You are on page 1of 4

2018 IEEE 24th International Symposium for Design and Technology in Electronic Packaging (SIITME)

Design and Simulation of a Sixth Order Band-Pass


Gm-C Filter

Elena-Mirela Stetco, Ovidiu Aurel Pop, Alin Grama, Emilian Ceuca


Doris Csipkes Department of Electronics
Applied Electronics Faculty of Exact Sciences and Engineering
Faculty of Electronics, Telecommunications and “1 Decembrie 1918” University of Alba Iulia
Information Technology, Alba Iulia, Romania
Technical University of Cluj-Napoca, Romania
stetco_elena@yahoo.com

Abstract—This paper is focused on achieving high-frequency have intermediate frequencies narrowband, it is necessary to use
CMOS circuits for continuous-time filters used in the range of tens BPF filters in modern RF communication systems [3]. The BPFs
of megahertz, used in wireless systems. The implementation and can be both external and on-chip. In literature [4][8], the most
the performance of a 6th order differential band-pass filter using adopted filters are the on-chip filters because of their advantage
the Gm-C (transconductance – capacitor) topology are analyzed.
The Butterworth type of approximation is evaluated. The
of higher stability, very good capability, low power consumption
performances of the circuits are proved by using two basic and noise coupling diminution.
methods to build a high-order filter: one by cascading Tow- The research work is focused on designing a 6th order BPF
Thomas biquads sections and the second one by emulating a using two basic methods in building a high-order circuit. The
passive LC ladder filter. The accuracy of Gm-C filters design is first one is performed by cascading Tow-Thomas biquads
demonstrated by simulating all possible test scenarios. As a main sections, which has the advantage that it can lead to any
contribution, the design of the building blocks was made based on arbitrary transmission zeros but cause an unwanted high
the mathematical model. A comparison between the synthesis sensitivity to element parameter variation. The second method
methods has been performed. used passive LC ladder filter, which has on one hand low
Keywords—Wireless systems, Gm-C topology, Band-pass filter,
sensitivity to variation of element parameter, but on the other
CMOS technology hand only on the imaginary axis can achieve transmission zeros.
Also, the performances of the circuit are demonstrated by
I. INTRODUCTION evaluating the Butterworth type band-pass filter with 10MHz
The transoconductance- capacitor (Gm-C) stages are used in center frequency and 4MHz bandwidth.
the architecture of several continuous time circuits for II. GM-C FILTER STRUCTURES
processing analog signals such as filters or any other circuits as
oscillators. A considerable interest in using the Gm-C filters is Most of the continuous-time and discrete - time filters have
that these circuits offer a very good efficiency and low-power as main building block the integrator. A Gm-C integrator, as a
consumption (few milliwatts). Also, the domain in which they result of open – loop operation, has robust stability. In high-
can perform is around several hundreds of kilohertz to hundreds speed applications, this type of circuit has small load capacitors
of megahertz and the quality factor can be adjusted through the and a high transconductance value of transistors.
control of the output resistance. Real transconductor circuit have parasitic input and output
Compared with active RC filters, the advantage of Gm-C capacitances. For low-frequency applications, the values of
continuous time filters is the higher frequency performance [1]. parasitic capacitances must be used in calculus of the real
Widely discussed in high speed applications, such as RF/IF capacitor used in the filters. But for high – frequency
filter, wireless communications, digital videos, this type of applications, several MHz, in order to have the high values of
filters can be tuned with high precision. Technical specifications poles frequency, the value of the real capacitors must be
of the filters directly depend on the value of transconductors, smaller. Thus, knowing that the poles are expressed as Gm/C,
which can be continuously adjusted by the bias voltage and of the pole frequency can be increased by decreasing the
the capacitors values [2][4]. capacitances. Summarizing, real integrators have parasitic
The transmitter and receiver circuits of numerous wireless poles, usually a low -frequency pole that introduces a lead
systems uses the band-pass filters (BPF) to achieve the channel phase, and a high - frequency pole that introduces an excess
selection and to filter in the radio frequency (RF) and phase. Thus, parasitic capacitance can considerably influence
intermediate frequency area (IF). Furthermore, the aimed radio the overall capacity of the circuit. As a consequence of this, the
frequency signal is narrowband and due to the fact, that time constant of the integrator is sensitive to process and
superheterodyne receivers implemented for application also temperature variations [6][8].

