You are on page 1of 8

Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Informatics in Medicine Unlocked


journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/imu

Efficient balance technique for brain-computer interface applications based


on I/Q down converter and time interleaved ADCs
Shams Al Ajrawi a, *, Walid Al-Hussaibi b, Ramesh Rao a, Mahasweta Sarkar c
a
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of California San Diego, CA, USA
b
Department of Electrical Techniques, Basrah Technical Institute, Southern Technical University, Basrah, Iraq
c
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, San Diego State University, San Diego, CA, 92182, USA

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Keywords: With the widespread of Internet of things, varied innovative tools are required to control the nearby smart
BCI communications devices. In this contest, brain-computer interface (BCI) technology can empower individuals to directly control
IoT varied electronic devices such as those used in smart home/office and associative robots via their thoughts. This
I/Q down converter
process requires efficient transmission of electro-corticographical (ECoG) signals from implanted electrodes in­
LMS algorithm
Time-interleaved ADCs
side the brain to an external receiver located outside on the scalp. However, the realization of this vision is still
challenging task due to the limited reliability of adopted wireless BCI communication systems. In particular, the
generated artifacts due to in-phase/quadrature (I/Q) imbalance of utilized down converter and time interleaved
analog-to-digital converters (ADCs) may lead to significant interference to desired signal which affects the
detection performance. In this paper, an efficient low complexity balance technique is proposed for BCI com­
munications to mitigate the interference using the adaptive least mean square (LMS) algorithm. Performance
results of conducted experiments on a near-realistic phantom human brain model are shown to validate the
designed balanced BCI (BBCI) scheme compared with the existing BCI approach.

1. Introduction machines, and other modern smart home applications. This will make
the home/office environment more accessible and comfortable for
During the last decade, intensive research efforts have been per­ disabled persons as well as normal users by simply employing their
formed on the promising brain-computer interface (BCI) technology for neuronal signals (i.e. brain reactions and thoughts) [7–10].
various health applications. It is used mainly to facilitate direct
communication links between the central nervous system of human 1.1. Technical background
beings with the external electronic devices. This approach can be
considered as a novel extension to the initial objective of BCI, repre­ Most of persons with tetraplegia have flawless cerebrum work but
sented by the realization of immediate communication environment cannot move due to some damage/infection that influences the spinal
between the brain and embedded devices, to help patients suffering from cord. Therefore, different BCI schemes are developed to sidestep the
spinal cord injuries, paralysis situations, and amyotrophic lateral scle­ harmed nerves and build up an alternative connection between brain
rosis [1–5]. In practice, BCI schemes have the effects to reduce the need signals and embedded devices to re-establish muscles’ development or
for typical information delivery methods and then improve the lifestyle co-appointment of paralyzed muscles [7,11]. For instance, Fig. 1(a)
of disabled persons. shows how the bypass wireless channel can handle the wireless trans­
On the other hand, massive number of devices/machines can be mission of brain messages as encoded data through BCI to activate and
connected to the Internet, usually referred as the Internet of things (IoT), control the movement of paralyzed arm through external controller
allowing a fundament shift on the way that individuals can interact with (brain spine interface, BSI) or implanted device. The implementation of
the surrounding objects [6]. Therefore, the integration of IoT and BCI utilized BCI requires bio-compatible electrodes for signal interface with
schemes represents an emerging technology to control varied personal neurons in the brain’s cortex and an external transceiver device on the
phones and computers, electronic and wearable devices, smart scalp to receive the electro-corticographical (ECoG) signals and

* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: salajraw@eng.ucsd.edu (S. Al Ajrawi), alhussaibi@stu.edu.iq (W. Al-Hussaibi), rrao@ucsd.edu (R. Rao), msarkar2@mail.sdsu.edu (M. Sarkar).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.imu.2019.100276
Received 27 October 2019; Received in revised form 26 November 2019; Accepted 29 November 2019
Available online 16 December 2019
2352-9148/© 2019 Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
S. Al Ajrawi et al. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

