You are on page 1of 281

Supply Chain

Management
MS 491
Hassaan Tariq
School of Management Sciences
Fall 2022

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 1


Introduction to Supply Chain
Management

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 2


Supply Chain Definition
• A supply chain is a focus on the core activities within our organisation
required to convert raw materials or component parts through to
finished products or services. We look upstream to our suppliers and
their supply of raw materials or components into our own
organisations supply chain.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 3


Generic Supply Chain Schematic

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 4


Main aim of Supply Chain Management
• To balance Demand and Supply

• Maximize value from People, process and system

Key stages in Supply Chain Management


1. Logistics
2. Operations
3. Marketing and Sales
4. Services
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 5
3 key Strategies to achieve Competitive
Advantage
• Cost Leadership

• Differentiation

• Response

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 6


Supply Chain Networks
• Amazon
• Toyota Motors
• Daraz
• Q-commerce Companies

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 7


Supply Chain
Processes –
Cycle View
Manufacturing Strategies / Order Fulfillment Responses in SCs
• Engineer-to-Order (ETO). With this approach, products are designed and built according to
customer specifications. This approach is frequently used for large-scale construction projects,
custom homebuilding, home remodeling, and for products made in job shops. The fulfillment
time can be relatively lengthy because of the nature of the project, as well as the presence of
other jobs ahead of the new one.

• Make-to-Order (MTO). With this approach, a standard product design is used, but production
of the final product is linked to the final customer’s specifications. This approach is used by
aircraft manufacturers such as Boeing. Fulfillment time is generally less than with ETO
fulfillment, but still fairly long.

• Assemble-to-Order (ATO). With this approach, products are assembled to customer


specifications from a stock of standard and modular components. Computer manufacturers
such as Dell operate using this approach. Fulfillment times are fairly short, often a week or less.

• Make-to-Stock (MTS). With this approach, production is based on a forecast, and products are
sold to the customer from finished goods stock. This approach is used in department stores
and supermarkets. The order fulfillment time is immediate. A variation of this is e-commerce;
although goods have already been produced, there is a lag in fulfillment to allow for shipping.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 9
Push vs Pull
View in Supply
Chain - MTS

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 10


Push vs Pull in
SC - MTO

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 11


Supply Chain Macro-Processes in a Firm
• 1. Customer Relationship Management (CRM): All processes at the
interface between the firm and its customers
• 2. Internal Supply Chain Management (ISCM): All processes that are
internal to the firm
• 3. Supplier Relationship Management (SRM): All processes at the
interface between the firm and its suppliers

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 12


Case Study
• Lets Discuss!
• Lecture Notes to Read and Discuss in the Next Class! This will be
counted as a ‘Marked Verbal Quiz’

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 13


Let’s Discuss Things!
• Marking Schemes stay the Same, Only Addition is Project instead of
Assignment

• What is SCM
• Vertical Integration
• Reverse Logistics
• Flows in SCM
• 1st and 2nd Tier Suppliers and Customers
• 3PL vs 4th Party Logistics
• Bull-Whip Effect
• Business Process Re-Engineering

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 14


Let’s Discuss Things!
• Supplier Management
• Supplier Evaluation and Certifications
• Expansion and Contraction of SCM → Nearshoring, Outsourcing,
Right-Shoring
• Agile, Lean and Green Supply Chains

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 15


Let’s Discuss Things!
• Chapter 2 – Purchasing Management
• Purchasing vs Procurement
• Traditional vs E-Procurement
• Tender , Bid, Purchase Order,
• Financial Impact of Purchasing → Return on Assets/ROI, Profit
Leverage Effect, Inventory Turnover
• Make or Buy in SCM and their Effect
• Breakeven Analysis
• Parameters for Supplier Selection → Technology, Info Sharing, Cost,
Quality, Reliability, Capacity, Ordering System, Communication
Capability, Location, Service Levels
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 16
Let’s Discuss Things!
• Chapter 2 – Purchasing Management
• Total Cost of Ownership → Order Processing Cost, Inventory Carrying
Cost, Cost of Working Capital, Back-Order Cost
• Single vs Multiple Suppliers
• Centralized and De-Centralized Purchasing
• Global Sourcing and Players
• Public Procurement and terms
• Problems and Numericals from the Chapter???

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 17


Current Supply Chain Scenario and Reasons!

• Disruptions → Due to ????????????????????

• Impact on Pakistan?????

• Is CPEC a Game Changer?????

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 18


Cycle View of
Supply Chain
Processes
Push/Pull
view of SCM
Manufacturing Strategies and De-Coupling Points – SCM Perspective

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 21


Supply Chain Macro-Processes

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 22


What’s a Responsive SC
• Respond to wide ranges of quantities demanded
• Meet short lead times
• Handle a large variety of products
• Build highly innovative products
• Meet a high service level
• Handle supply uncertainty

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 23


Drivers of SC
Performance

24
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM
Efficient vs Responsive SC

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 25


Supply Chain Flows
• Amazon
• Toyota
• Daraz

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 26


Procurement
Chapter 2,3 & 4

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 27


Traditional
Procurement

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 28


E-
Procurement

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 29


Advantages of E-Procurement

Time Savings Cost Savings Accuracy Real Time

Ease of
Mobility Trackability Business for Management
Suppliers

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 30


Hascol, Toyota, Suzuki Motors
Pakistan!

What had they done!

