You are on page 1of 5

Journal of Manufacturing Processes 53 (2020) 43–47

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Manufacturing Processes


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/manpro

Fabrication of a ceramic core for an impeller blade using a 3D printing T


technique and inorganic binder
Eun-Hee Kim, Hyun-Hee Choi, Yeon-Gil Jung*
School of Materials Science and Engineering, Changwon National University, Changwon, Gyeongnam, 51140, Republic of Korea

ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT

Keywords: Ceramic cores for fabricating an impeller blade were prepared by a process using 3D printing and an inorganic
Ceramic core binder system. This process is much simpler than precision casting and can produce ceramic cores with strength
3D printer suitable for casting. The two types of 3D printer, powder bed binder jet printing (BJP) and selective laser
Inorganic binder sintering (SLS), with different starting materials were used as 3D printers. The core prepared by the SLS showed
a higher strength than that by the BJP because of the smaller particle size of the starting powder, which induces a
large specific surface area, resulting in the high coating efficiency of the inorganic binder. The core sample
prepared using SLS showed a lower coefficient of thermal expansion than that by BJP, indicating that the core
made by SLS is more applicable in precision casting. In addition, the core after casting was completely eluted in a
NaOH solution. The casting of the real impeller blade casting was very successful and the precision of the
product was excellent.

1. Introduction been made on 3D printing technology and, in particular, attempts have


been made to improve the starting materials so as to produce high-
In the production of hollow mechanical components by casting, a quality products. However, the ceramic core produced by a 3D printing
ceramic core for forming an internal shape or flow channel is used to- technique still has a problem in that it is difficult to produce sufficient
gether with a ceramic mold for forming an external shape [1–3]. The strength, and a lengthy sintering process is required to induce the
external shape can be modified or complemented after casting, but strength [9]. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a new process that
because the internal space is difficult to advance after casting, the can induce strength without the sintering process while applying 3D
ceramic core is an important part for securing the precision and ob- printing technology. For this purpose, the inorganic binders were ap-
jectivity of the components. The cores used in precision casting for plied to the core fabrication using 3D printing technology to increase
manufacturing various mechanical components such as impellers, the firing strength of ceramic cores without sintering reaction between
blades, and vanes are prepared by a series of injection processes [4], but particles [6,10–12]. An inorganic binder was applied to maintain the
these processes have disadvantages of low productivity and high shape of the core and to withstand the molten metal. That is, when the
manufacturing cost [5]. green body is immersed in the inorganic binder solution, the inorganic
Recently, the development of 3D printing technology has made it binder is coated on the surface and interface between ceramic powders.
possible to fabricate precise and complicated parts with less cost and In inorganic precursors, NaOMe is hydrolyzed to form NaOH. Si(OEt)4
time, without mold making [6–8]. The production of the ceramic core (i.e., TEOS) is degraded to silici cacid (Si(OH)4) and ethyl alcohol
by 3D printing technology provides a speedy process and high energy (EtOH) through the hydrolysis reaction, and silica (SiO2) is formed by
saving in precision casting, compared with injection molding, in which the condensation reaction. This hydrolysis-condensation reaction is
it is not easy to change product design due to a high mold price and a usually called a sol-gel reaction. Then, the SiO2 and NaOH synthesized
long production time. In addition, small-sized companies can easily via the above mechanisms are glassified to form sodium silicate (Na2O
meet the needs of customers and thus gain competitiveness. By creating ㆍSiO2) during heat treatment at 1000 °C. The core has green strength
3D drawings and prototypes quickly, errors and defects can be easily by gelation of the inorganic binder and ultimately has firing strength
detected, making product modification easy and reducing product in- through the synthesis of sodium silicate during heat treatment. That is,
ventory and waste. Accordingly, many studies and developments have a glass phase converted from inorganic precursor is uniformly dispersed


Corresponding author.
E-mail address: jungyg@changwon.ac.kr (Y.-G. Jung).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2020.01.055
Received 9 May 2019; Received in revised form 9 September 2019; Accepted 29 January 2020
1526-6125/ © 2020 The Society of Manufacturing Engineers. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
E.-H. Kim, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 53 (2020) 43–47

