This document discusses different types of communication theory, including postpositivism and cultural theory. It provides context on the emergence of mass communication and changing communication technologies. Regarding Facebook specifically, it notes that while some argue personality drives Facebook use, research found people carry everyday personalities online. A typical Facebook user has around 130 friends, though the definition of "friend" is debated.
This document discusses different types of communication theory, including postpositivism and cultural theory. It provides context on the emergence of mass communication and changing communication technologies. Regarding Facebook specifically, it notes that while some argue personality drives Facebook use, research found people carry everyday personalities online. A typical Facebook user has around 130 friends, though the definition of "friend" is debated.
This document discusses different types of communication theory, including postpositivism and cultural theory. It provides context on the emergence of mass communication and changing communication technologies. Regarding Facebook specifically, it notes that while some argue personality drives Facebook use, research found people carry everyday personalities online. A typical Facebook user has around 130 friends, though the definition of "friend" is debated.
● But according to another psychologist, Samuel Gosling
Module 1: and his research team, maybe personality differences
UNDERSTANDING AND EVALUATING MASS have little to do with why people use facebook, as they COMMUNICATION THEORY discovered that rather than using the site to compensate Baran & David (2015) for aspects of their offline personalities, users simply carry those everyday characteristics over to their online ● Facebook debuted on the internet in 2003. Within 5 selves years, it grew to 100 million users. In October 2012, the ● Facebook is a useful medium to lots of people. company announced it has 1 billion members visiting ● Most users don’t give much thought to what they are monthly, networking in over 70 languages (Delo, 2012) doing and why ● Facebook released a video likening its brand to bridges, airplanes, and the universe DEFINING AND REDEFINING MASS ● Like social networking, facebook brings people COMMUNICATION together ● The number and variety of mass communication and ● Maybe the point was that facebook users represent a media theories have steadily increased universe unto themselves ● Media theory emerged as a more or less independent ● So, what else do we want to know about these 1 billion body of thought in both social sciences and humanities users? How many friends does a typical facebooker ● Mass communication occurs when an organization have? About 130 (Skelton, 2012) Now, this raises employs a technology as a medium to communicate another question. What exactly is a friend? If you can with a large audience. The professionals at the New have 130 of them, are they really friends? Of course York Times (an organization) use the printing press and they are, argue psychologists Ashwini Nadkarni and the newspaper (technology and medium) to reach their Stefan Hofmann readers (a large audience) ● Psychologists Ashwini Nadkarni and Stefan Hofmann ● Mass communication environment is changing quite argue that facebook fosters a sense of belonging and radically lets people express themselves as they’d like ● Remember that much has changed and is changing in ● Psychologists Laura Buffardi and Keith Campbell how people use technologies to communicate (2008) claim that narcissists and people with low self- ● Think of mediated communication as existing on a esteem spend more time on facebook than do others continuum that stretches from interpersonal communication at one end to traditional forms of mass ● Science is one of the fundamental reasons why we communication at the other enjoy our admirable standard of living and have a ● The telephone, for example, sits at one end. It is growing understanding of the world around us obviously a communication technology, but one that is ● Physical scientists and engineers are the dreamers, most typical of interpersonal communication: At most, fixers, the guardians a very few people can be involved in communicating at ● Social scientists are the naysayers, the grinches of the any given time, and they have a great deal of world involvement with and control over that communication. ● Physical science has allowed us to gain increasing The conversation is theirs, and they determine its control over the physical world. content ● Social sciences seem much less useful and their theories ● However, in a big-budget hollywood movie or a less practical and more controversial network telecast of the super bowl sits at the opposite ● One important basis for our society’s reluctance to pole. Viewers have limited control over the accept the theories of the social scientists is the logic of communication that occurs. Their control and causality involvement cannot directly change the content of the ● The implementation of the scientific method is difficult messages being transmitted, hence, message content is for those studying the social world for four reasons: centrally controlled by media organizations 1. Most of the significant and interesting forms of ● The rise of social networking and YouTube human behavior are difficult to measure demonstrates an ever-growing willingness to use media 2. Human behavior is exceedingly complex to share content and perspectives on content 3. Humans have goals and are self-reflexive ● New media companies are competing to provide 4. The simple notion of causality is sometimes innovative and useful technologies that deliver more troubling when it is