retransmit them to intended controller on the defective part of disabled found when extracting one or more channels in multi-channel filter
person’s body [3]. banks. This will have direct impact to improve the performance of BCI
On the other side, BCI can be considered as an emerging alternative system significantly.
for supporting interaction between IoT objects and individuals as shown
in Fig. 1 (b). In this scenario, the ECoG signals of wheelchair user are 1.2. Aims and contributions
transmitted with high data rate to the implanted external transceiver on
the scalp and then to the analyzer device (such as computer, tablet, and The employment of signal processing techniques to undo the signal
smart phone) for data analysis and examinations with pre-portrayed degradation caused by the analog I/Q imbalance is adopted as an effi­
examples. The determined person’s order is then sent through IoT cient solution in varied electrical, electronic, and communication sys­
network to the intended smart devices/applications for desired actions. tems [15–20]. This comes against the common idea that this kind of
In any of the aforesaid BCI applications, information messages are distortion is challenging and irreversible [14]. In this paper, we aim to
transmitted with high data rate using one of the well-known signal mitigate the inherited I/Q imbalance in BCI communication systems
modulation methods such as quadrature phase shift keying (QPSK) to using low complexity balance technique to achieve the target perfor­
the receiver side [11–13]. Besides, efficient BCI communication system mance and exploit this important technology.
can be determined typically when a distortion free transmission from the The main contributions of this work are summarized as follows:
wireless transmitter inside the brain to the receiver end on the scalp is
achieved. However, realization of this target is difficult owing to the � An efficient low complexity balance technique is proposed for BCI
effect of in-phase/quadrature (I/Q) imbalance in the employed fre­ communications to mitigate the interference caused by I/Q imbal­
quency down converter and time interleaved analog-to-digital con­ ance using the adaptive least mean square (LMS) algorithm. The
verters (TI-ADCs) at the receiver processor. In particular, the gain and integration of these cost-effective approaches is very important for
phase imbalance in the two paths of analog processor can cause unde­ feasible BCI applications toward wide adoption of this technology.
sired coupling between the positive and negative frequency components � For the considered technique, we present the time model of I/Q
of the signal carried by these paths [14–22]. This may potentially lead to mismatch in BCI and the employed adaptive cancellers to correct the
considerable interference level to desired signal which affects the DC offsets and imbalance defects of frequency down converter and
detection performance, and hence the required response. Therefore, QPSK signalling. A balanced model is demonstrated then to cancel
controlling this kind of mismatch is very important in the utilized re­ the DC offsets and spectral artifacts produced by the pair of TI-ADCs.
ceivers that detect signals spanning a wide range of levels as might be

Fig. 1. BCI applications: (a) Spinal cord using by-pass wireless channel; (b) Brain control for smart devices and IoT network.

2
S. Al Ajrawi et al. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

� Performance outcomes of conducted tests on a near-realistic phan­ reader is supported with an antenna and Ethernet connection for data
tom model of human brain demonstrate the effectiveness of designed transmission to intended controllers such as laptops/smartphones.
balanced BCI (BBCI) scheme compared with the generic BCI in Refs.
[3,11]. 3. Proposed balance technique for BCI

