You are on page 1of 6

BJA Education Advance Access published September 27, 2016

BJA Education, 2016, 1–6

doi: 10.1093/bjaed/mkw051

Matrix reference
1B04, 1I02, 2CO4

Current recommendations on adult resuscitation


S Williams MBChB FRCA1 and R Bacon MBBS FRCA FFICM2, *

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on September 27, 2016
1
Consultant in Anaesthesia, Royal Berkshire Hospital, London Road, Reading RG1 5AN, UK and 2Consultant
in Anaesthesia, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, Hammersmith Hospital, Du Cane Road, London W12
0HS, UK
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel: +44 20 3313 3143; Fax: +44 20 3313 5373; E-mail: rosalind.bacon@imperial.nhs.uk

recently October 2015.3 This article will discuss and summarize


Key points the main changes.

• Chest compressions must be of high quality with


minimal interruptions. If necessary for specific in-
History
terventions, interruptions should be <5 s duration.
In 1767, a Society in Amsterdam was established for the
• A stepwise approach to airway management is
Recovery of Drowned Persons.4 This was the first resuscitation
recommended.
organization dealing with education, guidelines, and collabor-
• Capnography should be used to confirm and con- ation between physicians and lay people. Despite some rather
tinually monitor tracheal tube placement, quality unusual techniques, many described are still used in modern-
of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), and to pro- day resuscitation, that is, warming the victim and artificial
vide an early indication of return of spontaneous respiration.
circulation. The first scientific paper on survival after closed chest com-
pressions was published in 19605 and was followed by a national
• Recommendations for drug therapy have not chan-
cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) educational programme in
ged but are now considered to be of secondary im-
the USA complete with video ‘The Pulse of Life’. The CPR commit-
portance to high-quality CPR.
tee of the American Heart Association (AHA) was started in 1963,
• Urgent percutaneous coronary intervention should the same year that the AHA formally endorsed CPR.
follow out-of-hospital cardiac arrest with a sus- In 1981, a group of medical practitioners from different
pected cardiac cause. specialities established the RC (UK) to promote scientific
guidelines, education, and training to healthcare professional
and laypersons. In 2012, the National Institute for Health and
Care Excellence (NICE) awarded the RC (UK) accreditation for
Cardiorespiratory arrest remains the most challenging of medical the 2010 guidelines. Three years on the RC (UK) has received
emergencies with ∼18% of in-hospital cardiac arrests surviving to accreditation for the process used to assemble its guideline
leave hospital in the UK.1 Despite data showing improvement in documents.
survival rates after cardiac arrest internationally, only 7–8% of The RC (UK) is a partner of the European Resuscitation Council
out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA)2 survive to hospital dis- (ERC), which was established in 1990 and had its first major
charge in England compared with higher rates in other developed conference in the UK in 1992 to which American and Australian
countries. In Seattle, North America, survival rates of 62% have colleagues were invited. This led to the formation of the Inter-
been reported in patients who had witnessed OHCA with an ini- national Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR) to provide
tial rhythm of ventricular fibrillation (VF). Continual evaluation a worldwide collaboration forum. The RC (UK) guidelines under-
and adjustments in resuscitation guidelines aim to improve sur- go a major revision every 5 yr (synchronized with the Internation-
vival rates. Adult resuscitation guidelines were last reviewed in al Consensus on Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation Science
this journal in 2007. There have been two Resuscitation Council Conferences and new ERC Guidelines), the latest published on
(UK) [RC (UK)] guideline updates since then: in 2010, and most 15 October 2015.

