Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original Article
Lived Experiences of Elderly Patients with Coronary Artery Disease: A
Hermeneutic Phenomenological Study
ABSTRACT
Article history
Received 5 March 2017 Introduction: Coronary artery disease is the most common type of cardiovascular disease.
Accepted 13 May 2017 Despite the increasing number of patients with coronary artery disease, the lived
experiences of these patients have remained unknown. The purpose of the study was to
understand the lived experiences of elderly patients with coronary artery disease.
Results: The main theme of study was "living with ups and downs". It included sub-themes
of 1) losing calmness,2) trying to achieve calmness through spirituality, 3) losing health, 4)
trying to promote health through modification of lifestyle, 5) perceiving family support, 6)
living in fear, 7) living with a damaged heart".
Conclusion: Findings of the research indicated that the coronary artery disease led patients
to experience ups and downs for the participations. After the disease, they were trying to
achieve calmness through some strategies. Members of the treatment team, especially
nurses should provide self-care education for to make them be have successfully in this
field.
Citation: Heravi-Karimooi M, Rejeh N, Abbasi M. Lived experiences of elderly patients with coronary artery disease:
a hermeneutic phenomenological study. Elderly Health Journal. 2017; 3(1): 28-34.
Introduction
Cardiovascular diseases are the most prevalent report several experiences after the onset of disease as
serious disease and the most problem of health which well as different signs and symptoms of angina (5, 6).
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.24236179.2017.3.1.5.2 ]
threatens human life in the world (1). These diseases Elderly people experience fear, feeling of insecurity,
are the most common causes of death in the developed as well as lack of confidence in the present and future
and developing countries and the numbers of suffering after myocardial infarction (7).
people from them are increasing (2). Based on the Fear of death during sleep and fear of pain during
available reports, cardiovascular diseases are walking have affected various aspects of their lives (3,
subjective to the most common cause of death in Iran 8, 9). Through a review on researches conducted in
(3). Coronary artery disease is the most common type Iran, it was concluded that less quantitative researches
of the cardiovascular disease which has made the have been conducted in Iran about experience of
following coronary artery atherosclerosis (1, 4). living with coronary artery disease. Furthermore, the
Suffering from the coronary artery disease causes conducted studies evaluated a few aspects of living
notable changes in all aspects of patients' lives. They
*
Corresponding Author: Department of Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Qom University of Medical Sciences, Qom,
Iran. Tel: +982537835588, Email address: mohamad_abbasi55@yahoo.com
Heravi-Karimooi et al.
with coronary artery diseases mostly rate of outbreak The first step: Turning to the nature of lived
and risk factors for cardiovascular diseases (10). experience
Despite previous study in Iran (11) these
Van Manen expresses that the first step in studying
experiences have not yet been examined deeply and
a phenomenon is the researcher’s interest in nature of
enough cognition is not available in this field.
that research. The researcher’s attention was drawn to
Therefore, it seems necessary to conduct a qualitative
the phenomenon of the lived experiences of elderly
research to explain experiences of elderly patients
patients with coronary artery disease since he was
with coronary artery disease deeply.
working in CCU of a hospital in Tehran.
Cognition of these patients' experiences leads to
creation of a unique knowledge in this field and
The second step: Investigating experience as we live it
provides some information for members of the
treatment team especially nurses about training, Patients who referred to Shahid Beheshti Hospital
caring, and consulting this type of patients. The in Qom city, Iran in 2016, underwent a purposive
purpose of the study was to explore the lived selection of participants with maximum variation
experiences of elderly patients with coronary artery sampling; nine men and four women. The inclusion
disease. criteria were willingness to participate in the
research,talk about their lived experiences and age 65
years or older; and people with severe spiritual-
Methods
psychological problems and physical diseases were
The qualitative study was performed using a excluded. Demographic characteristics of the study
hermeneutic phenomenological approach, a most participants are shown in Table 1.