The rest of this paper is organized as follows: In Section 2, the system For QPSK signalling, a balanced modulator is required which can be
model of BCI communications is described. Section 3 presents the pro­ comprised of two matched amplitude modulation modules. However,
posed balance technique for BCI applications. Section 4 deals with maintaining perfect balance between these modulation modules over RF
conducted experiments and performance results. Discussion on the carrier is not an easy process in BCI communication system. This kind of
achieved results is presented in Section 5. Finally, Section 6 concludes imbalance between I/Q channels may result in a signal distortion
the paper. leading to undesired inter channel interference (ICI) and increased error
rate performance [12]. For instance when a target bit error rate of 10 6
2. System model of BCI communications is desired, the required levels of amplitude imbalance and phase
imbalance should not exceed 1 dB and 5o , respectively [15,16]. There­
In this work, we consider a wireless BCI communication system for fore, an efficient low complexity balance method is proposed in the
health applications as shown in Fig. 2. It consists of implanted BCI following.
transmitter unit, wireless channel, and receiver device. The brain ECoG
signals from implanted electrodes are modulated using QPSK technique,
and the generated radio frequency (RF) signals are transmitted then over 3.1. IQ down converter
wireless channel through brain tissues to the fixed receiver on the scalp.
The received RF signal with an additive white Gaussian noise compo­ The received QPSK ECoG signal in BCI is processed using IQ down
nent is pre-filtered as in the typical communications systems to elimi­ converter which consists of two branches of multipliers, low pass filters
nate the noise effects [23]. Then, it will be down converted and sampled (LPFs), and ADCs as shown in Fig. 3(a). The in-phase and quadrature
using ADC unit for signal demodulation. The demodulated brain signals components for down conversion are represented by I ¼ cosðωtÞ and Q ¼
are processed to prepare the information and control messages for sinðωtÞ, respectively, where ω ¼ 2πf, and f denotes the carrier fre­
response/analyzer device, while a parameter estimation and balance quency. The mismatch in IQ down converter which leads to ICI is shown
unit is used to solve the problem of I/Q imbalance in BCI system. in the second path due to phase distortion ðαÞ and gain distortion ð1 þεÞ
Note that the propagation delay due to wireless signal propagation elements. The time-domain model of I/Q mismatch is demonstrated in
between the implanted electrodes and the reader on the scalp through Fig. 3(b). This model shows also the insertion of DC components in both
human tissues can be mitigated using multiple in-brain transmitters and of in-phase and quadrature paths due to the utilized ADCs. This can be
relevant multiple access technique as in Ref. [3]. This has direct impact explained mathematically without showing the time index n as
to satisfy the required user experience. But, signal propagation delay
between mounted device on the scalp and computer/smart devices I ’ ¼ I þ DCI (1)
through indoor wireless channel has no significant impact on the per­
formance of BCI as in the existing wireless systems [24]. Moreover, other Qj ¼ Qð1 þ 2 Þ þ αI þ DCQ (2)
signal processing delays can be ignored based on the advancement in
where α ¼ η ​ sinðφÞ; ε ¼ η ​ cosðφÞ 1; η and φ represent the amplitude
digital signal processing chips [4].
and phase elements of distortion signal, respectively. So, the quadrature
As in our previous work [3], a wireless identification sensing plat­
component can be simplified and rewritten as
form 5 (WISP5) is used for the adopted BCI system. It is based on a
passive RF identification (RFID) tag that works on an ultra-low power Q’ ¼ η sinðωt þ φÞ þ DCQ (3)
and micro-controller for sensing, processing, and communication [25].
The receiver on the scalp is implemented using RFID reader such as It can be seen that the I and Q signal components are not orthogonal due
Impinj’s Speedway model [26]. This RFID model is used to detect the to gain and phase imbalance as well as DC insertion in both of signal
WISP signals and also emits RF signals (in the frequency range 908–928 paths. Therefore, α and ε elements should be estimated, as b α and bε , for
MHz) to send commands and power to the implanted WISP tags. The possible signal correction with DC cancellation.

Fig. 2. System model of a general wireless BCI communications.

3
S. Al Ajrawi et al. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

Fig. 4. Adaptive canceller Model for BBCI scheme.

between desired and actual signals). This method is based on a sto­


chastic gradient-descent where the filter coefficients are adapted based
on the realized error at current time instant (more details can be found in
Ref. [27]). Therefore, to mitigate the ICI, the adaptive LMS algorithm is
used in our model to estimate the phase and gain parameters, b α ðnÞ and
ε ðnÞ, at current time sample n from actual values by minimizing the
b
following cost functions
n o n o
C α ðnÞ ¼ E jeα ðnÞj2 ¼ E jbα ðnÞ αðnÞj2 (4)

n� o n� o
� �
C ε ðnÞ ¼ E �eε ðnÞj2 ¼ E �bε ðnÞ εðnÞj2 (5)

where Ef:g is the expectation (mean) operator while eα ðnÞ and eε ðnÞ
denote the errors at the current time sample n. The parameters α b ðnÞ and
ε ðnÞ are used then to find bIðnÞ and QðnÞ
b b signals, respectively.

