Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mulinari Brenner2018
Mulinari Brenner2018
Fabiane Mulinari-Brenner
PII: S0738-081X(18)30182-2
DOI: doi:10.1016/j.clindermatol.2018.08.011
Reference: CID 7279
To appear in: Clinics in Dermatology
Please cite this article as: Fabiane Mulinari-Brenner , Psychosomatic aspects of alopecia
areata. Cid (2018), doi:10.1016/j.clindermatol.2018.08.011
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As
a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The
manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before
it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process errors may
be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the
journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
From the Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Dermatology, Universidade Federal do Parana, Hospital
PT
• Corresponding author.
RI
Fabiane Mulinari-Brenner, MD
SC
Av. Vicente Machado,1907 NU
Curitiba – PR – Brazil
80440-020
MA
fmbrenner@ufpr.br
D
Phone # 55-41-33523293
E
PT
55-41-988011818
CE
AC
Conflict of interest
Abstract
Psychologic and social impact of scalp hair is more important than its biologic significance. Etiology of
alopecia areata (AA) suggests a predominantly autoimmune reaction. Correlation between AA and psychologic
PT
disorders is reciprocal. Psychiatric disorders can trigger the onset of AA and its negative impacts may develop or
RI
exacerbate psychologic problems. The high incidence of a neurotic personality, depression, anxiety, and
SC
deficiency in coping with stress strengthen the role of psychic factors in the pathogenesis of AA.
Strategies to assess these patients are often not apparent for the clinician and identifying patients in
NU
need of extra psychologic support should be a mainstay for successful treatment. Women, young patients and
MA
those with significant AA or previous psychiatric disorders are at greater risk, requiring careful following. Proper
awareness and consciousness about the close relationship between AA and psychologic factors are essential.
D
Introduction
The psychologic and social impact of scalp hair can be more important than its biologic significance.
Etiology of alopecia areata (AA) is unknown, and the majority of evidence suggests that genetically predisposed
individuals, when exposed to an unknown trigger, develop a predominantly autoimmune reaction, leading to
PT
Environmental triggers, including viral or bacterial infections, along with autoimmune disorders, seem to
play a major role in the development of AA.1,2 Some observers consider stressful life events as being significant
RI
factors. Greater number of emotionally stressful events was seen in AA patients.3 Considering the theory of
SC
unity of body and mind, a correlation between AA and psychologic disorders is important. Additionally,
NU
psychiatric disorders may provide a trigger for initiation and exacerbation of the disease. Negative impacts of
the disease on the patient’s life, may develop or exacerbate existing psychologic problems.
MA
Effects of AA on social and emotional well-being, along with the patient’s mental health, can be found in
various cultures worldwide. Referring to the problem as ‘‘it’s just hair’’, especially by health care professionals,
D
Hair loss in AA may range from a circumscribed area or areas, involvement of the entire scalp (totalis), to
development of complete body hair loss (universalis). Considering there are 7.5 billion people on the globe and
AC
0.2% of them are estimated to have AA, around 15 million people are afflicted.4 Over 127 million people (1.7%
of the population) will experience an episode of AA during their lifetime.4 The course of the disease is not
predictable, with periods of hair loss and regrowth, without scarring. AA can occur at any age, although 60% of
patients develop their first episode of hair loss before the age of 20.4 Family history of AA is observed in 20% of
Spontaneous hair regrowth in AA may occur in 80% of the patients within a year.4 Alopecia totalis (AT),
alopecia universalis (AU), and ophiasis pattern (hair loss around the periphery of the scalp) are considerably
more treatment resistant.2 A poor prognosis is found in long term hair loss, as well as in cases with nail
dystrophy, onset in childhood, atopic background, autoimmune disorders and a family history of AA.5
