Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract— Capacitive sensors are key components in a wide Vertically aligned carbon nanotubes (VA-CNTs) are one of
range of sensing applications, such as gas detectors and safety the most interesting nano-materials known today. VA-CNTs
systems. While the mainstream silicon sensors demonstrated good comprise of billions of individual carbon nanotubes (CNTs)
performances, vertically aligned carbon nanotubes (VA-CNTs)
outperform them and, therefore, are an attractive candidate arranged in a highly dense and oriented formation. Recent
material for capacitive applications owing to their extremely high studies reported on their unique physical properties, such
surface area. Specifically, their top (crust) layer is characterized as high mechanical compliance [7] and excellent electrical
by a porous and dense morphology that further enhances and thermal conductance [8]. These properties in conjunc-
the capacitive area and, consequently, induces an electrostatic tion with nano-fabrication processes compatibility, photolitho-
fringe field and an enhancement of the capacitance. In this
paper, we study how the porosity of VA-CNTs determines their graphically definable geometry and high material capacitance
electrostatic behavior. We observed that the porous surface of the [9], have led to successful integration of VA-CNTs as capac-
crust layer generates a significant enhancement of the capacitance itors in wide range of applications. For instance, VA-CNTs
comparing to parallel plate capacitors. The rough surface of were integrated into nano-scale electromechanical switches
the crust layer results in amplification of the VA-CNT effective [10] and physical sensors [11].
capacitor area, which further increases with the electrostatic
gap. As-grown VA-CNTs with lower porosity demonstrate higher While the main stream silicon based capacitive sensors
capacitance; however, densified samples and samples reinforced demonstrated excellent performance, e.g., as proximity [3]
with conductive nano-particles did not show an enhancement and motion sensors [12], their porous counterparts presented
of the capacitance, due to a significant change in their CNT enhanced performances due to higher surface area. These
formation. Thus, this paper emphasizes the influence of the include, for example, porous humidity sensors [13] and gas
morphological structure of VA-CNTs on their capacitance and
enriches the material library that can be used for capacitive detectors [14]. VA-CNTs, on the other hand, hold even a
sensing. greater potential to operate as capacitive devices, as they have
an extremely high surface area that exceeds that of porous
Index Terms— V-shaped MEMS devices, thermal MEMS, tem-
perature sensors. silicon. A plethora of VA-CNT based capacitive devices has
been reported and include varactors for application of electro-
static forces [15], micro-electromechanical (MEMS) vertical
I. I NTRODUCTION comb-drive electrodes [16], electrostatic switches [10], force
and strain sensors [17], and biosensors [18].
D UE to their high performances, miniaturized size and
compatibility with integrated circuit (IC) technology,
capacitive sensors have shown increasing popularity in scien-
The porous morphology of VA-CNTs induces an electrosta-
tic fringe field when subjected to voltage. Fringe fields have
tific and industrial systems. These include capacitiave micro- been throughly investigated in many micro-scale devices, e.g.
accelerometers [1], proximity sensors [2], robotic sensory MEMS beams [19], plates [20], perforated elements [20], and
skin [3], and more [4], [5]. Emerging technologies, such as comb-drives [21]. Our recent work has shown that the unique
wearable electronics, autonomous robots, and the internet of fibrous microscopic structure of VA-CNTs results in sidewall
things (IoT) [6], will further increase the demand for multiple capacitive area significantly larger than a flat surface capacitor
small-size and accurate sensors that will be embedded in having the same dimensions [9].
engineering systems. This, therefore, requires the development Despite the extensive research on VA-CNT capacitive
of new sensing materials that can further improve the per- devices and the multiple reported applications, the influence
formance of such sensors and open new frontiers for future of the crust layer porosity on their capacitive behavior has
sensors. remained uncovered. In this work, we bridged this gap by
studying the porosity dependent electrostatic capacitive behav-
Manuscript received November 20, 2018; revised February 7, 2019; ior of the VA-CNTs crust layer.
