Professional Documents
Culture Documents
degree
1994
Approved by:
-
LTC Charles M.-~elwix,M.S.Ed.
ABSTRACT
USA, i l l pages.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
contributions:
Engineering Center
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT............................................. i i i
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS................................... .. iv
LIST OF FIGURES.................................... .. vi
CHAPTERS
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
1. Research Methodolgy.............................. 44
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
before we started.'
continued into more modern times. Between 1954 and 1990 the
burden. 16
Focus
it.
situation.
5
equal ly, if not more heavi 1 y, burdened. l7 A1 1 of these
soldiers comprise the group defined as Dismounted Combat
Soldiers by the U.S. Army Infantry School.18
Quest ions
p a ~ u m i~ong
t
on these effects.
Definitions
topic.
A ~ ~ r o a cMarch
h Load.
This is the load carried by
march load. This is the load the soldier normally has with
vehicles. 19
(MLC) .
pacto~;. One that actively contributes to an
Dictionary, 1984.
Potential Problems
duffel bags.
packing list because the "SOP says so," then they impact the
1987): p. 39.
8-11.
1 3 u s ~ C ~ C"A
,
Study to Conserve.
141bid., p. 15.
1 5 ~ 'The
~ Carrying
~ ~ ~ of, Loads.. .,' p . 1.
1 6 ~ "Techno1
~ ogy
~ Demonstrat
~ ~ ion..
~ .~,' p . ~6.
,
1 7 7-10,
~ ~ , pp. 8-9, 8-10.
.
1991 >
l9FM 7-10, pp. 8-9, 8-10.
CHAPTER TWO
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
...
what we want is not a light battalion but a light
army...such mobility is only to be obtained when the
army is formed of sturdy men, well practiced in peace,
well fed in the field, and carrying as regards all
arms a really practical equipment. An army which
marches light will also maneuver freely. 1
Helmuth von Moltke
to offer.
sical 1 y. 2
, otMarches.
The three manuals are up-t.o-date and we1 I -
171.27 pounds3 and recent data from JRTC shows that the
~ounds.T
~hese figures suggest that 30% for the average
endurance). 5
injury.6
these loads.7
his needs will be met, the commander must ensure that the
i t/s needed.8
Commander's Estimate
Mission
equipments are needed for the task? How much movement will
avai l abl e?
Enemv Threat
case there will be more potential threats than the unit can
T~OODS
required.lo
Time Available
20
doctrine.
Previous Studv
S. L. A . Marshall
One significant exception and a major work in this
area, is Brigadier General S. L. A . Marshall's Ilg
Soldier's Load and the Mobilitv of a Nation. First
printed in 1949 in various military journals in the United
States and abroad under the title "The Mobility of One
Man." it was published for the first time in 1950 and is
load.14
items he was issued; and if the load was too heavy, some
weight .20
today).22
combat -24
27
and the deletion of the M60 tripod and spare barrel. This
SAW.
f lash1 i g h t ~ . ~ ~
Modern Combat
operations.
amphibious logistics.
31
worst. 3 1
32
an area of operations.
(DBBL).
Periodicals
i ~ i a n and
articles were too numerous to address here. Suffice i t to
infantry leaders.
3~.~ .
Nat i ck Research, Devel opment , and
Army
Engineering Center, "1988Anthropometric Survey of U.S.
10~bid.,ch. 5.
1 8 ~ 'A ~Study
~ to ~Reduce..
24, C-11, C-39, E-4, F-5, F-8.
~ ."
~ p.~ 3, 5,
,
12, 23,
2 3 ~ "The
~ ~Carrying
~ ~ ,of Loads. .." p. 1.
10-11.
2 6 ~ 'Techno1
~ ~ogy ~Demonstrat
~ ..
~ion. ~ " pp.
~ 4-5,
,
2 7 ~ "1988
~ Anthropometric
~ ~ ~ ~ ,"
Survey..
~ ~ . ,
p. 320.
