13 in a study that included
TTSTUDY DESIGN: Clinical measurement. TTRESULTS: The VISA-P Brazil had high internal
612 athletes from different sports, re-
TTOBJECTIVES: To translate, adapt, and test the consistency (Cronbach α = .76; if item deleted,
ported a prevalence of patellar tendi-
measurement properties of the Brazilian Portu- Cronbach α = .69-.78), excellent reliability and
agreement (intraclass correlation coefficient = nopathy of 14.2%. This injury is twice as
guese version of the Victorian Institute of Sport
Assessment-Patella (VISA-P) questionnaire. 0.91; 95% confidence interval: 0.85, 0.95; standard prevalent in men as it is in women11 and
error of measurement, 5.2 points; minimal detect-
TTBACKGROUND: It is important to objectively
keeps 33% of athletes away from their
able change at the 90% confidence level, 12.2 sports activities for more than 6 months,
measure symptoms and functional limitations points), and good construct validity (Pearson r =
related to patellar tendinopathy using outcome forcing 50% of these athletes into early
0.60 compared to Lysholm). No ceiling and floor
measures that have been validated in the language effects were detected for the VISA-P Brazil, and the
retirement.2 Furthermore, it affects ap-
of the target population. Cross-cultural adapta- proximately 45% of volleyball athletes,
responsiveness, based on 32 patients receiving
tions are also useful to enhance the understanding as this is a sport with actions that in-
physical therapy intervention for 1 month, demon-
of the measurement properties of an assessment
strated a large effect size of 0.97 (95% confidence volve several risk factors for patellar
tool, regardless of the target language.
interval: 0.68, 1.25). tendinopathy.11
TTMETHODS: The VISA-P questionnaire was
TTCONCLUSION: The VISA-P Brazil is a Due to the high prevalence of patellar
translated into Brazilian Portuguese, culturally
reproducible and responsive tool and can be tendinopathy in athletes, early diagnosis
adapted, and titled VISA-P Brazil. It was then
used in clinical practice and research to assess and treatment are essential to avoid ex-
administered on 2 occasions with a 24- to 48-hour
the severity of pain and disability of patients
interval between them, and a third time after a tended periods away from sports activi-
with patellar tendinopathy. J Orthop Sports Phys
month of physical therapy treatment. The following ties. Clinical instruments to determine
Ther 2013;43(3):163-171. Epub 14 January 2013.
measurement properties were analyzed: internal the severity and the level of disability
doi:10.2519/jospt.2013.4287
consistency, test-retest reliability, agreement,
TTKEY WORDS: Brazil, knee, patellar tendinopathy,
resulting from patellar tendinopathy are
construct validity, floor and ceiling effects, and
responsiveness. questionnaire, tendinopathy highly useful because they can assess the
evolution of the condition and serve as
1
Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina, Florianópolis, Santa Catarina, Brazil. 2La Trobe Rural Health School, Bendigo, Victoria, Australia. 3Universidade da Cidade de São
Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil. 4Physical Therapy Department, Sports Orthopaedic Trauma Center, Universidade Federal de São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil. 5Saúde Plena, São Paulo, Brazil.
The protocol for this study was approved by the Institutional Review Board at Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina. The authors certify that they have no affiliations with or
financial involvement in any organization or entity with a direct financial interest in the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript. Address correspondence to Dr
Marcos Amaral de Noronha, La Trobe University, PO Box 199, Bendigo, Victoria, Australia 3552. E-mail: m.denoronha@latrobe.edu.au t Copyright ©2013 Journal of Orthopaedic
& Sports Physical Therapy
journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy | volume 43 | number 3 | march 2013 | 163
T
originally developed in Australia, which he study was approved by the ation, the specialist committee decided to
has limited its application to culturally Human Research Ethics Committee include an illustration of the lunge exer-
similar English-speaking countries.15 of Universidade do Estado de Santa cise, as the term lunge is not used often
To be useful in other languages, this Catarina (approval number 07/2010). among health professionals in Brazil and
questionnaire must be translated and a lack of understanding of the term could
cross-culturally adapted to the language VISA-P Questionnaire affect scores on the questionnaire. The in-
and culture of interest, and its measure- The VISA-P scale is an 8-item ques- clusion of the illustration was intended to
ment properties must be verified to allow tionnaire related to the symptoms and ensure that respondents fully understood
future comparisons and inclusions with disabilities of individuals with patellar the question. The committee also initially
different populations.1 Given that the tendinopathy (APPENDIX). Six of the 8 decided to include the option “not appli-
VISA-P is not available to the Brazilian questions are scored on a Likert scale, cable” to question 7, to account for those
population, its cross-cultural adaptation with scores ranging from 0 to 10, with respondents who did not perform regular
will provide clinical and research profes- 10 representing no pain or disability and physical activity, which was scored as 0
sionals in Brazil and other Portuguese- 0 representing maximum severity of the points, as was the option “no.” The option
speaking countries a valuable, low-cost disease. Question number 7 is a Likert- “not applicable” was then later removed
tool for quantifying the severity of pain type question with 4 possible answers (0, from the VISA-P Brazil.
