Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Amar
Who is the ideal literature teacher? The checklist below can help you assess your personal
and professional qualities expected or desired of the ideal literature teacher. Using a five-
point scale, tick the column which best fits or approximates such trait. The legend at the end
of the checklist
Assessment:
An ideal teacher usually possesses these characteristics: he has unassailable command on his
subjects. He knows fully the contents of the subjects which he has to teach. Truly exceptional
An ideal teacher has a good sense of humour/smiles. But this fun is not of impolite nature. An
ideal teacher has the highest degree of integrity. An ideal teacher is susceptible to adaptation
or modification.
Being flexible means that if students are not interested in learning a new or even a new good
lesson due to some reasons, then he is not recalcitrant regarding straightway teaching of the
lesson. Rather he talks about problems that have arisen in the classroom and eventually gets
back to the lesson.
An ideal teacher is concise and clear in both oral and written expression in the classroom. An
ideal teacher is patient. Being patient is often expressed as being diligent or persevering.
Learners are genius, gifted, mentally retarded, dyslexic, emotionally disturbed and some
patience is required for employing carefully individual teaching - learning technique for
individual learner. Only in this way, bits of progress can be observed day to day.
An ideal teacher is open. This trait is related with willingness of the teacher to share
happiness about his own life to illustrate a point or share how they feel about a given
situation. An ideal teacher is diversified with regard to his preparation. This means that the
teacher not only focuses on specific areas but has considerable command on the related
subjects. This diversification trait will enable him to elaborate and illustrate the subjects in
more persuasive manner.
The ideal teacher is an excellent role model. Being a good role model to all the children,
teacher whatsoever teaches is one of the greatest contributions he can make to society.
An ideal teacher is capable of relating theory with practice. In textbooks, there are
suggestions for doing things individually or as a group to enhance interest and motivation in
teaching. Learners can display these activities, if their teacher is capable of interrelating the
theory in practice.
An ideal teacher has good personal hygiene and is well groomed. He is always neat, clean,
and wears type of clothing that is acceptable in the school building in which he teaches.
Qualities of Literature Teacher Must Adopt.First and foremost, I should say, he must be a
lover of literature. The initial objection here may be that not everyone can love literature. This
I should immediately acknowledge, just as I would admit that not everyone can love cats,
accounting, or the binomial theorem; but that is just another way of saying that not everyone
should be given the privilege of teaching literature, and to me it is a great privilege. Within
limits, love of literature can be taught; at least students can be encouraged to develop it. Love
of literature usually grows from ex- perience with literature, from understanding, and from
what we rather vaguely call appreciation. This is not easy to teach. Teaching students the
names of Shakespeare’s plays and the birth and death dates of the author is much easier for
both the teacher and the taught than teaching the subtlety and pervading tragedy of Hamlet
True love of literature, like true love of anything, can be taught only indirectly.
The direct approach, “Isn’t it beautiful?” is not more likely to inculcate love of literature than
the commensurate question, **Why don’t you be good?” is likely to instil moral virtue.
Fortunately, love of art and language is infectious. It can be taught, to those who are
teachable, if we keep firmly before us the conviction that we are teaching the love of
literature, not the secondary facts about literature. For example, if we are endeavoring to
teach love of liteiature, very wide reading in literature is likely to do more good than any
amount of reading about literature. Second, I should say that a good teacher of literature
must be able to read. Here I am thinking of several sorts of reading. Presumably a teacher of
literature should be able to read rapidly in order to read widely, but, even more important, he
must be able to read accurately, with perception and penetration. Many pro- fessed teachers
of literature cannot read at all in this sense; they cannot penetrate to what an adult writer is
saying overtly, not to mention sensing what a poet endeavors to reveal.
A teacher of literature should be able to read orally, and the younger the students the more
important oral reading is. Most students at any level can sense literature only if it is read well
to them, and this is true particularly of poetry and drama; but it is also true, although to a
lesser degree, of truly great passages of prose, either fiction or nonfiction. Of course a
teacher can get some help here; we now have many records of modern poets reading their
own ,works and of skilled interpreters reading the classics. We can scarcely expect that all
English teachers will be able to read Chaucer with ease and comfort, but if they cannot they
had best play records. Chaucer wrote mellif- luous poetry, and to read him as though he was
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
3
a labor, even a labor of love, is scarcely a service to anyone. Teachers can profit from better
readers than they and from readers who have special qualifications for certain sorts of
reading, the reading of plays for example through a number of voices, but all the audio de-
vices in the world will not make a good teacher of literature.
The good teacher of literature should have had experience with his subject as a creator. That
is, he should have tried to write, and the more different sorts of writing re has tried the
better. I am not here saying that a good teacher of literature must be a good novelist or poet
or playwright. No doubt that would help, but there are many good teachers who could never
be good practicing literary artists and many good writers who would be bad teachers. But to
under- stand the written word the teacher must understand writing, and to understand
writing he must have faced blank paper and have wrestled with it. Pretty ob- viously, having
children helps women to become good mothers, and every teacher knows that no number of
courses in pedagogy can entirely replace classroom experience. To know writing one must try
to write, however bad the result; every teacher of literature needs it for his own well-rounded
approach to his job.
He needs it, also, because students should attempt creative writing, however mept the
products, and at a minimum a teacher should have seriously tried what he endeavors to
teach. A good teacher of literature has other skills and virtues, but partly in the interests of
space I shall mention only the most important of these, and relatively lightly. A good teacher
should be able to explicate; he should be literate enough so that he can help students
formulate their own thoughts by joining the students in the process of clarifying emergent
ideas. Thus training in the principles and practice of criticism is important for teachers of
literature, particularly if, in learning to explicate, the teacher learns to restrain his practice of
it.
READING AND WRITING, THE BASIC PRINCIPLES INVOLVED IN THE STUDY OF ENGLISH,
SERVE AS THE GATEWAY TO A DEEPER LEVEL OF THOUGHT. AFTER MASTERING THESE
ELEMENTARY SKILLS, COMPREHENSION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION ARE LEARNED
AND USED TO BETTER EDUCATE ONES SELF. STUDYING LITERATURE AND OBSERVING
PERSONAL REACTIONS TO THE LITERATURE CAN MAKE ONE MORE AWARE OF HIS OR HER
OWN VALUES. ENGLISH SKILLS ARE HELPFUL IN EVERY AREA OF LIFE. READING, WRITING,
COMPREHENSION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION INCREASE EFFICIENCY IN MULTIPLE
WAYS INCLUDING COMMUNICATION, DOCUMENTATION IN OTHER AREAS OF STUDY, AND
REFLECTION OF PERSONAL VALUES. I BELIEVE THERE IS NO AREA OF STUDY THAT ENGLISH
AND COMMUNICATION SKILLS DO NOT INFLUENCE. THAT IS WHY IT IS ESSENTIAL TO
STUDY LITERATURE.
Whereas many discuss literary works objectively, absolutely and with respect to how the
author developed the ideas on the page, reader response criticism focuses on the reader and
how she or he receives the literary work. In a sense, this moves the text from existing on its
own — on, for example, the physical pages of a book — and instead assumes that the text
exists only when it is read. This theory makes literary works more like performance art where
the reader's act of reading and interpreting the text is the performance. Critical theorists
continue to develop this approach, considering the nature of the reader and what he or she
brings to the text, along with the different "lenses" through which the text can be viewed.
In reader response criticism, the act of reading is like a dialogue between the reader and the
text that has meaning only when the two are joined in conversation. It redefines the role of
the text from an independent object into something that can only exist when it is read and
interacts with the mind of the reader. In this way, the reader is not a passive recipient of what
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
5
the text says, but rather takes an active role. The text then serves as a catalyst to spur
memories and thoughts within the reader allowing him or her to link the text to personal
experiences and thereby fill in the spaces left by the text. This allows theorists to explain why
people can have different responses to and interpretations of the same text.
This form of criticism even goes so far as to examine the role that individual words and
phrases in the text play when interacting with the reader. The sounds and shapes that words
make or even how they are pronounced or spoken by the reader can essentially alter the
meaning of the text, it is suggested. Some reader response critics go so far as to analyze a
text phrase by phrase in order to determine how much of the experience of reading it is
predetermined and then analyze how each reader's experience changes that initial meaning.
Teachers of English throughout the Philippines have long been confronted with a lot of
problems regarding the teaching of literature in the high school. These problems are most
difficult in the first year where it is quite a task to bridge the gap between the six-year
elementary course and the high school. It has become increasingly clear in the minds of those
who face the practical problems of improving the reading instruction, that the textbook
usually determines the success or failure of any method or technique. Since most of the
problems in the teaching of English literature are related to the reading materials, especially
the textbook, it was decided to limit this study to the evaluation of the basic text, in order to
find out how it can be made more readable and interesting to the first year students today.
With the years, it has become increasingly difficult for the teachers to render comprehensible
the materials in the literature text which was written more than two decades ago for first year
students who had had seven years of elementary schooling, without the necessity for
adjustment to the new educational trends is the Philippine public school system and with a
wealth of other reading materials provided for them.
Many educators believe that in the field of Phillippine education today mass promotion, the
elimination of the seventh grade, the double-single session plan, and, in some instances, the
inferior methods used due to the dearth of teaching materials have brought to the high
schools a mass of inadequately prepared students lacking proficiency in the tools of learning,
and in the basic skills needed to cope with the more advanced end more complicated high
school work.
Many of the English teachers believe that the selections included in the basic reader for the
first year possess vocabulary quite difficult for students with such inadequate background for
reading. Others are of the idea that the selections are either too mature or too outdated for
our students today. Some believe that the physical makeup of the book itself does not make
it suitable or attractive to our present-day first year students who are about the same age as
the seventh grade pupils before the six-year elementary course was introduced. Quite a
number of teachers suggest the reorganizing and rewriting of the selections in these readers
either to bring them up-to-date or, as Dr. Antonio Isidro advocates, to simplify them so that
“the substance and con tent are better understood by the learners even if much of the
elegance and beauty of the language of the classic authors way disappear.” There are even
some radically inclined teachers who recommend the changing of these texts for more recent
editions.
