Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Background: For a number of pediatric and adult conditions, morbidity and mortality are increased when
Received 29 July 2013 patients present to the hospital on a weekend compared to weekdays. The objective of this study was to
Received in revised form 5 January 2014 compare pediatric surgical outcomes following weekend versus weekday procedures.
Accepted 11 January 2014 Methods: Using the Nationwide Inpatient Sample and the Kids’ Inpatient Database, we identified 439,457
pediatric (b 18 years old) admissions from 1988 to 2010 that required a selected index surgical proce-
Key words:
dure (abscess drainage, appendectomy, inguinal hernia repair, open fracture reduction with internal fixation,
Surgical outcomes
National Inpatient Sample
or placement/revision of ventricular shunt) on the same day of admission. Outcome metrics were com-
Kids' Inpatient Database pared using logistic regression models that adjusted for patient and hospital characteristics as well as
Weekend effect procedure performed.
Patient safety Results: Patient characteristics of those admitted on the weekend (n = 112,064) and weekday (n = 327,393)
Pediatric surgery were similar, though patients admitted on the weekend were more likely to be coded as emergent (61%
versus 53%). After multivariate adjustment and regression, patients undergoing a weekend procedure were
more likely to die (OR 1.63, 95% CI 1.21–2.20), receive a blood transfusion despite similar rates of
intraoperative hemorrhage (OR 1.15, 95% CI 1.01–1.26), and suffer from procedural complications (OR 1.40,
95% CI 1.14–1.74).
Conclusion: Pediatric patients undergoing common urgent surgical procedures during a weekend admission
have a higher adjusted risk of death, blood transfusion, and procedural complications. While the exact
etiology of these findings is not clear, the timing of surgical procedures should be considered in the context of
systems-based deficiencies that may be detrimental to pediatric surgical care.
© 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Patients less than 18 years of age were selected from the NIS and
KID databases if they underwent a surgical procedure on the same
⁎ Corresponding author at: Division of Pediatric Surgery, Charlotte R. Bloomberg
Children’s Center, 1800 Orleans Street, Room 7310, Baltimore, MD 21287–0005.
calendar day as their inpatient hospital admission. Selected index
Tel.: +1 410 955 1983; fax: +1 410 502 5314. operations for analysis were chosen via an institutional review of
E-mail address: sgoldstein@jhmi.edu (S.D. Goldstein). common weekend cases in the American College of Surgeons Pediatric
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2014.01.001
0022-3468/© 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1088 S.D. Goldstein et al. / Journal of Pediatric Surgery 49 (2014) 1087–1091
Modification (ICD-9 CM) procedure codes present in the discharge Outcome Assessed
data. Index procedures chosen were: abscess drainage (AD), appen- Death Directly reported in database
dectomy (App), inguinal hernia repair (IHR), open reduction with Condition Assessed ICD-9 Diagnosis Codes
Hemorrhagic Complications 998.1, 998.11, 998.12, 998.13
internal fixation of bone fracture (ORIF), and placement or revision of
Accidental Puncture or
ventricular shunt (VS). Records were excluded if the admission or Laceration 998.2
operative day was unknown or if the admission was coded as elective. Wound Dehiscence or Nonhealing 998.3, 998.30, 998.31, 998.32, 998.33, 998.83
A complete list of the selection criteria and corresponding ICD-9 CM Wound infection or abscess 998.5, 998.50, 998.51, 998.52, 998.53, 998.54,
998.55, 998.56, 998.57, 998.58, 998.59
procedure codes is provided in Table 1.
Intervention Assessed ICD-9-CM Procedure Codes
Patients meeting these selection criteria were then sub-grouped Transfusion 99.0, 99.00, 99.01, 99.02, 99.03, 99.04, 99.05,
based on the day of the week that the patient was admitted and 99.06, 99.07, 99.09
operated upon; those admitted on a Saturday or Sunday were de-
ICD-9: International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision.
signated as weekend cases while those admitted on any other day ICD-9-CM: International Classification of Diseases, Clinical Modification.
were designated weekday cases. The outcomes of interest were death,
hemorrhagic complications, accidental puncture or laceration,
wound-related complications, infectious complications, transfusion procedures on the weekend were slightly older; were more frequently
of blood products, length of hospital stay, and total hospital charges. male, white, and uninsured; and had less comorbidity at discharge
A complete list of the corresponding procedure and diagnosis codes (Table 3).
for each index occurrence type is provided in Table 2. Finally, the Children undergoing procedures on the weekend were more likely
number of co-morbid conditions was assessed by counting the num- to have been admitted emergently (60.9% vs. 52.6%) and were slightly
ber of unique ICD-9 diagnosis codes associated with each admission. less likely to be at teaching hospitals or at facilities located in the West
region of the country (Table 4). Weekend procedures were less
1.3. Data analysis frequently AD, IHR, and VS and were more frequently App and ORIF
(Table 5).
