You are on page 1of 14

The

 Startup  Journey  Project  White  Paper  

The  Startup  Journey  Project  


Entrepreneurship  Methodology  for  Emerging  Economies  
                                                                                                         
Roberto  Musso    (@RobertoMussoM)  
Dario  Liberona    (@darioliberona)  
Revision  4.3    –  October  2016  

Summary
Startup   ecosystems   in   emerging   countries   are   very   different   from   those   in   developed  
economies.  Instead  of  just  replicating  exactly  their  entrepreneurial  practices,  they  must  
be  adapted  to  emerging  economies  conditions.  The  Startup  Journey  Project  (SJP)  is  a  
methodology   to   improve   the   odds   of   success   for   startups   in   emerging   countries.  
Based   on   concepts   transferred   from   the   evolutionist   model,   as   well   as   inspired   in  
software   development   methodologies,   specifically   the   Customer   Journey   Analysis,  SJP  
offers   a   model   to   analyze   the   gaps   among   the   particular   entrepreneurship   practices  
(“Premes”)   in   which   a   startup   needs   to   excel   in   a   restrictive   environment,   and   those  
practices  already  accomplished.  

Introduction
Successful   starting   up   a   new   dynamic   and   innovative   company   is   very   difficult.     The  
high   percentage   of   startups   that   fail   in   emerging   markets   shows   that   we   still   lack   a  
methodology   that   allows   us   to   improve   the   success   rates.   The   multidimensional  
challenges,  obstacles  and  surprises  that  a  project  faces  during  its  startup  journey  are  
multiple   in   number   and   nature.   Additionally,   these   challenges   differ   among   many  
types  of  projects  and  scenarios,  they  are  unknown  and  they  also  change  over  time.  
 
If  being  an  entrepreneur  is  difficult  everywhere,  in  emerging  countries  is  even  more  
complicated,   not   only   because   of   restrictive   conditions,   but   also   due   to   our   common  
habit   of   importing   models,   methodologies   and   entrepreneurial   practices   from  
developed  countries  that  may  be  valid  for  them,  but  which  don’t  necessarily  apply  in  
developing   economies.     Differences   in   our   entrepreneurial   ecosystems   are   not   limited  
to   customer’s   purchasing   power,   banking   services   penetration,   technology  
penetration   or   market   size.   Established   companies   often   do   not   compete   fiercely  
because   of   their   comfortable   dominant   positions,   they   don´t   need   to   innovate   much  
and   consequently   they   don´t   conduct   serious   open   innovation   processes   that   could  
drive  demand  to  startups.    
 

Electroniccopy
Electronic copyavailable
available at:
at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777
https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777
Universities,   meanwhile,   have   not   decidedly   adopted   entrepreneurship   and  
entrepreneurial   training   so   they   are   not   really   making   an   impact   in   the  
entrepreneurial  culture,  knowledge,  skills  or  intellectual  capital  property.  As  a  result  
of   this   scenario,   in   emerging   countries   there   are   no   relevant   amounts   of   venture  
capital  or  funds  that  will  take  more  risk,  neither  a  dynamic  stock  market  to  boost  the  
initial   public   offering   (IPO)   of   new   companies.   From   this   perspective,   it   is   clear   that  
just   replicating   entrepreneurial   practices,   which   could   work   well   in   developed  
economies,  will  not  produce  similar  outcomes  in  emerging  ones.  
The  aim  of  SJP  is  to  help  the  entrepreneurs  who  face  the  huge  challenge  of  starting  a  
new   company,   providing   them   a   new   methodological   model   that   improves   their  
projects  survival  and  success  rates,  based  on  the  identification  and  analysis  of  suitable  
entrepreneurial  practices.    Although  the  concepts  in  this  analysis  can  be  applied  to  any  
scenario,   its   application   has   to   consider   the   specific   conditions   for   particular  
ecosystems.    
 

Cross fertilization from other disciplines


The  Startup  Journey  Project  is  based  on  three  pillars:  

• Entrepreneurship   experience   in   emerging   countries   that   provides   a   general  


map  of  the  challenges  ahead.  
• The   evolutionist   model   provides   its   adaptive   method   and   its   concept  
of  genome2,  as  tools  for  selection  of  attributes1  which  can  contribute  to  survive.  
• Software   engineering,   particularly   its   methodology   for   optimizing   the   User  
Experience   (UX),   called   "The   Customer   Journey",   will   provide   its   holistic  
perspective,  its  multidimensional  vision  and  its  gap  analysis  focus.  

