*91>1
+D55>



!9;@/13+8
><38/<<
&-2996
!9;@+B
7+36
;3+8+<=//8,389

E7?
*9259B?


;9>:
;+C36
7+36
2>19;3,/3;93-61;9>:-97

>EB17
+8E;<1

69,+6988/-=
!9;@+B
7+36
+8>;+1<2>56+169,+6-988/-=89





B?=
D85
D85?B5D931<
@5BC@53D9F5C
DB149D9?>1<<I
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
B5@B5C5>D
49665B5>D
3?>D5HDC
G8938
381<<5>75C
5H381>79>7
9451C

=5D8?4C
1>4
B5CE<DC
25DG55>
D85C5
DG?
C395>D9693
695<4C
*85B56?B5
1
49CD9>3D9?>
25DG55>
D85C5
DG?
3?>D5HDC
21C54
?>
D85
9>D5>D9?>1<9DI

2589>4
E>G1>D54
5F5>DC
D85
G1I
B9C;
9C
E>45BCD??4
1>4
D85
=5D8?4C
EC54
D?
1CC5CC
1>4
=1>175
B9C;
9>
D85C5
3?>D5HDC
B?=
D85
@B13D931<

@?9>D
?6
F95G
49CD9>7E9C8
25DG55>
D85
B?<5C
1>4
B5C@?>C929<9D95C
?6
D85C5
DG?
@B?65CC9?>1<
3?==E>9D95C
1B5
E>3<51B
*89C
CDE4I
5H@<?B5C

D85
5HD5>D
?6
D85
3?==?>1<9D95C
1>4
49665B5>35C
9>
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
@B?65CC9?>1<C
3EBB5>D
CD175
-5
3?>4E3D
1
AE1<9D1D9F5
1>1<IC9C

21C54
?>

C5=9CDBE3DEB54
9>D5BF95GC
G9D8
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
4?=19>
@B?65CC9?>1<C
6?3EC9>7
?>
D85
3?>35@DE1<
>1BB1D9F5C

B5C@?>C929<9D95C
1>4
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
1@@B?1385C
6B?=
1
@B13D931<
@5BC@53D9F5
%EB
69>49>7C
9>4931D5
D81D
G89<5
D85
@B?65CC9?>1<C
9>
D85C5

DG?
695<4C
CDB?>7<I
49CD9>7E9C8
25DG55>
D85
3?>D5HD
?6
D859B
13D9F9D95C
D85I
C81B5
=1>I
3?==?>1<9D95C
B571B49>7
D859B
41ID?41I
D1C;C


6E>41=5>D1<
3?==?>
@B?2<5=
9>
=1>179>7
B9C;
9C
D81D
9D
9C
496693E<D
D?
5H@B5CC
E>35BD19>DI
1>4
45D5B=9>5
8?G
<9;5<I
9D
9C
D81D
1>

9>3945>D
5F5>D
81@@5>54
G5
1B5
E>12<5
D?
79F5
CDB?>7
1B7E=5>DC
6?B
C@539693
<9;5<98??4
1CC97>=5>DC
?6
D8B51D
?33EBB5>35
.5D
1

<9;5<98??4
31>
1<G1IC
25
1CC97>54
21C54
?>
1F19<12<5
;>?G<5475

8?<9CD93
B9C;
=1>175=5>D
1@@B?138
9>D57B1D9>7
B9C;
1>4
B5C9<95>35
21C54
D89>;9>7
13;>?G<5475C
D89C
1>4
3?>C945BC
1
C5D
?6
AE1<9D1D9F5
1>4
AE1>D9D1D9F5
=5D8?4C
D?
B56<53D
D89C
<13;
?6
;>?G<5475



/B@9;.<
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
)53EB9DI
)53EB9DI
@B?65CC9?>1<C
)165DI
@B?65CC9?>1<
(5C9<95>3521C54
B9C;
=1>175=5>D
9>3B51C5

@B5@1B54>5CC


 ! 
?6
1>
9>C945B
D8B51D
1B5
1C
6?<<?GC
D85
D8B51D
13D?BC
9>D5>D9?>


3?>C945B12<5
2?4I
?6
13145=93
<9D5B1DEB5
9>
D85
C53EB9DI
D?
3?>4E3D
1
=1<939?EC
13D
D85
@5B@5DB1D?BC
31@129<9DI
1>4

=1>175=5>D
CICD5=
1B7E5C
D81D
D85
C165DI
3?>35@D
4?5C
>?D
3?=@5D5>35
6?B
31BBI9>7
?ED
1
=1<939?EC
@<1>
1>4
1>

31@DEB5
1<<
C53EB9DI
C5DD9>7C

,8EC
D85I
C5@1B1D5
D85C5
DG?
?@@?BDE>9DI
D?
25
5H@<?9D54
2I
D85
@5B@5DB1D?B
D85B5
=1I

695<4C
1>9>
5D
1<

 
1>4
1B7E5
6?B
3?>C945B9>7
C53EB9DI
1<C?
25
1>
12C5>35
6B?=
4?9>7
?>5C
4ED95C
9>D5>D9?>1<<I
?B

1C
1>
9>45@5>45>D
C395>35
45D13854
6B?=
D85
C165DI
E>9>D5>D9?>1<<I
9
5

<?3;9>7
D85
G1B58?EC5C
G85>
<51F9>7

C395>35
"?B5
 

,859B
B1D9?>1<5C
1B5
2E9<D
?>
D85
D85
G?B;9>7
41I
C?
D81D
9>DBEC9?>
51C9<I
31BB954

-C9>7
D85

9>D5>D9?>1<9DI
2589>4
E>G1>D54
5F5>DC
8?G
B9C;
9C
CD1D9CD931<
1@@B?138
9>3<E49>7
D85
@B?2129<9CD93
B9C;

E>45BCD??4
1>4
D85
=5D8?4C
EC54
D?
1CC5CC
1>4
=1>175
B9C;
1>1<IC9C
D?
45D5B=9>5
D85
B9C;
<5F5<
9>
D89C
5H1=@<5
81C
9DC

9>
D85C5
3?>D5HDC

>1<IJ5
1>4
=1>175
B9C;
59D85B
9>
D85
<9=9D1D9?>

>
E>45B<I9>7
1CCE=@D9?>
9>
CD1D9CD931<
=5D8?4C

C165DI
?B
C53EB9DI
3?>D5HD
B5AE9B5C
1>
1@@B?138
?B
9C
D81D
CE669395>D
41D1
31>
@B5493D
6EDEB5
@5B6?B=1>35
1>4

6B1=5G?B;
4569>9>7
G81D
B9C;
9C
1>4
8?G
B9C;
C8?E<4
25
CICD5=C
1B5
DB13D12<5

,89C
=51>C
D81D
8?G
1
CICD5=
G?B;C

1CC5CC54
1>4
81>4<54

%1>I
CE38
1@@B?1385C
1>4
9C
;>?G>
1>4
D81D
D85
CE2CICD5=C
45D19<C
1>4
45C3B9@D9?>C

6B1=5G?B;C
5H9CD

?B
9>CD1>35
*5>>


1B5
E>3?=@<931D54
1>4
D81D
CICD5=C
4?
>?D
381>75
G89<5

9>DB?4E35C
1
3<1CC96931D9?>
CDBE3DEB5
21C54
?>
49C39@<9>5C
1>4
D85I
1B5
259>7
45C3B9254
B19D8G19D5
/51BC

?<<>175<

@5BC@53D9F5C

5
49CD9>7E9C85C
25DG55>
CD1D9CD931<
1>1<IC9C
 
(1DB91B31
?CD1>D9>?
1<57>1=9

9<?DD1
 

5@945=9?<?7I
@B?2129<9CD93
B9C;
1>1<IC9C
D85
53?>?=93C
?6
(B?F1>
/??4C
5;;5B

*15





B9C;
D85
@CI38?<?7I
?6
B9C;
>1DEB1<
81J1B4C
1>4
?G5F5B
1>
9>C945B
D8B51D
81C
1
3?=@<5H
>1DEB5
?6

3I25BC53EB9DI

3?>35B>
9>
2?D8
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI

?B
9>CD1>35
G89<5
D85

,?
C?<F5
@B13D931<
@B?2<5=C
C5F5B1<
?6
D85C5
9>D5>D9?>
2589>4
CE38
1>
13D
9C
=1<939?EC
9D
=978D
25

@5BC@53D9F5C
1B5
B5AE9B54

5C945C
F5>
 
8978<978DC
4569395>D
9>
D85
CICD5=
45C97>
=1;9>7
9D
FE<>5B12<5
D?
CE38

D85
9=@?BD1>35
?6
B?2ECD
D89>;9>7
D85
AE1<9DI
49C3?EBC5
1
C35>1B9?

>?D85B
@?CC929<9DI
9C
D81D
F1B9?EC
F9?<1D9?>C

1>4
?B71>9J1D9?>1<
<51B>9>7
9>
D5B=C
?6
3?<<53D9F5
9>3<E49>7
C9DE1D9?>1<
B?ED9>5
1>4
?B71>9J1D9?>1<<I
9>4E354

=9>46E<>5CC
9>
=1>179>7
CEB@B9C5C
1>4
2<13;
CG1>C
DI@5C
F9?<1D9?>C
=978D
E>9>D5>D9?>1<<I
@B?F945
CE38
1>
1DD13;

?6
5F5>DC

*?2ECD
D89>;9>7
B56<53DC
?>
D85
D89>;9>7
12?ED
?@@?BDE>9DI


,85
?B71>9J1D9?>1<<I
9>4E354
F9?<1D9?>C
?33EB

B9C;
D81D
C55C
25I?>4
D85
@B?2129<9CD93
@5BC@53D9F5

G85>
1>
?B71>9J1D9?>
1DD5=@DC
D?
=55D
9>3B51C54
?ED@ED

45=1>4C
2I
97>?B9>7
?B
CDB5D389>7
9DC
C165DI
4565>C5C

?>C945B
1
B9C;
C35>1B9?
G9D8
D85
@?D5>D91<
6?B
5HDB5=5

!'
 



