Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/286937018
CITATION READS
1 1,231
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Developing a Comprehensive Methodology for Rural Road Investment Prioritization in Developing Countries View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Md Tanvir Hossain Shubho on 16 December 2015.
ISSN 2051-2945
Abstract: In city's smart roadway system, the effectiveness in accessibility of traffic to various part of the city is
heavily determined particularly by the traffic volume. Hence, traffic congestion in roads significantly impedes
the accessibility, resulting in declining livability. Evidently land use and traffic are inveterately interrelated;
thereby change in land use has deterministic impacts on traffic volume. An overly populous megacity Dhaka is
confronted with escalating traffic volume day by day. In addition, concomitant land use pattern surrounding its
roadways is also changing significantly. Careless unplanned development of land uses in Dhaka city has
resulted in perpetual traffic congestion along with pollution, thereby aggravating its sustainability. In this
context, this paper addresses the impact of land use change on the traffic volume of Dhaka city. We first
identified and quantified the land use and traffic volume change from 2007 to 2012 based on the study route.
Next, we conducted Geographic Information System (GIS)-based assessment on the impact of land use change
on traffic volume and traffic Peak Hour Factor (PHF). Land use and traffic volume data are collected by field
survey and from secondary sources. Analyses are done employing dedicated ArcGIS and spreadsheet tools. The
results show that from 2007 to 2012 the traffic volume in the study route increased on an average by 30.75%.
Furthermore, the PHFs are much lower in 2012 indicating more variation in traffic flow distribution. These
phenomena can be attributed to land use change around the vicinity of the study route where residential and
commercial use increased and mixed use decreased. The obtained results thus have an implication on increasing
Keywords: Livability; Land Use Change; Traffic Volume; Peak Hour Factor; Geographic Information System.
*
Corresponding author
Email address: mnnneema@yahoo.com (M. Neema)
Received September 5, 2013
1
2 M. T. H. SHUBHO, AND M. N. NEEMA
1. Introduction
Ease of traffic circulation is one of the rudiments of livable city. Fast and frequent local
transport in a city’s roadway system makes the city livable and efficient. Reversely traffic
congestion due to increased traffic volume encumbers the accessibility and makes the city
inefficacious. Moreover, increased traffic congestion accelerates air pollution which also
undermines livability [1, 2, 3]. The basic tenet ‘traffic is a function of land use’ [4, 5] clearly
indicates that there is a relationship between land use and traffic volume, recognizing that the
way land is used affects generation and character of traffic on the street and highway network
[6, 7]. However, slapdash development of land uses exacerbates traffic congestion and
integrate transportation planning with land-use planning decisions so that they are
complementary rather than contradictory [8]. Prodigious growth of traffic volume and its
concentration into some specific location are influenced by the surrounding land uses of the
roadways. For instance, increasing commercial activity in the vicinity of a roadway section
can be directly attributed to the morning rush-hour traffic congestion [9, 10, 11]. On the
contrary, rising residential units will induce more traffic flow towards them in the evening
peak [12]. Apart from this, development growth in varied land uses will both attract and
produce traffic in a great amount. On the other hand, roads, transit and other transportation
elements shape land development, while the distribution and types of land uses affect travel
patterns and transportation facilities. A dispersed pattern of low density development relies
almost exclusively on cars as the primary mode for transportation. Alternatively, denser
urban centers can combine different land uses in closer proximity encouraging varied modes
of transportation such as biking, public transit and other forms of travel [13]. Moreover, land
use change has impacts on peak hour factor. Therefore, in future traffic volume, travel pattern,
traffic congestion etc. will change in response to the change in land use.