 
By   combining   these   techniques,   we   seek   to   develop   a   methodology   that   signals   the  
entrepreneurial  project,  our  main  study  subject,  revising  its  level  of  compliance  with  
respect   to   a   pattern   of   attributes   that   characterizes   successful   projects   in   similar  
environments.   Its   application   in   emerging   economies   can   allow   us   to   determine   a  
specific  pattern  guide  for  projects  in  this  environment.  
We   will   focus   this   effort   in   the  entrepreneurial   project,   as   the   analysis   unit.  Its   main  
constituent   elements   are:   the   team   project,   the   problem   or   opportunity   to   be  
addressed,  the  proposed  solution,  the  strategies  used,  the  business  model,  resources  
required  or  allocated  and  practices  carried  out.  

                                                                                                               
1
We will use the term “attribute” to represent features, abilities or skills of the entrepreneurial team, the
project, the opportunity, the solution or the entrepreneurial process.
 

Electroniccopy
Electronic copyavailable
available at:
at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777
https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777
SJP  seeks  to  provide  guiding  information  for  to  two  types  of  readers:  entrepreneurs,  in  
relation   to   their   projects,   and   public   policy   makers   to   promote   entrepreneurship   in  
their  ecosystems.  

Entrepreneurship in emerging economies


Modern  entrepreneurship  theory  is  the  first  area  in  which  we  rely  to  develop  SJP.      
A   startup   project   that   seeks   to   be   successfully   in   a   developing   economy   should  
prioritize   appropriate   practices.  To   achieve   this,   it   is   essential   to   understand   that  
there  are  crucial  differences  with  developed  economies  that  should  be  considered:  

• The  purchasing  power  and  the  level  of  banking  use  of  the  people  is  low.  
• Local   talent   is   not   sufficiently   trained   in   entrepreneurship   theory   yet.   There   is   not  
enough   experience,   and   relevant   information   is   not   widely   available   in   native  
languages  or  could  not  apply  to  local  markets.  
• Big  corporations  usually  don´t  face  high  levels  of  competition  yet,  so  they  are  not  
compelled   to   collaborate   with   startups   in   open   innovation   modes   to   produce  
competitive   advantages   as   much   as   in   developed   markets,   with   the   consequent  
benefit   and   support   that   this   would   represent   for   startups.  As   a   result,  
entrepreneurs  have  less  inclination  to  create  disruptive  products  and  services.  
• Universities   have   not   massively   developed   mechanisms   to   transfer   Intellectual  
Property   to   the   private   sector   yet,   which   could   eventually   provide   some  
advantages  to  new  companies.  Collaboration  between  companies  and  universities  
is  rather  scarce.  
• Regulatory   structures   are   very   slow   and   do   not   provide   effective   Intellectual  
Property  protection.  
• Ecosystems   are   not   mature   enough:   venture   capital   funding   is   not   abundant   and  
the   support   of   companies   as   potential   customers   for   startups   is   scarcer.  The  
possibility   for   a   startup   to   make   and   Initial   Public   Offering   (IPO)   is   almost  
impossible.  

However,   the   entrepreneurial   energy   is   a   growing   force   and   successful   projects  


already   exist,   but   they   are   rare.  To   some   extent,   this   situation   is   the   result   of  
importing  developed  world  practices  that  do  not  work  well  in  our  markets:  startups  
run  after  distinctions  in  contests,  forgetting  to  prioritize  market  success  search;  they  
seek   competitive   advantage   through   patents,   but   formal   intellectual   property  
protection  processes  take  years  to  provide  relative  usefulness;  startups  innocently  try  
to   solve   global   problems,   without   realizing   that   they   cannot   compete   against   the  
hugeness   of   the   capacity   that   companies   in   developed   countries   have   to   finance   and  
develop  their  own  initiatives  or  to  a  certain  extend  copy  others.  
Our   overall   knowledge   of   entrepreneurship   in   emerging   countries   (even   though   some  
of   these   points   are   debatable)   indicates   that   an   emerging   entrepreneurial   project  
must   seek   local   advantages   over   potential   competitors   from   developed   countries,  
which   will   have   large   amounts   of   funding   and   are   part   of   a   more   develop   startup  

Electroniccopy
Electronic copyavailable
available at:
at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777
https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777
ecosystem.  To  have  a  better  chance,  emerging  countries  projects  must  rely  on  features  
in  the  particular  space  in  which  they  will  operate,  to  get  a  natural  protection  against  
the   entry   of   powerful   competitors   from   developed   countries.  For   instance,   an  
entrepreneurial   project   can   focus   on   solving   emerging  problems 2 .  It   also   should  
urgently  try  to  reach  breakeven,  considering  the  local  venture  capital  scarcity.    
The   Appropriability3  advantage   should   be   obtained   through   strategies   that   are   not  
based  just  on  patents.  Companies  should  be  designed  to  stay  for  a  long  time  and  not  
just   to   be   sold,   because   acquisitions   are   rare4.  These   are   just   examples   among   many  
other  considerations,  but  they  allow  us  to  show  that  the  profile  of  a  successful  startup  
in   emerging   countries   necessarily   differs   from   the   corresponding   one   from   developed  
countries.  So,  exact  replication  may  not  work  as  well  has  hoped.  
Finally,   we   must   precisely   define   what   we   will   consider   a  successful  entrepreneurial  
project  in  the  context  of  emerging  countries  so  we  can  profile  them.  From  the  limited  
history   of   existing   successes   in   our   economies,   this   definition   differs   from   that  
obtained  from  developed  countries,  which  is  basically  determined  by  indicators  such  
as  user  traction,  high  sales,  high  valued  IPO’s  or  sky  rocketed  acquisitions  (even  when  
some   of   the   companies   still   show   big   financial   losses).  In   developing   countries,  
considering  the  restrictions  previously  mentioned,  we  defined  a  successful  project  as  
the   one   that   achieves   at   least   two   of   the   following   conditions:   stable   breakeven5,  
significant  independent  funding6  or  minimum  annual  contribution  margin  equivalent  
to  USD  100,000  in  year  three7.    
 

