You are on page 1of 7

Applied Catalysis A: General 196 (2000) 225–231

n-Butane isomerization over H-mordenite: role of the


monomolecular mechanism
P. Cañizares ∗ , A. de Lucas, F. Dorado
Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Chemistry, University of Castilla-La Mancha, Campus Universitario s/n,
13004 Ciudad Real, Spain
Received 14 June 1999; received in revised form 20 October 1999; accepted 21 October 1999

Abstract
Isomerization of n-butane over several H-mordenite and Pd/H-mordenite samples with different Si/Al ratios is studied.
1,1,1,3,3,3-Hexamethyldisilazane was injected to obtain catalysts with poisoned external Brönsted acid sites. In the absence
of metal, isomerization activity was virtually suppressed for the poisoned non-dealuminated mordenite catalysts. However,
dealuminated samples were more resistant to the poisoning, and showed a higher selectivity to isobutane. For these samples,
the reaction order with respect to n-butane was close to 1 for isobutane and close to 2 for pentanes, and turnover frequency
(TOF) was not dependent on acid site density. No significant behaviour changes were observed for samples modified with Pd.
It is proposed that isomerization of n-butane over the dealuminated samples can take place via monomolecular mechanism.
©2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Mordenite; n-Butane isomerization; Bimolecular/monomolecular isomerization mechanism

1. Introduction C8 carbenium ions, by isomerization and ␤-scission,


yield n- and i-butane, and by disproportionation, yield
Skeletal isomerization of n-butane is thought to pro- propane and pentane [2].
ceed via bimolecular reaction route, involving the for- Since a large molecule (C8 carbenium ion) has to be
mation of C8 carbenium ions [1,2]. The first step is formed, isomerization of n-butane could be sterically
the formation of a butylcarbenium ion via (i) protona- inhibited in mordenite micropores [5,6]. In this way,
tion of butane by a Brönsted acid site and subsequent only those sites that are located outside the microp-
abstraction of H2 , (ii) hydride abstraction by a Lewis ore system of the zeolite will effectively contribute to
acid site, or (iii) protonation of trace olefins formed by the catalyst activity [7]. This is a consequence of the
thermal cracking [3,4]. Then, C8 + ions can be formed general principle that bimolecular encounters are ex-
either by reaction of the butylcarbenium with an olefin tremely unlikely in one-dimensional micropores [8].
forming an octylcarbenium ion or by reaction with As stated by Liu et al. [5], this fact may easily ex-
an alkane forming an octylcarbonium ion. Finally, the plain the striking difference in catalytic performance
for n-butane isomerization between Pt/ZrO2 –SO4 and
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +34-926-295300; Pt/H-mordenite catalysts, with roughly the same num-
fax: +34-926-295318. ber of acid and exposed Pt sites and similar acid
E-mail address: pcanizar@inqu-cr.uclm.es (P. Cañizares). strength of the Brönsted acid sites. Their pore geo-

0926-860X/00/$ – see front matter ©2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 2 6 - 8 6 0 X ( 9 9 ) 0 0 4 7 7 - 9
226 P. Cañizares et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 196 (2000) 225–231

