Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Exercise BMT
Exercise BMT
Downloaded on 01 20 2018. Single-user license only. Copyright 2018 by the Oncology Nursing Society. For permission to post online, reprint, adapt, or reuse, please email pubpermissions@ons.org
Intervention
Attrition, compliance, adherence, and progression following
M
hematopoietic stem cell transplantation
Tara Peters, BS, Ruby Erdmann, RD, LDN, and Eileen Danaher Hacker, PhD, APN, AOCN®, FAAN
BACKGROUND: Exercise is widely touted as an MORE THAN 20,000 HEMATOPOIETIC STEM CELL TRANSPLANTATIONS (HSCTs) were
effective intervention to optimize health and performed in the United States in 2015, a rate that continues to increase (D’Souza
well-being after high-dose chemotherapy and & Zhu, 2016). This figure includes recipients of autologous and allogeneic
hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. HSCTs. The preparatory regimens used in conjunction with HSCT frequently
result in a wide range of acute and chronic side effects, such as infection, throm-
OBJECTIVES: This article reports attrition, bocytopenia, and fatigue (Copelan, 2006). Recipients of allogeneic HSCT are
compliance, adherence, and progression from the at risk for additional complications, including graft-versus-host disease.
strength training arm of the single-blind random- The adverse effects of the high-dose chemotherapy may be severe and
ized, controlled trial Strength Training to Enhance highly distressing, negatively affecting the recipient’s quality of life (Cohen
Early Recovery (STEER). et al., 2012). Although many side effects are temporary and resolve within
three to six months, others are long-term and develop months or years after
METHODS: 37 patients were randomized to the HSCT (Morrison et al., 2016). For example, moderate to severe persistent
intervention and participated in a structured strength fatigue has been documented during the early recovery period and years
training program introduced during hospitalization after HSCT (Gielissen et al., 2007; Hacker, Fink, et al., 2017; Jim et al., 2016).
and continued for six weeks after release. Research Interventions to address these distressing symptoms are needed to improve
staff and patients maintained exercise logs to docu- the long-term outcomes of HSCT recipients.
ment compliance, adherence, and progression. Strong interest exists in the development of effective exercise interventions
for patients receiving intensive cancer therapy, including those undergoing
FINDINGS: No patients left the study because of HSCT. Fewer than 20 randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) testing exer-
burden. Patients were compliant with completion cise interventions have been conducted in this population (Hacker, Collins,
of exercise sessions, and their adherence was high; et al., 2017; Jacobsen et al., 2014; Persoon et al., 2013). Although the general
they also progressed on their exercise prescription. evidence supports the use of exercise in this population, implementation
Because STEER balances intervention effectiveness varies across studies, such as timing of exercise initiation and the exercise
with patient burden, the findings support the likeli- modality, intensity, and duration. Because of the challenges associated with
hood of successful translation into clinical practice. conducting exercise studies and then translating these findings into clinical
practice, multiple additional pragmatic factors need to be fully assessed prior
to implementing exercise interventions in the general population of patients
KEYWORDS undergoing HSCT. These study factors include the following:
attrition; compliance; adherence; progres- ɐɐ Patient attrition (number of patients leaving the study prior to completion)
sion; hematopoietic stem cell transplantation ɐɐ Exercise compliance (ability to complete the prescribed number of exer-
cise sessions)
DIGITAL OBJECT IDENTIFIER ɐɐ Exercise adherence (ability to complete the specific exercises as detailed in
10.1188/18.CJON.97-103 the exercise prescription)
ɐɐ Exercise progression (ability to advance the exercise prescription)
Discussion
reported annual family income levels of less than $40,000. Most Growing evidence supports the health benefits of exercise in
received autologous transplantations. the population of patients undergoing HSCT (Persoon et al.,
2013; van Haren et al., 2013). However, wide variation exists in
Attrition the HSCT population examined, timing of the exercise interven-
Four patients died during the study because of disease- and/or tion, and exercise mode, duration, and intensity. Understanding
treatment-related complications, which represented an 11% patient attrition, along with exercise compliance, adherence,
attrition rate. None of the deaths, which occurred during HSCT and progression, is important for interpreting outcomes. A sin-
hospitalization, were attributable to STEER study–related activ- gle-blind RCT supports the use of strength training for reducing
ities. This resulted in a post-hospital STEER intervention group fatigue and improving functional ability (Hacker, Collins, et al.,
of 33 patients. 2017). Results from this study provide additional information
for clinicians to translate these findings into clinical practice. In
Compliance this study, no patients assigned to the STEER intervention left
The compliance results for the moderate-intensity strength the study because it was too burdensome. In addition, patients
training portion of the study (number of sessions completed of demonstrated high compliance and adherence. Patients assigned
18 scheduled sessions) are reported in Table 2. Overall, patients to the STEER intervention were able to demonstrate progression
—
were highly complaint, with a compliance rate of 83% (X = 15 ses- on the exercise prescription, further indicating improvement in
sions, SD = 4). One patient did not complete any exercise sessions; health status. Findings from the current study, along with out-
when this patient was removed from the analysis, the compliance comes from the main study, suggest that the STEER intervention
—
rate rose to 86% (X = 15.4 sessions, SD = 3). Independent sam- is effective for reducing fatigue and improving functional abil-
ples t tests were used to compare compliance rates based on age, ity. The STEER intervention effectively balances intervention
gender, and type of transplantation. No significant differences effectiveness with patient burden, as evidenced by the very low
were observed in compliance rates based on these variables. attrition and high compliance and adherence rates, as well as by
of the most complex cancer populations, particularly during the among people with cancer include community-based exercise
acute recovery period following transplantation. programs for cancer survivors (Musanti & Murley, 2016) and the
Other activities and advancements in technology may prove power of exercise from a survivor’s perspective (Hope, 2016).