Table 1
Starting materials used for each 3D printer.
Powder bed binder jet Selective Laser Sintering
printing (BJP) (SLS)

Molecular structure Quartz (SiO2) Mullite (3Al2O3ㆍ2SiO2)


Particle size 190 μm 70 μm
Binder Furan resin Phenol resin

between the particles by being coated on the ceramic powders and the
bonding force between the particles can be increased, resulting in im-
proved durability of the core [13].
In this work, the ceramic cores were prepared using two types of 3D
printer, namely a powder bed binder jet printing (BJP) type and se-
lective laser sintering (SLS) type. In addition, the organic–inorganic Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of the process sequence to prepare the ceramic core.
binder conversion process was applied to increase the mechanical
properties of the prepared core [14–18]. The cores with a real shape
Table 2
and a bar type were designed with a CAD program and formed through Composition ratio of the inorganic binder used in this study.
a 3D printing process, and then dipped into the inorganic precursor.
TEOS (wt% (mol%)) NaOMe (wt% (mol%)) Isobutyl alcohol (wt% (mol%))
Actual impeller blades were cast to test the applicability to the industry
of ceramic cores made using a 3D printing process. 38 (0.18) 56 (1.5) 6 (0.08)

2. Experimental procedure
USA) from room temperature to 1000 °C (no maintenance interval) and
2.1. Starting material and sample preparation in an atmospheric environment, with a heating rate of 10 °C/min. The
fracture strengths of the green and firing samples were measured using
Two types of 3D printer were used in this study: a BJP type (Voxeljet a universal testing machine (Instron 5566; Instron Corp., Norwood, MA,
VXC800 model, Germany) and SLS type (SENTROL SS600 G model, USA) in the 3-point bending mode, at a loading rate of 0.5 mm·min–1.
Republic of Korea). Quartz sand with a size of 190 μm and a mullite The span distance of low support was 40 mm. The test was performed
powder with a size of 70 μm were used as the starting material in the 10 times at room temperature to obtain the standard deviation in the
BJP and SLS types, respectively, as shown in Table 1. The shape of the fracture strength. The thermal expansion of the core samples was
starting materials used for each 3D printer is shown in Fig. 1. The furan measured with a heating rate of 5 °C min−1 up to 1000 °C, using a
resin and phenolic resin were used as organic binders in the BJP and dilatometer (Model 500S; Mac Science, Tokyo, Japan). To investigate
SLS types, respectively (Table 1). A schematic diagram for fabricating the possibility of elution, a NaOH solution of 50 wt% concentration was
the ceramic core is shown in Fig. 2. The inorganic binder employed in used and stirred for 24 h at 60 °C. A nondestructive test was performed
the coating process consisted of tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS; Sigma- after the dewaxing process using an X-ray machine (LK-C27
Aldrich Korea) as a silicon dioxide (SiO2) precursor and sodium meth- PROD170300414, Zzlinker, Zhengzhou, China) to confirm the sound-
oxide (NaOMe; Sigma-Aldrich Korea) as a sodium oxide (Na2O) pre- ness of the core. X-ray photographs were performed under the condi-
cursor. The composition of the inorganic binder system is shown in tions of 60 kV (voltage), 0.02 ∼ 2 s (exposure time), 0.3 × 0.3 mm
Table 2. Fig. 3 is a schematic drawing of the ceramic core for 450 mm (focus), and 30 kHz (frequency). The height of the blade was fixed by
impeller. The green bodies of a bar shape with 10 × 10 × 50 mm3 and the Coordinate Measuring Machine (CMM) equipment, and the height
a 4 mm thick impeller blade were designed using a CAD program and was measured at 10 points according to the position of the sample. The
prepared using the BJP and SLS printers. The green bodies were dipped experiment was conducted at a temperature of 25 °C and a humidity of
into the mixture solution of inorganic precursors and followed by a 45 %.
drying process at 80 °C for 1 h and heat treatment at 1000 °C for 1 h.
Heat treatment was carried out in the atmospheric environment as in a 3. Results and discussion
normal core fabrication process. The inorganic precursors cause a sol-
gel reaction during the drying process, The organic binder, a furan resin used in the BJP, is a thermosetting
resin containing a furan ring, and it is cured by heat and used as a
2.2. Measurement water-resistant adhesive. After curing, its color became black or dark
brown. The characteristics can be seen by looking at the color of the
The decomposition point of the organic binder was measured using core sample shown in Fig. 4. However, furan resins have drawbacks in
a thermogravimetric analyzer (Q600; TA Instruments, New Castle, DE, that when they are heated to 150 °C or more, cracks are generated due

Fig. 1. Starting materials with the type of 3D printer: (a) BJP type and (b) SLS type.

