Comparison sheet between Megger make SMRT-36 & omicron make CMC 356

Evaluating parameters Quoted Model Quoted Model

SMRT 36 Omicron make CMC
Model: SMRT36- 356
30P0F0I1T1 with
Maker’s name, address and country touch laptop.

Relay test kit should able to test following relays: YES. Yes
Definite and inverse time over current, Min/max
AC / DC voltage.• Directional over current. •
Frequency.• Distance.• Synchronizing.• Directional
power.• Loss of Field.• Reverse Phase.• Negative
sequence over current.• Reverse phase / voltage.•
Thermal.• Power factor.• Overvoltage.• Earth
detection.• Phase angle, Out of Step.• AC / DC
reclosing.• Directional voltage.• Directional voltage
and power.- Molded Case Breakers (MCB, MCCB),
distance relays, differential relays with quadruple
winding of all make and type including
electromechanical, electronics, numerical,
transducers etc

It has 6 Current channels as per specification YES. Yes

It has 3 voltage channels as per specification YES. Yes
YES. 4x 300V/No convertible
current source to inject
5A,100VA @100V to 400V
Does your kit meet specification of voltage only
amplifier?
Specification Voltage Amplifier
1.No of Channel : 3 voltage source
2.Output range : 0-300 V AC/0-5 A- AC, 0-220 V DC
3.Power : 100 VA continuous @ 37.5 – 150 V AC,
100W
4.Resolution : 10mV/1mA
5.Reversibility : It shall be possible.
 YES. 1. 100VA@5A not meeting the specs

Does your kit meet specification of current

amplifier?
Specification of Current Amplifiers
1.No of Channel : 6
2.Output range : 0 - 15 A AC and DC
3.Power :6 Channel mode: 100 VA @ 5A, 10A, 15A
AC at all ranges, 100 W to check Electromechanical
relays
3 Channel mode: 300VA @ 30A AC
4.Resolution : 1mA
For above the following parameter shall be
complying:
5.Accuracy 0.2% of the value ± 0.05% of the range
6.Distortion 0.1 % -resistive load / 2 % - maximum
inductive load
7.Isolation between mains and all channels shall be
available
CPC-OPTCL- Technical Specification for Testing
Equipment-2014 Page 44 of 47
8.Combined output Series and Parallel shall be
possible.
9.Frequency Adjustment range: 0.0 – 1KHz for pure
sine & for Transient Signals:0- 3KHz at Resolution:
1mHz- Accuracy: 25PPm at 50Hz
10.Phase angle Range: 0.0 – 359.9º /Accuracy:
(0.25deg)/ Resolution: 0.001º

Does your kit meet specification of low voltage YES. Yes

output?
Does your kit meet specification of binary channel? YES. Binary output transistor
Binary Inputs- type 2nos not available
Binary input: 8
Type- Dry or Voltage
Voltage range:300 V
 Resolution : 0.1 ms
 Range : 0.0001 to 999.99 sec
Accuracy : 0.001 ± 0.1 ms
Binary output:
BO are of two type:
1) Relay Type: High Current rating & slow operation
speed for CB contact simulation: 4 Nos. ( Break
Capacity AC Vmax:300V AC/DC/Imax 8A/2000
VA/240 W)
2) Transistor Type: Low Current rating & high
switching speed for electronics switch contact
simulation: (2 nos)
I max 1A, Response time 1mS

YES. Yes
Does your kit meet specification of Auxiliary
channel?
AUXILIAR DC SUPPLY
1.Ranges : 48, 125, 250 Vdc
2. Power : 60 W
3. Accuracy : 5 %
4. Ripple : 0.2 %

YES. Yes
Does your kit meet specification of Timer?
It shall able to measure and display multifunction
timer, countdown timer, analogue input
measurement, binary input pulse counter and
frequency measurement. It shall able to test battery
simulation of auxiliary DC supply setting for relay
powering.

The accuracy, resolution and VA are as per the YES. 5 x 150V whereas asked
specification asked. for 300V and 6 x 100VA @
Specification Voltage Amplifier 25A whereas @ 5A,10A it
1. No of Channel : 3 voltage source wont carry enough
2. Output range : 0-300 V AC/0-5 A- AC, 0-220 V DC burden to test
3. Power : 100 VA continuous @ 37.5 – 150 V AC, electromechanical relays/
100W Voltage channel cannot
4. Resolution : 10mV/1mA give 5A current as per the
5. Reversibility : It shall be possible. specs
CPC-OPTCL- Technical Specification for Testing Yes
Equipment-2014 Page 45 of 47 YES.
e) It shall able to playback and process COMTRADE
files to analyze transient fault and relay reaction.
f) RIO file shall be played back through proper
software and without the need of PC.
g) All binary I/P and O/P shall be configured
through on screen display.
h) Tools for development of test templates/existing
templates, data setting configuration for each relay
settings etc. shall be provided.
i) Powerful graphic editor shall be provided for
protective areas curves, with predefined templates.
j) Test engines shall be available for programming
with easy, in visual basic, .Net language with
function definition language.
k) Fault calculation and Sequential test execution
software shall be available for specified settings in
test point sequences.
l) Possible to find the pickup and drop out values of
the active elements of the relay.
m) Verification of the relays recloses function with
any number of reclosing cycles.
n) Software for evaluation of protection devices for
cold load functions.
o) SOTF function, I2/I 1 test , CB failure scheme
evaluation, Fuse fail, reset time function test shall
able to be tested.
p) It shall able verify the correct logic behavior of
the over current protective devices on signal
reception with forward and reverse faults.
q) The software shall able to search distance /
impedance for evaluation the boundary values of
distance zones in selected direction. It shall also be
possible to evaluation of impedance element
without zone geometry
r) It shall able to evaluate relay behavior during the
fault condition of single phase relay reclose cycle.
YES. Yes
It should have Hardware configuration in such a
way that the software can be upgraded through the
internet by downloading the various patches / up
gradation. The kit should not be send to factory /
works for the same. In case the kit needs to be
upgraded by adding channel or any hardware, it
should possible to do the same at site. Hardware
configuration and software up gradation should be
possible at site.
The kit should able to play Real time representation YES. yes
of power vectors, Timer operation/trip set up and
preferences, binary I/O setting etc.It should able to
generate Event ger, with event description and time
of the event. & automatic recording for all events,
such as sources switching and I/O setting. It should
able to measure external measurements
configuration, for testing of transducers, energy
meters and sensors.

The software is user friendly that user can picks up YES. Yes
the required functions to build a complete test
protocol by just clicking on a list.
The software facilitate to calculate, view and YES. Yes
express the test parameters in terms of each
protective function (e.g. reactance, impedance,
differential current, restraint voltage, negative
sequence, etc.) .

Three state fault functions with pre-fault, fault and YES. yes
post fault configuration possible.
Single ramp, double ramp with upward or down
ward should be possible. One upward and another
downward function should also be possible.

Pulse ramping with preset conditions should be YES. Yes

possible. Protection scheme and logical sequences
tests can be performed through state sequencer.

It should able to playback and process COMTRADE YES. Yes

files to analyze transient fault and relay reaction.

It should test SOTF function, I2/I 1 test , CB failure YES. Yes

scheme evaluation, Fuse fail, reset time function test
should able to be tested.
It should able verify the correct logic behavior of the YES. Yes
over current protective devices on signal reception
with forward and reverse faults.
The software should able to search distance / YES. Yes
impedance for evaluation the boundary values of
distance zones in selected direction. It should also
be possible to evaluation of impedance element
without zone geometry.

It should test operation of distance relay under YES. Yes

heavy load condition and power swing, with test
facility to test power swing block
It should test Differential Relay, Check consistencies YES. Yes
between the protected devices, relay settings,
differential set up and connections, Find the
boundary test value w.r.t the characteristics of the
relay, Harmonic restraint and relay behaviors to the
various harmonics

The test library for various test modules (Over YES. Yes
current, directional, distance, metering,
synchronism/voltage, converters, differential etc.)
should be given so that the user may choose to add
at any time. Each module should contain a test
module with routines test (reclosing, power
encroachment, breaker failure, etc.) that can be
used right off-the box and easily customized to the
need.

The equipment should able to get synchronization YES. Yes

which can take reference from GPS bus for end-to-
end testing
The kit is suitable for testing relays with IEC 61850 YES. Yes
protocols fully.
It is possible to calibrate the relay output at site YES. Not possible
without sending the kit to manufacturer
It is possible to repair / upgrade hardware at site YES. OK
without sending it for repair
/ up Gradation to factory / works

Test kit should have a common tool to create all YES. Not possible
types of distance characteristics like Quadrilateral,
Mho, Half circle by feeding the R, X Values and test
reach test automatically at various angles.?

Superimposing technique for testing the harmonics YES. Not possible

which creating a real condition of Harmonics block
and Harmonics trip test?
Software should have such a facility to test Stability, YES. Yes
Pick up, Timing test, Slope test automatic way.

Kit should have a facility to inject more burdens on YES. Not possible
low currents to test Electromechanical relays?

The kit meets the GENERAL Technical specification YES.

of clause I.
Does the kit has individual ground for individual YES.
current generator

Ground taken from

common source so if the
ground channel
developed a fault, the kit
cannot be used
anymore.But megger has
indivisual ground for
individual current
generator, so if one
ground channel
developed a fault still the
kit will be functional.