Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IMPACT
ASSESSMENT
For the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power Project-III (2x20 MW)
at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
FINAL REPORT
February 2015
PREFACE
Approved by : M. Janardhan
Signed :
The report has been prepared in line with the prescribed TORs issued vide letter No:
J-13012/30/2013-IA.I (T) dated 7th May 2014 of Ministry of Environment and Forests,
New Delhi.
This report has been prepared by Vimta Labs Limited with all reasonable skill, care
and diligence within the terms of the contract with the client, incorporating our
General Terms and Conditions of Business and taking account of the resources
devoted to it by agreement with the client.
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
________________________________________________________________
Chapter Title Page
________________________________________________________________
1.0 Introduction
1.1 Purpose of the report C1-1
1.2 Identification of the Project and Project Proponent C1-1
1.3 Brief Description of project C1-2
1.4 Importance to the Country & Region C1-3
1.5 Existing Project Clearance Details C1-8
1.6 Scope of the Study C1-8
1.7 Methodology of the Study C1-8
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
________________________________________________________________
Chapter Title Page
________________________________________________________________
5.0 Analysis of Alternative Site
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
________________________________________________________________
Chapter Title Page
________________________________________________________________
List of Annexures
Table of Contents
List of Figures
________________________________________________________________
Figure Title Page
________________________________________________________________
Table of Contents
List of Tables
Table of Contents
1.0 INTRODUCTION
This chapter describes the purpose of the report, identification of the proposed
project and brief description of nature, size and location of the project and
importance to the region and country. This chapter also describes the scope of
the study and details of regulatory scoping carried out as per Terms of Reference
(TOR) issued by Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), New Delhi.
1.1 Purpose of the Report
As per the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification dated 14th
September 2006 and its amendment thereafter, the proposed project falls under
‘Category B’ required clearance of State Environment Impact Assessment
Authority (SEIAA). Application for prior environmental clearance for the above
proposal was submitted to the MoEF and meetings were held for the proposed
project in MoEF on 13th -14th February, 2014 to determining Terms of Reference
(TOR) for the preparation of EIA/EMP report. The TOR conditions towards
proposed captive power plant received from MoEF, vide letter No.J-
13012/30/2013-IA.I (T) dated 7th May 2014. A copy of MoEF letter giving the
details of TOR and its compliance is given in Annexure-I.
EIA/EMP has been prepared and submitted to state PCB for conducting Public
Hearing and the meeting was held on 6th January 2015 at Rabindra Bhawan,
Shivaji Road, A-Zone, Durgapur, District Burdwan, West Bengal and public
concerns and comments are taken into consideration for preparing the final
EIA/EMP report. The public hearing details are incorporated in Chaper-7.
Accordingly, to obtain Environment Clearance (EC) from MoEF, this EIA report has
been prepared for assessing the environmental impacts due to the proposed
power plant.
1.2 Identification of Project and Project Proponent
NTPC Ltd formed a joint venture with SAIL on 50:50 basis in March, 2001 in the
name NTPC-SAIL Power Company Private Limited (NSPCL). NTPC-SAIL took over
captive power plant-II located at Durgapur Steel Plant (2X60 MW) and Rourkela
Steel Plant (2X60 MW) from SAIL.
NTPC Ltd formed another joint venture company with SAIL on 50:50 basis in
March, 2002 in the name of Bhilai Electric Supply Company (P) Ltd. (BESCL).
BESCL took over captive power plant-II located at Bhilai Steel Plant (2X30 MW +
1X14 MW BPTG) from SAIL. With effect from 11th September, 2006, BESCL was
amalgamated with NTPC-SAIL and all properties, licenses, permissions, debt,
liabilities etc. with respect to BESCL now rests in NTPC-SAIL.
The proposed coal based thermal power plant is located at Durgapur, Burdwan
district, West Bengal. The geographical co-ordinates of the proposed project for
Main Plant latitude 23º32’10.14” to 23º31’56.66’’Nand longitude 87º15’8.14” to
87º15’22.77” E and Ash Dyke latitude 23°32’47.65” to 23°32’36.75” N and
longitude 87°14’21.88’ to 87°14’37.92”.The present land use of proposed site is
industrial.
The details of environmental setting are given in Table-1.1. The index map,
study area map and google map of the proposed project are shown in Figure-
1.1, Figure-1.2 and Figure-1.3 respectively.
TABLE-1.1
DETAILS OF ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING
Ash Dyke
Sno Latitude Longitude
C 23°32’47.65’’N 87°14’21.88’E
D 23°32’36.75”N 87°14’37.92”E
Government of India decided to privatize the Power Sector in the year 1992 – 93
with the objective of capacity addition to fuel industrial growth. Though the
response from the Private Sector – Foreign as well as Indian – was huge, the
capacity addition by the private sector till 2009 was meager for various reasons.
In fact, in the last decade the capacity addition slowed down as neither the
private sector nor the electricity boards added adequate new capacity while
growth in demand was sustained. The Government of India took in view the
various reasons for lack of interest on the part of the private sector and after
discussions with various stake holders such as industrial consumers, farmers and
the power producers, revised the Electricity Act to promote the private
participation in power generation.
The all India region-wise forecast for electrical energy requirement and peak
demand scenario fare presented in Table-1.2.
TABLE-1.2
LONG TERM FORECAST OF POWER DEMAND
Plant Site
FIGURE-1.1
INDEX MAP
FIGURE-1.2
STUDY AREA MAP OF 10 KM RADIUS
FIGURE-1.3
GOOGLE MAP
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C1-6
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-1
Introduction
The economic growth of any country depends upon the availability and
consumption of energy. The level of development of a country is measured in
terms of per capita energy consumption. Presently India's per capita energy
consumption at 717 KWh/year (during 2007-08), which is less than that of other
developing countries like China (1891) and Malaysia (1000). The per capita
energy consumption of the developed countries are very much higher like United
States of America (13338), Sweden (16665) and Canada (18117).
Ministry of Power has estimated that by the year 2012, India’s peak demand
would be 152,746 MW with energy requirement of 975 Billion Unit (BU).
In order to meet the ever increasing gap in power demand and supply,
Government of India has widened the scope of private sector participation in
electricity generation by passing a resolution in October 1991 and allowing them
to set-up power plants. Moreover, the measures initiated through the Electricity
Act 2003 have further enhanced the opportunities to private participation in
power sector, especially in thermal power generation.
As per the TOR, 10 km around the proposed plant site is considered as study area
to carry out baseline environmental monitoring. The study area map is given in
Figure-1.2.The environmental attributes like ambient air quality, meteorological
parameters, water quality, soil characteristics, noise levels and ecology have been
monitored during 1st March 2014 to 31st May, 2014 covering pre monsoon season.
The monitoring frequency details are outlined in Table-1.3. The scope of study
broadly includes:
• To conduct literature review and to collect data relevant to the study area;
• Establishing the baseline environmental aspects in and around the proposed
project area;
• Identifying various existing pollution loads due to project activities;
• Predicting incremental levels of pollutants in the study area due to the
proposed operations;
• Evaluating the predicted impacts on various environmental attributes in the
study area by using scientifically developed and widely accepted
environmental impact assessment methodologies;
• To prepare an Environment Management Plan (EMP), outlining the measures
for improving the environmental quality.
1.7 Methodology of the Study
Reconnaissance survey was conducted by Vimta Labs Limited, Hyderabad and
officials of NTPC-SAIL and sampling locations were identified on the basis of:
Field studies have been conducted for a period of one season (non-monsoon)
from 1st March 2014 to 31st May 2014 representing pre monsoon season to
determine existing conditions of various environmental attributes. Environmental
legislation and applicable environmental standards are given in Annexure-III
and Annexure-IV.
TABLE-1.3
MONITORING FREQUENCY
The salient features of the power plant are given in Table-2.1. The existing plant
and proposed project area photographs are shown in Figure-2.1. The layout of
the plant site is given in Figure-2.2. The flow chart showing the process in power
plant is shown in Figure-2.3.
TABLE-2.1
SALIENT FEATURES OF PROPOSED POWER PLANT
FIGURE-2.1(A)
PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING EXISTING PLANT FACILITIES (2x60 MW)
FIGURE-2.1(B)
PROPOSED SITE PHOTOGRAPHS
N 20100
N 20000
N 19900
E 8100
E 8200
E 8300
E 8400
E 8500
E 8600
E 8700
E 8800
E 8900
N 19800
N 19700
N 19600
21
N 19500
E 7200
E 7300
E 7400
E 7500
E 7600
E 7700
E 7800
E 7900
E 8000
N 19400
ARY 28
N 19300 BOUND
DSP
FIGURE-2.2
N 19200
0
149.0
11
N 19100 20
N 198120.00
E
9
4
5 8 N 19461.00
14 26
2 3 6
1 27
N 19000 E 9462.00
13 30
7
25
19
19 17 12
15
18
16 29
N 18800
0
896.0
N 1878 8.00 N 19002.00
N 18700 E 2 E 8173.00
N 18600
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
C2-4
Chapter-2
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project Description
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District
Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-2
Project Description
FIGURE-2.3
PROCESS FLOW CPP
During Phase-II expansion the 3rd TA of 20 MW will be installed along with 3rd
boiler and other auxiliaries. After the installation of 3rd unit the total Category-I
and Emergency power demand will be met by new Power Plant and during shut
down of one machine the demand will be approximately 44.0 MW and will be met
by the remaining two units with necessary load shedding and switching.
Present generation turbine with high efficiency has been envisaged. Turbine will
be condensing type.
Each boiler will be provided with 2 x 60 % capacity forced draught (FD) fans, 2 x
60 % capacity Primary Air (PA) fans and 2 x 60 % capacity Induced Draught (ID)
fans. A common chimney will be provided for two boilers. The second chimney
will be provided for the third boiler with a provision for connection for future
fourth boiler. Chimney will be 75 m height.
• Turbines will be condensing type. Turbine casing will be equipped with lifting
lugs, jack screws for convenience of disassembly and alignment.
• The rotor of the machine will be of solid construction. Blading will be of robust
construction for strength and reliability and longer service life. The profile will
be designed to have the best efficiency for the specified performance.
The system will comprise of pumps, cooling tower, valves, piping, dosing unit,
maintenance hoist etc. The underground pipelines will be encased with RCC.
Make-up water will be tapped from the plant existing network. The total make-up
water requirement of 300 m3/h will be drawn from power plant-II network and
will be distributed to cooling tower and other applications. Cooling tower blow
down will be used in Ash slurry pump house for slurry preparation, gardening and
other miscellaneous purposes. As no storage for raw water has been envisaged
for Phase-I and Phase-II. The minimum will be kept in Phase-III.
• Suitable pretreatment facility with dosing and clarification has been envisaged
to take care the water quality from PP-III to meet the requirement of cooling
water system make-up and service water. Raw water will be directly taken to
ash pump house for ash slurry preparation as required.
• DM water requirement of approximately 6 m3/h will be met from existing PP-
II. Two transfer pumps (1w+1s) each of capacity 40 m3/h and 80 MLC head,
two nos. DN 100 MS rubber lined pipes with 1 no. 150 m3 DM water storage
tank, DM water transfer pumps (1w+1s), one pump for boiler initial filling etc.
have been envisaged.
2.3.5 Compressed Air system
The system will be comprised of air compressors, air driers, air receiver, valves,
piping, dosing unit, maintenance crane etc. 2 nos. (1s+1s) Air compressors will
be supplying instrument air as well as service air requirement of the total plant.
Each compressor will be 10 Nm3/min and 8 kgf/cm2g discharge pressure has been
envisaged.
With installation of 2-nos. boilers each of 100 TPH capacity for 2 x 20 MW Power
Plant, the plant will generate approximately 14 TPH considering 40% ash content
in coal.
Bed Ash Disposal System
• The bed ash generation will be approximately 2.8 TPH. Bed ash shall be
collected from the bottom of boilers and stored in bed ash storage bunkers.
Bed ash disposal have been envisaged through slurry mode. 2 nos. (1W+1S)
high pressure water pumps have been envisaged for supplying water to bed
ash storage bunkers. Bed ash will be mixed with water in the storage bunkers
and sent to bed ash slurry sump through channels.
• From the slurry sump, 2 streams (1W+1S) of slurry pumps have been
envisaged for pumping the slurry to the ash slurry pond.
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C2-7
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-2
Project Description
• The generated fly ash will be collected at the bottom of Economiser, APH and
ESPs. The fly ash will be approximately 11.2 TPH.
• The off-take of dry fly ash from RCC silo will be done by the various outside
consumers through rotary feeder and telescopic chute to closed trucks placed
below the silo. Fly ash in wet form will be disposed through rotary feeder and
pug mill to open trucks/dumpers placed below the silo. Nominal water supply
has been envisaged for ash wetting in pug mill. NTPC-SAIL has MOUs with 10
companies to lift the fly ash generated given in Annexure-V.
• In case the generated fly ash is more than the off-take, excess ash will be
sent in slurry form (approximately 35% by weight) to existing ash pond no.1.
• The pumps envisaged for Bed ash system will also be used for fly ash system.
• The Fly Ash slurry will be pumped through the same DN150 pipeline used for
bed ash slurry pumping. There will be 2 (1W+1S) DN 150 pipelines.
• Cooling tower blow down will be used in Ash slurry pump house for slurry
preparation for both bed ash and fly ash.
A new Coal Handling Plant (CHP) has been envisaged for transportation of coal
from existing coal storage yard for proposed 2 x 20 MW Power Plant. The existing
coal yard will be utilised for storage of coal.
Light Diesel Oil (LDO) will be used as secondary fuel for start-up and coal flame
stabilization during low load operation of the steam generator while firing coal.
TABLE-2.3
TYPICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF LIGHT DIESEL OIL (LDO)
2.5.2 Transportation
Coal receipt from existing coal stack area of DSP through conveyors for the
proposed captive power project.
2.5.3 Water Requirement
The total fresh water allocation for the power plant is 400 m3/hr. This water will
be drawn from the Waria reservoir of DSP. However by adopting water
conservation measures requirement been optimized to 300 m3/hr. The water
balance of existing and proposed power plant is shown in Figure-2.4. The water
allocation letter is enclosed as Annexure-VIII.
TABLE-2.5(A)
WATER REQUIREMENT (EXISTING)
Units Existing
Ash Slurry 500 m3/hr
Cooling tower evaporation 125 m3/hr
Drain from DM and Main Plant 12.5 m3/hr
Unaccounted loss 29.0 m3/hr
Total 666.5 m3/hr
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C2-9
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-2
Project Description
TABLE-2.5(B)
WATER REQUIREMENT (PROPOSED)
Units Proposed
Evap and Drift loss in CTs 205 m3/hr
Loss in ventilation system 20 m3/hr
Potable water system 04 m3/hr
Evap loss in Ash dyke 15 m3/hr
Loss in service water system 20 m3/hr
Loss in Central Monitoring Basin 36 m3/hr
Total 300 m3/hr
2.5.5 Manpower
The proposed power plant will require skilled and semi-skilled personal during
construction and operational phase. Many of the people from neighboring villages,
as found suitable will get opportunity for employment during construction and
operational phase. The total manpower required for the new power plant will be
around 70 nos (Executive 35 and Nonexecutive 35).
The basic amenities for the labour force during construction and operation phase
are proposed. The facilities comprises of the following;
• Separate shelters will be provided for male and female labours for resting;
• Separate wash rooms (sanitary facilities)will be provided for male and female
labours;
• The contractors will be directed to provide fuel to labours for cooking;
• The first aid facilities will be made available; and
• Drinking water will be provided.
2.6 Utilities
In the proposed plant, various utilities will be provided for the smooth and
efficient functioning of the plant. The proposed utilities are discussed in
subsequent sections.
2.6.1 Fire Detection and Alarm System
well as cabling from nearest exchange / junction box will be inclusive in the
scope.
Transformer rooms will have natural ventilation through wire mesh gate at one
side and louvers at other side.
• The room will be fitted with wall mounted heavy duty tube axial fan with wall
cowl, bird screen, panel type washable air filter, grills, gravity louvers, etc.
The Transformer Room will be fitted with wall mounted heavy duty tube axial fans
with wall cowls bird screen, etc.
The system consists of storage, pumping station, sprinkler and piping manifolds
etc.
The fuel from the authorized oil dealers will be transported through road tankers.
Unloading pumps with hoses shall be used for unloading. LDO will be stored in
three tank of 10 KL capacity.
The various types of pollution from the proposed power plant are categorized
under the following types:
• Air pollution;
• Water pollution;
• Solid waste; and
• Noise pollution.
FIGURE-2.4(A)
EXISTING WATER BALANCE DIAGRAM
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C2-12
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District
Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-2
Project Description
FIGURE-2.4(B)
WATER BALANCE DIAGRAM
The major pollutants emitting from the power plant will be SO2, NOx and
particulate matter. Proper control measures will be installed by project authorities
to minimize the stack emissions within the stipulated/permissible limits prescribed
by National Ambient Air Quality Standards. Effluents will be generated from
cooling tower blow down, wash water and wastewater from sanitary facilities.
Sanitary effluent will be treated in sewage treatment plant. The effluents from
auxiliary cooling tower blow down, boiler blow down, DM plant blow down, etc.
will be suitably treated in RO plant for recycle/reuse within the plant.
2.7.1.1 Stack Emissions
• Particulate Matter
Suspended Particulate Matter (PM) will be one of the important pollutants from the
proposed power plant. To limit the particulate matter emissions below 50
mg/Nm3, a high efficiency (99.9%) electrostatic precipitator will be installed.
• Sulphur Dioxide
• Oxides of Nitrogen
To reduce the NOx emissions from the steam generator, all provisions in the
steam generator design and fuel firing system, will be made. Maximum NOx
emission from the unit will not be more than 50 mg/Nm3 of NOx including thermal
NOx produced during the entire operating range of steam generator.
The details of stack emissions given in Table-2.6. However, NTPC-SAIL will
implement the various air pollution control measures to reduce the air emissions.
• ESP with 99.9% efficiency will be installed to limit the emissions of particulate
matter to less than 50 mg/Nm3;
• Dust suppression systems and dust extraction system will be practiced; and
• Regular monitoring of the air pollution control system.
TABLE-2.6
STACK DETAILS AND EMISSION RATES
Blow down from cooling towers will be the main sources of the wastewater.
Besides this, domestic waste from canteen and toilets will be generated in the
plant. The wastewater from different sections will be treated in settling
pond/neutralizing pit/ETP and the treated water will be reuse/recycled in the
plant process ash handling and greenbelt development. No rejects from RO plant
will be generated in Power Plant-III. The wastewater generated in the proposed
project is given in Table-2.7.
TABLE-2.7
WASTEWATER GENERATION AND TREATMENT/DISPOSAL
Ash is the main solid waste generated in the coal based thermal power plant. The
primary fuel for the proposed captive power plant would be coal from Ramnagar,
having an ash content of about 40% (max). Considering this, about 1,20,000 TPA
ash will be generated. In that 98,000 TPA of fly ash and 24,000 TPA bottom ash
will be generated.
The bottom ash will be utilized for road laying flooring within the plant. Major
portion of the ash will be utilized by supplying to potential users. Efforts will be
made to utilize 100% fly ash as per the Fly Ash Notification, 1999 and as
amended thereafter
The ash which is not lifted by the potential users will be disposed off in the ash
dyke using conventional slurry disposal method. The ash pond will be provided
with trenches to collect the storm water during rainy days. Greenbelt will be
provided enveloping the ash pond to arrest the fugitive dust emissions. Ash pond
will also be provided with impervious liner to prevent leaching of contaminants to
groundwater.