28~.Hastings and S. Jenkins, The Battle for the
Falklands. (London: W.W. Norton & Co., 1983), pp. 231-232,
263-269, 274, 319-320.
29~ajor General J. Thompson, The Lifeblood of War:
207, 311.
Books, 1991>, pp. 76, 225-6, 317, 319, 332, 346-347, 359.
3 4 data.
~
~ ~ ~
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH DESIGN
soldier's load.'
FM 7-10, 1990
MethodoI osy
Information Sources
* SOLDIERS OVERLOADED?
CHAPTER 4
db
COMMON FACTORS UNIQUE FACTORS
I I
CHAPTER 5
+I M
- -APPLICABLE TODAY?
APPLIES UNLESS 1 YES!
MISSION VALUE VALUE
ENEMY
TECHNOLOGY
TRAINING
44
and Engineering Center. The first two agencies have
Information Types
factor or factors.
Criteria
techniques, or procedures.
obsolete?
Conclusions
Endnote
' ~ ~ . 7 - 1 0p,. 8-1.
CHAPTER FOUR
RESEARCH ANALYSIS
Anonymous at JRTC
factors.
FACTORS LACK OF EFFECTS OF FEAR HE THE DRAG OF DISCIPLINE NATURE LACK MYTHS OF EFFECTS TERRAIN PHYSICAL
APPRECIA- FEAR AND OF :IRE ORTHODOXY ANDTHE OFTHE OF PEACE- OFTECH- AND CONDITION-
.OAD ENFORCE- SOLDIER TRANS- TIME NOLOGY WEATHER ING
MENT OF PORT TRAINING
STANDARDS
............
SLAM: SOLDIERS
X
!L?! .......................
BAKER. DONNELLY.
I
ROTH: OPERATION
JUST CAUSE
............. .
HASTING AND
JENKINS: BATTLE X
FOR FALKLANDS
.......
CALL
DUSlK AND
FULLERTON:
N OVERLOADIN x
GRENADA
...............
ADKIN: URGENT FURY
.
THOMPSON:
I
LIFEBLOOD
.........................
NATICK (73 '88)
.
JRTC
OF.- WAR
X
-.
..................
.....
USAlS (DCO, DDBL)
..
........................
USACDC '64
X
..................... ............... .-
INFANTRY MAGAZINE
I
.............- ..............................
#OF SOURCES
METT-T as a Factor
will have been properly assessed and the exact numbers and
prob 1 em.
Lack of Awareness
Inability to Resolve
swiftly tire.7
...
I didn't know my strength was gone until I hit
(the) beach. I was carrying part of a machinegun.
worst. 10
Fear of Risk
pointed out, the leader cannot equip his troops for every
soldiers will need; the consequences are that his unit may
agility and accept the risk that they may get cold or miss
.
f orrner 15
saw. The soldier related how his heavy load and hard
stress. 17
(he called it the "fire load"), noting two main reasons for
equipment. 18
Ranger Regiment.
weight.24
the problem. 25
soldier's rucks.29
well).30
by the terrain (marshy bogs and hills with few roads) and
what was available and the end result was almost always a
q - T
hazardous.39
"tai1 . " 4 4
soldier.
pound. 51
that replaces the older version but is more bulky and 10%
.
heavier 52
A less obvious way in which technology has
meant that the item was heavier and bulkier than i t needed
to be.
meet the infantry task and save weight; the increased costs
infantry units.56
less than all four components but more that any two) it was
"a11 or nothing."58
i
Terrain, Weather. and Phvsical Conditioninq
Physical Conditioning
was due to the sudden change to a field ration diet and the
fact that they normally did far less marching than the line
Endnotes
8~bid.,p. 43.
1 5 ~ " A ~Study .
~ to ~Reduce..
~ ~,' PP.
~ C-11,
,
E-4.
16Donnel I y, Roth, Baker, pp. 346-347.
1 7 bul letins
~ ~#1-88,
~ pp.~ 13-19 and #90-9,
PP. 1-19.
"~arshall , pp. 18-19. 30-31, 58.
191bid., pp. 12-13.
2 0 bulletin9
~ ~ p. ~15.
~ 1-88,
21~onnelly, Roth, Baker, p. 332.
C-39.
2 4 ~ " A~ Study
~ to~ Reduce..
~ ~ .,"~pp. ,
12, 23,
2 5 ~ "A~Study
~ to~ Reduce..
~ ~ .," ~p. ,
and
23
briefing packets from USAIS and ADEA.
2 6 bulletin
~ ~#1-88,
~ p . ~15 and author's
personal
experience.
2 7 data.
~
~ ~ ~
2 9 bulletins
~ ~ #1-88,
~ pp.
~
13-19 and #90-9,
pp. 1-19.
3 0 data.
~
~ ~ ~
36.
3 2 ~ a The
~ ~Carrying
~ ~ of, Loads. ..," pp . 13, 24,
3 7 bulletins
~ ~ #I-88,
~ pp.
~ 13-19 and #90-9,
pp. 1-19.
38~arshal1 , p p . xi, 35-36.
3 9 ~ "The
~ ~Carrying
~ ~ of, Loads. . .,
" p. 27.
41~arshal l , pp . x-x i .
~ ~ U S A I C D A"A
,
Study to Reduce ...," pp. C-11, E-4.
43~ubik and Fullerton, pp. 44-45 and briefing
packets from USAIS and ADEA.
44~asti ngs and Jenkins, pp . 319-320.
45~hompson. pp. 207. 31 1.
4 6 ~ 'The
~ ~Carrying
~ ~ of , Loads. ..," p. 13.
47~arshall, p.11.
48~and Warrior Weight Analysis, DCD, USAIS.
49~nhanced Land Warrior informat ion from DCD and
DBBL, USAIS.
5 0 ~ .A ~ Study
~ to , " pp. F-1, F-2.
~ Conserve...,
~ ~
5 1 ~ a n dWarrior Weight Analysis.
5 2 ~ "The
~ ~Carrying
~ ~ of, Loads.. . ," p. 43 and FM
21-18, p. 5-7.
53~arshal l , pp . 83-84.
54~nformation from DBBL, USAIS.
5 5 ~ "Technology
~ ~ Demonstrat
~ ~ ~ion.. ~ .I1 ~ ,
pp. 20-21.
5 6 ~ " A~ Study
~ to~ Conserve
~ ~ , ...," PP. F-1, F-2.
5 7 ~ "A~Study
~ to~ Reduce..
~ ~. ," ~
p. 24.
,
5 8 ~ ut h o r ~ spersonal experience .
5 9 briefing
~ packet
~ from DCD,
~ ~ DBBL,
~ USAIS
60~asti ngs and Jenkins, p p . 238-263.
Gladkin, pp. 222, 239.
62~onnel l y , Roth , Baker, pp . 255-256.
CHAPTER FIVE
S. L. A . Marshall
This chapter presents conclusions drawn from the
over 1 odd.
Mission
Enemy
such a war.
Technology
at Figure 3.
Fear of Risk
Drag of Orthodoxy
Physical Conditioning
Recommendations
soldier's load.
Training
Leader Trainins
similar recornmendation.10
to,
Soldier Traininq
Unit Traininq
Techno1ogy
whole. 21
Summarv
101
Endnotes
1. Lack of A ~ ~ r e c i a t i ofor
n
the Problem
- Fear-Fatigue-Fear cycle
- magnified by uncertainty over th
support
3. Fear of Risk
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books
1991.
periodicals
1964, p. 16.
13-14.
Government Publicationg
December 1991.
1991.
Leavenworth, KS.
Cameron Station
Alexandria, VA 22314
USACGSC
USACGSC
Kalamazoo, MI 49008
Sisnatures:
If your thesis does not fit into any of the above categories or is
classified, you must coordinate with the classified section at CARL. - -
/ /
/ /I
/ //
information.
purposes.
specific authority.
their contractors: (REASON AND DATE). Currently most used reasons are
1, 3, 7, 8, and9 above.