Professional Documents
Culture Documents
What is Economics
There's no one universally accepted answer to the question "What is economics?" Various
definitions are:
Islam is a religion that provides a set of rules for life. We therefore call it a ‘Complete code of
life. A code of life or system of life covers all aspect of life of a human being. Therefore, Islam
is not set of scattered teachings or rituals for worships only, instead it is a complete set of
rules which are interdependent. A successful Muslim is not a person who excels in one aspect
of life. An important factor in Islamic teachings that must be taken care of is that rules are set
in coherence with each other. One significant sign of completeness of Islamic teachings is
that the rules are interdependent. A social or political rule is not in conflict with other guidelines
of worship or economic relationships;
Islam – a complete code of life
ISLAM
I'badaat Mua'mlaat
(Worships – Man to God relations) (Dealings – Man to Man relations)
Basic needs are meant for requirement which an every human as a member
of group of living things needs to live his life. Food, shelter and clothes are
example of this type;
2. Convenience ﺳﮩﻮﻟﺕ:
The fulfillment of basic needs in convenient manners. Food for
survival need not be a cooked food or healthy one, anything that
provides support to humans to live is food. But as a matter of natural
requirement humans require convenience in their basic needs;
3. Comfort ﺭﺍﺣﺖ:
A convenient way of life may not be a comfortable way also.
Food for example in good environment with some varieties and pleasant
atmosphere is a comfortable food and also finely stitched clothes made of good
fabric is another example of comfort;
4. Luxuries ﺗﻌﻴﺶ:
A life style that is over the general standards of comfortable life of a society is a
luxury life style. Food with multiple choices, clothes of famous brands, expensive
daily-life things etc. etc.
These are four targets every human makes his all efforts to go higher and higher to top of the
pyramid. This is what conventional economic theory call 'scarcity of the resources' and 'needs
and wants are unlimited. The fulfilment of basic needs in convenient manners. Food for survival
need not be a cooked food or healthy one, anything that provides support to humans to live is
food. But as a matter of natural requirement humans require convenience in their basic needs.
Systems of Life
(Polictical,
Economic Self respect
and Social
Intellect (A'ql)
Life
Basic Economic problems
1- What to Produce? That is , Determination of Priorities
As we know that human wants are unlimited but the resources are scares, so the problem of
making choice between alternatives arises. Which want has to be satisfied first and which has to
be deferred is the problem of making choice. For example, I have got $50 to purchase flour or
cloth, fruits or vegetables or simply spend my $50 on dining out. So, I have got these five options
available and choose the one among these five is called “Determination of Priorities”.
The problem of determination of priorities is not restricted to the micro level (humans only) but
also encompasses the Macro level (The whole nation). Every country has got limited amount of
resources for example, human resource, mineral resource, and monetary resource. Alternatively,
the requirements and want of the whole nation is almost near to infinite. Now to determine what
to produce by utilizing these limited resources and which product should be given preference over
the others is called the problem of “Determination of Priorities”.
The second problem is the allocation of resources (land, labor and capital). What and how much
of the resource is allocated to produce what and in how much quantity of the products. For
Example, we have got land available to us, now how many acres of land should be allocated for
the cultivation of wheat, and how many acres of land should be allocated for cotton production.
Similarly, we have got the capability to develop production units (factories). Now how many
factories should be leather producing factories, and how many of cement producing or food and
beverage factories. This problem of allocation of different resources for the production of different
product is called the problem of “Allocation of Resources”.
4- Development
Fourth problem is “Development” i.e. How to improve our economic conditions? So that the
resulted production will be of high degree in terms of quality and quantity. How to innovate new
things, improve technology and develop new products so that society as a whole gets the benefit
and achieve higher income levels and opportunities to improve their economic well being. This
problem in economics is called the problem of “Development”..
To solve these economic problems the market economy suggest the following,
First, understand philosophy of market economy on the basis of which it claims to resolve the four
basic economic problems.
Market economy or capitalism suggest that the one and only solution to these problems is to get
every individual free for business and commercial activities and to give him right to choose any
method of making maximum profits as he thinks best. By giving this liberty to the individuals, these
economic problems would be resolved themselves. Because if everyone intends to make
maximum profits then he will work that is most wanted by the society and this way aforementioned
problems would be resolved automatically. But the question arises here as to how these economic
problems be solved themselves? To answer this question, some explanation is required.
