You are on page 1of 14

THE ANALYSIS OF HUMANISM AS REPRESENTED IN THE

ANIMATION SERIES “ASTRO BOY”

Abstract: This journal will discuss the topic of humanism as a subject brought by the
genre of science fiction—specifically in the animated series Astro Boy. The social
and psychological commentary of the idea given that, if an intelligent life were not
human, would you and others treat it the same way? It is depicted in Astro Boy
through still and moving images to tell a story about people and humanity. It is
expressed in a neat and concise way as to be understood by all audiences from every
background. It’s the reason why the series is so popular worldwide, even to this day.

Keywords: Humanism; Intelligent Life; Science Fiction


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction...................................................................................................................1
Methodology.................................................................................................................3
Result............................................................................................................................5
Discussion.....................................................................................................................7
Conclusion....................................................................................................................9
References...................................................................................................................10

● VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022


Introduction smartphones and the internet, how as

As a series, Astro Boy has had a result it makes people more

multiple remakes. From the original desensitised to cruelty in the world.

manga by Osamu Tezuka, to the True artificial intelligence is getting

animation in 1963, to the adaptation in closer day by day, we can see such

1980, another remake in 2003, and a progress of realistic robots being

3D animated movie in 2009. Time and proven through the Ameca, a robot

time again, we tell the story of Atom capable of mimicking human-like

and his friends. But the question is, emotions in extremely advanced

why? Although there are slight detail. If we don’t learn to be decent

differences between the stories and people to even each other as humans,

the way it is presented tonally, why what will happen to the man-made life

re-tell it within every generation? we create with our own hands? Atom,

Other than the fact that it’s Japan’s or more popularly known as Astro

most iconic anime and can be Boy, has his original origin story

recognisable worldwide, it tells a very about him being built in the image of

human story about a not so human his creator’s son, who unfortunately

robot and the people he encounters. passes away due to a car accident. In

As history repeats itself, it is a his grief, Dr. Tenma creates a perfect

constantly growing ever-present replica of his son, only this time

relevant story about our humanity inhumanely strong and unkillable.

through the increase of technology, Even though he tries, Dr. Tenma starts

teaching a lesson in a rapidly growing to notice that Atom doesn’t age like

world and told in a digestible manner. normal children do (as he is a robot)

Especially today, in the year 2022, we and acts hardly anything like his son,

can see how much technology has realising nothing can ever replace a

grown, with things such as human life that is his son and that it

VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022 ●


can only create something new, he that we forget when to draw the line. A
sells away Atom to a robot circus. lot of technology lets us distance
Even with a simple origin story, it ourselves emotionally and physically,
touches so much on grief and the beginning to take its negative hold on
emotional distance one can have people as we become colder towards
towards something man-made, even humanity as a whole. Now the
as an intelligent life who could feel question begs to repeat, if we as
emotions. This doesn’t even touch humans can be cold towards even our
upon Atom’s experiences with hatred, own kind, then what would happen if
harassment, and bigotry from other we were to have the capabilities of
people besides his creator, it being a creating life artificially? Where would
big part of the series. the balance be, and would there be
Astro Boy’s legacy has room for humanism, an idea in where
spanned decades, with it being we be good to ourselves, and to others
considered the first ever anime series for the greater good simply for the idea
since its release in the year 1963. Since of it being good. All this can be
then, there have been countless discussed in a fun animated sci-fi
remakes and movies retelling its series called Astro Boy.
stories. Even throughout it all, the Does Astro Boy critique how
series’ main focus is to tell a story, and people act towards differences in a
besides slight differences in iterations, fictional setting as a metaphorical way
it mostly stays the same. The idea of of delivering the moral? And while its
an ever-growing world full of tones are mostly for all audiences, is
technology, something made available that for the benefit or for the detriment
for our convenience, and the overall of the series? The purpose of this
betterment of humankind. How that research is to further the knowledge of
gives us improved lifestyles as we people’s understandings on empathy
embrace technology, but so much so and how, even when different, we can

● VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022


relate to each other and show kindness on which sections does something
to one another. Although it is told particularly apply to an aspect or point
through science fiction as a lense, it being made. Through the proper
heavily holds true to us with different categorisation of the data now
ethnicities, cultural backgrounds, and collected, in-depth analysis can be
ideals. How we treat those of us who made by looking through each of the
are also flesh and bone, and what that now made points and create something
answers for us as people. What that is extensive in detail. With all of
symbolisms and representations of the things that have been researched
humanity can Astro Boy give as an and analysed above, the research
animated series for all ages, and how journal can reach its proper conclusion
does it show? and tie everything being said together.
With all this being said, for ease, it will
Methodology be concised to a flow chart as shown

The journal will be followed below.

through in a step by step process


method, starting from gathering
research data through primary and
secondary means, which is via
watching the series itself throughout
the years and collecting the opinions of For the ability to understand

other people, what they have to say the series in different lenses, research

about the entire aspect of the story and must be done on varying topics about

what they’ve gathered as a lesson from the series to get a better picture of

the story itself. After that, the data what messages the show brings on as a

collected will be picked apart and put whole. What type of story it’s trying to

selectively in categories of research, tell, and how it resonates with different


people. The series’ timeline from its

VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022 ●


creation to present day, how it’s humanism, science fiction, and
changed throughout the years, what artificial intelligence. Although the
messages have changed through the series itself serves sufficient
years and yet what still remains the information on the discussion, it is
same despite the years. This section of always good to have backup data and
the article will go further in-depth with different opinions regarding the
the methods of what it’s researching subject matter at hand. With the
and the data it will be collecting. multiple ideas, thoughts, and opinions
The primary data, being the that can be collected, a more consistent
main data this research article will be narrative in the research can be
taking from is the Astro Boy series formed, giving way to a solid journal
itself. It doesn’t lend itself short to lack that can rely not just on personal bias,
of content, being that it has multiple but also a general understanding.
remakes over the decades, with each The method of research will
adaptation never being too short to mainly be through qualitative means,
have a discussion on and also being this by definition is collecting data
different enough to warrant its own through discussions and opinions, not
section for each adaptation. The reason graphs and numeric surveys. The
for this being that there is so much that reason behind this being that for the
can be said with the story and narrative topic of humanism, it will require more
provided in and of itself, being able to than just mere numbers on a yes or no
look in closer detail at its symbolisms question, there needs to be engagement
and find meaning through it all, having with what is being researched and the
a deeper understanding of what people themselves who are all unique
humanism means in Astro Boy. individuals with different thinking
The secondary data used will processes, opinions on the topic would
be gathered through other articles and greatly benefit as the question of what
journals researching similar topics on it means to be human and artificial life

● VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022


would vary from person to person. understand like human beings would.
Creating an impersonal experience They are self-aware and capable of
when collecting the data of Astro Boy free thought. You sympathise with
will just lend itself flat and not to its their plights and their hardships, their
benefit due to the fact that the research struggles are made real and to be
question is that of a more rooted for, even when they physically
philosophical nature. In a way, this aren’t human themselves. If they are
method of research also relays with the capable of all this, then they should be
research topic at hand, with human treated with equity, even if they are
connections and people being the main different. But are they? There’s
driving force of this discussion, even difficulty in some characters adjusting
creating more possibilities of said their world view and not just seeing
discussion on the topic at hand the robots as mere objects. Sometimes
between people. There needs to be a too, they can be seen as while still
person behind the answers, therefore having the same rights as humans do,
what it means and how the subject their value of life is considered much
matters to them, not just statistics. more replaceable than that of a
human’s, is that true? Is their life
Result worth less than humans because of the

The results for this research is fact that they are made with an

as follows. It is apparent that artificial conscious? If a human life is

humanism is represented in the a human life, then what is the life of a

animated series Astro Boy through the robot. Astro Boy teaches us that even

humanisation of robots. This is the if something is not human, you should

case because of how, instead of mere be able to treat and value it the same

thoughtless and unfeeling inanimate way as you would a human if it were

objects, they are able to think, feel, and free of having its own thoughts and
emotions, not tied down to a control of

VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022 ●


any kind other than the mind itself. humans and should be made clear and
Even then, we know that there is a lot acknowledged due to the fact that
of inequality in this world of our own, while they are thinking and feeling,
mistreatment of people, animals, and much of their needs are not the same
even plants, so would the world be as humans, and we should be able to
able to fair with one more major see that and treat that fact accordingly
species in the category without it but still treating robots as people, just
exploding into a series of hate and like how it is in real life with living
horrible actions that can be considered beings all having unique needs for
as hate crimes? Astro Boy, being for their own being to be able to live
all audiences, can teach us that we comfortably. It shouldn’t be stopping
should treat everyone and everything anyone from treating them as people
as with much respect and mutual love too. Differences should be celebrated,
as possible, through the symbolisms of not condemned or be straightened out
robots being presented as a minority just to make them the same as
within their world itself, which can be everyone else. While the robots are not
translated to real life too and can speak human, again, we can see how they
to a large variety of people without it symbolise a minority group of people
sounding preachy or it trying to capable of thinking and feeling like we
hammer down any other lesson than to do, the message we receive from it is
be a decent person to all the living how we need to be kinder to ourselves
beings around you. Some of the series and each other, despite our differences.
adaptations never touch on this matter If we’re already cruel to one another,
deeply or too seriously, so it is made then what would happen if the
digestible and a good simple lesson. hypothetical scenario of self-aware
Humans too in this world are artificial intelligence happens. Astro
of different shapes and sizes, although Boy shows this in the simplest but
robots have their differences to most effective ways, while presented

● VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022


as digestible and made understandable now rapidly growing society with all
in a wide range, it can be taken deeply its technological advancements, it
as a part of the human condition, or it reminds us to stay humble and have
can be taken face value still, to be kind compassion as humans towards
and help others, both ideas are correct different people and beings, with Astro
and both still speak to the idea of what Boy having yet another new adaptation
humanism is about. This actually coming that’s currently in production,
shows in the different adaptations of we will be able to see how the remake
the series, with the 1980s adaptation imagines the ideas of its creator in the
being far more serious and how the lense of the 2020s, our modern era.
idea can be taken with and work really
well in a more intense science fictional Discussion
setting like with Naoki Urasawa’s To start with, The topic given
remake of one of the arcs in Astro Boy, of this research is to answer the
it being called Pluto. Pluto is a question of what humanism means in
re-imagining of Osamu Tezuka’s work the animated series Astro Boy and how
with the lense of it being an it is represented. Though there are
exclusively adult fiction, portrayed as minor differences in each adaptation,
dark and noir, with the core message Astro Boy tells the story of a robot
and themes of the story being taken named Tetsuwan Atom, he is the
from the original, it still works really creation of Dr. Umataro Tenma, a
well, hammering the fact that Astro legendary robotics engineer who after
Boy can be interesting to all audiences, losing his son Tobio to an accident,
even with the different ways it can be decides to make an exact robot replica
presented and all. We tell the story of of his own son, only this time made to
Astro Boy again and again, time to be indestructible and unable to die, but
time, because it remains and will also unable to age.
possibly always remain relevant in a

VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022 ●


From this backstory alone, we them. Once Dr. Tenma gets through his
can see that the very reason Atom is denial and realises this, that he will
created is through the grief and loss of never be able to truly get his son back,
Dr. Tenma, who we can sympathise he rejects and throws Atom out, telling
for. Many people in real life have lost a him that he isn’t his son and sells him
loved one and can be able to relate to to a robot circus, this is the scenario
Dr. Tenma, many of whom would also that happens with many of the
go through desperate means if it can adaptations. With the realisation that
mean bringing back someone you care Atom is not Tobio, Dr. Tenma no
about from the dead if given the longer sees Atom as his son or as a
chance. Atom has the face of Tobio, person either, but only as a robot he
Dr. Tenma’s dead son, made to live as created, the value to him as a person
a replacement as if Tobio had never disappearing. But would that be valid,
died in the first place. But although considering that we see Atom being
Atom looks like Tobio and has his capable of expressing how he feels and
memories, he is not the same. He is an thinking for his own. Whether he likes
entirely new person created, even it or not, Dr. Tenma has created a life,
having a personality of his own, even if by artificial means, which is
different to that of Tobio. This can why it would be irresponsible to just
translate to real life scenarios of people throw that life away to the side, simply
trying to replace the loved ones for it not being the exact same as
they’ve lost in the expectation that someone he cares about.
they would be the same, whether a Although Dr. Tenma’s reaction
dog, a sibling, or child, but everyone, is understandable, the fact that Atom is
every living thing is unique in their someone with self-awareness and
own way and can never be replaceable emotions, even if a robot, means that
once they are gone, it is why you he’s a life created and thrown away on
cherish the time you do have with a whim. The contrast of Atom acting

● VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022


human and being treated inhumanely discussion being, even if Atom is a
for the fact that he is not flesh and robot and therefore considered an
blood, as if he was an object even with object, while he isn’t human, he is still
his feelings, it shows. Throughout all a person. And that is how humanism is
this, Atom stays good and kind represented in Astro Boy.
hearted. Like many people do, even
after they go through their own Conclusion
hardships, not wanting people to feel In conclusion to this article,
the same way as they did when they Astro Boy is an incredibly thought
themselves were mistreated by those provoking series when looked at
around them. If humanism stresses the deeper, despite it being for all ages. It’s
fact that there is value and the potential a science fictional series that can speak
to do good in all humans, that all to the human condition and the idea of
humans have their wants and needs, humanism itself through the metaphors
and that we as an individual are able to and symbolisms of robots created in
think and act on our own, then if the fictional world. The story of
something acts accordingly to the Tetsuwan Atom, or Astro Boy, a robot
human condition, then wouldn’t they made from the grief and loss of his
also apply to those rules? If they do creator, being made to think and feel
then would they not also be obligated with free conscious, just like how any
to be treated as a person too? other human being would. The idea of
Following the idea of humanism and humanism, the inherent goodness and
being treated with inherent kindness, capability of people doing good,
despite being different. This also regardless of who they are as a person,
shows when humans treat other they just need to be a person, it is
humans who are different than them, represented in Astro Boy with Atom
the robots in Astro Boy can be being able to be good and do good,
presenting of this. The point of this

VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022 ●


helping those in need despite him not period said adaptation was made, but
being the same as them at all, the core message stays the same. The
representing the fact that we can all be reason for this is that despite the
different and still help each other, to be changing eras throughout the decade,
able to create a better and warmer Astro Boy’s message remains the
environment in the ever growing same, they all remain important as it
coldness that is the distance caused by ties down with the very definition of
technology and its advancements, the humanity. And with the 2020s being an
over-reliance on it that makes us forget era of rapid technological
that everyone behind a screen is just a advancements, robots looking more
person. Astro Boy reminding us that, and more realistic each day, its story
even through wires and metal, a person could not be more relevant than it is
is a person, no matter what. Robots in today. Maybe one day, when true
real life can also be taken as minorities artificial intelligence is created in the
that are living in this world who are real world, we can welcome it with
often being seen as inhumane to open arms as people, without
certain people as well, it’s the fact that discrimination.
everyone should be treated with equity, References
acknowledging and celebrating the Peng, Qingque. (2019).
differences of people, adjusting to their The Humanity and Feminism of
Robots in Sci-fi Movies, Take Alita:
needs, not just their equality, because it Battle Angel (2019) as an Example.
is something that everyone should be Ajou University.
http://papers.iafor.org/wp-content/uplo
able to have access to, they all have the ads/papers/ecah2019/ECAH2019_522
right to be people. 21.pdf

All adaptations of Astro Boy Anzivino, Sophie. (2021).


have their unique takes on the matter The risk of connectivity and finding
God in the network: Analyzing Serial
of robots being able to think and feel Experiments Lain through a critical
for themselves depending on the time surveillance lens.

● VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022


University of Toronto. The Serious Side of Science Fiction
https://theijournal.ca/index.php/ On the Usage of Medial Depictions of
ijournal/article/view/37892 Artificial Intelligence for Ethical
Reflection Using Detroit: Become
Chen, Mengqian. (2018). Human as an Example.
AI, Cyborgs and Post-Humanism University of Education Ludwigsburg,
Theory in Animation and Films. University of Stuttgart.
Sino-Korea Multimedia School. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/P
https://www.matec-conferences.org/ar atrick-Maisenhoelder/publication/341
ticles/matecconf/pdf/ 901589_THE_SERIOUS_SIDE_OF_
2018/87/matecconf_cas2018_05005.p SCIENCE_FICTION_-_ON_THE_U
df SAGE_OF_MEDIAL_
DEPICTIONS_OF_ARTIFICIAL_
Mesbahi, Myriam El. (2015). INTELLIGENCE_FOR_ETHICAL_
Human-Robot Interaction Ethics in REFLECTION_USING_
Sci-Fi Movies: Ethics Are Not ‘There’, DETROIT_BECOME_HUMAN_
We Are the Ethics. AS_AN_EXAMPLE/links/5ed8b3924
Cadi Ayyad University. 58515294531305d/THE-SERIOUS-SI
https://link.springer.com/ DE-OF-SCIENCE-FICTION-ON-TH
chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-20886-2_ E-USAGE-OF-MEDIAL-DEPICTIO
55 NS-OF-ARTIFICIAL-INTELLIGEN
CE-FOR-ETHICAL-REFLECTION-
Holl, Elisabeth. (2019). USING-DETROIT-BECOME-HUMA
Rise of the machines, Moral decisions N-AS-AN-EXAMPLE.pdf
in Detroit: Become Human.
University of Luxemburg. Breidokienė, Lina. (2020).
https://orbilu.uni.lu/bitstream/ Posthumanism as Science Fiction. The
10993/39629/1/ICA%202019% Case of Netflix’s Altered Carbon and
20Flashlight_Holl.pdf Love, Death and Robots.
Kaunas University of Technology.
Lambert, Spencer Matthew. (2020). https://epubl.ktu.edu/object/elaba:623
The Struggle Against Discrmination 34906/
Seen in the Main Characters of
Detroit: Become Human by David Budianto, Firman. (2018).
Cage. Representation of Science,
Sanata Dharma University. Technology, and Memory of Postwar
https://repository.usd.ac.id/ Japan in Japanese Anime.
37637/2/164214074_full.pdf Indonesian Institute of Sciences.
https://media.neliti.com/media/publica
Maisenhölder, Patrick. Seng, Leonie. tions/261144-representation-of-scienc
(2019). e-technology-and-3e55279c.pdf

VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022 ●


Kovacic, Mateja. (2014).
The Many Faces of Popular Culture
and Contemporary Processes:
Questioning Identity, Humanity and
Culture through Japanese Anime.
The IAFOR Journal of Arts and
Humanities.
https://iafor.org/archives/journals/iafor
-journal-of-arts-and-humanities/10.22
492.ijah.2.1.02.pdf

● VOL.1 NO. 01 APRIL 2022

You might also like