Evolutionism
The   biological   evolutionary   discipline   will   be   the   second   contributor   to   the  
development  of  SJP  methodology.  

                                                                                                               
2  Emerging  problems:  those  that  don’t  exist  in  developed  markets,  so  their  startups  won´t  try  to  solve  

them  or  won’t  know  that  much  about  them.  


3  Appropriability  is  the  capacity  of  a  startup  of  building  ways  to  difficult  imitation  of  its  offering,  so  it  

can  retain  high  returns  for  itself.  


4  Founders  that  design  startups  to  stay  make  better  decisions.  If  they  get  an  offer  for  acquisition  

eventually,  they  still  can  consider  it  as  good  news.  


5  Breakeven  is  highly  desirable  for  startups  since  lack  of  funding  will  drive  them  to  die  if  they  don´t  

reach  financial  equilibrium.  At  the  same  time,  we  want  to  focus  on  breakeven  because  we  consider  this  
a  critical  goal  for  emerging  markets  startups.    
6  To  get  a  significant  investment  from  a  third  party  means  that  some  independent  player  carefully  

studied  the  startup  and  its  parameters.  It  represents  a  success  predictor  by  itself,  widely  used  in  
emerging  markets,  although  it  doesn´t  necessarily  implies  that  the  startup  will  succeed  in  scaling.  The  
precise  definition  of  “significant  investment”  in  every  scenario  will  be  relevant  to  distinguish  real  
successful  startups  from  just  candidates.  
7  Contribution  margin  goal  can  change  country  to  country.  This  is  the  estimated  for  Chile.  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


The   biological   evolutionary   process   selects   the   most   suitable   species   based   on   the  
presence   of  attributes  that   are   useful   for   survival.  These   attributes   are   physical  
manifestations   of   their  genes.  One   species   full   set   of   genes   constitutes  
its  genome,  which   defines   the   required   attributes   to  survive  and   reproduce   in   its  
environment.  For  example,  the  crocodile  genome  determines  one  of  its  attributes  fit:  
their  nostrils  are  exactly  above  the  waterline,  which  gives  him  advantages  to  hunt  in  
aquatic  environments8.  
Biological   evolution   is   an   iterative   process   of   adaptation   that   enables   species   to  
survive   in   diverse   and   changing   environments   through   the   selection   of   the  
appropriate  attributes,  by  means  of  the  permanent  correction  of  their  genomes.  
Despite   its   apparent   simplicity,   the   evolutionary   model   is   extremely   effective   in  
generating   viable   forms   of   life.  We’ll   take   three   of   its   elements   that   will   be   useful   to  
strengthen   entrepreneurship:  its   radical   focus   on   survival,   its   powerful   adaptation  
mechanism  and  its  genome  concept.  
 

The Customer Journey


The   third   input   to   build   The   Startup   Journey   Project   comes   from   the   software  
industry.  The   proliferation   of   technological   devices   such   as   smartphones,   PCs   and  
others,   pose   a   major   challenge   for   developers   of   corporate   software:   no   matter  
through   what   channel   users   will   interact   with   a   given   company,   its   programmers  
should   provide   them   with   the   best   overall   experience   because   it   will   be   key   for   the  
customer   retention   process.  The   problem   is   that   the   channels   are   many   and   varied,  
users   connect   at   any   time,   service   levels   provided   by   global   competitors  are  
spectacular  and,  to  top  it  off,  their  budgets  are  always  limited.  
The   software   community   solved   this   problem   with   a   new   software   analysis   approach:  
"The  Customer  Journey",  a  graphic  model  of  all  possible  interactions  of  the  customer  
with  the  company.  Using  this  tool  software  engineers  can  represent  and  evaluate  user  
experiences   in   multiple   individual   channels   in   search   for   optimizing   the   overall  
customer  sentiment.  This   methodology   allows   developers   to   discover   what  
interactions   and   channels   cause   bad   experiences   (compared   with   expectations),  
redirecting  the  software  development  investment  to  solve  them.  Thus,  a  new  kind  of  
return  on  investment  (ROI),  expressed  in  "client  sentiment/investments  in  software"  is  
obtained.  
A  startup  is  also  a  journey,  starting  when  the  future  entrepreneur   gets  motivated  and  
trained,   continuing   with   the   problem   definition   phase,   team   building,   project  
execution,   the   Valley   of   Death   Curve,  breakeven,   then   scaling   and   eventually   some  
form  of  exit.    
                                                                                                               