© The Author 2016. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the British Journal of Anaesthesia. All rights reserved.
For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oup.com

Page 1 of 6
Current recommendations on adult resuscitation

Chain of survival as it becomes available. Without interrupting CPR, the AED is is


switched on, pads applied, and instructions followed.
The chain of survival outlines four inter-related actions that
optimize survival from cardiac arrest if delivered correctly (Fig. 1).
Early bystander CPR can dramatically improve survival from Advanced life support
OHCA, but despite this, only 40% of victims receive bystander
The advanced life support (ALS) algorithm should be used by
CPR in the UK.6
healthcare professionals trained in ALS techniques (Fig. 2). It is
The current guidelines emphasize education with recom-
a continuum of care from ongoing BLS, which will overlap with
mendations that everyone should learn CPR. Children should
ALS interventions. If cardiac arrest is suspected, the adult resus-
be taught CPR and how to use an automated external defibrillator
citation team should be called, with the exact location made
(AED).
explicit. Meanwhile, CPR is commenced while self-adhesive
Defibrillators registered with local ambulance services ought
monitoring and defibrillation pads are applied to allow rapid as-
to be available anywhere there are large numbers of people,
sessment of rhythm. The treatment algorithm has two branches,
when cardiac arrest is more likely or where access to emergency
the shockable and the non-shockable pathway, depending on
services may be delayed.
whether defibrillation is indicated. Interventions including high

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on September 27, 2016
quality chest compressions with minimal interruptions, securing
the airway, vascular access, and seeking reversible causes are
Basic life support and automated external common to both groups.
defibrillation
Little has changed in the RC (UK) 2010 guidelines. Rescuers begin
CPR if the victim is unresponsive and breathing abnormally with
Shockable rhythms
the emphasis on minimizing delay in resuscitation. Carotid pulse Approximately 20%1 of in-hospital and out-of-hospital cardiac
check is inaccurate and wastes time and is not recommended. arrests have VF or pulseless ventricular tachycardia ( pVT) as
The 2015 guidelines have advised bystanders and medical emer- the first monitored rhythm. Defibrillating as soon as possible
gency dispatchers to be suspicious of any patient presenting with increases the likelihood of restoring a perfusing rhythm.
seizures, as after cardiac arrest, blood flow to the brain is marked- Chest compressions are stopped for a maximum of 5 s to
ly reduced which can result in seizure-like activity. confirm VF/pVT on the ECG. Chest compressions should then
Rescuers should ensure that help has been summoned and be immediately resumed while the defibrillator operator selects
an AED requested, preferably without leaving the victim, before the appropriate energy and charges the defibrillator. At this
starting CPR. Chest compressions are commenced over the time, the rest of the team (excluding the individual performing
centre of the victim’s chest at a depth of 5–6 cm and a rate chest compressions) are instructed to stand clear and the oxygen
of 100–120 min−1, allowing for permissive recoil. Two rescue delivery device removed if not a closed circuit. Only when the
breaths, each over 1 s, should be given after 30 compressions defibrillator is charged should compressions cease, the person
and then the cycle repeated. The 2010 guidelines emphasized delivering chest compressions warned to stand clear and the
the importance of good quality uninterrupted compressions to shock delivered. Without reassessing rhythm or feeling for a
maintain coronary perfusion pressure. CPR continues until pulse, chest compressions should be resumed immediately. If
there are signs of consciousness in the presence of normal the patient is not intubated, chest compressions should be
breathing. paused once 30 have been delivered for no longer than 5 s to
Compression only CPR remains an option when it is not pos- allow two breaths to be given. Asynchronous compressions
sible to provide rescue breaths or when the rescuer is untrained and ventilations can be commenced when an advanced airway
or unwilling to do so. It has been shown to be as effective as adjunct is secured.
standard CPR in pre-hospital studies7 and the 2012 hands-only After 2 min, having prepared the team for a pause in CPR, the
CPR campaign by the British Heart Foundation has highlighted team leader should check the rhythm. If the patient remains in
this to the general public. VF/ pVT, then a second shock is indicated and the process re-
The 2015 guidelines show a change in the Basic Life Support peated. After a third shock, epinephrine 1 mg and amiodarone
(BLS) Algorithm with the inclusion of AED utilization as soon 300 mg i.v./i.o. should be administered. The 2 min sequence

Fig 1 The chain of survival. Reproduced with the kind permission of Laerdal Medical.