3?>C5AE5>35C
1>4
G85B5
D85
E>35BD19>D95C
1B5
9==5>C5
6?B

9>CD1>35
D85
G1;5
?6
1>
9>C945B
D8B51D

,8B55
=19>
1C@53DC

Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference

Edited by Bruno Castanier, Marko Cepin, David Bigaud, and Christophe Berenguer
Copyright  c ESREL 2021.Published by Research Publishing, Singapore.
ISBN: 978-981-18-2016-8; doi:10.3850/978-981-18-2016-8 091-cd 490
 Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference 491

,89C
5H1=@<5
8978<978DC
D81D
DEB2E<5>D
381>75C
G9D8
B9C;
1>4
B5C9<95>35 21C54
D89>;9>7
F5>

,85;49

7B?G9>7
3?=@<5H9D95C
1>4
9>D5B45@5>45>395C
13B?CC
 
D85
+165DI !!
1@@B?138
9C
3?>C945B54
>535CC1BI
21C54

?B71>9J1D9?>C
1>4
9>3B51C9>7
E>35BD19>DI
<5F5<C
81F5
?>
D85
6?<<?G9>7
1CCE=@D9?>C
 ?<<>175<
 


3B51D54
1
7B5I
J?>5
25DG55>
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
695<4


,85
D8B51D
F53D?BC
1B5
9>D5BG?F5>

!>
D89C
J?>5
451<9>7
G9D8
•
+ICD5=C
31>>?D
25
453?=@?C54
9>
1
=51>9>76E<
G1I

381<<5>75C
9C
25I?>4
D85
2?E>41B95C
?6
DB149D9?>1<
C165DI
?B
•
F5BI41I
@5B6?B=1>35
9C
6<5H92<5
1>4
F1B912<5
9
5


C53EB9DI
1@@B?1385C

/5
>554
D?
C55
25I?>4
D85
CICD5=
6E>3D9?>C
1B5
>?D
29=?41<


3?>F5>D9?>1<
C165DI
1@@B?1385C
B5CE<DC
21C54
?>
D85
•
+E335CC
1C
G5<<
1C
619<EB5C
9C
1
B5CE<D
?6
8E=1>

89CD?B931<
41D1
1>4
D85
5H@53D54
>5D
@B5C5>D
F1<E5
@5B6?B=1>35
F1B9129<9DI


31<3E<1D9?>C

*9C;
@5B35@D9?>
C?391<
3?>35B>C
1>4
3E<DEB1<
•
F5>
D8?E78
C?=5
?ED3?=5C
31>
25
9>D5B@B5D54
1C

1C@53DC
?6
B9C;
1B5
9=@?BD1>D
6?B
D85
B9C;
=1>175=5>D
<9>51B
3?>C5AE5>35C
?6
?D85B
5F5>DC
C?=5
5F5>DC

CICD5=
7?F5B>1>35
1>4
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
B5CE<D
6B?=
3?E@<54
@5B6?B=1>35
F1B9129<9DI


=1>175=5>D
CICD5=


C
1
@1BD
?6
D85
C165DI
=1>175=5>D
CICD5=
D85
B9C;

/89<5
;55@9>7
9>
=9>4
D85
1B7E=5>DC
=5>D9?>54
1CC5CC=5>D
@B?35CC
6?3EC5C
?>
133945>DC
31EC54
2I
619<EB5C

12?F5
G5
C896D
?EB
1DD5>D9?>
6B?=
D85
D85?B5D931<
1>4
=1<6E>3D9?>C
1>4
19=C
D?
945>D96I
31EC5C
1>4

@5BC@53D9F5
D?
D85
B51<9CD93
F95G
9>
D89C
@1@5B

/5
144B5CC
3?>DB92ED?BI
613D?BC

!DC
B1D9?>1<9DI
9C
21C54
?>
1
31EC1<9DI

D85
6?<<?G9>7
B5C51B38
AE5CD9?>
3B54?
9
5

1
31EC5
<?793
21C54
?>
D85
6?<<?G9>7
1B7E=5>DC


 ?<<>175<
 
@




*)
?G
D85
@B13D9D9?>5BC
?6
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
49CD9>7E9C8
,85
31EC5C
6?B
D81D
D89>7
7?
B978D
?B
GB?>7
1B5

D85C5
DG?
695<4C
9>
D859B
41I D? 41I
13D9F9D95C
49665B5>D

,85
B51C?>
6?B
14F5BC5
?ED3?=5C
133945>DC


9>3945>DC
9C
D81D
C?=5D89>7
81C
>?D
6E>3D9?>54
1C
9D
C8?E<4


+9=9<1B<I
D85
B51C?>
6?B
CE335CC6E<
?ED3?=5C
9C
D81D

/5
25<95F5
D89C
AE5CD9?>C
1>CG5B
3?>DB92ED5C
D?
C165DI
1>4
5F5BID89>7
G?B;54
1C
9D
G1C
CE@@?C54
D?
4?

C
D85

C53EB9DI
C395>35
9>
45F5<?@9>7
1@@B?@B91D5
7E945<9>5C
D81D
E>45C9B12<5
3?>C5AE5>35C
81F5
31EC5C
9D
=ECD
25
@?CC92<5

CE@@?BD
@B?65CC9?>1<C
9>
3?>4E3D9>7
D859B
419<I
D1C;C

,85
D?
697EB5
?ED
D85C5
31EC5C
2I
3?<<53D9>7
5>?E78
5F945>35


B5=19>45B
?6
D85
@1@5B
9C
?B71>9J54
1C
6?<<?GC

+53D9?>


,85
945>D96954
31EC5C
31>
25
5<9=9>1D54
5>31@CE<1D54
?B

2B956<I
@B5C5>DC
D85
D85?B5D931<
213;7B?E>4
6?B
D89C
CDE4I

?D85BG9C5
>5EDB1<9J54
D?
B54E35
D85
>E=25B
?6
14F5BC5

9>3<E49>7
D85
6E>41=5>D1<
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
=1>175=5>D

?ED3?=5C
1>4
9=@B?F5
C165DI

,?
D89C
5>4
81>42??;C
1>4

3?>35@DC

+53D9?>

?ED<9>5C
D85
=5D8?4?<?7I
6?B
5H@<?B9>7
?B71>9J1D9?>1<
@B?354EB5C
@B?F945
G?B;
45C3B9@D9?>C
D81D

?EB
B5C51B38
AE5CD9?>

,85>
9>
+53D9?>

G5
CE==1B9C5
?EB
3?>CD9DED5
1>
9=179>54
F1B95DI
?6
G?B;
4?=19>C
9
5

/?B;
69>49>7C
1>4
49C3ECC
8?G
1
=?B5
8?<9CD93
1@@B?138
D?
C165DI
C !=179>54
/!

?G5F5B
G85>
1>
5F5>D
81@@5>C

1>4
C53EB9DI
=1>175=5>D
=978D
5>81>35
@B13D9D9?>5BC
451<9>7
G9D8
D85
381<<5>75C
C81B@ 5>4
B5AE9B5
49665B5>D

31@139DI
9>
3?>4E3D9>7
D859B
419<I
D1C;C

9>1<<I
+53D9?>

457B55C
?6
141@D1D9?>


,89C
@?9>D
9=@<95C
D81D
D85
B51<

3?>3<E45C
1>4
@B?F945C
B53?==5>41D9?>C
6?B
6EBD85B
13D9?>C
1B5
9>5C31@12<I
49665B5>D
6B?=
D85
/!
3?>CD9DED9>7

B5C51B38

1>?D85B
F1B95DI
?6
G?B;
>1=54
/?B; C ?>5
/

+D55>
5D
1<

 



 $

! $


,85
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
@B?35CC
31>
25
CE249F9454
9>D?


 
"#
F1B9?EC
31D57?B95C
C9=@<96954
CD1>41B4
1>4
=?45< 21C54

,89C
C53D9?>
3?=@1B5C
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
@B?65CC9?>1<C
F5>


3?>35B>9>7
D85
3?>35@DE1<
>1BB1D9F5C
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D

•
+9=@<96954
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
9C
1
<5CC
6?B=1<
1@@B?138

1@@B?1385C
1>4
D85
B9C;
=1>175=5>D
@B?35CC


EC9>7
2B19>CD?B=9>7
1>4
7B?E@
49C3ECC9?>
D?
5CD12<9C8



D85
B9C;
@93DEB5

,85
@B?35CC
9C
AE1<9D1D9F5




 


•
+D1>41B4
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
1
=?B5
6?B=1<9J54
1@@B?138

,85
!>D5B>1D9?>1<
'B71>9J1D9?>
6?B
+D1>41B49J1D9?>
!+'
EC9>7
5CD12<9C854
D538>9AE5C
6?B
81J1B4
945>D96931D9?>

 
4569>5C
C165DI
1C
1
3?>49D9?>
?B
C5D
?6
 0!
0'(
3BE45
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>DC
5D3


,89C

39B3E=CD1>35C
G85B5
D85
<9;5<98??4
?6
>571D9F5
56653DC
?6
1@@B?138
9C
AE1<9D1D9F5
?B
AE1>D9D1D9F5
?B
1

E>35BD19>DI
?>
?2:53D9F5C
9C
<?G

!>
9DC
DB149D9?>1<
G1I
D85
3?=29>1D9?>
EC9>7
B9C;
=1DB935C
G9D8
4569>54
B9C;

C? 31<<54
+165DI !
D89C
4569>9D9?>
<9>;C
D85
C165DI
3?>35@D
D?
31D57?B95C
D?
=1@
D85
B9C;
@93DEB5
1>4
B5CE<DC


1
3?>49D9?>
G85B5
1C
65G
D89>7C
1C
@?CC92<5
7?
GB?>7

•
%?45< 21C54
1@@B?138
G8938
9C
@B9=1B9<I
1

,8EC
D85
C165DI
=1>175=5>D
CICD5=
19=C
D?
1F?94
D89>7C
AE1>D9D1D9F5
1@@B?138

,89C
1@@B?138
1@@<95C

7?9>7
GB?>7
 ?<<>175<
 

C
1>
1<D5B>1D9F5
1@@B?138
(B?2129<9CD93
*9C;
CC5CC=5>D
(*
=5D8?4C
6?B

=?45B>
C165DI
=1>175=5>D
B5<95C
?>
C165DI
1C
1
3?>49D9?>
5H1=@<5
D85
(?9CC?>
=?45<

D538>9AE5C
CE38
1C
61E<D

G85B5
1C
=1>I
D89C
1C
@?CC92<5
7?
G5<<
+165DI !!

,85
DB55
1>1<IC9C
,
1>4
5F5>D
DB55
1>1<IC9C
,
1C

E>45B<I9>7
9451
?6
+165DI !!
9C
D81D
G5
31>>?D
=1;5
D89>7C
G5<<
1C
=?B5
14F1>354
@8IC931<
=?45<C
?6
@85>?=5>1

7?
B978D
C9=@<I
2I
@B5F5>D9>7
D85=
6B?=
7?9>7
GB?>7
1>4
@B?35CC5C
CE38
1C
69B5C
1>4
5H@<?C9?>C


<C?

9294

!>
D85
C1=5
695<4
9D
81C
255>
1B7E54
D81D
1
DB149D9?>1<
=?45<C
CE38
1C
1J1B4
>1<IC9C
1>4
B9D931<
?>DB?<

+165DI !
@5BC@53D9F5
=978D
25
1@@B?@B91D5
1>4
56653D9F5
E>D9<
(?9>DC
 (
19<EB5
%?45
1>4
6653D
>1<IC9C

CICD5=
3?=@<5H9DI
9C
<9=9D54
9>
D5B=C
?6
9>D5B13D9?>C
1>4
%
1J1B4
1>4
'@5B129<9DI
+DE495C
 0'(

3?E@<9>7C
1=?>7
49665B5>D
CICD5=
175>DC
1>4
3?=@?>5>DC
1B5
3?==?><I
9>3<E454
9>
D85
1CC5CC=5>D



(1DB91B31
5D
1<

 

!>
451<9>7
G9D8
3?=@<5H9D95C
9>
<9>5

 Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference 492

3?>C945B54
1
B9C;
C?EB35
9>
D85
+?395DI
6?B
*9C;
>1<IC9C

=?>7
D85C5
1@@B?1385C
=5>D9?>54
12?F5
D85
(*
9C
D85
<?CC1BI
 



=?CD
3?==?><I
EC54
D?
5F1<E1D5
B9C;C
9>
C165DI
33?B49>7
D?
':1>5>
 
4569>9>7
1
D8B51D
9>F?<F5C

=1>175=5>D

!D
9C
1
6?B=1<9J54
AE1>D9D1D9F5
4539C9?> =1;9>7
4539C9?>C
?>
G81D
D?
G?B;
?>
>5HD

!>
D85
C53EB9DI

CE@@?BD
D??<
2E9<D
D?
5CD9=1D5
@B?2129<9D95C
1>4
5H@53D54
3?>D5HD
1C
6?B
D85
C165DI
3?>D5HD
1
D8B51D
31>
<514
D?