Gender, race, insurance status (uninsured or insured), number of
co-morbid conditions, geographic region (Northeast, Midwest, South 2.2. Unadjusted outcomes: weekend vs. weekday
or West), type of hospital (urban teaching, urban non-teaching or
rural) and type of surgical procedure performed were compared In unadjusted analysis, 373 (0.11%) patients in the weekday
between weekend vs. weekday admission using Pearson’s chi-square group and 156 (0.14%) in the weekend group died prior to discharge
test for categorical variables and the Kruskal–Wallis test for non- (p = 0.099). Patients undergoing weekend procedures more fre-
normally distributed continuous variables. quently experienced an accidental puncture or laceration (0.21% vs.
Outcomes of surgical procedure performed on the weekend versus 0.18%, p = 0.018) and received transfusion of blood products (0.71%
weekday were compared using multivariable logistic regression and vs. 0.60%, p = 0.002). Patients in the weekend group were less likely
linear regression models adjusting for age, gender, race, insurance to receive the diagnosis of dehisced or non-healing wound (0.11% vs.
status, comorbid diagnoses, geographic region, type of hospital, ad- 0.13%, p = 0.044). The weekend and weekday groups were similar
mission type, and surgical procedure. Adjusted odds ratios (aOR) are with regard to rates of hemorrhage and wound infections (Table 6).
presented using weekday as the reference group. Statistical analyses
were performed using Stata MP, version 11 (College Station, TX). 2.3. Adjusted outcomes: weekend vs. weekday
Table 3
Demographics for patients undergoing weekday versus weekend surgical procedures.
Weekday Weekend
Age (years), mean [SD] 10.8 [4.71] 11.1 [4.46] 10.9 [4.65] b 0.001
Male Gender, n (%) 198,389 (60.6) 69,103 (61.7) 267,492 (60.9) b 0.001
Race, n (%) b 0.001
White 159,022 (48.6) 55,230 (49.3) 214,252 (48.8)
Hispanic 64,583 (19.7) 21,492 (19.2) 86,075 (19.6)
Black 21,820 (6.7) 7,064 (6.3) 28,884 (6.6)
Other/Unknown 81,968 (25.0) 28,278 (25.2) 110,246 (25.1)
Insured, n (%) 292,092 (89.2) 99,651 (88.9) 391,743 (89.1) b 0.001
Number of comorbities, mean[SD] 2.04 [1.70] 2.03 [1.72] 2.04 [1.71] b 0.001
Total (% of all cases) 327,393 (74.5) 112,064 (25.5) 439,457
evidence that mortality is overall increased during weekend hospi- the potential differences in disease severity within each cohort. For
talizations [1–5]. To date, specific adult conditions that have shown example, we wished to not be confounded by a potential scenario
to be subject to a detrimental weekend effect in the literature in- such as gender differences or higher severity trauma on the week-
clude diverticulitis [6], stroke [7], pneumonia [8], TBI [9], and inten- end manifesting as increased mortality following ORIF in this data-
sive care unit admission [10–12]. Children’s hospitals have not been set. Thus, in contrast to the European study, the presumption of a
immune to this phenomenon, particularly in pediatric intensive care systems-based root cause of the outcomes observed in our study is
units [13–16]. This study now adds evidence of a similar phenome- reasonable due to the specific adjustment for clinical and demo-
non, specifically regarding children undergoing common urgent sur- graphic discrepancies between weekend and weekday patient
gical procedures. populations. This indicates to us that patient and disease character-
We believe these findings to be predominately a result of systems istics are not likely to confound our findings of increased mortality on
issues such as decreased availability of staff and other hospital the weekend. In addition, with the possible exception of ORIF, the
resources that contribute to patient care in a manner that is multi- specific procedures chosen do not have any obvious disposition to
factorial and difficult to individually ascertain. Clearly, a tertiary present on the weekend in a different manner than during the week.
hospital-based surgical practice must include the capability to offer One variable that does appear to differ meaningfully is the proportion
emergency surgery regardless of time of day or day of the week. of emergent admissions, which likely reflects the mechanisms by
Furthermore, the quality of this surgical care should indisputably be which these conditions are logistically approached and managed on
maintained as uniformly as possible. Much has been written about Saturday and Sunday when outpatient clinics are closed. However,
the timing of urgent and emergent surgery and the effects of delay, even with multivariate adjustment and the inclusion of comorbid
which tend to be disease specific [17–20]. In this context, weekends diagnoses, it is not possible to eliminate all potential sources of bias.
