You are on page 1of 31

&

    


  

N?, *" 
 9=1?CD?>
C5=5CDB545

@@  





     
  
 
  

 

  
%!-)*!#!%+

  
&5413D14?19>939?C45<C97<?,*5<7479=27-.4*,76>.:;2H6-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;-.
"4*@,*4* 5C E>1 @95J1 4B1=KD931 45 31BK3D5B 4?3DB9>1< 3EI? 1B7E=5>D? 79B1 5>
D?B>?1E>5@9C?49?89CDOB93?<575>41B9?1=@<91=5>D5496E>494?@?B5>D?>35C5>
1AE5<<1@B?F9>391CD121C51B7E=5>D1<AE5:ECD96931<19>C5B39O>45<D5HD?5>5<
=1>EC3B9D?45ED9LBB5J45 E>1<?F9>3E<11CEF5J1<3?>D5HD?@?<MD93?5945?
<O793?5>5<AE56E53?=@E5CD?C9295>5C395BD?AE5<1<5I5>415>D?B>?1<1
D5=@B1>1135@D139O>45<3B9CD91>9C=?@?B@1BD545<?C7?25B>1>D5CD<1H31<D531C
AE541CE2?B49>1415><1?2B11<@B?@OC9D?B5<979?C?45<1=9C=1
*4*+:*;,4*>.ED9LBB5J45 E>17479=27-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;-."4*@,*4*D51DB?>?
F?89C@1>?D51DB?3B9?<<?!LH93?3?<?>91<


 
+B9DD5>1DD852579>>9>7?6D85 D835>DEBID8574479=2=57/<1.76>.:;2767/<1.
7=:260;7/"4*@,*4*9C14?3DB9>1<@<1IG8?C51B7E=5>D9C21C54?>189CD?B931<
<575>41BI 5@9C?45 G945<I C@B514 1D D81D D9=5 9> D81D @B?F9>35(89C 1B7E=5>D
G8938:ECD9695CD859>C5BD9?>?6D85D5HD9>D85ED9LBB5J45 E>1=1>EC3B9@D<9>;C
9DD?D85@?<9D931<1>4945?<?7931<3?>D5HD9>G89389DG1C3?=@?C54?G5F5B9>
D85@<1ID85<575>412?EDD8551B<IB5<979?EC3?>F5BC9?>?6D85(<1H31<1>;9>7C9C
CE2?B49>1D54D?9DCB5<979?EC@EB@?C5
.A?7:-;ED9LBB5J45 E>174479=2=57/<1.76>.:;2767/<1.7=:260;7/"4*@,*4*
"5G'@1>9C8(851D5BB5?<5(851D5B?<?>91<!5H93?

 "

=CA5 ;>B 5B31B>B C5GC>B 4A1<JC93>B 3>=B5AE14>B 45 9=939>B 45;
,*5=;1"D5E1B?1M1B55=3D5=CA1D=1>2A1C9CD;141&#&(,!&
# %,- &%-)*!6% 0 ,+!*$&  #&* ,+)& 7#+!$&* )0*  #/# % #
,- *'5'5CA1C145D=1?95I145E>C15=;1@D5B5453;1A1=W;>B

This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
    

<9BC5A9>B45;1'1=C151CN;931H45;'1=CLB9<>'13A1<5=C>45;;
C1AX@D531A535C1=C>45;>B?5AB>=1:5B1;57NA93>B3><>45;>B5;5
<5=C>B3N<93>B?A>?9>B45;1<1H>AL145;1B>2A1BC51CA1;5BA5;979>B1B
A5?A5B5=C141B5=;1K?>313DH><JB3;1A>5:5<?;>B5AL1=;>B&#&(,!&*
*'!)!+,#*0*)$%+#*45>=IJ;5I45B;1E1?D2;9314>B5=  
H@D5C><13><>21B51A7D<5=C1;D=5?9B>49>BD?D5BC1<5=C5>3D
AA94>5= 4DA1=C5;1?A9<5A15BC1=39145>ACKB5=5;C5AA9C>A9>
C;1G31;C531
;3>;>@D9>3><95=I13>=;1B9=C5AE5=39>=5B45;>B3D1CA>A5H5B
@D5;1<5=C1=5;B9;5=39>45BD49>B>=7>;HB5<D5BCA1=3>=6DB>B
?>A8125AB>M14>;1;;571414575=C55GCA1M1?1A535>=7>;@D95=
;5B3>=69A<15;1AA92>45;>B5B?1M>;5BH;5B1<5=1I13>=;1<D5AC5B9
135?C1=;1=D5E165?5A>?>3>45B?DKBB5;5B1?1A5355=BD5M>BD=
J=75;@D5;5B812;145;E5A4145A>9>B>=E5AC94>B?>A;1B?1;12A1B
45;J=75;;>BA5H5BA53925=1>ACKB@D95=;;57113><?1M14>?>A!1
A9=1!1;9=385H5;3;KA97>D1=L1I@D5B5AJ@D95=;5B?A549@D5;1B
E5A4145B 45 ;1 A5;979N= 3A9BC91=1 H ;>B 21DC935 D1=4> 5; 45<>=9>
>=7>;A51?1A53545B1691=C5;>7A1=;92A1AB545K;9=E>31=4>;1ADI
H5;"><2A545A9BC> 1>2A169=1;9I13>=D=1B4K39<1B5=C>=141B
?>A5;3;KA97>HD=E9;;1=393>31=C14>?>A;>BJ=75;5B5=8>=>A1;'1=
CLB9<>'13A1<5=C>
><>E5<>B?>ABD1A7D<5=C>=>B5=3>=CA1<>B1=C5D=1?95I1
4531AJ3C5A3;1A1<5=C54>3CA9=1;@D5V5=?1;12A1B45A<1=4>$1A
C941VWE1;941945>;N7931<5=C5;1C1A5145;15E1=75;9I139N=?>=95=4>
5=5E945=3915;CA9D=6>45;3A9BC91=9B<>B>2A55;45<>=9>9=4L75=1
?>A<549>45;1?AJ3C931B13A1<5=C1;X
'9=5<21A7>;15;5339N=
<9B<1454938121B51A7D<5=C1;=>B812;145;1E9=3D;139N=45BD
1DC>A3>=5;3>=C5GC>C;1G31;C5315=5;@D5B5812L1;;5E14>1312>
D=1A59=C5A?A5C139N=45;>B8538>B89BCNA93>B>3DAA94>B1?1AC9A45;1
;;5714145;>B5B?1M>;5B
=5;?A5B5=C5CA121:>B545BC131=;>B5;5<5=C>B@D5:DBC96931=;1
9=B5A39N=45;1>2A15=5;<1=DB3A9C>45DC9KAA5I45 D=1B5>6A5
35==D5E>B1A7D<5=C>B5=C>A=>1BD1DC>AL1HB5<D5BCA13N<>1;
A5C><1A;1;5H5=41B>2A5;1C5<?A1=13>=E5AB9N=45;>B7>25A=1=C5B
C;1G31;C531B BD 1DC>A 1BD<5 ;1 E5AB9N= @D5 ;1 =>2;5I1 45 (;1G31;1
812L16>A:14>45BD?1AC939?139N=5=;>B13>=C539<95=C>B@D5;;5E1A>=
1;13>=@D9BC145!KG93>?5A>C1<29K=;1CA1=B6>A<1?1A1BD2>A49
=1A;11;<5=B1:5A5;979>B>@D54><9=1;1>2A1

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

   


 

; C5GC> >A979=1; 45; &#&(,!&  #&* ,+)& )0* B5 3>=B5AE1 5= 5;
6>=4>5=1A>1A3L145;1)=9E5AB941445(5G1B3><>?1AC545;
$&)!##$+)!#&*2%#*!#)1&!*'&&%)&&0
&%+))*+)!)#* %!*&+)*&**,)!&**69A<14>?>AA9B
CN21; DC9KAA5I 45 D=1 5= 5; 1M>   938> <1=DB3A9C> @D5
?5AC5=539N5=CA5>CA>B1;5AD49C>'97P5=I1HN=7>A16D5414>1
3>=>35A5= 
?>A1A;>B1BC1M541@D95=49>?D=CD1;=>C939145
BD 3>=C5=94> W >B <1=DB3A9C>B ?5A494>BX
  B9= 5<21A7>
2D5=1?1AC545;<9B<>?5A<1=535C>41EL19=K49C1



$?BD14145<7479=27>B9CDO21<ED9LBB5J45 E>1.57:2*4-.4*5*<.:2*-.47;
D60.4.;$2-*-.4:B7+2;8776.-:77A*-.76<:.:*;*<:2*:,*-.4*;6-2*;'7
<:*;,7;*;,=:27;*;6

B


5>C?> 1D9>=5B931>?<<53D9?>(85)>9F5BC9DI?6(5H1C1DECD9>5
>1B?1B3M1?<<53D9?>!1>EC3B9D?C97>1DEB1'9>1ED?B><1@?B
D1411@1B5355<5C3E4?45!?I145?>DB5B1C

$B?212<5=5>D55<1ED?B@5>CO@?45BD5>5B1312141<1?2B15>  I1AE5
5C5CD1<165381AE51@1B5355><1@?BD1413?BB57941@?B<145  CD1P<D9=1
395BB1 145=KC 5< F?<E=5> 5> 3EI? @95 1@1B535 W45<   1N?C @1B1 8?>B1 I
7<?B91459?CX

45=KC45>E5CDB1@95J1D51DB1<F5BD?41C<1C54939?>5C5>&9F5B1WE1DB?
3?=5>D1B9?CX > C?<?C581@E2<9314?<1$2-*-.-76.-:77A*-.76<:.:*;
:E>D?1<1B5<139O>45W<?C>?=2B5C45<?C1BJ?29C@?C31CD5<<1>?CAE581>?3E
@14?<17<5C91!5DB?@?<9D1>145!LH93?XI5<31@MDE<?C97E95>D5W5B1BAEM1D5
BB5CDB545<?C@B5<14?C3B9?<<?C89:?C45<?C3?>AE9CD14?B5C45CD5B59>?@?2<14?
B5CX5>26,7,*:<*;

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

$>3>B125<>B45;1DC>A455BC1<9B35;J=51><>K;<9B<>9=
49315=E1A9>B<><5=C>B5A1W=1CDA1;45BC5A59=>X$&)!#66 E
A ;> 3D1; 5G?;931 @D5 ;1 A51;9414 =>E>89B?1=1 B5 3>=E95AC1 5=
395AC><>4>5=D=89;>3>=4D3C>A3>=5;@D5DC9KAA5I45 D=1E1
3A51=4>;1CA121IN=5=CA5;1B?1AC5B45;1>2A1529N5BC1A145<JB
5BCA5381<5=C5E9=3D;14>B9=>?5AC5=535A1;<D=4>53;5B9JBC93>;>
@D5B5A56;5:15=D=5E945=C5?A54><9=9>45;1C5<JC931A5;979>B15=5;
E>;D<5= 1?1AC5<JB5GC5=B145;<9B<>5B5;$&)!##$+)!
#&*2%#*@D5;541CLCD;>D=CA1C14>4>3CA9=1;H<>A1;5=5;@D5;1
4569=939N=H31C57>A9I139N=455BC>BB5A5B35;5BC91;5B41?951D=1A5
6;5G9N=B>2A5;131L4145 D3965AH5;?5314>45;8><2A53>=12D=
41=C5BA565A5=391B5AD49C1B1;7DBC>45;1K?>31=3;DH5145<JBD=1
29>7A16L145;1AI>29B?>!>H145>=CA5A1B5=;1@D53><>WC5BC97>
45E9BC1X5;1DC>A?A5B5=C1W;1BB1=C1BE9ACD45BH;>12;5B3>BCD<2A5BX
454938>?A5;14>1<2>BC5GC>B31251M149A;1?95I1@D5=>B>3D?1
HD=1 /'&*!!6%#+)%&*+)@D5DC9KAA5I45 D=149358125A81
;;14>W5=D=15B3D5;1B9=1DC>A?>A5BC1A<DHA>C>5;;92A>4>=455B
C121X6
9=3>A?>A1411;69=1;45;<1=DB3A9C>?>ABDE1;>A54969
31=C5
8>A1295=1?5B1A45@D55;?A>?NB9C>75=5A1;45;1>2A15BA5
;979>B> H ;1B <1C5A91B CA1C141B 3>= 1=C5A9>A9414 W=> 14<9C5= 3>B1
?A>61=1X 6>; A 5; E>;D<5= 9=3;DH5 1B9<9B<> :DBC> 1=C5B 45
=D5BCA>3>;>@D9>D=!*,)*&0)#!6%#)(,3*###0#&*&%(,!*
+&)**+)!%&?A535494>45D=1B>3C1E1BA51;5B45493141B15A=J=
>ACKB 3DH> 69= 5B WA5BD39C1A ;1 <5<>A91 45BC5 E1;5A>B> 31?9CJ=X
6>;B A E(A1BK;V145<JB45D=1B;9BC1B451AI>29B?>BH>CA>B
?A5;14>B@D5E5=4AL1=13><?;5C1A5;C5GC>4549314>1;1E94145!>H1



C@53D?AE545CD1311CEF5J5>5<P<D9=?6?<9?45<=1>EC3B9D?4?>455C
3B925W312?C55>(<1H31<145<B59>?45<1"E5F1C@1N1@?BB9CDO21<ED9L
BB5J45 E>13B9?<<?45!LH93?XC56?<9?69>1<5CDK14?B>14?3?>5<5C3E4?45
1B=1C61=9<91B5>3EI149F9C1C5<55W)>1<E>11<395<?IDB5C45OB4?211<CE5<?X

#3E@131C9<1=9D1445<=1>EC3B9D?6?<C 


CD55C5<DMDE<?12B5F914?AE5C54115CD1@1BD55><1W(12<1453?>D5>94?CX
69>1<1<1W&5<139O>I3?=@5>49?2B5F5ICE=1B9?45<9>F5>392<531@9DK>4?>5B
>1>4??BDLC!1BAELC45<*1<<5I45<?CF1<95>D5C3121<<5B?CCEC3?=@1N5B?C
AE53?>L<@1C1B?>1<1C3?>AE9CD1C455CD5>E5F?9=@5B9?IB59>?C45<1"E5F1
C@1N1-45<?C8538?CI81J1N1CAE5CE6B95B?>IF93D?B91CAE51<31>J1B?>X6?<
B