3.1 Introduction
This chapter illustrates the description of the existing environmental status of the
study area with reference to the prominent environmental attributes. The study
area covers 10 km radius area from the boundary of the plant site. The existing
environmental setting is considered to adjudge the baseline environmental
conditions, which are described with respect to climate, hydro-geological aspects,
atmospheric conditions, water quality, soil quality, ecology, land use and socio-
economic profiles for 10 km radius.
EIA Notification requires that 10 km radius area surrounding the project site shall
be covered under the study and the same is denoted as study area. As part of the
study, description of biological environment and human environment such as
environmental settings, demography & socio-economics, land-use/ land cover,
ecology & biodiversity have been carried out for entire 10 km radius. However, as
a universally accepted methodology of EIA studies, physical environmental
attributes such as ambient air quality, water quality, soil quality, noise levels,
physiography, hydrology, solid waste generation have been studied at selective
locations representing various land uses such as industrial, rural/ residential,
commercial and sensitive locations including the densely populated areas,
agricultural lands, forest lands and other ecologically sensitive areas, if any falling
within 10 km radius study area.
The baseline studies are carried out for three months, covering partly pre
monsoon season, 2014 (1st March 2014 to 31st May 2014) in the various domains
of environment. This report incorporates the baseline data monitored during
study period and secondary data collected from various Government and Semi-
Government organizations.
3.2.1 Physiography
The predominant physical features over major part of the study area is the rolling
and flat plan topography with substantial part under resent flood plains. The
topography of the project site is plain with elevation 75 m above Mean Sea Level.
The area is characterised by hat and humid climate. It receives adequate rainfall
from southwest monsoon which sets in the latter half of June and withdraws in
mid of October. The normal annual rainfall indicates that average rainfall is
1191.1 mm.
3.2.2 Drainage
Damodar River running west to southeast 1.3 km southwest of the plant site is
the major steam in the area. Damodar River is a river flowing across the Indian
states of West Bengal and Jharkhand. Rich in mineral resources, the valley is
home to large-scale mining and industrial activity. Earlier known as the Sorrow of
Bengal because of its ravaging floods in the plains of West Bengal, the Damodar
and its tributaries have been somewhat tamed with the construction of several
dams. It has a number of tributaries and sub-tributaries, such as Barakar, Konar,
Bokaro, Haharo, Jamunia, Ghari, Guaia, Khadia and Bhera.
The drainage in the study area is mainly Damodar river and its tributaries. The
secondary tributaries are Talma, Choupai, Barajuri and and Barjor. There are no
streams or rivers passing through the proposed project area.
The Drainage map of the study area is shown in Figure-3.2.1.
23° 23°
35' 35'
Ta
m
la
N
Chouphai N
Da
m
od 10 Km
ar
R ive
r
Barajuri N
23° 23°
30' 30'
aN
jor
Ba r
SCALE
1 0 1 2 Km
FIGURE-3.2.1
DRAINAGE MAP OF THE STUDY AREA
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C3-3
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-3
Baseline Environmental Status
The master slope of the district is from west to east and southeast with the land
having the highest altitude at the extreme western corner of approx. 150 m msl
to about 10 m near Kalna at the eastern border of the district. Laterite and red
soil in the western part of the district and Vindhyan and Gangetic alluvium in rest
of the area observed. The district remarkably presents the entire geological
succession from Archaean to recent. The western part of the district comprising
the Raniganj coalfield is underlain by the Gondwana sedimentary rocks and
contains valuable coal deposits. The central part and eastern part of the district
are underlain by alluvial formations.
3.2.5 Hydrogeology
FIGURE-3.2.2
HYDROGEOLOGICAL MAP OF THE STUDY AREA
As per the CGWB report of Burdwan District. In the major part of the district,
ground water in thick unconsolidated Quaternaries and Tertiaries deposited under
fluviatile environment, the sand and/or gravel in different proportions of this
formation constitute the main aquifer and they occur down to 295 m bgl in the
central and eastern part of the district. Deeper aquifers occur under semi-
confined to confined condition.
Study area comes under Durgapur-Faridpur block. As per the CGWB report of
Burdwan District. Ground Water occurs in the block Semi-confined to Confined
conditions. Occurrence of aquifers in general, in the depth span of 12.00-38.00 m
bgl, 31.00-55.00 m bgl and 70.00-88.00 m bgl.
As per the CGWB report of Burdwan District. The depth to water level in pre-
monsoon period (2006) varies from 1.43 to 19.03 m bgl whereas that to post-
monsoon it is from 1.03 to 31.00 m bgl.
The long term water level monitoring data of CGWB observation well data at
Burdwan and Bankura in the study area indicate a marginal declining trend (0.5
m) of average ground water levels. Water level data of CGWB monitoring wells
between 2005 & 2013 and the well hydrograph are presented in Table-3.2.1 and
Figure-3.2.3 respectively.
TABLE-3.2.1
LONG TERM WATER LEVELS OF CGWB
MONITORING WELLS IN STUDY AREA
FIGURE-3.2.3
WELL HYDROGRAPH OF CGWB MONITORING WELLS
As per the CGWB report of Burdwan District. Tube wells in the Central and
eastern part constructed tapping both semi-confined and confined aquifers are
characterized generally medium duty (50-150 m3/hr) to heavy duty (>150 m3/hr)
yield with nominal drawdown of 4-5 m. Transmissivity (T) values rages from
30.77-17.00 m2/day and the storativity ranges from 2.0 x 10-4 to 188 x 10-4. The
aquifers of Gondwana sedimentories and archaean metamorphics show T values
ranging from 40 to 50 m2/day and storativity value is about 14x10-4.
TABLE-3.2.2
THE DYNAMIC GROUNDWATER RESOURCES
OF BURDWAN DISTRICT AS ON 31.03.2009
TABLE-3.2.3
THE DYNAMIC GROUNDWATER RESOURCES OF
DURGAPUR-FARIDPUR BLOCK AS ON 31.03.2004
Ground water balance in respect of the study area has been estimated and
indicated in Table 3.2.4. As per the GEC 1997 norms, areas where ground water
resource assessment shows stage of ground water development 70% or lower,
and there is no significant long term decline of pre or post-monsoon ground water
levels are categorized as “Safe”. The stage of ground water development in the
study area is 23.64% and that in Durgapur-Faridapur block as per CGWB district
profile is 8.03%. Since the water requirement of the existing and proposed NSPCL
project is met from surface water drawn from Waria reservoir, there will be no
impact on ground water in the area.
TABLE-3.2.4
THE DYNAMIC GROUNDWATER RESOURCES OF STUDY AREA
Quantity
Sr. No. Particulars
(MCM)
I Gross groundwater recharge 83.30
ii Natural discharge to drain and other losses – 10% of (i) 8.33
Iii Net groundwater availability (i-ii) 74.97
iv Annual groundwater draft for all uses 17.72
v Groundwater balance (iii-iv) 57.25
vi Water requirement for proposed expansion 0.00
Vii Balance of groundwater left for development 57.25
viii Present stage of groundwater development in study area 23.64
Present stage of groundwater development in Durgapur-Faridapur 8.03
iX
block as per CGWB District Profile (Safe)
Stage of ground water development including use for proposed
X 23.64
project
Damodar River running west to southeast 1.20 km southwest of the plant site is
the major river in the study area. Damodar River is a river flowing across the
Indian states of West Bengal and Jharkhand. Earlier known as “Sorrow of Bengal”
because of its ravaging floods in the plains of West Bengal, the Damodar and its
tributaries have been somewhat controlled with the construction of several dams.
As per the flood hazard map published based on SOI (Survey of India) flood atlas
and CWC (Central Water Commission) task force report, the plant area is not
liable to floods. Flood hazard map is shown in Figure-3.2.4.
FIGURE-3.2.4
FLOOD HAZARD MAP
3.2.11 Cyclones
The coastal stretch of West Bengal is necessarily highly vulnerable to cyclone. The
phenomenal storm surge in coastal West Bengal is due to it peculiar bathymetry
and nature of coastal belt. The northern part of Bay of Bengal is very shallow. The
coast is also landlocked on three sides. As a result when a very severe cyclonic
storm or a hurricane approaches the coast, the enormous storm surge generated
by the wind pressure submerges the coastal belt at the time of the storm crossing
the belt. The frequency of storms crossing this belt is also high.
West Bengal has two cyclonic seasons – pre-monsoon and post-monsoon cyclone
during April-May and Nov-Dec respectively. Pre-monsoon cyclone, which causes
wide spread hailstorm and it is traditionally called in the state as Kalibaishaki.
Paschim Medinipur, Purba Medinipur, South 24 Paraganas, North 24 Paraganas,
Howrah, Hooghly, part of Nadia, Burdwan and Bankura are located in very high
damage risk zone (V=50m/s) with respect to cyclone, where as a major part of
Nadia, Burdwan, Bankura, Murshidabad, Malda, Uttar and Dakshin Dinajpur,
Jalpaiguir, Cooch Behar, Darjeeling, part of Purulia encounter with high damage
risk zone (V=47m/s). Wind and cyclone hazard map is shown in Figure-3.2.5.
FIGURE-3.2.5
WIND AND CYCLONE HAZARD MAP
Studies on land use aspects of eco-system play important roles for identifying
sensitive issues, if any, and taking appropriate actions for maintaining the
ecological balance in the development of the region.
3.3.1 Objectives
3.3.2 Methodology
For the study of land use, literature review of various secondary sources such as
District Census Handbooks, regional maps regarding topography, zoning
settlement, industry, forest etc., were taken. The data was collected from various
sources like District Census Handbook, Revenue records, state and central
government offices and Survey of India (SOI) Top sheets and also through
primary field surveys.
Based on the census report, 10-km radial distance around this Plant Centre has
been considered in the study. These areas were studied in detail to get the idea
of land use pattern in the study area. The land use census data 2011 is not
available and the land use pattern of the study area as per 2001 Census is
presented in Table-3.3.1. The village wise land use data is presented in
Annexure-IX.
TABLE-3.3.1
LAND USE PATTERN IN THE STUDY AREA
• Forest
The revenue forest land under the study area consists 954 ha (2.88%) of the
total geographic area.
• Cultivable Waste
This land includes that land, which was cultivated sometime back and left vacant
during the past 5 years in succession. Such lands may either be fallows or
covered with shrubs, which are not put to any use. Lands under thatching grass,
bamboo bushes, other grooves useful for fuel etc., and all grazing lands and
village common lands are also included in this category. The study area
comprises about 4.83% cultivable wastelands.
The land not available for cultivation is 13.07% of the total study area, which
includes area of land with scrub, land without scrub, quarry, mining area, rocky/
stony and barren area.
• Urban Area
The Urban area under the study area consists 14545 ha (43.87%) of the total
geographic area.
Present land use based on remote sensing satellite imageries were collected and
interpreted for the 10 km radius study area for analyzing the land use pattern of
the study area. Based on the satellite data, land use/ land cover maps have been
prepared.
The present land use / land cover maps were prepared based on the classification
system of National standards. For explanation for each of the land use category
the details as given in Table-3.3.2 are considered.
TABLE-3.3.2
LAND USE/LAND COVER CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM
Data Requirements
IRS Resourcesat 2 L4FMX was acquired for 24th February 2012 and was used for
the mapping and interpretation. Besides, other collateral data as available in the
form of maps, charts, census records, other reports and especially topographical
survey of India maps are used. In addition to this, ground truth survey was also
conducted to verify and confirm the ground features.
Methodology
The methodology adopted for preparation of land use/land cover thematic map is
monoscopic visual interpretation of geocoded scenes of IRS Resourcesat 2 L4FMX
and field observations are taken. The various steps involved in the study are
preparatory field work, field survey and post field work.
The False Color Composite (FCC) of IRS Resourcesat 2 L4FMX satellite data used
for pre-field interpretation work. Taking the help of topo-sheets, geology and
geomorphology and by using the image elements the features are identified and
delineated the boundaries roughly. Each feature is identified on image by their
image elements like tone, texture, colour, shape, size, pattern and association. A
tentative legend in terms of land cover and land use, physiography and erosion
was formulated. The sample areas for field check are selected covering all the
physiographic, land use/land cover feature cum image characteristics.
Both toposheets and imagery were taken for field verification and a transverse
plan using existing road network was made to cover as many representative
sample areas as possible to observe the broad landuse features and to adjust the
sample areas according to field conditions. Detailed field observations and
investigations were carried out and noted the landuse features on the imagery.
The base maps of the study area were prepared, with the help of Survey of India
Topo-sheets. Preliminary interpreted land use and the land cover features
boundaries from IRS Resourcesat 2 L4FMX (5 m resolution) False Colour
Composite were modified in light of field information and the final thematic details
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C3-13
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-3
Baseline Environmental Status
were transferred onto the base maps. The final interpreted and classified thematic
map was catrographed. The cartographic map was coloured with standard colour
coding and detailed description of feature with standard symbols. All the classes
noted and marked by the standard legend on the map.
Final Output
The final output would be the landuse/land cover map and numerals were given
different colour code for each category as shown in map. Area estimation of all
features of Land use/Land cover categories was noted. The thematic map and
land use pattern is shown in Figure-3.3.1 and Figure-3.3.2. The details of the
land use in 10 km radial study area are given in Table-3.3.3.
TABLE 3.3.3
LAND USE BREAK UP OF THE STUDY AREA
Area Percentage
Sr. No. Land Use
(Hectares) (%)
Built-up Land/Other Development
1 Settlements 7462 22.06
2 Industry/Institutional Land 3567 10.56
3 Layout/New Development 83 0.24
4 Airstrip/Airport 188 0.56
Forest
5 Dense/Open Forest 83 0.25
6 Degraded Scrub Land 69 0.21
7 Forest Blanks 7 0.02
Agricultural land
8 Plantation 87 0.26
9 Irrigated/Double Crop 1904 5.60
10 Single Crop 10291 30.46
11 Fallow Land 1150 3.41
Waste Land
12 Land with Scrub 2280 6.75
13 Land without Scrub 740 2.19
14 Rocky/Stony/Barren Land 259 0.77
15 Quary/Mining/Dumping Land 319 0.94
16 Grass Land/Water Logged 308 0.91
Water Body
17 Stream/River 1373 4.07
18 Dry River 2107 6.24
19 Tank/Pond/Reservoir 1510 4.47
Total 33787 100.00
Observations
• Built-up-land: The total build-up-land constitutes 33.42 % of total study area.
• Forest Land : 0.48 % of land is occupied by forest land
• Agricultural land: The major part of the study are is occupied by agricultural
land which constitutes about 39.73 % of the total area of 13432 ha.
• Waste Land : 11.56 % of land is waste land
• Water Body: 14.78 % of land is covered by water body.
FIGURE-3.3.1
SATELLITE IMAGERY
FIGURE-3.3.2
LAND USE MAP
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C3-16
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-3
Baseline Environmental Status
It is essential to determine the potential of soil in the area and identify the
impacts of industrialization on soil quality. Accordingly, a study of assessment of
the soil quality has been carried out.
For studying soil profile of the region, sampling locations were selected to assess
the existing soil conditions in and around the plant site area representing various
land use conditions. The physical, chemical and heavy metal concentrations were
determined. The samples were collected by ramming a core-cutter into the soil up
to a depth of 90 cm. A total of five samples within the study area were collected
and analyzed. The details of the soil sampling locations are given in Table-3.4.1
and are shown in Figure-3.4.1. The sampling has been carried out once in the
study period.
TABLE-3.4.1
DETAILS OF SOIL SAMPLING LOCATIONS
The soil quality at all the locations during the study period is given in
Table-3.4.2. The results are compared with standard classification given in
Table-3.4.3.
3.4.2 Baseline Soil Status
It has been observed that the texture of soil is mostly sandy clay in the study
area. It has been observed that the pH of the soil quality ranged from 7.5 to 8.2
indicating that the soil is slightly alkaline to moderately alkaline in nature.
The electrical conductivity was observed to be in the range of 168 to 250 µS/cm,
with minimum (168 µS/cm) observed at S1 and with the maximum 250 µS/cm
observed at S5 during the study period.
Phosphorus and nitrogen contents are in the range of 62.9 kg/ha to 126.5 kg/ha
and 54.6 kg/ha to 98.6 kg/ha.
TABLE 3.4.2
SOIL ANALYSIS RESULTS
Sr. No. Location UOM S1 S2 S3 S4 S5
1 pH -- 7.6 7.9 8.0 7.5 8.2
2 Conductivity µs/cm 168.0 182.0 175.0 210.0 250.0
3 Texture -- Sandy Sandy Sandy Sandy Sandy
Clay Clay Clay Clay Clay
4 Sand % 35 40 36 42 42
5 Silt % 27 22 24 18 23
6 Clay % 38 38 40 40 35
7 Bulk Density g/cc 1.0 1.1 1.1 1.2 1.2
8 Exchangeable Calcium as Ca mg/kg 1450 1510 1650 1850 2030
9 Exchangeable Magnesium as Mg mg/kg 180 210 350 250 280
10 Exchangeable Sodium as Na mg/kg 160 180 190 250 300
11 Available Potassium as K Kg/ha 224.8 289.9 306.9 372.0 465.0
12 Available Phosphorous Kg/ha 62.9 69.2 83.5 90.5 126.5
13 Available Nitrogen as N Kg/ha 55.8 54.6 58.0 63.2 98.6
14 Organic Matter % 2.05 2.27 2.06 5.15 6.99
15 Water soluble chloride as Cl mg/kg 212.7 248.2 283.6 319.1 460.9
16 Water soluble sulphates as SO4 mg/kg 158.0 167.8 172.3 256.3 296.6
17 Sodium Absorption Ratio mg/kg 0.47 0.51 0.50 0.65 0.74
18 Aluminium % 1.80 1.86 1.95 2.0 2.3
19 Total iron % 1.02 1.03 1.09 1.52 1.82
20 Manganese mg/kg 380.0 360.0 400.2 406.8 480.0
21 Boron mg/kg 35.0 40.0 42.0 52.4 60.8
22 Zinc mg/kg 78.0 82.0 76.0 86.0 98.6
23 Organic Carbon % 1.19 1.32 1.20 2.98 4.06
TABLE-3.4.3
STANDARD SOIL CLASSIFICATION
FIGURE-3.4.1
SOIL SAMPLING LOCATIONS
3.5 Meteorology
The meteorological data recorded during the monitoring period is very useful for
proper interpretation of the baseline information as well as for input prediction
models for air quality dispersion. Historical data on meteorological parameters will
also play an important role in identifying the general meteorological regime of the
region.
Secondary data from IMD-Bankura has been collected for pressure, temperature,
relative humidity, rainfall, evaporation, wind speed and direction. The data at IMD
is usually measured twice a day viz., at 0830 and 1730 hr.
The meteorological data is collected from the IMD-Bankura which is the nearest
operating IMD station to the project site area. The data collected from IMD
station includes wind speed, wind direction (recorded in sixteen directions),
temperature, relative humidity, atmospheric pressure and rainfall over a period of
10 years. The monthly maximum, minimum and average values are collected for
all the parameters except wind speed and direction. The collected data is
tabulated in Table-3.5.1.
TABLE-3.5.1
CLIMATOLOGICAL DATA-STATION: IMD, (1999-2012)
08:30 Hours:
Predominant winds from south direction were observed for 7.0 % of the total
time, with wind speeds (with % frequencies) in the range of 0.5-1.0 kmph
(2.4%), 1-1.5 kmph (2.7%), 1.5-4.5 kmph (1.8%), 4.5-7.0 kmph (0.1%) and
7.0-25.0 kmph (0.0%). In the NE direction winds were observed for 5.4% of the
total time, with wind speeds and frequencies in the range of 0.5-1.0 kmph
(2.6%), 1-1.5 kmph (1.7%), 1.5-4.5 kmph (1.0%), 4.5-7.0 kmph (0.1%) and
7.0-25.0 kmph (0.0%). Whereas in E direction the winds were observed for 3.8%
of the total time with wind speeds and frequencies in the range of 0.5-1.0 kmph
(1.0%), 1-1.5 kmph (1.9%), 1.5-4.5 kmph (0.9%) and 4.5-25.0 kmph (0.0%).
