Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The information in this PDF file is subject to Business Monitor International’s full copyright
and entitlements as defined and protected by international law. The contents of the file are for the
sole use of the addressee. All content in this file is owned and operated by Business Monitor
International, and the copying or distribution of this file, internally or externally, is strictly prohibited
without the prior written permission and consent of Business Monitor International Ltd.
If you wish to distribute the file, please email the Subscriptions Department at
subs@businessmonitor.com, providing details of your subscription and the number of recipients
you wish to forward or distribute this information to.
DISCLAIMER
All information contained in this publication has been researched and compiled from sources believed to
be accurate and reliable at the time of publishing. However, in view of the natural scope for human and/or
mechanical error, either at source or during production, Business Monitor International accepts no liability
whatsoever for any loss or damage resulting from errors, inaccuracies or omissions affecting any part of
the publication. All information is provided without warranty, and Business Monitor International makes no
representation of warranty of any kind as to the accuracy or completeness of any information hereto
contained.
ISSN 1474-5615
Vol 5 Issue 7 July 2011
Kenya
XXXXXXX THIS
THIS MONTH’S
MONTH’S TOP
TOP STORIES
STORIES
Present Danger
BMI View: The prospect of the withdrawal of about 20,000 UN
peacekeeping troops from the Democratic Republic of Congo
signals an encouraging development in the conflict-torn country,
BMI View: We believe the 25-basis-point interest rate hike enacted in late but it also represents an increased risk of a return to violence.
March will be grossly inadequate to tame surging inflation. We therefore We anticipate a drawdown in the coming months in anticipation
expect at least 100 basis points of further hikes as well as more concerted for the upcoming elections.
page 5
action to defend the shilling against bouts of weakness.
The Central Bank of Kenya (CBK)’s in order to tame price growth and man- Tanzania: Economy To Navigate Rising
monetary policy committee (MPC) age inflation expectations. With this in Headwinds
unexpectedly raised the Central Bank mind, we now see a further 100bps of BMI View: While the outlook for the Tanzanian economy contin-
Rate (CBR) by 25 basis points (bps) to hikes at the very least over the course ues to look bright for the most part, uncertainty has risen slightly
6.00% on March 22. The decision sig- of 2011. The CBK is also likely to in recent months. Exports have been buoyed by elevated gold
nals an abrupt about-turn in monetary be less lax about shilling weakness prices and high demand for manufactured goods, while the latest
policy as it follows close on the heels of and we believe the authorities will data from the Bank of Tanzania indicate that domestic demand is
a 25bps cut as recently as late January. intervene more actively in the foreign also robust. However, rising inflation and a weakening currency
The action is a clear indication that the exchange market in a bid to curtail have raised questions about whether the economic momentum
central bank has shifted its focus away currency weakness, thereby containing can and will be maintained over the short-to-medium term.
from stimulating growth and towards the imported component of inflation. page 7
fighting spiralling inflation. The sudden
change in policy is a worrying signal Usual Suspects Driving Prices Sudan: Peace Process On Edge
that the CBK was slightly behind the The onset of monetary tightening page 6
curve when it enacted the cut in January was inevitable when viewed in the
and we believe it will have to act ag- context of March’s inflation reading
OIL
OIL MARKET
MARKET OUTLOOK
OUTLOOK
gressively over the remainder of 2011 ...continued on page 2
XXXXXX
Uganda
Investment Looking
Good, For Now
BMI View: Uganda is expected to experience strong headline real GDP
growth over the coming years, especially after oil begins flowing in 2012. Source: BMI
Over the medium term, we believe political turmoil will keep the country
Front-month Brent crude traded in choppy fashion in May and
below its full potential – particularly with regard to investment and tourism
we still expect a moderation in prices in H211. However, any
– while inflation will constrain consumption.
sell-off would not mirror 2008. The underlying strength of the
BMI expects Uganda’s real GDP tion, slated to begin in 2012. Over the global economy would still be sufficient to provide long-term
growth to increase to an annual aver- near term, Uganda’s growth will be support in the US$90.00-100.00/bbl area. Moreover, the ration-
age of 8.6% over the next five years, constrained by rising inflation, which ing of power supply in China could be a supportive dynamics in
from an average of 7.5% over the past has put pressure on consumers, and the coming months, as it could drive a surge in diesel imports.
decade. Much of this growth will be ongoing political unrest. As a result, we note upside risks to our forecast for an average
underpinned by the onset of oil produc- ...continued on page 4 of US$94.00/bbl in 2011 and US$99.00/bbl in 2012.