4.How can new technology become an essential part of today’s teaching? Show some
examples of these technology.
Online learning opportunities and the use of open educational resources and other
technologies can increase educational productivity by accelerating the rate of learning;
reducing costs associated with instructional materials or program delivery; and better
utilizing teacher time.
2. 3D printing
3D printing has already seen an impressive application in the world at large. 3D printers have
been able to create anything from car parts to artificial organs. In the classroom setting, 3D
printing can create hands-on models that students can investigate and interact with. For
example, students could learn about the geography of an area by observing a 3D map of it.
3. Virtual reality
Technology for virtual reality, augmented reality, and mixed reality is rapidly developing. One
of the primary uses for this technology in the classroom is to take students on virtual field
trips to places otherwise inaccessible. For example, a student could take a virtual field trip to
ancient Egypt or to the bottom of the ocean.
4. Gamification
Students learn better when they’re having fun. The use of gaming in the classroom applies
this concept by tying together the fun part of play with the content and concepts that
students must learn.
5. Cloud technology
The cloud hosts apps and services on the internet instead of being on a user’s computer. It
enables information to be stored, shared, and accessed on any device that’s connected to the
internet. In education, the cloud is used to store and share digital textbooks, lesson plans,
videos, and assignments. It’s also used to give students the opportunity to chat live with their
instructors and other classmates. In a related vein, cloud technology is enabling a new
educational model known as ‘flipped classrooms’ in which students can watch a lecture
before class and spend the class time engaged in discussion, group work, and analytical
activities.
6. Artificial intelligence
AI is making its way into the educational sphere by means of automating grading and
feedback and providing personalized learning opportunities.
7. Mobile technology
Rather than banning cell phones and other mobile devices from use during class, some
schools are incorporating this technology into the learning process through educational apps.
Teaching is a dynamic profession. It changes year to year depending on the classes we teach
and the students we have. However, the world of education has remained largely the same
for the last one hundred years. Our classrooms are still teacher-centered. In the teacher-
centered classroom, the role of the teacher is to deliver information to students and test the
students on their ability to remember and understand that information. The students are
passive learners who understand and remember information, but do not analyze, apply,
evaluate, or create information.
Many educators are beginning to argue that this approach to teaching is now outdated. They
argue schools need to change to meet the increasingly technology-based and globalized
world in which our students will live and work in the future. This globalized world requires
students do more than understand and remember facts. It requires them to apply, analyze,
evaluate, and create new ideas and products.
Some educators argue that our current classroom approach only serves the most basic
learning: understanding and remembering.
Add the fact that we are still in the middle of pandemic. Everything becomes a struggle.
2. In what way can preparation makes our teaching effective? Provide examples.
Make you a better teacher: A significant part of planning and preparation is conducting
research. Studying educational theory and examining best practices helps define and shape
your own teaching philosophy. Studying the content that you teach in depth will also help you
grow and improve.
Boost student performance and achievement: As a teacher, you should have the content
that you teach mastered. You should understand what you are teaching, why you are
teaching it, and you should create a plan for how to present it to your students every single
day. This ultimately benefits your students. It is your job as a teacher to not only present the
information but to present in a way that resonates with the students and makes it important
enough for them to want to learn it. This comes through planning, preparation, and
experience.
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
9
Make the day go by faster: Downtime is a teacher’s worst enemy. Many teachers use the
term “free time”. This is simple code for I did not take the time to plan enough. Teachers
should prepare and plan enough material to last the entire class period or school day. Every
second of every day should matter. When you plan enough students remain engaged, the day
goes by quicker, and ultimately student learning is maximized.
Minimize classroom discipline issues: Boredom is the number one cause of acting out.
Teachers who develop and present engaging lessons on a daily basis rarely have classroom
discipline issues. Students enjoy going to these classes because learning is fun. These types of
lessons do not just happen. Instead, they are created through careful planning and
preparation.
Make you confident in what you do: Confidence is an important characteristic for a teacher
to possess. If for nothing else, portraying confidence will help your students buy what you are
selling. As a teacher, you never want to ask yourself if you could have done more to reach a
student or group of students. You might not like how a particular lesson goes, but you should
take pride in knowing that it was not because you lacked in preparation and planning.
Help earn the respect of your peers and administrators: Teachers know which teachers
are putting in the necessary time to be an effective teacher and which teachers are not.
Investing extra time in your classroom will not go unnoticed by those around you. They may
not always agree with how you run your classroom, but they will have a natural respect for
you when they see how hard you work at your craft.
The first three years of teaching are the most difficult. Spend lots of extra time planning and
preparing during those first few years as you are learning the nuances of teaching and
sequential years will become easier.
Keep all lesson plans, activities, tests, quizzes, worksheets, etc. in a binder. Make notes
throughout the binder according to what worked, what did not, and how you might want to
change things.
Every idea does not have to be original. There is no need to reinvent the wheel. The Internet
is the greatest teaching resource ever made. There are lots of excellent ideas from other
teachers floating around that you can steal and utilize in your classroom.
Work in a distraction-free environment. You will get a lot more accomplished when there are
no other teachers, students, or family members around to distract you.
When conducting an activity, have all the materials laid out before the students arrive.
Practice the activity to ensure that each works correctly. Establish specific procedures and
guidelines for students to follow.
Plan days to weeks in advance if possible. Do not wait until the last minute to try to throw
something together. Doing so limits your effectiveness.
No. The fact is that you cannot exist in a vacuum and rely only on the information in your
head to write a book or any piece of fiction. Writers need to see, hear, feel, taste, and smell
the world around them to be able to convey the same sense of realness into their work. They
also need to be exposed to the writing of others to be able to compare and contrast different
ideas. Part of refining writing includes learning what things you like or dislike in the work of
others and then applying it to your own writing.
There are limitless resources to use to improve their work and learn literature, here are a
few:
Read fiction. That’s right, pick up a book and read. Choose both books in your preferred
genre and also a selection of other literary works. Pay attention to elements that appeal to
you and think of ways that you can incorporate them into your work.
Read books on the craft of writing. There are many wonderful books written by successful
author’s that teach about their unique approach to the craft. These can be most helpful if you
are stuck in a rut or uninspired.
Watch TV and movies. Really, I mean it. Although it’s not the written word, there can be a
lot learned from visual media. Everything from story construction to realistic dialogue can be
found to one extent or another – and it’s faster than reading a book. That said, it can’t be lazy
TV watching. It has to be edge of seat, notebook in hand, watching and critiquing the
different elements.
Take a class. Being surrounded by other writers and having the chance to participate is a
wonderful way to expand a writer’s horizons. It is also great motivation to spend more time
writing when there are assignments to complete.
Utilize the web. There are also countless ways to expand your craft online. Some of my
favorites include blogging, podcasts, and online literary magazines.
4.What is your stand regarding the literature teaching in the Philippines? Cite some
situations to justify your answer.
The teaching of literature seeks to hone the students' lifelong learning skills such as
critical thinking and creativity. We develop different activities from literary materials to
achieve such learning goals which are either mandated by our institutions o r government
agencies. Teaching through literature has been an integral part of developing students’
capacity to become literate citizens. It polishes the skills of our students from reading,
writing, listening, and speaking. In the Philippines with differ ent approaches and
designs for English classes whether by literary competence, reading competence, or
language arts competence focused curriculum, the teaching of literature helps students
to practice these macro skills and to refine their critical thinkin g and creativity.
Teachers deliver literary texts and other multimodal texts in the classrooms to meet
their learning objectives. These texts often open discussions about genre, form, and
social issues. The Department of Education mandates teachers to teac h different
genres and forms of literature from fiction, poetry, and drama across the English
language curriculum for elementary to senior high school. These classes are also
expected to analyze different social issues embedded in literary text from class
oppression, desires, to gender. However, though the Department of Education also
encourages teachers to be creative with their classes, there is no mention of discussing
health, illness, and disability about teaching literature for English classes. With th is kind
of premise, we have lost many chances to see how we can also train our students’
critical thinking skills, creativity, and even the practice of empathy through literature
that discusses illness as a condition in literary texts.
5.Create a classroom-based activity of your chosen method in teaching literature. State the
procedures in performing the said activity.
In this section, I have chosen a poem entitled ‘The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost, to
become an example of teaching poem. If you want to teach poems to your students, here are
some strategies that can be conformed. They are:
a. Pre-reading
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
12
Ask the students about the poem (you have read the poem by your own already, but not your
students). Your students must be ever in confused condition. Ask them these questions: “how
is their feeling? what do they have to do? Do they ever get back to the first thinking or not?,
which will lead them to tell their ideas.
Pay attention to the title. Ask the students whether they can get the whole meaning of the
poem before reading it or not (only by looking at the title). Based on the title “The Road Not
Taken”, ask the implicit or maybe the explicit meaning that the students got at the glance
when they look at the title. You will hear many different ideas from your students.
b. listening
Ask them to listen to your poem reading. This activity can prepare them to read by
themselves and discuss it. And then you can start reading it with good rhythm. The good
rhythm shows the abstract feeling from the poem.
Read the poem aloud; pause where the punctuation marks appear, not where the line ends.
Because, stopping at appropriate spots helps the students to clarify the meaning and get the
feeling.
Pay attention to sound devices. A good poem uses sound devices for a reason, usually to
draw attention to major points.
d. Discussion Questions.
Remind the students that the questions about poem do not always have “right or correct”
answers. So students can answer it freely based on their ideas, experiences and maybe their
imaginations. Ask the students such questions like these:
What does the title “The Road Not Taken” mean to you?
What is the connection between the title and the content?
How do you interpret the first and the second line in the third stanza?
Do you ever have the same experience just like this poem? What it is?