metry is very different: mordenite has one-dimensional monium nitrate exchange and subsequent decomposi-
micropores, whereas Pt/ZrO2 –SO4 has a wide distri- tion under nitrogen at 510◦ C for 5 h. Depending on
bution of pore sizes. the dealumination level required, dealumination was
For C5+ hydrocarbons, it is admitted that iso- carried out by steaming at 400–600◦ C for 4–6 h, fol-
merization occurs via monomolecular mechanism. lowed by HCl treatment at 50–100◦ C for 4–24 h with
This different mechanism is related to the fact that a liquid/solid ratio of 15 ml/g. The HCl concentra-
monomolecular isomerization of n-butane would in- tion was 1–5 M. After filtration and rinsing, the re-
volve a very unstable primary carbenium ion as an sultant catalyst was dried at 120◦ C overnight. Metal
intermediate. free catalysts were then calcined under flowing air at
However, Garin et al. [9] reported that n-butane 500◦ C for 4 h. On the other hand, palladium loaded
isomerization could occur through a monomolecular catalysts were obtained after dealumination by ion ex-
mechanism over ZrO2 –SO4 based catalysts. More re- change with a palladium tetra-ammonium hydroxide
cently, Tran et al. [10] showed that the reaction or- solution. After drying the solid at 120◦ C for 14 h, it
der for n-butane isomerization over an H-mordenite was calcined in a flow reactor (0.7 cm height bed) un-
with a framework Si/Al ratio of 80 was close to 1 der the following conditions: weight of catalyst, 1 g;
(suggesting a monomolecular mechanism), whereas air flow-rate, 20 l/h; temperature increase from room
for an H-mordenite with a framework Si/Al ratio of temperature up to 180◦ C at 1◦ C/min, 1 h at 180◦ C;
6.6, it was close to 2. The greater significance of the increase in temperature at the same rate up to 450◦ C
monomolecular mechanism found for the more dealu- (which was maintained for 2 h), and finally, cooling
minated samples is related to their low acid site den- down to room temperature. These samples were re-
sity, and could also depend on the acid site strength. duced in situ at 400◦ C for 2 h before each experimental
The monomolecular mechanism could take place if run.
the catalyst had acid sites strong enough to catalyse Pore size distributions were determined by nitro-
this very difficult reaction. It is well known that, after gen adsorption at 77 K. The total acid site density
mordenite dealumination, the strength of the Brönsted of the catalysts was measured by temperature pro-
acid is increased. But at the same time, mesopores are grammed desorption of ammonia (TPDA). For the poi-
formed during dealumination, which might favour the soned samples, the signal due to the poison desorp-
bimolecular mode due to lower geometrical restric- tion was determined previously and subtracted from
tions. the TPDA profiles. The nature of the acid sites was de-
In this work, catalytic isomerization of n-butane termined by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) experi-
over several H-mordenite and Pd/H-mordenite sam- ments. No Lewis acid sites were observed by pyridine
ples with different Si/Al ratios is investigated chemisorption, as found previously by other workers
to clarify whether the monomolecular mecha- [10,11]. Thus, strong Brönsted acid site density can be
nism plays a significant role. The catalysts were drawn directly from the TPDA measurements. This is
tested both fresh and selectively poisoned with an important result, as FTIR experiments for the poi-
1,1,1,3,3,3-hexamethyldisilazane to suppress the ac- soned samples are difficult to carry out (the poison
tivity of those Brönsted acid sites that were not would be removed during the vacuum pretreatment
located in the micropore system. step). A detailed description of all these techniques is
given elsewhere [6,12]. Pd dispersion was measured
by volumetric hydrogen chemisorption, following the
method described by Kip et al. [13].
2. Experimental The most relevant characteristics of the catalysts
are given in Table 1. Catalysts have been identified
2.1. Catalysts preparation and characterization by a letter and a number. The letter refers whether
the catalyst is fresh (F) or poisoned (P). The num-
Non-dealuminated Na-mordenite was supplied by ber indicates the framework Si/Al ratio. If the cata-
PQ, with a framework Si/Al ratio of 5.5. Conversion lyst has been loaded with palladium, the symbol Pd is
to the protonated forms was carried out through am- added.
P. Cañizares et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 196 (2000) 225–231 227

Table 1
Characteristics of the mordenite samples
Sample Framework Si/Al Strong Brönsted acid BET surface area Pore volume (␮l/g)
ratio sites (mmol/g)a (m2 /g)
Mesopores (>10 Å)b Micropores (<10 Å)c

F-5.5 5.5 0.691 525 50 186


P-5.5 5.5 0.462 – – –
Pd/F-5.5d 5.5 0.693 499 50 180
Pd/P-5.5d 5.5 0.464 – – –
F-17 17 0.225 561 97 233
P-17 17 0.132 – – –
F-50 50 0.082 549 111 227
P-50 50 0.049 – – –
Pd/F-50d 50 0.082 538 115 220
Pd/P-50d 50 0.048 – – –
F-66 66 0.069 551 104 229
P-66 66 0.038 – – –
Pd/F-66d 66 0.073 555 103 233
Pd/P-66d 66 0.040 – – –
a NH3 desorbed above 350◦ C.
b Determined by the BJH method.
c Determined by the t-plot method.
d Pd content and Pd dispersion for all Pd-containing catalysts were 0.95 wt.% and 100%, respectively.

