Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Cellar workplaces are considered as confined environment with challenging indoor air quality
having higher than normal pollutants particularly that of soil gas origin. Radon, a major soil gas,
infiltrates and accumulates within indoor spaces and becomes harmful in the absence of ventilation.
Radon level in bank basements (cellars) in Ilorin, Lagos and Akure have been sampled and analysed
in this study. In Nigeria, most workers in basements are unaware of radon, and there is limited
documented research on its health hazards. The survey parameters of radon concentrations were
floor types, geographical locations and the influence of atmospheric conditions. Corentium monitor,
a continuous, digital radon monitor, temperature meters and Prologue wireless weather station
were used for the experiments. Annual average indoor radon concentration for the survey period
was 23 Bq/m3. The calculated mean annual effective doses in basements and different floors were
below the recommended ICTR level of 3 mSv/y.
Nomenclature
𝐶𝑅𝑛 Radon concentration, 𝐵𝑞 ⁄𝑚3 𝐻 Occupancy factor
𝐷 Dose conversion factor, 9 × 10−6 𝑚𝑆𝑣 ⁄ℎ⁄(𝐵𝑞 ⁄𝑚3 ) 𝑇 Time, ℎ𝑟
𝐸 Annual mean effective dose 𝐹 Equilibrium factor (0.4)
potentially causing an increase in the incidence of lung meteorological and geological conditions, lifestyle,
cancer [4]. The main radon source in most above construction materials, and ventilation [10].
ground workplaces with high radon concentrations is Radon is one of the most pervasive and serious global
the soil, but there can also be significant contributions indoor air concerns, organisations such as the
from building materials, groundwater, storage and International Commission on Radiological Protection
processing of large amounts of materials with elevated (ICRP), the European Radon Association (ERA), the
concentrations of radium. Radon is ubiquitous, it is International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), the
found everywhere in workplaces and dwellings, but United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of
levels vary from place to place and over time [4]. Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR) have made numerous
Occupied basements with air-tighter built envelopes, statements on radon gas [11-13] and [4]. They focus
are particularly utilised in the Banking industry in on setting radon reference/action levels for radon in
Nigeria, where the vault is often located in the air for different building types, producing maps
basement. These bank basements not only showing areas of high radon potential and
accommodate their vaults but also are substantially incorporating radon preventive measures into new
used for workspaces for the treasury staff. Basement constructions. Many countries, as a result of their
vaults are listed by Canadian Centre for Occupational numerous studies and interventions, now have active
Health and Safety as a confined place that require radon programmes in operation.The U.S EPA in
additional safety and health regulation [5]. Money 2015[9]recommended taking actions to reduce radon
stored in the basements vaults as in the case with the exposure if levels exceed four picocuries per liter of air
Central Bank of Nigeria buildings and large deposit (4 pCi/L). At the action level of 200 Bq/m3, there is
banks poses additional discomfort and health approximately a 3% life time risk of developing cancer
challenge to workers in these confined spaces. Uneke as a result of radon exposure [9] and [14].
and Ogbu in 2007 [6] observed that 90% of Nigerian Extensive radon surveys have been carried out in
bank notes in circulation were contaminated with many countries only in dwellings, whereas surveys in
either bacteria or fungi. Indoor air in these particular workplaces are rather sparse and generally restricted
basements are already contaminated by their contents to specific workplaces/activities, for example, schools
if the ventilation is not effective and the workers that and caves. The occupational exposure to radon in
spend substantial fraction of their time within these Nigeria has not generated much study as expected.
