You are on page 1of 33

$Owuke"hqt"vjg"Ocuugu$<"Oknvqp"Dcddkvv)u"Eqnf"Yct"Owuke"Vjgqt{

Cwvjqt*u+<"Octvkp"Dtqf{
Uqwteg<"Vjg"Owukecn"Swctvgtn{."Xqn0"99."Pq0"4"*Uwoogt."3;;5+."rr0"383/3;4
Rwdnkujgf"d{<"Qzhqtf"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu
Uvcdng"WTN<"http://www.jstor.org/stable/742554 .
Ceeguugf<"3613414236"34<26

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

Oxford University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Musical
Quarterly.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukeu"
Cogtkecp"

$Owuke" vjg"
Hqt" Ocuugu$<"
Oknvqp" Eqnf"
Dcddkvv)u" Yct"
Owuke"Vjgqt{"
Octvkp"
Dtqf{"

Kv"ku"gzegrvkqpcnn{"
korqtvcpv"vq"ocuvgt"
vjg"owukecn"
hqtou"qh"vjg"
ocuu<"uqpiu."
octejgu." gve0."hqtou"
fcpegu." yjkej"ctg"rctv"
qh"vjgkt"
nkhg0"
Vq"kipqtg"vjgug"
hqtou" yqwnf"
dg"kpeqttgev"cpf"jctohwn."
vq"ocuvgt"
vjgo" yqwnf"ogcp"jgnrkpi"
vjg" etgcvkxg"
itqyvj"qh"v jg"
ctvkuv"
cpf"jku"pgctgt" vq"
crrtqcej" v jg"
yqtmkpi"
encuu0"
*Ngx"Ngdkfkpum{." cv"vjg"
urggej" Ugeqpf"
Kpvgtpcvkqpcn"
Owuke" qh"vjg"
Eqphgtgpeg" Kpvgt/"
pcvkqpcn"Wpkqp"
qh"
Tgxqnwvkqpct{"Owuke."
3;55+3"
Ocuu"Ewnvwtg" ku"c"f{pcoke." tgxqnwvkqpct{" hqteg."dtgcmkpi"fqyp" vjg"
qnf"dcttk/"
gtu"qh"encuu"
vtcfkvkqp."
vcuvg."fkuuqnxkpi"cnn"ewnvwtcn"
fkuvkpevkqpu0"Kv"okzgu"
cpf"
uetcodngu" gxgt{vjkpi"vqigvjgt." yjcv"
rtqfwekpi" okijv" dg"e cnngf"jqoqigpk|gf"
ewnvwtg."chvgt"
cpqvjgt"Cogtkecp" cejkgxgogpv." vjg"jqoqigpk|cvkqp" rtqeguu"
vjcv"fkuvtkdwvgu"
inqdwngu"qh"etgco" gxgpn{"vjtqwijqwv" vjg"oknm" kpuvgcf"
qh"
cnnqykpi" vjgo"vq"hnqcv"ugrctcvgn{" qp"vqr0"Kv"vjwu"
fguvtq{u"cnn"xcnwgu."
ukpeg"
xcnwg"lwfiogpvu" korn{"fkuetkokpcvkqp0" Ocuu" Ewnvwtg"ku"xgt{."xgt{"fgoqetcvke<"
kv"cduqnwvgn{"
tghwugu"vq"fkuetkokpcvg" qt"
cickpuv." dgvyggp." cp{vjkpi" qt"cp{dqf{0"
Cnn"ctg"itkuv"
vq"kvu"
oknn."cpf" cnn"
e qogu"qwv" hkpgn{"
itqwpf0"
*Fykijv" Ocefqpcnf." $C" Vjgqt{" qh"Ocuu"Ewnvwtg.$" 3;73+4"
Vjg"eqorqugt" 0" 0"kp"ocp{"ecugu"]ku_" vq"hceg"
wpyknnkpi" yjcv"
kv"ku"nkmg"
pqv"vq"
dg"c"ewnvwtcn"
jgtq" kp"yjcv"qpg"ukorn{"jcu"vq"ecnn"c"fgoqetcvke"
ewnvwtg." c"
ewnvwtg."
rqrwnkuv" cp"gicnkvctkcp"
ewnvwtg0" Chvgt"
cnn."yg"mpqy"
yjq" vjg" ewnvwtcn"
jgtqgu"ctg"kp"c"rgqrng)u"
ewnvwtcn"
uqekgv{0"
*Oknvqp"Dcddkvv."3;:7"kpvgtxkgy+5"

Rtqnqiwg<"Vjg"Okijvkguv"
qh"Hqtvtguugu"
Yj{"ku"Oknvqp"Dcddkvv"eqpvtqxgtukcnA" Oquv"uvwfgpvu" qh"eqpvgorqtct{"
owuke"jcxg"cempqyngfigf"vjg"qtkikpcnkv{" cpf"korqtvcpeg" qh"jku"yqtm."
dwv"vjgkt"ejctcevgtk|cvkqpu"
qh"jku"kphnwgpeg" jcxg"dggp"ewtkqwun{" fkxgt/"
igpv0"Dcddkvv"gxqmgu"gzvtcxcicpv" etkvkecn"tgurqpugu0"Jku"rqukvkqp"jcu"

383"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
384" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

dggp" fguetkdgf" cu"$vjg" hwtvjguv" gzvgpukqp" qh"vjg"tqocpvke" kfgcn"qh"vjg"


Rtqogvjgcp." kpfgrgpfgpv" ctvkuv"yjq" hnkgu"htgg"qh"vjg" gctvj" cpf" kvu"
eqortqokugu0$6" Jg"jcu"dggp"ceewugf" qh"$hcpcvkecn" uekgpvkuo." c"ugctej"
hqt"
swcuk/nqikecn" rtgekukqp" qh" tghgtgpeg" 0"0"0" cp"
]ykvj_" w pfgtvqpg" qh"
gxgp"
fkuvtguu." tcig.$7"cpf"ku"uckf"vq"dg"rquuguugf" d{"$c"hkpg" ocfpguu0$8"
Kp"c"nguu" dwv"
hncodq{cpv"gswcnn{" tqdwuv" encko." jku"$yqtm" crrgctu" vq"
jcxg"gzvgpfgf" vjg"owukecn" wpkxgtug" kp"c"ownvkvwfg" qh"fktgevkqpu" cpf"
tgurgevu"cpf" j cu"v cmgp"kv"
p gct" vq"v jg"dqwpfctkgu" qh"j wocp" eqpegrvwcn"
cpf"rgtegrvwcn" ecrcekvkgu0$9"
Cnqpi" ykvj" uwej"kocigu" qh"jgtqkuo." gzrnqtcvkqp." kpvtcpukigpeg."
cpf"kpucpkv{." c"pwodgt" qh"vjgogu" tgewt<" vjcv" Dcddkvv"jcu"ctiwgf" hqt"
cpf"gzgornkhkgf" c"urgekcn"
tgncvkqpujkr" dgvyggp" owuke" vjgqt{" eqo/"
cpf"
rqukvkqp"*cpf"dgvyggp" eqorqugtu" cpf"wpkxgtukvkgu+=" vjcv" jg"jcu"rtq/"
rqugf"pgy" cpf" kphnwgpvkcn"yc{u" vq" vjkpm" cdqwv" vjg"ewnvwtg" qh"
eqpvgorqtct{" owuke" kp"vjg"eqpvgzv" qh"c"uqrjkuvkecvgf" owukecn" ogvc/"
vjgqt{="cpf" v jcv"kp" vjku"
fgxgnqrkpi" ogvcvjgqt{." Dcddkvv" jcu" gzvgpfgf"
vygpvkgvj/egpvwt{" rjknquqrj{" qh"uekgpeg" vq"owuke0" Vjgug" cejkgxgogpvu"
jcxg"dggp" xctkqwun{" rtckugf" cpf" f getkgf" cu" rtqxkpi" *coqpi" qvjgt"
vjkpiu+"Dcddkvv)u" $gnkvkuo.$"$tgncvkxkuo.$" $qticpkekuo.$" $uekgpvkuo.$" qt."
oqtg" rnckpn{." $cecfgokekuo0$" Dcddkvv" jcu" d ggp"tgictfgf" cu" vjg"ejctku/"
ocvke" hkiwtg"rgtjcru" oquv" tgurqpukdng" hqt" c"$oqwpvckp" qh"wpnkuvgpcdng"
cecfgoke" gzgtekugu" vjcv"fkf"uq"owej" vq"kpurktg." cpf"hqt" vjg" pqy" ykfg/"
urtgcf"dgnkgh"coqpi" nc{ogp" vjcv" cnn"p gy" owuke" ku"tgrgnngpv" rgfcpvt{0$:"
Qt"jg"jcu"dggp"jckngf" cu"vjg"$rtqvgcp$" etgcvqt" yjq" jcu"vcmgp" wu"
$pgct"000" vq"v jg" qh"
jgkijvu"eqpvgorqtct{" kpvgnngevwcn"ceeqornkuj/"
$;"
ogpvu0"
Vjg"rtgegfkpi" ctg"pqv"gpvktgn{"
fguetkrvkqpu" eqpvtcfkevqt{="tcvjgt."
vjg{"kpfkecvg" qt"fkhhgtgpegu"
codkiwkvkgu" kp"gorjcuku" cpf"xcnwgu//qpg"
etkvke)u"
$tgrgnngpv"
rgfcpvt{$"oc{" ygnn" dg"cpqvjgt)u"$jgkijv"qh"kpvgnnge/"
vwcn"
ceeqornkujogpv0$" Jqygxgt." vjg"fkhhgtgpegu"kp"vjgug"crrtckucnu"ctg"
pqv"ukorn{" qt"
xcictkgu" o cvvgtu"
qh"vcuvg0"
Vjg{" rqkpv" vq"
w ptguqnxgf"eqp/"
kp"qwt"
vtqxgtukgu" owukecn" eqpvtqxgtukgu"
nkhg." vjcv"
ctg"vjgougnxgu" qhvgp"
ygnn"
pqv"xgt{" ctvkewncvgf."
vjqwij" vjg{" eqpvkpwg"vq"ujcrg" qwt"owukecn"
tgurqpugu" Cpf"Dcddkvv"
cpf"xcnwgu0" *vjg"rgtuqpA"ytkvgtA"rgfciqiwgA"
eqorqugtA+" uggou"vq"
tgrtgugpv"vjgug" cv"
kuuwgu" vjgkt"
oquv" rqngoke0"
Oqtgqxgt." cnvjqwij"vjg"eqtrwu"qh"Dcddkvv)u"rtqug"ytkvkpi"vq"fcvg"ku"
eqorcev"gpqwij" vq"eqpukfgt"cu"c"yjqng." kv"qhvgp"
uggou" vjcv"eqoogp/"
ctg"
vcvqtu" p qv"
tgcfkpi"vjg"
ucog" vgzvu0"Etkvkeu"gzrgtkgpeg"kpcrrtqcej/"
cpf"rqngokekuo="
cdknkv{" crqnqikuvu" tgewttgpv"
rqkpv"vq"jku"ogvjqfkecn."
tgeqipkvkqp" kp"owukecn"
qh"fkxgtukv{" ewnvwtg."
pqvkpi"vjcv"Dcddkvv)u"
oquv"
qxgtvn{"rqngokecn"tjgvqtkecn"
swguvkqp" cvvtkdwvgf<"
ycu"hcnugn{" vjg"guuc{"
$Yjq"Ectgu"Kh"[qw"NkuvgpA.$"
vkvng." c"uqwpfdkvg" d{"Dcddkvv"
qhv/tgrgcvgf"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"385"

fgvtcevqtu."ycu"cp"gfkvqtkcn" hqt"
uwduvkvwvkqp" Dcddkvv)u"qyp." nguu"kphnco/"
ocvqt{" $Vjg" cu"
jgcfkpi." Eqorqugt"Urgekcnkuv0$"
Cpf"vjku" ku"yjgtg" vjg"fkuewuukqp" gpfu0"
wuwcnn{" Kp"vjku"guuc{."K"
yqwnf"nkmg" vq"rnc{"kv"qwv"c "dkv"hwtvjgt/vq"vguv"vjg"rqkpvu" vjcv"tgukuv"
tguqnwvkqp"cpf"vq"eqpukfgt" vjg"tgcuqpu"yj{" vjg"eqpvtqxgtukgu" uwttqwpf/"
kpi"Dcddkvv" ecppqv" dg" ykujgf" cyc{0" Vjg"h qewu"
qh"v jku"fkuewuukqp"yknn"
dg"Dcddkvv)u"korqtvcpv" ogvcvjgqtgvkecn" rcrgtu"vjcv"dgicp" vq"crrgct" kp"
vjg"ncvg"3;72u/vjg" ytkvkpiu" kp"y jkej"
jg"u q
gv" wv"
c "tgxkukqpkuv"ogvjqf/"
qnqi{"hqt"owuke" vjgqt{" cpf"c"htguj" rgturgevkxg"qp"kvu"tgncvkqpujkr"vq"
eqorqukvkqp0" Vjg" eqpvtqxgtukgu" uwttqwpfkpi"Dcddkvv" kp"igpgtcn."cpf"
vjg"eqorngzkvkgu" qh"vjgug"ctvkengu"kp"rctvkewnct."
rtqxkfg" dqvj"vjg" dcem/"
ftqr"cpf" tckuqp"f)gvtg" qh"v jg"
uvwf{" jgtg0"
rtgugpvgf"
Kp"jku"ogvcvjgqtgvkecn" ytkvkpiu."Dcddkvv"
uvtqpin{" cfxqecvgu" yjcv"
jg"uqogvkogu" ecnnu"$uekgpvkhke"ncpiwcig$" c"
d{"ycikpi"pgicvkxg" eco/"
rckip"cickpuv" kortgekug" ncpiwcig" kp"owuke"
fkueqwtug." d{"rtckukpi"vjg"
wugu"
ucnwvct{" qh"h qtocn" cpf"
vjgqt{." d{"fguetkdkpi" vjg" enqug"eqppgevkqp"
dgvyggp" owukecn" eqpegrv." uvtwevwtg."cpf"rgtegrvkqp0" Jgtg"ku"c"mg{"
htqo"
rcuucig" 3;83." c"vqwejuvqpg" hqt"
vjg"fkuewuukqp"vq"hqnnqy<"
Hqt"
vjg"
guugpvkcn" qh"vjg"
gngogpvu" cdqxg"
ejctcevgtk|cvkqpu"
]qh" fkuewuukqp"
Ectpcr)u"
qh"vjg"vgto" kpxqnxkpi"
$eqpegrv$_" qh"vjg"u{pvcevke"
vjg"eqttgncvkqpu" cpf"ugocpvke"
vjg"
fqockpu." pqvkqp"
qh"cpcn{uku." oquv"
cpf/rgtjcru" tgswktg/"
ukipkhkecpvn{//vjg"
ogpvu" hqtowncvkqp"
qh"nkpiwkuvke" cpf"vjg"fkhhgovkcvkqp"
]uke_"
coqpi"
rtgfkecvgf"
dg{qpf"
v{rgu." uvtqpin{"
uwiiguvkpi" vjg"
vjcv" rtqrgt"
qdlgev"qh"qwt" kpxguvk/"
cuukipgf"
oc{"
icvkqp" dg/kp"nkijv"
qh"vjgug"
etkvgtkc/c"
xcewqwu" cpf"uvtqpin{"
encuu." tgokpf/"
wu"qh"vjg"
kpi" u{uvgocvke"
qdnkicvkqpu" qwt"
cvvgpfkpi" qyp" xgtdcn"
pgeguuctkn{"
rtgugpvcvkqp" qh"vjku"
cpf"fkuewuukqp" rtguwogf"uwdlgev."
rtqxkfg"vjg"korqtvcpv"
tgokpfgt"vjcv"
vjgtg"
ku"dwv"
qpg"mkpf"
qh"ncpiwcig."
qpg"mkpf"qh"ogvjqf"
hqt"
vjg"
xgtdcn" qh")eqpegrvu)"
hqtowncvkqp" cpf"vjg"xgtdcn" qh"uwej"hqtowncvkqpu<"
cpcn{uku"
)uekgpvkhke)" cpf")uekgpvkhke)"
ncpiwcig" ogvjqf0"
32"

Vjg"pqvqtkqwu" uvtwevwtcn" cpf"gzvtcxcicpv"


eqorngzkv{" tjgvqtke"
qh"vjku"
ugpvgpeg" ycttcpv"
uwtgn{" jqygxgt."
fkuewuukqp=" K"yknn"
octm" vjg"
qpn{"
ugpug"qh"c"nqpi"wrdgcv"cpf"vjgp"cp"cttkxcn"
cv"vjg" uvtwevwtgu"
rctcnngn" qh"
vjg"hkpcn"
rjtcug"qh"vjg"ugpvgpeg."yjgtg" Dcddkvv"
hkpcnn{" jku"
fgenctgu"
rcuukqpcvg"cfxqece{" qh"$")uekgpvkhke)"
ncpiwcig"cpf")uekgpvkhke)"
ogvjqf0$"
Vjg"hnqy" qh"vjg"ctiwogpv/htqo" vq" vq"
eqpegrv" cpcn{uku"rtgfkecvkqp"
cpf"dcem" vq"cpcn{uku"
cpf"eqpegrv/tcvkqpcnk|gu"Dcddkvv)u"
ogvjqfqnqik/"
qp"uekgpvkhke"
ecn"kpukuvgpeg" Dwv"vjku"
ncpiwcig0" fkuewuukqp"
qh"vjg"vjgqtgv/"
kecn"ncpiwcig" qh"owuke"ku"cnuq"c"nkvowu" qh"vjg"eqpvtcfkevqt{"
vguv" etkvkecn"
tgegrvkqp" qh"
j ku"y cu"c"yjqng<"
qtm" hqt" vjg"
uwrrqtvgtu." ogvcvjgqt{" qhhgtu"
c"nqikecn"cpf"wpdkcugf" hqwpfcvkqp" hqt" kpvq"vjg"pcvwtg"
kpswkt{" qh"owuke="
etkvkeu"
hkpf"kp"kv"c"jkpv"qh"c"tgvtqitcfg" xkgy"
qticpkekuv" q h"
o wukecn"
ewn/"
vwtg"cpf"c"ujtknn."gxgp"dk|cttg" kpukuvgpeg"qp"tguvtkevkpi"
vjg"vgtou"
qh"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
386" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

owukecn" fkueqwtug0" Kp"vjg" hqnnqykpi." K"rtqrqug" vjcv"Dcddkvv)u"ogvc/"


vjgqt{" ku"oqtg" eqornkecvgf." tcfkecn." cpf"oqtg" rgtvkpgpv"vjcp" gkvjgt"
jku"fgvtcevqtu" qt"crqnqikuvu" cnnqy0" Vjg"kpvgteqppgevgf" ctiwogpvu" jg"
wphqnfu" *cdqwv" vjg"ukvwcvkqp" qh"eqpvgorqtct{" owuke." vjg"$pcvwtg" cpf"
nkokvu"qh"owuke$" cpf"owuke" vjgqt{." cpf" vjg"kornkecvkqpu" hqt"vygnxg/"
vqpg" vgejpkswg+" pgkvjgt" rnceg"jko" kp"vjg" ewnvwtcn" fgdcvg" kp"vjg"tgfwe/"
vkxg" vjcv"
yc{u" rtgxkqwu" etkvkeu"jcxg" fguetkdgf." pqt" nqecvg"jko" $dg{qpf"
ewnvwtg0$" Dcddkvv)u" fkuewuukqp" qh"uekgpvkhke" ncpiwcig" cpf"owuke" vjgqt{" ku"
pqv"lwuv" c"uvcvgogpv" qh"ogvjqf=" kv"ku"dqvj" c"tgurqpug" vq"cpf"gzrtguukqp"
qh"c"dtqcf" xkgy" qh"Cogtkecp" owukecn" ewnvwtg" cv"okf/egpvwt{0" Hcnnkpi"cv"
vjg"ewur" lqkpkpi" oqfgtpkuv" cpf" rquvoqfgtp" Dcddkvv)u"
vtclgevqtkgu."
rqukvkqpu" gpicig" vjg" rtqdngou" qh"eqpvgorqtct{" eqpuvtwevkqp"
ewnvwtcn"
oquv" eqorgnnkpin{" lwuv"yjgp" vjgug" ctg"
rqukvkqpu" quvgpukdn{" htggkpi"
vjgougnxgu" qh"cnn"ugevctkcp" ewnvwtcn"dkcugu0"
Jqy"fqgu"vjku" gpicigogpv" qeewtA" Kp"jku"itqwpfdtgcmkpi" ogvc/"
vjgqtgvkecn" ctvkengu." Dcddkvv" cvvcejgu" ugxgtcn" eqttgncvkxg"vjgogu" vq"jku"
crqnqikc" qp"uekgpvkhke" ncpiwcig0" Vjg"ogvcvjgqt{" eqodkpgu" c"pgq/"
rqukvkxkuv)u" eqpegtp" cdqwv" vjg"tgncvkqpujkr" dgvyggp" eqpegrv" cpf"rgt/"
egrv" ykvj" c"rnwtcnkuv1rtciocvkuv" xkgy" qh"ewnvwtcn" cpf"vjg"
fkxgtukv{"
koocpgpeg" qh"owukecn" xcnwgu0" Dqvj" hcegvu" ctg" tgrgcvgfn{" eqpetgvk|gf"
kp"Dcddkvv)u" qyp." rquv/Uejqgpdgtikcp" rtqencocvkqpu" qh"vjg"$gocpekrc/"
vkqp"qh"vjg" oqtg"
fkuuqpcpeg$//qt." ceewtcvgn{." fgpcvwtcnk|cvkqp" qh"vjg"
c"etkvkswg"qh"vjg"ogvcrj{ukecn" wpfgtewttgpv" kp"
eqpuqpcpeg//vjtqwij"
rtgxkqwu" owuke" Vjg"
vjgqt{0" ctiwogpvu"tqwijn{" ctg" cpf"
*cnuq"rctvkcnn{"
swkvg"u{pqrvkecnn{+" cu"h qnnqyu<"Vjg" q pn{" c"rtkqtk" eqpuvtckpvu"qp"owukecn"
kp"kvu" cpf"
uvtwevwtg." eqpegrvkqp" tgegrvkqp." ikxgp" ctg" d{"ru{ejqceqwu/"
vkeu"cpf"hqtocn" nqike0" Kp"Dcddkvv)u" 3;83"vgtou." vjg"nkokvu"qh"owukecn"
rqvgpvkcn" $tgukfg" kp"v jg"
wnvkocvgn{" rgtegrvwcn" ecrcekvkgu"vjg"
qh" jwocp"
tgegrvqt." lwuv" cu"vjg"ueqrg" qh"rj{ukecn" uekgpeg" ku"fgnkokvgf"d{"vjg"rgt/"
cpf"
egrvwcn" eqpegrvwcn" ecrcekvkgu" qh" vjg" jwocp" qdugtxgt0$$" Vjwu." yg"
ecp"*ujqwnf." owuv+" tgxgcn" *cpf"rwtig+" gzvgtpcn" qp"owukecn"
nkokvcvkqpu"
vjqwijv" /pqtocvkxg" qt"ogvcrj{ukecn" enckou" cdqwv" vjg"pcvwtg"cpf"
nkokvu"qh"owuke//enckou" vjcv"yknn"qvjgtykug" eqpuvtckp"
ctvkhkekcnn{" vjg"
htgg"fgxgnqrogpv" qh" o wuke" Dcddkvv"
eqpegrvwcnk|cvkqp0" wtigu" wu"$ vq"
tgeqipk|g" vjg" rquukdknkv{." cpf"vjg"cevwcnkv{." qh"cnvgtpcvkxgu"vq"yjcv"
ygtg" qpeg"tgictfgf" cu"owukecn" cduqnwvgu$" cpf"uwttgpfgt" cp{" tgukfwcn"
pquvcnikc" hqt"c"$wpkvct{" owukecn" wpkxgtug" qh")eqooqp" $"kp"
rtcevkeg)"
hcxqt"qh"c"xctkgv{" qh"fkxgtug" rtcevkegu034" Yg"yknn" gpeqwtcig" eqorquk/"
vkqpcn"gzrgtkogpvcvkqp" cpf"fkxgtukv{" qwt"qyp."cntgcf{"
yjkng"enctkh{kpi"
fkxgtug"eqpegrvwcn"itqwpfkpiu"cu"eqorqugtu." cpf"cwfkvqtu."
rgthqtogtu."
d{"kpxqmkpi" uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig."yjkej"ku"$vjg"qpg"mkpf"
q h"ncpiwcig"
vjg"xgtdcn"
hqt" hqtowncvkqp" cpf"vjg"xgtdcn"
qh")eqpegrvu)" qh"
cpcn{uku"
A0"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"387"

uwej" hqtowncvkqpu0$35" Qpn{" kp"vjku" eqpvgzv" yknn"vjg"oqtg" qt"nguu"eqxgtv"