Page 2 of 6 BJA Education | 2016


Current recommendations on adult resuscitation

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on September 27, 2016

Fig 2 ALS algorithm. Reproduced with the kind permission of the Resuscitation Council (UK).

continues as long as a shockable rhythm persists with epineph- If during the rhythm check there is electrical activity compat-
rine given after alternative shocks, every 3–5 min. A further dose ible with a cardiac output then signs of return of spontaneous
of amiodarone 150 mg i.v. may be given after five defibrillation circulation (ROSC) should be sought. These include a central
attempts. pulse check, observing end-tidal CO2, and signs of life. If present,

BJA Education | 2016 Page 3 of 6


Current recommendations on adult resuscitation

post-resuscitation care should be started. If not the patient is in a • Central venous blood analysis which may provide better ana-
non-shockable rhythm and treatment moves to the alternative lysis of tissue pH than blood gas values.
limb of the algorithm. • Invasive cardiovascular monitoring in a critical care setting.
Compressions must never be stopped during a cycle of CPR • Ultrasound to identify and treat reversible causes.
unless there are obvious signs of life.

Reversible causes
Defibrillation During CPR, reversible causes for which there is specific treat-
Defibrillation aims to restore a rhythm compatible with cardiac ment should be identified and treated. They are divided into
output and tissue perfusion with minimal insult to the myocar- two groups of four and are included in the ALS algorithm repre-
dium while ensuring the safety of patient and staff. Most defibril- sented by the four H’s and four T’s:
lators are equipped with adhesive pads rather than paddles
• Hypoxia is minimized by adequate ventilation using maximal
as they are effective, safer, and facilitate a more rapid shock deliv-
inspired oxygen.
ery. The pads are positioned below the right clavicle (sternal) and
• Hypovolaemia is usually due to severe haemorrhage.
in the V6 ECG position in the mid-axillary line. Implantable med-
• Hyperkalemia and metabolic disturbances which may be
ical devices must be avoided. Oxygen should be delivered via a

