Republic of the Philippines

9th Judicial Region

Regional Trial Court
Branch 34
Zamboanga City

Nick Tuazon Young,

Plaintiff,

-versus- Case No. 123123

For: Revocation of
Deed of Donation

Princess Intan Hussein and Register of Deeds, Zamboanga City

Defendant,
x-------------------------------------x

MINUTES OF THE PRE-TRIAL

I. Plaintiff’s/s’ Evidence

A. Documentary and other Object Evidence:

• Exhibit “C” – Blueprint of the house

• Exhibit “D” – Photo of the House and Lot
• Exhibit “E” – Deed of Absolute Sale
• Exhibit E - 1 - Acknowledgement receipt for the Deed of Absolute Sale
• Exhibit “F” – Tax Declaration.
• Exhibit “G” – Certificate Authorizing Registration.
• Exhibit “H” – Notice of Assessment of Real Property by City Assessor's
Office
• Exhibit “I” – Transfer Certificate of Title with title no 1234567890123
• Exhibit “J” – Copy of Deed of Donation with a condition
• Exhibit “K”- USB containing the video of Meagan Young
• Exhibit “L”- Copy of text conversation between the defendant and
plaintiff to show that defendant refused to return the TCT and had
submitted it to have the title transferred to her name,
• Exhibit “M”- copy of plaintiff’s demand letter to defendant
• Exhibit “N”-Letter from the counsel of defendant refusing to return the
TCT no 1234567890123
• Exhibit “O” -Copy of Deed of revocation of donation submitted to the
public respondent Register of Deeds
 2

B. Testimonial Evidence:

• Exhibit “A” – Judicial Affidavit of Capt Nick Tuazon Young

• Exhibit “B” – Judicial Affidavit of Megan Young

II. Defendant’s/s’ Evidence

A. Documentary and other Object Evidence:

• Exhibit 3 - Wedding Contract with coordinator

• Exhibit 4 - Invitation
• Exhibit 5 - Application for Marriage License
• Exhibit 6 - Pagturul Taymah (Audio Recording) with declaration of
donation
• Exhibit 7 - Deed of donation in writing
• Exhibit 8- Deed of Absolute Sale
• Exhibit 9- Certificate Authorizing Registration
• Exhibit 10- Tax declaration
• Exhibit 11- Title certificate of transfer

B. Testimonial Evidence

• Exhibit 1- Judicial Affidavit of Princess Intan Tan Hussein

Exhibit 2- Judicial Affidavit of ROD Darren Alaja

Evidence not listed herein and pre-marked (except in the case of reserved
evidence) shall not be allowed during trial. Reserved Evidence must be described
with specificity and must be included as one of the pieces of evidence in the
initiatory pleadings.

[Include appropriate spaces if there are cross-claimant, third-party complainant or

intervenor]

III. Genuineness and Due Execution Admitted:

For the Plaintiff/s:

• The personal circumstances of the defendant.
• The fact of the location of the house.
• The receipt of letter dated April 3, 2022 from the defendant’s
counsel, refusing to return the title to the property.
• That the said property was given through a deed of donation

For the Defendant/s:

• That they are, in fact, the person charged in the complaint.
 3

• That the plaintiff bought a house and lot located at Muruk

Pasonanca, Zamboanga City with an area of 8, 000 square meters,
amounting to 20, 000, 000 PHP on February 18, 2018 from Eric
Melburn, the best friend of the plaintiff.
• The wedding did not push through as planned

IV. Stipulation of Facts

a. The parties had their Pagturul Taymah (marriage engagement) on

February 14, 2022. The plaintiff offered several expensive gifts as
dowry without any conditions attached to it except the house and lot
with TCT 1234567890123.

b. 2. The plaintiff bought a house and lot located at Muruk, Pasonanca,

Zamboanga City with an area of 8,000 square meter amounting to
P20,000,000.00 on February 18, 2018 from Eric Melburn, the best
friend of the plaintiff as evidenced by the picture and blueprint of the
plan of the house and lot, deed of sale with acknowledgement receipt,
tax declaration, Certification Authorizing Registration, Notice of
Assessment of Real Property and Transfer Certificate of Title with
title no 01234567890123 and hereto attached as Exhibit A, B, C, D, E
F, and G.

c. The condition is that the private defendant will own the house and lot
after the solemnization of their marriage as evidenced by a copy of the
deed of donation and the video taken by the plaintiff’s sister Megan
Young attached hereto as Exhibit H and Exhibit I.

d. The wedding did not push through as planned yet the plaintiff refused
to return the title and continued to file for a transfer of certificate of
title at the Register of Deeds, Zamboanga City without the plaintiff's
knowledge and consent.

V. Issues to be Tried

I. Whether or not the court has jurisdiction over the case.

II. Whether or not the donation is valid.
III. Whether or not the plaintiff is liable to pay for damages.
IV. Whether or not the plaintiff has the right to recover the land.

VI. Possibility of Settlement

The parties, plaintiff and defendant, after being asked about

the possibility for amicable settlement, manifested
willingness for as long as the terms are acceptable and are
mutually beneficial to both.
 4

VII. Schedule of Continuous Trial

A. Presentation of Plaintiff’s/s’ Evidence

 Nick Tuazon Young July 4, 2022
Tetuan, Zamboanga City

 Megan Young July 5, 2022

Tetuan, Zamboanga City

B. Presentation of Defendant’s/s’ Evidence

 Princess Intan Tan-Hussein July 7, 2022
Tumaga, Zamboanga City
 Darren Alaja July 8, 2022
Tumaga Zamboanga City

CONFORMITY:

_____________________________ _____________________________
Nick Tuazon Young Princess Intan Tan- Hussein
Paintiff Defendant
Tetuan, Zamboanga City Tumaga, Zamboanga City

_______________________________ ________________________________
Atty. Liza Ledesma Atty. Conqueror Tabamo
Counsel for the Plaintiff Counsel for the Defendant
Pasonanca, Zamboanga City Canelar, Zamboanga City

ATTESTED BY:

_____________________________________
Atty. Haizel Sophia Hatimil
Branch Clerk of Court