17:30 Hours:
Predominant winds from S direction were observed for 7.6% of the total time,
with wind speeds (with % frequencies) in the range of 0.5-1.0 kmph (2.4%), 1-
1.5 kmph (2.6%), 1.5-4.5 kmph (2.6%) and 4.5-25.0 kmph (0.0%). In the E
direction winds were observed for 5.9% of the total time, with wind speeds and
frequencies in the range of 0.5-1.0 kmph (1.6%), 1-1.5 kmph (2.8%), 1.5-4.5
kmph (1.5%) and 4.5-25.0 kmph (0.0%). Whereas in SE direction the winds were
observed for 5.5% of the total time with wind speeds and frequencies in the
range of 0.5-1.0 kmph (1.6%), 1-1.5 kmph (2.2%), 1.5-4.5 kmph (1.7%) and
4.5-25.0 kmph (0.0%).
Primary data from project area has been collected for temperature, relative
humidity, rainfall, and atmospheric pressure.
3.5.2.1 Methodology
TABLE-3.5.2
SUMMARY OF THE METEOROLOGICAL DATA GENERATED AT SITE
The windrose for the study period is shown in Figure-3.5.3 and presented in
Table-3.5.3.
TABLE-3.5.3
SUMMARY OF WIND PATTERN AT THE STUDY AREA
Predominant winds from S direction were observed for 8.4% of the total time. In
the E direction winds were observed for 5.0% of the total time. Whereas, in SE
direction the winds were observed for 4.0% of the total time. In other directions,
the percentage frequencies observed were W (3.7%), SSW (2.7%), WNW
(2.5%), NE (2.4%), SSE (2.2%), NW (1.7%), N, NNE & ESE (1.6%), SW (1.4%),
NNW (1.2%), ENE (1.1%) and WSW (1.0%). Calm conditions prevailed for 57.9%
of the time.
The India Meteorological Department (IMD) records the data twice a day viz. 0830
hr and 1730 hr while the site-specific data has been recorded at an hourly interval.
On comparison of site specific data generated for study period vis-à-vis the IMD
data, slight variations were observed. The following observations are brought out:
• The predominant wind direction observed at the proposed project during the
study period were S for 8.4 % of the total time and followed by E direction for
5.0 % of the total time, whereas the predominant wind direction and wind
speed as recorded by IMD, Bankura during the Pre-Monsoon season are S and
E followed by SE;
• The temperature recorded on site when compared vis-à-vis the IMD data, slight
variations was found. The mean maximum and mean minimum temperatures
recorded at site during study period were 44.4oC and 19.3oC, whereas the
maximum and minimum values recorded at IMD-Bankura during the same
period are 36.3oC and 23.2oC respectively;
• The Relative Humidity was observed to range from 18.7-69.2% during the
study period at the site, whereas according to IMD-Bankura, the Relative
Humidity was observed to be in the range of 65% during the same season.
The data generated at proposed project site when compared with the data recorded
at IMD, it is observed that the data generated at the site is broadly in comparison
with regional meteorology, except for minor variations as described above. The
variation can be attributed to the topographical changes, elevation differences and
also could be due to distance between project site and IMD station.
FIGURE-3.5.1
ANNUAL WIND ROSE AT 08.30 HRS (IMD-BANKURA)
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C3-25
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-3
Baseline Environmental Status
FIGURE-3.5.2
ANNUAL WIND ROSE AT 17.30 HRS (IMD-BANKURA)
.6%
NN
N 1.6%
W
E1
4%
N
1.2
W
NN
2.
1.
WN
E
%
W
N
7
%
2.5 %
% E 1.1
EN
W 3.7% C-57.9% E 5.0%
% ES
1.0 E1
W .6%
WS
4%
1.
SS
SE
%
SW
E2
2.7
4.
0%
.2%
W
SS
S 8.4%
SCALE 5%
SPEED CALM
1.0 5 11 19 >19
FIGURE-3.5.3
SITE SPECIFIC WINDROSE (PRE-MONSOON 2014)
The ambient air quality with respect to the study zone of 10 km radius around the
plant site forms the baseline information. The prime objective of the baseline air
quality study was to assess the existing air quality of the area. This will also be
useful for assessing the conformity to standards of the ambient air quality during
the plant site operations. The study area represents mostly rural/residential
environment.
This section describes the selection of sampling locations, methodology adopted for
sampling, analytical techniques and frequency of sampling.
The baseline status of the ambient air quality has been assessed through a
scientifically designed ambient air quality-monitoring network. The design of
monitoring network in the air quality surveillance program has been based on the
following considerations:
Ambient Air Quality Monitoring (AAQM) stations were set up at four locations with
due consideration to the above mentioned points. Table-3.6.1 gives the details of
environmental setting around each monitoring station. The locations of the selected
stations with reference to the proposed plant site are given in the same table and
shown in Figure-3.6.1.
Ambient air quality monitoring was carried out at a frequency of two days per
week at each location. The baseline data of air environment was monitored for
parameters mentioned below as per revised MoEF notification dated 18th
November 2009:
TABLE-3.6.1
DETAILS OF AMBIENT AIR QUALITY MONITORING
Station Code Name of the Station Distance (km) Direction
Plant Site
AAQ1 Plant site -- --
AAQ2 Near DSP Main Gate-1 2.2 N
AAQ3 Faridpur 3.3 E
AAQ4 Pursha 1.1 S
Duration of Sampling
The sampling duration for PM10, PM2.5, SO2 and NO2 were twenty-four hourly
continuous samples per day and CO, O3 as sampled for 8 hrs continuous thrice a
day. This is to allow a comparison with the present revised standards mentioned in
the latest Gazette Notification of the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB)
(November 18, 2009).
Dust Samplers of Pollutech instruments were used for monitoring PM10 (<10
microns), PM2.5 and gaseous pollutants like SO2 and NO2. Glass tubes were
deployed for collection of grab samples of carbon monoxide. Gas Chromatography
techniques have been used for the estimation of CO.
Methods adapted for air quality analysis with its detection limits are given in Table-
3.6.2.
TABLE-3.6.2
SAMPLING AND ANALYTICAL METHODS
& DETECTION LIMIT FOR AMBIENT AIR QUALITY PARAMETERS
.6%
NN
N 1.6%
W
E1
4%
N
1.2
W
NN
2.
1.
WN
E
%
W
N
7%
2.5 .1%
% E1
EN
W 3.7% C-57.9% E 5.0%
% ESE
1.0 1.6
W
WS %
4%
1.
SS
SE
%
SW
E2
2.7
4.
0%
.2
W
%
SS
S 8.4%
FIGURE-3.6.1 SCALE 5%
1.0 5 11 19 >19
TABLE-3.6.3
SUMMARY OF AMBIENT AIR QUALITY RESULTS
The minimum and maximum concentrations for SPM were recorded as 93.5 µg/m3
and 168.2 µg/m3 respectively. The minimum concentration was recorded at
Faridpur village (AAQ3) and the maximum concentration was recorded at Near DSP
Main Gate (AAQ2).
The minimum and maximum concentrations for PM10 were recorded as 48.1 µg/m3
and 80.4 µg/m3 respectively. The minimum concentration was recorded at Faridpur
village (AAQ3) and the maximum concentration was recorded at Near DSP Main
Gate (AAQ2). All the results are found to be high when compared to the standard
limit of 100 µg/m3 as per latest NAAQS 2009.
The minimum and maximum concentrations for PM2.5 were recorded as 21.3
µg/m3 and 43.8 µg/m3 respectively. The minimum concentration was recorded at
Faridpur village (AAQ3) and the maximum concentration was recorded at Near DSP
Main Gate (AAQ2). All the results are found to be high when compared to the
standard limit of 60 µg/m3 as per latest NAAQS 2009.
The minimum and maximum SO2 concentrations were recorded as 10.6 µg/m3 and
26.3 µg/m3. The minimum concentration was recorded at Faridpur village (AAQ3)
and the maximum concentration was recorded at Near DSP Main Gate (AAQ2). All
the results are found to be low when compared to the standard limit of 80 µg/m3 as
per latest NAAQS 2009.
• Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2)
The minimum concentration of 15.7 µg/m3 for NOx was recorded at Faridpur village
(AAQ3) and maximum of 36.1 µg/m3 at Near DSP Main Gate (AAQ2). All the results
are found to be low when compared to the standard limit of 80 µg/m3 as per latest
NAAQS 2009.
• Ozone (O3)
The minimum and maximum O3 concentrations were recorded as 5.0 µg/m3 and
17.5 µg/m3.
• Lead (Pb)
• Ammonia (NH3)
• Benzene (C6H6)
• Arsenic (As)
• Nickel (Ni)
The information required has been collected through primary surveys and
secondary sources.
Two groundwater and three surface water sources covering 10 km radial distance
were examined for physico-chemical, heavy metals and bacteriological parameters.
The samples were collected and analysed once during the study period. The
samples were analyzed as per the procedures specified in 'Standard Methods for
Water samples were collected from two ground water and three surface water
sampling locations. These samples were taken as grab samples and were analyzed
for various parameters to compare with the standards. The water sampling
locations are listed below in Table-3.7.1 and are shown in Figure-3.7.1. The
results of monitoring carried out for the study are presented in Table-3.7.2.
TABLE-3.7.1
DETAILS OF WATER SAMPLING LOCATIONS
The results for the ground water samples analysed are presented in
Table-3.7.2(A) and are compared with the IS-10500 standards. The pH of the
water samples collected ranges between 7.5 to 7.6. The conductivity recorded in
between 555 to 665 µs/cm in the sample. The chlorides and sulphate
concentrations varied in between 100 to 123 mg/l and 18.5 to 19.0 mg/l
respectively.
The results for the surface water samples analysed are presented in
Table-3.7.2(B) and are compared with the IS-10500 standards. The pH of the
water samples collected ranges between 7.3 to 7.5. The conductivity recorded in
between 283 to 407.0 µs/cm in the sample. The chlorides and sulphate
concentrations varied in between 51.5 to 75.8 mg/l and 14.5 to 17.0 mg/l
respectively. The heavy metal concentrations in ground and surface water quality
are well within the limits as per IS-10500.
TABLE-3.7.2(A)
GROUND WATER QUALITY
TABLE-3.7.2(B)
SURFACE WATER QUALITY
FIGURE-3.7.1
WATER SAMPLING LOCATIONS
• The time of day at which noise occurs, for example high noise levels at night in
residential areas are not acceptable because of sleep disturbance; and
• The location of the noise source, with respect to noise sensitive landuse, which
determines the loudness and period of exposure.
The environmental impact of noise can have several effects varying from Noise
Induced Hearing Loss (NIHL) to annoyance depending on loudness of noise. The
environmental impact assessment of noise from the plant site operations,
developmental activity, and vehicular traffic can be undertaken by taking into
consideration various factors like potential damage to hearing, physiological
responses, and annoyance and general community responses.
The main objective of noise monitoring in the study area is to establish the baseline
noise levels and assess the impact of the total noise generated by the plant site
operations around it.
The noise monitoring has been conducted for determination of noise levels ten
locations in the study area. The noise levels at each location were recorded for 24
hours. The environment setting of each noise monitoring location is given in Table-
3.8.1 and shown in Figure-3.8.1.
FIGURE-3.8.1
NOISE MONITORING LOCATIONS
TABLE-3.8.1
DETAILS OF NOISE MONITORING LOCATIONS
Sound Pressure Level (SPL) measurements were measured at all locations. The
readings were taken for every hour for 24 hours. The day noise levels have been
monitored during 8 am to 8 pm and night levels during 8 pm to 8 am at all the
locations covered in 10 km radius of the study area. These results are tabulated in
Table-3.8.2.
TABLE-3.8.2
NOISE LEVELS IN THE STUDY AREA
The statistical analysis is done for measured noise levels at ten locations during
pre-monsoon season. The parameters are analyzed for Lday, Lnight, and Ldn.
The day time noise levels at all the locations ranged from 43.8 dB(A) to 51.2 with
the maximum recorded at Plant site (N1), and the minimum at Angadpur (N6).
The night time noise levels ranged from 40.9 dB (A) to 48.0 dB (A), with the
maximum value recorded at Plant site (N1) and the minimum at Angadpur (N6).
3.9.1 Introduction
The present study was undertaken with the following objectives to assess both
terrestrial and aquatic habitats of the study area:
To assess the nature and distribution of vegetation in and around the existing
project site.
3.9.3 Methodology
To achieve the above objectives a detailed study of the area was undertaken with
the existing site as its centre. The different methods adopted were as follows:
The list of Terrestrial and Aquatic sampling locations in the study area is
presented in Table-3.9.1 and shown in Figure-3.9.1
TABLE-3.9.1
LIST OF TERRESTRIAL ECOLOGICAL SAMPLING LOCATIONS
Sr. No Name of the location Distance from proposed Direction w.r.t proposed
plant site (km) plant site
Terrestrial
TE-1 Near kamalpur 9.6 NE
TE-2 Near kamalpur 8.8 NE
TE-3 Near Pardai 9.3 ENE
TE-4 Near Malbana 9.4 SSW
TE-5 Near Ratanpur 5.1 SW
Aquatic
AE-1 Damodar river 1.3 SW
AE-2 Damodar river 8.2 SE
AE-3 Damodar river 6.6 WNW
FIGURE-3.9.1
TERRESTRIAL AND AQUATIC SAMPLING LOCATIONS
The Forest area is chiefly situated in the lateritic and red soil high lands. The
forest type in this region is Tropical dry deciduous forest, these forests are found
in areas where the rainfall is between 70 -100cm. The most common trees were
teek, sal, pepal, kend, mahuland kusum.
The only protected forest in the study area is given below in Table-3.9.2.
Table-3.9.2
LIST OF FOREST BLOCKS IN THE SYUDY AREA
The flora of the core area is characterized by the arborescent species such as
Simul (Salmalia malabarica), Amlaki (Phyllanthu sembica), Khejur (Phoenix
dactylifera), Bat (Ficus bengalensis), Bans (Bambusa arundinacea), Arka
(Calotropis gigantea), lal-bharenda (Jatropha gossypifolia), Kend (Disopyros
melanoxylon), palas (Butea monosperma) and Mohua (Madhuca latifolia). The list
of the flora is given in Table-3.9.3.
TABLE-3.9.3
LIST OF FLORA IN THE CORE AREA
This area hosts common mongoose, field mouse, bandicoot and birds like house
sparrow, common myna and koel. There are no Schedule-I species in the core
area. The list of fauna is given in Table- 3.9.4.
TABLE-3.9.4
LIST OF FAUNA IN THE CORE ZONE
Most commonly found species in the buffer zone and along the road side trees are
Sal (Shorea robusta), kend (Diospyros melanoxylon), Pesal (Pterocarpus
marsupium), Mahul (Madhuca latifolia), Kusum (Kusum schleicheratrijuga), Karam
(Adina cardifolia), Asan (Terminalia tomentosa), Rahera (Soya midafebrifuga) and
Dhaw (Anogeissus latifolia). The list of flora is given in Table-3.9.5
TABLE-3.9.5
LIST OF FLORA IN THE BUFFER AREA
The buffer zone and core zone do not harbor any schedule I Species or faunal
species of conservation importance or migratory routes of fauna. The commonly
observed species include Canis aureus, Lepus nigricollis, Presbytis entellus,
Herpestes edwardii, Chameleon zylonicum. The commonly observed birds are Red
vented bulbul, Indian myna, Indian roller, Indian pond heron, white throated king
fisher.
TABLE-3.9.7
LIST OF PLANKTON RECORDED FROM THE STUDY AREA
3.9.8 Fishes
Principal catches from the Damodar River are given in Table-3.9.8
TABLE-3.9.8
LIST OF FISHES
3.9.9 Conclusions
The primary site survey and the data from the secondary sources suggest no
presence of any Schedule-I species or species of conservation importance the
study area has no Biosphere reserves, National parks or Wildlife Sanctuary and
there are no migratory corridors of any species. Only one protected forest is
present in the study area and the remaining area is covered with open mixed
jungle and road side plantations. List of flora and fauna in the study area is
submitted to DFO office, Durgapur for authentication given in Annexure-XI.
3.10.3 Demography
As per the 2001 census the total population of the study area is 713158. The
population reported as per the 2011 census is 805102. Overall around 12.8%
decennial growth is reported in the study areas. West Bengal decennial growth
rate of population is 13.8%.
The growth rate of population in the study area comparatively reported less than
the growth rate of state.
Distribution of Population
As per 2011 census the study area consisted of 805102 persons inhabited in
study area. The distribution of population in the study area is shown in Table-
3.10.1.
TABLE-3.10.1
DISTRIBUTION OF POPULATION
The study area has a household size of 4.43 as per 2011 census, which has
decreased from 4.64 in 2001. This is mainly due to population control measures,
health awareness programs.
Population Density
The density of population reveals that the study area has an overall density of
2428 persons per km2 (PP km2) as per 2011 census reports. West Bengal density
of population is 1028.
The growth rate of population density in the study area comparatively reported
more than the growth rate of population density of state. 13 census towns are
falling in the study area. The proportion of urban and rural population is, urban
population 707945 (88%) rural population 97157 (12%)
Sex Ratio
The configuration of male and female indicates that the males constitute to about
52.05% and females to 47.95% of the total population as per 2011 census
records. The study area on an average has 921 females per 1000 males as per
2011 census reports, which is low in comparison to the national and state sex
ratio (India 943, West Bengal 950).
The sex ratio in the study area indirectly reveals certain sociological and cultural
aspects in relation with female births. The trend is very unique to the study area
and reveals that the female infanticide is less due to the cultural aspects.
In the study area, as per 2011 census, 18.87% of the population belongs to
Scheduled Castes (SC) and 2.66% to Scheduled Tribes (ST). Overall the data of
social stratification reveals that the SC and ST % to population is more than 21%,
The SC and ST community are marginalized and they are at considered at low
level of social strata and calls for a special attention in Social Impact Management
Plan for improving their socio-economic status apart from preservation and
protection of their art, culture and traditional rights of livelihood.
The data of study area reveals that literacy rate of 74.35% as per 2011 census,
which is found to be lower than the state rate of literacy (West Bengal 76.3%).
The distribution of literate and literacy rate in the study area is given in Table-
3.10.3.
TABLE-3.10.3
DISTRIBUTION OF LITERATE AND LITERACY RATES
The percentage of male literates to the total literates of the study area works out
to be 55.77%. The percentage of female literates to the total literates, which is
an important indicator for social change, is observed to be 44.23% in the study
area as per 2011 census records.
3.10.6 Occupational Structure
The occupational structure of residents of work participation rate in the study
area is studied with reference to main workers, marginal workers and non-
workers. The main workers include 10 categories of workers defined by the
Census Department consisting of cultivators, agricultural laborers, those engaged
in live-stock, forestry, fishing, mining and quarrying; manufacturing, processing
and repairs in household industry; and other than household industry,
construction, trade and commerce, transport and communication and other
services.
The marginal workers are those workers engaged in some work for a period of
less than six months during the reference year prior to the census survey. The
non-workers include those engaged in unpaid household duties, students, retired
persons, dependents, beggars, vagrants etc.; institutional inmates or all other
non-workers who do not fall under the above categories.
As per 2011 census records altogether West Bengal total work participation is
38.1% of the total population, whereas the work participation in the project study
areas is 34.53% and the main workers is 74.57% to the total workers. West
Bengal state main workers participation rate to the total workers is 73.9 % (2011
census). In the project area the marginal workers and non-workers constitute to
8.78% and 65.47% of the total population respectively. The distribution of
workers by occupation indicates that the non-workers are the predominant
population. The occupational structure of the study area is shown in Table-
3.10.4.