Fig. 3. IQ down converter: (a) I/Q mismatch representation; (b) Time-domain


4. Experimental setup of BBCI and results
model of I/Q mismatch.

To show the effectiveness of BBCI, we have conducted different ex­


periments on phantom brain model. We replicate the near-realistic brain
environment using salt water as blood, glycerine to mimic tissues, and
plastic baker to mimic the skull. These adopted materials are used due to
their close dielectric properties with the brain. A single wireless sensor
(WISP5) is used to transmit the collected signals from implanted elec­
3.2. TI-ADCs trodes at a depth of 2 cm in the brain tissue to the BBCI receiver on the
scalp. The considered experimental setup for this work is shown in
In the utilized receiver, ADCs are used to convert the modulated RF Fig. 5. To the best of our knowledge, this work is the first of its kind and
signal into digital form. This is followed by signal detection using digital there is no close reference for fair comparisons. Therefore, we have
signal processing unit to extract the transmitted ECoG messages. In this compared the achieved results with that generated from the generic BCI
case, the ADCs need to convert analog signals of large bandwidth to scheme without balance technique in Refs. [3,11] to validate the pro­
digital forms with high processing speed and sufficient conversion ac­ posed BBCI design.
curacy. To avoid the aliasing effects, the sampling rate fs must fulfil the Performance of the DC canceller in BBCI is demonstrated in Fig. 6
Nyquist rate at least (i.e. fs � 2f). In general, the sampling rate can be which shows how fast the trajectory curve can learn as a function of time
increased using parallel ADCs with different sampling points of time, samples (for both in-phase and quadrature components) and then effi­
and higher digitization rate can be obtained by interleaving the outputs cient cancellation process for the system DC offset. Similarly, Fig. 7
of each ADC using TI-ADC approach. However, time interleaving in demonstrates the fast convergence of phase and gain estimates based on
ADCs may produce unwanted artifacts in the signal’s spectrum (due to LMS algorithm to detect the signals without distortion.
DCI and DCQ components) and ultimately leads to performance loss and
accuracy degradation. Therefore, removal/correction of the unwanted
artifacts in TI-ADCs is very essential to achieve high system performance
[16].

3.3. Adaptive canceller model for BBCI

To mitigate the drawbacks of down converter and TI-ADCs, an


adaptive canceller model based on the well-known LMS algorithm [27]
is designed for BBCI scheme as shown in Fig. 4. The DC cancellation
units are used to remove the DCI and DCQ components from desired I and
Q signals, respectively. Besides, α and ε estimation units with LMS
technique are used to provide α
b and bε elements, respectively for desired
signals’ correction.
The LMS algorithm is one of the adaptive filter approaches typically
used to estimate the desired filter coefficients which have the effect to
produce the least mean of squared error signal (i.e. the difference Fig. 5. Experimental setup of BBCI using near-realistic phantom brain model.

4
S. Al Ajrawi et al. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

Fig. 6. Learning curves of the in-phase and quadrature DC components (amplitude in volts) of BBCI as a function of time samples.

Fig. 7. Parameter estimation based on LMS algorithm: (a) Phase estimate in radian as a function of samples; (b) Gain estimate in volts as a function of samples.

The impact of ICI in BBCI scheme with QPSK signalling is shown in DC cancellation as a function of the number of received time instance
Fig. 8 through Lissajous patterns and constellation diagrams of detected for: (a) first 2000 samples and (b) last 2000 samples. The spectrum of
signals. From Fig. 8(a) of Lissajous patterns, it can be seen clearly that output signal of balanced model is demonstrated also in (c) for the first
both of phase and gain components (distorted BCI signals) are corrected 2000 samples and (d) for the last 2000 samples. These figures demon­
by the end of balancing process using BBCI scheme. This is shown also in strate that the first samples will suffer from possible signal distortion due
Fig. 8(b) where a clear QPSK constellation is achieved for BBCI system to imperfect estimation of the system parameters. But, the system will
after cancellation of the DC offset, phase error, and gain imbalance. converge to best estimate and produce reliable performance as the time
The spectrum (in log magnitude) of TI-ADCs is shown in Fig. 9 after samples grow.

5
S. Al Ajrawi et al. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

Fig. 8. QPSK of distorted (BCI signals) and non-distorted signal components (BBCI signals): (a) Lisasajous patterns; (b) Signal constellation.

