You are on page 1of 24

I Socbtyof PetrolslsnE@Iwsrs

SPE 28788

Java Sea Gas Reservoir Development Design


Prabodh Pathak,* A.T. Kasim,* Ida Yusmiati, and Hadi Ismoyo, Atlantic Richfield Indonesia
Inc., and Tahir Bukhari, ARCO Intl. Oil & Gas Co.
●SPE Members

Copwight1SS4,SooietYof PetroleumEngineers,inc.

Thts paper wee ~ared for Presantetiom


et the SPE Asia Paoifk Oil & Ges Conferenceheld in Mefbourna,Auetrslk, 7-10 November1SS4

Thk paper wee sekotad for p+eeentetlonby an SPE PrugremCernmitteefolkwing reviewof informationcontainedin en abetreoteubmittedby the euflwr(s).Contentsof the paper,
= ~tedi have not been ra@ewadby the Societyof PetroleumEnginaeraend are subjectto oorrectkn by the authc+(s).Tfw material,es presented,does not nacaesarilyreflect
SI’IY-MI of tb eC@SWof P~bum En9ineam,h *M. w mem-. pePSI=~ w SPE meetin9e=S SI@=f to P~~JOII r* by ~~~al ~mmMees of t~ **W
of PawdaumEnglneera.Parrnkabntoor@ymrealriotedtom ebetnwt ofnofmorethan s00WONIS.Illustrations
maynotbe copied.The abstractshouldoonteinconepiouous eoknowledgment
of where end by whomthe paper is presented.Write Ubrarkn, SPE, P.O. Sox S33SS6.Rkh-n, ~ 7~s U.S.A. Telax 1SS245SPEUT.

a@ lntroductim

Gas deliveries were started from the Offshore VW


-- uwIverIe5
starting of gas J-1: -.-J-- z---
IWIII
Ak- AAl\A/
LIIW VIVVVO
I

North-West Java Sea (ONWJ) concession area contract area to Indonesian electricity
to Indonesian electricity generating facilities in generating facilities represents the first time that
1993. This paper addresses the development a foreign contractor developed Indonesian gas
and reservoir engineering of shallow gas fields reserves for the domestic market. Atlantic
underlain by bottom aquifers. A multi- Richfield Indonesia Inc. has operated the ONWJ
disciplinary team of geologists, geophysicists, concession area mainly for oil since 1971 under
resetvoir engineers, production engineers and a Production Sharing Contract with the
facilities engineers conducted an extensive Indonesian State Oil Company, Pertamina. The
study to optimize the development plan. This ONWJ concession area currently produces
paper shows that the critical coning rates for about 115,000 BOPD and the total cumulative
high permeability reservoirs with a large gas oil produced until 1994 is about 975 MMSTB.
column thickness are very high and the Unlike other Indonesian gas developments for
reservoirs can be drained effectively by vertical the export market which are based on the
wells. Low permeability reservoirs with a small exploitation of a single large gas resource, the
gas column thickness require horizontal wells to ONWJ gas development consists of a large
increase production rates and ensure high number of small individual field developments, a
recovery efficiencies. Water breakthrough is complex pipeline delivery network, and a
early in the field life and there is substantial gas multitude of compression and gas processing
production after water breakthrough. This paper facilities 1~21s.
uses the concepts generated from single-well
models to develop the resewoir depletion plans The first stage of the ONWJ gas project will
t-.
iul
&_.
iuul
.. gaa
n-a G~l~ain +hn mM\A{ I mnrwieeinn
IIUIUa III LIICZ WIWW u WIIUUaQ vii. deliver ~~~ MMSC~~ nunr an 11 vaar narinfi tn
‘“-’ ‘“’ ‘ ‘ J-=- r-’ --- ● -
electricity generating plants in Tanjung Priok
References and illustrations at end of paper. and Muara Karang, north of Jakarta. Currently,

433
2 JAVA SEA GAS RESERVOIR DEVELOPMENT DESIGN SPE 28788

about 200 MMSCFPD is being supplied as the fraction of gas in the total reservoir column is
electricity plants ramp-up to their contracted also smaller - around 0.1 to 0.25. The smaller
rate. The gas development plan calls for the gas columns and the proximity to the aquifer
sequential development of 19 fields containing makes the development of these reservoirs
1100 BCF of sales gas. The gas associated with more difficult.
the existing oil production fields is collected and
combined with the gas from new gas fields for The remaining 10?40of the non-associated gas
delivery to the onshore power plants (Figure 1). reserves are contained in the deeper Main,
About 30 ?40 of the gas reserves are contained in Massive and Talang Akar formations. The gas
fields with associated, rich gas but the majority from these formations is generally richer with
of the gas reserves (70Yo) are from shallow gas gravities around 0.75 for the Main and Massive
fields containing lean gas, as shown in Table 1. formations and 1.1 for the Talang Akar
The resewe estimates of the ONWJ concession formations. The deeper Talang Akar formation
area fields have been verified by a team of gas also has considerable C02 content, up to
independent consultants also. 30 Yo, and condensate yields of 75-150
bbltimcf.
A large fraction of the non-associated gas
reserves, about 55Y0, are contained in the KLX Because of the large stakes in the Parigi and
field and the adjacent KLY field. These fields Pre-Parigi reservoirs, this paper focuses on the
have excellent deliverability and will form the development issues of shallow gas fields
backbone
-------- .. ----of the
--- QNWJ g~s wpply prQgr~rn, underlain by bottom aquifers= The controlling
Because of their strategic importance in being mechanisms in these fields are volumetric
able to meet large gas demands and having depletion and aquifer influx. This paper shows
excellent swing deliverability, these reservoirs that the development plan for each gas field has
were developed first in the beginning stages of to be tailored to the reservoir characteristics for
the sales plan. These fields produce from the that field. This paper concentrates on the
Middle Miocene Parigi formation at a depth of development plans for the KLX, KLY, LL and Y
about 1900 ft. As shown in Figure 2, the KLX fields. The more general concepts discussed
and KLY reservoirs are characterized by large here can be used for developing APN, which is
columns of gas about 250-300 ft. thick underlain slated for implementation after the year 2000.
by aquifers. The KLX reservoir is underlain by a
200 ft. thick aquifer, while the KLY reservoir is A multi-disciplinary team of geologists,
filled to the spill-point and the aquifer is only 40 geophysicists and reservoir engineers
ft. thick in certain areas. The fraction of gas in conducted an extensive reservoir study to
the total carbonate resetvoir column is about 0.5 optimize the development plan. The objectives
for KLX and 0.9 for KLY. of the development team were to optimize
recovery and rate, maintain high surface flowing
Another 35% of the non-associated gas pressures to minimize compressor usage, and
reserves are contained in the LL, Y and APN minimize water production to prevent water-
fields. These fields produce from the Parigi and handling problems. The constraints were that a
the slightly deeper Pre-Parigi formations. DST steady gas rate needed to be maintained for the
tests indicate that these fields also have end user. The geoscientists and engineers
excellent deliverability. Unlike the KLX and KLY worked in close cooperation to meet the team
fields, however, these fields have small gas objectives. High-resolution 3-D seismic data
columns, 30 to 80 ft. thick, which are underlain was interpreted to improve the structural
by thick aquifers (Figure 2). In the LL field the mapping and to understand the distribution of
aquifer columns are several hundred feet thick resewoir facies in the Parigi and Pre-Parigi
but in the APN area the aquifers are 40-80 feet carbonate buildups. In addition, detailed
thick. The total reservoir column for these sedimentological studies were conducted to
reservoirs is smaller, around 100 ft. and the evaluate the variability of facies type and quality
SPE 28788 P. PATHAK, A. KASIM, 1.YUSMIATI, H. 1SM0% & T. BUKHARI 3