beneficial in exercise studies following HSCT in the future. For
example, motivational text or voice messages may be used as an Conclusion
extra tool to facilitate compliance and adherence (Wang et al., Recipients of HSCT are able to tolerate a moderate-intensity
2015). Incentives, such as goal-related certificates or small prizes, strength training intervention during the acute recovery period
have been used in other studies with good results and should be following transplantation, as demonstrated by the low attrition
considered for future studies (Brassil et al., 2014). Adding a wear- and high compliance and adherence rates, as well as the patients’
able step counter may also be beneficial to patients enrolled in ability to progress on their exercise prescription during the study.
studies. Some patients could find the addition of group exercise These findings suggest that the STEER intervention maintains a
sessions in the clinical setting to be helpful; however, the need for beneficial sustained exercise regimen without placing additional
constant individualized reevaluation of exercise prescription may stress on an already highly burdened population. Addressing the
make that unmanageable. pragmatic concerns of intervention effectiveness and uptake
From a clinical practice perspective, oncology nurses are among participants provides important information to translate
uniquely qualified to lead programs aimed at increasing physical successful interventions, such as STEER, into clinical practice.
activity across the cancer survivorship trajectory. In consultation
with other oncology practitioners, efforts geared toward assessing Tara Peters, BS, is a visiting research specialist in the College of Nursing in the
patients for functional limitations, designing individualized phys- Department of Biobehavioral Health Science at the University of Illinois at Chicago;
ical activity and exercise interventions, and providing patients Ruby Erdmann, RD, LDN, is the director of nutrition services at Near North Health
with appropriate resources to facilitate successful implementa- Service Corporation in Chicago; and Eileen Danaher Hacker, PhD, APN, AOCN®,
tion will help to move exercise science forward (Austin, Damani, FAAN, is a professor in the School of Nursing and chair of the Department of
& Bevers, 2016; Haas, Hermanns, & Kimmel, 2016; McNeely, Science of Nursing Care at Indiana University in Indianapolis and was, at the time
Dolgoy, Al Onazi, & Suderman, 2016; Musanti & Murley, 2016). of this research, an associate professor in the College of Nursing at the University
Examples of initiatives to promote physical activity and exercise of Illinois at Chicago. Hacker can be reached at edhacker@iu.edu, with copy to
CJONEditor@ons.org. (Submitted April 2017. Accepted for publication June 19,
TABLE 3. 2017.)
ADHERENCE TO MODERATE-INTENSITY STRENGTH
TRAINING AFTER HSCT HOSPITAL DISCHARGE The authors gratefully acknowledge Kevin Grandfield, MFA, for his editorial
assistance.
MEAN ADHERENCE
CHARACTERISTIC N RATE (%)
The authors take full responsibility for this content. This study was funded by a Research Scholar
Overall 33 89 Grant (RSG, 13-054-01-PCSM; principal investigator: Hacker) from the American Cancer Society.
The article has been reviewed by independent peer reviewers to ensure that it is objective and
Type of HSCT
free from bias.
Autologous 20 92
REFERENCES
Allogeneic 13 92
Austin, A., Damani, S., & Bevers, T. (2016). Clinical approach for patient-centered physical
Age (years) activity assessment and interventions. Clinical Journal of Oncology Nursing, 20(Suppl. 2),
S3–S7. https://doi.org/10.1188/16.CJON.S2.3-7
Younger than 60 21 86
Borg, G. (1998). Borg’s perceived exertion and pain scales. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
60 or older 11 96 Brassil, K.J., Szewczyk, N., Fellman, B., Neumann, J., Burgess, J., Urbauer, D., & LoBiondo-
Wood, G. (2014). Impact of an incentive-based mobility program, “Motivated and Moving,”
Gender
on physiologic and quality of life outcomes in a stem cell transplant population. Cancer
Male 20 95 Nursing, 37, 345–354. https://doi.org/10.1097/NCC.0b013e3182a40db2
Cohen, M.Z., Rozmus, C.L., Mendoza, T.R., Padhye, N.S., Neumann, J., Gning, I., . . . Cleeland,
Female 13 80
C.S. (2012). Symptoms and quality of life in diverse patients undergoing hematopoietic
HSCT—hematopoietic stem cell transplantation stem cell transplantation. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management, 44, 168–180. https://
Note. The adherence rate was defined as the number of exercises performed during a doi.org/10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2011.08.011
session divided by the total number of exercises prescribed. A maximum of 11 exercises
could be prescribed. Copelan, E.A. (2006). Hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation. New England Journal of
Medicine, 354, 1813–1826. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMra052638