You can ask them to sit in pairs or group, so they can share the idea, but ask them to work on
questions individually.
e. Reading
Ask the students to read the poem by themselves, not only once but several times. So that
they can deeply get into the poem and hopefully get into the point that the author purposed
to be understood. The point from this poem is that the confused condition when someone
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
13
makes the chosen to be taken as the path that she or he will pass in your life. And she should
think carefully which one she should take as her path. And she should realize that she will
never come back to the other path when she has chosen another one. This point should be
the same as what your students have got, but they are free to say the different thing, because
everyone has different point of view on looking at some things.
f. Writing practice.
After they have discussed and read the poem several times, now ask them to make
connection between the title and the content, also and their experiences.
Ask them to imagine that they are the one in the poem. Then ask them “what can you see?,
how do you feel?”. Write a paragraph describing the scene. Use their own words, but feel free
to borrow some sights, words and phrase from the poem.
students?
These difficulties include three types: First, those related to the students such as using
a content-based approach to teaching literature and students' overall lack of
competency in English. Second, those difficulties related to the textbook such as the
abundance of farfetched ideas in literary texts Third, those difficulties related to
teachers such as the lack of the visual aids employed by teachers. Because literature
has an emotive and figurative use of language and because there is a cultural gap and
a lack of comprehending a discourse that is totally unfamiliar to the students' socio-
cultural background, the teacher has to excite the imagination of students to make his
or her teaching effective and refreshing.
In a country like the Philippines where access to technology is gradually taking off, the
use of technology has been seen as a possible way of enhancing learning. Specifically for a
literature class on modern short stories in a small university in the Philippines, blended
learning was used to facilitate interaction between teacher and students. Many components
of a traditional classroom were migrated online. Syllabus, homework, and announcements
were migrated online. Homework was submitted through a web forum. Student journals
were likewise posted in the web forum. Submission of papers was done through email. By
moving most of the requirements online, classroom time was devoted to more intensive one-
on-one interaction between teacher-student and student-student. Learning outside the
classroom enabled self-learning while in-class interaction facilitated personal dealings with
students. The flipped classroom experience showed that by transferring classroom
components online, students take control of learning. Better class interaction meanwhile
allowed the teacher to better guide student learning. The study assumed that all students
had access to the internet but still, there were a handful of students who had difficulties in
regularly going online. Nevertheless, just because of more classroom time devoted to student
interaction, the value of migrating many classroom components online is seen as
advantageous.
1.In what way the models of teaching literature contribute to the growth and
development of teaching. Be as creative as you can through a drawing.
Some of the great literary works like the Bible and Indian epics like Ramayana and
Mahabharata, among others, provide society with the guiding principles of life. Works by
poets like Homer, Plato, Sappho, Horace and Virgil, Shakespeare’s sonnets and notable poetry
by W.B. Yeats, John Keats, Wordsworth, Tennyson, and William Blake, among others, are
timeless. They have always amused their readers and shall continue to. The Lord of the Rings,
The Godfather, A Tale of Two Cities, and James Bond Series are some of the best-selling
books of all time that have entertained several generations. While some literary and poetry
works carry life’s lessons, many others make us think. Some works are known for the sheer
entertainment they provide, while others intrigue. Many works in literature establish a strong
connect with their audience through the stories they narrate or the message the carry.
Readers tend to associate themselves with the emotions portrayed in these works and
become emotionally involved in them. Literature thus has a deep impact on the readers’
minds and in turn, their lives.
Children’s Literature
It is through reading great literary and poetic works, that one understands life. They help a
person take a closer look at the different facets of living. In many ways, literature, in its
different forms, can change one’s perspective towards living. Biographies of great people,
real-life stories of courage, sacrifice and other good values never fail to inspire readers. Such
works give the masses an insight into the lives of eminent people, and also serve as a bible of
ideals.
It Provides Information
Scope of Literature
True, languages are the building blocks of literature. But the study of literature cannot be
restricted to only studying languages. In fact, literature cannot be confined to an educational
curriculum. A degree in language and literature is perhaps not able to provide one with
everything that literature can offer. Its scope is so deep and wide that even a lifetime may not
be enough to really ‘study’ literature.
Literature is Important
For the breadth of knowledge is gives, the moral values it carries, and the enjoyment it
provides, literature is important. An exposure to good literary works is essential at every
phase of life as it enriches us in more ways than one. Literature is definitely much more than
its literary meaning, which defines it as ‘an acquaintance to letters’. In fact, it lays the
foundation of a fulfilling life. It adds ‘life’ to ‘living’.
What are the 5 general classification of figures of speech? Name two (2 ) figures of speech
that are classified under each.
Resemblance
Allusion: reference to any scientific, historical, literary, mythological, biblical , political, etc.
event or personage
Emphasis
Parallelism
Arrangement
Anti- climax: opposite of climax, hence, the most important idea comes first
Transferred epithet: transferring an adjective from the noun to which it properly belongs to
another in the same group
Sound Effects
Alliteration
Examples include:
Anaphora
Anaphora is a technique where several phrases or verses begin with the same word or words.
Examples include:
Mad world! Mad kings! Mad composition! - King John II, William Shakespeare
It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of
foolishness. - A Tale of Two Cities, Charles Dickens
With malice toward none; with charity for all; with firmness in the right. - Abraham Lincoln
We shall not flag or fail. We shall go on to the end... we shall never surrender. - Winston
Churchill
Assonance
Assonance is the repetition of vowel sounds (not just letters) in words that are close together.
The sounds don't have to be at the beginning of the word.
Examples include:
A - For the rare and radiant maiden whom the angels named Lenore. (Poe)
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
19
E - Therefore, all seasons shall be sweet to thee. (Coleridge)
I - From what I've tasted of desire, I hold with those who favor fire. (Frost)
Euphemism
Euphemism is a mild, indirect, or vague term that often substitutes a harsh, blunt, or
offensive term.
Examples include:
Hyperbole
Examples include:
Irony
Irony occurs when there's a marked contrast between what is said and what is meant, or
between appearance and reality.
Examples include:
A traffic cop gets suspended for not paying his parking tickets. (Situational irony)
The Titanic was said to be unsinkable but sank on its first voyage. (Situational irony)
When the audience knows the killer is hiding in a closet in a scary movie, but the actors do
not.
Metaphor
Examples include:
Heart of stone
Time is money
He's an ogre
Onomatopoeia
Onomatopoeia is the term for a word that sounds like what it is describing.
Examples include:
Whoosh
Splat
Buzz
Click
Oxymoron
Examples include:
Peace force
Kosher ham
Sweet sorrow
Free market
Personification
Examples include:
Simile
A simile is a comparison between two unlike things using the words "like" or "as."
Examples include:
As slippery as an eel
As blind as a bat
As wise as an owl
Synecdoche
Synecdoche occurs when a part is represented by the whole or, conversely, the whole is
represented by the part.
Examples include:
Wheels - a car
Understatement
Examples include:
It's a litttle dry and sandy - referring to the driest desert in the world.
The key to easily spotting the difference is to focus on the meanings of the words themselves.
In an oxymoron, the words themselves have a shade of contradiction in their definitions.
For example: Billy hushed the other students and told them to act naturally before the teacher
walked in. In this case, act naturally is an oxymoron that combines two contradictory words.
During the coronavirus pandemic, many feel alone together as everyone engages in social-
distancing and takes comfort in this oxymoron.
Mary must be clearly confused because when I asked if she wanted to go out tonight, her
answer was, “definitely maybe.”
Assessment:
“ Never give in, Never give in. Never, never, never ,never , never, yield to force.” – Repetition
She is good in chemistry, but the chemistry of her body is poor. - Irony
“We’ll hear him, we’ll follow him, we’ll die for him”.- Julius Caesar - Climax
The moon was a silver ship sailing through the sea. - Metaphor
Activity:
1. Name the focus of questions related to the study of drama, short story, poetry.
Drama
What political / historical/ biblical/ mythological event or personage is the play based upon>
How is it reinterpreted in the play?
Select and quote a key line or two that best characterize each of the main characters in the
play.
Make sketches of each of the sets, or ach of the costumes for the play.
What incidents in the play delineate sharply the difference between the characters?
Who is the unseen character in the story? How does his absences affect the characters? The
flow of events in the story?
What speech acts would these passages reveal or suggest of the characters:
“ No, get out. Get out! I hate you! But ,don’t go! Oh, if you only knew how furious I am!
( Throws revolver on the table).
If you were to perform in the play, be able to explain your first, second and third choices of
parts.
Short Story
What is the main focus of the story? Does it center on character, action, setting, atmosphere,
etc.? Illustrate your points.
Indicate the function of these phrases/ sentences in the development of the story:
The ending sentence in Arguila’s story: “ How my Brother Leon Brought Home A Wife”
“ Then I went out. And in the darkened hall the fragrance of her was like a morning when
papayas are in bloom!:”
What are the related themes of the story? What ethical insight does it give?
Poetry
List down the figures of speech used in the poem. How do they help bring out the theme?
Point out the messages used in the poem? Explain their users.
What is the tone expressed in the first two stanzas? How do they differ in the succeeding
ones?
2. Read the given texts. Then construct questions that can serve as springboards for
discussion.
10. Which path had been walked on that morning before the poet traveled on one?
11. When the poet chose one of the paths, what did he hope to do?
12. In the line "Oh I kept the first for another day!", "the first" refers to_____.
14. According to the poet, the second road has "the better claim" because it...
15. This poem might have special relevance for you if you are...
17.Which of the following statements is the closest interpretation of the line "yet knowing
how way leads on to way?"
Assessment:
2. Write a short story in which this sentence plays an important part – Nothing is
impossible.’
Gaza was a swindler and a scammer. A lot of people have reported him to the police and he
was finally nabbed at a checkpoint going to downtown. He was then stripped of all his bank
accounts and properties. During his years of stay in prison, he was locked in with 6 inmates.
All of them shared their stories and promised to do good once they get out.
Among all of them, Armando has the lightest criminal case and has a penalty of only 5 years
in prison but has no money to pay for bail. The other 5 inmates shared all the money they
have to get Armando out of prison and they told him live a good life.