w- .Oow~arhnnata
nf tha —1 ------- hi Iilrhlns. F!nQ!y-gri&jed
--------- single notihwest-southeast towards the west area, as
well simulation models, which protiided shown in Figure 4. The Pre-Parigi sediments
important insights into gas and water movement were deposited on isolated, medium to high
in the vicinity of the wellbore, were used as energy, red-algal reef carbonate shelfs, and
precursors to the full-field reservoir simulation their orientation appears to be controlled by tidal
models. The optimum well spacings needed to influences. Inter-shelf areas accumulated
adequately drain the recoverable reserves and carbonate muds and silts, and thus, the rock
the use of horizontal wells to reduce water quality will not be very good in the sheet-like
coning at high production rates are also structures. The depositional environment starts
analyzed. Finally, the production from the free with a lowstand in the sea level, followed by
gas fields was combined with the associated growth in response to rising sea level, and
gas production to meet the contract finally drowning and deposition of the Cisubuh
requirements. claystone. The Parigi is are laterally more
extensive and thicker than the Pre-Parigi,
although the component Iithofacies and
depositional environments are similar. In most
Reservoir Geoloqy cases, the buildups appear to be structurally
controlled and they form above paleo-high’s
Gas-bearing Parigi and Pre-Parigi carbonate over the Batu Raja or basement structures.
buildups were encountered in the first well
drilled in the Java Sea concession area, the A-1 The predominant Iithofacies in the Parigi and
well. The early drilling programs were geared to Pre-Parigi are fine to medium grained, moderate
oil exploration and thus, the gas-bearing Parigi to well-sorted, skeletal packstone to grainstone
and Pre-Parigi were considered to be drilling with minor amounts of dolomite. The
hazards to be avoided as far as possible. With grainstones are generally soft and easily-friable.
● LA AA..A-* -4 m-m -*lm- n&nv +hn Aiaant*nn# n~ ~akta ~ ~o Immari7ne +ha Iithnfanine thd haua
LIIU auvuiil ul gaa aalwa alml LIIG uIavuvwIy UI I auw G aUIIIIIIa IILWS LIJQ SILOIWIUW-=Q ~muub U*U.W
the large L-Parigi field, the Parigi and Pre-Parigi been observed in core studies based on the
reservoirs began to get more geological and classification schemes of Dunham5 and Embry
engineering attention. and Klovam6. Skeletal grains are dominated by
benthonic foraminifera, echinoderms, bivalve
A schematic cross-section of the Parigi and Pre- and red algal bioclasts, and peloids (Figure 5).
Parigi formations through the ONWJ concession Intervals with foraminifera fragments, which are
area is shown in Figure 3. The Iithofacies can be also called foramhash, are also commonly
classified into two major types - buildup or obsemd. The limestones of the Parigi and Pre-
sheet-like. In certain areas, such as the L and Parigi are generally clean with little argillaceous
LL area, the Parigi and Pre-Parigi occur as minerals except for glauconite pellets.
buildups, which are easily recognizable in
seismic structure analysis, with reliefs up to The clay content from wireline logs appears to
1000 feet 4. In-between the buildups, the be large in certain internals within most Parigi &
formations are sheet-like and can be laterally Pre-Parigi wells. For instance, the clay fraction
extensive. There is a general deepening trend increases at a depth of 2240 ft. in the Parigi in
as the carbonates go from the northwest KLY-1, and at 2250 ft. in the KLX-1 Parigi
towards the east and south. In the northwestern (Figure 2). Mineralogy studies using thin-
part of the contract area, around APN and A-1 sections and X-ray diffraction data, however,
wells, these carbonates are deposited as sheets indicate the absence of significant clays. The
with localized thickening. reason for the shaliness in the gamma ray logs
can be attributed to the presence of glauconite
The Pre-Parigi buildups are generally oriented grains. This is particularly of the bioclastic
north-south in the central and eastern part of the glauconitic grainstones, which form excellent
Java Sea area, and fan progressively to the