Kenya is facing a shortage of nurses and is on-month terms, the consumer price basket
considering hiring laboratory technicians rose 2.3% from February to March, up from
and pharmacists, according to Public Health 1.3% a month prior. The major drivers of
Minister Beth Mugo. She added that the the increase in inflation were predictably
health ministry has urged the Public Serv- transport which, up by 15.9% y-o-y, was
ice Commission to change the available pushed higher by higher global oil prices.
positions for nurses to other professionals Food prices also rose sharply in March, up
in the healthcare sector. The shortage of 15.1% y-o-y, as poor rains in parts of the
nurses has been attributed to an increase in country have negatively impacted domestic
the number of health facilities constructed food production. While monetary tightening
through the country’s Constituency Devel- will have little impact on these supply-side
opment Fund. drivers of inflation, in the monetary policy
Our short-term political risk rating is 65.4. statement released subsequent to the hike,
the MPC was anxious that ‘temporary
shocks
should not be allowed to persist and
ECONOMIC RISK
be factored into pricing structures’. With
Remittances From Abroad political crises ongoing in the Middle East
On The Up and North Africa and meteorologists pre-
The Central Bank of Kenya stated on May dicting below-average long rains in parts
16 that remittances sent by Kenyans liv- of the country, high food and oil prices are
ing abroad increased by 37% y-o-y to likely to persist. The MPC will therefore be
Source: BMI
US$71.6mn in March, owing to an improve- forced to continue hiking in a bid to anchor
ment in economies in Europe and the US. inflationary expectations. As for the Kenyan shilling, a recent
This was an increase from the US$60.8mn spate of weakness certainly contributed to
Policy Reversal, Lending Rates Unmoved
transferred in February. Remittances from Kenya – Benchmark Lending Rate, Headline Inflation &
the sharp rise in inflation. The central bank
North America accounted for approximately Commercial Bank Lending Rate admitted as much in its communiqué and it
53% of the total in March, while Kenyans ‘felt there was a need to stabilise expecta-
in Europe contributed 27%. Furthermore, tions in the foreign exchange market’. With
remittances rose to US$196.5mn in Q111, this in mind, we expect the authorities to
compared with US$143.8mn in Q110. more actively defend the currency against
Money sent home from Kenyans working further weakness through direct intervention
abroad is the country’s fourth largest foreign if needs be. This, in combination with gener-
exchange earner. ally tightening monetary conditions, should
Our short-term economic risk rating is 46.5. provide support to the shilling, which we see
heading towards resistance in the KES82.00/
US$ region in the first instance.
BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
Source: Central Bank of Kenya, National Bureau Of Statistics
The outlook for the equity market is less
Mombasa Refinery Cut Loose positive. We have been warning of the risks
In The Summer The longevity of the CBK’s dovishness posed by rising inflation for some time. We
Kenya has announced that the troubled in the face of rising inflation was driven to believe that inflation has now reached the
Mombasa refinery will stop refining crude on a large extent by the authorities’ desire to point where price growth poses real risks to
behalf of fuels retailers as of July 2011. The lower borrowing rates. The CBK has consist- companies’ earnings as input costs rise and
move will allow retailers to source fuel from ently stated that commercial bank lending consumers’ purchasing power falls. Further-
international markets, improving the supply rates were too high and that this was putting more, the aggressive monetary policy that
of refined products. By opening up the plant bank finance out of the reach for the majority will be needed to try to rein in inflation will
to competition, the Kenyan government has of consumers and businesses. As the chart raise the cost of finance for companies that
implicitly admitted that it is willing to allow above shows, lending rates have been largely rely on bank financing. Foreign investors
the plant to fail, despite holding a stake in unresponsive to CBR cuts. It seems the CBK are also likely to be increasingly concerned
the refinery’s operator, Kenya Petroleum was left with little choice but to accept defeat about Kenya’s macroeconomic stability.
Refineries Ltd. The Mombasa refinery has on this front and turn its attention squarely While certain companies with little debt
a capacity of about 80,000 barrels per day. on price growth. and the ability to pass rising input costs to
Our business environment rating is 39.2. customers might fare better, we believe the
Market Implications broad direction of the Nairobi Stock Ex-
As we have argued previously, the direction change-20 Index will continue to be down.
BMI View: Although we are optimistic Headline price growth spiked sharply in April higher more quickly than we had anticipated.
about Kenyan economic prospects over the to 12.1% y-o-y, up from 5.4% in January. Al- With this in mind, we have downwardly
coming years, we are aware that significant though we have long espoused the view that revised our 2011 real GDP growth forecast
risks exist. The most obvious macroeco- inflation would rise over the course of 2011, to 5.2% from 6.0% previously. Our 2012
nomic concern centres around inflation. the April reading suggests prices are heading growth forecast remains at 6.3%.