The traffic volume of Dhaka city is increasing day by day along with the concomitant change
in surrounding land uses of its roadways [14, 15, 16, 17, 18]. There are many reasons for
IMPACT OF LAND USE CHANGE 3
traffic volume to increase such as population increase, increase in their income level and
standard of living and so on. However, since land use has a significant effect on traffic
volume, it can be inferred that haphazard land use development in Dhaka city is also
responsible for increasing traffic volume and declining livability. A number of studies have
been made abroad which examine the impacts of land use change on traffic [7, 19, 20]. But,
no such study has been performed yet to manifest the impact of land use change on traffic
volume in Dhaka city. In this backdrop, this research is an attempt to investigate the impact
of land use change on traffic volume and peak hour factor. The main objectives of the study
are to quantify land use change surrounding the study route over five years starting from
2007 to 2012, to determine the traffic volume of the study route in 2007 and 2012 and to
investigate the impact of land use change on traffic volume. This analysis will help to
understand the trip generation and attraction and associated land uses in the vicinity of the
roadway system of Dhaka city. From the trend analysis of increasing traffic volume, future
volume can also be predicted. Besides, better and enhanced information on the relationship
between land uses and traffic volume will help to make better decisions that can assist to
reduce traffic congestion, improve air quality, enable safer travel, and lower roadway
Dhaka city in respect of accommodating major bus routes, huge density of traffic and being
designated as an extremely busy corridor. It has a length of 5.76 kilometers. At its one end
there stands Motijheel, which is a Central Business District (CBD) of Dhaka city and at the
other stand there exists Farmgate. The study route within Dhaka City Corporation (DCC) is
shown by Fig 1(a). For the convenience of analysis the route has been divided into five
sections which are delineated by connecting major intersections. These sections are
Bangladesh Bank to Dainik Bangla, Dainik Bangla to Paltan, Paltan to Dhaka Bank Fountain,
Dhaka Bank Fountain to Shahbag and Shahbag to Farmgate. These sections are shown in Fig
4 M. T. H. SHUBHO, AND M. N. NEEMA
1(b). The study route runs through six roads namely Toyenbee Road (Bangladesh Bank to
Dainik Bangla), Purana Paltan Road (Dainik Bangla to Paltan), Topkhana Road (Paltan to
Dhaka Bank Fountain), Captain Monsur Ali Sharani (High Court to Matshya Bhaban),
Bashani Road (Matshya Bhaban to Shahbagh) and Kazi Nazrul Islam Road (Shahbagh to
Farmgate).
Both secondary and primary data have been collected to accomplish the study. Secondary
data such as digitized map of Dhaka city corporation (DCC) land use of 2007, existing roads
within DCC, google earth satellite image of 2013 and traffic volume data of 2007 have been
used in this study. Traffic volume data on 2007 have been collected from Transportation
Planning Workshop Report, 2007 [21]. Primary data includes the traffic volume and land use
data of 2012. Traffic volume data have been collected by volume survey. Method of manual
counting has been used to conduct the volume survey. The surveyor observed the volume of
traffic along a particular section. In this way, nearly all of the road sections of the selected
route were covered. While doing the volume survey, the surveyor standing at the intersection
counted the vehicles passing the intersection. To get the land use data of 2012, high
resolution google earth satellite image of 2013 has been used as results from field observation
show that there is no significant change in land use within just one year difference. Firstly,
the google satellite image has been projected to the UTM projection system. Then the newly
projected image has been projected to BTM projection system using “Geocentric
Translation”. Then the image has been inputted into ArcGIS to digitize the boundary of land
use of the 0.5 km buffer area. Since land use immediately surrounding a route has the most
influence on the traffic generation and attraction, land use distribution in the vicinity i.e. 0.5
km buffer area from the study route has been considered in the study.
IMPACT OF LAND USE CHANGE 5
(a) (b)
Figure 1. (a) Study route within DCC area; (b) Defined sections along study route
Overall and section wise traffic volume and land use data have been analyzed using ArcGIS
to investigate their relationship. To identify the impact of land use on traffic Peak Hour
Factor (PHF) eqn. 2 has been employed
where, PHF = Peak Hour Factor, V = Hourly Volume (Volume/hour), V15 = Volume during
the peak 15 minutes of the peak hour (Vehicle/15 min) [23]. PHF variation differs within a
site, from site to site along the route and from day to day as a result of the land uses in the
vicinity of the road system. Lower values of PHF signify greater variability of flow within the
subject hour. Higher values signify less flow variation. Greater variation in traffic flow
indicates development growth in variety of surrounding land uses of the road [19].
