Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stevens 2009
Stevens 2009
Nicole M. Stevens, DPT, Terry Shultz, MPT, Ryan L. Mizner, MPT, PhD,
and Meryl Gersh, PT, PhD
The purpose of this article is to describe a multifaceted saline irrigation, patient education, and dressing
approach to wound care in an outpatient setting for a changes during 9 treatment sessions. The patient’s total
patient with an infected, nonhealing surgical wound wound surface area decreased from 5.2 cm × 17.3 cm
with hypergranulation tissue following fasciotomy to 4 cm × 15 cm with increased epithelialization from
for acute compartment syndrome. A 44-year-old male approximately 40% to 85% after 29 days of treatment.
underwent an anterior and lateral lower extremity com- This article demonstrates the positive effect of a multi-
partment fasciotomy and developed a persistent right faceted approach for facilitation of wound healing in a
anterolateral lower leg wound. Thirty-six days after fas- lower extremity wound following fasciotomy.
ciotomy he came to the authors’ clinic after 2 failed skin
grafts with an infected wound covered in hypergranu- Keywords: wound healing; infection; granulation tis-
lation tissue. Treatment included sharp debridement, sue; silver application
I
nfected surgical wounds have a profound effect hydrocolloid. They also noted minimal cytotoxic
on a patient’s health. For example, surgical site effects with both dressings.
infections increase the length of stay in a hospi- Sharp debridement is a generally accepted
tal by 7.5 days, and treatment of an infected wound method for the removal of devitalized tissue; however,
ranges from $3000 to $26 000.1 Infection increases there is little evidence to support its efficacy.11,12
the risk of mortality, causes delayed healing time, Patients who received sharp debridement were found
and leads to extension of the inflammatory process.2-5 to have a total decrease in mean ulcer surface area of
Surgical site infections are reported to occur after 7.4 cm2 compared with a 1.3 cm2 increase in the con-
approximately 2.7% of all operations,6 and following trol group in a study by Williams et al.12
fasciotomies, wound infection rates have been Hypergranulation tissue can delay wound heal-
reported to be as high as 25%.7 ing impeding epithelialization across the wound
There is some evidence to support the use of sil- bed.13,14 In a study by Harris and Rolstad,15 a
ver when treating infected wounds.2-4,8-10 A study by polyurethane foam dressing was found to reduce
Schaller et al8 found that the use of a silver-based the presence of hypergranulation tissue in wound
hydrocolloid dressing was superior in reducing bac- beds and decrease the size of the subjects’ wounds
terial cells and edema in reconstituted human significantly.15 P value <0.01 Foam was also found
epithelium when compared with a non-silver-based to be less painful and more cost effective when
compared with gauze.16 A large randomized control
study (n = 99) conducted by Andersen et al17 found that
From Rockwood Clinic, Spokane (NMS); Lourdes Medical wound healing time was similar when comparing a
Center, Pasco (TS); Department of Physical Therapy, Eastern
Washington University, Spokane (RLM, MG), Washington. polyurethane foam dressing with a hydrocellular dress-
ing. However, polyurethane foam managed drainage
Address correspondence to: Nicole M. Stevens, DPT, Rockwood
Clinic, 605 E Holland Ave, Ste 112, Spokane, WA 99218; e-mail: better and therefore required less frequent dressing
neager@u.washington.edu. changes.17
37
Few studies appear to have focused on non- total hip arthroplasty, and a cholecystectomy. His
healing surgical incisions, which is surprising con- platelet count on the date of the initial injury
sidering the reports on lower extremity wounds of was 65 000 (normal range, 150 000-350 000). A
vascular etiology. The purpose of this case report is Doppler ultrasound at the initial date of injury was
to describe an evidence-based approach to wound negative for deep vein thrombosis. The patient was
care in an outpatient setting for a patient with an taking propoxyphene and acetaminophen (Darvocet;
infected, nonhealing surgical wound with hyper- Xanodyne Pharmaceuticals, Newport, KY) to help
granulation tissue status post fasciotomy secondary relieve the pain. One of the side effects of aceta-
to acute compartment syndrome of the lower leg minophen is anticoagulation.18 The patient’s history
using the aforementioned treatment methods. of thrombocytopenia necessitated vigilant attention
being paid to excessive blood loss during treatment.