commonly method for understanding meaning of lived Deep semi-structured face to face interviews were
experience. Van Manen believed that knowledge and carried out individually to collect data conducted in 55
understanding come through analyzing the reflective to 80 minutes sessions in coronary care unit and heart
descriptions of people with relevant experience.Van unit of Shahid Beheshti Hospital of Qom. Interviews
Manen's proposed six steps were used to conduct this started with a general question about cardiovascular
study (12). In Van Manen’s opinion hermeneutic disease. The researcher let the participants to say their
phenomenology, a combination of description and real experiences about coronary artery disease through
interpretation, expresses that description and his silence. In the case of needing more perception
interpretation are not separated from each other. It and explanation, the researcher used follow-up
should be noted that Van Manen's six steps are as a questions such as “would you please explain more
[ Downloaded from ehj.ssu.ac.ir on 2022-09-09 ]
guidance to conduct the research and there is no about the issue” or “what was your purpose about the
obligation to observe the order in the steps. Each part which you said”. Interviews were continued until
activity is explained in the following. data saturation was achieved, in the study after eleven
interviews, the interviews ended when no new data
was resulted.
The fifth step: Maintaining a strong and oriented expression, they had suffered from worry, and
nursing relation to the Phenomenon anxiety, thought seriously about importance of heart
in life and the fact that if the heart has problem, their
This stage is for maintenance of a strong and
lives might be in danger. They had lost their calmness
directional communication with the considered
by reviewing their heart task and further probabilities
phenomenon. In this stage, in order to avoid getting
such as cardiac arrest and myocardial infarction.
away from the purpose of study, the researcher
considered the main research question to maintain the About this issue a participant said : "man's life
strong and directional communication with the depends on heart; if a problem is made, the whole life
phenomenon. is endangered, one of our neighborhoods had heart
problem for years, the poor man had no relaxation, I
The sixth step: Balancing the research context by am really not calm now”. Another participant said:
considering parts and whole “Those early days when I was told that I have a heart
Van Mannen is making a balance in the field of problem and should be hospitalized, I didn’t believe it
linking whole and detail. He worked on this stage by at all. I didn’t have any problem. I was confused and
continues review of whole and detail through holistic believed that my life was ruined”.
and selective approaches and according to the main
research question. 2. Trying to Achieve Calmness through Spirituality
According to Lincoln and Guba, the authors Following to become aware about the critical situation
verified the accuracy of the data with the four criteria after the diagnosis of cardiovascular disease and
of validity, reliability, credibility, and transferability. discharge from hospital, the participants had
An effective communication was made with the concluded that they should keep calm to continue life.
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.24236179.2017.3.1.5.2 ]
participants based on trust to guarantee the validity of They utilized many strategies to keep calm. Many of
study (12). In order to increase the reliability of the them had resorted to spirituality and tendency to
data and create a deeper understanding of the religious practices to keep calm.
phenomenon, the authors used prolonged exposure to About this issue a patient said: “After it became clear
the subject and obtained data, reviewing the data and that I have heart disease I was trying to have night
matching them with the experiences of the prayer, I woke up and spoke to God for one or two
participants and the observers’ comments. To confirm hours. I was calming myself down with this plan.
the data, texts of the interviews were given to patients Through this I was keeping my morale high. I could
after analysis. Also, the research process was remove my anxious by reading Quran and saying
evaluated step by step through participation of the
prayer”.
research team as well as other experts.
About this issue another patient said: “After I was go mountains once a week for one or two hours ,but
discharged, I told O Lord! You created us, our deaths this was not enough for a person who is sitting all the
and lives are in your hands, ”I just put my trust in time, should deal with customers, becomes angry
God. regularly, and needs to work hard”
A patient said about his prayers after heart disease: Another patient said: “After diagnosis of the disease, I
“I was only thinking of God, I prayed, I had confided decided to have activity and do exercise, I shouldn’t
myself to God and thanked God”. sit in a place like old men, the situation was difficult”
Another participant mentioned his daily exercises and
3. Losing Health said: “After my heart disease, I exercised every day I
Many of participants said they have not paid much woke up at 5a.m., went to park and exercised.”