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM

31
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM

Make or Buy
The Decision
to Source or Backward Vertical Integration
Out-Source or
In-House
Forward Vertical Integration

Near Sourcing, Off-Shoring , Re-


Shoring

32
Cost Saving → Economies of Scale

Insufficient Capacity → Sub-Contracting


Reasons for
Lack of Expertise
Buying/Outsourcing
Quality

Geographical Advantage

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 33


Protect innovative Technology

No competent Supplier

Reasons to Better Quality Control

Make Using idle Capacity → Capacity Cushion

Control of Lead Time, Transportation Cost and


Warehousing Cost

Lower Cost → If right resources are available

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 34


Effect of Sourcing on ROA

Value of Assets = $ 500,000/


ROA in both Cases! 50,000/500000 or 70,000/500,00

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 35


Break-Even for Make or Buy

Make Simultaneous Equations

25000+ 5Q = 500+7Q

$25; 000 + $5 × (12250) = $86,250

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 36


Essential Criteria’s for Supplier Selection
• Process and Product Technologies
• Willingness to share technologies and Information → Early Supplier
Involvement
• Quality
• Cost
• Reliability
• Ordering System and Cycle Time
• Capacity
• Communication
• Location
• Service

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 37


Reasons for Choosing a Single Supplier

• Good Working relationships


• Less Variable Quality
• Lower Cost
• Transportation Economies → Truck Load (TL) OR Less than Truck Load
(LTL)
• Proprietary Product
• If dealing with less volumes
• ESI and Privacy

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 38


Reasons to Choose Multiple Suppliers

• Capacity Enhancement
• Less Risk of Supply Disruptions
• Creates Inter-Supplier Competition
• Information
• Social Sustainability → Promotion of women lead business, Social
Sustainability

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 39


Centralized vs De-Centralized Purchasing

Advantages of Centralized Purchasing

• Concentration of Purchase Volume → Quantity Discounts


• Avoid Duplication
• Specialization
• Lower Transport Costs
• No Competition within units
• Common Supply Base

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 40


Advantages of De-Centralized Purchasing

Closer
knowledge of the Local Sourcing Less Bereaucracy
requirements

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 41


Key Clauses in International Purchasing Contracts
• Product → International Standards , like ASTM
• Quantity → Units
• Delivery → Time, Schedule, FOB $ , Location, Carriage Cost
• Price → FOB $,
• Payment Terms
• Transfer of Ownership→ “Seller and buyer agree that owner ship of the
contract goods will pas to the buyer upon payment of the price to the
seller”
• Insurance → CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight)
• Government Requirements
• Dispute Resolution → ICC (International Court of Dispute Resolution)
• Applicable Laws → (CISG→ Contract of Intl. Sales of Goods states to
Domiciled Laws)
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 42
International
Commercial
Terms Rules

43
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM
Self-Study
• http://globalstandard.cips.org/?utm_source=CIPSwebsite&utm_medi
um=webpage&utm_campaign=AccessTheInteractiveToolScreenshotSt
ep2&_ga=2.57512111.42308048.1645167337-
1451748656.1633338469

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 44


Logistics

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 45


Logistics Basics Content

• Logistics → Definition
• Modes of Logistics→ Air , Sea, Ship, Road → Advantages and
Disadvantages
• Inbound/Internal/Outbound
• Last Mile Logistics
• 3PL vs 4PL
• Risks in Logistics

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 46


Forecasting & Demand Management
Chapter 5

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 47


• What is Forecasting??? E.g. Apple Iphone 4 – 600,000/ Pre-Orders
• Airbus delivered 29 planes out of the 202 ordered – A380
• Types of Forecasts?
• Where to Forecast and Where Not?

• Demand, Independent vs Dependent Demand?


• Demand Management in Pakistan?

• Ultimate aim of Supply Chain is to Balance Demand and Supply!

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 48


• Forecast→ A statement about the future value of a variable of
interest. Demand can be a variable.

• Long Term and Short Term Forecasting

• Famous Saying → Forecasting is In-Accurate

• Good Forecasting should be accurate, timely, reliable, meaningful


units, cost-effective and simple to use & understand.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 49
Forecasting in different Business Environments
• Accounting. New product/process cost estimates, profit projections, cash
management.
• Finance. Equipment/equipment replacement needs, timing and amount of
funding/borrowing needs.
• Human resources. Hiring activities, including recruitment, interviewing,
and training; layoff planning, including outplacement counseling.
• Marketing. Pricing and promotion, e-business strategies, global
competition strategies.
• MIS. New/revised information systems, internet services.
• Operations. Schedules, capacity planning, work assignments and
workloads, inventory planning, make-or-buy decisions, outsourcing, project
management.
• Product/service design. Revision of current features, design of new
products or services.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 50
Benefits of Forecast
• Reduced Inventories
• Reduced Stockout
• Smooth Production plans
• Reduced Cost
• Improved Customer Service levels

• Demand Forecasting is done at various levels in Supply Chains!


Suppliers→ Buyers → Consumers ; Invetory Forms and Where forecasting is
Required
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 51
Companies understanding about Forecasting
• To make forecast more reliable and accurate, a company must be
knowledgeable about the following factors.
• Past Demand
• Lead time of Product Replenishment
• Planned Advertising or Marketing Efforts
• Planned price and Discounts
• State of the Economy
• Actions that Competitors have taken

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 52


Steps in a Forecasting Process

• Determine the purpose of the forecast


• Establish a time horizon
• Obtain, clean, and analyze appropriate data
• Select a forecasting technique
• Make the forecast
• Monitor the forecast errors

Mandatory Reading.
https://hbr.org/1971/07/how-to-choose-the-right-forecasting-technique
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 53
2 Main types of Forecasting
• Qualitative → Qualitative techniques permit inclusion of soft
information (e.g., human factors, personal opinions, hunches) in the
forecasting process. Those factors are often omitted or downplayed
when quantitative techniques are used because they are difficult or
impossible to quantify

• Quantitative → Quantitative methods involve either the projection of


historical data or the development of associative models that attempt
to utilize causal (explanatory) variables to make a forecast

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 54


Classification of Forecasting Techniques
• Judgmental forecasts rely on analysis of subjective inputs obtained
from various sources, such as consumer surveys, the sales staff,
managers and executives, and panels of experts. For New Industries!

• Time-series forecasts simply attempt to project past experience into


the future. These techniques use historical data with the assumption
that the future will be like the past.

• Associative models use equations that consist of one or more


explanatory variables that can be used to predict demand. For
example, demand for paint might be related to variables such as the
price per gallon and the amount spent on advertising, as well as to
specific characteristics of the paint (e.g., drying time, ease of
cleanup).
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 55
Qualitative Methods

• Jury of Executive Opinion → Dominated Discussions by Top Mgt, e.g.