Case History Darvocet was replaced with hydrocodone approxi-
mately halfway through the treatment program after
This case report describes a 44-year-old male who was it began giving the patient stomach pain.
diagnosed in the emergency room with an acute onset, The wound had a malodor that was noticeable
nontraumatic compartment syndrome of the right from a distance of approximately 60 cm. A culture of
lower leg. The onset was thought to have been caused the wound was taken following saline irrigation by
by a bleed into the anterior compartment of the lower swabbing the wound surface with a sterile swab. The
leg, which increased compartment pressure and even- wound culture was positive for Enterobacter cloacae
tually led to arterial occlusion of the anterior tibial and Staphylococcus aureus infection. After receiving
artery. The patient was taken to the operating room results of a positive wound culture the patient started
where he underwent an anterior and lateral compart- taking antibiotics, sulfamethoxazole and trimetho-
ment fasciotomy. During the fasciotomy a skin incision prim (Bactrim DS; AR Scientific, Philadelphia, PA).
was made down the right anterolateral lower leg. This class of drugs can lead to blood disorders, such
Following the initial surgery, the patient under- as thrombocytopenia, which increased the risk of
went 3 surgical interventions: 2 split-thickness skin excessive blood loss during treatment.18
grafts, one 8 days after surgery and the other 24 days The periwound tissue was irritated and had non-
after surgery, and surgical debridement under anes- pitting edema. Girth measurements, measured by
thesia 22 days after surgery. These procedures were circumferential tape measurements, of 26 cm and
unsuccessful; however, some portions of the skin 35 cm, were taken at the malleoli and 15 cm above
graft healed over approximately 40% of the wound. the malleoli on the right, respectively.
The patient’s leg was placed in an Unna boot. Thirty- Approximately 25% to 50% of the wound bed
six days after the fasciotomy, the patient presented showed loosely to firmly adherent yellow slough.
to our physical therapy clinic with an infected, non- Under the slough, approximately 60% of the wound
healing wound with hypergranulation tissue on the bed was filled with bright, beefy red hypergranulation
right anterolateral lower leg. tissue that was elevated 1 to 2 mm above the wound
The patient lived with his wife in an apartment. bed. The remaining 40% was covered by epithelial
He was retired and occasionally cared for his grand- tissue that healed from the skin graft. The wound had
children. During the initial examination, the patient a moderate amount of serosanguinous and yellow
was alert and oriented to person, place, time, and purulent drainage that required management. The
situation and was able to follow multistep direc- wound edges were raised and rolled under.
tions. The patient was independent in all activities Measurements of the wound on the right antero-
of daily living and instrumental activities of daily lateral lower leg were 5.2 cm at the widest point and
living and was able to care for his grandchildren on an 17.3 cm at the longest point. Photo documentation
as needed basis. He did not use any assistive devices was also used as an objective way to document the
prior to his injury. He did not smoke, occasionally visual changes in the wound bed’s color and texture
consumed alcohol, and did not exercise regularly. over the course of treatment.5 Figure 1 shows a
The patient had a past history of cocaine abuse, but photo of the wound on the right anterolateral lower
denied current drug abuse. leg at the initial examination.
The patient’s medical history included thrombo- The 2 donor graft areas on the right anterior
cytopenia, hepatitis C, gunshot wounds to the right thigh were fully epithelialized and healing well. The
leg and hip years prior to the recent surgery, a right grafts were harvested 28 days and 12 days before the
chances for healing were predicted to be good. with his physician. During this visit the patient
Heemskerk and Kitslaar7 reported that subjects who received silver nitrate cauterization to the remaining
were less than 60 years were found to have signifi- open areas of the wound. For this reason, only dress-
cantly better outcomes after fasciotomies than older ing changes were performed on the ninth visit.
subjects. P value = 0.010 We paid careful attention to the moisture level
The goals of treatment set at initial examination, in the wound bed because the patient had moder-
to be achieved within 3 to 4 weeks, were ate amounts of exudate that required absorption.
However, areas of epithelialization were at risk of
1. Complete removal of necrosis becoming too dry. To adjust the moisture level in the
2. Increased epithelialization to 75% to 100% of wound, we used a combination of petrolatum
the wound covered impregnated gauze, silver-based hydrogel (SilvaSorb;
3. Patient compliant with a home exercise program
Acrymed, Inc, Beaverton, OR) and polyurethane
of elevation and ankle range of motion exercises
foam.