TABLE-3.10.4
OCCUPATIONAL STRUCTURE
Particulars 0-3 km 3-7 km 7-10 km 0-10 km
Total Population 566517 62645 175940 805102
Total workers 199013 20518 58482 278013
Work participation rate (%) 35.13 32.75 33.24 34.53
Total main workers 152499 13788 41040 207327
% of main workers to total workers 76.63 67.20 70.18 74.57
Marginal workers 46514 6730 17442 70686
% of marginal workers to total
workers 23.37 32.80 29.82 25.43
Non-workers 367504 42127 117458 527089
% of non-workers to total population 64.87 67.25 66.76 65.47
Source: District Census Hand Book-2011
4.1 Introduction
The chapter presents identification and appraisal of various impacts due to the
proposed power plant during construction and operational phases. The
environmental impacts are categorized as primary or secondary. Primary impacts
are those, which are attributed directly to the project and secondary impacts are
those, which are indirectly induced and typically include the associated
investment and changed pattern of social and economic activities by the proposed
action.
The mitigation measures proposed for minimizing the impacts have also been
discussed in this chapter. Environment Management Plan (EMP) is developed to
minimize adverse impacts and to ensure that the environment in and around the
project site is well protected. The EMP has been prepared for both construction
and operation phases of the proposed facilities.
The impacts have been assessed for the power plant assuming that the pollution
due to the existing activities has already been covered under baseline
environmental monitoring and continue to remain same till the operation of the
project.
The construction and operational phase of the proposed project comprises various
activities each of which may have an impact on some or other environmental
parameters. Various impacts during the construction and operation phase on the
environment have been studied to estimate the impacts on the environmental
attributes and are discussed in the subsequent sections.
This includes the following activities related to land acquisition, leveling of site,
construction of related structures and installation of related equipment.
NTPC-SAIL requires 35.5 acres of land for construction of power plant. The
proposed project site is located within the NTPC-SAIL premises. There will not be
any need for additional land requirement. The land is already under industrial
land use category.
The development in the study area will definitely bring changes in the land use
pattern due to the proposed plant. Shift in occupation or sectoral changes would
require more land for non-primary activities. However, the land identified for the
construction is under industrial use. Hence, the impact on land usages is
insignificant.
Also the development of greenbelt in 33% of plant area will help in attracting
minor fauna and birds. This will have a positive impact on the land use pattern.
• Temperature
• Rainfall
The average annual rainfall in the region is 1191.1 mm as per IMD data of
Bankura. Any changes in the pattern of rainfall will be on regional scale because
of cumulative reasons. The operation of plant is not expected to have any
adverse effect on the rainfall pattern of the area.
• Wind Speed
The wind speeds of any area depend on the existence of elevations and
depressions in the region. The proposed plant operation will have minor change in
topography and creation of structures in project area and its immediate vicinity.
Due to change in the topography of the project area minor variations are
envisaged at local level.
• Humidity
The relative humidity in the area is not likely to change because of the
construction operations, as it will not cause any changes in the prevailing
temperatures and rainfall of the region.
• Impact on Drainage
There are no seasonal nallah or streams that pass through the proposed project
site. Hence, construction activity of the plant will not have any impact on local
drainage pattern or drainage system.
The construction activities will result in loss of vegetation cover, topsoil and earthen
material to some extent in the plant area. However, it is proposed to use the soil
and earthen material for greenbelt development and levelling of project site.
Greenbelt will be developed in phased manner from inception of construction
activity. Apart from localized construction impacts at the plant site, no adverse
impacts on soil in the surrounding area are anticipated.
The main sources of emission during the construction period are the movement of
equipment at site and dust emitted during the leveling, grading, earthwork,
foundation works and exhaust emissions from vehicles and equipment deployed
during the construction phase. These emissions are likely to result in marginal
increase in the levels of SO2, NOx, PM and CO. The impact will be for short duration
and confined within the project boundary and is expected to be negligible outside
the plant boundaries. The impact will, however, be reversible, marginal and
temporary in nature. Proper maintenance of vehicles and construction equipment
will help in controlling the gaseous emissions. Water sprinkling on roads and
construction site will prevent fugitive dust.
The overall impact on water environment during construction phase due to proposed
project is likely to be short term and insignificant.
Heavy construction traffic for loading and unloading, fabrication and handling of
equipment and materials are likely to cause an increase in the ambient noise levels.
The areas affected are those close to the site. However, the noise will be temporary
and will be restricted mostly to daytime.
The noise control measures during construction phase include provision of caps on
the equipment and regular maintenance of the equipment.
The land identified for the proposed power plant is already under industrial
category and cutting of trees are not required. Therefore, no major loss of
biomass is envisaged during construction phase. Although the land required for
the proposed plant would be put to industrial use, there may not be any
significant impact on soil and agriculture in general. These impacts are, however,
restricted to the early phase of construction.
The removal of herbaceous vegetation from the soil and loosening of the topsoil
generally causes soil erosion during dry season. However, such impacts would be
primarily confined to the project site during initial periods of the construction
phase and would be minimized through adoption of mitigatory measures like
paving and surface treatment, water sprinkling and appropriate plantation
program. The project site and township area will be extensively landscaped with
the development of green belt consisting of a variety of taxa, which would enrich
the ecology of the area and add to the aesthetics.
Hence, in view of the above measures, the impact on terrestrial ecology would be
bare minimum and insignificant.
The proposed plant site will be located on a flat area. Minimum leveling is
required to be carried out during the construction of the plant. This will not cause
any significant topographical changes in the area.
Similarly, micro or macro climatic changes including thermal imbalances are not
envisaged since the maximum flue gas temperature will be about 140°C. It can
be concluded that the project as a whole is not likely to have any adverse impacts
on the topography and climate during its operation.
4.3.2 Impact on Air Quality – Point Emission Sources
Being a coal based power project, particulate matter (PM), sulphur dioxide (SO2)
and oxides of nitrogen (NOx) will be the important air pollutants from the
proposed project.
For prediction of maximum ground level concentrations (GLC’s), the air dispersion
modeling software (AERMOD version 7.1.0) was used. AERMOD is steady state
advanced gaussian plume model that simulates air quality and deposition fields
up to 50 km radius. AERMOD is approved by USEPA and is widely used software.
It is an advanced version of industrial source complex (ISCST3) model, utilizes
similar input and output structure to ISCST3 sharing many of the same features,
as well as offering additional features. The model is applicable to rural and urban
areas, flat and complex terrain, surface and elevated releases and multiple
sources including point, area, flare, line and volume sources.
Model Set-up
The model set-up details are presented in Table-4.1 below:
TABLE-4.1
MODEL SET-UP
Sr. No. Parameter Details
1 Model name AERMOD (Version 7.1.0)
2 Model type Steady state gaussian plume air dispersion model
3 Topography Rural, flat
4 Averaging time 24 hours
5 Source type Point source
6 Boundary limits 10 km X 10 km
7 Co-ordinate system Uniform polar grid
8 Receptor height 0
9 Anemometer 10 m
10 Surface meteorological data Site specific data processed by AERMET
11 Upper air data Upper air estimator using AERMET processor
TABLE-4.2(B)
CUMULATIVE STACK DETAILS AND EMISSION RATES
Sr. Stack Stack Stack Flow Rate Exit Temp Emission Rate
No Attached Height Diameter (Nm3/sec) Velocity (oK) (g/sec)
(m) (m) (m/s) PM SO2 NOx
1 Boiler (Unit-I) 122.5 4.3 75.35 16.99 414 3.92 50.71 32.48
2 Boiler (Unit-II) 122.5 4.3 71.31 17.29 439 9.38 49.70 32.73
3 BF-2 stove 60.96 2.4 14.26 3.8 381.3 0.55 0.49 0.47
4 BF-3 stove 60.96 2.4 14.27 3.9 381.3 0.56 0.35 0.43
5 BF-4 stove 68.96 2.4 13.63 3.7 382.3 0.53 0.31 0.44
6 Battery No.1 85.34 3.8 28.86 5.1 558.7 1.36 12.68 3.29
7 Battery No.3 85.34 3.5 32.95 5.9 498.7 1.34 15.90 3.59
8 Battery No.4 85.34 3.5 26.49 5.2 542.3 1.12 12.04 2.86
9 Battery No.6 110 4 29.47 7.3 448.3 1.43 12.73 1.07
10 SP-1 sinter 60 2.5 146.61 15.2 340.7 9.25 3.58 2.32
M/C-1&2
11 SP-1 sinter M/C 120 3.5 35.76 4.4 329.7 3.44 0.83 0.71
(T1 T2)
12 SP-2 Space 60 5.8 268.29 10.5 318 25.68 5.69 5.20
Sr. Stack Stack Stack Flow Rate Exit Temp Emission Rate
No Attached Height Diameter (Nm3/sec) Velocity (oK) (g/sec)
(m) (m) (m/s) PM SO2 NOx
dedusting (B1
B2)
13 Lime kiln-1 53 1 6.94 11.3 404 0.99 0.58 0.40
14 Lime kiln-3 53 1 7.35 13.3 423 1.08 0.59 0.43
15 Old Power Plant 45.72 1.8 14.35 9.6 507.3 3.66 9.89 6.10
(OPP) Boiler-1
16 Opp Boiler-3 45.72 1.8 12.84 8.4 495.5 1.28 7.50 1.90
17 Opp Boiler-5 45.72 2.3 19.58 7.7 493 4.38 8.69 5.21
18 Opp Boiler-7 45.72 2.1 15.1 7.5 505.3 1.40 7.70 1.90
The predicted incremental Ground Level Concentrations (GLCs) for PM, SO2 and
NOx are presented in Table-4.3.
TABLE-4.3 (A)
PROPOSED SHORT TERM MAXIMUM INCREMENTAL CONCENTRATIONS
TABLE-4.3 (B)
CUMULATIVE SHORT TERM MAXIMUM INCREMENTAL CONCENTRATIONS
The maximum incremental GLCs due to the proposed captive power plant for PM,
SO2 and NOX are superimposed on the maximum baseline PM, SO2 and NOx
concentrations recorded during the study period in the downwind direction to arrive
at the likely resultant concentrations during the same period after implementation of
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C4-6
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
TABLE-4.4 (A)
PROPOSED RESULTANT CONCENTRATIONS DUE TO INCREMENTAL GLC's
TABLE-4.4 (B)
CUMULATIVE RESULTANT CONCENTRATIONS DUE TO INCREMENTAL GLC's
The fugitive dust emissions expected are from coal storage yards, coal conveyor
belt area, ash dumping areas, transportation of fuel and solid waste.
In the proposed project, as the coal handling plant will be properly operated with
EMP suggested in this report, no major fugitive dust emissions are envisaged.
Similarly, HCSD system of ash stacking will be practiced for fly ash and wet
disposal system will be practised for disposal of bottom ash and hence, no dust
emissions are envisaged from ash dump areas. The fuel will be received through
rail line and the solid waste will be sent to dyke areas through pipeline. Hence, no
dust emissions from transportation are envisaged. However, internal roads are to
be asphalted to further reduce fugitive dust emissions.
The dust emissions, if any, from the above areas will be fugitive in nature and
maximum during summer season (when the wind velocities are likely to be high)
and almost nil during the monsoon season. The dust emissions are likely to be
confined to the place of generation only. The quantification of these fugitive
emissions from the area sources is difficult as it depends on lot of factors such as
dust particle size, specific gravity of dust particles, wind velocity, moisture content
of the material and ambient temperatures etc. Also, there is a high level of
variability in these factors. Hence, these are not amenable for mathematical
dispersion modelling. However, by proper usage of dust suppression measures,
dust generation and dispersions will be reduced.
FIGURE-4.1
SHORT TERM 24 HOURLY INCREMENTAL GLCs OF PM (2x20)
FIGURE-4.2
SHORT TERM 24 HOURLY INCREMENTAL GLCs of SO2 (2x20)
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C4-9
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
FIGURE-4.3
SHORT TERM 24 HOURLY INCREMENTAL GLCs of NOx (2x20)
PROJECT TITLE:
1.96
6000
1.96
4000
2000
1.96
Y-Direction [m]
0
6
3.8
1.9
6
-2000
-4000
-6000
-8000
-10000
-10000 -8000 -6000 -4000 -2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000
X-Direction [m]
PLOT FILE OF HIGH 1ST HIGH 24-HR VALUES FOR SOURCE GROUP: ALL ug/m^3
0.068 1.963 3.858 5.752 7.647 9.541 11.436 13.330 15.225 17.120
COMMENTS: SOURCES: COMPANY NAME:
M.Janardhan
441
Bh.Durga Bhavani
OUTPUT TYPE: SCALE: 1:140,980
Concentration 0 5 km
FIGURE-4.4
CUMULATIVE SHORT TERM 24 HOURLY INCREMENTAL GLCs of PM
PROJECT TITLE:
3.50
8000
6000
3.50
4000
50
3.
3.50
2000
Y-Direction [m]
6.88
0
0
3.5
-2000
3.50
-4000
-6000
-8000
-10000
-10000 -8000 -6000 -4000 -2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000
X-Direction [m]
PLOT FILE OF HIGH 1ST HIGH 24-HR VALUES FOR SOURCE GROUP: ALL ug/m^3
0.127 3.504 6.880 10.257 13.633 17.010 20.386 23.763 27.139 30.516
COMMENTS: SOURCES: COMPANY NAME:
M.Janardhan
441
Bh.Durga Bhavani
OUTPUT TYPE: SCALE: 1:140,980
Concentration 0 5 km
FIGURE-4.5
CUMULATIVE SHORT TERM 24 HOURLY INCREMENTAL GLCs of SO2
PROJECT TITLE:
1.97
8000
6000
1.97
4000
1.97
2000
3.89
Y-Direction [m]
0
97
1.
-2000
7
1. 9
-4000
-6000
-8000
-10000
-10000 -8000 -6000 -4000 -2000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000
X-Direction [m]
PLOT FILE OF HIGH 1ST HIGH 24-HR VALUES FOR SOURCE GROUP: ALL ug/m^3
0.048 1.969 3.890 5.812 7.733 9.654 11.576 13.497 15.418 17.339
COMMENTS: SOURCES: COMPANY NAME:
M.Janardhan
441
Bh.Durga Bhavani
OUTPUT TYPE: SCALE: 1:140,980
Concentration 0 5 km
FIGURE-4.6
CUMULATIVE SHORT TERM 24 HOURLY INCREMENTAL GLCs of NOx
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C4-13
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Water is required for various power plant operations and the water balance has
been explained in Chapter-2 under Section-2.5.3.
No groundwater source will be tapped for meeting the water requirements during
operation of the power plant. The water requirement of the project will be drawn
from the Waria reservoir of DSP.
The required water for regular operations of the plant will be about 300 m3/hr. As
the required water is available even during lean season, no impact on surface
water resources is envisaged.
The water balance and wastewater generation details have been described in
Chapter-2.
Garland drains around the ash pond site will be provided for the collection of run-
off water during monsoon season.
The storm water in the project area will be collected through storm water drains
and collected in the storm water tank, which is lined to prevent any
contamination of ground water. The stored storm water will be utilized for
secondary purposes in the plant operation resulting in conservation of fresh
water. Suitable rain harvesting pits will be provided along the storm water drain
to recharge the ground water table.
The expected quality of raw and treated wastewater from the power plant
including sewage water and discharge limits as specified by environment
protection rules is given in Table-4.5.
TABLE-4.5
EXPECTED QUALITY OF WASTEWATER
The land identified for the proposed 2x20 MW power plant is about 35.5 acres.
About 19 acres of the land will be used for ash disposal. About 3.5 acres of the
plant area will be developed as greenbelt and green cover, which is 33% of the
total plant area.
The greenbelt proposed will have a positive impact on land. There will be minimum
changes in land use during the operational phase of the project. Hence, no major
impacts are envisaged during operational phase of the project.
Most of the impacts of power plant project on soils are restricted to the construction
phase, which will get stabilized during operational phase. The impact on the topsoil
will be confined to the proposed main plant area only. Further, the greenbelt
proposed will have a very positive impact on soil quality.
The probable sources of degradation of soil quality will be due to generation &
disposal of ash and fugitive dust emissions. However, the impacts due to disposal of
ash are covered under Section-4.3.7.
The airborne fugitive dust from the plant is likely to be deposited on the topsoil in
the immediate vicinity of the plant boundary. However, the fugitive emissions are
likely to be controlled to a great extent through proposed control measures like
water sprinkling and development of greenbelt development. Hence, no major
impact is envisaged on soil quality of the project site.
4.3.7 Impact of Solid Waste
Ash is the major solid waste to be generated from the proposed coal based power
plant. Coal consumption of 0.3 MTPA was considered for estimation of ash
generation. Ash will be generated in both forms viz. bottom ash and fly ash.
About 80% of the total ash generation will be fly ash and remaining 20% comes
as bottom ash. The fly ash is the important air pollutant, which emits to outside
environment through stacks attached to boilers. ESP’s with >99.9% efficiency
shall be provided to prevent ash dispersions into ambient air. The details of the
solid waste generation are given in Table-4.6.
TABLE-4.6
EXPECTED SOLID WASTE FROM POWER PLANT
It is proposed to collect fly ash from ESP hoppers in dry from and provide/supply
to potential ash users depending on the demand. The balance unutilized ash will
be disposed off using High Concentrated Slurry Disposal (HCSD) technology. An
area of about 102 acres has been identified for ash pond within the project
premises. In view of the proposed HCSD ash disposal technology, ash pond
supernatant run-off would not be expected and the impacts on surrounding
environment would be insignificant. However, it is also proposed to provide the
ash pond with an impervious HDPE layers.
The sludge from sewage treatment plant will be dried, vermi-composted and used
as manure for greenbelt maintenance canteen/sanitary waste will be composted
and used as manure for greenbelt development.
For ash disposal, high concentration slurry disposal method will be adopted. The
bottom ash slurry and fly ash slurry will be led to common slurry sump of the
combined ash slurry disposal pump house. In view of the proposed HCSD ash
disposal technology, ash pond supernatant run off would not be expected. Hence,
the impact of the ash pond on the surface water will be insignificant.
Detailed flora and fauna studies were carried out during study period and the
details are presented in Section-3.9 of Chapter-3. About 127 plant species were
identified and these are commonly growing plant species of the region. As per
survey and also from field studies, there are no endangered, threatened and
protected plants. 67 animal species were recorded/ observed during study period.
It can be concluded that there are about 6 species which belong to Sch-II and 1
species belong to Sch-III, 52 species which belong to Sch-IV and 8 species which
belong to Sch-V of Wildlife Protection Act, 1972.
people will enhance the greenery of the area. Hence, no significant adverse
impact is envisaged on terrestrial ecology.
The impacts on aquatic ecology due to proposed project would be negligible as the
treated effluents from the proposed power project will meet the prescribed
standards prior to final discharge.
Similarly, as the discharge water will not have much higher temperature than the
receiving body, no thermal effects on receiving body due to discharge are
envisaged.
The main noise generating stationary sources from the power plant will be
pumps, compressors along with cooling tower and boilers. The noise levels at the
source for these units will be in the range of 75-85 dB(A). The noise dispersion
from the plant units has been computed based on the mathematical model. The
major noise generating sources from the proposed plant are identified and listed
in Table-4.7. These are considered as input to the noise model.
TABLE-4.7
MAJOR NOISE GENERATING SOURCES
The incremental noise levels are computed at proposed project site at 100 m X
100 m grid intervals over an area of 10 km X 10 km study area. The predicted
results of incremental noise levels at each grid points are used to draw noise
contours. The predicted noise contours around proposed sources are shown in
Figure-4.7. The predicted noise levels at the plant boundaries are given below in
Table-4.8.