 
2.2. Catalyst activity measurements a0 (butane) − a(butane)
x(%) = 100
a0 (butane)
The experiments were carried out in a flow-type where a0 and a are inlet and outlet amounts of n-butane
apparatus designed for continuos operation. This (in mmol), respectively.
apparatus consisted of a gas feed system for each Selectivities to individual products are defined as
component nitrogen and n-butane (≥99.95% purity,  
significant impurities being isobutane (max 400 ppm) ap
S(%) = 100
and propane (max 100 ppm)) with individual control a0 (butane) − a(butane)
by mass flow meters, a fixed-bed downflow reactor,
where ap stands for the individual product.
and an exit gas flow meter. The reactor was a quartz
The yield of a product is given by the equation
tube with an internal diameter of 4 mm. The weight
 
hourly space velocity (WHSV) was selected between ap
0.5 and 12 h−1 to yield different initial conversion Y (%) = 100
a0 (butane)
levels, but always lower than 10%. Partial pressures
of N2 and n-butane were 0.9 and 0.1 bar, respectively. The rate of transformation of n-butane into an indi-
Catalysts were pretreated in situ as described above, vidual product is defined as the number of millimoles
and then cooled to reaction temperature (250◦ C) of n-butane transformed into that product per hour and
under nitrogen. In order to minimize the influ- per gram of catalyst.
ence of deactivation, short values of time-on-stream
were chosen (0.5–10 min depending on WHSV). 2.3. Poisoning experiments
Reaction gas products were analyzed on line by a
Hewlett-Packard gas chomatograph, using a fused For the poisoning experiments, 0.1 ml of 1,1,1,3,3,3-
silica PLOT Al2 O3 /KCl column and an FID detec- hexamethyldisilazane was evaporated into the re-
tor. Conversion and selectivities were obtained from action mixture stream. 5 min after injection, the
the product distribution. The n-butane conversion is catalyst activity was measured as described above.
defined as the ratio 1,1,1,3,3,3-Hexamethyldisilazane is a selective poison
228 P. Cañizares et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 196 (2000) 225–231

of Brönsted acid sites [14,15], mainly those sites that suppressed over P-5.5, and a relatively high selectivity
are located at the outer zeolite surface or in accessible to light paraffins is obtained. However, P-17, P-50 and
mesopores, as it is large enough to hardly enter the P-66 had a higher selectivity to isobutane than their
micropore channel system. The poison remains on the non-poisoned parent catalysts. Finally, pentanes were
surface and only above 450◦ C does it slowly desorb obtained in a very low quantity over the poisoned cat-
or decompose. Thus, catalysts were never treated at alysts.
temperatures higher than 450◦ C after being poisoned. With regard to the Pd-loaded catalysts, only mi-
nor changes were observed upon Pd incorporation. A
small increase in selectivity to isobutane and a corre-
3. Results and discussion sponding decrease in selectivity to propane and pen-
tane were the most significant changes in comparison
Table 2 shows the product selectivity of the samples with their non-Pd-containing palladium parent cata-
at approximately 8% conversion. It is remarkable that lysts.
product distribution was practically constant for con- The big change in product distribution between the
version values between 1 and 10%, not being affected non-dealuminated sample (F-5.5) and the dealumi-
by deactivation. nated zeolites (F-17, F-50 and F-66) has been re-
For the non-poisoned samples, n-butane was always ported previously and explained in two different ways.
mainly transformed into isobutane, propane and pen- Asuquo et al. [2] related the high disproportionation
tanes. A small quantity (≤4%) of methane and ethane selectivity for the non-dealuminated mordenite to its
was also obtained. Isomerization is the main reaction high density of Brönsted acid sites. However, Tran
over F-17, F-50 and F-66 catalysts, while dispropor- et al. considered this explanation to be unlikely [10].
tionation (formation of propane and pentanes) is the They pointed out that the theoretical acid density of a
main reaction over F-5.5. non-dealuminated mordenite is only about 1.5 times
For the poisoned samples, an abrupt change in prod- greater than that of a dealuminated mordenite with a
uct distribution is observed. Isomerization is virtually framework Si/Al ratio of 10, but a very different prod-

Table 2
Product selectivity for the mordenite catalystsa
Catalyst Selectivity (%)