8  This  special  characteristic  is  a  good  example  of  an  adapted  attribute.  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


Applying  the  Customer  Journey  concepts  to  this  path,  we  can  have  a  conceptual  map  
focused   on   the   startup   that   allows   us   to   highlight   the   future   challenges   and   the  
attributes   required   to   overcome   them.  We   look   to   find   the   gap  between   the   optimal  
and   the   actual   level   of   capacity   for   each   of   the   attributes   required   to   solve   the  
challenges   for   a   particular   startup,   in   order   to   supply   them.  Our   final   objective   is   to  
maximize   a   new   type   of   ROI,   expressed   as   "probability   of   success/resource  
investment"9.  

From evolutionism to entrepreneurship


If  we  accept  that  the  previous  elements  could  help,  the  following  questions  should  be  
made:   What   specific   requirements   are   imposed   to   the   attributes   of   a   project   by   the  
special   characteristics   of   our   entrepreneurial   environment?   Which   should   be  
the  particular   genome  of   a   startup   to   succeed   in   emerging   countries?  What   are   the  
specific   relevant   genes   for   our   conditions?  Can   we   have   an   ideal   genome   that  
maximizes   the   chances   of   survival   and   success   of   a   startup?  Can   we   stimulate   the  
presence  of  the  necessary  attributes  in  a  project  to  maximize  odds?  At  an  ecosystem  
level,   could   we   maximize   the   probability   of   success   of   new   ventures   in   an  economy,   if  
we  achieve  a  minimal  genome  fitness  for  all  of  them?  
We  are  trying  to  answer  these  questions  with  The  Startup  Journey  Project.  
 

The Startup Journey Project


The   Startup   Journey   Project   is   an   evolutionary   holistic   methodology   developed   to  
improve   the   success   chances   of   startups   and,   by   aggregation,   of   an   entrepreneurial  
ecosystem  in  a  specific  scenario.  

Premes
In  emerging  countries  it  is  imperative  for  startups  to  really  focus  on  surviving  through  
reaching  financial  breakeven.  Applying  the  evolutionist  model  to  the  entrepreneurial  
process,   we   discover   that   companies   that   survived   and   were   later   reference   cases  
have   similar  attributes.  Interestingly,   some   of   these   attributes   are   similar   to   those   of  
developed  countries,  but  others  are  not.  In  addition,  some  attributes  are  very  specific  
to   spaces   in   which   startups   are   taking   place.  The   model   of   a  real   startup   genome  
begins   to   make   sense.  This   is   not   surprising   for   the   evolutionist   observer,   since   we  
know  that  different  species  present  some  common  genes  in  their  genomes,  but  differ  
in   the   rest.   This   structure   allows   them   to   develop   more   adjusted   or   fitted   aptitudes   to  
survive  in  their  specific  conditions.  The  same  is  valid  for  startups.  For  example,  every  
                                                                                                               