Once Armando got out, he looked for opportunities to succeed in life and pay back his
friends. He worked tirelessly in a factory and after a few years he went on to become a
supervisor and then a manager. Once he had enough money, he bailed one of his 5 friends in
prison and immediately employed him as one of his workers. Then both of them would save
enough money to get another one of their friends out of prison.
This went on until they paid for the last one left in the prison and the biggest bail, Gaza. Once
he got out, he used all of his marketing intelligence and business strategies to make the
factory the biggest in the city. When all of them saved enough, Gaza told them to invest in
him and make their own company.
Now, they are all stakeholders for a huge company that deals with bitcoins and digital
properties.
1. Enthusiasm is contagious.
When you believe in literature as a meaningful and fun way to build language skills, you can
persuade even skeptical students to take it seriously. I’ve had students begin the semester
thinking literature might be an inefficient use of their time, but in 40 years of teaching I’ve
almost never seen one who felt that way after a few weeks of class.
Adaptations: A useful way to get students to think about genre specifics is to ask them to
adapt a short story into a short play. Divide them into groups and assign them either a short
section of the work or the entire thing itself (if you think they’re up to it). Once they’ve written
a short script, ask them to act out their scene for the class. How does the loss of descriptions
change their interpretation of the dialogue? What editorial decisions (omission of dialogue,
addition of action, etc.) did they have to make and why where they necessary? This activity
can be time consuming, but it’s also a good way to draw out quiet students and visually
engage the students’ interest in an active way. It’s also easy to expand this adaptation
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
31
exercise by asking them to consider what a film adaptation of the short story would be like:
Who would you cast in the roles? Would we see the characters in close-up, medium, or long
shots? What colors would you want to present on camera? How long would the scene be?
Bringing in real theater terms (like “blocking” and “beats”) for either version of the activity can
give students some ideas of how to proceed with the task in a thoughtful way.
Alternative Ending: Have students write an alternate ending to the story and explain the
critical difference between their endings and the author’s.
Back to the Future: Many short stories may seem “old” to the students, and they will often
preface their interpretative comments with the phrase “back then”—or, worse, “back in the
olden days.” While it is obviously important to address the historical issues and contexts (and
clarify which “olden days” we’re talking about), an interesting challenge for the students is to
ask them to modernize the story to make it seem relevant to them today. Their changes can
include updating the setting or the use of language, increasing the severity of the
transgression or crisis so the impact is consistent with what they think it would have been at
the story’s original publication. Their changes can be quite innovative, and even radical, but
theymust maintain the overall theme and effect of the story as it is written. For this reason, it
is important to lay very specific boundaries for your students when doing this activity:
requiring that they not only update the story but set it in the neighborhood they grew up in
can be useful.
Class Consciousness: Have students find examples of a character’s class as compared to the
other characters. Then discuss how these details affect your reading of the story. (Adapted
from LeDon Sweeney)
Close Reading Passages: Below are some worksheets that might be assigned to students for
homework or as in-class group work. One is text-specific but could easily be adapted for a
different text.
Highlighting Character: Short stories use different techniques to set up character than
novels or drama (which have the advantage of development over a longer stretch of time).
Short stories have to establish character quickly, often in just a few words or sentences. Ask
students to choose a character from the story and describe him or her in detail. Then ask
them to identify passages from the text that support/flesh out their descriptions. What are
the author’s physical descriptions of the character? What do we know about their
demographic factors (age, gender, race, class, etc.)? You can divide your students into
different groups for multiple characters and have them compare and contrast their
descriptions. You might even want to put a focus on secondary characters: what is their
purpose, especially in relation to the central characters?
Highlighting Plot: Plot is also condensed in short stories and, because of its small scope, it is
often easier for students to see and understand how plot is working in a short story than in a
longer work. One way to help them focus on plot specifically is to have them list characters’
actions and reactions. Which actions/reactions are the most important? What about
reactions that aren’t fully explored in the text but may occur as a result of actions in the text?
(This is also a useful way to demonstrate the unity of plot and character.) Another way to
focus on plot is to ask your students to write a timeline of the events in the story. This is
especially useful for stories that have nonlinear plots, or when there are significant flashbacks
(as with Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily.”) It’s also a useful way to discuss the unity of plot and
point of view: Is the author recounting the story while it is happening or after the fact?
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
32
Writing a narrative timeline allows students to explore the author’s purpose in telling the
story as well as confirm actions of the plot.
How Would This Be Different If…?: Students struggle to remember that every word in a
story is a choice; they often talk about literature as if it were fact or if it emerged complete,
Athena-like, from the author’s head. A great way to counteract this impulse is to ask them to
consider how the story would be transformed by changing small things (specific words of
descriptions, minor details) and large things (point of view, important facts about the
characters, etc.). If the ending of the story is unsatisfactory to your students or surprising to
them in some way, asking them to rewrite the ending is a particularly effective way to make
them think about authorial decisions. (Students also tend to think that short stories are
always depressing. Giving them the opportunity to give a sad story a happy ending can be
really cathartic—and educational.)
Liking a Character: In something of a reader-response method, you can ask your students if
the author wants them to like or dislike a particular character. Then encourage students to
provide textual evidence for what makes the character likable or unlikable. (Adapted
from LeDon Sweeney)
Make a List: Listing out material objects in the text is a great way to get your students to pay
attention to detail in the text. Give them a category of material objects that are significant to
the text and ask them to go through the story and list all of those objects. (Think of the
personal contents of the GI’s packs in O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried” or the groceries in
Updike’s “A & P.”) Why are these objects described in detail? How do the material items focus
your attention on immaterial things, like character’s emotions? How do they convey
important information about character and setting by signaling personality,
historical/geographical location, and class status*? * Sometimes this requires helping your
students make contemporary comparisons to understand the significance of these items
(Herring snacks=caviar).
Map it Out: Anything you can to do help your students visualize the story more vividly is
good. Asking them do visualize it literally, by making a map, is really good, because it helps
them order things like plot events and identify the significance of settings in a really concrete
way. You can map settings or you can map out characters movements over the course of a
scene/story. If you story takes place in a real location, you might make use of Google
Maps/Google Earth to show various locations relationships to one another.
Model Paragraph Assignment: Have students produce a substantial paragraph interpreting
an element of a short story. The purpose of this paragraph is to highlight an implicit critique
in the story and to use evidence to show how the text makes this critique clear.
The Nuts and Bolts of Literature: For all that students use them every day, they are often
unaccustomed to thinking about the formal elements of literature when they read. Instruct
them to read a story while paying particular attention to sentence and paragraph length.
Why are some sentences/paragraphs longer than others, or even run-on sentences? Why are
some short and choppy? Often it’s the case that descriptive sentences are really long,
sustained by endless commas, while dialogue is fragmentary. Students will tell you that this
is because that’s how people really talk. Encourage them to think about whether or not that’s
actually true, and also what the difference tells us about descriptive writing. What would it be
like if you reversed this? Getting them to pay attention to literature’s most basic elements
(punctuation, sentences) not only gives them something concrete to begin with in their
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
33
analysis, but gets them to start paying attention to grammar more generally—which,
hopefully, will bleed into their own writing.
Perform the Story: For stories that rely almost entirely on the dialogue and actions of the
characters to convey meaning, rather than exposition, you might have your students perform
the literature. It is an effective way for them to figure out what is going on and to pick up on
things like sarcasm because it forces them to contemplate how each character delivers the
lines, the mood, and what lies beneath seemingly mundane phrases. You might break up the
class into groups of four and assign a director, an assistant director, and lead actors. Each
group performs a section of the story. They spend some time rehearsing, and the director
and assistant director help with directing the actors, which is where the real learning takes
place, as they puzzle it out.
Repeated Readings: Have students read a story four times at home and chart their
understanding and enjoyment of the text with each reading. Then, during class time,
ask them meet in four small groups and give short presentations about their experiences
with each reading and then to summarize their discussions to the larger group.
Repetition, Repetition: Another way to reinforce authorial choice and to teach students to
be aware of how an author might be focusing their attention in very specific ways, is to attend
to repetitions in a short story. Ask you students to track repeated words, phrases, or images
in a story. Why are they there? What are they supposed to communicate to you? Students
are occasionally resistant to this idea, but a good way to affirm that these repetitions are not
simply an accident made by an inattentive author is to have your students remove them from
the text and replace them with variations. What is lost in the communication and content of
the story if you remove the repetition(s)?
Round Table Reading: For short stories, you might have students read the story aloud and
ask them to comment on the variations. They have never failed to make excellent
observations, which, of course, gives me an opportunity to applaud their ability to read and
encourage them that they can do this with everything they read. This is also a nice way of
getting students to discuss what they like in a good story—not just plot, but how the story is
told. (Adapted from LeDon Sweeney)
Significant Quotes: Ask students to bring in passages or quotes that deserve attention in
discussion. They should have reasons why the quote is important and what it might signify.
Often several students bring in the same quote and this is a great opportunity for discussing
notions of individual reader responses vs. inherently poignant moments in the text. This is a
great activity to do since it 1) requires very little time of the students, but also guides their
reading of the text; 2) provides you with 20 launches for discussion if you need them; 3) can
be used as proof that your students are doing your homework (you can collect them, or
randomly call on people to present them, or have them share in groups); and 4) close reading
is one of the best tools they can cultivate as they improve their interpretative reading skills
and prepare to write persuasive essays. This activity can also be easily adapted: consider
asking them to bring in single words they find significant or quotations they believe to be
controversial.
Surprise! Epiphany: Short stories often contain some kind of revelation or significant
turning point in a character’s thought and/or action. This moment of realization is a major,
defining attribute of the short story genre. Although students will be familiar with the idea,
they may be unfamiliar with the term, so take some time to define what an epiphany is and
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
34
how it works in literature. Then ask them to look for the epiphanic moment in a particular
text. When and why does it occur? What changes because of it? It’s often useful to ask
students to select the specific sentence where they believe the epiphany occurs. Make the
students support their choice with argument: How does their sentence show change? Is it
internal, external, or both? What kind of change is it? Ultimately, the most important
question is not “Which sentence is the exact epiphany?” (although that does trick them into
close reading), but rather why does it occur and what is its result? This is a nice lead-in for
discussing the conclusion of a story.