CH4 C2 H6 + C2 H4 b C3 H8 + C3 H6 c i-C4 H10 C4 H8 d C5 H10 e,f


F-5.5 3.3 0.4 58.5 23.6 0.1 14.1
P-5.5 22.9 27.5 44.9 3.1 0.0 1.6
Pd/F-5.5 3.7 0.6 55.8 27.1 0.4 12.4
Pd/P-5.5 22.5 27.8 45.7 2.9 0.0 1.1
F-17 3.0 0.3 22.6 60.5 0.1 13.5
P-17 5.3 6.4 10.5 77.5 0.0 0.3
F-50 2.6 0.2 20.6 63.2 0.0 13.4
P-50 4.4 5.4 8.7 81.4 0.0 0.1
Pd/F-50 2.7 0.2 18.8 66.5 0.0 11.8
Pd/P-50 4.8 5.1 8.1 81.9 0.0 0.1
F-66 2.1 0.2 19.9 68.7 0.0 9.1
P-66 3.9 4.6 7.6 83.8 0.0 0.1
Pd/F-66 2.5 0.1 19.1 69.4 0.0 8.9
Pd/P-66 3.0 5.1 7.3 84.6 0.0 0.0
a Conversion ∼
= 8%.
b Ethane and propane were mainly obtained.
c Ethane and propane were mainly obtained.
d All isomers.
e n-C H + i-C H .
5 10 5 10
f Hexanes or higher were not obtained.
P. Cañizares et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 196 (2000) 225–231 229

uct distribution is obtained over these zeolites. They


associated the high disproportionation selectivity for
the non-dealuminated mordenite with the absence of
mesopores, and therefore, with the much longer diffu-
sion pathway for organic molecules. Thus, while the
reactant molecules diffuse through the channels, they
could undergo many successive intermolecular reac-
tions with a preferential formation of propane (butanes
and pentanes are very reactive compared to propane
and can be transformed into this product). Indeed,
mesopores are obtained in mordenites after dealumi-
nation [16–20], which could reduce the diffusional
limitations.
However, there is another interesting question to be
taken into account. It is well known that, after dea-
lumination, the strength of the Brönsted acid sites is
increased. This strengthening has been accounted for
from topological Al density [21], or using Monte Carlo
Fig. 1. Reaction order with respect to n-butane for i-C4 and C5
simulation [22], and by means of molecular orbital formation over P-17 catalyst.
calculation [23]. It could be thought that these stronger
Brönsted acid sites might stabilize the highly unstable
primary carbenium ions, thus allowing a monomolec- and P-66 samples via a monomolecular mechanism,
ular mode for n-butane isomerization. Therefore, we thus indicating that these mordenites certainly have
suggest that the higher selectivity to isobutane for very strong acid sites capable of catalyzing this very
dealuminated mordenites may be due not only to the difficult reaction.
presence of mesopores but also to a non-negligible To further confirm this conclusion, the reaction
contribution of the monomolecular mechanism (very order with respect to n-butane for the formation of i-
selective to isobutane) to that reaction. butane over P-17 was calculated by carrying out
The experiments with the poisoned samples seem n-butane transformation experiments under various
to confirm this hypothesis. Under inert gas atmo- n-butane pressures from 0.05 to 0.15 bar (Fig. 1). A
sphere, isomerization of n-butane via bimolecular reaction order of 1.17 was found, which certainly
mechanism could be expected to be favoured [10]. suggests a monomolecular mechanism. On the other
However, this mechanism may be sterically inhibited hand, the reaction order with respect to n-butane for
in mordenite micropores as commented above. In the formation of pentanes was of 1.9, which seems
that case, bimolecular mechanism would take place to be a reasonable result, as pentanes still have to be
mainly over the mordenite external surface and in formed through a bimolecular mechanism. It should
mesopores, whereas monomolecular mode might take be emphasized that both monomolecular and bi-
place inside the micropore system. After poisoning molecular mechanisms can co-exist, but we conclude
with 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexamethyldisilazane, those Brön- that, under especially favourable conditions (presence
sted acid centers that are located outside the zeolite of strong acid centers and absence of mesopores),
and in the mesopores are deactivated, but those cen- the monomolecular mode is more relevant than the
ters that are located in the micropore system remain bimolecular mechanism.
unaffected, as was reported in a previous work [7]. As On the other hand, as no isobutane is obtained over
pentanes were scarcely obtained after poisoning, it is the P-5.5 sample, it can be concluded that such very
concluded that the bimolecular pathway is virtually strong acid centers do not exist (or they are very
suppressed in the mordenite one-dimensional pore scarce) on that mordenite, which is consistent with
system, which is in agreement with previous works the next nearest neighbour (NNN) theory. This well
[5,6]. Hence, isobutane is formed over P-17, P-50 known theory predicts that the intrinsic acid strength of
230 P. Cañizares et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 196 (2000) 225–231