164 | march 2013 | volume 43 | number 3 | journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy
journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy | volume 43 | number 3 | march 2013 | 165
A
total of 52 participants with Minimal detectable change at 90% confidence level 12.2 points
patellar tendinopathy completed Ceiling and floor effects
the VISA-P Brazil questionnaire Percent of patients with maximum or minimum scores 4% with minimum, 4% with maximum score
on the first and second occasions (24 to Responsiveness
48 hours apart). Of these, 32 were receiv- Effect size, VISA-P 0.97 (0.68, 1.25)*
ing treatment for patellar tendinopathy Effect size, Lysholm 0.44 (0.14, 0.73)*
and also completed the questionnaire 1 Abbreviations: ICC, intraclass correlation coefficient; VISA-P, Victorian Institute of Sport
Assessment-Patella.
month after the first assessment. *95% confidence interval.
Internal Consistency
The Cronbach alpha for internal consis- physical therapy treatment for 1 month the influence of the exclusion of each of
tency was .76, and the Cronbach alpha if indicated an effect size of 0.97 (95% CI: the questions (alpha if item deleted), we
item deleted (for each question) varied 0.68, 1.25) for the VISA-P and 0.44 (95% observed that the absence of questions 1
from .69 to .78. CI: 0.14, 0.73) for the Lysholm question- and 7 caused a slight increase in the value
naire (TABLE 2). of Cronbach alpha (.78 and .77, respec-
Test-Retest Reliability tively), suggesting that these questions
The ICC2,1 was 0.91, with a 95% confidence DISCUSSION could be reformulated to improve com-
interval (CI) of 0.85 to 0.95 (TABLE 2). prehension of the questionnaire. Howev-
T
he present study aimed to er, this increase was insignificant, because
Agreement translate the VISA-P questionnaire the value was within the recommended
The SEM was 5.2 points and the MDC90 into Brazilian Portuguese, as well as interval. Interestingly, the original version
was 12.2 points. to test its measurement properties. Our of the VISA-P was not assessed in terms
results showed that the VISA-P Brazil of internal consistency, but validations of
Construct Validity has good measurement properties, high this questionnaire in other languages had
The level of association between the reliability, and appropriate construct va- high Cronbach alpha values.7,14,25 This ac-
VISA-P Brazil and Lysholm question- lidity, and can be used in Brazil to evalu- ceptable internal consistency across dif-
naires was 0.60 (TABLE 2). ate and monitor changes over time in ferent cultures may be an indication that
patients with patellar tendinopathy. The the original VISA-P is well formulated
Ceiling and Floor Effects instrument showed equivalence to the and also has good internal consistency.
No ceiling or floor effects were found, as English version and was more responsive The German version (Cronbach α = .88)14
only 4% of the participants scored the than the Lysholm scale in both the Eng- and the Swedish version (Cronbach α =
maximum or minimum possible score lish and Brazilian Portuguese versions. .83)7 had higher internal consistency
(TABLE 2), which is less than the 15% The internal consistency analysis using than the Brazilian version; however, they
threshold typically used to indicate ceil- Cronbach alpha showed the VISA-P Bra- are all well within the range considered
ing and floor effects. zil to be within the recommended range of acceptable. Overall, there seems to be a
values (.70-.95),21 meaning that the items confirmation among the different ver-
Responsiveness of the questionnaire are homogeneous sions that the VISA-P is well designed to
Data on the 32 participants who received while nonredundant. In the analysis of address a single construct.
166 | march 2013 | volume 43 | number 3 | journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy
B
95% CI: 0.992, 0.996).9 The level of with different characteristics from others ased on the results obtained in
agreement for the VISA-P Brazil may be that assess changes related to other knee the assessments of the measurement
considered excellent, with a SEM value conditions. properties of the VISA-P Brazil, we
of 5.2 points, which represents a small In the assessment of the presence of can conclude that the questionnaire is re-
portion of the 0- to 100-point scale.17 ceiling and floor effects, we found that liable and reproducible, and that it can be
Accordingly, the MDC90 was 12.2 points, the number of participants who scored used in clinical practice and in research to
which means that a change of at least 12.2 the maximum and minimum values on evaluate the severity of pain and disability
points is needed, on a scale of 100 points, the questionnaire was well below the 15% in people with patellar tendinopathy. t
to be confident that this change is not due threshold. This suggests that the VISA-P
to random measurement error. Brazil is an appropriate tool for individu- KEY POINTS
In the assessment of the correlation als with the full spectrum of severity of FINDINGS: This study demonstrated that
between the VISA-P Brazil and the Bra- patellar tendinopathy. The responsive- the VISA-P has high reliability, ap-
zilian version of the Lysholm question- ness analysis further corroborated the propriate construct validity, and high
naire, Pearson r was 0.60, which was absence of ceiling and floor effects. The responsiveness. Furthermore, the trans-
expected, because these 2 questionnaires VISA-P Brazil had an effect size of 0.97 lation process and measurement prop-
do not have the same construct. Accord- (95% CI: 0.68, 1.25), similar to the Span- erties demonstrated equivalence with
ing to Terwee et al,21 the recommended ish version of the VISA-P (standardized the English version, suggesting that its
level of agreement between question- effect size = 1.15), the only previous study measurement properties are very good
naires should be greater than 0.70 when that tested this property.9 These results across different languages and cultures.