(a) (b)
Figure 2. Land use of 0.5 km buffer area around study route in the year (a) 2007 and (b) 2012
Residential units in 2012 around the study route have increased by more than half of the
amount in 2007 accounted for 60.94% as shown in Table 2. From Fig. 2 it is apparent that,
the mixed uses in 2007 have been converted into residential area. Rising residential uses have
peremptorily generated more traffic in 2012. The commercial developers and individuals
have built many residential buildings by demolishing existing mixed use buildings or in
vacant places. Most of the buildings are erected haphazardly and without maintaining set
back rules. Concurrently commercial activity has increased by 26.27% over the five years
which is also indicative of escalating traffic. Institutional uses have also increased by 34.33%
from 2007 to 2012. Commercial buildings are also built along the main road without
maintaining building bye-laws and sometimes encroaching the road. Both education and
research use and recreational use have increased by 5.71% and 3.58% respectively. Reversely,
mixed use and open space have been decreased by 37.08% and 10.46% respectively from
2007 to 2012. An inconsequential decrease has been noticed in restricted area accounted for
only 0.78%.
8 M. T. H. SHUBHO, AND M. N. NEEMA
(a) (b)
Figure 3. Area (%) of different types of land uses within 0.5 km buffer area of the study route
in the year (a) 2007 and (b) 2012
Table 2. Land use change around study route from 2007 to 2012
Increase or Increase or
Land Use Decrease in (%) Land Use Decrease in (%)
From 2007 to 2012 From 2007 to 2012
4.2 Impact of land use change on traffic volume from 2007 to 2012
From 2007 to 2012 traffic volume has increased significantly in both directions of the study
route as shown in Fig. 4. To understand the attributes of this increasing traffic volumes,
section wise analyses have been performed (Fig. 5). In Fig. 4, the highest increase in traffic
volume of 2012 is noticed in the section of Dhaka Bank Fountain to Shahbag which is of
more than double of the volume of 2007. This increase can be attributed to the increased
residential areas. Around this section, there was a very little residential use in 2007, whereas
in 2012 residential uses proliferated (Fig 5(d)). Besides, in the section Shahbag to Farmgate
traffic volume has been enumerated the highest. The reason is the rising commercial activity
IMPACT OF LAND USE CHANGE 9
and residential uses around this section, which attract more traffic in the morning and the
evening hour respectively as found during the traffic volume survey (Fig 5(e)). In rest of the
sections traffic volume has increased by half of the volume of 2007 (Fig 4(a)).
(a) (b)
Figure 4. Traffic volume of 2007 and 2012 in the direction of (a) Bangladesh Bank to
Farmgate and (b) Farmgate to Bangladesh Bank
Similar increase can be noticed in either direction from Farmgate to Bangladesh Bank as
shown in Fig 4(b). In the segment Farmgate to Shahbag, traffic volume increase is somewhat
insignificant; nevertheless the volume is highest of all. Increase of about 70% is noticed in
the section Dainik Bangla to Bangladesh Bank which is attributed to the increasing
residential units in the vicinity of section Bangladesh Bank to Dainik Bangla where Motijheel
CBD exits (Fig. 5(a)).
Land Use
Land Use
Land Use
Around the CBD, private developers are erecting buildings imprudently in order to attract
people in CBD. During the traffic volume survey it was found that the traffic volume was
highest in this direction at the evening peak hour as people were returning to their home.
10 M. T. H. SHUBHO, AND M. N. NEEMA
Moreover, the commercial activity has also increased which attracted more traffic at both the
morning and the evening in both directions.
In the sections Shahbag to Dhaka Bank Fountain and Paltan to Dainik Bangla, traffic volume
increased to almost one and half of the volume of 2007. In the vicinity of these sections
residential use has increased conspicuously from 2007 to 2012 as manifested by (Fig 5(b), (c)
and (d)). Commercial activity has also increased around these sections. Hence, it can be
inferred that if the traffic volumes continue to increase in this rate, the total traffic volume
will be 18645.94 PCU and 15753.74 PCU in Bangladesh Bank to Farmgate and opposite
direction respectively in 2017 as extrapolated by linear trend analysis (Fig 5(f)). Therefore
the foreseeable results such as increasing traffic jam, air pollution and increased noise level
will downscale the livability in the years ahead.