accepted February 9, 2019. Date of publication February 13, 2019; date
of current version May 16, 2019. This work was supported by the Israeli
Ministry of Science and Technology under Grant 53253. The associate editor II. M ETHODS
coordinating the review of this paper and approving it for publication was
Prof. Bhaskar Choubey. (Corresponding author: Assaf Ya’akobovitz.) A. Samples Preparation
The authors are with the Department of Mechanical Engineering, VA-CNT were grown by chemical vapor deposition (CVD)
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva 84105, Israel (e-mail:
assafyaa@bgu.ac.il). process at atmospheric pressure. Silicon wafers with 1000 nm
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/JSEN.2019.2899060 thermal oxide were used as the substrates. The substrates were
1558-1748 © 2019 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
4376 IEEE SENSORS JOURNAL, VOL. 19, NO. 12, JUNE 15, 2019
Fig. 1. CVD recipe for VA-CNT growth. (a) Gases flow rates. (b) Temperarure.
Fig. 6. The ratio between the effective capacitor area of VA-CNTs and the
area of a flat capacitor, as a function of the gap between the electrodes. The
electrostatic force for 1 V is shown in the inset. The electrostatic force of a
flat capacitor is shown as a yellow line.
Fig. 7. (a) SEM images of a densified VA-CNT sample (scale-bar is 100 μm).
(b) Top view of the densified crust layer (scale-bar is 100 nm). (c) Side view Fig. 8. Capacitance measurements of (a) densified samples and (b) densified
of a sample densified and reinforced with gold nano-particles (scale-bar is samples reinforced with gold nano-particles. The capacitance of representative
100 nm). as-grown VA-CNTs (black and green circle markers) and a flat surface (yellow
squares) are shown as a reference.
surfaces present enhanced capacitance [31] that was further
increased with the gap [32]. In addition, samples with lower
porosity demonstrated higher values of enhancement, as these the CNTs [33]. SEM images of these samples are shown
samples have more CNTs in the crust layer, such that the in Fig. 7(a) and (b). In addition, other samples were densi-
electrostatic fringe field is more dominant. fied and reinforced with conductive spheres through wetting
The electrostatic force between the VA-CNTs and the elec- them with a liquid containing gold nano-particles, Fig. 7(c).
trode is Image processing analysis reveals that crust layer porosity of
r 0 Ae f f V 2 densified samples was reduced to 6% or less, namely lower
FE S = (3) than the as-grown samples.
2g 2
Capacitance measurements were then conducted on the
The electrostatic force under a voltage of V = 1 V is shown denfsified samples (Fig. 8(a)) and samples reinforced with
in the inset of Fig. 6. This force is proportional to V 2 , and conductive spheres (Fig. 8(b)). Although as-grown samples
consequently, when a voltage in the order of several tens of show that lower porosity is correlated with higher capacitance
Volts is applied (as commonly done in MEMS devices), then (Fig. 4(b)), similar measurements conducted on the densified
the relatively small force (nano-Newton) shown in the inset samples show that they do not present an enhancement of the
of Fig. 6 can be increased by several orders of magnitude. capacitance. The densification process of the samples creates
Analyzing the electrostatic force show, again, an amplification voids and increases the samples sidewall area exposed to the
comparing to a flat capacitor (yellow line in the inset of Fig. 6), electrode on the expanse of the crust layer area, as shown
due to the induced fringe field. in Fig. 7(a). The sidewalls demonstrate higher porosity com-
As low porosity samples demostrated enhanced capacitance, pared to that of the crust layer, and thus, they have lower
we densified several samples in order to further reduce their capacitive area. In addition, the electrostatic gap between the
porosity. Densification was carried out through immersing sidewalls and the electrode is larger than that of the crust layer.
the samples in a liquid to generate capillary densification of As a result, the capacitance of the densified samples is no
REDDY et al.: VA-CNTs CAPACITIVE SENSORS 4379
longer dominated solely by the crust layer and consequently, attractive to be integrated in emerging technologies that require
demonstrates comparable capacitance values to that of a flat multiple small-size and accurate capacitive sensors, such as
capacitor. IoT and automative systems.
