Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mital Thacker, Surajit Roy, John Patrick Kociolek, Rex L. Lowe &
Balasubramanian Karthick
To cite this article: Mital Thacker, Surajit Roy, John Patrick Kociolek, Rex L. Lowe
& Balasubramanian Karthick (2019): A new species of Germainiella (Bacillariophyta)
from the Myristica swamps of the Western Ghats, India, Diatom Research, DOI:
10.1080/0269249X.2019.1671236
A new species of Germainiella (Bacillariophyta) from the Myristica swamps of the Western
Ghats, India
MITAL THACKER 1,2 , SURAJIT ROY 1
, JOHN PATRICK KOCIOLEK 3
, REX L. LOWE4 &
BALASUBRAMANIAN KARTHICK 1,2∗
1 Biodiversity and Palaeobiology Group, Agharkar Research Institute, Pune, India
2 Savitribai Phule Pune University, Pune, India
3 Museum of Natural History and Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO, USA
4 Department of Biological Sciences, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, OH, USA
Germainiella chandranii sp. nov. is described from a Myristica swamp of the Western Ghats, India, on the basis of light and scanning
electron microscopy. The new species resembles two related genera, Fallacia Stickle & D.G. Mann and Germainiella Lange–Bertalot &
Metzeltin on the basis of valve morphology, but a thorough investigation of valve ultrastructure confirms its placement in Germainiella.
External valve outline and morphology, large conopeum covering the entire face of the valve, siliceous struts running perpendicular to
the raphe support the generic assignment. The main diagnostic features of the new species are the presence of small tubules running
perpendicular to the raphe, striae composed of a series of round to elongated areolae, which are not covered internally by hymenes, and a
larger central area. The new species occurs in acidic waters of the Myristica swamps of the Western Ghats and it can be considered as an
indicator of the acidic condition.
Keywords: biraphid diatom, Germainiella chandranii, Fallacia, India, Myristica swamp, taxonomy, Western Ghats
Figs 1–8. Type material of Germainiella chandranii from the Myristica swamp of the central Western Ghats, India. LM. Light micro-
scope images of the specimens from the type population showing valve views in size diminution series. Holotype depicted in Fig. 7.
(Scale bar = 10 μm).
valve (Figs 13–14). Striae are visible in the apical open- Habitat. Germainiella chandranii was distributed in a
ings (Figs 13–14). Striae form a series of round to elon- small swamp, almost stagnant or with low water flow; pH:
gated areolae which are not covered internally by hymenes 6.37, electrical conductivity: 75.8 μs cm−1 , dissolved oxy-
(Fig. 20; arrowhead), clearly seen in a tilted, broken valve gen: 7.7 ppm, nitrate: 0.6 ppm phosphate: 1.17 ppm, water
(Fig. 18). temperature: 24.5°C.
Internal valve view: Proximal and distal raphe ends curve
to opposite sides of the valve from each other (Figs 22–
24). Internal proximal raphe ends are simple and deflected Discussion
towards the same side (Fig. 23). Internal distal raphe ends Based on the valve external morphology, the new species
are slightly bent and terminate in poorly-developed, raised appears best placed in Germainiella as it possesses the
helictoglossae (Figs 22–24). main features of the genus, including a series of transapi-
cally elongated siliceous struts or canal-like apertures
Girdle view: The valvocopula, girdle bands and slit-like
running parallel to the raphe. However, our new taxon
areolae on the mantle are evident (Fig. 11). The valvo-
lacks some of the characters of Germainiella, such as
copula is accompanied by two to three unornamented
the single large internal areola present in the generitype,
girdle bands (Figs 15–17; Figs 25–26). The mantle has
G. enigmaticoides.
more or less equally spaced, longitudinally oriented slits
The genera Germainiella and Fallacia are quite sim-
(Figs 15–17). Distal raphe ends extend onto the valve
ilar but can easily be separated on the basis of several
mantle (Figs 16–17).
differences. Werum & Lange-Bertalot (2004) transferred
Holotype. Circled specimen on microscope slide marked Navicula enigmatica H. Germain to Fallacia on the basis
06–17 made from material #259, AHMA, Diatom Section, of the presence of conopeum. Later Meltzeltin et al. (2005)
Pune, India. Holotype specimen illustrated in Fig. 7. transferred this taxon into the new genus Germainiella
based on the conopeum masking the valve face and part
Type Locality. The Myristica swamp near Hulikal Falls
of the mantle, the presence of external canal apertures on
from Hosangara Taluka of the Shimoga district of Kar-
either side of the raphe, and striae composed of a single
nataka state, India. 13.71773°N, 74.99917°E, elevation
areola, which is not covered by an internal hymen. Based
589 m a.s.l.
on the presence or absence of a lyre-shaped canal, two
Etymology. The specific epithet refers to esteemed botanist, groups of Fallacia taxa can be recognized. A third group
Dr M.D. Subash Chandran, Kumta, Karnataka, to honour of taxa formerly placed in Fallacia were transferred into
his three decades of research in the conservation of Myris- a separate genus, Pseudofallacia Y. Liu, Kociolek & Q.X.
tica swamps of Western Ghats. Wang (Liu et al. 2012) on the basis of two longitudinal
4 Thacker et al.
Figs 9–11. Type material of Germainiella chandranii from the Myristica swamp of the central Western Ghats, India. SEM. Figs 9–10.