TABLE-4.8
PREDICTED NOISE LEVELS AT THE PLANT BOUNDARIES
The predicted noise levels at the boundary due to various plant activities will be
ranging in between 30 to 34 dB(A). The incremental noise levels will be less than
40 dB(A) at all the surrounding habitations. It is seen from the simulation results
that the incremental noise levels will be well within the CPCB standards.
Boilers and cooling towers are the high noise generating equipments in the
proposed power plant. However, impacts on the working personnel are not
expected to be significant on account of the high level of automation of the plant,
which means that workers will be exposed for short duration only and that too
intermittently.
The noise generation during operational phase would be at source itself through
different measures such as inspection, operation and maintenance at regular
intervals. The noise control measures as described in EMP will be fully followed.
The occupational noise exposure to the workers in the form of 8-hourly time
weighted average will be maintained well within the prescribed OSHA standards
(<90 dB (A)). Hence, the impact on occupational health of workers would be
insignificant.
As per the location of power plant, the minimum distance available between
proposed major noise sources and the outer periphery of the project site would
be more than 500 m. The cumulative incremental impact of all noise sources at
boundary will range between 30 and 34 dB (A). The effective increase of
incremental noise contours at the boundary would be only about 1.5 to 2.5 dB(A).
The nearest human habitations are located at about 0.7 km from the boundary
and the cumulative noise impacts would be insignificant.
This section of the chapter deals with the demographic, social and economic
impact of the proposed power plant study area. The project is expected to have
following impending impacts any industrialization would create on demographic,
socio-economic and health conditions of the study area.
There is no habitation at the project site and there will not be any displacement of
the population for this project as there is no land proposed for acquisition
separately; hence the issue of Rehabilitation and Resettlement will not arise. The
human settlements are at considerable distance from the existing power plant
area and also the proposed new power plant.
The project is expected to provide some employment to the families in the nearby
villages. It is assumed that half of the employees will be from the study area
itself. The population of the nearby village of project will grow more than the
average growth rate.
Increase of Migration
The trend is expected to continue as the proposed project also would provide
considerable direct and indirect employment to the families from the nearby
villages. About 50% employees from outside may take up jobs in the proposed
project and with migration of their families, an increase in the population is
anticipated.
Similarly the literacy level of the project area is likely to increase further as there
will be influx of many educated people taking up jobs in this project, which is
likely to result in establishment of better educational facilities.
Apart from this better literacy rates were also possible due to assumed better
economic conditions of the people. This has impacted on improving the social
status and will improve the living conditions in the region.
The study area has reasonably developed with improved network of roads,
educational institutions, post office, drinking water facility, communication,
entertainment and health care facilities. The construction of new roads in the
project area has enhanced the transportation facilities. With improved
transportation facilities there is always a scope for further development. Apart
from this the CSR activities undertaken by the project proponent had also
contributed to the overall development of the nearby villages. Overall a positive
impact on civic amenities and improved living conditions is expected.
Due to the development of the villages with infrastructure facilities like, safe
drinking water, sanitation, health centers and education facilities, the positive
impact on the health condition of the population is noted and the same is
expected to continue.
But the urbanization due to industrialization may have impact on health status of
both migrants and local population. The incidence of public health like, HIV/AIDS,
TB and other respiratory related issues may increase.
The impact of proposed project on the economic aspects can be clearly observed.
The proposed plant is also expected to have positive impact on economy in terms
of employment opportunities, infrastructure facilities and enhancement of per
capita income in the nearby region. Workforce available locally will be preferred
for employment depending upon their qualification and requirement of the
project.
The project will definitely help in improvement of the socio-economic status of the
society in the region by generating direct or indirect employment opportunities.
The project will also induce the development of ancillary and related small-scale
industries in the adjoining areas. It is obvious to assume that the activities of the
proposed project operations will produce some improvements in the socio-
economic levels in the study area.
The project will also contribute additional revenue to the State and Central
exchequer in the form of direct and indirect taxes etc.
Apart from this project proponent is committed to plan for development of local
village schools to provide support for creating sports facilities, additional
classrooms, sanitation facilities, etc. Skill development of local people through
training and local women entrepreneurs will be supported by providing petty
contracts.
-1000 -800 -600 -400 -200 0 200 400 600 800 1000
1000 1000
800 800
600 600
400 400
200 200
0 0
-200 -200
-400 -400
-600 -600
-800 -800
-1000 -1000
-1000 -800 -600 -400 -200 0 200 400 600 800 1000
FIGURE-4.7
PREDICTED NOISE DISPERSION CONTOURS
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C4-21
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
The discharge of waste materials (stack emission, wastewater and solid wastes)
from process operations may have potential impact on public safety and health.
The wastewater generated from power plant will be treated before discharging
outside. It is proposed to reuse the wastewater to the maximum extent. Since,
the adverse impacts on ambient air and soil quality are predicted to be low it is
anticipated that with effective implementation of control measures suggested for
pollution control, the impact on public health will be minimum.
During construction phase, the construction activities like site levelling, grading,
transportation of the construction material cause various impacts on the
surroundings. However, the constructional phase impacts are temporary and
localised phenomena except the permanent change in local landscape and land use
pattern of the project site.
Preparation of site will involve excavations and fillings. The earthen material
generated during excavations and site grading periods, shall be properly dumped
and slope stabilisation shall be taken. The topsoil generated during construction
shall be preserved and reused for plantations.
No nallas of water courses are present in the project site. However, natural drainage
pattern shall not be disturbed as far as possible.
The approach road to project site shall be appropriately widened and strengthened
to facilitate vehicular movement.
The greenbelt area shall be delineated before start-up of earthwork and tree
plantation shall be taken up during construction stage itself.
The activities like site development, grading and vehicular traffic contribute to
increase in PM and NOx concentrations. The mitigation measures recommended to
minimize the impacts are:
The soil erosion at site during heavy precipitation contributes to the increase in
suspended solids. The wastewater from vehicle and construction equipment
maintenance centre will contribute to oil and grease concentration. The wastewater
from labour colony will contribute to higher BOD concentrations. The mitigation
measures recommended to minimize the impacts are:
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C4-22
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
During operation phase, the impacts on the various environmental attributes should
be mitigated using appropriate pollution control equipment. The Environment
Management Plan prepared for the proposed project aims at minimizing the
pollution at source.
Fugitive and stack emissions from the power plant will contribute to increase in
concentrations of PM, SO2, and NOx pollutants. The mitigative measures
recommended in the plant are:
• Installation of ESP followed Fabric filter (Hybrid ESP) of efficiency more than
99.9% to limit the PM concentrations below 50 mg/Nm3;
• Provision of tall stack of 75 m height for wider dispersion of gaseous emissions;
• Provision of water sprinkling system at raw material storage yard;
• Asphalting of the roads within the plant area;
• Provision of dust extraction systems at dust generating source;
• Developing of greenbelt around the plant to arrest the fugitive emissions; and
• Online flue gas monitors as well as flue gas flow rates and temperature
measurement shall be provided for all stacks;
Wastewater will be generated from cooling towers, boilers in the power plant.
Besides, domestic wastewater from canteen and employees wash area, township
will also be generated. The recommended measures to minimise the impacts and
conservation of fresh water are:
The wastewater from various units of the plant shall be appropriately treated and
disposed and details are presented in Table-4.9.
TABLE-4.9
DETAILS OF WASTE WATER TREATMENT
The flowcharts of Effluent Treatment Scheme and the proposed STP are given in
Figure-4.8 and Figure-4.9, respectively.
There is generation of surface run-off from the plant facility during monsoon
season. The run-off will be of two types, i.e., run-off from the pervious area of
the facility site and run-off from the built-up area of the facility.
The run-off from the paved surfaces of the proposed facility will be routed
through a carefully designed storm water drainage network and collected in storm
water collection sump and excess rainwater will be discharged to bore wells
constructed on these internal drains.
The run-off from the pervious area will be routed directly to the rainwater
harvesting structures constructed at suitable locations as per the contours. For
augmenting the ground water resources in the plant premises, number of
rainwater harvesting pits will be constructed and the internal drains where excess
rain water is flowing in drain will be diverted to these pits. These structures will
facilitate percolation of water into the ground thus augmenting the groundwater
sources. The roof top water will be routed to the storm drains. This will result in
increase in groundwater tables and to some extent in the improvement of ground
water quality. The size and the locations of rainwater harvesting pits will be
decided during detailed engineering of the project. Run off from the proposed
project site is calculated using rational formula:
Q=CxIXA
Q = Run-off in m3/hr
A = Catchment Area (ha)
C = Coefficient of Run-off
I = intensity of Rainfall in mm/hr
Total area = 35.5 acres
Intensity of Rainfall (I) = 2.5 cm/hr (1 inch/hr)
Run-off co-efficient (C) = 0.7
Q = 0.7 x (2.5/100) m/hr x (35.5 x 10000) m2
= 6212.5 m3/hr
The power plant water management system will be designed to minimize the
potential for storm water contamination occurring at the site. This will be
achieved by incorporating the following features into the storm water
management system:
• Run-off from upstream areas will be diverted around the plant site;
• The quantity of contaminated run-off generated will be minimized by diverting
run-off from areas external to the plant to storm water discharge points;
• Hazardous material and fuel storage areas will be bunded and drains will be
provided to around these facilities to prevent entering of run-off water; and
• Run-off from area external to process areas of the plant will be contained
within a storage system.
In the plant operation process, various equipments like pumps, cooling tower,
compressors etc generate the noise. The recommendations to mitigate higher noise
levels are:
Solid waste in the form of ash will be generated in a coal based thermal power
plant. The total ash generated in the plant will be 1,20,000 TPA out of which 20%
will be bottom ash i.e. 24,000 TPA and balance will be fly ash of 98,000 TPA. The
following measures shall be taken for solid waste management:
• Whole fly ash generated in the plant shall be supplied to Letter of Award (LOA)
• The bottom ash will be disposed off in ash pond, which will be provided with clay
lining;
• Sufficient moisture content will be maintained in the ash dyke to prevent fugitive
dust;
• The used oil will be given to authorized recyclers;
• The organic portion of sludge waste generated in the sewage treatment plant
(STP) will be used as manure in greenbelt development; and
• Maintaining the data base on solid waste generation.
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C4-26
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
FIGURE-4.8
SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM OF EFFLUENT TREATMENT SCHEME
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C4-27
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-4
Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Domestic Wastewater
From Plant & Colony
Aeration
Bar Screen Grit Chamber Tank
Alum
Sludge Sludge
Treated
Water for
Reuse
FIGURE-4.9
SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM OF SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT
FIGURE-4.10
SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM OF RAIN WATER HARVESTING PIT
Cement mixed with fly ash is known as Portland Pozzolana Cement (PPC). As per
the Indian standards, fly ash can be used to replace 25% cement. The fly ash
cement is made by grinding with clinker. The fly ash generated from proposed
power plant will be supplied to cement plants in the region. The fly ash can be
utilized by these cement plants to manufacture PPC cement.
It is very much clear that the ash generated at the power plant can be effectively
used for various products. Though the acceptability of the ash-based products
may take a long time, it is always better to start on a small scale.
• The proponent will encourage the use of water treated fly ash as a soil
ameliorator and as a source of micro-nutrients and secondary nutrients for
improving agricultural productivity.
4.6.3.4 Conclusion
All efforts will be made for maximum utilization of ash. However, after reviewing
various proposals of the ash utilization, 100% of ash utilization is possible at the
initial period and same will be improved over the period of time in future. The
project proponent is committed to explore possibilities for ash utilization
considering new technologies and avenues and try to achieve the target fixed by
MoEF in this regard.
NTPC-SAIL Power Company Private Ltd is committed to comply with the Fly Ash
Utilization Notification, 2009.
The ash will be utilized in various construction material to the maximum extent and
100% utilization will be achived.
4.7 Greenbelt Development
With rapid industrialization and consequent deleterious impact of pollutants on
environment, values of environmental protection offered by trees are becoming
clear. Trees are very suitable for detecting, recognizing and reducing air pollution
effects. Monitoring of biological effects of air pollutant by the use of plants as
indicators has been applied on local, regional and national scale. Trees function as
sinks of air pollutants, besides their bio-esthetical values, owing to its large
surface area.
The greenbelt development not only functions as foreground and background
landscape features resulting in harmonizing and amalgamating the physical
structures of the plant with surrounding environment, but also acts as pollution
sink. Thus, implementation of afforestation program is of paramount importance.
It will also check soil erosion, make the ecosystem more complex and functionally
more stable and make the climate more conducive.
Greenbelt with a width of 50 m to 100 m will be developed around the plant site.
The total greenbelt around the power plant complex will be about 24.5 acres.
In the proposed greenbelt about 12000 trees will be planted over an area of 3.5
acres with a density of 2500 trees/ha. A capital budget for Environmental
protection measures is Rs. 16.9 crores capital cost and 8.1 crores recurring coat
per annum. The plantation schedule will be completed within five years from the
construction period of the project. The plantation schedule is given in Table-
4.10.
TABLE-4.10
GREENBELT DEVELOPMENT SCHEDULE
The layout plan of the greenbelt and tree cover in plant area is shown in Figure-
4.11.
The species proposed will have broad leaves. Trees will be selected based on the
type of pollutants, their intensity, location, easy availability and suitability to the
local climate. They have different morphological, physiological and bio-chemical
mechanism/ characters like branching habits, leaf arrangement, size, shape,
surface (smooth/hairy), presence or absence of trichomes, stomatal conductivity
proline content, ascorbic acid content, cationic peroxides and sulphite oxidize
activities etc to trap or reduce the pollutants. Species to be selected will fulfil the
following specific requirements of the area:
FIGURE-4.11
GREENBELT DEVELOPMENT PLAN
TABLE-4.11
RECOMMENDED PLANTS FOR GREENBELT
Note: S: Small, M: Medium, L: Large
Sr. Botanical Name of the Plant Size of Plant
No. with Height Type and Suitable Site
1 Acacia auriculaeformis M; Semi-evergreen fragrant white flowers;
(Mimosaceae) suitable in green belts and on road sides
Height: 5m
2 Adina cordifolia (Rubiaceae) L; deciduous, a light demander, suitable on
Height: 20m open areas & near flares
3 Aegle marmelos( Rutaceae) M; deciduous, good for green belts near temples
Height: 12m
4 Anogeissus latifolia M; deciduous suitable for green belts
( Combretaceae)
5 Artabotrys hexapetaius S; evergreen shrub with fragrant flowers good
(Annonaceae) for gardens & inside boundary wall and long
Height: 10m canals
6 Averrhoa carambola S; semi ever green good in narrow green belts (
(Averrhoaceae Oxalidaceae) green belts < 50 m width)
Height: 5m Along channels
7 Azadirachta India (Meliaceae) L; evergreen ;
Height: 20m Suitable in green belts and out side office &
hospital buildings
8 Bauhinia variegate M; deciduous, good in green belts in garden and
(Caesalpiniaceae) as a second row avenue tree
Height: 5m
9 Boswellia serrata M; deciduous suitable on green belt on shallow
(Burseraceae) soils
Height: 4m
10 Burera serrata (Bureraceae) M; evergreen, suitable on shallow soil as a
Height: 4m green belt or avenue tree
11 Butea monosperma M; deciduous for green belts and as a second
(Fabaceae; Papilionaceae) row avenue tree
Height: 10m
12 Caesalpinia pulcherrima S; a large shrub, suitable for gardens out side
(Leguminosae) offices and along channels
Height: 4m
13 Callistemon lanceolatus M; deciduous for some time, ornamental plant in
(Myrtaceae) garden
Height: 5m
14 Careva aroborea L; deciduous, good in green belts
(Lecythidaceae)
15 Carrisa carandas S; semi evergreen. Large bushy shrub, good as
(Apocynaceae) a hedge to protect against noise
Height: 3m
16 Caryota urens ( Palmae) A lofty palm, good as a windbreak
Height: 5m
17 Cassia fistula M; deciduous, good ornamental tree in green
(Leguminopsaae) belts
Height: 12m
18 C. Siamea L; evergreen, good an avenue tree
Height: 10-12m
19 Cedrela toona L; deciduous, good in open spaces, in green
(Meliaceae) belts and along ponds
Height: 5-8m
20 Cestrum diurnum S; a shrub with white fragrant flowers, suitable
(solanaceae) around boilers and waste disposal sites
Height: 3m
21 Cleistanthus collinus S; deciduous tree suitable in green belts
TABLE-4.12
COST PROVISION FOR ENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES
During Phase-II expansion the 3rd TA of 20 MW will be installed along with 3rd
Boiler and other auxiliaries. After the installation of 3rd unit the total Category-I
and Emergency power demand will be met by new Power Plant and during shut
down of one machine the demand will be approximately 44.0 MW and will be met
by the remaining two units with necessary load shedding and switching.
Present generation Turbine with high efficiency has been envisaged. Turbine will
be condensing type.
Considering 90% of consisting loading on each Boiler the capacity of each Boiler
has been selected as 100 TPH. Boilers will run only on coal for 100% of rated
capacity. Light Diesel Oil (LDO) shall be used as startup fuel.
The existing type stokered fired Boilers are old and have lower efficiency.
Pulverized fuel fired Boilers are efficient but most suitable for 200 TPH and above.
For the capacity of 100 TPH boiler both Atmospheric Fluidized Bed Combustion
(AFBC) and Circulating Fluidized Bed Combustion (CFBC) are suitable. The
comparison between AFBC and CFBC boiler are given in Table-5.2.
TABLE-5.2
COMPARISON BETWEEN AFBC AND CFBC BOILERS
It is observed that both the types have their own advantage and disadvantage.
NTPC-SAIL informed that they have discussed with leading Boiler manufacturers
and also visited some of the operating plants based on CFBC and AFBC Boilers. It
has been observed by them that for the intended capacity (100 TPH), the Boiler
of AFBC type are generally operating. CFBC Boilers are more in numbers for
higher capacities i.e 130 TPH and above. However, the manufacturers while
recommending AFBC Boilers for the capacity envisaged are also not against
supply of CFBC Boilers.
Based on the above comparison AFBC Boilers have been selected over CFBC type
for this project with boiler capacity 100 TPH.
6.1 Introduction
Usually, as in the case of the study, an impact assessment study is carried over
short period of time and the data cannot bring out all variations induced by the
natural or human activities. Therefore, regular monitoring programme of the
environmental parameters is essential to take into account the changes in the
environmental quality.
Monitoring will confirm that commitments are being met. This may take the form
of direct measurement and recording of quantitative information, such as
amounts and concentrations of discharges, emissions and wastes, for
measurement against corporate or statutory standards, consent limits or targets.
It may also require measurement of ambient environmental quality in the vicinity
of a site using ecological/biological, physical and chemical indicators. Monitoring
may include socio-economic interaction, through local liaison activities or even
assessment of complaints. NTPC-SAIL is presently out sourcing the monitoring
work MoEF recognised laboratory same will be utilized for the proposed expansion
project.
The proposed power project envisages setting up of boilers, turbines and cooling
towers etc. The construction activities require clearing of vegetation, mobilisation of
construction material and equipment. The construction activities are expected to
last for over three years.
TABLE-6.1
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING DURING PROJECT CONSTRUCTION STAGE
Equipment to be
maintained in good
working order.
Night working is to be Working hour records Daily records
minimized.
Generation of vehicular Maintenance of Daily records
noise records of vehicles
Noise to be monitored in Spot Noise recording As per
ambient air within the CPCB/SPCB
plant premises. requirement or
on quarterly
basis
whichever is
earlier
3 Wastewater No untreated discharge to No discharge hoses Periodic during
Discharge be made to surface water, will be in vicinity of construction
groundwater or soil. watercourses. activities
4 Soil Erosion Protect topsoil stockpile Effective cover in Periodic during
where possible at edge of place. construction
site. activities
5 Drainage and Ensure drainage system Visual inspection of Periodic during
effluent and specific design drainage and records construction
Management measures are working thereof activities
effectively.