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on September 27, 2016
suspected from the history or diagnosed by electrolyte or
closed circuit or the device removed at least 1 m away due to
ECG abnormalities should be aggressively treated.
the risk of sparks causing ignition.
• Hypothermia may be suggested by the history, for example,
A single-shock strategy and charging the defibrillator while
drowning.
compressions continue minimizes pauses in compressions.
• Tension pneumothorax may be the primary cause of PEA and
An exception to this approach is the delivery of three stacked
requires rapid decompression.
shocks before compressions in cardiac arrest during coronary
• Tamponade (cardiac) should be suspected after penetrating
catheterization, or after recent cardiac surgery. This may also
chest trauma. The use of ultrasound helps with the clinical
be considered in a witnessed VF/pVT arrest with the patient con-
diagnosis.
nected to a manual defibrillator, as it is unlikely that compres-
• Toxins or drug ingestion may be apparent from the history or
sions will improve the already high chance of ROSC.
the clinical picture. The mainstay of treatment is supportive
The majority of defibrillators used in hospitals are biphasic.
as few specific antidotes are available.
This type has greater efficacy in terminating VF/pVT than the
• Thromboembolic disease includes pulmonary embolus (PE)
monophasic defibrillators and, therefore, lower energy levels
and coronary thrombosis. PE may require thrombolysis
may be used. The first shock delivered using a biphasic defibrilla-
necessitating prolonged resuscitation. Coronary thrombosis
tor should be at least 150 J. Evidence for appropriate energy levels
associated with acute coronary syndrome (ACS) is usually di-
for subsequent shocks is lacking and local protocols exist in most
agnosed after ROSC but if suspected and ROSC has not been
Trusts.
achieved, urgent coronary angiography should be considered.
A precordial thump is rarely successful and is no longer
This may require support from mechanical chest compres-
routinely recommended. It can be given in the first few seconds
sion devices and extracorporeal CPR.
of a witnessed VF/pVT arrest while waiting for a defibrillator
but it must not delay definitive treatment (with defibrillation). The use of focused echocardiography/ultrasound peri-arrest may
be useful.8 Although no trials have shown this imaging modality
Treatment of PEA and asystole (non-shockable has improved outcome, its use during CPR can help to identify
cardiac tamponade, PE, hypovolaemia, and pneumothorax.
rhythms)
Asystole or pulseless electrical activity (PEA—absence of a pulse
with organized electrical activity which would be expected to
Airway management
produce a cardiac output) are rhythms which do not require The majority of cardiac arrests in the adult population are not of
defibrillation. CPR should be started and asystole confirmed by hypoxic origin with adequate arterial PaO2 immediately after the
checking the leads are actually attached. Epinephrine 1 mg i.v./ arrest. The issue is lack of oxygen delivery to the organs, hence
i.o. is recommended as soon as vascular access is secured. After the emphasis on the importance of maintaining coronary and
2 min, there should be a rhythm check. If there is no palpable cerebral circulation.
pulse, 2 min cycles of CPR should be continued, with epinephrine Basic airway management remains the same: head tilt and
given every 3–5 min. If a shockable rhythm develops, treatment chin lift or jaw thrust with the addition of airway adjuncts as
should switch to the alternative limb of the algorithm. If there required.
are P waves present, cardiac pacing may be attempted. Studies Tracheal intubation, once the gold standard of advanced air-
have shown no benefit in giving atropine, which is no longer way management, is no longer accorded the same importance.
recommended. Although it offers superior airway control and protection against
aspiration, attempts may lead to unacceptable pauses in chest
compressions and result in malposition of the endotracheal
Monitoring during CPR
tube (ETT). Early studies suggest that the use of video laryngo-
The importance of monitoring to assist with interventions is em- scopes may improve intubation success rates,9 but further data
phasized in the 2015 RC (UK) guidelines. In addition to clinical are required. Current recommendations are that tracheal intub-
signs, the following methods should be used during CPR: ation should only be attempted by trained personnel and chest
compressions should be interrupted for no longer than 5 s. Alter-
• End-tidal CO2 with waveform capnography. natively, intubation can be delayed until ROSC.
• CPR feedback or prompt devices. Supraglottic airway devices are now preferred as they can be
• Blood sampling and analysis to help identify reversible causes. inserted rapidly without interruption to chest compressions.

Page 4 of 6 BJA Education | 2016


Current recommendations on adult resuscitation

Ventilation with a laryngeal mask airway is easier than with a should be the aim as both hypocarbia and hypercarbia have dele-
bag-valve mask and does provide a degree of protection against terious effects.
aspiration. A randomized controlled trial is underway comparing ACS is a major cause of OHCA. More than 80% of patients with
the use of i-gel with tracheal intubation for initial airway man- ROSC and ST segment elevation (STE) or left bundle branch block
agement in OHCA. Currently, a stepwise approach to airway will have an acute coronary lesion and it has been shown that
management is proposed based on patient factors and compe- early percutaneous coronary intervention is beneficial.12 In
tencies of the rescuer. those patients without STE but potential ACS, there are conflict-
The guidelines emphasize the importance of waveform cap- ing data and treatment should be individualized in consultation
nography in resuscitation. Clinical signs alone are a notoriously with cardiology.
unreliable way to confirm tracheal placement. Waveform capno- Myocardial function may require optimization guided by
graphy allows conformation of correct ETT placement (although basic monitoring, echocardiography, and plasma lactate clear-
it will not distinguish between bronchial and tracheal place- ance. Intra-aortic balloon pumps (IABP) have not been shown to
ment). It permits monitoring of ventilation rate during resuscita- improve 30 day mortality in patients with cardiogenic shock.
tion, provides monitoring of the quality of chest compressions, Cooling reduces cerebral metabolism and oxygen free radical
provides an early indicator of ROSC, and allows for a certain de- production, inhibits excitatory amino acid release, attenuates the
gree of prognostication during CPR. Modern portable monitoring immune response during reperfusion, and inhibits apoptosis.