435
4 JAVA SEA GAS RESERVOIR DEVELOPMENT DESIGN SPE 28788

rQservQirrQcks that are free of clays but appear of pores, vugular pores are 59’., intergranular
to be shaly. pores are 15940,intercrystalline macro-pores are
4 YObut the majority are intercrystalline and
The diagenetic processes that affected the lime-mud micro-pores with 75 Yo. Although the
sediments are cementation, replacement and number of micropores may be large, their sizes
leaching, all of which have impacted reservoir are smaller and thus, their contribution to the
quality. Cements are dominated by non-ferroan overalt porosity is smaller. A core from KLY-1
calcite, with locally common glauconite. The with an overall porosity of 33 YOhas pores with
glauconite was precipitated during the reworking sizes greater than 20 ~ contribute 16 ?40 of the
and winnowing of grains on the sea floor. The porosity while micro-pores with sizes less than
cements are not extensive and have not 15 P make up the remaining 17 ?40 of the
reduced reservoir quality during the burial and porosity. These micro-pores will have a strong
diagenetic processes. The most common impact on the gas-water relative permeabilities
replacement mineral . is dolomite with and other two-phase flow properties through the
microcrystalline to idiotopic crystalline forms. pore network.
Dolomitization has generally increased reservoir
quality, as the primary pore network is replaced Reservoir rocks with poor quality, conversely,
by secondary micro- and macro-pores. have skelatal pores and micro-pores with very
Dissolution has created mouldic and vugular few intergranular or vugular pores. For instance,
macropores and enhanced the lime mud the total porosity of 14 YO in these rocks may be
micropores. Some pores formed during early composed on only 2% being pores larger than
dissolution have been filled by calcite 20 P while 12 ?40 is lime mud and interctystaline
precipitation but pores formed during later micro-pores.
phases of dissolution have remained open.
Fractures are rarely seen and those that are
present appear hairline in shape and are filled )%-w ir and FIUid Pr-nies
with calcite. Because these formations occur at
shallow depths, compaction has played a minor The Parigi and Pre-Pangi formations have high
role in reducing porosity. porosities around 32-45% and good gas
permeabilities ranging from 10 md to several
Five pore types have been identified in the darcies. Log porosities generally agree with core
Parigi and Pre-Parigi carbonates - intergranular, porosities. The porosity does appear to correlate
skeletal, intercrystalline, intragranular and with permeability, as shown in Figure 7, but
vugular pores. The distribution of these pore there is considerable scatter in the data. Thus,
types within the Iithofacies are also summarized rocks with porosities of 32?40 can have
in Table 2. The best quality reservoir rock with permeabilities from 50 to 500 md. The bioclastic
excellent porosity and permeability has pore grainstones have the highest porosities and
systems comprising a combination of permeabilities, followed by the bioclastic
intergranular, intragranular and vuggy pores, as packstones, which have have high ponsities but
shown in Figure 6. Intercrystalline pores also lower permeabilities. The coral bindstone facies
form an important part of the pore svstems
–, --- in have the lowest permeabilities. The permeability
certain cases where cement crystals have will, therefore, depend on the Iithology and the
developed in intergranular areas. The vuggy distribution of vugular and intergranular pores.
and intergranular pores have large pore sizes of The ratio of vertical to horizontal permeability
the order of 50-100 M but there is a has not been measured in laboratory tests but is
preponderance of intercrystalline pores with expected to be high because of the well-
sizes around 5-10 P. For instance, in cores with developed pore network in the Parigi and Pre-
bioclastic packstone facies from the KLY-1 well, Parigi formations.
which have average porosities of 31 .5Y0,
intragranular pores form 1?40of the total number
SPE 28788 P. PATHAK, A. KASIM, 1.YUSMIATI, H. 1SM0% & T. BUKHARI 5

Because of the absence of shale layers within md. permeability. The KLX, KLY and APN
the carbonate intervals, the formation cannot be reservoirs generally have excellent
divided into distinct flowunits with impermeable permeabilities from 284 md. to 1676 md. Log
boundaries. The porosity and permeability data data indicates that the reservoir quality of the LL
was plotted against depth to evaluate any and Y fields is not as good as the quality of the
changes in the resewoir properties with bedding KLX, KLY and APN fields. The fields were,
planes. As shown in Figure 8, there is no therefore, grouped into two sections - the low
correlation between the depth of burial and permeability, 50-500 red., LL and Y group, and
resewoir properties. the high permeability, 500-1000 red., KLX, KLY
and APN group. Table 4 lists the reservoir
The connate water saturation ranged from 20 to properties used in the base case for the
40% depending on the level of microporosity in simulations.
the rock. Log analysis indicated that in the KLX
and KLY wells, rock quality was generally high Compositional analysis of the produced gas
and connate water saturations were vey low. from the KLY-1 DST shows that the gas is dry
Special core analysis studies confirmed that with a low gas gravity around 0.58 (Table 5).
water saturations depend on pore types and the The gas consists of low molecular weight
fraction of micro-porosity. A core with 28% hydrocarbons, mainly methane (95 Yo) and
porosity, almost all of which is micro-porosity ethane (2.4 Yo), and inerts such as carbon
with pore sizes less than 20 ~, had a connate dioxide (1 Yo) and nitrogen (1.6 Yo). The heating
water saturation of 37.5%. In contrast, another value of the produced gas is close to 1000
core having 31 YO porosity, with 10% porosity in BTU/SCF. Compositional analysis of gases from
macro-pores and 21YOof the porosity in micro- other well tests give similar gas properties data.
pores, had a connate water saturation of 30.5Y0.
As the fraction of microporosity decreases,
connate water saturations as low as 23.3% were F-rvoir Deveiot)ment Des ian
measured in the relative permeability laboratory
tests. There are three important factors that control
the economics of many gas field developments -
Drill Stem Tests (DST) were conducted in Parigi first, the ability of the reservoir to supply a
and Pre-Parigi expiration weiis to assess the sustained nigh gas rate, second, the timing of
reservoir permeability and flow potential. The water breakthrough and the post-breakthrough
DST test run in the LL-1 Parigi zone is shown in water production rates which determine the size
Figure 9. The Parigi zone was perforated over and timing of water treatment and gas re-
the complete gas zone from 1878 ft. to 1900 ft. compression facilities, and third, the ultimate
(Figure 2) with the gas-water contact at 1900 ft. gas recovery factor obtained before the wells
but no water was produced in the DST tests. become uneconomic to operate. These three
Three drawdown tests were conducted with factors may, in some cases, be contrary to each
decreasing choke sizes and a final buildup test other, and thus, the best balance needs to be
was conducted with the well shut-in. All four made to optimize the development plan. For
phases of the DST testing were analyzed and instance, water production could be minimized
gave consistent results that the permeability is by producing at low gas rates, but this will have
around 650 md. The pressure and derivative an adverse ‘impact on the gas revenue stream
curves for the first drawdown test match the and make the project uneconomic. Conversely,
type curve for a homogeneous reservoir. No increased gas rates could accelerate the timing
boundaries were seen because of the short of water separation and compressor facilities
duration of the test. Table 3 summarizes the installation, reduce the ultimate gas recovery
DST data for the Parigi and Pre-Parigi factor, and also make the project uneconomic.
reservoirs. The LL Parigi permeabilities ranged The economics of the shallow gas reservoir
from 48 to 650 red., while the Pre-Parigi has 250 developments indicate that each well should

