You are on page 1of 6

LABORATORY EXERCISE 2: 

techniques are analyzed and calibrated to be used for


the design of ergonomic workstations and products
(NIOSH, n.d.). These data are only useful when it is
Anthropometric Product Design transformed into quantitative baselines for improving
work conditions and efficiency.
Celino, Czarina Joyce A.
II. METHODOLOGY
Masiglat, Adrian Byron L. Part I
Before designing the call center
IE 134 – ST1L workstation, the design requirements which include
the age range of the users were first considered. A
sketch of the office chair and table were drawn by the
I. INTRODUCTION group and the critical dimensions were indicated in the
A. Concept Discussion
drawing. The corresponding anthropometric
Anthropometric measurements are quantitative
dimensions were estimated from the tables provided. 
representations of the human body that are used in an
The design approach used for these products
array of applications (Casadei & Kiel, 2020). One
is design for ranges, thus, the 5th and 95th percentiles
application of anthropometric measurements is the
for certain measurements were considered. Since the
production or the enhancement of a product, service, or
data of male and female differ from each other for
a workspace. Stack et. al. (2016) deemed anthropometry
each anthropometric measurement, the lower 5th
as the main basis for setting up a workstation. From the
percentile value and the higher 95th percentile value
measurements that were gathered using anthropometric
between the two are considered in the design that we
approaches, ergonomic principles are applied in order to
have done so that wider users can be taken into
improve the work conditions and efficiency of a job.
account. In addition to the values from the tables, we
also have added enough allowance for certain parts in
B. Objectives of the exercise order to make the product more efficient to use.
The main objective of this exercise is to
introduce the student to the application of
Part II
anthropometric data for design of a product, process, or
For the Design Your Own portion of the
workplace.
exercise, the group suggests a user-friendly bunk bed
fortified by the anthropometric data given in the tables.
Specifically, it aims for the students to: The first step done was to enlist the critical dimensions
● Identify the critical dimensions of a of the product. Then, those critical dimensions were
product/process that requires consideration of human related to their equivalent anthropometric data that was
measurement available. From there, the group compared the data of
● Identify the anthropometric measures that male to female, and since the product requires
affect the critical dimensions generous allowance for movement, male data was
● Use the appropriate anthropometric deemed more significant since all critical dimensions
statistical measurement to produce a proposed product of male are larger than that of females. In that way,
design more users can be catered.
● Analyze the fit of the proposed product Although the whole bunk bed is designed for
design (perform product review) extremes (95th percentile), different design strategies
were used for different critical dimensions, since some
C. Significance of the concept dimensions are being used in a different way than the
This exercise is a clear example of how other dimensions. For example, the top and lower bunk
anthropometric measurements are applied in day to day heights are better suited when it is designed using
lives. Middlesworth (2020) mentioned in his article just averages rather than extremes because designing it for
how ergonomic principles and concepts like the middle of the population makes those heights not
anthropometry are being overlooked to ordinary people. too high and not too low. Another dimension that is
Most people may not even realize that they are dealing designed for averages is the step height, since
with ergonomics anywhere they look. For that, these designing it for extremes (95th percentile) may be
types of activities are helpful in order to relate complex overkill. Ample and generous allowances were
ergonomics principles into simple tasks. applied, especially for the bed width in order to allow
It is important to note that although enough room for movements. For the top bunk border
anthropometry, in its broadest sense, is quite thickness, the 95th percentile foot length was added to
straightforward, there are underlying concepts that are the average thickness of standard mattresses according
applied in a much deeper manner. For example, the to Sen (2020). That dimension will serve as the side
measurements obtained with the use of anthropometric and head guard for the top bunk, ensuring that the user
will not fall off the bed. and the higher 95th percentile between the male and
female dimensions were considered.These adjustable
features, especially the adjustable seat height will
allow the user to have a more comfortable working
experience, boost his or her productivity and prevent
III. MAIN EXERCISE further health risks. (Rupavate, 2020)
Part I:
In designing the call center workstation, the
group considered all the possible anthropometric
measurements which can aid in producing a better
output.