F1<E5C
6?B
1DDB92ED5C
<9;5
9>:EB95C
<?CC
?6
<9F5C
49665B5>D
3?>C5AE5>35C
5
7

61D1<9D95C
5>F9B?>=5>D1<

5>F9B?>=5>D1<
41=175
?B
B5@ED1D9?>1<
41=175


(*
81C
41=175
B5@ED1D9?>1<
41=175
1>4
53?>?=93
<?CC

I

255>
G945<I
EC54
9>
49665B5>D
C53D?BC
?F5B
D85
@1CD

I51BC

945>D96I9>7
D8B51DC
CDE4I9>7
D859B
31EC5C
1>4
3?>C5AE5>35C

,85
1CC5CC=5>DC
?B979>1D54
9>
D85
15B?C@135
1>4
>E3<51B
1>4
45C3B929>7
B9C;
4539C9?> =1;5BC
;>?G
D85
B9C;
<5F5<

9>4ECDB95C
2ED
1B5
>?G
1<C?
3?==?>
9>
=1>I
?D85B
C53D?BC
1>4
=19>
3?>DB92ED?BC
D?
B9C;

!>
D89C
G1I
1
C53EB9DI
B9C;

9>3<E49>7
851<D831B5
B?5;8E9J5>
5D
1<

 
1CC5CC=5>DC
@B9=1BI
6E>3D9?>
9C
D?
CE@@?BD
4539C9?>
@81B=13?<?7I
,1B495E
+9=?>>51E

%E<<5B
 
=1;9>7
9>
B5C@?>49>7
D?
D8B51DC

+5F5B1<
5H9CD9>7
C53EB9DI

85=931<
*931B45J +1>4?F1<
 
1>4
D85
?9<

71C
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
6B1=5G?B;C
81F5
D85
C1=5
21C93
5<5=5>DC

9>4ECDBI
%E:552 8=54
+5?

(19;
 


9>
3?>4E3D9>7
1
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
1C
9>
1
C165DI
3?>D5HD
1CC5D

,85
=19>
CD5@C
?6
1
(*
1B5
D85
945>D96931D9?>
?6
F1<E1D9?>
D8B51D
1>1<IC9C
FE<>5B129<9DI
1>1<IC5C
1>4

9>9D91D9>7
5F5>DC
31EC5
1>4
3?>C5AE5>35
1>1<IC9C
1>4
B9C;
C53EB9DI
B9C;
5F1<E1D9?>
$1>4?<<
 

H1=@<5C
9>3<E45

45C3B9@D9?>

,85
1CC5CC=5>D
6?3EC5C
?>
21C93
D538>9AE5C
!+'!
 
+D1>41B4
?>
C53EB9DI
=1>175=5>D

CE38
1C
1E<D
,B55
>1<IC9C
,
1>4
F5>D
,B55
>1<IC9C
!>D5B>1D9?>1<
'B71>9J1D9?>
6?B
+D1>41B49J1D9?>
1>4

,

5C945C
=?45<C
6?B
E=1>
BB?B
>1<IC9C
 *
!>D5B>1D9?>1<
<53DB?D538>931<
?==9CC9?>
 


1B5
3?==?><I
9>3<E454
9>
D85
1CC5CC=5>D

,85
B9C;
',.
6B1=5G?B;
'@5B1D9?>1<<I
B9D931<
,8B51D

5CD9=1D9?>
ED9<9J5C
2?D8
1>
?2:53D9F5
1@@B?138
21C54
?>
CC5D
1>4
.E<>5B129<9DI
F1<E1D9?>
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D

81B4
41D1
1>4
1
CE2:53D9F5
1@@B?138
21C54
?>
5H@5BD
<25BDC

1>4
',.
<<57B?
6B1=5G?B;
1B1<<9

:E47=5>DC

,85
=?D9F1D9?>
6?B
3?>4E3D9>7
1
(*
9C
5D
1<





4539C9?>
CE@@?BD
?>
D85
38?935
?6
1BB1>75=5>DC
1>4
*9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
9>
!+'!
 
9C
?>5
?6
D85

=51CEB5C

I
=51CEB9>7
B9C;
D85
4539C9?> =1;5B
9C
=19>
@1BDC
?6
D89C
B9C;
=1>175=5>D
6B1=5G?B;
6?E>454
?>

9>6?B=54

!>
D85
45C97>
@81C5
?6
1
CICD5=
D85
(*
31>
6?B
D85
D8B55 613D?BC
B9C;
@5BC@53D9F5

!D
3?>C9CDC
?6
D85

5H1=@<5
7E945
G81D
133945>D1<
<?14C
D85
CICD5=
C8?E<4
6?<<?G9>7
@B?35CC5C
B9C;
945>D96931D9?>
9>3<E49>7

G9D8CD1>4

!>
?@5B1D9?>
D85
(*
31>
C97>96I
G8938
945>D96I9>7
1CC5DC
D8B51DC
5H9CD9>7
3?>DB?<C
FE<>5B129<9D95C

=19>D5>1>35
=51CEB5C
81F5
1>
9==5>C5
9=@13D
?>
B9C;

1>4
3?>C5AE5>35C
B9C;
1>1<IC9C
9>3<E49>7
1CC5CC=5>D
?6

'>5
?6
D85
3B9D931<
D5B=C
9>
D85
C165DI
=1>175=5>D
3?>C5AE5>35C
D85
<9;5<98??4
?6
9>3945>35
1>4
<5F5<
?6
B9C;

CICD5=
9C
B?2ECD>5CC
1>D?>I=
FE<>5B129<9DI
B565BC
D?
D85
45D5B=9>1D9?>
1>4
B9C;
5F1<E1D9?>

*9C;
1CC5CC=5>D

9>C5>C9D9F9DI
?6
@5B6?B=1>35
D?
45F91D9?>C
6B?=
>?B=1<
CE@@?BDC
69>49>7
1@@B?@B91D5
B9C;
DB51D=5>D
?@D9?>C
1>4

3?>49D9?>C

%51CEB5C
D?
5>81>35
B?2ECD>5CC
9>3<E45
@B?4E39>7
1
B9C;
DB51D=5>D
@<1>
@

 



9>3?B@?B1D9>7
C165DI
613D?BC
1C
1>
1CCEB1>35
1719>CD
,85
',.
6B1=5G?B;
9C
21C54
?>
D85
D8B55 613D?BC

6E>3D9?>1<
F1B91D9?>

'D85B
=51CEB5C
3?E<4
25
49665B5>D
B9C;
@5BC@53D9F5
D8B51D
1CC5D
1>4
FE<>5B129<9DI

!D
9C

DI@5C
?6
21BB95BC
9>DB?4E39>7
B54E>41>D
1>4
49F5BC5
C165DI
6?E>454
?>
AE1<9D1D9F5
B9C;
5F1<E1D9?>
3B9D5B91
D81D
45C3B925

45F935C
D?
9=@B?F5
CDBE3DEB5C
1719>CD
=E<D9@<5
CDB5CC
D85
?B71>9J1D9?>C
?@5B1D9?>1<
B9C;
D?<5B1>35C

,85
B9C;

C9DE1D9?>C

CD12<9C89>7
2E9<49>7
3?45C
D?
@B?D53D
1719>CD
',.
<<57B?
1@@B?138
1B1<<9
5D
1<


9C
2E9<D
?>

>1DEB1<
81J1B4C
1>4
9=@B?F9>7
D85
?B71>9J1D9?>1<
31@129<9DI
D85
C1=5
D8B55
@81C5C
9<<ECDB1D54
9>
697EB5



D?
9>9D91D5
5>6?B35
=?>9D?B
1>4
B5F9C5
=1>175=5>D
13D9?>C
,85
69BCD
CD5@
6?3EC5C
?>
1CC5D 21C54
D8B51D

8978
B5<9129<9DI
<51B>9>7
?B71>9J1D9?>C
1B5
1<C?
1=?>7
945>D96931D9?>
5F1<E1D9?>
1>4
945>D96I9>7
C53EB9DI

=51CEB5C
D?
9=@B?F5
1
CICD5=C
B?2ECD>5CC


B5AE9B5=5>DC
21C54
?>
5H9CD9>7
;>?G<5475
1D
=E<D9@<5


<5F5<C
G9D89>
D85
?B71>9J1D9?>
1>4
CD1>41B4
31D1<?7E5C
?6


9>6?B=1D9?>

,85
C53?>4
CD5@
3?>35>DB1D5C
?>
D85
945>D96954






D8B51D
C35>1B9?C
1>4
5F1<E1D9>7
FE<>5B129<9D95C

,85
B5CE<DC


DI@931<
4569>9D9?>
?6
C53EB9DI
9C
1
3?>49D9?>C5D
?6
?6
D85
C53?>4
@81C5
@B?F945
9>C978DC
D?
45F5<?@
C53EB9DI

39B3E=CD1>35C
G85B5
D85
<9;5<98??4
?6
9>D5>D9?>1<
>571D9F5
@B?D53D9?>
CDB1D5795C
1>4
5CD12<9C8
1
@<1>
D?
=1>175
C53EB9DI

56653DC
?>
?2:53D9F5C
9C
<?G
1C
@B?@?C54
2I
<?;<1>4
1>4
B9C;


*5>95BC


,85B5
9C
1>
9>F?<F5=5>D
?6
=E<D9@<5
@1BD95C

9>
CE38
1
C5DD9>7
G9D8
=1<939?EC
9>D5>D9?>1<9DI
1>4
8?CD9<5

9>D5>D
G85B5
D85
D8B51D
9C
B??D54
?EDC945
1>
?B71>9J1D9?>

5
7

2I
813;5BC
1>4
D5BB?B9CD
+38E<=1>

"?B5

 

!>
D85
3?>D5HD
?6
C53EB9DI
D85
B9C;
9C
4569>54
21C54

?>
D8B55
613D?BC
F1<E5
1CC5D
D8B51D
1>4
FE<>5B129<9DI

3?>C5AE5>35C
<25BDC
5D
1<


$1>4?<<
 

+D1>41B4
&?B75

&+
 
+D1>41B4
&?B75
 
&+





,85
D8B51D
9C
B565BB54
D?
1C
&3
:3)*8.7*)
*;*39
9-&9

2&>
7*8:19
.3
9-*
1488
).8(148:7*
47
)&2&,*
94
&3


47,&3.?&9.43&1
&88*9
$1>4?<<
 

,85
D5B=
9C
1<C?
#
(




 