Valve exterior showing conopeum-covered linear valves with broadly rounded apices, undulating raphe, asymmetrical central area and
two apical openings. Fig. 11. Girdle view of the frustule showing valvocopula, girdle bands and slit-like areolae on the mantle. (Scale
bars = 4 μm).
Germainiella chandranii sp. nov. from Myristica swamps 5
Figs 12–17. Type material of Germainiella chandranii from the Myristica swamp of the central Western Ghats, India. SEM. Fig. 12.
Valve exterior showing the sternum positioned along the apical axis, half-elliptical central area and proximal raphe endings dilated and
slightly bent unidirectionally. Figs 13–14. Valve exterior showing apex with valve face/mantle junction and distal raphe endings. The
valve face shows two lines of transapically elongated slit like areolae (some are bifurcated) that create a boundary around the sternum.
Fig. 15. Girdle view of the middle of the frustule showing longitudinal slits on valve mantle. Figs 16–17. Girdle view of the frustule
showing the position of apical opening and distal raphe ends, valvocopula and unornamented girdle bands. (Scale bars = 2 μm).
depressions along the narrow sternum, covered externally Van de Vijver & Cox (2015), F. emmae lacks siliceous
by a perforated conopeum beside the raphe. However, Van struts (sub-conopeum canal system) and has striae com-
de Vijver & Cox (2015) described another interesting taxon posed of a single areola covered by an internal hymen.
(Fallacia emmae Van de Vijver & Cox) which shows fea- Kociolek et al. (2019) transferred this taxon to Ger-
tures of both Fallacia and Germainiella. According to mainiella as siliceous struts are present in this taxon but
6 Thacker et al.
Figs 18–21. Type material of Germainiella chandranii from the Myristica swamp of the central Western Ghats, India. SEM. Fig. 18.
Broken and tilted frustule (picture was taken by tilting the SEM stage at 13° angle) showing the areola structure beneath the conopeum
and siliceous struts perpendicular to the raphe (arrows) (full valve view in the inset). Fig. 19. Frustule showing detached siliceous struts
(arrows) on the valve face. Fig. 20. Note the transapically elongated slit (i.e. siliceous struts) from the valve view (arrows); arrowheads
showing areolae devoid of internal hymenes (half valve view as inset). Fig. 21. External view of central area highlighting the curved
proximal ends, asymmetric central area and siliceous struts (Scale bars = 1 μm).
not observable in unbroken valves. However, it is not straight raphe, and finely porous conopeum compared to
clear whether Fallacia and Germainiella are phylogenet- G. chandranii, and these features allow the taxa to be
ically related to each other or not, as formal analyses of distinguished. Fallacia lenzii (Hustedt) Lange-Bertalot is
morphological and molecular data are lacking. shorter (12 μm) and narrower (3.5 μm) but has a higher
Our new taxon resembles several species assigned stria density (over 40/10 μm) compared to G. chandranii.
to Fallacia and Germainiella and these are compared In Germainiella emmae (Van de Vijver & Cox) Koci-
in Table 1. Although Fallacia latelongitudinalis (R.M. olek, You, R. Lowe & Q. Wang (Van de Vijver & Cox
Patrick) M. Potapova (2013: 7) does not differ from 2015: 247), the striae are composed of a single elongated
G. chandranii with respect to valve length, shape, areola, a character that is absent in G. chandranii. Both
axial area, striation pattern, conopeum characters, sub- species share siliceous struts perpendicular to the raphe.
conopeum canal system, proximal and distal raphe ends, Germainiella enigmaticoides Lange-Bertalot & Metzeltin
and areola structure, it does differ from G. chandranii (Metzeltin et al. 2005: 75) and Germainiella clandestina
in being narrower (4.6–5.6 μm), having a higher stria R. Le Cohu, L. Ten-Hage & J. Barthés (Le Cohu et al.
density (45–50/10 μm), an elliptic central area, and lack- 2016: 185) are morphologically similar to G. chandranii,
ing transapically elongated siliceous struts encircling the but both are much smaller. Germainiella enigmaticoides
sternum (Table 1). A more detailed scanning electron and G. clandestina have very high stria densities (73–79
microscopical study of F. latelongitudinalis is needed to in 10 μm and 50–62 in 10 μm respectively), the conopeum
ascertain its correct generic placement. fully covers the valve, striae are composed of a single elon-
Fallacia subhamulata (Grunow) D.G. Mann (Round gated areola, and there is no sternum encircling transapi-
et al. 1990: 669) is shorter (15.0–17.3 μm), has a lower cally elongated siliceous struts; all of these features easily
stria density (28–31/10 μm), a small circular central area, differentiate both species from G. chandranii.