they are of the same construct, but lower show that the Brazilian and Spanish ver- IMPLICATIONS: The VISA-P Brazil can be
levels of agreement are allowed for ques- sions of the VISA-P are responsive to used by clinicians and researchers who
tionnaires with similar but different con- clinical changes and could potentially be need to assess severity of pain and dis-
structs. Therefore, considering that the used to monitor changes in symptoms ability in Brazilian Portuguese speakers
Lysholm questionnaire was developed over time and for specific interventions,21 with patellar tendinopathy. The results
as a region-specific questionnaire to as- providing clinicians and researchers from these assessments can be compared
sess symptoms and function for differ- with a quick and affordable tool for that to the results of the assessments per-
ent knee conditions, and the VISA-P was purpose. formed in other languages in which the
developed as a condition-specific ques- During the translation process of the VISA-P is available (English, German,
tionnaire to assess symptoms related to VISA-P questionnaire, we included the Dutch, Italian, Swedish, and Spanish).
patellar tendinopathy, the moderate level alternative answer “not applicable” for CAUTION: The VISA-P Brazil is a ques-
of correlation between these 2 instru- the seventh question. This alternative tionnaire designed to assess physically
ments is expected. Construct validity for was included because, at first, we con- active people; therefore, the results of its
the German version of the VISA-P was sidered the possibility of using the ques- application to other populations should
assessed using the Blazina classification tionnaire to assess patellar tendinopathy be interpreted with caution.
system for patellar tendinopathy, whereas in individuals not engaged in regular
the Spanish version was assessed using 3 physical activity. The present study used ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: The authors would like
different tools: the Medical Outcomes a sample of people who regularly prac- to acknowledge Lailah Fernandes de Noronha,
Study 36-Item Short-Form Health Sur- ticed physical activity; therefore, the op- Rafael Marinho, Lucíola Menezes Costa,
vey, the Kujala Scoring Questionnaire, tion “not applicable” was only marked 3 Guilherme Silva Nunes, Aridone Borgonovo,
and the Cincinnati Knee Rating System. times for the entire sample. Although the Fabrício Biscaro, Ricardo Burigo, and Carlos
In general, the results of the present option “not applicable” was useful during Alberto Pierri for their participation in the
study, combined with those of previ- the measurement property testing of the translation and recruitment of participants.
journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy | volume 43 | number 3 | march 2013 | 167
@ MORE INFORMATION
a low risk to sustain jumper’s knee patellar questionnaires for post-lumbar disc surgery. J
tendinopathy: a longitudinal study on Swedish Clin Epidemiol. 2004;57:268-276. http://dx.doi.
elite junior volleyball players. Br J Sports Med. org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2003.09.005 WWW.JOSPT.ORG
168 | march 2013 | volume 43 | number 3 | journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy
VISA-P BRAZIL
1. Por quantos minutos você consegue ficar sentado sem dor?
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Pontos ____
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Pontos ____
3. Você sente dor no joelho quando o estende totalmente de forma ativa e com apoio de peso?
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Pontos ____
4. Você sente dor quando faz o exercício afundo* com apoio de peso total?
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Pontos ____
exercício afundo
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Pontos ____
journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy | volume 43 | number 3 | march 2013 | 169
6. Você sente dor durante ou imediatamente após saltitar 10 vezes em uma perna só?
7. Atualmente, você está praticando algum esporte ou outro tipo de atividade física?
0 Não
7 treinamento sem restrição mas não competindo no mesmo nível anterior ao início dos sintomas
10 competindo no mesmo nível ou nível mais alto do que quando os sintomas começaram
Pontos ____
8. P
or favor, complete somente uma das questões, A, B ou C, conforme a explicação abaixo.
• Se você não sente dor ao praticar esportes, por favor, responda somente a questão 8A.
• Se você sente dor ao praticar algum esporte, mas esta dor não o impede de praticar a atividade esportiva, por favor, responda somente
a questão 8B.
• Se você sente dor que o impede de praticar atividades esportivas, responda somente a questão 8C.
8A. Se você não sente dor ao praticar esporte, por quanto tempo você consegue treinar/praticar?
Não consigo
treinar/praticar 0-5 minutos 6-10 minutos 11-15 minutos mais de 15 minutos
0 7 14 21 30
Pontos ____
OU
8B. S
e você sente dor ao praticar esporte, mas a dor não o impede de completar/praticar a atividade esportiva, por quanto tempo você consegue
treinar/praticar?
0 4 10 14 20
Pontos ____
170 | march 2013 | volume 43 | number 3 | journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy
OU
8C. Se você sente dor que o impede de completar o seu treinamento/prática esportiva, por quanto tempo você consegue treinar/praticar?
0 2 5 7 10
Pontos ____
Nome_______________________________________________________________
Idade_ ________________________________
Telefone_ ______________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
journal of orthopaedic & sports physical therapy | volume 43 | number 3 | march 2013 | 171