44
E.-H. Kim, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 53 (2020) 43–47

Fig. 3. Schematic drawings of (a) the 450 mm impeller and (b) the ceramic core.

Fig. 4. Real impeller blade (upper side) and bar sample (lower side) before dipping into inorganic binder solution: (a) BJP type and (b) SLS type.

to thermal expansion. The organic binder, a phenolic resin used in the samples (BJP type and SLS type), there was no significant difference in
SLS, is a thermosetting resin like furan resin. However, unlike the BJP the strength characteristics after one-time dipping, but the strength of
in which the binder is sprayed onto the powder, the starting powder is the core prepared using the SLS printer after the three-times dipping
irradiated with a CO2 laser to dissolve the phenolic resin coated on the was significantly increased. The cause is the difference in the shape and
powder to form the molded body by laminating the powder with the size of the ceramic particles used in the two samples. The starting
function of an adhesive. Both furan and phenolic resins do not dissolve powder for the SLS is about 70 μm in size, while the starting powder for
in solvents once hardened. However, it is difficult to maintain a form at the BJP is about 190 μm in size, indicating that the smaller the particle
a high temperature because the bond between the resins breaks down in size, the higher the coating efficiency of the inorganic binder due to the
the firing process (about 950 °C) or in the casting process. Similar larger specific surface area. In other words, the firing strength is in-
phenomena occur when using other resin-based binders instead of duced not by the sintering phenomenon between particles, but by the
phenol or furan resins. glass phase formed on the particle interface. Therefore, the coating
The fracture strength values of core samples prepared using a 3D efficiency of the inorganic binder onto the particle surface is an im-
printer are shown in Fig. 5. The strength before dipping into the in- portant factor for enhancing the strength. The smaller the size of the
organic binder was about 3 MPa, which is insufficient for direct ap- ceramic particles, the larger the surface area available for coating and
plication to the casting process. The binders used in two 3D printers the higher the strength of the core.
such as furan and phenolic resins, are thermosetting resins that form a The thermal expansion behavior for both samples was measured
network between molecular chains by heat or beam. Before the dipping after dipping into the inorganic binder and heat treatment (Fig. 6). The
of inorganic binder, the strength is totally maintained by the cross- core sample prepared by the BJP showed a thermal strain of about 1.25
linked resins generated at space between particles, so it does not affect % and a coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) of 13.2 × 10–6/℃. The
the strength depending on the particle size and type. Thus, the strengths core sample prepared by the SLS showed a thermal strain of about 0.5
of two ceramic cores prepared by 3D printers are similar before dipping % and CTE of 6.1 × 10–6/℃. Therefore, it was confirmed that the core
in the inorganic binder (As). However, after the dipping of inorganic prepared by the BJP had more thermal deformation than that by the
binder, since the strength is induced by the bonding of glass phase SLS. The difference in thermal properties is a result of the fact that the
between particles, the size of the particles has a great influence on the mullite powder has better thermal properties than the quartz powder.
strength. Therefore, the strength is greatly affected by the inorganic In addition, the core made by BJP printer has oscillation that undergoes
binder rather than the organic binders such as furan and phenolic re- expansion and shrinkage, while the core made by SLS printer expands
sins. Particularly, since these resins are completely decomposed within uniformly with temperature. The inorganic binder is coated with a thin
about 200 °C, there is no influence on the firing strength. When the layer of 10 μm–20 μm on the surface of particles. Since the SLS method
inorganic binder was impregnated once, the green strength was in- uses a mixture of an organic binder (phenol resin) and powder, the
creased by more than 1 MPa, but still insufficient and the firing strength inorganic binder is uniformly coated on the surface of the particles.
after heat treatment reached 5.8 MPa. When the inorganic binder is However, a BJP printer is a lamination method in which one layer is
coated twice, the strength was not improved much. Finally, in the case stacked with powder and the binder (furan resin) is stacked on the
of three coatings of inorganic binder, the green strength of the core powder. Thus, when the prepared core is dipped into the inorganic
prepared by the BJP was 9.5 ± 0.5 MPa and the firing strength was binder solution, the inorganic binder is not only coated on the surface of
12.5 ± 0.9 MPa. In the SLS, the green and firing strengths were particles, but also locally aggregated. As the temperature rises, the
12.5 ± 0.8 and 13.8 ± 4.3 MPa, respectively. Comparing the two evaporation of water and condensation reactions of inorganic binder