The crust layer is formed at early phases of the synthesis
process of VA-CNTs [29]. During those early stages of the ACKNOWLEDGMENT
growth, the relatively short CNTs interact with each, creating a
dense and entangled layer of CNTs that support each other and The authors thank Dr. Oriel Shoshani for his helpful advice.
enable the subsequent formation of vertically aligned structure
of the CNTs and the characteristic extremely high aspect ratio R EFERENCES
of VA-CNTs [28]. Despite the fact that the crust layer is [1] W. Wu, J. Liu, J. Fan, D. Peng, H. Liu, and L. Tu, “A nano-g
relatively thin, it was found to influence the physical properties micromachined seismic sensor for levelling-free measurements,” Sens.
of VA-CNTs. For examples, its influence over the mechanical Actuators A, Phys., vol. 280, pp. 238–244, Sep. 2018.
[2] Z. Chen and R. C. Luo, “Design and implementation of capacitive
properties of VA-CNT samples was studied [34]. Other work proximity sensor using microelectromechanical systems technology,”
has shown that the crust layer has a profound impact on the IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 45, no. 6, pp. 886–894, Dec. 1998.
electrical conductance of VA-CNTs [35]. Thermally, the crust [3] H.-K. Lee, S.-I. Chang, and E. Yoon, “Dual-mode capacitive proximity
sensor for robot application: Implementation of tactile and proximity
layer showed relatively high values of negative expansion sensing capability on a single polymer platform using shared electrodes,”
coefficient, which is different from that of other portions [22]. IEEE Sensors J., vol. 9, no. 12, pp. 1748–1755, Dec. 2009.
We show here that the crust layer has a dominant impact [4] Y. Bai et al., “Absolute position sensing based on a robust differential
capacitive sensor with a grounded shield window,” Sensors, vol. 16,
on the capacitive behavior of as-grown VA-CNTs. The fact no. 5, p. 680, 2016.
that this layer comprise of densely packed entangled CNTs [5] T. Zeng et al., “A capacitive sensor for the measurement of departure
results in significantly higher capacitance area and dominant from the vertical movement,” IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas., vol. 65, no. 2,
electrostatic fringe field. Interestingly, these insights are com- pp. 458–466, Feb. 2016.
[6] A. H. Alavi, P. Jiao, W. G. Buttlar, and N. Lajnef, “Internet of Things-
plimentary to other works that studied the interplay between enabled smart cities: State-of-the-art and future trends,” Measurement,
electrostatic fields and the hierarchical structure of VA-CNTs, vol. 129, pp. 589–606, Dec. 2018.
e.g., it was shown that the electrostatic field can modify [7] A. Misra, J. R. Greer, and C. Daraio, “Strain rate effects in the
mechanical response of polymer-anchored carbon nanotube foams,” Adv.
the formation of the CNTs by changing their alignment and Mater., vol. 21, no. 3, pp. 334–338, 2009.
interaction sites [23]. However, these works did not investigate [8] M. B. Jakubinek et al., “Thermal and electrical conductivity of tall,
the unique porosity dependent capacitive properties of the crust vertically aligned carbon nanotube arrays,” Carbon, vol. 48, no. 13,
pp. 3947–3952, 2010.
layer. While in a previous publication it was observed that [9] A. Ya’akobovitz, M. Bedewy, and A. J. Hart, “Electrostatic capacitance
VA-CNT sidewall capacitance outperforms flat capacitors only and faraday cage behavior of carbon nanotube forests,” Appl. Phys. Lett.,
at relatively large gaps (hundreds of microns or more) [9], here vol. 106, no. 5, 2015, Art. no. 053106.
[10] Y. Hayamizu et al., “Integrated three-dimensional microelectromechan-
we show that the crust layer demonstrates higher capacitance ical devices from processable carbon nanotube wafers,” Nature Nan-
than flat capacitors at all gaps including small gaps - a property otechnol., vol. 3, no. 5, pp. 289–294, 2008.
that is highly attractive for capacitive sensors. [11] T. Yamada et al., “A stretchable carbon nanotube strain sensor for
human-motion detection,” Nature Nanotechnol., vol. 6, no. 5, p. 296,
2011.
[12] G. Langfelder, A. F. Longoni, A. Tocchio, and E. Lasalandra, “MEMS
IV. C ONCLUSION motion sensors based on the variations of the fringe capacitances,” IEEE
Sensors J., vol. 11, no. 4, pp. 1069–1077, Apr. 2011.