9  Any  kind  of  resources:  funding,  energy  or  time.  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


company   requires   similar   financial   management   systems,   but   retail  companies   have  
particularly  strong  logistics  capabilities,  unlike  transport  companies,  which  developed  
significant  capabilities  in  optimization.  
Applying   the   evolutionist   model   to   entrepreneurship,   we   will   rescue   its   concept   of  
attribute   as   the   basic   unit   of   adaptation.   We   will   name   "premes"  10  (acronym   for  
"Práctica  Emprendedora",  or  Entrepreneurial  Practice  in  Spanish)  to  attributes,  skills,  
tactics,   characteristics,   techniques,   or   components   that   are   present   in   a   startup.  Our  
analysis   domain   will   be   the   entrepreneurial   project   as   a   whole   (our   specie),   not   its  
individual  components  as  founders,  business  process,  orchestration  strategy  or  others  
as  in  traditional  entrepreneur  teaching.  From  the  evolutionary  perspective  these  are  
just   participating   attributes,   single   or   compound,   that   packed   together   in   a   genome  
will   define   a   unique   species.   When   instantiated,   these   premes   will   characterize   a  
specific  startup.    Premes  constitute  the  basic  subject  of  analysis  in  the  SJP.    
Our  goal  will  be  to  find  suitable  premes  that  will  allow  startups  to  survive  and  scale  in  
their   environments11.  An   example   of   a   preme   suitable   for   an   emerging   economy   could  
be   the   urgent   seek   for   breakeven   as   soon   as   possible,   in   order   to   survive   even   in  
scarcity   of   funding.  Same   as   living   species   are   defined   by   a   set   of   genes,   a   startup   is  
defined   by   a   set   of   premes.  In   analogy,   to   maximize   the   chance   of   survival,   we  just  
need   to   "sequence"   the   startup’s   genomes   and   “replicate”   those   of   successful   projects,  
considering  the  characteristics  of  their  environments.  
Just   as   a   biological   species   is   born   and   develops   through   different   phases   that   require  
several   useful   capacities,   a   startup   goes   through   various   stages   during   its   lifetime:  
from   the   original   idea   (or   before),   through   launching,   the   Valley  of  Death12  crossing,  
pivoting   and   scaling,   among   others.  All   of   these   stages   require   adequate   premes   for  
their  requirements  and  challenges.  
In   the   biological   model,   different   species   genomes   have   similarities   and   differences  
between  them,  including  each  one  the  optimal  set  of  attributes  that  permits  life  in  its  
environment.  Similarly,   startups   require   sets   of   attributes   that   present   similarities  
and  differences  for  different  kinds  of  projects  and  environments.  Considering  this,  we  
will   try   to   define   a   general   startup   genome   for   emerging   markets.   Afterwards,   in  
further   studies,   we   will   seek   to   discover   the   particular   genomes   that   allow   startup  

                                                                                                               
10  The  word  “Premes”  was  coined  attending  to  the  original  biologic  and  cultural  evolutionist  terms,  

“genes”  and  “memes”.  In  general,  preme  will  refer  to  characteristics  under  the  startup  team  control,  so  
they  can  be  generalized  as  entrepreneurial  practices.  Environmental  characteristics  don´t  constitute  
premes,  unless  the  team  to  benefit  their  project  used  them.  Process  events  or  milestones  are  not  
premes  either.  They  are  just  their  manifestations  in  the  startup  life  cycle.    
11  Even  not  being  evident,  the  search  for  fit  premes  has  been  in  place  since  a  while,  through  the  

proliferation  of  papers  and  articles  about  lists  of  “Best  unicorn  practices”,  “Successful  founders  
characteristics”  and  others.    
12  In  entrepreneurship  “The  Valle  of  Death”  term  refers  to  the  dangerous  initial  period  of  the  project’s  

lifecycle,  when  expenses  are  bigger  tan  revenue.  This  period  goes  from  launching  of  the  startup  to  
reaching  breakeven.  [Musso  y  Echecopar,  El  Valle  de  la  Muerte,  2012]    

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


survival   in   specific   spaces   (technology,   industry,   female,   emerging,   social,   dynamic,  
etc.)13.  

Application to individual projects and ecosystems


In   the   case   of   a   specific   startup,   we   will   seek   to   diagnostic   the   actual   fit   level   of   its  
genome  in  contrast  to  the  ideal  genome  needed  to  succeed  in  its  space  of  operation.  
Doing   so,   we   will   be   able   to   reveal   the   gaps,   showing   to   the   founders   which   specific  
practices  should  be  added,  reinforced  or  corrected,  so  they  can  maximize  their  success  
option  with  optimal  levels  of  investments  at  the  same  time.  
In   the   case   of   an   entrepreneurial   ecosystem,   we   will   seek   to   create   a   framework  
focused  in  founders  and  their  projects,  in  order  to  provide  conditions  to  facilitate  the  
presence  of  the  required  premes,  through  the  development  and  transfer  of  knowledge,  
tools,   policies   and   facilities,   with   the   ultimate   goal   of   improving   the   probability   of  
startups  survival  and  scaling,  optimizing  the  resources  allocated  by  the  whole  system.  

Characterization of a project: life cycle and type


For  the  SJP,  the  relevant  life  cycle  of  an  entrepreneurial  project  ranges  from  the  basic  
training   of   the   founders,   long   before   the   startup   opportunity   appears,   until   they  
achieve   success,   in   the   form   of   relevant   scaling   or   a   successful   exit   (IPO   or  
acquisition).  Special  emphasis  is  given  to  the  pre-­‐startup  phase  and  to  the  crossing  of  
the  Valley  of  Death,  since  both  are  critical  periods  for  the  eventual  success  of  startups  
in  emerging  markets.  
SJP  is  specifically  focused  on  high  impact  startups  (or  "agile  startups"),  because  these  
projects  are  more  demanding  on  attributes.  A  standard  entrepreneurial  project  can  be  
modeled  as  a  simplification  of  the  "genome"  of  these  agile  startups.  
As  noted  before,  we  are  particularly  interested  in  understanding  the  adequate  genome  
for  startups  in  emerging  economies,  given  their  restrictions  and  particular  challenges  
that  require  some  different  premes  to  those  needed  in  developed  economies.  