applied to ourselves attractive services; these technologies and services will give us new ways to create and control media content DEFINING THEORY that is important to us ● Theories are stories about how and why events occur. Scientific theories begin with the assumption that the SCIENCE AND HUMAN BEHAVIOR universe, including the social universe created by acting ● Our society generally respects and believes the human beings, reveals certain basic and fundamental scientists properties and processes that explain the ebb and flow 1. Postpositivism of events in specific processes (Turner, 1998) 2. Cultural theory ● John Bowers and John Courtright offered a traditional 3. Critical theory scientific definition: Theories are sets of statements 4. Normative theory asserting relationships among classes of variables ● According to Charles Berger, A theory consists of a set POSTPOSITIVIST THEORY of interrelated propositions that stipulate relationships ● The idea that knowledge could be gained only through among theoretical constructs and an account of the empirical, observable, measurable phenomena mechanism/s that explain the relationships stipulated in examined through the scientific method the propositions ● After a century of trial and error, social scientists ● Kenneth Bailey’s conception of theory accepts a wider committed to the scientific method developed array of ways to understand the social world: postpositivist theory; this type of theory is based on Explanations and predictions of social phenomena empirical observation guided by scientific method, but relating the subject of interest to some other phenomena it recognizes that humans and human behavior are not ● Stephen Littlejohn and Karen Foss defined theory as as constant as elements of the physical world any organized set of concepts, explanations, and ● Goals of postpositivist theory are the same as those set principles of some aspect of human experience by physical scientists for their theories: ● Emory Griffin also takes this broader view, writing that 1. Explanation a theory is an idea that explains an event or behavior, it 2. Prediction brings clarity to an otherwise jumbled situation: it 3. Control draws order out of chaos. It synthesizes the data, ● For example, researchers want to explain the focuses our attention on what’s crucial, and helps us operation of political advertising, predict which ignore that which makes little difference commercials will be most effective, and control the ● Katherine Miller said that different schools of thought voting behavior of targeted citizens would rely on will define theory in different ways depending on the postpositivist theory needs of the theorist and on beliefs about the social ● Its epistemology argues that knowledge is advanced world and the nature of knowledge through the systematic, logical search for regularities ● Scholars have identified four major categories of and causal relationships employing the scientific communication theory: method ● Postpositivist communication theory then is theory ● Cultural theory is sometimes referred to as interpretive developed through a system of inquiry that resembles as theory; it seeks to interpret the meaning of texts for the much as possible the rules and practices of what we agents that produce them and the audiences that traditionally understand as science consume them ● Any text, any product of social interaction can be a CULTURAL THEORY source of understanding; understanding can in turn ● The goal is to understand how and why that behavior guide actions occurs in the social world ● The ontology of cultural theory says that there is no ● Cultural theory seeks to understand contemporary truly real, measurable social reality, instead, people cultures by analyzing the structure and content of their construct an image of reality based on their own communication; it finds its origin in hermeneutic preferences and prejudices and their interactions with theory- the study of understanding, especially began as others the study or interpretation of actions or texts ● The epistemology of cultural theory is how knowledge ● Hermeneutics originally began as the study or is advanced, relies on the subjective interaction between interpretation of the bible and other sacred works the observer and his/her community ● There are different forms of cultural theory. For ● Knowledge is local; it is specific to the interaction of example, social hermeneutics has as its goal the the knower and the known understanding of how those in an observed social ● According to Katherine Miller, these are a lens through situation interpret their own place in that situation which social phenomena are observed ● Ethnographer Michael Moerman explained how social ● A researcher interested in understanding teens’ hermeneutic theory makes sense of alien or unknown interpretations of social networking websites like cultures. facebook, or one who is curious about meaning- ● Social hermeneutics theory tries to understand how making that occurs in the exchange of information events in the alien world make sense to the aliens, how among teen fans of an online simulation game, their way of life coheres and has meaning and value for would rely on cultural theory the people who live it ● Another branch of cultural theory looks for hidden or CRITICAL THEORY deep meaning in people’s interpretation of different symbol systems- e.g. media texts ● They start from the assumption that some aspects of the ● When people are emancipated, they define reality social world are deeply flawed an in need of through their behaviors and interactions transformation ● Researchers interested in the decline of the power of ● Their aim is to gain knowledge is that social world so the labor