(a) (b)
Figure 6. PHF in 2007 and 2012 in the direction of (a) Bangladesh Bank to Farmgate and (b)
Farmgate to Bangladesh Bank
Fig 6(a) clearly demonstrates a greater PHFs values in 2007 than 2012 in the direction from
Bangladesh Bank to Farmgate. Therefore, it can be implied that there was a less variability of
flow throughout the study route in 2007. On the contrary, comparatively lower value of PHF
in 2012 indicates greater variation in flow. On an average a drop in the PHF factors in 2012
can be attributed to more traffic volume that is concentrated during a single 15 minute peak.
This scenario infers land development along the route. This land use change induces greater
variation in flow. From the figure another point is noticed that the PHFs are less stable in
2012 than these were in 2007 resulting in different peak flow associated with land use change.
In the direction from Farmgate to Bangladesh Bank similar scenario can be noticed. The
PHFs in 2012 are lower than the PHFs in 2007, as shown in Fig 6(b), which indicates greater
variation in traffic flow in study route in the year of 2012. This variation in turns indicates
development growth along the study route. However, the PHFs in 2012 also are fluctuating
for this direction which indicates development of varied land-use along the route in this
direction.
(CO), Carbon dioxide (CO2) and Particulate Matter (PM10) etc. are the main pollutants being
emitted daily from the dense congested traffic [24, 25]. Besides, heat generating from the
congested traffic intensifies suffocative condition for the passengers. All these consequences
indicate impeded efficiency of transportation in the study route and Dhaka’s all other
roadway system. The ultimate upshot is declined livability. This whole phenomenon can be
described by a flow chart shown in Fig 7.
Figure 7. Impact of land use change on traffic volume towards impeding livability
5. Conclusion
Patently a city’s livability is governed by its convenient and efficient transportation. However,
being a densely populous megacity, Dhaka is struggling to balance between accommodation
of billowing population and upkeep of its livability. Varied types of land uses are found in
this city each of which is unique and has its own propensity to generate trips. This research
examines the impact of land use change in increasing traffic volume thereby decreasing
livability. Analyses of the research divulge that traffic volume of study route in Dhaka city is
affected by its surrounding land use. Over the five years starting from 2007 to 2012,
residential uses in the vicinity of the study route have increased from 10% to 16% and the
mixed uses have decreased from 27% to 17%. Besides, the commercial activity has increased
by more than 2%. Concurrently, the overall traffic volume of the study route in the direction
from Bangladesh Bank to Farmgate has increased by 38%. In either direction, overall traffic
volume has increased by 23.5%. Besides, from the peak hour factor analysis, it is seen that in
both direction of the study route the PHFs are lower in 2012 than the value in 2007 indicating
IMPACT OF LAND USE CHANGE 13
greater variation in flow in 2012 which is a result of the land uses in the vicinity and traffic
conditions of the road. This increasing traffic volume is the main reason of congestion and
pollution in the study route. The more uncomforting verity is that, traffic situation is
analogous in the other primary routes of Dhaka city. Hence, it can be concluded that,
haphazard and uncontrolled land use development have worsened the traffic situation. Traffic
congestion is increasing and thereby bringing on air pollution, noise and heat problems.
These phenomena have a certain implication that the city’s livability is also declining bit by
bit.
Conflict of Interests
The author declares that there is no conflict of interests.
REFERENCES
[1] Vuchic VR. Transportation for Livable Cities. 1st ed. New Jersey: Edison; 1999
[2] Snyder D. Transportation for a Livable City. San Francisco CA; 2002, Retrieved July 2, 2013, URL:
http://livablecity.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/tlc_path.pdf.
[3] Gorham R. Air Pollution from Ground Transportation: An Assessment of Causes, Strategies and Tactics, and
Proposed Actions for the International Community. United Nations; 2002, Retrieved July 2, 2013, URL:
http://www.un.org/esa/gite/csd/gorham.pdf.
