Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction In my dream, I was briefly given that gift. I asked for one
last chance to speak. I said something like this:
I had a dream – on the morning of 14 December 2000. n We are all, at the moment, engaged in an occupation.
I was in a meeting. A high-powered meeting around a When we leave this room, we will go on to others
table in a university, and occupational therapy had been left throughout the day. The rest of our days will be filled
out of a committee which was planned to deal with with a plethora of doing. Some occupations will be
intervention for a group of people with some specific complex, like this; others will be simple. Some will
problem that had been in the too-hard basket for a long, provide physical exercise, some the use of language,
long time. As is often the case in dreams, what the problem some complex cognitive activity and thought, and some
was is forgotten and immaterial. sharing with others, but they are not simply made up of
Other health science therapists had been invited to take those capabilities or more obvious needs. They are a
a role on the committee, but the chairman scarcely listened complex mixture, which provides meaning, purpose,
when the senior occupational therapist claimed that her structure, contentment and happiness as well as the
profession should also be represented. Despite some support other requirements of life and health.
from other members around the table, after both the senior Occupation is so complex yet so fundamental to life
and I had tried again to propose that we had something of that I am not surprised that it has taken longer than
value and significance to add, it was to no avail. other areas of thought to achieve the recognition that it
It was the age-old story. As other therapists were on the requires a discipline with regard to its own study. Yet it
committee, it was obviously not the therapy part of our forms a part of all other disciplines’ ideas, because
calling that was causing the problem. It had to be the occupation is what people do minute by minute, hour by
occupation bit. Once more we were being pigeon-holed by a hour, day by day, week by week and year by year.
misunderstanding of the domain of our concern and our Throughout time, long before the advent of medical
inarticulateness, caused, in large part, by the complexity of science, what people did was central to their state of
what we do and because we have failed to develop a health. Early physicians recognised the link, yet they
language or sufficient understanding of the occupational could only deal with parts of it, and they divided it into
needs of people to articulate it clearly. rules which dealt with particular, simpler and more
British
Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at NORTH DAKOTA STATE UNIV LIB on JuneJournal
9, 2015 of Occupational Therapy August 2001 64(8) 413
One of the most respected of the new age English Locke was not alone in recognising the importance of
philosophers, John Locke (1632-1704), called by some the what people ‘do’ in more than economics. Many other
father of psychology, influenced modern concepts of liberal important figures in history did too. Why, then, I ask, is our
democracy and education. In the case of the latter, he philosophical base such a well-kept professional secret?
advised a broad curriculum which demonstrated an I suggest that we have been tight-lipped because we have
understanding of the breadth of human occupational not studied humans as occupational beings and do not really
capacities, and the need to enable children to learn to understand what that means. Look at most of the knowledge
balance their own particular talents. Indeed, well ahead of base subjects in our undergraduate education programmes.
his time, he recommended the inclusion of artistic, cultural, The subjects that the academics who develop curriculum
domestic and handiwork subjects, and physical exercise, took as occupational therapy students are often similar to
whilst children were assisted to develop ‘satisfactory the core subjects or philosophical underpinnings in today’s
characters, and good judgments, habits and manners’ programmes. Those did not include subjects related to a
(Macdonald 1981, p73). science or a philosophy of occupation and, mostly, that
Locke obviously studied his subject in terms of day-to- remains the case. Instead, anatomy, physiology, psychology,
day life, in An Essay Concerning Humane Understanding, sociology and perhaps anthropology provide our
making rare but commonsense recommendations to do with disciplinary knowledge base. Occupation has largely been
people accepting themselves as they are, making the most of taught in subjects applied to the medical model or been of a
their talents and skills, and not hankering after what is out purely practical nature. While subjects of that kind are
of reach and impossible to attain. He advised: important, they give more credence to knowledge external
to our domain of concern.
...it will become us, as rational Creatures, to employ our
Many occupational therapists cannot explain effectively
Faculties about what they are most adapted to, and follow the
what the occupation part of our title has to do with health;
direction of Nature, where it seems to point us out the way. For
many of us have wished that we were called something
’tis rational to conclude, that our proper Imployment lies in
different; and, indeed, some welcome being described in
those Enquiries, and in that sort of Knowledge, which is most
other ways, such as hand therapists or sensory integrative
suited to our natural Capacities, and carries in it our greatest
therapists. This scenario says to me that we need occupation
interest, ... (Locke MDCXC, p327).
knowledge base subjects as well as applied occupational
In terms of a science of occupation – Locke made a plea therapy subjects. This means that we need to assemble into
for what he considered to be the right approach for the a logical theoretical whole what we do believe about
acquisition of knowledge and ‘scientific’ understanding, occupation in relation to people and health: we need to test
which would eventually benefit humankind. He defined it, share it, and develop it further for evermore. We need a
science as the means to explore, discover and understand science of occupation as the primary knowledge base of the
the whys and wherefores of the world as far as it was profession, in which occupation is so central that it forms
possible, and argued that it could be divided into three part of its nomenclature.
distinct fields. His ideas differed somewhat from what would
be considered mainstream science in the present day, and
underlines his basic rationale – that science should add to How did occupational science
knowledge in a way that betters the human experience. The
three sciences he recommended included, in closest to
evolve and how does it fit into
modern-day terms, biological science, communication occupational therapy?
science and occupational science:
So how did occupational science evolve, what are its roots,
All things that can fall within the compass of humane
and how does it fit into occupational therapy? The founders
Understanding, being either,
of the world’s first Occupational Therapy Society recognised
First, [Biological science]
that the profession needed such a science; that it was one of
The Nature of Things, as they are in themselves, their
the keys to the continuing development of the profession.