attention to their health status before diagnosis of the Another patient emphasized the necessity to take care
disease and before appearance of the signs and of heart and said: “After the disease, heart needs care
symptoms of cardiovascular diseases. They had never and the suitable care is to avoid consuming salt, fat,
thought that they might have cardiovascular problems. and sweets according to physicians' orders. Doctors
Having had disclosure of the disease, they felt that gave us an instruction which we should observe, such
they had lost their health and each moment were as not eating salt, fat, and red meet. I observed these
waiting for its aftermath. The patients mentioned the cases”.
importance of heart and considered its health as health
of the body. One of the patients said: “with this heart 5. Perceiving Family Support
disease I know I have lost my health, each moment my
Participants mentioned that they perceived family
heart may become more clogged and have worse
support more than before. They considered that family
status. If man’s heart is clogged he will suffer from
support from the patient is important and emphasized
lesion”.
that this patient's life depends on support of family. In
In many participants' opinion, heart is the most
this regard a participant said: “family support from a
sensitive organ of a body and needs high care and
patient with heart disease is very important. If the
attention, but many of them didn’t pay attention to the
family doesn't support the patient, he/ she become
issue before suffering from heart disease at all.
[ Downloaded from ehj.ssu.ac.ir on 2022-09-09 ]
disease my heart was damaged; now I’m living with a remembering power of God in all affairs oflife and by
damaged heart.” resorting to Quran and Imams. They were always
Another participant said about his heart status after mentioning the holy verse of “Remembrance of God
the disease: "If a human’s heart is damaged what is certainly brings comfort to all hearts” “Verily hearts
left for him/her to live further? I didn’t care about become calm with rememberance of God”. Using
myself and damaged my heart.” spirituality in addition to compatibility with problems
had effects on recovery process. In many studies the
relation of spirituality, physical and psycholoigical-
spiritual health,as well ascompatibility with disease
Discussion has been mentioned (5, 14, 17).
After experiencing coronary artery
Findings of the research showed that the lived disease,patientsconcluded that they have lost their
experiences of elderly patients with coronary artery health and had totry to achieve it. All their efforts
disease were with “ups and downs” with sub-themes were in order to reach health again and even promote
of “losing the calmness, trying to achieve calmness itthroughsome startegies. They had decided to modify
through spirituality, losing health, trying to promote their lives to poromote their health. They were
health through modification of lifestyle, perceiving utilizing some startegis such as managing stress,
family support, living in fear and living with a regular exercising, modifying working hours, and
damaged heart”. Living with coronary artery disease changingfood diet. After a heart event, patients had no
was with ups and downs for participants of the study. other wayto modify lifestyle.
They were frequently comparing living with coronary Afrasiabi far et al., wrote: "elderly people had used
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.24236179.2017.3.1.5.2 ]
artery disease to their normal status. Suffering from some approaches to reduce consequences of the
the disease had divested patients from calmness and disease and return to previous life after heart attack
confidence; they were expressing some concerns despite tensions and limitations. They believed
about future by imagining probability of having heart returning to normal life requires maintenance of
problems in future such as heart attack and cardiac abilities despite the existing limitations. For this
arrest was with fear and stress. Many studies had purpose, patients had considered self-reliance and
mentioned heart disease as a stressful and anxious self-care as their strategies (20).
event (5). Symptoms of cardiovascular diseases are Patients said after suffering from coronary artery
with anxiety, depression, and fear of physical disease, they had well been supported by family. They
disability; this factor causes losing calmness of the were aware of the critical role or family support and
person by sudden and unexpected start. thought that continuing their lives with the disease
mostly depends on family support. Some experts They were supported by family along with their claim
described family support as the level of having of high positive effects of family members on heart
affection, companionship, care, respect, attention, and disease. Their lives was with fear, anxiety, worry, and
received help by other people, groups, friends, and feeling of hopeless. They imagined that their hearts
others. Patients also mentioned that they received are damaged and should continue their lives with
affection, companionship, support, and damaged heart. All findings of this study emphasized
encouragements from their families. on necessity of training patients and their family
Attention of family to patient is one of the most members. Also, findings of the research can be used
essential kind of care, according to Iranian culture, in care, training, and managing fields. Therefore,
since families have deep relationships with members. professors and trainers of nursing, nurses working in
Many reports are available about effects of families clinic and society, nursing mangers, patients 'planners
'supports on patients. Supporting patients prevents and families can use findings of the research to
from the outbreak of physiological effects of disease, promote patients 'training, consulting, quality of care
increases self-care, and has a positive effect on and support from patients more and more.