Fashion Trends

• Sales Forces Composite → Individual Biasis

• Delphi Method → Technology, Projects,

• Consumer Survey → Focused Groups as well

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 56


Machine Learning based Forecasting

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 57


Machine Learning Forecasting Methods
• ARIMA and S-ARIMA
• Artificial neural network
• Long short-term-memory-based neural network
• Random forest
• Generalized regression neural networks
• K-nearest neighbours regression
• Classification and regression trees (CART)
• Support vector regression
• Gaussian processes

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 58


ML vs Traditional Forecasting Results

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 59


Quantitative Methods – Traditional Forecasting
• Time series forecasting is based on the assumption that the future is
an extension of the past; thus, historical data can be used to predict
future demand.

• Since these forecasts rely solely on past demand data, all quantitative
methods become less accurate as the forecast’s time horizon
increases.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 60


Components/Behaviours of Time Series Method
• Trend A long-term upward or downward movement in data

• Seasonality Short-term regular variations related to the calendar or


time of day

• Cycle Wave like variations lasting more than one year

• Irregular variation Caused by unusual circumstances, not reflective of


typical behavior

• Random variations Residual variations after all other behaviors are


accounted for
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 61
Variations in Time Series

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 62


Naïve Forecasting
• A forecast for any period that equals the previous period’s actual
value. 2 Methods. Reliability is low but Simple to understand. Not
much previous data required.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 63


Averaging Techniques

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 64


Simple Moving
Average

•A moving average
forecast tends to
smooth and lag
changes in the data
MA 3 vs 5 Periods

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 66


• A weighted average is similar to a moving average,
except that it typically assigns more weight to the
most recent values in a time series.

Weighted
Moving
Average

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 67


Practice Question

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 68


Solution

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 69


Exponential Smoothing
• A weighted averaging method based on the previous forecast plus a
percentage of the forecast error.

• Next forecast = Previous forecast + α(Actual − Previous forecast)

• The closer α is to zero, the greater the smoothing

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 70


Numerical –Exponential Smoothing

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 71


Choosing Alpha – Exponential Smoothing
• Selecting a smoothing constant is basically a matter of judgment or
trial and error, using forecast errors to guide the decision.
• The goal is to select a smoothing constant that balances the benefits
of smoothing random variations with the benefits of responding to
real changes if and when they occur.
• Commonly used values of α range from .05 to .50.
• Low values of α are used when the underlying average tends to be
stable; higher values are used when the underlying average is
susceptible to change.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 72


Trend based Forecasting
• Trend Line Forecasting

• Spear Man’s Co-Efficient

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 73


Trend-Line Equation

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 74


Trend Line Practice Question

75
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM
Measuring Forecasting Accuracy
• Mean absolute deviation
(MAD) The average absolute
forecast error
• Mean squared error (MSE) The
average of squared forecast
errors.
• Mean absolute percent error
(MAPE) The average absolute
percent error.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 76


Practice
Question

9.5
Complex Forecasting Numerals

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 78


Exponential Smoothing with Trend Adjustment

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 79


Numeral – Exponential Smoothing with Trend Adjusted

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 80


Solution to the Numeral

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 81


Solution of the Numeral Continued

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 82


Solution of the Numeral - Continued

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 83


Solution of the Numeral – Continued

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 84


Determining Seasonal Index in
Forecasting

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 85


Calculating Seasonal Indices

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 86


Using Seasonal Indices for Forecasting

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 87


Using Seasonal
Indices with
Linear
Forecasting

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 88


Trend Line * Seasonal Index

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 89


Regression Analysis - Forecasting
• Independent vs Dependent Variable

• Zoom Session

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 90


Demand Management
• Demand management includes activities that range from determining
or estimating the demand from customers, through converting
specific customer orders into promised delivery dates, to helping
balance demand with supply.

• Timely and honest customer order promises are possible. Physical


distribution activities can be improved significantly.

• Demand management is also concerned with identifying all sources of


demand for manufacturing capacity, including service-part demands,
intra company requirements, and promotional inventory buildup or
other needs for pipeline inventory stocking.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 91
Demand Management VS Demand Driven Supply Chains
• Demand management is a process within an organisation which enables that
organisation to tailor its capacity to meet variations in demand or to manage the level of
demand using marketing or supply chain management strategies.

• Demand driven supply chain (DDSC), also known as demand-driven supply network
(DDSN), is a system of technologies and processes that sense and react to real-time
demand across a network of customers, suppliers and employees, this has been
significantly enabled due to the rise in the use of e-commerce systems and new
technologies due to the onset of the Internet of Things (IoT).
• In a traditional supply chain, inventory or services are provided based on a forecasted
demand and historical sales patterns, however, in a demand driven supply chain
companies that form part of the supply chain work closely to shape market demand by
sharing and collaborating information so avoiding time lags in information flow, with a
view to avoiding the bullwhip effect occurring across the supply chain.
• A demand driven supply chain focuses on the demand from the consumer data and
feeds this data through to the supply base so driving greater efficiency into inventory
availability giving a demand-pull technique.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 92
Demand
Management
Process

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 93


Objectives and Levers of Demand Management
• The objectives on the demand side are to (1) Grow market, (2) Steal market share from
competitors, or (3) Shift buying patterns of the customers

• Companies may deal with Limited Supplies through Demand Shaping

• ERP Systems can help to reduce Demand Variability through small and frequent orders,
and integrating Up and Down Stream SCM.

• Demand characteristics (sales volume, volatility, sales duration, etc.)

• Levers Include:-
• • Pricing – incentives (discounts, MOQ’s, etc.) → MOQ (Minimum Order Qty)
• • Advertising – increasing brand awareness, and
• • Promotions – price reduction over short period of time.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 94
Demand Shaping

• Demand shaping involves finding ways to balance supply with


demand and it can take two basic forms: influencing demand and
managing and prioritizing demand

• Another way to distinguish among methods of demand shaping is


called external balancing versus internal balancing.
• External balancing works to change customer behavior while internal
balancing works to change organizational behavior

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 95


Influencing Demand
• Influencing demand describes the activities of product and brand
management, marketing, and sales to convince customers to purchase the
organization’s products and services so that the organization’s business
objectives are met or exceeded.

• Another aspect of influencing demand is the requirement for the demand


side of the organization to influence the product development, logistics, and
supply sides of the organization to recognize and support actual customer
expectations and requirements.

• Changing how customers order goods can also be called external balancing
and the two key external balancing levers that most organizations have are
adjustments in price and Promotions and adjustments in lead time.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 96


Influencing Demand
• Positively influencing demand over the longer term involves
• Developing products that customers are actually demanding,
• Settling on the most profitable product mix,
• Setting strategic pricing,
• Placing products at various physical or online distribution points to establish a
presence and
• Level of customer convenience, and promoting products through
advertisement

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 97


Managing and Prioritizing Demand
• Organizations must manage and prioritize demand because sales will
differ on a regular basis from planned demand in total volume and/or
in product mix and because supply often cannot produce products in
the exact timing and mix specified by the demand plan.

• The primary internal balancing levers used to manage and prioritize


demand include production flexibility and inventory holding.
• Production flexibility involves small batches of production with fast
changeovers to produce more units that are in demand now. It can also involve
prioritizing production to increase supply of certain items or prioritizing items
within distribution systems to better distribute supply to meet demand.

• For inventory, safety stock helps manage supply-demand mismatches by


preventing stockouts or avoiding lead time issues; however, it only makes
oversupply situations worse.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 98
Managing and Prioritizing Demand – External Levers

• Management and prioritization from an external balancing perspective


can be based on customer segmentation strategies, such as fulfilling
orders to the most valuable customer segments first.
• Another example is rationing supply so that each warehouse or retailer
receives a portion of the full demand but no entity goes without a
certain minimum amount

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 99


Managing and Prioritizing Demand - Examples

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 100


Demand and Power Law Distribution
• Demand follows power law distribution, meaning large volume of
sales is concentrated in fewer products.

• The distribution of percent sales volume to percent of SKUs (Stock


Keeping Units) tends to follow a Power Law distribution (y = ax^k )
where y is percent of demand (units or sales or profit), x is percent of
SKUs, and a and k are parameters.
• The value for k should obviously be less than 1 since if k=1 the
relationship is linear.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 101


Sources of Variation in Demand Management

Demand is also affected by Seasonality


Lumpy Demand → When items are really slow moving
The hockey stick effect is characterized by a sharp rise or fall of data points after a long flat period
Corporate cannibalism is when a product sees a decrease in sales volume or market share due to the release
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 102
of some new product that has been introduced by the same company.
Supply Chain Segmentation using Demand Profiling

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 103


Enjoy the Supply Chain Videos!

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 104


• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvEh04LNJ_I → DHL Supply Chain

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rNVPdN4j-8o → BASF Intelligent SCM

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMPbKVb8y8s → Inside an Amazon


Warehouse

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NssC-foGO9c → Toyota Pakistan


Factory

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sZntBOWiAQ → ERP

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YKmFP5JuPTA → Digital Systems in


SCM
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 105
Resource Planning Systems
Chapter 6

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 106


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 107
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 108
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 109
Resource Planning
• Resource planning is the process of determining the production
capacity required to meet demand.

• In the context of resource planning, capacity refers to the maximum


workload that an organization is capable of completing in a given
period of time.

• A discrepancy between an organization’s capacity and demand results


in an inefficiency, the aim of Resource planning is to minimize this
Discrepancy.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 110


Approach towards Resource Planning
• Issues if Resource planning is not Carried??????

• Capacity is What???? Issues with High & Low Capacity!!!!!!

• Have a production plan to balance Capacity!!!

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 111


Manufacturing Operations & Planning Horizons!

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 112


Terminologies
• Aggregate production plan (APP) is a long-range materials plan. The
aggregate production plan sets the aggregate output rate, workforce
size, utilization and inventory and/or backlog levels for an entire
facility.

• Master production schedule (MPS) is a medium-range plan and is


more detailed than the aggregate production plan. It shows the
quantity and timing of the end items that will be produced.

• Material requirements planning (MRP) is a short-range materials


plan. MRP is the detailed planning process for component parts to
support the master production schedule.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 113


Systems for Manufacturing Planning
• MRP 1 → Material Requirement Planning

• MRP 2 → Capacity planning Included

• ERP → Enterprise Resource Planning


• accounting/finance,
• sales and marketing,
• human capital management (HCM),
• customer relationship management (CRM),
• purchasing management,
• inventory management,
• distribution management, and
• quality management.

• DRP → Distribution Requirement Planning

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 114


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 115
SCM KPIs –
ERP for
Efficiency

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 116


Information flow in ERP for Cash to Cash
Cycle Time -

Flow of
Information in
ERP to Calculate
Cash to Cash
Cycle Time

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 117


Aggregate Production Plan
• Aggregate production planning is a hierarchical planning process that translates
annual business plans and demand forecasts into a production plan for all
products.

• Aggregate production plans are typically stated in terms of product families or


groups. A product family consists of different products that share similar
characteristics, components or manufacturing processes.

• The objective is to provide sufficient finished goods in each period to meet the
sales plan while meeting financial and production constraints.

• Costs relevant to the aggregate planning decision include inventory cost, setup
cost, machine operating cost, hiring cost, firing cost, training cost, overtime cost
and costs incurred for hiring part-time and temporary workers to meet peak
demand.

• There are three basic production strategies that firms use for completing the
aggregate plan: (1) the chase strategy, (2) the level strategy and (3) the mixed
strategy.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 118
Aggregate Production Plan - Example

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 119


The pure chase production strategy adjusts capacity to
match the demand pattern.

Chase Using this strategy, the firm will hire and lay off workers to
match its production rate to demand.

Production The pure chase strategy obviously has a negative


Strategy motivational impact on the workers, and it assumes that
workers can be hired and trained easily to perform the job.
Best for MTO (Make to Order) and Low Skilled employees.

In this strategy, the finished goods inventories always remain


constant but the workforce fluctuates in response to the
demand pattern.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 120
Chase Production Strategy Example

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 121


Chase
Strategy -
Continued

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 122


Level Production Strategy
• A pure level production strategy relies on a constant output rate and
capacity while varying inventory and backlog levels to handle the
fluctuating demand pattern.
• Using this strategy, the firm keeps its workforce levels constant and
relies on fluctuating finished goods inventories and backlogs to meet
demand.
• Suitable for highly skilled labor.
• The firm allows finished goods inventories to accrue while cumulative
demand remains less than cumulative production
• This strategy works well for make-to-stock manufacturing firms, which
typically emphasize immediate delivery of off-the-shelf, standard
goods at relatively low prices. Firms whose trading partners seek the
lowest prices of stock items might select the level production strategy
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 123
Level Production Strategy – Example

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 124


• Mixed production strategy that strives to
maintain a stable core workforce while using
other short-term means such as overtime, an
additional shift, subcontracting or the hiring of
part-time and temporary workers to manage
short-term high demand.
Hybrid/Mixed
Production • Usually, these firms will then schedule
preventive maintenance, produce
Strategy complementary products that require similar
resources but different demand cycles, or
continue to produce the end items, holding
these as finished goods inventory during the off-
peak demand periods.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 125


Master Production Schedule

• The master production schedule is a time-phased, detailed


disaggregation of the aggregate production plan, listing the exact end
items to be produced. It is more detailed than the aggregate
production plan.

• ATPs→ Available to Promise and PAB→ Projected Available Balance

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 126


MPS - Example

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 127


MPS example

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 128


Master Scheduling Grid

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 129


Dependent vs Independent Demand
• Dependent→ demand that is directly related to or derived from the
bill of material structure for other items or end products. Such
demands are therefore calculated and need not and should not be
forecast.

• Independent→ the demand for an item that is unrelated to the


demand for other items. Demand for finished goods, parts required
for destructive testing, and service parts requirements are examples
of independent demand.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 130


Sample BOM – Bill of Materials

Bill of
Materials
(BOM)

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 131


BOM -
Schematic
Snow Shovel

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 132


Product Structure –
Diagram for Snow Shovel

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 133


Inputs and Outputs
for an MRP –
Materials
Requirement Planning

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 134


Basic MRP Record

Basic MRP
Record
Gross Requirement → Anticipated Future Use/Demand

Scheduled Receipts → Existing Orders for any item, is at the


beginning of that period/Manufactured Items

Projected Available Balance → How much is available in Inventory

Planned Order Release → Planned replenishment Orders/135


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM
Replenishments that will be added to the system.
Capacity Management and
Planning in SCM
From Different Books – Use Slides for Preparation of this Topic – For Others book
only!

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 136


Capacity Management
• Can we do it? When is the Deadline? Can we do it now? How much?

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 137


Capacity Management
• The function of establishing, measuring, monitoring, and adjusting
limits or levels of capacity in order to execute all manufacturing
schedules (i.e., the production plan, master production schedule,
material requirements plan, and dispatch list). Capacity management
is executed at four levels:
• + Resource planning,
• + Rough-cut capacity planning,
• + Capacity requirements planning, and
• + Input/output control

• The overriding goal is to keep demand and supply in harmony by


ensuring that the network contains the right amount of capacity in
the right configuration to serve customers in a cost-effective manner
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 138
Capacity Planning

• The process of determining the amount of capacity required to


produce in the future. This process may be performed at an aggregate
or product-line level (resource requirements planning), at the master
scheduling level (rough-cut capacity planning), and at the material
requirements planning level ( capacity requirements planning).

• Capacity planning involves identifying required resources and


selecting methods of making capacity available when needed.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 139


Capacity Control
• The process of measuring production output and comparing it with
the capacity plan, determining if the variance exceeds pre-established
limits, and taking corrective action to get back on plan if the limits are
exceeded.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 140


Time Horizon
of Capacity
Management

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 141


Resource Planning

• Part of the resource plan is


a long-range assessment of
capacity requirements at an
aggregate level. Given long-
range demand forecasts,
you need to ask about the
resources needed-including
plant, lab or, and
equipment-to create
enough supply to match
that demand one, two, or
even five years into the
future. E.g. Labor Hours,
Productivity
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 142
Ways for Capacity Growth

143
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM
Rough Cut Capacity Planning (RCCP)

• The process of converting the master production schedule into


requirements for key resources, often including labor; machinery;
warehouse space; suppliers' capabilities; and, in some cases, money.
Comparison to available or demonstrated capacity is usually done for
each key resource. This comparison assists the master scheduler in
establishing a feasible master production schedule

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 144


RCCP

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 145


Capacity Requirements Planning (CRP)

• Capacity requirements planning (CRP) determines in detail the


amount of labor and machinery required to carry out production
tasks specified in the MRP, translating MRP orders (measured in units)
into hours of work for each work center in each time period.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 146


Measuring Capacity
• Available Time → e.g. Machines Operating at 8hrs a Days, 5 Days a
Week, so we have 40 Hrs available)

• Design Capacity → The maximum output rate or service capacity an


operation, process, or facility is designed for. 100 Bottles/ Day

• Effective Capacity → Design capacity minus allowances such as


personal time, and preventive maintenance. 80 Bottles/Day

• Actual Output → Looking into Human Errors and product failures, the
actual output is less than Effective Capacity. 75 Bottles/Day

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 147


Measuring Capacity

• Utilization → Actual Time


a machine is being utilized.

• Efficiency → Output to
Input as percentage. Can
be in hours as well.
• Hours utilized/Hours Work Done

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 148


Measuring Capacity
• Rated Capacity →
Rated Capacity = Available Time x Utilization x Efficiency

Kanban Cards !
Just Talk – Self -
Reminder

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 149


Distribution Requirement Planning - DRP
• Distribution requirements planning (DRP) is a time-phased finished-
goods inventory replenishment plan in a distribution network.
Distribution requirements planning is a logical extension of the MRP
system, and its logic is analogous to MRP.
• Distribution requirements planning ties the physical distribution
system to the manufacturing planning and control system by
determining the aggregate time-phased net requirements of the
finished goods, and provides demand information for adjusting the
MPS.
• DRP is driven by customer demand of the finished goods. So DRP is
independent whereas MRP deals with Dependent Demand.

• Practice Example 6.3 from Page 188 of the Primary Book!


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 150
Capacity Utilization Chart

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 151


Other related Concepts
• Line Balancing
• Theory of Constraints (TOC)

• TOC scheduling provides improved performance by focusing on the


constraining resources.
• TOC implementation requires a change in plant culture in order to
obtain the full benefits of this approach.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 152


Chapter Ends!
Thank You for your Patience!

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 153


Inventory Management
Chapter 7

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 154


Inventory - Introduction
• A stock or store of goods.

• Inventory management is at the core of all supply chain and logistics


management.

• Inventory has a huge financial impact on a Company

• Stocking the Right amount of Inventory helps save costs

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 155


Why do we hold Inventory
• • Cover process time and make process smooth
• • Allow for uncoupling of processes → Inventory Buffers
• • Anticipation of Demand/Speculation of Price rise/Currencies
• Delayed differentiation/postponement → ZARA/Benetton
Garments/Lear
• Buffer against uncertainties such as demand, supply, delivery, and
manufacturing
• To take advantage of Quantity Discounts

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 156


Types of Inventory
• Raw materials and purchased parts
• • Partially completed goods, called work-in-process (WIP)
• • Finished-goods inventories (manufacturing firms) or merchandise
(retail stores)
• • Maintenance and repairs (MRO) inventory
• • Goods-in-transit to warehouses, distributors, or customers (pipeline
inventory)

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 157


Two key Decisions in Inventory Management
• How much ?
• When to Order?

• KPI to measure effectiveness of Inventory Management


• Inventory Turn-Over

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 158


Inventory Turn-Over Ratio Numerical

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 159


Essential Requirements for Inventory Management
• 1. A system to keep track of the inventory on hand and on order.
• 2. A reliable forecast of demand that includes an indication of
possible forecast error.
• 3. Knowledge of lead times and lead time variability. → Time interval
between ordering and receiving the order.
• 4. Reasonable estimates of inventory holding costs, ordering costs,
and shortage costs.
• 5. A classification system for inventory items

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 160


Inventory Tracking Systems

• Periodic Inventory system→ Physical count of items in inventory


made at periodic intervals (weekly, monthly).

• Perpetual inventory system → System that keeps track of removals


from inventory continuously, thus monitoring current levels of each
item. Possible through RFID, POS, SKU

• 2 Bin and 3 Bin Systems → Use multiple bins to satisfy Inventory


requirements. Helps keep a track of existing Inventory and time to
exhaust it

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 161


Costs of Inventory
• Purchase: Cost per item or total landed cost for acquiring product.

• • Ordering: It is a fixed cost and contains cost to place, receive and


process a batch of good including processing invoicing, auditing,
labor, etc. In manufacturing this is the set up cost for a run.

• • Holding: Costs required to hold inventory such as storage cost


(warehouse space), service costs (insurance, taxes), risk costs (lost,
stolen, damaged, obsolete), and capital costs (opportunity cost of
alternative investment).

• • Shortage: Costs of not having an item in stock (on-hand inventory)


to satisfy a demand when it occurs, including backorder, lost sales,
lost customers, and disruption costs. Also known as the penalty cost.
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 162
Total Cost of Inventory – Detailed Breakdown
• Total cost of Inventory = Purchase (Unit Value) Cost + Order (Set Up)
Cost + Holding (Carrying) Cost + Shortage (stock-out) Cost

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 163


Classification system for Inventory

• The A-B-C approach classifies inventory items according to some


measure of importance, usually annual dollar value (i.e., dollar value
per unit multiplied by annual usage rate).

• Typically, three classes of items are used: A (very important), B


(moderately important), and C (least important).

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 164


ABC Analysis
Finding A, B and C items! Pareto Analysis

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 166


Finding A, B and C items! Pareto Analysis, B and C items!
Pareto Analysis (80-20 Rule)

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 167


Applications of A,B and C items!
• Inventory Variation → Measure against physical checks

• Warehousing

• Product Analysis

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 168


Inventory Ordering Systems

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 169


Economic Order Quantity (EOQ)
• It is used to identify a fixed order size that will minimize the sum of
the annual costs of holding inventory and ordering inventory.
• It’s a fixed Quantity Model , so answers the basic question How much
to order?

• It suggests that the Total Cost of Inventory is minimum when Holding


Cost is equivalent to Ordering Cost.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 170


EOQ – Total Cost

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 171


EOQ Assumptions and Replenishment Policy
• Assumptions
• – Demand is uniform and deterministic.
• – Lead time is instantaneous (0) – although this is not restrictive at all
since the lead time, L, does not influence the Order Size, Q.
• – Total amount ordered is received.

• • Inventory Replenishment Policy


• – Order Q∗ units every T ∗ time periods.
• – Order Q∗ units when inventory on hand (IOH) is zero.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 172


EOQ – Inventory Profile

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 173


EOQ Focus

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 174


EOQ Formula’s

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 175


EOQ Numeral
• A local distributor for a national tire company expects to sell
approximately 9,600 radial tires of a certain size and tread design next
year. Annual carrying cost is $16 per tire, and ordering cost is $75. The
distributor operates 288 days a year.
• a. What is the EOQ?
• b. How many times per year does the store reorder?
• c. What is the length of an order cycle?
• d. What will the total annual carrying and ordering cost be if the EOQ
quantity is ordered?

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 176


EOQ Numeral Solution

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 177


Economic Batch Quantity
EBQ/POQ

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 178


Economic Batch Qty/Production Order Qty
• The Economic Manufacturing Quantity (EMQ) or Production Order
Quantity (POQ) model is another variation of the classic EOQ model.
• It relaxes the instantaneous replenishment assumption by allowing
usage or partial delivery during production.
• The EMQ model is especially appropriate for a manufacturing
environment where items are being manufactured and consumed
simultaneously;

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 179


EMQ/POQ

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 180


Practice Numerical
• Page 236 of the Book, Example 7.6

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 181


Process Management in Supply
Chains
Total Quality Management and Lean Six Sigma

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 182


Total Quality Management - TQM
• Total quality consists of the continual improvement of people,
processes, products (including services), and environments.
• With total quality anything and everything that affects quality is a
target for continual improvement.
• When the total quality concept is effectively applied, the end results
can include organizational excellence, superior value, and global
competitiveness.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 183


Principles of TQM

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 184


Quality, Productivity and Profit

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 185


Types of Quality
• 1. Quality of design → Quality of design is the quality which the
producer or supplier is intending to offer to the customer.

• 2. Quality of conformance → Quality of conformance is the level of
the quality of product actually produced and delivered through the
production or service process of the organization as per the
specifications or design. When the quality of a product entirely
conforms to the specification (design), the quality of conformance is
deemed excellent.

• 3. Quality of performance → Quality of performance can be


assessed through measurements of physical products, statistical
sampling of the output of processes, or through surveys of purchasers
of goods or services. Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 186
Levels of Quality

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 187


8 Dimensions of Product Quality by Garwin

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 188


Dimensions of Quality of Service - SERVQUAL

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 189


Walter Shewhart
• 1930s – USA
• Control Charts & PDCA

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 190


Kaoru Ishikawa
• 1940s – Japan → Country Culture
• Fish Bone Diagram / Cause & Effect Diagram / Root Cause Analysis
• 7 Tools of Quality

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 191


W. Edwards Deming
• 1950s - Post World War -USA and Japan
• Deming’s 14 Points
1. Create constancy of purpose for improvement of product and service
2. Adopt the new philosophy
3. Cease dependence on mass inspection
4. End the practice of awarding business on price tag alone
5. Constantly and forever improve the system of production and
service.
6. Institute modern methods of training on the job
7. Institute modern methods of supervision
8. Drive out fear
9. Break down barriers between staff areas
10. Eliminate numerical goals for the work force
11. Eliminate work standards and numerical quotas
12. Remove barriers that hinder the hourly worker
13. Institute a vigorous program of education and training
14. Create a situation in top management that will push every day on the
above points
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 192
5 Deadly Diseases by Deming
• 1. Lack of constancy of purpose to plan product and service that will
have a market and keep the company in business, and provide jobs
• 2. Emphasis on short-term profits: short-term thinking (just the
opposite from constancy of purpose to stay in business), fed by fear
of unfriendly takeover
• 3. Evaluation of performance, merit rating, or annual review – You
reward Results not Process Improvement
• 4. Mobility of management; job hopping
• 5. Management by use only of visible figures, with little or no
consideration of figures that are unknown or unknowable

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 193


Quality Circles and Kaizen
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 194
Shiego Shingo
• 1960s
• Poke Yoke (Error Proofing)
• SMED (Single Minute Exchange
of Die)
• Formation of JIT Manufacturing

• More focused towards Mass


Production , but with Statistical
tools and Do-It-Right-the First
Time.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 195


7 Types of Wastes - JIT
• Just-in-time (JIT) manufacturing, also known as just-in-time
production or the Toyota production system (TPS), is a methodology
aimed primarily at reducing flow times within production as well as
response times from suppliers and to customers.

• Waste from overproduction


• Excess transportation
• Excess inventory
• Waiting time
• Processing waste
• Wasted motion
• Waste from production defects
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 196
Kano Model – Customer Input

• 1980s Kano Model

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 197


Bottlenecks and
Theory of Constraint
Theory of
Constraints

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 198


Six Sigma and Continuous Improvement

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 199


Productivity and Product/Services Measure

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 200


Improving Productivity

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 201


Limitations to Productivity and Wastes

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 202


Lean Six Sigma

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 203


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 204
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 205
Lean Six Sigma Transformation Process

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 206


Business Canvas
• Strategic Lean Tool

• It is a visual and practical business tool to describe, test, implement,


and manage business models during their life cycle

• Business Model describes how Organization creates, develops and


captures value.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 207


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 208
Steps in creating a Canvas
• 1. Introduction to the methodology
• 2. Current Canvas
• 3. Research environment around the current canvas:
• • Market trends
• • Technology trends
• • Needs Trends
• • Strengths and weaknesses
4. Generate future canvas prototypes
5. Feedback
6. Define Canvas future and following

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 209


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 210
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 211
Hoshin Kanri

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 212


Introduction

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 213


Key Stages of Hoshin Kanri

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 214


Establish a
Company
Philosphy

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 215


Establish
Objectives

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 216


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 217
Develop Strategies

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 218


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 219
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 220
Develop Tactics

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 221


• Team formation and Team building is an Essential Par of Lean Six
Sigma

• Teams are built when they ‘Share the pain’

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 222


Stages of
Team
Development

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 223


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 224
5S
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 225
5S

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 226


Sort
Straighten

Shine
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 227
5S in Action

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 228


Andon

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 229


Introduction

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 230


Benefits of Andons
• Improves Quality
• Reduces Costs
• Improves Response Time
• Improves Safety
• Improves Communication
• Provides a way to bring Immediate
attention to a problem
• Offers a simple mechanism to
communicate information
• Improves accountability
• Increases the speed and quality of
decision-making
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 231
Standard Work Instructions

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 232


Introduction

• Help to achieve better Quality and Productivity


• Consistency in finished Product
• Employee Safety

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 233


Elements of Standard Work Instructions

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 234


Lean Processes and
their potential
Application

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 235


Waste Identification
• Waste appears throughout organizations and is often mixed with non-
waste. There are times and conditions within our organizations where
deciding what is waste versus non-waste can be somewhat of a
moving target.

Categorization for Waste related Activities

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 236


9 Types of Waste
• 1. Overproduction
• 2. Excess inventory
• 3. Defects
• 4. Extra processing
• 5. Waiting
• 6. Motion
• 7. Transportation
• 8. Underutilized people
• 9. Employee behavior

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 237


Lean vs Traditional Organization

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 238


Traditional vs Lean Organization

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 239


Traditional Lean
Special Topics in Supply Chain
Lean, Agile, Resilient and Green SCs

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 240


Demand Driven Supply Chains
Customer Value is the Driver for Demand Driven Supply Chain.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 241


Demand Profiling
• A critical component in SCM

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 242


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 243
SKU
Stock Keeping Unit
A stock keeping unit (SKU) is a product and service identification code for a store
or product, often displayed as a machine-readable bar code that helps track the
item for inventory.

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 244


Global Supply Chains

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 245


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 246
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 247
Global Supply Chain
Multiple Arc’s of Integration – Part of Extended Supply Chain to be actively
managed
De-Coupling Point – Point at which real demand penetrates upstream in a
Supply Chain / Simply Where the Inventory is Positioned

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 248


Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 249
Lean Supply Chain Management Principles
• Lean principles require cooperative supplier relationships while
balancing cooperation and competition.
• Supplier partnerships & strategic alliances represent a key feature of
lean supply chain management

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 250


Lean Relationships
“Markets” (Armʼs Length): Lower production costs, higher coordination costs
• • Firm buys (all) inputs from outside specialized suppliers
• • Inputs are highly standardized; no transaction-specific assets
• • Prices serve as sole coordination mechanism

“Hierarchies” (Vertical Integration): Higher production costs, lower coordination


costs
• Firm produces required inputs in-house (in the extreme, all inputs)
• Inputs are highly customized, involve high transaction costs or dedicated
investments, and require close coordination

“Lean” (Hybrid): Lowest production and coordination costs; economically most


efficient choice-- new model
• Firm buys both customized & standardized inputs
• Customized inputs often involve dedicated investments
• Partnerships & strategic alliances provide collaborative advantage
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 251
Lean Principles
• Focus on the supplier network value stream
• Eliminate waste
• Synchronize flow
• Minimize both transaction and production costs
• Establish collaborative relationships while balancing cooperation and
competition
• Ensure visibility and transparency
• Develop quick response capability
• Manage uncertainty and risk
• Align core competencies and complementary capabilities
• Foster innovation and knowledge-sharing
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 252
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 253
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 254
Lean Actions

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 255


Shift in Lean Supplier Network Development

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 256


Emerging Lean Practises

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 257


How To Enable Architectural Innovation in Lean

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 258


Value Stream Transformation

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 259


Virtual Integration – Lean Networks

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 260


Advantages of Virtual Integration

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 261


Agile Supply Chain Management
• “Agility is a business-wide capability that embraces organizational
structures, information systems, logistics processes, and, in particular,
mindsets. A key characteristic of an agile organization is flexibility”
(Christopher, 2000)

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 262


4 Characteristics of Agile SCM
Market Sensitive – Read Process Integration– Integrate
Market and Understand Process with Suppliers / NPD
Demands / Direct Access to
POS – Demand Driven

Network Based– Based on Virtual – No Boundaries / IT /


Supplier and Distributors / IS
Collaboration and Relationship
Management Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 263
Agile SCM Transformation Model

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 264


Green Supply Chain Management

Closed Loop SCMs


Reverse Logistics

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 265


Resilient Supply Chains
• The adaptive capability of a supply chain to reduce the probability of
facing sudden disturbances, resist the spread of disturbances by
maintaining control over structures and functions, and recover and
respond by immediate and effective reactive plans to transcend the
disturbance and restore the supply chain to a robust state of
operations

• Resilience is defined as the ability of a system to return to its original


state or a more favourable condition, after being disturbed

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 266


Objective of Resilient SCs

• Lower Risk
• Secure
• Transparent
• Adaptive
• Fast
• Optimized

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 267


4 Components of Resilient SCMs

• 1. Focus Event → Un-Expected, Negative, Risk Based,


• 2. Performance Level during Disruptions and How to Improve
• 3. Speed → Diminishing the time to return
• 4. Adaptive Framing→ Anticipate, and adapt to sustain and recover ;
Prepare, Respond, Recover, Maintain

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 268


Research Based factors that help to Measure & Build Resilient SCMs
• Supply Reliability Accessibility, Connectivity and Availability of Suppliers
• Structural and Supplier Complexities
• Demand , Supply and Transport Capacity Sources Criticality, Demand and Variance in Demand
• Resilience in SCM Network Flow and Cluster Reliability

• Sustainability
• Risk and Revenue Sharing Robustness
• Trust Recovery, Impact , Performance Loss,
• Visibility Inbound and Outbound Flows
• Risk Mgt Culture NPV, Customer Service Levels, Investments
• Adaptive Capability Geographical Segregation
• Structure Backup Supplier

• Sourcing Strategies that allow Switching Suppliers Re-Routing


• Flexible Sourcing Restoration Budget
• Strategic Stock Emergency Costs
• Lead Time Reduction Physical Protection of Assets
• Flexible Transportation Supply Chain Mapping
• Agility
• Collaboration
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 269
• Information Sharing
Strategies for
Building
Resilient SCs

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 270


What else can be done to build more Resilient SCs
• Redundancy→ Stock More Inventory, Work on Reduced Capacity
Utilization and Add more Suppliers to the Network, Cross-Facility
Training

• Flexibility → Adopt Standardized Process i.e. Modular Designs and


Multi-Product plants, Use Con-Current Process Design, Using Modular
and Semi-Finished Designs and giving sufficient time to postpone
before Manufacturing, Allign the procurement Strategy with Suppliers
Relationship(Deep, Broad and New)

• Cultural Change → Continuous Info to Employees, Distribution of


Power to Smaller Teams, Condition the teams for Disruptions,
Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 271
MITs Approach on Building Resilient SCs
Stress-Test for Various SCs

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 272


What are the Companies Doing in Response to COVID

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 273


SCs Investment Goals and Shift

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 274


SC Expectations in 3 Years

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 275


SC Risk Assessment based on Supplier & Manufacturing Locations – US Perspective

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 276


Resilience and Exposure to Risk

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 277


• Manufacturing Processes Basics

• Casting / Heating / Molding / Injection / Extrusion / Drawing / Joining


/ Welding / Machining / Mixing / Grinding / Milling(TAPERING /
DRILLING) / Polishing / Surface Treatment / Soldering / Sintering /
Laser Cutting / Water Jet Cutting / High Beam Energy Processes /
Compaction / Allignment /

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 278


Agile Manufacturing
• Agile manufacturing represents a very interesting approach to
developing a competitive advantage in today’s fast-moving
marketplace. It places an extremely strong focus on rapid response to
the customer – turning speed and agility into a key competitive
advantage. An agile company is in a much better position to take
advantage of short windows of opportunity and fast changes in
customer demand.

• Reacting quickly to Market Demands and Trends

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 279


Key Components of Agile Manufacturing

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 280


The End
Good Luck for your Finals

Hassaan Tariq, SMGs, GIKI, Fall 2022, MS 491, SCM 281

You might also like