Figure 1.1 Sketch for the Designed Office Chair

Figure 1.2 Sketch for the Designed Office Table

In designing this office table, the fact that the


workers are working for 8 hours is considered. This
means that sitting for 8 hours straight might be
uncomfortable to some. Because of this reason, the
group decided to make the table adjustable so that it
can also be used as a standing desk. According to a
Journal in Harvard Health Publishing, the benefits of
Table 1.1 Critical Dimensions of the Designed Office standing desks include lower risk of obesity,
chair cardiovascular disease, cancer, premature death, and
diabetes (Shmerling, 2016). In order to make this
The goal in designing this office chair is to possible, the sitting and standing height are considered
accommodate a wider range of users. In order to do for both males and females. The table also comes with
this, most of the features of this chair were designed to a footrest with an adjustable angle. Footrests allow
be adjustable such as the adjustable headrest, arm rest, better circulation and posture, reduce risks of back
and seat pan. In getting the appropriate measurements pain, and increase comfortability. (DiVincenzo, 2018)
for these adjustable features, the lower 5th percentile Aside from the adjustable height and the footrest, the
design of this table also considered the placement of
the computer that the workers will use. The group
considered the distance of the user to the computer to
avoid eye strain, and in order to do this, the width of
the table is measured in accordance with the length of
arm and hand. Moreover, the sitting and standing eye
height of the users are also taken into account so that
the position of the computer is at an appropriate angle
which is about 20 degrees. In measuring the length of
the table, the group made sure that the zones of reach
are considered. The position of the keyboard and
mouse should be on the primary zone where the
forearm can easily reach. The next zone is for the
phone which can be reached by extending the arms
without bending and leaning. This was measured using
Figure 2.1 Sketch for the Enhanced Bunk Bed
the thumb tip reach dimensions in the table. Lastly is
The proposed bunk bend is designed using
the tertiary zone of reach where the computer is found.
the design for extremes, since it is aimed to be used by
This is the zone in which extending the arms is
as many people as possible. By employing the said
needed, thus, the anthropometric dimension used for
design strategy, people with anthropometric
estimating this is the length of both arms and hand.
dimensions shorter than the 95th percentile can still fit
in the bed, the only difference being shorter people
will have more allowances for movement. Another
noticeable feature of the enhanced bunk bed is its
unusual staircase design. The group decided to go with
this stair layout because according to Baldwin (2018),
one risky thing about double decks is its stairs.
Traditional bunk beds have ladders instead of stairs.
Workplace Access and Safety (2017) have proved in
their article just how safer stairs are than ladders.
Considering that most people that use this product are
kids, safety should be considered more carefully. Since
the group’s individual anthropometric measurements
Table 1.2 Critical Dimensions of the Designed Office lie near the mean of each dimension, it is safe to say
table that the members of the group will easily fit on the
proposed product.

Part II:
Upon looking at the tables that are provided,
the introduction of ergonomic bunk beds is suggested.
All necessary anthropometric measurements for
designing a bunk bed is available on the tables. More
specifically, the bunk bed that is being suggested is
one that will cater up to the 95th percentile of the
population. Seen in Figure 2.1 is the sketch for the
enhanced bunk bed.