To combat desiccation and infection, a silver-
The patient’s personal goal was to “Heal the
based hydrogel was applied during all 9 treatments to
wound.” The discharge criterion for this case was
areas of epithelialization that were too dry and to the
that the wound bed would be fully epithelialized.
hypergranulation tissue.8,21 During treatments 4
through 8, the wound still produced a fair amount of
Treatment Methods exudate, although it was becoming progressively less,
most likely because of infection control and increased
The patient received a total of 9 treatment sessions epithelialization. At this point the petrolatum- impreg-
over the course of 29 days. At the initial examination nated gauze was applied to retain moisture over the
informed consent was obtained from the patient to areas that were becoming dry. The polyurethane
use his information for this case report. Photo doc- foam was applied over the gauze and silver-based gel
umentation of the wound was given to the patient so during all 9 treatment sessions. The foam was used
that he could provide his probation officer proof of to absorb exudate and help reduce hypergranulation
treatment. Pain medication was administered by the tissue.2,15-17
patient prior to wound care treatments to decrease Finally, the 4-layer bandage system (Profore;
pain during the treatment sessions and prevent a Smith and Nephew, London, UK) was wrapped from
pain cycle from beginning.20 During the course of the base of the patient’s toes to just below the knee
treatment, there was ongoing communication with with the bandages stretched to approximately 50%
the patient’s physician regarding the plan of care. of their elastic capacity. Compression was offered to
To begin each treatment session the patient’s help wound healing and to reduce edema in the
wound was cleansed with saline solution to help lower limb. The 4-layer bandage was also used to
remove debris from the wound bed and soften help protect the wound, keep the dressings in place,
necrosis.2 Following irrigation, sharp debridement and provide stability to areas of the skin graft that
was performed during 6 out of 9 treatment ses- were viable.22-27 The 4-layer compression wrap and
sions.11,12 Debridement was performed very gently polyurethane foam made it possible to have
and minimal bleeding was allowed secondary to the biweekly dressing changes because this dressing
patient’s history of thrombocytopenia. During occa- wrap absorbed the exudate and stayed in place for
sions of bleeding, gauze and pressure were applied long periods of time.17 This was preferable to daily
until hemostasis occurred. The majority of debride- dressing changes, which would have been necessary
ment was performed with forceps to remove yellow had a gauze and compression stocking bandage sys-
necrosis from the wound bed. During treatments 7 tem been used. This schedule permitted the patient
and 8, a scalpel was used to remove small areas of to continue to care for his grandchildren regularly
excessive hypergranulation tissue. We angled the during the course of treatment.
blade slightly so that it would remove only the top The patient was given instructions to perform
layer of hypergranulation tissue and not cut deeply ankle range of motion exercises and elevate the leg
into the wound bed. at home to reduce edema.28,29 He received education
Prior to treatment at our clinic on the day of the regarding the choice of dressing materials, moisture
ninth visit the patient had a follow-up examination levels in the wound bed, keeping the dressings dry,
Results
After 29 days of wound care treatment, the patient’s Figure 2. Photo of the wound on day 7 of treatment shows
wound showed increased epithelialization and a increased epithelialization but continued edema, hypergranula-
decrease in total surface area. The original size of tion tissue, and yellow slough.
the wound bed measured 5.2 cm wide × 17.3 cm
long and was approximately 40% epithelialized. At
the eighth appointment, the total surface area of the only minimal amounts of serosanguinous drainage.
wound bed decreased to 4 cm wide × 15 cm long and Figures 1 to 5 show the progress in wound resolu-
was approximately 85% epithelialized. The wound was tion that occurred during the healing process.
of similar shape and size during the ninth appoint- At the time of discharge the patient continued to
ment; however, the remaining open areas were use pain medication and walk with a single-point
covered by silver nitrate. cane. He was unable to wear his regular pants or
At the eighth appointment, only 2 sites remained jeans because of the bulk of the wound dressings.
open within the wound bed: an inferior site and a However, the pain had decreased to permit the
superior site. The inferior site was pear shaped, with patient to sleep at night.
a length of 4 cm and a width of 2.5 cm in the widest During the ninth treatment session the patient
dimension of the pear shape and 1.2 cm at the peak reported that he and his physician had discussed
of the pear shape. The superior site measured 0.8 the option of a skin graft to close the remainder of
cm wide and 2.5 cm long. Both open areas were the open wound. However, the patient reported that
covered by beefy red hypergranulation tissue. he was pleased with the progress he made and the
Over the course of treatment the periwound tis- treatments he received at our clinic and was unsure
sue became less irritated. In the end the wound of what he was going to do. The patient was lost to
edges were slightly elevated even around areas of follow-up after he did not attend his tenth appointment.