To conclude, in the present work we have investigated the
[13] S.-J. Kim, J.-Y. Park, S.-H. Lee, and S.-H. Yi, “Humidity sensors using
capacitance of VA-CNTs. The influence of the porosity of porous silicon layer with mesa structure,” J. Phys. D, Appl. Phys.,
VA-CNTs on their capacitance was studied. The porosity of vol. 33, no. 15, p. 1781, 2000.
VA-CNTs was acquired by means of image processing of [14] G. Di Francia, M. D. Noce, V. La Ferrara, L. Lancellotti, P. Morvillo, and
L. Quercia, “Nanostructured porous silicon for gas sensor applications,”
HR-SEM images, followed by their capacitance measurements Mater. Sci. Technol., vol. 18, no. 7, pp. 767–771, 2002.
and analysis. Our investigation has shown that due to the high [15] N. Olofsson, J. Ek-Weis, A. Eriksson, T. Idda, and E. E. B. Campbell,
porosity of as-grown VA-CNTs, they demonstrate significant “Nanotechnology determination of the effective Young’s modulus of
vertically aligned carbon nanotube arrays: A simple nanotube-based
electrostatic fringe field and enhanced capacitance, which stem varactor,” Nanotechnology, vol. 20, no. 38, 2009, Art. no. 385710.
from the dense CNT formation of the crust layer. An attempt [16] J. Choi, Y. Eun, S. Pyo, J. Sim, and J. Kim, “Vertically aligned carbon
to further reduce the porosity of the samples through their nanotube arrays as vertical comb structures for electrostatic torsional
actuator,” Microelectron. Eng., vol. 98, pp. 405–408, Oct. 2012.
densification, altered their structure and resulted in reduced [17] C.-F. Hu, J.-Y. Wang, Y.-C. Liu, M.-H. Tsai, and W. Fang, “Development
crust layer capacitive area. As a result, densified samples did of 3D carbon nanotube interdigitated finger electrodes on polymer
not exhibited capacitance enhancement. substrate for flexible capacitive sensor application,” Nanotechnology,
vol. 24, no. 44, pp. 444006-1–444006-14, 2013.
Our analysis shows that as-grown VA-CNTs can be used as [18] D. Li, C. Wang, G. Sun, S. Senapati, and H.-C. Chang,
a core material for high-accuracy capacitive sensors, as they “A shear-enhanced CNT-assembly nanosensor platform for ultra-
show superior performances comparing to flat capacitors. sensitive and selective protein detection,” Biosensors Bioelectron.,
vol. 97, pp. 143–149, Nov. 2017.
The enhanced capacitance in conjunction to other attractive [19] R. C. Batra, M. Porfiri, and D. Spinello, “Electromechanical model of
properties, such as its high mechanical compliance and com- electrically actuated narrow microbeams,” J. Microelectromech. Syst.,
patibility with micro-fabrication processes, make VA-CNTs vol. 15, no. 5, pp. 1175–1189, Oct. 2006.
an ideal material to be used in future miniaturized high- [20] A. Ya’akobovitz and S. Krylov, “The influence of perforation on
electrostatic and damping forces in thick SOI MEMS structures,”
end capacitive sensing applications. Therefore, VA-CNT is J. Micromech. Microeng., vol. 22, no. 11, 2012, Art. no. 115006.
4380 IEEE SENSORS JOURNAL, VOL. 19, NO. 12, JUNE 15, 2019
[21] M. M. Tilleman, “Analysis of electrostatic comb-driven actuators [34] Y. Won et al., “Nonhomogeneous morphology and the elastic modulus
in linear and nonlinear regions,” Int. J. Solids Struct., vol. 41, of aligned carbon nanotube films,” J. Micromech. Microeng., vol. 25,
nos. 18–19, pp. 4889–4898, 2004. no. 11, 2015, Art. no. 115023.
[22] A. Ya’akobovitz, “Multiple thermal transitions and anisotropic thermal [35] J. Marschewski, J. B. In, D. Poulikakos, and C. P. Grigoropoulos,
expansions of vertically aligned carbon nanotubes,” J. Appl. Phys., “Synergistic integration of Ni and vertically aligned carbon nanotubes
vol. 120, no. 16, 2016, Art. no. 165110. for enhanced transport properties on flexible substrates,” Carbon, vol. 68,
[23] A. Ya’akobovitz, M. Bedewy, A. Rao, and A. J. Hart, “Strain relaxation pp. 308–318, Mar. 2014.
and resonance of carbon nanotube forests under electrostatic loading,”
Carbon, vol. 96, pp. 250–258, Jan. 2016.