978-1-5386-5577-1/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE 201 25-28 Oct 2018, Iași, Romania


2018 IEEE 24th International Symposium for Design and Technology in Electronic Packaging (SIITME)
The Gm-C integrator is characterized by three main The transfer function of the second order TT biquad with
structures: an input stage, which defines its transconductance, complex poles and zeros is frequently expressed in the
an output stage, which provides a high output impedance, called following form:
the folded cascode (FC) and at the output, a feedback circuit, as Gm 2 Gm1 ω
it can be shown in figure 1. s s 0 H0
VoutBP C1 Gm 2 Q (1)
H
= (s) = =
Vin G G G ω
s 2 + s m 2 + m 3 m 4 s 2 + s 0 + ω02
C1 C1C2 Q
Common In equation (1) ω0 is the frequency at which the gain of the
vin
Gm Folded Mode
vout filter peaks, H0 is the filter gain and Q is the quality factor. At
Core Cascode Voltage the center frequency, can be defined: the angular frequency,
Control 𝑓𝑓𝑐𝑐
𝜔𝜔𝑐𝑐 = 2𝜋𝜋𝑓𝑓𝑐𝑐 and the quality factor 𝑄𝑄𝐵𝐵𝐵𝐵 = 𝐵𝐵𝐵𝐵 .
Fig. 1. The integrator circuit.
In order to implement the proposed 6 order BPF, three
th

The input stage or the transconductor element is a fully biquad sections are described.
differential, linear voltage to current converter, implemented The calculation of parameters starts from normalized LP
with resistive degeneration [5]. Resistive degeneration poles: two complex-conjugated poles -a1n+-jb1n=-0.5+-j0.866
technology using MOS resistors is chosen to build up high and one real pole -a3n=-1. A pair of low-pass (LP) normed poles
linear transconductors cells [4][8]. will implement two band-pass (BP) biquads, having: ω0, q and
The second stage, called the folded cascode stage increases �𝐻𝐻0 characteristics.
the output resistance of the circuit, minimizing the phase errors The parameters of the first and second biquads are
at the unity gain frequency [5]. expressed in equations (2) to (4), and for the third section in
Asymmetrical or fully balanced transconductance equation (5).
amplifiers, in their output stages, are commonly exposed to
biasing problems, because they need an additional circuit to  
) ( a12n + b12n )
2
control the DC voltage level at high impedance node. =q1
1
8a2
(
 a2 + b2 + 4Q2 +
 1n 1n

BP
+ 8Q2 (b2 − a 2 ) + 16 Q4 
BP 1n 1n BP 

(2)
For that reason, but also to provide suitable polarization of 1n
the transistors at the output stage, it is necessary to use CMFB q12
circuit. In this way, this circuit sets and maintains the DC H 01
= (a2
1n + b12n ) (3)
component of the single ended output voltages, ensuring the QBP
2

correct biasing of the transistors in the output stage [5]. ωC  2a1n q1 a12n + b12n 1  ωC2
ω01 =  + − 2 ω02 = (4)
III. FILTER DESIGN 2  QBP QBP2
q1  ω01
Using the previously designed and simulated integrator, a QBP
Tow-Thomas biquad based Gm-C 6th order band-pass filter, ω0real = ωC qreal = . (5)
with 10MHz center frequency (fc) and 4MHz bandwidth (BW) a3 n
is implemented. During the design process two synthesis
methods are developed and analyzed. After denormalization in frequency and impedance, the
The first is based on cascading Tow-Thomas biquads parameters that describe the proposed filter are: ω01 =74.7MHz,
sections and the second one is using LC ladder passive ω02 =52.8MHz, q1 =5.075, H01= 2.03, ω0real =62.8MHz and
prototype filter [8]. qreal =4.66.
In order to design a filter of any order it is necessary only In time of the design process, the value of Gm is chosen at
to duplicate the first order or second order sections by 74µS. Knowing the expression of ω0 and Q, according to the
cascading. To implement the transfer function, the Tow- equations below, the values of the C1, C2 and Gm1 which
Thomas (TT) filter designed with gm cells (figure 2) was used describe each biquad section are obtained.
due to its advantages, simplicity and efficiency. Thus, for biquad 1, parameter values are given by the
voutBP equations (6), for biquad 2 of equations (7) and for biquad 3 of
equations (8).
Gm4
vin
Gm q1 G
C1 = C2 = m Gm1 = Gm H 01 (6)
Gm1 ω01 ω01q1
Gm2 Gm q1 G
C1 Gm3 voutLP C1 = C2 = m Gm1 = Gm H 01 (7)
ω02 ω02 q1
C2
Gm qreal Gm
C1 = C = G = Gm (8)
Fig. 2. TT Second order section.
ω0 real 2 ω0 real qreal m1