pose a particular problem as a two-day period during which staffing Unfortunately, indices such as Charlson and Elixhauser tend to under-
levels are often lower and response times protracted, though some estimate comorbid disease in children, and the ability to risk-adjust
studies have questioned the presence of detriment as a result of this pediatric inpatients is currently limited.
effect [21,22]. A positive aspect of this line of thought is that when It is important to recognize and acknowledge the absolute as well
urgent and emergent needs are appropriately anticipated, as in a as relative magnitude of effects noted in this study. The mortality
mature trauma system, thoughtful design of systems can mitigate the associated with pediatric surgical procedures is generally very low,
weekend effect [23]. requiring the large patient numbers included in these cohorts to
One prior study of emergency medical admissions in Europe found detect potential differences. As an illustration, the significant adjusted
an increased weekend mortality that was statistically accounted for odds ratio for mortality of 1.63 represents an increase in actual
by disease severity at presentation [2]. Accordingly, our multivariable unadjusted death rate of only 0.03% (0.14% from 0.11%) It is possible
model incorporated patient and hospital characteristics to adjust for to interpret this as statistical significance without clinical relevance,
which is a phenomenon that can occur in samples of this size. For
example, we believe that our conclusions are supported by the
Table 4 presence of only minimal differences in demographics between
Admission characteristics associated with weekend versus weekday surgical procedures.
patients presenting during the week and on the weekend, but even
Admission Day of Procedure Total p these slight discrepancies reach statistical significance in Table 3.
Characteristics Nevertheless, we emphasize that a reduction of weekend mortality to
Weekday Weekend
Table 6
Unadjusted outcomes associated with weekend versus weekday surgical procedures.
Weekday Weekend
the levels seen during the workweek would represent a greater than common weekend cases in our institution’s NSQIP-Pediatric database,
20% reduction of inpatient death representing approximately 30 results may not generalize to centers with a different case-mix.
patients over the study period. And, though the change in absolute The potential implications of this study are two-fold. First, are
mortality rate is indeed modest, it is accompanied by increases in there design shortcomings within hospital systems that deliver
other perioperative complications in the multivariable adjustment pediatric surgical care that can be improved to mitigate the dele-
model—namely blood transfusion and procedural complication. This terious outcomes that we have identified? This possibility motivates
suggests that further analysis of the root causes related to differential further study to detail the multifactorial effects of weekend staffing
morbidity and mortality observed during the weekend and involving on patient care. For instance, it is unclear whether the increased
these common procedures could identify broader risks within the weekend mortality can be traced to the timeliness and quality of clinical
health care delivery system and be hypothesis generating in terms of interventions delivered in emergency departments, in operating rooms,
systems design. or in recovery areas. The increase in procedural complications could be
Other limitations of this study include potential error stemming arguably localized to the operating room, potentially as a function of the
from deficiencies in the NIS and KID databases. Coding errors may expertise or workload of available staff. Even if not occurring during
exist, though systemic differences in coding accuracy between the index procedure, an increase in “accidental perforation by catheter
weekday and weekend admissions are unlikely, as administrative or other instrument during a procedure” (ICD-9 description of 998.2)
coding is usually performed by dedicated staff during business hours. suggests a systemic cause of provider error. A recent study reporting
Furthermore, our reliance on administrative admission date when that degree of pediatric specialization of surgeons affects outcomes
applying inclusion criteria will artificially exclude some emergent could also be relevant in this context if provider training and
cases, as when a patient is admitted at 10:00 PM on Saturday and background vary substantially after hours [24].
subsequently taken for procedure three hours later at 1:00 AM on Secondly, given the disparities in personnel that exist between
Sunday (i.e. excluded because the procedure was not performed on weekends and weekdays, are there surgical conditions for which the
the same day as admission). Late Friday night cases would be similarly systems-based benefit of delay would outweigh the traditionally
excluded even if the operation was the same calendar day, as only perceived risk of delaying surgical intervention? Alternatively, is there
Saturday and Sunday were considered as weekend days. Lastly, sufficient justification for hospitals to commit to extended operating
though the inclusion of specific cases was predicated on the most room hours with full staffing? Further studies with cost analysis
would be required to answer these questions.
In conclusion, this study examined a large population of children
in two national inpatient databases and identified a significant in-
crease in the rates of blood transfusion, periprocedural complications,
and postoperative mortality following urgent pediatric surgical pro-
cedures that were performed upon admission on a weekend. While
the exact etiology of these findings is not clear, these findings moti-
vate a careful search for systems-based deficiencies that may be a
detriment to pediatric surgical care provided on the weekend.
References
[1] Bell CM, Redelmeier DA. Mortality among patients admitted to hospitals on
weekends as compared with weekdays. N Engl J Med 2001;345:663–8.
[2] Mikulich O, Callaly E, Bennett K, et al. The increased mortality associated with a
weekend emergency admission is due to increased illness severity and altered
case-mix. Acute Med 2011;10:182–7.