confined spaces of the buildings are at risk of Few studies have been performed in order to improve
contracting Building Related Illness (BRI). the knowledge of radon levels in workplaces with
Unfortunately, most of these basements vaults are not particular attention to schools. Obed, et. al [10]
tested for Radon and other chemical and conducted an indoor Radon survey in a university
microbiological infestations in third world countries campus of Nigeria; they measured the Radon
and in most cases the only protection available to concentration in 24 offices at the University of Ibadan,
workers in these confined environments is the face Nigeria and found out an average 293.3 Bq/ m 3in the
mask. offices. Afolabi, et. al [15] used a Pro 3-series radon
Radon, a typical soil gas normally dissipates detector to determine the radon levels in randomly
harmlessly into outdoor air, but it also flows into selected offices at the Obafemi Awolowo University,
buildings through cracks and gaps in the foundation, Ile-Ife; and their results revealed that the radon level
eventually reaching unsafe levels in lower floors and obtained in the sampled offices ranged from 0.0 to
basements [7]. It becomes an indoor air pollution 5.3 pCi/L (196 Bq/m3). The radon concentrations were
problem when it penetrates into buildings directly from all found to be within the reference levels of ICRP, but
the soil or is emitted from building materials and the availability of information on national scale is non-
accumulates inside the buildings [8]. Radon (222Rn) is existent.Of the few studies and surveys of indoor
a colourless, odourless, and tasteless radioactive gas radon concentrations carried out in Nigeria, no
formed from radium (226Ra), which is a decay product systematic study has investigated radon levels in
of Uranium (238U). It has a half-life of 3.8 days, and occupied basements. Therefore, this paper seeks to
tends to concentrate in enclosed spaces like investigate Radon concentrations in selected bank
underground mines, basements and crawl spaces basements and also increase public awareness about
[9].222Rn concentrations in dwellings depend on the radon hazard to workers in this confined space.
difference in radon levels, can be attributed to local Akure has the lowest Radon concentration in the2nd
geological characteristics. Interestingly the south west floor, while Lagos has the least Radon concentration
regions, Akure, (6.92Bq/m3) and Lagos (5.18Bq/m3) across floors except in 2nd floor. More so, Ilorin has the
showed quite low regional averages when compared highest mean and standard deviation (11.05Bq/m3;
with the North-Central zone city of Ilorin (23 Bq/m3). 5.882Bq/m3), while Lagos has the least (5.45Bq/m3,
However much higher radon concentration values 1.401Bq/m3).
(293.3Bq/m3) were obtained by [10] in a University of The implication of the variation in radon concentration
Ibadan campus survey of classrooms and offices. across the floor can be further understood by
The results from Ilorin city are in good agreement with estimating the radiation dose the workers in the
previous studies performed in dwellings and wells in basement and other floors are exposed to by virtue of
Zaria [20]. Ibadan and Zaria are within the South-West their locations in the bank building. The effective dose
and North-West geo-political zones of Nigeria of radon in the Ilorin study location was analyzed as a
respectively. case study.
Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used to test if there
is any significant difference between the radon 5.4 Effective Dose of Radon (Ilorin)
concentrations in Akure, Ilorin, and Lagos. The radon The effective dose of radon in mSv/y at any location
concentration in the three cities are considered depends upon the occupancy factor. The banks
significantly different between the radon management as a policy allow workers to alternate
concentrations in the three locations if p-value < their work periods on 2-week off and on basis. The
0.05.The F statistics was calculated as 3.072, at 5 bank’s basement workers occupancy factor was
percent level of significance under 2 degrees of determind as below:
freedom, the returned p-value of 0.071 was found 40 (ℎ⁄𝑤) × 26 (𝑤𝑘 ⁄𝑦𝑟) = 1040 ℎ⁄𝑦𝑟
greater than the level of significance (0.05); p > 0.05. The Occupancy factor(𝐻):
Thus, there is no significant difference between the 𝐻 = 1040ℎ⁄8760ℎ = 0.12
radon concentrations in the three selected locations. The bank’s workers in other floors will have an
However, the difference between the radon occupancy factor determind as below:
concentrations in the three selected locations is 40(ℎ⁄𝑤𝑘) × 44 (𝑤𝑘 ⁄𝑦𝑟) = 1760 (ℎ⁄𝑦𝑟 )
significant at 0.1 level of significance. The Occupancy factor (𝐻)
𝐻 = 1760 ℎ⁄8760ℎ = 0.20
5.3 Effects of Other Floors on Basement Indoor The annual mean effective dose to the occupants of
Radon Concentration these offices due to exposure to radon and its progeny
Table 2 below shows that Ilorin has the highest Radon was estimated by following [13].