cuugtvkqpu" qh"xcnwg" kp"kortgekug" qt"ogvcrj{ukecn" dg"
ncpiwcig" gzrqugf"
cpf"rwtigf0" Cpf"qpn{" kp"uwej" c"tgncvkxkuv" eqpvgzv" yknn"owukecn" etg/"
cvkqp" fgxgnqr" htggn{0"
Kp"uwrrqtv" qh"vjgug" enckou." Dcddkvv" cvvcemu" gcej"qh"vjg"vtcfkvkqpcn"
cduqnwvkuv" ctiwogpvu" owuke"
nkokvkpi" eqpegrvwcnk|cvkqp." yjgvjgt" vjg{"
vcmg" vjg" hqto" qh"cpcnqikgu" dgvyggp" rncpgvct{" uvtwevwtgu" cpf"vjg"qxgt/"
vqpg" ugtkgu" qt"qh"qticpkekuv" xkgyu" qh"owuke" jkuvqt{0"Hqt" gzcorng." jg"
eqpukfgtu" Ogtugppg)u" $]rwtuwkv" qh_" vjg"rgtgppkcn" )yj{)"qh"vjg" eqttg/"
urqpfgpeg" dgvyggp" vjg" kpvgtxcn" eqpvgpv" qh"v jg"oclqt" vtkcf" cpf" vjg"
hktuv"
ukz"fkxkukqpu" qh"vjg" xkdtcvkpi" uvtkpi$<" $]Ogtugppg_" uwrrnkgu" c"ejct/"
cevgtkuvke" )lwuvkhkecvkqp)"hqt" vjg" )wug)" q d
h" wv"ukz"d{"ekvkpi" vjg" pwogtkecn"
kpfgpvkhkecvkqp" ykvj"
]uke_" vjg"vjgp" mpqyp" pwodgt" qh"rncpgvu0" Dg{qpf"
vjg"kpvkocvkqpu" qh"vjg"equoke" ueqrg" cpf" chhkpkvkgu"qh"
o wuke."vjgtg" ku"
vjg"kornkecvkqp" vjcv" egtvckp" encuugu" qh"qdlgevu" jkgtctejkecnn{" )lwuvkh{)"
qvjgtu" 0"0" 0"]ngcfkpi_" qpg"vq"eqplgevwtg" cu"vq"yjgvjgt." kp"cnn"ugtkqwu/"
pguu." vjg"fkueqxgt{" qh"c"ugxgpvj" rncpgv" kpxcnkfcvgf" vjg"vjgqt{" qh"vjg"
owuke" hqwpfgf" vjg"
wrqp" cuuworvkqp" qh"v jg")kpeqttgev)"pwodgt0$36"
Cpf."kp"c"ukoknctn{" xgjgogpv" rqngoke" cickpuv" jkuvqtkecn" vgngqnqi{."
Dcddkvv" fguetkdgu" vjg"jgtqke" qh"
hkiwtg"Uejqgpdgti" cpf" j ku"
owukecn"
kppqxcvkqpu" cu"rctcfkiou" qh"ewnvwtcn" fkhhgtgpeg." pqv"vtcfkvkqpcnkuo=" jg"
hqewugu" qp"yjcv" fkuvkpiwkujgu" Uejqgpdgti" htqo" jku"rtgfgeguuqtu" tcvjgt"
vjcp" uoqqvjkpi" qxgt" $vjg" lciigf" gfigu" qh"cdtwrvkqp$" dgvyggp" Uejqgp/"
dgti)u" kppqxcvkqpu" cpf" vjgkt" rtgegfgpvu<" $Jqygxgt" rgfciqikecnn{"
eqpxgpkgpv" cpf"kpvwkvkxgn{" uwiiguvkxg" c"swcuk/igpgvke" crrtqcej" ]vq"
gzrnckpkpi" vjg" jkuvqtkecn" qtkikpu" qh"v ygnxg/vqpg" owuke_" oc{" dg." gxgpvw/"
cnn{"kv"u weeggfu" kp"
qpn{" qduewtkpi" dqvj" vjg" ejctcevgt" qh" vjg" u{uvgo" cpf"
vjg"rtqhqwpf" fkhhgtgpegu" dgvyggp" vjg"vygnxg/vqpg" u{uvgo" cpf"vjqug"
owukecn" u{uvgou" kp"y jkej" vjg" jkuvqtkecn" hqtgtwppgtu" qh"v jg"vygnxg" vqpg"
qrgtcvkqpu" crrgct0$$"37"Vjg"pqtocnk|kpi" ghhgevu"qh"$vkog" cpf"rtcevkeg.$"
yjkej" vgpf" vq"fkuvknn"qwv"ctvkuvke" fkhhgtgpegu" hqt"vjg"ucmg" qh"cp"gngicpv"
jkuvqtkecn" pcttcvkxg." owuv" pqv"kpvgthgtg" *cp{" oqtg" vjcp" hcnug" ogvcrj{u/"
kecn"korgtcvkxgu+" ykvj" vjg"gzrnqtcvkqp" qh"vjg" hwnn"tcpig" wukecn"
qh"o
rquukdknkv{0" 38"
Jqygxgt." d{"tgukuvkpi" ogvcrj{ukeu" cpf"fkuocpvnkpi" vjg" uvtwevwtgu"
qh"cduqnwvkuo" kp"owuke" vjgqt{" kp"hcxqt" qh"c"xcnwg/pgwvtcn." rqukvkxkuv"
grkuvgoqnqi{."Dcddkvv"
rqukvkqpu" cv"vjg"gfig"qh"c"rtgectkqwun{"
jkougnh"
tgncvkxkuvke" kh"vjg"etkvgtkc"
rtgekrkeg<" qh"owuke"vjgqtkgu"ctg"ogtgn{"vjcv"
dg"
vjg{" eqpegrvwcnn{" engct."vjgp"cp"kphkpkvg"
pwodgt" qh"$vjgqtkgu.$"
$eqorqukvkqpcn" qt."ukorn{."
u{uvgou.$" $rkgegu$"ecp"dg"gswcnn{"xkcdng="
owukecn" ku"ewv"nqqug"htqo"
eqorqukvkqp" eqpuvtckpvu"
cpf"dqwpfctkgu0"
Vjg"$jwocp" ecp"pq"nqpigt"
tgegrvqt$" qp"vtcfkvkqpcn"
tgn{" enckou"cpf"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
388" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

lwuvkhkecvkqpu" qh"xcnwg"vq"nkokv"vjg"tcpig" qh"yjcv" ku"owukecnn{"rquukdng0"


Jqy."vjgp." yknn"vjg"rtqnkhgtcvkqp"qh"fkxgtug" owukecn" eqpegrvu"cpf"
rtcevkegu" dg"eqpvckpgfA" Dcddkvv" dcemu" cyc{" htqo" vjku"cd{uu"d{"kpxqm/"
kpi" vjg"ucog" rtkpekrngu"vjcv" ngf"jko" vq"kv<"$]Yjkng" v_jgtg"ctg"cp"kphkp/"
qh"
kv{" cpcn{vke" gzrtguukqpu" yjkej" yknn"igpgtcvg" cp{" ikxgp" eqorqukvkqp"
2"0" 0"vjg"tgncvkqp"dgvyggp" c"hqtocn" vjgqt{" cpf"kvu" gorktkecn"kpvgtrtgvc/"
vkqp" ku"pqv"ogtgn{"vjcv" qh"xcnkfkv{"vq"vtwvj" 0"0" dwv" qh"vjg"yjqng" ctgc"
qh"vjg"etkvgtkc" qh"wughwn."wugcdng."tgngxcpv." qt"ukipkhkecpv" ejctcevgtk|c/"
vkqpu0$39" Vjg"y ctgc"
jqng" qh"vjg"etkvgtkc"
qh"000" ukipkhkecpv" ejctcevgtk|cvkqpu<"
Ykvj" vjku"oqxg." Dcddkvv" ujkhvu"vjg"fkuewuukqp" cyc{" htqo"enckou"cdqwv"
kpjgtgpv" xcnwgu" kp"*qt"ejctcevgtk|cvkqpu"qh+"rctvkewnct" eqorqukvkqpcn"
vgejpkswgu" qt"rtcevkegu"vq"vjg" etkvgtkc"
hqt"xgtdcn" ejctcevgtk|cvkqp"qh"
cp{" cpf" cnn"
o wukecn"
rtcevkegu0"Ykvjqwv" cvvgorvkpi" vq"f ghkpg"
$wug.$"
$wucdknkv{.$" qt"$tgngxcpeg.$" gve0."Dcddkvv"kpfkecvgu" c"tqng" $uekgpvkhke"
hqt"
ncpiwcig$" vjg" cpf"
dg{qpf" gzrtguukqp" rtqvgevkqp" qh" ewnvwtcn"
fkxgtukv{0"
Kp"cp"gurgekcnn{" rtqxqecvkxg" rcuucig."jg"dgikpu" vq"enctkh{"vjku"
nctigt"
tqng<"
vjgtg"
Rgtjcru" jcxg"
dggp" kp"vjg"
gtcu" owukecn" yjgp"
rcuv" fkueqwtug"
cdqwv"
owuke"
ycu"
pqv"c"rtkoct{" kp"fgvgtokpkpi"
hcevqt" yjcv"ycu"
rgthqtogf." fku/"
rwdnkujgf."
ugokpcvgf."cpf"
/vjgtghqtg" /eqorqugf"0"0"0"yjgp/kpfggf/vjg"eqorqukvkqpcn"
ycu"uwej"cu"pqv"vq"tgswktg"
ukvwcvkqp" vjcv"mpqykpi" ocmg"hwpfcogpvcn"
eqorqugtu"
vjcv"tgswktg"
ejqkegu"cpf"fgekukqpu" gxgpvwcn"xgtdcn" hqtowncvkqp."
enctkhkecvkqp."
cpf/vq"cp"korqtvcpv" 0"0" 0"Vjg"eqorqugt"
gzvgpv//tguqnwvkqp0" yjq"kpukuvu"vjcv"
jg"ku"eqpegtpgf" ykvj"
qpn{" cpf"pqv"
owuke"
ytkvkpi" ykvj" kv"oc{"
cdqwv"
vcnmkpi"
qpeg"jcxg"dggp."oc{"uvknn"
dg."c"eqoogpfcdng/gxgp" dwv"
gpxkcdng/hkiwtg."
vq"urgcm"qt"vcmg"rgp"kp"jcpf"kp"qtfgt"
qpeg"jg"rtguwogu" vq"fguetkdg."
kphqto."
gxcnwcvg." qt"vgcej."jg"ecppqv"
tgyctf." rtguwog"vq"encko"gzgorvkqp/qp"ogfk/"
ecn"qt"xqecvkqpcn" vjg"
itqwpfu//htqo" qh"eqipkvkxg"
tgswktgogpvu" eqoowpkec/"
vkqp0"
3:"

vjgug"
Cntgcf{." yqtfu"
oc{" uggo" Dcddkvv)u"
Tgegpvn{."
swckpv0" tgswktgogpv"
qh"xgtdcn" jcu"dggp"nctign{"
hqtowncvkqp" kp"vjg"
d{/rcuugf" rtqeguu"qh"fgvgt/"
okpkpi"yjcv"ku"
$rgthqtogf." cpf/vjgtghqtg/"
fkuugokpcvgf."
rwdnkujgf."
eqorqugf0$"Jqygxgt." vq"pqvg"
kv"ku"korqtvcpv" vjcv"
owuke" vjgqt{"ycu"
eqpegkxgf"
d{"D cddkvv"
cu"vjg" uqwteg"
rtkoct{" qh"
cwvjqtkv{"kp"cp"gtc"
cp{vjkpi"
ncemkpi" crrtqzkocvkpi"c"eqooqp" qt"vjg"
rtcevkeg" qh"
rtguvkig"
ctkuvqetcvke" Hqt"
rcvtqpcig0" Dcddkvv." uekgpvkhke" ku"vjg"
ncpiwcig" uqng."
hkton{" ogfkwo"
tgswktgf" qh"vjg"owukecn"eqipquegpvk"
*$mpqykpi"eqorqu/"
ocmg"
gtu"]owuv_" hwpfcogpvcn" c"hqwpfcvkqpcn"
ejqkegu$+." kp"cp"
fkueqwtug"
hqwpfcvkqpnguu"
qvjgtykug" Kpfggf."kv"ku"c"
qh"rtcevkegu0"
eqphkiwtcvkqp"
rtgeqpfkvkqp"qh"owukecn"ekvk|gpujkr<"$]E_qpegtpu"ykvj"0" 0" 0" xgtdcn"cpf"
ogvjqfqnqikecn"tgurqpukdknkv{"0" 0" 0" owuv"dg"egpvtcn"vq"vjg"kpuvtwevkqp" qh"
vjg"uvwfgpv"qh"owuke"vjgqt{"0" 0" 0" kh"jg"ku"vq"cvvckp"vjcv"tctguv"
qh"cnn"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"389"

uvcvgu."vjcv"qh"vjg"
eqpegtpgf" cpf"vjqwijvhwn"owukecn" ekvk|gp0$3;"Yjkng"
Dcddkvv)u"gorjcuku" qp"tgurqpukdng" owukecn" fkueqwtug"tgeqipk|gu"cpf"
gpeqwtcigu" fkxgtukv{"coqpi" cpf"f khhgtgpegu"
dgvyggp" owukecn" rtcevkegu."
kv"cnuq"rtqxkfgu"yjcv" uggou"vq"dg"vjg"ncuv"xkcdng" dcuku"
hqt"ftcykpi" c"
nkpg"dgvyggp" cpf"
tgurqpukdknkv{"kttgurqpukdknkv{." cpf"
ekvk|gpujkr" gzenw/"
ukqp0"Vjg"rqkpv" qh"gorjcuku" ku"vjg"codkxcngpeg"
jgtg" kp"vjg"cfxqece{"
qh"$uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig0$" Dcddkvv"ocpcigu" vq"tghcujkqp"c"eqpugtxcvkxg"
qtvjqfqz{" qwv"qh"c"tcfkecn."kh"cpzkqwu."cempqyngfigogpv" qh"ewnvwtcn"
tgncvkxkuo0"
Dwv"yj{" ujqwnf" $xgtdcn" cpf"ogvjqfqnqikecn" dg"vjg"
tgurqpukdknkv{$"
vqwejuvqpg" qh"ekvk|gpujkrA"Cpf"yj{" ujqwnf"vjg"cfxqece{" qh"ewnvwtcn"
fkxgtukv{"dg"uq"codkxcngpvn{" vq"eqpegtp"
nkpmgf" cdqwv"kvu"eqpvckpogpvA"
Kh"Dcddkvv"hcxqtu"cp"qrgp"eqpxgtucvkqp" coqpi" vjg"rctvkekrcpvu"kp"owuk/"
ecn"ewnvwtg."yj{" fqgu"jg"kpukuv"vjcv"vjg"t wngu"
qh"vjku"
eqpxgtucvkqp" dg"uq"
uvtkpigpvA"K"dgnkgxg"vjcv"Dcddkvv)u"gorjcuku" qp"owukecn" fkueqwtug" cpf"
jku"eqpeqokvcpv" hqt" cpf"
rtqrqucnu" vjgqt{" eqorqukvkqp" enqugn{"tgncvg" vq"
jku"kphqtocn" qh"owukecn"
xkukqpu" ewnvwtg"cu"c"yjqng0" Kp"vwtp."
dqvj" jcxg"
uvtqpi" kp"v jg"
rtgegfgpvu" rqnkvkeu" qh"C ogtkecp" ewnvwtg"htqo"Dcddkvv)u"
eqnngig" kp"vjg"3;52u"
{gctu" vq"vjg"gogtigpeg" qh"jku"ocvwtg" yqtm" fwtkpi"
vjg" Eqnf"Yct0"K"yknn" umgvej" qwvnkpgu"
vjg" qh"vjku"cnvgtpcvkxg"kpvgnngevwcn"
dkqitcrj{" kp"vjg"tgockpkpi" ugevkqpu"qh"vjku"
guuc{0"

Kp"vjg"encuuke"
ogvcvjgqtgvkecn" Dcddkvv)u"
ctvkengu." eqoogpvu"cdqwv"
owukecn" vgpf"
ewnvwtg" vq"crrgct"
ctqwpf" vjg"gfigu."
kp"vjg"kpvtqfwevkqpu"
cpf"eqpenwukqpu"vjcv" jku"fgvckngf."
uwttqwpf" uwuvckpgf" Kp"c"
ctiwogpvu0"
oqtg" tgegpv"
rwdnkujgf" jg"
ngevwtg." j cu"
d ggp"
oqtg"gzrnkekv<"
K"fqp)v"
vjkpm"
vjgtg)u" qt"gzciigtcvgf"
ognqftcocvke"
cp{vjkpi" cdqwv"
dtkpikpi"
wr"
vjg" qh"vjg"
swguvkqp" uwtxkxcn"
cevwcn" qh"ugtkqwu" 0"0" 0"]Unwtxkxcn"
owuke0" uggou"
yjgp"vjg"eqpfkvkqpu"
wpnkmgn{" hqt"
pgeguuct{" vjcv"uwtxkxcn"
ctg"uq"ugtkqwun{"
vjtgcv/"
Vjgug"
gpgf0" eqpfkvkqpu"
ctg"vjg"
eqtrqtcn" qh"vjg"
uwtxkxcn" kp"jku"tqng"
eqorqugt" cu"
c"eqorqugt." vjg"
vjgp" qh"jku"etgcvkqpu"
uwtxkxcn" kp"uqog"
mkpf"
qh"eqoowpkecdng."
cpf"tgcfcdng"
rgtocpgpv." cpf"hkpcnn{."
hqto." rgtjcru"cdqxg"cnn."vjg"uwtxkxcn"qh"
kp"c"tqng"yjkej"
vjg"wpkxgtukv{" uggo"nguu"cpf"nguu"cdng"qt"yknnkpi"
wpkxgtukvkgu" vq"
cuuwog<" qh"hqtvtguugu"
vjcv"ku"qh"vjg"okijvkguv" vjg"
cickpuv" qxgtyjgnokpi." qwvpwo/"
hqtegu."
dgtkpi" ykvjkp"
dqvj" cpf"ykvjqwv"
vjg" qh"cpvk/kpvgnngevwcnkuo."
wpkxgtukv{."
ewnvwtcn" cpf"rcuukpi"
rqrwnkuo." hcujkqp042"

Ceeqtfkpi"vq"vjku"
hqtowncvkqp." owuv"
eqorqugtu" pqv"qpn{"uwtxkxg"
cpf"jcxg"uqog"ogcpu"
eqtrqtcnn{" hqt" vjgkt"
fkuvtkdwvkpi" yqtm."vjg{"
pggf"vq"dg"rtqvgevgf"
htqo"vjg"nctig"
yqtnf" c"yqtnf"
qwvukfg." qh"
$cpvk/"
ewnvwtcn"
kpvgnngevwcnkuo." rqrwnkuo." hcujkqp0$"
cpf"rcuukpi" Wpkxgtukvkgu"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
38:" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

owuv" pqv"qpn{" jktg" eqorqugtu" cpf"jqwug" vjgkt"yqtmu" kp"nkdtctkgu."vjg{"


owuv" rtqxkfg" c"dwnyctm" cickpuv" hqtegu"
ewnvwtcn" vjcv"vjtgcvgp" vjg" nkhg"qh"
ugtkqwu"owuke0" *Vjgtg" ku"c"ejctcevgtkuvke"vqwej" qh"Dcddkvvkcp" ucvktg" kp"
jku"$okijv{" hqtvtguu$"tghgtgpeg." cp"cnnwukqp"vq"Nwvjgt)u" j{op" vu"
cpf" k
hqtokfcdng" jkuvqt{."lwuv"yjgp" Dcddkvv"ku"
ocmkpi" qpg" qh"jku"oquv" dnwpv"
uvcvgogpvu" cdqwv" vjg"hcknwtg" qh"eqpvgorqtct{" ewnvwtcn"cwvjqtkv{0" Jqy/"
gxgt."vjg" g qh"
hhgev" vjg"jwoqt" jgtg" ku"
wpejctcevgtkuvkecnn{" ugnh/ghhcekpi="
vjg"ykv" kp"kpeqpitwqwun{" lwzvcrqukpi" vjg"kpuvkvwvkqpcn" cpf"urktkvwcn"
tguqwtegu" cuuqekcvgf" ykvj" Nwvjgt" qt"Dcej"cpf"eqpvgorqtct{" cecfgog"
uggou" cfgswcvgn{" ktqpke" vq"wpfgtewv" Dcddkvv)u"qyp" tjgvqtke."cu"kh"jg"
ygtg"rctvkewnctn{" cpzkqwu" cdqwv" vjg"xktwngpeg" qh"j ku"
ctiwogpvu0+"
Kp"cp{" ecug."Dcddkvv)u" rqngoke" enckou" cdqwv" wpkxgtukvkgu"cpf"rqrw/"
nkuo"enctkh{"vjg"nkpgu" jku"
eqppgevkpi" ogvcvjgqt{" vq"j ku"
x kgy"qh"vjg"
ewnvwtcn"ncpfuecrg" cu"c"yjqng<" uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig" ku"vjg"ogfkwo" qh"vjg"
tgurqpukdng" owukecn" ekvk|gp0" Kh"vjg"wpkxgtukv{" ku"
v jg"hqtvtguu"
cickpuv"
ewnvwtcn"rqrwnkuo." cpf"ewnvwtcn" rqrwnkuo" vjtgcvgpu" ugtkqwu"owuke." vjgp"
uekgpvkhke"ncpiwcig" uchgiwctfu" ugtkqwu"owuke0" Dcddkvv" ftcyu" c"nkpg"
dgvyggp" ugtkqwu"cpf"rqrwnkuv" owuke="uekgpvkhke"ncpiwcig" ku"cv"vjg"
dqwpfct{0"
Kp"vjg" hqnnqykpi." K"urgewncvg" cdqwv" yj{" vjgug"fkuvkpevkqpu" cpf"
hwpevkqpu" dg" uq"
okijv" rqygthwn" hqt"
Dcddkvv." tqqvgf" cu"vjg{" p"vjg"
ctg"k
ewnvwtcn"fgdcvgu" cpf"etkvkecn" fkuewuukqpu"qh"ctv."nkvgtcvwtg."cpf"ocuu"
ewnvwtg"ecttkgf" qwv"d{"uwej" rtqokpgpv" $Pgy" [qtm" Kpvgnngevwcnu$" cu"
Engogpv" Itggpdgti." Fykijv" Ocefqpcnf." cpf"Ukfpg{" Jqqm0"Tghngev/"
kpi"qp" vjku"nctign{"wpcempqyngfigf" eqpvgzv" qh"D cddkvv)u"yqtm" yknn." K"
dgnkgxg." rtqxkfg" wu"ykvj" wughwn"
c"rctvkewnctn{" rgturgevkxg" qp" qwt" qyp"
ewnvwtcn" Vjg"
rtgfkecogpv0" qtkikpcn" korgvwu" hqt"vjku"rtqlgev" ecog" htqo"
Dcddkvv)u" qyp"cwvqdkqitcrjkecn" eqoogpvu" kp"tgegpv" kpvgtxkgyu" cpf"
ytkvkpiu." cpf"K"yknn"dgikp" o{" eqpvgzvwcnk|cvkqp" d{"tgecrkvwncvkpi" uqog"
qh"vjg"uwtrtkugu"K"gpeqwkkvgtgf" kp"vjgo0"