movement in industrialized nations or they can change it those interested in limiting the contribution of ● The goal is inherently and intentionally political childrens’ advertising to the nation’s growing because it challenges existing ways of organizing the consumerism would rely on critical theory social world and the people and institutions that ● They see media as an essential tool employed by exercise power in it corporate elites to constrain how people view their ● Critical theory is openly political; it assumes that by social world and to limit their agency in it reorganizing society, we can give priority to the most important human values NORMATIVE THEORY ● Critical theorist study inequality and oppression ● Its aim is neither the representation nor the reformation ● Their theories do more than observe, describe or of reality, instead, its goal is to set an ideal standard interpret; they criticize against which the operation of a given media system ● Critical theory view media as sites of struggles over can be judged social, economic, symbolic, and political power ● A normative media theory explains how a media system (Meyrowitz, 2008) should operate in order to conform to or realize a set of ● Its epistemology argues that knowledge is advanced ideal social values only when it serves to free people and communities ● Its ontology argues that what is known is situational. In from the influence of those more powerful than other words, what is real is knowable about a media themselves system is real or knowable only for the specific social ● They call this emancipatory knowledge; its ontology, system in which that media system exists however, is a bit more complex ● Its epistemology is how knowledge is developed and ● According to critical theory, what is real, what is advanced, based in comparative analysis- we can only knowable, in the social world is the product of the judge the worth of a given media system in a interaction between structure and agency comparison to the ideal espoused by the particular ● When elites control, they define reality social system in which it operates ● Theorists interested in the press’ role in a avoid the study of communication is that the democracy would most likely employ normative communication phenomena are hard to explain theory, as would those examining the operation of parsimoniously the media in an islamic republic or an authoritarian 5. How practical or useful is it? If the goals of state postpositivist theory are explanation, prediction, and control, how much assistance toward these EVALUATING THEORY ends is provided by the theory? ● French philosopher Andre Gide wrote, “No theory is ● When evaluating cultural theory, we need to ask these good unless it permits, not rest, but the greatest work. questions: No theory is good except on condition that one uses it 1. How much new or fresh insight into the event, to go on beyond” behavior, or relationship of interest does it ● In other words, good theory pushes, advances, improves offer? In other words, how much does it the social world advance our understanding? ● When evaluating postpositivist theory, we need to ask 2. How well does it clarify the values inherent in these questions: the interpretation, not only those embedded in 1. How well does it explain the event, behavior, or the phenomenon of interest, but those of the relationship of interests? researcher or theorist? 2. How well does it predict future events, 3. How much support does it generate among behaviors, or relationships? members of the scholarly community also 3. How testable is it? In other words, is it specific investigating the phenomenon of interest? enough in its assertions that it can be 4. How much aesthetic appeal does it have? In systematically supported or rejected based on other words, does it enthuse or inspire its empirical observation? adherents? 4. How parsimonious is it? In other words, is it the ● When evaluating critical theory, we need to ask the simplest explanation possible of the same questions we do of cultural theory, but we must phenomenon in question? Some call this add a fifth: elegance. Keep in mind that communication 1. How useful is the critique of the status quo? In theories generally tend to lack parsimony. In other words, does it provide enough fact, one of the reasons many social scientists understanding of elite power so that power can be effectively challenged? Does the theory video violence on children's behavior, but about the enable individuals to oppose elite definitions of appropriateness of the methods used, the value of the the social world? evidence obtained, or the influence of values on the ● When evaluating normative theory, we need to ask the work following questions: 1. How stable and definitive are the ideal standards MASS COMMUNICATION THEORY of operation against which the media system (or ● Theories have evolved in part as a reaction to changes its parts) under study will be measured? in mass media technology and the rise of new mass 2. What, and how powerful, are the economic, media organizations that exploited this technology social, cultural, and political realities ● Proponents for the four types of theories developed surrounding the actual operation of a system (or different but sometimes related theories its parts) that must be considered in evaluating ● Whenever new forms of media have been developed that performance? they have been praised by some and condemned by 3. How much support does it generate among others members of the scholarly community also ● Debate over the usefulness of new forms of media have investigating a specific media system (or its spawned numerous theories parts)? FOUR TRENDS IN MEDIA THEORY FLEXIBLE SOCIAL SCIENCE 1. The mass society and