Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7
l\'CERTA J\' (Jt;A,'\TITIL\
PROHAH/L/TY
IJISTRI HCT/0,\'S. /
A\'f) EXPECTATI(J~'S
/ ~ 1 ,% "( / .!% ....""í ..f ~ ,11/ .-,,• ...; ,1 "')" -' .-'/_: / / / ,.( / .,.,, , , / ' .F Á / ~ / A, ,- / /
1 .,,. / / , ,.:,,...,,,. , / / / , , , • 1 / , l / ;, ,r l _, /' I/ ,, t / f ,.4 ,-
1/"',VAf\_.,. -'/ .-'-,. .... , .... ~ ., ~ .,-, , / f, " r',J)? ";/ 1/,." ... , . . P,,.
CHAPTER
7
UNCERTAIN QUANTITIES,
PROBABILITY
DISTRIB UTI ONS,
AND EXPECTATIONS
The diagrams of rnany business decision problerns contain event forks represent-
ing the possible values of an uncertain quantity such as the amount of sorne prod-
uct that could be sold during the next year or the number of defectives that will
be produced in the next run of sorne rnachine. Since there is a possible event
corresponding to every possible value of the uncertain quantity, such forks often
have a very large number of branches, and when they do, they give rise to some
problems that we must now examine.
First of all, the mere description of such a fork presents a problem. A
fan Iike the one in Figure 2.2 (page 35) will serve to show the place of the fo rk
in the diagrarn .of the decision problem, but it offers no place to record the prob-
abilities assigned to its branches. In principle this problem can be solved by lisr-
ing the branches rather than diagramming them, but frequently th e nurnber of
branches is so great that even this device becomes very awkward. An eve n nwrc'
serious problem arises when we come to assessment of the probabilities for a li the
branches on the fork, since no decision maker can possibly sit down and think
out separately the probability he wants to assign to each of a thousand or fl: n
thousand possible values of the uncertain quantity. Ancl finally, supposing th:1r
the as~essment problem has somehow been solved, a serious computational pn)b·
lem anses w~en we try to cvaluate the decision makcr 's prcfercncc l)r m:1thL't11:11i-
c~I expectat1on for the unccrtain monetary value rcprcscnted by an cvt:nt fl) r~
with thousands of branchcs.
7 UNCER TAIN QUANTITIES
223
CONTENTS OF CHAPTER 7
l.
Probability Distributions, Mass
Functions, and Cumulative Functions
1 Definitions
2 Exact Graphs of Mass and Cumulative Functions
3 Smooth Graphs of Mass and Cumulative Functions
4 Relations between the Shapes of Mass and Cumulative Functions
5 Notation
2.
Summary Measures of a
Probability Distribution
1 Modes of a Distribution
2 Median of a Distribution
3 Fractiles of a Distribution
4 Identification of Fractiles by Use of a Smooth Graph
5 Mean of a Distribution or Expectation of an Uncertain Quantity
6 Relations among Mean, Median, and Mode
7 Variance and Standard Deviation of a Distribution
3.
Functions of an Uncertain Quantity
1 An Example
2 Definition of a Function of a UQ
3 Distribution of a Function of a Discrete UQ
4 Expectation of a Function of a Discrete UQ
5 Summary
4.
Approximation of an Expectation
1 An Example of Approximatc Computation
2 Alternatíve Dcscriplion or thc Mcthocl of Computntion
3 Groupcd Approximations lo Probability DistributÍllIIS
7.1.1
UNCER T AIN QUANTITIES
225
4 Equiprobable Groups
5 Bracket Medians
6 Construction of Grou dA • . .
. pe pprox1mat10ns Usrng Bracket Medians
7 S1ze of Groups and Accuracy of Approximation
8 U se of a Digital Computer
5.
Expectations of Linear Functions
1 A Common Error
2 Expectation of a Linear Function
3 Functions Linear over the Range of a UQ
4 A Common Variant of the Common Error
5 Use of Expectations in the Analysis of Decision Problems
6.
Summary
1 Definitions and Notation
2 Graphs
3 Summary Measures of a Distribution
4 Functions of a UQ
5 Grouped Approximations
6 Linear Functions
Appendix
Description of Computer Program Smooth
7.1
PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTIONS,
MASS FUNCTIONS, AND CUMULATIVE FUNCTIONS
7.1.1
Definitions
The reader will find it essential to keep the following definiti ons of tec hnical
terms absolutely clear in his mind. We first di stinguish between what wc shall
calI possible and impossible values of an «uncertain quantity», or UQ for short .
■ Any value which an uncertain quantity cannot have because of the way
in which its value will be measured will be called an « impossihle value»
of the UQ and wiH be automatically assumed to have zero prnba bility.
Any vaJue that is not exdudcd for this rcason will be called a « possibk
value» of the UQ, whethcr or not it ha s zcro probability in the dec ision
maker's judgment.
r
Event
FIGURE 7.1
Event Fork Representing the UQ "Number of Units Demanded Tomorrow"
TABLE 7.1
" Probability Distribution of the UQ
Number of Units Demanded Tomorrow"
1 2 3
Number Probability of
Demanded Demandfor:
d d dar less
o o o
1 .2 .2
2 .4 .6
3 .2 .8
4 .1 .9
5 .1 1.0
6 and up o 1.0
1.0
The list actually needs to contain only as many entries as there are values of the
UQ with nonzero individual probability, since it is only at these values of the
UQ that the value of the cumulative function actually changes. In the example
ofTable 7.1 , the entries in Column 3 suffice to show that the probability assigned
to "demand for 3½ or less" is .8.
7.1.2
Exact Graphs of Mass and
Cumulative Functions
A mass or cumula ti ve function can be much móre readily apprehended intuitively
if it is presented in the form of a graph rather than a list, and we shall see later
that graphs are often also very useful in the actual assessment of mass or cumula-
tive functions.
Graphing a mass function presents no real problems at all, as can be
seen by looking at the graph in Figure 7.2A of the mass function in Column 2 of
Table 7. l. The horizontal axis shows the possible values of the UQ "number of
units demanded"; the height of the bar above each value, when referred to the
vertical axis, shows the probability that the UQ is equal to that value.
In graphing a cumulative function, we must remember that such a func-
tion has a meaningful value in between as well as at the possible values of the
UQ ; with this fact in mind it is easy to see that Figure 7.2B is a correct represen-
tation of the cumula ti ve function defined by Column 3 of Table 7.1. The height
of the graph above any value on the horizontal axis, possible or impossibk.
shows the probability that the UQ is equal to that value or less ; at the poin t~
where there is a vertical jump in the graph, a heavy clot indica tes where the gr:1ph
is to be read. The reader should noticc, and cxplain to himself why :
1 There is a jump in the cumulative function at cach value of the UQ for
which the mass function shows nonzcro probahility.
7.1.3 UNCER T AIN QU ANTITIES 229
4
A
2::-
j .2
o
..D
1 .1
o 1 1
-
o 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
d, numbe r demonded
10
.9
1
B
.8
"'Q) . 7
o 5
:.g _4
..D
o
et .3
.2 r
.l
o
1
1
1
o 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
d, numbe r demonded
FIGURE 7.2
Probability Distribution of the UQ "Number of Units Demanded Tomorrow"
2 The height of each jump in the cumulative function is equal to the height
of the corresponding bar in the mass function.
7.1.3
Smooth Graphs of Mass and
Cumulative Functions
Graphs like those in Figure 7.2 become very tedious to draw when nonzero prob-
ability has been assigned to a large number of values of the UQ, and thcrefore we
shall in ali such cases use "smooth" graphs that are easier to draw even though
they cannot be read correctly without first remcrnbering which are the possible
values of the. UQ.
Taking another hypothetical probability distribution of demand for
some commodity as our example, we show exact graphs of its mass and cumula-
tive functions in Figure 7.3 with smooth graphs of thcsc sume functions sup~r-
230 ASS ESSM EN T OF PR EFE R EN CES A ND P RO BABILJTrEs
7.J.3
-
.08
I
/ -- . . . I'\.
-
"
0 .06
:¡¡ /
/
/
Í\
\
"I"-...
A
- -
-8 .04
r--.. , -
e 1
CL
/ r--...,~ -
.02 -
/ ~
o ~I 1 1 1 ri---r--,___
o 5 10 15 20 25 30
De mand x
1.0 .-==,---
.9
~
.8
/
/ ~
s
.7
"'
1 B
º.6
º .5
" jJ
~
:.o
_g .4
o
!1
l--J
et
.3 / -
.2 J
.l
jJ
~
k:1---'
o
o 5 10 15 20 25 30
Demand x
FIGURE 7.3
Exact and Smooth Graphs of a Distribution
posed. 2 Comparing the two graphs of the mass functi o n, the reader wi·11 s·ee that
. .. t .. ph at anY
the smooth graph (a) g1ves exactly the same p robab1hty as the e~ac gi '1 , hi.:n
possi ble value of th e UQ, but (b) is mea ningless at a ny im pnsstbk va hic.: . T .
. ·11 , ,thatt 1t,
compa nn g the two graphs of th c cumulati vc function, t hc rende r wi st: c .t
11 1
smooth gra ph (a) again givcs cxactly thc samc probability as thc cxact grap '
2 Bcca usc th c vert ica l scal es f'or th c 11111ss t'un e ti o ns in thesc two gra phs nrc ''.'.'. 1 ,h th.: snntl'
,,r ,11,·
as th c vert ica l sea lo:s f'o r th c cu 11111l 11 1i vc t'u11c1io 11s, thc jum ps in thc ••~a.: t ¡;•:','·. ,., 11 .¡ 11 1~
· c fu
c u111u 1atrv · 11ct 1·0 11 a n • prn po r1 11. ' 11t s• o 1· 111.: .:,,, , ,s i
· H111I rnth c r th n11 cq u11I to th .: he1¡;
ba rs in th c exael grnph o t' th e mnss fu 11e tio11 .
7.J.4 UNCERTAIN QUANTITIES 231
7.1.4
Relations between the Shapes of
Mass and Cumulative Functions
By comparing the two smooth graphs in Figure 7.3, the reader can readily ob-
serve that the upward slope of the cumulative function is great at those values of
the UQ at which the height of the mass function is great, that the slope of the
cumulative function is small where the height of the mass function is small, and
that the slope of the cumulative function is O (the graph is flat) where the height
of the mass function is O. Then by thinking about the implications of the two
remarks at the end of Section 7 .1.2, the reader can convince himself that these
same relations must hold in any case where (1) the possible values of a UQ are
evenly spaced out on the horizontal axis, and (2) the probabilities of these values
are all very small and change gradually from one value to the next. And with a
little more thought, the reader can convince himself that the relation can actually
be stated in the following stronger form :
■ If (1) the possible values of a UQ are evenly spaced out, and (2) the prob-
abilities of these values are all very small and change gradually from one
value to the next, then the slope of a smooth graph of the cumulative
function at any particular value ofthe UQ will be almost exactly propor-
tional to the height of the mass function at that value.
Smooth graphs are useful and will be used only when the two conditions
of this basic proposition are satisfied; and the reader should convince himself
that under these conditions the basic proposition implies the following particular
conclusions concerning smooth graphs:
7.1.5
Notation
Subsequent discussion of probability distributions of uncertain quantities wiJl be
very greatly facilitated by the use of some shorthand notation.
I. Any probability will be denoted by a capital P followed by paren.
theses enclosing the name of the event whose probability is in question . Thus
P(red) will denote the probability that a ball is red, P( defective) will denote the
probability that a manufactured part is defective, and so forth.
2. Any uncertain quantity will be denoted by a Ietter with a tilde (pro-
nounce til'deh) over it; thus we may use d to denote the UQ " tomorrow's de-
mand" or r to denote the UQ " number of defectives in this uninspected lot".
3. We have already seen that to each possible value of a UQ there corre·
sponds a possible event; thus if .x denotes demand, x = 4 denotes the event "de-
mand for 4" . Consequently we may write
P(x = 4): the probability that the UQ x has the value 4.
The symbol < means "less than", > means "greater than" ~ and >, mean re-
' " 1/
spectively "less than or equal to" and "greater than or equa1 to". Thus,
P(x ~ 4): the probability that the UQ x has a value Iess than or
equal to 4, or more briefly, the probability that x has
a value equal to 4 or less.
The following relations between the "tails" of ad'1st n·b u t·10n w1·11 g1ve
· anexa
· mplc
of the use of this notation.
7.2
SUMMARY MEASURES OF A
PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTION
7.2.1
Modes of a Distribution
When greater probability is assigned to some one value of a discrete UQ than to
the values just to either side of it, the value with the greater probability is called a
«mode» of the distribution. lf there is only one such value, it is called " the"
mode of the distribution. The mode of the distribution in Figure 7 .2 is 2.
A smooth graph of the mass function of a discrete UQ will have a local
maximum at each mode, and if the possible values of the UQ are evenly spaced,
the cumulative function will have greater slope at a mode than at neighboring
values of the UQ-there will be a reversal of curvature at each mode. The distri-
bution graphed in Figure 7 .3 has only one mode, namely the value 10.
Most distributions encountered in business decision problerns have only
one mode and are called «unimodal» . Distributions with two modes are some-
times of considerable interest; they are called «bimodal».
\ 7.2.2
Median of a Distribution
Roughly speaking, the «median» of a distribution is the value of the UQ which
"cuts the distribution in half" in the sense that the probability that the UQ will
have a value less than the median and the probability that the UQ will have a
value greater than the median are both approxirnately 1 /2. The median is pre-
cisely defined by the following procedure for identifying it on an exact graph of
the cumulative function of the UQ.
■ To identify the median of the distribution of a UQ, e~ter an_exact graph
of the cumulative function of the UQ at .5 on the vertical axis, read over
to the graph, and then read down to find the median on the horizontal
axis. 3
As shown in Figure 7.4, the median of the distribution of Figure 7.3 is 12.
7.2.3
Fractiles of a Oistribution
. . el Roughly speaking, thc « k fractilc»
Let k denote any fract10n between 0 ctn 1· . . . .
, . . . . _ _ UQ which divides thc d1stnbutwn 111 such n
0 f a d1stnbut1on 1s the value of t 1
1e
. j
.. • • r mcdi, 111 s by id c11tifyi11~ <>11c va l11l' .ni". .1\w
t· d·Hd def1111llOII O
·This rul e <lifkrs from t 1c s .in ' . . , .·• ¡ ,.. scs wln;rc by th c s1H1nlard dcl\11111,111
. ·¡ · -1 in so inc sp 1;1; 1•1 ~, 1• ·
UQ as "thc" median ora <listn JUliOI · ., . in ·iddition to thc ,H1C s in¡¡k,d ,1u1 b y lhl'
the distr ibution would havc inany o lllcr ,nci1l,lllS '
rule.
1.0 ,_____.....----
.9
~ ,_
.8
_r -- -- --
.7
Lr -
J
V)
V)
Q)
---
~
n
-► --- - - ~-------
~
--
1
1
1
r- ► -- ~ - - '""
1
1
.2 r- 1
1
~
1 1
1 1
1 1
.l
o - _f--
u t
1
1
1
±
o 5
.3 fract ile
J 10 \ 15
Med ian
20
Value x
25 30
FIGURE 7.4
Determination of a Median and a .3 Fractile
way that the probability that the UQ will have a value less than the k fractile is
approximately equal to k and the probability that the UQ will have a value
greater than the k fractile is approximately equal to (1 - k). The k fractile is
precisely defined by the following procedure for identifying it on an exact graph
of the cumulati ve function of the UQ:
As shown in Figure 7.4, the .3 fractile (read: point three fractile) of the distribn-
tion of F igure 7 .3 is 9.
Notation If a UQ.is called x, the k fractile of its distribution will be ca lled xk,
and similarly for other UQ 's.
By superposing a smooth graph on the exact graph in Figure 7.4, the reader can
verify for himself that this rule necessarily leads to the same value that would be
obtained by use of an exact graph.
7.2.5
Mean of a Distribution or Expectation
of an Uncertain Quantity
The <<mean>> of a proba bility distribution is defined by the following rule for
computation:
■ To compute the mean ofthe probability distribution of any discrete UQ,
(1) multiply each possible value of the UQ by the probability that the
UQ has that value, and (2) add these products.
In Table 7.2 we show that the mean of the distribution in Table 7.1 of the UQ
"demand" is 2.5.
TABLE 7.2
Computation of the Mean of a Distribution
d P(d = d) d X P(d = d)
o o o
1 .2 .2
2 .4 .8
3 .2 .6
4 .1 .4
5 .1 .5
6 and up o o
1.0 2. 5