Graphic Representation
While  the  use  of  the  paradigm  based  on  premes  doesn’t  necessarily  require  a  link  with  
the   temporal   dimension,   we   present   these   attributes   in   a   timeline   to   facilitate   the  
comprehension  and  to  highlight  the  changing  relevance  of   premes  depending  on  the  
stage  the  startup  is  going  through.  
 

                                                                                                               
13  Beinhocker  Erick,  2007,  The  Origin  of  Wealth:  The  Radical  Remaking  of  Economics  and  What  it  

Means  for  Business  and  Society.  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


Revenue*0*Expenses* The'Startup''
Team'
Focus''
& Model'
Journey
&
Structure'
Problem'' in''
Mentors' Survival' Orchestra-on'
Iden-fica-on' Exit'
' Funding' ' Harmonic'
Founder' Scaling'
Educa-on/' Pitch' Pivo5ng*
Management'
Mo-va-on'
Opportunity*

'
PRE'START:'
An-cipa-on'

Time*
Biz'Model'
Death&Valley& Break*Even*
va- '
on
'
Ac- ART:

Exposure'to'
ST

Ecosystem' ENTRANCE:'' RISING:'


Acknowledge' Adapta-on'

Entrepreneurship'Theory'(Slicing'Pie,'Globaliza-on,'Adapta-on,'Appropriability,''
Valua-on,'Digital'Strategy,'…)'
 
Fig.  1.  The  Startup  Journey  Model  
 
The   diagram   shows   a   startup   lifecycle,   highlighting   through   vertical   arrows   the  
various   premes   that   are   necessary   at   each   stage.   Even   those   premes   inherited   from  
acquired  skills  and  knowledge  of  its  founders  are  shown,  since  they  are  also  attributes  
the   project   needs   to   succeed.  The   exact   time   each   preme   is   required   is   not   necessarily  
accurate   in   the   diagram,   but   it   represents   closely   enough   the   phase   in   the   startup  
lifecycle  when  each  preme  is  most  needed.  
In   a   second   diagram   shown   below,   we   represent   as   green   dots   the   ideal   level   each  
preme   must   have   to   be   successful   at   a   particular   project   (or   ecosystem)   and,   in  
contrast,   as   red   dots,   what   level   of   performance   it   has   really   reached.  The   distance  
between   green   and   red   dots   reflects   the   gap   for   the   specific   preme,   and   therefore   a  
lower  probability  of  success,  which  should  be  corrected.  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


Revenue*0*Expenses* TSJ:
Team'
Focus''
& Tool'
Gap Analysis
&
Structure'
Problem'' in''
Mentors' Survival' Orchestra-on'
Iden-fica-on' Exit'
' Funding' ' Harmonic'
Founder' Scaling'
Educa-on/' Pitch' Pivo5ng*
Management'
Mo-va-on'
Opportunity*

'
PRE'START:'
An-cipa-on'

Time*
Biz'Model'
Death&Valley& Break*Even*
va- '
on
'
Ac- ART:

Exposure'to' Required&Level&
ST

Ecosystem' ENTRANCE:'' RISING:' Actual&Level&


Acknowledge' Adapta-on'

Entrepreneurship'Theory'(Slicing'Pie,'Globaliza-on,'Adapta-on,'Appropriability,''
Valua-on,'Digital'Strategy,'…)'
 
Fig.  2  Preme´s  Gap  Analysis  
 
The   attributes   shown   in   the   diagrams   are   examples   of   attributes   present   in   an  
ecosystem,   representing   their   specific   conditions14.  This   should   not   necessarily   be  
considered   as   a   complete,   definitive   or   exhaustive   set,   but   as   an   example   of  
genome15.  By   definition,   this   list   will   vary   depending   on   the   sectors   and   specific   types  
of  companies.  It  will  change  over  time  as  well,  due  to  changes  in  the  required  premes  
imposed   to   the   startups   by   the   scenario   and   even   by   other   startups,   so   preme   sets  
must  be  continually  revised.  
 

Preme Categories
As  a  way  to  facilitate  comprehension  and  analysis,  and  then  build  practical  application  
tools,   we   will   group   premes   depending   on   the   area   to   which   they   relate:   team,   project  
or  resources.    
                                                                                                               
