Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1, JANUARY 2008
The rotor is considered to be displaced vertically downward by The symmetry of rotor teeth permits further simplification of
a distance ∆ from the stator axis, as shown in Fig. 2. (8) by using a standard trigonometric identity to combine the
Although the air-gap flux leaves the rotor teeth and enters the inverse tangent functions. This leads to the following closed-
stator surface, both normally, the length of the flux path can be form expression for the UMP:
approximated to the diagonal g . The relation between g and π
4
∆
the original air gap g can be derived for the upper and lower a
1− g sin 2α
−1 .
halves as P = −K 2α− tan 2 4
c
2 ∆ + 1+ ∆ cos 2α
2 g g
g ∆ ∆ 0
(9)
= 1+ ±2 sin α. (1)
g g g
a) Special cases: Two extreme cases may be considered
to verify the authenticity of the closed-form expression. For
The vertical components of force F1 and F2 on the upper
convenience, a static eccentricity factor (SEF), as shown in the
and lower halves, respectively, of the machine are separately
following equation, is considered to specify the level of static
calculated by combining (1) with classical force equations as
eccentricity:
follows:
∆
SEF = (10)
π,0
2
g
µ0 lrV0 sin α · dα
F1 , F2 =
2 (2)
2g 2
where ∆ is the displacement of the rotor center vertically down-
0,−π 1+ ∆
g ± 2∆ g sin α ward from the stator center, and g is the normal air-gap length,
as shown in Fig. 2. As the first case, let the rotor of the alternator
where l is the axial length, r is the rotor radius, V0 is the dc be perfectly aligned with the stator, with no eccentricity, so
excitation per air gap in ampere turns, and α is the angle along that there is no UMP. In this case, SEF = (∆/g) = 0, and (9)
the periphery of the rotor. However, the integrals in (2) are not reduces to
continuous ones. They have to be integrated over the rotor teeth π
−1 sin 2α
only. Now, let P = −K 2α − tan = 0. (11)
cos 2α 0
2 2
∆ ∆ ∆ In the second case, the other extreme may be considered,
a=1+ b=2 c=1− . (3)
g g g where there is rub contact between the stator and rotor. The
ratio SEF = (∆/g) = 1, and the UMP may be calculated as
On substituting the expression for a and b in (2), we obtain π
2
F1 , F2 with appropriate limits of integration as P = −K 2α − tan−1 (0) . (12)
0 0
µ0 lrV02 α a dα Applying L’Hospital’s rule to (12), the value of the UMP is
F1 , F2 = ± ∓ . (4)
2g 2 b b a ± b sin α obtained as infinity indicating rub contact.
122 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON VEHICULAR TECHNOLOGY, VOL. 57, NO. 1, JANUARY 2008
2µ0 lrV0
ΦA =
{F (D, ϕ) + F (D, ω)} (14)
g 1+ ∆ g
where
In this paper, the UMP is calculated for a three-phase 4.5-kW $
2 ∆ π α π α
train-lighting brushless alternator by considering a set of nine g
D= ϕ= + ω= − . (15)
rotor positions, by shifting the rotor in steps of 5◦ , until the 1+ g∆ 4 2 4 2
original stator–rotor relative position is reached at 45◦ . The first
such position of the rotor, along with discrete limiting values of F (D, ϕ) and F (D, ω) are elliptic integrals of the first kind with
angle over rotor teeth, is shown in Fig. 3. sin−1 D as the modular angle. Equation (14) is summed up
Thus, limiting values of angle over rotor teeth for each of over the rotor teeth portion only, and from the table of elliptic
the nine positions of the rotor are noted down from elaborately integrals, the values of axial flux can be directly obtained.
prepared cross-sectional sketches of the alternator, and the The axial flux is dependent on the position of the rotor and
UMP is calculated by using the closed-form expression in (9). A will fluctuate with rotor position. However, the position of
correction is made on the values of the UMP so obtained, based maximum axial leakage flux alone is considered in this paper.