$Uqog"qh"o{"dguv"htkgpfu"
ygtg"Vtqvum{kvgu0$"

cpf"kphqtocn"
Kp"eqpxgtucvkqp" qhvgp"
Dcddkvv"
ngevwtgu." cp"
tgrgcvu"
cdqwv"
cpgefqvg" jku"gctn{"
{gctu"qp"vjg" cv"
hcewnv{"R Cu"
tkpegvqp0" c"
hqtogt" cpf"rtqvgi8"
uvwfgpv" qh"Tqigt" Dcddkvv"
Uguukqpu." jg"
gzrnckpu."
ycu"ujkgnfgf"
d{"Uguukqpu"
htqo" vjg"
cpvk/Ugokvkuo" v
qh" jg"
owuke"
fgrctv/"
ogpv043" vq"ocmg"vjg"oquv"
Vt{kpi" qh"cp"cymyctf" vjg"{qwpi"
ukvwcvkqp."
ogodgt"
hcewnv{" eqorqugf"jku"Owuke"
hqt" Ocuu"*3;62+"$vq"eqohqtv"
vjg"
Cu"Dcddkvv"
o{"ejcktocp0$" vjg"rkgeg"vjgp"yqp"vjg"rtguvk/"
kpfkecvgu."
kp"eqorqukvkqp"
Dgcou"Rtk|g"
ikqwu" cpf"ycu"ncvgt" tghgttgf"
okuvcmgpn{" vq"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"38;"

kp"c"dqqm" qp"vygpvkgvj/egpvwt{" owuke" cu"$Owuke" hqt"vjg"Ocuugu0$" Kp"


vjg"
eqpenwfkpi" uvqt{." Dcddkvv" enkpejgu"vjg" lqmg"d{"rtqrqukpi" cp"
gzrncpcvkqp/jku" ycu"c"ugvvkpi." chvgt"
cnn."qh"vjg"qtfkpct{" qh"vjg"ocuu0"
Vjg"ktqpkgu" qh"vjg" uvqt{" jkpig" qp" c"fqwdng" kpeqpitwkv{." pqv"qpn{"
vjg"eqorqukvkqp" qh"Ejtkuvkcp" ucetgf"owuke" d{"c"eqorqugt" qh"Lgykuj"
gzvtcevkqp." dwv" cnuq"vjg" kpcfxgtvgpv" rwp"*gejqgf" d{"D cddkvv" kp"jku"
$gzrncpcvkqp$" qh"vjg"lqmg+"vjcv" cuuqekcvgu"jko" ykvj" ocuu"ewnvwtg0" Vjg"
swguvkqp" dgiigf." jqygxgt." ku"yj{" vjg"o kuvcmg"
ujqwnf" dg" uq"hwpp{0"
Yjcv" ku"vjg"ukipkhkecpeg" kp"vjku" htqo"
unkr" ocuu"vq"ocuugu//qpg" vjcv"
kornkekvn{" vtcpuhqtou" Dcddkvv" htqo" c"igpvggn." cuukokncvgf" cecfgoke" kpvq"
c"tcfkecn"ewnvwtcn" rqnkvkekcpA" Jqy"fggr"ku"vjg"ktqp{" kp"ocmkpi" Dcddkvv"
kpvq"c"eqorqugt" qh"$owuke" hqt" vjg"ocuugu$A"
Ukoknct" tgokpkuegpegu" jcxg"dgiwp" vq"crrgct" kp"Dcddkvv)u" rwd/"
nkujgf"qgwxtg" cu"ygnn0"C"dqqm" qh"qhvgp"cpgefqvcn" ngevwtgu." c"eqpxgtuc/"
vkqpcn"ogoqkt." cpf"gzegtrvu" htqo" ugxgtcn" kphqtocn" kpvgtxkgyu" jcxg"
crrgctgf" kp"rtkpv044"Vjg"crrctgpv" urqpvcpgkv{" cpf"ecpfqt" qh"vjgug"
vgzvu"uwkv"vjgkt"igptgu0" Kp"oquv" ecugu."vjg"rtkpvgf" vgzv"tgcfu" cu"cp"
wpogfkcvgf" tgeqtf"qh"urggej" *ngevwtgu."eqpxgtucvkqpu+0" Dtgg|{." fgpug."
xkvtkqnke."cv"
q peg" cpf"
kortqxkucvqt{"ecnewncvgf." vqttgpvkcnn{" dtknnkcpv/"
vjg"vqpg" qh"vjku" vtcpuetkdgf" vcnmkpi" yknn"dg"hcoknkct" vq"Dcddkvv" chkekq/"
pcfqu0" Dcddkvv)u" pcttcvkxgu" kpvgtygcxg" fgvckngf" ceeqwpvu" qh"jku"qyp"
kpvgnngevwcn"cpf"ctvkuvke" fgxgnqrogpv" ykvj" cp"gxqecvkqp" qh"vjg" Cogtk/"
ecp"owukecn" uegpg" htqo" vjg"okf/3;52u" vq"vjg" rtgugpv0"
Pqpgvjgnguu." kv"ku"vgorvkpi" vq"fkuokuu" uwej"tgokpkuegpegu." nkmg"
vjg"gxgp" oqtg" kphqtocn" cpgefqvgu" vjcv"rwpevwcvg" Dcddkvv)u" eqpxgtuc/"
vkqp."cu"c"octikpcn" gpvgtvckpogpv/" fgeqtcvkxg" cpf"xktvwquke." dwv"
wpeqppgevgf" vq"vjg"ctiwogpvu" qh"Dcddkvv)u" vjgqtgvkecn"ytkvkpi0" Jqy/"
gxgt."kh"
yg"gngxcvg" vjku" mkpf" qh"ytkvkpi1urgcmkpi" vq"vjg"ucog" ngxgn" cu"
vjg"vjgqt{." rw||nkpi" kpeqpitwkvkgu" crrgct0" Vcmgp" ugtkqwun{."Dcddkvv)u"
tgegpv"ugnh/rtgugpvcvkqp" eqornkecvgu" qwt" qyp" guvcdnkujgf" kocig" qh"jku"
ceeqornkujogpv" cpf" j ku"cpvgegfgpvu0"
Hqt"gzcorng." eqpukfgt" vjg"hqnnqykpi" gzegtrv" htqo" cp"kpvgtxkgy."
kp"yjkej" Dcddkvv" chhknkcvgu"jkougnh" ykvj" vjg" Pgy"[qtm" nghvkuv"
kpvgnnge/"
vwcn"uegpg" qh"vjg"3;52u" cpf"3;62u<"

Cdqwv"o{"vkog"]cu"cp"wpfgtitcfwcvg"
cv"Ycujkpivqp"
Uswctg"Eqnngig."3;55/57_"
P[W"ycu"vjg"
uykpikpi"
rnceg0"
Ycujkpivqp"
Uswctg" ycu"
Eqnngig" yjgtg"
kv"ycu"cv0"
Cp{qpg"htqo"]Lcogu_"
Dwtpjco" vq"Ukfpg{"
Jqqm."cnn"vjg"rgqrng"ygtg"vjgtg0"
Vjgug"iw{u"
ygtg"vjg"Uvcnkpkuvu."
vjg"Vtqvum{kvgu."
vjg"Nqxguvqpkvgu."
vjg"
Ecppqpkvgu/K)xg"nkxgf" cnn"qh"vjku0"
vjtqwij" Uqog" qh"o{"dguv"
htkgpfu"
ygtg"
Vtqvum{kvgu0"
Ukfpg{"Jqqm"dghqtg"
jg"ejcpigf0" Jqqm."
Ukfpg{" yjq" jcf"lwuv"
iqv/"
vgp"jku"RjF0"ykvj"
Lqjp" ytqvg"
Fgyg{." c"dqqm"ecnngf"
Vqyctf"vjg"Wpfgtuvcpfkpi"
Mctn"
qh" Octz0"Jg"ycu"vjg" qh"Octzkuo."
iwtw" cpf"jg"ycu"c"dtknnkcpv"
iw{"cpf"uvknn"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
392" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

fqgu"vjg"pcog"Lcogu"
Dwtpjco/yjcv"
ku0"Jg"cpf"Lcogu" ogcp"vq"{qwA"
Dwtpjco"
Dwtpjco" ycu"hqt" hqt"
c"eqnwopkuv"
{gctu" vjg" Tgxkgy"
Pcvkqpcn" c"hcoqwu"
cpf"ytqvg"
dqqm" Vjg"
ecnngf" Vjcv)u"
Tgxqnwvkqp0"
Ocpcigtkcn" dghqtg"
{qwt"vkog" Dwo/"
vqq0"Lcogu"
jco" Jqqm"
cpf"Ukfpg{" kp"
ygtg" vjg"
nghv" wnvtc/nghv"
ykpi." ykpi" ecnngf"
rctv{" vjg"
Cogtkecp" Yqtmgtu" P[W"cpf"Ycujkpivqp"
Rctv{0" ygtg"
Eqnngig"
Uswctg" vqo"
lwuv"
vq"dkvu"
d{"kv045"

Vjgtg" ku"c"jkpv" qh"codkxcngpeg." kh"


pqv"fkuokuukxgpguu." kp"Dcddkvv)u"
gzrcpukxg" cpf"dgowugf" qh"v jg"
crrtgekcvkqp" $iwtwu" qh"O ctzkuo0$" Kp"c"
uwtig"qh"pquvcnikc." jqygxgt." Dcddkvv"cuuqekcvgu" jkougnh"ykvj" Jqqm"cpf"
vyq"
Dwtpjco." hcewnv{" ogodgtu" kp"vjg"P[W" rjknquqrj{" fgrctvogpv"
fwtkpi"jku"wpfgtitcfwcvg" {gctu."yjq" ygtg" coqpi" vjg"oquv" rtqokpgpv"
kp"
hkiwtgu" v jg"qxgtjgcvgf" rqnkvkecn"cpf"e wnvwtcn"fgdcvg"qh" v jcv"
oqogpv046" Gctn{" kp"vjg" fgecfg." Dwtpjco" lqkpgf"hqtegu"ykvj" Rjknnkr"
Yjggnytkijv." vjg" u gpkqt" cv" kp"
rjknquqrjgt"P[W." hqwpfkpi" U{orqukwo"
*3;53/55+."c"lqwtpcn" qh"$rjknquqrj{." nqike." cpf"vjg"ctvu.$" c"eqplwpe/"
vkqp"qh"hkgnfu" uvtkmkpin{" eqpitwgpv" ykvj" Dcddkvv)u"ocvwtg" kpvgtguvu0"
Dwtpjco" cpf"Yjggnytkijv" cnuq"ytqvg"Rjknquqrjkecn" Cpcn{uku" *3;54+."c"
dqqm" vjcv." ykvj"
cnqpi" U{orqukwo." Dcddkvv" cu"
ekvgf" cp"korqtvcpv" kphnw/"
gpeg<47" $]K"ecog_" vq"P[W."vq"gpeqwpvgt" Dwtpjco" cpf"Yjggnytkijv)u"
Rjknquqrjkecn" cpf" c"
Cpcn{uku." ocic|kpg" ]U{orqukwo_." cpf"K"cnyc{u" hqtigv"
vjg"pcog" qh"kv"000" kv"ncuvgf" hqt"
qpn{"vjtgg" qt"hqwt"{gctu"000" K"uvknn"
jcxg"vjg"eqrkgu0" Cpf"vjg{" fkueqxgtgf"K0"C0"Tkejctfu." cpf"vjg{" rwd/"
nkujgf"c"nqv"qh"rtcevkecn" etkvkekuo0"K"ycu"uwttqwpfgf" d{"vjku." cpf"kv"
gzekvgf" og"cpf"kpvgtguvgf" og0"Cpf"K"hgnv" ycu"owej"
vjku" oqtg" kpvgtguv/"
kpi"vjcp" cp{vjkpi" iqkpi" qp"kp"owuke" vjgqt{0$48" Vjg" h ktuv"
ctvkeng" vq"
crrgct" kp"vjg" xqnwog"
hktuv" qh"U{orqukwo" ycu" Lqjp" Fgyg{)u" $Swcnkvc/"
vkxg"Vjqwijv0$" Kv"ku"gcu{" vq"kocikpg" vjg" kpvgtguv"vjcv"Fgyg{)u" fkuewu/"
ukqp"qh"uvtwevwtg" kp"vjg"ctvu" yqwnf" jcxg"jgnf" hqt"Dcddkvv<" $Vjg"nqike" qh"
eqpuvtwevkqp"
ctvkuvke" cpf"guvjgvke" crrtgekcvkqp" ku"
rgewnkctn{" ukipkhkecpv"
dgecwug" vjgug" gzgornkh{" kp"c eegpvwcvgf" cpf" r hqto"
wtkhkgf" vjg" eqpvtqn"
qh"ugngevkqp" qh" f gvckn"cpf" q h"o qfg"qh" qt"
tgncvkqp."kpvgitcvkqp." d{"c"
swcnkvcvkxg" yjqng0" Vjg"wpfgtn{kpi" swcnkv{" fgocpfu" egtvckp" fkuvkpe/"
vkqpu."cpf" v jg" fgitgg" kp"y jkej"vjg"fgocpf" ku"
o gv"
eqphgtu" wrqp" vjg"
yqtm" qh"ctv" vjcv" pgeguuct{" qt"kpgxkvcdng" ejctcevgt" yjkej" ku"kvu"octm0$49"
Kp"vjg"ucog" lqwtpcn." Dcddkvv" yqwnf" jcxg" g peqwpvgtgf"qvjgt" uvkowncv/"
kpi"ctvkengu<"Tkejctfu)" $Dgnkgh)" *3."pq0"6+."Oqttku" Eqjgp)u" $Hckvj" qh"c"
Nqikekcp$" *3."pq0"3+."cpf"Yjggnytkijv)u" $Rqgvt{" cpf"Nqike$" *3."pq0"
6+0"Jqygxgt." Dcddkvv" owuv" cnuq"jcxg"dggp" fkucrrqkpvgf" d{" eqwtug"
vjg"
vqqm"qxgt"kvu"dtkgh"
U{orqukwo" D{"vjg"hkpcn"
jkuvqt{0" {gct"qh"rwdnkecvkqp."
jcf"oqxgf"
rqnkvkeu"
Dwotpjco)u" tcfkecnn{" cpf"gcej"kuuwg"
vq"vjg"nghv." qh"
dgicp"
U{orqukwo" ykvj"c eqoogpv"
p"gfkvqt)u" kp"yjkej"j g"cfxqecvgf"c"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"393"

tghqtogf" xgtukqp" qh"Cogtkecp" eqoowpkuo0" $Rqgvt{" cpf"Nqike$" icxg"


yc{" vq"Dwtpjco)u" $Octzkuo" cpf"Cguvjgvkeu$" *5."pq0"6+."cpf"vjg" yqtm"
qh"qvjgt" tcfkecn" ewnvwtg"etkvkeu"uwej" cu"Fykijv" Ocefqpcnf" hknngf"qwv"
vjg"rcigu" qh"vjg" lqwtpcn04:"
Dwtpjco" cnuq"ecog" vq"dg"enqugn{" cuuqekcvgf" ykvj" Ukfpg{" Jqqm."c"
fkuekrng"qh"Fgyg{" yjq" eqorqugf" xqnwogu" qp"vjg"kpvgteqppgevkqp" qh"
Octzkuo" cpf"rtciocvkuo0" Dqvj"Jqqm"cpf"Dwtpjco" ygtg"eqookvvgf"
nghvkuvu"
d{"vjg"okf/3;52u." cpf."kp"vjgkt" ngcfgtujkr" qh"vjg"Cogtkecp"
Yqtmgtu)" Rctv{." vjg{"ecnngf" hqt"
$c"pgy"eqoowpkuv" rctv{"cpf"c"pgy"
eqoowpkuv" kpvgtpcvkqpcn0)$4;" Kp"c"ocvvgt" qh"
qpn{" c"hgy"{gctu." jqygxgt."
Jqqm"cpf"Dwtpjco" yqwnf" dg"coqpi" vjg" cpvk/Uvcnkpkuv" kpvgnngevwcnu" vq"
uwrrqtv" cpf"
Vtqvum{" gxgpvwcnn{" uwttgpfgt" vjgkt"
uqekcnkuv" rqukvkqpu" cnvq/"
igvjgt0" Rtqitguukxgn{" oqtg" fkugpejcpvgf" ykvj"fgxgnqrogpvu" kp" vjg"
Uqxkgv" Wpkqp" cpf"ykvj" vjg"ghhkece{" qh"jku"qyp" vjgqtkgu." Dwtpjco"
ytqvg" yjcv" jcu"dggp"ecnngf" vjg"$ncuv"tkvgu"fgnkxgtgf" qxgt" vjg"itcxg" qh"
Vjg"
Octzkuo.$" Ocpcigtkcn" Tgxqnwvkqp"*3;63+052" Chvgt" vjg"yct." Jqqm"
cpf"Dwtpjco" dqvj" rctvkekrcvgf"kp"rtguvkikqwu"cpvkeqoowpkuv" ecwugu."
uwej" cu"vjg"Eqookvvgg" hqt"Ewnvwtcn" Htggfqo053"
Jqygxgt." Dcddkvv"cnuq"gpeqwpvgtgf" cpqvjgt" xctkgv{"qh"nghvkuv"
kpvgnngevwcn"kp"jku"{gctu" cu"c"uvwfgpv" cv"P[W"cpf"vjg" rgtkqf" ngcfkpi" wr"
vq"Yqtnf" Yct"KK0"Urgcmkpi" cdqwv"vjku" vkog"kp"c"fgekfgfn{" fkhhgtgpv"
vqpg." vjqwij" kp"vjg"ucog" kpvgtxkgy" kp"yjkej" jg"fkuewuugf" vjg"inqt{"
fc{u"qh"U{orqukwo." Dcddkvv" ycu"qxgtvn{" jquvkng"
vq"yjcv" jg"ecnngf" vjg"
$wnvtc/nghv"ykpi$" cpf" vq"c "mkpf"qh"nghvkuv"fkhhgtgpv"htqo" Jqqm)u" qt"
Dwtpjco)u/vjg" mkpf" yjq" pgxgt"qt"qpn{" dgncvgfn{" $ejcpigf.$" tgockp/"
kpi"nq{cn" vq"U vcnkp"cpf" v jg"U qxkgv"
Wpkqp." gxgp" kp" vjg"hceg"qh" vjg"
kphcoqwu" Oqueqy" Vtkcnu."vjg"Jkvngt/Uvcnkp" rcev." cpf"qvjgt" eqpvgorq/"
tct{"gxgpvu" kp" vjg" ncvg"3 ;52u"vjcv"fkuknnwukqpgf"ocp{" rtqokpgpv" kpvgn/"
ngevwcnu"uwej" cu"Jqqm"cpf"Dwtpjco0" Dcddkvv" cnuq"tghgtu" vq"Lqjp"
Fgyg{)u" eqookuukqp" vq"kpxguvkicvg" Uvcnkpkuv"
ejctigu" cickpuv"Vtqvum{"
*3;59+."yjkej." kp"gzqpgtcvkpi" Vtqvum{." enctkhkgf"
vjg"Uvcnkp1Vtqvum{"
swguvkqp" hqt"ocp{" rtqokpgpv" yguvgtp" kpvgnngevwcnu" cpf"ctvkuvu0"Dcd/"
dkvv)u"
qyp" ycu"
rqukvkqp" wpgswkxqecn<"

Yg"hqwpf"qwtugnxgu"
tgcfkpi" uwej"
ocic|kpgu." cu"qpg"ecnngf"
Owukecn"
Xcpiwctf"
0" hwnn"
0" qh"ctvkengu" kp"Twuukc"
$ygnn."
uc{kpi." vjg{" twp" dgvvgt"
vjkpiu" vjcp" fq"
vjg{"
jgtg"
ykvj" vq"owuke0$"
tgictf" Cctqp" uckf"vjcv."
Eqrncpf" hqt" vjcv"
gzcorng<" vjkpiu"
uggogf"
vq"dg"dgvvgt"
ykvj" vq"vjg"{qwpi"
tgictf" owukekcp"kp"Twuukc"vqfc{0"000"
Rgqrng"yjq"ncvgt"
ycpvgf"vq"dg"tgictfgf"
cu"kpvgnngevwcn" cu"rqnkvkecn"
octv{tu."
ecnngf"
jgtqgu." Lqjp"Fgyg{"c"hcuekuv#"
Yj{A" Dgecwug"
Lqjp"Fgyg{" dtqwijv"
vqigvjgt" c"
qh"ugtkqwu."
itqwr" rtqhguukqpcn" 0"00" vq"kpxguvkicvg"
vjkpmgtu" vjg"Oqueqy" 0"0" 0"Uq"
vtkcnu"
qpg"ycu"nkxkpi"
ykvj"vjku"
mkpf" qh"fcpigtqwu" cnn"vjg"
kttcvkqpcnkv{" vkog054"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
394" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

Jg"eqpenwfgu" jku"tgoctmu" ykvj" c"uvctvnkpi" rtqpqwpegogpv<" $Vjku"]pqv"


lwuv"Fgyg{)u" cguvjgvkeu" qt" T kejctfu)" etkvkekuo_"chhgevgf" vjg" kpvgnnge/"
vwcn"cvoqurjgtg" cv"ngcuv" cu"owej" cu"tgcfkpi" Uejgpmgt." Nqtgp|" cpf"
Mwtvj0$55" Yjkng" vjg" xqkeg" ku"wpokuvcmcdn{" Dcddkvv)u." vjg" lwzvcrqukvkqp"
qh"rqnkvkeu"
*Cogtkecp" eqoowpkuo" cpf"Vtqvum{kuo" kp"vjg" rgtkqf" dghqtg"
Yqtnf" Yct"KK"cpf"vjg" fkuewuukqp" qh"Cogtkecp" xu0"Uqxkgv" owukecn" ewn/"
vwtg"fwtkpi" vjg"jg{fc{" qh" u qekcnkuv/tgcnkuv"cguvjgvkeu+" cpf" o wuke"vjgqt{"
*Uejgpmgt." Nqtgp|." Mwtvj+" ku"ftcocvke" cpf"kpeqpitwqwu0"
Egtvckpn{."cp"gpicigogpv" kp"rqnkvkeu"ycu"fg"tkiwgwt" coqpi" curkt/"
kpi"kpvgnngevwcnu"kp"D cddkvv)u" uvwfgpv" oknkgw."cpf" vjg" rqnctkvkgu" dtgf" d{"
vjg"rqnkvkecn"oqxgogpvu" cpf" kfgqnqikecn" fkxkukqpu" qh" vjg" 3;52u/"
Uvcnkpkuv1Vtqvum{kuv."dqwtigqku1rtqngvctkcp." cxcpv/ictfg1ocuu" ctv/"
kphqtogf" Cogtkecp" ctvkuvke"ewnvwtg" hqt" uqog" vkog" vjgtgchvgt0" Kp"vjg"
yqtfu" qh"qpg"qh"Dcddkvv)u" Vtqvum{kuv" htkgpfu."Fykijv" Ocefqpcnf." yjq"
dgecog" cp"gfkvqt" qh"vjg"kphnwgpvkcn" lqwtpcnu"Rctvkucp" Tgxkgy" cpf" R qnkvkeu"
kp"vjg"ncvvgt"jcnh"qh"vjg" fgecfg." $Qxgt" jgtg."ytqvg" Gogtuqp" vq"Ectn{ng"
crtqrqu"vjg" Cogtkec" qh"v jg" 3:52)u." gxgt{qpg" {qw" oggv" jcu" c"rtqlgev"
hqt"wpkxgtucn"tghqto" kp"jku"rqemgv0" Uq"fkf"gxgt{qpg" vjcv" uqogqpg" nkmg"
Gogtuqp" okijv" jcxg" o gv"kp" v jg"Cogtkec" qh"c" ncvgt"
egpvwt{" *dwv" qwt"
ygtg"
uetkrvu" cnn"Octzkcp+0" Cp"kpvgtguv" kp"cxcpv/ictfg" rqnkvkeu" ycu"
qh"
gzrgevgf" gxgt{" rtqrgt" kpvgnngevwcn0$56" Dcddkvv)u" tgeqnngevkqp" qh"jku"
cpvkrcvj{" vq"vjg" Owuke" Xcpiwctf" *cpf"Eqrncpf)u" eqoogpvu" vjgtgkp" qp"
vjg"eqorctcvkxg" ukvwcvkqpu" qh" {qwpi" Twuukcp" cpf" C ogtkecp" eqorqugtu+"
uwiiguvu"vjcv"jg"ycu"jkijn{" gpicigf" d{"vjg" fgdcvgu" qxgt" rtqngvctkcp/"
kuo."tcfkecnkuo" kp"igpgtcn." cpf"owuke" fwtkpi" vjg"okf/3;52u0" Dcddkvv"
owuv" jcxg"dggp" rckphwnn{" ygnn" cyctg" vjcv"tcfkecn" rqnkvkeu" rnc{gf" cp"
tqng"kp"
korqtvcpv" fghkpkpi" c" htcikng"Cogtkecp" owukecn" ewnvwtg" kp"ugctej"
qh"vgejpkswgu" cpf"xcnwgu0" Cu"Eqrncpf" fgenctgf" kp" j ku"ctvkeng" $Pqvg" vq"
[qwpi" Eqorqugtu$" kp"vjg"kpcwiwtcn" kuuwg"
qh"vjg" Owuke" Xcpiwctf." vjg"
rtqngvctkcp" oqxgogpv" vjtgcvgpgf" vjg"
vq"qxgtvjtqy" itgcv" dqwtigqku"
qh"
nkpgcig" Gwtqrgcp" owukecn" vtcfkvkqp<" $Kv"ku"p q"ugetgv" vjcv" ocp{" qh"
vjg"{qwpi" eqorqugtu" yjq" jcf" vcmgp" qpg"q t"vjg" qvjgt" qh" vjgug" vyq"
qnfgt"ogp" ]Uejqgpdgti" cpf"Uvtcxkpum{_" cu"vjgkt"oqfgnu" jcxg"pqy"
vjtqyp" kp"vjgkt" nqv"ykvj" vjcv" qh"vjg" yqtmkpi" encuu0$57"
Tgecnnkpi"vjg" rgtkqf" qxgt" hqtv{" ncvgt."
{gctu" Ctvjwt" Dgtigt" gncdq/"
tcvgf"qp"Eqrncpf)u" encko<"

ygtg"
]C_tvkuvu" dgkpi"
uwrrqtvgf" qwv"
vq"ectt{"
cpf"eqookuukqpgf" ykvj"
rtqlgevu"
Cogtkecpc"cu"vjgkt" [qw"ecp"gcukn{"
ocvvgt0"
uwdlgev" vjcv"vjg"ocppgt/"
wpfgtuvcpf"
cpf"fgxkegu"kuuwkpi"
kuou" hqt"
qwv"qh"Xkgppc"ygtg"vqq"tgoqvg" vjku"
rwtrqug0"
000"
gpqwij."
Ewtkqwun{" Cogtkecpkuo" ]cv"vjcv" ygpv"
vkog_" kp"jcpf"
jcpf" ykvj"
0"0" 0"Pqy"kv"ujqwnf"
nghvkuo0"
rqnkvkecn" dg"qdxkqwu" vjg"
vjcv" qh"c"rtqngvctkcv"
fgocpfu"
owuke"
]uke_" tgswktgf" vjcp"
ceeguukdknkv{"
itgcvgt" d{"vjg"
dg"xqwejuchgf"
eqwnf" qh"
v{rg"
owuke"
gocpcvkpi" Xkgppc058"
htqo"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"395"

Vjku"uvctm"qrrqukvkqp" qh"Gwtqrg" cpf"Cogtkec." vjg"Uejqgpdgti/"