TABLE-6.2
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING DURING OPERATIONAL PHASE
Design to incorporate
existing drainage pattern
and avoid disturbing the
same.
5 Water Quality Monitoring used water Comprehensive Periodic during
and Water quality, groundwater quality monitoring as per operation phase
Levels around ash pond and IS:10500
ground water levels
Groundwater level
in meters bgl
River water quality As per CTO Once in a week
downstream to discharge
6 Work zone air Contaminants such as VOCs Monitoring of As per
contamination to be reduced by providing indoor air CPCB/SPCB
adequate ventilation contaminants such requirement
as CO, CO2 and
VOCs.
7 Emergency Fire protection and safety Mock drill records, Periodic during
preparedness, measures to take care of fire on site emergency operation phase
such as fire and explosion hazards, to be plan, evacuation
fighting assessed and steps taken plan
for their prevention.
8 Maintenance of Vegetation, greenbelt / No. of plants, Periodic during
flora and fauna green cover development species operation phase
9 Waste Implement waste Records of solid Periodic during
Management management plan that waste generation, operation phase
identifies and characterizes treatment and
every waste arising disposal
associated with proposed
activities and which
identifies the procedures for
collection, handling &
disposal of each waste
arising.
10 Soil quality Maintenance of good soil Physico-chemical Periodical
quality parameters and monitoring at
metals. ash pond site
11 Health Employees and migrant All relevant Regular check
labour health check ups parameters ups
including HIV
The emissions from all the stacks will be monitored regularly. The exit gas
temperature, velocity and pollutant concentrations will be measured. Any
unacceptable deviation from the design values will be thoroughly examined and
appropriate action will be taken. Air blowers will be checked for any drop in exit gas
velocity.
The ground level concentrations of PM, SO2 and NOX in the ambient air will be
monitored at regular intervals. Any abnormal rise will be investigated to identify
the causes and appropriate action will be initiated. Greenbelt will be developed for
minimising dust propagation. The ambient air quality data should be transferred
and processed in a centralised computer facility equipped with required software.
Trend and statistical analysis should be done. Ambient air quality monitoring
studies will be carried out as per recent amendment of 16th November-2009 on
NAAQM and will be strictly followed.
To ensure a strict control over the water consumption, flow meters will be installed
for all major inlets. All leakages and excess will be identified and rectified. In
addition, periodic water audits will be conducted to explore further possibilities for
water conservation.
All the wastewater streams in the project area will be regularly analysed for flow
rate and physical and chemical characteristics. Such analysis is carried out for
wastewater at the source of generation, at the point of entry into the wastewater
treatment plant and at the point of final discharge. These data will be properly
documented and compared against the design values for any necessary corrective
action.
The monitoring of groundwater is the most important tool to test the efficiency of
ash pond performance. This is indispensable as it provides detection of the
presence of waste constituents in groundwater in case of leachate migration. In
this programme, water samples are taken at a predetermined interval and analysed
for specific pollutant expected to be in the leachate.
Noise levels in the work zone environment such as boiler house, cooling tower
area, DG house will be monitored. The frequency will be once in three months in
the work zone. Similarly, ambient noise levels near habitations will also be
monitored once in three months. Audiometric tests will be conducted periodically
for the employees working close to the high noise sources.
The frequency of reporting will be on six monthly basis to the local state pollution
control board officials and to Regional office of MoEF & CC. The Environmental Audit
reports will be prepared for the entire year of operations and will be regularly
submitted to regulatory authorities.
The West Bengal Pollution control board has conducted public hearing on 6th
January 2015 at Rabindra Bhawan, Shivaji Road, A-Zone, Durgapur, District
Burdwan, West Bengal as per the provisions of EIA notification S.O. 1533
dated:14th September 2006 for the proposed Durgapur Captive Power Project-III
(2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan, West Bengal.
The press notification indicating date and venue of the public hearing was issued
by Member Secretary, West Bengal Pollution Control Board (WBPCB), on
8.12.2014 in prominent newspapers Viz. the Ananda Bazar Patrika local Bengali
News Paper and the Telegraph local English News Paper with project details
inviting suggestions, views, comments and objections from the public regarding
establishment of proposed project. The copies of the notification issued in
newspapers for public hearing are given below in Figure-7.1.
The EIA report along with Executive Summary in English and Bengali were
displayed and made available at the following places:
Further, one week before the public hearing, meetings and discussions were held
with the residents of the surrounding villages to familiarize them about the
project and proceedings of Public Hearing and briefed them about operations of
proposed project and allied development activities.
The Regional Officer briefed the public about the purpose of organizing the
hearing and assisted in smooth conduct of Public Hearing. The representative of
proposed project explained the salient features of project and specific reference
to the impacts on environment and its management.
After briefing the public about the project details by representative of M/s. NTPC-
SAIL and environmental details by consultant. They invited the public to express
their concerns, views and suggestions on this proposal. The minutes of the public
hearing is enclosed as Annexure-XIII.
FIGURE-7.1(A)
PAPER ADVERTISEMENT
FIGURE-7.1(B)
PAPER ADVERTISEMENT
All the issues raised by individuals and reply of project proponent are given in
Annexure-XIII. The summary of issues raised are grouped and discussed below
in Table-7.1.
TABLE-7.1
SUMMARY OF ISSUES RAISED ARE GROUPED AND DISCUSSED
Sr Issues raised by the Public Comment of the Action Plan with Estimated Budget
No Project Proponent
1 Smt. Kasturi Sengupta, WBCS (Exe), It has been noted and NSPCL expenditure for CSR in last 5
SDO, Durgapur opined that a review NSPCL will integrate years is listed in the table.
committee and grievance redressal the CSR activities as
cell should be formed at the sub- per the policies.
division level in order to oversee the Period Expenditure
proper fulfillment of CSR
commitments of different industries 2010-11 1358297
situated in and around Durgapur.
2011-12 1352882
2012-13 1692790
2013-14 3275327
2014-15 4250000
(ongoing)
2a Sri Apurba Mukherjee, Hon’ble Mayor Yes, all the pollution A provision of Rs. 18.1 Crores has been
of Durgapur Municipal Corporation control measures made for the Environment Management
(DMC) stated that Durgapur is an (ESP, Bag filters, Dust Plan the details are provided in section-
industrial area and the pollution level Suppression 4.8 of Chapter-4.
of the area is already very high; measures) are in
hence stringent pollution control place.
measures must be taken up by PP for
their proposed expansion project.
2b Sri Mukherjee further emphasized NSPCL will see that Proposed to spend Rs. 1.2 Crores on
that collective effort should there is no discharge water quality, monitoring and
immediately be initiated for de- into the river to avoid management
siltation of river Damodar and water pollution. NSPCL
industries should maintain their zero will participate in the
discharge norms in order to minimize Government
water pollution caused to River programmes and will
Damondar. donate for the noble
cause.
The treated
wastewater will be
used for dust
suppression, domestic
water will be used for
gardening
2c The Hon’ble Mayor also requested the NSPCL has a separate CSR plan for Rs. 62.5 lakhs per annum
NSPCL authorities to initiate extensive CSR wing with a will be prepared for the proposed project.
CSR activities. He opined that there Senior Official and
should be a subdivision level activities are being NSPCL has been consistently spending
committee to monitor the proper planned annually and CSR budget and the provision is
implementation of CSR commitments the budgeted amount enhanced during the year and will be
of industries situated in Durgapur and is spent for the cause. continued in next coming years.
its adjoining areas.
2d Lastly Sri Mukherjee expressed hope CSR activities under Expenses till : 119.29 lakhs
that the upcoming expansion project implementation will be Expenses proposed : 62.5 lakhs
will contribute to the overall socio- strengthen
economic development of durgapur.
3a Sri Pravat Chatterjee, Hon’ble Mayor- Thank you.
Sr Issues raised by the Public Comment of the Action Plan with Estimated Budget
No Project Proponent
in-Council of DMC welcomed the
project.
3b He also requested the PP to run their Yes, the regular Refer Point no. 2
pollution control devices effectively monthly monitoring
and initiate extensive CSR activity in works are in progress
consultation with the relevant district and will continue and
level committee in this regard. the reports are being
sent to regional MOEF
and Regional Pollution
Control Board office.
3c He finally thanked WBPCB for Noted. -----
conducting the public hearing and
thereby giving the common people of
the area to come up with their views,
queries and concerns about the
upcoming expansion project
4a Sri Lakhsman Mondal of Gopalmath Due care shall be Need based CSR plans will be developed
requested the PP to give priority to taken by NSPCL for and implemented in consultation with
villages which are situated adjacent to implementation of village level CSR committees.
their unit and mostly affected by various suggestions in
pollution generated from their process phased manner.
activities while executing CSR
activities.
4b He further requested the NSPCL The existing plant of As per the latest Fly ash notification all
authority to ensure proper utilization 2x60 MW has already the measures for the proposed plant will
of fly ash generated from their been following good be in place. An area of about 22 acres
process in order to minimize practices. The same has been allocated for ash disposal and
environmental nuisance created by shall be followed in an amount of Rs 10 crores has been
indiscriminate dumping of the same. the new plant and the allocated for ash pond and associated
concern of structures.
environmental
nuisance shall be
taken care by NSPCL.
4c Finally Sri Mondal thanked the PP for Thank you. An amount of Rs 30 lacs over a period of
their previous CSR activities and 5 years has been allocated for greenbelt
extensive plantation program. development.
5a Sri Srinibas Jana of B-Zone, Sri Manoj Thank you. ----
Kr. Bhattacharya of Ispatpally and Sri
Tapas Ghos of Baganpara welcomed
the project.
5b They requested the PP to ensure All the ESP, Bag filter Refer Point no. 2
proper functioning of pollution control and pollution control
devices and requested WBPCB to keep measures are in place
close vigil on the erring industries of and also adequate
the area in this regard. control measures are
designed to cater the
need of pollution
control. Monthly,
Quarterly and Annual
reports are always
being submitted to
WBPCB in time.
5c They also welcomed the idea of Noted. Refer Point no. 1
formation of a monitoring committee
to look after the proper
implementation of CSR commitments.
6a Sri Barun Paul and Smt. Kakoli of Thank you. -----
ward no.9 of DMC and Sri Soumen
Ghosh of J.C.Bose, Newtown
welcomed the project since it will
contribute towards overall
development of the neighboring area.
Sr Issues raised by the Public Comment of the Action Plan with Estimated Budget
No Project Proponent
6b They requested the PP to implement Noted. The CSR activities under the following
their CSR activities in order to ensure heads are carried out by Ms NSPCL in the
development of the relatively surrounding villages.
undeveloped local slums and village
areas. Education to Children
Health and Family Welfare
Women Empowerment
Infrastructural Facility
Aids for special Challenged
people
Promotion of sports and &
Cultural activities
6c They further requested the WBPCB to Noted. Refer Point no. 2
keep a strong vigil on the industries of
the area to provide a pollution free
environment to the local residents.
7 Sri Manas Mukherjee of ward no.9 of NSPCL is a power A request will be made to electrification
DMC requested the PP to arrange for generating company. board and municipal corporation as part
electrification of local slums through The CSR activities of CSR initiative for electrification of local
their CSR activities. shall be executed as slum
per company norms.
7.2.1 Introduction
Risk analysis follows an extensive hazard analysis. It involves the identification and
assessment of risks the neighboring populations are exposed to as a result of
hazards present. This requires a thorough knowledge of failure probability, credible
accident scenario, vulnerability of population etc. Much of this information is difficult
to get or generate. Consequently, the risk analysis is often confined to maximum
credible accident studies.
In the sections below, the identification of various hazards, probable risks in the
proposed power plant, maximum credible accident analysis, consequence analysis
are addressed which gives a broad identification of risks involved in the plant. The
Disaster Management Plan (DMP) has been presented.
Assess the overall damage potential of the identified hazardous events and the
impact zones from the accidental scenarios;
Assess the overall suitability of the site from hazard minimization and disaster
mitigation point of view;
Furnish specific recommendations on the minimization of the worst accident
possibilities; and
Preparation of broad Disaster Management Plan (DMP), On-site and Off-site
Emergency Plan, which includes Occupational and Health Safety Plan.
Identification of hazardous units and segments of plants and storage units based
on relative ranking technique, viz. Fire-Explosion and Toxicity Index (FE&TI).
Hazardous substances may be classified into three main classes; namely flammable
substances, unstable substances and toxic substances. The ratings for a large
number of chemicals based on flammability, reactivity and toxicity have been given
in NFPA Codes 49 and 345 M. The major hazardous materials to be stored,
transported, handled and utilized within the facility have been summarized in the
Table-7.2. The fuel storage details and properties are given in Table-7.3 and
Table-7.4 respectively.
TABLE-7.2
HAZARDOUS MATERIALS PROPOSED TO BE STORED/TRANSPORTED
TABLE-7.3
CATEGORY WISE SCHEDULE OF STORAGE TANKS
TABLE-7.4
PROPERTIES OF FUELS USED IN THE PLANT
7.4.1 Methodology
Thermal Plant
The nature of hazards that can occur at the thermal power plants of NSPCL-
Durgapur may be broadly classified in to two categories i.e. Natural and Man-
Made Hazards (Chemical Hazards).These are detailed below.
Natural Hazards
a. Earthquake;
b. Lighting Strike;
c. Dust Strom/Cyclone; and
d. Flash Floods.
Each of the above may constitute an emergency but it depends on their nature,
scale and speed end impact on environment.
Fire Hazard
Explosion Hazard
Release of Liquids
a. Fuel oil tanks in fuel oil handling section and Diesel tanks area;
b. Chemical tanks in water treatment plant; and
c. Ash dyke (bund failure).
Floods
No Smoking Zones
Fuel oil Handling Plant and Main Oil Tank areas in Main Plant;
CHP Conveyor & Crusher House;
Store Sheds / Cable storage areas/ Cable galleries;
Hydrogen Filling station/storage area;
Switch Gear rooms/ MCC rooms;
AVR Rooms;
Battery Rooms;
NR Relay Room; and
Control Rooms.
A preliminary hazard analysis is carried out initially to identify the major hazards
associated with storages and the processes of the plant. This is followed by
consequence analysis to quantify these hazards. Finally, the vulnerable zones are
plotted for which risk reducing measures are deduced and implemented. Preliminary
hazard analysis for fuel storage area and whole plant is given in Table-7.6. and
Table-7.7.
TABLE-7.6
PRELIMINARY HAZARD ANALYSIS FOR STORAGE AREAS
TABLE-7.7
PRELIMINARY HAZARD ANALYSIS FOR THE WHOLE PLANT IN GENERAL
Fire, Explosion and Toxicity Indexing (FE & TI) is a rapid ranking method for
identifying the degree of hazard. The application of FE & TI would help to make a
quick assessment of the nature and quantification of the hazard in these areas.
However, this does not provide precise information.
The degree of hazard potential is identified based on the numerical value of F&EI as
per the criteria given below:
Certain basic minimum preventive and protective measures are recommended for
the three hazard categories.
Based on the GOI Rules 1989, the hazardous fuels used by the proposed power
plant were identified. Fire and Explosion are the likely hazards, which may occur due
to the fuel storage. Hence, Fire and Explosion index has been calculated for in plant
storage. Estimates of FE&TI are given in Table-7.9.
TABLE-7.9
FIRE EXPLOSION AND TOXICITY INDEX
7.4.4 Conclusion
Results of FE&TI analysis show that the storage of LDO falls into Light category of
fire and explosion index with a Nil toxicity index.
The results of consequence analysis are useful for getting information about all
known and unknown effects that are of importance when some failure scenario
occurs in the plant and also to get information as how to deal with the possible
catastrophic events. It also gives the workers in the plant and people living in the
vicinity of the area, an understanding of their personal situation.
Fire Damage
A flammable liquid in a pool will burn with a large turbulent diffusion flame. This
releases heat based on the heat of combustion and the burning rate of the liquid. A
part of the heat is radiated while the rest is convected away by rising hot air and
combustion products. The radiations can heat the contents of a nearby storage or
process unit to above its ignition temperature and thus result in a spread of fire.
The radiations can also cause severe burns or fatalities of workers or fire fighters
located within a certain distance. Hence, it will be important to know beforehand the
damage potential of a flammable liquid pool likely to be created due to leakage or
catastrophic failure of a storage or process vessel. This will help to decide the
location of other storage/process vessels, decide the type of protective clothing the
workers/fire fighters, the duration of time for which they can be in the zone, the fire
extinguishing measures needed and the protection methods needed for the nearby
storage/process vessels. The damage effect on equipment and people due to
thermal radiation intensity is given in Table-7.10. Similarly, the effect of incident
radiation intensity and exposure time on lethality is given in Table-7.11.
TABLE-7.10
DAMAGE DUE TO INCIDENT RADIATION INTENSITIES
Sr. Incident Type of Damage Intensity
No. Radiation Damage to Equipment Damage to People
(kW/m2)
1 37.5 Damage to process equipment 100% lethality in 1 min.,
1% lethality in 10 sec.
2 25.0 Minimum energy required to ignite 100% Lethality in 1 min.,
wood at indefinitely long exposure Significant injury in 10 sec.
without a flame
3 12.5 Minimum energy required for 1% lethality in 1 min.
piloted ignition of wood, melting First degree burns in 10 sec
plastic tubing
4 4.0 -- Causes pain if duration is longer than
20 sec, however blistering is un-likely
(First degree burns)
5 1.6 -- Causes no discomfort on long
exposures
Source: Techniques for Assessing Industrial Hazards by World Bank
TABLE-7.11
RADIATION EXPOSURE AND LETHALITY
All values are given in KW/m2
Radiation Intensity Exposure Time Lethality (%) Degree of Burns
(KW/m2) (seconds)
1.6 -- 0 No Discomfort even
after long exposure
4.5 20 0 1st
4.5 50 0 1st
8.0 20 0 1st
8.0 50 <1 3rd
8.0 60 <1 3rd
12.0 20 <1 2nd
12.0 50 8 3rd
12.5 Inst 10 --
25.0 Inst 50 --
37.5 Inst 100 --
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C7-15
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-7
Additional Studies
The details of storages in the proposed power plant are given Table-7.2 above. In
case of fuel released in the area catching fire, a steady state fire will occur. Failures
in pipeline may occur due to corrosion and mechanical defect. Failure of pipeline due
to external interference is not considered as this area is licensed area and all the
work within this area is closely supervised with trained personnel.
7.4.6.2 Modeling Scenarios
Based on the storage and consumption of various fuels the following failure
scenarios for the proposed power plant have been identified for MCA analysis and
the scenarios are discussed in Table-7.12. The fuel properties considered in
modeling are given in Table-7.13.
TABLE-7.12
SCENARIOS CONSIDERED FOR MCA ANALYSIS
TABLE-7.13
PROPERTIES OF FUELS CONSIDERED FOR MODELING
Heat Radiation program ‘RADN’ has been used to estimate the steady state
radiation effect from storage of fuel at different distances. The model is based on
the equations compiled from various literatures by Prof.J.P.Gupta, Department of
Chemical Engineering, IIT Kanpur.
The results of MCA analysis are tabulated indicating the distances for various
damages identified by the damage criteria, as explained earlier. Calculations are
done for radiation intensities levels of 37.5, 25, 12.5, 4.5 and 1.6-kW/m2, which are
presented in Table-7.14 for different scenarios. The distances computed for various
scenarios are from the center of the pool fire.