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M 

45>=CA5A1BV5=3>=CA1<>BD=)!&+&&*#&*&%(,!*+&)*0
'&#&)**+)!%&@D55;1DC>A5GCA1545WD=;92A>45;17>25A=139N=
45BC1"D5E1B?1M1/U0<DHE9BC>H<1;CA1C14>X3>=5;69=45@D5
W=>B51312545?5A45ABD<5<>A91X6>;  E
13>=@D9BC145;C5AA9C>A9>=>E>89B?1=>1?1A5351BDE5I5=;>B
C5GC>BA5;979>B>BBL?>A5:5<?;>5;1DC>A5B?5A1@D5;1;53CDA145;1
/'&*!!6%#+)%&*+)B9AE1?1A1>A1AW1"D5BCA>'5M>A?>A;1BJ=9
<1B451@D5;;>BE95:>BB1=C>B3>=@D9BC14>A5B45BC1"D5E1B?1M1X
6>;
AH5;?A>?9>3>;>@D9>1?5B1A45BD31AJ3C5A4>3CA9=1;C95=5
3><>A565A5=C589BCNA93>5;<><5=C><9B<>45;13>=@D9BC1H1@D5
5=4938><><5=C>B5B9CO1;1;5H5=41@D5;541CLCD;>H3>=BC9CDH5
V3><> B5 81 B5M1;14>V ;1 21B5 45 BD 1A7D<5=C> ;1 BD?D5BC1 3>=
E5AB9N= 45 ;>B 3139@D5B 45 BDB 3D1CA> 312535A1B 4DA1=C5 ;1 ?A9<5A1
5BC1=39145>ACKB5=1@D5;;1BC95AA1B
=4569=9C9E1;1>2A1@D5=>B>3D?15=31:1?5A653C1<5=C53>=5;
?A>?NB9C>45;<1=DB3A9C>5=BD3>=:D=C>5=5;@D5>2B5AE1<>BD=
<1A314>?A54><9=9>45;1C5<JC931A5;979>B1HD=169=1;9414494J3C931
H 4>3CA9=1; 1; C95<?> @D5 D=1 9<175= ?>B9C9E1 45 ;1 3>=@D9BC1 45;
C5AA9C>A9> ;;5E141 1 312> ?>A ;>B 5B?1M>;5B E1;>A141 ?>A BD 1DC>A
3><>5;8538>85A>93>@D5?5A<9C9N;19=CA>4D339N=45;3A9BC91=9B<>
5=;1"D5E1B?1M1
$>A>CA>;14>414>@D55;3>;>@D9>?A5B5=C1D=13D94141E5AB969
3139N=45B45BDBB>=5C>B9=9391;5B ?D5453>=B945A1AB5145<JBD=1
3;1A1<D5BCA145;1E>3139N=;9C5A1A91455BC1<9B35;J=51@D545:1D=
2A5E5?5A>B97=96931C9E>5B?139>1;13><?>B939N=?>KC931H1@D59=9
3913>=D=14K39<145W5;;92A>1BD1DC>A?949K=4>;5;59<?A9<1X
9=3;DH5;1BH139C141B>3C1E1B3><?D5BC1B5=8>=>A1>ACKBH395AA1
3>=D=B>=5C>?A5BC14>5;1=N=9<>W;C95<?>H;13D5=C1X
3DH1



CD?C<9CD14?CAE59>3<EI5>9>3<EC?1W<1C@B9=5B1C=E:5B5CAE5F9>95B?>1
<13?>AE9CD1I@1C1B?>15CD5B59>?X6?<
BC53?=@<5D1>3?><1B5<139O>45
7?25B>14?B5CIF9BB5I5C45<D5BB9D?B9?

>3<EC?1<7E>1C45CEC3?=@?C939?>5C5>3?>3B5D?E>B?=1>35I<1C4L39
=1CI5<F9<<1>393?69>1<5C6E5B?>C5<5339?>141C@?B<6?>C?!L>45J$<1>31BD5
@1B1CEI13<KC9311>D?<?7M1457.<*;67>712;8*67;:25.:;2047 

'5DB1D145<3?>?394?C?>5D?W$M45=545=M=9C=?5<D95=@?3E5>D1XAE5
4EB1>D5F1B91C4L3141C6E51DB92E94?:E>D?1<W"?=5=E5F5=99?C@1B1AE5
B5BD5XI?DB?C1<17ECD9>?6B1I!97E5<45E5F1B1AE95><?9>3<EIOD1=29L>1<
69>1< 45 E>1 =9C35<K>51 5< :<. -7,<:26*4 A 57-7 0.6.:*4 8*:* *8:.6-.: 4* 4.60=*

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

?A5B5=3915=5;<1=DB3A9C>812L1?1B14>81BC118>A19=14E5AC941?1A1
;>B5B31B>B9=E5BC9714>A5B@D5B581=A565A94>1;<9B<>?5A>@D5
V3><>E5A5<>B13>=C9=D139N=V?D545A5BD;C1A459=C5AKB1;18>A1
45A5B>;E5A;>B?A>2;5<1B451DC>AL1?;1=C514>BA5B?53C>1=D5BCA1
?95I14A1<JC931


 !        



4965A5=39145;>B>CA>BC5GC>B@D53><?>=5=5;;92A>@D5=>B
>3D?1=D5BCA>3>;>@D9>31A53545D=19=CA>4D339N=@D55G?;9@D55;
?A>?NB9C> H ?A>3545=391 45; <9B<> = 5653C> ?>A 5; ?A>?9> 45
DC9KAA5I45 D=1B125<>B@D55;$&)!#*&)#&*2%#*;1!#
)1&!*'&&0&%+))*H5;?>5<1H;1#!6%4549314>B15A=J=
>ACKBB>=45BD?A>?91?;D<1@D5;>B;9BC14>B45?A5;14>B3>=@D9B
C14>A5BH?>2;14>A5B;>B815;12>A14>1?1AC9A454>3D<5=C>B3>=
BD;C14>BH@D5;1 /'&*!!6%#+)%&*+);15=3>=CAN5=D=15B3D5;1
B9=9=493139N=451DC>A(A1B5BC1O;C9<15G?;93139N=B9=5<21A7>;>
@D5 5=3>=CA1<>B => 5B ;1 /'&*!!6% B9=> 5; 3>;>@D9> 3>= ;1 ?179
=139N=>A979=1;C138141H3>AA579411;C5A1=4>1BL5;>A45=@D51?1A535
5=;1C12;169=1;453>=C5=94>B5=;1@D53>=BC13><>O;C9<>C5GC>
BC1B39A3D=BC1=391BD=941B1;8538>45@D5;1?95I1?1A5I315B3A9C1
3>=D=1;5CA149BC9=C11;1@D5;5?A53545HBD35455=5;<1=DB3A9C>
;;5E1A>=11BC1M5411>6A535A4>BC5>AL1B49BC9=C1BB>2A5BD1DC>AL1
5=D=3>AC>;1?B>45C95<?>B95= 
169A<121@D5;1?95I1?1A53L1
WB5A45?DM>H;5CA145;1DC>A?D5B;15B3A9CDA1B5?1A535<D38>1;1
45;1454931C>A91XW >B<1=DB3A9C>B?5A494>BX 3D1CA>1M>B<JB
C1A45 1?A539N @D5 5; C5GC> 5BC121 5B3A9C> W3>= ;1 31;97A16L1 31A13
C5ALBC93145;B97;>,*5=?1?5;@D549695A55=C5GCDA1H3>;>A45;A5BC>
45;;92A>X;>3D1;D=94>1BD;5=7D1:5BD?D5BC1<5=C5W<D38><JB
?D;94>XHD=5BC9;>W<JB;9C5A1A9>X@D55;45;1B>CA1B>2A1B;5;;5EN1
3>=3;D9A@D5DC9KAA5I45 D=1812L1A53>794>D=C5GC>?5AC5=5395=C5

5*<4*4<B260*45  $1B1E>5CD14?45<13E5CD9O>C?2B55CD5@?5=1CE@?C92<5
1ED?BM1I496EC9O>C?>459>D5BLC<1D?BB5W(95=@?I@?5CM1X *5B4WB1I
!97E5<45E5F1B1X I*5B4W 1C@?5CM1C45<=1>EC3B9D?45B1I!97E5<
45E5F1B1X  

1CD1N5415>CE45C3B9@39O>45<=1>EC3B9D?C5<9=9DO19>4931BW5C@ELC
45<M>493581IE>C?>5D?XW ?C=1>EC3B9D?C@5B494?CX >?855>3?>DB14?
=KCB565B5>391C1<=9C=?5><1292<9?7B16M1@?CD5B9?B

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M 

1;1B?A9<5A1B4K3141B45;15E1=75;9I139N=B57DA1<5=C55B3A9C>5=
(;1G31;1?>A5;6A1=39B31=>(>A929>45!>C>;9=L1
">3125A521C9A18>A1=9;141C139N==9;11CA92D39N=451BC1M541
5=5BC5B57D=4>5BCD49><DH?A>=C>45B<5=C941B?>A;13ALC931 >
@D5BL9<?>AC145BC131A5B@D5;19=35AC94D<2A5B5<2A141?>A5BC5
89BC>A914>AB>2A5;11DC>AL145;C5GC>4529N9=6;D9A5=;14539B9N=45
&>:1B1A394D5M1B45?A5B5=C1A;>3><>W1=N=9<>HB9=65381X3D1=
4>5BC51?1A539N?D2;9314>?>A?A9<5A1E5I5=BD;92A>45   #
++)&,- *'5%#*!#&  @DLC1<29K=5;C9?>45
;5CA1H5;5BC9;>E>;E95A>=1B5A1A7D<5=C>B?5A>=>?1A145C5A<9=1A
;11DC>AL145;1?95I1B9=>B>;1<5=C5?1A13>=B945A1A;13><>W45;>B
O;C9<>B1M>B45;B97;>,*>45;>B?A9<5A>B45;B97D95=C5X #++)&
,- *'5%#*!#&  89?NC5B9B@D56D53>AA>2>A141
?>A+9=BC>=&5H=>;4B5=D=1ACL3D;>45 5=5;@D5945=C9693121
D=?5@D5M>?;179>?>A?1AC545=D5BCA>4A1<1CDA7>D=<>=N;>7>
9=3;D94>5=;1>2A145 >?545*571 #,-&,%&*,!)+&'&)
)!*+6#&#6%3>=3A5C1<5=C51@D5;5=5;@D5D;31=@D5;;L=4D415=
CA55;B57D9<95=C>45;1=D5E1A5;979N=H5;A5B?5C>1;1B1=C97D1B3A55=
391B1?1A53L131B9L=C57A>5=5;3>;>@D9>=>E>89B?1=>5=2>3145;A5H
,93>CK=31C;;41C>@D5B9AE9N1&5H=>;4B   ?1A15G?;931A


WD3?>C9CDC?6DG5>DID8B55=1>EC3B9@D6?<9?CGB9DD5>9>D85381B13D5B9CD93
81>4GB9D9>7?6D8569BCD81<6?6D85C9HD55>D835>DEBI?>@1@5BD81>49665BC9>
D5HDEB51>43?<?B6B?=D85B5CD?6D852??;X1CD1N541W(859BCD=5B931>
$<1IX >5CD5C57E>4?DB121:?1CD1N5419>C9CD5145=KC5>AE5ED9LBB5J
45 E>1>?C5D?=O<1=?<5CD91453?@91B<?C9>?AE5<?9>3?B@?BO3?=@<5D?5>
CE<92B? 

*5B1<B5C@53D?&?:1C1B394E5N1CW$BO<?7?1<7479=27-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;-.
"4*@,*4*X  

 < =?>O<?7? I1 =EI 39D14? @?B <1 3BMD931 5C 5< C97E95>D5 WR%E5 81BL
R5:1BL=9#>7?<@?B5CD5B9CD?5HDB1>:5B?9?C8?=2B5I9?C5C@1N?<
R5:1BL<E>1I<E35B?>?3854M1395<?C?<$5B?CM<?45:1BL1E>AE5<131EC1
>?CL45AE51F5>DEB5CE<EJ@?B5CD?AE5<<1=1>3BEJ5>AE5CE=1BD9B9?
6E5!1C>?<?C@E54?61<D1BAE5C945CE7ECD?5H354?D5=?AE5=581>45
=1D1B=1CRAE9L>2EC3119?C@?B=954?C9@?B1=?BC5814581<<1B"?
81I3?C1=KC9=@?C92<5AE545:1B<11>D97E165I1<13?CDE=2B5D5BB92<5@5B?
C9#>7?<K>75<6E5IB9CD?9?C9>F5>392<51AEL<C?25B29?9=@1395>D5AE5
31CD97O CE 81354?B @?B B525<45 I 9=@BE45>D5 C57E9B 1 B9CD?5C =5:?BX 4
=.>7=6-7 FF

 67479=27-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;-."4*@,*4*


 
FF  
5>145<1>D5<1?2B1C539D1BKC57P><154939O>45&?:1C1B394E5N1C
5>":.;82.B*;<.*<:*4.;-.4>2::.26*<7  


 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

;1?A5B5=3915=;1?95I145D=?5AB>=1:51:5=>1;3>=C5GC><5G931=>
3><>5B>=7>;@D55;1DC>AC><13><>E5<>B45 >?5H5BC51
BDE5I45A39;;1>2;971211B9CD1A;16538145A541339N=45;&#&(,!&
1;A5454>A45  1M>5=@D5;1>2A145 >?51?1A53539C1415= #
'))!%& % *, '+)! / 0 H ?>A C1=C> ?D4> 39A3D;1A <1=DB3A9C1 >
@D9IJ<JB?A>212;5<5=C545B?DKB45  1M>4554939N=45;1)+
45BDB&$!*5=;13>;5339N=45'5AA1=>45*1A71B5BC>5B
D=165381<DH35A31=11;1453><?9;139N=45;<1=DB3A9C>
141C139N=45;1>2A1@D5B57O=&5H=>;4B  3>=69A<121;1
?1C5A=941445DC9KAA5I45 D=1=>6D51A7D<5=C>BD69395=C5?1A1
&>:1B1A394D5M1B@D95=C>41EL15=BDB57D=4154939N=45;1<9B<1
9=B9BCL1 5= 3>=B945A1A;1 1=N=9<1 W45; C>4> 97=>A1<>B V5B3A92L1 5=
VB9/DC9KAA5I45 D=103><?DB>5;&#&(,!&#&*,+)&7#+!$&*
)0*#/#>B9B>;1<5=C5;>3>?9N>B9;13>?915A11:5=1HB>;1
<5=C5;>9=3;DHN5=5B5E>;D<5=XW$AN;>7>UX BC189?NC5B9B
81?A5E1;5394>81BC1;1B9=E5BC97139>=5B<JBA5395=C5B H81?A>E>
314>1BDE5I1;7D=>B9=C5=C>BB9=>451CA92D39N=1;<5=>B4531
A13C5A9I139N=45;1DC>A45;1?95I13><>5;45;B1539;91A>BC?1A1
@D95= W5; 3>;>@D9> B5 ?A5BC1 /U0 1 ;1 A5?A5B5=C139N= 45B;D<2A1=C5
?A>?9145;C51CA>:5BD9C1X >5;<JBA5395=C545#3C1E9>&9E5A1
@D95=;1=I13><>89?NC5B9B@D55;3>;>@D9>?D495A18125AB94>5B3A9C>
W?>A D= C;1G31;C531 ?1A1 B5A A5?A5B5=C14> 3>= <>C9E> 45 1;7D=1
695BC1X @D9IJ;1A535?39N=45;E9AA5H D9B45*5;1B3>5= >
;145957>5A=J=45I45NA4>215= 

8>A1295=5;4521C5
5=C>A=>1;11CA92D39N=45;C5GC>1;?A>?9>DC9KAA5I45 D=15BCJ
;5:>B 45 @D541A I1=:14> ?>A ;> @D5 B5AJ OC9; ?D=CD1;9I1A 1;7D=1B
3D5BC9>=5B1;A5B?53C>


'?2B5<1C54939?>5C45<1?2B1F5B<19>DB?4E339O>45 5=1BD9>5<I!9>7E5D
1*5714=.>7=6-7-.;,=+2.:<787::2;<H+*474H6

$95>C?5>DB121:?C3?=?<?C455>9D?%E9>D1>1W1391E>21BB?AE9C=?
89C@1>?1=5B931>?XI<25BD?#BD9JW<45=?>9?M4?<?45<7479=27-.4*6=.>*
,76>.:;2H6X45

?5<45<21?38W!5=?B91@?<MD93145<13?>AE9CD1X45

 