5. Discussion cost-effective balance technique which includes parameter estimation


and balance circuits. In this case, the unwanted coupling between fre­
Signal processing techniques are widely used to considerably alle­ quency components of I/Q signals is removed in an effective manner.
viate the possible signal degradation produced by the I/Q imbalance in This is reflected on the received signal constellation and hence the
diverse electrical, electronic, and communication systems [15–20]. performance of BBCI system for modern and future special purpose
Therefore, the existing I/Q down converters and LMS techniques are wireless applications.
used in this research to overcome the problem of I/Q imbalance in
conventional BCI communication schemes that greatly affects the sys­ 6. Conclusions
tem performance. To the best of our knowledge, the integration of these
existing methods into BCI system is the first of its kind and demonstrated In this paper, an adaptive low complexity balance technique based
a cost-effective solution for feasible wireless BCI applications. on LMS algorithm is designed for wireless BCI communications to
The achieved results of proposed balance technique over near- mitigate the inherent interference due to I/Q imbalance of utilized down
realistic environment demonstrate the effectiveness of designed BBCI converter and TI-ADCs. The achieved performance results of conducted
communication system with approximately distortion free QPSK trans­ experiments on a near-realistic phantom human brain model demon­
mission. This has been validated through different performance mea­ strate the effectiveness of proposed scheme compared with the existing
sures such as trajectories of parameters estimation, Lissajous patterns of BCI. It shows fast convergence of estimated phase and gain parameters
the I/Q components, and signal constellation diagrams. It is shown that and accurate DC offset cancellation that allow an improved QPSK per­
the inherited effects of I/Q imbalance in the employed down converter formance. In future work, the blind equalization technique will be used
and TI-ADCs (i.e. DC offsets and spectral artifacts), as in the existing BCI to demonstrate the complexity-performance tradeoff. Besides, perfor­
system in Refs. [3,11], can be mitigated using low complexity and mance analysis and evaluation over actual human brain environment

6
S. Al Ajrawi et al. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

Fig. 9. Spectrum (log magnitude) of TI-ADCs after dc cancelling as a function of time instance for: (a) first 2000 samples and (b) last 2000 samples. Spectrum of
output signal of balanced model for (c) first 2000 samples and (d) last 2000 samples.

will be considered. References

[1] Meng J, Streitz T, Gulachek N, Suma D, He B. Three-dimensional brian-computer


Declaration of competing interest interface control through simultaneous overt spatial attentional and motor imagery
tasks. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng Nov. 2018;65(11):2417–27.
[2] Belkacem A, Nishio S, Suzuki T, Ishiguro H, Hirata M. Neuromagnetic decoding of
All authors have no conflict of interest to report. simultaneous bilateral hand movements for multidimensional brain-machine
interfaces. IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng Jun. 2018;26(6):1301–10.
[3] Al Ajrawi S, Bialek H, Sarkar M, Rao R, Ahmed S. Bi-directional channel modeling
Acknowledgements for implantable UHF-RFID transceivers in BCI applications. Future Gener Comput
Syst Jun. 2018;88:683–92.
[4] Ando H, Takizawa K, Yoshida T, Matsushita K, Hirata M, Suzuki T. Wireless
Authors’ Contributions Shams AL AJRAWI, Walid AL-HUSSAIBI,
multicannel neural recording with a 128-Mbps UWB transmitter for an implantable
Ramesh RAO, and Mahasweta Sarkar: provided the conception and brain-machine interfaces. IEEE Trans Biomed Circuits Syst Dec. 2016;10(6):
design of the study, acquisition of data, analysis and interpretation of 1068–78.
data, drafting the article, revised it critically for important intellectual [5] Nagaraj S, Rassam F. Improved non-coherent UWB receiver for implantable
biomedical devices. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng Oct. 2016;63(10):2220–5.
content, and final approval of the version to be submitted, drafting of [6] Yelamarthi K, Aman Md S, Abdelgawad A. An application-driven modular IoT
manuscript, responsibility for the article critically for important intel­ architecture. Wirel Commun Mob Comput May 2017;vol.2017:16. ID. 1350929.
lectual content, provided the revised article critically for important in­ [7] Andreu-Perez J, Leff D, Ip H, Yang G-Z. “From wearable sensors to smart
implants–toward pervasive and personalized healthcare. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng
tellectual content, and gave final approval of the version to be Dec. 2015;62(12):2750–62.
submitted. [8] Zhang X, Yao L, Zhang S, Kanhere S, Sheng M, Liu Y. Internet of things meets brain-
computer interface: a unified deep learning framework for enabling human-thing
cognitive interactivity. IEEE Internet Things J Apr. 2019;6(2):2084–92.
Appendix A. Supplementary data [9] Yong P, Ho E. Streaming brain and physiological signal acquisition system for IoT
neuroscience application. In: 2016 IEEE EMBS conference on biomedical
engineering and sciences. Malaysia: Kuala Lumpur; Dec. 2016. p. 4–8.
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi.
org/10.1016/j.imu.2019.100276.