437
6 JAVA SEA GAS RESERVOIR DEVELOPMENT DESIGN SPE 28788

produce at least 10 MMSCFPD initially to meet


the minimum acceptable economic criteria. In Analytic models are used in this paper to
addition, operational considerations and costs illustrate the basic reservoir parameters that
dictate that wells producing less than 0.5 impact the critical coning rate. The approach
MMSCFPD cannot be economically operated presented by Guo and Leel 1 for water coning
and have to be shut-in. This section discusses into an oil layer was modified to account for gas
the methodology used to optimize the flow in a gas-water system. Fine-gndded, single-
competing designs for the Java Sea reservoirs. well reservoir simulation models, as shown in
Figure 10, are used to evaluate the post-
breakthrough well performance and to help
e Well Mow guide the selection of parameters that impact
fluid movement in the fullfield simulations. An
Analytic correlations for critical coning rates additional benefit of the the computer simulation
were developed initially to model water coning approach is that wellbore hydraulics can be
into oil wells7~s. The earlier correlations included along with the reservoir simulation, and
approximated the system geomety by spherical the complete resetvoir plus downhole tubing
flow into a point source from an infinite system system can be modelled in one combined effort.
with a fluid interface. The water phase is This procedure has distinct advantages in our
considered to be immobile and the critical gas reservoirs which are prone to significant
coning rate is reached when the stable rise in water production, and thus, problems
the water cone touches the point source. These associated with the lifting of the produced water
enrral=tinne
ww1tc7uu&1uumuhmm hnnn mndifinrl
Imlvulomwu tn
&w snenl Int fnr hn addraced in
11UWX7UWWU8 uuwwuelb VW, Pan
“w, , ““ -“”m””””” ,,. tha
. ..” ~~~i)/ ~?~~~~ ~f ?h~
anisotropy and gas coning downwards into an design effort.
oil well g’10. Further enhancements to include a
partially-penetrating wellbore, which can be Critical coning rates calculated using the
modeled as a combination of radial flow around anaiytic modei show that for reservoirs with high
the wellbore and spherical flow below the permeabilities and thick gas columns, high gas
...-ll I—
--- L—..— --— -P-A, IA:nmwn+ma -Pa nnhiat~ahla imi+hnt *+ nnninfi
welluore, nave recentiy been repofied f f. p uuubLIuI I I am= ar w aw imvaum WILI IUUL euI III i~

Coning in horizontal wells can be approximated the water (Figure 11). For instance, KLX and
analytically using cylindrical flow equations to KLY type reservoirs with permeabilities
solve for the rise of a stable cusp 1011z. The exceeding 250 md. and gas columns larger than
critical coning rate calculated using various 150 ft. can be produced with vertical wells at
correlations can differ substantially 1z, and thus, gas rates in excess of 20 MMCFPD without
the correlations should be used as guides to the coning the water. However, APN reservoirs that
flow rates at which coning could occur. have 1000 md. permeabilities with small 25 ft.
gas columns can only be produced at very low
Althnl
r81bII mh
WU~II tha
UC-W aeenntial
gQQQCILIUI nht~eime
pll~eou~ ie eimilar
10 Q191111UI +n
LW nil-
WII– rates around 3 MMCFPD without coning. As the
water systems, water coning into gas wells has size of the gas columns increases to 75 ft.,
not been investigated extensively, especially the however, the critical coning rates for vertical
post-water breakthrough rates. The pre- wells increases sharply to 37 MMCFPD. Thus,
breakthrough behavior in which gas is the only APN wells with 60-70 ft. gas columns could be
flowing phase and stable water cones or cusps produced through vertical wells but the sham
are generated, can be analyzed by modifying slope of the critical coning rate curve indicates
existing approaches developed for water-oil that small variations in resewoir permeability
systems. Because of the complexity in could easily induce coning. Horizontal wells
developing tractable solutions for anisotropic would be recommended in these cases.
reservoirs with complex horizontal well
boundary conditions, reservoir simulation Wells in the LL and Y reservoirs that have low
techniques have gained increased popularity in permeabilities in the 50 to 250 md. range are
modelling such systems 1SS14S1S. going to be the most susceptible to water coning

438
SPE 28788 P. PATHAK, A. KASIM, 1.YUSMIATI, H. 1SM0% & T. BUKHARI 7

(Figure 11). Vertical wells have critical coning r)ressure control and the aas rate begins to
rates less than 1 MMSCFPD and horizontal decline. The water rate also declines as the gas-
wells have critical coning rates around 2 - 8 Iiquid ratio continues to decrease. If the initial
-. -—-- -1
MMSCFPD depending on the size of the gas gas production rate is increasea, the tkne that
column. Thus, the use of horizontal wells does the initial plateau rate can be maintained is
not completely alleviate the water coning smaller and surface pressures decline faster.
problems. The analytic model indicates that
water will be produced from these reservoirs if The maximum water rate produced increases as
economically acceptable gas production rates the initial gas rate is increased, as shown in
are needed. The post-waterbreakthrough Figure 14. The maximum water rate increases
behavior of these resewoirs will have to be sharply after the critical coning rate is reached,
studied in greater detail using computer but then stabilizes because the larger
simulations. production rates cannot be sustained for very
long and the gas rate falls quickly. As expected,
The single-well reservoir simulation results in the maximum water rate is larger as the
Figure 12 show that for a 50 md. gas reservoir perforated fraction of the gas column increases.
with a 40 ft. gas column underlain by a 60 ft. If the whole gas column is perforated, water is
aquifer, if the gas rate exceeds 2 MMSCFPD, produced at the startup of gas production and
water production starts as soon as the vertical the maximum rate is also high. Other studiesl 1
well is put on production. At a gas rate of 1 have shown conclusively that the optimum
MMSCFPD, small amounts of water are perforation fraction for minimizing coning is
produced at startup but the water increases around 30 YO and this ratio was used in the rest
substantially after 2000 days. Little or no water of the simulations discussed in this paper.
is produced at rates around 0.5 MMSCFPD. The Another interesting conclusion from the resuits
critical coning rate from the simulation would, in Figure 14 is that the maximum water rate
_ ● ~Ba~ ha f13tiC 0? tll~
depefids m ●Lllg
firnn . ..L. AL :- I-.-a. *hmm
tiierefore, be I nmvArru WI IIVII IS Ialgel Lllall ~~$ COi!J!7?~
+h anal tiin ram II+ n~ f) QK MMR~. FPIT I%acallea
Llle a!lal}tw I==ult u “.-W ,Wa.., w , . -. --- _- ?~i~k~~~~ @ ?h~ w~?e~ ~~i~rnn thid(~~ss, The

of the assumptions made in simplifying the flow results discussed untii now are based on the LL
geometry and the absence of capillary pressure wells that have a small 40 ft gas column
effects, the analytic model tends to be more underlain by a 60 ft. water column. For a KLY
conservative than the simulations in predicting well with a 400 ft gas coiumn tmderiain by a 40
critical coning rates. ft. water coiumn, there is no water production
uniess the compiete gas coiumn has been
The gas rate remains steady initially when the perforated. The reservoir produces by
well is put on production (Figure 13). The volumetric depletion with almost no contribution
wellhead pressures at the surface are high and from the aquifer.
the well is on rate-control, i.e., the well is being
choked back to maintain the constant rate. The uitimate recovery depends on both the size
Water breakthrough is early, and the water of the gas column and the relative sizes of the
production rate increases steadily as the well is gas and water coiumns (Figure 15). If the gas
produced. The bottom-hole pressure (BHP) column is larger than 100 ft., the recovery
decreases because of reservoir depletion and factors exceed 75-80 !+’0, and the recovery factor
the increased pressure drop associated with is independent of the size of the water coiumn.
lifting greater amounts of produced water. The The gas phase mobiiity is much iarger than the
surface pressures continue to decrease, and the water mobility, and thus, the buik of the gas
gas produced will need to be compressed when reserves can be produced at economical
the surface pressure falls below the pipeline production rates before water coning or aquifer
entry pressure. The water production rate movement become significant. This conclusion
reaches a maximum when additional water reinforces the earlier observation that in KLX
cannot be lifted by the gas. The well goes on and KLY welis that have large gas coiumns,