Rising Headwinds
Donor Dependence Down
The Tanzanian government is aiming to
reduce its dependence on donors to 10%
BMI View: While the outlook for the Tanzanian economy continues to look bright from the current 25% by 2015, according to
for the most part, uncertainty has risen slightly in recent months. Exports have been Philemon Luhanjo, public service head and
buoyed by elevated gold prices and high demand for manufactured goods, while the chief secretary to the cabinet. This will be
latest data from the Bank of Tanzania indicate that domestic demand is also robust. achieved by augmenting domestic revenue,
However, rising inflation and a weakening currency have raised questions about whether battling corruption and tightening public
the economic momentum can and will be maintained over the short-to-medium term. spending. Luhanjo stated that reports of the
Controller and Auditor General exposed
The latest data from the Bank of Tanzania caution that there remain several concerns serious weaknesses in the management of
show that the economy is growing at a relating to the economy. Most pertinently, human, financial and government resources.
healthy clip. Exports grew by 35.5% in inflation came in at 8.6% y-o-y in April, The government will also aim to provide a
nominal terms in the 12 months to Febru- having more than doubled since bottoming conducive environment to attract foreign
ary compared with the same period a year at 4.2% in October 2010. Although the rate investment, particularly in agro-processing
earlier. This was thanks in large part to of price growth has not spiked as sharply as and extractive industries.
record-high gold prices (gold is Tanzania’s in Kenya and Uganda, the authorities are Our short-term political risk rating is 66.7.
biggest foreign currency earner), rising clearly concerned and banned food exports
demand for manufactured goods from Tan- for three months in a bid to reduce food price ECONOMIC RISK
zania’s neighbours as well as increases in inflation (food is the biggest component of
tourist numbers and revenues. In addition the consumer price basket, making up 48%). Balance Of Payments Surplus
to a healthy external sector picture, the data In addition to food, the early 2011 spike Tanzania’s central bank has reported a
indicate that the domestic economy is also in oil prices has been another contributing US$191.5mn balance of payments surplus in
in a solid state. Indeed, the three-month factor to increasing price growth. Rising oil Q111, compared with a US$486mn surplus
moving average of the rate of credit growth prices have had a detrimental effect on the in Q110. Meanwhile, the current account
has headed steadily higher since bottoming country’s terms of trade and this has seen the deficit widened to US$2.32bn in the first
in February 2010. currency head to historic lows, exacerbating quarter from US$2.26bn in the year-ago
Despite these positive indicators, we price pressures via imported inflation. period. The increase came on the back
of higher oil prices, which resulted in an
DATA & FORECASTS inflated import bill. However, gold brought
in US$1.7bn in revenues in Q111, up from
BMI View: Higher prices for oil, which is the country’s largest single import, will more than offset
US$1.4bn a year earlier, while manufactured
the benefit of elevated prices for its biggest foreign currency earner: gold. Continued surpluses in
goods – including cement and textiles – gen-
the services and current transfers accounts will be insufficient to offset this growing trade account
erated US$1.0bn in earnings compared with
shortfall and we therefore see the overall current account deficit growing to US$3.2bn (12.6%
US$524.4mn in Q110. National debt rose
of GDP) in 2011, up from an estimated US$2.4bn (10.2% of GDP) in 2010.
1.1% y-o-y to US$11.34bn in Q111.
Our short-term economic risk rating is 56.7.
2008 2009 2010e 2011f 2012f
Population, mn [4] 42.5 43.8 45.0 46.4 47.8 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
Nominal GDP, US$bn [5] 21.2 22.6 23.7 25.9 29.7
GDP per capita, US$ [6] 499 523 525 559 621 Mobile Pressures
Real GDP growth, % change y-o-y [5] 7.4 6.0 6.4 6.5 6.6
Unemployment, % of labour force, eop [1,7] 4.1 5.0 5.5 5.3 5.1 Tanzania’s mobile operators may have to
Budget balance, % of GDP [2,9] 2.4 -2.2 -4.7 -4.9 -5.3 increase prices if fuel costs continue to rise,
Consumer prices, % y-o-y, eop [7] 13.5 12.2 3.8 7.5 7.0 according to Zantel ‘s chief commercial op-
Lending rate, %, eop [11] 14.1 11.0 9.2 8.6 8.0
Real lending rate, %, eop [3,12] 0.6 -1.2 5.4 1.0 1.0 erator, Norman Moyo. He said the Tanzanian
Exchange rate TZS/US$, eop [13] 1,310.00 1,330.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 1,500.00 shilling’s weakness was also playing a role,
Exchange rate TZS/EUR, eop [13] 1,834.00 1,689.10 2,006.55 2,145.00 2,010.00
Goods exports, US$bn [5] 2.7 3.1 3.6 4.0 4.2
putting pressure on operators, which are
Goods imports, US$bn [5] 6.5 5.8 7.0 8.2 9.1 already feeling the squeeze from the mar-
Balance of trade in goods, US$bn [5] -3.8 -2.7 -3.5 -4.1 -4.9 ket’s ongoing price war. Raising prices will be
Current account, % of GDP [6] -13.6 -7.7 -10.2 -12.6 -13.0
Foreign reserves ex gold, US$bn [14] 2.9 3.5 3.4 3.6 3.9 unpopular with subscribers, but BMI is also
Import cover, months g&s [15] 4.2 5.7 4.6 4.3 4.3 concerned that operators facing shrinking
Total external debt stock, % of GDP [17] 28.0 24.2 24.1 24.5 25.1 margins will find their funds for investing in
Short term foreign debt, % of total [17] 13.5 13.7 14.0 15.0 14.1
new technologies and infrastructure under
Notes: e/f = BMI estimates/forecasts. 1 Surveys conducted in 1990/91, 2000/01 and 2006; 2 Fiscal year (x-1)/(x), so 2008
figure is for FY2007/08. Includes grants; 3 Real rate strips out the effects of inflation; Sources: 4 World Bank/BMI calculation/ even greater pressure.
