SOAL NOMOR 1

JAWABAN NOMOR 1
POINT A
POINT B
Alternatif A (Menggunakan Formula IRR di Excel)
Tahun Net Profit
0 -2100
1 200
2 215
3 230
4 245
5 160
6 275
7 290
8 305
9 320
10 533
IRR 4,676%

Alternatif B (Menggunakan Formula IRR di Excel)

Tahun Net Profit
0 -1400
1 235
2 215
3 130
4 195
5 175
6 155
7 135
8 115
9 95
10 235
IRR 3,775%

Alternatif B (Menggunakan Formula IRR di Excel)

Tahun Net Profit
0 -2800
1 210
2 240
3 270
4 110
5 330
6 360
7 390
8 420
9 450
10 1110
IRR 5,009%
SOAL NOMOR 2

JAWABAN NOMOR 2
Point A
Point B
Alternatif A
PVBenefit
BCR =
PVCost
200 (𝑃/𝐴, 15%, 10) − 10(𝑃/𝐺, 15%, 10) + 250(𝑃/𝐹, 15%, 10)
BCR =
1100 + 80(𝑃/𝐴, 15%, 10) + 10(𝑃/𝐺, 15%, 10) + 30(𝑃/𝐹, 15%, 6)
200 (5,019) − 10(16,979) + 250(0,2472)
BCR =
1100 + 80(5,019) + 10(16,979) + 30(0,4323)
913,81
BCR =
1684,279
BCR ≈ 𝟎, 𝟓𝟒

Alternatif B
PVBenefit
BCR =
PVCost
750 (𝑃/𝐴, 15%, 10) − 15(𝑃/𝐺, 15%, 10) + 190(𝑃/𝐹, 15%, 10)
BCR =
1800 + 120(𝑃/𝐴, 15%, 10) + 30(𝑃/𝐺, 15%, 10) + 50(𝑃/𝐹, 15%, 5)
750 (5,019) − 15(16,979) + 190(0,2472)
BCR =
1800 + 120(5,019) + 30(16,979) + 50(0,4972)
3556,533
BCR =
2936,51
BCR ≈ 𝟏, 𝟐𝟏

Alternatif C
PVBenefit
BCR =
PVCost
750 (𝑃/𝐴, 15%, 10) + 45(𝑃/𝐺, 15%, 10) + 230(𝑃/𝐹, 15%, 10)
BCR =
1800 + 120(𝑃/𝐴, 15%, 10) + 30(𝑃/𝐺, 15%, 10) + 50(𝑃/𝐹, 15%, 4)
750 (5,019) + 15(16,979) + 190(0,2472)
BCR =
2250 + 300(5,019) − 25(16,979) + 50(0,5718)
4065,903
BCR =
3359,815
BCR ≈ 𝟏, 𝟐𝟏