TABLE-7.14
OCCURRENCE OF VARIOUS RADIATION INTENSITIES- POOL FIRE
The maximum capacity of storage of LDO tank will be 10 KL. The most credible
failure is the rupture of the largest pipe connecting to the storage tank. As the
worst case, it is assumed that the entire contents leak out into the dyke forming
a pool, which may catch fire on finding a source of ignition.
A perusal of the above table clearly indicates that 37.5 kW/m2 (100% lethality)
occurs within the radius of the pool which is computed at 2.9 m tank on pool fire.
This vulnerable zone will damage all fuel storage equipment falling within the pool
radius.
Similarly, the threshold limit for first degree burns is 1.6 kW/m2, this vulnerable
zone in which the thermal fluxes above the threshold limit for first degree is
restricted to 17.6 m in case tank on pool fire.
There will be one LDO storage tanks each of 10 KL capacity will be provided in the
LDO tank farm. The results of MCA analysis indicate that the maximum damage
distances for 12.5-Kw/m2 thermal radiations extends up to 5.4 m in the case of
10 KL on fire during worst meteorological conditions. As the fire resistant dyke
walls will be created, no cumulative effect of one tank farm on fire to create fire
on other tank farm is envisaged. The damage contours for tank on fire of two LDO
tanks is shown in Figure-7.2.
Coal dust when dispersed in air and ignited would explode. Crusher house and
conveyor systems are most susceptible to this hazard. To be explosive, the dust
mixture should have:
Particles dispersed in the air with minimum size (typical figure is 400
microns);
Dust concentrations must be reasonably uniform; and
Minimum explosive concentration for coal dust (33% volatiles) is 50 gm/m 3.
Dust explosions may occur without any warnings with Maximum Explosion
Pressure upto 6.4 bar. Another dangerous characteristic of dust explosions is that
it sets off secondary explosions after the occurrence of the initial dust explosion.
Many a times the secondary explosions are more damaging than primary ones.
The dust explosions are powerful enough to destroy structures, kill or injure
people and set dangerous fires likely to damage a large portion of the Coal
Handling Plant including collapse of its steel structure which may cripple the
lifeline of the power plant.
Stockpile areas shall be provided with automatic garden type sprinklers for dust
suppression as well as to reduce spontaneous ignition of the coal stockpiles.
Necessary water distribution network for drinking and service water with pumps,
piping, tanks, valves etc will be provided for distributing water at all transfer
points, crusher house, control rooms etc.
A centralized control room with microprocessor based control system (PLC) has
been envisaged for operation of the coal handling plant. Except for locally
controlled equipment like traveling tripper, dust extraction/ dust suppression /
ventilation equipment, sump pumps, water distribution system etc, all other in-
line equipment will be controlled from the central control room but will have
provision for local control as well. All necessary interlocks, control panels, MCC’s,
mimic diagrams etc will be provided for safe and reliable operation of the coal
handling plant.
The total quantity of coal shall be stored in separate stockpiles, with proper drains
around to collect washouts during monsoon season.
The various hazards associated, with the plant process apart from fuel storage have
been identified and are outlined in Table-7.15.
TABLE-7.15
HAZARD ANALYSIS FOR PROCESS IN POWER PLANT
The hazardous event scenarios likely to make the greatest contribution to the risk
of potential fatalities are summarized in Table-7.16. ‘Onsite facility’ refers to the
operating site at plant site, whereas ‘offsite facility’ refers to transport and
handling systems, which are away from the operating site.
TABLE-7.16
HAZARDOUS EVENTS CONTRIBUTING TO RISK AT ON-SITE FACILITY
The preliminary risk assessment has been completed for the proposed power
plant and associated facilities and the broad conclusions are as follows:
The hazardous event scenarios and risks in general at this facility can be
adequately managed to acceptable levels by performing the recommended
safety studies as part of detailed design, applying recommended control
strategies and implementing a Safety Management System.
E 8200
E 8300
E 8400
E 8500
E 8600
E 8100
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
N 19800 Chapter-7
Additional Studies
N 19700
N 19600
N 19500
E 8000
E 7200
E 7300
E 7400
E 7500
E 7600
E 7700
E 7800
E 7900
ARY
N 19400
UND
BO 2
DSP
N 19300
N 19200
0
149.0
N 19100 N 198120.00
E
11
20
4
5 8
N 19000
14 26
2 3 6
1 27
13 7 30
25
19
19 17 12
15
18
N 18900 16 29
N 18800
96.00
N 1878828.00 N 19002.00
N 18700 E E 8173.00
N 18600
FIGURE-7.2
DAMAGE CONTOUR FOR LDO TANK (1x10 KL) ON FIRE
Buildings and plant structures shall be designed for cyclone floods and seismic
events to prevent structural collapse and integrity of weather (water) proofing
for storage of dangerous goods;
Provision for adequate water capacity to supply fire protection systems and
critical process water;
Provision and integrity of process tanks, waste holding tanks and bunded
areas as per relevant standards;
Containment of hazardous materials;
Disasters can be divided into two main groups. In the first, are disasters resulting
from natural phenomena like earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, storm surges,
cyclones, tropical storms, floods, avalanches, landslides, forest fires. The second
group includes disastrous events occasioned by man, or by man's impact upon the
environment. Examples are armed conflict, industrial accidents, radiation accidents,
factory fires, explosions and escape of toxic gases or chemical substances, river
pollution, mining or other structural collapses, air, sea, rail and road transport
accidents which can reach catastrophic dimensions in terms of human loss.
There can be no set criteria for assessing the gravity of a disaster in the abstract
since this depends to a large extent on the physical, economic and social
environment in which it occurs. What would be consider a major disaster in a
developing country, ill equipped to cope with the problems involved, may not mean
more than a temporary emergency elsewhere. However, all disasters bring in their
wake similar consequences that call for immediate action, whether at the local,
national or international level, for the rescue and relief of the victims. This includes
the search for the dead and injured, medical and social care, removal of the debris,
the provision of temporary shelter for the homeless, food, clothing and medical
supplies, and the rapid re-establishment of essential services.
The Disaster Management Plan should reflect the probable consequential severalties
of the undesired event due to deteriorating conditions or through 'Knock on' effects.
Further the management should be able to demonstrate that their assessment of
the consequences uses good supporting evidence and is based on currently
available and reliable information, incident data from internal and external sources
and if necessary the reports of out side agencies.
7.5.3 Emergencies
The General Manager ,or Occupier who is designated as the Chief Incident
Controller, on receipt of information regarding the emergency inside the plant
premises will go to the Emergency Control Centre and will assume overall
responsibility for the factory/Storage site and its personnel. His responsibilities will
include:
5 To consult and liaise with senior officials of the government like fire brigade,
police, medical and the factories inspector through appropriate team leaders and
on the basis of the recommendation of team leaders provide advice to authorities
on possible harmful effects to neighboring population, staying outside the factory
premises. The overall action will be under the leadership of district
administration.
6 To inform CEO about the details of the disaster and arrangement made by him to
prevent loss of lives/property.
9 The corporate office assistance shall be sought as and when required depending
upon the severity of the situation.
The Additional General Manager and Factory Manager designed as the Work
Incident Controller on knowing about disaster, will immediately rush to the
incident site with appropriate safety measures.
2. He should assume the duty of the Chief Incident Controller pending the
latter’s arrival, in particular to:
3 His main function, however is to direct all operation at the scene of the
incident, e.g.
Rescue and firefighting operations, until the arrival of the fire brigade,
when he should hand over Control to a senior fire officer,
Search for casualties;
Evacuation of non-essential workers to assembly areas.
4 He should also:
6 Will take action to preserve the evidence for the further enquiry into the
cause and circumstances which caused or escalated the emergeny.
First Information
The first person who observe /identifies the hazardous incident shall inform by
shouting and going /running to nearest telephone (but while doing so, he will ensure
that he is not entering into area of hazards) and he will telephone to following in
terms of priority:
The emergencies that could be envisaged in the plant and fuel storage are as
follows:
Fire consequences can be disastrous, since they involve huge quantities of fuel
either stored or in dynamic inventory in pipelines or in nearby areas. Preliminary
hazard analysis has provided a basis for consequence estimation. Estimation can be
made by using various pool fire, tank fire consequence calculations. During the
study of risk assessment, the nature of damages is worked out and probability of
occurrence of such hazards is also drawn up.
Each Incident Controller, for himself, organizes a team responsible for controlling
the incidence with the personnel under his control. Shift-in-charge would be the
reporting officer, who would bring the incidence to the notice of the Incidence
Controller and Site Controller.
In each shift, electrical supervisor, electrical fitters, pump house in-charge, and
other maintenance staff would be drafted for emergency operations. In the event of
power or communication system failure, some of staff members in the office/plant
offices would be drafted and their services would be utilized as messengers for quick
passing of communications. All these personnel would be declared as essential
personnel.
Whoever notices an emergency situation such as fire, growth of fire, leakage etc
should inform his immediate superior and Emergency Control Center. A place nearer
to the Gate House Complex shall be identified as Emergency Control Center. The
person on-duty in the Emergency Control Center should appraise the Site Controller.
Site Controller verifies the situation from the Incident Controller of that area or the
Shift In-charge and takes a decision about an impending On Site Emergency. This
would be communicated to all the Incident Controllers, Emergency Co-ordinators.
Simultaneously, the emergency warning system would be activated on the
instructions of the Site Controller.
Works Incident Controller and other works personnel will have the key role to play
in providing advice and in implementing the decisions made by the Chief Incident
Controller (CIC).The key Personnel include the following:
Mechanical Maintenance;
Electrical Maintenance;
Control & Instruments; and
Chemical.
b. Head of personnel and officer connected with Industrial Relation and welfare
If necessary above personnel will decide the actions needed to shut down plants,
evacuate, personnel, Carryout emergency engineering works, arrange of supplies of
equipments, personnel etc., carryout atmosphere tests, provide catering facilities,
liaison with police, informing relatives of the victims, press media etc.
For the plants immediately affected or likely to be affected as decided by the Chief
Incident Controller/Works Incident Controller, efforts will be made for stepwise shut
down of the plant and to make process units safe. This work will be carried out by
plant supervisors and essential operators provided. They can do the same without
exposing themselves to undue risk. The following employees will also be required
to help in the above works:
Attendants;
First Aid;
Personnel for emergency engineering work such as for providing extra lighting
by passing of works etc;
Personnel acting as runners in case are communication difficulties;
Personnel for transporting equipments to the incident site from other parts of
the works; and
Personnel for maintaining plant entrance, in liaison with police, to direct
emergency vehicles to control traffic leaving the plant and to turn away or
make alternate arrangement for visitors and other traffic arriving at the plant.
It is the responsibility of the Works Incident Controller (WIC) to identify the above
essential staff and from a Task Force, which will report at defined location so that
they can be readily contacted. It is also the responsibility of the Works Incident
Controller to remove all non-essential staff to assembly points.
The teams along with their responsibilities and the list of their members constituted
to support CIC and WIC in effective management of an emergency situation are
detailed in the below sections.
Responsibility
Maintenance Team
Responsibility
Security Team
Responsibility
Responsibility
Safety Team
Responsibility
Medical Team
Responsibility
The head of personnel department, the head of materials department and the head
of finance are the members of this team.
Head of Personnel
Head of Materials
Head of Finance
This team will assist the WIC in manning communication and passing instruction
to the team or any other responsibility as given by WIC. The team may call any
and /or more persons depending upon the need.
In the event of failure of electric supply and thereby internal telephone, sets up
communication point and establishes contact with the ECC;
Organizes medical treatment to the injured and if necessary will shift the injured
to near by hospitals;
Mobilizes extra medical help from outside, if necessary;
Keeps a list of qualified first aid providers for the plant and seeks their
assistance;
Maintains first aid and medical emergency requirements;
Makes sure that all safety equipment is made available to the emergency team;
Assists Site Controller with necessary data to coordinate the emergency
activities;
Assists Site Controller in updating emergency plan, organizing mock drills,
verification of inventory of emergency facilities and furnishing report to Site
Controller;
Maintains liaison with Civil Administration;
Ensures availability of canteen facilities and maintenance of rehabilitation center.
Liaises with Site Controller/Incident Controller;
Ensures transportation facility;
Ensures availability of necessary cash for rescue/rehabilitation and emergency
expenditure;
Controls rehabilitation of affected areas on discontinuation of emergency; and
Makes available diesel/petrol for transport vehicles engaged in emergency
operation.
Intercom, telephone;
P and T telephone;
Self contained breathing apparatus;
Fire suit/gas tight goggles/gloves/helmets;
Hand tools, wind direction/velocities indications;
Public address megaphone, hand bell, telephone directories (internal, P and T)
Plant layout, site plan;
Emergency lamp/torch light/batteries;
Plan indicating locations of hazard inventories, plant control room, sources of
safety equipment, work road plan, assembly points, rescue location vulnerable
zones, escape routes;
Hazard chart;
Emergency shut-down procedures;
Nominal roll of employees;
List of key personnel, list of essential employees, list of Emergency
Coordinators;
Duties of key
personnel;
Number of assembly points, depending upon the plant location, would be identified
wherein employees who are not directly connected with the disaster management
would be assembled for safety and rescue. Emergency breathing apparatus,
minimum facilities like water etc would be organized.
In view of the size of plant, different locations would be ear marked as assembly
points. Depending upon the location of hazard, the assembly points are to be used.
a) Smoke Detector;
b) Temperature Detector; and
c) Gas Leakage Detector.
The plant protected against fire hazard by the following protection systems;
a) Fire hydrant System;
b) Sprinkler Systems for coal convey or belts and cable galleries;
c) Deluge water spray and emulsifier protection system for the transformer;
d) Fire alarm / detector system at various control room; and
e) Portable and mobile first aid fire extinguishers and Fire Tenders.
Wind socks shall be installed at appropriate places in the plant to indicate direction
of wind for emergency escape.
Stretchers, gas masks and general first-aid materials for dealing with chemical
burns, fire burns etc would be maintained in the medical center as well as in the
emergency control room. Medical superintendent of the medical center will be the
head of the casualty services ward. Private medical practitioners help would be also
be sought. Government hospital would be approached for emergency help.
Apart from plant first aid facilities, external facilities would be augmented. Names of
Medical Personnel, Medical facilities in the area would be prepared and updated.
Necessary specific medicines for emergency treatment of Patient’s Burns would be
maintained.
7.5.6.6 Ambulance
The emergency would be communicated both to the personnel inside the plant and
the people outside. An emergency warning system shall be established for this
purpose.
There are number of facilities, which can be provided to help deal with hazardous
conditions, when a tank is on fire. The suggested arrangements are:
1. Stop feed;
2. Dilute contents;
3. Remove heat;
4. Deluge with water; and
5. Transfer contents.
There could be a number of persons in the storage area and other areas in the
vicinity. The area would have adequate number of exits, staircases. In the event of
an emergency, unconnected personnel have to escape to assembly point. Operators
have to take emergency shutdown procedure and escape. Time Office shall maintain
a copy of deployment of employees in each shift at ECC. If necessary, persons can
be evacuated by rescue teams.
Also, at the end of an emergency, after discussing with Incident Controllers and
Emergency Co-ordinators, the Site Controller orders an all clear signal. When it
becomes essential, the Site Controller communicates to the District Emergency
Authority, Police, Fire Service personnel regarding help required or development of
the situation into an Off-Site Emergency. The on-site emergency organization chart
for various emergencies is shown in Figure-7.3.
7.5.8 General
The industrial disaster effects related to this plant may mostly be confined to the
plant area. The detailed risk analysis has indicated that the pool fire effects would
not be felt outside. However, as an abundant precaution, the information related to
fuels in use would be furnished to District Emergency Authority for necessary
dissemination to general public and for any use during an off site emergency. Plants
of this size and nature have been in existence in our country for a long time.
In the event of an emergency developing into an off site emergency, local authority
and District Emergency Authority (normally the Collector) would be appraised and
under his supervision, the Off Site Disaster Management Plan would be exercised.
For this purpose, the facilities that are available locally, i.e. medical, transport,
personnel, rescue accommodation, voluntary organizations etc would be mustered.
Necessary rehearsals and training in the form of mock drills would be organized.
Mutual aid in the form of technical personnel, runners, helpers, special protective
equipment, transport vehicles, communication facility etc would be sought from the
neighboring industries.
Once the Plant goes on stream, important information such names and addresses of
key personnel, essential employees, medical personnel outside the plant,
transporters address, address of those connected with Off Site Emergency such as
Police, Local Authorities, Fire Services, District Emergency Authority would be
prepared and maintained.
The task of preparing the Off-Site Emergency Plan lies with the District Collector;
however the off-site plan will be prepared with the help of the local district
authorities. The proposed plan will be based on the following guidelines.
7.6.1 Introduction
Off-site emergency plan would follow the on-site emergency plan. When the
consequences of an emergency situation go beyond the plant boundaries, it
becomes an off-site emergency. Off-site emergency is essentially the responsibility
of the public administration. However, the plant management will provide the public
administration with the technical information relating to the nature, quantum and
probable consequences on the neighboring population.
The off-site plan in detail will be based on those events, which are most likely to
occur, but other less likely events, which have severe consequence, will also be
considered. Incidents which have very severe consequences yet have a small
probability of occurrence would also be considered during the preparation of the
plan. However, the key feature of a good off-site emergency plan is flexibility in its
application to emergencies other than those specifically included in the formation of
the plan.
FIGURE-7.3
ON-SITE EMERGENCY ORGANIZATION CHART
The roles of the various parties who will be involved in the implementation of an off-
site plan are described below. Depending on local arrangements, the responsibility
for the off-site plan would either rest with the plant management or with the local
authority. Either way, the plan would identify an emergency coordinating officer,
who would take the overall command of the off-site activities. As with the on-site
plan, an emergency control center would be setup within which the emergency
coordinating officer can operate.
In the case of a major fire but without explosion risk (e.g. an oil storage tank),
only houses close to the fire are likely to need evacuation, although a severe
smoke hazard may require this to be reviewed periodically; and
Although the plan will have sufficient flexibility built in to cover the consequences of
the range of accidents identified for the on-site plan, it will cover in some detail the
handling of the emergency to a particular distance from each major hazard works.
The main aspects, which should be included in the emergency plan are:
Organization
Detail of command structure, warning systems, implementation procedures,
emergency control centers.
Names and appointments of incident controller, site main controller, their deputies
and other key personnel.
Communications
Specialized Knowledge
Details of specialist bodies, firms and people upon whom it may be necessary to call
e.g. those with specialized fuel knowledge, laboratories etc.
Voluntary Organizations
Fuel Information
Details of the hazardous substances stored and a summary of the risk associated
with them.
Meteorological Information
Humanitarian Arrangements
Public Information
Arrangements for (a) Dealing with the media press office; (b) Informing relatives,
etc.
Assessment of Emergency Plan
Arrangements for:
The duty to prepare the off-site plan lies with the local authorities. The emergency
planning officer (EPO) appointed should carry out his duty in preparing for a whole
range of different emergencies within the local authority area. The EPO should
liaison with the plant, to obtain the information to provide the basis for the plan.
This liaison should ensure that the plan is continually kept upto date.
It will be the responsibility of the EPO to ensure that all those organizations which
will be involved off site in handling the emergency, know of their role and are able
to accept it by having for example, sufficient staff and appropriate equipment to
Formal duties of the police during an emergency include protecting life and property
and controlling traffic movements.
The control of a fire should be normally the responsibility of the senior fire brigade
officer who would take over the handling of the fire from the site incident controller
on arrival at the site. The senior fire brigade officer should also have a similar
responsibility for other events, such as explosions. Fire authorities in the region
should be apprised about the location of all stores of flammable materials, water
and foam supply points, and fire-fighting equipment. They should be involved in on-
site emergency rehearsals both as participants and, on occasion, as observers of
exercises involving only site personnel.