#
$)''-%

 Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference 493

/85>
9D
3?=5C
D?
=1>175B91<
@B13D935C
9>
D85
4?=19>
?6
3?>D5HDLD89C
CDI<5
1<<?G54
6?B
1449D9?>1<
9>6?B=1D9?>
6B?=

C53EB9DI
(5D5BC5>
1>4
*K>>


8978<978D
D8B55
1B51C
?6
5F5BI
>5G
9>D5BF95G

*571B49>7
41D1
CE669395>3I
G5
G5B5

3?>35B>

,85I
9>3<E45
9>D5<<975>35
3?<<53D9?>
1>4
3?>35B>54
12?ED
81F9>7
1>
9> 45@D8
49C3ECC9?>
B1D85B
D81>

3?==E>931D9?>
1
>5G
6?B=
?6
D538>?<?795C
9>
41D1
D5CD9>7
8I@?D85C5C
D8B?E78
CD1D9CD931<
=5D8?4C

,89C
9C
9>

71D85B9>7
1>4
ED9<9J1D9?>
5
7

C?391<
=5491
9>6?B=1D9?>
<9>5
G9D8
G?B;9>


C1I9>7
D81D
9> 45@D8
9>D5BF95G

381>79>7
D85
D8B51D
175>D
1>4
@B13D935C
5
7

3I25BC53EB9DI

G?B;
9C
>?D
1C
3?>35B>54
G9D8
=1;9>7
75>5B1<9J1D9?>C
D?
1

(5D5BC5>
1>4
*K>>
1B7E5
D81D
D85C5
5<5=5>DC
3B51D5
1
CD?B=
<1B75B
@?@E<1D9?>
?6
9>D5B5CD
1>4
4?5C
>?D
D5>4
D?
B5<I
?>

?6
3?=@<5H9D95C
1>4
E>35BD19>D95C
G9D8
1>
5F5B 9>3B51C9>7
8I@?D85C9C
D5CD9>7
2ED
B1D85B
9C
=?B5
9>4E3D9F5
1>4
5=5B75>D

45=1>4
6?B
@B?F949>7
C53EB9DI

?G5F5B
133?B49>7
D?
D85C5
9>
9DC
@B?35CC

!>CD514
G5
6?<<?G54
B5CG5<<
1>4
B5CG5<<

C38?<1BC
D89C
9C
381<<5>79>7
D?
=1;5
G5<< 9>6?B=54


@



14F935
12?ED
D85
C1=@<5
C9J5
45@5>49>7
?>

:E47=5>DC
1>4
4539C9?>C
?>
C53EB9DI
=51CEB5C

,85I
D85
AE1<9D1D9F5
45C97>
259>7
EC54

?B
7B?E>454
D85?BI
DI@5C

144B5CC
1
>554
6?B
>5G
=5D8?4C
3?1<9D9?>C
1>4
@1BD>5BC89@C
?6
B5C51B38
D85I
B53?==5>4
3?>4E3D9>7
DG5>DI
D?
D89BDI

D?
451<
G9D8
D85C5
381<<5>75C

9>D5BF95GC


'EB
9>D5BF95G
@B?35CC
C?E78D
D?
E>45BCD1>4
8?G
D85




 $
@1BD939@1>DC
:?2
45C3B9@D9?>
3?F5BC
1<<
1C@53DC
?6
D859B
419<I

D1C;C
1>4
13D9F9D95C
9>
2?D8
695<4C

/89<5
G5
1DD5=@D54
D?

'EB
B5C51B38
19=C
D?
@B?F945
1>
9> 45@D8
E>45BCD1>49>7
?6
<9>;
?EB
D?@93C
?6
9>D5B5CD
D?
D85
9>D5BF95G55C
3?>D5HD
G5

8?G
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
@B13D9D9?>5BC
49CD9>7E9C8
D85C5
45F5<?@54
1
C5D
?6
DB9775B
AE5CD9?>C
9>
14F1>35
D?
EC5
4EB9>7

DG?
695<4C
9>
D859B
41I D? 41I
13D9F9D95C

/5
1@@<954
1

D85
9>D5BF95GC

AE1<9D1D9F5
=5D8?4
D?
@B?F945
1>
5H@<?B1D?BI
5475
D?
3<1B96I

8?G
@B?65CC9?>1<C
6E>3D9?>
9>
D859B
G?B;9>7
5>F9B?>=5>D

•
1>
I?E
45C3B925
I?EB
G?B;

/5
EC54
D85
CDE4IC
D85?B5D931<
213;7B?E>4
+53D9?>

1C
1
•
/81D
B?<5
?B
6E>3D9?>
4?
I?E
81F5


B?14=1@
D?
3?>4E3D
?EB
1>1<IC5C

/5
31BB954
?ED

9> •
/81D
9C
D85
49665B5>35
25DG55>
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
45@D8
C5=9 CDBE3DEB54
9>D5BF95GC
9> @5BC?>
1>4
?><9>5
B5<1D54
D1C;C
9>
I?EB
4?=19>

G9D8
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
@B?65CC9?>1<C
4EB9>7
'3D?25B

•
!C
I?EB
:?2
45C3B9@D9?>
3?F5B
1<<
1C@53DC
?6
I?EB
D1C;C

%1B38


G9D8
1>
1F5B175
4EB1D9?>
?6

=9>ED5C

<<
/81D
9C
=9CC9>7

CE2:53DC
17B554
1>4
G5B5
1CCEB54
D81D
1<<
9>6?B=1D9?>
G?E<4
•
/81D
F1B91D9?>C
1CC?391D54
G9D8
I?EB
D1C;C

25
DB51D54
9>
D85
CDB93D5CD
3?>6945>35
1>4
1>?>I=9J54
41D1
•
!C
D85
25CD
G1I
D?
4?
I?EB
D1C;
9C
D85
C1=5
1C
D85
G1I

C?
D81D
>?
9>49F94E1<
9>3945>D
?B
?B71>9J1D9?>
3?E<4
25
45C3B9254
9>
D85
@B?354EB5
!C
9D
D85
G1I
I?E
G5B5

945>D96954

,?
31@DEB5
D85
49F5BC9DI
?6
@B13D9D9?>5BC
DB19>54

5H@5B95>35C
?EB
9>D5BF95G55C
9>3<E454
@B?65CC9?>1<C
6B?=

2?D8
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
4?=19>C
9>
D85
F1B9?EC

9>4ECDB91<
C53D?B



!


/5
EC54
D85
(EB@?C9F5
C1=@<9>7
1@@B?138
D?
C5<53D
,85
?2:53D9F5
?6
D89C
CDE4I
G1C
D?
@B?F945
9>C978D
9>D?
D85

9>49F94E1<C
G8?
G9<<
25CD
85<@
D85=
E>45BCD1>4
D85
B5C51B38
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
@B?65CC9?>1<C
5H@5B95>35
1>4
@5B359F5

@B?2<5=
1>4
D85
B5C51B38
AE5CD9?>C
B5CG5<<

B5CG5<<
8?G
D85I
49CD9>7E9C8
25DG55>
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
3?>D5HD
9>



@




!D
9>F?<F5C
@B13D9D9?>5BC
G8?
81F5
5H@5BD9C5
D859B
419<I
13D9F9D95C

/5
C?E78D
D?
E>45BCD1>4
3EBB5>D

9>
D85
CE2CD1>D9F5
4?=19>
?6
9>D5B5CD
+EB9



G?B;9>7
@B13D935C
5<5=5>DC
?6
49665B5>35C
1>4
3?>F5B75>35
1B51C


G9D89>
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
4?=19>
B571B49>7
D85
3?>D5HD
/5
?B71>9J5
1>4
49C3ECC
?EB
69>49>7C
9>D?
DG?
@1BDC



?6
D89C
CDE4I


3?>35@DE1<
>1BB1D9F5C
1>4

41I D? 41I
D1C;C
/
1>4

'EB
@1BD939@1>DC
3?=5
6B?=
D85
6?<<?G9>7
3?E>DB95C
:?2
45C3B9@D9?>C
/!


B1J9<
1>141
89<5
89>1
-+
B1>35
E1D5=1<1


!>491
!CB15<
!D1<I
"1@1>
%5H93?
%5H93?
&?BG1I





(1>1=1
+9>71@?B5
+@19>
,B9>9414
1>4
D85
-#


!D
9C
,?
5H@<?B5
G85D85B
D85B5
9C
1>I
49665B5>35
9>
E>45BCD1>49>7

9=@?BD1>D
D?
>?D5
D81D
C5F5B1<
@1BD939@1>DC
G?B;
9>
D85
=19>
3?>35@DC
9>
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
695<4
+53D9?>

=E<D9>1D9?>1<
3?=@1>95C
G8938
9>49B53D<I
=1I
25
9>
C5F5B1<

G5
1C;54
?EB
@1BD939@1>DC
D85
6?<<?G9>7
AE5CD9?>
/81D

3?E>DB95C

,85
6?<<?G9>7
697EB5
9<<ECDB1D5C
?EB
@1BD939@1>DC
4?
I?E
E>45BCD1>4
2I
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
(1BD939@1>DC

213;7B?E>4
49F9454
9>D?
3?>D9>5>DC

5H@B5CC54
C165DI
1C
=19><I
B5<1D54
D?
D85
G?B;9>7


5>F9B?>=5>D
133945>DC
9>
D85
G?B;@<135
<965
1>4
851<D8



5>F9B?>=5>D
1>4
CEBB?E>49>7C
5D3




 (1BD939@1>DC
@5B35@D9?>
G1C
D81D
C165DI
75>5B1<<I
451<C




 G9D8
E>9>D5>454
E>G1>D54
5F5>DC

*571B49>7
C53EB9DI



 @1BD939@1>DC
5H@B5CC54
D81D
D89C
9C
B5<1D54
D?
@8IC931<


 
3?>49D9?>C
F1>41<9C=
C12?D175
@B?D53D9>7
@5?@<5
1>4


?D85BC
F1<E5C

+?=5
?6
D85
CD1D5=5>DC
1B5
1C
6?<<?G

•
 &+*9>
.8
1.30*)
94
&;4.).3,
&((.)*398
&9
<470
*(:7.9>


.8
7*1&9*)
94
;.,.1&3(*
&;4.).3,
74''*7>
;.41*3(*
&9

#
)

&







<470
9
.8
&'4:9
541.(.3,

,?
5>81>35
?EB
41D1
C1DEB1D9?>
G5
EC54
C5=9 CDBE3DEB54

9>D5BF95GC
G9D8
1>
?@5> 5>454
AE5CD9?> CDI<5

/5

1DD5=@D54
D?
<9>;
?EB
D?@93C
?6
9>D5B5CD
D?
D85
9>D5BF95G55C

 Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference
•
 &+*9>
.8
7*1&9*)
94
574(*887*1&9*)
7.808
.3
&3

.3):897>
.*
<.9-
34
.39*39.43
94
(&:8*
-&72
*(:7.9>

2*&38
5749*(9.43
+742
9-*+9
;.41*3(*
9*7747.82
*9(

•
 &+*9>
.8
.39*3)*)
94
0**5
9-*
<470*7
8&+*
&3)
*38:7*

9-*
(439.3:.9>
4+
9-*
(425&3>8
&(9.;.9.*8
<-.1*
8*(:7.9>

.8
&'4:9
57*;*39.3,
)&2&,*
94
.98
&88*98
5.7&(>
&3)