978-1-5386-5577-1/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE 202 25-28 Oct 2018, Iași, Romania


2018 IEEE 24th International Symposium for Design and Technology in Electronic Packaging (SIITME)
As a consequence, the longitudinal impedance Z2n (formed
To summarize, all the results obtained can be seen in table 1. by the capacitor C2n in series with the inductor L2n) and the
transverse Z2n-1 (capacitor C2n-1 in parallel with the inductor L2n-
TABLE I. TT SECOND ORDER SECTION PARAMETERS 1) can be implemented as in figure 5.
C1 C2 Gm1
Biquad 1 5.03pF 0.195pF 150µS Gm Gm
Biquad 2 7.11pF 0.267pF 150µS
Biquad 3 2.9pF 0.471pF 74µS

Another way to extract a transfer function of a filter of any Gm C2n Gm CL2n-1


order is achieved by using the LC ladder passive prototype CL2n C2n-1
filter. Generalized LC ladder topology can be shown in figure
3, where its element values for realizing the normalized 6th Fig. 5. a) Active impedance section, Z2n
order BP filter function are: R=1Ω, C1=1F, L2=2H, C3=1F. b) Active impedance section, Z2n-1

The performances of the filter are influenced by the non-


C2n L2n idealities of the transconductor, and the parasitic capacitances
produce a frequency deviation. After the design stage, in the
L2n-1 C2n-1 next point, the inductances are replaced with Gm-C active
structures, equivalent in function, which have the parasitic
capacitances CL1=0.47pF, CL2=5.9pF, CL3=0.47pF.
Fig. 3. Generalized LC passive filter
Knowing the value of the parasitic capacities, the value of
The ladder simulation technique has on one hand low the real capacities in the circuit are obtained by subtracting from
sensitivity to variation of element parameter, but on the other the ideal value, the parasitic capacitance value. Thus, the results
hand only on the imaginary axis can achieve transmission zeros. are: C1=2.94pF, C2=0.235pF, C3=2.94pF.
It can be implemented either with stare variable or by replacing At this point, two synthesis methods for a 6th order BPF,
the passive elements (inductors and resistors) with similar widely used in the literature, were analyzed, not taking into
structures made up with active elements [5][8]. account the approximation type of the filter.
The main step in designing a biquad is to replace the LC Using gyrator circuits, the structure of a biquad can be
reactive components with active circuits. observed in figure 6.
One of the most common technique used in literature CL1 CL3
[5][7][8], regarding the replacement of passive circuit elements
with structures built up with active elements is represented by
the gyrator circuit (figure 4). Another important idea behind this Gm Gm Gm Gm
paper is that the gyrators are used to implement transverse and
longitudinal impedances in the 6th order BPF in order to replace
inductors that would occupy large space on the chip. C1 C3
Vin
V Vout
I Gm
CL
Gm Gm

Gm
Fig. 4. The gyrator circuit
Gm Gm
Based on the circuitry that simulates the inductor behavior
using a capacitor as a reactive element, the circuit can transform
the capacitive character of impedance into inductive [7]. The
capacitor can be calculated according to the expression: CL2
V sC
Z in = = 2 = sLech ⇒ C = Lech Gm2 (9)
I Gm
The value of the transconductance Gm is chosen at 74µS. Gm Gm
After the denormalization in frequency and impedance, as with
the other synthesis method, the filter function parameters are C2
obtained as follows: L1=86uH, C1=2.94pF, L2=1.07mH, Fig. 6. Filter topology – active implementation.
C2=0.235pF, L3=86uH, C3=2.94pF.

