You are on page 1of 7

Journal of Manufacturing Processes 36 (2018) 44–50

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Manufacturing Processes


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/manpro

Effect of different grinding fluids applied in minimum quantity cooling- T


lubrication mode on surface integrity in cBN grinding of Inconel 718

Anirban Naskar , Biddu Bhushan Singh, Amit Choudhary, S. Paul
Machine Tool and Machining Laboratory, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, Kharagpur, West Bengal 721 302, India

A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Inconel 718 (IN 718) is one of the important nickel based alloys that is being extensively used in aerospace
Surface integrity industry. Being an aerospace material, surface integrity is of paramount importance due to high risk factor
Residual stress involved in this kind of industry. Superabrasive grinding wheels are believed to be superior over conventional
Nickel based alloy wheels, which can improve the surface integrity of the ground component. Further, minimum quantity cooling
lubrication (MQCL) is seems to be a promising technique that can also yield desirable surface quality. Therefore,
in the present study IN 718 was ground with single layer superabrasive cBN wheel with neat oil, soluble oil water
emulsion and different nanofluids in MQCL mode, and the surface integrity was studied. Flood cooling was also
used as a benchmark. Residual stress, ground surface morphology, and surface roughness were studied using X-
ray diffraction, scanning electron microscope, and 3D surface profilometer, respectively. Chip morphology was
also studied using scanning electron microscope to correlate it with the surface quality of the job. Performance of
MQCL neat oil was found to be the best as compared to other fluids in the context of surface integrity due to
proper lubrication and grit penetration.

1. Introduction wheels with higher porosity gave better surface characteristics due to
slower wheel loading and adequate transfer of cutting fluid. Also, high
The high fatigue strength of nickel based super-alloys even at high porosity led to more frequent bond fractures that resulted in self-shar-
operating temperature makes them an ideal choice for several in- pening of grinding wheel. Patil [7] studied the grindability of Inconel
dustries including the aerospace sector. However, these alloys are dif- 718 in flood cooling using the cBN wheel and found them suitable for
ficult to machine/grind. Cracking, high tensile residual stress, surface grinding Inconel. The effect of grinding on residual stress has not been
burn, and white layer formation are some of the major problems as- reported in the above studies [5–7]. Yao et al. [8] investigated the effect
sociated with machining such alloys [1–3]. Kovach and Malkin [4] of grinding on residual stress in Inconel 718 with flood cooling using
reported that microcracking may occur due to high tensile surface re- vitrified bonded single alumina (SA) wheel. The significant influence of
sidual stress. downfeed was observed on the affected layer. The affected depth of
Liu et al. [5] used cBN, diamond and alumina wheels while grinding residual stress of around 40–60 μm for 0.005 mm downfeed and
Inconel 718 under flood cooling environment. They proposed a per- 100–120 μm for 0.02 mm downfeed was found. For both the downfeed,
formance index by amalgamating surface roughness, grinding ratio, the surface residual stress was highly tensile in the range of
grinding force, and grinding temperature, for both rough and finish 700–1000 MPa.
grinding. The performance index was found to be higher for cBN and Flood cooling uses huge amounts of coolants that have a negative
diamond wheels as compared to conventional alumina wheel. They also impact on the environment and is an expensive process (can be as high
carried out cost analysis, which concluded that the diamond wheel was as 18% of the total manufacturing cost) [9]. Minimum quantity lu-
better than alumina wheel even after considering the huge difference in brication can serve as an alternative to the widely used flood cooling.
prices of the wheels. Cai and Rowe [6] ground Inconel 718 with dif- The advantages of MQL over the conventional cutting fluid includes
ferent cBN wheels having different porosity and investigated the per- very low consumption of cutting fluid, less maintenance and disposal
formance of each wheel in flood cooling mode. The study showed that cost of cutting fluid, and effective penetration of cutting fluid. Sinha