&99&(08

•
47
2*
8&+*9>
.8
&'4:9
2&3&,.3,
-*&19-
&3)
8&+*9>
&9

<470
(4257.8.3,
9-*
(4397418
4+
9-*
<470
89&9.438

7*,&7).3,
4((:5&9.43&1
7.808
4((:5&9.43&1
&((.)*398

&3)
+.7*
5749*(9.43
3
9-*
49-*7
-&3)
8*(:7.9>
.8

&((*88
(439741
&3)
7.80
2&3&,*2*39
94
9-*
(425&3>8


47,&3.?&9.438
&88*98

•
 &+*9>
.88:*8
&7*
.3;41;*)
<.9-
9-*
.39*,7.9>
4+
5*451*

&3)
8*(:7.9>
5749*(98
&88*98
&3)
+&(.1.9.*8

•
49-
8&+*9>
&3)
8*(:7.9>
)*&1
<.9-
(&7.3,
+47

*2514>**8
&3)
*38:7.3,
9-*>
&7*
8&+*
&9
<470

494
7.80
2&3&,*2*39
-&8
'**3
:8*)
+47
8*;*7&1
)*(&)*8
.3

;&7.4:8
)*,7**8
"*
-&;*
*=9*38.;*
*=5*7.*3(*
<.9-
7.80

&3&1>8.8
!-*
2&.3
2*9-4)414,>
:8*)
.8
9-*
574'&'.1.9>
=

(438*6:*3(*

=

&5574&(-
8*(:7*
/4'
&3&1>8.8
&3)


2*9-4)8
4<*;*7
9-*7*
-&8
'**3
247*
+4(:8
43
9-*

8*(:7.9>
).8(.51.3*
.3
9-*
1&89
+.;*
>*&78
<-*7*
<*
-&;*
&184

&)459*)
9-*
97**+&(947
24)*1


/5
1C;
6?<<?G E@
AE5CD9?>C
G8I
4?
I?E
D89>;
D89C
9C

C?
&9.43&1
8*(:7.9>
7*,:1&9.43
-&8
(-&3,*)
.3
9-*
1&89

9*3
>*&78
+742
85*(.+.(
&3)
)*9&.1*)
7*6:.7*2*398
94

'*(42.3,
+:3(9.43&1
7*6:.7*2*398
!-*
(9
8&>8
842*9-.3,

&'4:9
-4<
9-*
*3)
89&9*
8-4:1)
'*
&
7*&843&'1*
8*(:7.9>

1*;*1
&3)
7.80
&88*882*398
&+*9>
&3)
*(:7.9>
-&;*
2&3>

(42243
+*&9:7*8
349
/:89
7*&(9.;*
<-*3
>4:
148*
+4(:8

>4:
9>5.(&11>
<470
7*&(9.;*1>
&3)
'>
9-.8

2*&3
9-&9
'49-

2:89
'*
574&(9.;*
,89C
3?==5>D
8978<978DC
D81D
D85
B9C;

1>1<IC5C
G5B5
21C54
?>
!+'


1>4
%
6?B
D85
C165DI

1B51
?F5B
C5F5B1<
453145C

,85
6?3EC
9>
B535>D
I51BC
?>

,85C5
CD1D5=5>DC
C8?G
D81D
C53EB9DI
=19><I
451<C
G9D8
C53EB9DI
9>4931D5C
D81D
D85
3?=@1>I
EC5C
D85
DB55 613D?B

9>D5>D9?>1<
E>G1>D54
5F5>DC
1>4
C165DI
G9D8
E>9>D5>D9?>1<
=?45<
F1<E5
D8B51D
1>4
FE<>5B129<9DI
1>4
1@@<95C
=5D8?4C

?>5C
1<97>9>7
G9D8
D85
D85?B5D931<
F95GC


133?B49>7
D?
+D1>41B4
&?B75
&+



1>4
+D1>41B4

,?
E>45BCD1>4
@1BD939@1>DC
@5B35@D9?>
?6
B9C;
&?B75
&+



CD1>41B4C
1>4
81F5
=1>I

4569>9D9?>
G5
1C;54
D85
6?<<?G9>7
AE5CD9?>C
4<
)4
>4:
3?==?>1<9D95C
G9D8
D85
',.
=?45<
+53D9?>





)*+.3*
7.80
&3)
-4<
)4
>4:
&88*88
.9
'EB
?2C5BF1D9?>C
,85
B5CE<DC
6B?=
D85
9>D5BF95GC
B56<53D
D81D
D85B5
1B5

3<51B<I
C8?G
D81D
D85I
81F5
49665B5>D
B9C;
@5B35@D9?>C
=1>I
C9=9<1B9D95C
25DG55>
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI

C5F5B1<
=5>D9?>C
D81D
B9C;
9C
1>
14F5BC5
?ED3?=5
ECE1<<I
49C39@<9>5C

5B5
G5
31>
@?9>D
D?
D85
3?=@<5H9DI
1CC?391D54

<9>;54
D?
C?=5D89>7
41>75B?EC
1>4
B5<1D5C
9D
D?
6B5AE5>3I
G9D8
9>C945B
D8B51DC
1>4
D859B
B5<1D9?>
D?
D85
C165DI
1>4

1>4
@B?2129<9DI


+?=5
?6
D85
B5C@?>C5C
G5
B5359F54
1B5
1C
C53EB9DI
9CCE5C
+53D9?>


1>4
5H1=@<5
B5<1D54
D?
1>

6?<<?GC
5=5B75>3I
5H9D
6?B
1
41D1
35>D5B
+53D9?>




•
.80
.8
9-*
*=548:7*
94
4((:5&9.43&1
-&?&7)8
&3)
9-*>


&7*
*;&1:&9*)
'>
2*9-4)414,.*8
94
*1.2.3&9*
9-*
7.808












47
(439741
9-*2
,85
CEBF5I
=1@@54
D85
G?B;
5H@5B95>35
1>4
D85
B?<5
?B

•
.80
.8
(7488.3,
9-*
+7*6:*3(>
&3)
574'&'.1.9>
4+
&
6E>3D9?>
?6
@1BD939@1>DC
B5<1D54
D?
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
697


-&?&7)

&88*88
7.80
9-74:,-
+.*1)
4'8*7;&9.438
9-*
0*>


(1BD939@1>DC
81F5
G?B;
5H@5B95>35
6B?=


I51B
D?


54.39
.8
:3)*789&3).3,
574(*88
45*7&9.43
&3)
-:2&3
I51BC
G9D8
1>
1F5B175
?6


I51BC



9&808
4<*;*7
.3
2>
/4'
9-*
7.80
&88*882*39
.8
&
+472
!>
D85
CEBF5I
B5C@?>C929<9D95C
=1@@54
?ED
G85D85B
D85

+.11*)
43
9-*
)*80
@1BD939@1>DC
3?=@1>95C
814
1
49665B5>D
45@1BD=5>D
D81D

•
.80
.8
842*9-.3,
9-&9
-&8
9-*
549*39.&1
94
(&:8*
-&72
81>4<54
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
?B
=1>1754
2I
D85
C1=5

94
842*43*
88*88
.9
'>
.)*39.+>.3,
.9
)*(.).3,
<-4
45@1BD=5>D

2?ED


?6
@1BD939@1>DC
1>CG5B54
D81D
D859B

(4:1)
'*
-&72*)
&3)
-4<
;&1:&9.3,
9-*
7.808
&3)
3?=@1>I
81C
D85
C1=5
45@1BD=5>D
B5C@?>C92<5
6?B
2?D8
?6

)*(.).3,
43
57*(&:9.438
94
5:9
.3
51&(*
7*(47)
&3)
D85C5
49C39@<9>5C

+?=5
?6
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
1B51
?6

.251*2*39
94
&11
*2514>**8
#4:
8-4:1)
7*;.*<
&3)
B5C@?>C929<9DI
9>3<E45
51<D8
C165DI
5>F9B?>=5>D
1>4

:5)&9*
<-*3
7*6:.7*)
AE1<9DI
 +)
51<D8
+165DI
1>4
>F9B?>=5>D
 +

•
9
.8
9-*
1.0*1.-44)
4+
&3
*;*39
-&55*3.3,
&3)
.98
51<D8
+165DI
>F9B?>=5>D
1>4
+53EB9DI
 ++
+165DI

(438*6:*3(*8
1>4
+53EB9DI
DB19>9>7
B57E<1D?BI
16619BC
1E49D
1>4
<571<

•
.80
.8
&3
455479:3.9>
94
1*&73
&3)
.2574;*
3?=@<91>35


•
74'&'.1.9>
4+
*;*39
4((:77.3,
=
*;*7.9>
4+
*;*39


4((:77.3,

,?
?EB
CEB@B9C5
?><I
?>5
@1BD939@1>D
=5>D9?>54
E>35BD19>DI

B5<1D54
D?
D85
B9C;
3?>35@D
G89<5
C5F5B1<
B5<954 ?>
!+'C

4569>9D9?>C
?6
B9C;



?B
9>CD1>35
?>5
?6
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
45C3B9254
B9C;
1>4

B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
=5D8?4?<?7I
9>
D85
6?<<?G9>7
G1I
"*

)*+.3*
7.80
).++*7*391>
)*5*3).3,
43
9-*
(439*=9
<-.(-



2*&38
9-&9
<*
:8*
).++*7*39
7.80
)*+.3.9.438
)*5*3).3,
43
#
*#

&

 


9-*
<470
8(45*
*3*7&11>
<*
:8*
).++*7*39
7.80
2*9-4)8
+47

*(:7.9>
&3)
&+*9>
3
4:7
.3):897>
9-*7*
&7*
897.(9
/85>
G5
1C;54
G8938
1B51C
?6
B5C@?>C929<9DI
?B
D1C;C

7*6:.7*2*398
'&8*)
43
9-*
+&(9
9-&9
9-*
(438*6:*3(*8
(&3
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
494
D85
B5CE<D
9C
D85
?@@?C9D5

2?ED

?6

'*
8*;*7*
+47
84(.*9>
9-*
*3;.7432*39
&3)
1.+*
!-*7*+47*
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
G?B;54
G9D8
D85
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
CE2:53D

 Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference 495

1B51C

!>
3?>DB1CD

?><I
G?B;
G9D8
D85
C165DI
4?=19>

-&;.3,
8.2.1&7
4'/*(9.;*8
&3)
94418
4<*;*7
9-*
(-&11*3,*

B?=
?EB
41D1
G5
?2C5BF5
D81D
C?=5
@1BD939@1>DC
G8?
81F5
.8
9-&9
.9
.8
9&0*3
+47
,7&39*)
9-&9
<*
-&;*
*34:,-
034<1*),*

G?B;54
G9D8
D85
CE2:53D
6?B
1
<?>7
D9=5
81F5
255>
79F5>
&3)
80.118
94
5*7+472
'49-
8&+*9>
&3)
8*(:7.9>7*1&9*)

1449D9?>1<
G?B;
D1C;C
1>4
=?B5
B5C@?>C929<9D95C


&(9.;.9.*8



?G5F5B
69>49>7C
6B?=
D85
C53EB9DI
4?=19>
494
>?D

9=@<I
81F9>7
CE38
?F5B<1@@9>7
1>4
5H@53D1D9?>

!D
C55=C

D85I
C53EB9DI
@B?65CC9?>1<C
814
1
=?B5
133EB1D5
:?2

45C3B9@D9?>
/!
9>
<9>5
G9D8
D859B
419<I
13D9F9D95C
/


,85I
=5>D9?>54
8?G5F5B
D81D
1
D1C;
F1B91D9?>
9C
12?ED
D85

71@
25DG55>
D85
C53EB9DI
695<4
1>4
9>6?B=1D9?>
C53EB9DI

4?=19>
@1BD93E<1B<I
3I25BC53EB9DI


'>5
?6
?EB
@1BD939@1>DC
C194
<-*3
&
(>'*7&99&(0
47


(>'*7
.3(.)*39
4((:78
.3
9-*
.3+472&9.43
8*(:7.9>
)42&.3

#
+#




!