BMI; 5 Bank of Tanzania; 6 Bank of Tanzania/BMI; 7 Tanzania Bureau of Statistics; 8 Bank of Tanzania, Tanzania Ministry of Our business environment rating is 33.5.
Finance; 9 Bank of Tanzania, Tanzania Ministry of Finance, BMI; 10 Tanzania Bureau of Statistics/BMI; 11 IMF; 12 IMF/BMI;
13 BMI; 14 IMF IFS; 15 IMF IFS/BMI; 16 World Bank; 17 World Bank/BMI.
Economic outlook
has dimmed a little, although we remain suffering, widening current account deficits. CentAm
LatAm
US 6
broadly sanguine. We still see the external East Africa has been hard hit, since high
environment as relatively supportive, with oil import costs have been compounded by 4
BMI’s forecasts for 2011 economic growth weak harvests, necessitating elevated food 2
in the US and eurozone standing at 2.9% imports at a time when grain prices have
0
and 1.8% respectively. Furthermore, com- been lofty. The impact is illustrated in the
modity prices look set to remain high, even latest inflation numbers: in Kenya, inflation -2
factoring in an anticipated moderation in the has risen to 12.1% y-o-y in April from 5.4% -4
second half of the year. However, the ongo- in January; while in Uganda the prints were
2009f
2010f
2011f
2012f
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008e
ing increase in inflation across much of SSA 14.1% and 5.0% respectively. In Tanzania,
Source: African Central Banks & Statistics Bureaux
poses tangible risks to the growth trajectory. the price pressures have not been quite so
There have been several wild cards acute, but inflation has still risen notably to Although all these pressures will un-
for the global economy over the past few 8.6% in April from 6.4% in January. doubtedly put policymakers to the test, we
months, with varying implications for SSA. This faster-than-anticipated rise in infla- hold a sanguine view. Inflation should mod-
tion, in combination with a number of other erate if oil and food price pressures abate
Key Changes
SSA – 2011 Real GDP Growth Forecasts, %
factors, has prompted us to downwardly over the second half of the year. Moreover,
revise our real GDP growth forecasts for investor interest is likely to hot up as it be-
Kenya and Uganda. As shown in the chart comes increasingly clear that SSA will not
(left), we have lowered Kenya’s 2011 fore- suffer from a MENA-style meltdown.
cast to 5.2% from 6.0%. We see the economy We are above-consensus on Ghana,
suffering from high inflation, poor rains and Nigeria and Zambia, forecasting 2011 real
elevated oil prices. The ongoing tighten- GDP growth of 14.0%, 7.8% and 7.5%
ing of monetary policy could also dampen respectively. These countries’ strong,
economic activity if banks start to raise commodity-led growth is expected to be
borrowing costs for individuals and busi- sustained over the medium term. In Ghana’s
nesses. In Uganda’s case, we have revised case, we see double-digit growth spurred by
our 2011 real GDP growth forecast to 6.8% the onset of domestic oil production, with
Source: BMI
from 7.3%. This adjustment was in part the our bullishness reinforced by the strong eco-
The Tohoku earthquake that struck Japan in result of high inflation and the lacklustre lo- nomic expansion seen in 2010. For Nigeria,
March was devastating for parts of Asia, but cal harvest. However, we have also factored we envisage robust growth fuelled by strong
the implications for Africa are fairly mar- in an expected decline in foreign investment oil production, a recovering banking sector
ginal, as Japan is not a key export market. and tourism owing to political concerns – and rising investment inflows propelled by
More pertinently, the political crisis across Uganda’s reputation for stability is under an improved political risk environment in
the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) threat following recent demonstrations and the aftermath of elections. Finally, Zambia
has had a tangible, two-fold impact. Firstly, attacks on opposition leaders. remains a favoured market owing to buoyant
institutional investor interest has been Looking ahead, we believe the coming copper production, a recent bountiful harvest
dampened amid fears that the unrest could months will be a difficult period for African and a fast-improving business environment.