Quantitative hair loss and regrowth can be assessed with the Severity of Alopecia Tool (SALT) score,
which is a mathematic approach to the determination of hair loss and hair regrowth.6 The scalp is divided into
PT
four areas:
RI
1. vertex - 40% of scalp surface area;
SC
2. right profile of scalp - 18% of scalp surface area;
The percentage of hair loss in any of these areas is calculated by multiplying the percentage of hair loss by the
percentage surface area of the scalp in that area. The accurate determination of hair loss is important for
D
The SBN (scalp-body-nail) index grades hair loss in different areas of the body.6 Scalp hair loss (S) is graded:
PT
S0 = no hair loss,
CE
S4a = 75–95%,
Body hair loss may be rated as none, some, or 100% (B0, B1, and B2, respectively), and nail involvement as
none or some (N0 and N1) with a subcategory N1a for 20 nail dystrophy. This index is the mainstay for grouping
A high incidence of atopic dermatitis, vitiligo, lichen planus, psoriasis, asthma, thyroid conditions, vitamin D
PT
RI
Health Status and Quality of Life in Alopecia Areata
SC
Although AA is a medically benign disorder, its emotional and psychologic distress impacts on the HRQoL
NU
in extensive and chronic disease. Patients often report being harassed, stared at, or assumed to be undergoing
chemotherapy due to their hair loss.7 More than half of patients believe that their illness has major
MA
consequences on their lives.8 Understanding HRQoL is essential in recognizing all aspects of this ‘‘cosmetic’’
disorder and motivates good patient care. Patient self-image, interpersonal relationships, work, or school
D
activities can be affected, even in patients with localized hair loss. Simple decisions, such as wearing a wig, may
E
A specific stressful life event is reported as the trigger for AA in up to 77% of the patients. 8 AA patients
CE
seem to have experienced more stressful life events than their healthy siblings and control patients. 3 Loss of a
AC
family member during childhood and emotional neglect by relatives are sources of higher scores on the
Traumatic Events Questionnaire (TEQ).3 Accidents, bad news, and physical or sexual abuse are evaluated by this
tool. Stressful life events may influence immune responses related to neuropeptides, such as cells migration
and microvascular endothelium feedbacks.9 Most AA patients believe that stress is the cause of their disease.8
The association between severity of AA and HRQoL is uncertain, because the studies have used different
combinations of HRQoL questionnaires and disease severity measures.10 Several reports have suggested lower
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
HRQoL in adults in children with AA.11-15 The detrimental effect on quality of life is similar to other chronic
dermatologic diseases, including atopic dermatitis and psoriasis;11,13 however, AA leads to more self-
A wide range of HRQoL instruments are available to evaluate AA. Only three have been validated in the
AA population.10 Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI), Skindex and Short Form Health Survey (SF- 36) goals
PT
and findings in AA are reviewed in Table 1. The most affected aspects of DLQI in AA are symptoms, feelings, and
daily activities.10,13 Skindex emotions and SF-36 role-emotional, mental health, and vitality are also severely
RI
affected.10,16 Female gender, young age, unmarried status, severity of scalp involvement, and concomitant
SC
psychiatric disorders are more often associated with a lower HRQoL in AA.7,10,13
NU
Psychiatric aspects of Alopecia Areata
MA
Stressful events, trauma, and acute anxiety are the most common triggers of AA.18 Patients with AA
more often suffer from anxiety and depression than the general population. Hair loss, however, can also be
D
considered as an initiating factor in anxiety and depression.19,20 Psychiatric diagnoses, such as substantial
E
depression, generalized anxiety disorder, adjustment disorder and paranoid disorders, have been observed in
PT
up to 78% of patients with AA.19-21 Women, young patients, and those with extensive disease are more
CE
affected.20,22
Recognizing depression, along with underlining the profound impact the extensive hair loss, chronic
AC
nature of AA and frequent recurrences can have on the body image of such patients is not an easy task.