[4] Mitchell RB, Rapkin C. Urban Traffic: A Function of Land Use. Columbia University Press, New York;
1954.
[5] Hursta ME. Land Use and Traffic Generation in Urban Areas, with Particular Reference to Perth. Scottish
[6] Qi H, Wang W, Lu J. Study on the Relationship between Urban Land-Use and Traffic Generation with
[7] Oduwaye L, Alade W, Adekunle S. Land Use and Traffic Pattern along Lagos - Badagry Corridor, Lagos,
[8] Litman T. Land Use Impacts on Transport, How Land Use Factors Affect Travel Behaviour, Victoria
[9] Anaconda-Deer Lodge County Growth Policy Final – 2010, Retrieved July 2, 2013, URL:
14 M. T. H. SHUBHO, AND M. N. NEEMA
http://anacondadeerlodge.mt.gov/departments/planning/docs/BCC_Transportation_Element.pdf.
[10] Arnott R. A Bathtub Model of Downtown Traffic Congestion. University of California Riverside; 2012,
[11] NSW Department. Integrating Land Use and Transport, Improving Transport Choice - Guidelines for
Planning and Development. Urban Affairs and Planning; 2001, Retrieved July 4, 2013, URL:
http://www.planning.nsw.gov.au/programservices/pdf/prg_transport.pdf.
[12] Transport and Housing Bureau. Legislative Council Panel on Transport Subcommittee on Matters Relating
http://www.expressraillink.hk/pdf/en/dc/Paper1%20(ENG).pdf.
[13] Panel on The Transportation-Land Use Connection, Glades Road PD&E Study, Department of
http://www.gladesroadmobility.com/TransportationLandUseConnection.pdf.
[14] Ahmed S, Rahman M. Increase of Traffic Congestion and Private Cars in Dhaka through Planning against
http://fpd-bd.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Increase_Tra_fic_congestion_-Private-Car1.pdf.
[15] Ahsanl HM, Hoquel MM. Traffic Safety in Dhaka City: Key Issues and Countermeasures, Journal of Civil
[16] Siddique A, Iffat S. Effects of Traffic Demand Management in Reduction of Congestion in Dhaka City. 4th
Annual Paper Meet and 1st Civil Engineering Congress, Dhaka, Bangladesh; 2011, Retrieved July 9, 2013, URL:
www.iebconferences.info 3 .pdf.
[17] Habib KMN. Evaluation of Planning Options to alleviate Traffic Congestion and Resulting Air Pollution in
Dhaka City, Master Thesis, Department of Civil Engineering Bangladesh University of Engineering and
Technology; 2002.
[18] Department of Environment. Study on Bus Operation in Dhaka City. Final Report, Air Quality
[19] Phahlane MH, Salim RW, Ndambuki JM. Land Use Change Impact on Traffic Peak Hour Factor. 25th
ARRB Conference – Shaping the future: Linking policy, research and outcomes, Perth, Australia; 2012,
[20] Kuzmyak JR. Land Use and Traffic Congestion, Caliper Corporation Newton. Massachusetts and PolyTech
http://www.azdot.gov/TPD/ATRC/publications/project_reports/PDF/AZ618.pdf.
[21] A Report on an Assessment on Public Transportation System of Dhaka City: Case Study Route No. 12B
(Farmgate to Bangladesh bank). Transportation Planning Workshop, Department of Urban and Regional
[22] Kadiyali L. Traffic Engineering and Transport Planning, 7th ed, Delhi: Khanna publishers, India; 1978, pp.
517–19.
[23] Highway Capacity Manual 2000. Transportation Research Board, National Research Council, Retrieved
[24] Ahmmed KMT, Begum DA. Air Pollution Aspects of Dhaka City. Proc. of International Conference on
http://teacher.buet.ac.bd/tanvir/Air%20Pollution%20Aspects%20of%20Dhaka%20City.pdf.
[25] Karim MM. Status of Air Quality and State-of-art Control Measures in Dhaka, Bangladesh. 94 th Annual
Conference and Exhibition of Air and Waste Management Association, Orlando, Florida, USA; 2001, Retrieved