978-1-5386-5577-1/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE 203 25-28 Oct 2018, Iași, Romania


2018 IEEE 24th International Symposium for Design and Technology in Electronic Packaging (SIITME)
IV. SIMULATIONS AND COMPARISON RESULTS
Therefore, the change of the synthesis method brings a
The techniques discussed and analyzed above have been
major advantage in the correct operation of the filter, because
used for design and implementation of a sixth order band-pass
the error that influences the optimal functionality of the circuit
filer, considering the Butterworth approximation with10MHz
in the case of the biquads cascade method is considerably
center frequency and 4MHz bandwidth.
reduced.
Regarding the biquads cascade synthesis method, the BPF
is implementing by cascading three second order TT sections V. CONCLUSIONS
(fig. 2). Using the same value for transconductance of all
In conclusion, the purpose of this paper in terms of
sections, Gm=74µS, the cutoff frequency of each structure is
implementation, analyze and demonstration of the functionality
established by determining the proper capacitor value. Always,
of a 6th order band-pass filter has been achieved. All design
in this method, the output of the Laplace filter is compared with
requirements, 10 MHz center frequency, 4MHz bandwidth and
the output of the filter implemented with Gm-C cells.
transconductance value at 74µS for the 6th order Butterworth
As it can be observed in figure 7, the simulation result shows
band-pass integrated filter using a biquad Gm-C structure have
a slightly frequency shifting of the output signal.
been respected.
40dB 90°
The performance of the proposed filter was demonstrated by
studying two synthesis methods. The simulation results show
20dB 0°
that the error occurring at the output of the implemented filter
0dB -90° with biquads cascade synthesis method is considerably reduced
V(out) by applying the state variables method.
-20dB -180°
Thus, because it ensures effective filtering features and it
-40dB -270° has low power consumption, the band-pass filters (BPF) can be
-60dB V(laplace) -360°
used to achieve the channel selection and to filter in the radio
frequency (RF) and intermediate frequency area (IF).
-80dB -450°

-100dB -540°
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This work was partially supported by a grant of the Romanian
-120dB -630°
National Authority for Scientific Research and Innovation,
-140dB -720° CNCS/CCCDI–UEFISCDI, project number PN-III-P2-2.1-
PED-2016-1608, 222PED/2017, within PNCDI III.
-160dB -810°
1MHz 10MHz 100MHz 1GHz
Frequency [Hz]
Fig. 7. Implementation using TT biquads sections.
REFERENCES

Changing the synthesis method, as expected, the results are [1] R. Arya, G. Souliotis, S. Vlassis, C. Psychalinos, “A 0.5V 3rd- order
greatly improved. In this case, to the state variable based Tunable gm-C Filter”, Radioengineering ,vol. 22, no. 1, april 2013.
method, the output of the LC scale compared to the one of the [2] S. Mondal, K.V. Srivastava, A. Biswas, “ A 600MHz, 6th Order, Highly
Linear Gm-C Bandpass Filter Design”, IEEE Asia Pacific Conference on
implemented circuit with active structures is almost identical. Circuits and Systems, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, 6-9 Dec, 2010.
[3] F.Kacar, Arsen A.M.Shakie, Y. Özcelep, “A 4th Order Differential Gm-C
0dB 180°
Band-Pass Filter Using Improved Floating Current Source”, Journal of
-10dB 90° Microelectronics, Electronic Components and Materials, 2014, Vol.44,
-20dB 0° No.2 , 137-141
V(out)
-30dB -90° [4] C.Duan, W.Li, “A 46MHz Biquad Gm-C High Q Bandpass Filter Design
-40dB -180° for Wireless Application”, Ninth IEEE International Conference on
-50dB -270° Dependable, Autonomic and Secure Computing, 2011
-60dB
V(passive)
-360° [5] S.Hintea et.al, „Reconfigurable Analog Circuits for Mobile
-70dB -450° Communicaions. Variable topology filters and design automation”, Cluj-
-80dB -540° Napoca, 2011
-90dB -630° [6] J.E. Kardontchik, „Introduction to The Design of Transconductor-
-100dB -720° Capacitor Filters”, Kluwer Academic Publishers,
-110dB -810° Boston/Dordrecht/London, 1992.
-120dB -900° [7] T.Bakken, J.Choma, Gyrator-Based Synthesis of Active On-Chip
-130dB -990° Inductances, Analog Integrated Circuits and Signal Processing, 34, 171–
-140dB -1080°
181, 2003
-150dB -1170° [8] D.Csipkes, “Circuite integrate analogice. Circuite fundamentale”, Casa
1MHz 10MHz 100MHz 1GHz Cartii de stiinta, Cluj-Napoca, 2007
Frequency [Hz]

Fig. 8. Implementation using state variable synthesis method.

978-1-5386-5577-1/18/$31.00 ©2018 IEEE 204 25-28 Oct 2018, Iași, Romania

You might also like