Table 2.1 - Critical dimensions of the proposed bunk


bed

Part III: Other Product Design


Considerations
1. Which anthropometric product design approach/es
would be the most appropriate to be used? Clearly and 2. Look at the class’ anthropometric data from Lab.
concisely provide at least 3 justifications for each.  Exer. 1, would everyone be able to use your proposed
designs from Parts I and II? (need only find one
a. For the call center workstation, the appropriate exemption) If not, explain the problem.
anthropometric product design approach used for most Part I
of the parts is the design for ranges. Both products were Based on the class’ raw anthropometric data
designed to cater the dimensions of the users between from laboratory exercise 1, it is inferred that all of the
the 5th and 95th percentile. On some parts, the extremes subjects are able to use our designed office chair and
were considered but between these two approaches, we desks. This is because the products are originally
believe that the most appropriate is the design for designed to cater a broader range of users by adding
averages because of the following reasons. adjustable features.
 First with the office chair, the seat height was Part II
made adjustable because of the differences in the The dimensions of the enhanced bunk bed are
standing and sitting height of the workers. It is compared to the class data and there is not one
important to consider these height differences because respondent that will not fit in the design. The
they should be able to lay their feet flat on the floor or implementation of the design for extremes seems to be
on the foot rest. Also, when seated, their heights matter a success, at least for the class setting.
because their thighs need to be roughly parallel to the
floor. ( Muller, 2020) In addition to the adjustable 3. What design compromises would have to be made to
height, the armrests’ height are also made adjustable to allow everyone in the class data to use your designs? 
accommodate the differences in elbow to elbow breadth
and can also pivot inwards and outwards to support the
length of the lower arm when doing tasks like typing. Part I
These armrests give postural support and help in Since it is inferred that the design of both the
standing up and sitting down. Another feature that was chair and desks can accommodate the subjects from the
made adjustable is the headrest, this is because of the class data, there are no design compromises which are
differences in the head width of the workers. Headrests needed yet.
are important because of the support it gives to the back Part II
of the head and the upper neck, thus, reducing tension For the proposed product, since everyone in
in the shoulders and upper torso. (“The Ergonomics of a the class data fits into the design, there are no design
Chair”, 2020) compromises that need to be made.
For the office desk, the height was also
designed to be adjustable so that it can also be turned
4. With the onset of “the new normal” would there be
into a standing chair. The range of the height is based
any changes in the anthropometric considerations in
on the 5th percentile of the female sitting height with
product design (in general)? Discuss. 
some allowance and the 95th percentile of the male’s
With no end in sight, this new normal is
standing height respectively. A study in the Journal of
demanding for some considerations in the
Physical Activity and Health says that switching
anthropometric measurements used in product design.
periods of sitting or standing while walking has
Most of the time, people are just sitting in front of their
increased energy expenditure significantly (Creasy,
devices, which is bad for the posture. Consequently,
2016). 
Surgeon-Orthopedic William Morrison (2018) noted
that poor posture is the leading cause of hyperlordosis,
b. For the product you chose or the excessive spinal curvature in the lower back. This
As mentioned in the previous sections of this is just one example on how this pandemic is slowly
exercise, the most appropriate design strategy for the affecting the anthropometric measurements of the
enhanced bunk bed is the design for extremes, population, and the group believes that some
particularly the 95th percentile. This is to be able to fit considerations should be taken.
most of the population. Moreover, having quite a bit
extra allowance on dimensions such as bed length and
bed width is far from being overkill. Another reason is IV. RECOMMENDATION
for safety, since as mentioned before, most people that Much like the previous exercise, this activity is
use this product are children. Having that said, since the feasible given the learning setup that is being
product has several dimensions, it is best for some experienced. For further improvements, it is
dimensions to employ a different design strategy as recommended to have more anthropometric data
doing it with design for extremes may be an available on the tables to cater a vaster array of possible
overabundance. In Table 2.1, it can be seen in the products. Additionally, if the experimenters needed to
remarks column that the design strategy is different conduct some estimation techniques for unavailable
across all dimensions, since the group opted to evaluate measurements, a separate table for correlation
which design strategy to use per dimension. coefficients will increase the efficiency of the activity.
Sen, S. (2020, June 26). How thick should a
V. CONCLUSION mattress be? Retrieved from Early Bird by
In conclusion, the objectives of this exercise Amerisleep:
are achieved. The group has learned to apply https://amerisleep.com/blog/mattress-
anthropometric data for design of workplace and thickness/
product. The concept of anthropometric design
approaches was utilized. Moreover, different critical Shmerling, R. H., MD. (2016, June 18). The
dimensions along with the corresponding truth behind standing desks. Retrieved
anthropometric measurements which affect them were September 26, 2020, from
identified. Overall, this exercise has shown how being https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/the-truth-
knowledgeable on different anthropometric behind-standing-desks-2016092310264
measurements can lead to a more efficient and
comfortable way of living. Stack, T., Ostrom, L. T., & Wilhemlsen, C. A.
(2016, April 22). Anthropometry. Retrieved
from Wiley Online Library:
VI. REFERENCES
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/97
81118814239.ch3#:~:text=Anthropometry
Baldwin, A. (2018, April 20). Best Bunk Beds
%20is%20the%20measurement%20of,and
With Stairs: Safe for Children and Toddlers.
%20strength%20capabilities%20and
Retrieved from Sleepholic:
%20differences.
https://sleepholic.com/best-bunk-beds-stairs-
for-kids/
The Ergonomics of a Chair Explained:
ChairOffice. (2020, September 14). Retrieved
Creasy, S. (2016, June). Energy Expenditure
October 18, 2020, from
During Acute Periods of Sitting, Standing, and
https://www.chairoffice.co.uk/blog/the-
Walking. Retrieved September 26, 2020, from
ergonomics-of-a-chair-explained/
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26693809/
Workspace Access and Safety. (2017, June 1).
DiVincenzo, K. (2018, September 28). Unseen
Ladders, steps and stairs. What to use and
Benefits of Ergonomic Footrests At Your
when. Retrieved from Workspace Access and
Desk. Retrieved October 18, 2020, from
Safety:
https://www.work-fit.com/blog/unseen-
https://www.workplaceaccess.com.au/ladders-
benefits-of-ergonomic-footrests-at-your-desk
steps-and-stairs-what-to-use-and-when/
#:~:text=While%20all%20ladders%20are
Kiel, J., & Casadei, K. (2020, April 28). %20more,significant%20risk%20of%20falling
Anthropometric Measurement. Retrieved from %20backwards.
National Center for Biotechnology
Information:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK537
315/

Muller, J. (2020, June 07). Creating the Perfect


Ergonomic Workspace- The ULTIMATE
Guide. Retrieved October 18, 2020, from
http://ergonomictrends.com/creating-perfect-
ergonomic-workspace-ultimate-guide/?
fbclid=IwAR3OzwRiv9vlOBzlZuEpsE-
wwIxSU2WgBVhDIb3zJLmE2Otpzty07Hdm
6eI

NIOSH. (n.d.). Anthropometry. Retrieved from


Centers for Disease Control and Prevention:
https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/anthropomet
ry/default.html

Rupavate, S. (2020). 6 Health Benefits Of


Ergonomic Chairs At Work. Retrieved October
18, 2020, from
https://preferredergonomics.com/blogs/news/6
-health-benefits-of-ergonomic-chairs-at-work
Statement of Academic Integrity

As a student of the University of the


Philippines, I pledge to act ethically and uphold the
value of honor and excellence.

I understand that suspected misconduct on


given assignments/examinations will be reported to the
appropriate office and if established, will result in
disciplinary action in accordance with University rules,
policies and procedures. I may work with others only to
the extent allowed by the Instructor.

You might also like