very dependent on the acid site density. Obviously, if


the external surface and the mesopore system are not
deactivated, the bimolecular mode can play a role,
and hence, this TOF increase is an expected result.
At this point, the importance of the mesopores on
the dealuminated samples should be remarked. As
there are no steric restrictions in the mesopores, the
bimolecular mechanism should be favoured. More-
over, it seems that the bimolecular mode is more
selective to isobutane if it takes place in the meso-
pores [10]. The presence or absence of mesopores in
mordenite-based catalysts is hence very important to
understand the catalytic performance of this zeolite,
as far as n-butane isomerization is concerned.
For the Pd-containing catalysts, no drastic changes
are observed. The products obtained over these cat-
alysts are similar to those over H-mordenite. Just a
Fig. 2. TOF vs. strong Brönsted acid site density over dealuminated slight increase in selectivity to isobutane and a de-
mordenites. crease in selectivity to propane and pentanes are ob-
served, which is in agreement with results reported
by Asuquo et al. [28]. According to these workers,
an acid site is dependent on the number of aluminium the metal, under inert atmosphere, does not induce
atoms in the next nearest neighbourhood [24]. The any major changes in the mechanistic pathway. This
O–H bond strength is thought to decrease (meaning is consistent with the fact that the acid properties of
an increase in the acid strength) until all NNN-atoms the samples are hardly influenced by the metal (Table
are silicon [25,26]. Barthomeuf calculated this critical 1). Furthermore, when TOF is plotted versus strong
framework Si/Al ratio for different zeolites, finding a Brönsted acid site density for the Pd-containing cat-
value of 9.4 for mordenite [21]. Therefore, the mini- alysts (Fig. 2), the trend is very close to their parent
mum framework Si/Al ratio to have acid centers strong catalysts, which strongly suggests that the presence of
enough to catalyze the monomolecular reaction would the metal does not involve any change in mechanism.
be of 9.4, which is in agreement with our results and We can now speculate about a conceptually good
with those obtained previously [7,10]. catalyst for n-butane isomerization based on mor-
Further evidence of the monomolecular mechanism denite. To favour a (selective) bimolecular mecha-
role over the dealuminated samples can be obtained nism, Brönsted acid site density should be as high
by plotting the turnover frequency (TOF) versus as possible, and the presence of mesopores would be
strong Brönsted acid site density (Fig. 2). It can be necessary. However, bimolecular mode is restricted
observed that TOF is practically independent of acid inside the micropore system, where there are many
site density for the poisoned samples, which strongly acid centers. Hence, the monomolecular mode should
suggests a monomolecular mechanism. Therefore, it be favoured simultaneously. Therefore, the Si/Al ra-
can be concluded that this mechanism is not negligible tio should be high enough to have a maximum acid
over dealuminated mordenites even under nitrogen. strength, and in consequence, to catalyze this very
Furthermore, this finding seems to confirm that the difficult reaction. Dealuminated mordenite with a
bimolecular mechanism is sterically impeded inside framework Si/Al ratio about 15 would then be a good
the mordenite micropore system. catalyst, and in fact, it has been found to have the
As found previously [10], TOF is increased with maximum activity with a high selectivity to isobutane
acid site density for the non-poisoned dealuminated [7,10].
samples. Bimolecular n-butane transformation, which The repeatedly observed low TOF and isobutane
requires at least two close acid sites [27], is clearly selectivity for non-dealuminated mordenite can be
P. Cañizares et al. / Applied Catalysis A: General 196 (2000) 225–231 231