Teaching Interpretation through a Parable: This lesson plan introduces the concept of
“interpretation.” It is a very short reading of “the parable of the elephant and the blind men,”
which is well-known in several Eastern religions. (From Kelly Budruweit)
Tone: As with poetry, tone is a particularly tricky element of literature for our students to
understand. To help students arrive at a definitions of a story’s tone more organically that
just asking what mood the story creates or what emotions it draws out, as them to come up
with a list of things they might associate with a short story, however vaguely. These things
could be songs, other stories they’ve read, characters from TV or movies, people they know,
etc. (I find this activity works particularly well if you narrow their associations to songs.) For
each item they list, they should identify what motivates the association in their minds and
what feeling or quality each represents. Through these comparisons, students should
become better at assessing tone more directly.
1. Enumerate at least five structural features used in poetry. Give examples to illustrate
each.
Parallelism - is achieved in different ways; but collectively, this feature clearly distinguishes
poetic from non- poetic literature. In its broadest sense, parallelism can be achieved by the
repetition of similar phonological. Structural or lexical units.
Phonological parallelism --- this is the recurrence of certain sounds and sound blends in
order to produce a harmonious, musical effect. This is achieved through alliteration,
assonance and rhyme.
rocky road
big business
kissing cousins
jumping jacks
no nonsense
tough talk
Son of a gun
The cat is out of the bag
Dumb luck
After awhile, crocodile
Chips and dip
Cock of the walk
Inversion- is a type of shifting wherein the verb comes before the subject:
Example: And when kindly falls the night’
In all the town no spark of light
3. Develop a lesson plan for teaching following the poem “The road not taken”
OBJECTIVES
By the end of this lesson, students will be able to define pre-selected tier-two and tier-three
vocabulary terms and demonstrate understanding of the poem’s overall meaning with 70% or
higher accuracy as shown on the summative assessment.
By the end of this lesson, students will be able to identify and explain the use of setting and
symbolism in “The Road Not Taken” with 70% or higher accuracy as shown on the summative
assessment.
By the end of this lesson, students will be able to apply the meaning of “The Road Not Taken”
to their own lives by writing an organized paragraph that scores a three or higher on the
writing rubric.
MATERIALS
ANTICIPATORY SET
GUIDED PRACTICE
Text-Based Questioning: Extrapolate meaning from each stanza of the poem by guiding
students through a series of text-based questions. I use the following questions:
Depending on the skill level of your students, the literary analysis portion of the lesson can be
conducted independently or in small groups/pairs.
Literary Analysis: Students dive deeper into “The Road Not Taken” by analyzing Frost’s use of
setting and symbolism. Each step is explained below.
ASSESSMENT
For the assessment to align with the lesson objectives, it will need to assess students on their
mastery of the pre-selected vocabulary terms, overall poem meaning, and use of setting and
symbolism.
The structure of the assessment is up to you! I use a matching activity for vocabulary and
multiple choice questions for deeper meaning and literary devices.
APPLICATION
Students write an organized paragraph describing a major decision they have made in the
past and how that decision affected their life. The use of a 4-point grading rubric will give
students a clear understanding of the paragraph expectations and ensure that they have
met the lesson objective. I use the following criteria in my grading rubric:
1. To enable
the students to read
aloud prose lessons
with correct pronunciation stress, intonation and pause.
The specific aims vary according to the subject matter of the prose lessons. The specific aims
of different types of prose lessons are:
(i) To develop the student’s imagination and love for natural objects.
(ii) To acquaint the students with the writer’s style.
(b) Story
(c) Essay
(d) Play
(e) Biography
(i) To get students acquainted with the life and deeds of great men.
(ii) To inculcate in them desirable sentiments and ambitions.
(iii) To show them the path of character building.
Assessment:
General literature tests assess students’ knowledge on particular pieces of literature which
they are assigned for class. Such textual materials may include prose and/or poetry, and
teachers may ask students to focus on an individual work or multiple pieces simultaneously.
Tests like these are given to measure the progress and aptitude of students taking literature
classes.
Lesson 2:
Types of Literature Test
Activity :
Choose a reading passage from books or magazines and use it as a springboard for
literature tests. Prepare a set of tests for each level of questions in the Cognitive taxonomy
using the reading passage.
Erosion of America's farmland by wind and water has been a problem since settlers first put
the prairies and grasslands under the plow in the nineteenth century. By the 1930s, more
than 282 million acres of farmland were damaged by erosion. After 40 years of conservation
efforts, soil erosion has accelerated due to new demands placed on the land by heavy crop
production. In the years ahead, soil erosion and the pollution problems it causes are likely to
replace petroleum scarcity as the nation's most critical natural resource problem.
Knowledge
"How would you describe the rate of damage over the years?"
Comprehension
"What facts or ideas show are presented to show that erosion is a big problem?"
"How would you compare erosion effects from 10 years ago to today?"
Application
"What facts would you select to show that the problem is serious?"
"How would you use social media to spread awareness of this issue?"
Analysis
Synthesis
Evaluation
"How could you prove that your goal is for the better?"
It is clearly known that an ideal literary text with good quality can stimulate the
language learning among the readers and it can elicit a wide range of responses from
the learners which are facilitating for language learning. It can stimulate imagination
of the learners, make them use new beautiful words in their conversation .It helps
them to involve in various fruitful discussions. It creates personal involvement in the
learning process and brings out clear picture about different cultures and nationalities
by making them familiar with the norms and behaviors of the people and helps in
cultural enrichment.
Objective Type
Recall of details: Identify the characters who said the lines in the specific story.
Sequence: Rearrange the order of events below as they happened in the story.
Essay Type
Objective Type
Classifying: Select the item that does not belong to the group.
Synthesizing: From the choices given, select the statement that expresses each of the
following selections' theme.
Essay Type
Outlining: Construct a topic outline of the essay providing at least three main heads and
several sub-heads.
Summarizing: Write a one-paragraph summary of the plot of the story.
Test Include:
Objective Type
Interpreting figurative language: Choose the best interpretation of the following symbolic
lines within the poem's context.
Inferring character traits: Math the adjectives that best describe the character's qualities, as
shown by his/her actions.
Essay Type
Predicting outcomes: What do you think is in store for Lumnay as the symbols at the end of
the story portend?
Inferring author’s organization: Why did Nick Joaquin use three generations in his story?
4. Testing Evaluation – tests require students to compare information and ideas in a text with
the instructor or other authorities' material and with the student's knowledge and experience
to form various kinds of judgments.
Objective Type
5. Testing Appreciation – requires students to articulate emotional and aesthetic responses to the
text based on personal and professional standards of literary forms, styles, genres, theories,
critical approaches.
Test Includes:
Objective Type
The author's connotative use of language: Select the underlined word's meaning in each
statement lifted from the story.
Essay Type
Identifying with character or incidents: Which character in the story can you identify similarities?
Example: Are you responding emotionally to the text: How do you feel
towardsHamlet? Do you sympathize with him? Why or
why not?
6. Testing Appreciation – requires students to articulate emotional and aesthetic responses to the
text based on personal and professional standards of literary forms, styles, genres, theories,
critical approaches.
Test Includes:
Objective Type
The author's connotative use of language: Select the underlined word's meaning in each
statement lifted from the story.
Essay Type
Identifying with character or incidents: Which character in the story can you identify similarities?
Example: Are you responding emotionally to the text: How do you feel
towards Hamlet? Do you sympathize with him? Why or why
not?
Literary analysis questions may call on a student’s ability to interpret a particular passage or
segment of a piece. Such questions may involve recognizing references and allusions, tone and
meaning, identifying genres and conventions, grammatical structures and rhetorical strategies.
Identification questions may require a student’s recognition of author and publishing date, as
well as recalling content material such as particular elements of plot.
Cultural and historical context questions may ask a student to identify and further explicate the
specific literary, cultural, and intellectual history of a work. Such questions may also require a
student to provide biographical information about the author or give important background
details regarding the piece’s setting. For instance, a student may have to classify what features
define a piece that belongs to the Victorian Era or Medieval Period, or establish whether a piece
is of British or American origin.
History and theory of literary criticism questions may include identification and analysis of the
methods and characteristics of different theoretical and critical approaches.
Compare and contrast questions will ask students to examine two or more texts simultaneously,
pointing to the similarities and differences of such elements as style, language, theme, or
content.
Essays are (very) time-consuming to grade. To garner the full benefits of including essays on
your tests, you must allot sufficient time to read and comment on the students' responses.
Simply scanning a response and assigning it a numerical grade will not close the learning cycle.
Students quickly learn how to study for your exams! If they perceive that you fail to grade their
responses adequately (as indicated by your written comments and suggestions), students will
not bother to study at a higher level for the next test, but will instead return to memorizing facts.
Sometimes an essay question is not representative of the content covered. An example: In an
introductory course in human physiology, which has just covered blood, the circulatory system,
and the immune system, seven of the ten essay questions are about the circulatory system.
If you use essays, you must use course objectives to determine the content of the questions. By
referring to objectives, you will not make the mistake of focusing too narrowly on one aspect of
content.
The essay exam often has grading reliability problems. Unlike the multiple-choice format, the
essay is a subjective form of evaluation. And teachers often introduce biases into their grading. If
you know whose paper is being evaluated, the grade may reflect personal feelings for that
student, or may reflect influence from past grades. For example, if the student received an A on
a past exam, you may tend to give a higher grade than is actually deserved on this exam (and
vice versa if a student had received an F). Also, grades given on first papers may differ
significantly from those that are graded later. Other influences include your general mood and
stress level at the time of grading, the time of day, and your feelings about the subject of the
essay.
Activity .
1. Construct 5 multiple choices, matching type, and true or false test on any literary text.
Multiple Choice
a. A Winter Day
b. An Autumn Day
At the beginning of "The Road Not Taken," what decision does the speaker face?