 15<5339O>453E1<AE95B1455C1C4?C65381C9=@<931BM1@?B<?C=?D9F?CI1
C5N1<14?CAE55C51>O>9=?1ED?BD<1H31<D531812BM1<5M4?<13?=549145 ?@545
6?B=1=1>EC3B9D1

CM@?B5:5=@<?1@5>1C5>
 B?F1CW?BDLC3?>DB15<45=?>9?X
>? C5 @<1>D5121 C9AE95B1 <1 @?C929<9414 45 B5381J1B <1 1ED?BM1 45 ED9LBB5J 45
E>1

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

=?A9<5A;D71A;1B3>AA5339>=5B45=D<5A139N=5=;1B8>:1B45;
<1=DB3A9C>@D5A53>75=C1=C>5;3>;>@D9>3><>;1 /'&*!!6%#+)
%&*+)@D5;5BD3545?5A<9C5=454D39A@D55;3>;>@D9>=>6D5C><14>
45>CA>;92A>3><>B5;;57N1BD75A9A;>O=93>@D55=3>=CA1<>B5B
D=11;C5A139N=45;>A45=45?A5B5=C139N=451<2>BC5GC>B5=5;E>;D
<5=@D54529NB5A4539B9N=45O;C9<18>A1?>AC1=C>;1?95I1C51CA1;
6>A<N ?1AC5 45B45 5; ?A9=39?9> 45; ;92A> 94514> ?>A DC9KAA5I 45
D=1 ; 1?1A5=C5 31<29> 45 ;5CA1 => ?D545 B5AE9A C1<?>3> 3><>
1A7D<5=C>161E>A45@D56D5A1D=C5GC>1:5=>9=C5A31;14>?>AD=
;14>;131;97A16L1E1AL11;>;1A7>45;>B6>;9>B@D5A53>75=5;3>;>@D9>
<9B<> => ?>A 31<29> 45 1<1=D5=B5 B9=> ?>A 456>A<139N= 45 ;1
?A>?915B3A9CDA1?>A>CA>;14>B95B1;5CA1B53><?1A13>=;145;
A5BC>45;<1=DB3A9C>3125169A<1A3>=395AC1B57DA9414@D55;1<1
=D5=B5 5B O=93> = 4569=9C9E1 1D=@D5 => B5 ?D545 1B5E5A1A @D5
DC9KAA5I 45 D=1 => 3>?91A1 D= C5GC> 1:5=> ;> @D5 BL ?1A535
?A>214>5B@D5=>8D2>9=C5A?>;139N=458>:1B45>CA1<1=>
= B57D=4> ;D71A 5B 395AC> @D5 ;1 9=C5A?>;139N= 45; C5GC> B9=
=9=7O=C9?>455G?;93139N=A5BD;C15GCA1M15=D=1>2A15=;1@D55;
1DC>A2DB315BC12;535AD=1CA121IN=9=C5A=15=CA5;1B?1AC5B1;9=939>
45;1!&%)&&0&%+))*5G?;931@D5W;>B49B3DAB>BH
<1C5A91B45;>BB1=C>BJ=75;5B@D5/U0?A5B5=CK1;17;>A9>B1<5<>A91
45;5G35;5=C5E1AN=/U0<581414><>C9E>145B3A929ABDE941X6>;

A;19=3>A?>A139N=45D=1<1C5A91?A>61=13><>5B;13>=@D9BC1
;;5E1411312>?>A>ACKBB5:DBC969315=5;31?LCD;>
1;>;1A7>45
E1A9>B?JAA16>BW=@D5B5CA1C15;9=C5=C>45BC1>2A1H1@DK69=B5
5=45A5I1X6>;B AHBBH;1B?1;12A1B@D5452L1=8125A?A535494>
1;1 /'&*!!6%=>B>;>5G?;931=BD?A>3545=391B9=>C1<29K=;1?5AC9
=5=391 45 BD 9=3;DB9N= ?A539B1<5=C5 1; 69=1; 45; <9B<> W?1A539K=
4><5;><5:>A3>=@D5?>45A41A69=15BC5CA121:>X6>;

E;
O=93>C5GC>@D5B59=3;DH5C1<29K=5=5;E>;D<5=B9==9=7O=C9?>45
9=493139N=5B5;B>=5C>@D56D=39>=13><>3>;>6N=45;<9B<>5;H1
39C14>45W;C95<?>H;13D5=C1XW$L45<545<L<9B<>5;C95<?>
3D5=C1X@D5?A539B1<5=C5?>ABDD293139N==>=535B9C121D=15G?;9
3139N=?A5E918>A1295=1D=@D5?D541?1A535A?1A14N:93>;19=3>A
?>A139N=455BC5?>5<11;1<9B35;J=51=>E>89B?1=1?>4AL1B5AE9A45
1A7D<5=C>?1A13>=69A<1A;11DC>AL145DC9KAA5I45 D=1A5B?53C>1


$E545>3?=@1B1BC51=?4?455:5=@<?<?C6?<C

BICCI<?C
BICC

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms

   

;1?95I1C51CA1;H1@D55;3>=>39<95=C>45;B>=5C>?>ABD?1AC5?A5
39B1<5=C55=;>B1M>B5=@D55<?5I1211496D=49AB5=>B4935@D5
=D5BCA>1DC>A5BC1211;C1=C>45;1?A>4D339N=;9C5A1A9145;1<5CAN
?>;9;>@D5;>3>;>31C1<29K=5=49B?>B939N=458125A1?A>E53814>
;>BE5AB>B45;13><549145 >?5@D51?1A535=5=5;3>;>@D9>
$>AO;C9<>A5BD;C1B97=96931C9E>@D5;1B4>B?A>?D5BC1B39C141BB>
2A5>CA1?>B92;51DC>AL1=>;;57D5=11?>AC1AD==><2A53>=3A5C>H
1?D=C5=?A539B1<5=C5813911B?53C>B@D55=31:1=3>=;>B?>3>B41C>B
@D5C5=5<>BB>2A55;?A>?9>DC9KAA5I45 D=1$>AD=;14>BDE9=
3D;139N=3>=5;J<29C>53;5B9JBC93>H<JB3>=3A5C1<5=C53>=1;7D=>B
<95<2A>B45;1><?1ML1455BOB3><>5;$14A5$54A>45#AC97>B1
A5B?>=B12;545W;1B;5CA1BHE9;;1=393>B@D5812L14531=C1A;131?9;;1X
5=;1695BC145'1=!97D5;@D5?A><>E9N!>H145>=CA5A1B5=C>A=>
1  1;7D=1B45;1B3D1;5B6D5A>=A53>7941B?>A=D5BCA>1DC>A5=;1
! # )1&!*'& 6>;B A A 5=31:1AL1 3>= ;1 ?A>?D5BC1 45
A>BC459=B5AC1A;1?95I15=5;J<29C>:5BD9C189?NC5B9B5B?5391;<5=C5
A1I>=12;5B91C5=45<>B15;5<5=C>B45;1<9B<13><>;1H139C141
1DB5=391 45 5;5<5=C>B 3N<93>B ;1 9=CA>4D339N= 45 A565A5=391B
3;JB931B>;1?A565A5=391?>A5;CKA<9=>W3>;>@D9>X$>A>CA>;14>
BD5BCA5381E9=3D;139N=3>=(;1G31;139D4145=;1@D5@D9IJ=>=139N
?5A> BL 4529N E9E9A 4DA1=C5 1M>B VC1; 3><> A53>=>35 5= ;1 #!6%
4549314115A=J=>ACKBV;5812AL1?5A<9C94>3>=>35A45?A9<5A1



 *5B4 WB1I !97E5< 45 E5F1B1X    C5N1<1 AE5 45 <?C =1>EC3B9D?C
3?>?394?CAE53?>D95>5>5CD5C?>5D?IC53?>C5BF1>41D14?C<?C=KC1>D97E?C
C5BM1>5<,45<19C@1>93'?395DI2+:7-.5.57:2*A-.,*:<*;-.8*07-.;-..4*G7
-. (M)/.,1**
-.;.8<2.5+:.-.;<.-2,17*G79>F5>D1B914?5>&?4BM7E5J!?
N9>?IB5I*<D4707   
I5< 45<192<9?D531"139?>1<45!14B94
*:-F6-2>2671.,17.6.4*G7-.:2;<7-. 
8?B1295>3?=?14F95BD5<53E1<1
65381 45 5CD5 P<D9=? W81I AE5 5CD9B1B<1 21CD1>D5X @?BAE5 5> L<C5 3?@91> E>1C
9>4E<75>391C@1@1<5C3?>354941C5> 

W<31>39?>5B?<<1=14?*:-F6-2>267X

<?AE5C97>96931AE51=2?CC5BM1>=KCD1B4M?CAE5>E5CDB?=1>EC3B9D?

6<154939O>45<D5HD?5>26,7,*:<*;
 

?=?5H@<931!5>L>45J$5<K5JW?>5<DLB=9>?,7479=27<?C4B1=1DEB7?C
45<D51DB?:5CEMD93?45C97>1>1E>2E5>>P=5B?45@95J1C4B1=KD931CC9>AE5C5
@E5415CD12<535B5>DB55<<1CE>131B13D5B9J139O>@B539C1I295>45<9=9D141X


>5653D?5><1 .4*,2H6A,758.6-27+:.>.A;=5*:27-.426>.6,2+4.,*82<D6-76
.:6*6-77:<E;5H@<931AE5W$?B>?@B5C5>D1B89CD?B91CAE5?M45<5:?C?F9>95B?>
1=M>?DB1:5@?BB5<139?>5C9>395BD1CC9>?453?C1CAE5I1AE5>?@1C1B?>@?B
=9C=1>?C<1C85F9CD?5C1294?=EI4535B313?=?>1DEB1<45CD5B59>?AE5>13M

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

<1=>V3><>BD795A5#3C1E9>&9E5A1V5B1;5H5=4145;13>=E5AB9N=H
21DC9I> 45 ;>B A5H5B @D5 6D5 W1BD=C> 45 ?A9<5A1 9<?>AC1=391 5=;1
E941?>;LC931XC;1G31;C531H?>AC1=C>5=BDB35;52A139>=5B?O2;931B
4DA1=C5C>4>5;?5AL>4>E9AA59=1;WD1CA>3><5=C1A9>BB>2A55;&#&
(,!&X 


 "  !   


 

D5=C16A1H(>A929>!>C>;9=L15=BD !*+&)!#&*!%!&*,-
*'5@D5?1A135;52A1A5;4L145;>A?DB8A9BC945 ;>BC;1G
31;C531BB131A>=?>A?A9<5A1E5I5;5B3D4>451A<1B3>=35494>?>A
5;<?5A14>AW;13D1;<5A3541O==>B5818538>3>=>CA>/?D52;>0
=9=7D=>459=49>BB9=>3>=KBC5@D5;><5A535295=?>A@D51HD41A>=
<D38>3D1=4>B571=NC>41;1C95AA114>=5A=1=4>>ACKBX  
;41C>5B9=C5A5B1=C5?>A@D545<D5BCA1@D51?5=1BCA5B1M>B45B
?DKB45;13>=35B9N=45;>B?A9<5A>B?A9E9;579>B>C>A714>B?>A;1>
A>=15B?1M>;1;139D41445(;1G31;15G8929NH15=D=65BC5:>?O2;93>
A5;979>B> 5; BL<2>;> 45 5B>B ?A9E9;579>B 3>= ;>B @D5 3><5=I121 1
6>A:1AB5D=189BC>A91W456>A<141X45;>B8538>B>3DAA94>B1?1AC9A45
;1 ;;57141 45 >ACKB 5=  92B>= W'97=9693139N= 45 ;1 89BC>A91
C;1G31;C531X  @D55=3D2A9N81BC1395AC>?D=C>;1B21C1;;1B9=9391;5B
3>=CA1;>B5B?1M>;5B?1A19=B9BC9A5=31<29>5=;1?>;LC931451;91=I1
?>BC5A9>A@D5;5B41AL15;CA9D=6>B>2A5!KG93>(5=>38C9C;1= 

5> L< 5> <?C 35B31>?C D95=@?C 5> 5<<?C CE2354941C I 8125B 1<31>J14? F9F?C 1
=E38?C45<?C3?>AE9CD14?B5C1AE95><1C?MB5<1D1B3?=?<1CF95B?>I@?B5<<?C
@1C1B?><<5>1C45D?41F5B414-<?=9C=?1=E38?C9>49?CF95:?CAE58?IC?>
F9F?C5><139E41445(<1H31<14?>455CD?C55C3B925X6?<C F B

> <145<57139O>5>3125J141@?B4?>957?!1H9H31DJ9><?7BO@1B1
(<1H31<15<DMDE<?45W 51<9E414XI5<5C3E4?451B=1C3?BB5C@?>495>D5145=KC
45<1@B?=5C145<B5I45AE5<1@B?F9>391:1=KCC5BM1B5D9B14145<?C4?=9>9?C45
<1?B?>1'?2B55<F91:545493815=21:1419>4M75>15<C9=2?<9C=?45<5C3E4?
3?>35494? I <?C 1<31>35C :EBM493?C 45 5CD1 @B?F9C9O> B51< F5B 5BB5B1 *1<45J
W#B975>IC97>969314?45<5C3E4?45(<1H31<1X

E>AE5D1=29L>3?>E>=1B314?31BK3D5B@?<MD93?I1AE5<165CD9F941445<
?B@EC 8B9CD9 C5 31B13D5B9JO 45C45 CEC 9>939?C @?B <1 @1BD939@139O> 45 D?41 <1
39E414I5>5C@5391<45<1C1ED?B94145C39F9<5CIB5<979?C1C

12514F5BD9B5>3E1<AE95B31C?AE51<7E>?C3B?>9CD1C?6B535>41D?C@?3?
13?B45C 3?> 5CD5 @B?@OC9D? CM O@5J 45 O=1B1 1E>AE5 B53E5B41 <1

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
    

?5=1BD=>B<5B5B45B?DKB5; 4517>BC>6A1H1AC>;><K45
;1B 1B1B ?A5B5=39N 5= ;1 <9B<1 39D414 45 (;1G31;1 D=1 A5?A5
B5=C139N=C51CA1;B>2A5;1BD=39N=45!1AL1
=1@D5;;1>31B9N==>
8D2> D=1 A565A5=391 5G?;L39C1 1 ;1 3>=@D9BC1 ?5A> 5B =535B1A9> A5
3>A41A@D5456>A<1?1A1;5;11;135;52A139N=45'1=9?N;9C>?>A
?1AC545;>B5B?1M>;5B;>BC;1G31;C531B812L1=5;5794>1;1*9A75=45
;1BD=39N=?>A?1CA>=1CDC5;1A45BD39D414?1A1?>45AA5<5<>A1A
5=5;4L145BD14E>3139N=W;1E93C>A9169=1;B>2A5;>B<5G9313D;8O1
BD1;91=I13>=>ACKBH;19=CA>4D339N=45;'1=C>E1=75;9>5=(;1G
31;1X!1ACL=5IH'5<?1C#/# 938>45>CA><>4>;165B
C9E941445;1BD=39N=?5A<9C9N1;>BC;1G31;C531B5E>31ABD1;91=I1
3>=;>B5B?1M>;5BE9=3D;J=4>;1145<JB1BD3>=E5AB9N=1;1653A9B
C91=1'9=5<21A7>3><>18>A1E5A5<>B1<2>B8538>B=>812L1=
>3DAA94>456>A<1B9<D;CJ=51
=;1,%)+)#!6%5A=J=>ACKB5E9C1A565A9AB51BDB
6A131B14>B9=C5=C>B455E1=75;9I139N=4DA1=C5;1B?A9<5A1BB5<1=1B
455BC1=3915=(;1G31;15A=1;L1I45;1BC9;;>5=31<29>BL12>A41
5BC13D5BC9N=HCA1BA5BD<9A5;?1A;1<5=C>3>=5;@D55;3>=@D9BC14>A
?A5C5=49N3>=E5=35A1;>B=>2;5B9=4L75=1B45;1=535B9414459=C5
AAD<?9A;>BB13A96939>B1BDB61;B>BL4>;>BH3A55A5=5;E5A4145A>9>B
A53D5A41 @D5 5BC>B ;5 A5B?>=495A>= W@D5 => 3DAJB5<>B <JB 45 ;5B
812;1A 5= 1@D5;;1 3>B1 ?>A@D5 => ;>B 812L1= 45 45:1A 45 B13A96931A
1D=@D5;>B<1C1B5=X !*+&)!-))