45
E.-H. Kim, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 53 (2020) 43–47

Fig. 7. The results of the elution test after casting for ceramic cores prepared
using 3D printers: (a) BJP type and (b) SLS type. The arrows are ceramic core
that is not eluted.

shrinkage caused by the inter-silica bonds. However, in the case of BJP,


the bonds between locally aggregated silicas cause the large volumetric
shrinkage, and the dimension expands again due to the molecular ex-
pansion of the silica itself. As a result, when a ceramic core made by the
SLS is fabricated and applied, the shape stability of the core by the SLS
Fig. 5. Fracture strengths of the core sample before and after heat treatment printer can be ensured and the internal space will be sound during
produced through the process shown in Fig. 2: (a) BJP type and (b) SLS type. As, casting.
I, II, and III indicate the strength before dipping, after single dipping, double The results of elution for the core samples (bar samples) after
dipping, and triple dipping into the inorganic binder, respectively. casting with molten Fe metal are shown in Fig. 7. The inner core after
casting was eluted in a NaOH solution of 50 wt% concentration, and
generate a bond between inter-silicas (glass formation) and the small then the remaining core was removed with high-pressure water. The
volume shrinkages due to the thinly coated glass phase on the particles. core prepared by the SLS was excellent in casting and the elution was
At the same time, the silica molecule itself increases in volume with also great despite the high firing strength (Fig. 7(b-1) and (b-2)). In the
increasing temperature. Thus, in the core made by SLS, the dimensions case of the BJP, the core was not fully eluted (arrows in Fig. 7(a-1) and
of the core increase linearly with increasing temperature, since the (a-2)). This is because of the aggregated inorganic binder during the
volume expansion of the silica itself is more dominant than the core fabrication, resulting in the difficult infiltrate of alkali solution.

Fig. 6. Thermal behavior of core sample prepared using 3D printers: (a) BJP type and (b) SLS type.

46
E.-H. Kim, et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 53 (2020) 43–47

Fig. 8. X-ray nondestructive test for the real impeller blade core prepared using the SLS after dewaxing.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial


interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influ-
ence the work reported in this paper.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by grants (NRF-2019R1D1A3A03103822)