7
S. Al Ajrawi et al. Informatics in Medicine Unlocked 18 (2020) 100276

[10] Teles A, Cagy M, Silva F, Endler M, Bastos V, Teixeira S. Using brain-computer [19] Johansson H. A polynomial-based time-varying filter structure for the
interface and internet of things to improve healthcare for wheelchair users. In: The compensation of frequency-response mismatch errors in time-interleaved ADCs.
eleventh international conference on mobile ubiquitous computing, systems, IEEE J Sel Topics Signal Process Jun. 2009;3(3):384–96.
services and technologies; 2017. [20] Tsui KM, Chan SC. New iterative framework for frequency response mismatch
[11] Al Ajrawi S, Mohanty S, Sarkar M, Rao R, Mihovska A, Baweja H. Investigating correction in time-interleaved ADCs: design and performance analysis. IEEE Trans
feasibility of multiple UHF passive RFID transmitters using backscatter Instrum Meas Dec. 2011;60(12):3792–805.
modulation. Bellevue, WA: SSMC; Jul 2017. p. 552–63. [21] Soudan M, Vogel C. Correction structures for linear weakly time varying systems.
[12] Harris F, Parekh S, Gurantz I. I-Q balancing techniques for broad-band receivers. IEEE Trans Circuits Syst I Sep. 2012;59(9):2075–84.
In: Proceeding of the Software Defined Radio Technical Conference; 2005. 6 pages. [22] Tsui KM, Chan SC. A novel iterative structure for online calibration of M-channel
[13] Al-Hussaibi W. Signal design for higher capacity correlated fading signature time-interleaved ADCs. IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas Feb. 2014;63(2):312–25.
multiple access. Wirel Netw Nov. 2014;20(8):2275–85. [23] Al-Hussaibi W. Effect of filtering on the synchronization and performance of chaos-
[14] F. Harris, “Artifact-corrected time-interleaved ADC,” U.S. Patents, US8957798B1, based secure communication over Rayleigh fading channel. Commun Nonlinear Sci
17 pages, Feb. 2015. Numer Simul Sep. 2015;26(1–3):87–97.
[15] Tsai T, Hurst P, Lewis S. Time-interleaved analog-to-digital converters for digital [24] Al-Hussaibi W, Ali F. Generation of correlated Rayleigh fading channels for
communications. Proc. IASTED Conf. Circuits, Signals Syst 2004:193. accurate simulation of promising wireless communication systems. Simul Model
[16] Liu C-L. Impacts of i/q imbalance on qpsk-ofdm-qam detection. EEE Trans Consum Pract Theory Jun. 2012;25(4):56–72.
Electron Aug. 1998;44(3):984–9. [25] Sample A, Yeager D, Powledge P, Mamishev A, Smith J. Design of an RFID-based
[17] Tsou H. The effect of phase and amplitude imbalance on the performance of offset battery-free programmable sensing platform. IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas Nov.
quadrature phase-shift-keyed (OQPSK) communication systems. The 2008;57(11):2608–15.
Telecommunications and Mission Operations Progress Report; Sep. 1998. p. 1–15. [26] IMPINJ. Speedway R420 RAIN RFID Reader. URL: https://www.impinj.
[18] Vogel C, Mendel S. A flexible and scalable structure to compensate frequency com/platform/connectivity/speedway-r420/.
response mismatches in time-interleaved ADCs. IEEE Trans Circuits Syst I Nov. [27] Monson H. Hayes, statistical digital signal processing and modeling. first ed. Wiley;
2009;56(11):2463–75. 1996.

You might also like