easily explained in similar terms. Due to its weaker [4] M. Guisnet, N.S. Gnep, D. Aittaleb, Y.J. Dojomet, Appl.
acidity, it cannot catalyze the monomolecular mode. Catal. A: Gen. 87 (1992) 255.
Due to the absence of mesopores, the bimolecular [5] H. Liu, G.D. Lei, W.M.H. Sachtler, Appl. Catal. A: Gen. 137
(1996) 167.
mode is sterically restricted and is not selective to [6] P. Cañizares, A. de Lucas, F. Dorado, A. Duran, I. Asencio,
isobutane. Of course, ‘restricted’ does not mean ‘for- Appl. Catal. A: Gen. 169 (1998) 137.
bidden’. Some bimolecular intermediates may still be [7] P. Cañizares, A. de Lucas, F. Dorado, D. Pérez, Appl. Catal.
formed in the micropore system, so that isobutane A: Gen., in press.
and pentanes could be obtained. But, as no mesopores [8] R. Kopelman, Science (Washington) 241 (1988) 1620.
[9] F. Garin, L. Seyfried, P. Girard, G. Maire, A. Abdulsamad,
are present, while these molecules diffuse through J. Sommer, J. Catal. 151 (1995) 26.
the channels, they undergo intermolecular reactions [10] M.T. Tran, N.S. Gnep, G. Szabo, M. Guisnet, J. Catal. 174
with a preferential formation of propane, as explained (1998) 185.
above. [11] M. Guisnet, P. Ayrault, G. Datka, Polish J. Chem. 71 (1997)
1445.
[12] P. Cañizares, A. de Lucas, J.L. Valverde, F. Dorado, Ind. Eng.
4. Conclusions Chem. Res. 36 (1997) 4797.
[13] B.J. Kip, F.B.M. Duivenvoorden, D.C. Koningsberger, R.
Prins, J. Catal. 105 (1987) 26.
n-Butane isomerization over dealuminated mor- [14] A.J. Rosmalen, M.C.G. Hartman, J.C. Mol, J. Catal. 66 (1980)
denites can take place through both bimolecular and 112.
monomolecular mechanisms, even under nitrogen. [15] J. Houzvicka, V. Ponec, Appl. Catal. A: Gen. 145 (1996)
95.
Bimolecular mode is sterically inhibited in the mor-
[16] J. Scherzer, J.M. Bass, J. Catal. 28 (1973) 115.
denite one-dimensional micropore system. Therefore, [17] R. Dutartre, L.C. de Menorval, F. di Renzo, D. McQueen,
it is clearly favoured by the presence of mesopores, Microporous Mater. 6 (1996) 311.
having a higher selectivity to isobutane. Monomolec- [18] S. Moreno, G. Poncelet, Microporous Mater. 12 (1997) 197.
ular mode takes place when the framework Si/Al [19] I.V. Mishin, T.R. Brueva, G.I. Kapustin, Kinet. Catal. 38
(1997) 574.
ratio (related to the acid strength) is high enough to
[20] C.A. Henriques, J.L.F. Monteiro, P. Magnoux, M. Guisnet, J.
catalyze this very difficult reaction. Under nitrogen, Catal. 172 (1997) 436.
the presence of palladium has no influence on the [21] D. Barthomeuf, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 38 (1988) 177.
reaction mechanism. [22] T.D. Ding, P.C. Sun, Q.H. Jin, B.H. Li, J.Z. Wang, Zeolites
14 (1994) 61.
[23] T. Teraishi, Microporous Mater. 5 (1995) 233.
References [24] L.A. Pine, P.J. Maher, W.A.J. Wachter, J. Catal. 85 (1984)
2887.
[1] H. Krannila, W.O. Haag, B.C. Gates, J. Catal. 135 (1992) [25] W.J. Mortier, J. Catal. 55 (1978) 138.
115. [26] P.A. Jacobs, Catal. Rev. Sci. Eng. 24 (1982) 415.
[2] R.A. Asuquo, G. Eder-Mirth, J.A. Lercher, J. Catal. 155 [27] C. Bearez, F. Chevalier, M. Guisnet, React. Kinet. Catal. Lett.
(1995) 376. 22 (1983) 405.
[3] R. Shigeishi, A. Garforth, I. Harris, J. Dwyer, J. Catal. 130 [28] R.A. Asuquo, G. Eder-Mirth, K. Seshan, J.A.Z. Pieterse, J.A.
(1991) 423. Lercher, J. Catal. 168 (1997) 292.

You might also like