Fig. 9. Real impeller blade cast using ceramic core prepared using a 3D printer. from the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the
Korean Government and by the “Human Resources Program in Energy
Technology” of the Korea Institute of Energy Technology Evaluation
Therefore, the waxing process for casting an impeller blade was con-
and Planning (KETEP), granted financial resources from the Ministry of
ducted using the real-type core prepared by the SLS, and then a non-
Trade, Industry and Energy, Republic of Korea (No. 20194030202450).
destructive test was performed after dewaxing using an X-ray machine
to determine whether the core was broken in the dewaxing process. As
References
shown in Fig. 8, no cracks or broken parts were observed, indicating
that it is suitable for the actual casting process using the core made by a
[1] Saikaew C, Wiengwiset S. Optimization of molding sand composition for quality
3D printer and inorganic binder. The castability test was conducted improvement of iron castings. Appl Clay Sci 2012;67:26–31.
with molten Al metal to verify the casting applicability of the inorganic [2] Meng YA, Thomas BG. Modeling transient slag-layer phenomena in the shell/mold
binder and the 3D printing technique (see Fig. 9). The core inside the gap in continuous casting of steel. Metall Mater Trans B 2003;34B:707–25.
[3] Şimşir M, Kumruoğlu LC, Özer A. An investigation into stainless-steel/structure-
blade product was completely eluted after casting. The impeller blade
alloy steel bimetal produced by shell mold casting. Mater Des 2009;30:264–70.
with an average vane height of 4.56 mm and an error range of ± 0.44 [4] Jiang J, Liu XY. Dimensional variations of castings and moulds in the ceramic mould
mm could be fabricated, proved by the CMC test. The Al casting with casting process mater. J Mater Process Technol 2007;189:247–55.
[5] Kim EH, Cho GH, Oh YS, Jung YG. Development of a high-temperature mold process
the core made by a 3D printer and inorganic binder was very successful,
for sand casting with a thin wall and complex shape. Thin Solid Films
and the dimensional accuracy of the product was also obtained with the 2016;620:70–5.
designed values. [6] Park HY, Kim EH, Choi HH, Cho GH, Jung YG, Zhang J. New conversion process for
fabricating a ceramic core by a 3D printing technique. Surf Coat Technol
2017;332:527–32.
4. Conclusions [7] Dong YW, Li XL, Zhao Q, Yang J, Dao M. Modeling of shrinkage during investment
casting of thin-walled hollow turbine blades. J Mater Process Technol
In this study, two types of 3D printer, BJP and SLS, were employed 2017;244:190–203.
[8] Saridkmen H, Kuskonmaz N. Properties of ceramic casting molds produced with two
to prepare the ceramic cores and the organic–inorganic conversion different binders. Interceram - Int Ceram Rev 2005;31:873–8.
process was applied to provide a high temperature strength to the core. [9] Callister WD. Materials science and engineering: an introduction. New York: Wiley;
As the coating numbers of the inorganic binder increased, the firing 1997.
[10] Gurav JL, Rao AV, Rao AP, Nadargi DY, Bhagat SD. Physical properties of sodium
strength was significantly improved, showing the highest firing strength silicate based silica aerogels prepared by single step sol–gel process dried at am-
of 13.8 ± 4.3 MPa for the core prepared by the SLS after dipping three bient pressure. J Alloys Compd 2009;476:397–402.
times because of the increase of the amount of glass phase on the [11] Anbia M, Lashgari M. Synthesis of amino-modified ordered mesoporous silica as a
new nano sorbent for the removal of chlorophenols from aqueous media. Chem Eng
particles. The higher strength of the core produced by the SLS compared
J 2009;150:555–60.
with that by the BJP is due to the coating efficiency of the inorganic [12] Xue W, Bandyopahyay A, Bose S. Mesoporous calcium silicate for controlled release
binder, resulting from the particle size of the starting material. In ad- of bovine serum albumin protein. Acta Biomater 2009;5:1686–96.
[13] Kim EH, Jung YG, Lee JH. Development of a new coating system for the high
dition, the lower thermal strain of 0.5 % and the CTE of 6.1 × 10–6/°C
functional mold in thin-wall casting. Mater Today: Proceedings 2014;1:55–69.
were obtained in the core by the SLS, which can ensure the shape [14] Erich K, Wolfgang L, Hermann G. The Color Change in CO2 Absorbents on drying:
stability of the core prepared using the SLS during casting. In the an in vitro study using moisture analysis. Anesthesia & Analgesi 2003;97:151–5.
castability test, the sample prepared by the SLS showed a better elution [15] Schulz GO, Milkovich R. Graft polymers with macromonomers. I. Synthesis from
methacrylate-terminated polystyrene. Applied Polymer 1982;27:4773–86.
property in a NaOH solution. In the casting of a real-type impeller blade [16] Callister WD. Applications, and processing of polymers, materials science and en-
using the core by the SLS, the product was successfully fabricated with a gineering. 8th edition 2020. p. 570–671.
100 % elution and with excellent dimensional accuracy. Consequently, [17] Hasegawa N, Okamoto H, Kawasumi M, Usuki A. Preparation and mechanical
properties of polystyrene-clay hybrids. J Appl Polym Sci Symp 1999;74:3359–64.
it is verified that the 3D printing technique combined with the orga- [18] Callister WD. Thermoplastic and thermosetting polymers, materials science and
nic–inorganic conversion process can be employed to fabricate the engineering. 8th edition 2020. p. 550–1.
ceramic core for casting various hollow-type mechanical components.

47

You might also like