439
8 JAVA SEA GAS RESERVOIR DEVELOPMENT DESIGN SPE 28788

water influx is not a critical parameter. For The recovery factor for horizontal wells is higher
reservoirs with small gas columns, however, the than vertical wells, particularly in cases where
recovery factor decreases as the size of the gas the gas column thickness is small (Figure 18).
column decreases or the size of the water Because a steady gas rate is maintained longer
column increases. These reservoirs have to be and water production is aeiayea in norizontai
produced above the critical coning rates, water wells, the recovery factor at water-breakthrough
breakthrough is early in the production life and is larger and the ultimate recovery is also lamer.
the water rates can get large enough to drown The recovery does not depend on the size of the
out the gas recovery process. Thus, the LL wells water column that underlies the gas column.
will have lower recoveries compared with the Thus, horizontal wells are strongly
KLX or KLY wells, and the recovery will depend recommended for reservoirs with small gas
on the sizes of the gas and water columns in the columns and lower permeabilities.
vicinity of the wellbore.
Simulations were conducted to assess the
Horizontal wells can alleviate some of the sensitivity of the ultimate recovery to the ratio of
problems associated with water production from vertical ( kv ) to horizontal permeability ( kh )
vertical wells. As shown in Figure 16, the initial (Figure 19). With verlical wells, the recovery
plateau gas rate is maintained for a longer decreases because of excessive water coning
period in horizontal wells, water breakthrough is as the (kv / kh) ratio increases14. Because the
delayed, and the wellhead pressure does not flow into a vertical wellbore is partly radial
decrease as rapidly as for the vertical well in around the top of wellbore and partly spherical
Figure 13. The pressure drawdown on the below the wellbore, increasing the (kv / kh) ratio
reservoir is small, bottomhole pressures are does not impact the radial flow of gas into the
higher and the bulk of the pressure drop is wellbore but allows more water to move
associated with lifting the fluids to the surface. upwards and decreases the critical coning rate.
Thus, horizontal wells will help maintain the In horizontal wells, however, fluid flow is
contracted gas supply rate for a longer penod of cylindrical, along the length of the horizontal
time without the necessity for additional ——— ..—..—.drilling
. ~~cti~~. C.haper~n 10 hac ehnwn
vouu um VW-U
anslvtinsllu
8 mu 8WUJ wuu-my

or development, and will delay the necessity for that there is a weak dependence of the critical
additional compression of the wellhead gas. It coning rate on the (kv / kh) ratio, with the critical
should be noted, however, that the maximum coning rate increasing slightly with higher (~ /
water rate for a horizontal well is larger than the kb). Our simulation results confirm that the
mm”:-, ,- ..,-+-”
II Iaxll I IUIII “*+A III
:- an ..AA:AAI..#AllkAA-l.A- ..0
wacm I ate vu[ Lmal WUII UGGdU~U crmcai coning does increase with nigher (kv i
of the larger horizontal section exposed to water kb), and in addition, the recovery factor also
cusping. Thus, water handling facilities may be increases because of reductions in water
delayed if horizontal wells are used but the production.
facilities will need to be designed to handle
larger water volumes. In general for the Java
Sea facilities and the terms of the ARII
Production Sharing Contract, the economic entation
analysis showed that the increased size of
facilities impacted the economics marginally The development of four gas fields - KLX, KLY,
while the delay in installation improved LL and Y - is discussed in this section based on
economics markedly. A plot of the ratio of the groundwork established by the single-well
maximum water rates from horizontal wells and modelling of vertical and horizontal wells.
vertical wells shows that horizontal wells could Fullfield reservoir simulations were conducted
produce 2-3 times the rate from vertical wells if for all these developments to optimize field
the water column thickness is large and the gas deliverability, reservoir gas recovery, well
column is only 25 ft. (Figure 17). location, number of wells, water production, and
platform” location. - “

440
SPE 28788 P. PATHAK, A. KASIM, 1.YUSMIATI, H. 1SM0% & T. BUKHARI 9

simulations showed that only 40 ft. of the overall


Analytic aquifers were added to the fullfield 250-400 ft. gas column needed to be perforated
simulation models to model aquifer influx into to supply these rates. DST tests in the KLY-1
the simulation volume. Because of the shape of well confirmed that in the high permeability
the Parigi and Pre-Pangi buildups, the aquifer is wells, rates as high as 58.9 MMSCFPD could be
active through the thin, sheet-like carbonate obtained with only a 10 psi drawdown in the
sands in-between the buildups. The sheet-like resetvoir pressure. Because only the top 40 ft.
carbonates have lower quality than the gas- of the gas column needs to be perforated, some
containing buildups. The aquifers did not have of the KLX and KLY development wells were
much impact on the fluid production drilled only 150-200 ft. into the gas column and
charactersitics of the gas fields. Water the bottomhole depth was kept 50 ft. above the
production was controlled by the size and rock top of the aquifer. Large 7 in. tubing was used
quality of the water contained within the buildup downhole to reduce pressure loss as the gas
and
uuuu nnt
m,wbhu thci
WI bmaw
rcwdanichmant
oup9w9. cwo . . ..w . . .
nf
w.
that
. ..-9
watar
..-. -.
fmm
. . . . . . -------
travak fr~rn. the r~~~rv~ir ?~ the surface
outside aquifers. facilities.

Two of the field designs.. . . have .-. . . been


-----already The KLX and KLY wells have been on
implemented for the KLXand KLY fields, and production for the past 9 months at an average
the next phase of gas developments, which will rate of 20 MMSCFPD. The wells have not
be implemented in 1996 includes the LL field. produced water and no operational difficulties
The timing of the Y field development depends have been experienced. Pressure tests
on the growth of gas utilization by the electricity conducted recently indicated little reduction in
generating facility, and this development could resewoir pressures and the tests confirmed the
either be included with LL or delayed until the OGIP in the reservoirs. A program of periodic
next phase. Because the APN area is located pulsed neutron logging and pressure tesing is
far from existing Java Sea developments, it planned to manage the reservoirs. The
forms the last phase of gas development produced gas will need compression about 4
projects, and the field design is not included in years after startup. The overall gas recovery
this discussion. The development plans for the from these reservoirs is expected to be around
fields are summarized in Table 6. 75-80 ~0.

XLX and KLY LIEw


The KLX and KLY fields were developed with 2 The LL field will produce from both the Parigi
platforms each, as shown in Figure 20. The and Pre-Pangi reservoirs. As shown in Figure
single-well models have shown, and the fullfield 21, these two zones do not completely overlie
models confirmed, that there is little additional each other, with the Pre-Parigi having larger
benefit from drilling horizontal wells in high areal coverage than the Parigi. Both these
permeability and large gas pay reservoirs. zones have low permeabilities and thin gas
These two fields were developed with 3 columns with large water columns. The use of
Aviatd
-- ------ .. ---- cmnh
wdk ---- . frnm .. .. .KI
.. . ... th~ . . XA and .KI
.. . ---- .. .XR
.. .. ... . . ... . wdk
.hnrbnntal . . . ... hmnmm
--------- mandatnry
.. .. . .. . .. . ?~ ~n~~~~~~
platforms, and 2 deviated wells each from from critical coning rates and gas recoveries for both
the KLYA and KLYB platforms. The gas resewoirs. In the geographical locations where
deliverability requirements indicated that “the the two zones overlie each other, a horizontal
KLX and KLY wells be capable of supplying a well to the deeper horizon, the Pre-Parigi, is a
-..-*-:--A .- A- A-. .:-*-A ...-11 :- bL- -L-11-... a. La.:--- bkfi
Sustalrluu ralw d 20 NltiscFPD “with an Uuvleltuu well Ill Lllu SIlalluwu[ IIUIMUII, lIIU

occasional rampup to 40-50 MMSCFPD for Parigi. Thus, both zones can be produced
short-term supply to meet swing rate demand or simultaneously: the Parigi through the short-
during the shutdown of adjacent Platforms for string and the Pre-Parigi through the long-string.
testing or workovers. The fine-gridded If a horizontal well is drilled to the Pari~,

441
10 JAVA SEA GAS RESERVOIR DEVELOPMENT DESIGN SPE 28788

however, drilling and operational considerations about 60 MMSCFPD from both the Parigi and
preclude it from being extended to the Pre- Pre-Parigi. Water breakthrough is expected 1
Parigi. year after startup, and additional compression
capacity will be needed at that time. The field
A team of reservoir, production, facilities and production life will be about 7 years and the
planning engineers developed the optimum ultimate recovery will be 60 YO in the Parigi and
development plan for the LL field. The objective 70 ‘%0 in the Pre-Parigi. The recoveries could be
of the team was to maximize project economics increased by additional drilling, but the wells are
and fulfill the contractual gas obligation using not economically justifiable.
existing facilities if possible and minimizing the
investment for new facilities. The team
evaluated the existing piatforms and gas fiow XEisid
lines in the LL area, the availability of
compression capacity, and the associated gas The Y area was also analyzed by a team of
production from existing wells and gaslift engineers, similar to the LL team, to evaluate
requirement projections. The single-well existing facilities and recommend future
simulations had indicated that the wellhead development plans. There are no developments
pressures in LL wells would decrease as water currently in the Y area, and the nearest
production increased, which would necessitate platforms are in the BQ area (Figure 22).
the use of surface compression early in the Compression availability is again an important
development of the field. The currently installed consideration and the Y development has to be
compressors in the LL area are running at staged in to fully utilize existing installed units.
nearly full capacity and there is little excess
capacity available. The longest lead-time Although their gas column thicknesses in the Y
offshore facilities are compressors, and they are and LL areas are very similar, the permeability
also some of the most expensive facilities. The in the Y field is larger. Horizontal drilling of the
team spent considerable time and effort development wells is not as beneficial as it is in
optimizing compressor useage so that all the LL field. Initially Y produces about 8
available compressors in the gas grid were MMSCFPD, as the gas production from other
utilized effectively for gas lift or gas sales. fields tapers off and the gas from Y is blended
in. After 4 years, Y will deliver a maximum of 36
Another major consideration in the LL MMSCFPD and the rate will slowly decline over
development design is the presence of the next 8 years. The field simulations show that
considerable hydrocarbon reserves in a deeper vertical wells can supply this rate profile without
horizon. .... T~l~~~ Ak~!’, The l~cat~~n of new
-------- .. the excessive water production. Water breakthrough
platforms also had to be coordinated with the is delayed slightly with horizontal wells but the
future exploitation of Talang Akar oil and gas maximum water rate more than doubles. The
resetves. Fortunately the major portion of the ultimate recovery with vertical wells is 73 % of
undeveloped Talang Akar reserves could be the OGIP, and it increases slightly by 2 ‘?&with
reached from platforms in the central part of the horizontal wells. Economic analysis showed that
Parigi and Pre-Pangi reservoirs. drilling horizontal wells reduced project
economics. In addition, severe lost circulation
The LL field design calls for the installation of 2 problems have been encountered while drilling
tripods and 4 monopods, as shown in Figure 21. the Pre-Parigi in the Y area, and the risk of
Each tripod will have 2 wells for draining the losing the horizontal well was significant. It was
Parigi and Pre-Parigi, and 2 wells for draining decided, therefore, to develop the Y area with 1
the Talang Akar. There will be 6 horizontal wells new tripod having 3 deviated wells, and one
in the Pre-Parigi, which act as deviated wells in additional well from the existing BQA platform
the Pangi, and 2 horizontal wells exclusively for (Figure 22).
the Parigi. The maximum deliverability will be

442
SPE 28788 P. PATHAK, A. KASIM, 1.YUSMIATI, H. 1SM0% & T. BUKHARI 11

vertical wells for the fields studied. Water-


Cone lusion~ breakthrough is delayed in honzontai wells
but the maximum water rates are higher.
1. A well-coordinated team of geoscientists, --—-
reservoir engineers, production engineers, 5. Fiorizontai weiis in iow permeability
facilities engineers and planning engineers reservoirs with smali gas coiumns have
was needed to develop the Java Sea gas higher recovery factors than verticai weils.
reserves. The team optimized the design of The recovery factor for horizontal weiis
four gas fieids to meet the contractual gas increases siightiy and for verticai weiis
supply to the electricity generating facilities. decreases slightiy as the ratio of vertical to
The design for the first two fieids was horizontal permeability is increased.
implemented in 1993, and the Java Sea Recovery factors increase as the gas column
facilities are currentiy supplying about 200 thickness or permeability increases, but if the
MMSCFPD. it shouid be emphasized that gas coiumn thickness exceeds 100 ft., the
the results presented in this paper apply to recovery factor is independent of water
the Parigi and Pre-Parigi reservoirs in the column thickness.
Java Sea.
6. Horizontal wells are recommended for iow
2. The Parigi and Pre-Pangi buildups are fine to permeability reservoirs with smaii gas
medium-grained packstones and grainstones columns because of higher productivity,
with excellent reservoir quality. The rocks iower pressure drawdowns, delayed water-
have a weli-deveioped, interconnected breakthrough and higher recovery factors.
network of intercrystalline, intergranular, Verticai or deviated weiis suffice if
intragranuiar and vuguiar pores. The permeabilities are high or gas coiumn
reservoirs have excellent porosity, 20-35 ‘%0, thicknesses exceed 100 ft.
k... nnnnn+n ..,n4nr -n+, avn+inne C)fi-A nol. -nA
IUW UUI II lam watwl watulauui I=, Gu--ru /0, al IU
high permeabilities, 50-1000 md.
Pcknowkiaments
3. Critical coning rates for vertical weils depend
on the permeability, gas column thickness We acknowledge the following individuals for
and water coiumn thickness. The criticai their heip during the course of the Java Sea Gas
coning rate for high permeability resewoirs Project : Scott Kerr of Atlantic Richfield
such as KLX and KLY that have a large gas indonesia inc. (ARii) for his innumerable
coiumn thickness is very high, and these suggestions and enthusiasm to help guide this
reservoirs can be produced safely at rates project, Gerry Suellentrop of ARCO Expiration
up to 50 MMSCFPD without water intrusion. and Production Technology (AEPT) for
Low permeability reservoirs such as LL with discussions on reservoir simulation and
a small gas column thickness have low horizontal weii performance, Biii Neison of ARii
criticai coning rates and cannot be produced for initiating the gas reservoir simulation
at economic gas rates without coning water. program, Dave Ciark of Simon Petroieum
Horizontal weiis which have higher critical Technology (SPT) for the iithoiogy, mineralogy
coning rates are recommended but they wili and pore structure study, Peter Butterworth of
aiso produce water at the required gas SPT for heip in the thin-section and SEM
deliverabiiities. photomicrographs, Kakung P. of ARii for his
heip in the reservoir geoiogy, John Kaidi of ARii
4. Horizontal wells can be produced for ionger for stimulating discussions of carbonate
periods at constant, sustained gas rates geology, Jeff Morrow of ARii for the
compared with verticai wells, and the petrophysicai analysis: Scott Wiison of AEPT for
weiihead flowing pressures in horizontal patiently reviewing the manuscript, Kukuh Tjatur
welis does not decrease as rapidiy as of ARii for the Y-fieid simulations, and the ARii

443
12 JAVA SEA GAS RESERVOIR DEVELOPMENT DESIGN SPE 28788

Drafting Group for the fast turnaround and 8. Meyer, H. i. and A. O. Gardener,
excellent quality of the figures. We would also “Mechanics of Two immiscible Fluids in
like to thank the management of ARII, ARCO Porous Media”, J. Appt. Phy., 25, No. 11
International Oil and Gas Company, ONWJ (1954).
Concession Partners and Pertamina-BPPKA for
permission to publish this paper. 9. Chierici, G. L., and G. M. Ciucci, “A
—.-——..—
Syslemanc study Of Gas and ‘Water
Coning by Potentiometric Models”, JPT,
(August 1964), 923; Trans. AiME, 225.

1. Yaman, F., T. Ambismar and T. Bukhan, 10. Chaperon, i., ‘Theoretical Study of Coning
“Gas Exploration in Parigi and Pre-Parigi Towards Horizontal and Vertical Wells in
Carbonate Buildups, N. W. Java Sea”, Anisotropic Formations : Subcritical and
Proc. 20th Annual IPA Convention, Critical Rates”, SPE Paper No. 15377,
Jakarta, pp. 319-346, ((ktober 1991). Presented at 61st Annual Technical
Conference in New Orleans, LA, Oct. 5-8.
2. Pramono, D. H., G. Suns, R. Haryoto and (1986).
E. Pujianto, “Offshore Northwest Java Gas
Development”, Proc. 22nd Annual IPA 11. Guo, B. and R. L. Lee, “A Simple Approach
Convention, Jakarta, Vol. 11,pp. 509-524, to Optimization of Completion intetval in
(1993). Oil/Water Coning Systems”, SPE Res.
Eng., 249-255,(1993).
3. Kasim, A., S. Wilson, T. Utomo, P. Pathak
and S. 1. Kerr, “Strategic Management of 12. Joshi, S. D., “Jiorizontal Well
ONWJ Reservoirs for the Domestic Gas Technoiog,y”, PennWell Books, (1991).
Market”, To be publ., Proc. 23rd Annual
IPA Convention, (1994). 13. Yang, W. and R. A. Wattenbarger, “Water
Pnn:nA waiuulatruli=
UUlllllg
Pnln, ,ln+inne f~~ \v/~rt~~~! allu
9nA
4. Carter, D. and M. Hutabarat, “The Horizontal Wells”, SPE Paper No. 22931,
Geometry and Seismic Character of Mid- Presented at the 66th Annual Technical
Late Miocene Carbonate Sequences, SS Conference, Dallas, TX, (Oct. 6-9, 1991).
Area, Offshore Northwest Java, To be
publ., Proc. 23rd Annual IPA Convention, 14. Wang, B., “A Parametric Study of Gas and
(1994). Water Coning in Vertical and Horizontal
Wells”, Proc. 20th Annual iPA Convention,
5. Dunham, R. J., “Classification of 255-277, (October 1991).
Carbonate Rocks According to
Depositional Texture”, Classification of 15. Aminian, K., J. R. Duda and S.
Carbonate Rocks, (Ed. G. Ham), Mere. Ameri,”Type Curve Development and
AAPG, No.1 , pp. 108-121 (1962). Application for Predicting the Production
Performance of Horizontal Wells in Low-
6. Embry, A. F., and J. E. Klovan, “A Late Permeability Gas Resewoirs”, SPE Paper
Devonian Reef Tract on NortheasternBanks No. 19808, Presented at the SPE Annual
island, Northwest Terriiones”, Bull. Can. Techncial Conference, San Antonio,
Pet. Geol., 19,730-781 (1971). (1989).

7. Muskat, M. and R. D. Wyckoff, “An


Approximate Theory of Water Coning in Oil
Production”, Trans. AiME, 114, 144(1935).
*-.,- ●

ONWJ Gaa hVOIOpllWlt PISII SSISS GM Reserves


M... ridd...idd P... n.1.+

Field Formation Reserves


SCF

KLX Parfgi 257

KLY Parigi 149

u Padgi, Pre-Parigi 82

Y Pre-Pangi 61

APN Pra-Parigi 109

KL Main, Massive 40

LN TalangAkar 35

SE Main 11

SubTofal 744

BZZ, BTS, KN, Sims, NWC 353


SB, SC, P, ESW

Tofal 1,096

Uthofaoiaa and Pore Typaa In Parlgl and Fra+arlgl Formations

Biodaatic Glauoonitio
Grainatone Intergranular,infragranuiar,Intaroryetallina
nl-lm+k
“,—,,. D.,.I,*...
r —w 8. .Qlralabl
—--0, Int.n-nmtallina
..!.”. ”.,”-... .“

PlankfonicForaminiferaiWackaatona Intarcryatdlina,Infargranular,Vugular

Red AtgalWackeatona Interoryafalline,


Intergranular

coral Sindatona Skelafal,Infercryataliine

CalcareoueDdomifa Intenxyafalline,Intergranular,Vuguiar

oalTalaumnm$ror Fariolmrd
PrO+uluPman T0a19.

W9S U4 U/l u-e I&s K&l KLY-1 Am-l MM v-1

71mmeDo, n 24 2? 22 a MM 410 2? Is 20
.. ..
Chalm She, ins. 2/4 S14 2/4 1 2 %ii4 1wr5 lwlu
“--- =

an Me, MMWFPD $.$? $.27 $.$2 &o 22.0 5$.$ 10.5 5.s 3.7s

WObrrn, awm 4 2 5s o 0 0 0 0 0

w@stM3 Plauwe, od. so? $1$ Soo 4s2 S40 $57 472 2s0 $71

m?~

~ltn nlo. 250 $52 1050 4s.s 2s4 425 1s7s 41s m

Wdn -4.5 7 10 2 24 15s .0.1

r, od llW es 10s2 lLC?U


“--- imfs iiX2 iie m iOS7

445
Bees Ceee Reeervok
Date
rorsimulations.

Pomaity 35%

Permeabilii 10-1OOOmd.
LowPermeabilityReeetvoire
HighPermeatWtyReservoirs 2% ?d.

k/h , rnct./md. 0.1

ConnateWater Saturation 30%

InitialResewoirPressure ---
Partgi 890 psi
Pre-Pangi 1190 psi

Ges Gravity 0.58

Reservoir Tempersfure
Patigi 141 oF
Pra-Parigi 153 oF

Composiflon of Gas from the KLY Reeervolr

HydrogenSulphW 0.00

CatbonDioxide 0.96

Ntmgen 1.59

Methane 94.99

Ethene 2.3s

Propane 0.09
Iao-sutane 0.01
n-Butsne 0.00
lao-Pentme 0.00
n-Pentsne 0.00
Hexanes 0.00
Heptanes plus 0.00
Tofal lm.w

Cakulated Gee Gravity 0.5S23

CaloulatsdGas HeatingValue 1003 BTUISCF


; ------~
--..- w~
, 10s-
, 00.
,07-00,

m r;--------
‘6”

b
AV8
4 ivf-p..------ Nam. *.,
- .,
WssKw
I
BrMA /:

h
i
~
i
1’ ($.—..—-.—— .. I ..—.--..
—..—..-;
:_.. _.. i J
,-0--
H’ ARDJUNA r

Flp!ml. .lavamga dwdqnmmmmvdm andnuhendolhsry pOeMO

Davalopmanl Plan Summery for Perigl rsnrJPre-Parigl Reeervoira.

Flald Raeervok Area, Davlaiad Horizontal Platforms Reoovery Delivery


Aorw Wells Wells Fnotor, Rate,
% MMSCFPD

KLX Parigi 2100 6 2 Tti@s 75 110


KLY Parigi 1000 4 2 Tri@a 77 62

u Parigi 5100 4 2 2 Tripods+ 69 30

P*Parigi 5600 6 4 Monopods 73 30

Y Pr*Patini 1SnO 4 1 Ttinnd 73 36

447
KLY-1 LL-1
KLx-1
—–..–-=+.ti=,---qrn.

==:
.—— Dl
iMS 4s
.——

..

..

-

-.

Figura 2. KU-1, KLY-1 and U-I


~ _-liE14Q
Ioga alwwing the size of the gas columns and the gas-water contacts.
2
u
~~{,._.-_--_-.,-----..-.-..:;
I I
!_.. _..
-()&
o -K)~nMa AJA A<-’.

449
F@Ire 6. .%mmimg
dectron
Miwo@@M showioc
the
pore
sbuciwre
of Pd@ 8uI pm?m~ fonmtkm.

m——– .? ~m~_m .*..-* -——.L. .LA-. ●L- 1:*1..I— ..,+ . . .**.*. - A P.s.kd
rlgul-c a OwJmKrugrqmm Dmuw,q cu. “uw.~ .- p“. . . . . .—. . “. . . . ~

●II(I P*Pmigi fornution.

450
Iwo

A
●m -m
1ss0
B10 Pk81 ■ ■ ■ ■

■■ m
16M
A

16s0 cord Bnst

■ APN4

lm A APN-5

j ● APW3

● BNW-1 (37%2SSmD)
- I?sl
● BZN-1
i
A S73-2
180(

18s

190

WE

.-
ml 0.1 1 10 lm
!40 al w
10
PERMEAW ( mD )
.\ . .. . . . . .\\\\
\ \ \ \
\\\ \ \

I 1 1 I I
I I
I I I
l-l! 1 1

I I 1 -WI I I I I I 1 I
-wI1 1 I I

(8) (b)

Single Well Model - 1/4 Simulation Grid with


f * \ Veftieat
\-, ._ .. -—. well and ( b ) Horizontal Well

Figure 10. Simulatin gridforverticalandIwizontalwells.

I l-— I

I
I $RhfJ1 , Cwlri,$ms OVW4, mum P 4
.. .“ ......”
~.. ,

s
~“””-

~.. ...............1-

~~.~~.g & I
PARIGI ZONE (1878 ‘- 1900’)
I I I I I
s to 15 20 ‘M
- Omum)

TYPE CURVE PLOT


30
DRAWDOWN lEST #l

.
“.
i

al

AnALvss nwLTs
x.cu.c48tmd
cd . u4.7a80
B . 7s61

.-
w,
. .
“.,
. .“
. .
.N1
.-
*IK41
.—

ewlv- m (ham)

WWC 9. DSTmwits fromI-L-1pm8sumhsI h thePar@izone.


,g
I

I,@
In
Iu

, -——
--------- —––——----- —–

2
s

e
5
..

..—...-—

1
0

r , , , r

%
.- ggasq~”
adma“3.LVU
Nolunloow Um.vm

—..——. —....——
,,

I
e

* tlufm=nd
i
.

.. .. . . ... . ----

-----L
.- . .—.- ——--—

....-..-
~:
11
-- I
II‘)
,

{
:g88E8s
‘ I

. — .,”

I I

“<
.—
+

i
100

90

80

70

6C

5C

4(

J
0.01 U.1

Itvlktl

bulvmimlwails~ wnhhmMllKIWlkdtOllodzti~~
Figure 19. ReQaWlyhclorllx hOrkOntal*i—

455
. ,, .

4s6

You might also like