Uvtcxkpum{" vtcfkvkqp" cpf"rtqngvctkcpkuo." owuv"jcxg"vtqwdngf" vjg"{qwpi"
Dcddkvv0"Hqt" vjg" vjcv"
Dcddkvv." uwiiguvkqp" {qwpigt" Cogtkecp" eqorqugtu"
owuv" fgxqvg" vjgougnxgu" vq"vjg"fgxgnqrogpv" qh"yqtmkpi/encuu" ewnvwtg"
owuv" jcxg"uggogf" c"dngcm" rtqurgev0" Kp" vjku"
gpxktqpogpv." vjg" rtqdngo"
hqt"
Dcddkvv" ycu"engct<" vq"fgnkpgcvg" c"xkukqp"qh"Cogtkecp" owukecn" ewn/"
vwtg"vjcv"okijv" kpeqtrqtcvg" Gwtqrgcp" cejkgxgogpvu" ykvjqwv" dgkpi"
d{"*qt"cuukokncvgf"
uvkhngf" vq+"vjgo" cpf"cnuq"qhhgt" cp"cnvgtpcvkxg" vq"vjg"
encuu"
cpcn{uku" *cpf"yqtmkpi/encuu" qh"
chhknkcvkqp+" v jg"
nghv/ykpi" kpvgnnkigp/"
Cu"gctn{"
vukc0" cu"3;55." hqt"
gzcorng." Dcddkvv)u"eqorqukvkqp" vgcejgt."
Tqigt" Uguukqpu." urqmg" qwv"hqteghwnn{" cickpuv" vjg"kpxqecvkqp" qh"rqnkvkeu"
cpf"pcvkqpcnkuo" cu"qticpk|kpi" rtkpekrngu" hqt"owukecn" vjqwijv059"
Yjcv" jcu"cnn"qh"vjku" vq"fq"ykvj" vjg"ocvwtg" Dcddkvv" cpf"jku"kpuku/"
vgpeg"qp"uekgpvkhke" ncpiwcigA" K"rtqrqug" vjcv" Dcddkvv)u"ogvcvjgqt{." ykvj"
kvu"
qxgtv" cpvk/kfgqnqikecn" rnwtcnkuo." kvu"gorjcuku" qp"ncpiwcig." tcvkqpcn/"
cpf"hqtocnkuo."
kv{." cpf" kvu"
cpzkgvkgu" cdqwv" eqpugtxkpi" uvcpfctfu" qh"
owukecn" ekvk|gpujkr" *jqygxgt" owej" vjgug" cpzkgvkgu"okijv" dg"rwujgf" vq"
vjg" kp"j ku"
rgtkrjgt{" ytkvkpiu+." qhhgtgf"cp" cnvgtpcvkxg" rkevwtg" qh" C ogtk/"
ecp"owukecn" ewnvwtg" vq"vjcv"yjkej" qrrqugf" Gwtqrg" cpf"Cogtkec."
Uvtcxkpum{" qt"Uejqgpdgti" cpf"vjg"$yqtmkpi" ocp0$" Dcddkvv)u" rqukvkqpu"
gogtigf" kp"c"ewnvwtcn" cpf"rqnkvkecn" enkocvg" vjcv"ycu"cv"hktuv" tgukuvcpv."
dwv"ncvgt"oqtg" eqpigpkcn." vq"jku"rctvkewnct" kpvgtguvu"kp"Gwtqrgcp" vtcfk/"
vkqp."owuke" vjgqt{." cpf"rjknquqrj{0" Oqtgqxgt." Dcddkvv)u" ytkvkpi"
tgvckpu"c"nctign{"wpcempqyngfigf" vtceg"qh"v jg"
urgekhke" cpf"eqp/"
vgtou"
egtpu"vjcv" kphqtogf" cpvk/Uvcnkpkuv"rqukvkqpu" qp"ewnvwtg" *gurgekcnn{" cu"
vjg{"ecog" vq"d g"tgecuv" dghqtg" cpf" fwtkpi" Yqtnf" Yct" KK"kp"v gtou" qh"
$ocuu++"tcvjgt" vjcp" $encuu$"ewnvwtg+0" Vjg"xcnwgu" cpf"ogcpkpiu" vjcv"
Engogpv" Itggpdgti." Fykijv" Ocefqpcnf." cpf" qvjgt" rtqokpgpv" etkvkeu"
cuuqekcvgf"ykvj" vjg"vgtou" qh"vjgkt"ocuu" ewnvwtg"etkvkswg//uwej" cu"
$cxcpv/ictfg.$" cpf"
$mkvuej.$" $gzvtcxgtukqp$//ctg." K"dgnkgxg." enqugn{"
eqppgevgf" vq"vjqug" vjcv" Dcddkvv" ncvgt"cuuqekcvgf"ykvj" $rqrwnkuo.$"
$uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig.$" cpf"$owukecn" ekvk|gpujkr0$"

Ncpiwcig"xu0"Rtqrcicpfc"
$Yqtfu"cpf"Yct$<"Uekgpvkhke"
Kp"Pqxgodgt"
3;67"Dcddkvv" c"dtkgh"
rwdnkujgf" $Dcvvng"
rqgo." kp"
Et{.$"
Ocefqpcnf)u"
Fykijv" Rqnkvkeu0"
lqwtpcn."
Nkg"uggmu"qwv"nkg"
Wpvtwvj" hqnnqyu"wpvtwvj"
Vjku"ecp"dg"tgcf"
Kp"vjg"Dqqm"qh"vjg" Fgcf0"
Ocmg" kv"{qwt"
oczko"
cpf"hknn"
kv"ykvj" ngcf05:"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
396" Vjg"
Owukecn"
Swctvgtn{"

Ocefqpcnf." d{"vjgp" c"ugnh/fguetkdgf" cpctejkuv/rcekhkuv." hqwpfgf" Rqnkvkeu"


kp"tgcevkqp" vq"vjg"Rctvkucp" Tgxkgy)u" tgvtgcv" htqo" rqnkvkecn"
rqukvkqpu"
fwtkpi" vjg" yct05;" Kv"y qwnf"dg" gzvtcxcicpv" vq"c uetkdg"
cpctejkuv." rcek/"
qt"uqekcnkuv"
hkuv." qrkpkqpu" vq"Dcddkvv" dcugf" qp"jku"cuuqekcvkqp" ykvj" Oce/"
fqpcnf)u" lqwtpcn062" Jqygxgt." hqt"cp{" cwvjqt." c"eqppgevkqp" ykvj"Rqnkvkeu"
ukipcnngf" c"uvtqpi" cpvk/Uvcnkpkuv" rqukvkqp0" Vjg"swguvkqp" qh"htgg."engct."
pqpeqgtekxg" kp"
urggej." qrrqukvkqp" vq" v jg"uvcvg" rqnkekgu"qh"d qvj"Igt/"
ocp{" cpf"vjg"Uqxkgv" ycu"
Wpkqp." egpvtcn" vq"cnoquv" gxgt{vjkpi" vjcv"
crrgctgf" kp"R qnkvkeu0"
Ykvjkp" c"hgy" oqpvju" qh"v jg" qh"
crrgctcpeg"$Dcvvng"
Et{.$" Ocefqpcnf" rwdnkujgf" ctvkengu" d{" pwogtqwu" rtqokpgpv" Pgy"[qtm"
Kpvgnngevwcnu." coqpi" vjgo." E0"Ytkijv" Oknnu." Engogpv" Itggpdgti."
Fcpkgn" c pf"
Dgnn." Oct{" OeEctvj{0" Ukoqpg" Ygkn)u" $Yqtfu" cpf"Yct.$"
cp"korcuukqpgf" fgocpf" hqt"engct" vjqwijv" cpf"urggej" cu"c"tgogf{" vq"
vjg"vtgcejgtqwu" qduewtkvkgu" cpf"unqicpggtkpi" qh"yct." uggou" cp"qdxkqwu"
eqorcpkqp" rkgeg" vq"Dcddkvv)u" rqgo0" Jgt"eqpvtcuv" dgvyggp" $mpqyp"
cpf"
swcnkvkgu$" $gorv{" cduqnwvgu$" gxgp" uggou" vq"c fwodtcvg" Dcddkvv)u"
etkvkswg" qh"ogvcrj{ukeu" cpf"kortgekukqp" kp"owuke" fkueqwtug<" $Enqwfu" qh"
gorv{" cduqnwvgu" jkfg" vjg" rtqdngo)u" ]vjg"gnkokpcvkqp" qh" yct_" mpqyp"
swcnkvkgu." gxgp" vjg" hcev"vjcv" vjku"ku"c"rtqdngo" vq"uqnxg." cpf"pqv"cp"
hcvg0"
kpguecrcdng" Vjg{" fwnn"qwt"okpfu." vjg{" wu"
ectt{" qwt"
v q" fgcvju0$63"
Cnqpiukfg" Ygkn)u" rqngoke." Mctn"Lcurgtu" tgrqtvgf" qp"vjg"uvtwiing" hqt"
cecfgoke" htggfqo" kp"Igtocp{" vjg"
fwtkpi" yct." Oceqpcnf" fgpqwpegf"
$vjg"dki"nkg$"kp"dqvj" Uvcnkpkuv" Twuukc" cpf"vjg"Cogtkecp" Eqoowpkuv"
Rctv{."cpf" P keqncu" Pcdqmqx" dtqwijv" yqtf" qh" $vjg" owuke" rwtig$" kp"vjg"
Uqxkgv" Wpkqp064"
Vjtqwijqwv" vjg" jkuvqt{" qh"Rqnkvkeu"*3;65/6;+."Ocefqpcnf" cnuq"
rwdnkujgf" c"ugtkgu" qh"ctvkengu" qp"ocuu" ewnvwtg065" Yjkng" vjgug" oc{" pqv"
eqpvckp" vjg" hwnn" cpf"
fkxgtukv{" eqorngzkv{" qh" vjg" fkuewuukqp" qh"o cuu"
ewnvwtg." Ocefqpcnf)u" ycu"qpg"qh"vjg"uvtqpiguv" xqkegu"tckugf" kp"c"etk/"
vkswg"qh" o cuu"ewnvwtg" cu" cp"$kpuvtwogpv" qh"uqekcn" fqokpcvkqp0$66"
Pwogtqwu" etkvkeu."kpenwfkpi" Ugtig" Iwkndcwv" cpf"Cpftgy" Tquu." jcxg"
kfgpvkhkgf" vjg"fkuewuukqp" qh"ocuu" ewnvwtg" cu"c"egpvtcn" eqorqpgpv" qh"
ewnvwtcn" etkvkekuo" kp" v jg"ncvvgt"rctv"qh" vjg" 3 ;52u" cpf"vjtqwij" vjg"
3;62u067" Kp"Tquu)u" yqtfu." $]V_jg" crrgctcpeg" qh"hcuekuo"/ejctcevgtk|gf"
d{"c"hqto" qh" uqekcn" cpf" kfgqnqikecn" vjcv"
qticpk|cvkqp" crrgctgf" vq"vtcpu/"
hqto" encuugu" kpvq")ocuugu)" /gpuwtgf"vjcv" vjg"uqekcn" eqpegtp" qh"Cogtk/"
ecp"kpvgnngevwcnu" yqwnf" kpetgcukpin{" dg" y kvj"vjg" oqfgn" qh"c"ocuu"
uqekgv{" cpf"ocuu" ewnvwtg0$68" Hqt"Dcddkvv)u" Vtqvum{kuv" htkgpfu." kpfggf"
hqt" Cogtkecp"
ocp{" vjg"Uqxkgv"Wpkqp."cu"ygnn"cu"Igt/"
kpvgnngevwcnu."
ecog"vq"dg"uggp"cu"c"fcpigtqwu"
ocp{." rtqrqpgpv"qh"ocuu"ewnvwtg0"
Vjg"
hqtocvkqp" Htqpv"
qh"vjg"Rqrwnct" d{" vjg"ugxgpvj" qh"
eqpitguu" vjg" Oqueqy"
kp"3;57"cppqwpegf"
Eqokpvgtp" kp"vjg"Eqoowpkuv"
c"ujkhv"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"397"

ewnvwtcn"
rtqitco" cp"gorjcuku"
htqo" qp"rtqngvctkcpkuo." ug."vq"c"nguu"
rgt"
qdxkqwun{" vq"
crrtqcej"
rqnkvkek|gf" c tv"
vjcv" jcxg"
okijv" itgcvgt" koogfk/"
cvg"ocuu"
crrgcn0"Vjg"Cogtkecp"
Eqoowpkuv" Rctv{" Gctn"
ngcfgt." Dtqy/"
vq"
tghgttgf"
fgt." k ewnvwtcn"
vu" rtqitco"cu" ctvkuvke"
$vjg" tgetgcvkqp"
qh"
vjg"
itgcv" iqkpi"
rtqeguu" qp"coqpi"vjg"
rgqrng"qh"vjg"etgcvkqp"
qh"c"dtqcf"
fgoqetcvke" Fgurkvg"cp"qxgtvn{"
htqpv0$69" cpvkhcuekuv" vjg"ocuu"
rquvwtg."
ewnvwtg" qh"vjg"Rqrwnct"
uvtcvgikgu" Htqpv"dgecog" c"vqwejuvqpg" qh"vjg"
Cogtkecp" etkvkswg"qh"U Cv"
vcnkpkuo0" v jg"
ucog" vkog."gxgpvu"uwej" cu"vjg"
Oqueqy" Vtkcnu"cpf"vjg"Jkvngt/Uvcnkp" Rcev"eqpvtkdwvgf"vq"c"fkuknnwukqp/"
ogpv"ykvj" Twuukc"qp"vjg" qh"
rctv" ocp{" Cogtkecp" kpvgnngevwcnu"
cpf"c"
qh"rqnctk|cvkqp"
ugpug" cpf"$fcpigtqwu" vq"tgecnn"
kttcvkqpcnkv{.$" Dcddkvv)u"
yqtfu."cv"
j qog06:" Tgrqtvu"dqvj"qh"
U qxkgv" c tv"
uwrrtguukqp" vjcv"
qh" fkf"
pqv"eqphqto" vq"vjg"tgswktgogpvu"qh"vjg"uvcvg"cpf"vjg"kphknvtcvkqp"
qh"
hkhvj"
ewnvwtcn" eqnwopkuvu"kp"Cogtkec" tgiwnctn{"crrgctgf"kp"v jg"rtqitgu/"
ukxg"
ocic|kpgu0" Kp"3;66."hqt"
gzcorng." Mwtv" Nkuv." qp"Twuukcp"
ytkvkpi"
owuke"kp"Rqnkvkeu."
yctpgf" vjg"vjtgcv"
cickpuv" qh"Uqxkgv"
eqpvcokpcvkqp<"
$Yjgvjgt" qwt"owuke" yknn"
uweewod" vq"vjg"ujcnnqypguu" cpf"vjg" gcu{"
uweeguu"
qh"vjg"rtgugpv"Twuukcp" yknn"
uv{ng" nctign{" fgrgpf" vjg"
wrqp" hwvwtg"
kphnwgpeg"
rqnkvkecn" qh"vjg"Uqxkgv"Wpkqp0" Ykvj" qh"cnn"ujcfgu"
rqnkvkekcpu"
lworkpi"qp" vjg"Twuukcp"dcpfyciqp." kv"
ku"
p qv"
wpgzrgevgf" vjcv" owuk/"
ekcpu"ctg"hqnnqykpi0$6;"
Ocuu" ewnvwtg."kfgpvkhkgf" ykvj" vjg"Uqxkgv" Wpkqp" cpf"Igtocp{."
cpf"y kvj"$fgdcugf$" cpf" $ogejcpkecn$" ecrkvcnkuv"
rtqfwevkqp." ycu"uggp."
dqvj" kp"rtkpekrng"cpf"rtcevkeg." vq"dg"cp"kpuvtwogpv" qh"cwvjqtkvctkcpkuo"
cpf"vqvcnkvctkcp"uvcvgu0"Cu"Itggpdgti" rwv"kv"kp"3;5;." kp"vjg"korqtvcpv"
guuc{."$Cxcpv/ictfg" cpf"Mkvuej.$" $gxgt{"ocp." htqo" vjg" Vcoocp{"
cnfgtocp" vq"vjg"Cwuvtkcp" jqwug" rckpvgt."hkpfu"vjcv"jg" ku" vq"jku"
gpvkvngf"
qrkpkqp0" 0000" Jgtg"tgxqnxgtu" cpf"vqtejgu"dgikp" vq"dg"ogpvkqpgf" kp"
vjg"ucog" dtgcvj"cu"ewnvwtg0" Kp"vjg"pcog" qh"iqfnkpguu" qh"vjg"dnqqf)u"
jgcnvj."kp"vjg" pcog" qh"ukorng" yc{u" cpf"uqnkf" xktvwgu."vjg"uvcvwg/"
uocujkpi" eqoogpegu0$72" Yjcv" ku"
v jg"
c pvkfqvg"vq"v jg"xkqngpeg"gpuwkpi"
htqo" wphgvvgtgf"rqrwnct" qrkpkqpA" Hqt"
Ocefqpcnf." Ygkn."qt"vjg"Dcddkvv"
qh"$Dcvvng" Et{.$"cu"ygnn" cu"hqt"Itggpdgti." c"rctv"qh"vjg"cpuygt" eqwnf"
dg"hqwpf" kp"tgfwekpi" vjg"rgtxcukxgpguu" qh"rtqrcicpfc" *$nkg"uggmu"
qwv"
/kp" cpf" vjqug"
nkg$+" kfgpvkh{kpi"uwrrtguukpi" fcpigtqwu" $pcogu$" *$iqfnk/"
pguu.$"vjg"$dnqqf)u" jgcnvj$+" wugf"vq"xcnkfcvg" cpf"eqpuqnkfcvg" vqvcnkvct/"
kcp"rqygt0"
C"eqorngogpvct{" fghgpug"
cickpuv"ocuu"ctv"nc{"kp"vjg"rtqoqvkqp"
cpf"rtqfwevkqp"
qh"c"fkhhgtgpv"
mkpf"qh"ctvkuvke"
yqtm." yqtm" vjcv"ycu"
wpchtckf"
kpfkxkfwcnkuvke."
fqiigfn{" qh"eqorngzkv{." tgukuvcpv"
kttgfwekdng."
vq"crrtqrtkcvkqp0"
Vjg"cpvk/Uvcnkpkuv1cpvkhcuekuv"
etkvkswg"qh"
o cuu"
ctv"
rqnkvkecnn{"
rtqxkfgf" gpicigf"kpvgnngevwcnu"
cpf"ctvkuvu"ykvj"rqygthwn"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
398" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

ctiwogpvu" hqt" tgjcdknkvcvkqp"


vjg" qh"oqfgtpkuv"ocuvgtrkgegu0" Pq"nqpigt"
$wp/Cogtkecp$" qt"$cpvkrtqngvctkcp.$" Gwtqrgcp" oqfgtpkuv" ewnvwtg"
okijv"pqy" dg" xkgygf"cu"c"rctcfkio" hqt"Cogtkec" cpf"cp" cpuygt" vq"vjg"
ctvkuvke"
rtqfwevkqp" qh"vqvcnkvctkcp" Cu"vjg"Rctvkucp"
uvcvgu0" Tgxkgy" gfkvqt."
Tcjx."
Rjknkr" rtqrqugf" kp"$Rtqngvctkcp" Nkvgtcvwtg<"C"Rqnkvkecn"Cwvqru{$"
*3;5;+."$Vjgtg" ctg"egtvckp"hqtou" qh"fgociqi{" 0"00" yjkej" c"ogfkwo" cu"
rcnrcdng"cu"hkevkqp/wpnguu" kv"
fgigpgtcvgu" vq"
v jg"ngxgn"qh"rwnr"
rtqrcicpfc/" gzenwfgu" d{"kvu"xgt{"pcvwtg0"Vjwu"vjg" ogfkc" qh"ctv."kh"
qpn{" v
d{" jcv"hcev"
cnqpg." vjgkt"
rtqxg" uwrgtkqt" jwocpkv{" vq"vjg"ogfkc" qh"
xu0"rtqrcicpfc<"
Rcnrcdknkv{"
rqnkvkeu0$73" Hqt"
Tcjx." vjg"
ogfkc" qh"ctv"
cwvjqtkvctkcp"
tgukuv" xkqngpeg" wpnguu"vjg{" Cu"K"
fgigpgtcvg0" uwiiguv" kp"vjg"
hqnnqykpi" qpg"qh"Engogpv"
ugevkqp." Itggpdgti)u" eqpvtkdwvkqpu" vq"vjg"
cpvk/Uvcnkpkuv"
etkvkswg" e
qh" wnvwtg"ycu" cp"gurgekcnn{" hwnn"
ceeqwpv" qh"vjg"
eqpfkvkqpu"qh"pqp/eqqrvgf" *qt."vq"wug"Tcjx)u"vgto." pqpfgigpgtcvg+"
qpg"
ctv." v jcv"
ku" qh"
uwiiguvkxg" D cddkvv)u"
ncvgt"
ogvcvjgqtgvkecn" ytkvkpi074"

Vjg"Tghngevgf"Ghhgev<"
Ncpiwcig"cpf"Ctvkuvke"
Uekgpvkhke" Cwvqpqo{"

Itggpdgti)u" qh"ocuu"
cpcn{uku" ygpv"
ewnvwtg" hct"dg{qpf" c"igpgtke" yctpkpi"
cickpuv"rtqrcicpfkuvke" Jg" vjg"
ncpiwcig0" rtqxkfgf" fgpuguv." oquv"gng/"
icpv"u{pqruku"qh"vjg"jkuvqt{"qh"vjku"
oqogpv" kp"Cogtkecp" ewnvwtcn"
rtq/"
fwevkqp" cpf"etkvkekuo<"
$Uqogfc{" kv"
y knn"
jcxg" v q"
d g"vqnf"jqy" cpvk/"
Uvcnkpkuo"yjkej" uvctvgf"qwv"oqtg" qt"nguu"cu"Vtqvum{kuo" vwtpgf" kpvq"ctv"
hqt"ctv)u" cpf"
ucmg." vjgtgd{" engctgf"vjg" yc{." jgtqkecnn{" ]#_."hqt"
yjcv" ycu"
vq"eqog0$75" Itggpdgti)u" qyp" etkvkecn"
eqpvtkdwvkqp" vq"vjku" vtclgevqt{"
hqewugf"qp"jku"fkuewuukqp"qh"vjg"fkuvkpevkqp" dgvyggp" $cxcpv/ictfg$" cpf"
$mkvuej0$"
Cu"Itggpdgti" uwiiguvgf." Vtqvum{"*qrrqukpi" Uvcnkp" cpf"vjg"ewn/"
vwtcn" qh"vjg"Uqxkgv"
rqnkekgu" uvcvg+"
rtqxkfgf" nghvkuv"kpvgnngevwcnu" ykvj"
gzgornct{" fgenctcvkqpu"qh"vjg"pggf"hqt" ctv0"
ugnh/ngikuncvgf"*Tgecnn" vjcv"
Vtqvum{" ycu"xkpfkecvgf"d{"Lqjp" Fgyg{)u" eqookuukqp" tgrqtv" kp"3;59"
cpf"vjcv" Dcddkvv" qwv"
ukpingf" vjku"
kpekfgpv" kp" vjg"tgokpkuegpegu" qh"vjg"
3;52u" cdqxg0"
ekvgf" Vjg"gzqpgtcvkqp" qh"Vtqvum{" d{"c"hkiwtg" qh"Fgyg{)u"
uvcvwtg"jcf"gpqtoqwu" korcev" qp"C ogtkecp" kpvgnngevwcnu0+" Cu"rtqrqugf"
vq"vjg"gfkvqtu"
kp"c"ngvvgt" qh"vjg"Rctvkucp"Tgxkgy" ukipgf" d{"Vtqvum{" kp"
3;5:." etgcvkqp"
$Ctvkuvke" jcu"kvu"qyp"ncyu/gxgp" yjgp" kv"eqpuekqwun{"
ugtxgu"c"uqekcn"oqxgogpv0"Vtwn{" ku"kpeqorcvkdng"
etgcvkqp"
kpvgnngevwcn"
cpf"vjg"urktkv"
ykvj"nkgu."j{rqetku{." qh"eqphqtokv{0"Ctv"ecp"dgeqog"c"
uvtqpi" qpn{"kpuqhct"
cnn{"qh"tgxqnwvkqp" vq"kvugnh0$7u6"
hckvjhwn"
cu"kv"tgockpu"
Vjtqwij" vjg"ogfkcvkpi"vgto"$kpvgnngevwcn" vjku"
etgcvkqp.$" Vtqvum{kuv"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"399"

rqngoke"rtqenckou"vjg"qrrqukvkqp" qh"$nkgu."
j{rqetku{."cpf"vjg" qh"
urktkv"
cpf"
eqphqtokv{.$"ugnh/ngikuncvgf" ctv0"
Vjg" q
nkgu" h"
v qvcnkvctkcpkuo"
tgswktg"
pqv"qpn{"
eqttgevkxg" ncpiwcig."rgt"ug."dwv"cnuq"vjg" qh"ctv"
etgcvkqp" vjcv"
yknn"
dg"koowpg" vq"eqqrvcvkqp0" vjg"
Tgrncekpi" gorjcuku" qp"t gxqnwvkqp"
ykvj"vjg"oqtg" oqfguv" cko"qh"ucnxcikpi"ugtkqwu"ewnvwtg"
htqo"vjg"vqvcnk/"
vctkcp"
vjtgcv" ocuu"
cpf"ecrkvcnkuv" vjg"
rtqfwevkqp." Vtqvum{kuv" qrrqukvkqp"
qh"eqphqtokv{"cpf"vtwg"ctvkuvke"
etgcvkqp"eqogu" enqug"vq"Itggpdgti)u"
hcoqwu" qh"$mkvuej$"
ecvgiqtkgu" cpf"$cxcpv/ictfg0$" *Itggpdgti" rwdnkujgf"
$Cxcpv/ictfg" cpf"Mkvuej$"kp"vjg"Rctvkucp"Tgxkgy" kp"3;5;."c"{gct"
chvgt"
vjg" ngvvgt" cpf"
Vtqvum{kuv" crrgctgf" ujqtvn{" dghqtg" Tcjx)u"$cwvqru{$"qh"
nkvgtcvwtg."
rtqngvctkcp" swqvgf"cdqxg0+"Itggpdgti" qhhgtu"
c"fgvckngf"
ceeqwpv"qh"vjg"eqpfkvkqpu"pgeguuct{"hqt"ctv"vq"dg" $hckvjhwn"
gpvktgn{" vq"
kvugnh0$"

ku"vq"dg"fkuuqnxgf"
Eqpvgpv" uq"eqorngvgn{" hqto"
kpvq" vjcv"
vjg"
yqtm"
qh"ctv"
qt"nkvgt/"
ecppqv"
cvwtg" kp"yjqng"qt"rctv"vq"cp{vjkpi"
dg"tgfwegf" 0"0" 0"Vjg"pqp/"
dwv"kvugnh0"
tgrtgugpvcvkqpcn" kh"
kv"ku"vq"jcxg"
qt"$cduvtcev.$" cguvjgvke" ecppqv"
xcnkfkv{." dg"
qt"ceekfgpvcn."
ctdkvtct{" owuv"
dwv" uvgo" htqo"
uqog" qt"qtkikp0"
eqpuvtckpv"
yqtvj{"
Vjku"eqpuvtckpv."
qpeg"vjg"yqtnf"
qh"gzvtcxgtvgf" jcu"dggp"tgpqwpegf."
gzrgtkgpeg"
ecp"qpn{" kp"vjg"
dg"hqwpf" xgt{" qt"fkuekrnkpgu"
rtqeguugu" d{"yjkej"
ctv"
cpf"nkvgtc/"
jcxg"cntgcf{"
vwtg" kokvcvgf"
vjg"hqtogt077"

Vjg"hkpcn."tcvjgt"uvwfkgf" rtgrqukvkqpcn"
rjtcug"qh"vjku"
rcuucig" enqugu"
ykvj"
gnnkrvkecnn{" cp" cflgevkxg"*$vjg"hqtogt$+"vjcv" vq"
tghgtu" vjg"cntgcf{"
fkucrrgctkpi" vgto" *$vjg"yqtnf" qh"gzvtcxgtvgf"
gzrgtkgpeg$+" cv"vjg"
dgikppkpi" qh"vjg"ugpvgpeg=" vjg"xgtd"hqto"qh"vjg"enqukpi"rjtcug" guvcd/"
nkujgu"vjg"jkuvqtkecn"itqwpfkpi" qh"vjg"
rtqeguu"qh"ugnh/tghgtgpeg"*gorjc/"
uk|kpi" qt"
$rtqeguugu"fkuekrnkpgu$" tcvjgt"
vjcp"cp{" qtkikpcn"
qdlgev" qh"
kokvcvkqp+0"Itggpdgti)u" ugnh/tghgtgpvkcn"
kpvtkecvgn{" oc{"
ytkvkpi" tgokpf"
wu"qh"vjg"gncdqtcvg" ugnh/"
cpf"etquu/tghgtgpegu"
kp"ocp{" qh"Dcddkvv)u" nqpi"
ugpvgpegu0"Cpf"vjg"ugctej" hqt" c"$yqtvj{"
eqpuvtckpv$" wpdqwpf" htqo"
tgrtgugpvcvkqp" cpf"$gzvtcxgtvgf" tgecnnu"
gzrgtkgpeg$" Dcddkvv)u" $etkvgtkqp"
qh"ukipkhkecpeg.$"
wpjkpfgtgf" d{"ogvcrj{ukeu" qt"kfgqnqi{0"*Pqvg"cnuq"
vjg" kp"
gejqgu." Itggpdgti)u" eqpvgorncvkqp" qh"hqtocnkuo"cpf" vjg" eqp/"
uvtckpvu"
qh"ctv."qh"Lqjp"Fgyg{)u" qh"$ctvkuvke"
eqwrnkpi" eqpuvtwevkqp$" cpf"
$swcnkv{$"kp"v jg"
g ctnkgt"
guuc{."$Swcnkvcvkxg"
Vjqwijv.$" ekvgf" cdqxg0"
Yjgvjgt" qt"pqv"Itggpdgti" ycu"cu"gpvjwukcuvke"c"rtqrqpgpv" qh"vjg"
gctn{"kuuwgu"
qh"U{orqukwo" cu"Dcddkvv."$Cxcpv/ictfg" cpf"M kvuej$" rtq/"
xkfgu"cp"wtigpv"uqekcn"eqpvgzv"hqt"
vjg"tgxkxcn"
cpf"tgxkukqp"
qh"Fgyg{)u"
uvtwevwtcnkuo."ykvj"c"urgekcn"gorjcuku"
qp"eqpvgorqtct{" ctv0+"
K"yknn"tgvwtp"
vq"Itggpdgti)u" fkuvkpe/"
$gzvtcxgtukqp$1*kpvtqxgtukqp+"
vkqp"dghqtg" vjku"fkuewuukqp0"
enqukpi" K"ujqwnf"
Dwv"hktuv." pqvg"vjcv"Itggp/"
dgti."kp"vjku"hqtowncvkqp."
gzrnkekvn{" jku"ejctcevgtk|cvkqp"
eqpvtcuvu" qh"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
39:" Vjg"
Owukecn"
Swctvgtn{"

cduvtcev."
pgq/cxcpv/ictfg" ctv"
vq"vjcv"qh"mkvuej0" Dcddkvv"
*D{"eqpvtcuv."
tguvtkevu"
jku"fkuewuukqp" qh"mkvuej" ocuu"
]rqrwnkuo." vq"jku"pqp/"
ewnvwtg_"
vjgqtgvkecn"eqoogpvu0+" Yjkng" vjg"cxcpv/ictfg" kvugnh"
fkuvkpiwkujgu" d{"
cnn"vtcegu"
fkuvknnkpi" qh"eqpvgpv"htqo" hqtocn"ctvkuvke" vjg"ncvvgt"
rtqeguugu."
wugu"$fgdcugf" cpf"cecfgokek|gf" ukowncetc"
qh"igpwkpg"ewnvwtg$" kvu"
hqt"
ocvgtkcnu078"Vjg"jkij" ctv"qh"vjg"cxcpv/ictfg"ecp"$mggr"
ewnvwtg" oqxkpi"
kp"vjg"okfuv" qh"kfgqnqikecn"eqphwukqp" cpf"xkqngpeg.$79"
yjkng"mkvuej"
uwrrqtvu"qdhwuecvkqp" cpf"eqpuvkvwvgu"kfgqnqi{0"
Yj{" ku"m kvuej"uq"rqygthwn"cp"kpuvtwogpv"qh"$eqphwukqp"cpf"xkq/"
ngpeg$A"Dgecwug" kv"kokvcvgu"vjg"$ghhgevu$"
tcvjgt"
vjcp"vjg"$rtqeguugu$"
qh"ctv0"
wnvkocvg"
]V_jg" xcnwgu"
yjkej"
vjg"
ewnvkxcvgf" fgtkxgu"
urgevcvqt" htqo"
Rkecuuq"
ctg"
fgtkxgf"
cv"c"ugeqpf"tgoqxg."
cu"vjg"tguwnv"
qh"tghngevkqp"
wrqp"vjg"koogfkcvg"
nghv"
kortguukqp" d{"vjg" xcnwgu0"
rncuvke" Kv"ku"qpn{"
vjgp"
vjcv"vjg" vjg"
tgeqipk|cdng."
oktcewnqwu"
cpf"vjg" gpvgt0"
u{orcvjgvke" Vjg{" ctg"
pqv" qt"
koogfkcvgn{" gzvgtpcnn{"
kp"Rkecuuq)u"
rtgugpv" dwv"
rckpvkpi." dg"rtqlgevgf"
owuv" kpvq"
kv"d{"
vjg"urgevcvqt"
ugpukvkxg"
gpqwij"vq"tgcev" vq"rncuvke"
uwhhkekgpvn{" swcnkvkgu0"
Vjg{" vq"vjg"
dgnqpi"
$tghngevgf$" Kp"Tgrkp."
ghhgev0" qp"vjg"
qvjgt" vjg"
jcpf." $tghngevgf$"
ghhgev"
jcu"
dggp"kpenwfgf"
cntgcf{" kp"vjg"rkevwtg." hqt"
tgcf{" vjg"urgevcvqt)u"
wptghngevkxg"
Yjgtg"
gplq{ogpv0" Rkecuuq" ecwug."
rckpvu" Tgrkp"
rckpvu" 7:"
ghhgev0"

Cickp." Itggpdgti" uggou" vq"gejq"Fgyg{)u" fkuewuukqp" qh"swcnkvcvkxg"


vjqwijv0" vjg" qh"
Jqygxgt." rqkpv" gorjcuku" jgtg" ku"
v jcv"mkvuej"ku"eqgt/"
ekxg="kv"kpjgtgpvn{"eqpvckpu" kvu"
qyp"tgurqpugu." ngcxkpi" pgkvjgt" ejqkeg"
pqt"ghhqtv" vq"vjg"tgegkxgt0"Jgpeg." kv"ecp" d g"crrtqrtkcvg" hqt"vjg"
tgswktgogpvu" qh"vjg"uvcvg0"D{"eqpvtcuv." qpn{" vjg"$rncuvke"xcnwgu$" qt"
ugtkqwu"eqpvgorqtct{" *cxcpv/ictfg+" ctv"ctg" c eeguukdng"vq"tgegrvkqp0"
Uwej"ctv" ku"etgcvgf"
cpf"tgegkxgf" kvu"
hqt" qyp" ucmg="kvu"cwvqpqo{" gpuwtgu"
vjcv"kv"ecppqv" dg"uwdlgevgf" vq"uvcvg"
eqpvtqn0" vjg"
Vjwu." cxcpv/ictfg)u"
tgpwpekcvkqp" qh"$gzvtcxgtvgf" gzrgtkgpeg$" ku"nkpmgf" vq"kvu"kpukuvgpv"
cpf"
gzenwukxg" eqpegtp" ykvj" kvu"
qyp" rncuvkekv{="vjku"kp"v wtp"gpuwtgu" kvu"
kpjgtgpv" fkuvkpevkqp"htqo"vjg"ghhgevu"cpf"wugu" qh"ocuu" ctv0"
Kv"ku"rtqdcdn{" engct"d{"pqy" jqy" Itggpdgti)u" fkuewuukqp" qh"cxcpv/"
ictfkuo" jgnru" vq"gzrnkecvg"vjg"eqppgevkqp" dgvyggp" Dcddkvv)u"$qhhkekcn$"
fkuewuukqp" qh"uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig" cpf"j ku"
kphqtocn" cpvkrqrwnkuo0" Itggp/"
dgti)u"etkvgtkc"hqt"
kpenwukqp" kp"vjg" qh"
ecvgiqt{"cxcpv/ictfg"*cpf" ctv"
ewnvwtg+" tguqpcvg"enqugn{"ykvj" Dcddkvv)u"hqt" kpenwukqp" kp"vjg"ecvgiqt{"
qh"ugtkqwu" owuke"*owukecn" ekvk|gpujkr+0" cu"
Lwuv" cxcpv/ictfg" ctv"ku"
$cdqwv$" xcnwgu"
rncuvke" cpf"vjg"ecwugu" qh"ctvkuvke"gzrgtkgpeg." ugtkqwu"
owuke" kp"vgtou"
ku"vq"dg"wpfgtuvqqf" qh"uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig."pqv"vjg"xce/"
wqwu."$kpeqttkikdng$" qh"$gcu{"gxcnwcvkxg$"
ncpiwcig" cpf"$gzrtguukxg"
fguetkrvkxgu0"
$7;"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"39;"

Dqvj" Itggpdgti" cpf"Dcddkvv" fwcnkuvkecnn{" qrrqug" jkij" cpf"ocuu" ewnvwtg"


cpf"xkgy" vjg" fkuvkpevkqp" kp"vgtou" qh"vjg"eqpvtcuv" dgvyggp" rwtgn{" uvtwe/"
cpf"gzvtkpuke"
vwtcn" fguetkrvkqpu" qt" cpf"
rtqrgtvkgu" swcnkvkgu0" Dqvj" vcmg"
vjg"gzrgtkgpeg" qh"ocuu" ewnvwtg" kp"vjg"ncvg"3;52u" cpf"3;62u" cu"c"tghgt/"
gpeg"rqkpv0" Dqvj" rtqxkfg" cp"cwvjqtkvcvkxg" cpf" fkuvkpevn{"Cogtkecp"
crqnqikc" hqt" c"eqookvogpv" vq"vjg"gzgornctu" qh"Gwtqrgcp" oqfgtpkuo0"
yjkng"
Jqygxgt." Itggpdgti" fkuvkpiwkujgu" cxcpv/ictfg" kvuej"
cpf" m d{"
fguetkdkpi" vjg"kpjgtgpv" pcvwtg" qh"vjg" yqtmu" qh"ctv"
vjcv" hcnn"
kpvq" vjgug"
ecvgiqtkgu." Dcddkvv" htcogu" vjg" fkuewuukqp" kp"vgtou" qh"ncpiwcig." urgekhk/"
vjg"ncpiwcig"
ecnn{" hqt"tgiwncvkpi" vjg"ejctcevgtk|cvkqp" qh"owuke0" Hqt"
vjg"
Dcddkvv." ogvcvjgqtkuv." ytkvkpi" kp" vjg" 3 ;72u"cpf" 3;82u" cpf" eqipk/"
|cpv"qh"vjg"eqpvgorqtcpgqwu" grkuvgoqnqikecn" ytkvkpi"qh"Yknnctf" X0"
Swkpg" cpf" P gnuqp"Iqqfocp." vjg" fkuvkpevkqp" dgvyggp" jkij" ctv"cpf"
ocuu"ewnvwtg" /$cwvqpqoqwu$" cpf"$eqqrvgf$" ctv/eqwnf" pqv"dg"htcogf"
kp"vgtou" qh"cp{" kpjgtgpv" rtqrgtvkgu" qh"o wuke"$kvugnh0$82"
Vjg" fkuewuukqp"
pgeguuctkn{" ujkhvgf" htqo" vjg"kpjgtgpv" rtqrgtvkgu" qh"owuke" vq"vjg" rtqrgt/"
vkgu"
qh"ncpiwcig" wugf" vq"fguetkdg" owuke0" *Itggpdgti)u" qyp" encko." vjcv"
vjgtg"ctg"kpvtkpuke" ejctcevgtkuvkeu" fkuvkpiwkujkpi" yqtmu" qh"cxcpv/ictfg"
cpf"mkvuej" ctv."yqwnf" jcxg"dggp" fkhhkewnv"hqt"jko" vq"ocmg" kh"kv"ygtg"
crrnkgf"rtkpekrcnn{" vq"owuke=" owuke" yqwnf" pqv"jcxg" rtqxkfgf" jko" ykvj"
vjg"xkuwcn" ctvu)"uvtqpi" kpvwkvkxg" fkuvkpevkqp" dgvyggp" tgrtgugpvcvkqp" cpf"
cduvtcevkqp0+" Vjg" f khhgtgpeg" dgvyggp" Itggpdgti)u" crrtqcej" cpf" D cd/"
dkvv)u"
kpxqnxgu" c"nkpiwkuvke" vwtp" pgeguukvcvgf" d{"vjg"kpvgnngevwcn"fgxgn/"
qrogpvu" vjg"
fwtkpi" vygpv{" vjcv"
{gctu" ugrctcvg" $Cxcpv/ictfg" cpf"
Mkvuej$"htqo" Dcddkvv)u" korqtvcpv" ogvcvjgqtgvkecn" guuc{u0"Jqygxgt."
dqvj"ugvu" qh"qrrqukvkqpu" rtqxkfg" c"oqfwu" hqt"
qrgtcpfk" gzenwfkpi" vjg"
rtqfwevu" qh"ocuu" ewnvwtg" htqo" vjg"tgcno" qh"ugtkqwu" ctv0"
Kp"ujqtv." yjkng" qp" c"
kpukuvkpi" fg/rqnkvkek|gf" fkuewuukqp" qh"owuke"
eqorqukvkqp." Dcddkvv" jcu"rgtukuvgpvn{" yqttkgf" cdqwv"vjg" rtqdngou" qh"
owukecn" ekvk|gpujkr." ewnvwtcn" cpf"
fkhhgtgpeg."fkxgtukhkecvkqp." vjg" nkokvu"
qh"owukecn" vjqwijv." cpf"vjg"uwtxkxcn" qh"jkij" ewnvwtg0"Jku"eqoogpvu" qp"
vjgug"ocvvgtu" tgvckp" vtcegu" qh"vjg"cpvk/Uvcnkpkuv1ocuu" ewnv"cpzkgvkgu" jg"
cpf"jku"eqpvgorqtctkgu" gzrgtkgpegf" kp"vjg"3;52u" cpf"3;62u0" Kpfggf."
urgewncvkpi" cdqwv" vjg" tgopcpvu" qh"v jgug" cpzkgvkgu"kp"D cddkvv)u"ncvgt"
yqtm" jgnru" vq"gzrnckp" vjg"vgpukqpu" dgvyggp" vjg"tgncvkxkuvke"cpf"gnkvkuv"
curgevu"qh"j ku" Cu" K" kp"
ogvcvjgqt{0" uwiiguv" hqnnqykpi" vjg" ugevkqp." vjg"
Pgy"[qtm" Kpvgnngevwcnu)" fkuewuukqp" qh"ewnvwtcn" rnwtcnkuo"fwtkpi" vjg"
3;72u/hqnnqykpi" vjg"ocuu"ewnvwtg" qh"vjg"rtgxkqwu"
etkvkswgu" fgecfgu/"
eqwrngf"cp"cempqyngfigogpv" qh"ewnvwtcn" ykvj"
fkxgtukv{" c"tcvkqpcng"
hqt"
c"ewnvwtcn"
kpuwncvkpi" k
gnkvg"p"yc{u"vjcv"
ukipkhkecpvn{" vjg"
rctcnngn" e wnvwtcn"
eqoogpvct{" kp"Dcddkvv)u"
kpjgtgpv" ogvcvjgqt{0"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
3:2" Vjg"
Owukecn"
Swctvgtn{"

Vjg"Xkvcn"Egpvgt<"Uekgpvkhke"
Ncpiwcig"cpf"
Rnwtcnkuo"kp"vjg"Eqnf"Yct"Gtc"

Kv"okijv" dg"ctiwgf" cv"vjku" rqkpv" vjcv"K"jcxg"iqpg" vq"gzvtcqtfkpct{"


ngpivju" vq" cp"
qpn{" rctcrjtcug"kpvgtrtgvcvkqp" qh"D cddkvv" vjcv"jcu"
cntgcf{" dggp" ygnn"ctvkewncvgf0" Cu"Mgtocp" rwv"kv"kp"Eqpvgorncvkpi"
Owuke." $]Dcddkvv)u_" gxgp"
fkuvtguu." tcig." gtwrvkpi" kpvq" tgrgcvgf" cuucwnvu"
cpf"kppwgpfqu" fktgevgf" cickpuv" xctkqwu" rtgfkevcdng" vctigvu"0"0"0"kuuwgf"
qdxkqwun{" *cpf"qrgpn{" gpqwij+" htqo" vjg" ucog" ugpug" qh"oqfgtpkuv"
cnkgpcvkqp" cu"ycu"gzrtguugf" xgt{"fkhhgtgpvn{"d{"Uejqgpdgti" qt."vq"vcmg"
cp"gxgp" oqtg" gzvtcxcicpv" Cfqtpq0$83"
ecug." Mgtocp" iqgu" vq"rtq/"
qp"
rqug"vjcv." wpnkmg" Vjgqfqt" Cfqtpq." $Dcddkvv" cv"Rtkpegvqp" ycu"rqkpvkpi"
qwv"vjcv" cxcpv/ictfg" owuke" eqwnf"hkpf"kvu"pkejg" chvgt" cnn//vjqwij" qpn{"
d{"tgvtgcvkpi" htqo" qpg"dcuvkqp" qh"okffng/encuu" ewnvwtg." vjg"eqpegtv"
jcnn."vq"cpqvjgt." vjg"wpkxgtukv{0$84"
Hqt" Mgtocp." Dcddkvv)u" rqukvkqpu"kfgpvkh{" jko" cu"cp"$cnkgpcvgf"
nkmg"
oqfgtpkuv.$" Uejqgpdgti" cpf" C fqtpq0" Cnvjqwij" dqvj" Cfqtpq" cpf"
Dcddkvv" uvcvgf" vjgkt" cpvkrcvj{" vq"rqrwnct" ewnvwtg" kp"pq"wpegtvckp"
vgtou." vjqug" hcoknkct" ykvj" Dcddkvv)u"kphqtocn" eqoogpvu" cdqwv" Cfqtpq"
yknn"
dg"umgrvkecn" cdqwv" cp{" rwvcvkxg" eqppgevkqp" dgvyggp" jko" cpf"vjg"
etkvkecn"vjgqtkuv."yjqo" jg" qpeg"o kp"
gv" Ycujkpivqp" Uswctg085" Jqy/"
gxgt."Dcddkvv)u" rctvkewnct" dtcpf" qh"oqfgtpkuo" ku"c"hct" et{"htqo" Cfqt/"
pq)u"xkukqp" qh"Uejqgpdgti/vjg" jgtogvke." ugnh/ucetkhkekpi"ctvkuv"yjq"
rtgugpvu" c"$uwtxkxkpi" oguucig" qh"fgurckt" htqo" vjg"ujkrytgemgf.$" cpf"
yjq" tgvtgcvu" htqo"eqorncegpv" pqvkqpu" qh" yjkng"
dgcwv{" $rqkpv]kpi_" qwv"
vjg"knnu"qh"uqekgv{" tcvjgt" vjcp" uwdnkocvkpi" vjqug" knnu"
kpvq" c"fgegrvkxg"
*Hqt"
jwocpkvctkcpkuo0)$86" vjkpi." qpg" Dcddkvv" yqwnf" rtqdcdn{" eqpukfgt"
uwej"uvcvgogpvu" ogcpkpinguu." yjgvjgt" kp"e qppgevkqp" ykvj" jku" qyp"
owuke" cpf"vjqwijv" qt"Uejqgpdgti)u0+" Yjkng" Dcddkvv)u" ogvjqfqnqikecn"
rtgqeewrcvkqpu" cpf" vcuvg" okijv" fkueqwtcig" jko" htqo" gzrnkekvn{" uvcvkpi"
ocp{" qh"vjg"ewnvwtcn" kornkecvkqpu" qh"jku"vjgqt{." jku"crrtqcej" vq"owuke"
eqpvckpu" c"ewnvwtcn" etkvkswg" owej" oqtg" enqugn{"cnkipgf" ykvj" Itggp/"
dgti)u"cpf"Ocefqpcnf)u" qh"vjg"ncvg"3;52u" vjcp" Cfqtpq)u0" Yjcv" vjku"
K"
ogcpu."rtqrqug." ku"v jcv"vjgkt"dtcpf" qh"oqfgtpkuo" ycu" o qtg"$etkvk/"
ecn$"vjcp" $cnkgpcvgf.$" pqv"uq"owej" ykvjftcyp" cpf"ugnh/ucetkhkekpi" cu"
uqekcnn{"eqookvvgf" cpf" gpicigf0" Hkijvkpi" hqt"vjg" rtgugtxcvkqp" qh"uki/"
pkhkecpv" fkuvkpevkqpu" ykvjkp" cpf"dgvyggp" ctvkuvke"yqtmu" eqwnf" dg"eqp/"
uvtwgf."cu"Itggpdgti" uwiiguvgf." cu"c"jgtqke" cev."c"mkpf" qh"umgrvkecn"
Vjku"hkijv"
rcvtkqvkuo0" tgswktgf"cp"gnkvg"etkvkecn"
rgturgevkxg"ykvjkp"vjg"
ewnvwtcn"ockpuvtgco"tcvjgt" vjcp"cp"cuegvke" Vjku"
qt"ugnh/fgpkcn0"
tgvtgcv"
rqkpv"tgecnnu"
Mgtocp)u" hqtowncvkqp"qh"Dcddkvv)u" vq"vjcv"$dcu/"
$tgvtgcv$"
vkqp"qh"vjg"okffng"encuu.$"vjg"wpkxgtukv{0"
Dcddkvv)u"
wpkxgtukv{/wpfgt/"
uvqqf"kp"vgtou"qh"rquvyct" rqnkvkeu/ycu"enqug"vq"vjg"htqpv"
ewnvwtcn" nkpgu"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"3:3"

fgdcvg<"
qh"ewnvwtcn" kp"Dcddkvv)u"
qyp"vgto." kp"vjg"ewnvwtg"
c"$hqtvtguu$"
cecfgoke"
hqt"
yctu." pqv"c"$itggpjqwug.$"
eqorqugtu." cu"Mgtocp"
kv"kp"jku"eqoogpvu"
fguetkdgu" pgy"owuke087"
qp"wpkxgtukv{/dcugf"
Cu"vjg" jkuvqtkcp."Rgvgt" jcu"ujqyp."
Icnnkuqp." uwej"c"xkgy"qh"
ycu"rqygthwnn{"
ewnvwtg" hqtgujcfqygf" D
d{" cddkvv)u"
ugnh/cempqyngfigf"
grkuvgoqnqikecn" vjg"
kphnwgpegu." Xkgppc"Ekteng" vjgougnxgu0"
rqukvkxkuvu"
Cu"Icnnkuqp" rtqrqugu."

vjg"vyq"oqxgogpvu" ]vjg" cpf"vjg"


rqukvkxkuvu" Dcwjcwu" hcegf"
ctvkuvu_" vjg"
ucog"
gpgokgu//vjg" tgnkikqwu" pcvkqpcnkuv."
tkijv." xfnmkuej."Pc|k"
cpvjtqrquqrjkuv." cpf"
qrrqpgpvu//cpf" vjku"ftqxg"vjgo" gxgp"enqugt"
vqigvjgt." vjg"
vqyctf" nkhg"
eqplqkpv"
vjg{"jcf" kp"o kpf0"Dqvj" uqwijv"
gpvgtrtkugu" vq"kpuvcpvkcvg"
c"oqfgtpkuo" gorjc/"
yjcv"
uk|kpi" K"yknn"
ecnn"$vtcpurctgpv" c"ocpkhguv"
eqpuvtwevkqp.$" wr"htqo"
dwknfkpi"
ukorng"gngogpvu" vq"cnn"jkijgt"hqtou"
vjcv"yqwnf." xktvwg"
d{" qh"vjg"
u{uvgocvke"
eqpuvtwevkqpcn"rtqitco" kvugnh." vjg"
iwctcpvgg" qh"
gzenwukqp" vjg"fgeqtcvkxg."
o{uvk/"
ecn."qt"ogvcrj{ukecn0"Vjgtg" ycu"c"rqnkvkecn"
fkogpukqp"vq"vjku"hqto"
qh"eqpuvtwe/"
vkqp<"d{"dcukpi"kv"qp"ukorng."ceeguukdng"
wpkvu."
vjg{"jqrgf" vq"dcpkuj"
kpeqtrqtcvkqp"qh"pcvkqpcnkuv"qt"jkuvqtkecn"
hgcvwtgu088"

Yg"jcxg"cntgcf{" uggp" jqy"Dcddkvv)u" qyp"$u{uvgocvke" eqpuvtwevkqpcn"


rtqitco$" fgcnv"ykvj"jkuvqt{" cpf"g zenwfgf" ogvcrj{ukeu." cpf"yg"jcxg"
qdugtxgf"vjg"cpvk/xqnmkuej" ewttgpv"kp"jku"vjqwijv0" Ycu"Dcddkvv" *qt"
Itggpdgti+" cyctg"
gzrnkekvn{" vjcv"$vjg" Xkgppc" Ekteng"cpf" Fguucw)u"
Dcwjcwu" xkukqp"qh"vtcpurctgpv" eqpuvtwevkqp" ycu"cpcvjgoc" vq"vjg"Pc|k"
oqxgogpv=" kv"
e wv"
]vjcv_" cp{" vtcpuegpfgpv" pcvkqpcn"rwtrqug" htqo" vjg"
htqo"
uvcvg." ctejkvgevwtg." cpf"htqo"pcvwtg$A89" Ycu"jg"eqipk|cpv" qh"vjg"
dgvyggp"
rctcnngnu" jku"qyp" cpf"
rqnkvkeu" v jqug"qh"
j ku" cpvgegf/"
rqukvkxkuv"
gpvuA"Uqogfc{." vjku"uvqt{."vqq."yknn"jcxg"vq"dg"vqnf0"
Fwtkpi" vjg"gctn{"3;72u."kp"vjg"eqpvgzv" qh"Eqnf"Yct." cpvk/Uqxkgv"
ugpvkogpv." c"etkvkswg"qh"ocuu"ewnvwtg"cnqpi" Itggpdgtikcp" nkpgu"
gejqgf"
nqwfn{"kp"vjg" Cogtkecp" fkuewuukqp"qh"ewnvwtg0"Jqygxgt." vjg"rctvkek/"
rcpvu"kp"vjku"fkuewuukqp" lwuv"
itcrrngf" cu"eqpurkewqwun{" ykvj" vjg"swgu/"
vkqp"qh"ewnvwtcn"
rnwtcnkuo." gorjcuk|kpi" vjg"korqtvcpeg" qh"gpeqwtcikpi"
kp"c"htgg"
fkxgtukv{" uqekgv{0"Vjg"rjgpqogpqp" qh"ewnvwtcn"rnwtcnkuo"
nkmg"
kvugnh." Itggpdgti)u" cxcpv/ictfg" ctv."ycu"vq"ugtxg"cu"
cp" cpvkfqvg"vq"
vjg"kpukfkqwu."jqoqigpk|kpi." cpf"vqvcnk|kpi" gpetqcejogpvu" qh"o cuu"
ewnvwtg"*yjkej" ycu"uggp"cu"cp"kpuvtwogpv" qh"uvcvg"
qrrtguukqp" kp"vjg"
ecug"qh"vjg"Uqxkgv" Wpkqp+0"Eqpxgtugn{." uchgiwctfkpi"vjg" eqpfkvkqpu"
qh"cwvqpqoqwu." ctvkuvke"
gzrtguukqp."cpuygtcdng"vq"pq"cwvjqtkv{"qwvukfg"
eqwnf"dg"rtqrqugf"
qh"kvugnh." cu"qpg"qh"vjg"hwpfcogpvcn" qh"
rtkpekrngu"
ewnvwtcn" Chvgt"
rnwtcnkuo08:" vjg"yct."cxcpv/ictfg"ctv"eqpvkpwgf" vq"
qeewr{" hwpevkqp<"
c"rtkxkngigf" vq"qrrqug"ocuu"ewnvwtg0"Kp"vjku"eqpvgzv."
ugtkqwu."cxcpv/ictfg" Cogtkec0$"
ctv"eqwnf"dg"uggp"cu"$chhktokpi" Kp"vjg"
kphnwgpvkcn"dqqm."Vjg"X kvcn"
Egpvgt."Ctvjwt" Uejngukpigt"rtqrqugf"vjcv"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
3:4" Vjg"
Owukecn"
Swctvgtn{"

oqfgtpkuv"ocuvgtu"uwej"cu"Uvtcxkpum{" qt"Rkecuuq"
$tghngev"
cpf"kpekvg"
cpzkgvkgu"
yjkej"ctg"kpeqorcvkdng" ykvj"
vjg"oqpqnkvjke"ejctcevgt" qh"vjg"
)Uqxkgv" $8;"
rgtuqp0)" Oqtgqxgt." cu"Uejngukpigt"uvcvgf"
hqtvjtkijvn{"kp"vjg"
Rctvkucp"
Tgxkgy)u"3;74" hqtwo" qp"Cogtkecp" $vjg"
ewnvwtg." qpn{" cpuygt"
vq"ocuu" qh"eqwtug."
ewnvwtg." nkgu"kp"vjg"chhktocvkqp"
qh"Cogtkec." pqv"cu"c"
wpkhqto" dwv"
uqekgv{." cu"c"xctkqwu" cpf" uqekgv{." qh"ocp{"
rnwtcnkuvke" ocfg"
ykvj"
itqwru" kpvgtguvu0"
fkxgtug" Vjg"koogfkcvg" rtqdngo"ku"vq"eqpugtxg"
ewnvwtcn"
rnwtcnkuo"kp"hceg"qh"
v jg" v qh"
jtgcv" vjg"o cuu"
ogfkc0$92" Cpftgy"
Tquu"jcu"uwiiguvgf"
vjcv"Uejngukpigt)u"$cigpfc" ycu"engctn{"vq"fkuvkpiwkuj"
Cogtkecp" uqekcn"
gzrgtkgpeg"htqo" yjcv"ycu" nworgf"vqigvjgt" cu"hcuekuv"
cpf"Uqxkgv" $"
)vqvcnkvctkcpkuo0)"Ceeqtfkpi" vq"Tquu."
vjg"rnwtcnkuvke"
oqfgn"
vjcv" ycu"
gogtigf" rtqoqvgf" d{" kpvgnngevwcnu"yjqug"

tqng"]ycu_" egpvtcn"
vjgtghqtg" vq"vjg"rtqeguu"
qh"ngikvkocvkqp/vq" cickp"pqv"
ugtxg."
cu"vjg"
eqpuekqwun{."
cnyc{u" dgctgtu" qh"c"ncpiwcig"
cpf"ujcrgtu" vjcv" ocmgu" uqog"
hqtou"
qh"fkuewtukxg" cxckncdng"
gzrgtkgpeg" yjkng"
kv"kipqtgu." qt"uwrrtguugu"
gzenwfgu."
C"egtvckp"
qvjgtu0" ku"rtgugpvgf"
xqecdwnct{" cu"rgtokuukdng."
pqv"cnn"qh"kv"jgigoqpke"
*uqog"
eqwpvgtjgigoqpke" ctg"eqpvckpgf"
kfgcu" ykvjkp"kv+."cpf"pqv"kp"cp{"yc{"
dwv"
wpkhkgf." yjkej"
pqpgvjgnguu"
octmu"vjg"
vgorqtctkn{"ngikvkocvg"dqwpfctkgu"qh"
eqpuekqwupguu0"
93"

Tquu)u"fguetkrvkqp" qh"kpvgnngevwcnu"ujcrkpi"cpf"dgctkpi" c"ncpiwcig" vjcv"


cv"qpeg"rgtokvu" fkxgtukv{" cpf"n kokvu"
vjg"dqwpfctkgu" qh"rgtokuukdng"
vjqwijv" uvtqpin{"tgecnnu"qwt" fkuewuukqp"
rtgxkqwu" qh"Dcddkvv)u"codkxcngpv"
cfxqece{" qh"uekgpvkhke"ncpiwcig0" xkukqp"
Uejngukpigt)u" qh"ewnvwtcn"fkxgt/"
nkmg"
ukv{." Dcddkvv)u." kornkgu" eqphnkev0"
Dqvj" kornkekvn{"fkuvkpiwkuj"jgcnvj{"
fkxgtukv{"htqo" cpqvjgt" mkpf" qh"ewnvwtcn"
rtqnkhgtcvkqp."yjkej" ku"
wpjgcnvj{" cpf"pggfu" vq"dg"eqpvckpgf0"Vjg"rtqnkhgtcvkqp" qh"vjg"hqtogt"
mkpf"qh"fkxgtukv{" ku"pggfgf" vq"eqwpvgtdcncpeg"
cpf"eqpvckp" vjg"ncvvgt0"
Kp"tgegpv" ytkvkpi." kp"y jkej" jcu"
Dcddkvv" d ggp"gurgekcnn{" ecpfkf"
cdqwv" vjg"rtqdngou" qh"eqpvgzvwcnkuo"kp"owuke"cpf"fkxgtukv{" kp"owukecn"
ewnvwtg."jg" eqogu" enqug" vq" cempqyngfikpi" vjg"
eqpvtcfkevkqp" dgvyggp"
ukownvcpgqwun{" rtqoqvkpi" cpf"eqpvckpkpi" Kp"vjg"ucog"
fkxgtukv{0" rwd/"
nkujgf"ngevwtg"kp"yjkej" vjg"$okijvkguv"qh"hqtvtguugu$"
kocig" qh"vjg"wpk/"
xgtukv{"qeewtu."lwuv" cu"jg"kpvtqfwegu"vjg"vjgog" qh"ewnvwtcn" fkxgtukv{."
Dcddkvv" kpvtqfwegu" cp"cpzkqwu" yjkng"
swcnkhkecvkqp" tgchhktokpi" eqorquk/"
vkqp"cu"cp"kpvtcowtcn" wpkxgtukv{" $Vjg"hktuv"
cevkxkv{<" vjkpi" K"jcxg"vq"fq"
ku"fkucdwug"{qw" vjcv" K)o"vcnmkpi" c"rctvkewnct"
cdqwv" mkpf" qh"owuke" cpf"c"
rctvkewnct"mkpf" qh"wpkxgtukv{0" Vjcv"y qwnf"qhvgp"
dg"kphgttgf." rctvkewnctn{"
og."dwv"K"ogcp"pqvjkpi"qh"vjg"uqtv0"0"0" 0"Owuke"jcu"pgxgt"dggp"
htqo"
uq"rnwtcnkuvke0$94"
Kp"cp{"gxgpv."Tquu)u"fguetkrvkqp"
qh"vjg"rtqeguu"qh"ngikvkok|kpi"
uqog"hqtou"
qh"$fkuewtukxg"gzrgtkgpeg$"yjkng"gzenwfkpi"qvjgtu."eqo/"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"3:5"

dkpgf"ykvj"Itggpdgti)u" cpf"Ocefqpcnf)u" ewnvwtcn"


pqtou"
cpf"ecvgiq/"
tkgu." c"
rtqxkfgu"rtqxqecvkxg" cpuygt"
*kh"rctvkcn+" vq"vjg" tckugf"
swguvkqpu"
gctnkgt<"
Yj{" ujqwnf" Dcddkvv"
uq"enqugn{"nkpm"
eqpegrv" kp"owuke"
hqtocvkqp"
vq"$uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig$A" Yj{" ujqwnf" xgtdcn"
cpf"ogvjqfqnqikecn"
dg"vjg"vqwejuvqpg"
tgurqpukdknkv{$" qh"owukecn" Cpf"yj{"
ekvk|gpujkrA"
ujqwnf"vjg"cfxqece{" qh"ewnvwtcn" dg"uq"
fkxgtukv{" kpvkocvgn{"nkpmgf"
vq"
eqpegtp"cdqwv" kvu"eqpvckpogpvA"

Vjg"$wodknkecn"
eqtf"qh"iqnf$"
Kp"eqpukfgtkpi" gvjpqitcrjkgu" qh"nkvgtcvwtg"
cpf"ctv" kp"Vjg" Rtgfkecogpv"
Ewnvwtg."
qh" Lcogu" Enkhhqtf" jcu"uwiiguvgf" c"dgikppkpi" cpf"gpf"rqkpv" qh"
vjku"uvwf{0"Yjcv" jg" uc{u"cdqwv" owugwo" eqnngevkqpu" qh" ctv"qdlgevu"
crrnkgu."kp"nctig"rctv." vq"qwt" crrtqcejgu" vq"owuke" fkueqwtug<" $K"rtqrqug"
vjcv"cp{" eqnngevkqp" c" xkukqp"
kornkgu"vgorqtcn" igpgtcvkpi" tctkv{"cpf"
yqtvj." c"ogvcjkuvqt{0" Vjku"jkuvqt{" fghkpgu"yjkej" itqwru" qt"vjkpiu" yknn"
dg"tgfggogf" htqo" c"fkukpvgitcvkpi" jwocp" rcuv"cpf" y jkej"yknn" dg"
fghkpgf"cu"vjg"f{pcoke." qt"vtcike." cigpvu" qh"c"eqooqp" fguvkp{0" O{"
cpcn{uku"yqtmu" vq"
dtkpi" qwv" v jg"
n qecn."
rqnkvkecn" eqpvkpigpe{" qh"u wej"
jkuvqtkgu"cpf"qh"vjg"oqfgo" eqnngevkqpu" vjg{" lwuvkh{0"Urceg"ku"engctgf."
rgtjcru." hqt"cnvgtpcvkxgu0$$" Etkvkecn." qt"
cpcn{vkecn." jgqtgvkecn"
v ytkvkpi"
cdqwv" owuke" ku"kvugnh"
c"hqto" qh"eqnngevkpi." tgfggokpi" vjg"ctvkhcevu" $eqn/"
ngevgf$"*fkuewuugf+" $htqo" c"fkukpvgitcvkpi" jwocp" cpf"
rcuv.$" fghkpkpi"
vjg"rgtukuvgpv" ngikvkoce{" cpf"korqtvcpeg" qh"uqog" mkpfu" qh"owuke" tcvjgt"
vjcp" qvjgtu0"Nkmg" Enkhhqtf." K"vqq"jcxg"dggp"eqpegtpgf" ykvj" vjg" rqnkvk/"
ecn"eqpvkpigpekgu" qh"c"jkuvqt{." dwv" qpg"vjcv" lwuvkhkgu"c"rctvkewnct" mkpf"
qh"owuke" fkueqwtug=" vjku"
fkueqwtug." kp"vwtp."ku"qhvgp" wugf" vq"lwuvkh{"rct/"
owukecn"
vkewnct" rtcevkegu0"
Vq"c"nctig" fgitgg." vjg"mkpf" qh"$urceg" engctkpi$" vjcv" Enkhhqtf"
ogpvkqpu" jcu"cntgcf{" qeewttgf" ykvjkp" Cogtkecp" owukecn" ewnvwtg="
kpfggf." cu"yg"jcxg"uggp." Dcddkvv" jkougnh"ku"coqpi" vjqug" yjq" jcxg"
dgiwp" vq"e ngct"vjg"urceg0" Jqygxgt." cu"
K"jcxg" c nuq"uwiiguvgf."jcu"
jg"
gtgevgf"jku"cpvkrqrwnkuv" hqtvtguu" kp"vjku"
rgtknqwun{" qrgp"vgttckp0" Kp"rtq/"
rqukpi"c"ewnvwtcn1jkuvqtkecn" eqpvgzv" hqt"
Dcddkvv)u" ogvcvjgqt{." vq"K"ogcp"
uwiiguv"vjcv" vjg"vkog" jcu"eqog" vq"hkpkuj"vjg" lqd"qh"urceg/engctkpi" vjcv"
Dcddkvv"dgicp0"Jqygxgt." kp"fkuocpvnkpi"jku"oqfgtpkuv" yg"
hqtvtguu."
ujqwnf" vq"mggr"vjg"dtkemu."
dg"ectghwn" kh"pqv"vjg"oqtvct."
cu"yg"eqpvkpwg"
*cpf"vqrrng+"qwt"qyp"ewnvwtcn"
vq"tgdwknf" eqpuvtwevkqpu0"
Kp"nkijv" K"jcxg"vqnf"cdqwv"Dcddkvv"
qh"vjku"encko."vjg"uvqt{" jcu"
kornkecvkqpu"
urgekhke" hqt" vjg"fkuewuukqp"
qh"
q q
wt" yp"ewttgpv"ukvwcvkqp0"
Kh"
yg"ceegrv"vjg"rtgokug" vjcv"cp"kpukuvgpeg"
qp"uekgpvkhke"
ncpiwcig" *tcvjgt"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
3:6" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

vjcp" nguu"
c"nqqugt." ku"nkpmgf"
cvvkvwfg+"
gzenwukqpct{" vq"vjg"
jkuvqtkecn"
qh" dgvyggp"
rtqlgev" fkuvkpiwkujkpi" jkij" cpf" o cuu"
ewnvwtg." ctg"yg"
jqy"
kh"yg"pq"nqpigt"
vq"rtqeggf" vq"vjku"
uwduetkdg" fwcnkuoA"Gxgp"cu"gctn{"
cu"
3;5;."Itggpdgti" vjg" qh"
tgeqipk|gf" htciknkv{" v ektewouvcpegu"
jg" pgegu/"
vq"uwrrqtv"
uct{" jku"eqpegrvkqp"
qh"cxcpv/ictfg"ewnvwtg<"

Vjg"cxcpv/ictfg)u" qh"kvugnh."
urgekcnk|cvkqp" vjg"hcev"
vjcv"
kvu"
dguv"
ctvkuvu"
ctg"ctvkuvu)"
kvu"dguv"rqgvu"rqgvu)"rqgvu."
ctvkuvu." c"itgcv"
jcu"guvtcpigf" qh"vjqug"
ocp{" yjq"ygtg"
ecrcdng"hqtogtn{"qh"gplq{kpi"
cpf"crrtgekcvkpi"codkvkqwu" ctv" dwv"
cpf"nkvgtcvwtg."
yjq" ctg"pqy"wpyknnkpi"qt"wpcdng"vq"ceswktg"cp"kpkvkcvkqp"
kpvq" vjgkt"etchv"
Vjg"ocuugu"
ugetgvu0" jcxg"cnyc{u"tgockpgf" qt"nguu"
oqtg" kpfkhhgtgpv"vq"ewnvwtg"
kp"
vjg" qh" Dwv"
rtqeguu"fgxgnqrogpv0" vqfc{" uwej" ku"
ewnvwtg" dgkpi" cdcpfqpgf" d{"
vjqug"vq"yjqo" kv"cevwcnn{"
dgnqpiu/qwt" encuu0"
twnkpi" Hqt"kv"ku"vq"vjg"ncvvgt"
vjcv"
vjg"cxcpv/ictfg" Pq"
dgnqpiu0" ewnvwtg"ecp" ykvjqwv"
fgxgnqr" c"uqekcn"dcuku."ykvjqwv"
qh"uvcdng"
c"uqwteg" kpeqog0"Cpf"kp"vjg" ecug"qh"vjg"
cxcpv/ictfg." vjku"
ycu" rtq/"
xkfgf"d{"cp"gnkvg"
coqpi" vjg"twnkpi"encuu"
qh"vjcv"
uqekgv{"htqo" yjkej" kv"cuuwogf"
kvugnh"
vq"dg"ewv" dwv"
qhh." vq"yjkej"kv"jcu"cnyc{u"tgockpgf" cvvcejgf" d{" cp"wodknk/"
ecn"eqtf"
qh"iqnf0"
Vjg"rctcfqz" ku"tgcn0"
Cpf"pqy" vjku"
gnkvg"ku"tcrkfn{"ujtkpmkpi0"
Ukpeg"vjg"cxcpv/ictfg"hqtou"vjg"qpn{"nkxkpi"ewnvwtg"
yg"pqy" jcxg." vjg"uwtxkxcn"
kp"vjg"pgct"
hwvwtg" kp"igpgtcn"
qh"ewnvwtg" ku"vjwu"
vjtgcvgpgf096"

K"jcxg"swqvgf" vjg"gpvktgv{"qh"vjku"rctcitcrj" htqo"$Cxcpv/ictfg" cpf"


Mkvuej$" kv"
dgecwug" ku"uq"tkejn{" uwiiguvkxg" hqt"qwt"ewttgpv" fkuewuukqp0"
Vjg"ugeqpf" ugpvgpeg" gxqmgu"vjg"hcoqwu" rwdnkujgf" vkvng"
qh"Dcddkvv)u"
$Yjq"
guuc{." E ctgu"Kh"
[ qw"
NkuvgpA.$" yjkng" vjg"hktuv"
tgecnnu"vjg"qtkikpcn"
vkvng" vjg"ctvkeng."
hqt" $Vjg"Eqorqugt" cu"Urgekcnkuv0$"Vjg"swguvkqp" qh"
uwtxkxcn"
tckugf" kp"vjg"eqpenwukqp"qh"Itggpdgti)u" rctcitcrj" ku"
g ejqgf" kp"
vjg"$okijvkguv" qh"hqtvtguugu$"
rcuucig" htqo" vjg"ncuv"
ejcrvgt" qh"Yqtfu"
Cdqwv" ekvgf"
Owuke." cdqxg09$" qh"
Cpf." eqwtug." Dcddkvv"jkpvu"cv"jku"qyp"
xgtukqp"qh"vjg"$wodknkecn"eqtf" qh"iqnf$" kp"vjcv"rcuucig<"vjg"wpkxgtukv{"
ku"tgurqpukdng"
hqt"vjg"$eqtrqtcn"uwtxkxcn$" qh"eqorqugtu" cu"ygnn" cu"vjg"
fkuugokpcvkqp" cpf"rtqvgevkqp"qh"vjgkt"yqtm0" Vq"rctcrjtcug" Dcddkvv."yg"
pggf"qpn{"tgrnceg" Itggpdgti)u" $gnkvg"
rjtcug." coqpi" twnkpi"vjg" encuu.$"
ykvj"vjg"ukping" yqtf."$wpkxgtukv{.$"vjg" dgpkip" rcvtqpcig" qh"yjkej"
*vgpwtg."cecfgoke" htggfqo+"ku"ogcpv" vq"rtqvgev" vjg"eqorqugt)u" cwvqp/"
qo{0" Ykvjkp" vjg"gpenqugf" urceg"qh"vjg"cecfgoke" $hqtvtguu.$"vjg"eqo/"
rqugt"rtguwocdn{" pggfu" pq"wodknkecn" eqtf." dwv"oc{" rctvkekrcvg"
wpvgvjgtgf" kp"u{odkqvke."pqwtkujkpi" gzejcpigu" qh"iqnf"cpf"cecfgoke"
fkueqwtug0"
Yjgvjgt" qt"pqv"cp{" rctv"qh"vjku"xkgy" qh"jkij"ctv"
eqpvkpwgu" vq"
uggo"xkcdng"qt"fguktcdng."
kv"gzkuvu"
kp"tgncvkqp"
vq"c"eqpegrvkqp"qh"
$mkvuej$"
vjcv"oc{"pqy"uggo"gpvktgn{" vqq"oqpqnkvjke0"Vjwu."vjg"jkij1"
ocuu"ewnvwtg" ku"nkmgn{"
fkuvkpevkqp" vq"uggo"gpvktgn{"vqq"ugxgtg0"
Yg"ctg"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"3:7"