Germainiella chandranii sp. nov. from Myristica swamps 7
Figs 22–26. Type material of Germainiella chandranii from the Myristica swamp of the central Western Ghats, India. SEM showing
details of internal view of the valve with the internal raphe structure. Figs 22–24. Valve interior showing different valve structures,
proximal and distal raphe ends curving in opposite directions. Figs 25–26. Valve apices showing the peel off of unornamented girdle
bands (Scale bars: Figs 22–24 = 5 μm; Figs 25–26 = 2 μm).
8
Thacker et al.
Table 1. Comparison of morphological characteristics of Germainiella chandranii sp. nov. and closely related taxa (* denotes “measured from the published figures”).
Germainiella
Germainiella Germainiella Germainiella Germainiella Fallacia late- Fallacia Fallacia chandranii sp.
Characters enigmaticoides clandestina sinica emmae longitudinalis subhamulata lenzii nov.
9
10 Thacker et al.
According to Le Cohu et al. (2016), G. enigmaticoides B AWA), pp. 1–19. Oxford & IBH Publications Co, New
and G. clandestina favour environments rich in nitrogen Delhi.
and phosphorus and have an affinity for high electrolyte G ERMAIN H. 1980. Trois nouvelles diatomées dans le bassin
content; the ecological setting for G. chandranii is quite d’une serre à Angers (France). Cryptogamie, Algologie 1:
different, occurring in nutrient-poor, acidic waters. The 19–27.
G OGOREV R.M., S TEPANOVA V., C HUDAEV D.A. &
morphologically most similar taxon to G. chandranii is
K ULIKOVSKIY M. 2018. Russian and English terminologi-
G. sinica (Table 1). Germainiella chandranii differs from cal glossary on morphology of diatoms. Novosti sistematiki
G. sinica in that the latter species has a lower stria density nizshikh rastenii 52: 265–309.
(37–39/10 μm), is shorter (12–24 μm) and narrower (3.5– G URURAJA K.V., A RAVIND N.A., A LI S., R AMACHANDRA
4.0 μm). Pores on the valve outer surface (conopeum pores) T.V., V ELAVAN T.P., K RISHNAKUMAR V. & A GGARWAL
are not visible in G. sinica. The central area of G. sinica R. 2007. A new frog species from the central Western Ghats
differs in shape (rectangular) compared to that in G. chan- of India, and its phylogenetic position. Zoological Science
dranii, and while the raphe of G. sinica is straight, that of 24: 525–534.
G. chandranii is undulate. H USTEDT F. 1950. Die Diatomeenflora norddeutscher Seen mit
besonderer Berücksichtigung des holsteinischen Seengebi-
ets. Seen in Mecklenburg, Lauenburg und Nordostdeutsch-
land. V-VII. Tafs 21-41. Archiv für Hydrobiologie 43:
Acknowledgements
329–458.
The authors would like to thank the Director, Agharkar Research J OSE J., R AMACHANDRAN K.K., R OBY T.J. & N AIR P.V.
Institute, for support and encouragement. Authors are also thank-
2014. A preliminary checklist of amphibians in and around
ful to the Karnataka Forest Department for permission to carry
out this research with research permit. The authors are thankful the Myristica swamp forests of Kulathupuzha, South West-
to two anonymous reviewers for constructive comments on the ern Ghats. Journal of Entomology and Zoology Studies 2:
previous version of the manuscript. 11–18.
K ARTHICK B., TAYLOR J.C., M AHESH M.K. & R AMACHAN -
DRA T.V. 2010. Protocols for collection, preservation and
enumeration of diatoms from Aquatic habitats for water
Disclosure statement
quality monitoring in India. The IUP Journal of Soil and
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors. Water Sciences 3: 1–36.
K OCIOLEK J.P., Y OU Q.M., L OU F., Y U P., L OWE R. L. &
WANG Q.X. 2019. First report and new freshwater species
Funding of Germainiella (Bacillariophyta) from the Maolan nature
This work is part of the project supported by Ministry of reserve, Guizhou province, China. Phytotaxa 393: 35–46.