mass culture trend in media ● Sociologist Kenneth Bailey wrote, “To this day you theory will find within social science both those who think of ➔ Can be regarded as a collection of conflicting themselves as scientists in the strictest sense of the notions developed to make sense of what is word and those with a more subjective approach to the happening whenever there is large-scale and/or study of society, who see themselves more as humanists disruptive social change than as scientists” ➔ An essential argument of mass society theory is ● To some observers, especially committed that media subvert and disrupt the existing postpositivists, this seems unsystematic. It also social order generates disagreement among social scientists, not 2. The limited-effects trend in media theory about the issue under examination, say the influence of ➔ Throughout the 1950s, limited-effects notions 3 CONSTRUCTING THEORIES IN COMMUNICATION about media continued to gain acceptance RESEARCH within academia. These ideas dominated the Robert T. Craig new field of mass communication research ➔ Media were not nearly as powerful as had been 1. Metatheory - is a branch of theory that articulates and feared or hope, instead, these researchers found critiques the assumptions underlying particular theories that people had numerous way of resisting or kinds of theory media influence (Lazarsfeld) An ontological issue: what is a communication 3. The critical cultural trend in media theory theory? ➔ ➔ Communication is still commonly understood as 4. The meaning-making trend in media theory a process in which some content is transmitted ➔ At the heart of many, this theory focus on a from a sender through a medium or channel to a more or less active audience that uses media receiver; although a transmitted message may be content to create meaningful experiences called a communication, it acquires that status only by virtue of being transmitted SUMMARY ➔ From a transmission view it thus makes perfect ● Social science is sometimes controversial because it sense to say that two parties in conflict are suggests causal relationships between things in the communication successfully if they decode each social world and people’s attitudes, values, and other’s message correctly behaviors ➔ The transmission model has been critiqued by ● In physical sciences, causal relationships are often communication theorists who propose instead easily visible and measurable versions of what can be called a constitutive ● While these types of theory have a commitment to an model of communication increased understanding of the social world, they differ An epistemological issue: universal or culture-specific in their goals, their ontology (the nature of reality, what theories? is knowable), their epistemology (how knowledge is ➔ created and expanded), and their axiology (the proper 2. Empirical-scientific approaches - role of values in research and theory building) ➔ However, today, audiences can already make choices, contribute, and share content - media DISCUSSION NOTES users ● Communication is a process ● According to McQuail audiences are critical, empirical, ➔ Within which messages are transmitted cultural (transmission model) ● Communication as a discipline (Craig, 1999; Littlejohn, ➔ Through which meaning is created (ritual Foss & Oetzel, 2017)) model) ➔ Communication has multidisciplinary origins ➔ Through which people are persuaded (publicity and at some point exhibits fragmentation model) ➔ Communication is the social process that ➔ Within which interpretations occur (reception constitutes reality, not a factor in the process model) ➔ “The goal should not be a state in which we ● The mass in mass communication have nothing to argue about, but one in which ➔ Communicating to many we better understand that we all have something ➔ Unidirectional flow very important to argue about” (Craig, 1999); ➔ Asymmetrical relationship between sender and dialogical-dialectical coherence receiver ➔ Should not be stagnant; should evolve ● What is mass media? ● Theorizing new media (Lievrouw, 2009) ➔ Technologies that carry messages to a large ➔ The road to the convergence perspective in number of people (Baran, 2014) NO communication theory ➔ Not a neutral entity; has the capacity to reshape 1. Bridging the interpersonal and the mass the culture aspects of communication ● How is the audience viewed? - Decision and diffusion ➔ Media audience - a group of receivers of perspectives in communication information theory ➔ A consumer market - Viewing audience as active ➔ A cultural group with tastes and preferences agents ➔ A market of technology 2. Making sense of how new media reshaped the way we communicate - Emergence of computer- Defining paradigm mediated communication as a ● Fundamental models or frames of reference we use to subfield organize our observations and reasoning (Bobbie, 2010) - Accounting for presence, ● A cluster of beliefs and dictates which for scientists in a interactivity particular discipline influence what should be studied, 3. Delving into the cultural and critical how research should be done and interpreted (Bryman, aspects of new media technologies 1988) - Media as both material and Dimensions of a theory symbolic ● Philosophical assumptions - Viewing new media as cultural ➔ Ontology - nature product ➔ Epistemology - validity ● Key aspects of mediated communication ➔ Axiology - values 1. Technological ● Concepts - building blocks of theory 2. Social ● Explanations - dynamic connections made by the theory ● Principles - guidelines for actions Defining theory: characterizations and evaluation ● Theory is an organized set of concepts, explanations, Evaluation of theory and principles that depicts some aspect of human ● Theoretical scope - is the theory sufficiently general? experience (Littlejohn et al, 2017) ● Appropriateness - is the theory logically consistent? ● A set of systematic, informed hunches about the way ● Heuristic value - does it generate new ideas? things work (Griffin et al, 2019) ● Validity - are the concepts observable/measurable? ● Grand theory - all encompassing ● Parsimony - is the theory simple enough to be ● Middle-range theory - based on empirical facts; understood well? sufficiently abstract yet clear; specific ● Openness - can the theory be challenged and/or built upon? Defining model ● Model is a representation of phenomenon (Craig, 2013) Organizing theories: categorization and overlaps ● Model is a description and visualization of a process ● Interpersonal ● Group ● Organizational ● Normative - theory explaining how a media system ● Mass should be structured and operate to conform to a set of ● Culture/Society ideal social values
Basic paradigms Communication traditions
1. Positivism ● Socio-psychological - expression, interaction and ➔ Ontology - objective; knowable influence ➔ Epistemology - dualism-objectivity ● Cybernetic - information processing ➔ Methodology - experimental-manipulative ● Rhetoric - practical art of discourse 2. Interpretivism ● Semiotics - intersubjective mediation by signs ➔ Ontology - multiple, created truths ● Socio-cultural - reproduction of social order ➔ Epistemology - non-dualism; non-objectivity ● Critical - discursive reflection ➔ Methodology - empathetic interaction ● Phenomenological - experience of otherness; narratives 3. Postpositivism ➔ Ontology - critical realism Constructing frameworks ➔ Epistemology - modified dualism-objectified Trends in media research ➔ Methodology - modified experimental- ● Mass society and mass culture - media can be easily manipulative corrupted; for propaganda ● Limited effects - media has little direct influence to Major categories of communication theory people ● Postpositivism - theory based on empirical observation ● Critical-cultural - media is a space for oppression; the guided by the scientific method power that the media hold in perpetuating ● Cultural - theory seeking to understand contemporary ● Meaning-making - interactions through media cultures by analyzing the structure and content of their communication Questions and contexts ● Critical - theory is seeking transformation of a ● How do you view the actors in a communication dominant social order in order to achieve desired values process? ● How do you see the context of the communication problem? ● Where do you stand as a researcher? What perspectives gratifications theory; by proving that audiences and inform your inquiry? users really play an active role and provides user- generated content rather than being a passive consumer Levels of a framework of media 1. Theoretical level - taking the theory for what it is; ● I am personally interested in media phenomena theory vs. the current topic specifically social media, like how twitter could 2. Conceptual level - application of theory to the topic; possibly shape or contribute to the socio-political look for the equivalences knowledge of its users, or how a certain social media 3. Operational level - usually for quantitative research; becomes an effective place or not for citizen explaining the concepts in measurable terms journalism; it is also in my interest to at least contribute in helping to combat the spread of fake news, with all SPECIAL NOTES these, I think uses and gratifications theory along with ● Theorists are products of their time spiral of silence theory can help me progress with the ● Theories help us build up an existing foundation of interests i have as these theories mainly focus on the knowledge media users as merely active rather than passive also ● Theory helps us in identifying gaps in our knowledge opinions are dependent on the majority opinion of the and attempting to fill those gaps with intuitive, group just like what is happening in social media impressionistic, or extensional generalizations, among nowadays, people with less knowledge of what is other approaches. Karl Jaspers once observed that It is happening around the world tends to just believe with only when using methodologically classified sciences what the majority of people believe in and so i wanted that we know what we know and what we do not know. to draw the line where we as media consumers and In this way, theory serves as a crucially important guide users should be accountable in not just consuming a for the design of fruitful research projects. In response particular content, but also in contributing to the to Jocel earlier, I think we better understand a theory by credible contents online using it in a research, for example, in our group in cres 101, we use uses and gratifications theory because we Module 2: want to study the effects of election-related contents on POST-POSITIVIST THEORIES tiktok to the voting attitudes of filipino youth voters, ● Cognitive dissonance - with that we can understand easier what is uses and ● Uses and gratifications - ● Cultivation - Second, Symbolic interactionism is a micro-level theory that ● Diffusion of innovations - examines how the social world develops and sustains itself ● Agenda-setting - through continuous and varied interactions between people. As ● Social issue: electoral politics (national or local), covid- a result, it rejects idealist and materialist assumptions about 19 vaccine development and rollout, disaster risk and ontological precedence. response concerning typhoons Third, The media can be used to create a social reality in which Module 3: users can interact and relate with one another and share this CULTURAL THEORIES reality with the public.
Discussant Script Fourth, Framing analysis is a micro-level theory that examines
how people learn to construct meaning in their social world and Good afternoon, everyone! So for this afternoon’s discussion how that meaning is transmitted and shared through the media. we are your discussants, with me are Alex and Sid! O diba sorry kung yung discussants last time ay mga naka red, kami Lastly, The narrative paradigm builds on the fact that humans naman may matchy matchy na zoom background para kabog di are inherently storytellers and enjoy being told stories. History ba! Pero siyempre may significance yan that will be revealed demonstrates a long-held tradition of perceiving our world by Alex and Sid later! Hindi sa pinepressure namin yung through narratives, from cave paintings to bedtime stories. susunod na discussants ha eme so ayun I’m Mark, and I’ll briefly go back to each theory discussed a while ago by our Ayarn, so Alex and Sid share your insights/comments or presenters. questions tapos pag walang nag raise ng hand magtawag kayo hindi pwedeng walang engagement itong discussion natin eme! First, Semiotics is the system of reading signs and focusing on how different cultures or societies interpret them. According to Barthes, signs have both a signifier (the material existence of I learned that these theories are anchored with the social the sign as we perceive it through our senses) and a signified construction of reality. I also learned that framing theory is (the meaning that is interpreted). somehow interconnected with the agenda-setting theory but they cannot work together. They have the connection in a way that agenda-setting focuses on the media effects and that framing theory is about how the effects were transmitted 1. Sexuality is a social construct through the media. 2. Gender is a social construct 3. Gender studies Module 4: 4. Normative structures CRITICAL-CULTURAL THEORIES 5. International relations ● Postcolonial Theory Discussion Notes 1. Racial issue 2. The experience of the Philippines as a former ● Marxist Theory colony greatly shapes the identity of the 1. Commodification of audience attention to sell to Filipinos today advertisers (Smythe, 1977) 3. Constitutes a movement asserting our positions 2. Alienation of users of social media from their against hegemony own selves due to the commodification of their ● It’s good that we had a chance to discuss these theories data (Reveley, 2013) as mass communication students. Power is really 3. Digital divide refers to the unequal access of difficult to define and locate where it is located and advanced ICT resources and facilitates among where it originated. With these theories, we do not only classes leading to the problem of information see how things work but we also learn how to examine inequality (McQuail, 2010) and evaluate media texts that are really essential in a 4. Social movements and how they utilize media in way that it impacts us and the society we live in. And I waging a social revolution or lobbying social think these theories exist to challenge the status quo and reforms can be investigated through Marxist by exposing elite manipulation to the media. perspective 5. Media concentration refers to how the media economy is overwhelmed with the increasing Module 5: number of concentrated media ownership by the INDIGENOUS PERSPECTIVES elite few ● Feminist Theory ● Pantayong Pananaw 1. The concept of intersectionality 1. Pantayo - sumasalamin sa panloob na ● Queer Theory pagkakaugnay-ugnay at pag-uugnay ng mga katangian, halagahin, kaalaman, karunungan, hangarin, kaugalian, pag-aasal, at karanasan ng isang kabuuang pangkalinangan 2. Pangkami - nakikipag-usap mula sa labas tungo sa mga tagaloob ● Pagkataong Pilipino
● As theory is an ever-ending cycle, I think that
understanding indigenous perspectives is just a right thing to do for us to be able to contribute in theorizing and operationalizing our thoughts in improving what we already have in our context. Lastly, I believe to what has been agreed in class that we can't have a pure Filipino identity yet after everything that has been inculcated to us, I guess all we have to do now is to find the line where we can benefit from being both a colony and an indigenous Filipinos.