B?>B92;5@D5>ACKB;>7A1A11;<5=>B5=1@D5;?A9<5A3>=C13C>
;9<?91AD=>45;>B14>A1C>A9>BW?1A1?>=5A5=K;D=13ADIH;19<175=
45"D5BCA1'5M>A1XV3><>A579BCA15A=1;V?5A>=>8D2>5=C>=35B
=9=7D=13>=E5AB9N=B>;>@D9IJ5;21DC9I>6>AI14>45;1B313931BA5
71;141B 5=C>=35B 1 ;>B 5B?1M>;5B H 1D=@D5 ,93>CK=31C; 5; *95:>


9=@?BD1>391 AE5 4121> <?C D<1H31<D531C 1 CE <51<D14 81391 <?C 5C@1N?<5C C5N1<1
D1=29L>AE55CD?CWC5@B539121>=E38?/U045<1B5C9CD5>391I21D1<<1AE5495B?>
1?BDLC45(5?13139>3?I1CM3E1>4?8135>695CD1C?B53925>1<7P>F9BB5IC1<5>
1<31=@?C5C5>D1?C5D5>D1=9<455<<?C15C31B1=EJ1BI@5<51>3?=?@5<51B?>
3?>L<X2;<7:2*-.4*,769=2;<*-.E@2,7



*5B 1C1C1C87470E<2,*12;<7:2*-.4*;6-2*;

$1B1<?C45D1<<5C45
<1@E5CD15>5C35>1F5B1B3M1*8244**+2.:<*-.4*8:E-2,**4*.;,.62/2,*,2H6 



M1J45<1CD9<<?
 6<1F5BC9O>45!EN?J1=1B7?AE95>812<145<1
5>DB5715>1AE5<<1?31C9O>45=KC45DB5C395>D1C=E:5B5C@5B?5C3<1F1C1<C5BF939?

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

?D4>8125AB521DC9I14>4DA1=C5;1B57D=415BC1=39145;3>=@D9BC14>A
5=(;1G31;1CA1B;1">385(A9BC54938>13C>=>812AL19=6;D94>5=
5;A5BC>45;1?>2;139N=9=3;DB>;>B7D5AA5A>BC;1G31;C531B@D5;D381
A>=:D=C>1;>B5B?1M>;5B<1=CDE95A>=BDBB13A96939>BA9CD1;5B4DA1=C5
;>B<5B5B451B549>1;139D41445(5=>38C9C;1=
= 4569=9C9E1 W=> 81H ;1 <5=>A 4D41 45 @D5 ;>B C;1G31;C531B
135?C1A>=1;>BB>;414>B5B?1M>;5B3><>1;914>B<9;9C1A5B1;C95<?>
@D5A5381I121=;1A5;979N=5B?1M>;1X92B>=#/#%#*!#& 
'9=5<21A7>D=1E5I?A5E1;539N;13>=E5AB9N=A5;979>B14DA1=C5
;14K314145 5BC>B8538>B5<?5I1A>=1>3D;C1AB5?1A141A?>A
B5=C14>WD=31<29>9=<5491C>HE>;D=C1A9>5=5;?5=B1<95=C>A5;9
79>B> 5= 5; <><5=C> 45 ;1 >=@D9BC1X 92B>= #/# % # *!#&
  45<1=5A1@D53D1=4>5=  1B1B1B1B9BC9N1;135;5
2A139N=45;1695BC145;1BD=39N=5=(;1G31;1;>@D5?D4>>2B5AE1A
6D5;15G1;C139N=45;1653A9BC91=1?>A?1AC545D=?D52;>BD?D5BC1
<5=C53>=E5AC94>45B45BD?A9<5A3>=C13C>3>=;>B5B?1M>;5B
BC59<?>AC1=C531A9IA5;979>B>@D514@D9A9N;1A59=C5A?A5C139N=45;
?1B14>9=<5491C>?>A?1AC545;1=>2;5I1C;1G31;C531B5<>BCANH145
6>A<1 3;1A1 1?5=1B D= 1M> <JB C1A45 4DA1=C5 D=1 =D5E1 A5?A5
B5=C139N=C51CA1;>A71=9I141?>A;>B6A1=39B31=>B5=5BC531B>4531
AJ3C5A<1B9E>&%(,!*+ ),*#3%5=;1@D55B>B<9B<>B=>2;5B
1BD<95A>=5;?1?5;45D=5:KA39C>=J8D1C;?1AC939?1=4>5=D=9<179
=1A9> 35A3> 1 (95AA1 '1=C1 1 ;1B NA45=5B 45; *9AA5H !5=4>I1 H 45;
<9B<LB9<>1A;>B*
1?D5BC15=5B35=145B3A9C1HC1;E5I945141?>A!>C>;9=L1
 

?A5C5=4L13D<?;9AD=4>2;5>2:5C9E>?>AD=;14>3>=CA92D9A1;
?A>35B>453>=E5AB9N=@D5B55BC121;;5E1=4>1312>C>41EL15=5B>B
1M>B;>3D1;B5;>7AN1;69=1;45;1A5?A5B5=C139N=3D1=4>B535;52AN5;
21DC9I>A51;45=D<5A>B>B9=4L75=1B5=5;?1?5;45CDA3>B?>A>CA>
;14>A5169A<1A;19<175=45;>BC;1G31;C531B3><>9=4L75=1BH13A9BC91
=>B ?A5B5=CJ=4>;>B 3><> E1;5A>B>B 3ADI14>B 31?135B 45 ;D381A

45!1B9>1C9>AE5AE5453<1B?C969>1<=5>D56E5B?>21ED9J141C2;<7:2*-."4*@
,*4*  


CM<?B579CDB15<=9C=?5B>1<M1J 

*5B5<D5CD9=?>9?AE51@?BD15<@B?@9??BDLCC?2B55CD?C8538?C5>B139<
W<8LB?5ICEC1<914?CX

'?2B5<1C49693E<D145C@1B1<19>DB?4E339O>45<1653B9CD91>15>(<1H31<1F5B
>4B51!1BDM>5J#607+2.:67-.26-27; 


 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

3>=CA1W<>A>BH:D4L>BX5=4565=B145;1E5A4145A1658>A1295=
D=1A7D<5=C>455BC5C9?>4529N5E>31A=535B1A91<5=C5BD?1?5;5=
;1A5395=C53>=@D9BC145;139D41445!KG93>39C14>456>A<15G?;L39C1
5=D=<><5=C>3AD391;45;1>2A1?A5E9>1;121C1;;169=1;5=5;@D5
D=J=75;B549A9751;5:KA39C>=J8D1C;?1A11=D=391A;5;19=C5AE5=39N=5=
BD61E>A45'1=9?N;9C>
E>AE5C?9CD95B>?C5><165?C81AE5B94?9?C@B?21BIAE9C?AE56ELC545C
F5>394?C@1B1AE53?>?J3K9CAE5C9>CE1IE41F1<L9C@?3?@5B?I1AE5?C
812L9C8E=9<<14?9?C81?M4?FE5CDB1?B139O>I<E57?F5>4BK5>FE5CDB?
61F?B5<12?714?I@1DBO>45<1"E5F1C@1N1'1>9@O<9D?5>3EI?4M1<?C
C@1N?<5C3?>F?C?DB?C<?C(<1H31<D531C71>1CD59C1!LH93?!?D?<9>M1

><>E5<>B5;J=75;A53>=>355=BD?1A;1<5=C>;1A5395=C53>=
E5AB9N=45;>BC;1G31;C531BWB>9BC95A=>B5=;165X?5A>1;5BC12;535A
D=?1A1;5;9B<>5=CA5;13>=@D9BC1455ADB1;K=H;145!KG93>1?1AC9A
45;19451453ADI1415@D9?1A1=4>5;?1?5;45;>BC;1G31;C531B5=5B1
9<179=1A91C><145(95AA1'1=C13>=5;@D545B5<?5M1A>=5=5;1B549>
1 (5=>38C9C;1= 69:1 H1 ;1 9<175= 45 5BC>B 3><> 3A9BC91=>B 45B45 ;>B
C95<?>B45;11;91=I11=C9<5G931)=19<175=@D5B5<>BCA1AJ456>A<1
<D38><JB5E945=C55=;1B4K3141B?>BC5A9>A5B3D1=4>;1BB97D95=C5B
75=5A139>=5B3>=CA92DH1=15BC1A53>=BCAD339N=45;?1B14>3>=;5H5=
41B@D5W1D=@D5=>1DCK=C931B3><>6D5=C5B89BCNA931B/U0A5E5;1=
9=4D412;5<5=C5 81BC1 @DK 7A14> 5; 3A9BC91=9B<> 1312N B95=4> 14>?
C14>X92B>=#/#%#*!#&  3><>;145;11?1A939N=<9
;17A>B145;1ADIH;145;21DC9B<>45;>B3D1CA>B5M>A5B45(;1G31;1
$A>212;5<5=C5 5; ?A9<5A C5GC> 5B3A9C> 5= 5; @D5 B5 A53>79N ;1 ;5
H5=415=C>A=>13N<>;>B3D1CA>B5M>A5B45(;1G31;1B5812L1=3>=
E5AC94>1;3A9BC91=9B<>H812L1=B94>21DC9I14>B4DA1=C5;>B?A9<5A>B
4L1B455BC1=39145>ACKB5=5BC1?A>E9=3916D55;@D5A5413CN5= 
(8145>45"9I18>H?5A494>$>3>B1M>B<JBC1A455=CA5
H

 5; 3129;4> 45 ;1 39D414 >A45=N ;1 5;12>A139N= 45 D=1 ?9=CDA1


'?2B5<1C9=@<93139?>5C@?<MD93?945?<O7931C455CD1@E5CD15>5C35>1F5B
B139<4<.*<:7.>*60.42B*-7:  6<1C9>D5B@B5D139?>5C451E=1>> 

(B5H<5B

1BB9C

?<1=KCB5395>D545!1BDM>5J'17B54?
IM1JB1I1

'?2B55<@B?35C?45W=E<D9@<93139O>I49C@5BC9O>X451=21C<5I5>41CF5B
92C?>"4*@,*4*.6.4;2047&$  

 E>AE5 3?@914? @1B391<=5>D5 @?B 5B>1>4? 45 <F1 HD<9<HO389D< 5> CE
2;<7:2*-.4*6*,2H6,12,125.,*

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M 

CA1=B?>AC12;5W@D545B3A9295B5;13>;12>A139N=45;>BC;1G31;C531B5=;1
3>=@D9BC145!KG93>H/U0<>BCA1B5BD?A>=C1H5=CDB91BC13>=E5AB9N=
A5;979>B1X!1ACL=5IW 1B?9=CDA1B45;!1=DB3A9C>45;1B7>FX  
3>=>3941 ?>BC5A9>A<5=C5 3><> 5; !%1&  #/# @D5 4525AL1 B5A
?A5B5=C1411=C55;9?5?>AD=145;57139N=45=>2;5B9=4L75=1BH;1
3><?>B939N=45D=1B?9=CDA1B<DA1;5B3>=5B>B<9B<>B<>C9E>B5=;1B
1B1B&51;5B45;139D414'9295=1<2>B4>3D<5=C>B?93C>7AJ693>B
5BCJ= 18>A1 ?5A494>B 3>=C1<>B 3>= ;1 3>?91 45; ;95=I> @D5 ;6A54>
81E5A> ?D2;93N 5= 
  3DH1 ;J<9=1  9=3;DH5 D=1 ;5H5=41 5=
=J8D1C; 
  

  
@D5WB97=96931Y-1B521D
C9I1A>=;>BB5M>A5BZ=5653C>B5E51;3;KA97>L1I21DC9I1=4>1;3957>
,93>CK=31C;H45CAJB45K;HC1<29K=1AA>49;;14>B1;>B>CA>BCA5BB5M>A5B
@D55B?5A1=5;21DC9B<>X &$%")!*+6#&#6%
'125<>B145
<JB@D5;1?A>=C13>=E5AB9N=1;3A9BC91=9B<>6D5D=1A7D<5=C>14D
394>4DA1=C5;1B5=CA5E9BC1B3>=354941B15B15<21:14145 
?1A1;1
@D545295A>=A51;9I1AB5;1B?9=CDA1B?>A@D55=;131AC145;3129;4>C;1G
31;C531@D56D5?A5B5=C1411;<>=1A31
B5A53>A4121@D5;>BC;1G31;C531B
W6D5A>=;>B@D5?A9<5A>E9=95A>=5=3>=>39<95=C>45=D5BCA1'1=C15
1CN;931X)+* %!*  
11A4D1;D38145;1=>2;5I1C;1G31;C531?>A<1=C5=5AH<5:>A1A5=
;> ?>B92;5 ;1 B9CD139N= ?>;LC931 H 53>=N<931 1;31=I141 => B5 45CDE>
C1<?>3> 3>= ;>B ?A9E9;579>B >C>A714>B ?>A 5;9?5  5=   3><>



 $1B1 '1<F14?B *5<1C3? <1C @9>DEB1C =EB1<5C 812BM1> C94? B51<9J141C 3?>
1>D5B9?B94141<<95>J?