What do the following lines from "The Road Not Taken" mean?
And sorry I could not travel both
And be one traveler,
What is the difference between the two roads in "The Road Not Taken"?
a) After choosing the first road, the speaker will return and go down the other road.
b) The speaker does not like to travel in the same part of the woods more than once.
c) The speaker likes to walk in the woods alone and knows the way very well.
d) After choosing the first road, the speaker will not return to go down the other road.
Matching Type
Directions: Match the vocabulary word and its definition. Write the letter of the correct
answer on the line provided.
_____ 6. Small trees and plants growing beneath larger trees e. undergrowth
True or False
2. Best “the amount of course material covered to the amount of time spent to construct the
questions” ratio.
3. Allow for great flexibility and accuracy in counting the learners’ scores.
4. Give an objective assessment of the learners’ knowledge.
5. At their most useful when used in areas mostly dealing with facts.
6. Least chance of guessing the correct answer compared to other question types.
3. Give the three formats of Literature test and briefly discuss each.
Multiple Choice
A multiple-choice question (MCQ) is composed of two parts: a stem that identifies the question
or problem, and a set of alternatives or possible answers that contain a key that is the best
answer to the question, and a number of distractors that are plausible but incorrect answers to
the question. Students respond to MCQs by indicating the alternative that they believe best
answers or completes the stem. There are many advantages to using MCQs for assessment. One
key advantage is that the questions are easy to mark and can even be scored by a computer,
which makes them an attractive assessment approach for large classes. Well designed MCQs
allow testing for a wide breadth of content and objectives and provide an objective
measurement of student ability.
Matching Type
Matching test questions measure the student’s ability to connect words, complete sentences, or
pair words with their definition. The matching test format consists of two columns, including one
with a definition or phrase, and another with a word, number, or symbol. Teachers refer to each
item in the first column as the premises, or the questions involved in the matching tests.
Likewise, instructors refer to the answers in the second column as responses in the matching
tests. Teachers everywhere agree that learners should select the correct response in the second
column to its corresponding premises in the first. Conventional matching tests usually have
items in the first column numbered and items in the second column labeled with alphabetical
letters.
True or False
In a traditional true/false question, students are asked to judge whether a factual statement is
either true or false. True/false questions are best suited to assessing surface level knowledge,
but can be crafted to assess higher order thinking. Like multiple choice, students can process
and respond to true/false quickly, allowing the test designer to assess more content areas in an
exam. They are also easy and quick to mark. However, traditional multiple choice is thought to
be superior to true/false for several reasons, including:
Students have a higher probability of guessing the right answer in True/False responses
True/false questions offer little insight into why students may answer incorrectly
True/false questions are necessarily absolute; it can be difficult to write questions that are
unambiguously true or false.
Activity.
Assessment:
Before you can create a rubric, you need to decide the type of rubric you'd like to use, and that
will largely be determined by your goals for the assessment.
Ask yourself the following questions:
5. What standards must the students hit in order to achieve acceptable or exceptional
performance?
6. Do I want to give one final grade on the project or a cluster of smaller grades based on several
criteria?
7. Am I grading based on the work or on participation? Am I grading on both?
Once you've figured out how detailed you'd like the rubric to be and the goals you are trying to
reach, you can choose a type of rubric.
1. Analytic Rubric: This is the standard grid rubric that many teachers routinely use to assess
students' work. This is the optimal rubric for providing clear, detailed feedback. With an analytic
rubric, criteria for the students' work is listed in the left column and performance levels are
listed across the top. The squares inside the grid will typically contain the specs for each level. A
rubric for an essay, for example, might contain criteria like "Organization, Support, and Focus,"
and may contain performance levels like "(4) Exceptional, (3) Satisfactory, (2) Developing, and (1)
Unsatisfactory." The performance levels are typically given percentage points or letter grades
and a final grade is typically calculated at the end. The scoring rubrics for the ACT and SAT are
designed this way, although when students take them, they will receive a holistic score.
2. Holistic Rubric: This is the type of rubric that is much easier to create, but much more difficult
to use accurately. Typically, a teacher provides a series of letter grades or a range of numbers (1-
4 or 1-6, for example) and then assigns expectations for each of those scores. When grading, the
teacher matches the student work in its entirety to a single description on the scale. This is
useful for grading multiple essays, but it does not leave room for detailed feedback on student
work.
This is where the learning objectives for your unit or course come into play. Here, you'll need to
brainstorm a list of knowledge and skills you would like to assess for the project. Group them
according to similarities and get rid of anything that is not absolutely critical. A rubric with too
much criteria is difficult to use! Try to stick with 4-7 specific subjects for which you'll be able to
create unambiguous, measurable expectations in the performance levels. You'll want to be able
to spot the criteria quickly while grading and be able to explain them quickly when instructing
your students. In an analytic rubric, the criteria are typically listed along the left column.
Once you have determined the broad levels you would like students to demonstrate mastery of,
you will need to figure out what type of scores you will assign based on each level of mastery.
Most ratings scales include between three and five levels. Some teachers use a combination of
numbers and descriptive labels like "(4) Exceptional, (3) Satisfactory, etc." while other teachers
simply assign numbers, percentages, letter grades or any combination of the three for each
level. You can arrange them from highest to lowest or lowest to highest as long as your levels
are organized and easy to understand.
This is probably your most difficult step in creating a rubric.Here, you will need to write short
statements of your expectations underneath each performance level for every single criteria.
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
55
Republic of the Philippines
Iloilo State College of Fisheries
DUMANGAS CAMPUS
Dumangas, Iloilo Registration No. 78Q13035
The descriptions should be specific and measurable. The language should be parallel to help
with student comprehension and the degree to which the standards are met should be
explained.
Again, to use an analytic essay rubric as an example, if your criteria was "Organization" and you
used the (4) Exceptional, (3) Satisfactory, (2) Developing, and (1) Unsatisfactory scale, you would
need to write the specific content a student would need to produce to meet each level. It could
look something like this:
4 3 2 1 Unsatisfactory
Exceptional Satisfactory Developing
A holistic rubric would not break down the essay's grading criteria with such precision. The top
two tiers of a holistic essay rubric would look more like this:
One of the downfalls of essay tests is that they lack in reliability. Even when teachers grade
essays with a well-constructed rubric, subjective decisions are made. Therefore, it is important to
try and be as reliable as possible when scoring your essay items. Here are a few tips to help
improve reliability in grading:
1. Determine whether you will use a holistic or analytic scoring system before you write
your rubric. With the holistic grading system, you evaluate the answer as a whole, rating papers
against each other. With the analytic system, you list specific pieces of information and award
points for their inclusion.
2. Prepare the essay rubric in advance. Determine what you are looking for and how many points
you will be assigning for each aspect of the question.
3. Avoid looking at names. Some teachers have students put numbers on their essays to try and
help with this.
4. Score one item at a time. This helps ensure that you use the same thinking and standards for all
students.
5. Avoid interruptions when scoring a specific question. Again, consistency will be increased if you
grade the same item on all the papers in one sitting.
6. If an important decision like an award or scholarship is based on the score for the essay, obtain
two or more independent readers.
7. Beware of negative influences that can affect essay scoring. These include handwriting and
writing style bias, the length of the response, and the inclusion of irrelevant material.
8. Review papers that are on the borderline a second time before assigning a final grade.
Rubrics are multidimensional sets of scoring guidelines that can be used to provide consistency
in evaluating student work. They spell out scoring criteria so that multiple teachers, using the
same rubric for a student's essay, for example, would arrive at the same score or grade.
Rubrics are used from the initiation to the completion of a student project. They provide a
measurement system for specific tasks and are tailored to each project, so as the projects
become more complex, so do the rubrics.
Rubrics are great for students: they let students know what is expected of them, and demystify
grades by clearly stating, in age-appropriate vocabulary, the expectations for a project. They also
help students see that learning is about gaining specific skills (both in academic subjects and in
problem-solving and life skills), and they give students the opportunity to do self-assessment to
reflect on the learning process.
Rubrics also help teachers authentically monitor a student's learning process and develop and
revise a lesson plan. They provide a way for a student and a teacher to measure the quality of a
body of work. When a student's assessment of his or her work and a teacher's assessment don't
agree, they can schedule a conference to let the student explain his or her understanding of the
content and justify the method of presentation.
The Role of Rubrics in Testing and Teaching booklet turns rubrics inside out and reveals them as
an incredibly helpful tool in the effort to teach students of all ages in a variety of subjects and
assess their learning, progress, and performance.
The multiple intelligence theory can draw students back into learning. Using the different
intelligences to teach a concept allows each of your diverse learners a chance to succeed at
learning. The learner with strength in the visual-spatial intelligence will do well with drawing
and puzzles. Students with strength in the linguistic intelligence would do well with a written
report over a reading assignment, while those dominant in interpersonal intelligence excel at
classroom discussions of what was read. As students feel success in learning, problem
behavior decreases. Teaching to a student's strength helps increase learning success.
By using a variety of teaching strategies across the multiple intelligences, the teacher can
assess or measure student learning. The assessment could be a written or oral test, original
artwork by the student, a building task or some other activity which gives the teacher an idea
of how well the student learned the new concept. For instance, after successfully assembling a
small engine, students in a technical college could be assessed by developing a how-to manual
complete with verbal instructions and diagrams. In this example, students learn by building the
engine tapping into the bodily-kinesthetic intelligence, while the assessment of a written
manual with diagrams draws on linguistic and visual-spatial intelligences. The teacher can then
measure how well students mastered the concept by the completeness and accuracy of the
written manual while students tapped into three intelligences to learn and master the concept.
Assessing multiple intelligences should be as diverse as the learning styles themselves. Teachers
should be aware that testing in one way, such as an essay, will naturally play to the strength of
some learners, such as linguistics, and weakness of others, such as spatial learners. Consider
eliminating traditional methods of testing when determining multiple intelligences of your
students, and instead supplement with authentic assessments.