Corresponding author at: Machine Tool and Machining Laboratory, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, Kharagpur,
West Bengal 721 302, India.
E-mail addresses: aniprit.09@gmail.com (A. Naskar), bhushan.biddu@iitkgp.ac.in (B.B. Singh), achoudhary@iitkgp.ac.in (A. Choudhary),
spaul@mech.iitkgp.ac.in (S. Paul).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmapro.2018.09.023
Received 26 March 2018; Received in revised form 14 September 2018; Accepted 19 September 2018
Available online 26 October 2018
1526-6125/ © 2018 The Society of Manufacturing Engineers. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
A. Naskar et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 36 (2018) 44–50

et al. [10] optimized experimental conditions to obtain the best results Table 1
in grinding of Inconel 718 with soluble oil water emulsion (1:20) ap- Composition of Nanofluids.
plied in MQL mode using conventional alumina wheel. The document Sl. No. Particle Density % volume Mass of Mass of
provided the experimental parameters that produced least surface (g/cm3) concentration nanoparticle in surfactant in
roughness (flow rate at 150 ml/h, angular nozzle position at 15° and air 100 ml of water 100 ml of
pressure at 8 bar). It was suggested that the standoff distance should (in g) water (in g)

neither be too high nor too low. The droplet quality was observed to be 1 MoS2 4.8 0.1 0.4800 0.2400
good at low flow rate (best at 150 ml/h). Grinding of Inconel 718 was 2 WS2 7.5 0.1 0.7500 0.3750
attempted with alumina wheel using different grinding fluids applied in 3 hBN 2.29 0.1 0.2290 0.1145
MQL mode [11]. Performance of ZnO and Ag nanofluids were com-
pared with dry grinding, wet grinding, and MQL with soluble oil water
emulsion. Improvement in grindability was observed while grinding reported values of residual stress are average of two measurements.
with nanofluids. Sinha et al. [12] performed dry grinding of Inconel ZEISS SEM-EVO18 was used to observe the ground surface morphology
718 using conventional silicon carbide (SiC) and alumina (Al2O3) and the chip morphology. Surface roughness was measured using
wheels. The investigation concluded that Inconel 718 can be ground Taylor Hobson-Form Talysurf-50 which is a 3D contact type surface
more efficiently using alumina grinding wheels compared to the SiC profilometer. The roughness values reported are average of ten surface
grinding wheel. This happened because silicon carbide wheels under- roughness profiles.
went severe wear as it reacted with Inconel at higher temperatures.
Effect of different MQL parameters (air pressure and fluid flow rate) 3. Results and discussion
was studied in the grinding of Inconel 751 with resin bonded diamond
grinding wheel [13]. Lowest surface roughness and normal grinding 3.1. Surface roughness and ground surface morphology
force were observed at highest air pressure (6 bar) and lowest flow rate
of the fluid (60 ml/h) whereas lowest grinding temperature was found Ground surface morphology under different grinding environments
at highest pressure (6 bar) and highest flow rate (100 ml/h). But they is shown in Fig. 1. Surface irregularities (e.g. ploughing) are presents in
[10–13] did not investigate the role of cooling-lubrication in MQL mode each of the grinding environments even in flood cooling except for
on the residual stress on the ground surface. MQCL neat oil. Ploughing is the sidewise displacement of the material.
It is quite apparent that the literature focusing on the surface in- The ploughed material remains attached to the groove generated by the
tegrity of IN 718 upon grinding using superabrasive wheels under micro-cutting action of the abrasive grit. Fig. 2 shows schematically the
conventional cooling-lubrication environment is very scant. Further, material that has been ploughed on both the sides of the grinding-
residual stress, which is a key factor of surface integrity, has not been groove. The nature of schematic depiction of ploughing matches closely
investigated in detail in MQCL grinding of IN 718. Therefore in the with the actual SEM microphotograph as shown in Fig. 2(c). Often the
present work, the effect of grinding of Inconel 718 with single layer cutting action of an abrasive grit mechanically interacts with the al-
superabrasive cBN wheel under MQCL mode on surface integrity has ready ground surface. Fig. 3 shows the effect of such ploughing sche-
been investigated in detail. Three different nanofluids along with neat matically and as a microphotograph obtained under SEM (Fig. 3(c)).
oil and soluble oil water emulsion have been applied in MQCL mode. The ground surface generated under neat oil shows very little or no
Flood cooling has also been used as a benchmark. Residual stress along ploughing (Fig. 1). Grinding marks are clearly visible on the ground