concentration in the basement and other upper floors. 𝐸 = 𝐶𝑅𝑛 × 𝐻 × 𝐹 × 𝐷 × 𝑇 (1)
Table 3: The annual mean effective dose to the occupants in the floors (Ilorin)
Space type Radon Concentration Effective Dose (E), (mSv/y)
(CRn)(Bq/m3)
Basement 23.68 0.0896
Ground Floor 11.84 0.0747
First Floor 5.18 0.0326
Second Floor 5.92 0.0377
With this occupancy, the exposure of workers to A weather station was setup 20 meters from the
radon is reduced in the case of maximum radon building to record all relevant weather data hourly.
concentration (equals to 107 Bq/m3), the effective The result of the seasons are as shown in Tables 4,
dose was calculated to be 0.4049 mSv/y. The 5, 6 and 7. The tables display the maximum radon
reduced occupancy time gives rise to low doses in the concentration, humidity, air temperature and wind
case of bank’s basement staff when compared to the speed. Table 6 and 7 show that Ilorin has the highest
staff occupying the ground floor with a reduced radon Radon concentration in both dry and wet seasons,
concentration (11.84Bq/m3), but with almost an followed by Akure, while Lagos has the least Radon
equivalent annual mean of radon effective dose concentration. More so, Radon Concentrations in
exposure of 0.0747mSv/y and 0.0896mSv/y in the Ilorin has the highest mean and standard deviation.
ground floor and basement respectively. The radon The table shows further that the Radon
concentration and effective dose were found to be concentrations in dry season across the three
lower in the first floor than the second floor. This can geographical locations are higher than those of the
be explained by the space conditions of the measured wet season.
floors. The first floor is a mezzanine floor which allows The humidity in Lagos is highest in the two seasons,
higher air flow from the mechanical ventilations while the air temperature and wind speed varies
system than is obtainable at the second floor. Recent across the cities. The air temperature appears to have
epidemiological findings from residential studies little effect on the radon concentration, while
demonstrate a statistically significant increase of lung humidity has an inverse relationship with the radon
cancer risk from prolonged exposure to indoor radon concentration which reduces as the humidity
even at low level of exposure [3]. increases. The result is in agreement with the
findings of Schumann et. al [21] that the most
5.5 The Effect of Weather Condition at important factors appear to be precipitation (as it
Different Geographical Locations affects soil moisture conditions) and barometric
Indoor air qualities are greatly impacted by the air pressure. They further stated that radon transport is
quality outside of the buildings. The time that the generally inhibited by soil moisture because water
data were taken was divided between dry and wet tends to block soil pores, reducing the gas
seasons. Dry season has been set between October permeability of the soil resulting in lower values of
and April, and Wet set between May and September. radon in the wet seasons.
Workshop"http://www.herca.org/uploaditems/
The t-test statistics was calculated as 1.725, at 5 documents/151020%20-
percent level of significance under 4 degrees of %20WS%20Radon/Radon%20WS%20final%2
freedom, the returned p-value of 0.160 was found 0Report.pdf. Accessed 21 March, 2017.
greater than the level of significance (0.05); p > 0.05. [4] International Atomic Energy Agency."Radiation
Thus, it is concluded that there is no significant protection against radon in work places
difference between the radon concentration in dry and other than Mines". http://www-
wet seasons. pub.iaea.org/MTCD/publications/PDF/Pub1168
_web.pdf Accessed on 21 February, 2017.