Relations, and their manner of Operation:
Many of you will recall from studies about the history of
Or, Secondly, [Occupational science]
occupational therapy the objectives of the National Society
that which Man himself ought to do, as a rational and
for the Promotion of Occupational Therapy in the USA in
voluntary Agent, for the Attainment of any Ends, especially
1917. Let me draw them to your attention once more. They
Happiness:
were:
Or, Thirdly, [Communication science]
The ways and means, whereby the Knowledge of both the one the advancement of occupation as a therapeutic measure;
and the other of these, are attained and communicated; the study of the effect of occupation upon the human being;
I think, Science may be divided properly into these Three sorts. and the scientific dispensation of this knowledge
(Locke MDCXC, p361). (Constitution of the National Society for the Promotion of
Occupational Therapy, Inc. 1917, p1).
The one that resembles occupational science, he called
ethics. These objectives suggest that those founders saw the
British
Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at NORTH DAKOTA STATE UNIV LIB on JuneJournal
9, 2015 of Occupational Therapy August 2001 64(8) 415
perspective it is important to ask: what benefits does contribution to medical science which challenges it from a
occupational science hold for the future wellbeing of our different perspective entirely. This would place us in a much
planet and its peoples? stronger position to increase awareness of the importance of
The way I see it, occupational scientists study people’s occupation to health than our present supplementary role,
occupational natures across a broad spectrum of concern, which is dependent on others’ domains of concern.
that is, they explore any other perspective, philosophy or Additionally, to make sure that individuals and society are
idea from the point of view of the human need for enabled to engage in occupations for health, it is imperative
occupation (Wilcock 1991). So, for example, they for us to promulgate broadly information about humans as
reconsider, research and advise on politics, spirituality, occupational beings and the health consequences of this.
education, social structures, science and technology, the We need to establish ourselves as advisers at all levels of
media, work, growth, development and creativity, and society to increase awareness and understanding. However,
health from an occupational perspective. If they are this is a huge undertaking and I think it is fair to say that
thorough, that will encompass reductionist as well as most occupational therapists, in the past, have been poor at
holistic perspectives and exploratory methods. proclaiming our distinctive views whenever legislative
So, for the discipline to grow and develop most change or departmental policy have compromised them.
effectively and quickly, it would be best for it to be studied There is such a lot to do. If we do adopt occupational
internationally across many disciplines. Some interest by science as the discipline upon which our profession rests, it
other discipline groups is apparent, in part through the will not, necessarily, be a comfortable seat. I suspect we will
Journal of Occupational Science and occupational science find that, in the future, we have many contradictory and
symposia, which have encouraged important scientists from competing as well as compatible theories, which together
other fields to contribute. These have included political, give us some understanding of our occupational natures.
ecological and social scientists, human geographers, Contrary to many who seek a single and simple model for
physicists, anthropologists and psychologists. Occupation our profession, I think this would be great. Today, for
crosses so many boundaries that there are hardly any areas example, it must be understood that I am giving you part of
of study which could not contribute to what is essentially a my version of which doors occupational science keys could
new way of looking at the world and its peoples. It is a new open. Other occupational scientists would provide different
perspective which has much to offer in the next century. keys.
Present social and political thinking largely fails to In this way, we stand in the tradition of other disciplines,
acknowledge a human need for occupation for its own sake, such as psychology which started from a clinical base and
apart from paid employment for monetary reasons. In fact, became recognised as having prime importance in almost
an economic perspective of life has been imposed upon every other sphere. Who, for example, would expect
everyone. Even we consider occupation and health, along Skinner, Maslow or Csiksentmihalyi to offer the same keys
with everything else, from a material perspective. People, to psychological practice? We can only benefit from diverse
occupational therapists, have often told me to get real and to growth and the development of a multiplicity of ideas. Then,
think of the economics of the situation, to accept a less than instead of adopting other disciplines’ ideas in entirety, we
satisfactory outcome because that is how it is. But I am an can view and analyse them from our own occupational
occupational therapist and an occupational scientist and my perspectives and offer distinctive opinions to not only our
job is to consider the occupational consequences of any traditional client group but also the general population, as
situation and to enable occupational health to the best of my well as to political, medical and social planners. This, I am
ability: to fight for people’s occupational rights and sure, is what our founders intended to happen from the first
occupational health. if we had not mislaid the keys.
As well as this economic perspective, most health Occupational science can inform traditional practice, but
workers, including occupational therapists, consider health it can also provide a point of departure towards adventures
from the perspective of medical science. Medical science into the world of enabling occupation to enhance and enrich
values are so integral to the post-industrial culture’s thinking the lives of many who are experiencing occupational
that it is difficult for those brought up in such a society to dissatisfaction. This may be at a personal level using a
perceive health from other than this perspective. Because of wellness approach, which is a useful model to consider in
the dominance of this medical science view of health, it is conventional practice venues such as hospitals, as well as in
seldom that adequate recognition is given to the health- the wider community.
promoting effects of occupational wellbeing or to the Working at a personal or community level, a preventive
susceptibility to ill-health that results from occupational approach may be appropriate not only in the obvious
injustice, deprivation, alienation or imbalance. occupational health and safety venues but in the public
Medical science looks at parts of occupation from its health arena, looking at the underlying occupational
reductionist viewpoint, and for direct cause and effect determinants which lead ultimately to disease, disability,
relationships, but not holistically and not from an handicap or death. What, for example, are the occupational
occupational needs point of view. With a well-developed experiences of people who later develop addictions and
and well-researched background, it will be possible in the what was it in the occupational structure of societies that led
future for us to make a significant and complementary to such experiences? Also at community levels, an
British
Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at NORTH DAKOTA STATE UNIV LIB on JuneJournal
9, 2015 of Occupational Therapy August 2001 64(8) 417