9-*
!
)*5&792*39
9&0*8
9-*
.3;*89.,&9.43
8
1*&)
*;*3

 !

 &
!

"
9-4:,-
.9
.8
9-*
8*(:7.9>
)*5&792*398
(47*
9&80
!-*

)*;.&9.43
-*7*
.8
7*1&9*)
94
9-*
741*
(43+:8.43
<-*3
9-*

'EB
69>49>7
9>4931D5C
D81D
3?=@1>95C
G85B5
?EB
8*(:7.9>
)*5&792*39
8:554798
9-*
!
)*5&792*39
):7.3,

@1BD939@1>DC
G?B;
=?CD<I

G1>D
D?
49665B5>D91D5
(>'*78*(:7.9>
.3;*89.,&9.438

25DG55>
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
49C39@<9>5C
2I
?B71>9J9>7
1>4
>
5H1=@<5
=5>D9?>54
2I
?>5
?6
?EB
@1BD939@1>DC
G1C

@<139>7
D85
B5C@?>C929<9DI
?>
49665B5>D
45@1BD=5>DC
?B
@1BDC
B5<1D54
D?
1>
5=5B75>3I
5H9D
6?B
1
41D1
35>D5B

9
.8
(7:(.&1

?6
D85
?B71>9J1D9?>
697



,I@931<
5H1=@<5C
6B?=
+47
9-*
(425&3>
9-&9
9-*
)&9&
(*39*7
<4708
&8
.9
8-4:1)

9>D5BF95GC
1B5
D81D
9-*

)*5&792*39
.8
7*85438.'1*
+47
49-*7<.8*
.9
&++*(98
.98
+:3(9.43&1.9>
-*3(*
7*5:9&9.43
!6

8&+*9>
<.9-
&
'&(0,74:3)
.3
 

 
&7*&
<-.1*
9-*
1>
9>3945>D
?33EBC
9>
D85
41D1
35>D5B
C?
D81D
@5BC?>>5<
9>C945

':8.3*888
45*7&9.43&1
5&79
.8
7*85438.'1*
+47
8*(:7.9>

=ECD
5F13E1D5
D85=C5<F5C
133?B49>7
D?
25CD
@B13D935

+?=5
?6
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
1<C?
C194
D81D
*
9C
1<C?
7E945<9>5C
/!

,85>
D85
5=5B75>3I
5H9D
=ECD
25
?@5>
?B

B5C@?>C92<5
6?B
;>?G<5475
45F5<?@=5>D

!>
C?=5
31C5C
D85
51C9<I
?@5>C
C?
D81D
D85
5F13E1D9?>
31>
?33EB
9>
1
=9>9=E=

B5CE<D
?6
D85
9>D5BF95G
C8?GC
D81D
D85
*
45@1BD=5>D
9C
D9=5

'>
D85
?D85B
81>4
D85
C1=5
5=5B75>3I
5H9D
4??B
=ECD

B5C@?>C92<5
6?B
8E=1>
B5C?EB35C
G89<5
C559>7
1
<9DD<5
DB135
B5C9CD
2EB7<1BI
45D53D
1DD5=@D54
2EB7<1BI
C12?D175
1>4

?6
D85
9>C945
D8B51DC
381<<5>75C
1>4
81>4<9>7
5H1=@<5
9>
>?D96I
9D
/



+53D9?>



+?=5
?6
D85
49665B5>35C
G5B5
B5<1D54
D?
D85
,89C
5H1=@<5
9<<ECDB1D5C
D85
@?CC92<5
71@
25DG55>

@1BD939@1>DC
419<I
13D9F9D95C
1>4
B5C@?>C929<9D95C
/
1>4
/!
1>4
/
>1=5<I
?@5B1D9?>1<
F1B9129<9DI

!>
451<9>7

:?2
45C3B9@D9?>C
/!

+?=5
?6
D85
49665B5>35C
G5B5
G9D8
F1B9129<9DI
9D
9C
>535CC1BI
D?
3?>C945B
C165DI
1>4

B5<1D54
D?
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
419<I
13D9F9D95C
1>4
C53EB9DI
C9=E<D1>5?EC<I
+D55>
 
?D85BG9C5
D85
69>1<

B5C@?>C929<9D95C
/
1>4
:?2
45C3B9@D9?>C
/!

+?=5
C?<ED9?>
G9<<
81F5
C5B9?EC
FE<>5B129<9D95C

+E@@?C5
G5
D1;5

?6
D85
49665B5>35C
G5B5
B5<1D54
D?
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
419<I
1
CD1BD9>7
@?9>D
D81D
D85
5=5B75>3I
5H9D
C8?E<4
?@5>
AE93;<I

13D9F9D95C
1>4
B5C@?>C929<9D95C
/
1>4
:?2
45C3B9@D9?>C
9>
1>
9>3945>D
D81D
B5AE9B5C
5F13E1D9?>

5C945C
D85B5
1B5

/!

/5
C55
D81D

?6
@1BD939@1>DC
G?B;
G9D8
?B
1B5
=1>I
6E>3D9?>1<
1>4
D538>931<
B5AE9B5=5>DC
6?3EC9>7
?>

B5C@?>C92<5
6?B
2?D8
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
1B51C
+.,



8?G
61CD
9D
3?E<4
25
?@5>54
D?
C53EB5
D85
<?31D9?>
1719>CD


?D85B
D8B51DC
6?B
9>CD1>35
2EB7<1BI



$5DC
<??;
1D
1
3?>3B5D5
D538>931<
5H1=@<5
G9D8
1
D9=5

45<1I
1D
D85
5=5B75>3I
5H9D

,85
B978D
C?<ED9?>
85B5
9C

5>D9B5<I
45@5>45>D
?>
81F9>7
1
21<1>354
=51CEB5
D81D
D1;5C

31B5
?6
D85
>554C
6?B
5F13E1D9?>
1>4
D85
>554
D?
@B?D53D
D85

1D1
5>D5B
1D
D85
C1=5
D9=5

,89C
5H1=@<5
@?9>DC
D?
G81D

?5CC<9>7 *59C5=1>>
1>4
,895B
 
@

@ED
9D
D85

)>3&2.(
(-&3,*8
.3
8>89*2
897:(9:7*
&3)
*3;.7432*39


.77*,:1&7
(43).9.438
1.2.9*)
57*).(9&'.1.9>
&3)
8:757.8*8

#
,#
 &


!
!
!
&(9.3,
43
9-*
8>89*2




!

 !
>?D85B
F1B91D9?>
25DG55>
/!
1>4
/


8978<978D54
9>
?EB
9>D5BF95GC
G1C
B5<1D54
D?
DB19>9>7

*571B49>7
6E>3D9?>1<
F1B9129<9DI
C165DI
@B?65CC9?>1<C
13D9F9D95C

!D
D?E385C
?>
8?G
D?
141@D
D85
;>?G<5475
6B?=

=5>D9?>54
14=9>9CDB1D9F5
G?B;
1C
D85
=?CD
C97>96931>D
14F5BC5
39B3E=CD1>35C

(1BD939@1>DC
2?D8
6B?=
D85
C165DI

F1B91D9?>
9>
D859B
B?<5
3?=@1B54
G9D8
D859B
:?2
45C3B9@D9?>

1>4
C53EB9DI
4?=19>
=5>D9?>54
D85
3?>4E3D9?>
?6
452B956C

+5F5B1<
@1BD939@1>DC
6B?=
D85
C165DI
4?=19>
>?D54
D81D
D859B
16D5B
1>
9>3945>D

?B=1<
54E31D9?>
9C
1<C?
39D54
1C
1>?D85B

419<I
13D9F9D95C
/
9>3<E45
C53EB9DI
D1C;C
5F5>
D8?E78
C?EB35
?6
<51B>9>7



D85I
1B5
>?D
5H@<939D<I
4569>54
9>
D859B
:?2
45C3B9@D9?>C
'>5
?6
D85
@1BD939@1>DC
C53EB9DI
4?=19>
45C3B925C
9D

/!


1C
2>
*):(&9.43
.8
)>3&2.(
&3)

&2
89.11
1*&73.3,
&3)

,85C5
D1C;C
9>3<E45
9>3945>D
9>F5CD971D9?>C
3853;9>7
)*;*145
2>8*1+
&3)
97>
94
&551>
1*&73.3,
54.398
.3
2>
)&.1>

1<1B=C
1>4
31=5B1C
1>4
=?B5

/5
6?<<?G54
E@
G9D8
9&808
5B5
D85
@1BD939@1>D
@?9>D54
D?
D85
9=@?BD1>35
?6

AE5CD9?>C
?>
G8I
D89C
9C
D85
31C5

'>5
@1BD939@1>D
4I>1=93
<51B>9>7
D?
9>3B51C5
5H@<939D
1>4
D139D
;>?G<5475

5H@<19>54
$@%
8&+*9>
&3)
8*(:7.9>
&7*
1.30*)
94,*9-*7
'>

 Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference 496

:E47=5>D
C;9<<C
1>4
129<9D95C

?B
2?D8
D85
C165DI
1>4
13D9F9D95C

+E38
1
=5381>9C=
81C
D?
CDB5>7D85>
3??@5B1D9?>

C53EB9DI
4?=19>
4I>1=93
<51B>9>7
5>81>35C
3?@9>7
25DG55>
D85C5
DG?
4?=19>C
1>4
9>3B51C5
9>D5B?@5B129<9DI

31@129<9D95C
D?
451<
G9D8
3?=@<5H9D95C
9>
@5B6?B=9>7
419<I
9>D57B1D9>7
@<1>C
1>4
CDB1D5795C

!D
9C
<9>;54
D?
1>
?@5B1D9?>1<

D1C;C
(B?F1>
/??4C
5;;5B

*15

+D55>
3?==E>931D9?>
CDB1D57I
2E9<D
?>
DBECD
1>4
?@5>>5CC

(1DB91B31

9
B1F9?



25DG55>
D85
@1BD95C
9>F?<F54


*5C9<95>35
9>
D89C
3?>D5HD
9C

>?D85B
@1BD939@1>D
9>
D85
C165DI
4?=19>
3?==5>D54
12?ED
259>7
2?D8
5669395>D
1>4
@B?13D9F5

/89<5
56653D9F5

?>
<51B>9>7
9D
9>
D85
6?<<?G9>7
G1I
9-*7*
.8
34
+4(:8
43
3?==E>931D9?>
9C
12?ED
3?==E>931D9>7
1<<
B5<5F1>D

1*&73.3,
7*1&9*)
94
*;*398
.3
4:7
7.80
2&3&,*2*39
9>6?B=1D9?>
9>
1>
?@5>
8?>5CD
133EB1D5
1>4
@B539C5
G1I

574(*):7*8
$@%
*&72.88
.3(.)*398
47
*;*398
&7*
349
+@5D1<5>
+DK<5>

5=


@B?13D9F9DI
5=2B135C

7*5479*)
47
&9
'*89
&7*
:3)*77*5479*)

259>7
1D
D85
6?B56B?>D
?6
@?CC92<5
9>DBEC9F5
C9DE1D9?>C


,89C
3?==5>D
=1I
9>4931D5
1
3E<DEB5
?6
651B
9>
D85

3?=@1>I
G8938
=51>C
D81D
9=@?BD1>D
9>6?B=1D9?>
4?5C
>?D


!