81F5B?B51<9JO5CD13?@911>D5C45AE55<2.6B7-."4*@,*4*45C1@1B5395B1
1=1>?C45<1?=9C9O>395>DM69316B1>35C14EB1>D55<'57E>4?9=@5B9?I<1@E
2<93O3?>E>15H@<93139O>5>75.6*3.*:2;<H+*474H66<20J.-*-.;.@2,*6*;
)>13?@91@?CD5B9?B1=@<9141I1D9>D1@?4BM18125B3?>CD9DE94?<1@1BD5@93D?
7BK693145<?AE58?I3?>?35=?C3?=?5<*6=;,:2<7-.4*;07?1<AE5C581BK
B565B5>39113?>D9>E139O>!1BDM>5JW 1C@9>DEB1C45<!1>EC3B9D?45<1C7?GX
 >
 C5549DO<13?@9113?<?B45<<95>J?B51<9J1415>  @?BE1>
!1>E5< -<<1>5C 45< E5BD? 54 45 E141<E@5 <5=K> !LH93?(<1H31<1
""


W1BD145<?C>1DEB1<5C45<1@B?F9>39145(<1H31<11<&5I?>5<9@5
CE@<931>4?<5C3?>35495B15H5>39?>5CDMDE<?CI@B9F9<579?C5>B5=E>5B139O>45
<?CC5BF939?C45CEC1>D5@1C14?C1<D95=@?45<13?>AE9CD1X5>*:<*;-.6-2*;
 

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

A5B?D5BC111@D5;;15<21:141B9=>@D5>2CDE>=D5E>B6ADC>B7A1391B1
;145;57139N=5=E9141D=?1A454K3141B<JBC1A455=   1A535?
39N=45;1B3K4D;1BA51;5B3>=354941B5=1@D5;;1>31B9N=3>9=3949N145
<JB3>=;1;;571411;1"D5E1B?1M1D==D5E>E9AA5H[;E1A>!1=A9
@D545.OM971<1A@DKB45*9;;1<1=A9@D5$>A5;;>3D1=4>5BC5E9B9CN
(;1G31;1?>A?A9<5A1E5I5B5<9B<>1M>;>B9=4L75=1B;5?A5?1A1A>=
D=B>;5<=5A53929<95=C>45BC9=14>1A53>A41A;5BD3>=4939N=5G35?39>
=1; 5= 5; C5AA9C>A9> =>E>89B?1=> '57O= 5; C5BC9<>=9> 45; ?14A5 6A1H
;>=B>$>=35@D55BCDE>?A5B5=C55=1@D5;13>=C539<95=C>
<57O5<F9BB5I11AE5<<139E414I1<15>DB14189395B?><?C9>49?CCE35B5=?>91
I<55>DB571B?><1C<<1F5CI5>E>?CC?>5D?C5><5>7E131CD5<<1>1<5@9495B?>
AE5<5C7E1B41C5CEC6E5B?C5H5>39?>5CI<925BD145CCD121>1<<M1<1@E5BD1
3E1DB?9>49?CF95:?CF5CD94?C1<?1>D97E?3?>3?B?>1C45B5I5C5><1C3125
J1C<?C3E1<5CB5@B5C5>D121>1<?C3E1DB?B5I5C?3E1DB?312535B1C451AE5<<1
@B?F9>39145(<1H31<1AE51IE41B?>1<=1BAELC45<*1<<5D1>F1<5B?C1=5>D5
5><13?>AE9CD145!LH93?IC589395B?>F1C1<<?C45<9>F93DMC9=?5=@5B14?B
1B<?C*I45<?C45=KCB5I5C45C@1N1CECCE35C?B5CI5CD?C3E1DB?F95:?C
5B1><?CAE5812<121>5><?CC?>5D?CC?2B54938?C9E414&51<":*<*-7
 
><>E5<>B;1B5=39;;15B35=9693139N=@D5CDE>;D71A5=1@D5;;1
>31B9N=45B1AA>;;1415=31BC5;;1=>?1A1@D56D5A13><?A5=4941?>A5;
E9AA5H5=;1@D55=3>=CA1<>BH13><>?5AB>=1:5B1;>B3D1CA>B5M>A5B
45(;1G31;1CDE>D=31AJ3C5A5G3;DB9E1<5=C5?>;LC93>1;<5=>B1?1A5=
C5<5=C5B9=5<21A7>3125A53>A41A@D5B545B1AA>;;N4DA1=C5D=>B
65BC5:>B>A71=9I14>B?>A;>B6A19;5B6A1=39B31=>BH@D55=;13K4D;1A51;
?>A;13D1;5;9?5812L1>A45=14>W%D5;>BE9AA5H5B45;1"D5E1B
?1M1 8>=A5= H 61E>A5I31= 1 ;>B =49>B 45 (;1G31;1 H 1 BD 9D414 H
&5?O2;931XB5812L1414>9=3;DB>?A9>A94141;1A7D<5=C>A5;979>B>H1
@D5;>B?A9E9;579>BB5:DBC9693121=?>A@D5W;>B=49>B45(;1G31;16D5A>=
45;>B?A9<5A>B@D55=;1"D5E1B?1M1A539295A>=;1'1=C151CN;931


938?C@B9F9<579?C5>DB5<?CAE545CD13OCE>?=2B1=95>D?3?=?39E414
!EI"?2<5I!EI 51<@E545>5>3?>DB1BC55>5<<9CD14??6B5394?@?B92C?>
"4*@,*4*.6.4;2047,*





<@B?@9?$?>35D9DE<15<31@MDE<?W5<1<<5714145<F9BB5I45(<1H31<1I
B53929=95>D?AE5<?C6B19<5C<589395B?>X 
>5CD5C5>D94?3?=?@B?@?>5
1E=1>>5CD15C35>9693139O>45  C5F9>3E<11<145<1769=2;<*-..:=;*4E645
5><1=549415>AE51=21C45=E5CDB1>3O=?W@?B=549?45<4B1=1Y6B1>
39C31>?Z<?C>?2<5CD<1H31<D531C6E5B?>31@135C455H@B5C1BCE?B7E<<?LD>93?ICE
F9C9O>45<1?>AE9CD1X


 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M 

H=>B495A>=;1#25495=391X&'!#!6%0*#&*!%&* %!*
92A>*(LCD;> 5H,,,,VE>;6>;  AV$>A5;;>3>=E95=5
45C5=5AB55=;>B4>B4>3D<5=C>B@D56D5A>=5=CA5714>B1;A5H5=1@D5
;;1>31B9N=H@D53>=6>A<1=;>@D545=><9=1<>B5;%,*)!+&
#*
&.#*)!'!6%#!,0')&-!%!#/#A5413C141?>A5;3A>
=9BC1<5BC9I>957>!DM>I1<1A7>H5;1<?;9>7AD?>45492D:>B
 ;J<9=1B5=C9=C1@D5456>A<13><?;5<5=C1A9145B3A92L1=;189B
C>A9145(;1G31;13>=5B?5391;9=3945=3915=BD3>;12>A139N=5=;1;12>A
453>=@D9BC1H?139693139N=45;C5AA9C>A9>=>E>89B?1=>3>9=3945=C5B5=
D=1 ?1AC5 9<?>AC1=C5 3>= ;1B ?9=CDA1B A53>7941B 4K3141B 1=C5B 5= 5;
!%1&#/#
$>A;>@D5A5B?53C11;C5<1@D5=>B>3D?1!DM>I1<1A7>@D5
A5381I1 ;1 A5B?>=B129;9414 45 ;>B C;1G31;C531B 5= ;>B 5=6A5=C1<95=C>B
2K;93>B 9=9391;5B 3>= ;>B 5B?1M>;5B 1CA92DHK=4>;>B 1 ;>B 9=49>B >C>
<L5B454931D=1<?;9>5B?139>145B3A929A5;3>;>@D9>@D5BD?D5BC1
<5=C5812AL1C5=94>;D71A5=CA5W;>B3D1CA>B5M>A5B45;1B3D1CA>3125
35A1BXH5A=J=>ACKB13>=C539<95=C>@D5=>9=E5=C1?D5BC>@D5H1
1?1A535A579BCA14>?>A>CA>B1DC>A5B?5A>BL<>496931B5=B92;5<5=



<@1B535B5<1ED?B7E1B4OE>13?@91455CD1B5<139O>AE56E5@E<95>4?5>
65381C@?CD5B9?B5CAE55C<1AE53?>?35=?C3?=?2;<7:2*-."4*@,*4*<D5HD?
C539D15>5<@B5C5>D5DB121:?C57P>5CD1F5BC9O>@?BC5B3?>C945B141<14569>9D9F1
I@?BAE51<8125BAE5414?5>(<1H31<1@E4?C5B3?>?3941@?BCEC3?5DK>5?C

B?D85BC?>I1<<57?C1@E>D1>1E>16E5>D5@B5F91F9>3E<1411CEF5J1
<1C @9>DEB1C =EB1<5C D<1H31<D531C D1>D? @1B1 <1C 9=K75>5C 45 5CD5 =1>EC3B9D?
3?=?@1B1<1C45<2.6B7-."4*@,*4*AE5812BM1@?494?6?B=1B@1BD545E>@B?
I53D?=KC1=@<9?455CD5P<D9=?>3E1<AE95B31C?!EN?J1=1B7?>?C5BM15<
1ED?B455CD1@1BD545<3O4935

*5B!EN?J1=1B7?2;<7:2*-."4*@,*4*  

45=KC455B>1<M1JI139D14?C5B5695B5>1L<3B?>9CD1C3?=? O@5J
45O=1B15>5<31@ *45CE2;<7:2*-.4*,769=2;<*-.E@2,7AE95>C5N1<1
AE5?BDLC<5C9>D5>DO3?>F5BD9B59>3<EI5<?C1B7E=5>D?C@1B1<1>571D9F1 
1N1495>4?AE5?BDLC@B?=5D9O5>D?>35C5>F91B=9C9?>5B?C@1B1E>13?BB53D1
5F1>75<9J139O>?5BF1>D5C45'1<1J1BAE51=@<M1<1F5BC9O>45O=1B19>3?B
@?B1>4? E>1 @B?653M1 45 ,93?DL>31D< 5< *95:? C?2B5 5< DB9E>6? 45 ?BDLC I <1
@B?>D13?>F5BC9O>45<?CD<1H31<D531C:H62,*-.4*=.>*;8*G*31@, *I
E>1=@<9?@1B<1=5>D?45<3?>AE9CD14?B5>5<AE55H@<931<1C@B9>39@1<5CF5B4145C
45<1>E5F16559>D5>D149CE149B1<?CC5N?B5C@1B1AE5121>4?>5>1CEC61<C?C
M4?<?C31@ 

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

C55=;1E5AB9N=45;3A>=9BC1<5BC9I>4938>5=3D5=CA>B545B1AA>;;15=
4>B61B5B5=D=?A9<5A<><5=C>;1BW2;1=41BH1<>A>B1B?1;12A1BX
45 >ACKB ?5=5CA1= 5= ;>B 3>A1I>=5B 45 ;>B 3D1CA> B5M>A5B W9=6D=
495=4>5=5;;>B<9;17A>B1<5=C5;17A13915;B?LA9CD'1=C>X !*+&)!
#/# ?5A>=>;>7A1=3>=E5=35A;>B?>A;>@D5A5B?>=45=>65=
494>BWT3N<>45B8135BHC95=5B5=?>3>3>=C1=7A1=1CA5E9<95=C>;1
45941445=D5BCA>B49>B5BX HB5=9571=1121=4>=1A;1B3A55=391B
45BDB1=C5?1B14>BWT3N<>@D95A5BCO@D53>=C1=C16139;9414;>B45:5
<>BH3>=B9=C1<>B@D53>=CDBE9>;5=C1BHB13AL;571B<1=>BC545:5<>B
?A>61=1A;>B49>B5B@D55=C1=C>C5=5<>BH5BC9<1<>BX >ACKB
A5C><113>=C9=D139N=BDA1I>=1<95=C>?1A114E5AC9A;5B@D5BDB61;B>B
L4>;>BW=9B>=49>B5B=9B>==141=9C95=5==9=7O=?>45AX
;>
7A1=4>18>A1BL3>=E5=35A1;>BB5M>A5BW;5A5B?>=495A>=453><O=
3>=B5=C9<95=C>@D5?D5B5;;>B;5812L1=414>BDB3>A1I>=5BH1<9BC14
/U0=>C5=L1=@D5A5B?>=45AB9=>@D55:53DC1B5BDE>;D=C14X
 B
5=C>=35B3D1=4>1?5C939N=45;>B?A>?9>B3139@D5BC95=5;D71AW3>=
5GC5=B>B>;5<=5H35;52A14>A57>39:>XBD21DC9B<>W?>A<1=>45D1=
L1I?A5B2LC5A>X
  13>=E5AB9N=H21DC9B<>45;>BB5M>A5B=>
812AL19<?;9314>5=3D1;@D95A31B>;145C>41;1?>2;139N=B57O=5;
?A>?9>!DM>I1<1A7>5;45<>=9>B51?1A53L11;>B9=49>B13>=B5
:J=4>;5BW@D5=>45B<1H1B5==9;>B8><2A5B14E5=549I>B;>B5=71M1
B5=;>3D1;;5B453L15=BD5M>BH>CA1B1?1A95=391BX
 45<1=5A1
@D5C>41EL15= <D38>B?A9=39?1;5BE95:>BA53>=>395A>==>5BC1A
21DC9I14>B
 
=3D1=C>1;>B492D:>B@D513><?1M1=1;1*)!'!6%5BC>BB5;9
<9C1=1A5?A>4D39A;19<175=45;21DC9B<>45;>B3139@D5B?>A?1AC545;
3;KA97>D1=L1I@D5H15=3>=CAJ21<>B5=5; 95=I>45(;1G31;1B9
295=;1;5H5=411?1A53518>A15=31BC5;;1=>W1DC9B<>@D5B589I>1
;>B3D1CA>B5M>A5B45(;1G31;1@D5?9495A>=B5A3A9BC91=>BX6>;
E
5=!DM>I1<1A7>*)!'!6%#!,0')&-!%!#/# 5
5BC5<>4>45<1=5A1<D38><JBB9<?;9693141@D5;13AN=931;1B9<J
75=5B45;%,*)!+&
#*&.1;97D1;@D5;1B45; 95=I>H;1B?9=CDA1B
<DA1;5B BD795A5= W9=75=9>B1<5=C5 V3><> ?A>?>=5= A>C85ABC>= H
1;;57>BV@D5(;1G31;1135?CN5;3A9BC91=9B<>5=D=5B?139>1=C5A9>A1



%E9JKC97E95>4?3?=?@B?@?>5'1<F14?B*5<1C3?5<=?45<?45<7479=27
AE5<?C4?356B1>39C31>?C=1>DEF95B?>3?><?CC129?C=5H931C5>
B53?794?
@?B5B>1B49>?45'1817P>5><14L314145 

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

BD13C9E9414<9;9C1A>C>A7J=4>;5B1BL5;45A538>453>=B945A1AB53>=
@D9BC14>A5B5;;>B<9B<>BX 



1ED9C=?45<?C3E1DB?C5N?B5C45(<1H31<1>*6=;,:2<74*;07?6
F

;?>=5A5=A5;139N=;>B4>3D<5=C>B45;%,*)!+&
#*&.H;1
5B35=9693139N=45  1=C55;E9AA5H312514<9C9A@D5;1?A5B5=39145
;>B3D1CA>1=391=>B5=5;?1?5;45A5H5B45;1B3D1CA>312535A1B45(;1G
31;1 5= 5BC1 O;C9<1 5E>3N C1=C> BD 3>=4939N= 45 1;914>B 45 >ACKB H
BO249C>B695;5B45;1>A>=15B?1M>;15G?;L39C15=;>BB>=5C>BA539C14>B
3><>BD4539B9E13>=E5AB9N=1;1653A9BC91=1?D5BC>@D51<2>B8538>B
812L1=B94>H15=;1I14>B5=5;9<179=1A9>C;1G31;C5314569=5B45;,*
D51BL3><>4529N1BD<9A;>B5;1DC>A45;&#&(,!&#%,-&%-)*!6%
0,+!*$&#&*,+)&7#+!$&*)0*#/#%#,- *'5@D95=
B9=5<21A7>>6A539ND=1=D5E1E5AB9N=45;1;5H5=415=;1@D5;13>=
E5AB9N=45BDB?A>C17>=9BC1B45:145B5AD=1A7D<5=C>1;B5AE939>45;1
A59E9=493139N=?>;LC93145;>BC;1G31;C531BHB5CA1=B6>A<15=5;1BD=C>

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms

   

35=CA1;45;1>2A114@D9A95=4>=D5E>BHB97=96931C9E>B<1C935B13>A45B
3>=BD?A>?NB9C>4>3CA9=1;