1. Factually, this universe is made on different natural principles and laws that results the
same every time they are applied. One of these laws is the “Law of Supply and Demand”.
Supply is the quantity of goods and services that the seller is willing and able to sell in
the market whereas demand is the quantity of goods and services that the buyer is
willing and able to buy from the market. The law of supply and demand says that
whenever there is an excess of supply over demand, price will go down and wherever
there is shortage of supply compare to demand, price will rise. For instance, in extremely
hot and sunny weather, there are more people who demand ice that is demand for ice
increases. If supply of ice remains the same, price of ice would get increased.
Nevertheless, price will not increase if percentage increase in supply is exactly the same
as percentage increase in demand. Likewise, in winter season, demand for ice goes
down and keeping supply constant, price of ice will go down. This law is known as law
of Supply and Demand.
2. Philosophy of market economy says that this basic natural law of supply and demand
helps farmers determine what to produce. This law also helps industrialists,
manufacturers, and sellers determine what to sell in the market place and in what
quantity. This way aforementioned basic economic issues would be resolved easily.
3. Supply and demand analysis answers the basic question of determination of priorities in
a way that the seller will bring the commodity to the market that is most demanded by
people so that he can receive higher prices. Likewise, farmers and industrialist will
produce and sell the product which is in high demand. Because if they bring less
demanded commodity in the market they will receive less price. Resultantly, although
everyone acts for his own self interest, supply and demand forces bound them to fulfill
supply and demand of the society. Producers will keep on producing and selling
commodity in the market as long as there is excess demand over supply and stop
bringing the product in the market when supply equates demand. That’s why there is
always a production of that product which is demanded by the society. Moreover,
quantity of produced goods would be as same as needed by the society.
4. Allocation of Resources
5. The third problem is of distribution of income. According to the market economy, income
should be distributed among the factors of production which are as follows.
Land
Labor
Capital
Entrepreneur
The answer lies with supply and demand forces, the factor which is highly demanded will
be given more compensation.
Secondly, Zaid requires laborers to work for him in the factory. Compensation of laborers
is also determined by the market forces of supply and demand. If more laborers are willing
to work than demanded, wages may be low and opposite is true for high wage. Similarly,
to purchase capital equipment and/or machineries Zaid requires funds. The price of money
(funds) needed by Zaid is also determined by the supply and demand forces. If there are
more lenders than borrowers, the price of money i.e. interest rate may be low and
conversely is true for high interest rate. After the land, labor and capital suppliers are paid,
the residual is for the entrepreneur to enjoy.
In this way, problem of distribution of income is also resolved by the market forces of
supply and demand.
6. Development is the fourth economic problem. Every economy needs to grow and
develop its production opportunities. According to the market economy, if every individual
is absolutely free to undertake any economic activity for making profits then people will
produce innovative and quality products to increase their profitability and the objective of
development can be accomplished.
Now, I want to discuss the principles of Islam regarding four basics economic problems.
It should be clear and understood in the very beginning that Islam is not an economic
system. Rather, it is a “Deen”. The principle of which pertains to each and every course of
business. One of them is an Economy. So, there is no particular philosophy or rule written
in Quran and Hadith. There is no direct discussion about allocation of resources,
distribution of income, determination of priorities and development in Islamic Fiqh. But,
Islam has given some principles regarding economy like other spheres of life. Out of these
principles, we do able to understand the point of view given by Islam regarding these
economic problems.
After reading and analyzing principles of Islam regarding economy, one can understand
that Islam allows market forces of supply and demand.
“We have divided the economy among them and made some of them superior on
some others so that they can help each other in doing their work.
Therefore, it is very much clear that the one who provides his services is supply and the
one who takes it is demand. Through interaction of supply and demand, an equitable
economy can be established.
At the time of Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) when rural people used to take their produce to
the city in order to sell it, some urban people used to say to the rural person that don’t sell
your produce in the city on your own. Sell your produce to me first and then I will sell the
produce in the city when the appropriate time comes so that higher prices may be
received.
So, Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) restricted the presence of the third person between buyer
and seller so that the true equilibrium of supply and demand is established. Logically
speaking , if the rural individual sells the products on his own , he will sell it without storing
it. He will have to go back to his village. But, if some urban person purchase the product
and then sell it, there is higher probability that he will wait for the time at which he draws
maximum price. He will store the goods and create temporary shortage in the market. This
disturbs the basic of market forces of supply and demand.
When the question of setting market prices was asked from Hazrat Muhammad
(S.AW). (He replied, the meaning of which is as follows.)
“Undoubted , Allah is the one who sets market prices. He who reduces supply and
expand it. And He is the best provider.”
Accepting that Allah Tah’la sets prices is the implied acceptance that Allah Tah’la has set
the natural principles of supply and demand which determines the market prices. Setting
artificial prices without taking natural markets forces into account is disliked.
It is very much clear from the aforementioned sayings of Quraan o Sunnah, that Islam
accepts the market forces of supply and demand. Similarly, right of profit motive is also
acceptable. In Capitalism, there is an absolute and unconditional right given for private
profit and market forces. This is the reason why already discussed economic problems
are created.
Contrarily, Islam while accepting the right of profit motive and principles of market forces,
does not permit someone to harm the entire society and the system. Islam imposes certain
conditions and stipulations on these rights so that economic and social evils of the society
are eliminated.
Devine restrictions
Islam imposes certain conditions on the economy which can be implemented irrespective
of the society and time. For instance; Interest , Gambling , etc are strictly prohibited in the
Muslim economy. These thing usually creates monopolies and creates disturbances in the
society. Similarly, the things which are responsible for hurting ethical and moral values are
also prohibited.
It should be very much clear that these prohibitions are from Allah for all mankind. Islam
does not let it on humans to decide whether this is beneficial or not. Had these decision
been made by humans, there would have been disagreements among different people
based on personal traits and geographical locations. One thing which is true for one
person or place may not be true for another person or place. That’s why , Allah Tah’la
knows that these restrictions are necessary for all the people irrespective of place that’s
why Allah made it concrete through Wahee. So that a man based on his own logic will not
let the society and economy disturb.
So it is very much clear that these conditions and stipulations imposed by Quraan o
Sunnah are practicable whether the rationale of the stipulated principles are understood
by the people or not.
As discussed previously, some of the capitalists nations have imposed certain laws and
regulations on the market structure but these stipulations are not enough and lacks with
what is actually prohibited by Quraan and Sunnah. For instance, interest , gambling etc
are legally allowed in western nations that creates economic disturbances.
State Restrictions
In Sharia point of view, it is allowed for the Government to restrict trade of the
goods which are not haram and comes in the category of Mubah but for the given point in
time it create social ills. For instance, govt can restrict the trade of melon if cholera exist
in the society. So, buying and selling of melon is prohibited in sharia point of view till the
restriction of the govt prevails. Exclusive material on this particular subject matter”Sadd e
Zaraae” has been written and booked by sharia’ scholars.
By this principle , Govt can impose rules and regulations for the welfare of the Economy
or save the economy and society from illness. Once Hazrat Umer (R.A) saw that one seller
is selling the products below the market price. Hazrat Umer (R.A) said, (the meaning of
which is as follows)
The reason of the above statement is not written in the books. But the reason why
Hazrat Umer (R.A) restricted that person to sell the product below the market price may
be he thinks that low selling price causes harm to other seller at large. Or may be he was
at the point of view that low selling price results in excessive consumption or storage by
the consumers. Basic shariah’ principle permits the seller to sell the product at
whatever prices. Selling on the low price in the above case is permissible by shariah’
but Hazrat Umer (R.A) restricted that person because of the societal issue at large.
Following is the meaning of the verse which permits the Govt to impose the
conditions of this type.
O’ believer, obey Allah, and obey prophet, and who has authority over you.
In the above mentioned translation of the Aayat, there is a difference between
obedience of Allah and his Prophet and the people of Authority. Only those orders of the
authority should be obeyed which are inconformity of the Quraan o Sunnah.
It should be clear that this is not an absolute right of the Govt to impose such
restrictions without any limits. Rather, restrictions should be in line with certain principles
laid down by shariah. The details of these principles are not laid down here but two points
are taken into consideration here for the purpose of discussion. Firstly, the condition or
law or principle made by the Govt is only implemented when it is not contrary to the Shaira
rules. Secondly, Govt can impose such orders only when there is a collective problem of
the society as a whole. A well renowned fiqh book says the following statement in the
particular matter.
