Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Archimedes and Newton might be the two best geometers ever, but although each
produced ingenious geometric proofs, often they used non-rigorous calculus
to discover results, and then devised rigorous geometric proofs for publication.
Archimedes used integral calculus to determine the centers of mass of hemisphere and
cylindrical wedge, and the volume of two cylinders' intersection. He also worked with
various spirals, paraboloids of revolution, etc. Although Archimedes didn't develop
differentiation (integration's inverse), Michel Chasles credits him (along with Kepler,
Cavalieri, and Fermat, who all lived more than 18 centuries later) as one of the four
who developed calculus before Newton and Leibniz. (Although familiar with the
utility of infinitesimals, he accepted the "Theorem of Eudoxus" which bans them to
avoid Zeno's paradoxes. Modern mathematicians refer to that "Theorem" as the
Axiom of Archimedes.)
Archimedes was an astronomer (details of his discoveries are lost, but it is likely he
knew the Earth rotated around the Sun). He was one of the greatest mechanists ever,
discovering Archimedes' Principle of Hydrostatics. (A body partially or completely
immersed in a fluid effectively loses weight equal to the weight of the fluid it
displaces. Archimedes is famous for testing the purity of his King's gold crown, but he
didn't write up his solution; it was finally Galileo who pointed out that a test based on
measuring water displacement, as had been assumed to be Archimedes' "Eureka!"
method, would be extremely imprecise. Instead Archimedes must have applied the
less trivial corollaries of his Principle of Hydrostatics by comparing a balance scale's
reading in and out of water.) Archimedes developed the mathematical foundations
underlying the advantage of basic machines: lever, screw and compound pulley.
Although Archytas perhaps invented the screw, and Stone-Age man (and even other
animals) used levers, it is said that the compound pulley was invented by Archimedes
himself. For these achievements he is widely considered to be one of the three or four
greatest theoretical physicists ever. Archimedes was a prolific inventor: in addition to
inventing the compound pulley, he invented the hydraulic screw-pump (called
Archimedes' screw); a miniature planetarium; and several war machines -- catapult,
parabolic mirrors to burn enemy ships, a steam cannon, and 'the Claw of Archimedes.'
(Some scholars attribute the Antikythera mechanism to Archimedes -- Is it the
Archimedean planetarium mentioned by Cicero? However this is unlikely: the
detailed motion of the Moon produced by the mechanism was probably unknown until
Hipparchus.)
That Archimedes shared the attitude of later mathematicians like Hardy and Brouwer
is suggested by Plutarch's comment that Archimedes regarded applied mathematics
"as ignoble and sordid ... and did not deign to [write about his mechanical inventions;
instead] he placed his whole ambition in those speculations the beauty and subtlety of
which are untainted by any admixture of the common needs of life."
Top
Eratosthenes was one of the greatest polymaths; he is called the Father of Geography,
was Chief Librarian at Alexandria, was a poet, music theorist, mechanical engineer
(anticipating laws of elasticity, etc.), astronomer (he is credited as first to measure the
circumference of the Earth), and an outstanding mathematician. He is famous for his
prime number Sieve, but more impressive was his work on the cube-doubling problem
which he related to the design of siege weapons (catapults) where a cube-root
calculation is needed.
Eratosthenes had the nickname Beta; he was a master of several fields, but was only
second-best of his time. His better was also his good friend: Archimedes of Syracuse
dedicated The Method to Eratosthenes.