Earth Sciences under paleoclimate program (MoES/CCR/Paleo- L E C OHU R., B ARTHÈS A., L EFLAIVE J. & T EN -H AGE L.
26/2015). SR would also like to thank Science and Engineering 2016. Germainiella clandestina sp. nov. (Bacillariophyta),
Research Board (SERB), India for providing National Post- a new species in a little-known diatom genus. Fottea, Olo-
Doctoral Fellowship (PDF/2017/000877). mouc 16: 184–188.
L IU Y., K OCIOLEK J. P., F AN Y., & WANG Q. 2012. Pseudofal-
lacia gen. nov., a new freshwater diatom (Bacillariophyceae)
ORCID genus based on Navicula occulta Krasske. Phycologia 51:
Mital Thacker http://orcid.org/0000-0002-6409-1779 620–626.
Surajit Roy http://orcid.org/0000-0003-2339-9723 M ETZELTIN D., L ANGE -B ERTALOT H. & G ARCÍARO -
John Patrick Kociolek http://orcid.org/0000-0001-9824-7164 DRÍGUEZ F. 2005. Diatoms of Uruguay compared with other
Balasubramanian Karthick http://orcid.org/0000-0003-4066- taxa from South America and elsewhere. In: Iconographia
2458 Diatomologica. Annotated diatom micrographs. taxonomy-
biogeography-diversity (Ed. by H. L ANGE -B ERTALOT),
Vol. 15. A.R.G. Gantner Verlag K.G., Ruggell. 736 pp.
References M YERS N., M ITTERMEIER R.A., M ITTERMEIER C.G., D A
B ORREGO -R AMOS M., B LANCO S. & O LENICI A. 2018. F ONSECA G.A.B. & K ENT J. 2000. Biodiversity hotspots
Diatoms from the Valporquero cave (León, NW Spain) with for conservation priorities. Nature 403: 853–858.
the description of Germainiella legionensis sp. nov. Journal N AIR P.V., R AMACHANDRAN K.K., S WARUPANANDAN K.
of Cave and Karst Studies 80: 181–189. & T HOMAS T.P. 2007. Mapping biodiversity of the
C HANDRAN M.D.S., M ESTA D.K., R AO G.R., A LI S., G URU - Myristica swamps in Southern Kerala [online]. Kerala
RAJA K.V. & R AMACHANDRA T.V. 2008. Discovery of Forest Research Institute, KFRI Research Report. Available
two critically endangered tree species and issues related to from: http://www.docs.kfri.res.in/KFRI-RR/KFRI-RR326.
relic forests of the Western Ghats. The Open Conservation pdf [Accessed 25 December 2018].
Biology Journal 1: 1–8. N OSS R.F., P LATT W.J., S ORRIE B.A., W EAKLEY A.S.,
C HANDRAN M.D.S. & M ESTA D.K. 2001. On the conserva- M EANS D.B., C OSTANZA J. & P EET R.K. 2015. How
tion of the Myristica swamps of the Western Ghats. In: global biodiversity hotspots may go unrecognized: lessons
Forest genetic resources: status and conservation strategies from the North American Coastal Plain. Diversity and Dis-
(Ed. by R. U MA S HAANKER , K.N. G ANESHAIAH & K.S. tributions 21: 236–244.
Germainiella chandranii sp. nov. from Myristica swamps 11
P OTAPOVA M. 2013. The Types of 22 Navicula (Bacillar- S CHMIDT A. 1936. Atlas der Diatomaceen-kunde. Series VIII
iophyta) species described by Ruth Patrick. Proceedings (Heft 101–102). O.R. Reisland Leipzig. pls. 401–408.
of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 162: 401pp.
1–23. VAN DE V IJVER B. & C OX E.J. 2015. Fallacia emmae sp. nov.,
R OSS R., C OX E.J., K ARAYEVA N.I., M ANN D.G., PADDOCK (Bacillariophyta) a new soil-inhabiting diatom species from
T.B.B., S IMONSEN R. & S IMS P.A. 1979. An amended the Sub-Antarctic region. Cryptogamie, Algologie 36: 245–
terminology for the siliceous components of the diatom cell. 254.
Nova Hedwigia, Beiheft 64: 513–533. W ERUM M. & L ANGE -B ERTALOT H. 2004. Diatoms in spring
R OUND F.E., C RAWFORD R.M. & M ANN D.G. 1990. The from central Europa and elsewhere under the influence
Diatoms. Biology & morphology of the genera. Cambridge of hydrogeology and anthropogenic impacts. Iconographia
University Press, Cambridge. 747 pp. Diatomologica 13: 1–417.