So, if the Govt imposes certain law in the absence of societal needs , that law is
prohibited and one can terminate this in the court of law.
Moral Restrictions
As discussed earlier, that Islam is a Deen not a an economic system. Islam teaches
in all sphere of life including economics. Islamic teaching regarding economics clearly
shows that material well being is not an end. Quraan o sunnah emphasized that the worldly
life is a short term life and the life hereafter is immortal that never ends. Humans should
devote their energies for making this world as a means to achieve a good end. i.e. the life
hereafter. So, making more and more money is not a success. Rather, success lies in the
work beneficial for the life hereafter. The way to achieve this end is the work done in this
world most liked by Allah Tahla’. When this thinking is developed in human mind, then he
will not consider only material things to make money but he will also consider the acts
done for the benefit of the life comes hereafter. There are certain situations the mandatory
orders of which are not exclusively given by the Allah Tahla’ but benefits of such acts are
disclosed. In relation to it, human can impose certain restrictions to himself.
One of the simple examples of such situations is as follows. If a person has an option to
develop and construct an amusement park which is more profitable than the projects of
constructing homes for poor people having low profits. Then, a person of secular mind
would choose the project of amusement park while a person having religious mind will opt
for the home construction project for poor people because he considers the benefits of the
life hereafter.
In the aforementioned situations , Shariah allows either projects but the one who has fear
of Allah and belief on the day of judgment imposed moral restrictions on himself. This
moral restrictions helps determining better allocation of resources and better distribution
of income. This was the simple example, if belief on the day of judgment is strong then it
leads to prosperous economic conditions.
I am not opposing the fact that un Islamic societies have moral values which have positive
effects on the economy, but as they are lacking in the faith of the day of judgment, thus
entire benefits of moral values are not achieved. Contrary to it, Islam with its full
implementation has much more positive economic effects. So moral restriction in Islam
pertaining to the economy is not weak rather, it has much more value.
The word "Riba", in Arabic language, literally means an "increment' or addition". In Islamic Fiqh the term
riba has a special meaning. Riba is an unjustified increment in borrowing or lending money, paid in kind
or in money above the amount of loan, as a condition imposed by the lender or voluntarily by the
borrower. Riba defined in this way is called in Fiqh riba al-duyun (debt usury). Riba also is an unjustified
increment gained by the seller or the buyer if they exchanged goods of the same kind in different
quantities. This is called "riba al-fadl" or "riba-al-buyu" (trade usury).
The Prophet (p.b.u.h.) exposed to his companions, also, this form of riba known as "riba al-buyu". He
warned them that barter exchange of commodities of the same kind will be leading to riba. He (p.b.u.h.)
advised all traders to use money for the exchange of such goods to avoid riba. In Islamic literature this
kind of riba is also described as riba al-khafi, i.e. disguised or implicit riba, in contrast to "riba al-duyun"
which is considered "Jali" i.e., explicit or clear.
Riba prohibition in Quran is mentioned in three distinct passages. To consider the chronological order of
the Quranic revelation, Allah, firstly, gave a warning (Sura 30:39) that riba earnings will be wiped out
while persons giving charity will be rewarded more than they have spent. Secondly, believers have been
ordered, and warned never to take riba at compound rates (Sura 3:130). Thirdly riba in all forms was
utterly condemned, and those cared not for its prohibition were threatened a holy war to be waged
against them by Allah and his Messenger (Sura 2:275-279). It was made clear that riba transaction is
different than trade and that it is the Will of Allah to prohibit riba irrespective of any reasons which may be
given for its support. Prohibition of riba in Quran is undoubtedly quite strict and decisive. Sunna explains
different forms of riba and puts more emphasis on its prohibition. The Prophet (p.b.u.h.) in his hadith
warned that riba is more sinful than committing adultery repeatedly.
The "riba" system was formally introduced in Islamic countries during the 19th and 20th Centuries through
two channels; (i) secular legislations which have endorsed the Western definition of usury, (ii) the modern
banking system whose activities are interest based. These two channels were opened during the era of
Western colonial rule to the Islamic world. Besides, the riba system has increasingly gained strength in
the Islamic world because of the serious economic dependence on the Western world on one hand and
secular education which neglected the teachings of Islam.