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on September 27, 2016
equipment includes waveform capnography. Therapeutic hypothermia was recommended in the 2010 guide-
In the event of a failure to establish an airway and ventilate lines for all unconscious patients with ROSC. The original 2002
an apnoeic patient, needle or surgical cricothyroidotomy can trials showed improved neurological outcomes with cooling to
be life-saving techniques. However, the fourth National Audit 32–34°C for 12–24 h after OHCA in VF.13,14 At the time, the RC
Project (NAP4) showed that needle cricothyroidotomy was un- (UK) guidelines expanded this to include all comatose patients
successful in 60% of cases. on the basis of data from several non-randomized trials. NICE
guidelines published in 2011 concurred. In fact, the evidence of
improved outcome is less conclusive for non-shockable rhythms.
Drugs Subsequently, the Targeted temperature management (TTM)
ILCOR systemic reviews have not found sufficient evidence to trial has shown no benefit in cooling to 33°C compared with
comment on survival to discharge and neurological outcomes 36°C in patients with OHCA.15 Importantly in the TTM trial, after
with any drug during CPR. Drugs are now considered to be of sec- the initial cooling period, both groups of patients had their tem-
ondary importance to high-quality chest compression and CPR. perature maintained at normothermia (37.5°C) for 3 days after
A recent trial of epinephrine administration in OHCA found ROSC. Many units prefer cooling to the higher temperature as it re-
no improvement in survival to hospital discharge, but there duces the need for vasopressor support, shortens the rewarming
was significantly increased likelihood of achieving ROSC.10 The phase, and lessens the risk of rebound hyperthermia. The 2015
PARAMEDIC 2 randomized controlled trial is now recruiting and guidelines suggest that TTM should be guided by local policy.
aims to determine if epinephrine improves long-term survival Seizures occur in up to 40% of unconscious survivors and
in OHCA. The 2015 guidelines do not propose a change to current must be controlled to prevent associated increase in cerebral
practice until there are high-quality data available. metabolic demand.
A bolus of amiodarone 300 mg is still recommended after the Hyperglycaemia is strongly associated with a poorer outcome.
third shock in VF/VT. It has been shown to increase the survival However, due to the risks of hypoglycaemia, blood glucose should
to hospital admission but not to hospital discharge. A rando- be maintained at <10 mmol litre−1 rather than 4.5–6 mmol litre−1.
mized controlled trial comparing outcomes with amiodarone, Post-resuscitation care is complicated, time-intensive, and
lidocaine, and placebo is underway.11 expensive. Reliable methods of predicting neurological outcome
Peripheral venous access remains the preferred route for drug after cardiac arrest are needed, so that appropriate management,
administration followed by the intraosseous route if this is not including limitation or withdrawal of care, can be followed. There
achieved. are currently no clinical tests, biochemical markers, or neuro-
physiological or imaging studies that can reliably allow a progno-
sis at <72 h. Prognostication needs to include multiple different
Post-resuscitation care tests of brain function and should be delayed until any neuro-
Survival to hospital discharge in comatose patients with ROSC is logical recovery and clearance of sedatives has occurred. The
∼40–50% and the majority have a good neurological outcome 2015 guidelines include a prognostication strategy algorithm.
depending on the cause and quality of care. The pathological pro- In the event of death, the guidelines emphasize that the pos-
cess after ROSC is described as post-cardiac arrest syndrome and sibility of organ donation should not be overlooked. For patients
comprises brain injury, myocardial dysfunction, systemic ischae- who survive to hospital discharge, rehabilitation and follow-up
mia/reperfusion response, and persistence of the precipitating care is essential.
pathology. Little is known about the underlying mechanisms
and the best treatment strategies. Despite this, the knowledge
and skills possessed by anaesthetists and intensivists make
Summary
them the best-qualified specialists to manage these patients. The new guidelines emphasize the importance of early interven-
This is arguably the time when they can contribute most in the tion by the bystander and emergency dispatcher with rapid
resuscitation process with treatment involving airway, breath- deployment of an AED during BLS. Education of the general pub-
ing, circulation, and neurological optimization. lic is paramount for providing early CPR.
Oxygenation should be titrated to an arterial saturation of Provision of high-quality chest compressions with minimal
94–98% and hyperoxia avoided as it has been associated with interruptions for interventions and a greater degree of monitor-
worse outcomes. If the airway is compromised, tracheal intub- ing during CPR to help diagnose and treat reversible causes are
ation, ventilation, and sedation may be necessary. Normocarbia highlighted.