[3] Freemantle N, Richardson M, Wood J, et al. Weekend hospitalization and additional
risk of death: an analysis of inpatient data. J R Soc Med 2012;105:74–84.
[4] Buckley D, Bulger D. Trends and weekly and seasonal cycles in the rate of errors in
the clinical management of hospitalized patients. Chronobiol Int 2012 Aug;29(7):
947–54.
[5] Cram P, Hillis SL, Barnett M, et al. Effects of weekend admission and hospital
teaching status on in-hospital mortality. Am J Med 2004;117:151–7.
[6] Worni M, Schudel IM, Østbye T, et al. Worse outcomes in patients undergoing
urgent surgery for left-sided diverticulitis admitted on weekends vs weekdays: a
Fig. 1. Adjusted odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals for selected postoperative population-based study of 31 832 patients. Arch Surg 2012;147:649–55.
complications following surgical procedures performed on weekends (referenced to [7] Tung Y, Chang G, Chen Y. Associations of physician volume and weekend admis-
weekdays). Adjusted for type of procedure performed, patient age, sex, insurance status sions with ischemic stroke outcome in Taiwan: a nationwide population-based
and number of diagnoses, hospital characteristics, and admission year. study. Med Care 2009;47:1018–25.
S.D. Goldstein et al. / Journal of Pediatric Surgery 49 (2014) 1087–1091 1091
[8] Chang G, Tung Y. Factors associated with pneumonia outcomes: a nationwide [16] Hixson ED, Davis S, Morris S, et al. Do weekends or evenings matter in a pediatric
population-based study over the 1997–2008 period. J Gen Intern Med 2012;27: intensive care unit?Pediatr Crit Care Med 2005;6:523–30 619–621.
527–33. [17] Papandria D, Goldstein SD, Rhee D, et al. Risk of perforation increases with delay in
[9] Schneider EB, Hirani SA, Hambridge HL, et al. Beating the weekend trend: recognition and surgery for acute appendicitis. J Surg Res 2013 Oct;184(2):723–9.
increased mortality in older adult traumatic brain injury (TBI) patients admitted [18] Kluger Y, Ben-Ishay O, Sartelli M, et al. World society of emergency surgery study
on weekends. J Surg Res 2012;177:295–300. group initiative on Timing of Acute Care Surgery classification (TACS). World J
[10] Barnett MJ, Kaboli PJ, Sirio CA, et al. Day of the week of intensive care admission Emerg Surg 2013;8.
and patient outcomes: a multisite regional evaluation. Med Care 2002;40:530–9. [19] Ingraham AM, Cohen ME, Bilimoria KY, et al. Effect of delay to operation on
[11] Bhonagiri D, Pilcher DV, Bailey MJ. Increased mortality associated with after-hours outcomes in adults with acute appendicitis. Arch Surg 2010;145:886–92.
and weekend admission to the intensive care unit: a retrospective analysis. Med J [20] Gurusamy KS, Samraj K, Davidson BR. Early versus delayed laparoscopic
Aust 2011;194:287–92. cholecystectomy for biliary colic. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2008 Oct 8;(4):
[12] Laupland KB, Shahpori R, Kirkpatrick AW, et al. Hospital mortality among adults CD007196.
admitted to and discharged from intensive care on weekends and evenings. J Crit [21] Kim S, Hong K, Hwang S, et al. Weekend admission in patients with acute ischemic
Care 2008;23:317–24. stroke is not associated with poor functional outcome than weekday admission.
[13] Fendler W, Baranowska-Jazwiecka A, Hogendorf A, et al. Weekend matters: Friday J Clin Neurol (Korea) 2012;8:265–70.
and Saturday admissions are associated with prolonged hospitalization of [22] Worni M, Ostbye T, Gandhi M, et al. Laparoscopic appendectomy outcomes on the
children. Clin Pediatr (Phila) 2013 Sep;52(9):875–8. weekend and during the week are no different: a national study of 151,774
[14] Salihu HM, Ibrahimou B, August EM, et al. Risk of infant mortality with weekend patients. World J Surg 2012 Jul;36(7):1527–33.
versus weekday births: a population-based study. J Obstet Gynaecol Res 2012 [23] Carr BG, Reilly PM, Schwab CW, et al. Weekend and night outcomes in a statewide
Jul;38(7):973–9. trauma system. Arch Surg 2011;146:810–7.
[15] Arias Y, Taylor DS, Marcin JP. Association between evening admissions and higher [24] Rhee, et al. Comparison of pediatric surgical outcomes by the surgeon's degree of
mortality rates in the pediatric intensive care unit. Pediatrics 2004;113:e530–4. specialization in children. J Pediatr Surg 2013;48(8):1657–63.