 "  " 







  

=BD !*+&)!##!+)+,)%2 ,+#[=75;!S1A921H169A<N@D55;
&#&(,!&#&*,+)&)0*5A1D=1DC>WB9=3>=>39<95=C>45;1<5=C1;9414
9=491=9B9@D95A145;1<JBAD49<5=C1A919=6>A<139N=135A3145;1B3>B1B
45;1A1I1H39D4143DH189BC>A91B5?A5C5=4535;52A1AX K3141B
<JBC1A45;B1539;91A>BC9=B9BCL15=;>BW1=13A>=9B<>BH12BDA
4>BX45D=1>2A15=;1@D5;>B9=4L75=1B5A1=W31?135B4549B3DAA9A
3><>3D1;@D95A5B3>;JBC93>B>2A55;<9BC5A9>45;15D31A9BCL1X?5A>
A53>=>3L1@D5;169=1;941445;1?95I1=>5A1A53A51A;189BC>A91B9=>
W;15G1;C139N=45;165XA>BC =5653C>?>3>9<?>AC1;1BD?D5B
C16945;941489BCNA9315=5BC53>;>@D9>=>B5=3>=CA1<>BV3><>H1B5
81B5M1;14>V1=C5D=1?95I14531AJ3C5A3D;C>5B3A9C1W17;>A91H1;1
21=I145;'1=CLB9<>'13A1<5=C>X5=;1@D5;1;5H5=41C;1G31;C531
@D5;541CLCD;>HBDB?5AB>=1:5B@D541=BD2>A49=14>B1;?A>?NB9C>
4>3CA9=1;?A>?9>45;7K=5A>?5A>5;;>=>B97=96931@D5BD1DC>A45B3>
=>395A15;3>=C5GC>89BCNA93>@D5A>451;11339N=4A1<JC931
5:>B45B5A3>=B945A14145B45D=1?5AB?53C9E1?>;LC931;13>=
E5AB9N=45;>B7>25A=1=C5BC;1G31;C531BB512>A4145B45D=149<5=
B9N=C5>;N7931@D5B5?5A3925H15=5;CLCD;>@D5B5411;1>2A15=;1
(12;1453>=C5=94>B45;<1=DB3A9C>45DC9KAA5I45 D=1&#&(,!&
#0%,-&%-)*!6%#&*,+)&7#+!$&*)0*#/#569=9A5BC1
3>=E5AB9N=3><>%,-5=5;B5=C94>5C9<>;N793>45;CKA<9=>5BC>5B
3><>))>/'!&%#59=B9BC9A5=@D5;>BA5H5B81=A539294>5;4>=
45;1E9ACD4C5>;>71;@D5B>;>?D545B5A>C>A7141?>A9=C5AE5=39N=



9C3B5@?5>5CD5@E>D?45<11B7E=5>D139O>451E=1>>AE95>F9>3E<15<
7479=27-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;3?><15C35>9693139O>45  I@B?@?>59>3<EC?AE5W<?C
D<1H31<D531C @E495B?> 8125B 3?>DB1D14? 1 E> @?5D1 5C@1N?< @1B1 3?=@?>5B CE
89CD?B915>6?B=1C@?LD931C5C@1N?<1CX
 ?=?B53E5B411CD5<<C5>5<3?
<?AE9?5<1C@53D?B5<979?C?@B5F1<535C?2B5<1F5BD95>D5@?<MD93145<1<5I5>41

>DB5<1C@5AE5N1CF1B91>D5CAE5=E5CDB1><?CDMDE<?C45<?C31@MDE<?CB5C
@53D?1<1(12<1453?>D5>94?C69>1<C55>3E5>DB1<15<9=9>139O>45<DLB=9>?/.
5><1DB1C<139O>45<D5HD?3?=@<5D?45<3?<?AE9?1<=1>EC3B9D?CD55C5<=?D9F?

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

49E9=1B9CO1;>B13>=C539<95=C>B45B3A9C>B5=5;J<29C>45;>B>2A5
=1CDA1;H41?951;14>3CA9=1<95=C>45;1D49C>A9>B>2A51;7D=>B45;>B
?A9=39?1;5B4>7<1B3A9BC91=>B
13>=E5AB9N=45;>BA5H5B5BD=<9;17A>H3><>C1;A5@D95A545
;19=C5AE5=39N=49E9=1518L;19<?>AC1=39145;BD5M>5=;1>2A1@D5
=>5BB>;>5;5B?139>45;1?A5<>=939N=A5B?53C>1;1;;5714145;>B
5B?1M>;5B&#&(,!&   
B9=>C1<29K=45;1A5E5;139N=C1;3><>
B5<D5BCA15=;15B35=15=@D5;>BB5M>A5BB5@D541=4>A<94>BCA1B
;1E9B9C145;5<21:14>A&#&(,!&  3><>14E95AC551CA9I45
;21>38WBC54>A<9AB5@D51?A9<5A1E9BC1?>4AL1?1A535A9=
3>=7AD5=C55B5B5=391;?1A1A5?A5B5=C1A@D5;>BA5H5B5B3D381=49
A53C1<5=C5;1?1;12A1459>B1;1<1=5A145;11=C97P54142L2;931X
 
; W[=75;X @D5 ;5B CA1=B<9C5 ;1 $1;12A1 9E9=1 5B '1= !97D5;
@D95=1BDE5I81B94>?5AB>=1:53;1E55=5;$&)!##$+)!
#&* 2%#* @D5 12A5 5; <1=DB3A9C> 45 DC9KAA5I 45 D=1 ?>A B5A 5;
1A3J=75;@D5CA9D=61B>2A5 D3965AH1;@D5145<JB812L1<>BE9BC>
C1<29K=A5E5;1AB55=BD5M>B1;1AI>29B?>!>H145>=CA5A1B=;1
?95I1C51CA1;BD9=C5AE5=39N=5B=535B1A911D=C95<?>?1A19=6D=49A
;1651;>BA5H5BH?1A114E5AC9A;5BB>2A5;1E5A4145A1=1CDA1;5I1455B5
49>B>=7>;1;@D514>A1=W1@D5B5295==1394>5=C1=<1;B97=>
@D51;<9B<>9>BB51CA5E518135A7D5AA1@D5A9K=4>B597D1;1A1
9>B25=97=>X&#&(,!& EE  @D5;>BC95=55=71M14>B
1 31A13C5A9I139N= 45 >=7>; 3><> 45<>=9> 5=71M14>A 3>=B
C9CDH5D=3;1A>5:5<?;>45<1=5:>45;@D56D5D=>45;>B?A9=39?1;5B
1A7D<5=C>B 45 3>=E5AB9N= 45B45 ;>B 9=939>B 45 ;1 C1A51 5E1=75;9I1
4>A1=5BC5B5=C94>;1W45<>=9I139N=45;>B49>B5B?A9<975=9>BX


@?B5<AE5>?1@1B5355>5<DMDE<?45<1C49CD9>D1C54939?>5C45<1?2B11E>AE5
3?=?18?B1F5B5=?CB5CE<D16E>41=5>D1<@1B1<19>D5B@B5D139O>45<1=9C=1

 $1B1 B?CD 5CD1 5C35>1 45=E5CDB1 AE5 <1 ?2B1 31B535 45 F5B?C9=9<9DE4
".*<:78:7/.;276*43.;=2<*-.4;2047&$ 61C9=9C=?1B921I2;<7:2*-.4*42<.
:*<=:*6D1=*<4 

5CD5B5C@53D?B5CE<D19>D5B5C1>D5<11@B539139O>45%E9>D1>1C?2B53O=?
1@5C1B45C5BE>B53EBC?=EIED9<9J14?<1B5F5<139O>5>CE5N?CF9>3E<1D1=29L>
<1?2B11<1DB14939O>45<1C@1CD?B5<1CAE5D5>4BK5C@5391<1E755>=LB931 


*5B*94145<1BJ?29C@?5>26,7,*:<*;



65<=9C=?1B7E=5>D?I15>7479=27;A7,<:26*,:2;<2*6*    

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
    

#AC9I
 5B D= 5;5<5=C> @D5 =D5BCA1 >2A1 3><?1AC5 3>= >CA1B
?95I1B=>E>89B?1=1B45;1K?>31H<DH5B?5391;<5=C53>=;1B45B
C9=141B5=3>=3A5C>1;1?>2;139N=9=4L75=15=;1B@D55=3>=CA1<>B
97D1;<5=C5 ;>B BL<2>;>B 45 ;1 45E>39N= 3A9BC91=1 DC9;9I14>B ?>A ;>B
A5H5B?1A118DH5=C1A1;5<>=9>5;"><2A5455BOB;1'1=C1ADI
H5;<9B<>'1=C>'13A1<5=C>
$>A>CA>;14>5;<>45;>49A53C>455BC131A13C5A9I139N=45252DB
31AB5V3><>H1B581B5M1;14>V5= #,-&,%&*,!)+&'&))!*
+6#&#6%45 >?545*5714>=45C1<29K=B58135A565A5=391=535
B1A91<5=C51;131L4145 D3965AH13N<>813>=B57D94><1=C5=5A
5=71M14>B1;>B8129C1=C5B45<KA931 ;3>;>@D9>B9=5<21A7>
<1A311;7D=1BB97=96931C9E1B49BC1=391BA5B?53C>14938><>45;>@D5
H181=B94>1?D=C141B?>A&931A4>1BC5;;BB95=;13><549145 >?5
;15G?;93139N=B>2A55BC545<>=9>5=71M14>A;1A51;9I1D=3>=@D9BC1
4>A45<>A1;4D4>B1(5AA1I1B@D95=4569=5145<JB1;3139@D5D;
31=@D5;;L=3><>2))&5=5;3>;>@D9>=>E>89B?1=>;19=BCAD339N=
A5;979>B1;;57145;1<1=>45WD=J=75;@D55BC12;535D=1A5;139N=49
A53C15=CA5;1653A9BC91=1H;>BA5H5BC;1G31;C531BX H5;O=93>2JA
21A>1;@D5B58135A565A5=3915=;1>2A15B5;?A>?9>>=7>;H1@D5
4141BD31?1394149=C5;53CD1;W9>B815B3>794>1;>B3D1CA>A5H5B
?1A1B5A;>B?A9<5A>B<5G931=>B5=A53929A;19;D<9=139N=49E9=1X 
<21B4965A5=391BB5A56;5:1=1BDE5I5=;149BC9=C16D=39N=@D55;
<>=N;>7>3>?914>45;1>2A145 >?514@D95A55=2>3145,93>CK=
31C; H ?>A C1=C> 5= ;1B ?5@D5M1B <>49693139>=5B @D5 5; 1DC>A



$1B1#BD9JB5CE<D1455C@5391<9>D5BLC5<W5CAE5=145@5>C1=95>D?49C3B9
=9>1>D5I8575=O>93?X=?CDB14?5>5CD1?2B1WAE59>CD1<1945>D96931I3?>
F95BD549B53D1=5>D51<M4?<?@B589C@K>93?5>E>1F5BC9O>45<45=?>9?5EB?@5?X



615CD5@B?@OC9D?145=KC45<39D14?DB121:?45#BD9J5<45%E9>D1>1
  

'?2B5<1@B5C5>391455CD51B7E=5>D?5>5<D51DB?5F1>75<9J14?B>?F?89C
@1>?F5BB139<4<.*<:7.>*60.42B*-7:
  

7479=27

FF  C?2B5<1ED9<9J139O>454938?CCM=2?<?C5>5<
D51DB?=9C9?>5B?F5BB139<4<.*<:7.>*60.42B*-7: 


*5B ?@545*5714=.>7=6-7-.;,=+2.:<787::2;<H+*474H6  FF

 I  FF

 

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

=>E>89B?1=>9=CA>4D355=;>BE5AB>B
1;A5?5C9A;1B?1;12A1B45D;
31=@D5;;L=@D95=BL4D41B>2A5;1135?C139N=45;3A9BC91=9B<>H45
8538>B97D545=D5E>1BD49>B3D1=4>5BC5;514E95AC5B>2A5;1B9=
C5=39>=5B45(5AA1I1B,93>CK=31C;9=3DAA55=D=1?5@D5M13>=CA1
49339N=?>A@D5W5G?A5B14D41B@D5=>812L1C5=94>1=C5A9>A<5=C5XH
@D55=3D1;@D95A31B>B5A5BD5;E5=456>A<14569=9C9E15=5;<>=N
;>7> H1 @D5 ?D5BC> @D5 81= ?A5B5=3914> D=1 9=C5AE5=39N= 49E9=1
W=>81H=9=7D=1?>B929;941445@D5;>B3D1CA>A5H5BED5;E1=1;3D;C>
4912N;93>X1BC5;;B 
1?1AC93D;1AE5AB9N=45;1;5H5=41@D5B5<D5BCA15=5;3>;>@D9>
B5 49BC1=391 1 BD E5I 45 ;1 >6A53941 ?>A !DM>I 1<1A7> => B>;>
?>A@D5 6A5=C5 1 ;>B B5A9>B 1A7D<5=C>B @D5 ;>B B5M>A5B C;1G31;C531B
?A5B5=C1=1>ACKB?1A1<1=C5=5AB5695;5B1;1B3A55=391B45BDB1=C5
?1B14>B5=;13AN=931;1B4D41B45,93>CK=31C;B>2A55;121=4>=>45
;11=C97D1A5;979N=B>=V3><>13121<>B45E5AV31B9A5CNA931BB9=>
C1<29K=?>A@D5;19=C5AE5=39N=<9B<145>ACKB=>5B=535B1A91?1A1
;;5E1A1312>;13>=E5AB9N=45;>BA5H5B1@D95=5B5;J=75;819=6D=
494>H1;1653D1=4>B55=3D5=CA1=3>=5;3>=@D9BC14>A$>A5;;>5=
;1<9B<15B35=15=;1@D5B5A53>755;<>=N;>7>45 >?5?A5E911
4938>5=3D5=CA>>2B5AE1<>BD=?A>7A5B9E>121=4>=>455B1B4D
41BHC5<>A5B81BC1;;571A1;1135?C139N=9=3>=4939>=1;45;1=D5E1
A5;979N= @D5 B5 <1=9695BC1 45 <1=5A1 5G?;L39C1 5= ;1B ?1;12A1B 45
.9C;1;?>?>31CI9=
E>9?CAE5>?85F9CD?3B5?/U0
'5N?B=9B14=916939O>
AE55C7B1>45@E5CAE5C12L9C



?=?14F95BD51CD5<<C 5>5<3?<?AE9?C5CE@B9=5E>F5BC?45 ?@5


WI1<13?CDE=2B5D5BB92<5XF

IC51N145E>?69>1<WI5CD1B<5AE95B??25
495>D5X7479=27-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;


 FF  


<21?38C5B5695B51C9=9C=?1?DB1C4965B5>391CAE5@B5C5>D1><1@95J1
5C@1N?<1I<1>?F?89C@1>1IAE5D1=29L>@5B=9D5>1@B5391BE>1497>9693139O>45<
9>4M75>1 1=5B931>? 5> 5CD1 P<D9=1 
  5C45 5CD1 @5BC@53D9F1 B5CE<D1
496M39<135@D1B<1D5C9C45"E>5CAE95>@B539C1=5>D51@B?@OC9D?45<1697EB145
?>7?< @<1>D51 E>1 W21B21B9J139O> 45 <1 697EB1 45< 9>4M75>1X 5> 5< 3?<?AE9?
 