BJA Education | 2016 Page 5 of 6


Current recommendations on adult resuscitation

Patients suspected of having a cardiac cause after OHCA need MEDIC): a pragmatic, cluster randomised controlled trial.
urgent referral for coronary catheterization. Lancet 2015; 385: 947–55
Although guidelines are under constant review and develop- 7. SOS-KANTO Study Group. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation by
ment, recent studies from the American Heart Association pub- bystanders with chest compression only (SOS-KANTO): an
lished in the British Medical Journal in April 2016 show that observational study. Lancet 2007; 369: 920–6
adherence to them is not consistent. 8. Flato UA, Paiva EF, Carballo MT et al. Echocardiography for
The National Cardiac Arrest Audit (NCAA) continues to moni- prognostication during the resuscitation of intensive care
tor in-hospital cardiac arrests while the National Out of Hospital unit patients with non-shockable rhythm cardiac arrest.
Cardiac Arrest project measures outcome variables from OHCA. Resuscitation 2015; 92: 1–6
Both foster quality improvement initiatives with the hope of 9. Lee DH, Han M, An JY et al. Video laryngoscopy versus
improving outcomes. direct laryngoscopy for tracheal intubation during in-
hospital cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Resuscitation 2015;
89: 195–9
Declaration of interest 10. Jacobs IG, Finn JC, Jelinek GA et al. Effect of adrenaline on sur-
vival in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. A randomized double-
None declared.
blind placebo-controlled trial. Resuscitation 2011; 82: 1138–43

Downloaded from http://bjaed.oxfordjournals.org/ by Syed Zeeshan Javaid Hashmi on September 27, 2016
11. Kudenchuk PJ, Brown SP, Daya M et al. Resuscitation
Outcomes Consortium-Amiodarone, Lidocaine or Placebo
References Study (ROC-ALPS): rationale and methodology behind an
1. Nolan JP, Soar J, Smith GB et al. Incidence and outcome of in- out-of-hospital cardiac arrest antiarrhythmic drug trial. Am
hospital cardiac arrest in the United Kingdom National Heart J 2014; 167: 653–9
Cardiac Arrest Audit. Resuscitation 2014; 85: 987–92 12. Nikolaou NI, Arntz HR, Bellou A et al. European Resuscitation
2. Perkins GD, Lockey AS, de Belder MA et al. National initiatives Council Guidelines for Resuscitation 2015 Section 8. Initial
to improve outcomes from out of hospital cardiac arrest management of acute coronary syndromes. Resuscitation
in England. Emerg Med J 2015, doi:10.1136/emermed-2015- 2015; 95: 263–76
204847 13. The Hypothermia after Cardiac Arrest Study Group. Mild
3. Resuscitation Guidelines 2015. Resuscitation Council UK. therapeutic hypothermia to improve the neurologic outcome
Available from www.resus.org.uk/resuscitation-guidelines/ after cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med 2002; 346: 549–56
4. Johnson A. An account of some societies at Amsterdam and 14. Bernard SA, Gray TW, Buist MD et al. Treatment of comatose
Hamburg for the recovery of drowned persons, 1773, London survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest with induced
5. Kouwenhoven WB, Jude JR, Knickerbocker GG. Closed-chest hypothermia. N Engl J Med 2002; 346: 557–63
cardiac massage. J Am Med Assoc 1960; 173: 1064–7 15. Nielsen N, Wetterslev J, Cronberg T et al. Targeted tempera-
6. Perkins GD, Lall R, Quinn T et al. Mechanical versus manual ture management at 33 degrees C versus 36 degrees C after
chest compression for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (PARA- cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med 2013; 369: 2197–206

Page 6 of 6 BJA Education | 2016

You might also like