oqtg"
hct" nkmgn{"vq"tghgt"vq"vjg" rtgectkqwu" octikpcnkv{" qh"vjg" jkij" oqf/"
gtpkuv"ykpi" kp"Cogtkecp" pgy" owuke." tcvjgt" vjcp" vjg"jgtqke" eqpvckp/"
ogpv" qh"kvu"cpvkvjguku"/gurgekcnn{" cu"vjg"dtkgh" rctc/ctkuvqetcvke" tgkip" qh"
vjg"wpkxgtukv{" eqorqugt" ikxgu"yc{" vq"vjg"pgy" cttcpigogpvu" qh"c"owuke"
cecfgoke" fkuekrnkpct{" rgtguvtqkmc0"
Vjku"rqkpv" dtkpiu" wu"dcem" vq"ogvjqfqnqi{0" Qxgt" hqtv{"{gctu"chvgt"
Dcddkvv)u" korqtvcpv" qp"
guuc{u" ogvcvjgqt{" vq"
dgicp" crrgct." vjg"fkuewu/"
ukqp"qh"oqfgnu" qh"fkxgtukv{."itqwr" eqpuvkvwvkqp" kp"owukecn" ewnvwtg."cpf"
vjg"ewnvwtcn" jkuvqt{"qh"owukecn" rtczgu"oc{" rnc{" cu"nkdgtcvkpi" cpf"enctk/"
h{kpi"c"tqng" cu" jcxg"j ku"
v jgqtgvkecn"kppqxcvkqpu0" Oqtgqxgt." vyq"
vjg"
mkpfu" qh"kpxguvkicvkqp" ctg"pqv"fkueqpvkpwqwu<" pqvkqpu" cdqwv" ewnvwtg."
vjg"kpuvkvwvkqpu" cpf"rtcevkegu" vjcv"uwrrqtv" vjgo." cpf" v jg"ogvcrjqtu"
kpxqmgf" vq"ectt{" vjgo." rnc{"c"etwekcn" tqng"kp"ujcrkpi" qwt" vgejpkecn"
ncpiwcigu" cpf"ctvkuvke" rgtegrvkqpu0" Vjg"hgokpkuv" etkvke"Vgtguc" fg"Ncwtg/"
vku"
rtqrqugu" c"oqtg" igpgtcnk|gf" cpf"uweekpev" uvcvgogpv" qh"rtkpekrng<"
$Rtcevkegu//gxgpvu" cpf" d gjcxkqtu"qeewttkpi" kp" u qekcn"
hqtocvkqpu/"
ygkij" kp"vjg"eqpuvkvwvkqp" qh"uwdlgevkxkv{"cu"owej" cu"fqgu"ncpiwcig0$98"
Htqo" vjku" qh"
rqkpv" xkgy." vjg"fkuewuukqp"qh" cpf" gzrgtkogpvcvkqp" ykvj"
fkhhgtgpv" ewnvwtcn"ecvgiqtkgu." crrtqcejgu" vq"owukecn" fkueqwtug." kpuvkvw/"
vkqpcn" cpf"
chhknkcvkqpu." eqoowpcn" rtcevkegu" oc{" dg"eqpukfgtgf" rctv"qh"
vjg"etgcvkxg" owukecn" rtqeguu" cu"owej" cu"vjgqtk|kpi" *kp"vjg"ugpug" qh"
Dcddkvv+0" Vq"vjg" g zvgpv" vjcv"uwej" fkuewuukqp" cpf" gzrgtkogpvcvkqp"
dqttqyu" htqo" eqpvgorqtct{" gvjpqitcrj{" cpf"ewnvwtcn" jkuvqt{."vjg{"
oc{" eqpuvkvwvg" c"tgncvkxkuvke"rqukvkqp" oqtg" tcfkecn" vjcp" Dcddkvv)u"dwv"
cdng"vq"ceeqooqfcvg"
uvknn" jku"ogvjqfqnqikecn" cfxcpegu0" Cv"vjg"ucog"
vkog." vjg{" oc{" jgnr"wu" h kpf"
cnvgtpcvkxgu"vq" v jg" uvctm"qrrqukvkqp" qh"
$pgicvkxg" fkcngevkeu$" cpf"$rqukvkxg$" hqtocnkuo" vjcv" uq"qhvgp" fkxkfgu"
etkvkecn"vjgqt{" htqo"owuke" vjgqt{0"
Kv"ycu"Dcddkvv)u" cntgcf{" tcfkecn"oqxg" vq"ujqy" wu"jqy"owej" ncp/"
iwcig" eqwnf" kphqto" vjg" $ eqpuvkvwvkqp"qh" hqt"vjg"
uwdlgevkxkv{$" rctcfki/"
ocvkecnn{" pqpxgtdcn." pqptgrtgugpvcvkqpcn" ctv." owuke0" Kp"urkppkpi" vjg"
vgtou" cickp." vjg"
gorjcuk|kpi"eqorngz." jkuvqtkecn" godgffgfpguu" qh"
uwdlgevkxkv{" cpf"qwt" eqpegrvkqpu" qh"kpvgtuwdlgevkxkv{." kv"ku"vgorvkpi"vq"
vcorgt" ykvj" qpg"qh"Dcddkvv)u" qyp" gxqecvkxg" vkvngu<"$Eqpvgorqtct{"
Owuke" Eqorqukvkqp" cpf"Owuke" Vjgqt{" cu"Eqpvgorqtct{" Kpvgnngevwcn"
Jkuvqt{0$" Yg"oc{" ukorn{" ycpv" vq"tgxgtug"vjg"vgtou" qh"vjku"hqtownc/"
vkqp."vq"ugg"jkuvqtkecn" cpf"gvjpqitcrjke" pcttcvkxgu" cdqwv" owuke" cu"
*coqpi" qvjgt" ghhqtvu"
vjkpiu+" pgy"eqpegrvwcnk|cvkqpu"
vq"uvkowncvg" cpf"
qh"vjgqt{"
rtcevkegu" cpf"eqorqukvkqp0"
Jqygxgt."vq"vjg"gzvgpv"vjcv"vjku"
vjg"mkpfu"
tgrncegu"
rtqlgev" qh"kpvgtcevkqpu"
dgvyggp" cpf"eqorquk/"
vjgqt{"
vkqp"fguetkdgf" vjg"ukornkhkecvkqp"
d{"Dcddkvv." yknn"dg"wpucvkuhcevqt{0"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
3:8" Vjg"
Owukecn"
Swctvgtn{"

Vjgqt{."jkuvqt{."
eqorqukvkqp."cpf"etkvkekuo" cu"K"jcxg"uwiiguvgf."
yknn."
eqpvkpwcnn{" c"fkcnqiwg"
ockpvckp" kp"dtqcfgpkpi" ewnvwtcn"
eqpvgzvu0"
Cu"
vjg"ctv" V0"L0"Enctm"
jkuvqtkcp" kv"kp"c"fkuewuukqp"
hqtowncvgf" qh"Lcemuqp"
Rqnnqem<"
Jqy"fq"yg"ocr" vjg"eqpvgzv" qh"gzrnqkvcvkqp."
okuwug."
tgtgcfkpi." kp"
okutgcfkpi"
vjg" qpvq"
ewnvwtg" cpf"kpvq"
c"egtvckp" c"egtvckp"
rtcevkeg." ugv"qh"
kpvgpvkqpu/"
kpvgpvkqpu"
tgcnk|gfA"Ctgp)v"yg"cnn"uvknn" ykvj"
uvtwiinkpi" vjcvA"
$Uvtwiinkpi$" ku"
tgcnn{" vjg"yqtf0"Yg" uvknn"
fqp)v"jcxg"gxgp"vjg"
dgikppkpiu"qh"
cp"cfgswcvg"ugv"qh"vgtou/ugv" qh"eqqtfkpcvgu//ykvj"yjkej" vq"fq"vjg"
ocrrkpi0"000"
Kpvgtpcn"
xgtuwu"
gzvgtpcn"ku"nkmg" xgtuwu"
$qtkikpcnkv{$" $qpn{" qt."eqog"
chvgtyctf.$" vq"
$vgzv$"
vjcv." xgtuwu"
$eqpvgzv0$" Pqv"vjcv" qwt"
yqtm" yknn"
gxgt"ocikecnn{"
guecrg"htqo"
vjgug"
ogvcrjqtkecn" fkxkukqpu."dwv" vjg"
oqtg"rtguuwtg"vjg{)tg" wpfgt."
rwv" kp"vjg"cevwcn"
qh"jkuvqtkecn"
rtqeguu" kpswkt{."vjg" cnn"qh"wu099"
hqt"
dgvvgt"

Dcddkvv)u"
tgxqnwvkqpct{"
ogvcvjgqt{" wu"jqy"
vcwijv" owuke"fkueqwtug"
okijv." ocike/vt{"
tcvkqpcnn{//ykvjqwv" vq"hkpf"
c"yc{"qwv"qh"vjg"ogvc/"
rjqtkecn" Enctm"
fkxkukqpu" Kp" vjgkt"
rqugu0" tgcuugtvkpi" rqygt" cpf"uvtwi/"
*cpf"hcknkpi+"
inkpi" vq"
cickp" v tcpuegpf" yg"
vjgo." oc{" eqog"vq"hggn"
vjg"
qh"rtguuwtg"
etquuewttgpvu" gocpcvkpi"htqo"
dqvj" Enctm)u" qh"jku/"
$rtqeguu"
vqtkecn" cpf"
kpswkt{$" Dcddkvv)u"
$uekgpvkhke"
ogvjqf" cpf"uekgpvkhke"
ncp/"
iwcig0$"

Pqvgu"
C"pwodgt" qh"rgqrng"jcxg"eqoogpvgf" xgt{" qp"ftchvu"
jgnrhwnn{" qh"vjku"
rcrgt0"Vjcpmu"
vq"
gurgekcnn{" Uwucp"D ncwuvgkp."
Uvgrjgp" Fgodumk." Octkqp"Iwem."E ctqnkpg"
Lqpgu."Htgf"
Ocwu."Tqdgtv" Mcvjctkpg"
Oqttku." Rctm." Uvcfgnocp."
Lghh" cpf"Lwfkvj"Vkem0"Vjcpmu"cnuq"
vq"Octkqp"Iwem"cpf"Htgf" Ocwu"cpf"vq"o{"kpvgtxkgy" eqnncdqtcvqtu"Uwucp"Dncwuvgkp"
cpf"Fgppku"Oknngt"hqt"
rgtokuukqp"vq"swqvg"rtgxkqwun{"
wprwdnkujgf" kpvgtxkgy"
ocvgtkcnu0"
Cpf"vjcpmu" vq"Oknvqp"Dcddkvv"
gurgekcnn{" jku"itcekqwu"
hqt" kp"vjg"kpvgt/"
rctvkekrcvkqp"
ekvgf"jgtg"cpf"jku"eqqrgtcvkqp"
xkgyu" kp"gfkvkpi"
vjgo0"
30" Swqvgf" kp"Tkejctf"C0"Tgwuu."
Cogtkecp" Hqnmnqtg"
cpf"Nghv/Ykpi"Rqnkvkeu<"
3;49/3;79"
Kpfkcpc"
*Rj0F0"fkuu0." 3;93+."
Wpkxgtukv{" 8;0"
40" $Vjgqt{" qh"Ocuu"Ewnvwtg.$"
Fkqigpgu"5"*Uwoogt" kp"Dgtpctf"
3;75+<"3/39="tgrt0"
Tqugpdgti"cpf" Fcxkf"Ocppkpi"Yjkvg." gfu0."Ocuu"Ewnvwtg" Knn0<"
*Ingpeqg." Mpqrh."
840"
3;79+."
50" Uwucp"Dncwuvgkp."cpf"Octvkp"Dtqf{." cp"Cogtkecp"
$Kpxgpvkpi" Owukecn" Ewnvwtg<"cp"
ykvj"
Kpvgtxkgy" Oknvqp"Dcddkvv.$"
gzegtrvu" vtcpu0"
kpvq"Htgpej"kp"Eqpvtgvgoru" *Igpgxc."
Uykv|gtncpf."3;:9+0"Vjg"kpvgtxkgy"
ycu"eqpfwevgf"fwtkpi"Lcp0"3:/42."3;:70" Gzegtrvu"
htqo"vjg"
wprwdnkujgf" qh"vjg"kpvgtxkgy"
rqtvkqp" yknn" kp"vjg"
dg"ekvgf" tgockpfgt" qh"vjku"
rcrgt0"
60" Lqjp"Tqemygnn." Cnn"Cogtkecp"
Owuke"*Pgy" [qtm<"Mpqrh."3;:5+."540"
70" Lqugrj"Mgtocp." Owuke"
Eqpvgorncvkpi" *Ecodtkfig<"Jctxctf" Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."
3;:7+."3230"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"3:9"

80" Itgi"
Ucpfqy." eqnwop"
owuke" qh"vjg" Xqkeg"
Xknncig" ;:0"
*Oct0"38."3;:4+<"
90" Dgplcokp"
Dqtgv|."$Oknvqp" kp"Fkevkqpct{"
Dcddkvv.$" Owuke"
Eqpvgorqtct{"
qh" gf0"Lqjp"
Xkpvqp"
*Pgy"[qtm<"G0"
R0"Fwvvqp." 6:0"
3;96+."
580"
:0" Tqemygnn."
;0" Dqtgv|."
6:0"
320" Dcddkvv." cpf"Rtgugpv"
$Rcuv" qh"vjg"
Eqpegrvu" Pcvwtg" qh"Owuke.$"
cpf"Nkokvu" Kpvgt/"
pcvkqpcn"
Owukeqnqikecn" Eqpitguu"
Uqekgv{" [qtm."
*Pgy"
Tgrqtv" 3;83+."5;:/625=" kp"
tgrt0"
Owuke"
qp"Eqpvgorqtct{"
Rgturgevkxgu" gf0"Dgplcokp"
Vjgqt{" Dqtgv|"
cpf"Gfyctf"Eqpg"
*Pgy"[qtm<"Y0"Y0"Pqtvqp" 50"
("Eq0."3;94+."
330" Dcddkvv."
$Rcuv"cpf"Rtgugpv"Eqpegrvu"qh"vjg"
Pcvwtg"
cpf"Nkokvu"
qh"Owuke.$";0"
340" Dcddkvv."
gf0"$Yjq" Ectgu" kp"Eqpvgorqtct{"
Kh"[qw"NkuvgpA.$" Eqorqugtu" qp"Eqp/"
Owuke."
vgorqtct{" Dctpg{" cpf"
Ejknfu" Gnnkqvv"
Uejyctv|"
*Pgy"[qtm<"
Jqnv."Tkpgjctv"cpf"
Ykpuvqp."
3;89+."466="qtkikpcnn{" kp"
rwdnkujgf"Jkij" :" 5:/62."348/"
*Hgd0"3;7:+<"
Hkfgnkv{"
490"
350" Dcddkvv."
$Rcuv"
cpf"Rtgugpv"
Eqpegrvu" Pcvwtg"
qh"vjg" qh"Owuke.$"
cpf"Nkokvu" ;0"
$Rcuv"
360" Dcddkvv." cpf"Rtgugpv" qh"vjg"
Eqpegrvu" cpf"Nkokvu"
Pcvwtg" qh"Owuke.$"370"
$Vygnxg/vqpg"
370" Dcddkvv." Kpxctkcpvu"
cu"Eqorqukvkqpcn" kp"Rtqdngou"
Fgvgtokpcpvu.$"
qh"
Oqfgo"Owuke."gf0" J0"
R0" *Pgy"
Ncpi." [qtm<"Y0"Y0"
Pqtvqp"(" 32:0"
Eq0."3;94+."
380" Dcddkvv)u" $Vygnxg/vqpg"
gzrtguukqp." 32:0"
Kpxctkcpvu.$"
cpf"Hwpevkqp"
$Vjg"Uvtwevwtg"
390" Dcddkvv." qh"Owuke"
Vjgqt{.$" qp"Eqpvgo/"
Rgturgevkxgu"
Owuke"
rqtct{" gf0"Dqtgv|"
Vjgqt{." cpf"Eqpg."35/360"
$Uvtwevwtg"
3:0" Dcddkvv." 340"
cpf"Hwpevkqp.$"
$Uvtwevwtg"
3;0" Dcddkvv." 430"
cpf"Hwpevkqp.$"
Cdqwv"
420" Yqtfu" gf0"Uvgrjgp"
Owuke." Fgodumk" cpf"Lqugrj"Uvtcwu" Wpkxgt/"
*Ocfkuqp<"
qh"Ykueqpukp"
ukv{" 3;:9+."3850"
Rtguu."
430" Hqt" Dcddkvv"
gzcorng." vqnf"vjg"
uvqt{"
tgegpvn{"
fwtkpi"c"ngevwtg"
cv"vjg"
Jctxctf"
Owuke" kv"kp"vjg"kpvgtxkgy"
*Pqx0"6."3;;3+0"Jg"cnuq"pcttcvgf"
Fgrctvogpv" ykvj"
ekvgf"
cpf"Dtqf{"
Dncwuvgkp" cdqxg0"
440" Fgodumk" cpf"Uvtcwu."
Yqtfu"Cdqwv" $Qp"Jcxkpi"
Dcddkvv."
Owuke=" Dggp."cpf"Uvknn"
cp"Cogtkecp"
Dgkpi." Eqorqugt.$"Rgturgevkxgu"Pgy"
qh" Owuke" 49"*Ykpvgt" 3;:;+<"328/"
340"Vyq"kpvgtxkgyu"ykvj"Dcddkvv"
vjcv"K"eqpfwevgf/qpg" *cntgcf{" ykvj"
ekvgf+" Uwucp"
cpf"vjg"
Dncwuvgkp" qvjgt"ykvj"Fgppku"Oknngt"
*Oct0"36."3;:7" cv"vjg" Uejqqn+/"
Lwknnkctf"
owej"
rtqxkfgf" qh"vjg"
uvkowncvkqp"
vq"ytkvg"
vjku"
rcrgt0"Rqtvkqpu" qh"vjg"
ncvvgt"
kpvgtxkgy"
kp"vjg"
crrgctgf" rtqitco"dqqmngv"vq"vjg" Rkcpq"
tgeqtfkpi" Yqtmu" Oknvqp"
qh" Jct/"
Dcddkvv."
oqpkc"Owpfk"Tgeqtfkpiu." cpf"$Oknvqp" Dcddkvv<"
Cp"Crrtgekcvkqp$" *Ngciwg/KUEO"
Rwdnkecvkqpu<"
Dquvqp." 3;:7+0"Cpqvjgt" eqpfwevgf"
kpvgtxkgy." d{"Octkqp" Iwem"cpf"Htgf"
Ocwu"*Cwi0"8."3;::+/yjkej" yknn"
dg"swqvgf"kp"vjg"hqnnqykpi//ku"ewttgpvn{"
dgkpi"
hqt"
rtgrctgf" rwdnkecvkqp0"
450" Kpvgtxkgy"ykvj"Dncwuvgkp"
cpf"Dtqf{0"
460" C"itgcv"
fgcn"jcu"dggp"
ytkvvgp"
cdqwv"
vjg" cpf"ewnvwtg"
rqnkvkeu" qh"vjg"
Pgy"[qtm"
uegpg"
kpvgnngevwcn" htqo" vjg"3;52u"
vq"vjg" Tkejctf"
rtgugpv0" J0"Rgnnu)u"
Tcfkecn"
Xkukqpu"
cpf"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owukecn"
3::" Vjg" Swctvgtn{"

Cogtkecp"
Ftgcou"*Okffngvqyp<"Ygung{cp" Rtguu."
Wpkxgtukv{" 3;95+"cpf"Vjg"Nkdgtcn"
Okpf"
kp"c"Eqpugtxcvkxg"
Cig"*Pgy" [qtm<" cpf"Tqy."3;:7+"cpf"Cncp"Ycnf)u"
Jctrgt" Vjg"
Pgy"[qtm"Kpvgnngevwcnu"
*Ejcrgn"Jknn<"Wpkxgtukv{"
qh"
Pqtvj"
Ectqnkpc" 3;:9+"jcxg"
Rtguu."
dggp" vq"og"kp"uqtvkpi"
jgnrhwn"
gurgekcnn{" vjg"
vjtqwij" vgzvu0"
rtkoct{"
470" R0"Yjggnytkijv"
cpf"
L0"Dwtpjco." [qtm<"
*Pgy"
Cpcn{uku"
Rjknquqrjkecn" Jqnv."3;54+0"
480" Kpvgtxkgy"
ykvj"
Iwem"cpf"Ocwu0"
490" Lqjp"
Fgyg{."
$Swcnkvcvkxg"
Vjqwijv.$" 3"*3;53+<"390"
U{orqukwo"
4:0" Hqt"
gzcorng." ugg"Ocefqpcnf)u" $Pqvgu"
vyq/rctv" qp"Jqnn{yqqf" kp"U{o/"
Fktgevqtu$"
6"*3;55+<"4/50"
rqukwo"
4;0" Ukfpg{"Jqqm." $Yj{" K"co"c"Eqoowpkuv<"Eqoowpkuo" Ykvjqwv"Fqiocu.$"Oqf/"
go"Oqpvjn{":"*3;56+<"45/46="tgrt0"
kp"Ycnf."
60"
520" Lcogu"Dwtpjco." Vjg" Tgxqnwvkqp"
Ocpcigtkcn" [qtm<"
*Pgy" Lqjp" cu"
Fc{."3;63+."
kp"Rgnnu."
fguetkdgf" Tcfkecn" 5740"
Xkukqpu."
530" Vjg"Eqookvvgg" hqt"
Ewnvwtcn" cp"qticpk|cvkqp"
Htggfqo." qh"kpvgnngevwcnu"
vjcv"
*kv"ycu"
tgxgcngf+"
gxgpvwcnn{" hwpfgf"
ycu" EKC."jcu"dggp"
d{"vjg" ytkvvgp"cdqwv" Ugg"
gzvgpukxgn{0"
Rgvgt"
gurgekcnn{." Eqngocp." Vjg"
Nkdgtcn" *Pgy"
Eqpurktce{" [qtm<"
Vjg"Htgg"
Rtguu."
3;:;+0"
ykvj"
540" Kpvgtxkgy" Iwem"cpf"Ocwu0"
550" Kpvgtxkgy"
ykvj" cpf"Ocwu0"
Iwem"
560" Fykijv" Ocefqpcnf." Ogoqktu" c"Tgxqnwvkqpkuv"
qh" *Pgy" [qtm<"Ogtkfkcp" Dqqmu."
3;7:+." 50"
570" Cctqp" Eqrncpf."$C"Pqvg"vq"[qwpi" Eqorqugtu.$"Owuke"
Xcpiwctf" 3"*Oct0/Crt0"
3;57+<"36/380"Kp"vjg"kpvgtxkgy" ykvj"Iwem" cpf"Ocwu."Dcddkvv" vq"dg"tghgttkpi"
ku"nkmgn{"
vq"vjg"hqnnqykpi"eqoogpv" qh"
Eqrncpf)u<" $Vjg"etgcvkxg" nkhg"
ctvkuv)u" jcu"pgxgt"dggp" cp"
gcu{"qpg"kp"cp{" grqej0"*Wpfqwdvgfn{." kp"vjg"
Uqxkgv"Wpkqp"vjg{" qtfgt"vjgug"vjkpiu"
dgvvgt0+$"
580" Lcpg" Eqrrqem." $C"Eqpxgtucvkqp" ykvj"Ctvjwt"Dgtigt.$"
Rgturgevkxgu"qh"Pgy"
Owuke" 39"*3;::+<"6;0"Dgtigt" iqgu"qp"vq"eqoogpv" qp"vjg"
eqorngzkvkgu" qh"vjg"ejcpikpi"
tgncvkqpujkr" dgvyggp"rtqngvctkcpkuo."ocuu" cpf"Gwtqrgcp"
ewnvwtg." oqfgtpkuv" eqorquk/"
vkqp0"K"yknn"vqwej"qp"vjg"ucog" kp"vjg"
kuuwgu" hqnnqykpi."
vjqwij"o{" gorjcuku" yknn"
dg"qp"
vjg"qrrqukvkqp" qh"
o cuu"
cpf" jkij"ewnvwtg"
tcvjgt"
vjcp"encuu"
cpcn{ugu"qh"
e wnvwtg0"
590" Ugg"Tqigt" Uguukqpu."$Uqog" Pqvgu" qp"Ft0"Iqgddgnu)"
Ngvvgt"vq"Hwtvycgpingt.$"
Oqfgtp" Owuke" 33"*3;55+<"5/54="tgrt0" cu"$Owuke"
cpf"Pcvkqpcnkuo.$" kp"Tqigt"Uguukqpu"
qp"
Owuke<" Eqnngevgf" gf0"Gfyctf"
Guuc{u." V0"Eqpg"*Rtkpegvqp<"
Rtkpegvqp" Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."
3;9;+." 493/:30"
4"*Pqx0"3;67+<"
5:0" Rqnkvkeu" 5680"
5;0" Ocefqpcnf" cppqwpegf" htqo"
jku"ykvjftcycn" vjg" Rctvkucp"
Tgxkgy." cpf"jku"kpvgp/"
vq"hqwpf"
vkqp" kp"c"ngvvgt"
Rqnkvkeu." vq"vjg"
gfkvqt"
*Rctvkucp"Tgxkgy"32"]3;65_<"
5:4+0"
620" Kp"tgegpv" Dcddkvv"
{gctu." jcu"fguetkdgf"
jkougnh"cu"c"eqpugtxcvkxg"cpf"jcu"kpfk/"
ecvgf" vq"nghvkuv"
jku"cpvkrcvj{" oqxgogpv" cu"
rqnkvkeu" hct"
dcem"cu"j ku"
uvwfgpv"
{gctu0" Egt/"
$Dcvvng"
vckpn{." Et{$" vcmgu"
c"e{pkecn"cvvkvwfg"
vqyctf"vjg"$oczkou$" K"cumgf"
qh"yct0"
Dcddkvv"cdqwv"vjg"rqgo" chvgt"
vjg"Jctxctf"
ngevwtg"
cntgcf{"ekvgf0" vjcv"
Kpfkecvkpi" kv"
ycu"c"tgurqpug"vq"yjcv"jg"xkgygf"cu"Cogtkec)u"
dgncvgf" kpvq"
gpvt{" Yqtnf"Yct"KK."jg"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"3:;"

tghgttgf"vq"vjg"rqgo"cu"cp"gzcorng" qh"yjcv"jg"ecnngf" gnkvkuo0$"