on equivalent air-gap length, by using the magnetization curve A plot of the variation of axial flux expressed as a ratio of
of the machine, to account for saturation [7]. The dependence noneccentric air-gap flux with different values of SEF is shown
of the UMP for different variations of SEF is assessed. In this in Fig. 5.
paper, a dedicated software on MATLAB platform based on 2) FEM: The rotor eccentricity is assumed to be static
the expression is also developed for determining the UMP in and constant in the axial direction. The distribution of the
inductor-type train-lighting alternators, which saves much time radial force due to eccentricity is calculated using the classi-
and computational effort. cal Maxwell stress tensor method. Moving the rotor mesh in
An earlier experimental investigation [8] shows that skewing discrete predetermined angular steps as the solution progresses
the rotor of a rotating machine will influence the UMP. Hence, in 2-D finite-element (FE) analysis simulates movement at
as a next step, a skew of 72◦ electrical is introduced in the constant speed. Starting from a particular position, the rotor is
rotor of the machine. The 2-D problem was approached with moved by ∆θ◦ each time, until the original rotor–stator relative
classical layer theory, where the machine is divided into layers position is reached [10], and the flux linkage distribution in the
or regions of interest. The magnetic field is solved for each air gap is obtained. Maxwell’s stress tensor dF is calculated
of these regions, and the UMP is calculated in each of these from the radial component of flux density Br as
regions by using the closed-form expression in (9), and then,
the resultant value is determined. The values of the UMP at Br2
no load for 3◦ of rotor eccentricities for the alternator for both dF =
2µ0
. (16)
unskewed and skewed rotors at a total dc excitation of 1600 A
are listed in Table II. The total force is then obtained by integrating Maxwell’s
The closed-form expression can also be used to determine stress tensor around the rotor. FE modeling of the alternator was
the UMP under the conical motion of the eccentric rotor. The done for three different variations of SEF, each time shifting
machine is divided into three slices of equal length. Fig. 4 the rotor center alone vertically in the negative y-direction,
PILLAI et al.: UMP IN TRAIN-LIGHTING BRUSHLESS ALTERNATORS WITH STATIC ECCENTRICITY 123
TABLE III
UMP IN NEWTONS FOR THE CONICAL MOTION OF THE ROTOR
Fig. 8. Theoretical and FEM values of the UMP for alternator with skewed
rotor.
dϕ dϕ dθ
VP (t) = − =− . (17)
dt dθ dt
dθ 360 in the two coils A and B lying in the y-axis, at 1500 r/min, were
= = 6N (19)
dt 60/N predetermined by FEM for three different variations of SEF.
This requires about 40 FE models of the alternator. The Fourier
where N is the rotor speed in revolutions per minute, which analysis of (VB ∼ VA ) presents a marked pattern with changing
depends on the speed of the train. Arriving at the voltage wave- static eccentricity. The magnitude of the fundamental compo-
form in this manner is extremely advantageous in the case of nent is found to increase initially but then starts to decrease
train-lighting alternators, since they operate over a wide range with increasing SEF. However, the rising magnitudes of the
of speed. The tedious procedure of FEM needs to be done only dc component and the second harmonic indicate a progressing
for any one speed of operation, and the waveform for any other static eccentricity, as in Fig. 9. The variation of the effective
speed can be obtained by using a scaling factor for the speed. value of the difference in voltages in the two coils with SEF
This is then analyzed by discrete Fourier transform to obtain the is shown in Fig. 10. The Fourier analysis of the voltage VB
harmonic components [13], [14]. In the present investigation, induced in the bottom coil also shows a clear variation with
the no-load voltage VA and VB induced in two coils A and B, increasing SEF, as in Fig. 11.
respectively, situated in diametrically opposite stator slots along Hence, this pattern of changing harmonics in (VB ∼ VA ),
the y-axis only were considered. No-load-voltage waveforms, along with the harmonic changes occurring in the induced
PILLAI et al.: UMP IN TRAIN-LIGHTING BRUSHLESS ALTERNATORS WITH STATIC ECCENTRICITY 125
voltage in the bottom coil in the stator ac slot, may be used [4] K. P. P. Pillai, A. S. Nair, and G. R. Bindu, “Design of a train
to monitor the progress of the defect in the rotor of the lighting brushless alternator to minimize harmonic distortion and derat-
ing,” in Proc. IEE 5th Int. Conf. CEM, Stratford-upon-Avon, U.K., 2004,
brushless alternator. Thus, it provides clear evidence for the pp. 105–107.
potential of condition monitoring to identify increasing static [5] K. P. P. Pillai, A. S. Nair, and G. R. Bindu, “Novel numerical techniques
eccentricity of the rotor over a period of time by observing the for determination of unbalanced magnetic pull and for condition moni-
toring of train lighting brushless alternators with static eccentricity,” in
changes in magnitude of these voltage harmonics. The main Proc. 15th Int. Conf. COMPUMAG, Shenyang, China, Jun. 2005, vol. 1,
advantage is that both these techniques can be applied under pp. 78–79.
site conditions without stopping the machine. Moreover, it [6] K. P. P. Pillai, A. S. Nair, and G. R. Bindu, “Analysis of unbalanced
magnetic pull in train-lighting brushless alternators with skewed rotor
does not require any complex sophisticated instruments for the under static eccentricity and conical rotor motion,” in Proc. 17th ICEM,
implementation of this concept. Hence, condition monitoring Chania, Greece, Sep. 2006, pp. 46–47.
through voltage analysis is one of the most viable techniques [7] A. K. Sawhney, A Course in Electrical Machine Design, 5th ed.
New Delhi, India: Dhanpat Rai & Sons, 1984, pp. 186–188.
since, for machines like train-lighting alternators, which oper- [8] D. G. Dorell and A. C. Smith, “Calculation and measurement of unbal-
ate under extreme environmental conditions, vibration analysis anced magnetic pull in cage induction motors with eccentric rotors—
using transducers is very difficult [15]. However, since this is Part 2: Experimental investigation,” Proc. Inst. Electr. Eng.—Electr.
Power Appl., vol. 143, no. 3, pp. 202–210, May 1996.
a new area with very little field experience, standards as to [9] A. Tenhunen, “Electromagnetic forces acting between the stator and ec-
when failure will occur and how much harmonic content would centric cage rotor,” Doctoral dissertation, Dept. Electr. Commun. Eng.
guarantee an impending stator–rotor rub contact have to be Lab. Electromech., Helsinki Univ. Technol., Espoo, Finland, 2003.
[10] K. P. P. Pillai, “Predetermination of generated voltage in heteropolar
found out. inductor alternators,” Proc. Inst. Electr. Eng., vol. 122, no. 11, pp. 1265–
1272, 1975.
[11] S. Williamson, T. J. Flack, and A. F. Volschenk, “Representation of
III. C ONCLUSION AND F UTURE W ORK skew in time stepped two-dimensional finite element models of electri-
cal machines,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 31, no. 5, pp. 1009–1015,
For machines like flexible mounted train-lighting alternators, Sep./Oct. 1995.
[12] A. Tenhunen and A. Arkkio, “Modelling of induction machines with
which operate under extreme environmental conditions and skewed rotor slots,” Proc. Inst. Electr. Eng.—Electr. Power Appl., vol. 148,
constantly under the influence of vibrations, contributed by no. 1, pp. 45–50, Jan. 2001.
the movement of the coach itself, the UMP is too significant [13] K. Ide, M. Takahashi, M. Sato, and H. Nishizawa, “Higher harmonics
calculation of synchronous generators on the basis of magnetic field
to be ignored. Moreover, in inductor alternators, the air gap analysis considering rotor movement,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 28, no. 2,
is too small for saturation to be neglected, as in classical pp. 1359–1362, Mar. 1992.
analysis. Hence, the techniques discussed in this paper are [14] A. Darabi and C. Tindall, “Brushless exciter modeling for small salient
pole alternators using finite elements,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers.,
extremely helpful in calculating the UMP and obtaining a vol. 17, no. 3, pp. 306–312, Sep. 2002.
signature for condition monitoring to identify increasing static [15] M. E. H. Benbouzid, “A review of induction motors signature analysis as
eccentricity of the rotor over a period of time. This then a medium for faults detection,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 47, no. 5,
pp. 984–993, Oct. 2000.
aids in avoiding rub contact between stator and rotor during [16] P. Gupta, “Condition monitoring of the train lighting and air conditioning
prolonged operations of these alternators, which is a major system on the Indian Railways,” J. Indian Railways Inst. Electr. Eng.
problem, as reported by the Indian Railways and alternator (IRIEEN), vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 27–30, Mar./Apr. 2000.
manufacturers [16]. A single software package for detection
and calculation of a UMP can be developed by combining
the proposed FEM-based condition-monitoring technique with
the analytical procedure developed in this paper. The depen-
dence of the UMP on rotor skew under both balanced and
unbalanced loaded conditions are also to be investigated in the
future.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors would like to thank M/s KEL, Kundara, India, K. P. P. Pillai (M’65–SM’70–LSM’01) was born in
manufacturers of train-lighting alternators, and M/s EMRC, Kerala, India, on August 28, 1936. He received the
Bangalore, India, for their help with this project. B.Sc. (Engg.) and M.Sc. (Engg.) degrees from the
University of Kerala, Thiruvananthapuram, India, in
1957 and 1960, respectively, and the Ph.D. degree
from the Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur,
R EFERENCES
India, in 1965.
[1] S. Nandi, R. M. Bharadwaj, and H. A. Toliyat, “Performance analysis of From 1971 to 1976, he was a Professor of elec-
a three phase induction motor under mixed eccentricity condition,” IEEE trical engineering with the College of Engineering,
Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 17, no. 3, pp. 392–399, Sep. 2002. Thiruvananthapuram, where he later became the
[2] C. E. Kim and J. K. Sykulski, “Harmonic analysis of output voltage Principal. From 1982 to 1988, he was the Director
in synchronous generator using finite element method taking account of the LBS Engineering Research and Consultancy Centre, which is a state-
of the movement,” IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. 38, no. 2, pp. 1249–1252, run enterprise. From 1995 to 1997, he was the Founder Director of the
Mar. 2002. School of Technology and Applied Sciences, Mahatma Gandhi University,
[3] D. G. Dorell, T. T. William, and R. Steven, “Analysis of airgap flux, Kottayam, India. From 1997 to 1999, he was the Executive Secretary and the
current and vibration signals as a function of the combination of static and Director of the Indian Society for Technical Education, New Delhi, India. He
dynamic airgap eccentricity in 3-phase induction motors,” IEEE Trans. is a Consultant to various electrical industries in India. His research interests
Ind. Appl., vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 24–34, Jan./Feb. 1997. include electromagnetic field theory and condition monitoring of electric drives.
126 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON VEHICULAR TECHNOLOGY, VOL. 57, NO. 1, JANUARY 2008
Achuthsankar S. Nair (M’06) was born in Kerala, G. R. Bindu was born in Kerala, India, on
India, on July 14, 1963. He received the M.Tech. February 2, 1967. She received the M.Tech. and
degree from the Indian Institute of Technology, the Ph.D. degrees from the University of Kerala,
Mumbai, India, in 1987, the M.Phil. degree from the Thiruvananthapuram, India, in 1992 and 2005.
University of Cambridge, Cambridge, U.K., in 1992, She was an Engineer with KERAFED and a mem-
and the Ph.D. degree from the University of Kerala, ber of the faculty of various engineering colleges
Thiruvananthapuram, India, in 1996. in Kerala. She is currently a Senior Lecturer with
From 1999 to 2001, he was the Academic Head of the Department of Electrical Engineering, College
the De Montfort University Campus, Kuala Lumpur, of Engineering, Thiruvananthapuram. Her research
Malaysia. He was an Assistant Professor of computer interests include electromagnetic field theory and
science with the University College of Engineering, control and condition monitoring of electric drives.
Thiruvananthapuram. He was the Director of the Centre for the Development
of Imaging Technology, Thiruvananthapuram, which is a state-run enterprise.
He is currently the Hon. Director of the Centre for Bioinformatics, University
of Kerala. His research interests include neuro-fuzzy systems and digital image
processing.