[24] M. Xu, D. N. Futaba, M. Yumura, and K. Hata, “Alignment control
of carbon nanotube forest from random to nearly perfectly aligned by
utilizing the crowding effect,” ACS Nano, vol. 6, no. 7, pp. 5837–5844,
2012.
[25] K. Hata, D. N. Futaba, K. Mizuno, T. Namai, M. Yumura, and S. Iijima, Siva K. Reddy received the Ph.D. degree from the Indian Institute of Science,
“Water-assisted highly efficient synthesis of impurity-free single-walled Bengaluru, India. He has worked on the mechanical behavior of CNT and
carbon nanotubes,” Science, vol. 306, no. 5700, pp. 1362–1364, 2004. Graphene foams. Earlier, he was working as a Research Engineer at the
[26] E. Teblum, A. Itzhak, E. Shawat-Avraham, M. Muallem, R. Yemini, and Masdar Institute of Science and Technology, Abu Dhabi, in collaboration
G. D. Nessim, “Differential preheating of hydrocarbon decomposition with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA. He
and water vapor formation shows that single ring aromatic hydrocarbons is currently a Post-Doctoral Fellow with the Department of Mechanical
enhance vertically aligned carbon nanotubes growth,” Carbon, vol. 109, Engineering, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beersheba, Israel, under
pp. 727–736, Nov. 2016. the supervision of Dr. A. Ya’akobovitz.
[27] E. Teblum, Y. Gofer, C. L. Pint, and G. D. Nessim, “Role of catalyst
oxidation state in the growth of vertically aligned carbon nanotubes,”
J. Phys. Chem. C, vol. 116, no. 46, pp. 24522–24528, 2012.
[28] M. F. L. De Volder, D. O. Vidaud, E. R. Meshot, S. Tawfick, and
A. J. Hart, “Self-similar organization of arrays of individual carbon nan-
otubes and carbon nanotube micropillars,” Microelectron. Eng., vol. 87, Itay Gendelis received the B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees in mechanical engineering
nos. 5–8, pp. 1233–1238, 2010. from Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel. His research interests include
[29] M. Bedewy, E. R. Meshot, M. J. Reinker, and A. J. Hart, “Population electrostatic fields in NEMS devices and CNTs.
growth dynamics of carbon nanotubes,” ACS Nano, vol. 5, no. 11,
pp. 8974–8989, 2011.
[30] M. S. Dresselhaus, G. Dresselhaus, and A. Jorio, “Raman spectroscopy
of carbon nanotubes in 1997 and 2007,” J. Phys. Chem. C, vol. 111,
no. 48, pp. 17887–17893, 2007.
[31] A. Ya’akobovitz and A. J. Hart, “Enhanced surface capacitance of Assaf Ya’akobovitz received the B.Sc., M.Sc., and Ph.D. degrees in mechan-
cylindrical micropillar arrays,” Sens. Actuators A, Phys., vol. 219, ical engineering from Tel-Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel, in 2006, 2007,
pp. 32–37, Nov. 2014. and 2012, respectively. From 2012 to 2013, he was a Post-Doctoral Fellow
[32] L. Kogut, “The influence of surface topography on the electromechan- with the Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Michigan,
ical characteristics of parallel-plate MEMS capacitors,” J. Micromech. Ann Arbor, MI, USA. From 2013 to 2014, he was a Post-Doctoral Fellow
Microeng., vol. 15, no. 5, p. 1068, 2005. with the Department of Materials and Interfaces, Faculty of Chemistry,
[33] M. F. L. De Volder, S. J. Park, S. H. Tawfick, D. O. Vidaud, and Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel. He is currently the leader of
A. J. Hart, “Fabrication and electrical integration of robust carbon the NEMS/MEMS and Nanomaterials Laboratory, Department of Mechanical
nanotube micropillars by self-directed elastocapillary densification,” Engineering, Faculty Engineering Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the
J. Micromech. Microeng., vol. 21, no. 4, 2011, Art. no. 045033. Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel.