Professional Documents
Culture Documents
their Notation
Reading music is really all about memorization. Your painfully learn how to
look at a printed note (on paper) and immediately finger the instrument in the
correct way. On a piano, each note lands on exactly one of the 88 keys, and this
is fantastic. On a guitar, a given note could land on up to five separate strings,
and you can always finger a lower fret and bend said strings, and so forth. So, it
might not be unfair to say that you could find given note in perhaps fifteen
distinct locations on a guitar neck---perhaps more! So, learning to navigate the
guitar neck can be a real problem, and it is very important to keep the note
names clear as one learns this complex layout.
Some of my friends who are real musicians have complained about the way
that I have burned away so much theory and tradition to get such a minimalist
view of notes. Their complaints invariably revolve around, "you've removed a
perspective that I use to compose." They start to get upset at the point where
one goes to a chromatic (semitone number) representation of all notes, and I'm
sure that they're right. That said, one can think in any style that they want
depending on their circumstance, and thinking about semitone number 5 (me) is
not incompatible with "the second note in the Phrygian mode" (them). Really,
you can see it both ways at the same time. Also, I see little point in worrying
about issues like "modes" until one is a great "typist" of existing musical
manuscripts---most compositional perspectives will do nothing for you in this
important regard. Therefore, without further ado or apology, let's look into
naming musical notes.
Frequencies
Pretend that you had a piston, and it is open to the air. Now, let's say that you
start it moving back-and-forth, with a smooth sinusoidal motion, at a given
frequency, f, i.e., a particular number of cycles per second. If f=440Hz, i.e., 440
times per second, you'll hear "concert A" (also known as A4), coming out of
your loudspeaker!
If you experimented with the knob for f, you'd discover that you'd only be able
to hear sound between about f=20Hz and f=20kHz (20 thousand Hz). Your dog
will be able to hear well above you, and your pet bat even further.
Now that we have learned that there are actually eleven C's, let's pick one
specific octave and stay within it. How many notes are in this octave? It turns
out that each octave has exactly twelve notes. We can number the notes by
means of their value as semitones, where the notes go up in frequency as we
go:
Semitone Name
0 C or B#
1 C# or Db
2 D
3 D# or Eb
4 E
5 F
6 F# or Gb
7 G
8 G# or Ab
9 A
10 A# or Bb
11 B or Cb
Look at the uniformity of the numbers on the left, and the crazy sharps (#) and
flats (b) on the right! What is going on here? Well, in the early days of Western
music, there were only seven distinct notes: C, D, E, F, G, A, and B. (Each
exists in each octave, of course.) Over time, it was realized that five more notes
should be added, eventually enabling the transposition of music (i.e., raising or
lowering the pitch of an entire piece to meet the limited abilities of particular
singers, etc.). The new notes fit between C/D, D/E, F/G, G/A, A/B. So, the
problem became, "how does one notate the new note between C and D, for
example," but in such a way as not to destroy existing sheet music? (Yes, the
legacy problem rears its head....) One notation option is C# ("C sharp, the new
note above C), and another is Db ("D flat, the new note below D"). (Sadly, I
don't have the proper character to make a flat, so I need to use the letter "b".)
Adding further obscurity to this notation, while there is no new note between
E/F, E# is taken to be F, for example. There are canonical naming conventions
that dictate if you should view a note as (say) A# or Bb in a given key, and you
can learn all about them in music theory books---if you care, that is!
Why is there no F10, for example? Notes above D10 can only be heard by your
pets! And even notes above C8 don't sound very good---that's the highest key
on a piano or piccolo! So, we probably should ignore the bottom three rows of
the above table, and perhaps even most of the first row! In other words, the 8th,
9th, and 10th octaves are probably worthless (except as harmonics of lower
frequencies, of course).
So, when you talk to somebody who calls his guitar's E2 string "low E," just
slap him, and shout, "E2, buddy!" Most musicians, because of the intense
demands of their partying lifestyle, have little time to study their octaves and
learn that every E has a unique name. But one warning: Guitar music is notated
one octave up, i.e., when you're supposed to play C4, it is traditional to write
C5.
The people who become conductors and writers know perfectly well that each
note has a unique name, but they use some crazy notation systems. For
example, C6 can be notated as c''' (Helmholtz), C64 (piano key number), C^3
(organ notation).
Note that the harmonics start an octave above the fundamental that you
pluck---a harmonic can never be lower than the fundamental, or even in
the same octave.
So, turning back to C9, you might hear it as an octave if you plucked C5,
perhaps faintly, but nobody would ever try to make a C9 string and pluck that.
For those interested in "why," f(n + m)/f(n) = exp((m/12) ln(2)). If you divide
the length L of the string by N, where N is an integer, N = exp((m/12) ln(2)), or
m = (12/ln(2)) ln(N). So, if you have a harmonic that cuts the string into N
parts, it is m semitones above the fundamental.
Using Semitones
My personal, totally non-standard notation is the best, in my opinion. If I want
to talk about a note, like E, I'll just say 4, since it is the 4th semitone in any
octave. If I mean to talk about E2, I'll say 2_4 (actually, just 24 in base 12).
And if I'm doing computations (as you'll see later), I view 2_4 as its absolute
semitone number, 2*12 + 4 = 28. (Note that o_s = 12o + s, o_(12 + s) =
(o+1)_s, and so forth.) For those of you who remember base twelve arithmetic
from elementary school (it was probably taught around the time of "clock
arithmetic"), yes, you're right, the ultimate thing is to just remember the
numbers in base twelve, and this is actually what I do. (If you don't know what
the prior statement means, ignore it for now.)
I tune my guitar uniformly in fourths, so the notes on it are (low to high) E2,
A2, D3, G3, C4, F4. But this isn't the way that I think about it; to me, they're
2_4, 2_9, 3_2, 3_7, 4_0, 4_5. Your guitar is probably tuned E2, A2, D3, G3,
B3, E4, or 2_4, 2_9, 3_2, 3_7, 3_11, 4_4.
If I'm thinking of an F3, I might be lazy and only say 5, but I should never lose
track that it's 3_5 I'm talking about. Some people might think this is overly
complicated, but I find it easier to think of 6 than F# or Gb. In other words,
there is now only one name for a particular note. And it is easy for me to
answer questions like, "what is a perfect fourth above C?" It's F! I know
because a "perfect fourth" means five semitones (more on this later), and 0 (=
C) + 5 (= perfect fourth) = 5 (= F). The following sections on intervals make
this kind of work easy.
A critical factor in reading sheet music is to memorize of the exact note. Don't
just think "C" when you look at the staff---if you're looking at middle C, think
"C4," "4_0," or at the very least "middle C," but not just "C." The same should
go when you look at a "C" on your guitar neck---you should know the octave,
both on the written sheet music and the instrument neck.
You can also note that the pentatonic scales are just a subset of the major
scale---just view them as a major scale without the 11, and a 4 or 5.
As a quick reason to use semitones, "what key has N flats?" The answer is, key
= 5 * N mod 12. So, for example, if N=3 (three flats), the key is 5*3 mod 12 =
15 mod 12 = 3 = Eb. Cool, huh?
"What key has N sharps?" The answer is, key = -5 * N mod 12. So, for
example, if N=2 (two sharps), key = -5*2 mod 12 = -10 mod 12 = 2 = D.
(For those of you who do not remember what "mod" means, "a mod b" means
that you can add/subtract b's from a until you get the smallest positive number
possible. So, for example, 24 mod 12 = 0, 30 mod 12 = 6, etc.)
Sadly, the names of musical intervals are full of rich historical legacy.
Basically, if you view two notes as an absolute semitone, and subtract them,
this difference is the interval.
Most of you will try to guess a solution of the form f(n)=a exp(b n), and with
the back of an envelope you will be able to determine that f(n) = C0 *
exp((n/12)*ln(2)), and C0 = 440Hz/exp(57/12 ln(2)) = 16.3516Hz.
So, for a practical example, given that a phone passes frequencies below about
3kHz, the highest semitone it can hear is around 90, or F7#.
If you have a string of length L, put the first fret at (94.38%)L, and the next fret
at (94.38%)^2L, and so forth, until you get close enough to the bridge to stop.
Why? The frequency of a string goes as the reciprocal of its length. So, pretend
that length L gets frequency f(n). You want a shorter length, k * L (where k <
1), to get frequency f(n+1). Therefore, you can say, where m is some (arbitrary)
constant, f(n) = m/L. f(n+1) = m/(k L). Therefore, k f(n) = f(n+1). You can
easily solve for k = exp(-(ln(2))/12) = 0.9438743 = 94.39%.
Every note....