Keep the following in mind when considering assessments:
Variety - Because your learners are unique, their response to testing will be also. Use different
tools, procedures, and instruments to assess.
Give it time - Look at this process as a gathering of evidence, not a one-and-done assessment.
You're never finished - Think you've figured out which learning style a student is? Chances are,
he or she has characteristics of many and will show those strengths during differing tasks.
Build a team - Having a team of professionals who are part of the process gives opportunities for
many objective eyes to determine strengths and weaknesses.
To use the theory of multiple intelligences successfully, teachers must first understand what
type of intelligence students are. Each domain has particular characteristics teachers can use to
determine how to best instruct students.
Assessment:
The MI theory is a vital one when it comes to equipping students with a better understanding of
how they learn. In a typical classroom environment, a single learning style is usually
encouraged — one that suits primarily learners with a high verbal-linguistic (reading and writing)
intelligence. But by helping learners identify which type of intelligence suits them, they can adapt
the content to their learning style to help them grasp the material, even if it’s taught in a
different way. For example, learners with a high musical intelligence can put together a rhyme to
help them learn, or students with a high visual-spatial intelligence could create drawings of
concepts to help.
This can also help students overcome learning difficulties with specific subjects that they may
traditionally consider themselves weak at. By helping them overcome these hurdles, students
may find themselves motivated and enthusiastic about subjects that they previously struggled
with.
What makes the Multiple Intelligences Theory strong and useful in a classroom is the fact that it
can be used for any subject and at any level. Each student comes to a classroom as an individual
who has developed a different type of intelligence. This means that each student has their own
intelligence superiorities and weaknesses. Called a learning style, these intelligence domains
determine how easily or difficultly a student can learn through a specific teaching method.
There can be more than one learning style present in a classroom. To balance learning styles
and subject matter, a teacher should show students how to understand a subject which
addresses one of their weak intelligence domains by applying their most developed intelligence
domain. For instance, a student who has highly-developed musical intelligence can be asked to
learn about a war and what happened during that war by making up a song about it (Temur,
2007).
Moreover, students who apply their strong fields of intelligences in learning activities can learn a
subject that they used to hate with joy and without pressure. As another example, mathematics
is considered to be a tough subject for many students due to the abstract concepts they have to
learn. However, when such concepts are explained through a learning activity that implements
students’ intelligences, students will find it more interesting and more fun because it is given as
something they love to do. Students can learn mathematics by drawing, dancing, blogging, and
much more. A whole curriculum can be created with activities based on multiple intelligences in
a way that develops different fields of intelligences for each student; such curriculum will be
more student-centered. Students will then discover the best ways by which they’re able to
receive information.
The table of specifications (TOS) is a tool used to ensure that a test or assessment measures the
content and thinking skills that the test intends to measure. Thus, when used appropriately, it
can provide response content and construct (i.e., response process) validity evidence. A TOS may
be used for large-scale test construction, classroom-level assessments by teachers, and
psychometric scale development. It is a foundational tool in designing tests or measures for
research and educational purposes.
The primary purpose of a TOS is to ensure alignment between the items or elements of an
assessment and the content, skills, or constructs that the assessment intends to assess.
2. Develop a 20- item test on literary skills on the passage “ The Road Not taken”.
1. Why does the poet say he shall tell people "this with a sigh"? Why do you think the final stanza
starts with a sigh?
2. Bring out the symbolism in the poem "The Road Not Taken"
3. The road is used as a metaphor for life in this poem. Can you think of another metaphor and
explain why that has been used to describe life.
4. What does the narrator mean by "a yellow wood"?
5. What choice did the narrator have to make?
6. What does the narrator regret?
7. What did the narrator see in the wood?
8. In this poem, Robert Frost is comparing a path through the woods to what?
9. What does trodden mean here: "And both that morning equally lay / In leaves no step had
trodden black?
10.The poet says, "I took the one less traveled by, / And that has made all the difference." Have you
ever taken a road "less traveled"? If so, did it make a difference to you? How?
11.Give ONE reason why it was hard for the speaker to decide which road to take.
12."Yet knowing how way leads on to way, I doubted if I should ever come back." Explain this
quote in your own words. Do you agree with the speaker? Explain why or why not.
13.The poem ends: "And that has made all of the difference." This quote describes how the
speaker will relate to his decision later on in life. How does he think he will feel about his
decision?
14.The last stanza begins: "I shall be telling this with a sigh / Somewhere ages and ages
hence:" a. Why do you think the speaker will be "telling this with a sigh"?
15.What connection can we make between this quote and the title of the poem?
16."Take a chance! All life is a chance. The man who goes the furthest is generally the one who
is willing to do and dare. The 'sure thing' boat never gets far from shore." - Dale Carnegie,
American writer Make a connection between the above quote and the poem. Give information
from the poem to support your answer.
17."In the long run, we shape our lives, and we shape ourselves... And the choices we
make are ultimately our own responsibility." – Eleanor Roosevelt Make a connection
between the above quote and the poem. Give information from the poem to support
your answer.
18.Robert Frost said that "The Road Not Taken" was written about a friend of his who,
whatever road he went on, was sorry that he hadn't chosen another. How does this quote
help you understand the poem?
19."Frost uses nature as a background. He usually begins a poem with an observation of
something in nature and then moves toward a connection to some human situation." – The
Pastoral Art of Robert Frost by John F. Lynen Explain how the above quote adds to your
understanding of the poem.
20.. Some people say the poem is about regret. Why do you think they say that? Support your
answer with information from the poem.
1. Explain why is it necessary to create table of specification (TOS) in preparing and creating
exams?
Tables of Specifications can help students at all ability levels learn better. By providing
the table to students during instruction, students can recognize the main ideas, key skills,
and the relationships among concepts more easily. The Table of Specifications can act in
the same way as a concept map to analyze content areas. Teachers can even collaborate
with students on the construction of the Table of Specifications- what are the main ideas
and topics, what emphasis should be placed on each topic, what should be on the test?
Open discussion and negotiation of these issues can encourage higher levels of
understanding while also modeling good learning and study skills.
Assessment:
Begin with the lesson objectives in mind. Make sure to know what you wish the student to show
by answering the essay question.
Decide if your goal requires a restricted or extended response. In general, if you wish to see if
the student can synthesize and organize the information that they learned, then restricted
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS IN TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF LITERATURE STUDIES
61
Republic of the Philippines
Iloilo State College of Fisheries
DUMANGAS CAMPUS
Dumangas, Iloilo Registration No. 78Q13035
response is the way to go. However, if you wish them to judge or evaluate something using the
information taught during class, then you will want to use the extended response.
If you are including more than one essay, be cognizant of time constraints. You do not want to
punish students because they ran out of time on the test.
Write the question in a novel or interesting manner to help motivate the student.
State the number of points that the essay is worth. You can also provide them with a time
guideline to help them as they work through the exam.
If your essay item is part of a larger objective test, make sure that it is the last item on the exam.
Make sure that the answer is clear and that it could not be either or
Try not to use negative questions such as 'this novel was not written by...." but instead use 'this
novel was written by...."
Use a random order of true and false responses with your test questions to avoid creating a
pattern
Use more false questions than true questions as they have been proven to cater towards
higher cognitive level students
Fill-in-the-Blank Questions
Fill in the blank questions require the student to know the correct answer rather than
having the ability to guess from a list of possible answers. Here are some tips to consider
when writing good fill in the blank test questions:
Ensure that there is only one possible correct answer to avoid confusion and difficulty grading
Blanks should come at the end or as close to the end of the question or statement as possible
Questions should recall important information taught within the lesson plans
Open-Ended Questions
Open ended or essay format questions are excellent for measuring higher level cognitive
learning and overall comprehension of a subject. They allow the student to select content
for their response, to organize their thoughts in a logical manner and to present their
ideas on a given subject matter. Overall, these types of test questions allow the teacher to
test the student's broader understanding of a subject matter. And, these types of
questions are often more applicable to real life situations that the student may be
presented with in the future.
When writing good open-ended questions, keep the following tips in mind:
Be sure that the test question clearly states the answer that you are seeking from the student.
For example, 'discuss the recent election outcome' is a poor test question. But, worded as
'describe the potential positive and negative impacts that Barack Obama's recent election win
for president could have on the US's economy' is a better test question as it clearly gives the
student something to compare and contrast within a focused area, the US economy.
If you are requiring the student to prepare a longer essay (2-3 pages), include several questions
that are intended to be in addition to the primary question for the student to respond to rather
than only a single question to answer.
If you are looking to test comprehension, a good opening line for the test question is, 'Explain
the following..."
If you are seeking to test the student's ability to analyze a concept, a good opening phrase for
your test question is, 'compare and contrast....."
Don't give students the option to pick 2 or 3 questions from among 5. This can add confusion
for the students and complexity for the teacher when grading for a classroom. How can you
accurately compare students to each other when they have answered different test questions?
When creating good test questions, first be sure that you have selected the best format
for what skills or concepts you are seeking to test for. Then, take your time to construct
the best possible test questions using the tips mentioned above.
Test development or test construction refers to the science and art of planning, preparing,
administering, scoring, statistically analyzing, and reporting results of tests. This article
emphasizes a systematic process used to develop tests in order to maximize validity evidence
for scores resulting from those tests.
Topic words are easy to locate. They tell you what you have to write about. But be careful as you
may only have to write about some aspect of this topic. Never stop here! Go to the next step
(restricting words).
3. Look for any words that may restrict the topic in any way
Restricting words are words or phrases that narrow the topic and make it more specific, i.e. this
is the part of the broad topic that the lecturer wants you to investigate—you will only be given
marks on subject matter that is restricted to the aspect of the topic.
Instruction words are words that tell you what to do. Be careful with these. If the lecturer wants
you to describe, your answer will not be the same as when you are asked to critically assess. The
ASO factsheet: Analyzing the question gives you a number of common instruction words and
shows you what they mean. Be careful:
Words such as what, how and why can also be used, and you will have to interpret the specific
meaning behind the question
Two or more instruction words in a question means that you will have to answer each part of the
question.
Rewriting the question in your own words is a good way of making sure that you have
understood the question, BUT you must stay close to the original question. Then, you need to
match your version to the original—if you have any doubts about your interpretation, check with
your lecturer.
Once the items, directions, and answer key have been written, the teacher should consider the
manner in which the test will be presented in advance. Factors such as duplication, visual aids,
and use of the blackboard should be considered in advance to insure clarity in presentation as
well as to avoid technical difficulties.
Establish Classroom Policy
Because discipline is a major factor in test administration, the teacher must establish a
classroom policy concerning such matters as tardiness, absences, make-ups, leaving the room,
and cheating (see Classroom Management). The teacher must also advise students of
procedural rules such as:
° What to do if they have any questions.
° What to do when they are finished taking the test.
° What to do if they run out of paper, need a new pen, etc.
Though students will work on different activities and demonstrate their knowledge through a
variety of products, teachers can accurately evaluate student performance using one of several
recommended methods:
Rubrics: A rubric is an objective set of guidelines that defines the criteria used to score or grade
an assignment. It describes the requirements of the assignment and clearly outlines the points
the student will receive based on the quality of his or her work. Teachers can give students the
rubric in advance to help them understand the requirements and expectations for the
assignment. Even if the students are completing a variety of products to demonstrate their
knowledge of the same content or skill, teachers can use the same rubric for grading all of the
students’ products.
Portfolios: A portfolio is a collection of artifacts, or individual work samples, that represent a
student’s performance over a period of time. In general, this type of assessment allows teachers
to more accurately evaluate a student’s mastery of content or a skill than a single assessment
such as a test that captures one moment in time. A portfolio also allows a student to reflect on
his or her performance over time and to perhaps establish future goals.
Self-assessment: Student self-assessment is the process of students using specific criteria to
evaluate and reflect on their own work. In doing so, students become more responsible for their
own learning and may be more prepared to work with the teacher to develop individual learning
goals. For students to effectively evaluate their own work, teachers should provide them criteria
to evaluate themselves against.
2. Are exams the best way to evaluate students? Prove your answer.
As a college student, tests can dominate your entire education experience. They probably should,
considering the fact that they can sometimes account for half of your entire grade. Since we spend
all of this time studying for, stressing about and taking tests, I think we should ask ourselves the
question: Are tests actually a good way to measure a student’s knowledge?
Personally, I think that they are a great way to measure a student’s knowledge, but only at the time
when the test is taken. Think about it: how often do you have cram-sessions in hopes of memorizing
all of the necessary material in the days leading up to a test, only to “brain dump” all of the things
that you learned the second after you turn in the exam?
If you’re anything like me, you probably do it pretty often. That’s a great strategy if you want nothing
more than a solid test grade, but it is not a great way to ensure that you retain the information that
you’ve spent hours studying. I’m as guilty of this as anyone, but we should care about the knowledge
we obtain more than we care about our grade, not the other way around.
As much as you can blame the student for having their priorities twisted, you also have to blame the
practice of giving tests itself. When taking a test, a student has no incentive to do anything outside of
what is necessary to ensure that their desired grade is made. With that in mind, shouldn’t instructors
be encouraged to use practices to measure students’ knowledge that makes them want to learn the
information in such a way that they will actually retain it?
I think that should be the case, and there are virtually an endless amount of ways that you can
measure a student’s knowledge.
One of the more popular ways to do this is by assigning essays. I know, most of us let out a massive
groan every time that we hear that we have been assigned an essay. However, I think that this is a
great way to measure what a student knows while ensuring that they actually become relatively
knowledgeable in the topic at hand. On top of being a surefire way to make sure that students retain
a large amount of what they’ve learned, it is also very efficient. When you write an essay, you’re not
spending hours upon hours pouring over a textbook like you would before a test. Instead you’re
spending maybe an hour or two gathering the information necessary to write the essay before
expanding on that information using your own original thoughts. What better way to make a concept
stick with a student than making them think and write about those concepts critically?
Another tried and true way to evaluate student’s knowledge in this way is with a presentation. When
you hear presentation, your mind probably jumps to the boring PowerPoint presentations that you
had to sit through during your ninth grade world history class. While this certainly is one mode of
presentation, there are a variety of other ways you can have students present information, such as
video presentations or speeches. These are not only ways that allow students to use their creative
side to absorb and display information, but the change of pace that comes from hearing information
coming from one of your peers can also do wonders for the audience when done properly.
Now, those are only a couple of different ways that you can evaluate a student’s knowledge without
testing, but I think that they sufficiently got my point across. Everyone has their own unique set of
talents and weaknesses, and students are no different. It is time that we start treating them as such.
Lesson 4: Scoring
Activity:
Based on the classroom grades achieved, a teacher might receive a raise or be fired from their
job. This creates a host of learning problems. For starters, only the students who are performing
poorly on testing simulations receive a majority of the attention from the teacher, leaving good
students to fend for themselves. Teachers then begin to “teach to the test” instead of teaching
subject materials to obtain needed results. This creates a reduction of higher-order thinking,
reduces complex assignments, and prevents cognitive understanding.
Standardized tests narrow the curriculum.
According to the Center on Education Policy, from 2001-2007, school districts in the United
States reduced the amount of time spent on social studies, creative subjects, and science by
over 40%. This results in the average student losing more than 2 hours of instruction time in
these areas so that they can focus on subjects that are on standardized tests, such as reading
and math.
More time is spent on test preparation instead of actual learning.
Many school districts, especially those with lower test scores, spend more classroom time on
test preparation than learning the curriculum. In 2010, New York City took the extraordinary
measure of including 2.5-hour test preparation sessions on scheduled school vacation days.
The advantages and disadvantages of standardized testing show that it can be a useful tool for
student evaluation, but only when it is used correctly. Like any system, it can be abused by those
who are looking for shortcuts. That is why each key point must be carefully considered before
implementing or making changes to a plan of standardized testing.
One of the downfalls of essay tests is that they lack in reliability. Even when teachers grade
essays with a well-constructed rubric, subjective decisions are made. Therefore, it is important to
try and be as reliable as possible when scoring your essay items. Here are a few tips to help
improve reliability in grading:
1. Determine whether you will use a holistic or analytic scoring system before you write
your rubric. With the holistic grading system, you evaluate the answer as a whole, rating papers
against each other. With the analytic system, you list specific pieces of information and award
points for their inclusion.
2. Prepare the essay rubric in advance. Determine what you are looking for and how many points
you will be assigning for each aspect of the question.
3. Avoid looking at names. Some teachers have students put numbers on their essays to try and
help with this.
4. Score one item at a time. This helps ensure that you use the same thinking and standards for all
students.
5. Avoid interruptions when scoring a specific question. Again, consistency will be increased if you
grade the same item on all the papers in one sitting.
6. If an important decision like an award or scholarship is based on the score for the essay, obtain
two or more independent readers.
7. Beware of negative influences that can affect essay scoring. These include handwriting and
writing style bias, the length of the response, and the inclusion of irrelevant material.
8. Review papers that are on the borderline a second time before assigning a final grade.
Assessment:
The analytical approach for scoring essays allows an instructor to be fairly objective. It consists
of four steps: (a) specifying the features the answer must contain; (b) specifying the criteria for
judging the adequacy of each feature; (c) assigning point values to each of the criteria; and (d)
reading each student’s answer using the criteria to help determine the student’s score.
In spite of several problems the analytical approach may present, I prefer it because it is more
objective and thus enables instructors to score essays more accurately
Activity:
The Item Analysis output consists of four parts: A summary of test statistics, a test frequency
distribution, an item quintile table, and item statistics. This analysis can be processed for an
entire class. If it is of interest to compare the item analysis for different test forms, then the
analysis can be processed by test form.
Item analysis is the act of analyzing student responses to individual exam questions with the
intention of evaluating exam quality. It is an important tool to uphold test effectiveness and
fairness.
Item analysis is likely something educators do both consciously and unconsciously on a regular
basis. In fact, grading literally involves studying student responses and the pattern of student
errors, whether to a particular question or particular types of questions.
But when the process is formalized, item analysis becomes a scientific method through which
tests can be improved, and academic integrity upheld.
Assessment:
Item analysis is a process which examines student responses to individual test items (questions)
in order to assess the quality of those items and of the test as a whole. Item analysis is especially
valuable in improving items which will be used again in later tests, but it can also be used to
eliminate ambiguous or misleading items in a single test administration. In addition, item
analysis is valuable for increasing instructors’ skills in test construction, and identifying specific
areas of course content which need greater emphasis or clarity.
1. It is relatively easier to prepare and administer a six-question extended- response essay test
than to prepare and administer a comparable 60-item multiple-choice test items.
2. It is the only means that can assess an examinee’s ability to organise and present his ideas in
a logical and coherent fashion.
4. Some of the objectives such as ability to organise idea effectively, ability to criticise or justify a
statement, ability to interpret, etc., can be best measured by this type of test.
6. It helps to induce good study habits such as making outlines and summaries, organising the
arguments for and against, etc.
7. The students can show their initiative, the originality of their thought and the fertility of their
imagination as they are permitted freedom of response.
8. The responses of the students need not be completely right or wrong. All degrees of
comprehensiveness and accuracy are possible.
10. They are valuable in testing the functional knowledge and power of expression of the pupil.
1. One of the serious limitations of the essay tests is that these tests do not give scope for larger
sampling of the content. You cannot sample the course content so well with six lengthy essay
questions as you can with 60 multiple-choice test items.
3. Moreover, scoring may be affected by spelling, good handwriting, coloured ink, neatness,
grammar, length of the answer, etc.
4. The long-answer type questions are less valid and less reliable, and as such they have little
predictive value.
5. It requires an excessive time on the part of students to write; while assessing, reading essays
is very time-consuming and laborious.
7. Improper and ambiguous wording handicaps both the students and valuers.
10. The scores may be affected by his personal bias or partiality for a particular point of view, his
way of understanding the question, his weightage to different aspect of the answer, favouritism
and nepotism, etc.