Psychiatric evaluation is often required. In fact, AA is the second most referred dermatosis to psychiatrists from
dermatologists, surpassed only by psoriasis.23 Results vary, but 1/3 up to 3/4 of AA patients have psychiatric
disorders after structured psychiatric evaluation.19,24,25 Unfortunately, concomitant systemic disorders, such as
One of the most common diseases in all ages is depression. It is predicted to be the second most
prevalent disease by the year 2025.26 Dermatologic diseases are considered one of the most important
predisposing factors for depression and suicidal ideation. Some patients do not seek help or even carry out
treatment, as they consider their condition to be hopeless. A small number may even commit suicide due to
PT
A variety of questionnaires can be applied in the clinical evaluation of these patients. A complete
medical history should be taken before considering these tools. Psychiatric hospitalization, a background of
RI
cognitive disorders, brain damage or epilepsy, alcohol abuse, and use of narcotics can lead to incorrect
SC
evaluation. Table 2 review the most widely used psychometric tests that can evaluate the severity of psychiatric
NU
damage in AA.20-23 In pediatric patients, family members should also be observed and specific scales may be
helpful.19,29
MA
Ophiasis, AU, and diffuse AA are more often affected by depression.26 Depressed AA patients are more
likely to mention stress as the cause of the disease.30 Prevalence of a death wish and suicidal ideation among
E D
alopecia patients varies in different groups from zero to 25%.21,26 Women are more often affected by
PT
depression, with feeling loss of love from family and friends.28 Beyond the generally higher rate of depression
CE
among women, chronic skin manifestations are usually associated with a greater psychologic burden and a
feeling of loss.24 Facial involvement is more often associated with depression, anxiety, and neurosis.31
AC
Neurosis is a class of mental disorders involving distress, without delusions or hallucinations. Neurosis
should not be mistaken for psychosis which refers to a loss of touch with reality. There is no difference in AA
patients and the control group in psychosis and lying.31 Neuroticism, a fundamental trait, and a neurotic
personality type are predominant in AA patients.31 The neurotic personality found in a high percentage of the
patients may be an additional element in the group of psychologic factors that possibly have some influence on
Glutamate is the main excitatory neurotransmitter in the normal brain, perturbations of glutamate
homeostasis may be expected to have consequences beyond the modulation of excitatory communication
between neurons. High concentration of glutamate is found in anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder
which is the neurosis more often identified in AA in children and adolescents.29 Low levels of glutamate in
schizophrenia may explain the low rates of this disorder in AA group. 30,31
PT
All of these psychologic morbidities may lead to suicide; however, depression plays a crucial role. Half
of those who commit suicide are depressed.26 As might be expected, suicide attempts are highest among
RI
patients with AU and diffuse AA.26 Suicidal ideation is reported in 60% of AU patients, more than three times
SC
the 18% of patients with localized alopecia.26 NU
Difficulty in expressing emotions, as in alexithymia, is often reported in patients with AA, adding to the
complex evaluation of these patients. Alexithymia can be assessed by the Toronto Alexithymia scale; however,
MA
the difference between the alexithymia incidence among AA and control patients is controversial.22,32-33 Some
Despite the evidence provided above for proving the association of AA with psychiatric disorders, the
PT
efficacy of antidepressants, psychotherapy, relaxation techniques, individual or group therapy, and hypnosis in
CE
AA treatment has not been evaluated by appropriate clinical trials.10,34,35 Trials with hypnotherapy suggest
possible hair growth and improvement in HRQOL, although clinical responses varied and relapse rates were
AC
high.10,34
The onset of a chronic condition brings with it a range of difficulties that may show considerable
variation in their nature and severity as perceived by the patient. More than 60% of AA patients believe their
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
behavior could determine improvement or worsening of their illness.9 To respond to the difficulties that a
chronic illness presents, patients construct their own common-sense cognitive model of their condition. Such a
model is based on information received from a range of sources including physicians, family members, friends,
internet, and existing social concepts. Cultural cosmetic appeal, current life status, and stage of development all
may interfere with the effects of a skin disease on body self-image. Unfortunately, inaccurate interpretation of
PT
the given information may lead to poor compliance and treatment leave.
Negative psychologic issues in patients with AA, particularly regarding self-esteem, body image, and self-
RI
confidence lead to three coping steps:
SC
avoidance
NU
appearance fixing
MA
acceptance.36
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA), an approach to psychologic qualitative research, can offer
E D
insights into how the patient makes sense of AA. It can be used to provide a holistic perspective of four key
PT
themes:
CE
loss (self/social)
concerns (physical/future)
AC
negative (emotions/thoughts)
Initial intropunitive maladaptive forms of coping behaviors in AA are later replaced by more adaptive forms of
coping, such as treatment and support seeking, religious coping, and acceptance. Women experience greater
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
feelings of loss and report more negative thoughts and emotions.37 Adolescents are known to have more
Support groups may play a definite role in the coping framework of AA. Sharing experiences with others
and gaining support from others with the same or similar diseases can be a definite link to the treatment. There
is a stronger deficiency in coping with stress in AA patients, when compared to androgenetic alopecia
PT
patients.38 Parents should always be the focus in pediatric AA, as they may send the message that the child is
not “normal.” Support groups help parents learn to communicate with their child, adding to the influence and
RI
information health care providers can give during the regular visits.38 Patients can derive emotional support and
SC
information that can improve quality of life and increase treatment compliance. An excellent source is the
NU
National Alopecia Areata Foundation web site (www.naaf.org), which provides patients, parents, and
Conclusions
E
PT
Proper awareness and consciousness about the close relationship between AA and psychologic factors is
essential for a desirable management of AA. The high incidence of neurotic personality, depression, anxiety,
CE
and deficiency in coping with stress strengthens the role of psychic factors in the etiopathogenesis of AA.
AC
Strategies to assess these patients are often not part of the armamentarium for many dermatologists.
Identifying patients in need of extra psychologic support is the mainstay for successful treatment. Women,
young patients, and those with extensive disease or previous psychiatric disorders are at greater risk and
References
1. McElwee KJ, Gilhar A, Tobin DJ, et al. What causes alopecia areata? Exp Dermatol. 2013;22:609-626.
2. Olsen EA. Investigative guidelines for alopecia areata. Dermatol Ther. 2011;24:311-319.
3. Taheri R, Behnam B, Tousi JA, et al. Triggering role of stressful life events in patients with alopecia areata.
PT
4. Madani S, Shapiro J. Alopecia areata update. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2000;42:549-566.
5. Hordinsky M, Ericson M. Autoimmunity: Alopecia areata. J Investig Dermatol Symp Proc. 2004;9:73-78.
RI
6. Olsen EA, Hordinsky M, McDonald-Hull S, et al. Alopecia areata investigational assessment guidelines. J Am
SC
Acad Dermatol. 1999;40:242–246. NU
7. Liu LY, King BA, Craiglow BG. Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) among patients with alopecia
8. Firooz A, Firoozabadi MR, Ghazisaidi B, et al. Concepts of patients with alopecia areata about their disease.
9. Ruiz-Doblado S, Carrizosa A, Garcia-Hernandez MJ. Alopecia areata: psychiatric comorbidity and adjustment
E
PT
10. Rencz F, Gulácsi L, Péntek M, et al. Alopecia areata and health-related quality of life: a systematic review
CE
11. Karia SB, De Sousa A, Shah N, et al. Psychiatric morbidity and quality of life in skin diseases: A comparison
12. Kacar SD, Soyucok E, Bagcioglu E, et al. The perceived stigma in patients with alopecia and mental disorder:
13. Ghajarzadeh M, Ghiasi M, Kheirkhah S. Associations between skin diseases and quality of life: a comparison
14. Janković S, Perić J, Maksimović N, et al. Quality of life in patients with alopecia areata: a hospital-based
15. Bilgiç Ö, Bilgiç A, Bahali K, et al. Psychiatric symptomatology and health-related quality of life in children
and adolescents with alopecia areata. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2014;28:1463-1468.
16. Chren MM, Lasek RJ, Quinn LM, et al. Skindex, a quality-of-life measure for patients with skin disease:
PT
reliability, validity, and responsiveness. J Invest Dermatol. 1996;107:707-713.
17. Gulec AT, Tanriverdi, N, Dürü C, et al. The role of psychological factors in alopecia areata and the impact of
RI
the disease on the quality of life. Int J Dermatol. 2004;43:352-356.
SC
18. Manolache L, Benea V. Stress in patients with alopecia areata and vitiligo. J Eur Acad Dermatol
Venereol. 2007;21:921-928.
NU
19. Schmitt JV, Riberio CF, Souza FH, et al. Hair loss perception and symptoms of depression in female
MA
20. Baghestani S, Zare S, Seddigh SH. Severity of depression and anxiety in patients with alopecia areata in
D
21. Gupta MA, Gupta AK. Depression and suicidal ideation in dermatology patients with acne, alopecia areata,
PT
23. Ocek T, Kani AS, Baş A, et al. Psychodermatology: knowledge, awareness, practicing patterns, and attitudes
24. Colón EA, Popkin MK, Callies AL, et al. Lifetime prevalence of psychiatric disorders in patients with alopecia
25. Saleh HM, Salem SA, El-Sheshetawy RS, et al. Comparative study of psychiatric morbidity and quality of life
26. Layegh P, Arshadi HR, Shahriari S, et al. A comparative study on the prevalence of depression and suicidal
ideation in dermatology patients suffering from psoriasis, acne, alopecia areata and vitiligo. Iran J Dermatol.
2010;13:106-111.
27. Picardi A, Pasquini P, Abeni D, et al. Psychosomatic assessment of skin diseases in clinical practice.
PT
28. Niemeier V, Harth W, Kupfer J, et al. Prevalence of psychosomatic disorders in dermatologic patients.
RI
29. Ghanizadeh A. Comorbidity of psychiatric disorders in children and adolescents with alopecia areata in a
SC
child and adolescent psychiatry clinical sample. Int J Dermatol. 2008;47:1118-1120.
31. Chu SY, Chen YJ, Tseng WC, et al. Psychiatric comorbidities in patients with alopecia areata in Taiwan: A
D
32. Karia SB, De Sousa A, Shah N, et al. Psychiatric morbidity and quality of life in skin diseases: A comparison
PT
33. Sellami R, Masmoudi J, Ouali U, et al. The relationship between alopecia areata and alexithymia, anxiety
of alopecia areata in patients with major depressive disorder. J Dermatolog Treat. 2014;25:153-155.
36. Tucker P. Bald is beautiful?: the psychosocial impact of alopecia areata. J Health Psychol. 2009;14:142-151.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
37. Rafique R, Hunt N. Experiences and coping behaviours of adolescents in Pakistan with alopecia areata:
38. Monselise A, Bar-On R, Chan L, et al. Examining the relationship between alopecia areata,
39. Kalabokes VD. Alopecia areata: Support groups and meetings - how can it help your patient? Dermatol Ther.
PT
2011;24:302-304.
RI
SC
NU
MA
E D
PT
CE
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Appendices:
Table 1. Health-related quality of life indices for evaluating patients with alopecia areata
Self-reported questionnaire composed of 10 questions, The percentage of body hair loss was
assessing effect of skin condition on various aspects of related to poor DLQI14
life. Scores range from 0 (no effect on patient’s life, high Concomitant depression in AA is
HRQoL) to 30 (extremely large effect on patient’s life, associated with poor DLQI13,15
PT
poor HRQoL). Scores range from 5.3 to 137
Skindex
RI
Self-reported questionnaire composed of 61-item Related to severity of disease14
survey, assessing the degree to which an individual is Pronounced symptoms in older
SC
bothered in various aspects of skin condition. Scores patients14
range from 0 (never bothered, high HRQoL) to 100
(always bothered, poor HRQoL). Dimensions assessed
NU
are symptoms, emotions and function.16
Original constructed for use in the Medical Outcomes No correlation with AA severity14
Study, not specific to skin. Scores range from 0 (poor Poorer HRQoL in role emotional,
HRQoL) to 100 (high HRQoL). Evaluates 8 dimensions of mental health, and vitality17
HRQoL, including physical functioning, role physical, role
D
Adults Beck Depression Inventory A multiple choice self-report inventory with three different
versions to help health care and researchers on the
diagnosis of depression for adults and adolescents 13 years
PT
old and over.
Fear of Negative Evaluation Scale The brief version is most often used to measure social
RI
anxiety, evaluating on how the patient self identifies in 12
different social situations
SC
The Holmes and Rahe Stress Scale The number of "Life Change Units" apply to events in the
(Social Readjustment Rating Scale) past year of a patient's life are added and the final score
NU
will give a rough estimate of how stress affects health.
externally.
Traumatic Events Questionnaire The 11-item questionnaire with a 7 points scale that
CE
Children Children’s Depression Inventory A 27-item self-rated and symptom-oriented scale to assess
the severity of symptoms related to depression and
dysthymic disorders in children and adolescents.
State-Trait Anxiety Inventories for Two 20-item scales that measure state and trait anxiety in
Children children between the ages of 6 and 14, that could measure
anxiety at both poles of the normal affect curve.
PT
RI
SC
NU
MA
E D
PT
CE
AC