physical and social statuses of patients. Also, family It is suggested to conduct a study in the field of
support increases patient's performance (5, 21,22). strategies of achieving calmness and effects of
For patients, living with coronary artery disease religious consultations on promoting calmness and
was always accompanied by fear, anxiety, worry so giving confidence to patients’ lives suffering from
that all participants had experienced fear after coronary artery disease.
disclosure of the disease. They were always afraid of
heart attack, cardiac arrest, and sudden death. The
prevalence of worry and fear of heart attack were so Study limitations
high in some patients that they felt them even in sleep.
The negative feelings of anxiety and fear caused Some limitations of qualitative studies are small
disturbance of their sleeps. Afrasiabi Far et al., sample size and the inability to generalize the results.
expressed experience of patients’ lives after heart The forgetfulness of some elderly participants about
attack as “in shadow of fear". Theme of life in shadow their experiences can be considered as another
of fear had sub-classes of death fear by having another limitation of this research.
heart attack, fear of physical disability, and fear of
becoming dependent to others. Fear of cardiac arrest
and sudden death is one of psychological responses of
[ Downloaded from ehj.ssu.ac.ir on 2022-09-09 ]
Medicine. 2002; 47(6): 408-26. 22. Lisa W, Amanda T, Ma'en Aq, Amanda Ch. The
11. Moeini M, Naseri N, Zargham-Boroujeni A. role of the family in supporting the
Lived experiences of women with ischemic self‐management of chronic conditions: A
heart disease. Iranian Journal of Nursing and qualitative systematic review. Journal of Clinical
Midwifery Research. 2012; 17(2):137-42. Nursing. 2017: 1-9.
12. Van Manen M, editor. Writing in the dark: 23. Fors A, Dudas K, Ekman I. Life is lived
Phenomenological studies in interpretive forwards and understood backwards–
inquiry. Left Coast Press; 2003. experiences of being affected by acute coronary
13. Taheri ZS, Zandi MA, Ebadi A. The effect of syndrome: a narrative analysis. International
spiritual care based on Ghalbe Salim Model on Journal of Nursing Studies. 2014; 51(3): 430-7.
the sleep quality of the patients with coronary 24. Xavier D, Gupta R, Kamath D, Sigamani A,
artery disease. Iranian Journal of Critical Care Devereaux P, George N, et al. Community
Nursing. 2014; 7(2): 92-101. health worker-based intervention for adherence
14. Zamanzadeh V, Rassouli M, Abbaszadeh A, to drugs and lifestyle change after acute
Nikanfar A-R, Alavi-Majd H, Mirza-Ahmadi F, coronary syndrome: a multicentre, open,
et al. Spirituality in cancer care: a qualitative randomised controlled trial. The Lancet Diabetes
study. Journal of Qualitative Research in Health & Endocrinology. 2016; 4(3): 244-53.
Sciences. 2014; 2(4): 366-78. 25. Hildingh C, Fridlund B, Lidell E. Access to the
15. Akhbardeh M. Role of spiritual beliefs and world after myocardial infarction: experiences of
prayer in health promotion of chronic patients: a the recovery process. Rehabilitation Nursing.
qualitative study. Quran and Medicine. 2011; 2006; 31(2): 63-8.
[ DOR: 20.1001.1.24236179.2017.3.1.5.2 ]
1(1): 5-9.
16. Abbasi M, Tasooji HR, Hasan M, Ahmari
Tehran H, Sadeghi T, Dehghani F, et al.