B5138
C5>9?B
=1>175=5>D

!D
1<C?
@?9>DC
D?
?B71>9J1D9?>1<

3E<DEB5
1>4
9DC
56653D
?>
<51B>9>7
6B?=
D85
9>3945>D
1>4
>51B 'EB
1>1<IC9C
45=?>CDB1D5C
D81D
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI

=9CC
9>3945>DC

!>C978D
9>D?
?B71>9J1D9?>1<
<51B>9>7
9C
;5I
D?
@B?65CC9?>1<C
81F5
=1>I
3?==?>1<9D95C
9>
3?>4E3D9>7
D859B

E>45BCD1>49>7
3?>D5HDC
85>35
9=@B?F9>7
B5C9<95>35
419<I
D1C;C

?B
9>CD1>35
D85I
2?D8
3?>C945B
D859B
3?B5

 ?<<>175<



,85
1*&73.3,
574(*88
)*;*1458
,*3*7&1
B5C@?>C929<9DI
D?
@B?D53D
?B71>9J1D9?>1<
F1<E5C
3?>35B>9>7

80.118
3**)*)
+47
+:9:7*
&342&1.*8
/??4C


D8EC
5=@<?I55C
@B?@5BDI
5>F9B?>=5>DC
B5@ED1D9?>
?@5B1D9?>1<

5>81>35C
D85
129<9DI
D?
1>D939@1D5
381>75C


1>4
=?B5

?D8
13;>?G<5475
D85
B?<5
?6
DB19>9>7
D?
5>81>35

*571B4<5CC
?6
G8938
4?=19>
?B71>9J1D9?>C
>554
D?
41I D? 41I
13D9F9D95C

?G5F5B
49665B5>D
D5B=9>?<?7I
9C

<??;
1D
8?G
D85I
=19>D19>
?@5B1D9?>C
G85>
D85
DB149D9?>1<
EC54
1>4
F1B9?EC
1C@53DC
1B5
8978<978D54

,85
D5B=9>?<?7I

G1I
?6
@<1>>9>7
6?B
?@5B1D9?>C
>?
<?>75B
@B?F945C
145AE1D5
9C
D?
1
F1BI9>7
457B55
3?>C9CD5>D
G9D8
D85
9>D5>D9?>C
1>4

13D9?>
7E945<9>5C

*1D85B
D81>
144B5CC9>7
D85
CICD5=C
1=29D9?>C
?6
D85
1>1<IC9C

,85I
1<C?
1@@<I
49665B5>D
B9C;

C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
DB149D9?>1<<I
21C54
?>
31EC1<9DI
3B54?
1CC5CC=5>D
D538>9AE5C
D??<C
1>4
CD1>41B4C
D?
@B?F945

2E9<D
?>
1
C5>C5
?6
@B5493D129<9DI
?6
1
CICD5=C
6EDEB5
9>C978DC
9>D?
D85
D8B51D
@85>?=5>1
@B?35CC5C
13D9F9D95C
1>4

@5B6?B=1>35
D85I
>554
D?
13;>?G<5475
@5B6?B=1>35
FE<>5B129<9DI
?6
D85
CICD5=
259>7
1>1<IJ54
1>4
945>D96I

F1B9129<9DI

+165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
31>>?D
25
?2D19>54
2I
1@@B?@B91D5
=51CEB5C
D?
451<
G9D8
D85
CICD5=C

3?>CDB19>9>7
@5B6?B=1>35
F1B9129<9DI
C9>35
D81D
G?E<4
1<C?
FE<>5B129<9D95C



16653D
D85
45C9B54
?ED3?=5C

!>CD514
D85
C?<ED9?>
9C
D?
'>
D85
?>5
81>4
D85
3?>D9>E1<<I
9>3B51C9>7
<5F5<
?6

41=@5>
F1B9129<9DI
D81D
=1I
<514
D?
14F5BC5
56653DC
1>4
E>35BD19>DI
9>
D85
?B71>9J1D9?>1<
5>F9B?>=5>D
1>4
D85

C9=E<D1>5?EC<I
B59>6?B35
F1B9129<9DI
D81D
=1I
<514
D?
7B?G9>7
9>D57B1D9?>
?6
9>6?B=1D9?>
D538>?<?795C
9>D?

@?C9D9F5
B5CE<DC


@?D5>D91<
C?<ED9?>
D?
D85
381<<5>75C
9>4ECDB91<
3?>DB?<
CICD5=C
81F5
3B51D54
1
2?B45B<9>5

9>F?<F54
9>
D85
C9DE1D9?>
G9D8
8978
E>35BD19>DI
9C
D?
45F5<?@
25DG55>
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
3?>D5HDC


'>
D85
?D85B
6?3EC

1
8?<9CD93
1@@B?138
9>D57B1D9>7
B9C;
1>4
B5C9<95>35 21C54
?>
5669395>3I
9451<<I
19=54
1D
G?B;9>7
61CD5B
25DD5B
1>4

D89>;9>7
?9>

.1>
5D5>


,85;49

F5>



3B51D9>7
3?>DB1493D?BI
?B71>9J1D9?>1<
7?1<C

4F5BC9D95C

'EB
69>49>7
1<C?
9>3<E45C
3?==5>DC
12?ED
D85
7B?E@
CDB5CC
1>4
B54E354
6E>3D9?>1<9D95C
9>
D85
41I D? 41I

4I>1=93
"?>5C

*?5<?6C=1

25DG55>
C165DI
1>4

C53EB9DI
4?=19>

$@%

-&;*
&
,44)
*=&251*
&
+*<
<**08

'&(0
&'4:9
&
574/*(9
9-&9
)*&18
<.9-
97&385479
!-*
574/*(9

,74:5
(438.89*)
4+
8*;*3
5*451*
<.9-
'49-
8&+*9>
&3)


(B?35CC5C
>554
D?
25
9>9D91D54
D?
CDB5>7D85>
D85

8*(:7.9>
).8(.51.3*8
<-4
<*7*
94
9&0*
&
(148*7
1440
&9
9-*

97&385479
4+
&
574):(9
9-&9
.8
;*7>
(7.9.(&1
+47
4:7
':8.3*88


*1D85B
D81>
=1>179>7
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI

9
+.789
,1&3(*
9-*
7*5479
<&8
'&8*)
43

&3)
9-*

&3&1>8.8
8**2*)
,44)
:9
<-*3

&80*)
&'4:9
842*
5&798

4+
9-*
7*5479
43
-4<
>4:
-&)
&77.;*)
&9
9-*
7*8:19
!-*

574/*(9
9*&2
(4:1)
349
&38<*7
2>
6:*89.438

6:.(01>


,89C
@B?=9C9>7
1B51
C8?E<4
25
5H@<?B54

(43(1:)*)
9-&9
9-*7*
<&8
&
1&(0
4+
97&(*&'.1.9>
&3)

;*7.+.&'.1.9>


>?D85B
@1BD939@1>D
6B?=
D85
C165DI
4?=19>



=5>D9?>54
1>
?2C5BF1D9?>
B5<1D54
D?
D85
'.!


C9DE1D9?>
"*
)4
*;*7>9-.3,
<*
(&3
94
).88*2.3&9*
5*451*

&3)
&;4.)
5*451*
,*99.3,
94,*9-*7
94
&;4.)
(411*(9.;*
47


#1>179>7
9>6?B=1D9?>
C53EB9DI
B9C;C

D85

(422:3.9>
.3+*(9.43
!-*
8*(:7.9>
)*(.)*)
94
'14(0
9-*

?@5B1D9?>
6?B
2?D8
@B?65CC9?>1<C
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI

DI@931<<I
B5<1D5
D?
D85
DB51D=5>D
?6
E>35BD19>D95C
G8938
9C

>?D
5H@<939D<I
B56<53D54
9>
D85
DB149D9?>1<
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D

@B?35CC
1@@<931D9?>
?6
D85?B5D931<
F95G
9>
@B13D935
6?B
2?D8

49C39@<9>5C
C5@1B1D5<I
21C54
?>
4917>?CD93
3?>DB?<C
1
@?D5>D91<
C?<ED9?>

D?
8978
E>35BD19>DI
C9DE1D9?>C
9C
D?
45F5<?@
1
8?<9CD93
B9C;

=1>175=5>D
1@@B?138
9>D57B1D9>7
B9C;
1>4
B5C9<95>35
21C54
D89>;9>7
6B?=
>?B=1D9F5
3?>35@DE1<
1>4
45C3B9@D9F5
=?45
?6

?2D19>9>7
@B13D931<
1>4
?@5B1D9?>1<
9=@<931D9?>C
<9>5C
?6

B5C51B38
9>
6EDEB5



<25BDC


%*,
1@@B?138

9<=98
..3<98*/<6/B


'&),*8
.+
5*78433*1
-&;*
349
:8*)
9-*2
*39*7*)
9-*
<25BDC
 
58B5>C
 )

&5D891
 (

%@5B1D9?>1<<I

':.1).3,
9-*
1&89
8*;*3
)&>8
:))*31>
*;*7>'4)>
3**)*)
B9D931<
*8B51D
CC5D
1>4
,E<>5B129<9DI
F1<E1D9?>

%*,
B1=5G?B;
,5BC9?>


(&
/:+;=7/8=
90

94
,*9
.38.)*
94
7*&1.?*
9-&9
9-*.7
'&),*
<&8
'14(0*)
&3)

/0/8</
'2/
&90=@+;/
8138//;381
8<=3=>=/

*36<98
%*

(4:1)
349
,*9
.3
!-*
7*8:19
<&8
&3
*34724:8
1.3*
4+
5*451*
F5>
*


(9C;
1>1<IC9C

1CC5CC9>7
E>35BD19>D95C
25I?>4

&9
9-*
2&.3
,&9*
94
:3'14(0
9-*.7
'&),*8
5H@53D54
F1<E5C
1>4
@B?2129<9D95C

5B5
G5
C55
D85
>554
6?B
=5381>9C=C
D81D
5>CEB5
F5>
*



3?>35@DE1<
6?E>41D9?>
6?B
1CC5CC9>7
1>4

CI>38B?>9J9>7
F1B9?EC
C165DI
1>4
C53EB9DI
7?1<C
1>4
=1>179>7
B9C;
CEB@B9C5C
1>4
2<13;
CG1>C
>

#?D5D



 Proceedings of the 31st European Safety and Reliability Conference 497

9545B
4C 
=2/
66><398
90
%3<5
98=;96
@@

#E:5528=54
#
& 
)5?