with other surface integrity parameters such as ground surface mor- surface under neat oil that stands for material removal by proper
phology, surface roughness has been studied. Chip morphology has also shearing. Cooling ability of the neat oil is expected to be lower than
been investigated to correlate it with surface quality. other fluids [14]. Therefore, it can be directly attributed to the excellent
lubricating property of neat oil that enabled proper shearing action. For
2. Experimental details a fixed grit geometry, ploughing to cutting transition occurs once it
reaches a critical rake angle [15]. It is known that high negative rake
Horizontal spindle plunge surface grinding of Inconel 718 was angle promotes more ploughing action in grinding as compared to
carried out with monolayer electroplated cBN wheel using Cosmos cutting. There exists a critical rake angle below (less negative) which
EARTH-6030 NC grinding machine. The dimension of work-piece was cutting occurs and above which ploughing takes place. This critical rake
8 mm × 8 mm × 25 mm. The grinding speed was 30 m/s, table speed angle depends on the lubrication imparted by the grinding fluid. For a
was 2 m/min and downfeed was 10 μm. Ten passes were taken for each better lubrication, cutting occurs even at higher negative rake as the
experiment. The mean of the observed forces in the last five passes was critical rake angle increases (more negative) with lubrication [15]. In
considered to calculate the net tangential and normal force. The MQCL grinding, the rake angle of the grits is not same. It changes from grain to
parameters were: lubricant flow rate was 200 ml/h, gas pressure was grain due to random orientation. Therefore, it is suspected that grits
5 bar, horizontal stand-off distance was 20 mm, vertical stand-off dis- those failed to provide cutting due to high negative rake in poor lu-
tance was 15 mm and the angle at which the nozzle was inclined was brication medium, provided cutting with proper lubrication. Hence,
10° with horizontal. neat oil, which is expected to provide better lubrication, shows less
0.1 v/v% nanofluids of MoS2, WS2 and hBN were prepared by ploughing as compared to other fluids. It also supports MQCL as a
mixing the surfactant with nanoparticles in distilled water. The re- capable technique that makes the cutting fluid reach the grinding zone.
sulting mixture was sonicated for 1 h to prepare a homogeneous na- Among the nanofluids, hBN provided a ground surface with more
nofluid. Sodium Dodecyl Sulphate (SDS) was used as surfactant to im- ploughing. This can be ascribed to agglomeration of hBN nanoparticles
prove the stability of nanofluids. The composition of nanofluids has at high temperature.
been mentioned in Table 1. Soluble oil (Veedol – Solucut super) water
emulsion in 1:20 ratio was used both in MQCL and flood cooling mode. 3.1.1. Correlation between ground surface morphology and surface
Neat oil (HP – Trimofin 23) was also used in MQCL mode. roughness parameters
The normal and tangential grinding forces were measured using Fig. 4 shows the effect of grinding environments on the different
piezoelectric dynamometer (Kistler – 9257B). X-Ray diffraction tech- surface roughness parameters and their ratios. Despite providing better
nique was used to measure residual stresses (PANalytical EMPYREAN). lubrication, arithmetic average surface roughness (Ra) of neat oil has
The peak that was considered was at a nominal 2θ (diffraction angle) been found to be the highest as compared to other grinding environ-
value of 129.5° of (220) crystallographic plane with Cr X-ray target. The ment as shown in Fig. 4(a) whereas lowest Ra is found for WS2

45
A. Naskar et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 36 (2018) 44–50

Fig. 1. SEM images of ground surface under different cooling lubrication conditions.

nanofluid. However, if the root mean square surface roughness (Rq) is n


1
compared from Fig. 4(b), neat oil provides comparable results as WS2. Rq = ∑ y2
n i=1 i (2)
To understand this discrepancy in the result of these two roughness
parameter, a careful observation is required on the mathematical for- As the formula shows in Eqs. (1) and (2), Ra is the average value of
mulae and on the ground surface morphology. all the peak and valley heights (yi) from the mean line whereas for the
calculation of Rq all the heights (yi) are squared first then the average
n
1 value gets square rooted. Therefore, Rq amplifies occasional high and
Ra = ∑ |y |
n i=1 i (1) low readings [16] and the increase in Rq will be more for surface with
peaks and valleys as compared to Ra. So, the surface with sudden peak

Fig. 2. (a) 3D view of ploughed surface, (b) top view, (c) experimentally observed surface by the action of a single grit.

46
A. Naskar et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 36 (2018) 44–50

Fig. 3. (a) 3D view of ploughed surface, (b) top view, (c) experimentally observed surface by the action of multiple grits.

and valley is expected to have higher Rq/Ra ratio than a surface with irregularities e.g. ploughing. These surface irregularities amplify the Rq
uniform peak and valley height. For example, Fig. 5 shows roughness and consequently, the Rq/Ra ratio also increases. This phenomenon can
profile of two typical surfaces. The case I is having a surface of uniform be further supported by core roughness parameter (Rk). Rk is a measure
peak and valleys whereas case II is a surface having some occasional of core roughness (peak to valley) that excludes unusually high peaks
peaks and valleys. Therefore, based on the above discussion it can be and deep valleys. In grinding, this parameter can be used to exclude the
(
said that Rq Ra ) > Rq Ra
Case II
( )
.
Case I
peaks that can come due to ploughing or other irregularities generated
on the ground surface. Flood cooling and hBN nanofluid yield similar Ra
Occasional peak and valleys are expected to be higher in the ground
surface with higher ploughing. Fig. 4(c) depicts Rq/Ra ratio for different value like that under neat oil as can be seen in Fig. 4(a). But, the Rk
grinding environments. Neat oil shows comparatively lower Rq/Ra ratio value obtained under neat oil is much higher than that under flood
close to 1.1 as compared to other grinding environments which prove cooling and hBN nanofluid (Fig. 4(d)). Higher Ra value along with
that ploughing in case of neat oil was comparatively lower than others. lower Rk value under flood cooling and hBN nanofluid can be ascribed
For other samples, it is above 1.2 which can be directly correlated to the to more ploughing generating unusual high peaks. In case of neat oil,
ground surface morphology that shows the presence of surface higher Rk value can be attributed to higher grit penetration as discussed
in the next section.

Fig. 4. (a) arithmetic average surface roughness, (b) root mean square surface roughness, (c) ratio of Rq/Ra and (d) core roughness (Rk).

47
A. Naskar et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 36 (2018) 44–50

Fig. 5. Schematic representation of two typical surfaces.

Fig. 6. (a) tangential and (b) normal grinding force under different grinding environments.

3.2. Grinding force and residual stress

Fig. 6 shows tangential and normal grinding forces of different


grinding environments. Neat oil shows maximum normal force and
second highest tangential force. This result is quite interesting and
contradictory as well to the earlier observation on surface morphology
in which it has been observed that neat oil performed better than others
due to its better lubricating nature. Better lubrication ability of neat oil
can also be confirmed by the tangential to normal force ratio (Ft/Fn).
For neat oil, it came to be 0.35 whereas for other fluids it is around 0.4
and above. Low force ratio in conjunction with clean ground surface
implies that higher grinding force for neat oil cannot be accounted
owing to inadequate lubrication. Therefore, it is being suspected that
higher forces are due to higher grit penetration in case of neat oil as
compared to other fluids. One can argue that for the same maximum
undeformed chip thickness (hm) grit penetration should remain same.
But, if the arithmetic average surface roughness (Ra) is observed (which
is a rough estimator of grit penetration), neat oil shows the maximum
surface roughness (Ra) despite having a clean ground surface which Fig. 7. Surface residual stress of different grinding environments.
clearly indicates that the grit penetration is more in case of neat oil. The
grit penetration of any grinding conditions cannot exceed the hm.
stress for all the used grinding environments. Residual stress has been
Therefore, it can be concluded that proper grit penetration occurred
found to be minimum while grinding with neat oil. Usually, residual
during grinding with neat oil. Further, confirmation of this correlation
stress becomes less tensile with the reduction in grinding temperature
between grinding force and Ra can be drawn by observing the force and
or with the increase in plastic deformation due to the mechanical cut-
Ra value obtained while using WS2 nanofluid. WS2 nanofluid shows
ting action of the grits [17]. Lower residual stress for neat oil can be
minimum Ra along with minimum tangential force and second lowest
attributed to the proper mechanical action of the grits. Highest normal
normal force. It indicates that grit penetration is lower for WS2 than
grinding force in conjunction with clean ground surface stands for
other fluids, which is responsible for lowering the force. Hence, lower
proper grit penetration during grinding with near oil. Further, it is
grinding force and lower average surface roughness (Ra) cannot be
expected that the grinding temperature remains comparable under neat
made as an indicator of better grindability without considering other
oil with respect to other grinding fluids. Neat oil has less cooling-ability
aspects.
due to its lower thermal conductivity as compared to water based
Another justification of proper grit penetration during grinding with
grinding fluids [14]. But its enhanced lubrication ability is expected to
neat oil is obtained from the residual stress. Fig. 7 shows the residual

48
A. Naskar et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 36 (2018) 44–50

Fig. 8. Typical serrated chip obtained while grinding Inconel 718 using single
layer electroplated cBN grinding wheel under flood cooling.

compensate for its lower cooling-ability and provide similar grinding


temperature. For the same soluble oil water emulsion that has been
used in flood cooling and MQCL mode, flood cooling yields lower re-
sidual stress as compared to MQCL. Convective heat transfer co-effi- Fig. 10. variation of cutting stain with coefficient of friction at the chip-tool
cient under flood cooling is much higher than MQCL [18]. This in- interface.
dicates that the higher heat transfer co-efficient of flood cooling is
responsible for better cooling that has provided less tensile residual
3.3. Chip study
stress as compared to MQCL. Nanofluids have provided much higher
residual stress as compared to other fluids. This may be due to the in-
Serrated chips are found for all the grinding environments. One such
sufficient cooling and lubrication ability of the nanofluids owing to
image of the serrated chip is shown in Fig. 8. Typically, nickel-based
agglomeration.
alloy provides long chip owing to their high ductility [14]. Flowing type
long chips have been found for flood cooling, neat oil and soluble oil

Fig. 9. SEM images of chip morphology that formed during grinding under different environments.

49
A. Naskar et al. Journal of Manufacturing Processes 36 (2018) 44–50

water emulsion whereas very short broken type of chips are observed • Residual stress was found to be minimum for neat oil followed by
during grinding with all nanofluids as shown in Fig. 9. Flowing type flood cooling.
chip forms in grinding of IN 718 if grits are very sharp [19]. Single layer • Flood cooling, MQCL neat oil, and soluble oil water emulsion pro-
superabrasive cBN wheel which has been used in the present study is duced the flowing type of chip whereas broken small chips were
considered to be one of the sharpest wheels among the others which observed for all the nanofluids.
justify the flow type chip formation. Flow type chip formation was also • Performance of MQCL neat oil was found to be most favourable as
correlated with the best surface quality in the same study [19]. Residual compared to other fluids.
stress is one of the most crucial aspects of surface quality. Lowest re-
sidual stress has been observed in the earlier section for neat oil fol- Acknowledgement
lowed by flood cooling and soluble oil water emulsion. Neat oil, flood
cooling and soluble oil water emulsion produced flow type chip that The research did not receive any specific grant from funding
supports the correlation between flow type chip and good surface agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
quality. Chip produced by nanofluids in the present study are found to
be broken type that contradicts to an earlier research [11] in which References
flow type chips were observed for nanofluids. Broken type of chips has
been observed in this study for all the three nanofluids irrespective of [1] Xu XP, Yu YQ, Xu HJ. Effect of grinding temperatures on the surface integrity of a
the surface quality of the job. nickel-based superalloy. J Mater Process Technol 2002;129(1–3):359–63.
[2] Österle W, Li PX. Mechanical and thermal response of a nickel-base superalloy upon
Chip breaking occurs when the cutting strain reaches a limit [20]. grinding with high removal rates. Mater Sci Eng A 1997;238(2):357–66.
The cutting strain can be obtained from Eq. 3. A direct correlation [3] Österle W, Li PX, Nolze G. Influence of surface finishing on residual stress depth
between cutting strain and co-efficient of friction at the chip-tool in- profiles of a coarse-grained nickel-base superalloy. Mater Sci Eng A 1999;262(1-
2):308–11.
terface (μ) can be obtained by combining Eqs. 3–5 which is expressed as [4] Kovach JA, Malkin S. Thermally induced grinding damage in superalloy materials.
Eq. 6. Fig. 10 shows this correlation in a graphical way while γo (rake CIRP Ann-Manuf Technol 1988;37(1):309–13.
angle) has been considered as –60°. It shows that cutting strain in- [5] Liu Q, Chen X, Gindy N. Assessment of Al 2 O 3 and superabrasive wheels in nickel-
based alloy grinding. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2007;33(9–10):940–51.
creases with the increase in co-efficient of friction. It means that with
[6] Cai R, Rowe WB. Assessment of vitrified CBN wheels for precision grinding. Int J
the increase in μ, probability of chip breaking increases. It seems na- Mach Tools Manuf 2004;44(12–13):1391–402.
nofluids failed to provide proper lubrication in the chip-tool interface [7] Patil DV. Ph.D. Thesis] Grindability study of Inconel 718 using monolayer gal-va-
nically bonded monolayer cBN wheel. IIT Kharagpur; 2006.
which provided the broken type of chips.
[8] Yao CF, Jin QC, Huang XC, Wu DX, Ren JX, Zhang DH. Research on surface integrity
εc = cot β + tan(β−γo) (3) of grinding Inconel718. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2013;65(5–8):1019–30.
[9] Sanchez JA, Pombo I, Alberdi R, Izquierdo B, Ortega N, Plaza S, et al. Machining
cos γo evaluation of a hybrid MQL-CO2 grinding technology. J Clean Prod
tan β = 2010;18(18):1840–9.
ζ − sin γo (4) [10] Sinha MK, Setti D, Ghosh S, Rao PV. An alternate method for optimisation of
minimum quantity lubrication parameters in surface grinding. Int J Mach Mach
π
ζ= e μ ( 2 − γo) (5) Mater 2016;18(5–6):586–605.
[11] Sinha MK, Madarkar R, Ghosh S, Rao PV. Application of eco-friendly nanofluids
cos γo during grinding of Inconel 718 through small quantity lubrication. J Clean Prod
π π −tan γo
e μ ( 2 − γo)−sin γo e μ ( 2 − γo) − sin γo 2017;141:1359–75.
εc = + cos γo tan γo [12] Sinha MK, Setti D, Ghosh S, Rao PV. An investigation on surface burn during
cos γo 1 + μ ( π −γ ) grinding of Inconel 718. J Manuf Process 2016;21:124–33.
e 2 o − sin γ
o (6) [13] Balan ASS, Vijayaraghavan L, Krishnamurthy R. Minimum quantity lubricated
grinding of Inconel 751 alloy. Mater Manuf Process 2013;28(4):430–5.
[14] Klocke F. Manufacturing processes 2—grinding. honing, lapping. Berlin Heidelberg:
4. Conclusions Springer-Verlag; 2009. p. 2009.
[15] Williams JA, Y Xie. The generation of wear surfaces by the interaction of parallel
grooves. Wear 1992;155(2):363–79.
In the present research, an attempt has been made to study the ef- [16] http://www.alphaomegapt.com/pdf%20files/Surface%20Finish%20Definitions.
fect of different grinding fluids applied in MQCL mode on the grind- pdf (Accessed 26 March 2018).
ability of Inconel 718. Based on the above results and discussion some [17] Brinksmeier E, Cammett JT, König W, Leskovar P, Peters J, Tönshoff HK. Residual
stresses—measurement and causes in machining processes. CIRP Ann-Manuf
major conclusion can be drawn: Technol 1982;31(2):491–510.
[18] Hadad MJ, Tawakoli T, Sadeghi MH, Sadeghi B. Temperature and energy partition
• Neat oil could produce a clean ground surface with very less in minimum quantity lubrication-MQL grinding process. Int J Mach Tools Manuf
2012;54:10–7.
ploughing as compared to other fluids.
• Neat oil shows lowest Rq/Ra ratio owing to its uniform surface
[19] Tso PL. An investigation of chip types in grinding. J Mater Process Technol
1995;53(3–4):521–32.
roughness. [20] Nakayama K. A study on chip-breakers. Bull Jsme 1962;5(17):142–50.

• Coefficient of friction was minimum for neat oil.

50

You might also like