H9CD5>C9>5=21B7?9>D5B@B5D139?>5C4965B5>D5C455CD5@1C1:53?=?<145
M1JI45#F1>4?AE95>@B?@?>5AE5W@1B15<1ED?B45<?<?AE9?3?=?@1B1
D?4?5C@1N?<>?4529O@1C1B9>14F5BD94?5<5CD14?45K>9=?<1<E381D5BB92<545
<?C9>49?C1<3?>F5BD9BC51<31D?<939C=?X 

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

AE51>D5C458125B?CF9CD?
D1>31ED9F?=5D5>L9C
AE55CD?I14?B1>4?1B9CD?
C9>8125BF9CD?AE9L>5C
7479=27
 
 FF I 
 
BL1D=@D5>ACKB169A<11=C5;>BB5M>A5B@D5BD?A>?NB9C>5B
W@D519>B3>=>I3J9BX&#&(,!&
E =>?A>=D=39113>=C9
=D139N==9=7O=?1A;1<5=C>?1A13>=E5=35A;>B?>A@D53><>;5A5B
?>=45,93>CK=31C;W(>4>B;514>A1<>BH1XE 
5B?A>E9BC>45;?1?5;<9B9>=1;@D5;51B97=1!DM>I1<1A7>
?1?5;@D51?5=1B5:5A355;3;KA97>D1=L1I@D95=B5;9<9C11A5BD<9A
;>B ?D=C>B ?A9=39?1;5B 45; A54> ?1A1 ?A>3545A 1; 21DC9B<> 45 ;>B
=>2;5B9=4L75=1B5;3>=@D9BC14>A1BD<5B9=5<21A7>D=16D=39N=
BDBC1=391;5=;1?95I15=;1<549415=@D5BDB9=C5AE5=39>=5B45:1=
3;1A1;1A5;139N=5G9BC5=C55=CA55;1BD=C>A5;979>B>12>A414>H5;3>=
C5GC>5=5;@D5B545B1AA>;;1;13>=@D9BC145;C5AA9C>A9><5G931=>@D5
5B?A5B5=C141=535B1A91<5=C5456>A<1?>B9C9E1H1@D55;C5GC>2DB31
WBD2A1H1A;1E>;D=C149=4L75=1C;1G31;C531451?>H>H135?C139N=45
;1B=D5E1B9=BC9CD39>=5BX&9E5A1

;1DC>A45;3>;>@D9>=>=535B9C15;D49A;>B5=6A5=C1<95=C>B2K
;93>B?A5E9>B1;5=3D5=CA>3><>8135456>A<1?A>2;5<JC931!DM>I
1<1A7>?>A@D55=;1;N793145;49B3DAB>4A1<JC93>=>81H<>C9E>
?1A1 5;;>B ;>B A5H5B 453945= B><5C5AB5 1 ;1 >A>=1 5B?1M>;1 5=



 > 5< =9C=? C5>D94? C5 =1>9695CD1> 5< B5CD? 45 <?C B5I5C 5> <?C F5BC?C
C97E95>D5C 7479=27
 
  FF 
 E>AE5 <1 3?>C945B139O> 45 <?C
9>4M75>1C3?=?W@B53B9CD91>?CX75>D9<5C@B5@1B14?C@1B1B53929B<16545B9CD?
6E58129DE1<5><1C@B9=5B1C4L3141C45<15F1>75<9J139O>IC5B56<5:O1CEF5J5>
<1CB5@B5C5>D139?>5C=9C9?>5B1CF5BB139<4<.*<:7.>*60.42B*-7:  <131
B13D5B9J139O>45<?CB5I5CD<1H31<D531CCE@?>5C9>4E41E>1F1>353?>C945B12<55>
5CD5C5>D94?I1AE55CD?C9>CDBE94?C@?B5<K>75<3?=?85=?CF9CD?C?>3?>C
395>D5C455CD1B@B5@1B14?C@1B1C5B3B9CD91>?CW()W-?3B9CD91>?AE95B?
C5B!,'(B9CD5@?B>?C5B<?<<?B?XFF


58538?5CD13?>4939O>AE5D95>5><?CB5I5C45W@B53B9CD91>?CXI15CC5
N1<141@?B5<@B?@9??BDLC3?>1>D5B9?B94143E1>4?=1>9695CD11<5=21:14?B1
DB1FLC45!1B9>1AE5W@?BAE53?>?3519?C@95>C11IE41B<5=91=?BX747
9=27
 FF   

&53?B45=?CAE55><13BO>93145!EN?J1=1B7?5<@B9=5B?2:5D9F?45
?BDLC5CB5<979?C?W4K>4??C15>D5>45B3O=?>?81I=KC45E>9?CF5B4145B?
@?BAE5D?4?C<?C45=KCAE5D5>L9CI14?BK9C@?B49?C5CC?>49?C5C61<C?CX

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M 

3D1=C>C95=5==>C939145;1;;5714145;>B5B?1M>;5B=>B>;>?>A5;
5AA>A 5BCA1CK793> @D5 BD?>=4AL1 5=6A5=C1AB5 1; <1H>A <>=1A31 45;
<D=4>1A;>B*5BB5M>AW45B91[6A931HDA>?1XB9=>B>2A5
C>4>?>A@D5;1;;5714145;1W75=C55B?1M>;1XB53>=B945A145B455;
?A9=39?9>E5=C1:>B1?1A1;>BC;1G31;C531BH1@D5>ACKB;5B81>6A5394>
D=11;91=I1@D5;5B?5A<9C9AJ;925A1AB545;HD7>45!>3C5ID<1
5394<5!1B9>1>?C
15CD5>?2<55=21:14?B
AE5<549711CEC5N?B/U0
AE5>E5CDB?B5I81C1294?
3O=?3?>DB1!?JD5JE=1
7B1>45C7E5BB1C81D5>94?
IAE5C53?>CE5<55>CE=1
AE5C5BK61F?B5394?
AE5@1B11IE41B<5F5>7?
7479=27
 FF  I 
 
>=E5AC94>B;>B3D1CA>A5H5B1;1=D5E165HBO249C>B45;<?5A9>
5B?1M>;?>A?A>?91E>;D=C145;1B?53C>2K;93>B535=CA1B>;>5=5;
6DCDA>1B549>1;131?9C1;<5G9313DH>?A>C17>=9B<>5B1BD<94>?;5
=1<5=C5 ?>A >ACKB  ; 21DC9B<> 14@D95A5 1BL D=1 4>2;5 B97=969
3139N=5=;1?95I13><>=535B1A913>=B53D5=39145;1<9;17A>B13>=
E5AB9N= 45 ;>B B5M>A5B C;1G31;C531B H 3><> A5@D9B9C> 9=49B?5=B12;5
?1A1;181I1M12K;9313>AC5B91=1H1@D55B;1W?A9<5A1>6A5=41@D545
1@DL81B1;94>X?1A1A>71A19>B?>AW1;31=I1A;1BE93C>A91B@D5=>B


>3<EC?5<@B?@9?45=?>9??>7?<<5CB53?=95>41AE51CM<?8171>1E>AE5
1=5>1J13?>31CD971B<?CC9C53?>F95BD5>1<3B9CD91>9C=?W&571<14<?CIC5BF94<?C
ICE1=9CD14@B?F538?C1D5>54=1C>?<?C3B5K9C/U0'949:5B5>AE51CEB5I
FE5CDB1C6B5>D5C@?45B?C1CC5CE:5D5>295>@?4L9C=1C>?1CE4?3DB9>1?39?
C1X7479=27  FF




 

CD19>C9CD5>3915>=?CDB1B<13?>AE9CD13?=?E>11<91>J11>D9=5H931I
@?BD1>D?61F?B12<51(<1H31<15CDKD1=29L>5><1C@1<12B1CAE5!EN?J1=1B7?
@?>55>2?3145?BDLC5>CE49K<?7?3?><?C3139AE5CD<1H31<D531CW*5>7?1
1IE41B?C I 1 41B =EI 3BE41 7E5BB1 1 !?3D85EJ?=1 FE5CDB? 5>5=97? 31@9D1<X
2;<7:2*-."4*@,*4*  

?=?14F95BD51CD5<<C<?CB5I5CWC53?>F95BD5>5>3B9CD91>?CICP249D?C45
1B<?CC9>8125BC94?3?>AE9CD14?C?45BB?D14?C@?B5B>K>?BDLCX 

"?3?9>394?5>5CD5@E>D?3?><21?38AE95>3?=@1B15<3?<?AE9?3?>
<1B5<139O>454931411?BDLC5>5<=1>EC3B9D?@1B13?>3<E9BAE5<1?2B1D51DB1<
W@B?2<5=1D9J1<1F9C9O>45<13?>AE9CD1AE57<?B969311?BDLCXW!5=?B91@?<MD931
45<13?>AE9CD1X 

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

7D1A41= 81BC1 ;;571A 1; 35;52A14> !KG93>X &#&(,!&



 EE  

 $5A>4938181I1M1=>C95=5312941H15=;1A5?A5B5=C139N=
$>A 5;;> ;1 <1A381 45; 3>=@D9BC14>A 81391 (5=>38C9C;1= BD?D5BC1
<5=C5:D=C>1BDB1;914>BB53>AA5B?>=453>=5;69=1;45;1>2A1
I4?>455<=5C=?@?<?>?6E5F9CD?
@95>C?1<31>J1BF93D?B91
41>4?3?>5CD?69>1>E5CDB189CD?B91
7479=27
FF    
!
=  B1;9N1;1;DI5='5E9;;1;1<17=1>2A1456A1HD1=45
(>A@D5<141C9CD;141&%)(,4!%!%=5; 92A>,*4549314>1
;1 14<9=9BCA139N= 45 ;>B B13A1<5=C>B 5; 6A1=39B31=> 9=3;DHN D=
31?LCD;> 4549314> 1; W?A9<5A 21DC9I> @D5 8D2> 5= 5BC1 "D5E1 B
?1M1X5=5;@D5A53>7L1;1E5AB9N=45!DM>I1<1A7>B>2A5;13>=
E5AB9N=45;>B3D1CA>A5H5B45(;1G31;17A1391B1;?5ABD1B9E>49B3DAB>
45>ACKB( 31? 


;5B6D5AI>45;1=>2;5I1C;1G31;
C531?>AA53>=BCAD9ABD?1B14>A5395=C5E9=3D;1=4>BD1;91=I1<9;9C1A
3>=;>B5B?1M>;5BH;1135?C139N=45;1=D5E165?>A?1AC545;>BB5
M>A5BC;1G31;C531B812L1414>BDB6ADC>B;1;5H5=41812L15=CA14>1
6>A<1A ?1AC5 45; A5;1C> >69391; B>2A5 ;1 ;12>A 5E1=75;9I14>A1 5= ;1
"D5E1B?1M1
B?>B92;5@D55;1DC>A45;&#&(,!&#&%-)*!6%#&*,+)&)0*
#/#3>=>395A15BC1E5AB9N=69:141?>A;1?;D<145!DM>I1
<1A7>?5A>=>4529N21B1AB55=5;;1?1A13><?>=5ABDC5GC>'D>2
:5C9E>5A1<>BCA1A@D5;13>=E5AB9N=45BDB?A>C17>=9BC1B=>B5812L1
;>7A14>7A1391B1;1;12>A<9B9>=5A145>ACKBB9=>1D=19=C5AE5=39N=
B>2A5=1CDA1; H ?1A1 5;12>A1A BD 1A7D<5=C> => =535B9C121 <JB @D5
>2B5AE1AD=19<175=HBD;5H5=41;145;W1DC9B<>@D5B589I>1;>B
3D1CA>B5M>A5B45(;1G31;1@D5'!!)&%*))!*+!%&*X
"1AA15A=1=4>45;E1GC;9;GN389C;5=BD !*+&)!#%!6% !
 !$@D5W5=;1?9=CDA1@D51D=5;4L1458>H7D1A415;3129;4>45
5BC1B5M>AL1B581;;1@D55=5BC1B1IN=B521DC9I1A>=;>BB5M>A5B45
5;;1?>AD1=L1I3;KA97>H6D5BD?14A9=>5;31?9CJ=>ACKB5;?A9
<5A>6D5,93>CK=31C;@D5B5;;1<N4>=1AC>;><KHCA1BK;.9C;1;?>
?>31CI9= @D5 B5 ;;1<N 4>= 1;C1B1A H ;D57> (;58D5G>;>CI9= @D5B5
;;1<N4>=>=I1;>H5;?>BCA5A>!1G9G31CI9=@D55A1<1=352>HB5
;;1<N 4>= D1=X 
  "9 ;>B =><2A5B 3A9BC91=>B 1B97=14>B 1 ;>B

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M 

3D1CA>A5H5B=9;19<175=45>ACKB3><>?14A9=>O=93>3>9=3945=
3>=;>B41C>B1?>AC14>B?>A!DM>I1<1A7>H1BD<94>B?>A(>A
@D5<141
?5A>BL;>8135456>A<15G13C13>==D5BCA>3>;>@D9>
529NB5A5B1?9=CDA15;12>A141?>A>A45=45;3129;4>45(;1G31;1;1
@D5 B9AE9N 3><> ?D=C> 45 ?1AC941 ?1A1 ;1 A541339N= 45 D=1 ?95I1
C51CA1;5=;1@D51<>4>45K36A1B9BB5?A5C5=4L1A5;1C1A;>B8538>B
@D5812L1=414>;D71A1;21DC9B<>45;>B3D1CA>A5H5B;5E1=4>5B>B
8538>B1;131C57>AL145<9;17A>5:5<?;1AH1BDB?A>C17>=9BC1B1;145
5;5794>B459>B5;1DC>A45;3>;>@D9>>6A539ND=1=D5E1E5AB9N=45
;>B<9B<>B13>A453>=;19<175=45BD<9B9N=?>;LC931HA5;979>B1@D5
(;1G31;1 812L1 <>BCA14> 1=C5 ;1 >A>=1 5B?1M>;1 1 ;> ;1A7> 45 D=
B97;> ?5A> C1<29K= 3>= 5; 5B6D5AI> 45 D=1 ?1AC5 9<?>AC1=C5 45 ;1
7;5B91 =>E>89B?1=1 ?>A ;>7A1A ;1 497=9693139N= 45; 9=4L75=1 45=CA>
45;?1A1497<13D;CDA1;HA5;979>B>5DA>?5>

 
 

<1D?BB5>D?>9?W(95=@?I@?5CM1X,<*7E<2,*
 
  
<21?3851DB9J45W!5=?B91@?<MD93145<13?>AE9CD1I5F1>75<9J139O>45<1
"E5F1C@1N1X=*-.:67;2;8*67*5.:2,*67;
   
<F1HD<9<HO389D<5B>1>4?452;<7:2*-.4*6*,2H612,125.,*!14B941CD9>


B139<51DB9JW<8LB?5ICEC1<914?C5<@1@5<45<?CD<1H31<D531C5><1CB5<1
39?>5C3?BD5C91>1CX>&&&7479=27.:>*6<2676<.:6*,276*47;:.4*<7;-.4
6,=.6<:7 E@2,7 ;2047 &$ E1>1:E1D? 5>DB? 45 CDE49?C 5BF1>D9
>?CE>4139O> 5BF1>D9>1 45 !LH93?!EC5? 3?>?7BK693? 45< %E9
:?D5)>9F5BC941445E1>1:E1D?
   