$o{" Dcddkvv"
cpf"Oce/"
fqpcnf" eqwnf" jcxg"
jctfn{" citggf" cdqwv"vjg"yct="pqv"nqpi"
dghqtg" $Dcvvng"
rwdnkujkpi"
Et{.$" Ocefqpcnf" uvknn"
ycu" hqt"
ecnnkpi" cevkqp"
$tgxqnwvkqpct{" vjg"
cickpuv" yctocmgtu0$"Kp"
tghgttkpi"vq" K"vqqm"
$gnkvkuo.$" Dcddkvv"
vq"
d g" jkougnh"
cuuqekcvkpi" ykvj"kpvgnngevwcnu"
uwej"
cu"Ocefqpcnf//umgrvkecn" cpvk/Uvcnkpkuvu"
yjq" tgockpgf" gpicigf" jqygxgt"
d{." etkvkecn"
qh."
ockpuvtgco" cpf"
rqnkvkecn" e wnvwtcn"
vjqwijv"*cpf"y jq"
fghgpfgf"vjg"
rtqfwevkqp"qh"
$cwvqpqoqwu$" jkij"ctv+0"Kp"qwt"
eqpxgtucvkqp"cdqwv"Ocefqpcnf."Dcddkvv"
tghgttgf"
vq"
jko" cu"c"enqug"
htkgpf"
cpf"eqnngciwg"hqt"qxgt" {gctu0"
hqtv{"
630" Ukoqpg" $Yqtfu"
Ygkn." cpf"Yct.$" Rqnkvkeu"
7"*Oct0"3;68+<"990"
640" Ugg"Mctn" $Vjg"Tgdktvj"
Lcurgtu." qh"vjg" Rqnkvkeu"
Wpkxgtukv{.$" 5"*Hgd0"3;68+<"
74/79="
Fykijv" $WUC"xu0"WUUT.$"7"*Urtkpi"
Ocefqpcnf." 3;6:+<"99="Pkeqncu"
Pcdqmqx."$Vjg"
Owuke" 7"*Urtkpi"
Rwtig.$" 3;6:+<"324/80"
650" C"$Rqrwnct"
Ewnvwtg$"ugevkqp"
ycu" hgcvwtgf"
tgiwnctn{" kp"Rqnkvkeu0"
Kp"vjg"
hktuv"
kuuwg."
Ocefqpcnf" $C" qh"
rwdnkujgf" Vjgqt{" Rqrwnct" Ewnvwtg$"
*Hgd0"3;66+." yjkej" jg"
ncvgt"
tgyqtmgf"wpfgt"
vjg" $C"Vjgqt{"
vkvng" qh"Ocuu"
Ewnvwtg$"
*ugg"pqvg"4+0"Hqt"uqog"qh"Oce/"
fqpcnf)u"
qvjgt" ugg"$Qp"Nqydtqy"
eqpvtkdwvkqpu." 3"
Vjkpmkpi.$"*Cwi0" 3 4
;66+<" 3;/42"
cpf"$Hkgnf" 4"*Crt0"3;67+<"334/360"
Pqvgu.$"
660" Ocefqpcnf." qh"Ocuu"
$Vjgqt{" Ewnvwtg.$" cpf"Yjkvg."
Tqugpdgti" 860"
670" Ugg"Ugtig" Jqy"Pgy"
Iwkndcwv." [qtm"Uvqng"
vjg"
Kfgc" Oqfgtp"
qh" vtcpu0"
Ctv." Ctvjwt"
Iqnfjcoogt" *Ejkeciq<" qh"Ejkeciq"
Wpkxgtukv{" Rtguu." cpf"Cpftgy"
3;:5+." $Eqp/"
Tquu."
Ewnvwtg"
vckpkpi" kp"vjg"
Eqnf"Yct.$"
kp"Pq"Tgurgev<"
Kpvgnngevwcnu"
cpf" Ewnvwtg"
Rqrwnct"
*Pgy"[qtm<" 3;:;+0"
Tqwvngfig."
720"
680" Tquu."
690" Gctn" $Ytkvgtu"
Dtqyfgt." cpf"vjg"
Eqoowpkuv" 3;5:."
Rctv{.$" kp"Fcpkgn"
swqvgf"
Cctqp."Ytkvgtu"
qp"vjg" *Pgy"
Nghv" [ qtm<"
Jcteqwtv." cpf"
Dtceg." 3;83+."382/"
Lqxcpqxkej."
830"
6:0" Ugg"Iwkndcwv."
43."rcuuko0"
6;0" Mwtv" $Vjg"Owuke"
Nkuv." qh"Uqxkgv"
Twuukc.$" 3"*Oc{"3;66+<"32:0"
Rqnkvkeu"
720" Engogpv"
Itggpdgti." cpf"Mkvuej.$"
$Cxcpv/ictfg" kp"Ctv"
cpf"
Ewnvwtg"
*Dquvqp<"
Dgceqp" 3;83+."390"
Rtguu."
730" Tgrt0"
kp"Rjknkr"
Tcjx." qp"Nkvgtcvwtg"
Guuc{u" cpf"
Rqnkvkeu"
gf0"C0"L0"Rqtvgt"
cpf"C0"L0"
Fxqukp"
*Dquvqp<" Okhhnkp."
Jqwijvqp" 5250"
3;9:+."
740" Ycu"Tcjx"ugnh/eqpuekqwun{" cpf"kpxgtvkpi"
gejqkpi" vjg"Pc|k"gzrtguukqp."
$gpvctvgvg"
Mwpuv$A"
750" Itggpdgti."
$Vjg"Ncvg"
Vjktvkgu"
kp"Pgy"[qtm.$"
kp"Ctv"
cpf"
Ewnvwtg" Dgc/"
*Dquvqp<"
eqp"Rtguu." 4520"
3;85+."
760" Ngqp" $Ctv"
Vtqvum{." cpf"Rqnkvkeu.$"
Rctvkucp"
Tgxkgy" 3;5:+="
*Cwi0/Ugrv0" kp"
swqvgf"
53/540"
Iwkndcwv."
770" Itggpdgti." 80"
$Cxcpv/ictfg.$"
780" Itggpdgti." 320"
$Cxcpv/ictfg.$"
790" Itggpdgti." 70"
$Cxcpv/ictfg.$"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
3;2" Vjg"
Owukecn"
Swctvgtn{"

7:0" Itggpdgti." 370"


$Cxcpv/ictfg.$"
7;0" Ugg"Dcddkvv."
$Vjg"Uvtwevwtg" qh"Owuke"
cpf"Hwpevkqp" 33/340"
Vjgqt{.$"
820" Ugg."hqt" vjg"
gzcorng." fkuewuukqp"
qh"
pqokpcnkuo"
kp"qpg"qh"Dcddkvv)u"
oquv"
cfoktgf"
rjknquqrjkecn" Pgnuqp"
uqwtegu<" Iqqfocp." Vjg"Uvtwevwtg"
qh" *Ecodtkfig<"
Crrgctcpeg"
Jctxctf" Rtguu."
Wpkxgtukv{" gur0"53/570"
3;73+."
830" Mgtocp."
3230"
840" Mgtocp."
3230"
850" Kp"vjg"kpvgtxkgyu"
dqvj"
ykvj" cpf"Oknngt"
Dtqf{" cpf"Iwem" cpf"Ocwu." jcu"
Dcddkvv"
jku"rgtuqpcn"
fkuewuugf" fkufckp"
hqt"
Vjgqfqt"Cfqoq0" Jg"ogv" Cfqtpq" vjg"
vjtqwij"
ogfkcvkqp"qh"Tqigt" cpf"vjg"
Uguukqpu" Rcwn"Nc|gtuhgnf0"
uqekqnqikuv" Cfqtpq)u" qp"
ytkvkpi"
owuke"yqwnf"pgxgt" Dcddkvv)u"
rcuu" vguvu"
qh" cpf"
enctkv{" x gtkhkecvkqp"
hqt" owuk/"
tgurqpukdng"
ecn"fkueqwtug0"
860" Vjgqfqt" Y0"Cfqtpq."Vjg" Rjknquqrj{" Oqfgtp"
qh" Owuke." C0"I0"Okvejgnn"
vtcpu0" cpf"
Y0"X0"Dnqouvgt"*Pgy"[qtm<"Ugcdwt{" Rtguu."3;95+."324/50"Vjku" dg"cp"crrtqrtkcvg"
oc{"
vq"ogpvkqp"
rqkpv" cpqvjgt"
dkv"qh"Cfqtpq)u" qh"oqfgtpkuo"
eqpuvtwevkqp" jcu"eqpvtkd/"
vjcv"
vq"vjg"
wvgf" ewttgpv"
etkvkecn"
xkgy" qh"yjcv" vgpfu"
*uvknn+" vq"dg"ecnngf"
$wrvqyp$"owuke0"
vq"vygnxg/vqpg"
Tghgttkpi" owuke"cu"$ogejcpkuvke.$" $cduqnwvgn{" cpf"$qduvk/"
fgvgtokpgf.$"
pcvgn{"
tkikf$"
*Rjknquqrj{"Oqfgtp"
qh" Owuke." /jgpeg"*hqt"
93."rcuuko+" jko+"
cfoktcdn{"
fgvcejgf"htqo"vjg"
eqorncegpv"jcdkvu"qh"ewnvwtcn"gzrtguukqp/Cfqoq" oc{"kpcfxgtv/"
dg"vjg"
gpvn{" qh"owej"
uqwteg" qh"vjg"ewttgpv"etkvkecn"
kpxgevkxg" owukecn"
cickpuv" $kpvgnnge/"
vwcnkuo0$"
870" Ugg"Mgtocp." 326<"$Vjg"cecfgo{" jcu"dgeqog" c"uqtv" qh"itggpjqwug=" gxgp" c"ytkvgt"
uq"eqpvgorvwqwu" qh"vjg"wug"qh"ogvcrjqtkecn" ncpiwcig" cu"Dcddkvv" ecppqv" cxqkf" uqog/"
vkogu"uweewodkpi" vq"vjg" )qticpke" $"Kp"vjku"
hcnnce{0)" eqpvgzv." kv"ku"kpvgtguvkpi" vq"tgecnn"
vjg"ktqpkgu"qh"Dcddkvv)u"$Owuke" hqt"vjg"Ocuugu$" cpgefqvg." gurgekcnn{" kp"tghgtgpeg" vq"jku"
Lwfckuo0" Cncp"Ycnf" jcu"rqkpvgf" qwv"vjcv"ocp{" qh"vjg" Pgy"[qtm" Kpvgnngevwcnu" yjq"
ecog" kpvq"rtqokpgpeg" fwtkpi" vjg"3;52u"ygtg" vjg"hktuv"Cogtkecp" Lgyu" vq"cejkgxg"
rtqokpgpeg" kp"vjg" cecfgoke" gnkvg0"Vjgktu"ycu" c" hqt"
uvtwiing"gpicigogpv" kp"c"pgyn{"
hqtokpi"Cogtkecp" ewnvwtg/pqv" c"ykvjftcycn" htqo" c" Gwtqrgcp" ewnvwtg" kp" vtcike"
fgenkpg0"C"iqqf" fgcn"jcu"dggp" ytkvvgp"cdqwv" vjku"cpf"cdqwv" vjg" ugpukdknkvkgu" qh"vjqug"
dqvj"
kpvgnngevwcnu." cpf"
Lgykuj" pqp/Lgykuj." hqtokpi" vjg" qh"
chhknkcvkqp" y tkvgtu"
tghgttgf"vq"
cu"Pgy"[qtm" Kpvgnngevwcnu0" Cu"Tkejctf" Rgnnu"
rwv" kv."
v jg{" $vjqwijv" qh" v jgougnxgu" cu"
swkpvguugpvkcnn{"wtdcp." tghtgujkpin{" cpf"cdqxg"
e{pkecn." cnn"gtwfkvg0" 0"0" 0"Vjg"kpvgnngevw/"
cnu"yjq"enwuvgtgf" ctqwpf" Eqoogpvct{" cpf"Vjg" Rctvkucp" Tgxkgy" ygtg" kpuvkpevkxg" qwvukf/"
fguegpfcpvu"
gtu." qh"kookitcpvu" cpf"ijgvvq"fygnngtu" 0"0"0"uwurkekqwu" qh"rqrwnkuv"
ugpvkogpvcnkv{"cu"c"rtgnwfg" vq"vjg"rqitqou$" *Vjg" Nkdgtcn"Okpf." 96+0"
Dcddkvv)u"cpgefqvg" tgokpfu" wu"vjcv"jg"ycu" vjg" hktuv"
Lgykuj" eqorqugt" vq"dg"jktgf"
cv"Rtkpegvqp."lwuv" cu"Jqqm"ycu" vjg" hktuv"
Lgykuj" rjknquqrjgt" cv"P[W"cpf"Vtknnkpi" vjg"
hktuv"
Lgy" kp"vjg"Eqnwodkc" Gpinkuj" fgrctvogpv0" Dcddkvv." nkmg"Jqqm." Vtknnkpi." Itggp/"
dgti."Og{gt" Uejcrktq." cpf"Rjknkr" Tcjx." ycu." cu"Ktxkpi" Jqyg" rwvu" kv."coqpi" $vjg"
Pgy"[qtm" ytkvgtu" ]yjq_" ecog" cv"vjg"gpf"qh"v jg"oqfgtpkuv" gzrgtkgpeg." cu"
lwuv" vjg{"
ecog" cv"yjcv" oc{" {gv"jcxg"vq"dg"lwfigf" vjg" gpf"qh"vjg" tcfkecn"gzrgtkgpeg." cpf"cu"
vjg{"egtvckpn{"ecog" cv"vjg" gpf" qh"v jg"
kookitcpv" Lgykuj" gzrgtkgpeg0$" Egtvckpn{." qpg"
qh"Jqyg)u" qh" vjgug"
fguetkrvkqpu" qhvgp/Lgykuj" kpvgnngevwcnu" hkvu"
Dcddkvv" rgthgevn{<" $Vjg{"
eqwnf"vcnm"hcuvgt"vjcp" cp{qpg" gnug."vjg{"mpgy" vjgkt"yc{" ctqwpf" dgvvgt." vjg{" ygtg"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Owuke" vjg"
hqt" Ocuugu"3;3"

qp"vjgkt"
swkemgt" *$Vjg"Pgy"[qtm"
hggv$" Vjg"
Kpvgnngevwcnu.$" Fgenkpg"vjg"
qh" Pgy"*Pgy"
[qtm<" ("Yqtnf."
Dtceg"
Jcteqwtv." 43:0"Vjg"rqkpv"
3;92+." vq"gorjcuk|g"
jgtg"ku"vjcv"
vjku"
jqygxgt"
ugpukdknkv{." etkvkecn" dg."ycu"
kv"okijv" pqv"qpg"qh"kuqncvkqp"
cpf"cnkgpcvkqp0"
880" Rgvgt" $Cwhdcw1Dcwjcwu<"
Icnnkuqp." Rqukvkxkuo"
Nqikecn" Oqfgtp/"
cpf"Ctejkvgevwtcn"
Etkvkecn"
kuo.$" 3;;2+<"932/330"
38*6+"*Uwoogt"
Kpswkt{"
890" Icnnkuqp."
9660"
8:0" Ocefqpcnf." hqt"
gzcorng." jku"nqpiuvcpfkpi"
eqpvkpwgf" qh"mkvuej"
etkvkswg" cpf"ocuu"
ewnvwtg"
kp"vjg"
rquvyct" cu"
rgtkqf." vjg"
swqvcvkqp" dgikppkpi"vjku"
cv"
v jg" qh" guuc{"
gzgornk/"
Jku"fkuewuukqp"
hkgu0" qh"vjg"
yc{"mkvuej"
$okzgu"
cpf"uetcodngu" cfwodtcvgu"
gxgt{vjkpi$"
Dcddkvv)u"
eqoogpvu" qp"$wpuekgpvkhke$"
owukecn"
fkueqwtug"$yjkej"
rgtokvu" vq"dg"
cp{vjkpi"
uckf"
cpf"xktvwcnn{"
pqvjkpi"vq"
d g"eqoowpkecvgf$" cpf"
*$Uvtwevwtg" Hwpevkqp.$"33+."
jgpeg"qdhwuecvkpi"
ogcpkpihwn"fkuvkpevkqpu0"
8;0" Ctvjwt" Vjg"
Uejngukpigt." Xkvcn"
Egpvgt=" Rqnkvkeu"
vjg" qh"Htggfqo"
*Dquvqp<"
Jqwijvqp/"
3;6;+."9;0"
Okhhnkp."
wpvkvngf"
920" Uejngukpigt)u" eqpvtkdwvkqp"vq"$Qwt" cpf"qwt"
Eqwpvt{" Rctv"
Ewnvwtg." KKK$"
Rctvkucp" xqn0"3;"pq0"7"*3;74+<"7;40"
Tgxkgy"
780"
930" Tquu."
940" Yqtfu" Cdqwv" Owuke." 3860"Jgtg" Dcddkvv)u" fkuewuukqp"qh"rnwtcnkuo"
cpf"vjg"rtqdngo"
ku."kp"ocp{"
qh"fkxgtukv{" yc{u." jku"
o quv"gzrnkekv0"Ejcrvgt" $Vjg"
8." Wpnkmgn{"Uwtxkxcn"qh"
Eqpvgorqtct{" Owuke.$" fkuewuugu"$vjg"etwz" 0"0"0"qh"vjg" qh"
rtqdngo"fkxgtukv{$" kp"o wukecn"
kp"vgtou"
ewnvwtg" qh"eqpvgzvwcnkv{."
vjcv"ku."kp"vgtou" qh"vjg"kpvgtpcn."
kpfkxkfwcnk|gf"
fkhhgt/"
gpegu"dgvyggp" owukecn" yqtmu0" $Vjku"ku"yjgtg" kv"dgicp0"Vjqug" yqtmu"
okffng/rgtkqf" qh"
Uejqgpdgti" 000" ctg"vq"cu"nctig"cp"gzvgpv" cu"rquukdng" ugnh/tghgtgpvkcn."
ugnh/eqpvckpgf."
cpf"yjcv" K)o"ikxgp" vq"ecnn")eqpvgzvwcn0)"
Eqpvgzvwcnkv{" ogtgn{"jcu"vq"fq"ykvj"
vjg"
gzvgpv"vq"yjkej" c"rkgeg"fghkpgu"kvu"ocvgtkcnu"ykvjkp" kvugnh)"
*389+0"Hqt" vjg"
Dcddkvv."
rctcfkio"qh"fkxgtukv{" ku"vjg" uvtwevwtg"
qh"vjg"kpfkxkfwcn" yqtm." tcvjgt"
vjcp"vjg"ejctce/"
qh"fkhhgtgpv"
vgtk|cvkqp" kfgqnqikgu."uv{ngu."cpf1qt" qvjgt" ujctgf"kfgpvkvkgu0"
Kpfggf."yqtfu"
nkmg"
$kfgqnqi{.$" $uv{ng.$"cpf"$cguvjgvkeu.$" qt"hqt" vjcv"ocvvgt." ctg"
$ewnvwtg.$" pqv." hqt"
tgcuqpcdng"
Dcddkvv." eqpegrvu" hqt"
eqpegrvwcnk|kpi" owuke0"Cickp."vjg"gorjcuku"ku"qp"
rtgugtxkpi"cpf"xcnwkpi" kpvtc/yqtm" uvtwevwtcn"kpfkxkfwcvkqp" cpf"kpvtc/yqtm"uvtwevwtcn"
fkuvkpevkqpu0"
950" Lcogu" Vjg"
Enkhhqtf." Rtgfkecogpv"Ewnvwtg"
qh" Jctxctf"
*Ecodtkfig<" Wpkxgtukv{"
3;::+."350"
Rtguu."
960" Itggpdgti." :0"
$Cxcpv/ictfg.$"
970" Cu"vjg" eqorqugt" Uvcfgnocp"
Lghh" jcu"rqkpvgf" qwv"vq"og."vjgtg"ctg"cnuq"gejqgu"
jgtg"qh"vjg"
enqukpi"rcuucig"qh"
$ Yjq" Ectgu" Kh"[ qw"
N kuvgpA$"
*Vjg" eqppgevkqp" ujqwnf"
pqv"dg"qxgtnqqmgf="kv"rgtvckpu" vq" v jg"
ukipkhkecpvn{" swguvkqp" qh"
D cddkvv)u" vq"
tgncvkqpujkr"
Cfqtpq" cpf"vq"vjg" qh"jku"cecfgoke"
ejctcevgtk|cvkqp" Dcddkvv"
$tgvtgcv0$+" uvcvgu<"
Itcpvkpi" vq"owuke" vjg" ceeqtfgf"
rqukvkqp" qvjgt"ctvu"
cpf"uekgpegu"]kp"wpkxgtukvkgu_"
rtqokugu" vjg"uqng"uwduvcpvkxg"
ogcpu" qh"uwtxkxcn"hqt"vjg"
owuke" K"jcxg"dggp"
fguetkdkpi0"Cfokvvgfn{."kh"
vjku"
owuke" ku"pqv"uwrrqtvgf."
vjg" yjkuvnkpi" qh"
tgrgtvqt{"
vjg"ocp" kp"vjg" yknn"
uvtggv" dg"nkvvng" vjg"
chhgevgf." eqpegtv/iqkpi" cevkxkv{"qh"
v jg"
eqpurkewqwu" eqpuwogt"qh"owukecn"ewnvwtg" yknn"
dg"nkvvng"
fkuvwtdgf0"Dwv" owuke"yknn"
egcug"vq"gxqnxg"cpf."kp"vjcv"
korqtvcpv" ugpug."yknn"
egcug"vq"nkxg0"
*472+"

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
3;4" Vjg"
Owukecn"
Swctvgtn{"

Tgcfkpi" vjku"rcuucig"kp"Eqpvgorncvkpi" Owuke." Mgtocp" rwvu"jku"gorjcuku" qp"vjg" yqtf"


yjkej"
gxqnxg." jg"kpvgtrtgvu"cu"c"uygtxg" kpvq"jkuvqtkecn"qticpkekuo0"K"rtqrqug"c"dncpfgt"
tgcfkpi"qh"$gxqnxg$" cpf"ykuj" vq"rnceg"oqtg" gorjcuku" qp"Dcddkvv)u"swguv"hqt"cp"cnvgtpc/"
vkxg"
kpuvkvwvkqpcn"eqpvgzv" hqt"pgy" owuke."qpg"vjcv" yqwnf" dg"wpjkpfgtgf" d{"eqpuwogt/"
kuo."
rjknkuvkpkuo." cpf"vjg" rtguuwtgu"qh"ocuu"ewnvwtg0" Vyq"rqkpvu" ujqwnf"dg"gorjcuk|gf0"
Dcddkvv)u"
Hktuv." cfxqece{" *kp"$Yjq" EctguA$+" qh"c"$ykvjftcycn"htqo" vjg"rwdnke"yqtnf$"
ujqwnf"dg"tgcf" kp"vjg"eqpvgzv" qh"Itggpdgti)u" twokpcvkqpu" qp"vjg"cxcpv/ictfg" cpf"
Ocefqpcnf)u" qh"ocuu"
etkvkswg" ewnvwtg0"Kp"vjku"eqpvgzv." Dcddkvv)u"
wug"qh"vjg"vgto" $rwdnke"
owuke$"cpf"$rwdnke" yqtnf$" uggo" vq"ftkhv"
xgt{" htqo"
unkijvn{" $ocuu"ewnvwtg$"qt"$mkvuej0$"
Vjg"ykvjftcycn" htqo" vjku"
rwdnke" yqtnf"*ocuu." mkvuej."eqpuwogt" ewnvwtg+"pggf" pqv"dg"
kpvgtrtgvgf"cu"c"tgvtgcv"
kpvq" jgtogvkekuo0" Kp" cp{"ecug."Dcddkvv)u"
fkufckp" hqt"
vjg" gicnk/"
vctkcpkuo"qh"vjg"$octmgv" rnceg" qh"vjg"eqpegtv" jcnn$"*46:+"eqphqtou" ykvj"vjg"tjgvqtke"
cpf"xcnwgu"qh"Itggpdgtikcp" cxcpv/ictfkuo." gurgekcnn{"cu"vjgug"ecog" vq"dg"kfgpvkhkgf"
ykvj"eqpugtxcvkxg." Eqnf"Yct" tgcevkqpu"vq"Uqxkgv" ewnvwtcn" Ugeqpf."
rqnkvkeu0" cu"K"jcxg"
uwiiguvgf"vjtqwij" owej" qh"vjku" Dcddkvv"
guuc{." uggu"
ykfg/tcpikpi." fkuewtukxg"
eqppge/"
vkqpu"
dgvyggp" kpuvkvwvkqpu."ncpiwcig."fkuugokpcvkqp" qh"xcnwgu."
cpf"dgjcxkqt" qh"vjg"
itqwru"cpf"kpfkxkfwcnu" gpicigf" kp"xctkqwu"curgevu"qh"owukecn"rtczku0"Vq"dqttqy" Itggp/"
vgtou"
dgti)u" cickp."Dcddkvv"uggmu" vq"rkgeg"vqigvjgt" vjg"tgopcpvu" qh"c"$nkxkpi"ewnvwtg$"
chvgt"
vjg"cxcpv/ictfg1twnkpi" gnkvg"
cttcpigogpv" jcu"fkuuqnxgf0"
980" Vgtguc" $Vjg"Xkqngpeg"
fg"Ncwtgvku." qh" kp"Vgejpqnqikgu"
Tjgvqtke.$" Igpfgt"
qh"
Kpfkcpc"
*Dnqqokpivqp<" Rtguu."
Wpkxgtukv{" 640"
3;:9+."
990" V0"L0"
Enctm." Rqnnqem)u"
$Lcemuqp" kp"Tgeqpuvtwevkpi"
Cduvtcevkqp.$" Ctv"
Oqfgtpkuo<"kp"
Pgy"[qtm." cpf"
Rctku." Oqpvtgcn" gf0"Ugtig"
3;67/3;86." Iwkndcwv" OKV"
*Ecodtkfig<"
Rtguu." 4650"
3;;2+."

This content downloaded from 149.130.90.2 on Sun, 14 Dec 2014 12:04:11 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

You might also like