epithelialization but were only rolled under around A phone call to the patient revealed that he and his
the inferior site, which was still open. There was no physician decided to try a third, full-thickness skin
yellow slough or yellow purulent drainage and graft over the inferior site in the wound bed. Therefore,
Figure 3. Photo of the wound on day 11 of treatment shows Figure 4. Photo of the wound on day 15 of treatment shows
increased epithelialization. the remaining open areas of the wound following debridement.
final girth measurements were not recorded. the treatments at our facility and treatments the
However, visual observation at his last appointment patient received from his referring physician during
revealed decreased edema in the right ankle and his course of care. Although practical and realistic,
periwound area. this multifaceted set of treatment protocols compli-
cates the evaluation of which treatments were
the most beneficial. It also hinders insight into
Discussion which treatments may have prolonged healing of the
patient’s wound.
This case report described a comprehensive treatment It is worthwhile reflecting on the possible bene-
approach for a patient with an infected, nonhealing fits of other adjuvant therapies such as electrical
surgical wound with hypergranulation tissue. With stimulation that has been reported to reduce infection,
the use of sharp debridement, 4-layer compression thereby helping to heal recalcitrant wounds.5,30-33
bandaging, petrolatum-impregnated gauze, a silver- Vacuum-assisted closure is also another treatment
based hydrogel, saline irrigation, polyurethane foam, method that could have been helpful.34
and patient education, the patient’s wound decreased In summary, there is limited research about the
in total surface area and epithelialized from approxi- treatment of wounds that occur following fasciotomy
mately 40% to 85%. in the current literature. This case report demon-
Factors that complicate clear explanations of strates the positive effect of a multifaceted approach
outcomes in this case were the numerous types of for facilitation of wound healing in a lower extremity
treatments and treatment agents used. This includes wound following fasciotomy.
23. Gupta AK, Koven JD, Lester R, Shear NH, Sauder DN. 29. Sims D. Effects of positioning on ankle edema. J Orthop
Open-label study to evaluate the healing rate and safety Sports Phys Ther. 1986;8:30-33.
of the Profore Extra Four-Layer Bandage System in 30. Mehmandoust FG, Torkaman G, Firoozabadi M, Talebi G.
patients with venous leg ulceration. J Cutan Med Surg. Anodal and cathodal pulsed electrical stimulation on
2000;4:8-11. skin wound healing in guinea pigs. J Rehabil Res Dev.
24. Ukat A, Konig M, Vanscheidt W, Munter KC. Short-stretch 2007;44:611-618.
versus multilayer compression for venous leg ulcers: a com- 31. Merriman HL, Hegyi CA, Albright-Overton CR, Carlos
parison of healing rates. J Wound Care. 2003;12:139-143. J Jr, Putnam RW, Mulcare JA. A comparison of four
25. Medical Encyclopedia. Skin graft. http://www.nlm.nih.gov/ electrical stimulation types on Staphylococcus aureus
medlineplus/ency/article/002982.htm. Updated May 3, growth in vitro. J Rehabil Res Dev. 2004;41:139-146.
2007. Accessed May 16, 2007. 32. Houghton PE, Kincaid CB, Lovell M, et al. Effect of
26. Wheeless CR. Split thickness skin grafts. http://www electrical stimulation on chronic leg ulcer size and
.wheelessonline.com/ortho/split_thickness_skin_grafts. appearance. Phys Ther. 2003;83:17-28.
Accessed May 16, 2007. 33. Kloth LC. Electrical stimulation for wound healing.
27. Weiss JM. Treatment of leg edema and wounds in a In: Kloth LC, McCulloch JM, eds. Wound Healing:
patient with severe musculoskeletal injuries. Phys Ther. Alternatives in Management. 3rd ed. Philadelphia, PA:
1998;78:1104-1113. F. A. Davis; 2002:271-315.
28. McCulloch J, Boyd V. The effects of whirlpool and the 34. Petrie N, Potter M, Banwell P. The management of
dependent position on lower extremity volume. J Orthop lower extremity wounds using topical negative pressure.
Sports Phys Ther. 1992;16:169-173. Int J Low Extrem Wounds. 2003;2:198-206.