V4<.*<:7.>*60.42B*-7:!7,2.-*-,=4<=:*.2-.7470F*.64*=.>*;8*G*-.4;2047&$
&?=1E<J?>9 




WE5B?>@14B9>?C45<?C3E1DB?C5N?B5C4?>5B>1>4??BDLC4?>$54B?
45<F1B14?5<31@9DK>>4BLC45(1@91I?>J1<?45'1>4?F1<IB9CDO21<45
#<94,93?DL>31<DC5<<1=O*935>D5!1H9H31DJ9> ?B5>J?(<58E5H?<?DJ9>?>
J1<?I9D<1<@?@?311BD?<?=LX(?BAE5=14176*:9=F*26-2*6*( 
36
!EN?J1=1B7?2;<7:2*-."4*@,*4*
 
 

 W/, 0 AE95B? @14B5 =M? C5B 5> FE5CDB1C =1>?C 3B9CD91>? /U0
!  <K=1C5 1BD?<?=L /U0    *?C F1<95>D5 31@9DK> RAEL
>?=2B5 AE5BL9C AE5 ?C 4L ! $14B5 =M? >? <? CL    $E5C
<<1=1?C3?=?I?E1>/U0!  <K=5C51AE5CD5?>J1<?/U0.
%E95B?3?>?35B1<9?C  $E5C<<1=1?C1<D1C1BX7479=27


FF  

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
   

1E=1>>&?<1>4WH@B5C9O>D<1H31<D531451ED?>?=M1I4B1=1B5<979?C?5>5<
C97<?,*X>4<.*<:7/:*6,2;,*67.64*=.>*;8*G*=.6<.;A.6;*A7;8*:*.4
.;<=-27 -.4 <.*<:7 -. .>*60.42B*,2H6 .6 .4 ;2047 &$ !1BM1 'D5> 54 !LH93?
)"!#"
  

<53E1?CL!1>E5<W<31>39?>5B?<<1=14?*:-F6-2>267X>75.6*3.;A7<:*;
4*+7:.;.1B17?J1>CD9DED?5B>1>4?5<1DO<93? 


B?D85BCD?>?B4?>I>11<<57?CW< 95>J?45(<1H31<1I5<!1>EC3B9D?45
<1C7?GE>D5B

X;<=-27;-.=4<=:*D1=*<4
   
*:<*;-.6-2*;
F?<CE141<1:1B14=E>4?F9N1 5FI549D?B 
1CD1N5411B<?CW ?C=1>EC3B9D?C@5B494?C45ED9LBB5J45 E>1X>":.;
82.B*;<.*<:*4.;-.4>2::.26*<7?CL&?:1C1B394E5N1CI?CLE1>BB?=54C
!LH93?)"!   /54?B979>1< .>2;<*.@2,*6*-.;<=-27;2;
<H:2,7; C5@?3D 
  0
1CD1N5411B<?CW(859BCD=5B931>$<1IX&5@B9>D546B?=*<1742,%7:4-
1>E1BI 

 
1CD5<<C&931B4?WSR5:1BL=9?>7?<@?B5CD5B9CD?5HDB1>:5B?T5<7479=27
-. 47; ,=*<:7 :.A.; -. "4*@,*4* I <1 DB1>C6?B=139O> 45 E> 5@9C?49? 4B1=KD93?
D?=14?45E>13?=549145 ?@545*571X>:*5*<=:02*A<.*<:*42-*--.4
!2047-.:74*8:.;.6,2*3.;=2<*?CL&1=O><3K>D1B1!5:914B91>1#>D9F5B?C
I1>>1JLCBI93??B4C!LH93?)25B?1=5B931>1
  
26,7,*:<*;-.44457A@57!.G7:.-:77A*-.76<:.:*;:B7+2;87$2::.AA
8:25.:69=2;2-7:-.4*=.>*;8*G*8:.,.-2-*;-.4*12;<7:2*-.;=>2-*;.0I6:2;
<H+*4=<2E::.B-.=6*A:*6,2;,7-.!7;*!14B94?CL$?BBP1(EB1>J1C 

9E414 &51< 6B1I >D?>9? 45 ":*<*-7 ,=:27;7 A -7,<7 -. 4*; 0:*6-.B*; -. 4* =.>*
;8*G* .4*,2H6 +:.>. A >.:-*-.:* -. *40=6*; ,7;*; -. 4*; 5=,1*; 9=. ;=,.-2.:76 *4
*-:./:*A476;776,..64*;8:7>26,2*;-.4*=.>*;8*G*;2.6-7,752;*:270.6.:*4
-.*9=.44*;8*:<.;
F?<C?C569>1%E9>D1>1I*M3D?B!1CD9<<?5BB5B1C54C
!LH93?)"!>CD9DED?45>F5CD97139?>5C9CDOB931C  
7479=27-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;-."4*@,*4*/7479=27-.4*6=.>*,76>.:;2H6A+*=<2;57-.47;
,=*<:7 I4<257; :.A.; -. "4*@,*4* .6 4* =.>* ;8*G*0 > ":.; 82.B*; <.*<:*4.; -.4
>2::.26*<7?CL&?:1C1B394E5N1CI?CLE1>BB?=54C!LH93?)"!
  

7479=27;A7,<:26*,:2;<2*6*,769=.47;-7,./:*24.;-.!*6:*6,2;,7.6>2*-7;87:.48*8*
-:2*67$A87:.4.58.:*-7:*:47;$,76>2:<2.:76*47;26-27;-.4*=.>*;8*G*
!97E5< 5O>$?BD9<<154!LH93?)"! 
M1J45<1CD9<<?5B>1<2;<7:2*>.:-*-.:*-.4*,769=2;<*-.4*=.>*;8*G* E9C
'K9>J45!54B1>?54!14B94$<1>5D1 

M1J I 45 #F1>4? <5=5>D9>1 W(<1H31<1 5> <1 L@931 I 5> <1 4B1=KD931 45 <1
3?<?>91X6*4.;-.46;<2<=<7-.6>.;<20*,276.;;<E<2,*;      
B?CD<C1539<91".*<:78:7/.;276*43.;=2<*-.4;2047&$?<5339O>(51DB?!5H9
31>?9CD?B91IB1=1DEB791F?<*!LH93?#") ( 

1B3M1 \C31B B=1>4? *8244* *+2.:<* -. 4* 8:E-2,* * 4* .;,.62/2,*,2H6 !LH93?
(&)"#") (
 
1B921I[>75<!1BM12;<7:2*-.4*42<.:*<=:*6D1=*<4!LH93?$?BBP1 


 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms


 
  
M  

92C?>81B<5CW'97>9693139O>45<189CD?B91D<1H31<D5315>5<C97<?,*X2;<7:2*
5.@2,*6* 12B9<:E>9?   
 
V"4*@,*4*.6.4;2047&$!LH93??295B>?45<CD14?45(<1H31<1  
B?F1C 1:: *M3D?B W?BDLC 3?>DB1 5< 45=?>9? 1<D5B9414 5> E>1 ?2B1 D51DB1<
>?F?89C@1>145<C97<?,*XC<=-.;:75*6.;-.:67 

   
ED9LBB5J45 E>1B9CDO21<.57:2*4-.4*5*<.:2*-.47;D60.4.;$2-*-.4:B7+2;87
76.-:77A*-.76<:.:*;*<:2*:,*-.4*;6-2*;'7<:*;,7;*;,=:27;*;(<1H31<1
 !1>EC3B9D?45<1?<5339O>5>1B?1B3M15>C?> 1D9>=5B931>
?<<53D9?>(85)?6(5H1C1DECD9>
1BB9C!1HW&53?>39<9139?>5C49C6B1J141CF?35C9>4M75>1C5><?C3?=95>J?C45<
4B1=1=9C9?>5B?6B1>39C31>?5>!LH93?X>4<.*<:7/:*6,2;,*67.64*=.>*
;8*G*

 
5BB5B1*1<45J E9C5B>1>4?W#B975>IC97>969314?45<5C3E4?45(<1H31<1X
7<.;<*;;<=-27;-.4=6-74D;2,7.2;<7:2*-.4:<.
    
75.6*3.*:2;<H+*474H66<20J.-*-.;.@2,*6*;8=+42,*-*;87:4*=6<*7475+26*
-. E@2,7 .6 .4 ,=*:<7 ,.6<.6*:27 -.4 .;,=+:252.6<7 -. 5E:2,* !LH93? #6939>1
(9@?7BK693145<1'53B5D1BM145?=5>D? 

1C1C1C6B1I1BD?<?=L4587470E<2,*12;<7:2*-.4*;6-2*;!14B94  
O@5J45O=1B1B1>39C3?2;<7:2*-.4*,769=2;<*-.E@2,7?B75EBBM1 1
3B?9H@BO<1B131CI13E38?

!1BDM>5J/1B13C0>4B51W 1C@9>DEB1C45<!1>EC3B9D?45<1C7?GX;<=-27;-.
=4<=:*D1=*<4
   

!1BDM>5J 1B13C >4B51 #6 07+2.:67 -. 26-27; "4*@,*4*    !LH93?
?<579?459CD?B9145(<1H31<1''

!1BDM>5J1B13C>4B51I1B<?C'5=@1DCC14?EB91>"4*@,*4*#6*12;<7:2*,75
8*:<2-*!2047&$!LH93?#") (  
!1BDM>5J'17B54?$1E<1I<25BD?M1JB1I1W<?B@EC8B9CD9"?F?89C@1>?
45 (51DB1<9J139O>45E>145BB?D15>DB5CB5@B5C5>D139?>5C3?<?>91<5CX
2<.:*<=:*A260JF;<2,*

  
!L>45J$<1>31BD5<6?>C?7.<*;67>712;8*67;:25.:;2047  !LH93?
)"!  
!5>L>45J$5<K5J5CPCW 13?=5491:5CEMD9315>5<C97<?,*X>*:*626/7;
;.0=6-76.;A.8F0767;-.4*,75.-2*-.4!2047-.:77>139?B5<<1>?3??B4>
D8B?@?C)>9F5BC941445"1F1BB1
   
!?D?<9>M1 6B1I (?B929? 45 5>1F5>D5 2;<7:2* -. 47; 26-27; -. =.>* ;8*G*
5?B75C1E4?D54!14B941CD1<91  
!EN?J1=1B7?957?2;<7:2*-."4*@,*4*<6B54?81F5B?54!LH93?>
>?F139O> 
V.;,:28,2H6-.4*,2=-*-A8:7>26,2*-."4*@,*4*4939O>613C9=9<1B45<!1>EC3B9D?45
<1C7?G&5>L3EN154!LH93?)"!  
"E>5C <9395 W'9>3B5D9C=? 697EB1C 1=297E1C D51DB? 45 5F1>75<9J139O> 5<
=E>4?3?<?>91<1=5B931>?5><1?2B17479=27-.47;,=*<:7:.A.;-."4*@,*4*X
707; 
  

 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms

   

#BD9J<25BD?W<45=?>9?M4?<?45<?<?AE9?45<1>E5F13?>F5BC9O>I21E
D9C=?45<?C3E1DB?P<D9=?CB5I5C45(<1H31<15><1"E5F1C@1N1X>2;
,=:;7;,76<:*4*;=8.:;<2,2H6A4*2-74*<:F*.6.4=.>7=6-7*1<5>391)>9F5BC9414
45*1<5>391




$1BD941B=1>4?W 1>1BB1D9F9414>?F?89C@1>15>4?C?2B1C4539B3E>CD1>391
C?2B5<15F1>75<9J139O>X>2D4707;,=4<=:*4.;.64*42<.:*<=:*2+.:7*5.:2,*6*,
<*; -.4 &&&& 760:.;7 -.4 6;<2<=<7 6<.:6*,276*4 -. 2<.:*<=:* +.:7*5.:2,*6*
?>35@39O>&5F5BD554!14B94*5B2E=
 


%E9>D1>15>9D?W1391E>21BB?AE9C=?89C@1>?1=5B931>?892B945J59>D5B
D5HDE1<94145>5<7479=27-.47;,=*<:7I4<257;:.A.;-."4*@,*4*X 75*6,.7<.;

 

 

.,7824*,2H6-.4*;.A.;-.47; .267;-.6-2*; F?<C!14B94E<DEB19C@K>931  
/4613C9=9<1B45<145!14B94E<9K>$1B545C  0
&5I>?<4C+9>CD?>W<45=?>9?I ?@545*5715>5<=1>EC3B9D?=5H931>?
7479=27-.4*6=.>*,76>.:;2H6A+*=<2;57-.47;,=*<:7I4<257;:.A.;-."4*@,*4*.64*
=.>*;8*G*X=*-.:67;5.:2,*67;    
  
&9F5B1#3D1F9?WE1DB?3?=5>D1B9?CC?2B55<7479=27-.4*6=.>*,76>.:;2H6A+*=
<2;57-.47;,=*<:7I4<257;:.A.;-."4*@,*4*.64*=.>*;8*G*X>=*<:7,2.6<7;
*G7;-.4N:<.6=.>7-.1*,.:,75.-2*;O-.78.-.$.0*,<*;;.4.,<*;-.4&$76
0:.;7-.4*;7,2*,2H66<.:6*,276*4-.".*<:7;8*G74A7>712;8*67-.47;!2047;-.
:75B=K>*571IL3D?B)BJK9J54C*1<<14?<94)45*1<<14?<94IE>
D1=95>D?45#<=54?
   
&?4BM7E5J!?N9>?>D?>9?I!1BM1B5I!1B9N?*<D4707-.47;5*6=;,:2<7;87E<2
,7;,*;<.44*67;.@2;<.6<.;.64*+2+427<.,*-."1.2;8*62,!7,2.<A7/5.:2,*;2047;&$
&$A&$"5G-?B;9C@1>93'?395DI?6=5B931  
&?:1C1B394E5N1C?CLW$BO<?7?1<?<?AE9?45<?C3E1DB?B5I5C45(<1H31<1X
>":.;82.B*;<.*<:*4.;-.4>2::.26*<7?CL&?:1C1B394E5N1CI?CLE1>BB?=
54C!LH93?)"!    
V4<.*<:7-.=.>*;8*G*.6.4;2047&$!LH93?=@455CPC[<F1B5J  
(B5H<5B&9381B4W"?C?DB?C@5>C1=?C5<<?C13DP1><53DEB1C3<5B931<5C45<D51DB?
=9C9?>5B?5><1"E5F1C@1N145<C97<?,*X>4<.*<:7/:*6,2;,*67.64*
=.>*;8*G*    
*571 ?@5 45 4 =.>7 =6-7 -.;,=+2.:<7 87: :2;<H+*4 74H6  5=1BD9>5< I
81B<5C!9>7E5D54C 9<<5$B5CC5C)>9F5BC9D19B5C45 9<<5 
*571 ?@54548.:.0:267.6;=8*<:2*!14B941CD1<91  
*5<1C3?'1<F14?BW<?<?AE9?45(<1H31<145957?!EN?J1=1B7?X;<=
-27;-.=4<=:*D1=*<4 
  

*5B4?>B14912B95<!1BM1WB1I!97E5<45E5F1B1#'<25BD?!1BM1
1BB5N?I5<C?>5D?S"?=5=E5F5=99?C@1B1AE5B5BD5TX:,12>7".74H02,7
:*6*-267
   
VW 1C@?5CM1C45<=1>EC3B9D?45B1I!97E5<45E5F1B1I5<C?>5D?S"?=5
=E5F5 =9 9?C @1B1 AE5B5BD5TX =.>* .>2;<* -. 247470F* 2;8D62,*  


    


 This content downloaded from


200.52.255.1 on Tue, 25 Jul 2023 23:42:09 +00:00
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms

You might also like