14  Obviously,  the  set  of  attributes  will  differ  form  one  ecosystem  to  other.  

15  Or  “Prenome”?  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


Preme   category   associated  with   team,  includes   all   those   that   are   part   of   the   individual  
or  group  capacities  of  the  founding  team  or  startup  employees,  including  motivation,  
training,  expertise,  experience,  knowledge  and  soft  skills.    
Premes   associated   with   the  project   are   those   related   to   the   problem   or   opportunity   to  
be  addressed,  the  value  proposition,  project  dynamics,  industrial  or  economic  area  in  
which  it  operates,  business  model  and  strategy  in  every  aspect.    
The  resources  category  of  premes  includes  all  attributes  that  relate  to  assets,  financial  
or  not,  own  or  provided  by  third  parties,  all  orchestrated  by  the  project  team.  
Additionally,   the   analysis   must   consider   the   characteristics   of   the   environment,   which  
are  those  that  relate  to  the  geographical,  cultural,  temporal,  economic,  technological,  
regulation   or   market   context   in   which   the   startup   operates.  In   general,   these  
environmental   conditions   beyond   the   control   of   the   team,   will   not   be   considered  
premes,   just   as   the   characteristics   of   the   physical   environment   are   not   part   of   the  
genes   of   a   biological   species,   although   both   meet   the   crucial   role   of   selecting   the  
premes  sets  or  fittest  genes.  

Practical application of SJP


For startups in developing countries
The  practical  application  of  SJP  could  take  place  in  several  dimensions:  
The   fit   preme   set   (required   preme   profile   or   genome)   of   an   emerging   environment  
can  drive  research  about  these  attributes  by  members  of  an  ecosystem  and  then  it  can  
transmit   information   regarding   them   to   entrepreneurs.  Just   putting   more   focus   on  
these   concepts   and   unleashing   discussions   about   them,   will   increase   the   flow   of  
information  on  entrepreneurial  theory  and  concrete  benefits  will  be  achieved.  
The   identification   of   critical   preme   gaps   will   enable   entrepreneurs   to   better  
understand   the   requirements   for   their   startups   and   focus   investments   in   their  
development.  It  will  allow  them  also  to  assess  their  capacities  to  compare  the  level  of  
entrepreneurial   attributes   required   by   the   startup,   and   seek   ways   to   improve   them,  
increasing  their  chances  of  success.  
 

For Public Policymakers


For   managers   of   public   policy   and   entrepreneurship   development   agencies,  
understanding   structured   profile   attributes   required   to   undertake   in   a   particular  
ecosystem,  especially  in  emerging  environments,  allow  diagnose  what  elements  of  the  
system   are   absent   or   need   to   be   more   developed.  In   response   to   generally   be   multiple  
needs,  gap  analysis  methodology  of  SJP  also  offers  the  ability  to  prioritize  investments  
to  be  made  in  the  attributes  to  strengthen,  following  an  efficiency  criterion.  This  will  
be  achieved  by  analyzing  the  return  on  investment  in  the  attributes  candidates  to  be  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


supported,  as  regards  its  impact  on  the  average  probability  of  success  of  projects  and  
system.  
 

Emerging Markets Premes


The   following   is   a   list   of   some   of   the   candidate   premes   for   emerging   markets.  
Naturally,   this   premes   should   be   validated   considering   particularities   of   the   specific  
market.  

1. “Designed to stay”

The  founders  must  design  their  company  to  stay  on  the  property  and  not  to  be  sold,  in  
order   to   avoid   the   problem   of   lack   of   exit   ways.  This   practice   will   allow   them   to   make  
wiser   decisions   throughout   the   life   of   the   company,   without   incurring   in   makeup  
mistakes,  or  divert  their  focus  from  management.    

2. “Focus on survival”

The   shortage   of   funding   options   and   capital   indicates   that   the   urgent   search   for  
financial  breakeven  is  extremely  important  in  emerging  markets.  

3. “Protected Problems"

Emerging  markets  startups  should  find  a  problem  to  address  that  allows  them  to  be  
protected   from   competitors   with   greater   financing   resources,   such   as   those   from  
developed   markets.  Hypothetically   it   could   be   an   authentic   native   problem   or  
opportunity,   that   is   unknown   or   below   the   radar   of   startups   from   developed  
countries.  

4. "Emerging Revenue Management"

The   particularities   of   those   markets   where   consumers   have   little   income   or   is   badly  
distributed   force   the   startup   to   design   sophisticated  revenue   management  
mechanisms   to   capture   the   willingness   to   pay   of   as   many   customers   as   possible,  
wealthy  or  poor.  

5. “Guerrilla Appropriability”

Deficiencies   in   the   mechanisms   of   intellectual   property   protection   and   lack   of   funding  


don´t   allow   startups   to   protect   their   competitive   advantage   in   the   usual   ways.   Thus,  
they   need   to   build   appropriability   from   particular   elements   of   local   markets16.  An  
                                                                                                               
16  Example  pending  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


emerging   markets   startup,   which   lacks   the   capacity   to   finance   all   links   in   its   supply  
chain  (full  stack),  is   practically   forced   to   articulate   or  orchestrate  third   parties   assets  
to   build   its   final   product   or   service.   The   startup   can   build   competitive   advantage  
through   blocking   strategic   partners   in   this   articulation,   building   momentum17  and  
reaching  appropriability  based  the  complexity  of  this  structure.  