! 

&19;

!
 

)@B9>75B
81=
4?9
 
 0
&B?2129<9CD93
1@@B?138
6?B
3?<<9C9?>
B9C;
1>1<IC9C
?6
@?G5B54

F5>
*

*85;49
)
 
*85
=@?BD1>35
?6
(5C9<95>35 F5CC5<
G9D8
?66C8?B5
@<1D6?B=C
"-/+8
/8138//;381


1C54
)DB1D5795C
9>
(9C;
>1<IC9C
1>4
,935
,5BC1
>


 
4?9 
: ?351>5>7   

*BE=@
# ,
<?B9>


"9>;?F
4C 
(
B5C?EB35
%:1>5>

 
*85
+C
&?G5B
9>
8=/;";1+83C+=398+6

7E945
?>
B5C9<95>35
,?<E=

?=19>C
?6
B5C9<95>35
6?B
%/6+=398<

3?=@<5H
9>D5B3?>>53D54
CICD5=C

"1EC1>>5
&1DB91B31
( 
9
B1F9?
 
?CD1>D9>?
 
1<57>1=9
 


)G9DJ5B<1>4
>D5B>1D9?>1<
(9C;
?F5B>1>35
?E>39<
9<?DD1

 
>
>1<ID93
B1=5G?B;
D?
CC5CC

(
%B71>9J1D9?>1<
(5C9<95>35
&+0/=B
+8.
/+6=2
+=
*9;5


<?;<1>4
&


(5>95BC

"
  
*85
?E@<9>7
?6
)165DI
 
4?9 
: C81G   

1>4
)53EB9DI
H@<?B9>7
>D5BB5<1D9?>C
9>
*85?BI
1>4
&5D5BC5>
!
" 

(L>>
!
,
 
>DB?4E39>7
D85
C@5391<

&B13D935

M

)@B9>D5B
%@5>
4?9
 
 9CCE5
2B9>79>7
9>
D85
@E2<93
>D5<<975>35
?>
D85
6B?>D95B

 
25DG55>
CD1D5
1>4
39F9<
C?395DI


?9>


F1>
5D5>
#


 
*85
(5C9<95>D

4?9
 
    

%B71>9J1D9?>

,?<

CCE5

 
M

#>,63-
&B?F1>


-??4C

 
5;;5B
)
-
 

(15



7+8+1/7/8=
;/?3/@
  
)165DI

@B?65CC9?>1<C
?G
B5C9<95>35
5>79>55B9>7

B19D8G19D5

-51BC
( " 
?<<>175<

 
(5C9<95>D
31>
DB1>C6?B=
C165DI
@B13D935
%/63+,363=B
8138//;381
+8.

851<D8
31B5
DEB>9>7
@1D95>D
C165DI
?>
9DC
8514

8=/;8+=398+6
&B<=/7
&+0/=B

4?9 
: B5CC  

9>;8+6
09;
$>+63=B
38
/+6=2
+;/

 



 
(5>>
%
 
(9C;
7?F5B>1>35

3?@9>7
G9D8
E>35BD19>DI
9>
1

B?5;8E9J5>
 
B??D8E9C%E4C8??B>


# 
F1>
*9<

 
3?=@<5H
G?B<4
"?>4?>
+;=2<-+8

E==5<

# 

:J5B=1>
#

 

(5F95G
1>4
(5>>
%
  
$5G
381<<5>75C
6?B
B9C;
1>1<IC9C
CICD5=93

<1CC96931D9?>
?6
@@B?1385C
6?B
51<9>7
G9D8
+>35BD19>DI
B9C;C
9>;8+6
90
;3<5
;/</+;-2
+2/+.90:;38=
+2/+.90
9>
#E<D9B9D5B91
539C9?>
>1<IC9C
6?B
51<D831B5
:;38=

4?9 
   

539C9?>C
#2+;7+-9-98973-<
 

(931B45J)1>4?F1<
"

  
%@D9=1<
45C97>
1>4
3?>DB?<
?6

4?9 
C  H
4I>1=93
CICD5=C
E>45B
E>35BD19>DI

:;9,+,363<=3-

1B1<<9
(
 
)D5F5>C

 
.?E>7
"
( 

-9<C?>
-
(
+::;9+-2
97:>=/;<

-2/73-+6
/8138//;381



 
>DB?4E39>7
?3D1F5
1<<57B?
=@B?F9>7
D85
4?9 
: 3?=@385=5>7   

9>6?B=1D9?>
C53EB9DI
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
@B?35CC
+;8/13/ )@5D1<5>
*
 
)DL<5>
 

5=
"

 
#5B;5B
9
;B9C5

/6698
(83?
#3==<,>;12
#
&90=@+;/
8138//;381
8<=
CDB1D579C;
=5B;5F1B5<545<C5
C?=
=?45B5B5>45
61;D?B

B5CG5<<

- 

B5CG5<<


 
(5C51B38
45C97>
+17+



'E1<9D1D9F5
AE1>D9D1D9F5
1>4
=9H54
=5D8?4C
1@@B?1385C
)?395DI
6?B
(9C;
>1<IC9C
 
&9-3/=B
09;
%3<5
8+6B<3<

&+1/
:>,63-+=398<
'29><+8.
"+5<
+6309;83+
&+1/
69<<+;B

8DD@

CB1 ?B7
C9D5C
4561E<D
69<5C
@46
)( 

:>,63-+=398<
<?CC1BI

 $" @46

G?B;9>
)
"
  
)1=@<5
)9J5
&?<93I
6?B
'E1<9D1D9F5
)38E<=1>
&
(
  
)165DI
1>4
)53EB9DI
#1>175B91<

)DE495C
+C9>7
>5@D8
>D5BF95GC
;-2
&/A
/2+?
 
*5>C9?>C
1>4
)I>5B795C
>

9545B


!
&5DD5BC5>


 
4?9 
C 


41 
'2/
9>:6381
90
&+0/=B
+8.
&/->;3=B
A:69;381

1>9>

 
'E138
& 
&1>G1B
# 
?<<95B
/
 
!59C<5B

8=/;;/6+=398<
38
'2/9;B
+8.
#;+-=3-/

)@B9>75B

# 
#1B385C5
 

"9>;?F

 
>6=3-;3=/;3+
81=
4?9   0

/-3<398
;+7/@9;5
09;
B,/;</->;3=B
%3<5
<</<<7/8=
+8.
)D1>41B4
$?B75
 
(5AE9B5=5>DC
6?B
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
$)

+8+1/7/8=
%3<5
8+6
 

 
"IC1;5B
&=+8.+;.
!9;1/

4?9 
B9C1  
)D1>41B4
$?B75
 
)?395D1<
C53EB9DI

&B?D53D9?>
1719>CD

?5CC<9>7(59C5=1>>
) 

*895B
&
 
%>
D85
49665B5>35
9>D5>D9?>1<
E>45C9B12<5
13D9?>C

(5AE9B5=5>DC
6?B
C53EB9DI

25DG55>
B9C;
=1>175=5>D
1>4
B5C9<95>35
=1>175=5>D
6?B
B9C;
1>1<IC9C
$)
  
"IC1;5B
&=+8.+;.
!9;1/

3B9D931<
9>6B1CDBE3DEB5C
>

%>=2

&
9/<<6381 )D55>
(
 
%>
D85
1@@<931D9?>
?6
D85
)165DI
3?>35@D
9>
1

%/3</7+88
.<
+8.,995
98
%/<363/8-/
90
&9-39 C53EB9DI
3?>D5HD
>;9:/+8
9>;8+6
09;
&/->;3=B
%/</+;-2

'/-283-+6
&B<=/7<


85<D5>81=
+!
4G1B4


 

<71B
&E2<9C89>7
"9=9D54
)D55>
( 
&1DB91B31
( 

9
B1F9?

  
*85
389=5B1
?6

?<<>175<

 
53?=9>7
(5C9<95>D
>
&

$5=5D8


D9=5

H@<?B9>7
D85
6E>3D9?>1<
@B?@5BD95C
?6
1>
5=5B75>3I

?<<>175<
4C 
%/<363/8-/
/8138//;381
38
:;+-=3-/

B5C@?>C5
B??=
9>
13D9?>
9>;8+6
90
98=381/8-3/<
+8.
;3<3<

)96>7/



/-97381
;/<363/8=


1B>81=
+!
+8+1/7/8=
4?9 
  

C871D5
@E2<9C89>7
)EB9

 
&EB@?C56E<
)1=@<9>7
9>
'E1<9D1D9F5
(5C51B38

%
  
)165DI
#1>175=5>D

#1>E1<
)##
>

)I>D85C9C
$>+63=+=3?/
;/</+;-2
49>;8+6
 




8=/;8+=398+6
3?36
?3+=398
";1+83C+=398
4?9 
'(  

>D5B>1D9?>1<
)D1>41B4
 
(9C;
#1>175=5>D
M
E945<9>5C
*1B495E
 
)9=?>>51E
* 

#E<<5B

 
*85

)%
 
&8IC9?<?7931<
1C9C
?6
B?E78D
*?<5B1>35
9>
B?@
&<1>DC


?>5C
&
 

(?5<?6C=1
&

#
&
 
*85
@?D5>D91<
6?B
&-/8+;39/:/8./8=
#;9,+,363<=3-
::;9+-2
88>
%/?

C?391<
3?>D5HDE1<
1>4
7B?E@
291C5C
9>
D51=
4539C9?>=1;9>7
#6+8=
396
 

4?9 
1>>EB5F1B@<1>D
,3+</<
-98.3=398<
+8.
:<B-296913-+6
7/-2+83<7<
  

;198973-<

 
*85;49
)
1>4
*
F5>
 
>
9>D57B1D54
@5BC@53D9F5
6?B

4?9 

21<1>39>7
@5B6?B=1>35
1>4
B9C;

%/63+,363=B
8138//;381


?B5
)

 
*85
?>35@DE1<
1>4
)395>D9693
5=1B31D9?>
?6
&B<=/7
&+0/=B

)96>7

 

)53EB9DI
9>
?>DB1CD
D?
)165DI 
>;9:/+8
9>;8+6
09;
-??4C

 
*85
D85?BI
?6
7B1356E<
5HD5>C929<9DI
21C93

&/->;3=B
%/</+;-2
 

BE<5C
D81D
7?F5B>
141@D9F5
CICD5=C
9;7/;6B
'2/

"1>4?<<

 
*85
C53EB9DI
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>D
81>42??;

1
8?3;987/8=+63<=


4?9 
C
3?=@<5D5
7E945
6?B
@5B6?B=9>7
C53EB9DI
B9C;
1CC5CC=5>DC 


%
#;/<<
'+B69;

;+8-3<
;9>: