Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The present study intends to assess the utilisation of and satisfaction on government
healthcare system by the community in East Godavari district of Andhra Pradesh,
India. The study is a community-based, cross-sectional study utilising both
quantitative and qualitative methods. Majority of the people said that the visits of
peripheral health workers were regular and their services were relevant to the needs
of the people. More women are satisfied with these services than men. Almost 60 per
cent of people are satisfied with the services available at different healthcare
institutions. The qualitative data revealed that some members of the vulnerable
communities expressed their dissatisfaction with the healthcare providers by citing
incidences of discrimination due to caste and economic condition. Some respondents
of the present study were also dissatisfied with the functioning of the health services,
and with the attitude of healthcare providers at different health institutions.
Functioning of the primary health centre (PHC) system and the attitude of the staff
were reasons for dissatisfaction of the people of this area. Though the health outreach
of rural Andhra Pradesh is better than the national scenario, to improve further, the
attitude of the staff of PHCs should be reoriented. Discrimination between different
economic/ethnic groups has a great impact on health outreach in toto. A substantial
number of people have no trust on the local health system by virtue of which they
prefer the services of private practitioners. Therefore, confidence-building measures
should be taken by providing ‘quality healthcare services’ at the PHC level.
Dr. B.V. Babu is Assistant Director (Social Science), Mr. G.R. Varma is Research
Assistant in WHO/TDR Project, and Mr. A.N. Nayak and Ms. K. Rath are Senior
Research Fellows in Division of Epidemiology, Regional Medical Research Centre,
Indian Council of Medical Research, Bhubaneswar, Orissa, India.
INTRODUCTION
India being the largest democracy in the world, with a sheer size of its
population characterised by diversity, initiated the process of planned
development to raise the living standard of its people, soon after its
Independence. Establishment of primary health centres (PHC) in
community development blocks was an integral part of the community
development programme, launched in the year 1952 on the basis of the
recommendations of the Bhore Committee with the aim to spread the
modern medicine in rural areas. One of the important
recommendations of the Bhore Committee was to establish first level
referral centres, the PHC, which was to cover only a population of
236 B.V. Babu, G.R. Varma, A.N. Nayak and K. Rath
METHODS
Study Area
The present study was undertaken in the East Godavari district of
Andhra Pradesh, a southern state of India. The population of East
Godavari district is 75.7 million (India: Office of the Registrar-General,
Utilisation of Primary Healthcare Services 237
and Oken, 1992). The in-depth interviews and focus group discussions
were recorded by note-taking and audio cassette recording. At the end
of each interview/discussion, the audio cassettes were played back and
the text was transcribed along with field notes. These notes were
entered into a personal computer in a word processor and were
analysed by using Textbase Beta (Centre for Qualitative Research,
Institute of Psychology, Aarhus University, Risskov, Denmark).
RESULTS
The quantitative data obtained through the study is analysed and
presented in Table 1. The respondents were enquired about various
aspects of services they are receiving from the PHC and sub-centre as
well as from health workers. From the analysis of quantitative data, it
is evident that, majority of people are satisfied with the visits of health
workers to their locality.
DISCUSSION
per cent of those below poverty line still seek immunisation from the
private sector. Similarly, the private sector accounts for 25 per cent of
antenatal care, 30 per cent of institutional deliveries, and 40 per cent of
hospitalisation among the people living below the poverty line. This,
however, leaves out a large chunk of unmet needs and about 60 per cent
non-institutional deliveries. Thus, the recent trends in health finance
and policies resulted that private sector is the dominant provider and
financier of healthcare in India.
Though a majority of the respondents have given positive remarks
towards the healthcare system in the quantitative household survey,
the qualitative research findings reflect that there are some
respondents who are not satisfied with the functioning of the
healthcare system. Respondents of the present study are, somehow,
dissatisfied about the functioning of the health service, attitude of
providers at different government health institutions, and sometimes
with non-availability of medicines. Other studies also reported similar
findings. Many maternal and child health indicators such as coverage
of antenatal check-up, coverage of pregnant women, and place and
assistance during pregnancy are higher for Andhra Pradesh than the
country’s average (NFHS-2: India, 2000). But the number of
institutional deliveries and antenatal care among SC and Scheduled
Tribe (ST) population is not encouraging (NFHS-2: Andhra Pradesh,
2000). These sections of people are yet to receive better healthcare
during pregnancy and post-partum period. The activities like providing
tetanus toxoid injections and iron folic acid tablets are dependant upon
the functioning of health workers. So the visits of health workers have
not yet provided optimum health outreach among the vulnerable
communities like the SC, ST and BC communities. People from these
underprivileged groups grumbled that health workers were
discriminating against them and were not giving adequate attention. It
was also reported that the health service providers were also creating
discrimination between the people of high income and lower
socioeconomic group. Zurbrigg (1984) identified the apathy of the staff
and the existing barrier between the doctor and the people of low
socioeconomic group as the reason of low utilisation and lower
satisfaction by the people. Banerji (1975) also expressed a similar
opinion. He said ‘the urban orientation of health staff distances them
from the rural population’. Sometimes, during visits, health workers do
not give equal attention to the people of lower segment such as the SCs
and BCs, though these are the people who utilise the government
healthcare system the most. This type of discrimination on the basis of
caste has also been reported from Orissa, one of the neighbouring states
of Andhra Pradesh (Babu, Chhotray, Hazra and Satyanarayana, 2000).
They reported the apathy of health workers and hesitation of health
staff to enter the houses of SCs and STs, which speaks volumes about
the care available to needy people. It is also evident from the present
Utilisation of Primary Healthcare Services 245
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This study is part of multi-centric study of community directed treatment of
lymphatic filariasis, funded by the UNDP/World Bank/WHO’s Special Programme
for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases (TDR), World Health Organisation,
Geneva, Switzerland.
REFERENCES
Babu, B.V., : Perception and Interaction of Vulnerable Groups with the
Chhotray, G.P., Government Health Services, The Indian Journal of Social
Hazra, R.K. and Work, 61(1), 54–65.
Satyanarayana, K.
2000
2001 : Community Perception of a District Health System,
Journal of Health Management, 3, 1–13.
Banerji, D. : Social and Cultural Foundations of Health Service
1975 Systems of India, Inquiry, Supplement 12, 2.
1982 : Poverty, Class and Health Culture in India, New Delhi:
Prachi Prakasana.
Chuttani, C.S. : Factors Responsible for Under Utilization of Primary
1976 Health Centres: A Community Survey in Three States in
India, NIHAE Bulletin, 9, 3.
Cornia, G.A. and : The Mortality Crisis of Transitional Economies, Oxford:
Paniccia, R. : Oxford University Press.
2000
Dreze, J. and Sen, A. : India: Development and Participation, New Delhi: Oxford
2002 University Press.
Duggal, R. : Healthcare Utilization of India, Health Millions, 2, 10–12.
1994
Ghosh, B.N. and : An Analysis of Health Services Coverage of a Primary
Mukherjee, A.B. Health Centre in West Bengal, Indian Journal of Public
1989 Health, 33, 26–30.
Goyal, R.C. : Awareness and Utilization of MCH and FP Services by a
1990 Rural Community in Maharashtra, Indian Journal of
Maternal and Child Health, 4, 149.
246 B.V. Babu, G.R. Varma, A.N. Nayak and K. Rath
Health for All: Serial : World Health Report 2000: Health Systems — Improving
No 1, Geneva. Performance, Geneva.
2000
India : Report on the Health Survey and Development Committee,
1946 Shimla.
India: Ministry of : Bulletin on Rural Health Statistics in India, New Delhi:
Health & Family Rural Health Division, Director General of Health
Welfare Services.
1998
2002 : National Health Policy 2002, New Delhi.
India: Office of the : Census of India (Series-1, India, Provisional Population
Registrar-General Totals, Paper 1), New Delhi.
2001
Indian Council of : Health for All: An Alternative Strategy, Pune.
Social Science
Research and Indian
Council of Medical
Research
1980
International Institute: National Family Health Survey-2: India 1998–1999,
of Population Mumbai.
Sciences
2000a
2000b : National Family Health Survey-2: Andhra Pradesh
1998–1999, Mumbai.
Khan, M.E., Anker, M., : The Use of Focus Groups in Social and Behavioural
Patel, B.C., Barge, S., Research: Some Methodological Issues, World Health
Sadhwani, H. and Statistics Quarterly, 44, 150–159.
Kohle, R.
1991
Kline, A., : Minority Women and Sexual Choice in the Age of AIDS,
Kline, E. and Social Science and Medicine, 34, 447–457.
Oken, E.
1992
Kumar, A. : Utilisation Pattern of MCH Services in an Urban
1982 Community, POPCEN Newsletter, 8, 1–5.
Lengeler, C., : The Value of Questionnaires Aimed at Key Informants,
Mashinda, H., and Distributed through an Existing Administrative
Savigny, D., System for Rapid and Cost-effective Health Assessment,
Kilima, P., World Health Statistics Quarterly, 44, 150–159.
Morona, D. and
Tanner, M.
1991
Madhiwalla, N., : Health, Household and Women’s Lives: A Study of Illness
Nandraj, S. and and Childbearing among Women in Nasik District of
Sinha R. Maharashtra, Mumbai: Centre for Enquiry for Health and
2000 Allied Themes.
Pelto, P.J. and : Anthropological Research: The Structure of Enquiry,
Pelto, G.H. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1978
Utilisation of Primary Healthcare Services 247
THE INDIAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK, Volume 68, Issue 2, April 2007