6. “Emerging Timing”

It   refers   to   the   launching   of   products   or   services   exactly   when   the   market   starts  
demanding   massively   and   persistently   for   them   at   a   structural   level,   especially  
considering   that   the   demand   at   emerging   markets   is   not   necessarily   synchronized  
with  the  corresponding  one  at  developed  countries.  

7. “Focus on Local Customers”

One   of   the   few   advantages   that   an   emerging   markets   startup   may   have   against   a  
foreign   competitor   in   their   targeted   segment   is   its   deep   knowledge   about  
customers.  Through   perfectly   knowing   their   characteristics,   ability   to   pay,   use   cases,  
expectations  and  forms  of  interaction,  a  local  project  can  draw  definite  advantage  over  
an  external  one.  

8. “Guerrilla Funding”

The   essentially   less   affluent   economy   and   the   lack   of   risk   funding   forces   the   emerging  
startup  to  be  really  lean  (lean  concept  taken  to  the  extreme  developing  markets  level),  
so   they   can   succeed   in   surviving   and   growing   with   less   amounts   of   funding   and   lower  
returns.  In   addition   and   ideally,   the   entrepreneur   should   look   for   financing   from  
customers,   with   the   consequent   benefits   of   proposal   validation   and   alignment   with  
the  market.  

9. "Radical Lean Scaling"

Scaling   sales   in   emerging   markets   should   be   realized   through   tactics   and   channels  
following  lean  principles   and   no   others.  The   small   size   of   the   emerging   economies  
forces   startups   to   grow   outside   of   their   original   countries.  This   can   be   an   immense  
challenge  for  underfunded  startups,  so  the  ways  of  scaling  sales  must  be  carried  out  at  
the   lowest   cost,   avoiding   own   foreign   sales   structures   at   least   at   the   beginning   and  
taking  full  advantage  of  any  digital  mean.  

10. “Financing Mothership Company"

                                                                                                               
17  Momentum:  competitive  power  accomplished  by  a  specific  player  by  taking  advantage  of  the  
combined  weight  and  speed  of  an  articulated  network  of  companies  that  collaborate  to  support  its  
specific  innovation.  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777


Having  low  risk  capital  availability,  startups  should  seek  for  a  “Financing  Mothership  
Company”,  which  is  a  big  company  that  could  provide  sustained  “feeding”  to  support  
the   Valley   of   Death   crossing.   This   “Financing   Mothership   Company”   can   be   a   parent  
company,   a   customer   corporation,   a   partner,   a   main   provider   or   any   other  
organization   that   could   provide   recurrent   financial   support,   as   part   of   its   regular  
business.  
 

Conclusion
The  aim  of  this  paper  was  to  present  The  Startup  Journey  Project,  a  methodology  to  
improve  the  success  rate  for  startups  in  emerging  markets.  
We   described   the   stages   of   the   entrepreneurial   process   on   a   graphic   representation  
seeking   to   highlight   the   relevant  premes  needed   for   each   phase   and   each   scenario,  
which   put   together   make   up   the   startup   genome.  We   understand   that   the  
identification   of   the   specific   attributes   required   for   each   environment   represents  
multiple  possible  different  genomes.  We  are  particularly  interested  in  identifying  the  
common  premes  shared  by  successful  startups   in  emerging  economies,  so  we  can  use  
them   as   a   benchmark   for   future   projects.  We   hope   that   our   effort   in   provoking   the  
startup   community   to   pay   more   attention   to   adaptive   entrepreneurial   practices   can  
improve  their  chance  of  success,  as  a  consequence  of  the  transfer  of  knowledge18.  
We   seek   to   be   able   to   compare   the   genome   of   a   specific   startup   against   the   pattern  
suitable  to  the  characteristics  of  emerging  economies  environments.  This  will  allow  us  
to  identify  gaps  to  be  resolved,  in  the  hope  to  improve  the  chances  of  survival  of  the  
startup.  If   we   apply   this   project   to   a   representative   number   of   startups   in   a   whole  
ecosystem  at  the  aggregate  level,  we  will  have  contributed  to  improve  the  chances  of  
success  of  the  entire  ecosystem.  

Thanks
We  want  to  thank  the  invaluable  collaboration  of  Germán  Echecopar,  Tadashi  
Takaoka,  Constanza  Musso,  Catalina  Romero,  Jaime  Arnaiz,  Marcelo  Diaz,  Rodrigo  
Musalem,  Pablo  Gimenez,  Inti  Nunez,  Felipe  Jara,  Pablo  Fernandez,  Roberto  Musso  
Azúa,  Mario  Ibáñez,  Matías  Gonzalez,  Paula  Latorre  and  many  others  who  gave  us  
their  support  and  expertise.  

                                                                                                               
18    The  transfer  of  adaptive  premes  in  the  entrepreneurial  ecosystem  is  equivalent  to  the  replication  of  

genes  in  the  biologic  space.  

Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2862777

You might also like