For major fires, injuries should be the result of the effects of thermal radiation to a
varying degree, and the knowledge and experience to handle this in all but extreme
cases may be generally available in most hospitals.
Major off-site incidents are likely to require medical equipment and facilities
additional to those available locally, and a medical "mutual aid” scheme should exist
to enable the assistance of neighboring authorities to be obtained in the event of an
emergency.
This will be the factory inspectorate available in the region. Inspectors are likely to
satisfy themselves that the organization responsible for producing the off-site plan
has made adequate arrangements for handling emergencies of all types including
major emergencies. They may wish to see well-documented procedures and
evidence of exercise undertaken to test the plan.
In the event of an accident, local arrangements regarding the role of the factory
inspector will apply. These may vary from keeping a watching brief to a close
involvement in advising on operations.
The action plan suggested for control of the off-site emergencies is given in Table-
7.17.
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C7-40
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-7
Additional Studies
TABLE-7.17
OFF-SITE ACTION PLAN
H1 Representatives of all departments are in Local Crises Must have all resources at
the local crisis group; therefore they are Group hand, specially disaster
expected to render services available with management plan and its
them. Since it is a group of experts with implementation method.
authority, the mitigating measures can be All relevant information
implemented speedily. The related to hazardous industry
representatives from locals are also there shall available with crisis
so that communication with local people group
is easy and quick. Newspaper editor shall be a
2 The district emergency or disaster control part of the group so that
officer / collector shall be the president right and timely media
and he shall do mock drill etc so that release can be done
action can be taken in right direction in
For large industries, where multifarious activities are involved during construction,
erection, testing, commissioning, operation and maintenance; the men, materials
and machines are the basic inputs. Along with the boons, industrialization generally
brings several problems like occupational health and safety.
The industrial planner, therefore, has to properly plan and take steps to minimize
the impacts of industrialization and to ensure appropriate occupational health and
safety including fire plans. All these activities again may be classified under
construction and erection, and operation and maintenance.
The occupational health problems envisaged at this stage can mainly be due to
constructional accident and noise. To overcome these hazards, in addition to
arrangements to reduce it within TLV's, necessary protective equipments shall be
supplied to workers.
Boiler suit;
Safety belt/line man's safety belt;
Leather hand gloves;
Acid/Alkali proof rubberized hand gloves;
Canvas cum leather hand gloves with leather palm;
Electrically tested electrical resistance hand gloves; and
Industrial safety shoes with steel toe and fiber toe (electrical).
Full-fledged hospital facilities shall be available round the clock for attending
emergency arising out of accidents, if any. All working personnel shall be medically
examined at least once in every year and at the end of his term of employment.
This is in addition to the pre-employment medical examination.
Safety of both men and materials during construction and operation phases is of
concern. Safety plan shall be prepared and implemented in the proposed power
plant. The preparedness of an industry for the occurrence of possible disasters is
known as emergency plan. The disaster in the plant is possible due to collapse of
structures and fire/explosion etc.
of employees;
To prepare separate safety rules for each type of occupation/processes involved
in a plant; and
To ensure regular safety inspection by a competent person at suitable intervals
of all buildings, equipments, work places and operations.
A full-fledged training center shall be set up at the plant. Safety training shall be
provided by the Safety Officers with the assistance of faculty members called from
Professional Safety Institutions and Universities. In addition to regular employees,
limited contractor labors shall also be provided safety training. To create safety
awareness safety films shall be shown to workers and leaflets shall be distributed.
Some precautions and remedial measures proposed to be adopted to prevent fires
are:
Reliable and dependable type of fire detection system with proper zoning and
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C7-44
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-7
Additional Studies
interlocks for alarms are effective protection methods for conveyor galleries;
The health of all employees shall be monitored once in a year for early detection of
any ailment due to exposure to heat and noise.
If an accident takes place in NSPCL-Durgapur units and its effects are felt outside its
premises, the situation thus created is called and OFF-Site emergency. In this
situation it is no longer remains the concern of the factory management alone but
also becomes a concern for the general public living outside. To meet such
situations, OFF-Site emergency plans are to be prepared as stipulated and put into
operation as & when required.
This section of the plan details how emergency related to major accidents inside the
plan should be dealt with, by the concerned district authorities. Wherever required
the concerned district authority can consult the General Manager and /or other
persons who would be concerned with the execution of emergency management
plan. The management of NSPCL-Durgapur shall provide all necessary information
to the concerned district authorities related to its industrial activities under their
respective control.
The following conditions can contribute and should be noted by all concerned in
respect of the accidents which can demand involvement of outside agencies:
1. Major fire involving combustible material like LDO (light Diesel Oil) storage and
or/Coal.
Note: The outside agencies will be involved for the emergency situation which has
potential to cause impacts beyond the plant premises. The hydrogen used in turbo
generator coolers impacts beyond the plant premises. The hydrogen used in turbo
generator coolers is stored and /or handled in small quantities. Thus the emergency
situations due to hydrogen storage or handling have not been considered for the
involvement of any outside agencies.
7.8.3 Communication
The people of the area and large number of media representatives would like to
know about the situation from time to time and respond of the District authority to
the crisis. It is important to give timely credible information to the public in order to
prevent panic and rumor. The spread of emergency public information could be
carried out in following three phases with the support of relation department of
industry and the district.
FIGURE 7.4
COMMUNICATION NETWORK
7.8.5 Warning
However depending upon the nature of hazards and the area affected, concerned
district authority may explore the use of other method of warning if required. The
details of these methods are as follows:
TABLE-7.18
EMERGENCY CONTACT NUMBER
During construction phase, the proposed power project will benefit the region in
following manner:
The proposed power project will generate employment opportunities to the local
populace during construction phase.
The total manpower requirement during construction is about 150 people. This
will last for approximately six months. Unskilled/semi-skilled labour for the plant
would be drawn locally or from nearby places. The employment of local personnel
in skilled and executive staff category will depend on availability and suitability of
individuals.
8.1.2 Transportation
As the labours / workmen are generally un-skilled, the locals will get
opportunities for employment during construction activities. Construction and
operational phase some in-migration will happen. They need shelters because of
that local people will earn some money through rent from migrated people. In
addition to the opportunity of getting employment as construction laborers, the
local population also would get have employment opportunities in related service
activities like petty commercial establishments, small contracts/sub-contracts and
supply of construction materials for buildings and ancillary infrastructures etc.
Consequently, this may lead to economic up-liftment of the area.
The proposed project is expected to create full time as well as part time job
opportunities to the local population through direct and indirect employment.
The living conditions are expected to improve due to improvement in income
levels.
The food security is ensured due to regular income and other welfare
measures
Children, old aged and other vulnerable groups would get welfare services
like, education, scholarships, nutrition and health
The improvement in education facilities would impact on overall literacy rate
in the area.
The overall health environment is expected to improve due to health services,
awareness programs and food security through improvement in livelihood.
It is expected that the marginalized communities like SCs and STs would be
given priority in employment and other corporate social responsibility
measures, which will reduce the socio- economic disparities.
Health
Infrastructure
Employment
• During the construction and operation period, project would have significant
requirement for masons, plumbers, electricians, carpenters, fitters, welders,
security personnel, other miscellaneous services in canteen, plantation,
drivers, housekeeping etc.;
• During construction phase, project would employ about 150 skilled, semi-
skilled and unskilled laborers; and
• During operational phase, power plant would employ more than 70 personnel.
TABLE-8.1
CSR EXPENDITURE
FOR THE YEARS 2010 to 2015
TABLE-8.2
BUDGET BREAKUP OF CSR ACTIVITIES
FIGURE-8.1(A)
CSR PHOTOGRAPHS
FIGURE-8.1(B)
CSR PHOTOGRAPHS
In case the monitored results of environmental pollution are found to exceed the
allowable limits, the Environmental Management Cell will suggest remedial action
and get these suggestions implemented through the concerned authorities.
The Environmental Management Cell also co-ordinates all the related activities
such as collection of statistics of health of workers and population of the region,
afforestation and greenbelt development.
GENERAL MANAGER/
BUSINESS UNIT HEAD
ENVIRONMENT ECOLOGIST/
SAFETY OFFICER
ENGINEER HORTICULTURIST
FIGURE-9.1
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE OF ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT
The proposed captive power plant project falls under ‘Category B’, as per
Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) notification dated 14th September 2006
which requires preparation of EIA Report to get Environmental Clearance (EC)
from the State Pollution Control Board, West Bengal. The Terms of Reference
(TOR) for the proposed project was issued by MoEF, vide letter no. J-
13012/30/2013-IA.I (T) dated 7th May 2014.
• Land Requirement
Land requirement for the proposed captive power plant is around 35.5 is already
in industrial use. The proposed power plant will be built within the existing plant
premises hence no change in land use. No additional land acquisition for the
power plant. Hence, there will not be any Resettlement & Rehabilitation issues
involved for the proposed power plant.
• Fuel Requirement
Coal requirement for the proposed 2x20 MW power plant will be about 0.3 MTPA
(Indian coal).
• Water Requirement
The water requirement for the proposed plant is 300 m3/day, which will be met
from existing Durgapur Steel Plant (DSP) network which is fed from Waria
reservoir of DSP.
• Manpower
The total manpower requirement during construction stage will be about 150 nos
and during operation phase requirement will be about 70 nos. including skilled
and unskilled workers.
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C10-1
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-10
Summary & Conclusion
A total of five samples within the study area were collected and analyzed. It has
been observed that the pH of the soil quality ranged from 7.5 to 8.2 indicating
that the soil is moderately alkaline in nature. The conductivity was observed to be
in the range of 175 to 250 µS/cm. Available potassium was observed to be in the
range of 224.8 kg/ha to 465 kg/ha. The nitrogen values range between 54.6
kg/ha to 98.6 kg/ha and the phosphorus values observed in sampling locations
varies between 62.9 kg/ha to 126.5 kg/ha.
The meteorological parameters were recorded on hourly basis during the study
period near proposed plant site and comprises of parameters like wind speed,
wind direction (from 0 to 360 degrees), temperature, relative humidity,
atmospheric pressure, rainfall and cloud cover.
TABLE-10.1
AMBIENT AIR QUALITY IN 10-KM RADIUS AROUND THE PROJECT SITE
IN PRE-MONSOON, 2014
Sr. No Parameters Range of Conc., µg/m3 NAAQM Standards, µg/m3
1 PM2.5 21.3-43.8 60
2 PM10 48.1-80.4 100
3 SO2 10.6-26.3 80
4 NOx 15.7-36.1 80
5 CO 318-568 2000
6 O3 5.0-17.5 100
The pH of the water samples collected ranges between 7.3 to 7.5 and
conductivity recorded in between 283 µs/cm to 407 µs/cm in the sample. The
Total Dissolved Solids was observed about 180 mg/l to 260 mg/l. The Chlorides
and Sulphates were found 51.5 mg/l to 75.8 mg/l and 14.5 mg/l to 17.0 mg/l
respectively.
The pH of the water samples collected was observed to be in the range of 7.5 and
7.6. The conductivity was found to be 555 µs/cm and 665 µs/cm. Total Hardness
of the samples ranged from 151 mg/l to 174 mg/l. Calcium and Magnesium
concentrations ranged from 34 mg/l - 40 mg/l and 16 mg/l -18 mg/l respectively.
Range of Chlorides and Sulphates concentrations at all the locations 100 mg/l -
123 mg/l and 18.5 mg/l – 19.0 mg/l respectively. Fluoride concentrations are
ranging in between 0.4 mg/l and 0.5 mg/l and are found to be within the
permissible limits. The results of ground and surface water quality are well within
limits.
The noise monitoring has been conducted for determination of noise levels at ten
locations in the study area. Noise monitoring results reveal ambient noise levels in
all locations are well within the limits as per Ambient Noise standards.
• The daytime noise levels at all the locations are observed to be within the range
of 43.8 dB(A) to 51.2 dB (A).
• The night time noise levels at all the locations were found to be in the range of
40.9 dB (A) to 48.0 dB (A).
67 animal species were recorded/ observed during study period. It can be concluded
that there are about 6 species which belong to Sch-II and 1 species belong to Sch-
III, 52 species which belong to Sch-IV and 8 species which belong to Sch-V of
Wildlife Protection Act, 1972.
10.4 Anticipated Environmental Impacts and Mitigation Measures
Adequate stack heights have been provided to disperse gaseous emissions over a
wider area. In order to control emissions of Particulates adequate control
equipment are proposed.
VIMTA Labs Limited, Hyderabad C10-3
Environmental Impact Assessment for the Proposed Durgapur Captive Power
Project-III (2x20 MW) at Durgapur, District Burdwan in West Bengal
Chapter-10
Summary & Conclusion
Prediction of impacts on air environment has been carried out by using AERMOD
and the resultant ground level concentrations for PM10, SO2 and NOx would be as
80.74 µg/m3, 35.98 µg/m3 and 37.34 µg/m3. After the implementation of the
proposed expansion project, these concentrations are found to be below the
permissible NAAQS norms for rural/residential zone and industrial/mixed zone.
Therefore, the proposed activity is not likely to have any significant adverse
impact on the air environment.
The total water requirement for the proposed captive power plant will be about
300m3/day. The source of water for proposed plant will be from existing Durgapur
Steel Plant (DSP) network which is fed from Waria reservoir of DSP. The treated
CPP wastewater will be re-cycled back for use in greenbelt development. The
domestic wastewater will be treated and utilized for green belt development and
dust suppression.
The proposed plant contains number of items of heavy equipment such as fans,
engines, generators, and turbines. There will be associated road or rail traffic,
including truck movement and loading equipment. Noise and vibration is greater
from heavy truck traffic associated with operations and transport of raw materials
and finished product.
The details of the solid waste generated in the plant are given in Table-10.2.
TABLE-10.2
EXPECTED SOLID WASTE FROM POWER PLANT (WORST CASE SCENERIO)
Sr. No. Plant Proposed Mode of Disposal
1 Ash 1,20,000 TPA
2 Bottom ash 24,000 TPA Silo for dry form and wet disposal to
3 Fly ash 98,000 TPA ash dyke
4 Used oil 2 KL Sold to authorised Recycler
5 Domestic solid 500 kg/month Vermi Composting
waste/Municipal
solid waste
ETP of 1 KL and STP of 2.5 KL capacity are proposed. The ash generated in the
plant will be supplied to potential users. The Sludge from sewage treatment plant
will be dried and used as manure for greenbelt maintenance. Canteen/sanitary
waste will be composted and used as manure for greenbelt development.
With the implementation of above precautionary measures, the impacts due to
solid waste disposal are insignificant on environment.
Impact on Ecology
increase the presence of avifauna and related faunal components which a positive
impact over the project.
Fugitive and stack emissions from the power plant will contribute to increase in
concentrations of PM, SO2, and NOx pollutants. The mitigative measures
recommended in the plant are:
• Installation of ESP followed Fabric filter (Hybrid ESP) of efficiency more than
99.9% to limit the PM concentrations below 50 mg/Nm3;
• Provision of tall stack of 75 m height for wider dispersion of gaseous emissions;
• Provision of water sprinkling system at raw material storage yard;
• Asphalting of the roads within the plant area;
• Provision of dust extraction systems at dust generating source;
• Developing of greenbelt around the plant to arrest the fugitive emissions; and
• Online flue gas monitors as well as flue gas flow rates and temperature
measurement shall be provided for all stacks;
The design features provided to ensure low noise levels are as follows:
• All rotating machinery will be well lubricated and provided with enclosures as
far as possible to reduce noise transmission;
• Provision of silencers will be made wherever possible;
• The insulation provided for prevention of loss of heat and personnel safety will
also act as noise reducers;
• Necessary enclosures will also be provided on the working platforms/areas to
provide local protection in high noise level areas;
• The workers will be provided with ear plugs; and
• Plantation in the zone between plant and township would attenuate noise in
the residential area.
All the solid waste generated will be reused either in process or in ancillary
operations.
Greenbelt Development
Due care will be taken to ensure that a greenbelt is developed around the plant.
All areas devoid of vegetation and having low density will be systematically and
scientifically afforested. In the proposed greenbelt about 12000 trees will be
planted with a density of 2500 trees/ha.
10.7 Conclusion
The proposed captive power plant will have marginal impacts on the local
environment with proper mitigation measures with the effective implementation
of the environment management measures as suggested in the EIA/EMP report
and as recommended by MoEF & CC, CPCB and State Pollution Control Board, the
negative impacts will be minimized to a great extent. However, development of
this project has beneficial impact/effects in terms growth in regional economy,
transform the region's economy from predominantly agricultural to significantly
industrial, increase Government earnings and revenues and accelerate the pace
of industrial development in the region.
Thus, in view of considerable benefits from the project without any adverse
environmental impact, the proposed project is most advantageous to the region
as well as to the nation.
11.1 Introduction
Studies were carried out by several institutions of different disciplines during the
preparation of the EIA/EMP report based on the Expert Appraisal Committee
(EAC) prescribed Terms of Reference. The list of consultants involved in different
studies is given below:
The Environment Division has been in the forefront of its vision to provide
better environment through guiding and assisting the industry for sustainable
development. A stalwart in the mission to protect and preserve the natural
resources on earth for future generations, it offers extensive research and
consultancy services in the field of environment. With its rich experience, multi-
disciplinary expertise and with the support of its state-of the-art analytical
equipment, the services offered by the division are wide ranging and
encompasses entire gamut of environment management and monitoring services.
With its emphasis on quality services over the years, it has evolved itself into a
single reference point in India for comprehensive environmental services.
• Vimta shall provide the services in accordance with national and international
norms;
• Vimta shall implement quality systems as per ISO/IEC 17025 and applicable
Good Laboratory Practices (GLPs) & Good Clinical Practices (GCPs), to
generate technically valid results/data; and
• Vimta shall ensure that all its personnel familiarize with the policies and
procedures of the quality system and implement the same in their work.
Spread over 70,000 sq.ft lush green garden premises at Cherlapally, Hyderabad
(India), the scientifically designed and meticulously groomed infrastructural
facility of the Central Laboratory of VIMTA has the most sophisticated
instruments backed by an excellent team of professionals.
Over 150,000 sq. ft. of world class research laboratory is also under operation at
Biotech Park-Genome Valley, Hyderabad (India). Having all the facilities under
one roof is perhaps the only one of its kind in South Asia in the contract testing
and research sector.
VIMTA Central Laboratory, Cherlapally, Hyderabad VIMTA Life Sciences, Genome Valley, Hyderabad
• Environment;
• Analytical;
• Clinical Reference Lab;
• Clinical Research;
• Preclinical;
• Molecular Biology; and
• Research and Development.
The environment division of VIMTA Labs Limited (VLL) has its presence all over
India and other countries including a strong association with international
consultants like Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC), Kennametal
Inc.-USA, Rudal Blanchard–UK, E&E Solutions–Japan, NAPESCO & Kuwait
National Petroleum Corporation–Kuwait, Marafiq and Haif Consultants–Saudi
Arabia and others. Vimta Labs Limited has the following credentials:
samplers, noise meters, portable water kits etc, the other major specialized
equipment include:
The basic fact that environment division and its supporting site laboratories are
accredited by NABL (IS0-17025) and Ministry of Environment and Forests, India
and by other international bodies stand testimony to its emphasis on Quality
Systems.
11.2.7 Achievements
Being the first laboratory to be recognized under Environment Protection (EP) Act
by Government of India (GOI), environment division with its best mind power and
industrial knowledge competency that allows it to compare with the best in the
business.
• The environment division till date has executed about 650 environmental
impact assessment and environment management studies with risk
assessment and disaster management plans for various spectrum of industries
and obtained statutory approvals;
• Undertaken environmental impact assessment studies for pulp and paper mill
expansion of Mufindi Paper Mills, Tanzania, Africa; and