Many Nepalis saw the federal project as either achieving full inclusion for marginalized groups like Janajati and Madhesi or total failure. Conservatives feared federalism would undermine national unity. While Nepal has seen social and political progress, violence has erupted from unfulfilled promises of inclusion and the constitution failed to fulfill aspirations of marginalized groups for greater participation and rights. Social justice remains distant for many outside the prevailing elite.
Many Nepalis saw the federal project as either achieving full inclusion for marginalized groups like Janajati and Madhesi or total failure. Conservatives feared federalism would undermine national unity. While Nepal has seen social and political progress, violence has erupted from unfulfilled promises of inclusion and the constitution failed to fulfill aspirations of marginalized groups for greater participation and rights. Social justice remains distant for many outside the prevailing elite.
Many Nepalis saw the federal project as either achieving full inclusion for marginalized groups like Janajati and Madhesi or total failure. Conservatives feared federalism would undermine national unity. While Nepal has seen social and political progress, violence has erupted from unfulfilled promises of inclusion and the constitution failed to fulfill aspirations of marginalized groups for greater participation and rights. Social justice remains distant for many outside the prevailing elite.
Many Nepalis have seen the federal project as zero-sum.
Janajati and Madhesi activists felt that anything less achieving
their full aspirations would represent total failure. On the other side, the conservative Khas Arya political elite and intellectuals believed that federalism would undermine national unity and interests
Krishna Khanal, Accord 26 author and Professor of Political
Science at Tribhuvan University (1979-2010) Episodic violence has gripped parts of the country since the CPA, often to protest unfulfilled promises of inclusion by political actors. Many perceive the 2015 Constitution as having failed to fulfil the aspirations of many marginalised groups for greater participation and rights. And victims of violence committed by prominent political actors are yet to see accountability or justice. Although there have been significant instances of social and political progress in Nepal over the past decade, social justice remains a long way off for many Nepalis outside the prevailing elite.